assessing groundwater quality of cr(vi) impacted water ... · water samples were collected from 13...

1
Water samples were collected from 13 case study areas in central and eastern Mediterranean countries including Italy, Greece, Cyprus and Turkey during wet and dry seasons of 2017. The effect of dry climate conditions on groundwater quality was also examined by using Oman as the arid end member. The main objectives of the present study are to: Compare the major groundwater quality parameters from present wet to dry climate conditions. Assess Cr(VI) occurrence in groundwater under the present climate gradient from Italy to Oman. Propose a conceptual framework for identifying feedbacks between Cr(VI) groundwater contamination and future climate scenarios in the study areas. The general characteristics of the case studies are described in Table 1. ERANETMED CrITERIA- CrVI Impacted Water Bodies in the Mediterranean: Transposing management options for Efficient water Resources use through an Interdisciplinary Approach Acknowledgement: The present work was co-funded by the European Union (ERDF) and Greek national funds through the Operational Program "Competitiveness, Entrepreneurship and Innovation", under the ERANETMED Joint Call (project Acronym: CrITERIA). References: [1] Gassert, F., M. Landis, M. Luck, P. Reig, and T. Shiao. (2014). “Aqueduct Global Maps 2.1.” Working Paper. Washington, DC: World Resources Institute. Available online at http://www.wri.org/publication/aqueduct-global-maps-21. [2] Fantoni, D., Brozzo, G., Canepa, M., Cipolli, F., Marini, L., Ottonello, G., & Zuccolini, M. (2002). Natural hexavalent chromium in groundwaters interacting with ophiolitic rocks. Environmental Geology, 42(8), 871-882. [3] Hatzaki, M., et al. (2017) "A future climate assessment on the quality and quantity of CrVI contaminated groundwater in the eastern Mediterranean." AGU Fall Meeting Abstracts. 2017. [4] Mills, C. T., Morrison, J. M., Goldhaber, M. B., & Ellefsen, K. J. (2011). Chromium (VI) generation in vadose zone soils and alluvial sediments of the southwestern Sacramento Valley, California: a potential source of geogenic Cr (VI) to groundwater. Applied Geochemistry, 26(8), 1488-1501. Case Study Total Prec. Wet Season (mm) Total Prec. Dry Season (mm) Main Water Uses Lithology of Cr(VI) Impacted Aquifer IT-Pollino 793 337 Domestic & Industrial Serpentinite, shale & conglomerate GR-Thiva 445 111 Irrigation, Industrial Conglomerate, sand, silt GR-C.Evia 258 81 Irrigation & Industrial Serpentinite & conglomerate, sand, silt GR-Loutraki 272 56 Drinking & domestic Serpentinite & conglomerate, sand, silt GR-Schinos 272 56 Irrigation Serpentinite & conglomerate, sand, silt TU-Mersin, Tarsus, Karaduvar Kazanli 515 122 Irrigation & Industrial Serpentinite, sedimentary rock & alluvial Deposits CY-Troodos 685 202 Irrigation purposes Serpentinite CY-Kiti- Perivolia 345 70 Domestic & Irrigation Conglomerate, sand, silt CY- Kokkinochoria 327 77 Irrigation Conglomerate, sand, silt OM-Nakhl 120 22 limited water use Serpentinite OM-Barka 77 7 Irrigation Conglomerate, sand, silt Figure 5 -Interannual evolution of SPI12 for Italy, Greece, Turkey, Cyprus and Jordan case studies according to model simulations under RCP 4.5 and RCP 8.5 for 1971-2095 Table 1- Precipitation, water uses and aquifer lithology of the study areas. 2 Sapienza University of Rome Dep. Of Chemical Materials , Environmental Engineering, DICMA, Italy 3 University of Basilicata Department of Sciences, Potenza, Italy 4 Geological Survey Department, MOA Nicosia, Cyprus 5 Agricultural Research Institute Nicosia, Cyprus 6 Mersin University Dept. of Geological Engineering, Mersin, Turkey 7 Sultan Qaboos University Dept. of Earth Science, Muscat, Oman 8 National Technical University of Athens School of Civil Engineering, Greece Assessing groundwater quality of Cr(VI) impacted water bodies along climate gradient from Central- East Mediterranean to Oman K Pyrgaki 1* , A Argyraki 1 , M Hatzaki 1 , E Kelepertzis 1 , F Botsou 1 , I Megremi 1 , L Di Palma 2 , M Paternoster 3 , A Zissimos 4 , A Christou 5 , Z Hatipoglu Bagci 6 , D Moraetis 7 , D Dermatas 8 Correspondence e-mail: [email protected] Figure 2-Piper diagram of a)Wet season and b) Dry season of 2017 Figure 1- a) Map showing occurrences of eastern Mediterranean and Peri-Arabic ophiolite sequences -remnants of the ancient Tethys ocean floor and potential sources of Cr(VI) in groundwater. Case study areas of the ERANETMED CrITERIA project are marked with stars b) Drought Severity map with CrITERIA case studies [1]. Figure 3- Diagrams of the main physicochemical parameters of wet and dry season of 2017 a)Conductivity EC , b) pH, c) Dissolved oxygen (DO), d) Nitrate (NO 3 ), e) Hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) f) Scatter plot of Hexavalent chromium concentrations vs total chromium concentrations in groundwater of the Greek case study areas. Table 2 Trends and differences of precipitation indices between the reference period and near and distant future of precipitation indices for RCP 4.5 | RCP 8.5. Non statistical significant values (at a=0.05) are indicated with n.s. b) Figure 4- Scatterplot diagram of HCO3/Mg molar ratio vs Mg/Ca molar ratio. a) b) c) d) e) f) Present Groundwater Quality Characteristics Background & Scope of Research Climate Predictions and Potential Groundwater Feedbacks 1 Department of Geology and Geoenvironment b) a) (Source: Colorado Division of Water Resources) Freshwater resources are directly linked to both ecological services and human development, while water quality has been recognized as a water management problem with great sensitivity to climatic variability and change as early as the 1980's. Specifically, groundwater quantity and quality can be directly affected through changes in precipitation, evapotranspiration, recharge rates, and indirectly through changes in land use, irrigation and other human activities. In the present collaborative research within the frame of the ERANETMED CrITERIA project, we assess real situation data from case study areas following a gradient from relatively wet to dry conditions (Fig.1a-b). A common feature of the studied groundwater bodies is the presence of geogenic Cr(VI) which is linked to ophiolitic rock occurrences. A total of 245 groundwater samples were collected from the studied aquifers. Both major and minor elements were analysed with a variety of analytical techniques including spectrophotometry, atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS) and inductively coupled mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). The majority of groundwater samples are of Mg-HCO 3 , Mg-Ca-HCO 3 and Ca-Mg-HCO 3 type (Figure 2a,b). However, the dispersion of samples towards high chloride and sodium concentrations indicate the impact of sea water intrusion on the quality of groundwater in some areas. This is also justified by the elevated values of conductivity in these areas (Fig.3a). Slightly alkaline pH values, typical of groundwater interacting with ultramafic rocks, predominate in all areas (Fig.3b). A decreasing trend of dissolved oxygen (DO) is observed from wet to dry climate conditions (Italy to Cyprus). This, combined with an increasing trend in ambient temperature possibly points to biogeochemical processes lowering the DO concentration in water (Fig.3c). The influence of anthropogenic activities such as intensive agriculture is indicated by high nitrate concentrations occurring mainly in the groundwater of agricultural areas of Greece and Cyprus (Fig.3d). Cr(VI) concentrations range between < 2 μg/L and 130 μg/L are in agreement with reported geogenic concentrations from the international literature. The systematically higher concentrations observed in Italian and Greek areas compared to the other countries could partly be attributed to a higher level of industrialization of both countries. However, selection bias can not be excluded as a reason. In Oman, concentrations of total Cr range from 30.9-59.8μg/L and 16.5-90.5 in the Nakhl and Barka areas respectively. Cr in groundwater occurs mainly in its hexavalent state which is the toxic form of Cr (Fig. 3f). No significant differences were observed between the wet and dry sampling seasons for any of the parameters. The majority of samples have a molar ratio of HCO 3 /Mg close to 2 (Fig. 4), indicating water interaction with seprentinite [2] which is a potential geogenic source of Cr. From a climate change perspective, an overview of the present conditions and possible future changes has been assessed based on CORDEX experiment simulations under RCPs 4.5 and 8.5 after further downscaling over the case study areas providing high spatial resolution information. The comparison between present and future climate for both scenarios points towards a dryer climate. RCP 4.5 shows a mild decrease in precipitation that becomes more severe towards the end of the century, though under the RCP 8.5 intense decrease is explicit in most timescales ( Fig. 5 and Table 2) [3]. The significant increase of precipitation variability and short and long-term drought are likely to affect freshwater systems in the case studies as temperature and air humidity rates influence evapotranspiration, one of the basic components of the simplified water balance equation: P= E + R + G P: Precipitation, E: Evapotranspiration, R: Surface Runoff and G: Groundwater Recharge As a result the simultaneous increase of evapotranspiration and the decrease of precipitation can reduce the infiltrated water (Fig.6) in groundwater bodies increasing the risk for both quantitative and qualitative degradation. The case studies inter-comparison stresses the diverse needs on water management along the Mediterranean and at the same time identifies common messages related to the future changes on water resources. Our data indicate that under present conditions the problem of Cr(VI) contamination in ophiolite related aquifers is also related to land use and that feedbacks exist between water quality and agricultural and industrial (anthropogenic) pressures. For example, nitrification may play an important role on Cr release from its primary mineral hosts [4]. Although, seasonal short term variations of aquifer conditions do not seem to play a significant role on Cr(VI) concentration levels in any of the study areas, a decreasing gradient is observed in DO concentrations moving from Mediterranean countries to Oman, indicating changes in biogeochemical conditions taking place within the aquifers. The increased predicted climate variability and the trend in precipitation decrease with probable evapotranspiration increase has profound impacts on water balance. These will primarily affect groundwater recharge and quantity in the study areas, but will also lead to increased anthropogenic pressures on water. The key for the estimation of potential groundwater quality feedbacks under changing climate in the future, including geogenic Cr release and oxidation, lies with being able to better constrain and manage the effects of anthropogenic pressures within water recharge zones. Figure 6 The Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey-TÜBİTAK (Project No 115Y844) IT Pollino RCP 4.5 IT Pollino RCP 8.5 GR Evia RCP 4.5 GR Evia RCP 8.5 TR Mersin RCP 4.5 TR Mersin RCP 8.5 CY Troodos RCP 4.5 CY Troodos RCP 8.5 JO Zarqa River RCP 4.5 JO Zarqa River RCP 8.5

Upload: others

Post on 10-Aug-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Assessing groundwater quality of Cr(VI) impacted water ... · Water samples were collected from 13 case study areas in central and eastern Mediterranean countries including Italy,

Water samples were collected from 13 case study areas in central and eastern Mediterranean countries including Italy, Greece, Cyprus and Turkey during wet and dry seasons of 2017. The effect of dry climate conditions on groundwater quality was also examined by using Oman as the arid end member.

The main objectives of the present study are to:• Compare the major groundwater quality

parameters from present wet to dry climate conditions.

• Assess Cr(VI) occurrence in groundwater under the present climate gradient from Italy to Oman.

• Propose a conceptual framework for identifying feedbacks between Cr(VI) groundwater contamination and future climate scenarios in the study areas.

The general characteristics of the case studies are described in Table 1.

ERANETMED CrITERIA- CrVI Impacted Water Bodies in the Mediterranean: Transposing management options for Efficient water Resources use through an Interdisciplinary Approach

Acknowledgement: The present work was co-funded by the European Union (ERDF) and Greek national funds through the Operational Program "Competitiveness, Entrepreneurship and Innovation", under the ERANETMED Joint Call (project Acronym: CrITERIA).

References:[1] Gassert, F., M. Landis, M. Luck, P. Reig, and T. Shiao. (2014). “Aqueduct Global Maps 2.1.” Working Paper. Washington, DC: World Resources Institute. Available online at http://www.wri.org/publication/aqueduct-global-maps-21.[2] Fantoni, D., Brozzo, G., Canepa, M., Cipolli, F., Marini, L., Ottonello, G., & Zuccolini, M. (2002). Natural hexavalent chromium in groundwaters interacting with ophiolitic rocks. Environmental Geology, 42(8), 871-882.[3] Hatzaki, M., et al. (2017) "A future climate assessment on the quality and quantity of CrVI contaminated groundwater in the eastern Mediterranean." AGU Fall Meeting Abstracts. 2017.[4] Mills, C. T., Morrison, J. M., Goldhaber, M. B., & Ellefsen, K. J. (2011). Chromium (VI) generation in vadose zone soils and alluvial sediments of the southwestern Sacramento Valley, California: a potential source of geogenic Cr (VI) to groundwater. Applied Geochemistry, 26(8), 1488-1501.

Case StudyTotal Prec.Wet Season

(mm)

Total Prec.Dry

Season (mm)

Main Water Uses

Lithology of Cr(VI)

Impacted Aquifer

IT-Pollino 793 337Domestic &Industrial

Serpentinite, shale &

conglomerate

GR-Thiva 445 111Irrigation, Industrial

Conglomerate, sand, silt

GR-C.Evia 258 81Irrigation &Industrial

Serpentinite &conglomerate,

sand, silt

GR-Loutraki 272 56Drinking & domestic

Serpentinite & conglomerate,

sand, silt

GR-Schinos 272 56 IrrigationSerpentinite &conglomerate,

sand, siltTU-Mersin,

Tarsus,Karaduvar

Kazanli

515 122Irrigation & Industrial

Serpentinite,sedimentary

rock & alluvialDeposits

CY-Troodos 685 202Irrigation purposes

Serpentinite

CY-Kiti-Perivolia

345 70Domestic & Irrigation

Conglomerate, sand, silt

CY-Kokkinochoria

327 77 IrrigationConglomerate,

sand, silt

OM-Nakhl 120 22limited

water useSerpentinite

OM-Barka 77 7 IrrigationConglomerate,

sand, silt

Figure 5 -Interannual evolution of SPI12 for Italy,Greece, Turkey, Cyprus and Jordan case studiesaccording to model simulations under RCP 4.5 andRCP 8.5 for 1971-2095

Table 1- Precipitation, water uses and aquifer lithology of the

study areas.

2 Sapienza University of RomeDep. Of Chemical Materials ,

Environmental Engineering, DICMA, Italy

3University of BasilicataDepartment of Sciences, Potenza, Italy

4Geological Survey Department, MOANicosia, Cyprus

5Agricultural Research InstituteNicosia, Cyprus

6Mersin University

Dept. of Geological Engineering, Mersin, Turkey

7Sultan Qaboos University

Dept. of Earth Science,Muscat, Oman

8National Technical Universityof Athens

School of Civil Engineering, Greece

Assessing groundwater quality of Cr(VI) impacted water bodies along climate gradient from Central- East Mediterranean to Oman

K Pyrgaki1*, A Argyraki1, M Hatzaki1, E Kelepertzis1, F Botsou1, I Megremi1, L Di Palma2, M Paternoster3, A Zissimos4, A Christou5, Z Hatipoglu Bagci6, D Moraetis7, D Dermatas8

Correspondence e-mail: [email protected]

Figure 2-Piper diagram of a)Wet season and b) Dry season of 2017

Figure 1- a) Map showing occurrences of eastern Mediterranean and Peri-Arabic ophiolite sequences -remnants of the ancient Tethys ocean floor and potential sources of Cr(VI) in groundwater. Case study areas of the ERANETMED CrITERIA project are marked with stars b)Drought Severity map with CrITERIA case studies [1].

Figure 3- Diagrams of the main physicochemical parameters of wet and dry season of 2017 a)Conductivity EC , b) pH, c) Dissolved oxygen (DO), d) Nitrate (NO3), e) Hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) f) Scatter plot of Hexavalent chromium concentrations vs total chromium concentrations in groundwater of the Greek case study areas.

Table 2 Trends and differences of precipitation indices

between the reference period and near and distant future of

precipitation indices for RCP 4.5 | RCP 8.5. Non statistical

significant values (at a=0.05) are indicated with n.s.

b)

Figure 4- Scatterplot diagram of HCO3/Mg molar ratio vs Mg/Ca molar ratio.

a) b)

c) d)

e) f)

Present Groundwater Quality Characteristics Background & Scope of Research Climate Predictions and Potential Groundwater Feedbacks

1 Department of Geology and Geoenvironment

b)

a)

(Source: Colorado Division of Water Resources)

Freshwater resources are directly linked to both ecological services and human development, while water quality has been recognized as a water management problem with great sensitivity to climatic variability and change as early as the 1980's. Specifically, groundwater quantity and quality can be directly affected through changes in precipitation, evapotranspiration, recharge rates, and indirectly through changes in land use, irrigation and other human activities.

In the present collaborative research within the frame of the ERANETMED CrITERIA project, we assess real situation data from case study areas following a gradient from relatively wet to dry conditions (Fig.1a-b). A common feature of the studied groundwater bodies is the presence of geogenic Cr(VI) which is linked to ophioliticrock occurrences.

A total of 245 groundwater samples were collected from the studied aquifers. Both major and minor elements were analysed with a variety of analytical techniques including spectrophotometry, atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS) and inductively coupled mass spectrometry (ICP-MS).

• The majority of groundwater samples are of Mg-HCO3, Mg-Ca-HCO3 and Ca-Mg-HCO3 type (Figure 2a,b). However, the dispersion of samples towards high chloride and sodium concentrations indicate the impact of sea water intrusion on the quality of groundwater in some areas. This is also justified by the elevated values of conductivity in these areas (Fig.3a). • Slightly alkaline pH values, typical of groundwater interacting with ultramafic rocks, predominate in all areas (Fig.3b). • A decreasing trend of dissolved oxygen (DO) is observed from wet to dry climate conditions (Italy to Cyprus). This, combined with an increasing trend in ambient temperature possibly points to biogeochemical processes lowering the DO concentration in water (Fig.3c).

• The influence of anthropogenic activities such as intensive agriculture is indicated by high nitrate concentrations occurring mainly in the groundwater of agricultural areas of Greece and Cyprus (Fig.3d).

• Cr(VI) concentrations range between < 2 μg/L and 130 μg/L are in agreement with reported geogenic concentrations from the international literature. The systematically higher concentrations observed in Italian and Greek areas compared to the other countries could partly be attributed to a higher level of industrialization of both countries. However, selection bias can not be excluded as a reason. In Oman, concentrations of total Cr range from 30.9-59.8μg/L and 16.5-90.5 in the Nakhl and Barka areas respectively.

• Cr in groundwater occurs mainly in its hexavalent state which is the toxic form of Cr (Fig. 3f).

• No significant differences were observed between the wet and dry sampling seasons for any of the parameters.

• The majority of samples have a molar ratio of HCO3/Mg close to 2 (Fig. 4), indicating water interaction with seprentinite [2] which is a potential geogenic source of Cr.

From a climate change perspective, an overview of the present conditions and possible future changes has been assessed based on CORDEX experiment simulations under RCPs 4.5 and 8.5 after further downscaling over the case study areas providing high spatial resolution information.

The comparison between present and future climate for both scenarios points towards a dryer climate. RCP 4.5 shows a mild decrease in precipitation that becomes more severe towards the end of the century, though under the RCP 8.5 intense decrease is explicit in most timescales (Fig. 5 and Table 2) [3].

The significant increase of precipitation variability and short and long-term drought are likely to affect freshwater systems in the case studies as temperature and air humidity rates influence evapotranspiration, one of the basic components of the simplified water balance equation:

P= E + R + G

P: Precipitation, E: Evapotranspiration, R: Surface Runoff and G: Groundwater Recharge

As a result the simultaneous increase of evapotranspirationand the decrease of precipitation can reduce the infiltrated water (Fig.6) in groundwater bodies increasing the risk for both quantitative and qualitative degradation.

The case studies inter-comparison stresses the diverse needs on water management along the Mediterranean and atthe same time identifies common messages related to the future changes on water resources.

Our data indicate that under present conditions the problem of Cr(VI) contamination in ophiolite related aquifers isalso related to land use and that feedbacks exist between water quality and agricultural and industrial(anthropogenic) pressures. For example, nitrification may play an important role on Cr release from its primarymineral hosts [4].

Although, seasonal short term variations of aquifer conditions do not seem to play a significant role on Cr(VI)concentration levels in any of the study areas, a decreasing gradient is observed in DO concentrations moving fromMediterranean countries to Oman, indicating changes in biogeochemical conditions taking place within the aquifers.

The increased predicted climate variability and the trend in precipitation decrease with probable evapotranspirationincrease has profound impacts on water balance. These will primarily affect groundwater recharge and quantity in thestudy areas, but will also lead to increased anthropogenic pressures on water.

The key for the estimation of potential groundwater quality feedbacks under changing climate in the future, includinggeogenic Cr release and oxidation, lies with being able to better constrain and manage the effects of anthropogenicpressures within water recharge zones.

Figure 6

The Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey-TÜBİTAK (Project No 115Y844)

IT Pollino RCP 4.5 IT Pollino RCP 8.5

GR Evia RCP 4.5 GR Evia RCP 8.5

TR Mersin RCP 4.5 TR Mersin RCP 8.5

CY Troodos RCP 4.5 CY Troodos RCP 8.5

JO Zarqa River RCP 4.5 JO Zarqa River RCP 8.5