counterplans 2
TRANSCRIPT
COUNTERPLANS
STOCK ISSUESHarms
Plan
Solvency
Advantages
STOCK ISSUESHarms
Plan
Solvency
Advantages
COUNTERPLAN
STOCK ISSUESHarms
Plan
Solvency
Advantages
Harms
COUNTERPLAN
STOCK ISSUESHarms
Plan
Solvency
Advantages
Harms
Counterplan
COUNTERPLAN
STOCK ISSUESHarms
Plan
Solvency
Advantages
Harms
Counterplan
Solvency
COUNTERPLAN
STOCK ISSUESHarms
Plan
Solvency
Advantages
Harms
Counterplan
Solvency
Advantages
COUNTERPLAN
HARMSStatus Quo (SQ)
What is bad with the SQ
HARMSStatus Quo (SQ)
What is bad with the SQCan be Gov. harms
COUNTERPLANNon Topical and/or Non-Resolutional
COUNTERPLANNon Topical and/or Non-Resolutional
NO !!!
COUNTERPLANNon Topical and/or Non-Resolutional
Fix the Harms
SOLVENCY“How” the counterplan fixes harms.
(Mechanism)
ADVANTAGESGood stuff that springs from Solvency
“Seeds” of Solvency – Yield the “fruit” of advantages
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGHarms
Nuh, uhYesYes, but
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGCounterplans
It is T or ResolutionalInherency
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGSolvency
Nuh, uh *********Alternate Causality (Prime Causality)Yes, but
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGSolvency
Nuh, uh *********Alternate Causality (Prime Causality)Yes, butWe solve better
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGAdvantages
No Solvency = No AdvantagesNuh, uhYes, but
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGAdvantages
No Solvency = No AdvantagesNuh, uhYes, butOur advantages are better
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGPermutations (Government Answers)
Do both
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGPermutations (Government Answers)
Do bothDo both at different times
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGPermutations (Government Answers)
Do bothDo both at different times
Permutations (Opposition Answers)
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGPermutations (Government Answers)
Do bothDo both at different times
Permutations (Opposition Answers)Mutually exclusive
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGPermutations (Government Answers)
Do bothDo both at different times
Permutations (Opposition Answers)Mutually exclusiveGov. plan still links to the D/A
COUNTERPLANS- ANSWERINGDisadvantages (Still Links to the D/A)
UniquenessLinkMPX