consolis asia - presentation bonna pipes - meralco
TRANSCRIPT
-
Divisions : Buildings Infrastructure Rail
-
4 Mars 2014 Consolis Corporate
-
CONSOLIS GROUP Leader in precast concrete solutions with over 1000 diversified products
Now offering ONSITE PRODUCTION from mobile factories to reach out overseas customers EPC/IPP with large diameter CW & onshore / offshore turnkey projects.
WATER PIPELINE SOLUTIONS for COOLING WATER SYSTEMS in POWER PLANTS & WATER SUPPLY PIPELINES Since 1993 CONSOLIS supplies its customers across South East Asia from partner subsidiary PT BONNA INDONESIA.
-
CONSOLIS - Bonna Indonesia REFERENCES & PROJECTS LOCATION
Since 1993, CONSOLIS supplies its customers across South East Asia from subsidiary PT BONNA INDONESIA
NATURAL MARKET
-
BONNA RCCP pressure pipes in POWER PLANTS
Solutions for Cooling systems
-
CONSOLIS pressure pipeline in ENERGY & WATER SUPPLY Bonna RCCP pipes for power plants
Prestressed PCP pipes for water supply
-
EPC design choices DRIVE overall performance of POWER PLANT Key impact of COOLING WATER (CW) pipeline material choice.
POWER PLANT CONSTRUCTION & COMMERCIAL CONDITIONS : EFFICIENCY and RELIABILITY OF A PLANT are MAJOR FACTORS for COMMERCIAL SUCCESS of their OWNERS (including IPPs).
typically, for the FIRST 4 YEARS, the EPC CONTRACTOR is RESPONSIBLE for CONSTRUCTION and WARRANTY
for the NEXT 25 YEARS, the OWNER becomes RESPONSIBLE for O&M, RELIABILITY and EFFICIENCY which WILL BE the MAIN DETERMINANT for the COMPANY FINANCIAL RESULTS.
CONDENSER efficiency will depend on GOOD CW DESIGN and will indirectly IMPACT TURBINE performance
ADEQUATE SELECTION of RELIABLE CW MATERIAL / EQUIPMENT at EPC STAGE will contribute to CONTROL of POWER PLANTs future overall O&M and EFFICIENCY
Bonna RCCP pipes : concrete-based solution to optimize cost of ownership
-
NEW POWER PLANT : COOLING SYSTEM is only a minor CAPEX component yet its performance will impact OPEX & OVERALL EFFICIENCY
Boiler Turbine
Generator
CW pumps Intake head Discharge outfall
CIVIL WORKS 10%
CW pipes = usually 0.2% to 1.5% of total CAPEX depending of diameter & length
condenser
POWER ISLAND 85%
Important : choose the right PIPELINE MATERIAL with proven performance.
-
SEAWATER COOLING SYSTEMS CRITICAL TARGET : EFFICIENCY by REDUCING MAINTENANCE
In a context of rising CW diameters the MAIN ISSUES are linked to SURFACE & DESIGN Proliferation of marine life will affect flow rates
If corrosion prone high-maintenance, impaired durability
All linings (rubber, epoxy) will eventually peel off
Important : choose the right PIPELINE MATERIAL with proven performance.
Plants capacity MW
CW diameters
-
BONNA pipes - CUSTOM-MADE integrated SOLUTIONS
for ENERGY POWER PLANTS owners & EPC contractors
-
BONNA offers complete SERVICES for the BENEFITS of its customers
( ENGINEERING, DESIGN, STUDIES, INSTALLATION & TECHNICAL FIELD ASSISTANCE )
-
COMPLETE INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS for COOLING WATER SYSTEMS 1. ONSHORE inlet/outlet pipelines from pumping station to condenser
2. OFFSHORE intake pressure pipeline & discharge outfall
3. Modular precast concrete intake headers/risers & diffusers
BONNA RCCP PIPES in POWER PLANTS
-
header intake inshore pipeline
PRESSURE (typical
-
COOLING WATER SYSTEM - OFFSHORE PIPELINE Discharge OUTFALL in RCCP and DIFFUSER in precast concrete
Custom-made diffusers (= RCCP tees)
Discharge OUTFALL in RCCP and DIFFUSER in precast concrete
Custom-made diffusers (= RCCP tees)
-
Custom-made intake head in precast concrete
Underwater jacking tightening system of pre-welded RCCP piping sections.
COOLING WATER SYSTEM - OFFSHORE PIPELINE Pressurized INTAKE PIPE in RCCP and aspiration HEADER / RISER in precast concrete
-
CONSOLIS - COOLING WATER SOLUTIONS for POWER PLANTS EXPANDING SCOPE of OFFER to MEET NEW DEMAND
TRENDS in BOP Bonna RCCP new benefits Innovative + cost effective requirements for owners / IPP / EPC integrated SOLUTIONS
Increased customer support across ASIA :
Expanded CW scope beyond ONSHORE into OFFSHORE
advantageously replace traditional carbon steel / GRP / HDPE
BONNA RCCP pipes
3500 4000
Future 5000
-
COOLING WATER SYSTEMS for POWER PLANTS Trend : demand for LARGE DIAMETER PIPES > ND4000 mm
So BONNA RCCP pipes even more attractive cost-wise, compared to CARBO STEEL PIPE
Bonna RCCP pipes response to MARKET DEMAND (internal in mm)
Current catalog : from 400 to 3500
Transport limit from our Indonesian factory (bridge height) : 3800
Current demand up to 4000 now offering onsite production (mobile factory)
Near future already testing 4800
-
BONNA RCCP pipes made onsite in MOBILE FACTORY
Offshore launching
Inland fabrication & long sections pre-
assembly
Onshore launching
Custom-Made precast concrete Intake header/risers
-
OFFSHORE CASE STUDY
Intake / Discharge Pipelines Intake Header/Riser
-
OFFSHORE COOLING WATER SOLUTIONS in PRECAST REINFORCED CONCRETE Modular intake / outfall PIPELINES + HEADER + DIFFUSERS
DESIGN of the CW will determine its own performance and directly impact the operating EFFICIENCY of the power plant CONDENSER.
minimize CAPEX to fit offshore contractor equipment at construction stage
optimize OPEX to site-specific constraints (depth, water flow, speed)
Modular construction to fit marine contractors equipment, facilitate handling and avoid underwater welding. Intake head assembled under or above water.
Chlorination kit and access manhole included, pre-assembled in factory
Maintenance-free (no apparent steel, no need for cathodic protection)
Environmental-friendly structural concrete design : typical height 2.0m to limit maximum water flow to 0.2-0.3m/s and organic intake.
Custom-made aspiration header / risers for power plants up to 1000 MW
Example above : 5.5m velocity cap,
4 components, total weight
-
conceptual drawing
OFFSHORE INTAKE PIPELINE
Intake Heads x3
Pump station
A
B
C
Typical
Bonna RCCP ND2800 x2 lines ?
SAVINGS in dredging+ backfill reduction ?
23
Typical
-
OFFSHORE INTAKE PIPELINE in BONNA pipes Proposed installation method 1/2
1. Pre-assembly: Bonna pipe type S-L welded in sections of 5-6 spools (~100 tons) on shore on barge
E and R ends are generally fitted with anchoring boxes for underwater jointing purpose..
2. Sections are then floated with temporary inflatable plugs Launching from on shore Sunk from barge/platform with crane (typical
250 tons capacity)
3. Towed sections by tugboat to sink on place with crane on barge.
24
-
4. Divers guide sinking, alignement and positioning
of sections, until ready to connect by jack fitting.
5. Underwater assembly :
Fitting of flexible joints by tightening of hydraulic jacks.
Divers to check compressed PU foam seals on inner/outer pipe circumference.
6. Once joined together, the sections are secured before backfilling, with tied rods, using the same anchor boxes.
No underwater use of welding or mortar for jointing is necessary.
OFFSHORE INTAKE PIPELINE in BONNA pipes Proposed installation method 2/2
25
-
OFFSHORE INTAKE PIPELINE Bonna RCCP pipe instead of HDPE
CONSOLIS PROPOSAL : Since RCCP self-reinforced internal structure allow very large pipe diameter,
replacie the 3 lines of HDPE ND2400 (13.6m2 combined section) by 2 lines of RCCP ND2800 (12.3m2)
RCCP ND2800 typical pipe characteristics : external diameter OD3280mm, length 3.50 meters, weight
5.50 tons/linear meter
1. DREDGING Reduced trench pathway (width x depth) if only 2 lines are used instead of 3 lines. Reduces dredging volume proportionately. Dimensional savings : m3 x dredging cost at $/m3
2. FOUNDATION / BEDDING
Rough trench surface is acceptable for Bonna reinforced concrete pipes. Specially graded bedding material not required as with HDPE. Savings : m3 x crushed aggregates at $/m3
3. COST OF PIPELINE MATERIAL (including installation ingredients)
Assumption : same order of magnitude between RCCP and HDPE. Difference = $ ?
4. INSTALLATION METHOD (without underwater welding) Field manual & technical assistance by BONNA specialist
5. BACKFILLING
Bonna ND2800 pipes are heavier and also have an inherent resistance under load and higher density (2.45 versus HDPE 0.95), offer the possibility of natural backfilling (as in Indonesia) then savings in crushed stones or controlled
Backfill. Potential savings : m3 x graded aggregates at $/m3
Bonna pipes 2 lines ND2800 = 10 tons/ml
Estim. weight trenching material : 52m3 x1.8 = 95 tons/ml
26
-
Intake Heads x3
Intake Head
conceptual drawing
OFFSHORE INTAKE HEADER/RISER
Replace by 2 precast RCCP INTAKE HEADS ?
Possibility to let (partial) natural backfilling fill in the RCCP trenched pipeline ?
27
-
CONSOLIS PROPOSAL : precast concrete head with velocity cap in a 5.m. Factory-made modular structure of 4 full
reinforced components for a total weight
-
1. Dredge seabed for the intake platform imprint.
2. Prepare seabed for 2 identical heads Can be based on 100m2 or 150m2 Can be with rock or other base
3. Pre-assemble intake head T-shaped base Can be done on barge Can be done on pier. Only needs grouting (Connexions only by fitting, grouting or bolting with resin) Field manual & technical assistance by BONNA specialist
4. Mount Ring on the top of the T-shaped base Welding of SL type joints (10mm steel plate) Protect with grouting
5. Attach Ring+T-shaped base on 5 lifting cables and lower piece in position
6. Attach velocity cap to lifting cables Lower piece in position Bolt the 5 screws Protect with grouting
7. Protect all metallic parts with grouting Fill area between seabed and intake head if relevant
8. Lower manhole into position Close manhole Tighten 8 bolts
OFFSHORE INTAKE HEADER/RISER 8 easy steps to install the modular precast structure
29
-
30
OFFSHORE INTAKE HEADER/RISER 8 easy assembly steps - summary
-
MATERIAL COSTS 2 heads versus 3 heads Less dredging for intake head location.
INSTALLATION COST & METHOD (without underwater welding)
Time to install 2 versus 3 heads Lifting equipment and barges only for 60T max Assemble head components above surface or directly underwater Connexions only by fitting, grouting or bolting
BACKFILLING COSTS
Self supporting pipes can sustain higher weight and loads No risk of ovalization No need for special backfilling materials No need for anchoring as pipes are self anchoring
MAINTENANCE COSTS
No need for cathodic protection (no steel is in contact with water) Chlorination pipe facilitates protection against marine life incursion
(mussels and algae)
OFFSHORE INTAKE HEADER/RISER Savings compared to Cast-in-place ?
31
-
BONNA RCCP pipes & SPECIAL FITTINGS
Manufacturing Process
-
SMOOTH PERMANENT LINING :
Protection against chemical corrosion of the steel thanks to passivation effect
Anti-abrasion Low hydraulic head loss
Watertightness Self-anchoring (no thrust blocks)
REINFORCED OUTER CONCRETE:
Resistance to water pressure Protection against full vacuum conditions Structural protection against mobile + fixed loads (backfill & wall side charges)
-
RCCP pipes PRODUCTION in FACTORY & SHIPPING POSSIBILITIES
-
Bonna pipes RCCP solutions COMPLETE range of diameter & components
As per EN639-641 up to 10% more economical than AWWA C-300
-
BONNA RCCP pipes & SPECIAL FITTINGS
Field Installation
-
Bonna RCCP pipes installation welded/flexible joints A SIMPLE LEGO-LIKE FIELD ASSEMBLY
TYPICAL SEQUENCE of OPERATIONS 1. Ground support foundations & bedding preparation 2. Laying-out the pipe spools / special fittings (Tees, Elbows,
Reducers, Wall crossings, Manholes, Flanges, etc) 3. Fitting of pipe segments (or closing the pipeline with lap-joints) 4. Welding S-L end-rings or fitting E-R flexible joints 5. Joint filling with mortar 6. Backfilling with native material Installation may proceed simultaneously on several fronts. Full choice of starting point : at interface or anywhere else. STAFF & EQUIPMENT - Optional ingredients (proposed by Consolis / Bonna) Welders & non-specialist semi-skilled labor Crawler crane for spools lifting & placement Loader for backfilling
-
BONNA RCCP pipes DESIGN ENGINEERING Typical trench design - as per NT 216
-
BONNA RCCP pipes DESIGN ENGINEERING Typical trench design - as per NT 216
Massive anchor / thrust blocks at every change of direction are NOT required. Backfilling can be done with the native material and single layer compaction
-
SPECIAL WORKS PIPE JACKING & MICRO-TUNNELLING
AREAS of EXPERTISE Capability to design PIPES for JACKING
-
Bonna RCCP pipes - BENEFITS of SELF-ANCHORING absence of massive anchor/thrust blocks
GRP
Welded restrained joint
W
W
W
W
W
W
With RCCP, massive concrete thrust (anchor) blocks are NOT required
WW WWWWW
THRUST FORCE
Welded or Fitted / flexible joints
W/F
W/F
W/F
-
ONSHORE CASE STUDY
Large diameter pipes Total Owners Cost (TCO) analysis
-
Soil improvement
ONSHORE TCO ANALYSIS : SHALLOW FOUNDATIONS for large diam BONNA RCCP pipes Design must be validated with specialist geotechnical engineers
Calculated savings > 4m USD/km Ie over 20m USD over whole project
CARBON STEEL PIPES Cost of traditional DEEP FOUNDATIONS PC piles (50m deep x 6 piles x 3m spread) and/or concrete cradles Estimated cost 5.0 mUSD/km versus BONNA RCCP pipes with SHALLOW FOUNDATIONS combining : Geo-textile mattress Sand bedding Rock stone ballast Estimated cost 300-500k USD/km
+Soil improvement
-
ONSHORE TCO ANALYSIS : CW for 2x600MW power plant (weak soil conditions)
44
-
FOUNDATION SUPPORT & GEOTECHNICAL DESIGN
with BONNA reinforced concrete cylinder pipes (RCCP) RIGIDITY & self-supporting BEAM capability
-
BONNA RCCP pipes DESIGN ENGINEERING CW foundations to be specified / verified by geotechnical specialists
-
BONNA RCCP pipes design engineering GEOTECHNICAL CONSIDERATIONS versus CARBON STEEL, GPR/FRP or HDPE pipes
backfill density 1.8
water density 1.0
PIPE MATERIAL density x thickness typical for ND3000
RCCP (rigid, heavier) 2.40 240 mm
Carbon steel (semi-rigid) 7.85 16-22 mm
GRP/FRP (flexible) 1.3-1.9 20-30 mm
HDPE plastic (flexible) 0.95 100-300 mm
The CW pipeline INTRINSIC MATERIAL CHARACTERISTICS (rigidity / flexibility) may be affected and/or determine the FOUNDATION REQUIREMENTS and NATURE and VOLUME of the BACKFILL MATERIAL particularly OFFSHORE.
CONSOLIS & geotechnical specialists should be consulted for suggestions of optimization
-
BONNA RCCP pipes can be designed to behave as a RIGID BEAM and offer more economical ground support solutions than SEMI-FLEXIBLE CARBON
PIPES, particularly with weak soils / risks of differential settlements
RCCP maximum allowable deflection : 1. Curvature depends of pipe diameter and can be dimensioned from internal design
2. Shallow foundations (graded aggregates in geotextile mattress) spread pipe load
3. shallow foundations allow wider span between deep piles compared to semi-rigid carbon steel pipes
RCCP are self-anchoring pipes : they DO NOT REQUIRE massive anchor/thrust blocks.
BONNA RCCP pipes are quite different in their principle compared to steel pipes or GRP/FRP :
Carbon steel pipes/GRP/FRP need sufficient thickness to avoid deformation under external loads (backfill, traffic live load).
RCCP resistance to pressure is provided by thin steel cylinder, resistance to external loads by the reinforced concrete.
RCCP pipe can therefore be economical in low and middle-range pressure such as in power plants usual conditions.
-
BONNA RCCP pipes - GEOTECHNICAL CONSIDERATIONS Allowable Pipeline Curvature & Bending Deflection
Thanks to their inherent rigidity and robustness, BONNA RCCP pipes
Are less sensitive to deformation than carbon steel pipes
Can tolerate full vacuum after an internal depression
Require less precautions during field installation
Bonna RCCP pipes & maximum allowable deflection
Can be designed to act as self-supporting beam
Can be bent to a radius of approx 1000 times the nominal pipe diameter
Curvature depends of pipe diameter - ie ND3800 : 1/400th ie +/-50mm every 20m of pipe section
Overall performance can be improved by combining with SMJ flexible joints & other special fittings
Minimum backfill up to the pipe low angle of support then native as dug material
-
BONNA RCCP pipes A superior solution compared to traditional products
-
BONNA reinforced concrete cylinder pipes (RCCP) Benefits vs OTHER PIPE MATERIALS for power plants cooling systems
Prestressed concrete PCCP Carbon Steel GRP/FRP HDPE Plastic
BONNA RCCP pipes are quite different in their principle compared to steel pipes or GRP/FRP : Steel pipes and GRP/FRP need sufficient thickness to avoid deformation under external loads (backfill, traffic live load).
With RCCP, the resistance to pressure is given by a thin steel cylinder and the resistance to external loads is provided by reinforced concrete.
RCCP pipe can therefore be economical in low and middle-range pressure such as in power plants usual conditions.
-
BONNA RCCP pipes versus CARBON STEEL pipes + LINING
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES Attractive economics / proven durability / maintenance-free / simple installation
Weld inspection by simple PT test
ADVANTAGES of BONNA PIPES SITE INSTALLATION
1. No surface treatments, linings or coatings with pinhole / peeling risk
2. Jointing : straight-forward filet welding assembly & PT inspection
3. Joint closing by simple mortar by mason or semi-skilled labor
4. Pipe closing by lapjoints (supplied as ingredient)
5. Trench reclamation : faster , more economic backfilling with native material, single-layer compaction
6. No cathodic protection maintenance-free passivation
Epoxy multi-coatings
Rubber / Epoxy lining
16-25mm steel thickness + arc
rings (depends of pipe diameter)
Expensive Non-Destructive Examination (NDE)
by Ultrasound or X-ray radiography
Outer self -flow grouting
External welding
for smaller pipes
-
CW pipeline construction: CARBON STEEL PIPES require delicate treatments during fabrication
-
Power plant CW pipeline construction - comparison Bonna Precast Concrete RCCP versus Carbon Steel pipes
TYPICAL SEQUENCE of OPERATIONS 1. Reception numbered pipes on site 2. Ground support foundations & bedding preparation 3. Laying-out the pipe spools / special fittings (Tees, Elbows,
Reducers, Wall crossings, Manholes, Flanges, etc) 4. Fitting of pipe segments with simple jack-pull 5. Two-pass filet weld S-L end-rings or fitting of E-R flexible joints 6. Joint filling inner/outer gap with mortar/self-flow grout 7. Close pipeline with lap-joints 8. Backfill with native material 9. Simple compaction 10. Field trench test with end caps Pre-checked factory QA data Pipeline installation may proceed simultaneously on several fronts. Choice of starting point : at interface or anywhere else. Possibility to modify/repair pipes onsite ABSENCE of costly anchor blocks at every change of direction REQUIRED STAFF & EQUIPMENT Optional ingredients (may be supplied by Bonna) Welders & non-specialist semi-skilled labor Crawler crane for spools lifting & placement Loader for backfilling
Bonna RCCP (typical length 2.00-6.15 ml)
SIMPLE LEGO-LIKE FIELD ASSEMBLY ensures PREDICTABLE planning & budgeting
Carbon steel pipes (typical length 6-12ml)
CHALLENGING onsite QA REQUIREMENTS affect PRODUCTIVITY & COSTS
TYPICAL SEQUENCE of OPERATIONS 1. Build massive concrete anchor / thrust blocks 2. Import source thick steel plates, bevel-cut, roll (onsite QA) 3. Weld plates together by multi-pass welding 4. Weld spur reinforcement rings every 1-2m (ovalisation) 5. Inspection of welds by radiography / ultrasound 6. Prepare surface by sand blasting 7. Apply Inner/External coatings (primer, middle, top layers) in
epoxy, rubber, coal tar 8. Dry curing conditions to be ensured 9. Alignment issues vs conformers 10. Pipe joints assembly by multipass butt-welding 11. Inspection of welds by radiography / ultrasonic testing 12. Close pipeline with lap-joints 13. Install & refill cathodic protection 14. Backfill only with graded material 15. Compacting requires several passes 16. Post-field test integrity (vacuum, ovalization) Cost of non-conformity ? Waste disposal ? REQUIRED STAFF & EQUIPMENT Highly qualified welders Crawler crane for spools lifting & placement Numerous smaller loaders for backfill compaction
-
GRP/FRP PIPES - typical characteristics
Available in lengthy sections
Maximum diameter size ND3000 mm ?
Lightweight material (density 1.3-1.9)
Corrosion resistant for chemical industries and tanks
Time degrading, UV-sensitive material
E Young modulus not constant in time : ovalization / elliptical deformation creates flow rate discrepancy
Quality depends on raw materials must verify grade (stiffness depends of fibers orientation)
Delicate joints assembling by hazardous resins with solvents
Geometrical irregularities of smooth internal surface in annular waves increase boundary layer thickness and head losses
Reduced repairs after installation (
-
BONNA RCCP pipes versus GRP/FRP pipes
1- Inherently robust, not a time-degrading material. 2- No internal lining or outer coating needed. No deterioration risk from UV exposure. 3- No need to protect the pipe against UV during transportation & storage. 4- Totally innocuous jointing material. No hazardous solvents used in lamination joints. 5- Absence of massive anchor blocks at every change of direction. Rigidity allows shallow foundations 6- Simple backfilling with native material. Without tedious multi-layer compaction of graded aggregates. No risk of pipe ovalisation. 7- Comparable roughness coefficient (k = 0.002 mm). Absence of wavy profile at boundary layer. 8- No risk of pipe bursting or collapse under excessive water pressure.
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES Attractive economics / proven durability / maintenance-free / simple installation
-
Available in lengthy sections
Maximum size ND2500 mm
Ultra lightweight material (density 0.95)
Time degrading material, UV-sensitive
Thermo-sensitive to temperature
Massive thrust blocks at each onshore directional change
Underwater laying requires concrete ballast inner grout or external collars or rings.
Butt-fused joints requires special equipment & cooling time
Hardly repairable after installation
HDPE plastic pipes - Main characteristics
-
REFERENCES
PROVEN DURABILITY
-
CONSOLIS Bonna RCCP PIPELINE KEY REFERENCES in ASIA - Energy & Power plants
-
BONNA Reinforced Concrete Cylinder pipes (RCCP) : over 4000 WORLDWIDE REFERENCES in ENERGY, INDUSTRY & WATER SUPPLY
JAPAN
NUCLEAR APPLICATIONS (17% worldwide market share)
SOUTH EAST ASIA
CHINA
EUROPE
AFRICA
FRANCE
AMERICAS EAST ASIA
Toyo
KOREA
POSCO ENGINEERING
-
PRICES
TYPICAL VALUE of BONNA RCCP pipes
-
BONNA PIPES TYPICAL MATERIAL VALUE in USD per linear meter Ex-Works basis
These are approximate figures only, subject to change according to each project specific site conditions (total pipeline length, pressure, backfill, live loads, elevations, interface connections) and owner specific design / engineering requirements. Excluded : transportation (maximum +30%), special fittings (elbows, tees, wyes, reducers, SMJ, wall crossings, manholes, flanges), soil improvement, ground bedding preparation, field assembly installation costs (onshore / offshore). Please consult CONSOLIS or PT Bonna Indonesia for a qualified estimate of your EPC / IPP specific project.
Subject to prior validation for each specific project