architecting and engineering the naval force warfare systems and systems of systems engineering mr....

ASN (RDA)Chief Systems Engineer

Architecting and Engineering the Naval ForceWarfare Systems and

Systems of Systems Engineering

Naval Warfare Systems Symposium 200917 June 2009Mr. Carl Siel

ASN(RDA) Chief Systems Engineer

[email protected]

1

RDA CHSENG, June 2009

DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

Purpose

Discuss what it takes to Architect and Engineer the Naval Force

RDA CHSENG Actions to Accomplish

2


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

3

Naval Systems

AIRCRAFTSHIPS AND AIRCRAFTCARRIERS

WEAPON SYSTEMS

SUBMARINES

C4ISR SYSTEMS LAND COMBAT SYSTEMS


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

JCA to Naval Missions

4

01 Force Support• Force Management (6)• Force Preparation (8)• Human Capital Management (8)• Health Readiness (10)

02 Battlespace Awareness• Intelligence, Surveillance and

Reconaissance (33)• Environment (20)

03 Force Application• Naval Land Ops (7)• Naval Maritime / Littoral Ops (13)

• Surface Warfare• Offensive Surface Warfare• Defensive Surface Warfare

• Undersea Warfare• Antisubmarine Warfare• Subsurface Warfare• Mine Warfare

• Mine Countermeasures• Mining

• Maritime Interdiction• Sea Lines of Communication (SLOC) Disruption• Maritime Interception Operations

• Maritime / Littoral Expeditionary Operations• Amphibious Force Operations• Riverine Operations• Advance Force Operations

• Maritime / Littoral Fires• Naval Fire Support

• Ocean / Hydro / River Survey & Support Operations• Naval Space Ops (2)• Naval Air Ops (8)• Naval Info Ops (9)• Naval Global Deterrence (3)• Naval Stability Ops (4)• Naval Force Protection (8)• Naval Access Operations (6)• Naval SPECOPS (7)

04 Logistics• Deployment and Distribution (5)• Supply (3)• Maintain (8)• Logistics Services (14)• Operational Contract Support (2)• Engineering (13)• Installations Support (15)

09 Corporate Management and Support• Advisory and Compliance (6)• Strategy and Assessment (4)• Information Management (1)• Acquisition (2)• Program, Budget and Finance (2)

06 Net-Centric• Information Transport (6)• Enterprise Services (12)• Net Management (6)• Information Assurance (8)

07 Protection• Prevent (9)• Mitigate (19)• Research and Development (3)

08 Building Partnerships• Communicate (9)• Shape (9)

05 Command and Control• Organize (9)• Understand (9)• Planning (13)• Decide (7)• Direct (11)• Monitor (6)

Naval Missions, defined as Navy and Marine Corps contributions to the JCAs, yield 350+ Mission Areas


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

Naval Engineering of Systems

5


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

Mission Area System-of-Systems Engineering

6

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements

Operations & Maintenance

Deployment

Validation

TESTING (DT / OT)• Platform Operation Testing (OT)• Platform Training• Platform &

SoS Developmental Test

System VerificationICD / CCD / CPD

• SETR Process• Interface Management

Analysis ProcessImplementation

PLATFORM PLATFORM

Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System

System Functional Behavior

Platform

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements

OP

NA

V


Deployment FL

EE

T

Validation

CO

TF

ASN (RDA)

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements

OP

NA

V

- Operational Capability Needs - DOTMLPF - KPPs

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform

Develops, Designs, Simulations, Models, Prototypes, Tests, Procedures

ASN (RDA)

Derived Requirements

Platform Verify

System Verify

Components Verify

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform

Validation

CO

TF- OAs/ OPEVAL

- System Mission Environment

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform


Deployment FL

EE

T- In-Service Support- Facilities- Personnel


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

DoD 5000 Process

7

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






PLATFORM PLATFORM

Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

To Architect and Engineer the Naval Force…

8

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






PLATFORM PLATFORM

Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

… What’s Missing

1. ASN(RDA) Engineering Community working at the Mission Level

2. Mission Based Capability Strategic Plan(s) that include and look beyond the FYDP

9


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

Collision of Plans

10

PLATFORM

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operations

Requirements


Deployment

Validation

PAST / In-Service 2010

PLATFORM

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operations

Requirements


Deployment

Validation

EXECUTING 2015

PLATFORM

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operations

Requirements


Deployment

Validation

FUTURE / Planning 2020

NOW

In-Service, Execution, and Planning Collide


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

Capability Plan Composition

11


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

Engineering at the Mission Level

12

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






PLATFORM PLATFORM

Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

RDA CHSENG Initiative

13

Mission Operations

RequirementsValidation

Net-Centric Integration & Interoperability

DODAF Usability For Engineers- Architecture Data Elements- Architecture Repository- Architecture Hierarchy

ISP Review

NR KPP Guidebook

Mission SoS Engineering Guidebook

Mission Area CHENG

Modeling and Simulation

• NMSO• Large Scale

Capability Assessment• COTF

Analysis – Engineering – T&E CommunityMeta Data Strategy

Mission Threads Mission Based Test Scripts

Use of Live Virtual Constructive Environment


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

Problem / Challenge Proposed Solution

Ability to integrate mission capabilities across multiple missions, platforms, and systems

• Clear architectural depictions• Codify Mission Area Chief Engineers• Test and Validation Facilities

• Insufficient Government Technical Insight

• Insufficient System Integration (SI) Requirements for Optimum Interoperability

• Insight into System Development and SI implications

• Government owns IP and System Architecture

• Access to SoS T&E Facilities• Government mechanism to track/report SI

Knowledge to make SI decisions and lack of clear requirements to maximize commonality

• Update technical processes (e.g. SETR) to address SI related information

• Intellectual Property Rights• Assess Human Capital Capacity

Insufficient Government Insight

• Contracting strategy and language to address IP

• Increased Government activity in system architecture and specifications

• Government Rapid Prototyping (sustain knowledge base)

14

Government Role as LSI

Technical discipline and competency is required at each level Quality System Integration is essential to delivering mission capability

through multiple PORs

End Item Focus

Components

Functional Focus

System

Enterprise Force Focus

Capability Focus

MissionSoS(Platform / Net Centric)


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

RDA CHSENG Mission Engineer POCs

DODAF Usabilityo NetCentric I&I Management Plan: Kevin Smith, RDA CHSENGo Architecture Data Elements: Mark Econie, SPAWARo Architecture Repository: Mark Econie; Pat Roche, SPAWARo Architecture Hierarchy: Kevin Smith; Mike Jacobs, DoN CIO

ISP Review Process (Exists): Dr. Cheryl Walton, RDA CHSENG NR KPP Guidebook (Fall 2009): Dr. Cheryl Walton Mission SoS Engineering Guidebook (V1 Exists / V2 Spring 2010):

Melinda Reed, RDA CHSENG Mission Area CHENG (On-going): Kevin Smith Analysis / Engineering / T&E Meta Data Strategy (On-Going):

John Moore, NMSO Large Scale CPA / CPE (Fall 2009): Tony Devino, RDA CHSENG Government Role as LSI (Initial Exists / Follow-On):

Joan Johnson, NAVAIR

15


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

Summary

Architecting and Engineering the Naval Force Complimentary Strategic Capability Plan ASN(RDA) Engineering Community Engaged and Employing

Disciplined Practices at the Mission Level

16


DA HIEF

YSTEMS NGINEER

Mission Gap Closed

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

MISSION

SYSTEM

COMPONENTS

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






PLATFORM PLATFORM

Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements


Deployment

Validation






Sub-System

Sub-System

Sub-System


Platform

CONOPS

Operational Needs

Mission Operational

Requirements

OP

NA

V


Deployment FL

EE

T

Validation

CO

TF

ASN (RDA)

17

architecting and engineering the naval force warfare systems and systems of systems engineering mr....

Documents

naval force warfare

naval missions

naval access operations

naval force protection

naval systems aircraftships

naval specops

naval air ops

naval info ops