24 BROOKLANDS AVENUE, CAMBRIDGE, CB2 8BU

Telephone 01223 582749 HistoricEngland.org.uk

Historic England is subject to both the Freedom of Information Act (2000) and Environmental Information Regulations (2004). Any Information held by the organisation can be requested for release under this legislation.

Ms Sarah Scott Direct Dial: 01223 582711 Babergh and Mid Suffolk District Councils Endeavour House Our ref: W: P01062387 8 Russell Road Ipswich Suffolk IP1 2BX 12 April 2019

Dear Ms Scott

T&CP (Development Management Procedure) (England) Order 2015 & Planning (Listed Buildings & Conservation Areas) Regulations 1990

LAND ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF THORNHAM ROAD, GISLINGHAM, SUFFOLK Application No. DC/19/01755

Thank you for your letter of 11 April 2019 regarding the above application for planning permission. On the basis of the information available to date, we do not wish to offer any comments. We suggest that you seek the views of your specialist conservation and archaeological advisers, as relevant.

It is not necessary for us to be consulted on this application again, unless there are material changes to the proposals. However, if you would like detailed advice from us, please contact us to explain your request.

Yours sincerely

Joanne Robinson Business Officer E-mail: Joanne.Robinson@HistoricEngland.org.uk

From: Planning <planning@suffolkwildlifetrust.org> Sent: 02 May 2019 12:45 To: BMSDC Planning Mailbox <planning@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Subject: RE: Expiring Consultation Requests Dear Katherine, DC/19/01634 – as Place Services commented on the original application, SWT have no further comment DC/19/01755 – SWT have no further comment Kind regards, Jill Crighton

Your Ref:DC/19/01755Our Ref: SCC/CON/1496/19Date: 15 April 2019

Endeavour House, 8 Russell Road, Ipswich, Suffolk. IP1 2BXwww.suffolk.gov.uk

All planning enquiries should be sent to the Local Planning Authority.Email: planning@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk

The Planning DepartmentMidSuffolk District CouncilPlanning Section1st Floor, Endeavour House8 Russell RoadIpswichSuffolkIP1 2BX

For the attention of: Sarah Scott

Dear Sir,

TOWN AND COUNTRY PLANNING ACT 1990CONSULTATION RETURN: DC/19/01755

PROPOSAL: Application under Section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act Outline Planning

Permission 0294/15 and Reserved Matters DC/17/06092 without compliance with

Condition 1 (Approved Plans and Drawings).

LOCATION: Land On The South Side Of Thornham Road Gislingham

ROAD CLASS:

Notice is hereby given that the County Council as Highway Authority make the followingcomments:

There is no objection to the revised drawings as there are no highway related amendments.

Yours faithfully,

Martin EganHighways Development Management EngineerGrowth, Highways and Infrastructure

From: Paul Harrison <Paul.Harrison@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Sent: 30 April 2019 11:27 To: Sian Bunbury <Sian.Bunbury@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk>; BMSDC Planning Area Team Yellow <planningyellow@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Subject: DC 19 01755 Gislingham Sian Heritage does not wish to offer comment on this proposal. Paul Paul Harrison Heritage and Design Officer T 01449 724677 | 07798 781360 E paul.harrison@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk E heritage@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk W www.babergh.gov.uk | www.midsuffolk.gov.uk

Consultee Comments for Planning Application DC/19/01755

Application Summary

Application Number: DC/19/01755

Address: Land On The South Side Of Thornham Road Gislingham Suffolk

Proposal: Application under Section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act Outline Planning

Permission 0294/15 and Reserved Matters DC/17/06092 without compliance with Condition 1

(Approved Plans and Drawings).

Case Officer: Sian Bunbury

Consultee Details

Name: Miss Parish Clerk

Address: 30 Broadfields Road, Gislingham, Eye, Suffolk IP23 8HX

Email: gislinghamparishcouncil@gmail.com

On Behalf Of: Gislingham Parish Clerk

Comments

Following the Gislingham Parish Council meeting held on 20th May 2019

The Parish Council wish to express concern over the developer ensuring adequate and permanent

provision to prevent surface water. This area is already flooding and causing problems for users of

the footpath registered on this development. We wish District Council to qualify who is now

responsible for safeguarding this following the responses received from consultees.

From: Nathan Pittam <Nathan.Pittam@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Sent: 29 April 2019 15:02 To: Sarah Scott <Sarah.Scott@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Cc: BMSDC Planning Area Team Yellow <planningyellow@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Subject: DC/19/01755. Land Contamination

Dear Sarah EP Reference : 258295 DC/19/01755. Land Contamination Land On The South Side Of, Thornham Road, Gislingham, EYE, Suffolk. Application under Section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act Outline Planning Permission 0294/15 and Reserved Matters DC/17/06092 without compliance with Condition 1 (Approved Plans and Drawings). Many thanks for your request for comments in relation to the proposed variation to the 2015 permission at the above site. I can confirm that I have no objection to the proposed variation. Kind regards Nathan Nathan Pittam BSc. (Hons.) PhD Senior Environmental Management Officer Babergh and Mid Suffolk District Councils – Working Together Email: Nathan.pittam@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk Work: 07769 566988 / 01449 724715 websites: www.babergh.gov.uk www.midsuffolk.gov.uk

Page 1 Ref1: SHMA 2012, p.122, Summary section Ref2: SHMA 2012, p.121, Table 9.22.1 Ref3: SHMA 2012, p.141, Table 12.1.9 Ref4:

MID SUFFOLK DISTRICT COUNCIL

MEMORANDUM

TO: Sarah Scott – Planning Officer From: Julie Abbey-Taylor, Professional Lead – Strategic Housing Date: 15/01/2018 SUBJECT: - Application Reference: DC/19/01755 Application under S73 of the T&C Planning Permission 0294/15 and Reserved Matters -DC/17/06092 without compliance with Condition 1 (approved Plans and drawings) at Land south side of Thornham Road, Gislingham.

Key Points 1. Background Information

A development proposal for fourty (40) residential dwellings

This is an open market development and offers 8 affordable housing units which = 20%.

2. Housing Need Information:

2.1 The Ipswich Housing Market Area, Strategic Housing Market Assessment (SMHA)

document, updated in 2019, confirms a continuing need for housing across all tenures and a growing need for affordable housing. A new SHMA is currently being written but outcomes are not available at the time of this consultation.

2.2 The 2019 SHMA indicates that in Mid Suffolk there is a need for 127 new affordable

homes per annum. Ref1 2.3 Furthermore, by bedroom numbers the affordable housing mix should equate to:

Ref2 Estimated proportionate demand for

affordable new housing stock by bedroom number

Bed Nos % of total new affordable stock

1 46%

2 36%

3 16%

Page 2 Ref1: SHMA 2012, p.122, Summary section Ref2: SHMA 2012, p.121, Table 9.22.1 Ref3: SHMA 2012, p.141, Table 12.1.9 Ref4:

4+ 2%

2.4 This compares to the estimated proportionate demand for new housing stock by bedroom size across all tenures.

Ref3Estimated proportionate demand for all tenure new housing stock by bedroom

number

Bed Nos % of total new stock

1 18%

2 29%

3 46%

4+ 6%

2.5 The Council’s 2014 Suffolk Housing Needs Survey shows that there is high demand for

smaller homes, across all tenures, both for younger people, who may be newly forming households, and also for older people who are already in the property-owning market and require different, appropriate housing, enabling them to downsize. Affordability issues are the key drivers for this increased demand for smaller homes.

2.6 The Council’s Choice Based Lettings system currently has circa.780 applicants

registered for affordable housing in Mid Suffolk at January 2019. 2.7 This site is a S106 planning obligation site, so the affordable housing provided will be to

meet district wide need hence the 780 applicants registered is the important number. 3. Mix for Open Market homes. The open market mix consists of: -

• 13 x 3 bed detached houses ranging in size from 85.2 – 102.2 sqm

• 13 x 4 bed detached houses ranging in size from 116.4 – 153.2 sqm

• 7 x 5 bed detached houses ranging in size from 180.1 – 223 sqm There are no 2 bed houses or bungalows within this development which is a point I raised in my consultation on the outline application. The affordable housing unlike most of the open market dwellings is located in a clump off a shared drive and due to their size and that they are the only semi-detached dwellings will not be tenure blind as per the Council’s requirements. The open market homes will not be affordable to buy by first time buyers or event for those households in existing entry level to upgrade to as they are aimed to be a premium product and are all detached dwellings. The open market mix does not provide opportunities for young purchasers or for older owner occupiers to downsize. There is already a high proportion of large executive housing in Gislingham with 36% of the homes with 4 or more bedrooms. 86% of the homes in Gislingham are owner-

Page 3 Ref1: SHMA 2012, p.122, Summary section Ref2: SHMA 2012, p.121, Table 9.22.1 Ref3: SHMA 2012, p.141, Table 12.1.9 Ref4:

occupied and of those, 83% are under-occupied by one or more bedroom. The village does not need this level or 4 and 5 bed bedroomed detached dwellings. 4. Preferred mix for Affordable Housing 4.1 The most recent information from the Mid Suffolk’s Council’s Housing Register shows

10 applicants registered who have a connection to Gislingham.

4.2 8 of the proposed dwellings on the development will be for affordable housing. These have been offered the form of: -

Rented 75% = 6 units: -

• 6 x 2-bedroom 4-person houses at 76.4 sqm. Our requirements are for all 2 bed houses to be suitable for 4 persons and 79sqm, so these are 2.6sqm too small.

Shared ownership 25% = 2 units: -

• 2 x 2 bed 4-person houses @ 76.4 sqm. Our requirements are for all 2 bed houses to be suitable for 4 persons and 79sqm, so these are 2.6sqm too small.

The revised layout and property mix has not changed from the previous application for the affordable homes so they are still not up to NDSS sizes. 5. Other requirements for affordable homes:

• Properties must be built to current Housing Standards Technical requirements March 2015.

• The council is granted 100% nomination rights to all the affordable units on first lets and on subsequent lets in perpetuity

• All affordable units to be transferred freehold to one of the Councils preferred Registered providers.

• Adequate parking provision is made for the affordable housing units Julie Abbey-Taylor, Professional Lead – Strategic Housing

From: Robson, Liam S <Liam.Robson@environment-agency.gov.uk> Sent: 02 May 2019 13:11 To: BMSDC Planning Area Team Yellow <planningyellow@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Subject: RE: DC/19/01755 - Land on the South Side of Thornham Road, Gislingham Dear Katherine, Thank you for your email – the application does not trigger a consultation on our checklist so we therefore have no comments. I can see that we provided a response to the outline application (0294/15) on 25 March 2015 and requested a surface water condition. We no longer comment on surface water and as such I would recommend that the LLFA are consulted. Any questions, do let me know. Kind Regards Liam

Liam Robson Sustainable Places Planning Advisor – East Anglia Area (East) Environment Agency | Iceni House, Cobham Road, Ipswich, Suffolk, IP3 9JD liam.robson@environment-agency.gov.uk External: 02084 748 923 | Internal: 48923 Working hours: Monday to Friday 7am-3pm

Do your future plans have environmental issues or opportunities? Speak to us early! If you are planning a new project or development, we want to work with you to make the process as smooth as possible. We offer a tailored advice service with an assigned project manager giving you detailed and timely specialist advice. Early engagement can improve subsequent planning and permitting applications to

you and your clients’ benefit. More information can be found on our website here.

From: RM Floods Planning <floods.planning@suffolk.gov.uk> Sent: 15 April 2019 08:50 To: BMSDC Planning Area Team Yellow <planningyellow@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Cc: Sarah Scott <Sarah.Scott@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Subject: 2019-04-15 JS Reply Land On The South Side Of, Thornham Road, Gislingham Ref DC/19/01755 Dear Sarah Scott, Subject: Land On The South Side Of, Thornham Road, Gislingham Ref DC/19/01755 Suffolk County Council, Flood and Water Management have reviewed application ref DC/19/01755 We have no comments to make. Kind Regards, Jason Skilton Flood & Water Engineer Suffolk County Council Growth, Highway & Infrastructure Endeavour House, 8 Russell Rd, Ipswich , Suffolk IP1 2BX

Enter the Creating the Greenest County Awards!

From: Infrastructure Team (Babergh Mid Suffolk) <Infrastructure@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Sent: 12 April 2019 14:29 To: BMSDC Planning Area Team Yellow <planningyellow@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Cc: Infrastructure Team (Babergh Mid Suffolk) <Infrastructure@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Subject: RE: MSDC Planning Consultation Request - DC/19/01755 Dear Sarah, The development lies in the high value zone for MSDC and will attract CIL at a rate of £115m² subject to indexation. The CIL Liability is not calculated until approval of reserve matters for the dwellings. Kind Regards, Richard Kendrew Infrastructure Support Officer Babergh District & Mid Suffolk District Council – Working Together 01449 724563 www.babergh.gov.uk & www.midsuffolk.gov.uk

Consultee Comments for Planning Application DC/19/01755

Application Summary

Application Number: DC/19/01755

Address: Land On The South Side Of Thornham Road Gislingham Suffolk

Proposal: Application under Section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act Outline Planning

Permission 0294/15 and Reserved Matters DC/17/06092 without compliance with Condition 1

(Approved Plans and Drawings).

Case Officer: Sian Bunbury

Consultee Details

Name: Mr Tony Bass

Address: Endeavour House, Ipswich IP1 2BX

Email: tony.bass@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk

On Behalf Of: Communities (Major Development)

Comments

No comments

From: BMSDC Public Realm Consultation Mailbox <consultpublicrealm@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Sent: 18 April 2019 16:02 To: BMSDC Planning Area Team Yellow <planningyellow@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Subject: RE: MSDC Planning Consultation Request - DC/19/01755

Planning Team Yellow The Public Realm Team have no further comments on this application. We note that a landscape/public open space management plan is due to be submitted and approved in due course and we would welcome the opportunity to input into this process. The open spaces within this development should be maintained locally as it is not an area that the District Council would seek to acquire or maintain in the future. Regards

Dave Hughes Countryside and Public Realm Babergh & Mid Suffolk District Councils – Working Together Tel 01449 724639 Mob 07990 542090 Email: david.hughes@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk Websites www.midsuffolk.gov.uk www.babergh.gov.uk

From: Andy Rutson-Edwards <Andy.Rutson-Edwards@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Sent: 01 July 2019 09:37 To: Sian Bunbury <Sian.Bunbury@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk>; BMSDC Planning Area Team Yellow <planningyellow@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk>; BMSDC Planning Mailbox <planning@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Subject: DC/19/01755 APPLICATION FOR PLANNING PERMISSION WITHOUT COMPLIANCE OF CONDITION(S) - DC/19/01755 Proposal: Application under Section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act Outline Planning Permission 0294/15 and Reserved Matters DC/17/06092 without compliance with Condition 1 (Approved Plans and Drawings). Location: Land On The South Side Of, Thornham Road, Gislingham, Suffolk Thank you for re consulting me on the above application following the submission of amended plans. I have no further comments to make in addition to those already submitted in terms of noise from the air source heat pumps and working hours during development Andy

Andy Rutson-Edwards, MCIEH AMIOA Senior Environmental Protection Officer Babergh and Mid Suffolk District Council - Working Together Tel: 01449 724727 Email andy.rutson-edwards@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk www.babergh.gov.uk www.midsuffolk.gov.uk

From: Andy Rutson-Edwards <Andy.Rutson-Edwards@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Sent: 10 May 2019 11:32 To: Sian Bunbury <Sian.Bunbury@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk>; BMSDC Planning Area Team Yellow <planningyellow@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk> Subject: DC/19/01755 additional comments APPLICATION FOR PLANNING PERMISSION WITHOUT COMPLIANCE OF CONDITION(S) - DC/19/01755 Proposal: Application under Section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act Outline Planning Permission 0294/15 and Reserved Matters DC/17/06092 without compliance with Condition 1 (Approved Plans and Drawings). Location: Land On The South Side Of, Thornham Road, Gislingham, Suffolk Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the above application, in addition to my earlier comments. The original permission granted under appeal required a construction method statement. Please condition as below:

1. No development shall commence until a Construction and Environmental Management Plan (CEMP), to cover both site clearance and construction phases of the development, has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The CEMP shall be undertaken in accordance with best practice guidelines and BS: 5228:2009 + A1:2014 (and any revisions thereof).

The plan shall include details of operating hours, (recommended 0800-1800 Mon-Fri, 0900-1300 Sat with no working on Sundays or bank holidays) scheduled timing/phasing of development for the overall construction period, means of access, traffic routes, vehicle parking and manoeuvring areas (site operatives and visitors), loading and unloading of plant and materials, location and management of wheel washing facilities, external lighting, location and nature of compounds and storage areas (including maximum storage heights), waste removal, location and nature of temporary buildings and boundary treatments, dust management, noise management (both in terms of workers and local residents) and waste/litter management during the construction phases of the development. Thereafter, the approved construction plan shall be fully implemented and adhered to during the construction phases of the development hereby approved, unless otherwise agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority. Note: the Construction Management Plan shall be submitted in phases for each phase of construction so as to take account of protection measures for both newly constructed (and occupier) dwellings as well as those dwellings which existed prior to commencement

Reason – To minimise detriment to nearby residential amenity.

2. No burning shall take place on site during the site clearance/demolition or construction phases of the development.

Reason – To minimise detriment to nearby residential amenity.

3. Any external lighting associated with the development shall be kept to the minimum necessary for the purposes of security and site safety and shall prevent upward and outward light radiation. Reason – To minimise detriment to nearby residential amenity.

Andy

Andy Rutson-Edwards, MCIEH AMIOA Senior Environmental Protection Officer Babergh and Mid Suffolk District Council - Working Together Tel: 01449 724727 Email andy.rutson-edwards@baberghmidsuffolk.gov.uk www.babergh.gov.uk www.midsuffolk.gov.uk

APPLICATION FOR PLANNING PERMISSION WITHOUT COMPLIANCE OF CONDITION(S) - DC/19/01755 Proposal: Application under Section 73 of the Town and Country Planning Act Outline Planning Permission 0294/15 and Reserved Matters DC/17/06092 without compliance with Condition 1 (Approved Plans and Drawings). Location: Land On The South Side Of, Thornham Road, Gislingham, Suffolk Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the above application. Although I have no objections in principle, The noise levels from all of the Air Source heat pumps are close to the maximum MCS 020 maximum recommended levels. The acoustic technical memo relating to noise from the air source heat pumps indicates that the plant has a potential to cause unacceptable noise at several plots. This noise is caused by the proposed air source heat pumps installed in plots 22-29 without mitigation ( as shown in Table 3). The Adrian James Acoustic memo ref M001 Section 4.2 recommends mitigation methods that should be used to reduce the levels of noise from the plant at plots 22-29. The mitigation method recommended should be secured by way of the following condition: Noise

1. All proposed plots having Air Source Heat Pump (ASHP) installations that will exceed the MCS 020 recommended levels, as highlighted in Table 3 of Section 4 of the ‘12139 ASHP CALCULATIONS, GISLINGHAM TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM NO. M001‘ by Adrian James Acoustics Limited dated 29th March 2019. shall be constructed with the relevant ASHP installation location and mitigation scheme as specified in Figure 6 of section 4.2 to achieve the levels shown in Table 4.

2. As the levels at all plots are close to the maximum levels recommended in MCS 020,

Prior to first occupation, a sample of dwellings, the number and location of which shall be agreed by the LPA and the developer, shall be independently tested to ensure that MCS 020 values are being met. If the levels are not achieved then a scheme of mitigation to ensure that the levels are met, shall be submitted for agreement by the LPA and installed in line with the recommendations.

3. All mitigation methods employed shall be maintained throughout the lifetime of the development.

Reason – To protect the future occupiers of noise sensitive dwellings from any adverse impacts of plant noise. Andy

Andy Rutson-Edwards, MCIEH AMIOA Senior Environmental Protection Officer