“surgical spending” for pavement preservation · from surface score history 0 ... lane miles...

85
1 “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation 2007 School for Highway Superintendents

Upload: others

Post on 23-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

1

“Surgical Spending” forPavement Preservation

2007 School for Highway Superintendents

Page 2: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

2

Outline

• How we know which roads to fix.• Windows of opportunity for treatment.• Treat the pavement early.• Less expensive to keep good roads good.• Tools in the toolbox

Page 3: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

How do we decidewhich roads to fix?

Page 4: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Pavement Management

The Right Pavementwith the Right Treatment

at the Right Time

Page 5: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Pavement Management

How do we identifycandidates for work?

Page 6: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Network Level Windshield Survey

Page 7: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

7

Pavement Surface Score

• 10 – 9: Excellent• 7 – 8: Good• 6: Fair• <5: Poor

Page 8: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

89/10 – Excellent

Page 9: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

98 - Good

Page 10: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

107 - Good

Page 11: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

116 - Fair

Page 12: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

125 - Poor

Page 13: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

134 - Poor

Page 14: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

14

Page 15: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

E-Score Hardware

Page 16: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

16

Page 17: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

17

Pavement Surface Score

10 – 9: Do Nothing8: Crack Seal7: PM Paving6: Rehab

<5: Major Rehab/Replace

Page 18: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

18

Pavement Surface Score

10 – 9: Do Nothing8: Crack Seal7: PM Paving6: Rehab

<5: Major Rehab/Replace

Page 19: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Pavement Management

Pavement Preservation Strategy

Page 20: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years

Typical Pavement Deterioration Curvefrom Surface Score History

0

Flex/Overlay

Page 21: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

21

Page 22: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

22

Page 23: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

23

What are we trying to do with Preventive Maintenance?

• Seal cracks to keep water out

• Rejuvenate a weathered surface

• Prolong life of the pavement

Page 24: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

24

Side Benefits ofPreventive Maintenance

• Restores friction

• Some improvement to ride quality

• Some repair to rutting

Page 25: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Pavement Management

Pavement Preservation Strategy

Page 26: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 27: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 28: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

28

Page 29: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

29

Page 30: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

30

Page 31: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

5

6

7

8

9

10

Time

Con

dit io

n R

atin

g

Pavement Performance Curveand Windows of OpportunityDo Nothing

Non-Paving PM

PM Paving

Multi-Course

Major Rehab/Recon

Page 32: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

PM Overlay by Initial Surface Score

5.0

6.0

7.0

8.0

9.0

10.0Y

1

Y2

Y3

Y4

Y5

Y6

Y7

Y8

Y9

Y10

Y11

Project Age

Surfa

ce S

core Score 6

Score 7

Page 33: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

Page 34: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

Page 35: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

Page 36: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

Page 37: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

Page 38: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

Page 39: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

Page 40: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

Page 41: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

$25k $25k $100k

Page 42: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

$1M

Page 43: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

20105 15 25 30

6

7

8

9

10

5

Years0

$150k $1M

Page 44: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s

Page 45: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

sWorst First

Page 46: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

sWorst First

Page 47: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

sWorst First

Page 48: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

sWorst First

Page 49: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

sWorst First

Page 50: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s Worst First

Page 51: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s Worst First

Page 52: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s Worst First

Page 53: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s

Pavement Preservation

Page 54: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s

Pavement Preservation

Page 55: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s

Pavement Preservation

Page 56: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s

Pavement Preservation

Page 57: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s

Pavement Preservation

Page 58: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s

Pavement Preservation

Page 59: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s

Pavement Preservation

Page 60: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 61: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

61

Page 62: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 63: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

63

Page 64: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 65: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

65

Page 66: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 67: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 68: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 69: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

October 3, 2000 17th Annual AGC Texas Trade &Equipment Show

Neil Insert Picture on this slide

Micro-Surfacing Operation

Page 70: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 71: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

NovaChip

Page 72: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 73: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management
Page 74: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

74

Page 75: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

75

Page 76: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

76

Type I

Page 77: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

77

Type II

Page 78: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

78

Page 79: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

79

Page 80: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

80

Page 81: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

81

Pavement Preservation Tools• Crack Sealing• Chip Seal• Quick-set Slurry• Microsurfacing• Paver-Placed

Surface Treatment• Single Course HMA• Mill and Fill• Cold-in-Place

Recycling

Page 82: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Far less expensive to keep good pavements good.

Treat the pavement early before distress becomes severe.

The time window is narrow for optimal performance.

#1

#2

#3

Page 83: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Poor Fair Good Excel

Lane

Mile

s

Key Concept of Pavement Preservation

Page 84: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

Questions?

Page 85: “Surgical Spending” for Pavement Preservation · from Surface Score History 0 ... Lane Miles Key Concept of Pavement Preservation. Questions? 85 Rick Bennett Pavement Management

85

Rick BennettPavement [email protected]