armed forces tribunal, principal bench, new · pdf filearmed forces tribunal, principal bench,...
TRANSCRIPT
1
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 15-02-2017
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 1 (Ground Floor)
HON'BLE THE CHAIRPERSON HON'BLE LT. GEN. SANJIV LANGER
CORAM:
S. No. Case No. Parties Name
For Admission Advocate
1. OA 230/2017 with MA 181/2017
Col Vikram Chauhan V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. IS Singh/Abhishek Singh (Advocate for Petitioner) None (Advocate for Respondents)
2. OA 232/2017 Ex Gnr (Opr) Gupta Sunil Kumar Ramesh Kumar (Through his brother Shri Pankaj Gupta) V/s UOI & Ors
Mr.SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) None (Advocate for Respondents)
For Orders 3. RA 15/2016
in OA 245/2013
Sqn Ldr (Retd) S Joshi V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. S M Dalal (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Anil Gautam & Mr DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
4. RA 42/2016 in OA 379/2016
Lt Col Gyanendra Pandey V/s UOI & Ors & Ors.
Mr. Amandeep Joshi (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh Kumar & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
5. MA 950/2016 In RA 45/2011 in TA 300/2010
L/Nk Surat Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S M Dalal (Advocate for Petitioner)
Mr Shyam Narayan (Advocate for Respondents)
6. MA 1178/2016 in OA 1057/2016
Col Madhukar Prasad Sinha (Retd) & Ors V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. V S Kadain (Advocate for Petitioners) Mr V Pattabhi Ram (Advocate for Respondents)
2
7. MA 183/2017 in OA 159/2017
Nb Sub Vinod Prasad V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioners) None (Advocate for Respondents)
8. MA 184/2017 in OA 369/2016
Col Harison Verma V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioners) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC (Advocate for Respondents)
Part Heard 9. TA 359/2010
Writ Petition No. 3806/2007)
Ex Col Rajat Das V/s Union of India & Ors
Mr Mohan Kumar (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh Kumar & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
For Hearing 10. TA 396/2009
Writ Petition No. 17758/2004
Ex Hav Hans Raj V/s Union of India & Ors
Mr SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
11. TA 130/2010 (Writ Petition (Civil) No. 11588/2004)
Smt. Sunita Devi V/s Union of India & Ors.
Mr SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
12. TA 533/2010 (WP(C) 18279/2005)
Ex. Nb. Sub. Asim Kumar Mitra V/s Union of India & Ors.
None (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Ashok Chaitanya & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
13. TA 4/2015 (WP(C) 12329/2005)
Maj. Sanjay Ahlawat V/s UOI & Ors.
None (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr VS Tomar & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
14. OA (Appeal) 3/2016 with MA 1/2016
Wg Cdr Rajat Sharma V/s COAS & Ors.
Mr. Mohameed Mujeeb (Advocate for Petitioner) VS Tomar & Jyotsana Kaushik (Advocate for Respondents)
3
HON’BLE CHAIRPERSON WILL SIT SINGLY SOON AFTER MATTERS OF REGULAR BENCH ARE OVER CORAM: HON'BLE THE CHAIRPERSON
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate
For Orders 1. AT 49/2016
in OA (Appeal 06/2014 (RB Jaipur)
Ex Sigmn Sultan Khan V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Md Irshad Hanif & Associates (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
2. AT 7/2017 in OA 832/2016
Maj Gen Sukesh Rakshit V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Rajiv Manglik (Advocate for Petitioner)
Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC with DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
3. MA 179/2017 in OA 1638/2016
Hav Rana Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr V Pattabhi Ram (Advocate for Respondents)
4. MA 180/2017 in OA 128/2017
L/Nk Husensab Nadaf V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) None (Advocate for Respondents)
5. MA 185/2017 & AT 8/2017 in OA 199/2017
Ex L/Nk (TA) Ashish Ramdas Kulsange V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajiv Manglik (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC (Advocate for Respondents)
6. MA 186/2017 & AT 9/2017 in OA 195/2017
Ex L/Nk (Tailor) Jagga Rao V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajiv Manglik (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC (Advocate for Respondents)
7. MA 187/2017 & AT 10/2017 in OA 197/2017
Ex GNr (GD) Prameesh A V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajiv Manglik (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC (Advocate for Respondents)
4
8. MA 188/2017 & AT 11/2017 in OA ___/2017 (Dy No 629/2017)
Ex L/Nk (DS) Prabir Kumar Barman V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajiv Manglik (Advocate for Petitioner) None (Advocate for Respondents)
9. MA 189/2017 & AT 12/2017 in OA ___/2017 (Dy No 630/2017)
Ex Gnr (GD) Adwaitya Mondal V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajiv Manglik (Advocate for Petitioner) None (Advocate for Respondents)
5
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 15-02-2017
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 2 (First Floor) CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BABU MATHEW P. JOSEPH HON'BLE LT. GEN. S. K. SINGH
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate
For Admission 1. OA 1659/2016 Sub/M Tech (NW) Darshan Singh
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. H S Tiwari ,Niyati Arun & Somya (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr VS Tomar (Advocate for Respondents)
2. OA 128/2017 Lance Nk Husensab Nadaf V/s UOI & Ors
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
3. OA 223/2017 Wg Cdr Arun Kumar Dikshit V/s UOI & Ors
Mr Sukhjinder Singh (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
For Orders 4. OA 1093/2016 Sub Maj (TIFC) Raj Kumar
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Ms Jyotsana Kaushik & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
5. MA 173/2017 In OA 103/2017
Sub Kamlesh Prasad V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Mohan Kumar (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar (Advocate for Respondents)
For Hearing 6. TA 6/2015
(TA 1448/2010 (RB, Lucknow)
Nb Sub Ramesh Chander V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Rajiv Manglik (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr KK Tyagi & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
6
7. OA 1507/2016 Cadet (Spr) Parveen Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr IS Singh & Abhishek Singh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel (Advocate for Respondents)
7
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 15-02-2017
Timing: 10:30 AM to 01.00 PM & 02.00 PM to 04.30 PM
COURT No. 3 (Ground Floor) CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. K. SHALI HON'BLE LT. GEN. SANJIV CHACHRA
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate
For Admission 1. OA 847/2016
with MA 647/2016
Ex Sep Nand Kishore V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel & SR Swain for R 1-3, Mas Anjali Vohra for R-4 (Advocate for Respondents)
2. OA 1175/2016 with MA 885/2016
EX MWO Bal Krishan Puri V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Praveen Kumar (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Ashok Chaitanya (Advocate for Respondents)
3. OA 1337/2016 with MA 1007/2016
HFO (Retd) Shiv Om V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Praveen Kumar (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr YP Singh (Advocate for Respondents)
4. OA 1521/2016 Col R N S Singal (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. I S Singh & Abhishek Singh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr KK Tyagi (Advocate for Respondents)
5. OA 1582/2016 Sub (JENE) Binod Mandal V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. H S Tiwari, Niyati Arun & Somya (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr S R Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
8
6. OA 1605/2016 with MA 1205/2016
Ex LMUS Mukesh Chand V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr.J P Shamra (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr S P Sharma (Advocate for Respondents)
7. OA 1632/2016 with MA 1219/2016 & 7/2017
Col Rajinder Singh Pahwa (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Sunita Sharma (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Surjeet Singh (Advocate for Respondents)
8. OA 1694/2016 Ex Capt Charu Kaushik V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Surjit Singh for R 1-4, Ms Anjali Vohra for R-5 (Advocate for Respondents)
9. OA 51/2017 Col Dhruva Kumar (Retd.) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. I S Singh & Abhishek Singh (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
10. OA 146/2017 with MA 146/2017
COl (TS) Sanjay Kumar Gupta (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
11. OA 147/2017 Lt Col Chandan Singh (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
12. OA 148/2017 Hon Lt MCPO -I (GW ) Pawan Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
13. OA 149/2017 with MA 133/2017
Ex EAR -3 Ved Prakash V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
14. OA 150/2017 Ex Sub Maj Naresh Kumar V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
15. OA 225/2017 Bri PK Narula, VSM (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
9
16. OA 229/2017 Lt Col Anil Sabhlok (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Rajiv Manglik (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
17. OA 231/2017 With MA 182/2017
Col Pradeep Kumar Tiwari (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner)
None
For Orders 18. MA 144/2016
in OA 491/2014
Lt Col Mantha Nagraj (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. Rajesh Nandal (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
19. MA 578/2016 in OA 96/2016
Col (TS) Sarjit Singh Raghaw (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors & Ors.
Mr. Rajendra Kumar (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Avdhesh Kumar & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
20. MA 781/2016 in OA 194/2016
Lt Col Shailesh Kumar Rai (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. Inder Sen Singh & Abhihsek Singh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr YP Singh & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
21. MA 176/2017 in OA 1382/2016
Maj Kushal Roy (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors
Mr. VS Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Ms Jyotsana Kaushik (Advocate for Respondents)
For Final Orders 22. OA 689/2016 Ex NK Vijender Kumar Yadav
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr.V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Arvind Patel & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
23. OA 706/2016 Ex JWO R K Tayagi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Narender Kaushik & Pankaj Kaushik (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SD Windlesh & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
24. OA 831/2016 Sep C Jaya Kumar (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh Kumar (Advocate for Respondents)
10
25. OA 848/2016 with MA 648/2016
Ex Sep Kanwar Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms. Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Ashok Chaitanya & Mr S R Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
For Hearing 26. OA 38/2014
with MA 364/2014
Brig Sunil Bhandari V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr SS Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC with DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
27. OA 108/2014 with MA 548/2014
Dr. Ajamal Singh Bhayal V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. SK Das, GD Suraj Garia, Anant K. Vatsya (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Avdhesh Kumar & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
WITH
28. OA 178/2014 Gp Capt (Dr. KP Singh) V/s UOI & Ors.
None (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
29. OA 153/2014 Ex-Naik/Clerk Gajraj Singh V/s UOI & Ors & Ors.
Mr. VS Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SP Sharma & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
30. OA 453/2014 Col Vinod Singh Gaur V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Indra Sen Singh & Abhishek Singh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Harish V Shankar & Satya Ranjan Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
31. OA 554/2014 (End of the Board)
Col. R.P.Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S.S.Pandey (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Karan Singh Bhati, Sr CGSC & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
32. OA 116/2015 Smt. Jayamani V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr SM Dalal (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Shyam Narayan & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
11
33. OA 538/2015 with MA 577/2015
Ex Nb Sub N Satyanarayana V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr YP Singh & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
34. OA 121/2016 Sub AR Biswas V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. J R Rana (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr V Pattabhi Ram (Advocate for Respondents)
35. OA 133/2016 Nb Sub Shyam Bir V/s UOI & Ors.
Ms Archana Ramesh (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr SD Windlesh (Advocate for Respondents)
36. OA 348/2016 Ex Sub Ramashankar Chaurasiya V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. V S Kadian (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Prabodh Kumar & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
37. OA 498/2016 Wg Cdr Gurpreet Singh Sohal (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Ajai Bhalla (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr. VVV MBNS Pattabhiram (Advocate for Respondents)
38. OA 529/2016 Ex WO Gajinder Singh V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. S S Tiwari (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr VS Tomar & SR Swain (Advocate for Respondents)
39. OA 536/2016 Nk Daya Ram V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. D S Kaunate (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr YP Singh & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
40. OA 984/2016
Maj Dhamendra Nath Saxena (Retd) V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr. Triloknath Saxena ,H C Kharbanda & Vipin Kumar Saxena) (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Avdhesh Kumar Singh (Advocate for Respondents)
Note : The Cause List is also available at www.aftpbba.in
12
ARMED FORCES TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI LIST OF BUSINESS
Date: 15-02-2017
Time : 2:30 PM
SUPPLEMENTARY LIST
COURT No. 3 (Ground Floor) CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. K. SHALI HON'BLE LT. GEN S.K SINGH
S. No. Case No. Parties Name Advocate
For Judgement 1. OA 435/2015 Col Rajendra Prakash Verma
V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr Mansi jGupta (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Anil Gautam & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)
2. OA 825/2015 Nb Sub (Retd) Trilochan Joshi V/s UOI & Ors.
Mr S.K. Mohan (Advocate for Petitioner) Mr Anil Gautam & DK Bhati (Advocate for Respondents)