anesthetic training in resource-poor settings – our ...1department of anesthesia and perioperative...

1
Anesthetic Training in Resource-Poor Settings – Our Experience in Uganda Shin-e Lin, MD 1 ; Brian Kim, MD, MPH 1 ; Fred Bulamba, MD 2 ; Cornelius Sendagaire, MD 2 ; Michael Lipnick, MD 1 ; Stephen Kelleher, MD 3 ; Gerald Dubowitz, MB,ChB 1 1 Department of Anesthesia and Perioperative Care, University of California, San Francisco 2 Department of Anaesthesia, Makerere University 3 Department of Anesthesia, Stanford University Introduction Inadequate anesthe,c workforce and limited capacity for anesthesia training are major obstacles to the provision of surgical services in lowincome countries. Recent increases in enrollment of anesthesia residents at Makerere University (Kampala, Uganda) is encouraging and through an ongoing collabora,on between Makerere University and GPAS, we see an unique opportunity to further improve, streamline, and advance the anesthe,c training environment in Uganda. Our goal was to determine whether the implementa,on of a selfsustaining, lowcost orienta,on course based on those used for residents at Stanford and UCSF would improve access to highquality anesthe,c educa,on in Uganda. Methods Stanford and UCSF anesthesia residents have a rigorous, monthlong orienta,on program to introduce them to major concepts in anesthesia. The program includes: Key subject lectures Airway workshop OR simula,on sessions 1:1 supervised OR cases Video lectures We modeled an orienta,on course aQer the Stanford/UCSF programs modified it to make it lowcost and context appropriate with material tailored to the local prac,ce environment and designed to be taught by local anesthesiology faculty and senior trainees. Discussion Survey of par,cipants to determine whether each component of the orienta,on was helpful in preparing them for the opera,ng theater Scale 17 (1 – least helpful, 7 – most helpful) Ranking from 14 in terms of best experience Lectures, videos, airway workshop, simula,on Most helpful – Simula,on Overall 2fold improvement in feeling of preparedness The orienta,on course was successful and has been expanded and improved since its ini,al roll out. The airway workshop has been expanded to include an advanced airway workshop. Since its assembly, the simula,on center has remained in use on a regular basis by both the anesthesia department as well as other departments for resident training purposes. We constructed a lowcost, selfsustaining orienta,on course for new anesthesia residents consis,ng of lectures, an airway workshop, and a new, fullyfunc,onal simula,on center. This orienta,on course has been wellreceived by the trainees and represents a model for sustainable, posi,ve improvement in the quality of anesthesia educa,on in a resourcepoor seZngs. Acknowledgements L E C T U R E S Lectures Airway Workshop Simula6on Videos Constraints addressed: Low faculty:trainee ra,o No clear guidelines for key topics Limited didac,cs/instruc,on prior to clinical prac,ce in the first year of training Solu,ons: Premade standardized lectures containing core materials Designed so senior residents can give the lectures (not dependent on a^ending availability) Seven sta,ons to orient residents to available airway equipment Donated equipment Each sta,on prepackaged in compact boxes Contains easytofollow educa,onal goals and objec,ves A I R W A Y S I M U L A T I O N Built a lowcost simula,on center Repurposed parts for simula,on dummy Donated iPad apps Recording and playback capability for educa,onal purposes Taught senior residents to run full simula,ons Results 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Level of Preparedness 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 Order of helpfulness www.globalsurgery.org Niels Castle – SimMon soQware Department of Anesthesia Mak CHS, especially Ac,ng Head of Department, Dr. Agnes, and the residents and anesthesia staff who all helped create the sim sessions The University at Makerere and MakCHS for dona,ng the Sim center space V I D E O S Constraints addressed: Available educa,onal videos online oQen not applicable due to resource limita,ons Certain topics not amenable to lecture format Solu,ons: Helped residents generate videos applicable to prac,ce at Makerere Current videos: machine check, monitors h^p://www.globalsurgery.org/projects/capacitybuilding/educa,on/ anesthesiammedorienta,on/

Upload: others

Post on 13-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Anesthetic Training in Resource-Poor Settings – Our ...1Department of Anesthesia and Perioperative Care, University of California, San Francisco 2Department of Anaesthesia, Makerere

Anesthetic Training in Resource-Poor Settings – Our Experience in Uganda Shin-e Lin, MD1; Brian Kim, MD, MPH1; Fred Bulamba, MD2; Cornelius Sendagaire, MD2; Michael Lipnick, MD1;

Stephen Kelleher, MD3; Gerald Dubowitz, MB,ChB1 1Department of Anesthesia and Perioperative Care, University of California, San Francisco 2Department of Anaesthesia, Makerere University

3Department of Anesthesia, Stanford University

Introduction!Inadequate   anesthe,c   workforce   and   limited  capacity   for   anesthesia   training   are   major  obstacles   to   the   provision   of   surgical   services   in  low-­‐income   countries.   Recent   increases   in  enrollment   of   anesthesia   residents   at   Makerere  University   (Kampala,   Uganda)   is   encouraging   and  through   an   ongoing   collabora,on   between  Makerere  University  and  GPAS,  we  see  an  unique  opportunity   to   further   improve,   streamline,   and  advance   the   anesthe,c   training   environment   in  Uganda.      Our   goal   was   to   determine   whether   the  implementa,on   of   a   self-­‐sustaining,   low-­‐cost  orienta,on   course   based   on   those   used   for  residents   at   Stanford   and   UCSF   would   improve  access   to   high-­‐quality   anesthe,c   educa,on   in  Uganda.  

Methods!Stanford   and   UCSF   anesthesia   residents   have   a  rigorous,   month-­‐long   orienta,on   program   to  introduce   them   to   major   concepts   in   anesthesia.    The  program  includes:    •  Key  subject  lectures  •  Airway  workshop  •  OR  simula,on  sessions  •  1:1  supervised  OR  cases  •  Video  lectures  

We   modeled   an   orienta,on   course   aQer   the  Stanford/UCSF   programs   modified   it   to   make   it  low-­‐cost   and   context   appropriate   with   material  tailored   to   the   local   prac,ce   environment   and  designed   to   be   taught   by   local   anesthesiology  faculty  and  senior  trainees.  

Discussion!

Survey  of  par,cipants  to  determine  whether  each  component   of   the   orienta,on   was   helpful   in  preparing  them  for  the  opera,ng  theater  •  Scale  1-­‐7  (1  –  least  helpful,  7  –  most  helpful)  •  Ranking  from  1-­‐4  in  terms  of  best  experience  

²  Lectures,   videos,   airway  workshop,  simula,on  

²  Most  helpful  –  Simula,on  ²  Overall   2-­‐fold   improvement   in  

feeling  of  preparedness  

The   orienta,on   course   was   successful   and   has  been  expanded  and  improved  since   its   ini,al  roll-­‐out.   The  airway  workshop  has  been  expanded   to  include   an   advanced   airway   workshop.   Since   its  assembly,   the   simula,on   center   has   remained   in  use   on   a   regular   basis   by   both   the   anesthesia  department   as   well   as   other   departments   for  resident  training  purposes.      We   constructed   a   low-­‐cost,   self-­‐sustaining  orienta,on   course   for   new   anesthesia   residents  consis,ng  of   lectures,  an  airway  workshop,  and  a  new,   fully-­‐func,onal   simula,on   center.   This  orienta,on   course  has  been  well-­‐received  by   the  trainees   and   represents   a  model   for   sustainable,  posi,ve  improvement  in  the  quality  of  anesthesia  educa,on  in  a  resource-­‐poor  seZngs.    

Acknowledgements!

LECTURES

Lectures   Airway  Workshop  

Simula6on   Videos  

Constraints  addressed:  •  Low  faculty:trainee  ra,o  •  No  clear  guidelines  for  key  topics  •  Limited   didac,cs/instruc,on   prior   to   clinical  

prac,ce  in  the  first  year  of  training    Solu,ons:  •  Pre-­‐made   standardized   lectures   containing   core  

materials  •  Designed   so   senior   residents   can   give   the   lectures  

(not  dependent  on  a^ending  availability)  

Seven   sta,ons   to   orient   residents   to  available  airway  equipment  •  Donated  equipment  •  Each   sta,on   pre-­‐packaged   in  

compact  boxes  •  Contains   easy-­‐to-­‐follow   educa,onal  

goals  and  objec,ves  

AIRWAY

SIMULATION

Built  a  low-­‐cost  simula,on  center  •  Repurposed  parts  for  simula,on  dummy  •  Donated  iPad  apps  •  Recording   and   playback   capability   for  

educa,onal  purposes  Taught  senior  residents  to  run  full  simula,ons  

Results!

0  

1  

2  

3  

4  

5  

6  

7  

Level  of  Preparedness  

0  

0.5  

1  

1.5  

2  

2.5  

3  

3.5  

4  

Order  of  helpfulness  

www.globalsurgery.org  

•  Niels  Castle  –  SimMon  soQware  •  Department  of  Anesthesia  Mak  CHS,  especially  Ac,ng  Head  of  

Department,  Dr.  Agnes,  and  the  residents  and  anesthesia  staff  who  all    helped  create  the  sim  sessions  

•  The  University  at  Makerere  and  MakCHS  for  dona,ng  the  Sim  center  space  

VIDEOS

Constraints  addressed:  •  Available   educa,onal   videos   online   oQen   not  

applicable  due  to  resource  limita,ons  •  Certain  topics  not  amenable  to  lecture  format  Solu,ons:  •  Helped   residents   generate   videos   applicable   to  

prac,ce  at  Makerere  •  Current  videos:  machine  check,  monitors     h^p://www.globalsurgery.org/projects/capacity-­‐building/educa,on/

anesthesia-­‐mmed-­‐orienta,on/