depression and suicidality in first episode psychosis: subordination and shame
TRANSCRIPT
Abstracts of the 4th Biennial Schizophrenia International Research Conference / Schizophrenia Research 153, Supplement 1 (2014) S1–S384 S11
suicide-related behaviour in young people and the to examine in more
detail the evidence for a range of interventions designed to reduce risk that
could inform both clinical practice and government policy.
Methods: Three systematic reviews, and one narrative review, were con-
ducted in order to examine the range, and effectiveness, of interventions
designed to reduce suicide risk among young people, in clinical, school-
based and online settings. For each of the reviews conducted suicide-related
behaviour had to be a primary outcome of interest.
Results: Suicide prevention in clinical settings: Fifteen published trails were
included. Of them two targeted young people with mood disorders, one
targeted young people with borderline personality disorder and one study
targeted young people with a psychotic disorder. Interventions included
(but are not restricted to): medication, a family-based intervention, dialec-
tical behavioural therapy, problem-solving therapy, cognitive behavioural
therapy and group therapy. No differences were found between treatment
and control groups except in one study that found a difference in rates
of suicidal ideation between individual cognitive behavioural therapy and
treatment as usual. Suicide prevention in school settings: Forty-three stud-
ies were included here, of which 15 reported on universal education or
awareness programs, 23 reported on selective interventions (e.g. gatekeeper
training and screening programs), 3 reported on targeted interventions, and
2 examined a postvention response in schools. Of these studies the most
promising appeared to be gatekeeper training and screening programs,
although more research is necessary. Suicide prevention in online settings:
These reviews found that, despite the number, and potential effectiveness
of, online programs for young people with depression and/or anxiety dis-
orders, there are currently no published studies reporting on the effects
of online therapy for suicidal youth. Similarly a number of studies have
been found that discuss the relationship between suicide and social media,
however despite the popularity and the potential reach of social media, no
actual interventions studies were identified.
Discussion: Overall it is concluded that whilst we know much about the
epidemiology of suicide among youth, there is a dearth of well-conducted
studies that provide adequate evidence regarding what works in youth sui-
cide prevention. This has implications both clinically and at a policy level. A
greater emphasis on intervention studies – including novel interventions –
would lead to better practice in terms of detecting and supporting suicidal
young people, and could also contribute to a better informed, and more
evidence-based, policy agenda around the world.
PSYCHOTIC EXPERIENCES AS A PREDICTOR OF THE NATURAL COURSE OF
SUICIDAL IDEATION: A SWEDISH COHORT STUDY
Ian Kelleher1, Martin Cederlöf2, Paul Lichtenstein2
1Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm,
Sweden; 2Karolinska Institutet, Department of Medical Epidemiology and
Biostatistics, Nobels vag 12A, 17177 Stockholm, Sweden
Background: Psychotic experiences are far more prevalent in the popu-
lation than psychotic disorders and are associated with a wide range of
depressive, anxiety and behavioral disorders, as well as increased risk for
psychotic disorder. Recently, psychotic experiences have been highlighted
as a potentially valuable clinical marker of risk for suicidal behavior. There
have been few studies to date, however, to assess psychotic experiences as
a predictor of suicidality over time.
Method: Wewished to assess whether young persons with suicidal ideation
at baseline assessment who reported psychotic experiences were at higher
risk for persistence of suicidal ideation at follow up than young persons
who also reported suicidal ideation at baseline but who did not report
co-occurring psychotic experiences. A total of 2,263 Swedish adolescents
were assessed at ages 13 to 14 years for psychotic experiences, suicidal
ideation and internalizing and externalizing psychopathology. Participants
were re-assessed at ages 16 to 17 years and 19 to 20 years.
Results: Among 13- to 14-year olds with suicidal ideation, co-occurring
psychotic experiences did not predict an increased odds of persistence of
suicidal ideation to 16 to 17 years (OR=0.94, 95%CI=0.19-4.78). Among 16-
to 17-year olds with suicidal ideation, however, co-occurring psychotic
experiences predicted a 6-fold increased odds of persistence of suicidal
ideation to ages 19 to 20 years (OR=5.53, 95%CI=1.33-23.00). This finding
was not explained by internalizing or externalizing psychopathology or by
cannabis use.
Discussion: Although most suicidal ideation is transient and does not re-
quire close clinical attention, for some individuals, suicidal ideation becomes
persistent, causing long-term morbidity, mental distress and ultimately in-
creasing the risk of attempted and completed suicide. Identification of
individuals whose suicidal ideation is likely to become persistent, then,
is an important, if complex, challenge in clinical psychiatry. Our results
show that psychotic experiences are an important, but under-recognized,
marker of risk for persistence of suicidal ideation, in particular from mid-
adolescence. An increased emphasis on the clinical assessment of psychotic
experiences in mental health services should be a priority
DEPRESSION AND SUICIDALITY IN FIRST EPISODE PSYCHOSIS:
SUBORDINATION AND SHAME
Rachel Upthegrove1,2, Jonathan Ives3, Amrita Sandhu3, Lisa Jones3,
Kerry Ross4, Katerine Brunet4
1University of Birmingham; 2Early Intervention Service; 3School of Clinical and
Experimental Medicine, University of Birmingham; 4Early Intervention Service,
Birmingham and Solihull Mental Helath Trust
Suicidal behaviour in early psychosis is linked to depression and hope-
lessness, however the meaning and mechanisms of this association is
understudied. We may accept a depressive dimension in psychosis, in
keeping with a dimensional rather than categorical approach, however
our concepts of this depression here has been transported wholesale from
unipolar affective disorders. It is not clear that this is a valid approach.
We will present a series of short papers exploring the development and
phenomenology of depression and suicidal thinking in early psychosis. We
aimed initially to have a clearer understanding of the ebb and flow of
depression and suicidal thinking in the early phase of psychosis, whether
these events are predictable and how they relate to the early course of
psychotic symptoms. Ninety-two patients with first episode psychosis (FEP)
completed measures of self harm, hopelessness, depression, and duration of
untreated psychosis. Follow-up took place over 12 months. A combination
of depression and suicidal thinking was present in 63%. Depression in the
prodromal phase was the most significant predictor of future depression
and acts of self-harm and thus may be key to the development of fu-
ture depression and suicidal thinking. Exploring the relationship between
early psychotic symptoms and suicidal ideation in detail, we examined the
relationship of depression and suicidal thinking with appraisal of illness,
voices and persecutors. Prospective data was gathered on 72 patients with
acute FEP on depression, severity and experience of positive symptoms,
insight and appraisals of illness using validated interviews over12 months.
Malevolent voices, use of safety behaviours and subordination to persecu-
tors was associated with depression and suicidal behaviour in acute FEP.
Loss, shame, low level continuing positive symptoms and longer duration
of untreated psychosis were associated with post psychotic depression.
Negative appraisals remained stable despite recovery in other symptom
domains. Thus depression in early psychosis may be propagated by the
personal significance and content of positive symptoms experienced in FEP.
In recovery, low level symptoms, longer period of illness and negative
appraisals are significant factors. Using novel qualitative methodology, we
went on to explore the subjective experience and phenomenological fea-
tures of post-psychotic depression using photo-elicitation and unstructured
interviews. The psychotic episode was a traumatic event followed by sub-
jective doubt, shame and embarrassment. Common biological symptoms
of depression did not feature. Participants rather felt that the psychotic
episode had destroyed their personality and identity, leading to a loss of
role, status and suicidal ideation; “It’s a feeling of worthlessness, feeling of
no hope, feeling of you’re useless to anything, anyone . . . you got nothing
to look forward to, it’s all taken away from you.” Efforts to predict and
reduce suicide in psychosis may need to target the early phase of illness to
reduce later risk. Understanding this dimension of psychosis in and of itself
has the potential to improve and aid development of more effective and
appropriately targeted interventions.