charge asymmetries of top quarks at lhc · charge asymmetries of top quarks at lhc paola ferrario,...

27
Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ´ an Rodrigo Instituto de F´ ısica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario, G. Rodrigo, Phys. Rev. D 78, 094018 (2008)

Upload: others

Post on 07-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC

Paola Ferrario, German Rodrigo

Instituto de Fısica CorpuscularUVEG-CSIC

April 22, 2009

P. Ferrario, G. Rodrigo, Phys. Rev. D 78, 094018 (2008)

Page 2: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

LHC is starting soon! (hopefully...)

Runs√

s = 14 TeV, L = 10 fb−1/year√

s = 14 TeV, L = 100 fb−1/year in a second phase

Huge production of top quarks

More top-antitop quark pairs than in the whole Tevatron life√

s = 14 TeV, σ = 950 pb → for L = 10 fb−1/year 10 millions ofevents per year!

Possibility of new physics discovery thanks to the high statistics

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 2 / 22

Page 3: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Charge asymmetry

Difference in top-antitop production

Nt − Nt

Nt + Nt

In QCD it is different from zero at O(α3). appendix

Tops are produced mostly in the direction of the quarks.

It arises mostly from qq and small contribution of qg events,because gg is symmetric.

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 3 / 22

Page 4: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Resonances

New physics color-octet resonances have been predicted to bedetected at LHC by decaying to top-antitop. Masses under around 1TeV already ruled out at Tevatron.Resonances appear as a peak in the cross section → we couldobserve these resonances in events with invariant masses close to theresonance mass.

Figure: R. Frederix, F. Maltoni

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 4 / 22

Page 5: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Resonances

High momenta top pairs are difficult to distinguish from light quarkjets, because the decay products are more collimated. Standardreconstruction algorithms are not efficient anymore at pT > 400GeV. Studies for new algorithms see

* Kaplan, Rehermann, Schwartz and Tweedie, arXiv:0806.0848 [hep-ph]* Thaler and Wang, JHEP 0807 (2008) 092* L. G. Almeida, S. J. Lee, G. Perez, G. Sterman, I. Sung and J. Virzi, arXiv:0807.0234

[hep-ph]

Resonances can produce asymmetries. Since these arise frominterference terms, they are more sensitive to higher masses than thedifferential cross section, because they are less suppressed.

This makes more effective studying asymmetries than cross sections.

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 5 / 22

Page 6: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Resonances

High momenta top pairs are difficult to distinguish from light quarkjets, because the decay products are more collimated. Standardreconstruction algorithms are not efficient anymore at pT > 400GeV. Studies for new algorithms see

* Kaplan, Rehermann, Schwartz and Tweedie, arXiv:0806.0848 [hep-ph]* Thaler and Wang, JHEP 0807 (2008) 092* L. G. Almeida, S. J. Lee, G. Perez, G. Sterman, I. Sung and J. Virzi, arXiv:0807.0234

[hep-ph]

Resonances can produce asymmetries. Since these arise frominterference terms, they are more sensitive to higher masses than thedifferential cross section, because they are less suppressed.

This makes more effective studying asymmetries than cross sections.

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 5 / 22

Page 7: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Resonances

High momenta top pairs are difficult to distinguish from light quarkjets, because the decay products are more collimated. Standardreconstruction algorithms are not efficient anymore at pT > 400GeV. Studies for new algorithms see

* Kaplan, Rehermann, Schwartz and Tweedie, arXiv:0806.0848 [hep-ph]* Thaler and Wang, JHEP 0807 (2008) 092* L. G. Almeida, S. J. Lee, G. Perez, G. Sterman, I. Sung and J. Virzi, arXiv:0807.0234

[hep-ph]

Resonances can produce asymmetries. Since these arise frominterference terms, they are more sensitive to higher masses than thedifferential cross section, because they are less suppressed.

This makes more effective studying asymmetries than cross sections.

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 5 / 22

Page 8: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Charge asymmetry @LHC

At Tevatron charge asymmetry = forward–backward asymmetry' 5%

pp is symmetric → no FB asymmetry appendix BUT it’s possible tolook for a charge asymmetry in an appropriate kinematic region

Main problem: 85% of the events is gg → tt (symmetric)

At low x the gluon contribution dominates → cuts on thetop-antitop invariant mass eliminate low x momenta where gluondensity is bigger than the quark one.

Asymmetry is enhanced, even with less statistic.

Not a problem at LHC

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 6 / 22

Page 9: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Charge asymmetry @LHC

At Tevatron charge asymmetry = forward–backward asymmetry' 5%

pp is symmetric → no FB asymmetry appendix BUT it’s possible tolook for a charge asymmetry in an appropriate kinematic region

Main problem: 85% of the events is gg → tt (symmetric)

At low x the gluon contribution dominates → cuts on thetop-antitop invariant mass eliminate low x momenta where gluondensity is bigger than the quark one.

Asymmetry is enhanced, even with less statistic.

Not a problem at LHC

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 6 / 22

Page 10: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Charge asymmetry @LHC

At Tevatron charge asymmetry = forward–backward asymmetry' 5%

pp is symmetric → no FB asymmetry appendix BUT it’s possible tolook for a charge asymmetry in an appropriate kinematic region

Main problem: 85% of the events is gg → tt (symmetric)

At low x the gluon contribution dominates → cuts on thetop-antitop invariant mass eliminate low x momenta where gluondensity is bigger than the quark one.

Asymmetry is enhanced, even with less statistic.

Not a problem at LHC

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 6 / 22

Page 11: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Charge asymmetry @LHC

At Tevatron charge asymmetry = forward–backward asymmetry' 5%

pp is symmetric → no FB asymmetry appendix BUT it’s possible tolook for a charge asymmetry in an appropriate kinematic region

Main problem: 85% of the events is gg → tt (symmetric)

At low x the gluon contribution dominates → cuts on thetop-antitop invariant mass eliminate low x momenta where gluondensity is bigger than the quark one.

Asymmetry is enhanced, even with less statistic.

Not a problem at LHC

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 6 / 22

Page 12: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Pure QCD

Central asymmetry, built choosing a limited rapidity region

AC (yC ) =Nt(|y | ≤ yC )− Nt(|y | ≤ yC )

Nt(|y | ≤ yC ) + Nt(|y | ≤ yC )

Cut on the top-antitop invariant mass mtt to have more qq, gqevents.

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 7 / 22

Page 13: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Pure QCD

QCD predicts that tops (antitops) are produced mostly in the direction ofthe incoming quarks (antiquarks)

For low yC only the region with more abundant antitops is selected −→the asymmetry is negative and decreases in magnitude with yC

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 8 / 22

Page 14: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Pure QCD: significance

SSM =signal√

background=

Nt − Nt√Nt + Nt

Significance is greater for lower cuts → identifying soft tops is easierthan the highly boosted ones

The higher statistic compensates the smaller asymmetry

The maximum is around yC ' 0.7− 1 and it has a high value

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 9 / 22

Page 15: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Pure QCD: asymmetry and significance with fixed yC

Even if the asymmetry is smaller, the significance is greater at lowcuts in mtt

10 fb−1 luminosity allows charge asymmetry measurement

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 10 / 22

Page 16: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Color-octet boson resonance exchange

(gV + gAγ5

)γµ

Arbitrary couplings gV , gA ∈ [0, 2]

Couplings independent on flavour gqV (A) = g t

V (A)

Examples: axigluon (gV = 0, gA = 1), KK gluon

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 11 / 22

Page 17: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Color-octet boson resonances

In the partonic cross section cross section wehave s − m2

G , so for low s it is negative −→Positive charge asymmetry for low cuts

If the cut grows, the asymmetry changessign and becomes negative

Maximum for the significance at yC ' 0.7for s < m2

G

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 12 / 22

Page 18: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Varying mmintt

AC goes from positive to negative → S reaches a maximum there andgoes to zero.

AC grows negative → S increases again and has another maximum beforethe number of events becomes small.

The maxima are at mmintt /mG = 0.5 and mmin

tt /mG = 0.8− 1 for almostall couplings → a low cut is enough for a good statistical significance

The maxima position does not depend on the mass

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 13 / 22

Page 19: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Varying the couplings

Fixed cuts mmintt /mG = 0.5, 0.8

Three resonance masses: 1.5 TeV, 2 TeV and 3 TeV

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 14 / 22

Page 20: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Varying the couplings

The pattern depends mainly on mmintt /mG and not on mG

The asymmetry is sizable for whatever value of mG

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 15 / 22

Page 21: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Motivation LHC: pp Conclusions

Conclusions

Charge asymmetry in top-antitop production in QCD and through acolor-octet massive resonance exchange

@LHC

Pure QCD analysis: the statistical significance is greater with no cutsin the invariant massResonances: a cut of 1/2 the resonance mass is enough to see theasymmetry and detect or exclude these particles

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 16 / 22

Page 22: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Appendix

Appendix

Pair asymmetry

Back

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 17 / 22

Page 23: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Appendix

Appendix

Tevatron

Back

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 18 / 22

Page 24: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Appendix

Appendix

Interference contributions to QCD charge asymmetry

Back

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 19 / 22

Page 25: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Appendix

Appendix

Cross section and FB asymmetry

σ =

∫ −1

1

d cos θdσ

d cos θ+

∫ 1

−1

d cos θdσ

d cos θ

→ only even terms in cos θ contribute.

AFB ∝dσ(cos θ)

d cos θ− dσ(− cos θ)

d cos θ

→ only odd terms in cos θ contribute. Back

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 20 / 22

Page 26: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Appendix

Appendix

Charge asymmetry at LHC

Back

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 21 / 22

Page 27: Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC · Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC Paola Ferrario, Germ an Rodrigo Instituto de F sica Corpuscular UVEG-CSIC April 22, 2009 P. Ferrario,

Appendix

Color-octet boson resonance: differential cross section

dσqq→tt

d cos θ= α2

sTFCF

NC

πβ

2s

(1 + c2 + 4m2 +

2s(s −m2G )

(s −m2G )2 + m2

G Γ2G

[gq

V g tV×

× (1 + c2 + 4m2) + 2gqAg t

Ac]

+s2

(s −m2G )2 + m2

G Γ2G

×

×[(

(gqV )2 + (gq

A)2)(

(g tV )2(1 + c2 + 4m2) +

+ (g tA)2(1 + c2 − 4m2)

)+ 8gq

V gqAg t

V g tAc

])

c ≡√

1− 4m2

t

scos θ appendix

Back

Charge Asymmetries of Top Quarks at LHC 22 / 22