appendix a crc financial plan
TRANSCRIPT
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 1/51
Costs, Benefits andFinancial Feasibility
Preliminary Results
June 17, 2010
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 2/51
Analysis Components
2
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 3/51
Agenda
• Cost and schedule estimates from latest CEVP• Assumptions
• Key cost and schedule risks
• Summary of results
• Project Worthiness
• Modeling assumptions
• Summary of results
• Financial Feasibility Analysis
• Tolling Analysis:• Modeling assumptions
• Traffic and revenue projections
• Key risks and issues• Financial Model
• Modeling assumptions
• Financial feasibility
3
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 4/51
Scenarios under Consideration
LPA (Full Build)• New crossing over Columbia River
• I-5 highway improvements,including 7 interchanges, north
and south of river• Extension of light rail from Expo
Center in Portland to Clark Collegein Vancouver, with associatedtransit improvements
• Bicycle and pedestrian
improvements throughout projectcorridor
• System and demandmanagement, including toll
LPA Phase 1
• Most project elements built inPhase 1
• Some construction deferred:
• I-5 braided on- and off-ramps at Victory Boulevard
• Marine Drive interchange flyover
• Northern half of the I-5/SR 500interchange
• New crossing striped for 10highway lanes rather than 12
4
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 5/51
Cost Risk Assessment Objectives
Encouraging pro-activity and early planning
Building confidence and credibility in project’s plansand estimates
Developing targeted mitigation strategies for allanticipated threats
Better allocation of risks and identification of projectdelivery methods
Ensuring transparency, integrity, and accountabilitythroughout the life-cycle of the project
Maximizing the Likelihood of Meeting On-Time, On-Budget Goals
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 6/51
Cost Estimate Validation Process (CEVP)
• Process overview:
• Review of base schedule and base cost estimates
• Quantification of uncertainties
• Identification and quantification of project-type risks
• Events occurring in planning, design, bidding, construction and changed conditions• Political, management continuity and “Acts of God” generally not considered
• Identification of mitigation strategies
• Risk tracking and updates
• Outcomes:
• A “snapshot in time” • Probability distributions for project completion date and project cost
• Ranking of quantified risks
6
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 7/51
Project Flowchart, LPA Full Build
7
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 8/51
Base Cost
Estimates
# DESCRIPTION LPA FULL BUILD LPA Phase 1
1 Prepare & Publish FEIS $3,000,000 $3,000,000
2 PE - Highway and Columbia River Bridges $45,930,366 $41,372,990
3 FTA Pre-PE Review $862,236 $862,236
5 Transit Modeling and 15% PE $2,586,708 $2,586,708
6 Pre-ROD Environmental Permitting $9,725,455 $8,965,892
7 Review for ROD $600,000 $600,0009a ROW - Highway and Columbia River Bridges $77,894,270 $77,894,270
9b Agreements $200,000 $200,000
10a PS&E - Highway and Columbia River Bridges $103,264,187 $94,130,309
10b PS&E - Transit $20,392,172 $20,392,172
11 ROW - Transit $31,345,260 $31,345,260
12a PE - Transit $5,173,415 $5,173,415
13 Post-ROD Environmental Permitting $9,725,455 $8,965,892
14 A/B/A - Bridges and SR 14 & Hayden Island Interchanges $4,500,000 $4,500,000
15 Construction - Columbia River Bridges $521,864,398 $496,986,647
16 Construction - SR 14 Interchange, Stage 1 to 3 $187,708,200 $186,978,653
17 Construction - Hayden Island Interchange, Stage 1 to 3 $227,359,733 $204,343,675
18 Advertise/Bid/Award - Transit $1,500,000 $1,500,000
19 Procurement - LRVs $84,162,400 $84,162,400
20 Construction - Transit, Oregon $105,027,492 $105,106,549
21 Construction - Transit, Washington $236,674,435 $236,852,586
22 Advertise/Bid/Award - Marine Drive Interchange $1,500,000 $1,500,000
23 Advertise/Bid/Award - Mill Plain Interchange $1,500,000 $1,500,000
24 Advertise/Bid/Award - Fourth Plain Interchange $1,500,000 $1,500,000
25 Advertise/Bid/Award - SR 500 Interchange $1,500,000 $0
26 Construction - Columbia River Bridges $57,984,933 $55,220,739
28 A/B/A - Demolish Existing Columbia River Bridges $500,000 $500,00029 Construction - SR 14 Interchange, Stage 4 to 7 $143,559,194 $142,829,647
30a Construction - Hayden Island Interchange, Stage 4 to 7 $172,886,815 $155,749,677
31 Construction - Marine Drive Interchange $262,116,682 $234,979,929
32 Construction - Mill Plain Interchange $44,341,605 $44,224,400
33 Construction - Fourth Plain Interchange $79,611,308 $79,400,877
34 Construction - SR 500 Interchange $79,048,170 $5,367,548
35 Construction - Columbia River Bridges, LRT $7,352,295 $7,352,295
36 Construction - Demolish Existing Columbia River Bridges $49,789,739 $49,789,739
37 Construction - Transit, Burn $2,636,667 $2,636,667
TOTAL PROJECT BASE COST $2,585,323,590 $2,398,471,172
8
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 9/51
Build-Up of LPA Phase 1 Cost Curve
9
LPA Phase 1 Scenario Costs by Category and Probability of NOT Exceeding (Millions $'s)
Cost Curve Build-UpCategory
Effect 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%
Base Cost EstimateProject Base Costwithout Risk or
Escalation$2,398 $2,398 $2,398 $2,398 $2,398 $2,398 $2,398 $2,398 $2,398
Base Costs + Budget UncertaintyBase Costs Budget
Uncertainty Effect
$1,971 $2,106 $2,210 $2,297 $2,376 $2,452 $2,534 $2,631 $2,758
Base Costs + Budget Uncertainty+ Escalation (Base Schedule)
Escalation Effect toBase Schedule
$2,281 $2,438 $2,558 $2,660 $2,751 $2,840 $2,935 $3,048 $3,195
Base Costs + Budget Uncertainty+ Escalation (Risk Adjusted
Schedule)
Escalation Effectdue to Schedule
Event Risks$2,309 $2,471 $2,595 $2,699 $2,789 $2,877 $2,977 $3,087 $3,240
Base Costs + Budget Uncertainty+ Escalation (Risk Adjusted
Schedule) + Event Risks
Cost Impact due toCost Event Risks
$2,532 $2,690 $2,811 $2,918 $3,016 $3,109 $3,205 $3,322 $3,479
Base Costs + Budget Uncertainty+ Escalation (Risk AdjustedSchedule) + Event Risks + Additional Support Costs
Cost Impact due to Additional Support
Costs due toExtended Overhead
Costs
$2,604 $2,763 $2,883 $2,992 $3,088 $3,184 $3,283 $3,400 $3,554
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 10/51
Probabilistic LPA Phase 1 Cost
10
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 11/51
Build-Up of LPA Full Build Cost Curve
11
LPA Scenario Costs by Category and Probability of NOT Exceeding (Millions $'s)
Cost Curve Build-UpCategory
Effect 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%
Base Cost EstimateProject Base Costwithout Risk or
Escalation$2,585 $2,585 $2,585 $2,585 $2,585 $2,585 $2,585 $2,585 $2,585
Base Costs + Budget UncertaintyBase Costs Budget
Uncertainty Effect
$2,119 $2,265 $2,378 $2,472 $2,557 $2,640 $2,728 $2,833 $2,969
Base Costs + Budget Uncertainty+ Escalation (Base Schedule)
Escalation Effect toBase Schedule
$2,453 $2,623 $2,754 $2,864 $2,963 $3,059 $3,162 $3,283 $3,442
Base Costs + Budget Uncertainty+ Escalation (Risk Adjusted
Schedule)
Escalation Effectdue to Schedule
Event Risks$2,483 $2,657 $2,792 $2,905 $3,003 $3,099 $3,206 $3,324 $3,489
Base Costs + Budget Uncertainty+ Escalation (Risk Adjusted
Schedule) + Event Risks
Cost Impact due toCost Event Risks
$2,708 $2,877 $3,008 $3,128 $3,228 $3,330 $3,434 $3,558 $3,723
Base Costs + Budget Uncertainty+ Escalation (Risk AdjustedSchedule) + Event Risks + Additional Support Costs
Cost Impact due to Additional Support
Costs due toExtended Overhead
Costs
$2,775 $2,943 $3,072 $3,190 $3,295 $3,400 $3,503 $3,626 $3,793
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 12/51
Probabilistic LPA Full Build Cost
12
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 13/51
Tornado Chart – Top Risks Impacting Cost
Estimates – LPA Scenario
13
Notes: The numbers in parentheses following the risk description identify which flow chart activities each risk can affect.
Costs presented are the average or expected value impacts, these values compare closely to 50
th
percentile costs.
Principal Cost Risks
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 14/51
Probabilistic LPA Phase 1 Completion Date
14
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 15/51
Probabilistic LPA Full Build Completion Date
15
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 16/51
Tornado Chart – Top Risks Impacting
Schedule Estimates – LPA Scenario
16
Notes: The numbers in parentheses following the risk description identify which flow chart activities each risk can affect.Delays presented are the average or expected value impacts, these values compare closely to 50th percentile delays.
Principal Schedule Risks
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 17/51
Summary of CEVP Results
17
Scenario
Total Cost (millions of YOE dollars)
Lower 10% Median60%
Likelihood90%
Likelihood
LPA Phase 1 $2,604 $3,088 $3,184 $3,554
LPA Full Build $2,775 $3,295 $3,400 $3,793
Scenario
Completion Date
Lower 10% Median60%
Likelihood
90%
Likelihood
LPA Phase 1 Jun-2019 Feb-2020 Apr-2020 Jan-2021
LPA Full Build Oct-2019 May-2020 July-2020 Feb-2021
Financial Model
Inputs
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 18/51
Project
WorthinessCost Benefit Analysis
18
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 19/51
Measuring Project Objectives
• The CRC project is focused on addressing6 problems identified in the I-5 corridorwhile meeting community needs andminimizing impacts:
• Safety and vulnerability to collisions
• Growing travel demand and congestion
• Impaired freight movement
• Limited public transportation operation,
connectivity and reliability• Substandard pedestrian and bicycle
facilities
• Seismic vulnerability
19
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 20/51
Benefit-Cost Analysis Principles
• Evaluates the effects of a project or policy on people’squality of life (social welfare)
• Considers a net increase in welfare as a good thing, even
if some groups within society lose out
• Focuses on “monetized” costs and benefits
• not all effects can be quantified
• not all quantifiable effects can be monetized
• Benefits and costs are measured by how individuals valuethem (willingness-to-pay)
20
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 21/51
Categories and Distribution of Benefits
CATEGORY
OF BENEFITS
DISTRIBUTION OF BENEFITS
Transit Customer Benefits Highway User BenefitsCommunity and
Neighborhood Benefits
CongestionManagementBenefits
Value of travel time savings to transit users.
Value of travel time savings to highway users.
Value of improvements in region-wide reductions in vehicle operating costs and improvements in air quality and transportation safety.
MobilityBenefits
Value of transit to low income users as an alternative to less affordable or unaffordable transportation.
Value of cross-sector benefits and burdens on home-based social services.
Value of reduced pockets of structural unemployment and improved welfare-to-work mobility.
CommunityDevelopmentBenefits
Value of transit-oriented development, including shorter trip lengths and lower auto dependence.
Value of neighborhood economic development and amenity in relation to both residential and mixed use land uses.
Value reduced auto- dependence and lower total vehicle miles of travel.
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 22/51
Average Speed and Travel Time Savings for Auto Trips along I-5
22
Average Auto Speed in Peak Period(miles per hour) 2020 2030 2040
Base 24.2 21.7 15.4
LPA Full Build 34.2 29.8 21.2
LPA Phase 1 34.2 29.8 21.2
Average Time Savings per Auto Trip in Peak
Period (minutes)
2020 2030 2040
LPA Full Build 11.7 12.1 17.3
LPA Phase 1 11.6 12.0 17.2
Average Time Savings per Auto Trip ($2009) 2020 2030 2040
LPA Full Build $2.86 $2.95 $4.23
LPA Phase 1 $2.85 $2.94 $4.22
Note: The Average trip length is 16.1 miles , and the value of time is $18. Value of Time is based on the 2005 Oregon DOT study, The Value of Travel-Time: Estimates of the Hourly Value of Time for Vehicles in Oregon.
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 23/51
Average Saving per Driver (Commuter)
using the New Columbia River Crossing
23
Note: All monetary values are expressed in 2009 dollars. * Assuming 500 one-way commuting trips per year.
LPA Full Build
Average Savingper One-Way Trip
Annual Savingper Commuter *
In 2020 In 2040 In 2020 In 2040
Out-of-Pocket Cost Saving(fuel, oil, vehicle depreciation, etc.)
$0.51 $0.62 $257 $311
Travel Time Saving(at average value of time)
$2.86 $4.23 $1,428 $2,114
Total Saving $3.37 $4.85 $1,685 $2,425
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 24/51
Average Saving per Low-Income Rider
24
2020 2040
Number of Low Income Ridersduring Peak Period, trips/day 1,810 3,210
Average Annual Saving in TransportationCosts per Low Income Household, $/year *
$1,880 $4,510
Note: All monetary values are expressed in 2009 dollars. * Assuming 500 one-way commuting trips per year.
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 25/51
Expected Uplift in Property Values
25
ResidentialProperties
CommercialProperties
Estimated Number of Properties in Vicinity of LRT Stations (within 3 blocks) 2,450 1,950
Average Increase in Property Value Due toTransit, $ per property
$10,740 $83,260
Average Percentage Increase in Property Value
+7% +18%
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 26/51
Summary of BCA Output
26
Categories of Benefits & Costs LPA Full Build LPA Phase 1
Affordable Mobility Value to Low Income Households $128.4 $136.4
Cross Sector Benefits $8.6 $8.6Total Affordable Mobility $137.0 $145.0Economic Development
Residential Development $26.2 $26.2Commercial Development $161.8 $161.8
Total Economic Development $188.0 $188.0Congestion Management
Travel Time Savings $2,365.8 $2,357.8 Accident Cost Savings $470.5 $472.7
Vehicle Operating Cost Savings $368.5 $344.8Emission Cost Savings $11.3 $11.8Total Congestion Management $3,216.1 $3,187.1Salvage Value $574.7 $538.8Bridge Lift Time Savings $94.4 $94.4Grand Total Benefits $4,210.2 $4,153.3
Project CostsCapital Costs $2,258.1 $2,117.1Operation and Maintenance Costs -$67.3 -$67.3
Disruption Costs $44.6 $44.2Total Project Costs $2,235.4 $2,094.0
Net Present Value $1,974.9 $2,059.4Benefit/Cost Ratio 1.9 2.0Internal Rate of Return, % 4.36% 4.46%
Mean Expected outcomes over 30 years of operation; 2.8% real discount rate Note: All monetary values are expressed in millions of 2009 dollars
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 27/51
Net Present Value
27
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
($4,000.0) ($2,000.0) $0.0 $2,000.0 $4,000.0 $6,000.0 $8,000.0 $10,000.0
P r o b a b i l i t y
o f N o t E x c e e d i n g
Net Present Value, Millions of 2009 Dollars
LPA LPA Phase 1
Over 80%probability of
breaking even
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 28/51
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
(2.00) (1.00) 0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00
P r o b a b i l i t y o
f N o t E x c e e d i n g
Benefit-Cost Ratio
LPA LPA Phase 1
Benefit/Cost Ratio
28
Over 80%probability of
breaking even
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 29/51
Financial Feasibility Analysis
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 30/51
Financial Analysis and Planning
• Project Revenues
• Toll Bond Proceeds
• Federal Discretionary Highway Funds
• Oregon and Washington Highway Funds• FTA Section 5309 New Starts Funds
• Project Costs:
• Capital Costs (CEVP©)• O&M Costs
30
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 31/51
Tolling Analysis Assumptions(December 2009)
• New bridge would open for toll revenue operations on July 1, 2018
• Ramp-up factor of 85% applied in first year and 95% applied in second year
• with both I-5 and I-205 tolled: 95% in first year and 97.5% in second
• 100% electronic toll collection, with no cash alternative:
• user account (transponder) or license plate list-based payment (pay-by-plate)
• transponder penetration starts at 71% and increases 2% per year to 85% max
• pay-by-plate surcharge to recover cost:
• $1.22 per transaction (in 2018 $) if I-5 only tolled
• $1.15 (in 2018 $) per transaction if I-5 and I-205 tolled
• Gross revenue reduced by 4.5% in first year and 3.45% every year thereafterto account for bank card / credit card fees
• 5% of tolls uncollectable (e.g., violations, delinquent accounts)
31
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 32/51
• Traffic projections developed for two years only
• 2015 and 2030
• Intermediate years obtained by linear interpolation
• Use of two modeling approaches
• METRO regional travel demand model
• Post-processing model
• Toll modeled as “equivalent” increase in travel time• Value of time held constant in real terms between 2015
and 2030
32
Toll Modeling Assumptions(December 2009)
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 33/51
Alternative Tolling Scenarios(December 2009)
• For all scenarios:
• Tolls are in $2006
• Tolls are for vehicles withtransponders or registeredlicense plates
• Medium and large trucks paytolls 2X and 4X passenger cartoll rates, respectively
• Surcharge for “pay-by-plate”,where applicable
• Tolls increase by 2.5% peryear (constant in real terms)
33
Source: 3.0-Rep-AF3007-10-01-01.toll_scenario_funding_report.pdf
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 34/51
Toll Elasticities
34
Estimated Implied Elasticities by Scenario
Tolling of I-5 Only Elasticity
Lower than DEIS Toll Rates on I-5 Bridge Only Base case
Flat Toll Rate on I-5 Bridge Only -0.28
DEIS With Additional Price Points -0.52
1.5*DEIS Tolls Rates on I-5 Only -0.38
2*DEIS on I-5 Only -0.35
3*DEIS on I-5 Only -0.32
DEIS Rates on I-5 and I-205 Bridges 0.00
Tolling of I-5 and I-205
Lower than DEIS Toll Rates on I-5 and I-205 Bridges Base case
DEIS Toll Rates on I-5 Bridge and Lower I-205 Toll -0.20
User Input % Deviation from peak DEIS Toll 0.00
* Using Post-Processing Model Data
Bridge and Tunnel Elasticities From Other Studies
Toll Road / Type of Toll Road Elasticity Low High Source
Bridges-0.15 -0.31
Wuestefel and Regan (1981), 16 Tolled infrastructures in U.S.
(roads, dridges, and tunnels)
Bridge - Peak -0.21 -0.36
Bridge - Off-Peak -0.14 -0.29
Bridges-0.05 -0.15
Harvey(1994), Golden Gate Bridge, San Francisco Bay Bridge,
and Everett Turnpike in New Hampshire (U.S.)
Bridges and Tunnels
-0.25 -0.01 -0.50
Hirschman, McNight, Paaswell, Pucher, and Berechman (1995),
Six bridges and two tunnels in the New York City area, U.S.
Henry Hudson Bridge - Passenger Cars -0.50
Verrazano Bridge - Passenger Cars -0.10
Brooklyn Battery - Tunnel - Light Trucks -0.54
Queens Midtown Tunnel - Light Trucks -0.45
Triboro Manhattan Plaza - Light Trucks -0.07
White-Stone Bridge - Light Trucks -0.13
Throg's Neck Bridge - Light Trucks -0.12
Verrazano Bridge - Light Trucks -0.17
Brooklyn Battery - Tunnel - Heavy Trucks -0.60
Hirschman, McNight, Pucher (1994), Bridge and tunnel toll
elasticities in New York
White (1984), quoted in Oum et al. (1992), Bridge in
Southampton, UK
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 35/51
Summary of Traffic & Revenue Projections
35
Toll Scenario
In 2015 In 2030
I-5 Volume
I-205 Volume
TotalRevenue
I-5 Volume
I-205 Volume
TotalRevenue
T o l l i n g
I - 5
O n l y
DEIS Toll Rate 133.4 205.6 $337.0 170.6 234.6 $625.4
Lower than DEIS Toll Rate 143.6 198.6 $293.5 180.4 227.6 $533.4
Flat Toll Rate 129.8 201.4 $329.5 166.2 229.6 $609.9
Additional Price Points 126.2 210.4 $356.0 163.4 239.2 $668.0
1.5*DEIS Toll Rate 105.6 220.0 $395.4 142.0 247.4 $773.8
2*DEIS Toll Rate 80.6 231.0 $397.7 116.2 257.4 $837.9
3*DEIS Toll Rate 41.4 243.6 $288.3 74.8 269.0 $783.2
T o l l i n g
I - 5
a n d
I - 2 0
5 DEIS Toll Rate 174.0 148.2 $802.9 210.2 178.0 $1401.9
Lower than DEIS Toll Rate 176.4 151.0 $652.6 213.0 181.2 $1139.1
Lower I-205 Toll 167.0 157.8 $731.1 203.2 188.0 $1,277.0
Source: Columbia River Crossing, Description of Revised Toll Model and Traffic and Gross Revenue Projections for Tolling Scenarios, January 2010.Notes: Traffic in thousands of trips; toll revenues in thousands of dollars. Traffic estimates from METRO’s Regional Travel Demand Model.
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 36/51
Revenue Projections
36
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 37/51
Financial Feasibility
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 38/51
Financial Planning Framework
38
60% CostEstimates a
PNSFederalFunding
ODOT
Funding90% CostEstimates
New StartsFederalFunding
WSDOTFunding
VariousTolling
Scenarios
Project
Schedule
Financial Feasibility(i.e. shortage/Surplus,
Debt Service Coverage)
Potential Revenues
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 39/51
Allocated Funds
39
Existing Funds By Source (In Millions)
ODOTFunding
JTA $30.0
WDOTFunding
TPA $50.0
Federal InterstateMaintenance
$1.0 FY 2010 IMD Funds $2.0
FY09 IMD Funds $3.3 FY 2009 IMD Funds $1.3
FY08 IMD Funds $0.7 SAFETEA-LU $9.5
FY07 IMD: Corridors of the Future
$15.0State MatchingFunds
$0.1
SAFETEA-LU $5.6 Federal Earmarks $5.0
OTIA III $5.0
ODOT $4.6
H.J. Res 2 $1.3
EARMARK Bill 3058 $0.8
Total $67.3 $67.9
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 40/51
Scenarios Considered in the Financial Model
40
Source: 3.0-Rep-AF3007-10-01-01.toll_scenario_funding_report.pdfNote: * Tolls are in 2010 dollars (growing at 2.5% annually). For example, a $2.00 in 2006 dollars is $2.21 in 2010.The range reflects the lowest and highest rates per time of the day.
DescriptionToll
Collection
1A DEIS tolls $1.10 / $2.21 Each Way
1B Lower than DEIS $1.10 / $1.66 Each Way
1C Fixed-rate equivalent to DEIS tolls (flat toll) Each Way
1D Additional Price Points $1.10 / $2.76 Each Way
1E 1.5 X DEIS tolls $1.66 / $3.31 Each Way
One-way Toll
Rate Range *
T o l l s o n I - 5 O n l y
$1.82
Scenarios
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 41/51
Finance Plan Implementation Schedule
41
Activity Date
Start Right-of-Way Acquisition January-11
Washington Legislative Approval Committing State Funds June-11
Washington Legislative Approval Authorizing Tolling for the CRC Project June-11
Oregon Legislative Approval Committing State Funds June-11
Federal Transportation Reauthorization Enacted making Highway Discretionary Funds Available (1) October-11Bridge Construction Contract Executed September-12
FTA Approval of Full Funding Grant Agreement Committing Section 5309 New Starts Funds (2) September-13
New Bridge Fully Open/Start Tolling July-18
Light Rail Construction Complete/Service Starts September-18(1) Highway discretionary funding may come in form of a congressional earmark and/or approval of an administrative programfor which the CRC project is eligible.
(2) Assumes sufficient local funding commitments are in place to secure FTA approval to enter Final Design in November 2011.
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 42/51
Expenditure Plan(December 2009)
42
Phase I: MediumThrough
20102011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 TOTAL
Highway AA, DEIS, Eng.
Construction$93.5 $33.9 $121.3 $210.3 $445.9 $485.6 $453.8 $232.1 $213.4 $70.8 $2,360.6
Transit PE, Design and
Construction$5.9 $7.5 $12.8 $21.0 $74.8 $234.5 $223.5 $168.5 $37.9 $786.4
Total Design and Construction $99.4 $41.4 $134.1 $231.3 $520.7 $720.1 $677.3 $400.6 $251.3 $70.8 $3,147.0
Phase I: HighThrough
20102011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 TOTAL
Highway AA, DEIS, Eng.
Construction$98.1 $38.7 $136.7 $235.6 $499.5 $543.9 $508.3 $260.4 $239.5 $79.6 $2,640.3
Transit PE, Design and
Construction$6.6 $8.4 $14.3 $23.5 $83.6 $262.3 $250.0 $188.5 $42.4 $879.6
Total Design and Construction $104.7 $47.1 $151.0 $259.1 $583.1 $806.2 $758.3 $448.9 $281.9 $79.6 $3,519.9
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 43/51
Anticipated Funding - Phase 1 In Millions of Dollars (December 2009)
43
New Starts Assumes full FTA New Starts request granted.CRC may fulfill FTA local match requirements using local highwayexpenditures, per Congressional action.
$850
Projects of National Significance Additional funding above and beyond existing allocations. Assumedlikely based on scope of CRC project and historical success in
securing Federal discretionary funding.
$400
Additional WSDOT/ODOT Funding$50M in existing funding, $90M in total allocations, less $40Mexpended. Assumes additional funding generated from both DOTs.
$750-$850
Pre-Completion Toll Proceeds
Assumes pre-completion tolling of I-5, generating about $40M peryear for 5 years.
$0-$200
Bond Proceeds $803-$1,466
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 44/51
• Interim financing money is used to fund cash-flow needs before bonds are issued starting
in 2015 to replace it.• Adds to total financing cost, but is necessary to bridge gap between early expenditures on
construction (and related interest on borrowings) and later receipt of project revenues.
• Bonds are issued in five consecutive years (2015-2019) and repayment of principal canstart as early as 2020.
• IRS requires a “reasonable expectation” that bond proceeds be spent within three to five years, soa series of issuances is likely to be required. Multiple closing may add to total financing costs.
• Sinking fund payments are mandatory and there is no return on these reserve funds. DebtService structure with repayment of principal is recommended to reduce interest payments.
• Interest costs can be managed through the issuance of “serialized” bonds with principal andinterest payments in each year.
• Target debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) of at least 1.25.
• DSCR of 1.25 on median traffic forecast for a Brownfield facility considered moderate assumption.
• All scenarios tested using 90% cost estimate (high estimate) and 60% toll revenueestimate (low estimate).
• Interest rate assumptions are: 6% on bonds and 7% on interim financing. Bondunderwriting costs are assumed to be 6.5% of the issue amount.
44
Analytical Assumptions
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 45/51
Scenario 1A: DEIS Toll Rates on I-5LPA Phase I Option
45
Capital Cost (In Millions of US$) Phase I: 60% Phase I: 90% Phase I: 60% Phase I: 90%
Construction & Design $3,147 $3,520 $3,147 $3,520
Finance Interim Costs $90 $80 $90 $80
Total Cost $3,237 $3,600 $3,237 $3,600
Revenue Source (In Millions of US$)Net Toll Bond Proceeds $803 $1,166 $1,103 $1,466
Pre-Completion Toll Revenues $200 $200 $0 $0
Interim Financing
Federal: Discretionary Highway: Existing $44 $44 $44 $44
Federal: Discretionary Highway: Addition $400 $400 $400 $400
ODOT/WSDOT Highway Funds: Existing $90 $90 $90 $90
ODOT/WSDOT Highway Funds: Additiona $850 $850 $750 $750
FTA Section 5309 New Starts $850 $850 $850 $850
Total Revenues $3,237 $3,600 $3,237 $3,600
Pre-completion Tolling No Pre-completion Tolling
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 46/51
46
Capital Cost (In Millions of US$) Phase I: 60% Phase I: 90% Phase I: 60% Phase I: 90%
Construction & Design $3,399 $3,797 $3,399 $3,797
Finance Interim Costs $90 $80 $90 $80
Total Cost $3,489 $3,877 $3,489 $3,877
Revenue Source (In Millions of US$) Pre-completion Tolling No Pre-completion Tolling
Net Toll Bond Proceeds $805 $1,193 $1,105 $1,493
Pre-Completion Toll Revenues $200 $200 $0 $0
Interim Financing
Federal: Discretionary Highway: Existing $44 $44 $44 $44
Federal: Discretionary Highway:
Additional $500 $500 $500 $500
ODOT/WSDOT Highway Funds: Existing $90 $90 $90 $90ODOT/WSDOT Highway Funds:
Additional $1,000 $1,000 $900 $900
FTA Section 5309 New Starts $850 $850 $850 $850
Total Revenues $3,489 $3,877 $3,489 $3,877
Scenario 1A: DEIS Toll Rates on I-5LPA Full Build Option
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 47/51
Debt Service Coverage Ratio: Tolling I-5 atDEIS Toll Rate (LPA Phase I Option)
47
-
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
7.00
8.00
9.00
10.00
2 0 1 5
2 0 1 6
2 0 1 7
2 0 1 8
2 0 1 9
2 0 2 0
2 0 2 1
2 0 2 2
2 0 2 3
2 0 2 4
2 0 2 5
2 0 2 6
2 0 2 7
2 0 2 8
2 0 2 9
2 0 3 0
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 48/51
Summary of Capital Finance Plan Scenarios
48
LPA Phase I Option LPA Full Build
Revenue Source Medium High Medium HighFed. Discretionary Highway:
Existing $44 $44 $44 $44
Fed. Discretionary Highway:
Additional $400 $400 $500 $500
ODOT/WSDOT: Existing $90 $90 $90 $90
ODOT/WSDOT: Additional
$750.0 -
$850.0
$750.0 -
$850.0
$901.5 -
$1,001.5
$926.7 -
$1,026.7
Post Completion Toll Bond
Proceeds
$803.0 -
$1,103.0
$1,166.2 -
$1,466.2
$803.0 -
$1,103.0
$1,166.2 -
$1,466.2
Pre-Completion Toll
Revenues $0.0 - $200.0 $0.0 - $200.0 $0.0 - $200.0 $0.0 - $200.0
Section 5309 New Start
Funds $850 $850 $850 $850
Total Revenues $3,237 $3,600 $3,489 $3,877
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 49/51
Implementation Components
• WSDOT, ODOT, C-TRAN, and TriMet must enter into agreements.
• Legislative/administrative approval of the ODOT and WSDOT fundingcontributions must be secured.
• Legislative approval to toll the I-5 bridge must be obtained.
• An earmark of federal discretionary highway funds would be sought inthe upcoming transportation reauthorization bill.
• C-TRAN district voter approval for high capacity transit system andfinance plan.
• Information of an updated New Starts rating to be submitted to FTA,and a Final Design application to be approved by FTA.
• A toll agreement between the 2 DOTs and FHWA must be executed.• A finance plan must be submitted to FTA and FHWA in compliancewith its requirements for Major Projects.
• FTA must approve and execute a Full Funding Grant Agreement.
49
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 50/51
Conclusion
• The project is financially feasible based on the fundingsources assumptions
• The toll revenues are shown to be adequate to cover mostof the cost including insurance, issuance, and O&M costs
• Besides toll revenues, the financial plan mainly relies onfederal sources that are unique to the project such as NewStarts and Project of National Significance and thereforedoesn’t have an effect on other local projects
• The toll rates and the exact amount of funding from varioussources will be updated over time
• The finance plan will be continuously updated based on theproject progress and how the implementation issues areaddressed
50
8/7/2019 Appendix a CRC Financial Plan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/appendix-a-crc-financial-plan 51/51