spc performance report - silverton consulting · 2017. 8. 29. · excelero using nvme ssds and...

TWITTER.COM/RAYLUCCHESI|RAYONSTORAGE.COM|GREYBEARDSONSTORAGE.COM|1-720-221-7270|SILVERTONCONSULTING.COM©2016SILVERTONCONSULTING,INC.ALLRIGHTSRESERVED

SPC performance report SilvertonConsulting,Inc.StorInt™DispatchThisStorageIntelligence(StorInt™)dispatchcoversStoragePerformanceCouncil(SPC)results1.TherehavebeenfournewSPC1v3theFujitsuETERNUSDX200S4,HuaweiOceanStor™Dorado6000v3,HuaweiFusionStorage,andLenovoDS4200andtherehavebeennonewSPC-2submissionssincelastquarter.JustaboutallofourSPC-1(non-diskonly)toptenperformancechartshavechanged.

SPC-1resultsWebeginourdiscussionwithtoptenSPC-1IOPS™showninFigure1.

Figure1Top10SPC-1IOPS

InFigure1,wecanseethenewHuaweiFusionStoragecameinat#2with~4.5MIOPS.TheHuaweiFusionStorageisthefirstbenchmarksubmissiontofeatureNVMeSSDsandshowsupwellinthisrawIOPSworkload.

1AllSPCresultsavailablefromhttp://www.storageperformance.org/home/asof27Aug2017

27Aug2017 SCISPCPERFORMANCEREPORT PAGE2OF4

TWITTER.COM/RAYLUCCHESI|RAYONSTORAGE.COM|GREYBEARDSONSTORAGE.COM|1-720-221-7270|SILVERTONCONSULTING.COM©2015SILVERTONCONSULTING,INC.ALLRIGHTSRESERVED

HuaweiFusionStoragehad132-1600GBNVMeSSDcardsacross36(33storageand3storage-ZK)nodes.TheyalsohadafewSAS400GBSSDsinthestorage-ZKnodesbutnothingcomparedtotheNVMecards.It’ssomewhatsurprisingthattheyweren’tabletogeneratemoreIOPSwiththatmanyNVMecardsbuttheywereusing144-10GbEinterfacestoconnectthe21serversdrivingtheIOPStothe36storage/storage-ZKnodes.IassumeHuaweiFusionStoragewasusingtheiSCSIprotocolintheirbenchmarksubmissionandnotNVMeF.Buttherewasnodetailsonthis.InFigure2weexamineSPC-1LRT(leastresponsetime)reportedbySPC.

Figure2SPC-2Top10SPC-1LRTperformance

InFigure2,theFujitsuDX200S4storagesystemcameina3-waytiefor8thplaceata0.22msecLRT.RecallthatLRT,istheaverageIOresponsetimeat10%ofachievablemaximumworkloadforthesubmission.AsfarasIcantelltheFujitsuETERNUSDX200S4isjustamidrangestoragesolution,whichused16GFCconnectionsforhostand(Ithink)FCconnectionsforbackendstorage.Theydidhave128GBofDRAMacrossthedualcontrollersand20-400GBSSDsbutIdidn’tseeanything

27Aug2017 SCISPCPERFORMANCEREPORT PAGE3OF4

TWITTER.COM/RAYLUCCHESI|RAYONSTORAGE.COM|GREYBEARDSONSTORAGE.COM|1-720-221-7270|SILVERTONCONSULTING.COM©2015SILVERTONCONSULTING,INC.ALLRIGHTSRESERVED

elsewhichmightexplaintheirsuperior(formidrangestorage)LRTperformance.Itjustgoestoshowyouthatgoodcodemakesadifference.It’ssomewhatsurprisingthattheHuaweiFusionStoragewithNVMeSSDsdidn’tdoaswellherebutitcouldhavesomethingtodowiththeiruseoftheiSCSIstackratherthanFC.Figure3showstheSPC-1reported$/IOPS™metricorSPC-1Price-Performance™.

Figure3SPC-2Top10SPC-1$/IOPS

InFigure3,thenewLenovoDS4200cameinat3rdplacewith$0.14/IOPSandtheFujitsuETERNUSDX200S4cameinat#5witha$0.21/IOPS.RecallthatlowerisbetterandAFAsystemsdominatethiscategorythesedays,justlikeLRTandIOPS.TheLenovoDS4200used12GbSASconnectionsbetweenthehostandthestorage,sported12-400GBSSDsand16GBofDRAMacrossthetwocontrollers.Butthesurprisewastheir$13.6Kpriceandbygenerating100KIOPS,itseemslikearealsteel.The300KIOPSoftheETERNUSDX200S4atapriceof$64Kalsodoesn’tseemlikeabaddeal.Buttheadded6SSDsintheDX200vs.theLenovoDS4200andtheabilityoftheDX200togenerate3XtheIOPSseemslikeevenbetterasolution.

27Aug2017 SCISPCPERFORMANCEREPORT PAGE4OF4

TWITTER.COM/RAYLUCCHESI|RAYONSTORAGE.COM|GREYBEARDSONSTORAGE.COM|1-720-221-7270|SILVERTONCONSULTING.COM©2015SILVERTONCONSULTING,INC.ALLRIGHTSRESERVED

SignificanceThenewSPC-1resultswereforv3ofthebenchmark.SPCreportstheseresultsseparatelyfromv1,butherewecombineresults.Thedifferencesbetweenthetwoversionsarenotthatsignificantfromourperspectiveandaremoreintheblocksizeusedratherthantheworkloadsbeinggenerated.SeeingNVMeSSDsstartingtoshowupisexciting.TheyarefastbutwhenbehindaniSCSIinterfacethere’sjustnotthatmuchthatcanbedone.ExcelerousingNVMeSSDsandNVMeFshowedover4MIOPSfrom2(small)NVMeSSDsatunder100microsec.Buttheywereusing100GbEandRoCE/RDMA.Someday,wemaystartseeingNVMeFstoragesystemsbenchmarkedinSPC-1andthenwewillseeanotherstepupinIOPSandstepdowninlatencies,untilthenwerelyonFCandiSCSI.Asalways,suggestionsonhowtoimproveanyofourperformanceanalysesarewelcomed.Additionally,ifyouareinterestedinmoreblockstorageperformanceinformation,checkoutourrecentlyupdated(August2017),SANStorageBuyingGuideavailableforpurchasefromourwebsite.2InSCI’sSANStorageBuyingGuidewenowprovidetop30resultsforsomeofourSPCperformancechartsandnew,SCIderived,OLTP,ThroughputandEmailChampionsCharts™forenterprise,all-flash,mid-rangeandSMBclassSANstorage.

Silverton Consulting, Inc., is a U.S.-based Storage, Strategy & Systems consulting firm offering products and services to the data storage community

SANStorageBuyingGuideURLinQRcodeNewslettersignupURLinQRcode)

2Ibid