combustion dynamics in sequential combustorsyju/2nd-near-limit-flames-workshop/...vitiated air + ch...
TRANSCRIPT
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19 1
Combustion Dynamics in Sequential combustorsNear-Limit Flames Workshop – Beijing 2019Nicolas NoirayCAPS ETH: Oliver Schulz, Markus Weilenmann, Claire Bourquard, Yuan XiongPSI: Dominik Ebi, Ulrich Doll
Noiray Nicolas
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering
CAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 2
Sequential Combustion for operational and fuel flexibility
Ansaldo GT36 gas turbineSingle cycle: 538 MW – 42.8% eff.
Operational flexibility with ultra-low NOx
for compensating renewables intermittency
and ensuring grid stability
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering
CAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 3
GT36 sequential combustor
Pennell et al. „An introduction to the Ansaldo GT36 constant
pressure sequential combustor.“, ASME Turbo Expo (2017)
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 4
Combustion tomorrow: Burn Hydrogen in large gas turbines à storage, no more CO2
Bothien et al, GT2019-90798
Demonstration of transition from 100% NG to 100% H2 at engine condition with standard GT36 hardware
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 5
Sequential combustion research at ETH
1st stage
2nd stage
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 6
The experiment and the computational domain
2.12 m
1st stage
2nd stage
Perfectly premixed fuel + air
Swirler
Fuel
Outlet
Dilution air
VGs
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 7
Combustion Dynamics in Sequential Combustor
1. From spontaneous ignition to deflagration
2. Thermoacoustic instabilities in sequential combustors
3. Sequential flame stabilization using NRP discharges
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering
CAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 8
The combustion process in the sequential stage is complexCold dilution air Gas
Temperature at the inlet
of the sequential burner
decrease with increasing
dilution air.
8% decrease from 1278K to 1129K
Ebi et al.Proc. Comb. Inst. 2019
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 9
Sequential stage ignition at low and high dilution air mass flow
Time (s)
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 10
1D solutions, detailed chemistry (GRI 3.0) for 2 domain lengths
Mixing between CH4 and air-diluted vitiated flow (N2,CO2,H2O,O2)
Mixture fraction
Mixture Temperature 1450 K (atm. pressure)
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 11
Z=0.005Z=0.02
0 5 10 15Inlet velocity uin [m/s]
1D solutions, detailed chemistry (GRI 3.0) for 2 domain lengths
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
Transient combustion regimes (1-D flames) at elevated temperatures
Flame propagationFlame propagation
enhanced by autoignition Autoignition
lAI = u in ⌧AI<latexit sha1_base64="nndx8M0MkW4oEoCI2fAkqKs85pY=">AAACHnicbZDLSsNAFIYnXmu9RV26GSyCCymJKLoRqm50V8FeoAllMp22QyeTMHMilpAnceOruHGhiOBK38bpBbStPwx8/Occzpw/iAXX4Djf1tz8wuLScm4lv7q2vrFpb21XdZQoyio0EpGqB0QzwSWrAAfB6rFiJAwEqwW9q0G9ds+U5pG8g37M/JB0JG9zSsBYTftENFPv0AP2AOnFTZbhc5z8Olxm2YBJMtnVtAtO0RkKz4I7hgIaq9y0P71WRJOQSaCCaN1wnRj8lCjgVLAs7yWaxYT2SIc1DEoSMu2nw/MyvG+cFm5HyjwJeOj+nUhJqHU/DExnSKCrp2sD879aI4H2mW+OjBNgko4WtROBIcKDrHCLK0ZB9A0Qqrj5K6ZdoggFk2jehOBOnzwL1aOia/j2uFC6HMeRQ7toDx0gF52iErpGZVRBFD2iZ/SK3qwn68V6tz5GrXPWeGYHTcj6+gEgeqMc</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="nndx8M0MkW4oEoCI2fAkqKs85pY=">AAACHnicbZDLSsNAFIYnXmu9RV26GSyCCymJKLoRqm50V8FeoAllMp22QyeTMHMilpAnceOruHGhiOBK38bpBbStPwx8/Occzpw/iAXX4Djf1tz8wuLScm4lv7q2vrFpb21XdZQoyio0EpGqB0QzwSWrAAfB6rFiJAwEqwW9q0G9ds+U5pG8g37M/JB0JG9zSsBYTftENFPv0AP2AOnFTZbhc5z8Olxm2YBJMtnVtAtO0RkKz4I7hgIaq9y0P71WRJOQSaCCaN1wnRj8lCjgVLAs7yWaxYT2SIc1DEoSMu2nw/MyvG+cFm5HyjwJeOj+nUhJqHU/DExnSKCrp2sD879aI4H2mW+OjBNgko4WtROBIcKDrHCLK0ZB9A0Qqrj5K6ZdoggFk2jehOBOnzwL1aOia/j2uFC6HMeRQ7toDx0gF52iErpGZVRBFD2iZ/SK3qwn68V6tz5GrXPWeGYHTcj6+gEgeqMc</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="nndx8M0MkW4oEoCI2fAkqKs85pY=">AAACHnicbZDLSsNAFIYnXmu9RV26GSyCCymJKLoRqm50V8FeoAllMp22QyeTMHMilpAnceOruHGhiOBK38bpBbStPwx8/Occzpw/iAXX4Djf1tz8wuLScm4lv7q2vrFpb21XdZQoyio0EpGqB0QzwSWrAAfB6rFiJAwEqwW9q0G9ds+U5pG8g37M/JB0JG9zSsBYTftENFPv0AP2AOnFTZbhc5z8Olxm2YBJMtnVtAtO0RkKz4I7hgIaq9y0P71WRJOQSaCCaN1wnRj8lCjgVLAs7yWaxYT2SIc1DEoSMu2nw/MyvG+cFm5HyjwJeOj+nUhJqHU/DExnSKCrp2sD879aI4H2mW+OjBNgko4WtROBIcKDrHCLK0ZB9A0Qqrj5K6ZdoggFk2jehOBOnzwL1aOia/j2uFC6HMeRQ7toDx0gF52iErpGZVRBFD2iZ/SK3qwn68V6tz5GrXPWeGYHTcj6+gEgeqMc</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="nndx8M0MkW4oEoCI2fAkqKs85pY=">AAACHnicbZDLSsNAFIYnXmu9RV26GSyCCymJKLoRqm50V8FeoAllMp22QyeTMHMilpAnceOruHGhiOBK38bpBbStPwx8/Occzpw/iAXX4Djf1tz8wuLScm4lv7q2vrFpb21XdZQoyio0EpGqB0QzwSWrAAfB6rFiJAwEqwW9q0G9ds+U5pG8g37M/JB0JG9zSsBYTftENFPv0AP2AOnFTZbhc5z8Olxm2YBJMtnVtAtO0RkKz4I7hgIaq9y0P71WRJOQSaCCaN1wnRj8lCjgVLAs7yWaxYT2SIc1DEoSMu2nw/MyvG+cFm5HyjwJeOj+nUhJqHU/DExnSKCrp2sD879aI4H2mW+OjBNgko4WtROBIcKDrHCLK0ZB9A0Qqrj5K6ZdoggFk2jehOBOnzwL1aOia/j2uFC6HMeRQ7toDx0gF52iErpGZVRBFD2iZ/SK3qwn68V6tz5GrXPWeGYHTcj6+gEgeqMc</latexit>
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 13
Combustion regimes (1-D flames) at elevated temperatures 1000 K 1450 K
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 14
Application to a laboratory sequential combustor
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 15
Numerical methods• 16 and 65 millions mesh cells at 1 bar and 10 bar
• LES with AVBP
• Dynamic Thickened Flame (DTF) model
• Wall heat losses
• Analytically Reduced Chemistry (ARC) mechanism for CH4 combustion
(Gicquel et al. Comptes Rendus – Mec., 2011)
(Colin et al. Phys. Fluids 12, 2000)
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 16
Ignition of the sequential combustor (1 bar)
800 1450 2200
Pressure 1 barInlet Temperature 1450 K
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
Transient change of operating conditions
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 17
§ Inlet velocity = 60 m/s§ Simulated physical time = 60 ms§ Pressure 10 bar§ Inlet Temperature changed from1350 K to 1200 K
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering
CAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 18
Transient change of operating conditions§ Inlet velocity = 60 m/s§ Simulated physical time = 60 ms§ Pressure 10 bar§ Inlet Temperature changed from1350 K to 1200 K
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering
CAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 19
Transient change of operating conditions§ Inlet velocity = 60 m/s§ Simulated physical time = 60 ms§ Pressure 10 bar§ Inlet Temperature changed from1350 K to 1200 K
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 20
Transient change of operating conditions§ Inlet velocity = 60 m/s§ Simulated physical time = 60 ms§ Pressure 10 bar§ Inlet Temperature changed from1350 K to 1200 K
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 21
Combustion Dynamics in Sequential Combustor
1. From spontaneous ignition to deflagration
2. Thermoacoustic instabilities in sequential combustors
3. Sequential flame stabilization using NRP discharges
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering
CAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 22
Thermoacoustic instabilities are a major obstacle to cleaner combustion
Gas turbine
combustors
Boilers, Industrial
furnaces
Power generation
Liquid Rocket
Propellant
Solid Rocket
Propellant
Aerospace
Afterburners
Aeronautics
Aero-engine combustors
Resonant feedback loop
Chamber
acoustics
Reactive flow
dynamics
p0u0
Q̇0
Pulsations-induced damages
Frequency
Time
Dynamic pressure
Frequency
Time
Structural vibrations
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 23
Thermoacoustic Instabilities1st stage flame 2nd stage flame
Complexity of pathways of thermoacoustic instabilities
Susceptibility to thermoacoustic instabilities
Complexity of numerical modeling
Prieur et al. (EM2C laboratory), J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power 140, 2018
Bonciolini et al., Royal Soc. Open Sci., 2018
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering
CAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 24
The experiment and the computational domain
P1st = 40 kW
Φ1st = 0.8
Fuel 1st : CH4
P2nd = 24 kW
Φ2nd = 0.77
Fuel 2nd : CH4 + C3H8
290<latexit sha1_base64="bNi5Wv7eTJKOpdq1JJNoP0bI2XQ=">AAAB6nicbZBNS8NAEIYn9avWr6pHL4tF8FSSIqi3ohePFe0HtKFstpt26WYTdidCCf0JXjwo4tVf5M1/47bNQVtfWHh4Z4adeYNECoOu++0U1tY3NreK26Wd3b39g/LhUcvEqWa8yWIZ605ADZdC8SYKlLyTaE6jQPJ2ML6d1dtPXBsRq0ecJNyP6FCJUDCK1nqoXbv9csWtunORVfByqECuRr/81RvELI24QiapMV3PTdDPqEbBJJ+WeqnhCWVjOuRdi4pG3PjZfNUpObPOgISxtk8hmbu/JzIaGTOJAtsZURyZ5drM/K/WTTG88jOhkhS5YouPwlQSjMnsbjIQmjOUEwuUaWF3JWxENWVo0ynZELzlk1ehVat6lu8vKvWbPI4inMApnIMHl1CHO2hAExgM4Rle4c2Rzovz7nwsWgtOPnMMf+R8/gBlvY0z</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bNi5Wv7eTJKOpdq1JJNoP0bI2XQ=">AAAB6nicbZBNS8NAEIYn9avWr6pHL4tF8FSSIqi3ohePFe0HtKFstpt26WYTdidCCf0JXjwo4tVf5M1/47bNQVtfWHh4Z4adeYNECoOu++0U1tY3NreK26Wd3b39g/LhUcvEqWa8yWIZ605ADZdC8SYKlLyTaE6jQPJ2ML6d1dtPXBsRq0ecJNyP6FCJUDCK1nqoXbv9csWtunORVfByqECuRr/81RvELI24QiapMV3PTdDPqEbBJJ+WeqnhCWVjOuRdi4pG3PjZfNUpObPOgISxtk8hmbu/JzIaGTOJAtsZURyZ5drM/K/WTTG88jOhkhS5YouPwlQSjMnsbjIQmjOUEwuUaWF3JWxENWVo0ynZELzlk1ehVat6lu8vKvWbPI4inMApnIMHl1CHO2hAExgM4Rle4c2Rzovz7nwsWgtOPnMMf+R8/gBlvY0z</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bNi5Wv7eTJKOpdq1JJNoP0bI2XQ=">AAAB6nicbZBNS8NAEIYn9avWr6pHL4tF8FSSIqi3ohePFe0HtKFstpt26WYTdidCCf0JXjwo4tVf5M1/47bNQVtfWHh4Z4adeYNECoOu++0U1tY3NreK26Wd3b39g/LhUcvEqWa8yWIZ605ADZdC8SYKlLyTaE6jQPJ2ML6d1dtPXBsRq0ecJNyP6FCJUDCK1nqoXbv9csWtunORVfByqECuRr/81RvELI24QiapMV3PTdDPqEbBJJ+WeqnhCWVjOuRdi4pG3PjZfNUpObPOgISxtk8hmbu/JzIaGTOJAtsZURyZ5drM/K/WTTG88jOhkhS5YouPwlQSjMnsbjIQmjOUEwuUaWF3JWxENWVo0ynZELzlk1ehVat6lu8vKvWbPI4inMApnIMHl1CHO2hAExgM4Rle4c2Rzovz7nwsWgtOPnMMf+R8/gBlvY0z</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bNi5Wv7eTJKOpdq1JJNoP0bI2XQ=">AAAB6nicbZBNS8NAEIYn9avWr6pHL4tF8FSSIqi3ohePFe0HtKFstpt26WYTdidCCf0JXjwo4tVf5M1/47bNQVtfWHh4Z4adeYNECoOu++0U1tY3NreK26Wd3b39g/LhUcvEqWa8yWIZ605ADZdC8SYKlLyTaE6jQPJ2ML6d1dtPXBsRq0ecJNyP6FCJUDCK1nqoXbv9csWtunORVfByqECuRr/81RvELI24QiapMV3PTdDPqEbBJJ+WeqnhCWVjOuRdi4pG3PjZfNUpObPOgISxtk8hmbu/JzIaGTOJAtsZURyZ5drM/K/WTTG88jOhkhS5YouPwlQSjMnsbjIQmjOUEwuUaWF3JWxENWVo0ynZELzlk1ehVat6lu8vKvWbPI4inMApnIMHl1CHO2hAExgM4Rle4c2Rzovz7nwsWgtOPnMMf+R8/gBlvY0z</latexit>
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 25
The experiment and the computational domain
2.12 m
1st stage
2nd stage
Perfectly premixed fuel + air
Swirler
Fuel
Outlet
Dilution air
VGs
Ø 40 millions mesh cellsØ 860000 CPU hoursØ TTG4A
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
3-D LES
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 26
q̇ = 1⇥ 109 W/m3<latexit sha1_base64="/ZYWV+B3Y5XA6kmh2ciYAFvJ7H4=">AAACCnicdVDJSkMxFM2rU61T1aWbaBFc1by20nYhFN24rGAH6ERemraheYPJfWJ5dO3GX3HjQhG3foE7/8Z0EFT0QOBwzh1yjxNIoYGQDyu2sLi0vBJfTaytb2xuJbd3qtoPFeMV5ktf1R2quRQer4AAyeuB4tR1JK85w/OJX7vhSgvfu4JRwFsu7XuiJxgFI3WS+82uD9H1+NRugnC5tkm7iJvAbyHCtWN33M52kimSLk6BDclnstkJITlykilgO02mSKE5yp3ku5nJQpd7wCTVumGTAFoRVSCY5ONEM9Q8oGxI+7xhqEfN2lY0PWWMD43SxT1fmecBnqrfOyLqaj1yHVPpUhjo395E/MtrhNArtCLhBSFwj80W9UKJwceTXHBXKM5AjgyhTAnzV8wGVFEGJr2ECeHrUvw/qWbSNknbl7lU6WweRxztoQN0hGyURyV0gcqoghi6Qw/oCT1b99aj9WK9zkpj1rxnF/2A9fYJjWKaLA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/ZYWV+B3Y5XA6kmh2ciYAFvJ7H4=">AAACCnicdVDJSkMxFM2rU61T1aWbaBFc1by20nYhFN24rGAH6ERemraheYPJfWJ5dO3GX3HjQhG3foE7/8Z0EFT0QOBwzh1yjxNIoYGQDyu2sLi0vBJfTaytb2xuJbd3qtoPFeMV5ktf1R2quRQer4AAyeuB4tR1JK85w/OJX7vhSgvfu4JRwFsu7XuiJxgFI3WS+82uD9H1+NRugnC5tkm7iJvAbyHCtWN33M52kimSLk6BDclnstkJITlykilgO02mSKE5yp3ku5nJQpd7wCTVumGTAFoRVSCY5ONEM9Q8oGxI+7xhqEfN2lY0PWWMD43SxT1fmecBnqrfOyLqaj1yHVPpUhjo395E/MtrhNArtCLhBSFwj80W9UKJwceTXHBXKM5AjgyhTAnzV8wGVFEGJr2ECeHrUvw/qWbSNknbl7lU6WweRxztoQN0hGyURyV0gcqoghi6Qw/oCT1b99aj9WK9zkpj1rxnF/2A9fYJjWKaLA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/ZYWV+B3Y5XA6kmh2ciYAFvJ7H4=">AAACCnicdVDJSkMxFM2rU61T1aWbaBFc1by20nYhFN24rGAH6ERemraheYPJfWJ5dO3GX3HjQhG3foE7/8Z0EFT0QOBwzh1yjxNIoYGQDyu2sLi0vBJfTaytb2xuJbd3qtoPFeMV5ktf1R2quRQer4AAyeuB4tR1JK85w/OJX7vhSgvfu4JRwFsu7XuiJxgFI3WS+82uD9H1+NRugnC5tkm7iJvAbyHCtWN33M52kimSLk6BDclnstkJITlykilgO02mSKE5yp3ku5nJQpd7wCTVumGTAFoRVSCY5ONEM9Q8oGxI+7xhqEfN2lY0PWWMD43SxT1fmecBnqrfOyLqaj1yHVPpUhjo395E/MtrhNArtCLhBSFwj80W9UKJwceTXHBXKM5AjgyhTAnzV8wGVFEGJr2ECeHrUvw/qWbSNknbl7lU6WweRxztoQN0hGyURyV0gcqoghi6Qw/oCT1b99aj9WK9zkpj1rxnF/2A9fYJjWKaLA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/ZYWV+B3Y5XA6kmh2ciYAFvJ7H4=">AAACCnicdVDJSkMxFM2rU61T1aWbaBFc1by20nYhFN24rGAH6ERemraheYPJfWJ5dO3GX3HjQhG3foE7/8Z0EFT0QOBwzh1yjxNIoYGQDyu2sLi0vBJfTaytb2xuJbd3qtoPFeMV5ktf1R2quRQer4AAyeuB4tR1JK85w/OJX7vhSgvfu4JRwFsu7XuiJxgFI3WS+82uD9H1+NRugnC5tkm7iJvAbyHCtWN33M52kimSLk6BDclnstkJITlykilgO02mSKE5yp3ku5nJQpd7wCTVumGTAFoRVSCY5ONEM9Q8oGxI+7xhqEfN2lY0PWWMD43SxT1fmecBnqrfOyLqaj1yHVPpUhjo395E/MtrhNArtCLhBSFwj80W9UKJwceTXHBXKM5AjgyhTAnzV8wGVFEGJr2ECeHrUvw/qWbSNknbl7lU6WweRxztoQN0hGyURyV0gcqoghi6Qw/oCT1b99aj9WK9zkpj1rxnF/2A9fYJjWKaLA==</latexit>
q̇ = 4⇥ 108 W/m3<latexit sha1_base64="dXaaVO3FxfQblHO44N/sIbEVvDw=">AAACCnicdVDLSgMxFM34rPVVdekmWgRXNdNWWhdC0Y3LCvYBfZFJ0zY08zC5I5ahazf+ihsXirj1C9z5N2baCip6IHA45z5yjxNIoYGQD2tufmFxaTmxklxdW9/YTG1tV7UfKsYrzJe+qjtUcyk8XgEBktcDxanrSF5zhuexX7vhSgvfu4JRwFsu7XuiJxgFI3VSe82uD9H1+DTfBOFybZN2ETeB30KEa0fuuJ3rpNIkczIBNqSQzeViQvLkOFvEdoZMkEYzlDupdzOThS73gEmqdcMmAbQiqkAwycfJZqh5QNmQ9nnDUI+ata1ocsoYHxili3u+Ms8DPFG/d0TU1XrkOqbSpTDQv71Y/MtrhNArtiLhBSFwj00X9UKJwcdxLrgrFGcgR4ZQpoT5K2YDqigDk17ShPB1Kf6fVLMZm2Tsy3y6dDaLI4F20T46RDYqoBK6QGVUQQzdoQf0hJ6te+vRerFep6Vz1qxnB/2A9fYJkKSaLg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dXaaVO3FxfQblHO44N/sIbEVvDw=">AAACCnicdVDLSgMxFM34rPVVdekmWgRXNdNWWhdC0Y3LCvYBfZFJ0zY08zC5I5ahazf+ihsXirj1C9z5N2baCip6IHA45z5yjxNIoYGQD2tufmFxaTmxklxdW9/YTG1tV7UfKsYrzJe+qjtUcyk8XgEBktcDxanrSF5zhuexX7vhSgvfu4JRwFsu7XuiJxgFI3VSe82uD9H1+DTfBOFybZN2ETeB30KEa0fuuJ3rpNIkczIBNqSQzeViQvLkOFvEdoZMkEYzlDupdzOThS73gEmqdcMmAbQiqkAwycfJZqh5QNmQ9nnDUI+ata1ocsoYHxili3u+Ms8DPFG/d0TU1XrkOqbSpTDQv71Y/MtrhNArtiLhBSFwj00X9UKJwcdxLrgrFGcgR4ZQpoT5K2YDqigDk17ShPB1Kf6fVLMZm2Tsy3y6dDaLI4F20T46RDYqoBK6QGVUQQzdoQf0hJ6te+vRerFep6Vz1qxnB/2A9fYJkKSaLg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dXaaVO3FxfQblHO44N/sIbEVvDw=">AAACCnicdVDLSgMxFM34rPVVdekmWgRXNdNWWhdC0Y3LCvYBfZFJ0zY08zC5I5ahazf+ihsXirj1C9z5N2baCip6IHA45z5yjxNIoYGQD2tufmFxaTmxklxdW9/YTG1tV7UfKsYrzJe+qjtUcyk8XgEBktcDxanrSF5zhuexX7vhSgvfu4JRwFsu7XuiJxgFI3VSe82uD9H1+DTfBOFybZN2ETeB30KEa0fuuJ3rpNIkczIBNqSQzeViQvLkOFvEdoZMkEYzlDupdzOThS73gEmqdcMmAbQiqkAwycfJZqh5QNmQ9nnDUI+ata1ocsoYHxili3u+Ms8DPFG/d0TU1XrkOqbSpTDQv71Y/MtrhNArtiLhBSFwj00X9UKJwcdxLrgrFGcgR4ZQpoT5K2YDqigDk17ShPB1Kf6fVLMZm2Tsy3y6dDaLI4F20T46RDYqoBK6QGVUQQzdoQf0hJ6te+vRerFep6Vz1qxnB/2A9fYJkKSaLg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dXaaVO3FxfQblHO44N/sIbEVvDw=">AAACCnicdVDLSgMxFM34rPVVdekmWgRXNdNWWhdC0Y3LCvYBfZFJ0zY08zC5I5ahazf+ihsXirj1C9z5N2baCip6IHA45z5yjxNIoYGQD2tufmFxaTmxklxdW9/YTG1tV7UfKsYrzJe+qjtUcyk8XgEBktcDxanrSF5zhuexX7vhSgvfu4JRwFsu7XuiJxgFI3VSe82uD9H1+DTfBOFybZN2ETeB30KEa0fuuJ3rpNIkczIBNqSQzeViQvLkOFvEdoZMkEYzlDupdzOThS73gEmqdcMmAbQiqkAwycfJZqh5QNmQ9nnDUI+ata1ocsoYHxili3u+Ms8DPFG/d0TU1XrkOqbSpTDQv71Y/MtrhNArtiLhBSFwj00X9UKJwcdxLrgrFGcgR4ZQpoT5K2YDqigDk17ShPB1Kf6fVLMZm2Tsy3y6dDaLI4F20T46RDYqoBK6QGVUQQzdoQf0hJ6te+vRerFep6Vz1qxnB/2A9fYJkKSaLg==</latexit>
p0 [Pa]<latexit sha1_base64="E92AfPB2J6GNT2RcFBOgVeH+sqw=">AAAB+HicdVDLTgJBEJzFF+ID1KOXicToicwCBrwRvXjERB7JsiGzwwATZh+Z6TXihi/x4kFjvPop3vwbhwUTNVpJJ5Wq7nR3eZEUGgj5sDIrq2vrG9nN3Nb2zm6+sLff1mGsGG+xUIaq61HNpQh4CwRI3o0Up74necebXM79zi1XWoTBDUwj7vp0FIihYBSM1C/koxPcA34HCXaa1J31C0VSOk+BDamVK5U5IVVyVq5ju0RSFNESzX7hvTcIWezzAJikWjs2icBNqALBJJ/lerHmEWUTOuKOoQH1uXaT9PAZPjbKAA9DZSoAnKrfJxLqaz31PdPpUxjr395c/MtzYhjW3UQEUQw8YItFw1hiCPE8BTwQijOQU0MoU8LcitmYKsrAZJUzIXx9iv8n7XLJJiX7ulpsXCzjyKJDdIROkY1qqIGuUBO1EEMxekBP6Nm6tx6tF+t10ZqxljMH6Aest0+G6JME</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="E92AfPB2J6GNT2RcFBOgVeH+sqw=">AAAB+HicdVDLTgJBEJzFF+ID1KOXicToicwCBrwRvXjERB7JsiGzwwATZh+Z6TXihi/x4kFjvPop3vwbhwUTNVpJJ5Wq7nR3eZEUGgj5sDIrq2vrG9nN3Nb2zm6+sLff1mGsGG+xUIaq61HNpQh4CwRI3o0Up74necebXM79zi1XWoTBDUwj7vp0FIihYBSM1C/koxPcA34HCXaa1J31C0VSOk+BDamVK5U5IVVyVq5ju0RSFNESzX7hvTcIWezzAJikWjs2icBNqALBJJ/lerHmEWUTOuKOoQH1uXaT9PAZPjbKAA9DZSoAnKrfJxLqaz31PdPpUxjr395c/MtzYhjW3UQEUQw8YItFw1hiCPE8BTwQijOQU0MoU8LcitmYKsrAZJUzIXx9iv8n7XLJJiX7ulpsXCzjyKJDdIROkY1qqIGuUBO1EEMxekBP6Nm6tx6tF+t10ZqxljMH6Aest0+G6JME</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="E92AfPB2J6GNT2RcFBOgVeH+sqw=">AAAB+HicdVDLTgJBEJzFF+ID1KOXicToicwCBrwRvXjERB7JsiGzwwATZh+Z6TXihi/x4kFjvPop3vwbhwUTNVpJJ5Wq7nR3eZEUGgj5sDIrq2vrG9nN3Nb2zm6+sLff1mGsGG+xUIaq61HNpQh4CwRI3o0Up74necebXM79zi1XWoTBDUwj7vp0FIihYBSM1C/koxPcA34HCXaa1J31C0VSOk+BDamVK5U5IVVyVq5ju0RSFNESzX7hvTcIWezzAJikWjs2icBNqALBJJ/lerHmEWUTOuKOoQH1uXaT9PAZPjbKAA9DZSoAnKrfJxLqaz31PdPpUxjr395c/MtzYhjW3UQEUQw8YItFw1hiCPE8BTwQijOQU0MoU8LcitmYKsrAZJUzIXx9iv8n7XLJJiX7ulpsXCzjyKJDdIROkY1qqIGuUBO1EEMxekBP6Nm6tx6tF+t10ZqxljMH6Aest0+G6JME</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="E92AfPB2J6GNT2RcFBOgVeH+sqw=">AAAB+HicdVDLTgJBEJzFF+ID1KOXicToicwCBrwRvXjERB7JsiGzwwATZh+Z6TXihi/x4kFjvPop3vwbhwUTNVpJJ5Wq7nR3eZEUGgj5sDIrq2vrG9nN3Nb2zm6+sLff1mGsGG+xUIaq61HNpQh4CwRI3o0Up74necebXM79zi1XWoTBDUwj7vp0FIihYBSM1C/koxPcA34HCXaa1J31C0VSOk+BDamVK5U5IVVyVq5ju0RSFNESzX7hvTcIWezzAJikWjs2icBNqALBJJ/lerHmEWUTOuKOoQH1uXaT9PAZPjbKAA9DZSoAnKrfJxLqaz31PdPpUxjr395c/MtzYhjW3UQEUQw8YItFw1hiCPE8BTwQijOQU0MoU8LcitmYKsrAZJUzIXx9iv8n7XLJJiX7ulpsXCzjyKJDdIROkY1qqIGuUBO1EEMxekBP6Nm6tx6tF+t10ZqxljMH6Aest0+G6JME</latexit>
�6000<latexit sha1_base64="Uw5Qc+MC6udv+iASTP6gTegX0VY=">AAAB7HicdVBNS8NAEN3Ur1q/qh69LBbBi2HTVltvRS8eK5i20Iay2W7apZtN2N0IJfQ3ePGgiFd/kDf/jZu0goo+GHi8N8PMPD/mTGmEPqzCyura+kZxs7S1vbO7V94/6KgokYS6JOKR7PlYUc4EdTXTnPZiSXHoc9r1p9eZ372nUrFI3OlZTL0QjwULGMHaSO7ZBUJoWK4g+zIHNKRRrdUygurovNqEjo1yVMAS7WH5fTCKSBJSoQnHSvUdFGsvxVIzwum8NEgUjTGZ4jHtGypwSJWX5sfO4YlRRjCIpCmhYa5+n0hxqNQs9E1niPVE/fYy8S+vn+ig6aVMxImmgiwWBQmHOoLZ53DEJCWazwzBRDJzKyQTLDHRJp+SCeHrU/g/6VRtB9nObb3SulrGUQRH4BicAgc0QAvcgDZwAQEMPIAn8GwJ69F6sV4XrQVrOXMIfsB6+wTQ244J</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Uw5Qc+MC6udv+iASTP6gTegX0VY=">AAAB7HicdVBNS8NAEN3Ur1q/qh69LBbBi2HTVltvRS8eK5i20Iay2W7apZtN2N0IJfQ3ePGgiFd/kDf/jZu0goo+GHi8N8PMPD/mTGmEPqzCyura+kZxs7S1vbO7V94/6KgokYS6JOKR7PlYUc4EdTXTnPZiSXHoc9r1p9eZ372nUrFI3OlZTL0QjwULGMHaSO7ZBUJoWK4g+zIHNKRRrdUygurovNqEjo1yVMAS7WH5fTCKSBJSoQnHSvUdFGsvxVIzwum8NEgUjTGZ4jHtGypwSJWX5sfO4YlRRjCIpCmhYa5+n0hxqNQs9E1niPVE/fYy8S+vn+ig6aVMxImmgiwWBQmHOoLZ53DEJCWazwzBRDJzKyQTLDHRJp+SCeHrU/g/6VRtB9nObb3SulrGUQRH4BicAgc0QAvcgDZwAQEMPIAn8GwJ69F6sV4XrQVrOXMIfsB6+wTQ244J</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Uw5Qc+MC6udv+iASTP6gTegX0VY=">AAAB7HicdVBNS8NAEN3Ur1q/qh69LBbBi2HTVltvRS8eK5i20Iay2W7apZtN2N0IJfQ3ePGgiFd/kDf/jZu0goo+GHi8N8PMPD/mTGmEPqzCyura+kZxs7S1vbO7V94/6KgokYS6JOKR7PlYUc4EdTXTnPZiSXHoc9r1p9eZ372nUrFI3OlZTL0QjwULGMHaSO7ZBUJoWK4g+zIHNKRRrdUygurovNqEjo1yVMAS7WH5fTCKSBJSoQnHSvUdFGsvxVIzwum8NEgUjTGZ4jHtGypwSJWX5sfO4YlRRjCIpCmhYa5+n0hxqNQs9E1niPVE/fYy8S+vn+ig6aVMxImmgiwWBQmHOoLZ53DEJCWazwzBRDJzKyQTLDHRJp+SCeHrU/g/6VRtB9nObb3SulrGUQRH4BicAgc0QAvcgDZwAQEMPIAn8GwJ69F6sV4XrQVrOXMIfsB6+wTQ244J</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Uw5Qc+MC6udv+iASTP6gTegX0VY=">AAAB7HicdVBNS8NAEN3Ur1q/qh69LBbBi2HTVltvRS8eK5i20Iay2W7apZtN2N0IJfQ3ePGgiFd/kDf/jZu0goo+GHi8N8PMPD/mTGmEPqzCyura+kZxs7S1vbO7V94/6KgokYS6JOKR7PlYUc4EdTXTnPZiSXHoc9r1p9eZ372nUrFI3OlZTL0QjwULGMHaSO7ZBUJoWK4g+zIHNKRRrdUygurovNqEjo1yVMAS7WH5fTCKSBJSoQnHSvUdFGsvxVIzwum8NEgUjTGZ4jHtGypwSJWX5sfO4YlRRjCIpCmhYa5+n0hxqNQs9E1niPVE/fYy8S+vn+ig6aVMxImmgiwWBQmHOoLZ53DEJCWazwzBRDJzKyQTLDHRJp+SCeHrU/g/6VRtB9nObb3SulrGUQRH4BicAgc0QAvcgDZwAQEMPIAn8GwJ69F6sV4XrQVrOXMIfsB6+wTQ244J</latexit>
6000<latexit sha1_base64="UMR5jVWj1IwuB2Cg6gcEookXfvY=">AAAB63icdVDLSgMxFM34rPVVdekmWARXQ6attu6KblxWsA9oh5JJM21okhmSjFCG/oIbF4q49Yfc+TdmphVU9MCFwzn3cu89QcyZNgh9OCura+sbm4Wt4vbO7t5+6eCwo6NEEdomEY9UL8CaciZp2zDDaS9WFIuA024wvc787j1VmkXyzsxi6gs8lixkBJtMukAIDUtl5F7mgJbUK9VqRlANnVca0HNRjjJYojUsvQ9GEUkElYZwrHXfQ7HxU6wMI5zOi4NE0xiTKR7TvqUSC6r9NL91Dk+tMoJhpGxJA3P1+0SKhdYzEdhOgc1E//Yy8S+vn5iw4adMxomhkiwWhQmHJoLZ43DEFCWGzyzBRDF7KyQTrDAxNp6iDeHrU/g/6VRcD7neba3cvFrGUQDH4AScAQ/UQRPcgBZoAwIm4AE8gWdHOI/Oi/O6aF1xljNH4Aect09nCY3S</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="UMR5jVWj1IwuB2Cg6gcEookXfvY=">AAAB63icdVDLSgMxFM34rPVVdekmWARXQ6attu6KblxWsA9oh5JJM21okhmSjFCG/oIbF4q49Yfc+TdmphVU9MCFwzn3cu89QcyZNgh9OCura+sbm4Wt4vbO7t5+6eCwo6NEEdomEY9UL8CaciZp2zDDaS9WFIuA024wvc787j1VmkXyzsxi6gs8lixkBJtMukAIDUtl5F7mgJbUK9VqRlANnVca0HNRjjJYojUsvQ9GEUkElYZwrHXfQ7HxU6wMI5zOi4NE0xiTKR7TvqUSC6r9NL91Dk+tMoJhpGxJA3P1+0SKhdYzEdhOgc1E//Yy8S+vn5iw4adMxomhkiwWhQmHJoLZ43DEFCWGzyzBRDF7KyQTrDAxNp6iDeHrU/g/6VRcD7neba3cvFrGUQDH4AScAQ/UQRPcgBZoAwIm4AE8gWdHOI/Oi/O6aF1xljNH4Aect09nCY3S</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="UMR5jVWj1IwuB2Cg6gcEookXfvY=">AAAB63icdVDLSgMxFM34rPVVdekmWARXQ6attu6KblxWsA9oh5JJM21okhmSjFCG/oIbF4q49Yfc+TdmphVU9MCFwzn3cu89QcyZNgh9OCura+sbm4Wt4vbO7t5+6eCwo6NEEdomEY9UL8CaciZp2zDDaS9WFIuA024wvc787j1VmkXyzsxi6gs8lixkBJtMukAIDUtl5F7mgJbUK9VqRlANnVca0HNRjjJYojUsvQ9GEUkElYZwrHXfQ7HxU6wMI5zOi4NE0xiTKR7TvqUSC6r9NL91Dk+tMoJhpGxJA3P1+0SKhdYzEdhOgc1E//Yy8S+vn5iw4adMxomhkiwWhQmHJoLZ43DEFCWGzyzBRDF7KyQTrDAxNp6iDeHrU/g/6VRcD7neba3cvFrGUQDH4AScAQ/UQRPcgBZoAwIm4AE8gWdHOI/Oi/O6aF1xljNH4Aect09nCY3S</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="UMR5jVWj1IwuB2Cg6gcEookXfvY=">AAAB63icdVDLSgMxFM34rPVVdekmWARXQ6attu6KblxWsA9oh5JJM21okhmSjFCG/oIbF4q49Yfc+TdmphVU9MCFwzn3cu89QcyZNgh9OCura+sbm4Wt4vbO7t5+6eCwo6NEEdomEY9UL8CaciZp2zDDaS9WFIuA024wvc787j1VmkXyzsxi6gs8lixkBJtMukAIDUtl5F7mgJbUK9VqRlANnVca0HNRjjJYojUsvQ9GEUkElYZwrHXfQ7HxU6wMI5zOi4NE0xiTKR7TvqUSC6r9NL91Dk+tMoJhpGxJA3P1+0SKhdYzEdhOgc1E//Yy8S+vn5iw4adMxomhkiwWhQmHJoLZ43DEFCWGzyzBRDF7KyQTrDAxNp6iDeHrU/g/6VRcD7neba3cvFrGUQDH4AScAQ/UQRPcgBZoAwIm4AE8gWdHOI/Oi/O6aF1xljNH4Aect09nCY3S</latexit>
YO2 = 0.12<latexit sha1_base64="bAJ/pcBRUCbn8plqm3ZKexEXRIE=">AAACBXicdVC7SgNBFJ31GeMraqnFYBAsJOxuIkkKIWhjZwTzkCQss5NJMmT2wcxdMSzb2PgrNhaK2PoPdv6Nk4egogcu93DOvczc44aCKzDND2NufmFxaTm1kl5dW9/YzGxt11UQScpqNBCBbLpEMcF9VgMOgjVDyYjnCtZwh2djv3HDpOKBfwWjkHU80vd5j1MCWnIye9dO3D5qA7uF+CJxpsROkhMzZ9lOJqtb3s4Xy9jMla18uWSPSalsFo6xlTMnyKIZqk7mvd0NaOQxH6ggSrUsM4ROTCRwKliSbkeKhYQOSZ+1NPWJx1QnnlyR4AOtdHEvkLp8wBP1+0ZMPKVGnqsnPQID9dsbi395rQh6pU7M/TAC5tPpQ71IYAjwOBLc5ZJRECNNCJVc/xXTAZGEgg4urUP4uhT/T+p2ztJZXRayldNZHCm0i/bRIbJQEVXQOaqiGqLoDj2gJ/Rs3BuPxovxOh2dM2Y7O+gHjLdPPw2YZw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bAJ/pcBRUCbn8plqm3ZKexEXRIE=">AAACBXicdVC7SgNBFJ31GeMraqnFYBAsJOxuIkkKIWhjZwTzkCQss5NJMmT2wcxdMSzb2PgrNhaK2PoPdv6Nk4egogcu93DOvczc44aCKzDND2NufmFxaTm1kl5dW9/YzGxt11UQScpqNBCBbLpEMcF9VgMOgjVDyYjnCtZwh2djv3HDpOKBfwWjkHU80vd5j1MCWnIye9dO3D5qA7uF+CJxpsROkhMzZ9lOJqtb3s4Xy9jMla18uWSPSalsFo6xlTMnyKIZqk7mvd0NaOQxH6ggSrUsM4ROTCRwKliSbkeKhYQOSZ+1NPWJx1QnnlyR4AOtdHEvkLp8wBP1+0ZMPKVGnqsnPQID9dsbi395rQh6pU7M/TAC5tPpQ71IYAjwOBLc5ZJRECNNCJVc/xXTAZGEgg4urUP4uhT/T+p2ztJZXRayldNZHCm0i/bRIbJQEVXQOaqiGqLoDj2gJ/Rs3BuPxovxOh2dM2Y7O+gHjLdPPw2YZw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bAJ/pcBRUCbn8plqm3ZKexEXRIE=">AAACBXicdVC7SgNBFJ31GeMraqnFYBAsJOxuIkkKIWhjZwTzkCQss5NJMmT2wcxdMSzb2PgrNhaK2PoPdv6Nk4egogcu93DOvczc44aCKzDND2NufmFxaTm1kl5dW9/YzGxt11UQScpqNBCBbLpEMcF9VgMOgjVDyYjnCtZwh2djv3HDpOKBfwWjkHU80vd5j1MCWnIye9dO3D5qA7uF+CJxpsROkhMzZ9lOJqtb3s4Xy9jMla18uWSPSalsFo6xlTMnyKIZqk7mvd0NaOQxH6ggSrUsM4ROTCRwKliSbkeKhYQOSZ+1NPWJx1QnnlyR4AOtdHEvkLp8wBP1+0ZMPKVGnqsnPQID9dsbi395rQh6pU7M/TAC5tPpQ71IYAjwOBLc5ZJRECNNCJVc/xXTAZGEgg4urUP4uhT/T+p2ztJZXRayldNZHCm0i/bRIbJQEVXQOaqiGqLoDj2gJ/Rs3BuPxovxOh2dM2Y7O+gHjLdPPw2YZw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bAJ/pcBRUCbn8plqm3ZKexEXRIE=">AAACBXicdVC7SgNBFJ31GeMraqnFYBAsJOxuIkkKIWhjZwTzkCQss5NJMmT2wcxdMSzb2PgrNhaK2PoPdv6Nk4egogcu93DOvczc44aCKzDND2NufmFxaTm1kl5dW9/YzGxt11UQScpqNBCBbLpEMcF9VgMOgjVDyYjnCtZwh2djv3HDpOKBfwWjkHU80vd5j1MCWnIye9dO3D5qA7uF+CJxpsROkhMzZ9lOJqtb3s4Xy9jMla18uWSPSalsFo6xlTMnyKIZqk7mvd0NaOQxH6ggSrUsM4ROTCRwKliSbkeKhYQOSZ+1NPWJx1QnnlyR4AOtdHEvkLp8wBP1+0ZMPKVGnqsnPQID9dsbi395rQh6pU7M/TAC5tPpQ71IYAjwOBLc5ZJRECNNCJVc/xXTAZGEgg4urUP4uhT/T+p2ztJZXRayldNZHCm0i/bRIbJQEVXQOaqiGqLoDj2gJ/Rs3BuPxovxOh2dM2Y7O+gHjLdPPw2YZw==</latexit>
YCH4 = 0.06<latexit sha1_base64="o4vEoZx5LBOIbDwbrYC6CRPoM+k=">AAACBnicdVDLSgMxFM34rPU16lKEYBFcSJmppa0LodhNlxXsQ9oyZNK0Dc08SO6IZZiVG3/FjQtF3PoN7vwb04egogcunJxzL7n3uKHgCizrw1hYXFpeWU2tpdc3Nre2zZ3dhgoiSVmdBiKQLZcoJrjP6sBBsFYoGfFcwZruqDLxmzdMKh74VzAOWdcjA5/3OSWgJcc8uHbizkkH2C3ElWrizFg+Sc6trFVwzIyVPSsW7FIR6/cUE3Kas+0itudKBs1Rc8z3Ti+gkcd8oIIo1batELoxkcCpYEm6EykWEjoiA9bW1CceU914ekaCj7TSw/1A6vIBT9XvEzHxlBp7ru70CAzVb28i/uW1I+iXujH3wwiYT2cf9SOBIcCTTHCPS0ZBjDUhVHK9K6ZDIgkFnVxah/B1Kf6fNHJZ28ral/lM+WIeRwrto0N0jGxURGVURTVURxTdoQf0hJ6Ne+PReDFeZ60LxnxmD/2A8fYJlnmYig==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="o4vEoZx5LBOIbDwbrYC6CRPoM+k=">AAACBnicdVDLSgMxFM34rPU16lKEYBFcSJmppa0LodhNlxXsQ9oyZNK0Dc08SO6IZZiVG3/FjQtF3PoN7vwb04egogcunJxzL7n3uKHgCizrw1hYXFpeWU2tpdc3Nre2zZ3dhgoiSVmdBiKQLZcoJrjP6sBBsFYoGfFcwZruqDLxmzdMKh74VzAOWdcjA5/3OSWgJcc8uHbizkkH2C3ElWrizFg+Sc6trFVwzIyVPSsW7FIR6/cUE3Kas+0itudKBs1Rc8z3Ti+gkcd8oIIo1batELoxkcCpYEm6EykWEjoiA9bW1CceU914ekaCj7TSw/1A6vIBT9XvEzHxlBp7ru70CAzVb28i/uW1I+iXujH3wwiYT2cf9SOBIcCTTHCPS0ZBjDUhVHK9K6ZDIgkFnVxah/B1Kf6fNHJZ28ral/lM+WIeRwrto0N0jGxURGVURTVURxTdoQf0hJ6Ne+PReDFeZ60LxnxmD/2A8fYJlnmYig==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="o4vEoZx5LBOIbDwbrYC6CRPoM+k=">AAACBnicdVDLSgMxFM34rPU16lKEYBFcSJmppa0LodhNlxXsQ9oyZNK0Dc08SO6IZZiVG3/FjQtF3PoN7vwb04egogcunJxzL7n3uKHgCizrw1hYXFpeWU2tpdc3Nre2zZ3dhgoiSVmdBiKQLZcoJrjP6sBBsFYoGfFcwZruqDLxmzdMKh74VzAOWdcjA5/3OSWgJcc8uHbizkkH2C3ElWrizFg+Sc6trFVwzIyVPSsW7FIR6/cUE3Kas+0itudKBs1Rc8z3Ti+gkcd8oIIo1batELoxkcCpYEm6EykWEjoiA9bW1CceU914ekaCj7TSw/1A6vIBT9XvEzHxlBp7ru70CAzVb28i/uW1I+iXujH3wwiYT2cf9SOBIcCTTHCPS0ZBjDUhVHK9K6ZDIgkFnVxah/B1Kf6fNHJZ28ral/lM+WIeRwrto0N0jGxURGVURTVURxTdoQf0hJ6Ne+PReDFeZ60LxnxmD/2A8fYJlnmYig==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="o4vEoZx5LBOIbDwbrYC6CRPoM+k=">AAACBnicdVDLSgMxFM34rPU16lKEYBFcSJmppa0LodhNlxXsQ9oyZNK0Dc08SO6IZZiVG3/FjQtF3PoN7vwb04egogcunJxzL7n3uKHgCizrw1hYXFpeWU2tpdc3Nre2zZ3dhgoiSVmdBiKQLZcoJrjP6sBBsFYoGfFcwZruqDLxmzdMKh74VzAOWdcjA5/3OSWgJcc8uHbizkkH2C3ElWrizFg+Sc6trFVwzIyVPSsW7FIR6/cUE3Kas+0itudKBs1Rc8z3Ti+gkcd8oIIo1batELoxkcCpYEm6EykWEjoiA9bW1CceU914ekaCj7TSw/1A6vIBT9XvEzHxlBp7ru70CAzVb28i/uW1I+iXujH3wwiYT2cf9SOBIcCTTHCPS0ZBjDUhVHK9K6ZDIgkFnVxah/B1Kf6fNHJZ28ral/lM+WIeRwrto0N0jGxURGVURTVURxTdoQf0hJ6Ne+PReDFeZ60LxnxmD/2A8fYJlnmYig==</latexit>
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 27
Comparison between experiments and the LES - acoustics
Acoustic pressure sensor
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 28
Typi
cal s
elf-s
usta
ined
th
erm
o-ac
oust
ic c
ycle
(7 m
s)
OH Planar Laser Induced Fluorescence (PLIF)
OH fraction in central plane from the 3D LES
Sequential burner and chamber
Complex thermoacoustics in sequential combustors
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
2nd stage autoignition modeling
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 29
t/T period = 1, 2, 3, ...<latexit sha1_base64="a9o2/+YodiJtkaPDmoePqGVcuOg=">AAACC3icbVDJSgNBEO2JW4xb1KOXJkHwEMaZKOhFCHrxGCEbJCH0dCpJk56F7hoxDLl78Ve8eFDEqz/gzb+xsxw08UHB470qqup5kRQaHefbSq2srq1vpDczW9s7u3vZ/YOaDmPFocpDGaqGxzRIEUAVBUpoRAqY70moe8ObiV+/B6VFGFRwFEHbZ/1A9ARnaKRONoenlU7SKrQQHjCJQImwOx5fuQVaLNCzArVtu5PNO7YzBV0m7pzkyRzlTvar1Q157EOAXDKtm64TYTthCgWXMM60Yg0R40PWh6ahAfNBt5PpL2N6bJQu7YXKVIB0qv6eSJiv9cj3TKfPcKAXvYn4n9eMsXfZTkQQxQgBny3qxZJiSCfB0K5QwFGODGFcCXMr5QOmGEcTX8aE4C6+vExqRdt1bPfuPF+6nseRJkckR06ISy5IidySMqkSTh7JM3klb9aT9WK9Wx+z1pQ1nzkkf2B9/gBzWJiy</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="a9o2/+YodiJtkaPDmoePqGVcuOg=">AAACC3icbVDJSgNBEO2JW4xb1KOXJkHwEMaZKOhFCHrxGCEbJCH0dCpJk56F7hoxDLl78Ve8eFDEqz/gzb+xsxw08UHB470qqup5kRQaHefbSq2srq1vpDczW9s7u3vZ/YOaDmPFocpDGaqGxzRIEUAVBUpoRAqY70moe8ObiV+/B6VFGFRwFEHbZ/1A9ARnaKRONoenlU7SKrQQHjCJQImwOx5fuQVaLNCzArVtu5PNO7YzBV0m7pzkyRzlTvar1Q157EOAXDKtm64TYTthCgWXMM60Yg0R40PWh6ahAfNBt5PpL2N6bJQu7YXKVIB0qv6eSJiv9cj3TKfPcKAXvYn4n9eMsXfZTkQQxQgBny3qxZJiSCfB0K5QwFGODGFcCXMr5QOmGEcTX8aE4C6+vExqRdt1bPfuPF+6nseRJkckR06ISy5IidySMqkSTh7JM3klb9aT9WK9Wx+z1pQ1nzkkf2B9/gBzWJiy</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="a9o2/+YodiJtkaPDmoePqGVcuOg=">AAACC3icbVDJSgNBEO2JW4xb1KOXJkHwEMaZKOhFCHrxGCEbJCH0dCpJk56F7hoxDLl78Ve8eFDEqz/gzb+xsxw08UHB470qqup5kRQaHefbSq2srq1vpDczW9s7u3vZ/YOaDmPFocpDGaqGxzRIEUAVBUpoRAqY70moe8ObiV+/B6VFGFRwFEHbZ/1A9ARnaKRONoenlU7SKrQQHjCJQImwOx5fuQVaLNCzArVtu5PNO7YzBV0m7pzkyRzlTvar1Q157EOAXDKtm64TYTthCgWXMM60Yg0R40PWh6ahAfNBt5PpL2N6bJQu7YXKVIB0qv6eSJiv9cj3TKfPcKAXvYn4n9eMsXfZTkQQxQgBny3qxZJiSCfB0K5QwFGODGFcCXMr5QOmGEcTX8aE4C6+vExqRdt1bPfuPF+6nseRJkckR06ISy5IidySMqkSTh7JM3klb9aT9WK9Wx+z1pQ1nzkkf2B9/gBzWJiy</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="a9o2/+YodiJtkaPDmoePqGVcuOg=">AAACC3icbVDJSgNBEO2JW4xb1KOXJkHwEMaZKOhFCHrxGCEbJCH0dCpJk56F7hoxDLl78Ve8eFDEqz/gzb+xsxw08UHB470qqup5kRQaHefbSq2srq1vpDczW9s7u3vZ/YOaDmPFocpDGaqGxzRIEUAVBUpoRAqY70moe8ObiV+/B6VFGFRwFEHbZ/1A9ARnaKRONoenlU7SKrQQHjCJQImwOx5fuQVaLNCzArVtu5PNO7YzBV0m7pzkyRzlTvar1Q157EOAXDKtm64TYTthCgWXMM60Yg0R40PWh6ahAfNBt5PpL2N6bJQu7YXKVIB0qv6eSJiv9cj3TKfPcKAXvYn4n9eMsXfZTkQQxQgBny3qxZJiSCfB0K5QwFGODGFcCXMr5QOmGEcTX8aE4C6+vExqRdt1bPfuPF+6nseRJkckR06ISy5IidySMqkSTh7JM3klb9aT9WK9Wx+z1pQ1nzkkf2B9/gBzWJiy</latexit>
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 30
Combustion Dynamics in Sequential Combustor
1. From spontaneous ignition to deflagration
2. Thermoacoustic instabilities in sequential combustors
3. Sequential flame stabilization using NRP discharges
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 31
Flame stabilization using nanosecond repetitively pulsed
discharges
CH4-air
mixture
1st stage
flame
Dilution
air
2nd stage
CH4
Sequential
flame
1st stage power 30 kW
Equivalence Ratio: 0.64
Plasma
Electrode
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 32
Vitiated flow
CH4 jet
Vortex generators
Electrodes and plasma discharge
Side view sequential
burner
Vitiated flow
Quartz walls
Quartz wallsElectrodes
Plasma Discharge
40 m
m
Top view
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 33
Intensifier HSC 2
100 μs expo. OH filter
Top ViewNikon 2
5s exposure, CH filter
Nikon 1
1s exposure, no filter
HSC
1
100 μs expo, 8 kHz
About 10 ns pulses of 8 kV, Pulses repetition rate 50 kHz
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 34
Plasma-enhanced autoignition
No flame without NRPD
Electrodes and NRPD
Flame with NRPD
Vitiated Air + CH41300 K and 70 m/s
High Speed imaging after NRPD start
1.6 ms
2.1 ms
2.6 ms
40mm
CH* Intensity
(1 sec. exposure no filter)
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering
CAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Noiray Nicolas 35
Plasma-enhanced autoignition
No flame without NRPD
Electrodes
and NRPD
Flame with NRPD
Vitiated Air + CH41300 K and 70 m/s
High Speed imaging after NRPD start
1.6 ms
2.1 ms
2.6 ms
40mm
CH* Intensity
(1 sec. exposure no filter)
Camera settings: 0.1 millisec. exposure 8 kHz
Flame Thermal Power:
45 000 WElectric Power for Plasma:
115 W (0.25%)20 μs
(50 kHz)
10 ns
8 kV
Xiong,… , Noiray Proc. Comb. Inst. 2019
||D MAVT Department of Mechanical and Process EngineeringCAPS Combustion and Acoustics for Power & Propulsion Systems
8/14/19Oliver Schulz 36
Summary§ Autoignition and flame propagation can both
govern the combustion regime in sequential combustors at relevant conditions
§ Understanding, modeling and simulating transitions between these regimes is very challenging but it is key for design of new sequential combustors
§ Thermoacoustic instabilities in these combustors involve complex pathways where flames talk to each other via acoustic, but also compositional and entropy waves
§ NRP discharges have significant impact on autoignition in sequential combustors, significant research effort is necessary to understand and model it
Exp.LES
Ebi et al., PROCI 2019
Schulz and Noiray, CNF 2019
Schulz et al., PROCI 2019
Xiong et al., PROCI 2019