boma webinar: seattle building code calculating the occupant … · 2021. 5. 12. · occupant load...
TRANSCRIPT
BOMA Webinar: Seattle Building Code – Calculating the Occupant Load of Office Spaces
Presenter Bios and Contact Info
Ardel Jala, PE is Building Official for Seattle Department of Construction & Inspections. She is responsible for establishing technical policy and consistent enforcement of Seattle Building Codes throughout the department. Prior to joining the city in 2011, she worked as a structural engineer for 15 years designing seismic upgrades for a variety of existing building and historic preservation projects. Ardel serves on the Structural Engineers Association of Washington Existing Building Committee, the AIA Seattle Technical Code Committee and the BOMA Technical Code Committee. Ardel enjoys time with family, eating, being prep cook for her husband’s cooking and planning the next family adventure. She serves on the PTSA Racial Equity Committee for her children’s school and volunteers weekly for Food is Love, a local non-profit established during Covid19 that delivers meals from local restaurants to food insecure families. Email: [email protected]
Amie Joyce, IIDA, LEED ID + C, is a Project Manager and Senior Interior Designer with Weaver Architects in Seattle. She is responsible for all phases of project work starting with initial client contact, programming, planning, design development, construction documentation, and construction administration. Project types include tenant improvement, building re-positioning and common area upgrades, as well as working directly with owners and managers to implement BOMA surveys and strategies, as well as feasibility planning of vacant spaces for marketing purposes. Prior to moving to Seattle and starting work with Weaver Architects in 2009, Amie spent 11 years in Southern Arizona working in tenant improvement design and custom cabinetry. Email: [email protected]
Richard Pellinger Technical Codes Manager, City of Seattle Richard is currently the Technical Codes Manager for Seattle Department of Construction and Inspections. He is responsible for implementing technical policy and the Seattle Building Codes throughout the department. Prior to joining the City in 2007, Richard worked in Seattle with over 20 years of experience in building design and construction, including residential, mixed-use, and commercial work. Richard serves on the AIA Codes Committee and is a voting member for the ICC Code Development. In addition, he is a proud graduate of North Dakota State University. Email: [email protected]
Cited Resources Find your building occupancy: https://buildingconnections.seattle.gov/2021/02/03/how-to-find-your-business-occupancy/
Reopening resources for Businesses: https://www.seattle.gov/mayor/covid-19/covid-19-reopening
1
BOMA: Calculating the Occupant Load of Office Spaces
Ardel Jala and Richard Pellinger
Photo by John Skelton
May 12, 2021
2
Agenda
SDCI:
✓ Assembly vs Office Areas✓ Concentrated business use areas (new in 2018 SBC)✓ Non-simultaneous occupancy for the purpose of determining egress, plumbing fixtures or
risk category designation.✓ Code compliant options to increase existing egress capacity
Weaver Architects:
✓ Design and treatment of smaller tenant suites.✓ Egress design and review of multi-suite office floors and full floor tenant improvements✓ What does post-pandemic return to work look like?
3
Typical assembly occupancies
4
Typical open office seating
5
What is an Assembly Occupancy?
Group A Occupancy - AssemblySeattle Building Code (SBC) 303.1: “...for the gathering of persons for purposes such as civic, social or religious functions; recreation, food or drink consumption or awaiting transportation.”
Many types including:• Sporting Event Facilities• Food/drink consumption• Large gathering spaces such as
▪ Conference rooms▪ Lecture halls
6
Occupancy - Small Assemblies
Small buildings and tenant spaces – SBC 303.1.1
• Less than 50 occupants → Group B occupancy
Small assembly spaces accessory to another occupancy – SBC 303.1.2
• Two exceptions (<50 occ, <750 sf)
• Group B occupancy OR part of the occupancy it is accessory to
7
What if my Assembly meets Ch 5 Accessory limits?
Accessory Occupancies
SBC 508.2: “...ancillary to the main occupancy of the building or portion thereof.”
• Occupancy classified by Ch 3.
• Still an Assembly occupancy when exceeds limits of SBC 303.1.2 Small Assembly spaces
• Area limited to 10% of floor
• Height and location in the building per the main occupancy of the building
• No separation to main occupancy
8
Occupancy Classification vs Occupant load factor
• Occupancy classification per SBC Chapter 3• Occupant load factor per SBC Chapter 10
assigned based on how a space is used
Conference Room example: Occupancy is based on size and occupant load
Assembly (A-3) OccupancyOffice (B) Occupancy
Occupant Load Factor is the same for these conference rooms → 15 net sf/occ assembly without fixed seats, unconcentrated
9
New in 2018 SBC: Office Occupant Load Factor = 150 gross sf/occ
▪ Office Occupant Load per 2018 SBC Table 1004.5 changed to
150 gross sf/occ
▪ Previously was 130 gross sf/occ for sprinkled building; 100 gross for non-sprinkled
10
Potential impacts of an Assembly occupancy classification or assembly occupant load factor
• Adding occupants to a floor can trigger an increase in required egress capacity and may require another exit from the story
Assembly occupancies have higher structural live load requirements (100 psf) than typical office floors (50 psf). May require strengthening existing floor framing.
Assembly occupancies are not permitted as part of a blanket permit
Adding occupants to a floor can trigger more plumbing fixtures
Changing a floor to all assembly occupancies can trigger sprinklers or fire alarm requirements for buildings without those systems (not as typical)
11
Separation of adjacent spaces
1) The vertical plane between the spaces is 50% or more
2) There is a major egress path separating adjacent spaces.
POLICY: Where multiple seating areas are adjacent to one another, each room is considered a separate space for determining occupancy classification when:
50% vertical plane
Major egress
Open office
Open office
Lounge Kitchen
12
Calculating Occupant Loads - Assembly or Office?
Whether a space should be assigned an assembly occupant load factor (OLF) or an office occupant load factor will depend on how the space is used and configured
13
Occupant Load and Non-simultaneous use
SBC Ch 10 Means of egress sizing is based on the occupant load with all spaces fully loaded. SDCI does not accept non-simultaneous use as justification to reduce the occupant load for calculating required egress capacity. Occupancy lives with the building not with the tenant and we cannot regulate use of the space.
SBC Ch 29 permits limited non-simultaneous use. Spaces “not normally occupied” and ancillary to the main occupancy of the building can be assigned zero occupants for calculating min plumbing fixtures.
Non-Simultaneous Use: same people in a conference room or on the balcony as on the floor so should not have to double count those occupants
14
Assembly or Office OLF? Small Conf Rooms
SDCI POLICY: SDCI accepts an office OLF (150 sf/occ gross) for small conference rooms <=150 sf
Small conference rooms, huddle rooms, focus rooms, breakout rooms <=150 sf→ Office OLF
15
Assembly or Office OLF? Reception Area
Reception Areas
seating areas with adjacent assembly spaces → Assembly OLF
PantryPrivate booths
16
Assembly or Office OLF? Reception Area
Reception Areas
Example: Adjacent to assembly space but limited area given circulation path to elevators and conference rooms
→ Office OLF
17
Gathering space adjacent to assembly spacesi.e. break rooms, large conference rooms, large gathering areas
→ Assembly OLF
Assembly or Office OLF? Lounge seating
18
Assembly or Office OLF? Lounge Seating
Lounges, Collab Space
Lounge areas withinopen office seating
→ Office OLF
19
Assembly or Office OLF? Kitchens
• Cafeteria, Kitchenette, coffee counter, break room, beverage bar → Assembly OLF
• OK to omit built in casework from OL calculation
• Does SDCI accept non-simultaneous use for these spaces? No
20
Assembly or Office OLF?
Office or Concentrated business use OLF
Assembly OLF
21
• Balconies → Assembly OLF
• OK to omit major egress path and permanent planters when applying a net occupant load factor for assembly
• Does SDCI accept non-simultaneous use for these spaces? No
• Structural: live load is 1.5 times LL of area served, not to exceed 100 psf
Assembly or Office OLF? Balconies
22
Occupant Load Factor: Office Example
150 gross
23
Occupant Load Factor: Office Example
Small Conf Rooms <150 sf- Ok at Office OLF
150 gross
24
Occupant Load Factors for other typical spaces
• Circulation on the floor – it depends
• Where adjacent areas are primarily open office with an OLF of 150 gross sf/occ → apply the same OLF to circulation
• Where adjacent areas are primarily assembly with an OLF using a 15 or 7 net sf/occ → OK to exclude assignment of OLF to circulation
• Main lobby spaces at primary entrance
• Generally have large open areas with no programming
• Assign something to lobby – OK to use an office OLF
• Assign seating areas assembly OLF
• Training spaces - 20 net sf/occ Classroom OLF ok if configured like a classroom; else use 15 net sf/occ for Assembly
25
Occupant Load Factor: Office Example
OLF at CIRCULATION - It depends!
150 gross
26
New in 2018 SBC: Concentrated Business Use
Apply a concentrated business use OLF when the ratio of the number of occupants per square feet based on the seating layout is closer to 1:50 than 1:150
27
Clustered Conference Rooms
• Contiguous conference rooms assigned an assembly occupant load factor but may be individually classified as Group B occupancy
• When grouped together as a cluster, likely to be used simultaneously
• POLICY: Design for an assembly live load (non reducible) when the contiguous assembly areas covers a significant portion of floor plate - more than 25% of the floor area of the story
SDCI Code Interpretation “Clustered Conference Rooms – Live Load and Occupancy”
http://www.seattle.gov/Documents/Departments/SDCI/Codes/2015SBC16072ClusteredConfRooms.pdf
28
Seismic Risk Category and non-simultaneous use
• When a buildings occupant load reaches 5,000 occupants it triggers in increase from a typical Risk Category II building to Risk Category III.
• The building must be designed for the higher force seismic forces and snow loads associated with the higher RCIII.
• Non-simultaneous use is accepted for calculating occupant loads for determining Risk Category. See SDCI Code Interpretation “Risk Category Occupant Load Calculations”
http://www.seattle.gov/Documents/Departments/SDCI/Codes/2015SBC16045RiskCategoryOccupantLoad.pdf
29
New in 2018 SBC: who reviews plumbing?
Public Health – Seattle King County (PH-SKC) still has authority for plumbing permits…
New in the 2018 SBC• SDCI to check SBC Ch 29 including the count and
location of minimum plumbing fixtures• PH-SKC is enforcing fixture count as shown on
construction permit plans as approved by SDCI
2015 SBC … going back to 2003 SBC and earlier..• PH-SKC review and enforced Ch 29
30
SBC Ch29 Plan Review - Min plumbing fixtures
When is plan review of minimum plumbing fixtures required for a tenant improvement in an existing building?
• Change of occupancy classification or change of use for an existing tenant space or building.
• An addition or alteration that increases the occupant load of an existing building
• Addition or alteration that proposes a reduction in plumbing fixtures/facilities
What permit do I need for alterations to plumbing fixtures?
• SDCI permit (STFI or plan review depends on extent of alterations)
• PH-SKC plumbing permit
What if my proposed alterations do not impact the toilet facilities, are not part of a change of use and do not increase the occupant load on the story?
Existing facilities may remain as existing non-conforming without complying with current plumbing fixture requirements.
31
What options are there to increase my egress capacity?
What options are there when the proposed occupant load of a floor exceeds the egress capacity of the existing two stairs?
• Sprinklers and an emergency voice/alarm communication system
• Horizontal Exit• Refine occupant load analysis• Egress modeling (Code modification)
32
Horizontal Exits – flexibility around SBC 1006.3
Horizontal Exits can be always be used to increase existing egress capacity, i.e. from 440 to 500 occ.
SBC 1006.3 prohibits horizontal exits to count towards the required number of exits from a story. However, SDCI is open to a code modification to waive this when:
• The building is Type 1 construction
• The building is sprinklered throughout (NFPA13)
• Other two exits must meet exit separation requirements
• Movable partitions OK only within allowable openings of the fire barrier
33
QUESTIONS?
Ardel Jala, Building [email protected]
Richard Pellinger, Technical Codes [email protected]
DW
COPY /SUPPLY
BREAK
SERVER
ENTRY
RECEPTION
COLLABORATION
5' BENCHING
LARGECONFERENCE
MED. CONF.
SM. CONF.
OFFICE OFFICE
LARGECONFERENCE
ENTRYHOTEL COPY
8x8WORKSTATIONS
5x7WORKSTATIONS
OFFICE
SERVER
CAFE
COPY /COFFEE MEETING
Conf / Collab. > 150 sf (1/15 Net SF)Lounges
Business Office Areas (1/150 Net SF)
Unplanned Vacant Tenant Space -Occupant Load Max 77
Concen. Business Use (1/50 Gross SF)
Conf / Collab. < 150 sf (1/150 GrossSF)
Break Rooms w/ Seating (1/15 Net SF)
MEETING
MEETING MEETING
Suite Area Appx 4,970 SF
Maximum Available OccupantLoad = 77
28
11
13
16LOUNGE
37
1
11
10
1 1
19
24
12
1
4
12
Suite Area Appx 1,380 SF17 Occupants
Suite Area Appx 3,470 SF57 Occupants
Suite Area Appx 4,940 SF115 Occupants
Multi-Tenant Floor Non-Sprinkled Bldg.
Per SDCI, Concentrated Business Useis intended to be utilized in areas thathave a much denser headcount that atypical office setting.
If the Concentrated Business Use areais not "significant portion" of the tenantspace, after Assembly areas havebeen deducted from the SF, they canbe tabulated at the Business OfficeAreas factor of 1/150
"Significant Portion" = 30% or more ofthe available SF dedicated to thedenser layout.
Egress Components that Determine Occupant Load in this Example:Egress Stair Door (Qty of 2): 34" clear opening / .2 x 2 = 340 OccupantsStair Width (Qty of 2): 41.5" wide / 0.3 x 2 = 276 Occupants276 Occupants is the maximum load that the stairs can support
Area of Concentrated Business Use is a "significantportion" (i.e. more than 30%) of available area
Area of Concentrated BusinessUse is a "significant portion" (i.e.more than 30%) of available area
Note: Buildings and space layouts shown in slides are not to scale and arenot indicative of specific buildings or tenants. Cores and buildingperimeters have been altered for presentation purposes. All areas calledout do not reference BOMA calculations for Usable or Rentable area.
DW
5' BENCHING
LARGECONFERENCE
COLLAB
COFFEESERVER
PRINT RECEPTIONMEET
PHONE
PHONE
PHONE
PHONE
OFFICE OFFICE
CAFE
COLLAB
CO
PY
/ SU
PP
LIE
S
6x8WORKSTATIONS
6x8WORKSTATIONS
Why is this not consideredConcentrated Business Use?
This area consists of 25% of theavailable tenant suite SF afterAssembly Areas have beendeducted Conf / Collab. > 150 sf (1/15 Net SF)
Lounges
Business Office Areas (1/150 Gross SF)
Conf / Collab. < 150 sf (1/150 Gross SF)
Break Rooms w/ Seating (1/15 Net SF)
21 24
29
Suite Area Appx 4,970 SF74 Occupants
For this example, if the Prospective Tenant desiredto install 5' Benching in both Open Office Areas,that area would total 60% of the available tenantsuite SF after Assembly Areas have beendeducted, requiring them to be calculated asConcentrated Business Use.
With the conversion to Concentrated Business UseArea and the associated denser calculation of1/50, the total Suite Occupant Load would increaseto 126 Occupants, which is 49 occupants too highto be supported by the egress componentsavailably on the floor.
POTENTIAL TENANT SPACE LAYOUT LIMITED TOA MAXIMUM OCCUPANT LOAD OF 77 OR LESS
Strategies for Limiting Occupant Loads toAccommodate Egress Components
- Limit Conference Rooms > 150sf- Limit Break Room Spaces- Increased Built-out Environment
- Consider Traditional 6x8 or larger workstations to work within the 1/150 calculation
- Limit amount of Dense Bench Seating in Open Office so as not to trigger the Concentrated Business Use Classification
Multi-Tenant Floor Non-Sprinkled Bldg.Note: Buildings and space layouts shown in slides are not to scale and arenot indicative of specific buildings or tenants. Cores and buildingperimeters have been altered for presentation purposes. All areas calledout do not reference BOMA calculations for Usable or Rentable area.
COLLAB
KITCHEN
SEATING
SEATING
GAMES
OFFICEOFFICEOFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
COLLAB
CO
PY
/ SU
PP
LIE
S
CONFERENCE
COFFEE
OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE
SERVER
MEETING
CONFERENCECONFERENCE
CO
FFEE
FLEXIBLEMEETING
PHONE
PHONE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
OFFICE
PHONE
PHONE
CONFERENCE
STO
RA
GE
CO
ATS
CO
PY
/ SU
PP
LIE
S
STO
RA
GE
CO
ATS
WELLNESS
CONFERENCE
PHONEOFFICE
PHONEOFFICE OFFICEOFFICEOFFICE OFFICE
PANTRYSTORAGE
COLLAB
MEETING
5' BENCHING
5' BENCHING
5' BENCHING
5' BENCHING
5' BENCHING
5' BENCHING5' BENCHING
STORAGE COATS
RECEPTION
Full Floor Tenant Sprinkled Bldg.
Conf / Collab. > 150 sf (1/15 Net SF)Lounges
Business Office Areas (1/150 Net SF)
Concen. Business Use (1/50 Gross SF)
Conf / Collab. < 150 sf (1/150 GrossSF)
Break Rooms w/ Seating (1/15 Net SF)
Per SDCI, Concentrated Business Useis intended to be utilized in areas thathave a much denser headcount that atypical office setting.
If the Concentrated Business Use areais not "significant portion" of the tenantspace, after Assembly areas havebeen deducted from the SF, they canbe tabulated at the Business OfficeAreas factor of 1/150
"Significant Portion" = 30% or more ofthe available SF dedicated to thedenser layout.
Egress Components that Determine Occupant Load inthis Example:Egress Stair Door (Qty of 2): 34" clear opening / .15 x 2= 453 OccupantsStair Width (Qty of 2): 44" wide / 0.2 x 2 = 440Occupants
440 Occupants is the maximum load that the stairs cansupport
(Note: Max Occupant Load Decreases to 293 ifSprinklers & Fire Alarm are not updated to 2018 SBC)
EGRESS PATH
COLLAB
COLLAB
COLLAB
56 58
13133613
12
1
1
25
393818
20
19
Individual areas are separated bymin. 50% wall or barrier, which doesnot trigger a Change of Use forAssembly Occupancy
3
3
3
64
Suite Area Appx 21,730 SF435 Occupants
Note: Buildings and space layouts shown in slides are not to scale and arenot indicative of specific buildings or tenants. Cores and buildingperimeters have been altered for presentation purposes. All areas calledout do not reference BOMA calculations for Usable or Rentable area.
Area of Concentrated Business Use is a"significant portion" (i.e. more than 30%)of available area. This plan examplereflects a 40% SF usage for ConcentratedBusiness Use