city of cape coral memorandum to: john szerlag, city … · 2019-07-22 ·...

40
CITY OF CAPE CORAL DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City Manager THRU: Vincent A. Cautero, Development Director#-- FROM: Derek C.S. Burr, Planning Manager DATE: May 28, 2014 SUBJECT: Comprehensive Plan Amendment- Water Supply Facilities Work Plan The primary purpose of the City staff amendment is to adopt an updated Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, consistent with the South Florida Water Management District's update to the Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan. The Cape Coral Water Supply Facilities Work Plan is incorporated by reference in Policy 2.4.2 of the Infrastructure Element. The Utility Department's consultant has prepared an updated Water Supply Facilities Work Plan for this purpose, and it has been reviewed by staff. Adoption of this update is a requirement of s. 163.3177(6)(c), F.S. The secondary purpose of the amendment is to update Policy 2.2.1., a housekeeping task to update the list of infrastructure projects to meet our demands, consistent with the schedule of capital improvements. Cape Coral has a long history of planning for its water supply, treating brackish well water from the Upper Floridan Aquifer, conserving its potable water supply with a reuse water supply for irrigation. The City's ongoing plan is to gradually extend potable water and reuse water (for irrigation) to areas that rely on domestic self supply wells as development density increases. The draw from domestic self supply wells had substantially lowered the water levels in the Sandstone aquifer in a declining trend since the 1970s. This downward trend has reversed in the early 2000s, indicating the aquifer is now recovering as more residents are supplied with municipal water. This program is consistent with the updated Lower West Coast Regional Water Supply Plan, therefore no policy or program shift is necessary. Please review the application and the attached document that identifies the draft proposed amendments in strike-thru/underlined format, along with the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan to be incorporated by reference. Feel free to contact Rick Sosnowski, Planning Team Coordinator, if you have any questions. Thank you for your consideration of this amendment. DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning Team Coordinator

Upload: others

Post on 26-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

CITY OF CAPE CORAL DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT

MEMORANDUM

TO: John Szerlag, City Manager

THRU: Vincent A. Cautero, Com~nity Development Director#--

FROM: Derek C.S. Burr, Planning Manager ~

DATE: May 28, 2014

SUBJECT: Comprehensive Plan Amendment- Water Supply Facilities Work Plan

The primary purpose of the City staff amendment is to adopt an updated Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, consistent with the South Florida Water Management District's update to the Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan. The Cape Coral Water Supply Facilities Work Plan is incorporated by reference in Policy 2.4.2 of the Infrastructure Element. The Utility Department's consultant has prepared an updated Water Supply Facilities Work Plan for this purpose, and it has been reviewed by staff. Adoption of this update is a requirement of s. 163.3177(6)(c), F.S. The secondary purpose of the amendment is to update Policy 2.2.1., a housekeeping task to update the list of infrastructure projects to meet our demands, consistent with the schedule of capital improvements.

Cape Coral has a long history of planning for its water supply, treating brackish well water from the Upper Floridan Aquifer, conserving its potable water supply with a reuse water supply for irrigation. The City's ongoing plan is to gradually extend potable water and reuse water (for irrigation) to areas that rely on domestic self supply wells as development density increases. The draw from domestic self supply wells had substantially lowered the water levels in the Sandstone aquifer in a declining trend since the 1970s. This downward trend has reversed in the early 2000s, indicating the aquifer is now recovering as more residents are supplied with municipal water. This program is consistent with the updated Lower West Coast Regional Water Supply Plan, therefore no policy or program shift is necessary.

Please review the application and the attached document that identifies the draft proposed amendments in strike-thru/underlined format, along with the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan to be incorporated by reference. Feel free to contact Rick Sosnowski, Planning Team Coordinator, if you have any questions. Thank you for your consideration of this amendment.

DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment

c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning Team Coordinator

Page 2: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

CASE# =rX::CJ;f -OOQ{

CITY OF CAPE CORAL REQUEST FOR TEXT AMENDMENT TO COMPREHENSIVE PLAN

APPLICANT

City of Cape Coral

Department of Community Development

AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE

Wyatt Daltrv. AICP, Planner IV

Rick Sosnowski, AICP, Planning Team Coordinator.

Derek C.S. Burr. AICP, Planning Manager

Address P.O Box 150027

Cape Coral, Florida

Zip Code 33915-0027

Phone {239) 57 4-0566

Phone {239) 57 4-0566

This application shall include a Letter of Intent stating the nature and rationale of the proposed request, a notarized authorization from the applicant for representation at the Public Hearings, if other than the applicant and/or his/her attorney, and any and all applicable supporting documents necessary to present and clarify the proposal.

The applicant, or his/her authorized representative, agrees to conform to all applicable laws of the City of Cape Coral and to all applicable Federal, State, and County Laws, and certifies that all information supplied is accurate and relevant in nature to this request to the best of their knowledge.

STATEOF ____ ~r_L-________________ __ COUNTY OF __ ~~~-------------------Sworn to and ~bscribed before me this 5Jh. day of :!vtvZ- 20--.l.Y._, and who is personally known ./ or has produced identification , (type of I. D. produced: ), and who did/did not take an oath.

fl1~ KAREN A RAMOS :•: ~·i MY COMMISSION ## EE862353

EXPIRES March 24, 2017 I'IDitciiiNDW~ySer~tculllll

Notary Public

My Commission Expires: __ J=+/..:...;~:.......;~:....t-~....:..\4] __ _

10/12/01

Page 3: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

CITY OF CAPE CORAL

AUTHORIZATION TO REPRESENT PROPERTY OWNER(s)

PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT Rick Sosnowski, Planning Team Coordinator and Wyatt Daltrv. Planner IV, Department of Community Development (Name of person giving presentation)

ARE AUTHORIZED TO REPRESENT ME IN THE APPEAL TO THE PLANNING & ZONING COMMISSION/LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY, BOARD OF ZONING ADJUSTMENTS AND APPEALS AND/OR CITY COUNCIL FOR

Comprehensive Plan Text Amendment-Policies 2.2.1 and 2.4.2 Infrastructure Element (Type of Public Hearing- i.e. PDP, Zoning, Special Exception, Variance, etc.)

BLOCK __ __;N:....o;Ac.....:,__ LOTS NA ___ UNIT NA _SUBDIVISION NA ____ _

OR LEGAL DESCRIPTION _ _____,N-=A--'-----------------

LOCATED IN THE CITY OF CAPE CORAL, COUNTY OF LEE, FLORIDA.

PROPERTY OWNER (Please Print)

PROPERTY OWNER (Signature)

County of----'"""""".....___ ______ _

The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before..)'Tle this SJh day of :lUrLL.. , 20 1~. by an individual who is personally known_.../_ oror has produced identification_, (type of I. D. prOcfuced ), and who did/did not take an oath.

NOtrY Public

My Commission Expires: ,3(J.~ In J

111.' KAREN A RAMOS w MY COMUISSION • EE882363 • EXPIRES March 24, 2017 .....

1401) -.o1S3 .011111

Note: Please list all owners, if a corporation, please supply the Planning Division with a copy of corporation papers.

Page 4: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

Planning Division Staff Summary

Review Date:

Applicant:

Authorized Agent:

Case Staff:

Reviewed by:

Request:

May 20,2014

The City of Cape Coral

Planning Division, Department of Community Development

Rick Sosnowski, AICP, Planning Team Coordinator

Derek C.S. Burr, AICP, Planning Manager

TXT 14-0001

To revise two objectives (Objective 2.1 and 2.2) and two policies (Policies 2.2.1 and 2.4.2) of the Infrastructure Element of the Comprehensive Plan.

Purpose:

The primary purpose of this amendment is to adopt an updated Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, consistent with the South Florida Water Management District's update to the Lower West Coast Regional Water Supply Plan. The Cape Coral Water Supply Facilities Work Plan {2009) is incorporated by reference in Policy 2.4.2 of the Infrastructure Element. The Utility Department's consultant has prepared an updated Water Supply Facilities Work Plan for this purpose, and it has been reviewed by staff. Adoption of this update is a requirement of s. 163.3177(6)(c), F.S. The secondary purpose of the amendment is to update Objective 2.1, 2.2 and Policy 2.2.1., housekeeping tasks to update the list of infrastructure projects to meet Cape Coral's future demands, consistent with the already-adopted schedule of capital improvements.

This text amendment would be undertaken through the "expedited state review process", a process that takes approximately six (6) months to complete.

Background:

Since the early 2000s, the Florida Legislature has enacted several bills that strengthen the statutory links between the regional water supply plans prepared by the water management districts and the comprehensive plans prepared by local governments. To that end, Florida Statutes require that the Infrastructure element identify such alternative water supply projects and traditional water supply projects and conservation and reuse necessary to meet the water needs identified in the regional water supply plan. Further, the state requires that the Infrastructure Element include a work plan, covering at least a 10-year planning period, for building public, private, and regional water supply facilities, including development of alternative water supplies, which are identified in the element as necessary to serve existing and new development. This is to ensure that local governments plan for the water supply sources and facilities to serve the existing needs and future growth.

Page 5: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

May 20,2014 TXT 14-0001 Page 2 of 3

The South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) approved the 2012 Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan Update (2012 LWC Water Supply Plan Update), which triggers all of the local governments to update their water supply facilities work plans to maintain consistency with the regional plan. The 2012 LWC Water Supply Plan Update and its supporting documents can be viewed at http://www .sfwmd .gov /porta 1/page/po rta l/xweb%20-%20release%203%20water%20supply/lower%20west%20coast%20plan. The Governing Board of the SFWMD approved an amendment to the 2012 LWC Water Supply Plan Update on April 15, 2012 to designate the Lower West Coast region as a Water Resource Caution Area (WRCA). This WRCA designation requires that an applicant for a permit to operate a domestic wastewater treatment facility is required to submit a reuse feasibility study. The WRCA designation has no effect on Cape Coral's municipal facilities because they already employ reuse.

Cape Coral Water Supply Facilities Work Plan

The essential reason the state requires updates to Water Supply Facilities Work Plans is to ensure that local water supply facilities are appropriately coordinated with the periodic updates to regional plans. The 2012 LWC Water Supply Plan Update presents water demand estimates, water supply issues and evaluations, water source options, and water resource and water supply development projects to ensure that future water supplies are adequate to support the region's growth, while sustaining its natural systems. It concludes that the future water demands of the LWC Planning Area can continue to be met through the 2030 planning horizon with appropriate management and continued diversification of water supply sources.

The conclusions of the 2012 LWC Water Supply Plan Update most relevant to Cape Coral are that meeting the regional water demands necessitate continued development of alternative water supplies, including increased use of the Floridan aquifer system and reclaimed water, as well as increased emphasis and implementation of appropriate water conservation practices and water storage for dry season use. The Cape Coral Water Supply Facilities Work Plan states, "The City of Cape Coral's plan utilizes brackish well water treated using reverse osmosis, thereby already minimizing regional impacts indentified for 2030 in the Lower West Coast Water Supply planning Region." The brackish well water is from the Floridan Aquifer, mentioned in the 2012 LWC Water Supply Plan Update. Cape Coral has been regarded as a pioneer in reclaimed water, which has enabled the City to lower its annual per capita demand for water, also clearly consistent with the 2012 LWC Water Supply Plan Update.

The Cape Coral Water Supply Facilities Work Plan provides annual projections of both potable and raw water demand to the year 2033. It also projects the incremental decrease in the potable and irrigation water supplied by domestic self-supply wells, that draw from the sandstone aquifer. The Work Plan also describes the small area of Cape Coral served by the Greater Pine Island Water Association, and the capital improvements necessary. No capital improvements were identified as needed that are not already in Cape Coral's schedule of capital improvements.

Objective 2.1, 2.2 and Policy 2.2.1. Objective 2.1 and Policy 2.2.1. are proposed to be updated to reflect that some projects currently listed as being needed have already been completed, and to reflect the recently updated schedule of capital improvements. Adoption of these amendments will achieve consistency between the FY 2014 Adopted

Page 6: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

May 20, 2014 TXT 14-0001 Page 3 of 3

Budget, the Schedule of Capital Improvements, and the Comprehensive Plan. This amendment does not identify any new projects that have not already been reviewed and approved by the City Council.

Staff Analysis: No changes to Cape Coral's water supply facilities planning were identified as being necessary to attain consistency with the 2012 LWC Water Supply Plan Update, nor were any changes identified from the review of projected population demands. Adoption of the proposed amendment would appropriately update the Comprehensive Plan and achieve internal consistency and consistency with statutory requirements and the 2012 LWC Water Supply Plan Update.

Page 7: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

DRAFT 5/12/14

INFRASTRUCTURE ELEMENT

GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND POLICIES

GOAL 2: Provision of Sanitary Sewer, Drainage, Potable Water, and Solid Waste Services - the City of Cape Coral will provide sanitary sewer, drainage, and potable water facilities, and will coordinate with private and County sources for provision of solid waste facilities to meet the existing and projected needs identified in this plan.

Objective 2.1: Existing deficiencies will be corrected by undertaking the following projects:

a) Sanitary Sewer and Potable Water Implement SW-4 Utility Expansion Program

b) Drainage Complete CRA .. Phase II 8tormwater Improvements Implement recommendations of the Master Storm Water Management Plan

Policy 2.1.1. All projects will be undertaken in accordance with the Five Year Schedule of Capital Improvements adopted as part of the Capital Improvements Element.

Policy 2.1.2. Projects needed to correct existing deficiencies will be given priority in the formation and implementation of the Capital Improvements Plan.

Objective 2.2: Projected demands through the year ~2018 will be met.

Policy 2.2.1. The City will meet projected demands by undertaking the following projects within the short-term planning timeframe:

a. Sewer and Water Projects

1. Continue to provide planning and studies necessary for orderly expansiOn

2. 8outhvrest 4 Utility EJcpansion Program North 1 Utility Expansion Program

3. Southwest 5 Utility EJcpansion Program North 2 Utility Expansion Program

1

Page 8: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

DRAFT 5/12/14

4. Southwest 6 Utility Expansion Program

5. Southwest 7 Utility Expansion Program

6. Construct North Cape Water Reclamation Facility

7. Construct North Cape Reverse Osmosis Plant

8. gouthvrest Reclamation Plant E)tpansion

9. goutffivest Reverse Osmosis Plant Expansion

10. North 1 Utility Expansion Program

7. 11. Upgrade Rehab Lift Stations

8. 12. Construct Rehab/Replace Raw Water Production Wells

13. Construct Aquifer gtorage and Recovery 'Neils

14. Everest Parkvray Reclamation Plant Expansion

9.15. Construct Southwest Bio-Solids Centrifuges Treatment Facility

10. Palm Tree Water Main Extension Phase I

11. Palm Tree Water Main Extension Phase II

12. Galvanized Pipe Replacement

13. UCD Administration Building

14. Manhole Rehabilitation

15. Infiltration/Inflow

16. Weir# 4 Construction

1 7. Force main Interconnect

18. Fire Sprinkler Conversion (lrr to PW)

19. Weir# 16 and # 1 7 Construction

20. Reuse Water Main-River Crossing

2

Page 9: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

DRAFT 5/12/14

21. ASR/Irrigation Supply Improvement

22. North RO Deep Injection Well

23. Potable Water Infrastructure Replacement

24. Reuse Utilities Main Extension-FGUA

25. SWRO Deep Injection Well

26. Southwest Operations Building

27. Analyzer Building

28. Retro SWRO Well Field Control/Communication

29. SWRO Control Systems Upgrade

30. Distribution System Automation

b. Solid Waste Projects

- to be coordinated with Lee County

c. Drainage Projects

1. Continue to develop drainage improvements city wide Continue to construct city-wide drainage improvements, including modifications to weirs, based on the recommendations in the Master Storm Water Management Plan.

2. Provide drainage improvements for Utility EJ(pansion A..reas Continue to dredge the canals to provide required conveyance of storm water.

3. Complete CRt'\. Phase II 8tormv.'ater Impro-vements

Policy~ 2.3.5.The City hereby adopts the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, dated September 21, 2009 Mayl2, 2014, thereby being consistent with the South Florida Water Management District's Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan Update. The City shall continue to coordinate future updates of the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan with the South Florida Water Management District, as required by law.

3

Page 10: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

DRAFT 5/12/14

4

Page 11: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

FLORIDA

WATER SUPPLY FACILITIES WORK PLAN

Utilities Department

Utilities Director Jeff Pearson

Utilities Engineer Jody Sorrels

Community Development Department

Comprehensive Planning Team Coordinator Rick Sosnowski, AICP

Consulting Engineer

Hole Montes, Inc. Ronald E. Benson, Ph.D., P .E.

May 12,2014

Page 12: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

1.0 INTRODUCTION

The purpose of the City of Cape Coral Water Supply Facilities Work Plan (Work Plan) is to identify a plan for the water supply sources and facilities to serve the existing needs and future growth within the City of Cape Coral's jurisdiction. The City of Cape Coral continues to be a leader in the use of alternative water supplies, dating back to 1988 when the City adopted the "Water Independence for Cape Coral" (W.I.C.C.) Plan. The City utilizes brackish water for its potable water supply, and utilizes 1 00 percent of their treated wastewater reclaimed effiuent for irrigation. Chapter 163, Part II, Florida Statues (F.S.), requires local governments to prepare and adopt Work Plans into their comprehensive plans within 18 months after the water management district having jurisdiction approves a regional water supply plan or its update. The 2012 Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan Update was approved by the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) on November 15, 2012. Therefore, the deadline for local governments within the Lower West Coast Region to amend their comprehensive plans to update the Work Plan is May 15, 2014.

Residents of the City of Cape Coral primarily obtain their water from the City's Utilities' Department, which is responsible for ensuring sufficient capacity is available for existing and future customers. Many City residents rely upon domestic self supply wells for their potable and irrigation water needs. The City's plan is to gradually extend potable water and reuse water (for irrigation) to these areas as development density increases. In addition, approximately a few hundred City residents currently are served by the Greater Pine Island Water Association.

The Work Plan will reference the initiatives already identified to ensure adequate water supply for the City of Cape Coral. According to state guidelines, the Work Plan and the comprehensive plan must address the development of traditional and alternative water supplies, service delivery, conservation and reuse programs necessary to serve existing and new development for at least a I 0-year planning period. The Work Plan will have a planning time schedule consistent with the comprehensive plan and the 2012 Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan Update. Refer to Figure I: Location Map.

1.1 Statutory History

The Florida Legislature enacted bills in the 2002, 2004, 2005, and 2011 sessions to address the State's water supply needs. These bills, in particular Senate Bills 360 and 444 (2005 legislative session), significantly changed Chapters 163 and 373, F.S. by strengthening the statutory links between the regional water supply plans prepared by the water management districts and the comprehensive plans prepared by local governments. In addition, these bills established the basis for improving coordination between local land use planning and both regional and local water supply planning.

Page II

Page 13: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

1.2 Statutory Requirements

The City of Cape Coral has considered the following statutory provisions when updating the Water Supply Facilities Work Plan (Work Plan):

1. Coordinate appropriate aspects of its comprehensive plan with the 2012 Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan [Chapter 163.3177(4) (a), F.S.].

2. Ensure that the future land use plan is based upon availability of adequate water supplies and public facilities and services [s.l63.3177 (6) (a), F.S.]. Data and analysis demonstrating that adequate water supplies and associated public facilities will be available to meet projected growth demands must accompany all proposed Future Land Use Map amendments submitted for review.

3. Ensure that adequate water supplies and facilities are available to serve new development no later than the issuance by the local government of a certificate of occupancy or its functional equivalent and consult with the applicable water supplier to determine whether adequate water supplies will be available to serve the development by the anticipated issuance date of the certificate of occupancy [s. 163.3180 (2) (a), F.S.].

4. For local governments subject to a regional water supply plan, revise the General Sanitary Sewer, Solid Waste, Drainage, Potable Water and Natural Groundwater Aquifer Recharge Element (the "Infrastructure Element"), within 18 months after the water management district approves an updated regional water supply plan to:

a. Identify and incorporate the alternative water supply project(s) selected by the local government from projects identified in the 2012 Lower West Coast Regional Water Supply Plan, or the alternative project(s) proposed by the local government under Section 373.709(8)(b), F.S. [s. 163.3177(6)(c), F.S.].

b. Identify the traditional and alternative water supply projects and the conservation and reuse programs necessary to meet water needs identified in the 2012 Lower Regional Water Supply Plan [s. 163.3177(6)(c)3, F.S.].

c. Update the Work Plan for at least a 1 0-year planning period for constructing the public, private and regional water supply facilities identified in the element as necessary to serve existing and new development [Section 163.3177(6)(c)3, F.S.].

5. Revise the Five-Year Schedule of Capital Improvements to include water supply, reuse and conservation projects and programs to be implemented during the five-year period [ s. 163.3177(3)(a)4, F .S.].

Page 12

Page 14: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

6. To the extent necessary to maintain internal consistency after making changes described in Paragraph 1 through 5 above, revise the Conservation Element to assess projected water needs and sources for at least a 1 0-year planning period, considering the 2012 Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan, as well as applicable consumptive use permit(s) [s.163.3177 (6) (d), F.S.]. The plan must address the water supply sources necessary to meet and achieve the existing and projected water use demand for the established planning period, considering the applicable regional water supply plan [s.163.3167 (9), F.S.].

7. To the extent necessary to maintain internal consistency after making the changes described in Paragraphs 1 through 5 above, review the Intergovernmental Coordination Element to ensure coordination of the comprehensive plan with 2012 Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan [s.163.3177 (6) (h)l., F.S.].

8. While an Evaluation and Appraisal Report is not required, local governments are encouraged to comprehensively evaluate, and as necessary, update comprehensive plans to reflect changes in local conditions. The evaluation could address the extent to which the local government has implemented the need to update their Work Plan, including the development of alternative water supplies, and determine whether the identified alternative water supply projects, traditional water supply projects, and conservation and reuse programs are meeting local water use demands [s. 163.3191 (3), F.S.].

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

Page 13

Page 15: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

CITY OF CAPE CORAL LOCATION MAP

Figure 1: Location Map

Page 14

Page 16: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

2.0 BACKGROUND INFORMATION

The City of Cape Coral's Water Production Facilities are authorized to withdraw groundwater from the Upper Floridan Aquifer as granted by the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) Water Use Permit (WUP) number 36-00046-W. Issued in October 2009, the WUP is valid for a 20-year period ending October 22, 2029. The WUP limits the maximum monthly withdrawal to 1.312 billion gallons per month and a maximum annual withdrawal to 14.326 billion gallons.

2.1 Overview

The City of Cape Coral is a peninsular community situated about 120 miles south of Tampa on the west coast of Florida. The Caloosahatchee River lies to the east and south, Matlacha Pass on the south and west and Charlotte Harbor to the north and west. The City is a pre-platted community with approximately 150,000 building sites and covers an extensive area of 120.6 square miles. Cape Coral has 105.67 square miles of land area and 14.95 square miles of water area. The City incorporated in 1970 and at the time had less than 12,000 residents. The population of the City of Cape Coral at the time of the 2010 census was 154,305.

2.2 Relevant Regional Issues

The regional issues identified for 2030 in the Lower West Coast Water Supply Planning Region are:

• Increased withdrawals from the surficial aquifer system and the freshwater portion of the intermediate aquifer system are generally limited due to potential impacts on wetlands and existing legal water users including Domestic Self Supply, the potential for saltwater intrusion, and the possibility of reaching the maximum developable limits of aquifers. New or increased allocations will be evaluated on an application-by-application basis to determine if the project meets consumptive use permitting criteria.

• Surface water allocations from Lake Okeechobee and hydraulically connected surface waters are limited by the Lake Okeechobee Service Area Restricted Allocation Area criteria.

• Peak freshwater discharges during the wet season are affecting the health of the Caloosahatchee Estuary and additional storage is required in both the basin and the regional system to attenuate damaging peak flow events.

• Surface water availability and current storage capacity is insufficient for the Caloosahatchee River and Estuary during dry conditions. (2012 LWC Water Supply Plan update)

The City of Cape Coral's plan utilizes brackish well water treated using reverse osmosis, thereby already minimizing regional impacts indentified for 2030 in the Lower West Coast Water Supply planning Region.

Page IS

Page 17: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

3.0 DATA AND ANALYSIS

3.1 Population Information

Over the years, the City of Cape Coral has extended utility service into new areas as the population density has grown. Typically, the higher density areas within the City have potable water, sanitary sewer, and irrigation water utility service provided by the City whereas the areas with lower density remain on domestic self supply wells and septic tanks. At this time, as it relates to population, approximately 3 out of 4 residents are served by the City's utility system.

Upon the completion of the 201 Facilities Plan Update in 2012, the City made a substantial commitment to expanding its utilities system into portions of the City not previously served by public utilities. As of February 15, 2012 eight geographic areas of the City remain to be connected to the City's utility services. Each of these areas will be connected to the City of Cape Coral's Utility system after new portions of the utility system are completed. The proposed extension areas scheduled for construction are as follows:

Area Begin Construction Complete Construction Southwest 6 & 71 2014 2015

North Area 21 2015 2017 North Area 1' 2017 2019 North Area 32 2019 2021 North Area 4L 2021 2023 North Area 5L 2023 2025 North Area 6L 2025 2027 North Area 7L 2027 2029 North Area 8L 2029 2031

These eight phases of construction were introduced at the February 15, 2012 Cape Coral City Council meeting while discussing Utility Extension Project (UEP) Recommendations. The planned construction phases were subsequently adopted during the FDEP State Revolving Fund (SRF) loan program approval process. Refer to Appendix A for the January 31, 2013 letter from FDEP approving the City's Facility Plan. The City's request for SRF funding was approved. The expansion areas are identified in Figure 2.

1 Approved by City Council 2 Tentatively approved by City Council for planning purposes

Page 16

Page 18: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

EXIS'iiNG SER'•'lCE AREA

SOU'THWEST611

rr.oRn·t1

hO~TH2

, F'.mJRE EXTENS!QNNtEA r NORTHi·l

"-'PMIIOil&Oifll~ 011 dllu pmcNeld bt' IN Ofr rl .:.P.Cof1111. ~r h sot. PW'PO"cf~ ... ~Mltiloncf:--.rtld

~r Mfcthira.t . ..,.,.,.MitfiiiiWI!'t;~ll:ltlftla1.ttM...._ Cfo1nf~Md>M No~il,...t,-U..~ ti~CWI

~ffllltanddlla~f«~,._

;;;:&atct1.t/XI1J (M;Ipba"'don'Wail<ILat'lf)

CITY OF CAPE CORAL PROPOSED UTILITY EXTENSION

0 0.5 1 2 4 -==-::::JI--t:==::::JI--Miles

3

Figure 2: Future Utility Service Areas

Page 17

Page 19: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

Figure 3 provides a comparison between the projected City of Cape Coral population (April 1, 2013 BEBR) and the projection of Equivalent Residential Units (ERU) to be served. Note that the growth in ERU capacity is incrementally greater than the growth in population as utility service will be extended into new areas. The City of Cape Coral is a pre-platted community and each buildable lot has been identified as such by the City. Each such lot contains minimum size to support a single family house and has also been assigned one utility ERU or Equivalent Residential Unit. This is the same system which the City employs when allocating assessments for utility expansion and extension projects. In the event that a group of lots are consolidated to make a larger parcel, that larger parcel will initially contain the sum of the ERUs which were previously assigned to the individual lots. At the time of development of a parcel for anything other than a single family home, the actual number of utility ERUs needed is determined based on the planned/permitted development ofthe parcel.

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

Page 18

Page 20: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

330,000

275,000

220,000

r:: ,g

1165,000 0

Do.

110,000

55,000

2005

114,000

95,000

.... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... ....

76,000

, ~

57,000 Jl :5 a: "'

38,000

--- Cape Coral Population

--ERUs Served

19,000

Source for population data: http:/ /www.bebr.ufl.edu/data/series/tables/150/annual

------- -- --- -- --- ---- ------------- ------------- 0

2040 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035

Year

Figure 3- Comparison of Population to ERUs

Page \9

Page 21: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

3.2 Description of Future Areas Served

The North 1 Utility expansion area is located in northeast Cape Coral. East of Del Prado Boulevard, the area's northern boundary is NE 28th Street. West of Del Prado, the northern boundary is Kismet Parkway. The southern boundary is generally Pine Island Road/State Road 78. The eastern boundary ofNorth 1 is NE 24th Avenue. The western boundary is Andalusia Boulevard, except that the southern portion of this area extends to Santa Barbara Boulevard.

The North 2 Utility Expansion Area is located generally west of the North 1 Area. However, North 2 is actually a series of geographic areas, extending discontinuously from the west side of Andalusia Boulevard to the City's western boundary. From east to west, this Utility Expansion Area includes:

• An area bounded roughly on the east by Andalusia Boulevard, on the west by Santa Barbara Boulevard, on the north by Diplomat Parkway, and on the south by the Hermosa Canal.

• An area bounded on the north by the Hermosa Canal, on the east by Santa Barbara Boulevard, on the South by SW 1st Street, and on the west by Nicholas Parkway and Nelson Road.

• An area bounded by Nicholas Parkway and Nelson Road to the east, TroEicana Parkway to the north, Chiquita Boulevard to the west, and SW 6th Terrace/SW 4 Terrace to the south.

• An area bounded on the east by Chiquita Boulevard, on the south by Pine Island Road/SR 78 and SW 4th Street, and on the west by ElDorado Boulevard.

• And area bounded on the east by El Dorado Boulevard, on the south by Ceitus Parkway, on the west by Burnt Store Road, and on the north by the Shadroe Canal.

• An area bounded on the east by Burnt Store Road, on the south by Pine Island Road/SR 78, on the west by the west City Boundary, and on the north by Embers Parkway.

The North 3 Utility Expansion Area is located north of the three westernmost areas within the North 2 Utility Expansion Area. The North 3 Area's southern boundary runs along the Shadroe Canal and Embers Parkway. Its west boundary is the west City boundary, its north boundary is the Horseshoe Canal (east of Burnt Store Road) and the Gator Slough Canal (west of Burnt Store Road).

The North 4 Utility Expansion Area is located north of North 2 Utility Expansion area. The North 4 Area's southern boundary is Tropicana Pkwy E., Nelson Road to the west, Andalusia Boulevard to the east, and Jacaranda Parkway to the north.

Page 110

Page 22: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

The North 5 Utility Expansion Area is located east of North 3 Utilities Expansion area and extends south just past Embers Parkway, bounded by Chiquita Blvd to the east and to the west by El Dorado Boulevard N. and Burnt Store Rd. N.

The North 6 Utility Expansion Area is located east of the North 5 Utility Expansion Area and bounded by Tropicana Parkway to the south, Chiquita Boulevard to the west, Nelson Road to the east and Wilmington Parkway to the north.

The North 7 Utility Expansion Area is located north of Utility Expansion Area's 3 and 5. It is bounded by undeveloped preserve to the west, the city boarder to the north, Chiquita Boulevard the east, and just south of Kismet Parkway to the south.

The North 8 Utility Expansion Area is located north of the North 1 Utility Expansion Area. It is bounded by Jacaranda Parkway and N. Del Prado Boulevard to the south, Garden Boulevard to the east, Andalusia Boulevard to the west, and Durden Parkway to the North.

3.3 Potable Water Level of Service Standard

For the purpose of this analysis, each of the lots which have been identified as meeting the criteria as having the minimum size to support a single family home have been assigned the equivalent of one 5/8-inch water meter (or one equivalent residential unit or ERU). The City of Cape Coral has in the past established a level of service standard for their utility system that one ERU is equal to 200 gallons per day of potable water demand on an annual average daily flow basis (AADF) and 200 gallons per day of sanitary sewage generated on an average annual daily flow (AADF) basis. (City of Cape Coral Comprehensive Plan, Irifrastructure Element, Policy 1.1.1.)

Historic potable water demands were 9.619 million gallons per day (AADF) in FY 2010 and 10.226 million gallons per day (AADF) in FY 2009. As of December 2013 the City provided service to 56,674 water meters. Using the most recent year's water demand divided by the number of water meters for the same period results in an average demand of 167 gallons per day per water meter (AADF).

[9,483,000 gallons per day-AADF]/[56,674 meters] = 167 gallons per day/meter-AADF

There are a number of water meters which serve commercial establishments, as well as, a number of water meters which serve multi-family developments. The net result is that these two categories offset one another, especially since the vast majority of the City's meters serve single family residences. Thus, the total number of meters is considered to be approximately equivalent to the total number of utility ERUs served by the City's system. Therefore, the above calculation appears to confirm the City's level of service standard of 200 gallons per day per ERU (AADF), which has been used to project future demands.

Page Ill

Page 23: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

The Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) permits water production facilities on a maximum daily flow (MDF) basis. The City has observed a historic ratio between maximum day demand and annual average daily demand equal to 1.20 which can be used to adjust the City's level of service standard on an annual average daily flow basis to a maximum day flow basis.

[200 gallons per day per ERU-AADF][l.20 MDF/AADF] = 240 gallons per day per ERU (MDF)

3.4 Potable Water Demand Projections

Future potable water demand projections are being made using current potable water demands combined with projected demand for future ERUs (equivalent residential units) as they will be added to the City utility system.

The total number of future ERUs is the sum of existing customers, plus infill in the current service area, plus those for areas which have not yet been provided with utility service. The number of Infill ERUs and ERUs for currently unserved areas used here is consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan and Utility Expansion Program assessment methodology.

The following table identifies the total number ofERUs which have been identified as future City utilities customers beyond those already served.

Number ofERUs Served Unserved Buildout

Areas currently served 56,ooo· 14,227 70,227 SW Areas 6 & 7 0 6,128 6,128 North Area 1 0 6,901 6,901 North Area2 0 7,628 7,628 North Area 3 0 7,949 7,949 North Area 4 0 7,057 7,057 North Area 5 0 7,266 7,266 North Area 6 0 5,690 5,690 North Area 7 0 7,986 7,986 North Area 8 0 6,212 6,212

TOTAL 56,000 76,161 132,161 *56,000 ERUs at 200 = 11.2 MGD Annual Average Daily Flow; 56,000 ERUs at 240 gaVday/ERU = 13.5 MGD Maximum Daily Flow

The City of Cape Coral has two potable water production facilities with a combined permitted capacity of 30, I 00,000 gallons per day. 5

5 The Southwest RO Water Treatment Plant is presently permitted for 18, I 00,000 gallons per day (MDF) and the North RO Water Treatment Plant is presently permitted for 12,000,000 gallons per day (MDF).

Page Jl2

Page 24: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

These facilities are permitted for operation to meet the maximum day flow (MDF) demand. The current level of demand in recent years is approximately 12,000,000 gallons per day (MDF).

The current level of reserve capacity for water supply and treatment can be calculated as follows:

[30, 100,000- 12,000,000 gallons per day] I 240 gallons per day/ERU = 75,400 ERUs

Note that the above number of ERUs which represent 100 percent of lots in the City not presently on City Utilities is approximately equal to the available water treatment capacities of the City's existing facilities. This is not the entire picture. It must be understood that all water treatment facilities require a factor of safety when assessing capacity. One reason is to accommodate changes in per capita consumption of water. It is not an accepted practice to operate water supply and production facilities at or near 100 percent of its permitted capacity. A primary reason not to do this is the standard practice of providing reserve capacity to handle the likelihood of some treatment units being offline for either scheduled maintenance or unexpected repairs. Also, the geographic distribution of customer needs compared to source of water supply and water treatment is an important consideration. FDEP rules and regulations require that a utility system continue to assess their system demands and project their future needs on a periodic basis once they reach 75 percent of permitted capacity in order to plan for making sure demands will be able to be met. 6

In 2012, in the City of Cape Coral, 42 percent of lots are served by the City Utilities. It is projected that by 2033, that 73 percent of the pre-platted lots will be served by City Utilities. This is based on the combination of population growth of 2 percent per year combined with expansion of water service throughout the City. In the event of more rapid growth, the demand is expected to remain within the capacity of the City's water treatment facilities during the ten year planning period.

Figure 4 and Table 1 provides a projection of potable water demands from 2013 through 2033 based on the combination of population growth and increasing utility service area. The projected water demand for 2033 is 23.1 MGD or 77 percent of the combined capacity of the City's two water treatment facilities (30.1 MGD).

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

6 The total number of ERUs used are the number of parcels to be assessed based on current lot dimensions. The total number of dwelling units at build-out is greater than this number based on anticipated future land use changes throughout the City.

Page 113

Page 25: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

170,000 l"""""a 1""'"""1 Dn+""hla \Al""+;a,. nzu-""""'..1 30.00

100,000 North8 Complete 25.00

"'t:J ., ~ 80,000 20.00 g ~ ~ ~ "'t:J ~ ~ = E ~ North 5 Complete ~ ~ ~ ., ., ~ ~

~ 60,000 ' 15.00 ~ I ! r & ' - y[ : North3Complmo I i ~ I : North 2Complm I ! ffi 40,000 ':JW b&/ complete 10.00 ~ - I

*240 Gallons/ERU * 2% increase in population per year

20,000 5.00

0 +:-----,------,-----.-----~----.------,-----.-----.------r-----.-----~----.------+ 0.00 2035 2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 2019 2021 2023 2025

~Total ERU's --Water Demand MGD Year

Figure 4: Potable Water Demand

2027 2029 2031 2033

Page I 14

Page 26: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

Table 1: City of Cape Coral Potable Water Supply Demand

Year Total ERU's in service Potable Water Supply Demand Raw Water Max Day (MGDJ Max Day (MGD)

2010 54,347 13.0 16;3 2011 54,387 13.2 16.5 2012 55,347 13.3 . ·. 16.6 2013 55,847 13.4 16.8 2014 56,347 13.5 16.9 2015 60,230 14.5 18.1 2016 60,798 14.6 18.3 2017 64,346 15.4 19.3 2018 64,976 15.6 19.5 2019 68,495 16.4 20.5 2020 69,188 16.6 20.8 2021 72,553 17.4 21.8 2022 73,307 17.6 22.0 2023 77,079 18.5 23.1 2024 77,904 18.7 23.4 2025 81,962 19.7 24.6 2026 82,864 19.9 24.9 2027 86,085 20.7 25.9 2028 87,050 20.9 26.1 2029 89,769 21.5 26.9 2030 90,787 21.8 27.3 2031 93,982 22.6 28.3 2032 95,065 22.8 28.5 2033 96,159 23.1 28.9

.. Water supply demand based upon peak demand of240 gal!ERU. By 2031, all geographic regions of Cape Coral will have Pubhc Ut!hty Service

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

Page 115

Page 27: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

3.5 Water Supply Provided by the City of Cape Coral

The City water system is divided into two separate systems (dual water system). The drinking water system uses subsurface brackish water aquifers as a raw water source to be processed into potable water by the City's two reverse osmosis plants. The irrigation water system is supplied by highly treated wastewater reuse quality effluent and water from the City's extensive network of freshwater canals to provide non-potable (irrigation and limited fire protection) water for the City. Development of the irrigation system was a condition of the City's Consumptive Use Permit from the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) permit number 36-00046-W; expiration October 2029.

In September 1984, as a condition of the consumptive use permit from the South Florida Water Management District, the City agreed to implement Phase 1 of a dual water system that would utilize canal water for the source of irrigation water. Subsequently, in November 1989, a public referendum endorsed the use of treated wastewater reuse quality effluent for residential reuse. At that point, the irrigation system was expanded to include the use of treated effluent. Since that time, the City has provided reuse irrigation water service to areas which essentially overlap the City's potable water service areas. Use of the irrigation water system has significantly enabled the City to lower its annual per capita demand for potable water.

The City of Cape Coral's potable water production facilities are supplied with brackish raw water from the Upper Floridan aquifer. There are a total of fifty-five wells. Plant No. 1 at the Southwest RO WTP, [built in 1977], is supplied by twelve wells; Plant No. 2 at the Southwest RO WTP, [built in 1985], is supplied by twenty-one wells5

; and the North RO WTP [completed in 201 0] is supplied by twenty-two wells. Each well field supplies water to its respective water treatment facility through an independent raw water transmission system.

3.6 Water Supply Provided by Other Entities

A portion of Cape Coral is served by the Greater Pine Island Water Association (GPIW A). The GPIW A service area includes Pine Island, Little Pine Island, Matlacha, portions of western Cape Coral, and portions of unincorporated Lee County. The portion of the service area in Coral Cape is bound on the north by Embers Parkway, on the east by Nott Road [Southwest 20th Street], on the south by Pine Island Road [except for a small area just south of Pine Island Road near Veteran's Parkway], and on the west by Matlacha Pass (not including the Matlacha Isles development). However, not all of this area currently receives service, as portions of the service area are currently undeveloped.

GPIW A currently provides service to commercial establishments along S.R. 78, an apartment complex and some residential units in Unit 54 and 58.

5 Originally there were twenty-two water supply wells, although one is no longer available for use for water supply and it is being used to collect water quality samples.

Page 116

Page 28: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

The Greater Pine Island Water Association provides potable water service to a total of 6,700 customers (accounts) in unincorporated Lee County, with approximately 270 in the City of Cape Coral.

The GPIW A has a contract to service this area until the City is able to provide service to individuals in this area and will discontinue service when the City extends water to this area.

Water is supplied by groundwater wells from the Lower Hawthorn aquifer. There are three Lower Hawthorn wells located on the water treatment plant premises and an additional two wells along Stringfellow Road. Lower Hawthorn groundwater is processed through a 3.2 MGD RO plant. These facilities are permitted by the South Florida Water Management District for an average daily withdrawal of 2.44 MGD and a monthly maximum allocation of 97.0542 million gallons (annual allocation of 890 million gallons; SFWMD Consumptive Use Permit 36-00045-W; expires October 20 15).

3.7 Domestic Self- supply Water

There are areas in the northern part of the City of Cape Coral where the population density has yet to reach the threshold where the City will begin extending utility service. As provided in Section 3.1, the City has a plan for extending water lines into areas generally north of Pine Island Road (currently un-served areas). The amount of well water used by the residents in these areas has been estimated based on the level service standard for the City's utility customers. This is provided in Table 2.

Table 2: Estimated Potable and Irrigation Water Use from Domestic Self-supply Wells

Year Potable Water Irrigation Water Estimated Use Estimated Use

(MGD) (MGD) 2010 3.4 6.8 2015 3.6 7.2 2020 2.7 5.4 2025 1.2 2.4 2030 0.5 1.0 2035 minimal minimal

The above projections for irrigation water used from domestic self supply wells assumes that private wells will be taken offline as service becomes available from the City's utility.

*Irrigation water estimated at 400 gpd/ERU #Potable water estimated at 200 gpd/ERU

Page 117

Page 29: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

-10

-15

-20

-25

FIGURE 5 ·PLOT OF WATER LEVEL ELEVATION FOR SANDSTONE AQUIFER COLLECTED IN USGS WELL L-581.

~5+-----------------------------------------------------------------~

~+---~~--~--~---r--~--~--~--~-,--~--~--~--~--~--~--r-~ Feb-78 Feb~ Jan-82 Jan-84 Jan-86 Jan-88 Jan-90 Jan-92 Jan-94 Jan-96 Jan-98 Jan-00 Jan-02 Jan-<l4 Jan-06 Jan-08 Jan-10 Jan-12

---Water Level Elevation (It NGVD)

Figure 5 illustrates the benefits of extending potable water and reuse water utility service to residents of the City of Cape Coral. The large number of domestic self supply wells in this area of the City of Cape Coral had caused a drop in water levels in the sandstone and Mid-Hawthorn aquifer over a twenty-five year period. Once potable water and reuse water lines were extended into this portion of the City, the water levels in the sandstone and Mid-Hawthorn aquifer immediately began to recover.

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

Page !18

Page 30: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

Table 3: Service & Bulk Purchase Agreements (outside jurisdiction)

Bulk Sales from Cape Coral Utility to Others Local Government Served Bulk Sales Water Supplied (MGD) Year 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Lee County Utilities 1.858 1.721 3.325 1.797 2.655 5.23

Bulk Purchases by Ca_pe Coral Utility from Others Local Government Served Bulk Sales- Water Received (MGD) Year 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013

- - - - - -

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

Page 119

Page 31: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

3.8 Conservation

3.8.1 Specific Actions, Programs, Regulations, or Opportunities

The City of Cape Coral has adopted a number of water conservation programs, primarily directed toward reducing the amount of potable water that is used by City residents to irrigate lawns and landscaped areas. The City also has programs promoting household water conservation. City potable water conservation programs include:

Staggered Watering Schedules

The City allows residents to water their lawns twice per week regardless of the irrigation water source. Permitted watering times are regulated by reference to the last number in a property's address.

The two day schedule, in effect for all of Cape Coral, is as follows:

Monday and Friday: Midnight to 4 a.m. for addresses ending in 0

Monday and Friday: 4 a.m. to 8 a.m. for addresses ending in 1

Wednesday and Saturday: Midnight to 4 a.m. for address ending in 3 and 5

Wednesday and Saturday: 4 a.m. to 8 a.m. for addresses ending in 7 and 9

Thursday and Sunday: Midnight to 4 a.m. for addresses ending in 2 and 4

Thursday and Sunday: 4 a.m. to 8 a.m. for addresses ending in 6 and 8

Lawn watering is restricted to no more than four hours per each irrigation event. This program is enforced through the City's Code Compliance Division. Residents watering on the wrong day or time initially receive a "1st offense" notice, which is essentially a warning and carries no fine. A violator is charged $100 for the 2nd offense, $200 for the 3rd offense and $400 for the 4th offense. If the address is hooked up to the City's centralized irrigation system, repeat violators can be disconnected and charged an $80 fee for reconnecting. Failure to pay fines can result in a lien against the subject property.

Other Watering Restrictions

The City allows limited use of water for various outdoor activities. There are no restrictions on pressure washing or car washing. New plants, planted for less than 30 days, may be watered on Monday through Thursday of each week, between the hours of 2:00 a.m. and 8:00 a.m. New plants established between 31 and 60 days may be watered between the hours of 2:00 a.m. and 8:00a.m., on Monday, Wednesday, Thursday and Saturday.

Page 120

Page 32: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

Water Conservation Tips

The City of Cape Coral's Watering Schedule webpage includes a link to a water conservation page established and maintained by the South Florida Water Management District (http://www.savewaterfl.com). This site features information on current water use restrictions, landscaping maintenance, and water-saving tips. There are sub-pages for homeowners, businesses, agricultural interests, utilities, government agencies, teachers and news media.

Florida Friendly Landscaping Program

The City of Cape Coral sponsors the Florida Friendly Landscaping Program in Cape Coral. The program is a partnership between the landscape industry, the University of Florida Cooperative Extension Service, Florida's National Estuary Programs, Florida's Sea Grant College Program, and various State and local environmental agencies. The program focuses on yards, as they are the first line of defense for estuaries, rivers, lakes, aquifers and the City's canal system.

The Florida Friendly Landscaping Program adheres to nine basic principles that, if implemented properly, are designed to reduce the adverse impacts of a yard on stormwater quality. Each principle contains a series of actions that landowners can take to improve the environmental health of their yards and the health of the waterways these yards drain to. Through implementation of the principles and actions program participants are awarded points, or "inches." When a participating yard achieves 36 inches (a "yard"), the yard receives a plaque, which can be placed in the yard to let everyone know that the subject property is a "Certified Florida Yard." The program's nine principles are:

• Right plant, right place;

• Water efficiently;

• Reduce stormwater runoff;

• Proper maintenance of waterfront properties (to reduce stormwater impacts);

• Mulching;

• Vegetation recycling;

• A void or reduce use of fertilizers;

• A void use of pesticides and herbicides; and,

• Maintain areas for wildlife.

More information on these nine principles can be found on the City's website.

Page 121

Page 33: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

3.8.2 Identify any Local Financial Responsibilities as Detailed in the CIE or CIS

This subsection is not applicable.

3.9 Reuse

State law supports reuse efforts. Florida's utilities, local governments, and water management districts have led the nation in the quantity of reclaimed water reused and public acceptance of reuse programs. Section 373.250(1) F.S. provides "the encouragement and promotion of water conservation and reuse of reclaimed water, as defined by the department, are state objectives and considered to be in the public interest." In addition, Section 403.064(1) F.S., states "reuse is a critical component of meeting the state's existing and future water supply needs while sustaining natural systems."

3.9 .1 Regional and Countywide Issues

The City of Cape Coral continues to support and encourage water reuse initiatives under consideration by both the SFWMD and FDEP and the implementation of new regulations, programs or conservation activities designed increase the use of reclaimed water and encourage public acceptance ofbeneficial reuse of reclaimed water.

3.9.2 Local Government Specific Actions, Programs, Regulations, or Opportunities

Reuse water from both the Everest Parkway and Southwest WRF is distributed to the City of Cape Coral's citizens via a reuse irrigation system. In the event the reuse irrigation system does not use 100 percent of the treated reclaimed water, after filling the five reuse storage tanks [two at the Everest WRF and three at the Southwest WRF, approximately 25 million gallons of reuse storage capacity], the unused portion is disposed of via deep injection wells or, if necessary, reclaimed water from the Everest WRF could be discharged to the Caloosahatchee River. Reclaimed water from the Southwest WRF is no longer able to be discharged to the Caloosahatchee River.

When the reuse demand exceeds treatment output and available storage, reuse flow is supplemented by canal water from the City's 300 miles of freshwater canals, which is pumped from five canal pump stations maintained by the City.

As the City extends potable water and sanitary sewer service to new service areas, the City will also extend its reuse water for irrigation unless there are reasons that warrant deviation 6 .

6 Infrastructure Element of the Comp Plan Policy 2.3.4 says, "Potable water, secondary irrigation water, and sanitary sewer service will be extended concurrently to new service areas unless unusual conditions peculiar to a particular area warrant a deviation based on sound planning principals."

Page 122

Page 34: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

3.9.3 Identify any Local Financial Responsibilities as Detailed in the CIE or CIS

This subsection is not applicable.

3.1 0 Sector Plans

This section is not applicable.

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

Page 123

Page 35: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

4.0 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS

4.1 Work Plan Projects

All Public, Private & Regional Utility Projects and Programs Serving the City of Cape Coral Utility Future Finished Water Date Capital Population

Serving Cape Project or Water Source for Project on Cost Served with Coral's Program (MGD) Project or line Jurisdiction

Jurisdiction Providing Program Water to

Jurisdiction No Projects* - - - - -

City of Cape Coral Utility Projects and Programs serving_ outside its own jurisdiction Other Future Finished Water Date Capital Population

Jurisdictions Project or Water Source for Project on Cost Served with being served Program (MGD) Project or line Jurisdiction

by Cape Providing Program Coral Water to

Jurisdiction No Projects - - - - -

*The City has not budgeted nor scheduled the future project to expand the North R.O. Water Treatment Plant. The City presently has sufficient potable water supply and treatment to meet

their needs.

Page 124

Page 36: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

4.2 Capital Improvements Element/Schedule

CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM

Funding Source FY 2014 FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 FY 2018 FY 2019 TOTAL

Utilities Infrastructure

South RO

Palm Tree Water Main Extension Water & Sewer Fees 300,000 1,700,000 - - - - 2,000,000

Upgrade Security at North/South Pump Station Water & Sewer Fees - 100,000 - - - - 100,000

Retro SW RO Wellfield Control/Communication 300,000 250,000 - - - - 550,000

SW RO Control System Upgrade Water & Sewer Fees 700,000 - - - - - 700,000

Underground Wellfields Water & Sewer Fees 43,759 45,071 46,423 47,816 - - 183,069

New Maintenance Shop & Storage Water & Sewer Fees - 750,000 - - - - 750,000

Plant 2 Feed Water & Blend Line Upgrade Water & Sewer Fees - - - 1,340,000 - - 1.340,000

Plant 2 Building Replacement Water & Sewer Fees - - - 1,000,000 - - 1,000,000

SW RO Deep Injection Well Water & Sewer Fees 2,500,000 2,500,000 - - - - 5,000,000

SW RO Lightning & Grounding Protection Water & Sewer Fees 125,000 - - - - - 125,000 1

North RO !

North RO Deep Injection Well Water & Sewer Fees 100,000 - 2,500,000 2,400,000 - - 5,000,000 I

North RO Perimeter Wall Water & Sewer Fees - 850,000 - - - - 85o,ooo I

North RO Landscaping Water & Sewer Fees - - 300,000 - - - 300,000 I

Auxiliary Power Van Loon PS & SRO Water & Sewer Fees 300,000 - - - - - 300,000 I

Distribution System Automation Water & Sewer Fees - 950,000 - - - - 950,000 I

Rehab/Replace Raw Water Wells Water & Sewer Fees 800,000 - 800,000 - 800,000 - 2,400,000

Page J25

Page 37: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

4.2 Capital Improvements Element/Schedule cont.

Funding Source FY 2014 FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 FY 2018 FY 2019 TOTAL

Fire Sprinkler System Conversion (Irr to PW) Water & Sewer Fees 500,000 500,000 500,000 - - - 1,500,000

Potable Water Infrastructure Replacement Water & Sewer Fees 300,000 300,000 300,000 300,000 - - 1,200,000

Del Prado Water Transmission Improvements Water & Sewer Fees 370,000 1,000,000 - - - - 1,370,000

Coronado Potable Water Transmission Improvements Water & Sewer Fees - - - - 1,400,000 1,400,000

Uns~fied Future Projects- Water Water & Sewer Fees - - - - - 5,000,000 5,000,000

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

Page 126

Page 38: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

5.0 GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES

The following comprehensive plan goals, objectives, and polices (OOPs) have been reviewed for consistency with the Work Plan. The Water Supply Plan continues to be consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan therefore there is no need to modify the plan. No changes are proposed to the City's goals, objectives and policies.

The following OOPs were adopted in the original Work Plan and have been reviewed to see if updates or revisions are needed:

a. Coordination of land uses and future land use changes with the availability of water supplies and water supply facilities. [No changes necessary]

b. Revision of potable water level of service standards for residential and non-residential users. [No changes necessary]

c. Provision for the protection of water quality in the traditional and new alternative water supply sources. [No changes necessary]

d. Revision of priorities for the replacement of facilities, correction of existing water supply and facility deficiencies, and provision for future water supply and facility needs. [No changes necessary]

e. Provision for conserving potable water resources, including the implementation of reuse programs and potable water conservation strategies and techniques. [No changes necessary]

f. Provisions for improved or additional coordination between a water supply provider and the recipient local government concerning the sharing and updating of information to meet ongoing water supply needs. [No changes necessary]

g. Coordination between local governments and the water supply provider in the implementation of alternative water supply projects, establishment of level of service standards and resource allocations, changes in service areas, and potential for annexation. [No changes necessary]

h. Coordination of land uses with available and projected fiscal resources and a financially feasible schedule of capital improvements for water supply and facility projects. [No changes necessary]

i. Additional revenue sources to fund water supply and facility projects. [No changes necessary]

Page 127

Page 39: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

j. Coordination with the respective regional water supply plan. [No changes necessary]

k. Update the Work Plan within 18 months following the approval of a regional water supply plan. [No changes necessary]

I. Concurrency requiring water supplies at the building permit stage. [No changes necessary]

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

Page 128

Page 40: CITY OF CAPE CORAL MEMORANDUM TO: John Szerlag, City … · 2019-07-22 · DCSB/RSS(TXT14-0002Application) Attachment c: Jeff Pearson, Utilities Director Rick Sosnowski, Planning

6.0 REGIONAL ISSUES IDENTIFIED IN REGIONAL WATER SUPPLY PLAN

Detailed information on regional issues can be found in Chapter 3, Issues and Evaluations, in the Lower West Coast Water Supply Plan. A summary of relevant regional issues indentified for the Lower West Coast Water Supply Planning Region can be found in sub-section 2.2 within this plan update.

A summary of the City of Cape Coral's impact on these issues:

1. The City of Cape Coral does not use the surficial aquifer or the freshwater portion of the intermediate aquifer.

2. The City of Cape Coral does not use surface water from the Lake Okeechobee.

3. The City of Cape Coral does not use freshwater from the Caloosahatchee River or Estuary.

-Remainder of page intentionally left blank-

Page 129