book review on coping proverty final
TRANSCRIPT
BOOK REVIEW ON
Coping PovertyA Psychological Perspective
Authors:
Nurun Nahar KabirRanjan Kumar Guh
Reviewed By:
Dr. Monira Yasmin, Roll-41Dr. Mymoon Redwan Chowdhury, Roll-42
Guided by:Mr.Abdullah Al Mamun,Joint
Director(Research),BARD
Bangladesh Academy for Rural Development (BARD)Kotbari, Comilla
1
Acknowledgement
All praises go to the Almighty Allah, the Creator of Universe, Who enabled us to complete the review work
of such a resourceful book successfully.
We express our gratefulness to our learned guide, Mr. Abdullah Al Mamun, Joint Director (Research),
BARD, Comilla, For his kind co-operation, valuable suggestions & inspiration regarding
this book review to be done in such a short course of time.
We are also highly obliged for expressing our gratification and sincere appreciation to the respected course management and to all the
participants of the 124th Special Foundation Training Course for their warmth co-operation, encouragement and valuable suggestions during
the entire period of work.
In addition, we apologize to the Authors of this book for any of our mistakes regarding this review.
2
ContentsSl
No.Subjects Page
1 Introduction 4 - 6Bibliographic Information of the book 4
Introducing the authors of the book 5Main theme of the book 5
Structural & Physical Get up of the book 6Importance, Significance & Relevance of the book 6
2 Components of Subject Matter 6 - 12Objectives: General & Specific 6
Methodology 7Study areas & livelihood strategies 8
Approaches, perception, reaction & understanding of poverty
9
Psychological impact of poverty 9Access to control over resources & services 10
Case of Milk Vita 11Vulnerability & Coping of crisis 11
3 Community 124 Criticism 12 5 Conclusion 136 Suggestions 14
3
Introduction
Bibliographic Information of the book:
Title: Coping Poverty
A Psychological Perspective
Authors: Mrs. Nurun Nahar Kabir Mr. Ranjan Kumar Guha
Published By: Bangladesh Academy for Rural Development (BARD) Kotbari, Comilla
Year : First Published in 2009
4
Introducing the Authors of the book:
Ms Nurun Nahar Kabir obtained MSc in Psychology from University of
Dhaka, Masters in Gender & Development from United Kingdom, having 40
research studies ranging from Psychology, Rural Development to Gender
issues. She served as Project Director of different projects of BARD
(Bangladesh Academy for Rural Development).
Mr. Ranjan Kumar Guha obtained Masters with Honors in Management
from University of Dhaka, having more than 20 research studies in various
fields of development. He has developed his interest in the field of poverty
analysis by leading to research project namely Local Level Poverty
Monitoring System at BARD (Bangladesh Academy for Rural
Development). He presented five papers on the issue of poverty at
International conferences. He is now serving as Joint Director (Training) of
BARD (Bangladesh Academy for Rural Development).
Main Theme of the Book:
The pro-poor policy of Bangladesh aims at providing well-prioritized
national strategy for poverty reduction, human development & gender
equality. The book attempts to explore the complex inter linkages of gender
and age with poverty and the interface of both with psychological and social
perspectives. The main aim was to provide an alternative conceptualization
and analysis of resource for coping process and support required for
addressing poverty.
5
Structural & physical get up of the book:
The book consists of 168 pages, six chapters. Each chapter contains
elaborate discussion on specific issues with case studies (25 case studies). It
is illustrated with tables and appendices. It is printed on offset paper with
clear black letters and has a matted binding with a nice cover. It also
contains a preface given by the authors. The cover page shows smiling face
of a child behind rods of a window.
Importance, significance and relevance of the book:
This book is very important as it may be helpful for planning development
intervention for the poor to eradicate poverty. It is significant in the sense
that authors tried to explore impact of poverty in relation to different aspects
including psychological point of view, which might not have been studied
before. It is very much relevant as the poor are still representing 40% of our
population who remain under poverty line.
Components of Subject Matter
Objectives:
General objective:
To explore the consequence of poverty on the poorest people from the
psychological perspectives and their coping mechanism to reduce
6
stress, vulnerability, shocks by gender and age groups in different
regions of the country.
Specific objectives:
Identify the psychological impacts of poverty on the poorest people by
gender and age
Find out coping strategies of the poorest people by gender and age
Identify access to control over the resources and services provided by
the development organizations and communities to the poorest group.
Methodology:
The book is a research work based on participatory method. The research
was mainly conducted on primary information and facts collected from four
districts of Bangladesh. It is a very useful and effective method where the
trained field investigators were able to collect both qualitative and
quantitative data. In the first phase of fieldwork, the field investigators
conducted a household census. In the second phase of fieldwork,
investigators collected in-depth information with the help of checklist. In the
third phase of fieldwork, the field investigators conducted a large number of
case studies. The major tools used in this research, were Focused Group
Discussions (FGDs) and Case Studies. All information collected separately
from different age, gender and socio economic status groups of Near Poor
7
(NP), Poor (P), Very Poor (VP) households. Male and female children of
same economic group were discussed separately for maintaining their
information secrecy. Aged male and female of different socio economic
groups were discussed in different small groups separately. A few FGDs and
case studies were conducted with youth group to know their views
separately.
Stu
dy areas and livelihood strategies:
The different livelihood of respondents is nicely described at the chapter-2 in
this book. This chapter briefly introduces the area coverage, livelihood
pattern and socio-economic condition of the respondents. The major
concerns for selecting the areas were seasonal variations, natural resources
and calamities, difference in language, culture and presence of development
interventions. The natural calamities were flood, drought, river erosion, tidal
wave in the coastal belt. Livelihood system generally defines as the mix of
individual and household survival strategies developed over a given period
of time through mobilizing available resources and opportunities. In
analyzing livelihood three distinct features are observed: entitlement, gender
and socio-economic status (SES). Time specific and season based income,
locality, environment and surrounding opportunities etc. largely influence
the respondents to adjust with these mix strategies for livelihoods.
8
Approaches, Perception, Reaction and Understanding
of poverty:
These are described at the chapter-3.
Absolute poverty is measured by assessing minimum standard of living
calorie intake and nutritional levels, clothing, sanitation, health, and
education housing etc. that usually vary according to socio-economic and
political environment. Relative poverty states the relative position of
deprivation as compared to national average income levels. Along with the
perception of shortage of income, poverty also encounters the lack of access
to education, health, technology, inputs, and other social services. It is
related to the need of redistributing the wealth. Though not much significant
there were some differences in perception, reaction, and coping mechanisms
by gender, age, socio-economic condition, and geographic location. In
describing poverty situation the reactions expressed by the respondents of
different age, gender and SES groups were more about their experiences,
feelings and attitude. Method-mix process like FGD, case studies, and close
discussion brings tremendous advantages in building rapport and in going
closer to the feeling retort reaction expressed by the respondents.
Psychological impact of poverty:
It is described at the chapter- Four.
In this book the psychological impact of poverty on children and adult
described separately in a very nice way. In analyzing the findings of this
9
study gender dimensions, socio-cultural norms and values (like patriarchy,
power relation, peoples attitude and practice), development and welfare
activities and people access to and control over the resources are discussed
for better understanding of the poverty and psychological perspectives. Poor
people in general face problems of growing unemployment, declining real
wages and unsatisfactory working environment at the work place. Mental
illness among them is in the rise, which is mostly related to stress from
unemployment, increased violence against them, social unrest, etc. Major
reasons for psychological and mental stress informed by the respondents are
mainly four types: social, economical, health and emotional. Social reasons
include dowry, violence insecurity, lack of shelter etc. Economic reasons are
lack of food, unemployment and lack of work and lack of work. Health
reasons comprise chronic disease, disability of the earning member and in
case of women involvement of husband and children in risky jobs.
Emotional ground comprises neglect, abuse, mistrust, negative attitude etc.
This study confirms that the poverty makes a child emotionally isolated
from the society and develop depression, anxiety among the adult people.
Access to control over resources and services:
This is described at the chapter- Five.
Micro-credit means spending money on the income generation activities but
they often spend it to the survival needs, to pay for dowry or for the paying
back another loan. Sometimes they spend the money for treatment and
medication purpose. Based on the above-mentioned situation, the
respondents distinctly divided the types of the credit support they require
into two: a. in cash and b. in kind. The respondents described sources of
10
credit support as a. formal (from bank, organizations) and b. informal (from
relatives, friends and neighbors). A significant number of respondents
mentioned moneylenders as one of the important sources of credit. Though
the risk and vulnerability is greater than rate of interest, poor people borrow
credit from moneylenders as they have no options left. Unfortunately, the
institutional credit support provided by the GOs and NGOs for addressing
health crisis and risks was found almost absent in all study areas.
Case of Milk Vita (Established in 1973):
It is also mentioned at chapter-Five.
It organized poor, landless and low-income milk producers of the local area
of Sirajgonj district and create secured marketing facilities through
providing fair price for produced milk. It also supply pure hygienic milk and
milk products foods to the urban areas with fair price.
Vulnerability and Coping of Crisis:
This is described at the chapter-Six.
Natural risks e.g. flood, cyclone, continuous rainfall and draught.
Personal risks e.g. diseases, disability, divorce, homelessness.
Economic risk e.g. lack of ownership of productive assets.
11
Political risk e.g. threat from musclemen, negative behaviour of
providers.
Social risks e.g. demand of dowry, lack of bargaining power.
Technical risks e.g. lack of information about facilities coping
competence and poverty.
Community:
Quality of social relation, level of peace or violence, activity
and power of community-based organizations
Coping with poverty includes adaptation with situation silently. Poor people
cope with shocks and problems by using their social capital. They frequently
borrow from relatives to ensure their food for very poor and poor household
it was found difficult to use social capital. MAN said ‘Goriber abar shoshur
bari’ meaning support from Father-in-laws home is not for the poor.
Criticism
Positive aspects:
Poverty viewed as complex multi-dimensional process.
12
It includes qualitative variables like participation, community
capability, crisis coping mechanism and psychological attributes.
The psychological analysis shows the socio-cultural practices of the
community significantly perpetuated poverty.
Poverty has been defined by a set of indicators perceived, identifies
and distinguished by the respondents of different age gender and class
in this group.
Taking cognizance different vulnerabilities and address them
differently for bringing equality not only between male and female but
also between different groups based on age, sex, class and area.
Negative aspects:
There was no definite set of indicators to define poverty by the
researchers.
They did not use any clinical tool to measure psychological impacts.
There was repetition of some concepts.
They were dependent only on focused group discussions and case
studies.
The study was also limited to certain areas of the country.
Conclusion
This book generates a vast quantity of uncovered information on coping
strategies of the poorest segment based on psychological perspective and
13
finds out ways and means for the GOs, NGOs and communities to mitigate
the psychological stress of these people and to give them the resources,
services and counseling. They need to succeed in better life. The GOs,
NGOs, communities, international organizations, research and training
institutes would be able to devise new development initiatives. Their
involvement with the basic development of the poor people in general raises
questions about how they can contribute to achieve the Millennium
Development Goals (MDGs). They already have initiated a number of
programs to redress poverty some of which are effective while others are not
much ineffective. A research needs to be conducted to find out the best
practices for immediate adoption. The findings of the study generate ample
opportunities for the GOs, NGOs and the INGOs as well as the communities
to design effective programmes and to expand a number of existing
programmes after redesigning them for outreach population.
Suggestions
This kind of study should be conducted all over the Bangladesh.
It is necessary to undertake a more comprehensive study highlighting
the different issues so as to have better understanding of the coping
poverty.
Bengali is our mother language. So this type of helpful book should
be in Bangle. We believe that, if this book would have been written in
Bangle it would be more useful to the general.
.
14