commissioning the hudson-bergen light rail the …...commissioning the hudson-bergen light rail the...

26
* Vice President Operations, Hudson-Bergen Light Rail ** President, Rail Technology Inc. *** General Manager, Rail Operations, Hudson-Bergen Light Rail July 5, 2001 COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the Annual Meeting of the American Railway Engineering and Maintenance Association (AREMA) Chicago, IL September, 2001 1. INTRODUCTION The Hudson-Bergen Light Rail (HBLR) is a twenty-one mile, multiple branch light railway currently being deployed in New Jersey’s Hudson River Waterfront communities under a Design, Build, Operate and Maintain (DBOM) contract. New Jersey Transit is the owner with Washington Group and Kinkisharyo forming Twenty First Century Rail Corporation (TFCRC) as the DBOM contractor. Revenue service was initiated on April 15, 2000 over approximately six route miles, 41 months after provision of Notice to Proceed on the DBOM contract. Currently eight route miles are in service with seven miles presently in construction. Due to the success of the initial DBOM, planning is already in progress for extensions beyond the original 21-mile system. Figure 1 illustrates the current 21-mile system. Daily ridership is currently at just under 10,000. This paper describes the process used to transition from construction to revenue service (commissioning) for the initial segment.

Upload: others

Post on 05-Mar-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

* Vice President Operations, Hudson-Bergen Light Rail ** President, Rail Technology Inc. *** General Manager, Rail Operations, Hudson-Bergen Light Rail

July 5, 2001

COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL

THE “RAINBOW PLAN”

by

A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the Annual Meeting of the American Railway Engineering and Maintenance

Association (AREMA) Chicago, IL

September, 2001

1. INTRODUCTION

The Hudson-Bergen Light Rail (HBLR) is a twenty-one mile, multiple branch light

railway currently being deployed in New Jersey’s Hudson River Waterfront communities

under a Design, Build, Operate and Maintain (DBOM) contract. New Jersey Transit is

the owner with Washington Group and Kinkisharyo forming Twenty First Century Rail

Corporation (TFCRC) as the DBOM contractor. Revenue service was initiated on April

15, 2000 over approximately six route miles, 41 months after provision of Notice to

Proceed on the DBOM contract. Currently eight route miles are in service with seven

miles presently in construction. Due to the success of the initial DBOM, planning is

already in progress for extensions beyond the original 21-mile system. Figure 1

illustrates the current 21-mile system. Daily ridership is currently at just under 10,000.

This paper describes the process used to transition from construction to revenue service

(commissioning) for the initial segment.

Page 2: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

The commissioning process is often the most challenging aspect associated with the

deployment of a new passenger railway. On Hudson-Bergen these challenges were

compounded by:

• The accelerated schedule and concurrency of activities associated with a Design-

Build process.

• Creation of a totally new operating entity, including such factors as formulation of an

entirely new set of operating procedures, and protocols, and training and qualification

of new employees.

For HBLR a carefully coordinated Commissioning Plan was followed. This plan was

based on a step-wise approach to achieving the functionality required at any given time in

the commissioning process, rather than being based in purely geographic stages of

completion. This plan was referred to as the “Rainbow Plan”. An important aspect of

this Plan was its close relationship to final System Safety certification, as well as the to

the issuance of “safety authorizations” which were provided for use of each of the interim

configurations. Each interim configuration was assigned a color and represented a phase.

Prior to initiating each phase of the Rainbow Plan, the required level of physical

completion and the operating functions of each system and subsystem as well as

associated levels of training, rules and procedures were defined. Satisfactory completion

of “Authorized Lists” led to issuance of Temporary Use Notices (TUNs) for each system

and facility. These were based on achieving an acceptable combination of functionality

in an engineered system, special procedures which were necessary to mitigate “lost

functionality”, and training in place for each level of predefined use for each Rainbow

Page 3: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

Plan phase. The TUNs authorized incremental testing and defined the elements to be

used and the restrictions to be placed on their use due to reduced functionality.

The Commissioning process described herein is comprehensive in nature and, in addition

to Safety Certification, includes:

• Testing at the system and sub-system level

• Integration Testing, i.e., testing which occurs between “systems” or between sub-

contracts.

• Training and Qualification of Employees

• Operational Validation. This validates that the engineered systems in concert with

the newly established rules and procedures and along with employee training and

qualification will achieve the operating requirements. This is a contractual

requirement wherein TFCR was required to demonstrate to the owner (New Jersey

Transit), all routine and special operations for a pre-determined period of time.

• Operational Demonstration

This paper describes the HBLR start-up with emphasis on how the process consistently

satisfied the requirements of the System Safety Plan. The process described in this paper

required approximately 15 months from formal beginning of system-wide commissioning

efforts to the achievement revenue ready status.

Page 4: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

2. CRITICAL FACTORS

A number of issues were identified by the HBLR management team during the early

planning of the commissioning process. These issues primarily stemmed from the “fast-

track” nature of this deployment and the fact that HBLR is an entirely new system

utilizing a technology (light rail) that has not been operated in the New Jersey/New York

area (with the singular and somewhat special exception of the Newark City Subway) for

50 years. The latter, for example, influenced the level of preparation required in the

community for in-street operation.

The most significant issues to be addressed in formulating the commissioning plan were:

• The significant amount of “concurrent engineering” which was occurring as

part of the Design/Build process. This was a necessary consequence of the

ambitious deployment schedule. Shortening (“crashing”) durations while

retaining a “sequential”, conventional deployment process would not have

achieved the schedule goals.

• The short time available between completion of the construction or

installation of each system and the mandated “revenue ready” date. This

reduced the durations available for integrated testing and also limited the

time for which that particular system or element would be available to the

operations management team for training and qualification of new

employees.

Page 5: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

• The contractual requirement for self-certification of a new operating transit

system by a private operator; this was a first!

• The relative inexperience of the workforce of the new operating group,

particularly in the transportation department. Almost all train operators were

new to the railway industry, and a large number of line supervisors were also

new to railway operations.

TFCR’s leadership team, in cooperation with New Jersey Transit, began detailed

planning for Commissioning, with initial focus on “engineering start-up” a full two years

prior to the contractually mandated revenue ready date. As trivial as it may sound, first

order of business was to standardize terminology, i.e., what is meant by “Start-up”,

“Activation”, “System Testing”, “Integrated Testing” and so on. This was a real issue

since managers and lead discipline engineers with different technical backgrounds

(transportation, construction, and design) used the terms differently. Appendix “A”

summarizes the defined usage of the important terms.

In order to address these issues the Commissioning process for the initial operating

segment would require the following attributes:

• Stepwise Functionality. The process would achieve incremental

commissioning of elements (systems, sub-systems, areas) as they became

available according to a carefully defined progression. Each step in the

process would be based on the minimal level of completion that was required

to achieve the functionality defined for that particular phase.

Page 6: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

• Discipline. Due to the relative inexperience of some of the field forces,

particularly as previously noted in the Transportation Department, the

process was somewhat dogmatic. A set of Special Start-up and Test

Procedures (STP’s) was written expressly for Commissioning. These

procedures addressed all aspects of commissioning, from performing

engineering tests to establishment and operation of a temporary office until

the control center was placed in service. Included in these STP’s were

carefully defined protocols, defined below, for transfer of “ownership” from

the Construction group to the Start-Up unit to Rail Operations.

• Ownership Authority. This needed to be clearly defined between TFCR

organizational units. As part of the commissioning “dogma” a specific trail

of “ownership” of fixed plant equipment and systems was as defined and

illustrated in Figure 2. Under this protocol ownership was jealously guarded

to the point where even padlocks on equipment cases were changed upon

“turnover” or “release” to a “following” group. Provisions were necessarily

made for entry or work by one group into areas or systems owned by another.

This, for example, occurred when construction forces entered a system

“owned” by start-up in order to complete punchlist items. When this

occurred Construction personnel were required to comply with STP’s. An

important aspect of “ownership” pertained to electrified energy (traction

power, building, shops), and of authority for train movement.

• Flexible . While flexibility seems at odds with a “dogmatic” approach, the

leadership of the Commissioning team constantly reevaluated status and

forecast of schedule progress in order to accele rate required work or establish

Page 7: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

commissioning “work-arounds”. In fact, each of the letter descriptions

appended to the color phases represents such a work-around. The key to

maintaining flexibility in a dogmatic process, was the understanding and

“protection” of the “stepwise” progression of functionality.

• Safe. Clearly the most important attribute, this focused strongly on “interim”

conditions or use of partially “disabled”/completed engineering systems.

Thus a special aspect of the system safety process evaluated and “authorized”

(using TUN’s) operation over interim configuration.

3. ORGANIZATION

A “Start-up” unit was organized. This unit was separate and distinct from Construction

Division as well as from Rail Operations and reported directly to Program Management

at the same level as each of these other units. The Start-Up unit was comprised of a mix

of personnel with extensive, fixed plant railway (maintenance of way) experience. Rail

experts with experience (primarily in traction power, signals, track and rolling stock)

were complemented with personnel with experience in power plants and the defense

industry (for fiberoptics, SCADA, shops, traffic system, stations). In particular,

personnel with power plant experience were well versed in concepts pertaining to

achieving partial functionality in an engineered system or sub-system while protecting

the safety aspects of the “missing” functions through procedures or “limited usage”

protocols.

Page 8: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

4. THE RAINBOW PLAN

As previously noted the fundamental basis for establishing the level of completion, by

type of system or sub-system as well as by geographic extent was the minimal

functionality required to achieve the objectives of that particular phase. This was, in turn,

based on a rigorous “backwards” pass along the Program’s Design/Build and

Commissioning schedules. This approach was required because the original optimized

project logic was at 3 to 4 months’ negative float with 18 months remaining prior to the

targeted revenue ready date, with a likelihood of further slip due to unknowns in the areas

of “safety certification” and “staffing and qualifying” train operators. Thus, a PERT

analysis would have shown an even more critical situation. Under the Rainbow Plan a

revised commissioning (as defined including Start-up, Activation, etc.) CPM was

developed showing absolute essentials. This schedule was formulated, backwards from

the revenue ready date, with zero float. As one would expect, this schedule clearly

indicated the critical nature of the test and acceptance of the Light Rail Vehicle (LRV) to

the entire commissioning process. This was because the LRV was required for selected

integrated tests (e.g., safe braking, dynamic clearances, ride quality, EMI, and

pantograph/trolley wire) and to supervisor and operator training, all of which were

prerequisite to validating the Hudson-Bergen Operating Plan.

Appendix “C” provides a tabular description of each of the Rainbow Plan Phases,

including a “purpose” for each phase. The next step in this “backwards” process was to

determine minimal levels of completion of the HBLR fixed plant for each of these

commissioning phases. Clearly validating the HBLR Operating Plan required all of the

fixed plant to be operable, but earlier “phases” could be accomplished with less. This

process of differentiating between what was absolutely essential from the “good to have”

Page 9: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

caused the commissioning process to be somewhat less than optimal from an economic

viewpoint, but was required in order to maintain total program schedule. Most

importantly, adherence to the schedule for revenue service achieved total economic

optimization. In the limit, it was determined that the first major tasks, the integration of

the sub-systems aboard the LRV (braking, traction power, controls) and the “proof of

design” testing of the LRV could be achieved with approximately one mile of single

track, and that an old fashioned “baton” could be utilized as a means of train control. The

initial commissioning phase, termed the “red” phase after the color used to denote the

limits of energized catenary and live track on the “war room” drawings, was

accomplished under a railway plant configured as illustrated in Figure 4 and described in

the associated Table. During this phase ownership of Red (and its associated “fouling

envelope”) was assigned to the Start-up Unit. Construction forces were not permitted to

work in Red territory without formal authorization and when they entered were required

to comply with the Start-up unit’s STP’s. A temporary movement office was established

in a sub-station and a baton (as called for by STP’s) provided authority for train

movement. Since Start-up “owned” Red, all involved transportation personnel worked

under the tactical direction of the daily Test Manager. Since interlockings were not yet

“in-service”, the STP’s required that each turnout be locked and wedged prior to any train

movement. Further, since the route between the Red section trackage and the car house

remained an active construction site, and remained under Construction’s jurisdiction, the

Test Manager was required to coordinate yard moves with Construction’s site manager.

The Red “A” phase consisted of approximately 1½ miles of track No. 1 on the Bayonne

Branch.

While Red phasing LRV tests occurred on this track, Construction required to initiate

vehicle acceptance testing was expedited. This was designated as the Green Phase. A

Page 10: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

minimum of 12 (of the total of 29) LRV’s were required to support supervisor and

operator training and integrated testing. At an estimated one week per LRV it was

essential that capability be provided to test two cars independently, hence two tracks were

required. Arrival of the production LRV’s coincided with completion of all LRV

acceptance tests with the exception of the “safebraking” function initiated under the

Automatic Train Control (ATC) system. Since the ATP sub-system was not operable,

these tests were deferred until the train control system was fully functional. Although

this could be considered as “doubling” the hill, it was necessary to maintain the

commissioning schedule.

The initial Rainbow Plan called for cut-in of the train control system in time for Green

Phase; since this did not occur, Green “A” was designated for operation of two tracks

using special batons (a “track 1” baton and a “track 2” baton) and the Green territory

remained under Start-Up’s control. Consequently, work progressed in accordance with

STP’s. Shortly after the initiation of Green “A” the wayside functions of the train control

system were placed in service. Unfortunately, unresolved issues caused temporary

disablement of the cab signal/ATC sub-systems. Likewise, the OCC was not yet

completed. It was now only eight months to revenue ready status and the Leadership

Team determined that it was essential that the Rail Operations Department take charge

and that, in particular, the Senior Transportation Managers begin to apply the permanent

Operating Rules & Procedures. This was considered to be an essential part of the

“activation” process. Accordingly, at the commencement of the Green “B” control of

“Green Territory” was assigned to Rail Operations, and the LRV Test Manager now

worked under the cognizance of TFCRC’s General Manager and, more importantly, tests

in Green “B” were conducted under the authority of the Operating Rules & Standard

Operating Procedures (SOP’s); the STP’s no longer applied to Green Territory. The new

Page 11: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

HBLR Operating Rules were modified to reflect the lack of cab signals and OCC and put

into effect as the “Green Rules”. A discussion of the basis for such modification and

issuance of a Temporary Use Notice (TUN) by the System Safety Committee is included

in the following section. The splitting of the Green Phase into “A” and “B” portions and

the formal issuance of the “Green Rules” provide a good example of the apparent

oxymoron of a “flexible, dogmatic” approach.

The basic logic shown in Figure 2 is illustrative; its implementation required concurrent

progression of activities wherever possible. Consequently, as Green Phase activities

progressed on the Bayonne Brach, the West Side Branch and portions of the mainline

were moved into the “Orange “A” phase “System Level and Preliminary Integrated

Testing”. This territory was “turned over” by the Construction Manager to the Start-up

Manager, and subsequently all activities, including train movements (within Orange)

were conducted under the STP’s. Immediately following integrated testing the West Side

branch along with those cars which had completed commissioning were designated as

“Blue” and released to “Rail Operations” for use in operator training. Thus, at

approximately six months prior to revenue ready date the status of HBLR was depicted in

Figure 5. Likewise, subsequent phases continued to occur concurrently until the entire

Initial Operating Segment was released to the General Manager.

The stepwise commissioning of HBLR according to the Rainbow Plan is summarized in

Appendix “C”. Two processes which are strongly related to success of the HBLR’s

initial commissioning are Systems Integration and Systems Safety. Each of these need to

be initiated at the very beginning of a program in order to maximize their benefits.

Page 12: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

5. SYSTEM INTEGRATION AND SYSTEMS SAFETY

Systems Integration is a program wide process which initially assures that the design of

individual system is such that the Railway’s (or any product’s) operational requirements

will ultimately be achieved by the completed systems acting individually and in

combination. A fundamental aspect of SI is the early formulation of interface control

requirements and criteria, and their formal delineation by Interface Control Documents

(ICD’s). Properly optimized design is a deductive process, that is, it is top down where

design in each discipline must conform to “System Level” design requirements, and

where the ICD’s are the means of assuring such conformance. The list of systems and

sub-systems utilized in the HBLR program are listed in Appendix “B”. This

classification is recommended as an industry-wide protocol. The approach to Systems

Integration used on Hudson-Bergen Light Rail was previously presented at the 1999

AREMA Signals and Communication Conference in Baltimore.

Commissioning and pre-commissioning testing, conversely, is inductive, and works up

the hierarchy of each system as illustrated in Figure 6. Integrated Testing, which is near

the top of the hierarchy, is based on the ICD’s. If an active SI process has been

implemented throughout the deployment cycle (as it should be!), the integrated testing

essentially becomes a validation of the original integration criteria and proves that these

criteria have been satisfied by the design, manufacture and construction. The keystone of

the Integrated Test Plan is therefore the ICD’s.

Under the Rainbow Plan certain systems were placed in service at partial functionality,

i.e., with certain sub-systems not in service. A good example is train control during the

Green Phase, where EMI issues precluded use of the cab-signal system. The concept of

Page 13: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

utilization of a system which is partially disabled is a common practice used explicitly

(i.e., well known, well documented, and well controlled) in such industries as power

generation and defense, as well as railroading. It is based on a full understanding of the

design functionality of each sub-system, and on the integration requirements of each

system. The concept of “graceful degradation” (while protecting safety) is critical to use

of partial systems. In the case of the Green Phase, the train control system was placed in

service with the function of “train separation” performed as if all trains had experienced

an “on-board” cab signal failure. Trains were moved using “clear block” (green) aspects

on the wayside signals, which could only be displaced if the entire block to the next

interlocking was unoccupied, rather than “proceed cab” (Lunar). This method provided

normal train routing and broken rail protection, and limited following trains to an

approximately six minute headway, rather than the design headway of two minutes. As a

consequence, later action then involved subsequent retest of the interface between on-

board cab signal equipment and the vehicle traction power and braking equipment.

For each phase of the Rainbow Plan the System Safety Process evaluated:

• The intended operation, i.e., the operation which was required to achieve the stated

goal of each phase, including associated test plans.

• The level of system/sub-system completion and the safety of implications of any

missing functionalities.

• Mitigation methods which were proposed for that phase, to accommodate

degradation of systems functionality.

Page 14: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

• Documentation and training of all personnel involved on temporary operating

protocols (STP’s, “Green” Operating Rules, etc.). This includes safety critical

inspections and tests.

Upon review and findings that all items were compliant, the System Safety Committee

issued a Temporary Use Notice (TUN). This indicates that the operations, as stated for

that phase in association with the mitigation measures, is safe. The TUN process is

maintained as separate and distinct from the Safety Certification process. The latter is

directed strictly to certification for revenue operation.

6. CONCLUSIONS

(a) Just as in revenue operation, safety is the highest priority during the

commissioning process. The safety of interim conditions, and temporary

operations requires careful engineering and operation review through a formal

process. On HBLR this was the “Authorization” process, as differentiated from

the “Certification” process. Safety “Certification” is reserved for final readiness

for revenue service.

(b) The Commissioning Process should be highly disciplined and well documented.

A reasoned, dogmatic approach is beneficial, particularly to a new start property.

(c) Concurrent engineering and performance of concurrent construction and testing

activities was essential to the fast track deployment of the initial operating

section of HBLR. This was most “efficient” in bringing the “product” to the

marketplace, but did not necessarily provide the “cheapest” commissioning cost.

Page 15: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

(d) A robust System Integration process is absolutely essential to an efficient and

safe commissioning process. The most apparent reason is that it provides ICD’s,

which are, in turn, the basis for integrated testing. A more subtle and perhaps

even more significant reason is that SI is critical to evaluating safety and

formulating protocols for test operations which will occur under “degraded”

conditions. SI also is critical to final safety certification.

(e) Planning for Commissioning should start early; on HBLR the Start-Up

organization was mobilized two years prior to the “revenue ready” date.

Page 16: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The support and cooperation of New Jersey Transit’s executive and technical staff was

instrumental in the success of the HBLR. In particular, Jeff Warsh, Executive Director, Dan

Censullo, Assistant Executive Director, and Rich Falcon, Director of Systems Engineering

provided outstanding leadership during Start-up and Activation. Bob Sedlock of the NJ DOT

(System Safety Oversight) offered outstanding insights into the safety of interim conditions.

Page 17: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1 HBLR System Map Figure 2 Ownership Flow Figure 3 Basic Backwards Logic Figure 4 Red “A” Phase Schematic Figure 5 Green/Blue/Orange Schematic Figure 6 Integration Hierarchy Appendix A Definitions Appendix B List of Systems & Sub-Systems Appendix C Table of Rainbow Plan Phases

Page 18: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the
Page 19: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

hb5_0739p

Figure 2

CONSTRUCTION

Complete sub-system construction and inspection.Complete testing belowsub-system level

Documentation & punchlist clearly delineated

joint reviewwith start-up

Failure

If pass, turnover to start-up

“Energy Applied”

Sub-System Testing STP’s ApplySystem TestingIntegrated Testing

with documentation & punchlist substantially completed

Joint review with Rail Operations passes

Rail Operations Owns ; Rules and SOP’s Apply

Page 20: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

Hb5-0739

Figure 3

Dynamic Integration of LRV Subsystems

2 PrototypeLRV’s,QualificationTesting

Initial Fleetof LRV’s, AcceptanceTesting

SupervisionTrainingSelectedIntegratedTesting

OperatorTraining

Validationof HBLROperatingPlan

Full Demo Revenue Ready

Page 21: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

Hb5-0739

Figure 4Status of HBLR, Red “A” Phase

SYSTEM LEVEL OF COMPLETION

Track 1 ½ miles: Turnout locked & blocked for all train movements

Traction Power 1 ½ miles of OCS & 1 Sub-station

Integrated Control System Not available, use of radio, temporary movement office, and train sheets

Train Control Not available, use of baton

Shop Minimal repairs only

Yard Under construction, start-up moves through the yard under authority ofConstruction group

• “Red A” Phase1.5 Single Track• Start-up Control

All Systems Except Red underControl of Construction Division

“Y-South”Interlock Shops

“Y-North”Interlock

Page 22: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

676+00676+00

CROSSINGTEMP. GRADE

L 311+00

34TH STREET STATION

L 310+00

L 309+00

L 308+00

L 307+00

L 306+00

R 311+00

R 310+00

R 309+00

R 308+00

R 307+00

R 306+00

L 355+00

R 355+00

L 333+00

L 319+00

L 318+00

L 317+00

L 316+00

L 315+00

L 313+00

L 312+00

R 318+00

R 317+00

R 316+00

R 315+00

R 313+00

R 312+00

L 322+00

L 321+00

L 320+00

R 322+00

R 321+00

R 320+00

R 319+00

L 331+00

L 330+00

L 329+00

L 328+00

L 327+00

L 326+00

L 325+00

R 333+00

R 331+00

R 330+00

R 329+00

R 328+00

R 327+00

R 326+00

L 324+00 R 325+00

R 324+00

L 344+00

R 344+00

45TH STREET STATION

L 340+00

L 339+00

L 338+00

L 337+00

L 336+00

L 335+00

L 334+00

R 339+00

R 338+00

R 337+00

R 336+00

R 335+00

R 334+00

L 343+00

L 342+00

R 343+00

R 342+00

R 340+00

CR1 350+00

CR3 1+00

CR1 355+00

CR1 354+00

CR1 353+00

CR1 352+00

CR1 351+00

CR1 349+00

CR1 348+00

CR1 347+00

R 352+00

L 354+00

L 353+00

L 352+00L 351+00

L 349+00

L 348+00

L 347+00

R 354+00

R 353+00

R 351+00

R 349+00

R 348+00

R 347+00

L 346+00

L 345+00 R 346+00

R 345+00

CR1 358+00

CR1 357+00

CR2 1+00

CR1 356+00

L 360+00

L 358+00

L 357+00

L 356+00

R 360+00

R 358+00

R 357+00

R 356+00

L 378+00

CR1 366+00

L 366+00

R 366+00

CR1 365+00

CR1 363+00

CR1 362+00

CR1 361+00

CR1 360+00

L 365+00

L 364+00

L 363+00

L 362+00

L 361+00

R 365+00

R 364+00

R 363+00

R 362+00

R 361+00

CR1 367+00

L 376+00L 375+00L 374+00L 373+00

L 372+00

L 371+00

L 370+00

L 369+00

L 367+00

R 378+00R 376+00R 375+00R 374+00R 373+00

R 372+00

R 371+00

R 370+00R 369+00

R 367+00

L 391+00

R 391+00

L 379+00

R 379+00 R 383+00

L 390+00

R 390+00R 390+00

L 389+00L 388+00L 387+00L 385+00L 384+00L 383+00L 382+00L 381+00L 380+00

R 390+00R 389+00R 388+00R 387+00R 385+00R 384+00R 382+00R 381+00R 380+00 CR2 38+00

L 394+00L 393+00L 392+00

R 394+00R 393+00R 392+00 CR2 39+00

DANFORTH AVENUE STATION

L 403+00L 402+00L 401+00L 400+00L 399+00L 398+00L 397+00L 396+00

R 403+00R 402+00R 401+00R 400+00R 399+00R 398+00R 397+00R 396+00

S72^23'29"E

L 2407+00

R 2406+00

L 411+00L 410+00L 409+00L 408+00L 407+00L 406+00L 405+00

R 411+00R 410+00R 409+00R 408+00R 406+00R 405+00

L 416+00L 415+00L 414+00L 412+00

R 416+00R 415+00R 414+00R 412+00 L 422+00

L 422+00 L 427+00

L 426+00

L 425+00L 424+00L 423+00L 421+00L 420+00

R 420+00 R 421+00 R 423+00 R 424+00 R 425+00 R 426+00 R 427+00

L 419+00L 418+00L 417+00

R 418+00 R 419+00R 417+00

L 429+00

L 428+00

R 428+00 R 429+00

L 442+00

RICHARD STREET STATION

N41^38'31"E L 441+00L 439+00L 438+00L 437+00L 436+00L 435+00L 434+00L 433+00L 432+00

L 430+00

R 430+00 R 432+00 R 433+00 R 434+00 R 435+00 R 436+00 R 437+00 R 438+00 R 439+00 R 441+00 R 442+00

L 444+00

L 443+00

R 443+00

454+50

454+50

R 457+00

L 457+00

L 456+00

R 456+00

R 455+00

L 455+00

L 454+00

L 453+00

L 452+00

L 451+00

L 450+00

L 448+00

L 447+00

L 446+00

L 445+00

R 444+00

R 445+00

R 446+00

R 453+00

R 447+00

R 448+00

R 450+00

R 451+00

R 452+00

R 454+00

L 458+00

R 458+00

478

0

0

ML1XO2

470

469

468

467

466

465

464

463

462

461

460

459

470

469

468

467

466

465

464

463

462

461

460

459

478

477

476

475

474

473

472

471

477

476

475

474

473

472

471

483

482

481

480

479

483

482

481

480

479

L 2429+00R 2429+00

L 2417+00R 2417+00

L 2410+00

L 2409+00

L 2408+00

R 2410+00

R 2409+00

R 2408+00

R 2407+00

MLK DRIVE STATION

12.00'

L 2416+00

L 2415+00

L 2414+00

L 2413+00

L 2412+00

L 2411+00

R 2416+00

R 2415+00

R 2414+00

R 2413+00

R 2412+00

R 2411+00

L 2423+00

L 2422+00

L 2421+00

L 2428+00

L 2427+00

L 2426+00

L 2425+00

L 2424+00

L 2420+00

S72^16'44.00"E

S72^16'44.00"E

L 2419+00

L 2418+00

R 2428+00

R 2427+00

R 2426+00

R 2425+00

R 2424+00

R 2423+00

R 2422+00

R 2421+00

R 2420+00

R 2419+00

R 2418+00

R 2441+00

L 2440+00

L 2439+00

L 2438+00

R 2440+00

R 2439+00

R 2438+00

R 2437+00

0

2452

2451

2450

2449

2452

2451

2450

2449

L 2448+00

L 2447+00

L 2446+00

L 2445+00

L 2444+00

L 2443+00

L 2442+00

L 2441+00

12.00'

R 2448+00

R 2447+00

R 2446+00

R 2445+00

R 2444+00

R 2443+00

R 2442+00

L 2437+00

L 2436+00

L 2435+00

L 2434+00

L 2433+00

L 2432+00

L 2431+00

L 2430+00

R 2436+00

R 2435+00

R 2434+00

R 2433+00

R 2432+00

R 2431+00

R 2430+00

GARFIELD AVENUE STATION

496

495

494

493

492

491

490

489

487

486

485

484

495

494

493

492

491

490

487

486

485

484

12

11

10

9

2

1

0

2

1

2464

2463

2462

2461

2460

2459

2458

2457

2456

2455

2454

2453

2464

2463

2462

2461

2460

2459

2458

2457

2456

2455

2454

2453

496

2

0

2471

2470

2469

2468

2467

2466

2465

2471

2470

2468

2467

2466

2465

504

503

502

501

500

499

498

497

504

503

501

500

499

498

497

2

L 510+00

L 509+00

L 508+00

L 507+00

L 506+00

L 505+00

L 504+00

L 503+00

L 502+00

R 510+00

R 509+00

R 508+00

R 507+00

R 506+00

R 505+00

R 504+00

R 503+00

R 502+00

R 501+00

LIBERTY STATE PARK STATION

L 512+00L 511+00

R 512+00

R 511+00

L 523+

00

L 522+

00

L 520+

00

L 519+00

L 518+00

L 517+00

L 516+00

L 515+00

L 514+00

L 513+00

R 523+

00

R 522+

00

R 521+

00

R 520+

00

R 519+00

R 518+00

R 517+00R 516+00

R 515+00

R 514+00

R 513+00

S72^11'55"E

TRACK R

>

TRACK L

>

S66^28'26"E

S72^11'55"E

S76^27'24"E

S72^11'55"E

WEST SIDE AVENUE STATION

14'

28.375'

L 2392+00

L 2391+00

L 2390+00

L 2389+00

L 2388+00

L 2387+00

L 2386+00

R 2393+00

R 2392+00

R 2391+00

R 2390+00

R 2389+00

R 2388+00

R 2387+00

R 2386+00

TRACK R

TRACK L

>

>

S77^55'24"E

S77^55'24"E

S72^23'29"E

S72^11'55"E

S72^11'55"E

14'

L 2405+00

L 2404+00

L 2403+00

L 2402+00

L 2401+00

L 2400+00

L 2399+00

L 2398+00

L 2397+00

L 2396+00

L 2395+00

L 2394+00

R 2405+00

R 2404+00

R 2403+00

R 2402+00

R 2401+00

R 2400+00

R 2399+00

R 2398+00

R 2397+00

R 2396+00

R 2395+00

R 2394+00

>

TRACK R

TRACK L

>

S72^23'29"E

L 2406+00

L 635+00

L 551+00

JERSEY CITY MEDICAL CENTER STATION

R 551+00

L 534+00

L 525+

00

L 524+

00

R 525+

00

R 524+

00

LR 534+00

LR 533+00

LR 532+00

LR 531+00

LR 530+00

L 536+00

L 535+00

R 536+00

R 535+00

LR 529+00

LR 528+00

LR 527+00

LR 526+00

RR 533+00

RR 532+00

RR 531+00

RR 530+00

RR 529+00

RR 528+00

RR 527+00

RR 526+00

R 534+00

L 550+00

L 549+00

L 548+00L 547+00

L 546+00

L 544+00

L 543+00

L 542+00

L 541+00

L 540+00

L 539+00

L 538+00

L 537+00

R 550+00

R 549+00

R 548+00

R 547+00

R 546+00

R 545+00

R 544+00

R 543+00

R 542+00

R 541+00

R 540+00

R 539+00

R 538+00

R 537+00

L 577+00

R 577+00

L 564+00R 564+00

L 563+00

L 562+00

L 561+00

L 560+00

L 559+00

L 558+00

R 563+00

R 562+00

R 561+00

R 560+00

R 559+00

R 558+00

L 555+00

L 554+00

L 553+00

L 552+00

R 555+00

R 554+00

R 553+00

R 552+00

L 576+00

L 575+00

L 574+00

L 573+00

L 572+00

L 571+00L 570+00

L 569+00

L 568+00

L 567+00

L 566+00

L 565+00

R 576+00

R 575+00

R 574+00

R 573+00

R 572+00

R 571+00

R 570+00

R 569+00

R 568+00

R 567+00

R 566+00

R 565+00

NORTH STATION

LIBERTY HARBOR

NORTH STATION

LIBERTY HARBOR

L 588+00

L 587+00

L 586+00

L 585+00

L 583+00

L 582+00

L 581+00

L 580+00

L 579+00

L 578+00

R 588+00

R 587+00

R 586+00

R 585+00

R 583+00

R 582+00

R 581+00

R 580+00

R 579+00

R 578+00

++

L 600+00

L 599+00

L 598+00

L 597+00

L 596+00

L 595+00

L 594+00

L 592+00

L 591+00

R 600+00

R 599+00

R 598+00

R 597+00

R 596+00

R 595+00

R 594+00

R 593+00

R 592+00

R 591+00

L 590+00

L 589+00

R 590+00

R 589+00

ESSEX STREET STATION

ESSEX STREET STATION

EXCHANGE PLACE STATION

L 610+00

L 609+

00

L 608

+00

L 607+00

L 606+00

L 605+00

L 604+00

L 603+00

L 602+00

L 601+00

R 610+00

R 609+

00

R 608

+00

R 607+00

R 606+00

R 605+00

R 604+00

R 603+00

R 602+00

R 601+00

L 620+00

L 619+00

L 617+00

L 616+00

L 615+00

L 613+00

L 612+00

R 620+00

R 619+00

R 618+00

R 617+00

R 616+00

R 615+00

R 614+00

R 613+00

R 612+00

HARBORSIDE STATION

HARBORSIDE STATION

L 634+00

L 633+

00

L 632

+00

L 631

+00

L 629

+00

R 634+00

R 633+

00

R 632

+00

R 631

+00

R 630

+00

R 629

+00

L 628

+00

L 627

+00

L 625+

00

L 624+

00

L 623+

00

L 622+

00

L 621+

00

R 628

+00

R 627

+00

R 62 6

+00

R 625+

00

R 624+

00

R 623+

00

R 622+

00R 6

21+00

STATION

HARSIMUS COVE

STATION

HARSIMUS COVE

L 644+00

L 643+00

L 642+00

L 641+00

L 640+00

L 638+00

L 637+00

L 636+00

R 644+00

R 643+00

R 642+00

R 641+00

R 640+00

R 639+00

R 638+00

R 637+00

R 636+00

R 635+00

656+00

655+00

654+00

655+00

NEWPORT STATION

L 651+00

L 650+00

L 649+00

L 648+00

L 647+00

L 645+00

NEWPORT STATION

R 651+00

R 650+00

R 649+00

R 648+00

R 647+00

R 645+00

657+00

665+00

664+00

662+00

661+00

660+00

659+00

658+00

657+00

665+00

664+00

662+00

661+00

660+00

659+00

658+00

675+00

674+00

673+00

672+00

671+00

670+00

669+00

668+00

675+00

674+00

673+00

672+00

671+00

670+00

669+00

668+00

666+00

666+00 R 3665+00

677+49

677+00

677+49

677+00

R 683

+00

R 682+

00

R 681+00

R 680+

00

R 678+00

R 3680+00

R 3679+00

R 3678+00

R 3677+00W 103+00

W 102+00W 101+00

R 3676+00

R 3675+00

R 3674+00

R 3673+00

R 3672+00

R 3671+00

R 3670+00

R 3669+00

R 3668+00

R 3667+00

R 3666+00

H P M5 2 = V

' 0 0 . 0 5 6 = R

' 0 0 . 0 5 6 = R

' 0 9 3 = R

R 3664+00

R 3663+00

R 3662+00

R 3661+00

R 3660+00

R 3659+00

R 3658+00

R 3657+00

R 3656+00

R 3654+97

' 0 7 2= R

' 0 7 2= R

H P M5 1 = V

' 5 8 2 = R

HOBOKEN TERMINAL ST

ATION

EG

2394+25

2411+00

310+

00

314+

70

P

431+

50

539+00

540+00

563+00627+70

Bayview A

ve

E 4

0th

St.

383+

70G

ates

Ave

(clo

sed

)

1 1 '

16.0'

15.0'

18.0'

12.0'

12.0'

16.0'

16.0'

16.0'

16.0'

STA

R 5

04+

58.9

2 BK

STA

R 5

05+

16.9

6 A

HD

PS

N75^13' 58"E

N47^49' 00"E

N54^58'10"E

N68^04' 48"E

N73^01' 02"E

N65^51'52"E

14.52'14.54'

16.33'

R81

L81

STA

L 5

04+

58.5

6 BK

STA

L 5

05+

15.0

6 A

HD

PS

C81

Bergen Ave

2

2471

2470

2469

2471

2470

2469

504

504

503

502

L 505+00

L 504+00

L 503+00

R 505+00

R 504+00

R 503+00

E 31

st S

t.

ORANGE PHASE

FOR INTEGRATED TESTINGUNDER START-UP'S CONTROL

AREA 3

UNDER CONSTRUCTION DIVISIO

N'S CONTROL

GREEN PHASE

UNDER CONTROL OF RAIL OPERATIONS; FOR VEHICLE ACCEPTANCE

UNDER CONTROL OF RAIL OPERATIONS; FOR TRAINING

BLUE PHASE

CIH

TPSS

TPSSCIH

CIH

TPSS

TPSS

CIH

CIH

TPSS

676+00676+00

CROSSINGTEMP. GRADE

L 311+00

34TH STREET STATION

L 310+00

L 309+00

L 308+00

L 307+00

L 306+00

R 311+00

R 310+00

R 309+00

R 308+00

R 307+00

R 306+00

L 355+00

R 355+00

L 333+00

L 319+00

L 318+00

L 317+00

L 316+00

L 315+00

L 313+00

L 312+00

R 318+00

R 317+00

R 316+00

R 315+00

R 313+00

R 312+00

L 322+00

L 321+00

L 320+00

R 322+00

R 321+00

R 320+00

R 319+00

L 331+00

L 330+00

L 329+00

L 328+00

L 327+00

L 326+00

L 325+00

R 333+00

R 331+00

R 330+00

R 329+00

R 328+00

R 327+00

R 326+00

L 324+00

R 325+00

R 324+00

L 344+00

R 344+00

45TH STREET STATION

L 340+00

L 339+00

L 338+00

L 337+00

L 336+00

L 335+00

L 334+00

R 339+00

R 338+00

R 337+00

R 336+00

R 335+00

R 334+00

L 343+00

L 342+00

R 343+00

R 342+00

R 340+00

CR1 350+00

CR3 1+00CR1 355+00

CR1 354+00

CR1 353+00

CR1 352+00

CR1 351+00

CR1 349+00

CR1 348+00

CR1 347+00

R 352+00

L 354+00

L 353+00

L 352+00

L 351+00

L 349+00

L 348+00

L 347+00

R 354+00

R 353+00

R 351+00

R 349+00

R 348+00

R 347+00

L 346+00

L 345+00

R 346+00

R 345+00

CR1 358+00

CR1 357+00 CR2 1+00

CR1 356+00

L 360+00

L 358+00

L 357+00

L 356+00

R 360+00

R 358+00

R 357+00

R 356+00

L 378+00

CR1 366+00

L 366+00

R 366+00CR1 365+00

CR1 363+00

CR1 362+00

CR1 361+00

CR1 360+00

L 365+00

L 364+00

L 363+00

L 362+00

L 361+00

R 365+00

R 364+00

R 363+00

R 362+00

R 361+00

CR1 367+00

L 376+00

L 375+00

L 374+00

L 373+00

L 372+00

L 371+00

L 370+00

L 369+00

L 367+00

R 378+00

R 376+00

R 375+00

R 374+00

R 373+00

R 372+00

R 371+00

R 370+00

R 369+00

R 367+00

L 391+00

R 391+00

L 379+00

R 379+00

R 383+00

L 390+00

R 390+00R 390+00L 389+00

L 388+00

L 387+00

L 385+00

L 384+00

L 383+00

L 382+00

L 381+00

L 380+00

R 390+00

R 389+00

R 388+00

R 387+00

R 385+00

R 384+00

R 382+00

R 381+00

R 380+00

CR2 38+00L 394+00

L 393+00

L 392+00

R 394+00

R 393+00

R 392+00

CR2 39+00

DANFORTH AVENUE STATION

L 403+00

L 402+00

L 401+00

L 400+00

L 399+00

L 398+00

L 397+00

L 396+00

R 403+00

R 402+00

R 401+00

R 400+00

R 399+00

R 398+00

R 397+00

R 396+00

S72^23'29"E

L 2407+00

R 2406+00

L 411+00

L 410+00

L 409+00

L 408+00

L 407+00

L 406+00

L 405+00

R 411+00

R 410+00

R 409+00

R 408+00

R 406+00

R 405+00

L 416+00

L 415+00

L 414+00

L 412+00

R 416+00

R 415+00

R 414+00

R 412+00

L 422+00

L 422+00

L 427+00L 426+00

L 425+00

L 424+00

L 423+00

L 421+00

L 420+00

R 420+00

R 421+00

R 423+00

R 424+00

R 425+00

R 426+00

R 427+00

L 419+00

L 418+00

L 417+00 R 418+00

R 419+00

R 417+00

L 429+00

L 428+00

R 428+00

R 429+00

L 442+00RICHARD STREET STATION

N41^38'31"E

L 441+00

L 439+00

L 438+00

L 437+00

L 436+00

L 435+00

L 434+00

L 433+00

L 432+00

L 430+00

R 430+00

R 432+00

R 433+00

R 434+00

R 435+00

R 436+00

R 437+00

R 438+00

R 439+00

R 441+00

R 442+00

L 444+00

L 443+00

R 443+00

454+50

454+50

R 457+00

L 457+00

L 456+00

R 456+00

R 455+00

L 455+00

L 454+00

L 453+00

L 452+00

L 451+00

L 450+00

L 448+00

L 447+00L 446+00L 445+00

R 444+00 R 445+00 R 446+00

R 453+00

R 447+00R 448+00

R 450+00

R 451+00

R 452+00

R 454+00

L 458+00

R 458+00

478

00

ML1XO2

470

469

468

467

466465

464

463462

461

460

459

470

469

468

467

466

465

464

463

462

461

460

459

478

477

476

475

474

473

472

471

477

476

475

474

473

472

471

483

482

481

480

479

483

482

481

480

479

L 2429+00R 2429+00

L 2417+00R 2417+00

L 2410+00

L 2409+00

L 2408+00

R 2410+00

R 2409+00

R 2408+00

R 2407+00

MLK DRIVE STATION

12.00'

L 2416+00

L 2415+00

L 2414+00

L 2413+00

L 2412+00

L 2411+00

R 2416+00

R 2415+00

R 2414+00

R 2413+00

R 2412+00

R 2411+00

L 2423+00

L 2422+00

L 2421+00

L 2428+00

L 2427+00

L 2426+00

L 2425+00

L 2424+00

L 2420+00

S72^16'44.00"E

S72^16'44.00"E

L 2419+00

L 2418+00

R 2428+00

R 2427+00

R 2426+00

R 2425+00

R 2424+00

R 2423+00

R 2422+00

R 2421+00

R 2420+00

R 2419+00

R 2418+00

R 2441+00

L 2440+00

L 2439+00

L 2438+00

R 2440+00

R 2439+00

R 2438+00

R 2437+00

0

2452

2451

2450

2449

2452

2451

2450

2449

L 2448+00

L 2447+00

L 2446+00

L 2445+00

L 2444+00

L 2443+00

L 2442+00

L 2441+00

12.00'

R 2448+00

R 2447+00

R 2446+00

R 2445+00

R 2444+00

R 2443+00

R 2442+00

L 2437+00

L 2436+00

L 2435+00

L 2434+00

L 2433+00

L 2432+00

L 2431+00

L 2430+00

R 2436+00

R 2435+00

R 2434+00

R 2433+00

R 2432+00

R 2431+00

R 2430+00

GARFIELD AVENUE STATION

496

495

494

493

492

491

490

489

487

486

485

484

495

494

493

492

491

490

487

486

485

484

12

11

10

9

2

1

0

2

1

2464

2463

2462

2461

2460

2459

2458

2457

2456

2455

2454

2453

2464

2463

2462

2461

2460

2459

2458

2457

2456

2455

2454

2453

496

2

0

2471

24702469

2468

2467

2466

2465

2471

2470

2468

2467

2466

2465

504503502

501500499498

497

504

503

501

500499

498

497

2

L 510+00L 509+00L 508+00L 507+00L 506+00L 505+00

L 504+00

L 503+00

L 502+00

R 510+00R 509+00R 508+00R 507+00R 506+00R 505+00

R 504+00

R 503+00

R 502+00

R 501+00

LIBERTY STATE PARK STATION

L 512+00

L 511+00 R 512+00

R 511+00

L 523+

00

L 522+

00

L 520+

00

L 519+

00

L 518+00

L 517+00

L 516+00

L 515+00

L 514+00

L 513+00

R 523+

00

R 522+

00

R 521+

00

R 520+

00

R 519+

00

R 518+00

R 517+00

R 516+00

R 515+00

R 514+00

R 513+00

S72^11'55"E

TRACK R

>

TRACK L

>

S66^28'26"E

S72^11'55"E

S76^27'24"E

S72^11'55"E

WEST SIDE AVENUE STATION

14'

28.375'

L 2392+00

L 2391+00

L 2390+00

L 2389+00

L 2388+00

L 2387+00

L 2386+00

R 2393+00

R 2392+00

R 2391+00

R 2390+00

R 2389+00

R 2388+00

R 2387+00

R 2386+00

TRACK R

TRACK L

>

>

S77^55'24"E

S77^55'24"E

S72^23'29"E

S72^11'55"E

S72^11'55"E

14'

L 2405+00

L 2404+00

L 2403+00

L 2402+00

L 2401+00

L 2400+00

L 2399+00

L 2398+00

L 2397+00

L 2396+00

L 2395+00

L 2394+00

R 2405+00

R 2404+00

R 2403+00

R 2402+00

R 2401+00

R 2400+00

R 2399+00

R 2398+00

R 2397+00

R 2396+00

R 2395+00

R 2394+00

>

TRACK R

TRACK L

>

S72^23'29"E

L 2406+00

L 635+00

L 551+00

JERSEY CITY MEDICAL CENTER STATION

R 551+00

L 534+00

L 525+

00

L 524+

00

R 525+

00

R 524+

00

LR 534+00

LR 533+00

LR 532+00

LR 531+00

LR 530+00

L 536+00

L 535+00

R 536+00

R 535+00

LR 529+00LR 528+00

LR 527+00

LR 526

+00

RR 533+00

RR 532+00

RR 531+00

RR 530+00

RR 529+00RR 528+00

RR 527+00

RR 526

+00

R 534+00

L 550+00

L 549+00

L 548+00

L 547+00

L 546+00

L 544+00

L 543+00

L 542+00L 541+00

L 540+00

L 539+00

L 538+00

L 537+00

R 550+00

R 549+00

R 548+00R 547+00

R 546+00

R 545+00

R 544+00

R 543+00

R 542+00

R 541+00

R 540+00

R 539+00

R 538+00

R 537+00

L 577+00R 577+00

L 564+00R 564+00

L 563+00

L 562+00

L 561+00

L 560+00

L 559+00

L 558+00

R 563+00

R 562+00

R 561+00

R 560+00

R 559+00

R 558+00

L 555+00

L 554+00

L 553+00

L 552+00

R 555+00

R 554+00

R 553+00

R 552+00

L 576+00

L 575+00

L 574+00

L 573+00L 572+00

L 571+00

L 570+00

L 569+00

L 568+00

L 567+00

L 566+00

L 565+00

R 576+00

R 575+00

R 574+00

R 573+00

R 572+00

R 571+00

R 570+00

R 569+00

R 568+00

R 567+00

R 566+00

R 565+00

NORTH STATION

LIBERTY HARBOR

NORTH STATION

LIBERTY HARBOR

L 588+00

L 587+00

L 586+00

L 585+00

L 583+00

L 582+00

L 581+00

L 580+00

L 579+00

L 578+00

R 588+00

R 587+00

R 586+00

R 585+00

R 583+00

R 582+00

R 581+00

R 580+00

R 579+00

R 578+00

++

L 600+00

L 599+00

L 598+00

L 597+00

L 596+00

L 595+00

L 594+00

L 592+00

L 591+00

R 600+00

R 599+00

R 598+00

R 597+00

R 596+00

R 595+00

R 594+00

R 593+00

R 592+00

R 591+00

L 590+00

L 589+00

R 590+00

R 589+00

ESSEX STREET STATION

ESSEX STREET STATION

EXCHANGE PLACE STATION

L 610+00

L 609+

00L 6

08+0

0

L 607+00

L 606+00

L 605+00

L 604+00

L 603+00

L 602+00

L 601+00

R 610+00

R 609+

00R 6

08+0

0

R 607+00

R 606+00

R 605+00

R 604+00

R 603+00

R 602+00

R 601+00

L 620+00

L 619+00

L 617+00

L 616+00

L 615+00

L 613+00

L 612+00

R 620+00

R 619+00

R 618+00

R 617+00

R 616+00

R 615+00

R 614+00

R 613+00

R 612+00

HARBORSIDE STATION

HARBORSIDE STATION

L 634+

00

L 633

+00

L 632

+00

L 631+

00

L 629+

00

R 634+

00

R 633

+00

R 632

+00

R 631+

00

R 630+

00

R 629

+00

L 628

+00

L 627

+00

L 625+

00

L 624+00

L 623+00

L 622+00

L 621

+00

R 628

+00

R 627

+00

R 626

+00

R 625+

00

R 624+

00

R 623+

00

R 622+

00

R 621+

00

STATION

HARSIMUS COVE

STATION

HARSIMUS COVE

L 644+00

L 643+00

L 642+00

L 641+00

L 640+00

L 638+00

L 637+00

L 636+00

R 644+00

R 643+00

R 642+00

R 641+00

R 640+00

R 639+00

R 638+00

R 637+00

R 636+00

R 635+00

656+00

655+00

654+00

655+00

NEWPORT STATION

L 651+00

L 650+00

L 649+00

L 648+00

L 647+00

L 645+00

NEWPORT STATION

R 651+00

R 650+00

R 649+00

R 648+00

R 647+00

R 645+00

657+00

665+00

664+00

662+00

661+00

660+00

659+00

658+00

657+00

665+00

664+00

662+00

661+00

660+00

659+00

658+00

675+00

674+00

673+00

672+00

671+00

670+00

669+00

668+00

675+00

674+00

673+00

672+00

671+00

670+00

669+00

668+00

666+00

666+00

R 3665+00

677+49

677+00

677+49

677+00

R 683+

00

R 682+

00

R 681+00

R 680+00R 678+00

R 3680+00

R 3679+00

R 3678+00

R 3677+00

W 103+00

W 102+00

W 101+00

R 3676+00

R 3675+00

R 3674+00

R 3673+00

R 3672+00

R 3671+00

R 3670+00

R 3669+00

R 3668+00

R 3667+00

R 3666+00

H P M 5 2 = V

' 0 0 . 0 5 6 = R

' 0 0 . 0 5 6 = R

' 0 9 3 = R

R 3664+00

R 3663+00

R 3662+00

R 3661+00

R 3660+00

R 3659+00

R 3658+00

R 3657+00

R 3656+00

R 3654+97

' 0 7 2= R

' 0 7 2= R H P M 5 1 = V

' 5 8 2 = R

HOBOKEN TERMINAL STATION

11'

16.0'

15.0'

18.0'

12.0'

12.0'

16.0'

16.0'

16.0'

16.0'

STA

R 5

04+5

8.92

BK

STA

R 5

05+1

6.96

AH

D

PS

N75^13' 58"E

N47^49' 00"E

N54^58'10"E

N68^04' 48"E

N73^01' 02"E

N65^51'52"E

14.52'

14.54'16.33'

R81

L81

STA

L 5

04+5

8.56

BK

STA

L 5

05+1

5.06

AH

D

PS

C81

2

2471

24702469 2471

2470

2469

504

504

503502

L 505+00

L 504+00

L 503+00

R 505+00

R 504+00

R 503+00

NEWPORT

PROPERTIES

VACATION OF

1ST STREET BY

CITY OF JERSEY CITY

PARCEL E96

HUDSON

LIMITED PARTNERSHIP

EXCHANGE PLACE

HARBORSIDE

PARCEL E49-2, E49-3

LIMITED

EXCHANGE PLACE

HARBORSIDE

PARCEL E49-1

~

~~

~

~

MARGARET ANN JOHNSON

PARCEL 77

FREDERICK P. JOHNSON ~

PARTNERSHIP

34th STREET PARK-N-RIDE MOTB PROPERTY

NOT AVAILABLE UNTIL JULY, 1999

N.J. TRANSIT ACCUIRING HICOR

PROPERTY FOR AN ALTERNATE FACILITY

WEST SIDE PARK-N-RIDE

ALL PROPERTY ACQUIRED

LUMBER BUSINESS TO BE

RELOCATED EARLY 1999

HOBOKEN LRT TERMINAL

FTA/ACOE/USCG

APPROVAL REQUIRED

N.J. TRANSIT CONSIDERING

A SIMPLIFIED, LESS COSTLY

STATION

RIGHT OF ENTRY

HOSPITALITY

ISSUES

PROPERTY

AVAILABILITY AGREEMENT

101 HUDSON

STREET

REQUIRED

TRIZECHAHN

AGREEMENT

AUGUST, 1999

AFTER

SURCHARGE PLACED

BENEFICIAL USE

{

{

BAYONNE

PARK-N

-RIDE

City of Bayonn

e

City of Jersey C

ityPARK-N

-RIDE

E 34th St.

E 45TH St.

P P

King Dr

COMMUNIPAWSHOP AND

Garfield Ave

Martin Luther D

anfo

rth A

ve

NC

ON

RAIL

Rou

te 169

GR

Richard

St.

YARD

Martin Luther King Dr.

Kennedy Blvd.

West Side Ave

P

Garfield Ave

(Park-N-Rid

e)Park

Montgom

ery St.

Exchange Place

P

Marin Blvd

Essex St.Hudson StFerry

Columbus Dr.

Gro

ve St.

Ferry

Harborside

West Side Ave

Park-N-Ride

Liberty State

HUDSON - BERGEN LIGHT RAIL TRANSIT SYSTEM (IOS)

FIGURE 5; RAINBOW PHASINGNOVEMBER 1999

DRA

WIN

G N

AM

E : H

:\96

ct00

1\H

U6-

AA

.DW

G

Page 23: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

Hb5-0739

Figure 6Integration Hierarchy

Read Down Commissioning

Total Railway Operating Requirements Documents (ORD)Operation Validation

(RAIL OPERATONS)

Individual Systems Integration Requirements are Defined Integrated Testing(START-UP)

SUB-SYSTEMS ICD’S

ASSEMBLIES

COMPONENTS

PARTS

DetailedDesignGoverned by ICD’s and Criteria

Sub-System Testing(START-UP & CONSTRUCTION)

Construction, Inspection & Testing

Read Up

Deployment:

ACTIVATION(RAIL OPS)

Page 24: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

APPENDIX A

DEFINITIONS

These are the definitions as used on the HBLR Program: 1. Commissioning. The total of all activities required to transform a new railway from the

point at which all construction/installation is completed to revenue ready status. The components of “commissioning are:

• integrated testing • activation • safety certification • operation demonstration

2. Systems

An assemblage of hardware, software and documentation which is capable of delivering a “high level” stand alone function, e.g., train control. A list of systems and sub-systems, as used on HBLR, is provided in Appendix “B”. On HBLR systems are further broken down into sub-systems, assemblies, components and parts.

3. Systems Integration is a program-wide and program-duration process which defines and controls interfaces in order to assure that the operating requirements on HBLR systems and criteria are achieved. SI is intended to provide for total optimization (i.e., to guard against optimization of any system at the expense of another or total railway performance).

The SI process provides the basis for Integrated Testing, particularly in its generation of ICD’s.

4. Integrated Testing is testing which verifies the joint performance of two or more systems, or between selected sub-systems. Safe brake tests and LRV/clearance tests are categorized as integrated tests.

5. Start-up includes all engineering aspects of final testing at systems level and integrated

testing, and provision of as-in-service documentation. 6. Activation pertains to preparation and validation of operating documents, e.g., rulebooks,

operating procedures and maintenance plans. Includes developing and validating operating schedules. Also includes defining and staffing the organization, training and qualification of employees. This also includes operational validation, i.e., the sum total of rules, procedures, engineered systems, and training and qualification can collectively satisfy the operational requirements.

7. Safety Certification. Verification and certification that all engineered systems and rules

and procedures, training and qualification satisfy the requirements of the Program Safety Plan.

Page 25: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the
Page 26: Commissioning the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail The …...COMMISSIONING THE HUDSON-BERGEN LIGHT RAIL THE “RAINBOW PLAN” by A. E. Fazio*, D. Dali** and S. A. Feil*** Prepared for the

APPENDIX C

“RAINBOW PLAN”

PHASE PURPOSE DESCRIPTION

RED “A” VEHICLE SHAKEDOWN

(integration of LRV sub-systems)

“Shakedown” consists of continuous operation at maximum performance parameters (accelerations, braking, MU Operation) with vehicles 2001 & 2002 in order to identify any immediate corrective actions and to provide a basis for initial verification of the performance of two prototypes. “Shakedown” does not represent a part of the vehicle commissioning process.

RED “B” VEHICLE QUALIFICATION TESTING

Qualification testing involves a full range of instrumented testing consisting of dynamic vehicle tests (full acceleration, balancing speed, service braking, etc.) in order to verify design, design integration, and manufacturing of the vehicle but is not intended to accomplish integrated testing or vehicle commissioning. Failures will be reviewed for cause and appropriate rework defined.

GREEN “A”

VEHICLE COMMISSIONING

(proof of assembly)

Vehicle commissioning begins. Estimated to require 1 week per car. Due to change in date of signal cut-in this phase will be initiated over Tracks 1&2 from Conrail Flyover to S/o Yard North. Will have ability to commission two vehicles at a time.

GREEN”B” VEHICLE COMMISSIONING Vehicle commissioning continues with train control system fully functional for Green Configuration (YS, GR, 34 th, SSY and SMY) .Train movements will be governed by modified version of the HBLR Rulebook, referred to as “Green Rules”.

BLUE “A” ACTIVATION & QUALIFICATION

This phase is intended for training and qualification of operational personnel, as well as for establishing coordination with external agencies e.g. police and fire, and for shakedown of OCC procedures. Will also include APTA & 2nd Peer review. TFCRC revised physical limits of the Blue Phase; deleted west branch, added mainline as far north as Creek interlocking.

BLUE “B”

ACTIVATION & QUALIFICATION

Activation & Qualification continues with northern mainline limits extended to Canal interlocking with use of one crossover.

ORANGE “A” INTEGRATED TES TING AND INITIAL OPERATIONAL VALIDATION

Truncated IOS capable of providing service to Exchange Place. The in-service target date is during March 2000. The “Orange” is referred to as IOS-1. The location of the terminal of the terminal crossover will now be on ballasted track adjacent to Harborside. Systems layout (traction power, train control, and communications) requires design. Typical of the activities which are to be performed during Orange Phase include:

a. Systems commissioning – includes commissioning and transition to full O&M status of all systems except vehicle (over the geographic extent of the Orange Configuration). Note: vehicles have previously been commissioned in green.

b. Confirm and shakedown operational practices.

ORANGE “B” ALL SYSTEMS COMPLETED; FINAL OPERATIONAL VALIDATION

This phase validated that the combination of engineering systems, and the staffing and training of the operating organization, could jointly achieve the HBLR Operating Requirements.

DEMONSTRATION Operational demo – In order to achieve service initiation in March. 30 days to make 10.