by: geeva gopalkrishnan and james gadea israeli diplomatic relations and arab fund disbursements:

19
The Politics of Arab Foreign Aid By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Upload: bennett-rodgers

Post on 30-Dec-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

The Politics of Arab Foreign Aid

By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea

Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Page 2: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Research QuestionWhat role do Israeli diplomatic relations have on

foreign aid disbursement by the Arab Fund to Arab League members?

Page 3: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

LEAGUE OF ARAB STATES

Page 4: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

ARAB FUND FOR ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

Page 5: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

HypothesisThe Arab Fund provides more aid to Arab

League countries that have diplomatic relationships with Israel.

Page 6: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Literature ReviewArab countries give

aid for economic development and political reasons.

Saudi Arabia gave aid during Cold War to counter socialist movements.

(Momani & Ennis)

Page 7: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Literature Review

(Neumayer 2003)

Greater Arab population, more Arab aid

Poorer Arab country, more Arab aid

No relationship with Israel, more Arab aid

Page 8: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:
Page 9: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Anwar Sadat

Page 10: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Case Study

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 450

1

2

3

4

5

6

Years

Aid

Dis

burs

em

ents

by A

rab F

und (

ln)

201220071978 1988

Aid Disbursements Received by Egypt

Page 11: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Theory

Arab States use the Arab Fund for Political Gain

Page 12: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Theory

Secret Promotion of Security

Economic Engagement

Page 13: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

• Arab Solidarity• Economic Engagement

instead of punishing

Theory

Page 14: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

TheoryArab Fund favors members who have

relations with Israel Publicly denounce IsraelPromote securitySecurity benefits of encouraging

diplomacy

Page 15: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Essentially…

It’s politics, baby.

Page 16: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

MethodologyAid Disbursements by

Arab Fund

Diplomatic Relations with Israel

GDP/capita

Population

African Country War Pariah

Dependent Variable:

Independent Variable:(Dichotomous)

Control Variables:

US AllyBritish

Colonial Legacy

Page 17: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Results

Page 18: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

Results * denotes significance at the |P|<.1 level; ** denotes significance at the |P|<.05 level; *** denotes significance at the |P|<.01 level

Page 19: By: Geeva Gopalkrishnan and James Gadea Israeli Diplomatic Relations and Arab Fund Disbursements:

No evidence that the members of the Arab League punish the establishment of diplomatic relationships with Israel through the Arab Fund.

In fact, we find significant evidence that points to the contrary.

Conclusion