v12-062 canadian derivatives markets-co-existing in the shadow of a giant
Post on 18-Jul-2016
616 Views
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
Canadian Derivatives Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant
The US and Canada are indelibly intertwined. Sharing a 5,525 mile border, acting as
primary trading partners and having symbiotic economies that ebb and flow in tandem has
resulted in two distinct yet highly correlated capital markets that are actively traded by
investors around the world. Although Canadian securities markets operate in the shadow of
the world’s largest capital market, distinct differences in Canada’s marketplace appeal to
both domestic and international investors.
Canadian derivatives markets hold special appeal to investors. A thriving domestic investor
base is increasingly participating in the listed futures and options markets, even as
international regulators seek to move over-the-counter derivatives into central clearing
mechanisms and onto organized exchanges around the world. This slow moving but ongoing
shift, along with the eventual recovery of global economies, will drive continued growth in
Canada’s exchange-traded derivatives markets.
Andy Nybo
V12:062
November 2014
www.tabbgroup.com
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 1
The Uniqueness of Canadian Capital Markets
Although sometimes overlooked by the US, Canada’s financial markets are substantial in
their own right. The country's equity markets, with a market capitalization of $2.3 trillion,
rank seventh in the world. Its fixed income markets are also expansive, with more than $1
trillion in outstanding government and corporate debt. Add to that a $1.2 trillion mortgage
market and all the ingredients are in place for a thriving securities market that is attracting
growing demand from investors around the world.
Canada occupies a unique position in the global capital markets. Its vast store of natural
resources has created an economy in which activity is closely correlated with the state of
the world’s energy, mining and commodity markets. Not surprisingly, Canada’s equity
markets are dominated by these sectors, with energy and natural resource companies
accounting for more than one-third of market capitalization.
Canada’s markets are also home to a vibrant financial sector, with financial institutions
accounting for 34% of total market capitalization. The strength of the Canadian financial
sector is a major attraction for global market participants. The sector’s conservative lending
practices, firm regulatory oversight and strong capital base are primary reasons why the
country’s banking sector avoided much if not all of the fallout from the global financial crisis.
Indeed, although the Canadian economy experienced many of the same recessionary
pressures that hit economies around the world, the banking sector suffered little financial
fallout from the crisis, and Canada still maintains its vaunted AAA credit rating. The
country’s appeal as a reserve currency for central banks and monetary authorities around
the world has thus been reinforced. That is a major factor driving interest in Canada’s cash
and equity markets and related derivative markets from the global investment community.
Exhibit 1: Canadian Equity Market Capitalization by Sector
September 2014
Source: Toronto Stock Exchange
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 2
The concentration in the natural resource and financial sectors is a double-edged sword.
Canada’s vast pool of natural resources provides it with a strong foundation for future
growth, yet its energy and mining industries are often held hostage to global economic
conditions that impact their performance. In addition, although it forces domestic investors
to look to foreign markets for diversification, it also creates an attractive opportunity for
foreign investors seeking to gain exposure to the energy and natural resource sector (see
Exhibit 1, previous page).
Derivatives trading occurs primarily on the Montreal Exchange (MX), a fully electronic
exchange where financial derivatives including equity options, options on ETFs, currency
options, index derivatives and interest rate derivatives trade. In addition, ICE Futures
Canada offers trading in agricultural derivatives with its most successful contract a Canola
futures contract.
Investor Base
Canadian financial markets are supported by demand from both domestic and international
investors. The domestic investor base is substantial and includes pension funds, insurance
companies, and mutual funds, as well as exchange traded funds (ETFs) that are seeing
rising assets under management. With assets of more than $3.2 trillion under management
they represent an important source of demand for Canada’s equity and fixed income cash
markets (see Exhibit 2).
Exhibit 2: Estimated Assets under Management in Selected Institutional Segments ($ Billions)
Source: CLHIA, IFIC, Statistics Canada, ETFInsights, TABB Group estimates
Canada’s equity and fixed income markets also enjoy considerable demand from foreign
investors that are attracted to its natural resource sectors, as well as its AAA rated
government debt markets.
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 3
Not surprisingly, US investors are active participants but Canada also attracts attention from
a broad range of international investors seeking to gain exposure to the natural resource
and financial sectors. According to Statistics Canada, foreign direct investment in Canadian
equities totaled $686.3 billion in 2013. More than half of the total came from US-based
accounts (51.3%), followed by European and Asian investors, who accounted for 31.9% and
13.1% of the total, respectively.
Canada’s bond markets are also growing as demand from money managers running global
macro and index strategies has reinforced domestic demand to add to an already active
trading environment. Net flows into Canadian fixed income securities (including government
and corporate debt) from international investors totaled $24.9 billion in the first eight
months of 2014, coming on the heels of significant net flows of $69.1 billion and $26.4
billion in 2012 and 2013, respectively.
Derivatives Trading in Canada
Canada’s derivatives markets appeal to a broad range of domestic and international
participants who use the country’s futures and options markets to generate income, make
directional plays and manage risk exposures for fixed income and equity portfolios.
Although stagnant volatility and economic weakness in the natural resource and commodity
sectors has caused trading in equity options to decline in recent years, the reverse is true
for its futures markets which have benefited from rising demand for fixed income exposure
(see Exhibit 3).
Exhibit 3: Futures and Options Trading on the Montreal Exchange
Annual Trading Volume 2001 to 2014 (as of October)
Source: Montreal Exchange, TABB Group
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 4
Although overall options volumes may be trending downward, the decline is likely to reverse
as recent spikes in volatility promise to stoke renewed interest in options trading. Rising
geopolitical tensions, concerns about international growth and the recent Ebola scare are
beginning to see growing investor attention, with the rising uncertainty resulting in
increased market volatility. Investors are also closely watching how US Federal Reserve
winds down its quantitative easing programs, with unanticipated adjustments met with
renewed volatility, especially in fixed income markets.
In addition, rising open interest suggests considerable demand exists to use futures and
options in longer term strategies, especially those intended to earn income or manage
longer term risk exposures. These types of strategies tend to build open interest, and thus,
volume, over time, as opposed to smaller, more speculative accounts that trade frequently
as part of short term directional or volatility strategies (see Exhibit 4).
Exhibit 4: Futures and Options Open Interest on the Montreal Exchange
2001 to 2014 (as of October)
Source: Montreal Exchange, TABB Group
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 5
Options Trading on MX
After a record year in 2011, options trading volumes have declined, falling victim to the
anemic volatility environment that has plagued derivatives markets around the world. In
addition, the global recession has resulted in falling commodity prices. Energy and mining
have borne the brunt of falling demand, which, six years after the recession's onslaught,
remains depressed. The decline in trading activity is most apparent in sector-specific
strategies, a situation expected to persist until the global economy fully recovers and
investor interest in the energy sector rebounds.
The vast majority of equity options traded on the MX are on individual equities, accounting
for 84% of the total, with volumes in ETF and S&P/TSX 60 index options representing 16%
of total activity (see Exhibit 5). Options on futures are also traded on the MX, with options
on bankers’ acceptances futures the most actively traded contract with just over 350,000
contracts traded in the first ten months of 2014.
Exhibit 5: Most Active Options on the Montreal Exchange
Jan-14 to Oct-14 trading volume (millions of contracts)
Source: Montreal Exchange
The Growing Presence of Institutional Investors in Options
Options trading in Canada is predominantly institutional, with traditional asset managers
(including pension funds, mutual funds and insurance companies) accounting for an
estimated 55% of total customer activity and trading by retail accounts and investment
advisors accounting for the remaining 45%.
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 6
The growing presence of institutional investors in Canadian options markets is a result of
both rising demand and a flexible market structure on MX that facilitates institutional flow
through a crossing mechanism first introduced in 2008. This capability allows specific types
of pre-arranged trades to be executed in the market after all orders in the central limit
order book at better or equal prices have been executed.
Although the crossing facility has been credited with building institutional participation on
the exchange, it does create challenges because it reduces the ability of market makers to
interact with customer order flow. Alternative methods of attracting market maker
participation with new mechanisms that improve their ability to interact with order flow is
and continues to be an important consideration to build liquidity.
Trading Choice Since many of the companies inter-listed in Canada and the US have options trading in each
market, the decision to trade Canada or US revolves around a number of factors.
Fees and commissions for institutional investors to trade options in the US or Canada are
roughly the same and so factors such as market quality metrics, execution price and fill
percentage are all incorporated into the trading decision.
As investors look at market quality and liquidity when deciding where to trade, the decision
to trade a derivative on an inter-listed stock needs to take each respective market structure
into account. Although US options markets may appear to have more liquidity, often times
investors need to balance the additional costs of trading in US markets against trading on
MX.
For example, an investor trading options on an inter-listed Canadian company needs to be
cognizant of the liquidity in the underlying cash market. Deeper home market liquidity
allows market makers and dealers to offer better pricing, since they are able to reduce
hedging costs and can manage their risk exposure more efficiently.
Another factor influencing Canadian institutions to use home markets is potential currency
risk for positions traded in US markets. Having to hedge a US dollar position adds a layer of
complexity and increases the cost of maintaining the position. Exposure to fluctuations in
US and Canadian dollars needs to be hedged by all but the most aggressive institutions.
Domestic institutions with limited foreign exchange exposure have little need to build out
these costly capabilities. Instead, they direct trading into MX listed options in order to lower
potential costs and minimize complexity of trading activities.
Futures Trading on MX
Futures trading on MX is concentrated in a small range of products, with two of the most
actively traded instruments fixed income products: the three-month bankers’ acceptances
future contract and the 10-year Canadian Government Bond futures contract.
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 7
Trading in these two products is driving much of the exchange’s volume growth, as rising
interest rate volatility resulting from shifts in global monetary policy attract hedging activity
from both domestic and international investors. Trading in the equity segment has been flat,
a by-product of low equity market volatility (see Exhibit 6).
Exhibit 6: Most Active Futures Contracts Traded on the Montreal Exchange
Jan-14 to Oct-14
Source: Montreal Exchange
Not only is rising international demand for access to fixed income exposure adding to
volumes but the regulatory preference for centrally-cleared products is slowly but surely
contributing to rising end user demand. For example, futures on bankers’ are increasingly
being used by investors seeking to hedge short term interest rate exposure associated with
their OTC activities as reference indices for many Canadian OTC floating rate swap
agreements are based on bankers’ acceptance rates. This increased demand bodes well for
the future, especially since investors are just beginning to use listed futures as an
alternative to OTC interest rate swap products.
The benchmark 10-year Canadian Government Bond futures contract is also seeing rising
international demand, as US and European-based customers are accounting for a growing
proportion of trading. MX has embraced these trends, opening offices in New York, London
and Singapore in an effort to attract a broader international investor base.
International demand should also drive growth in S&P/TSX 60 Index futures for two main
reasons. First, it’s the only contract that efficiently give investors broad exposure to the
Canadian equity market. Second, it also offers exposure to the energy and commodity
sectors, so when interest in those sectors returns, S&P/TSX 60 Index futures will benefit.
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 8
Canada’s derivatives markets will benefit from increased participation from a broader range
of institutional investors, a regulatory environment that favors centrally-cleared instruments
and ultimately, a more volatile trading environment. Indeed these are the same factors
driving growth in global derivatives markets.
What’s more, a broader range of market participants, not just large institutional investors
that have long been active users of listed and OTC derivatives, are increasingly exploring
ways to use derivatives to improve returns and manage risk. Use of derivatives by smaller
institutions represents a large growth opportunity as many of these institutions are just
beginning to use derivatives in their investment strategies.
To be sure, challenges associated with rising adoption from institutions exist. One of the
biggest challenges revolves around the time-consuming process of obtaining internal
approvals. Firm protocols for approving new trading strategies and instruments need to be
followed, presentations to management and investment committees need to be scheduled
and arranged, and ultimately, sign off from senior management needs to be obtained.
Despite this hurdle, rising demand from these segments will ultimately add to volumes.
OTC Market Developments
The Canadian regulatory environment is fragmented, with provincial bodies all having
authority over the financial industry within their respective jurisdictions. Each province and
territory in Canada has a regulatory agency but there is no true national regulatory
authority that operates at the federal level. Despite the fragmented structure (or perhaps
because of it) Canadian markets have avoided some of the regulatory missteps that have
dogged other countries and jurisdictions.
The lack of a national regulatory authority may also explain why Canada has not
implemented any major OTC derivatives regulatory changes. Instead, they have stayed on
the sidelines and let regulatory battles play out in US and Europe.
Although Canada has not effected a formal set of rules to regulate its OTC derivatives
markets, the global nature of OTC trading effectively forces market participants in Canada
to adhere to global best practices.
In the US, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (DFA) was
signed into law in July 2010, while European regulators addressed the issues through the
European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) and Market in Financial Instruments
Directive (MiFID) initiatives. The most far reaching components of the US and European
efforts are the requirements to centrally clear standardized OTC instruments, which will lay
the foundation for the shift of more liquid interest rate swaps to be traded on a regulated
trading facility such as an exchange, board of trade or swap execution facility.
The ultimate impact of this push will be rising costs since the buy side will now have to post
margin for all cleared swap transactions.
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 9
As these costs become more apparent and tangible, buy side managers will increasingly
explore the use of futures or futures swaps as more economic alternatives, driving more
demand for interest rate futures on MX.
The potential impact of investors switching from OTC to listed derivatives products could be
substantial, with trading in interest rate products expected to see substantial volume
growth, especially given the size of the Canadian dollar swap markets. According to
SwapClear, the Canadian dollar swap market measures $8.7 trillion in outstanding notional,
with $7 trillion of the total in interest rate swaps. Client notional volumes outstanding are
substantially smaller, with $727 billion of the total representing client cleared volumes (see
Exhibit 7).
Exhibit 7: Notional Amount Outstanding of Canadian Dollar Swaps Cleared on SwapClear
(Millions of contracts)
Source: SwapClear
As global clearing initiatives become mandated, a growing proportion of OTC swaps trading
will migrate to organized trading facilities such as exchanges and SEFs. The process will be
slow but steady as end users of swaps begin to evaluate the relative costs of centrally-
cleared OTC products against the costs of exchange-traded futures and options. The process
would accelerate dramatically if an iron clad regulatory mandate required all OTC swaps to
be centrally cleared and traded on exchanges.
Despite continued regulatory pressures to move OTC bilateral agreements onto exchanges
and into central clearing facilities, the utility of OTC remains a powerful attraction for larger
buy side institutions trading in size.
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 10
The ease in which a trade can be completed, along with the considerable flexibility in
structuring the details of the trade make OTC instruments a logical tool of choice for larger
buy side institutions with complex portfolio needs who have little alternative to OTC when
seeking to express a view on a position.
This is not to say that OTC swaps transactions will not eventually transition to interest rate
futures products. As end users begin to realize the explicit costs associated with margining
OTC swap instruments, listed markets will begin to see renewed demand. But the process
will be slow and only will add marginally to overall trading volumes.
Large investors with the need for size and structural flexibility use OTC products by
necessity but many small and medium sized investors are not able to participate in OTC
markets due to the complexity and necessary legal thresholds. These small- and medium-
size institutions represent an expanding sector that will increase their use of listed interest
rate futures for managing interest rate exposure, especially as new products like swap
futures become available on exchanges that provide similar structural capabilities as OTC
swaps.
Although equity swaps have effectively remained out of most of major global regulatory
initiatives, they will be impacted by efforts to improve the fiscal condition of global banks.
As these regulatory efforts are implemented, brokers will be forced to rationalize the cost of
providing capital, and will ultimately pass the higher costs on to clients. Although these
regulations will be phased in over a longer time frame, brokers are beginning to tighten the
amount of capital they extend to clients, especially smaller institutions without the
wherewithal to demand the banks attention.
A Look Ahead
Canadian derivatives markets are becoming an increasingly important part of global
financial markets, with both domestic and international investors focusing greater attention
on the use of derivatives as part of their investment strategies. Although anemic volatility
has hit trading volume, open interest in both options and futures continues to expand,
illustrating rising demand from institutions in using derivatives.
Canada’s conservative fiscal discipline is a prime factor behind the rising demand for
exposure to Canada, as investors in the country’s fixed income markets are attracted to its
financial stability and growing role as an international reserve currency. Continued gyrations
in global monetary policy will reinforce these trends, especially as global economies emerge
from recession and interest rate volatility reemerges.
The return of global economic growth also stands to benefit Canadian capital markets. As
growth reignites and price pressure on energy and commodities returns, the country’s
dominant energy and natural resource sector will see renewed interest from international
investors. Often considered both a benefit and a challenge, the concentration of these two
sectors in Canada’s economy will impact future growth prospects in both its stock and
derivatives markets.
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 11
Rising investor demand will also contribute to growth in Canada’s derivative markets.
Traditional asset managers such as pension funds, mutual funds and portfolio managers are
increasingly exploring the use of derivatives as part of strategies to provide investment
efficiencies, enhance income and ultimately improve returns. Part of the challenge in getting
this group to fully and enthusiastically embrace derivatives is education and market
acceptance.
Many of Canada’s small- and medium-sized asset managers are just beginning to explore
the potential benefits of using derivatives in investment strategies. These efforts will only
expand, especially as funds compete to attract new assets through improved returns and
risk management. Interest in using listed derivatives will only be enhanced through global
regulatory pressures designed to reduce risk and boost market transparency.
The wild card is the global pace of regulatory reform. As efforts to move OTC derivatives
onto central clearing mechanisms and organized trading facilities begin to gain steam, the
true costs associated with trading OTC instruments will become clear. As these costs
become transparent, investors will evaluate the best mix of instruments for gaining desired
exposure. When the regulatory dust settles, OTC instruments may still fit the needs of many
large investors while exchange-traded instruments will increasingly appeal to smaller and
mid-sized institutions looking for ways to manage risk and improve returns.
While still below the record volume peaks of a few years ago, Canada’s listed derivatives
markets are poised to benefit from three major trends moving in their favor: an improving
economic environment, regulatory initiatives and the return of market volatility. And
although some hurdles need to be cleared, both domestic and international investors are
showing signs of playing a bigger role in these markets.
Canadian Derivative Markets: Co-Existing in the Shadow of a Giant | November 2014
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 12
About
TABB Group
TABB Group is a financial markets research and strategic advisory firm focused exclusively
on capital markets. Founded in 2003 and based on the methodology of first-person
knowledge, TABB Group analyzes and quantifies the investing value chain, from the
fiduciary, investment manager and broker, to the exchange and custodian. Our goal is to
help senior business leaders gain a truer understanding of financial market issues and
trends so they can grow their businesses. The press regularly cites TABB Group members,
and members routinely speak at industry conferences and gatherings. For more information
about TABB Group, visit www.tabbgroup.com.
Author
Andy Nybo
Andy Nybo has more than 25 years of experience in research and technology applications in
the global capital markets, and is a Principal and Head of Derivatives at TABB Group.
Currently focusing his research efforts on the OTC and listed equity derivatives markets,
examining how technology is playing an increasingly integral role on both the buy-side and
sell-side desktops, he has written the following recent TABB Group studies: “US Retail
Options Trading: It Doesn’t Get Any Better Than This,” “US Options Trading 2013: Looking
for the Edge,” “US Options Market Making 2013: Scale, Scope and Survival,” “US Options
Trading 2012: Standing Out in the Crowd,” “Processing Complexity: Back Office Challenges
of Listed Derivatives,” “Innovations in Accessing Asia: Listed Equity Derivatives & Delta One
Products,” and “Accelerated Expirations: The Growing Relevance of Short Term Options.”
2014 The TABB Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. May not be reproduced by any means without express permission. | 13
www.tabbgroup.com
New York
+ 1.646.722.7800
Westborough, MA
+ 1.508.836.2031
London
+ 44 (0) 203 207 9027
top related