clin reasoning

30
Hospital Medicine 101 Jeanne M. Farnan, MD MHPE Jina Saltzman, PA-C University of Chicago Section of Hospital Medicine October 17 th , 2012

Upload: athetriia

Post on 11-Nov-2015

241 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

book

TRANSCRIPT

  • Hospital Medicine 101

    Jeanne M. Farnan, MD MHPE

    Jina Saltzman, PA-C

    University of Chicago

    Section of Hospital Medicine

    October 17th, 2012

  • Outline

    Hospital Orientation Clinical Reasoning

    Rounds Fever & Shortness of Breath

    Noon conference Antibiotics overview

    Rounds Altered Mental Status & Hypotension

    Afternoon report Communication & other Practical Skills

    Signing out Wrap-up and questions

  • Learning objectives

    Give a man a fish and you feed him for a

    day.

    Teach him to fish and you feed him for a

    lifetime.

    -Chinese proverb

  • What we are attempting to avoid

  • Learning Objectives

    Develop a targeted approach to the management of common admission and cross-cover scenarios including: Fever

    Dyspnea

    Hypotension

    Altered mental status

    Overview of antibiosis selection and side effects

    Discuss practical procedural skills

  • But first.clinical reasoning

    What IS clinical reasoning?

    The early generation of ordered hypotheses which are subsequently tested and validated or refuted through an active process of acquisition of relevant data

    This data can be historical, physical, test-based, or even the response the treatment trials

    Courtesy of Adam Cifu, MD

  • Bringing the scientific method to the bedside

    Develop hypothesis based on initial data

    Design your experiment (H/P/Tests)

    Analyze the results

    Does your new data support your hypothesis?

    Do you need to re-formulate your hypothesis?

    Courtesy of Adam Cifu, MD

  • The Process

    1. After taking history, driven by a preliminary differential diagnosis based upon information you have, identify all clinical problems and generate the problem list

    2. Prioritize problem list

    3. Use the prioritized problem list to develop a final differential diagnosis for each specific problem

    Courtesy of Adam Cifu, MD

  • Preliminary Differential Diagnosis

    Developed during the history taking and ancillary information

    Makes use of pivotal points in the history

    Pivotal points are organizing data points Anemia

    Microcytic vs. normocytic vs. macrocytic

    Headaches New vs. old

  • Prioritized Problem Lists

    After the history and physical you have a preliminary differential diagnosis and a non-ordered problem list

    Prioritizing the problem list makes it useful for developing a final differential diagnosis

    Courtesy of Adam Cifu, MD

  • DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS VERSUS PROBLEM LIST?

  • Differential Diagnosis

    A list of potential diagnoses

    Will inform the collection of a problem list and will be narrowed by the problem list

    Problem List

    A list of important complaints or abnormalities that need to be addressed

    Problem lists narrow differentials and assure that all issues are dealt with

    Differential diagnoses & problem lists are co-dependent processes en route to a final dx

    Courtesy of Adam Cifu, MD

  • Differential Diagnosis

    Generate and prioritize Start with a complete list!

    Common things are common, but dont miss high stakes diagnoses

    For each possible diagnosis decide, is it: Likely?

    Possible and high stakes (potentially lethal or requires prompt specific therapy)?

    Possible and low stakes?

    Unlikely?

    Courtesy of Donald R. Bordley, M.D.

  • Differential Diagnosis

    Plan work-up based on differential diagnosis

    Aggressively work-up all likely diagnoses

    Aggressively work-up all possible high stakes diagnoses

    Defer work-up of possible low stakes and unlikely diagnoses

    Re-prioritizing bases upon findings from above

    Courtesy of Donald R. Bordley, M.D.

  • Ways to prioritize problem list: SSADD

    Specificity of abnormality (fatigue vs. 3rd heart sound)

    Severity of problem (cough vs. hemoptysis)

    Active and acute problems

    Diagnostic grouping

    Degree of abnormality (WBC of 11,000 vs. 110,000)

  • Developing the Final Differential Diagnosis

    Category Description

    Leading Hypothesis Best explanation

    Active Alternatives Cant miss

    Most common

    Other Alternatives Zebras

    Excluded

    Courtesy of Adam Cifu, MD

  • Developing the Final Differential Diagnosis

    Category Description

    Leading Hypothesis Gout

    Active Alternatives -

    common

    CPPD

    Active Alternatives -

    Cant miss Septic Arthritis

    Other Alternatives Lyme Disease

    Courtesy of Adam Cifu, MD

  • Identify Chief Complaint

    Recall differential diagnosis & develop

    ranked, working hypotheses

    Test hypotheses - reordering with each

    new piece of information

    Develop more limited list of

    working hypotheses

    Retest with PE and

    diagnostic tests

    Accurate Diagnosis

  • SOB

    Problems

    SOB, CP, LEE

    Differential Diagnosis

    CP

    Differential Diagnosis

    SOB

    Differential Diagnosis

    LEE

    Asthma

    PE

    CHF

    MI

    PE

    Angina

    CHF

    VTE

    Cellulitis

    Diagnosis = PE

  • Identify Chief Complaint

    Recall differential diagnosis, develop

    ranked working hypotheses.

    Test hypotheses - reordering with

    each new piece of information.

    Develop more limited list of

    working hypotheses.

    Retest with history, physical

    and diagnostic tests.

    Preliminary

    Diagnosis

    D

    e

    v

    e

    l

    o

    p

    i

    n

    g

    P

    r

    o

    b

    l

    e

    m

    L

    i

    s

    t

    + =

    F

    I

    N

    A

    L

    D

    i

    a

    g

    n

    o

    s

    i

    s

  • Lets Practice

    A 57 year old man with joint pain. He was awakened at 3:30 AM the morning of presentation with severe pain in his right ankle. When he tried to get out of bed he realized he was unable to walk on the ankle. By morning the ankle is red, warm, swollen and extremely painful

  • PMH

    HTN

    One previous episode of similar foot pain affecting the other foot about 2 years ago

    Ulcerative Colitis

    Meds

    HCTZ

    Balsalazide

    SH

    Married, office job, social ETOH, no tobacco

    Recent travel to Ecuador

    F/H

    Father with Crohns disease

    Mother died from breast cancer

    No rheumatologic disease

    PE

    Nl Vitals

    Right ankle is exquisitely tender, warm, red and swollen and has markedly limited ROM

  • Diagnosis?

  • Cervical strain

    Trapezius strain

    RTC, impingment

    Olecranon bursitis

    Epicondylitis

    CTS, dqt, OA

    Piriformis, MP

    Chondromalacia

    Ligament injury

    PF, MSF

    Metatarsalgia

    Ankle/Foot

    Knee

    Hip

    Hand

    Elbow

    Shoulder

    Neck

    Periarticular

    Lyme disease

    GC arthritis

    Septic Joint

    CPPD

    Gout

    Isolated

    CPPD

    Gout

    Recurrent

    Inflammatory

    OA

    Traumatic

    Noninflammatory

    Monoarticular

    Monoarticular

    Lyme disease

    SBE

    Post viral arthritis

    Reactive Arthritis

    Acute/Subacute

    MCTD

    Psoriatic arthritis

    RA

    SLE

    Chronic

    Polyarticular

    Joint Pain

  • Osteoarthritis, cervical strain

    RTC, impingment

    Olecranon bursitis

    Epicondylitis

    CTS, dqt, OA

    Piriformis, MP

    Chondromalacia

    Ligament injury

    PF, MSF

    Metatarsalgia

    Ankle/Foot

    Knee

    Hip

    Hand

    Elbow

    Shoulder

    Neck

    Periarticular

    Lyme disease

    GC arthritis

    Septic Joint

    CPPD

    Gout

    Isolated

    CPPD

    Gout

    Recurrent

    Inflammatory

    OA

    Traumatic

    Noninflammatory

    Monoarticular

    Joint Pain

  • Lyme disease

    GC arthritis

    Septic Joint

    CPPD

    Gout

    Isolated

    CPPD

    Gout

    Recurrent

    Inflammatory

    OA

    Traumatic

    Noninflammatory

    Monoarticular

    Joint Pain

  • Lyme disease

    GC arthritis

    Septic Joint

    CPPD

    Gout

    Isolated

    CPPD

    Gout

    Recurrent

    Inflammatory

    Monoarticular

    Joint Pain

  • Gout CPPD

    Recurrent

    Inflammatory

    Monoarticular

    Joint Pain

    Preliminary

    Differential

    Diagnosis

  • Problem Synthesis Statement

    A summary of the main clinical problem and the associated pivotal points

    Can include history, physical, and sometimes lab pivotal points

    Courtesy of Adam Cifu, MD

    This is a 57 year old man on HCTZ for HTN who presents with an acute, recurrent, inflammatory, monoarticular arthritis

  • Not every encounter is the H&P

    C collect the information that you need during the phone call

    Prior vitals, trajectory, pivotal points

    A anticipate problems/supplies/needs en route to the patients room

    L Learn the situation

    Examine and interview the patient, review the chart , nursing, other data

    L lifelines?

    Who to call and how?