calculation no. st-503, rev. 0, '3-60b cask trunnion ... · title 3-60b cask trunnion analyses...

30
Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural evaluation of the 3-60B Cask trunnion assembly under various load conditions. 2.0 INTRODUCTION The 3-60B cask is equipped with four identical trunnions to help the lifting, handling and transportation of the cask. The details of the trunnions are shown in Reference 1 drawing. Analyses of the trunnion assemblies and the cask body are provided in this document to show that the trunnion design meets the applicable requirements of 10 CFR Part 71 (Reference 2). The following load cases have been addressed. Load Case 1: Lifting The loaded cask is lifted using the two upper trunnions as shown in Figure 1. Load Case 2: Handling The cask is designed to be supported on the two pairs of the trunnions during the transportation. The trunnions also help the cask down-ended and lowered unto the supporting structure. See Figure 1 for the trunnion loading during the handling process. Load Case 3: Transportation/Regulatory Requirement Trunnions are used for the tie-down of the 3-60B Cask package during transportation. The transportation of the packages in the United States is controlled under the provisions of 49 CFR 393 (Reference 3). Loadings are specified by 49 CFR 393.102 for minimum performance criteria for cargo securement devices and systems. However, 10 CFR 71.45(b) requires that: "If there is a system of tie-down devices that is a structural part of the package, the system must be capable of withstanding, without generating stress in any material of the package in excess of its yield strength, a static force applied to the center of gravity of the package having a vertical component 2 times the weight of the package with its contents, a horizontal component along the direction in which the vehicle travels of 10 times weight of the package with contents, and a horizontal component in the transverse direction of 5 times the weight of the package with its contents." Since the I OCFR71 loading on the tie-down system is much more severe than the 49CFR393 loading, it is used for the evaluation of the 3-60 Cask package for the transportation conditions. Enveloping loading conditions on the trunnions are developed from the above load cases and for these load cases analyses of the trunnion assembly and the cask body has been performed using ANSYS finite element models (Reference 4).

Upload: others

Post on 10-Sep-2019

13 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions

Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8

1.0 OBJECTIVE

Structural evaluation of the 3-60B Cask trunnion assembly under various load conditions.

2.0 INTRODUCTION

The 3-60B cask is equipped with four identical trunnions to help the lifting, handling andtransportation of the cask. The details of the trunnions are shown in Reference 1 drawing.Analyses of the trunnion assemblies and the cask body are provided in this document to showthat the trunnion design meets the applicable requirements of 10 CFR Part 71 (Reference 2).

The following load cases have been addressed.

Load Case 1: Lifting

The loaded cask is lifted using the two upper trunnions as shown in Figure 1.

Load Case 2: Handling

The cask is designed to be supported on the two pairs of the trunnions during thetransportation. The trunnions also help the cask down-ended and lowered unto the supportingstructure. See Figure 1 for the trunnion loading during the handling process.

Load Case 3: Transportation/Regulatory Requirement

Trunnions are used for the tie-down of the 3-60B Cask package during transportation. Thetransportation of the packages in the United States is controlled under the provisions of 49CFR 393 (Reference 3). Loadings are specified by 49 CFR 393.102 for minimumperformance criteria for cargo securement devices and systems. However, 10 CFR 71.45(b)requires that:

"If there is a system of tie-down devices that is a structural part of the package, thesystem must be capable of withstanding, without generating stress in any material ofthe package in excess of its yield strength, a static force applied to the center of gravityof the package having a vertical component 2 times the weight of the package with itscontents, a horizontal component along the direction in which the vehicle travels of 10times weight of the package with contents, and a horizontal component in thetransverse direction of 5 times the weight of the package with its contents."

Since the I OCFR71 loading on the tie-down system is much more severe than the 49CFR393loading, it is used for the evaluation of the 3-60 Cask package for the transportationconditions.

Enveloping loading conditions on the trunnions are developed from the above load cases andfor these load cases analyses of the trunnion assembly and the cask body has been performedusing ANSYS finite element models (Reference 4).

Page 2: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions

Cale. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 2 of 8

3.0 REFERENCES

1. EnergySolutions Drawing C-002-165024-001, Rev. 0, "3-60B Cask General Arrangement andDetails."

2. Code of Federal Regulations 10 CFR PART 71- Packaging and Transportation of RadioactiveMaterial.

3. Code of Federal Regulations 49 CFR PART 393 - Transportation.

4. ANSYS, Rev. 11.0, Computer Software, ANSYS Inc., Canonsburg, PA, 2007.

4.0 MATERIAL PROPERTIES

Cask Shell

Specification: ASTM A-240 Type 304L

Minimum Yield Strength, SY = 25,000 psi

Minimum Ultimate Strength, S, = 70,000 psi

Trunnions

Specification: ASTM A-240 Type 304 (or Equivalent)

Minimum Yield Strength, SY -= 30,000 psi

Minimum Ultimate Strength, S, = 75,000 psi

5.0 ALLOWABLE STRESSES

The load cases described in Section 2.0 of this document require that the materials of the caskpackage do not yield under specified factored loads. Thus the following stress criteria are setfor the factored loads:

Normal stress allowable = yield strength of the material (Sy)

Shear stress allowable = 0.6xNormal stress allowable = 0.6Sy

Material Type Normal Stress Shear Stress Allowable,Allowable, psi psi

ASTM A-240 Type 304L 25,000 15,000

ASTM A-240 Type 304 30,000 18,000

The allowable stresses in the weld are conservatively taken to be the same as the base metal.

Page 3: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions

Cale. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 3 of 8

6.0 DESIGN LOADING

Weight of the package with its content, W = 80,000 lb

Load Case 1:

As shown in Figure 1, under the lifting conditions, each trunnion is subjected to the followingloading:

Longitudinal = 1.5xW = 1.5x80,000 = 120,000 lb

Lateral 0

Radial = 0

Load Case 2:

As shown in Figure 1, under the handling conditions, each trunnion is subjected to the followingloading:

Longitudinal = 0.25xW = 0.25x80,000 = 20,000 lb

Lateral 0.25xW = 0.25x80,000 = 20,000 lb

Radial 0

Load Case 3:

As shown in Figure 1, subject to the transportation loading enveloped by the 1OCFR71 loading,the maximum load a trunnion is subjected to is the following:

Longitudinal = 2.5xW = 2.5x80,000 = 200,000 lb

Lateral = 0.5xW 0.5x80,000 40,000 lb

Radial = 2.5xW 2.5x80,000 = 200,000 lb

Enveloping Loading

From the above loading cases the following enveloping loading is developed. If the materialsmeet the allowable for this loading, they will automatically meet the allowable stresses for otherload cases as well.

Longitudinal = 2.5xW = 2.5x80,000 = 200,000 lb

Lateral 0.5xW 0.5x80,000 = 40,000 lb

Radial = 2.5xW 2.5x80,000 = 200,000 lb

Page 4: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions

Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 4 of 8

7.0 MODEL DESCRIPTION

The trunnion assembly is modeled and evaluated for the enveloping loads using ANSYS finiteelement program (Reference 4).This model is a half-symmetry solid model representing thetrunnion assembly, including the 3 1/" thick back-up plate, a portion of the cask inner andouter shells, and the lead material in between the cask inner and outer shells. It comprises of3-D, 8-Node structural solid elements (SOLID 185) for the trunnion, backing plate and thelead and 3-D, 8-Node solid shell elements (SOLSH 190) for the cask inner and outer shells.Various components of the model are tied together with the contact and target surfacecombinations. The model is shown in Figures 2 and 3, and it is analyzed for the envelopingloading conditions shown in Section 6.0. Loading condition 1 a longitudinal load of 200,000lbs., loading condition 2, a radial load of 200,000 lbs, and loading condition 3, a vertical loadof 40,000 lbs.

Figure 4 shows the applied loading for Condition 1, Figure 8 shows the applied loading forCondition 2, and Figure 12 shows the applied loading for Condition 3.

8.0 RESULTS & CONCLUSIONS

Figures 5 to 7 show the stress intensity distribution in the model for loading Condition 1.Maximum stress intensity in the trunnion is 27,953 psi that is less than the 30,000 psimaximum allowable stress. Maximum stress intensity in the attaching shell is 14,652 psi thatis less than the 25,000 psi maximum allowable stress. Figures 9 to 11 show the stress intensitydistribution in the model for loading Condition 2. Maximum stress intensity in the trunnion is14,026 psi that is less than the 30,000 psi maximum allowable stress. Maximum stressintensity in the attaching shell is 9,445 psi that is less than the 25,000 psi maximum allowablestress. Figures 13 to 15 show the stress intensity distribution in the model for loadingCondition 3. Maximum stress intensity in the trunnion is 5,403 psi that is less than the 30,000psi maximum allowable stress. Maximum stress intensity in the attaching shell is 3,695 psithat is less than the 25,000 psi maximum allowable stress.

It should be noted that the welds in the trunnion assemblies have been exclusively included inthe finite element model. Therefore, the stresses in the welds have been implicitly analyzed.They are also subjected to stresses below their allowable values.

It has been demonstrated by the analyses presented in this document that the 3-60B casktrunnion assemblies have a sufficient margin of safety in its design to be safely lifted, it couldsafely be downended to a horizontal orientation with the help of a pair of trunnions providedin the lower part of the cask and also meets the regulatory requirements of 1OCFR71.45 (b).

9.0 ANSYS PRINTOUT AND DATA FILES

The printout of the important data from the program is included with this document inelectronic form as Appendix 1. The following is the directory of the data on the CDR.

Volume in drive F is My DiscVolume Serial Number is ABAF-A995

Page 5: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions

Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 5 of 8

Directory of F:\

12/07/2007

12/10/200709/24/200709/24/200709/24/2007

09/24/200709/24/2007

09/24/2007

09/24/2007

09/24/2007

09/24/2007

09/24/2007

09/24/2007

09/24/2007

09/24/2007

11/08/200711/08/2007

11/08/200711/08/200711/08/2007

11/08/2007

11:33 AM03:25 PM

10:06 AM

07:53 AM07:56 AM

09:59 AM

10:11 AM

10:12 AM10:16 AM

10:21 AM10:21 AM10:22 AM

10:23 AM10:24 AM

10:25 AM

02:27 PM

02:34 PM02:35 PM

02:40 PM03:51 PM

03:55 PM21 File (s)

0 Dir (s)

15,761 Model.txt2,924,234 file.cdb

51,118,080 file.rst65,949 file.s01

112,121 file.s0265,949 file.s03

135,899 fileOOO.png160,936 fileool.png121,466 file002.png186,871 file003.png186,281 file004.png117,210 file005.png158,600 file006.png158,788 file007.png119,253 fileOO8.png199,319 file009.png213,759 fileolO.png211,548 fileOll.png140,407 file012.png100,030 file013.png144,967 file014.png

56,657,428 bytes0 bytes free

10.0 APPENDICES

Appendix 1 Print-out of the ANSYS model data input

Appendix 2 Electronic data on CDROM

Page 6: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions

Cale. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 6 of 8

Figures

(15 Pages)

Page 7: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

0.-1

z

Lifting1-W 11W

22' W 2½1 W 21'W

I(w 11w

I I, Regulatory •

twh

0

Handling <

0

0

Figure 1

Y 1 ,1 • 1 • y *• I T 1 • • 4 w ,1 41w

Loads on the Irunnions dunng Lilting and Handling Uperation and per the RegulatoryK Requirement

Page 8: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ELEMENS ANREAL NU NOV 8 200715:55:56 0 1PLCT NO. I w X

z0

CD

ON

C)

r r

0

Fge

(DC

Figure 2 "4,

Finite Element Model of the 3-60B Cask Trunnion & its Vicinity

Page 9: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

Note: Part of the outer shell has been removed from the figure for clarity.

Figure 3Finite Element Model Close-Up of the Trunnion

Page 10: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ANNOV 8 2007

14:34:27PLOT NO. 1

0,

3667

7334

11001

14668jý

18335]

22002.1

256691

29336-

0

HT

0

(n00

S.'.

CI

0

C6'

Longitudinal Load of 200,000 lb

Figure 4Finite Element Model Analysis Load Step I - Applied Loading

0

Page 11: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

NODAL SOLUTIONSTEP=1SUB =1TIME=ISINT (AVG)DMX =.022402SMN =9.932SMX =27953

ANSEP 24 2007

11:11:28PLOT NO. 1

9.93

3503

6996

10489

13982j

17471

20967j

244601ý

279531

z90

rQ

Xm

CA0r0

cn

Longitudinal Load of 200,000 ib0

Figure 5

Load Step 1 - Stress Intensity Plot

Page 12: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

NODAL SOLUTIONSTEP=1SUB =1TIME=1SINT (AVG)DYEX =.016895SMN =144.294SMX =14652

ANSEP 24 2007

11:12:46PLOT NO. 1

144.294

1958

3771

5585:,

73981

921 L

11025

12838j

146524

00

z0

6~1

rAj

X

(D

CD

0Longitudinal Load of 200,000 lb

Figure 6

Load Step 1 - Stress Intensity in the Shell

Page 13: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

NODAL SOLUTIONSTEP=1SUB =1TIME=1SINT (AVG)DMX ='022402

AmSEP 24 2007

11:16:30PLOT NO. 1

660.938

40721

7484

10895

14307

17719i

21130

245421

279531

0-

z0

'T

(p

C,,

CL0A

Longitudinal Load of 200,000 lb0-h

Figure 7

Load Step 1 - Stress Intensity in the Trunnion

Page 14: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ANNOV 8 2007

14:35:34PLOT NO. 1

Radial Load of 200,000 Ib

Figure 8

Finite Element Model Analysis Load Step 2 - Applied Loading

Page 15: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

NODAL SOLUTIONSTEP=2SUB =1TIME=2SINT (AVG)DIAX =.020896SMN =30.901SJAX =14026

Radial Load of 200,000 lb

SEP 24 200711:21:14 0 q

PLOT NO. 1 _

z30.901

1780C ,

3530o• .

Cj2

5279"

70281 6.

8778 ;"

105271

12277-t

14026

cn~(o

CL

0

--9,

Figure 9 -Load Step 2 - Stress Intensity Plot

Page 16: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

I0H~J10

I

CD

0

Co

CDCD

C~)

C-)

0

Figure 10

Load Step 2 - Stress Intensity in the Shell

0,-h

Page 17: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

NODAL SOLUTIONSTEP=2SUB =1TIME=2SINT (AVG)DMX =.020896SMN3 63

ANSEP 24 2007

11:22:13PLOT NO. 1 0

393.163-

2097f

3801.

5505~

7210

8914

106181

12 3 2 2i

140261

II

=r

0

CD

CD

CL

Radial Load of 200,000 lb0--.

(ilFigure 11

Load Sten 2 - Stress Intensity in the Trunnion

Page 18: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ELEMENTSTYPE NUMPRFS -NOPN4

ANNOV 8 2007

14:40:45PLOT NO. 1

0 --

0733.51

1ZAT2200ý

2934f

36681

44011

5134j

586

cj~

X

CD(D(D

0

rpi

C,'

0

Vertical Load of 40,000 lb

0Figure 12

Finite Element Model Analysis Load Step 3 - Applied Loading

Page 19: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

NODAL SOLUTIONSTEP=3SUB =1TIME=3SINT (AVG)DMX =.004964SMN =2.351SMX =5430

SEP 24 200711:23:44

PLOT NO. 1

2.351

680. 769

1359

2038

2716;

339AI

40731

47511

543041

Vertical Load of 40,000 lb

Figure 13

Load Step 3 - Stress Intensity Plot

Page 20: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

NODAL SOLUTION

STEP=3SUB =1TIME=3SINT (AVG)DMX =.00316SMN =92.317SMX =3695

ANSEP 24 2007

11:24:35PLOT NO. 1

92.317-

542.644

992.97

1443'

18K94

234

27941

3245-

36951

0 -1

z0

0

-t

I

X

C',

0

0

(r-ON

0

0

Vertical Load of 40,000 lb

Figure 14

Load Step 3 - Stress Intensity in the Shell

0

Page 21: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

NODAL SOLUTIONSTEP=3SUB =1TIME=3SINT (AVG)DMX =.004964SMX=1.0

ANSEP 24 2007

11:25:06PLOT NO. 1 00

z0t

715.118 (.11

~T11389i

2062

2736&

3409_1

4083i

0

0

ff2

0

r)

~1

0

cj~

0

0

0

C,)

47561

54301

Cn0r

Vertical Load of 40,000 lb0

Figure 15

Load Step 3 - Stress Intensity in the Trunnion

Page 22: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions,

Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 7 of 8

Appendix 1

Printout of the ANSYS Model Data

(7 Pages)

Page 23: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ST-503, Rev.0, Appendix 1, Page 1 of 7

3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses

By Dr. Mirza I. Baig

Report Generated by ANSYS

Title Listing

***** TITLES *****

*** YOU ARE IN ANSYS - ENGINEERING ANALYSIS SYSTEM *

ANSYS Mechanical/EmagRELEASE II.0SP1 UPDATE 20070830 CUSTOMER 00222442

INITIAL JOBNAME = fileCURRENT JOBNAME = file

Current Working Directory: Y:\Trunnion

MENULIST File: C:\Program Files\ANSYS Inc\vllO\ANSYS\gui\:en-us\UIDL\menuiistllo.ans

Global Status

GLOBAL STATUS

ANSYS - Engineering Analysis System Dec 07, 2007 11:33Release II.0SPl 00222442 INTEL NT Version

Current working directory: Y:\Trunnion

MENULIST File: C:\Program Files\ANSYS Inc\vllO\ANSYS\gui\en-us\UIDL\menulistllo.ans

Product(s) enabled: ANSYS Mechanical/Emag

Total connect time ..... .. 0 hours 0 minutesTotal CP usage ......... .. 0 hours 0 minutes 2.6 seconds

JOB I N FORMAT I ON------------------------------------------------------

Current jobname ... ...... fileInitial jobname ... ...... file

Units ...... ........... unknown

Available UsedScratch Memory Space. . . . 256.000 mb 3.871 mb ( 1.5%)

Page 24: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ST-503, Rev.0, Appendix 1, Page 2 of 7

Database space ...... 65535.750 mb 37.573 mb ( 0.1%)

User menu file in use . . .C:\Program Files\ANSYS Inc\vllO\ANSYS\gui\en-us\uidl\UIMENU.GRNUser menu file in use .C:\Program Files\ANSYS Inc\vllO\ANSYS\gui\en-

us\uidl\UIFUNCl.GRNUser menu file in use .C:\Program Files\ANSYS Inc\vll\ANSYS\gui\en-

us\uidl\UIFUNC2.GRN

User menu file in use .C:\Program Files\ANSYS Inc\vll0\ANSYS\gui\en-us\uidl\MECHTOOL.AUIBeta features ... ....... .are not shown in the user interface

M 0 D E L I N F 0 R M A T I 0 N,---------------------------------------------

Solid model summary:

Largest Number NumberNumber Defined Selected

Keypoints ... ......... 32 24 24Lines .... ........... 56 36 36Areas .... ...... ..... 28 16 16Volumes .... .......... 3 2 2

Finite element model summary:

Largest Number NumberNumber Defined Selected

Nodes. ............... .. 22230 12268 10261Elements ........... . . .. 32839 9870 7632

Element types ......... 30 14 n.a.Real constant sets ..... 8 6 n.a.Material property sets. . 2 2 n.a.

Coupling ............. 0 0 n.a.Constraint equations. . . 0 0 n.a.Master DOFs ... ........ 0 0 n.a.Dynamic gap conditions. . 0 0 n.a.

BOUNDARY CONDITION INFORMATION----------------------

NumberDefined

Constraints on nodes .... ........... 928Constraints on keypoints ........ ......... 0Constraints on lines ..................... 0Constraints on areas ..................... 0

Forces on nodes ............ ............. 0Forces on keypoints .......... ........... 0

Surface loads on elements .......... 96Number of element flagged surfaces 0Surface loads on lines ......... .......... 0Surface loads on areas ......... .......... 0

Body loads on elements. . 0

Page 25: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ST-503, Rev.0, Appendix 1, Page 3 of 7

Body loads on nodes ...... ...........Body loads on keypoints .... .........

TemperaturesUniform temperature ..... ..........Reference temperature .... ..........Offset from absolute scale .........

Linear acceleration ...... ...........Angular velocity (about global CS) ...Angular acceleration (about global CS) .Location of reference CS .... ..........Angular velocity (about reference CS)Angular acceleration (about reference CS)

00

0.0000.0000.000

x0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

Y0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

Z0.00000. 00000 .00000.00000.00000.0000

RONUFTOIMNAE I N F 0 R M A T 1 0 N--------------------------------------------

Current routine ..... ...........

Active coordinate system ..........

Display coordinate system .........

Current element attributes:Type number . . . ... .... . ...Real number ...... ...........Material number .... .........Element coordinate system number.

current mesher type .... ..........

Current element meshing shape 2D

.Preprocessing (PREP7)

1 (Cylindrical)

0 (Cartesian)

30 (CONTAl75)810

.free mesher

.use default element shape.

Current element meshing shape 3D . . .use hexahedra.

SmrtSize Level ..... ............ OFF

Global element size ............. .. 0 divisions per line

Active coordinate system ...... . . . 1 (Cylindrical)

Display coordinate system ............ 0 (Cartesian)

Analysis type ....... ............. Static (steady-state)

Active options for this analysisLarge deformation effects . .Plasticity .... ...........Creep ...... ............Equation solver to use. ...

Results file .... ..........

Load step number .... ........

Number of substeps ... ........

type:. . .Not included. . .Not included. . .Not included. . .Program Chosen

. . .file.rst

1

Page 26: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ST-503, Rev.0, Appendix 1, Page 4 of 7

Step change boundary conditions . No

Solution Status

SOLUTION OPTIONS

PROBLEM DIMENSIONALITY. ............. .3-D

DEGREES OF FREEDOM ........ UX UY UZ ROTX ROTY ROTZ

ANALYSIS TYPE ............... ................. STATIC (STEADY-STATE)

NEWTON-RAPHSON OPTION . . ....... ........ . .PROGRAM CHOSEN

GLOBALLY ASSEMBLED MATRIX ....... ........... SYMMETRIC

LOAD STEP OPTIONS

LOAD STEP NUMBER ............... ................ 1

TIME AT END OF THE LOAD STEP .... .......... 1.0000NUMBER OF SUBSTEPS ............. ................ 1

MAXIMUM NUMBER OF EQUILIBRIUM ITERATIONS. . . 15

STEP CHANGE BOUNDARY CONDITIONS ... .... .... NO

TERMINATE ANALYSIS IF NOT CONVERGED ... ...... YES (EXIT)

CONVERGENCE CONTROLS .......... .............. USE DEFAULTS

COPY INTEGRATION POINT VALUES TO NODE ..... YES

PRINT OUTPUT CONTROLS

ITEM FREQUENCY COMPONENT

RSOL NONEDATABASE OUTPUT CONTROLS

ITEM FREQUENCY COMPONENT

ALL ALL

Element Type Listing

LIST ELEMENT TYPES FROM 1 TO 30 BY I

ELEMENT TYPEKEYOPT(1-12)=

ELEMENT TYPEKEYOPT(I-12)=

ELEMENT TYPEKEYOPT(1-12)=

ELEMENT TYPEKEYOPT(1-12)=

ELEMENT TYPEKEYOPT(I-12)=

ELEMENT TYPEKEYOPT(I-12)=

1 IS SOLID1850 0 0 0 0

2 IS SOLSH190

0 0 0 0 0

19 IS TARGE170

0 0 0 0 0

20 IS CONTA174

0 0 0 0 3

21 IS TARGE1700 0 0 00

22 IS CONTA174

0 0 0 0 3

3-D 8-NODE STRUCTURAL SOLID0 0 0 0 0 0 0

3-D 8-NODE SOLID SHELL

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

3-D TARGET SEGMENT0 0 0 0 0 0 0

3D 8-NODE SURF-SURF CONTACT0 0 0 0 2 0 0

0

0

0

0

0

0

INOPR

INOPR

INOPR

INOPR

INOPR

INOPR

3-D TARGET SEGMENT

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

3D 8-NODE SURF-SURF CONTACT0 0 0 1 2 0 0

Page 27: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ELEMENT TYPE 23 IS TARGE170

KEYOPT(1-12)= 0 0 0 0

ELEMENT TYPE 24 IS CONTA174

KEYOPT(1-12)= 0 0 0 0

ELEMENT TYPE 25 IS TARGE170KEYOPT(1-12)= 0 0 0 0

ELEMENT TYPE 26 IS CONTA174

KEYOPT(1-12)= 0 0 0 0

ELEMENT TYPE 27 IS TARGE170

KEYOPT(I-12)= 0 0 0 0

ELEMENT TYPE 28 IS CONTA175

KEYOPT(I-12)= 0 0 0 0

ELEMENT TYPE 29 IS TARGE170

KEYOPT(I-12)= 0 0 0 0

ELEMENT TYPE 30 IS CONTA175

KEYOPT(1-12)= 0 0 0 0

CURRENT NODAL DOF SET IS UXTHREE-DIMENSIONAL MODEL

Real Constant Listing

0

3

0

3

0

3

0

0

UY

ST-503, Rev.0, Appendix 1, Page 5 of 7

3-D TARGET SEGMENT INOPR

0 0 000 00 0 0

3D 8-NODE SURF-SURF CONTACT INOPR

0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0

3-D TARGET SEGMENT INOPR

0 00 0 0 0 0 0

3D 8-NODE SURF-SURF CONTACT INOPR

0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0

3-D TARGET SEGMENT INOPR

0 0 000 00 0 0

NODE-TO-SURFACE CONTACT INOPR

0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0

3-D TARGET SEGMENT INOPR

0 0 000 00 0 0

NODE-TO-SURFACE CONTACT INOPR

0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0

UZ ROTX ROTY ROTZ

LIST REAL SETS

REAL CONSTANT

0.0000

REAL CONSTANT

0.0000

REAL CONSTANT

0.0000

REAL CONSTANT

0.0000

REAL CONSTANT0.0000

REAL CONSTANT

0.0000

REAL CONSTANT

0.0000

REAL CONSTANT

0.0000

1 TO

SET0.0000

SET

0.0000

SET

0.0000

SET

1.0000

SET 4

0.0000

SET 4

0.0000

SET 4

0.0000

SET 4

1.0000

8 BY

ITEMS 1 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 7 TO

0.10000E+21

ITEMS 13 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 19 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 1 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 7 TO

0.10000E+21

ITEMS 13 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 19 TO

1.0000

1

6

0.10000

120.0000

18

0.0000

24

0.0000

6

0.10000

12

0.0000

18

0.0000

24

0.0000

0.0000

1.0000

1.0000

0.0000

0.0000

1.0000

1.0000

0. 0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.50000

1.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.50000

1.0000

Page 28: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ST-503, Rev.0, Appendix 1, Page 6 of 7

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET0.0000 1.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000, 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 1.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.-0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 1.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

10.000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 0.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

0.0000 1.0000

REAL CONSTANT SET

10.000 0.0000

ITEMS I TO

1.0000

ITEMS 7 TO

0.10000E+21

ITEMS 13 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 19 TO1.0000

ITEMS 1 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 7 TO

0.10000E+21

ITEMS 13 TO1.0000

ITEMS 19 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 1 TO.

1.0000

ITEMS 7 TO

0.10000E+21

ITEMS 13 TO1.0000

ITEMS 19 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 25 TO0.0000

ITEMS 1 TO1.0000

ITEMS 7 TO0.10000E+21

ITEMS 13 TO

1.0000

ITEMS 19 TO

1.0000

6

0.10000

12

0.0000

18

0.0000

24

0.0000

6

0.10000

12

0.0000

180.0000

24

0.0000

60.10000

12

0.0000

18

0.0000

24

0.0000

30

0.0000

6

0.10000

12

0.0000

180.0000

24

0.0000

0.0000

1.0000

1.0000

0.0000

0.0000

1.0000

1.0000

0.0000

0.0000

1.0000

1.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

1.0000

1.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.50000

1.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.50000

1.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.50000

1.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.50000

1.0000

0.0000

8 ITEMS 25 TO0.0000

300.0000 0.0000

Page 29: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

ST-503, Rev.0, Appendix 1, Page 7 of 7

Material Properties Listing

LIST MATERIALSPROPERTY= ALL

PROPERTY TABLETEMPERATURE

0.0000

PROPERTY TABLE

TEMPERATURE

0.0000

PROPERTY TABLETEMPERATURE

. 0.0000

I TO 2 BY 1

EX MAT=

DATA0.30000E+08

NUXY MAT=

DATA0.30000

1 NUM.TEMPERATURE

1 NUM.

TEMPERATURE

DENS MAT= 1 NUM.DATA TEMPERATURE

0.28300

POINTS=DATA

POINTS=

DATA

POINTS=DATA

POINTS=

DATA

POINTS=

DATA

TEMPERATURE

1TEMPERATURE DATA

DATA

TEMPERATURE DATA

PROPERTY TABLE MU MAT=

TEMPERATURE DATA

0.0000 0.0000

PROPERTY TABLE EMIS MAT=TEMPERATURE DATA

0.0000 0.78886E-30

1 NUM.TEMPERATURE

1 NUM.TEMPERATURE

TEMPERATURE

1TEMPERATURE

1TEMPERATURE

1

TEMPERATURE

DATA

DATA

PROPERTY TABLE

TEMPERATURE

0.0000

PROPERTY TABLE

TEMPERATURE

0.0000

EX MAT= 2 NUM. POINTS=

DATA TEMPERATURE DATA

0.22700E+07

NUXY MAT= 2 NUM. POINTS=

DATA TEMPERATURE DATA0.45000

DATA

DATA

Page 30: Calculation No. ST-503, Rev. 0, '3-60B Cask Trunnion ... · Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions Calc. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 1 of 8 1.0 OBJECTIVE Structural

Title 3-60B Cask Trunnion Analyses under Various Load Conditions

Cale. No. ST-503 Rev. 0 Sheet 8 of 8

Appendix 2

Electronic Data on CDROM

(1 CDROM)