cl 323 term paper final

8
Morrongiello 1 Dylan Morrongiello May 11, 2015 CL 323: Self-Revelation in Women’s Writing The Childhoods of Hurston and FarrokhzadZora Neale Hurston and Forugh Farrokhzad have similar relations to their respective literary traditions. They differentiated themselves from their more traditional peers both because of their gender and Forugh’s non-participation in Muslim and Zora’s embracing of her African ancestry. Hurston and Farrokhzad demonstrated very similar subject interests, due to their modernist perceptions and separation from their dominant cultures. Both authors presented a great deal of self- revelation in their literary works. Hurston’s self-revelation shows through her knowledge of Florida culture and her depth of experience, whereas Farrokhzad’s self-revelation appears in her frank descriptions of her actions, thoughts, and feelings. Within this revelation, Hurston and Farrokhzad both note a strong influence of their childhoods on their adult life and their writings. Many factors influenced Zora and Forugh’s childhoods. One important difference is their financial upbringing and the environment provided by their families, specifically Hurston and Farrokhzad’s relations to their mothers. Several intrinsic characteristics also contributed to their childhood years. Both writers exhibited natural inquisitiveness in their attitude and demeanor, expressed interests that were contradictory to the mainstream cultures to which they belonged, and possessed feelings of isolation and loneliness. Though these variables did not

Upload: dylan-anthony-morrongiello

Post on 08-Nov-2015

215 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

DESCRIPTION

CL 323

TRANSCRIPT

  • Morrongiello 1

    Dylan Morrongiello

    May 11, 2015

    CL 323: Self-Revelation in Womens Writing

    The Childhoods of Hurston and Farrokhzad

    Zora Neale Hurston and Forugh Farrokhzad have similar relations to their

    respective literary traditions. They differentiated themselves from their more

    traditional peers both because of their gender and Forughs non-participation in

    Muslim and Zoras embracing of her African ancestry. Hurston and Farrokhzad

    demonstrated very similar subject interests, due to their modernist perceptions and

    separation from their dominant cultures. Both authors presented a great deal of self-

    revelation in their literary works. Hurstons self-revelation shows through her

    knowledge of Florida culture and her depth of experience, whereas Farrokhzads

    self-revelation appears in her frank descriptions of her actions, thoughts, and

    feelings. Within this revelation, Hurston and Farrokhzad both note a strong influence

    of their childhoods on their adult life and their writings.

    Many factors influenced Zora and Forughs childhoods. One important

    difference is their financial upbringing and the environment provided by their

    families, specifically Hurston and Farrokhzads relations to their mothers. Several

    intrinsic characteristics also contributed to their childhood years. Both writers

    exhibited natural inquisitiveness in their attitude and demeanor, expressed interests

    that were contradictory to the mainstream cultures to which they belonged, and

    possessed feelings of isolation and loneliness. Though these variables did not

  • Morrongiello 2

    always positively influence the writers childhoods, they did mold a childhood that led

    to an adulthood characterized by significant literary achievement.

    A major difference between Hurston and Farrokhzads childhoods is their

    financial circumstances. Hurston grew up in the town of Eatonville, Florida, which is

    located approximately 5 miles outside of Orlando. Eatonville was the first

    incorporated black community in Florida. In her childhood, Zora was relatively

    uneducated and very poor, but was very much immersed in black life, which she

    reveals in her writing. When Zora was sixteen, she joined a traveling Gilbert and

    Sullivan theatre company to be able to support herself after her mothers death. In

    return, the mother of the woman for whom she worked arranged for her to attend

    high school at Morgan Academy in Baltimore, which enabled her to later attend

    Howard University and Barnard College to study anthropology.

    Forugh, on the other hand, was born in Tehran, Iran, into a middle-class

    family and her father ensured she was absorbed in education from a young age.

    Forughs father had a personal library and taught Forugh to read before she was old

    enough to attend school. It was because of this that Forugh developed a love of

    literature, which is particularly unusual in a society where most women are illiterate.

    After finishing the ninth grade, Forugh left high school to attend a technical school

    where she studied dressmaking and painting. Forugh felt that writing poetry became

    more natural for her in this discipline.

    Both Hurston and Farrokhzad had rather close relationships with their

    mothers. However, their mothers treated their daughters very differently. Zoras

    mother, Lucy Potts strongly encouraged Zora to be creative. In her autobiography,

  • Morrongiello 3

    Dust Tracks on a Road, Hurston recalls that her mother would always encourage

    her children to jump at de sun. Unlike black women of the time, Lucy Potts

    possessed a voice and was herself contrary to the gender expectations set by her

    society. At the time of her death, Lucy had specifically requested that Zora ensure

    her pillow does not get turned over when she dies. Though Hurston was ultimately

    unable to fulfill her mothers wishes, this instance shows the will power possessed

    by Lucy in her lifetime.

    Forughs mother Turan Vaziri Tabar was much more rigid and succumbed to

    the gender roles present in Iranian society. Forughs sister Puran described their

    mother as a slave to rules and regulations. She describes a moment in Forughs

    childhood when her mother berated her after she showed her friends her New

    Years Eve outfit, which is an act against Iranian culture. Unlike Zoras mother,

    Forughs mother believed her daughter should conform to her cultures expectations

    and she imposed her societys gender roles on her. She sought to mold Forugh and

    her other daughter into ideal Iranian women that are subservient and loyal to their

    men, whereas Lucy Potts sought to give Zora the independent voice that she could

    never have herself.

    Spiritual independence and a sense of natural inquisitiveness were traits that

    characterized Hurston and Farrokhzads childhoods. Hurston wrote in-depth about

    her inquisitiveness in her autobiography Dust Tracks on a Road. She writes that she

    naturally picked up the reflections of life with her own instruments and absorbed

    what she gathered according to her own experience. Zora also possesses a very

    fanciful imagination. She explains that she had many imaginary friends as a child,

  • Morrongiello 4

    and turned inanimate objects into her friends and playthings, such as Miss Corn-Cob

    and Reverend Door Knob. When these inanimate objects ceased to commune with

    Zora like real men, her imagination shifted to actual men. She tells a story of a

    simple man, Mr. Pendir, who lived by himself in Lake Belle, whom Zora turned into

    an alligator at night for her own amusement. In her autobiography, she also tells the

    story of how she thought the moon was her own special playmate, and how she

    became very jealous and upset when a friend told her that the moon was also her

    playmate. This attitude and sense of imagination never quite left her in her

    adulthood. Zora wrote her novels with a sense of understanding created by her own

    influence of experience. This appears most predominantly in Seraph on the

    Suwanee, in which Hurston tells the story of a Florida white cracker culture. Her

    descriptions of shrimping, the turpentine industry, and the Floridian fauna show her

    immense knowledge derived from anthropological experience.

    Forugh Farrokhzad also possessed a similar natural inquisitiveness.

    However, opposed to Hurston, this inquisitiveness was present as a sense of

    instinct. Forughs life closely resonated with nature, so many of her ideas and her

    literal development occurred with a natural progression. In her poem Another Birth,

    Farrokhzad describes her childhood nature as one who plants their hands in the

    garden. Naturally, Forugh was a rebellious child and her sense of instinct led her to

    the alley with the boys, in which she was blown away by her first marriage. By the

    time she was sixteen, her independent spirit began to strike acquaintances with

    boys in her neighborhood, and she married her distant relative Parviz Shapur, after

    much insistence by Forugh, when she was sixteen.

  • Morrongiello 5

    In their childhoods, both Hurston and Farrokhzad expressed interests and

    behaviors that did not conform to their cultures pre-conceived gender norms. In her

    autobiography Dust Tracks on the Road, Hurston describes many moments of her

    childhood in which she exhibited this sort of behavior. Zora was not only a naturally

    inquisitive child. She was also very insistent. In her childhood, Hurston sought to

    create a unique identity for herself. She was not able to simply conform to any belief

    that was presented to her without questioning it.

    Farrokhzads had an intense sexual interest in her childhood. As a child and

    as an adolescent, she was naturally curious about her body. She writes in an early

    poem entitled Awareness about how her body, on its first day of adolescence,

    began to open in innocent amazement. In another poem, Those Days, Forugh

    presents a childhood that is filled with nostalgia and innocence, and a contrasting

    adolescence that she describes as those days of wonder at the bodys secret. This

    sexual interest was also very much present in Farrokhzads adulthood, where she

    demonstrates rejection of Iranian sexual values. In arguably her most famous poem,

    The Sin, Farrokhzad describes a first-person recollection of a sexual encounter

    with a man who is not her husband. Unlike the Iranian society, which viewed

    premarital or extramarital sexual pleasure a grave sin, Forugh saw it as a natural

    function within a relationship.

    Because of these interests and behaviors, Hurston and Farrokhzad both

    reveal feelings of isolation from their respective cultures and traditions in their

    childhoods. Both writers existed within societies that suppressed women. In the

    African American culture, women suffered retribution from the dominant white

  • Morrongiello 6

    culture as well as the black male culture. In the Iranian tradition, women are strictly

    subservient to men. Several passages in the Koran back this assertion.

    In her childhood, Zora was never particularly friendly with her peers. She was

    isolated because of her natural curiosity and her excellence in the classroom. As a

    child, Hurston mostly kept to herself and her imagination. She credits the sense of

    imagination to her interest in reading as a child. In school, she was a very avid

    reader, having read from authors such as the great Greeks, Robert Louis

    Stevenson, and Hans Andersen. She would always read through to the end of her

    school reader before the rest of the class. In Dust Tracks on a Road, she describes

    a time when two white women recognized her literary excellence in the classroom.

    This gift of educational excellence was also a curse. Zora explains how her

    elaborate stories and imagination kept her from making friends with the other school

    children. Even at a young age, Zora recognized that she was different from her

    peers. They wouldnt understand her imaginative personality and would simply laugh

    off her extravagant story-telling. Hurston had a mature sense of understanding that

    her peers did not possess.

    In her poem Friday, Farrokhzad describes the isolation she felt on Fridays

    in Tehran. According to the Iranian tradition, Friday was the weekly day off. In

    Forughs early years, this means that Friday was, for most Iranians, a day of

    window-shopping and visits with relatives. However, because Forugh was an

    unchaperoned teenage girl, Fridays were for her a day of loneliness, when she was

    forced to stay indoors because of her gender and young age. This poem seems to

    characterize Forughs adolescence, in that it represents a period of time in which the

  • Morrongiello 7

    Iranian society muffled Forughs femininity and thus repressed her budding

    sexuality. These feelings of loneliness followed Forugh into her adult life. She writes

    in her poem Those Days that that girl who once enjoyed all of the simplicities and

    frivolities of childhood has now become a lonely woman. In her life, the

    companionship of a male partner never satisfied her. It wasnt until she discovered

    her love of writing poetry and resolved to live her life according to that love. She

    reveals these sentiments in Conquest of the Garden when she expresses her

    determination to follow the dictates of her heart.

    As is true of any life, childhood plays an important role in the development of

    human beings into adulthood. Both Zora Neale Hurston and Forugh Farrokhzads

    experiences and attitudes in childhood influenced their individuality in adulthood and

    their dedication to writing. While many factors contribute to this development, it

    becomes clear that some aspects had more influence than others. Financial

    upbringing and family relations are a significant dynamic in the development of the

    two writers. However, there were also several inherent factors present in the

    childhoods of the two writers, such as their natural inquisitiveness and their

    rebellious behaviors that also contributed to their development. It is a combination of

    these variables that create a unique voice for the writers, allowing their literary works

    to stand out as individual and removed from the literary and cultural traditions to

    which the writers belong. Their writing transcends their cultural norms to create an

    experience that is universal for the reader. In their departure from their mainstream

    cultures, Hurston and Farrokhzad are able to better illustrate their respective

  • Morrongiello 8

    experiences in life, in a manner that is purely original and not influenced by a

    dominant authority.