armed forces tribunal, principal bench, …1 armed forces tribunal, principal bench, new delhi list...
TRANSCRIPT
1
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 06-02-2017
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 1 (Ground Floor)
THIS BENCH WILL NOT ASSEMBLE TODAY
HON'BLE THE CHAIRPERSON HON'BLE LT. GEN. SANJIV LANGER
CORAM:
S. No. Case No. Parties Name
For Admission
Advocate
1. OA 1486/2016 with MA 1114/2016
Ex Sep Raj Kumar Yadav thru Smt. Bachan Yadav (LR) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar (Advocate for Respondents)
For Hearing 2. TA 449/2010
WP(C) 8809/2003 Ex-Maj. C. Prasad V/s Union of India & Ors.
Mr. S K Sanan (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr. Anil Gautam (Advocate for Respondents)
3. TA 583/2010 WP(C) 4518/1998
Ex. Sepoy Rajender Kumar V/s Union of India & Ors.
Mr SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Avdhesh Kumar Singh & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
4. OA 1190/2016 Maj MC Ashish Chinnappa V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. T Prasad (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar (Advocate for Respondents)
2
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 06-02-2017
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 2 (First Floor) CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BABU MATHEW P. JOSEPH HON'BLE LT. GEN. S. K. SINGH
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate
For Admission 1. OA 1255/2016 Wg Cdr APK Gupta
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajit Kakkar (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC with JS Rawat (Advocate for Respondents)
2. OA 1474/2016 Nk Dinesh Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. D S Kauntae (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr VS Tomar (Advocate for Respondents)
3. OA 157/2017 with MA 140/2017
Hav Suresh Kumar (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) None (Advocate for Respondents)
4. OA 161/2017 Air Cmde PK Sharma V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Ajit Kakkar (Advocate for Petitioner) None (Advocate for Respondents)
For Orders 5. MA 130/2017
in OA 703/2016 Wg Cdr Pooja Thakur V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar (Advocate for Respondents)
6. MA 137/2017 in OA 300/2015
Lt Col PK Malik V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr V Pattabhi Ram & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
3
Part Heard 7. OA 593/2016 Brig Arun Kumar
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC with DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
For Hearing 8. OA 254/2011 Col Sarat Chandra Mishra
V/s Union of India & Ors.
Mr. S. S. Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr VS Tomar & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
9. OA 144/2015 Sub Maj/Chief D Man Hari Om Dubey V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Ms Jyotsana Kaushik & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
10. OA 145/2015 Sub Maj/Clk (SD) Mitter Pal Singh Tanwar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Anil GAutam (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
11. OA 199/2015 Sub Maj Clk (SD) Subhash Chander Vaidya V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr KK Tyagi (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
12. OA 200/2015 Sub Maj Gurbaj Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Anil Gautam (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
13. OA 201/2015 Sub Maj Gurpritam Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SD Windlesh (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
14. OA 202/2015 Sub Maj Mahmood Khan V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr KK Tyagi (Advocate for Respondents)
4
WITH
15. OA 203/2015 Sub Maj Panna Lal Arun V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh Kumar (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
16. OA 219/2015 Sub Maj Laxman Ram V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Ms Jyotsana Kaushik (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
17. OA 220/2015 Sub Maj Dayal Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr YP Singh (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
18. OA 221/2015 Sub Maj Wazir Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr KK Tyagi (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
19. OA 222/2015 Sub Maj/Hony Lt. Subhash Chand V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh KUmar (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
20. OA 223/2015 Sub Maj Balwant Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
21. OA 224/2015 Sub Maj Mohan Chandra V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr JS Rawat (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
22. OA 225/2015 Sub Maj Narayan Singh Gariya V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
23. OA 226/2015 Sub Maj Shankar Datt V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Ms Barkha Babbar
5
(Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
24. OA 235/2015 Sub Maj. Dibakar Dass V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Dr Vijendra Mahndiyan (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
25. OA 236/2015 Sub Maj Anbu Rajan V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
26. OA 238/2015 Sub Maj. Pratap Sharma V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
27. OA 245/2015 Sub Maj Venkappa Shetty M V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
28. OA 246/2015 Sub Maj Jiwan Chandra V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
29. OA 247/2015 Sub Maj Baldev Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh Kumar (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
30. OA 288/2015 Sub Maj Thomas TM V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr VS Tomar (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
31. OA 299/2015 Sub Maj Dasarathi Swain V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Avdhesh Kumar Singh (Advocate for Respondents)
6
WITH
32. OA 330/2015 Sub Maj Mahendra Singh Dhankar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
33. OA 331/2015 Sub Maj Mohan singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Satya Ranjan Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
34. OA 332/2015 Sub Maj Shinde PS V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
35. OA 437/2015 Sub Maj Mritunjoy Guchhait V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
36. OA 517/2015 Sub Maj Khandagale Vaman Ramachandra V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
37. OA 521/2015 Sub Maj Nar Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
38. OA 524/2015 Sub Maj Amar Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr KS Bhati, Sr CGSC (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
39. OA 528/2015 Sub Maj Ratheesh Koyatan V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr KS Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
7
WITH
40. OA 529/2015 Sub Maj Babu N V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
41. OA 530/2015 Sub Maj Sivadasan R V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr V Pattabhi Ram (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
42. OA 562/2015 Sub Maj Ingle Devidas Mahadeo V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Satya Ranjan Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
43. OA 578/2015 Sub Maj Vidya Ram V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Satya Ranjan Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
44. OA 596/2015 Sub Maj Gangadhar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
45. OA 618/2015 Sub Maj Manoj Kumar N B V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Avdhesh Kumar Singh (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
46. OA 79/2016 Sub Maj Dayanand Singh Yadava V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Shyam Narayan (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
47. OA 235/2016 Sub Maj Ravinder Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey & Abhsihek R Shukala (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr V Pattabhi Ram (Advocate for Respondents)
48. OA 196/2015 Nk Sandeep Kumar Punia V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. DS Kauntae (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
8
49. OA 662/2015 (At 4.00 PM)
Ex Swr Narender Singh Dahiya V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S M Dalal (Advocate for Petitioner) Ms Jyotsana Kaushik & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
50. OA 544/2016 Hav Rajinder Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
9
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 06-02-2017
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 3 (Ground Floor) CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. K. SHALI HON'BLE LT. GEN. SANJIV LANGER
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate
For Admission 1. OA 847/2016
with MA 647/2016
Ex Sep Nand Kishore V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel & SR Swain for R 1-3, Ms Anjali Vohra for R-4 (Advocate for Respondents)
2. OA 937/2016 with MA 720/2016
Nk TS Subbaraj (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Shyam Narayan (Advocate for Respondents)
3. OA 1078/2016 with MA 840/2016
Ex Rect Hira Singh Bisht V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms.Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh Kumar (Advocate for Respondents)
4. OA 1583/2016 with MA 1193/2016
Ex Sep Parmal Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Rajesh Nandal (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
5. OA 1584/2016 Sub (TIFC) Raj Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner)
Mr VS Tomar (Advocate for Respondents)
6 OA 1646/2016 with MA 1239/2016
Ex Sgt K C Saini V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Rupesh Kumar (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
10
7. OA 1664/2016 Cadet Deepak Lakhera V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) None (Advocate for Respondents)
8. OA 1686/2016 Commander (Retd) Sukhdev Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Sarvendra Singh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar (Advocate for Respondents)
9. OA 1698/2016 Col L B Malla (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. A S Mathur (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
10. OA 36/2017 Lt Col Ramakrishnan T (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. I S Yadav (Advocate for Petitioner)
Ms Jyotsana Kaushik (Advocate for Respondents)
11. OA 37/2017 Maj Gen U S Dadu V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. I S Yadav (Advocate for Petitioner)
Mr Avdhesh Kumar Singh (Advocate for Respondents)
12. OA 134/2017 Col (Dr) Jyoti Kotwal V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner)
None (Advocate for Respondents)
13. OA 135/2017 with MA 125/2017
Ex Sub Dharam Singh Jakhar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner)
None (Advocate for Respondents)
14. OA 136/2017 With MA 127/2017
Col (TS) Khangara Ram (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Rajendra Kumar (Advocate for Petitioner)
None (Advocate for Respondents)
15. OA 137/2017
Wg Cdr Ajay Kumar (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner)
None (Advocate for Respondents)
16. OA 158/2017
Ex Hav Ram Dulare V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. HS Tiwari, Niyati Arun, Somya & SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner)
None (Advocate for Respondents)
11
17. OA 159/2017
Nb Sub Vinod Prasad V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner)
None (Advocate for Respondents)
For Orders 18. MA 82/2014
in OA 543/2011
Ex Nk Suk Bahadur Gurung V/s UOI & ORs
Mr Anil Gupta & Ritu Meena (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SD Windlesh & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
19. MA 207/2015 in OA 312/2014
Lt. Col. Venugopal Rangaswamy (Retd.) V/s UOI
Mr. A K Aggarwal (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr V Pattabhi Ram & DK Bahti (Advocate for Respondents)
20. MA 726/2015 in OA 396/2014
Ex AC Hemraj Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma (Advocate for Respondents)
21. MA 837/2015 in OA 408/2014
Brig Deepak Sinha (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC with DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
22. MA 569/2016 in OA 197/2016
Maj Ram Kumar (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Ashok Chaitnya & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
23. MA 887/2016 in OA 474/2015
Rfn Hari Kishan Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. D S Kauntae (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
24. MA 1232/2016 in OA 804/2016
Col Pranab Chandra Malakar V/s UOI & Ors
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
25. MA 1234/2016 in OA 805/2016
Col Jagdish Chandra Kakati (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
12
26. MA 129/2017 in OA 664/2016
Lt Col KP Radhakrishnan (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Anil Srivastava (Advocate for Petitioner)
Mr Prabodh Kumar for R-1, Mr SD Windlesh & DK Bhati for R-2, Mr Shyam Narayan for R-3 (Advocate for Respondents)
For Final Orders 27. OA 967/2016 Col Umesh Nirula (Retd)
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar (Advocate for Respondents)
28. OA 991/2016 with MA 775/2016
Smt Prem Devi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S M Dalal (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
For Hearing 29. OA 201/2014 Ex Hav Jehan Singh
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
30. OA 486/2015 Brig Satya Prakash yadav V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Anil Srivastava & Associates (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC with Mr Prabodh Kumar & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
31. OA 559/2015 with MA 603/2015
Lt Col. Naveen Nand Keswani (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma & DK Bhati for R 1,2 & 4, Ms Anjali Vohra for R-3 (Advocate for Respondents)
32. OA 629/2015 with MA 672/2015
Air Cmde K N Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rupesh Kumar (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
33. OA 658/2015 Lt Col M S Krishnan (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms.Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Ms Jyotsana Kaushik & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
13
34. OA 688/2015 Ex PO ELP PL Bhardwaj V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Dr Vijendra Singh Mahndiyan & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
`35. OA 709/2015 (OA 1142/2012 (RB, Chandigarh)
Col. (Retd) Manmohan Singh Jaswal V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Shyam Narayan for R 1-4 None for R-5 (Advocate for Respondents)
36. OA 711/2015 Ex NK Yogesh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Rajesh Nandal (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel & Satya Ranjan Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
37. OA 730/2015 with MA 780/2015
Capt. Jagan Deep Sandhu (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr. KK Tyagi & Mr. SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
38. OA 732/2015 with MA 781/2015
Capt. Ajay Kumar Gulati (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma for R 1,2 & 4 Ms Anjali Vohra for R-3 (Advocate for Respondents)
39. OA 784/2015 Smt Gayatri Devi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh Kumar & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
40. OA 912/2015 Ex Hav Jogindra Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Shara & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
41. OA 1061/2015 with MA 59/2017
WO Tej Pratap Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian & J P Sharma (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh Kumar (Advocate for Respondents)
42. OA 1065/2015 Ex (Nk ) Kewal Krishan V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Amar nath Singh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr YP Singh & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
14
43. OA 174/2016 Sub Suresh Kumar (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Rajesh Nandal (Advocate for Petitioner) Dr. Vijendra Mahndiyan & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
44. OA 459/2016 with MA 285/2016
Smt Kamla Devi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr KK Tyagi & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
15
THIS BENCH WILL NOT ASSEMBLE TODAY CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. K. SHALI HON'BLE AIR MARSHAL J.N. BURMA
Part Heard 1. OA 18/2014 Ex LS UWI Naresh Kumar
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar & Satya Ranjan Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
16
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 06-02-2017
Timing: 11:00 AM
PRINCIPAL REGISTRAR COURT
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate
For Appearance/Direction 1. OA 1577/2016 Commander Rajesh Vaid
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ankur Chhibber (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar (Advocate for Respondents)
2. OA 1578/2016 Lt Col Ram Karan Yadava V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ankur Chhibber & V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr VS Tomar (Advocate for Respondents)
Note : The Cause List is also available at www.aftpbba.in