angst to action 2016
TRANSCRIPT
FROM ANGST TO ACTION
Effective Climate Health Communication
AGENDA
What do we bring?
Where did we go wrong?
Healthy framing
Solutions
Connecting
Nuts and bolts
Motivating action
Putting it all together
Harris Poll 2014Occupational prestige
DoctorMilitary officer
FirefighterScientistNurse
EngineerPolice officer
ClergyArchitectAthleteTeacher
GALLUP POLL 2013 HONESTY AND ETHICS Highest LowestNursesPharmacistsTeachersDoctorsMilitary OfficersPoliceClergy
LawyersTV ReportersAdvertising AgentsState Office HoldersCar SalespeopleCongresspeopleLobbyists
CASE DISCUSSION:
Patient with blood pressure 200/120 taking his meds every other day.
Who are you talking to?
What do you want them to do?
Why aren't they doing it?
84% OF ALL VOTERS AND 72% OF GOP
78% support regulation of GHG emissions
59% support ending fossil fuel subsidies
68% support energy portfolio standards
63% (57% of Republicans) support programs to decrease car use
US PUBLIC OPINION
US should act on climate change even if it costs jobs and slows economic growth
US has a responsiblility to take steps to deal with climate change
Our government is not doing enough to deal with climate change
US should be willing to decrease GHGs if other countries sign a Copenhagen type agreement
MAJORITY OF RED & BLUE DISTRICTS AGREE
July 2014 Program for Public Consultation
Despite the fact that so many agree that US should do more on climate,
70% of those polled rarely or never discuss climate change with friends or family.
2016
and it remains a low priority (#16) for most Americans
What We Think About When We Try Not To Think About Global Warming: Stoknes, PE 2015
Why?
Distance
Doom
Denial
How does it make YOU feel?Frustrated Betrayed Depressed
Guilty Angry Sorry
Helpless Nervous Glimmer of hope
Anxious Apathetic Despair
Worried Optimistic Perplexed
Dumbfounded Distressed Exasperated
Solastalgia
Emotional distress resulting from damage to local environment
Solastalgia increases risk of clinical depression for people who experience:
Wildfire RR 1.29
Mountaintop removal RR 1.40
Dissonance
Identity
Solution Aversion
Campbell and Kay, 2014
Market solutions
Regulatorysolutions
HEALTH FRAMES
NEGATIVE
Disease
Disaster
Dystopia
Devils and Angels
POSITIVE
Healing the earth
Health Improvment
Caring
Preparedness & prevention
CENTER FOR CLIMATE COMMUNICATIONGeorge Mason University
6 GROUPSAlarmedConcernedCautiousDisengagedDoubtfulDismissive
Benefits more effective than harm
Maibach BMC Public Health 2010 10-299
Health harms of inaction
Health benefitsof action
O'Neill, S and Nicolson-Cole S. 2009
Solution images empower Problem images disempower
Benefits motivate actionregardless of climate belief
Bain, 2015
ACTION Vote Lifestyle Donate
“Redesigning our cities and towns to make it easier and safer to travel by foot, bicycle, and public transportation will reduce the
number of cars on the road, reduce carbon dioxide emissions, reduce traffic injuries and fatalities, and help people become
more physically active, lose weight, strengthen their bones, and possibly even
to remain mentally sharp as they age.”
Maibach, 2010
Health Benefits Induce HopeRegardless of Belief
Smith and Leiserowitz, 2013
Positive emotions correlate with Support for climate action
thesolutionsproject.org
We KNOW this stuffTOP 5 CAUSES OF DEATH IN US
Heart Disease (diabetes)
CancerChronic Lung DiseaseStrokeUnintentional Injury
(mva)
CAUSES OF THE CAUSESof death in developed countries
1) tobacco
2) high blood pressure
3) overweight and
obesity
4) physical inactivity
5) high blood glucose
6) high cholesterol
7) low fruit and vegetable intake
8) urban outdoor air pollution
9) alcohol
10) occupational
WHO 2009
UNDERLYING CAUSES
Air pollution
Car centric built environment
Industrial agriculture and food system
75 cents of every health care dollar
Is spent on preventable chronic disease
CLEAN AIRBetter pediatric lung function
Lower incidence of asthma
Fewer cardiac events
Lower CVD mortality
Less obesity
Less DM2 and insulin resistance
Less autism, ADD, behavior and learning problems
WALKABLE COMMUNITIESLess DM
Less CVD
Less overweight and obesity
More physical activity
Lower BP
3 years additional life expectancy
PUBLIC TRANSIT
More physical activity
Lower MVA mortality
Lower obesity and overweight
Decreased health spending per capita
LESS MEAT, MORE VEGGIESProspective and intervention studies:
Lower rates of DM
CVD
Cancer
Metabolic syndrome
Specific and all cause mortality
FINDING AN AUDIENCE
CONNECTING WITH YOUR AUDIENCE
Get personal
Share an experience that spurred you to act.
Find common ground / identity.
VALUES WHICH RESONATE
RESPONSIBILITY1) We owe it to our kids and future generations2) Its important to respect and take care of the planet3) We should prevent human harm and suffering
DEMOCRACY1) Its time to break Big Oil's stranglehold on Washington
PATRIOTISM1) Americans have the ingenuity and resourcefulness to
tackle this problem
Tailoring your talk to fit your listeners
Row 1 Row 2 Row 3 Row 40
2
4
6
8
10
12
Column 1Column 2Column 3
People in pictures should look like audience
Make it local
Farm on former football field, Dallas.
TELL SUCCESS STORIES Jeffery Thompson MD
Gundersen Lutheran Health System LaCrosse, WI
Sam Moody Atlanta, GA
CARMAGEDDON Los Angeles, CA
Ultrafine Particulates down 83 % PM2.5 down 36 percent
ER Visits UCLA decreased 23%ER Visits Mt Sinai decreased 13%911 calls decreased 12%
Isiah Webb, Hospital Farmer
LANGUAGE
Align with public's priorities ENVIRONMENTAL Pollution Clean energy
HEALTH ObesityCancerDiabetesHeart disease
Avoid jargon and triggers
EnvironmentCo-benefitsEmissions, GHGCarbon tax, cap & tradeRenewable energyActive transportationEnergy EfficiencySustainable agriculture
Air we breath, water we drink etcBetter healthPollutionMake polluters payClean energySafe & easy walking and bikingCut wasteHealthy food and farms
Be mindful of literacy level
QUICK AND DIRTY READING LEVEL
# of 3+ syllable words
0-1 in 30 sentences 4th grade1 in 10 sentences 5th grade1 in 5 sentences 6th grade1 in 2-3 sentences 7th grade1 per sentence 8th grade
LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD
MAKE BIG POLLUTERS PAY
Fruits and Vegetables prevent chronic disease and multi-morbidity
Ruel, Clinical Nutrition Volume 33, Issue 3, Pages 513–520, June 2014
Mediterranean Diet Prevents Obesity, Heart Disease and Diabetes
Decrease in O3 and PM 2.5 with 3 Climate Policy Options
Clean Electricity Std Transportation Carbon Tax
T Thompson, Nature Climate Change (July 2014)
20,000 Heart Attacks PREVENTED200,000 Deaths each year
SAVED: OVER 100 BILLION DOLLARS PER YEAREPA 2013
HUMOR
300,000 Heart Attacks/Strokes PREVENTED260,000 New Diabetes Cases127,000 CVD Deaths each year144,000 Cancer Deaths
METHANE
Control Your Own Blood Sugar in 3 Easy Steps
WHY DID IT WORK?Rider: How solution works.
Elephant: Partnership, Participation, Success
Path: Broken down into steps. Clear instructions.
Will we gain or lose?
How do we get there from here?
What can I do (and how do I do it)?
COGNITIVE PROCESSING
Analytic Experiential
Logical, abstract, deliberative,Learned, slow
Intuitive, concrete, immediate,Visual, emotional, past experience
3 D's of inaction
Disempowered
Demoralized
Don't know how
20 Years Ago
Coffee(with whole milk and sugar)
Today
Mocha Coffee
45 calories 8 ounces ?
PARTICIPATION
Which 5 US cities have the worst air in the country?
Not enough is being done and we're all going to fry if we don't change.
We're already making some progress on the path to a healthier future.
SENSE OF MOMENTUM
THE POWER OF GROUPS
CLEAR INSTRUCTIONS
The evolution of a message
BEFORE
AFTER
What changed
Specific actionShort term personal benefitsEnvironmentStoryAppealed to identityCredible messengerPositive emotionsInstructions
AbstractLong term societal dangersClimate change StatementNo connection to audienceUnknown messengerNegative emotionsNo instructions
THE MESSENGER Mobilize the majority.
Inspire hope, not fear.
Talk about people, pollution and solutions.
Start where people are and build bridges.
Use humor. Tell stories. Show pictures. Invite participation.
Enlist the power of groups.
Don't leave without a plan.
THE MESSAGE
We've got solutions.
They will make us healthier now.
A majority of Americans want them.
They work.
We have to change policies, not individuals.
We're part way there already.
Here's what you can do:
What just happened? Connect with you as a human being
Start where you were
Tell you stories
Make you laugh
Talk about benefits relevant to you
Get you to participate
Involve the group
Help you feel moreEmpowered, competent, hopeful
HEALTHY PEOPLE = HEALTHY PLANET
www.climate911.org