diary section 6

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

1

The Clerk to the Patents Court Web Site: www.hmcourts-service.gov.uk

ARCHIVE OF PATENTS TRIALS AND APPLICATIONS

4 DECEMBER 1997 TO 31 DECEMBER 2002 Chancery Number 96 A 86. Abeco Ltd v Tavismanor Ltd Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Roger Wyand QC One Raymond Buildings Wragge & Co Mr Richard Miller QC & Mr Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Bird & Bird.

Result Action dismissed with costs. Particulars of objection certified as reasonable. Finding of non-infringement. No finding of invalidity. Leave to appeal on issue of costs refused. See Patents web site for full judgment

2 days 8 12 97

Chancery Number 96 S 7434 A M Sandman v Panasonic UK Ltd Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Michael Silverleaf QC.11 South Square Linklaters Mr Henry Whittle 11 South Square Kingsley Napley 0171 814 1200 Mr Osborne

Result Judgment 21 1 98 See Patents web site for full judgment

1 day 18 12 97

Chancery Number 95 H 7418 In The Matter of the Registered Designs Act 1949-88 and in The Matter of Registered Design No 2044802 in the name of Household Articles Limited and in The Matter of Bodum (UK) Limited for the rectification of the Register of Designs by the deletion of the registration. Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr George Hamer 8 New Square. Clifford Chance Mr Mills 0171 600 1000 Mr Richard Hacon 11 South Square Mr Berry 0171 208 8888

Result Judgment 22 1 98

3 days 14.1.98

Chancery Number 95 P 7585 Oy Parok AB v Jonesco (Preston) Limited Mr Justice Pumfrey

Result Action dismissed. Patent 2110157 revoked. Orders made as to cost. See Patents web site for full judgment

3 days 24.11.97

Chancery Number 97 C 2546 Appeal 1/97 - Fosroc

Representatives P Gladwin & Co 01494 862436 Laurence Shaw & Associates 0121 454 4692

Result Appeal withdrawn 23 12 97

1 day 19 1 98

Chancery Number 93 E 7192 Uni-Continental Holdings Ltd v Eurobond Adhesives Ltd Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Richard Mead 8 New Square Hamilton Downing 0171 831 8939 Mr Colin Birss 3 New Square. Hammond Suddards 0171 448 1000

Result Judgment handed down Monday 2 2 98 See Patents web site for full judgment

Estimate 6 days 8.12.97 Ran 6 days

Chancery Number 94 B 2945 Valmet v Beloit

Result Settled

Chancery Number 94 S 1719 Sandvick v Pfiffner

Representatives Mr Andrew Waugh 3 New Square Mr Richard Arnold 11 South Square

Result Order made for directions.

1 day 8.12.97

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

2

Chancery Number 97 1 1454 TWR v ICO

Representatives Mr David Kitchin QC 8 New Square & Mr Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Simmons & Simmons. Mr R Freeland 0171 628 2020 Mr Peter Prescott QC 8 New Square. Clifford Chance Mr J Hornby 0171 600 1000

Result Settled 9.1 98

10 days 25.6.98

Chancery Number 96 B 817 SmithKline Beecham & Anr v Norton Healthcare & Lek

Representatives Mr Christopher Floyd QC & Mr Mark VanHegan 11 South Square Dibb Lupton Alsop 0345 262 728 Mr David Kitchin QC 8 New Square & Dr Justin Turner 3 New Square & Mr Tom Moody-Smith 8 New Square. Simmons & Simmons. Mr M Hodgson 0171 628 2020 Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square & Mr Henry Whittle & Dr Piers Acland 11 South Square. RoiterZuker.Mrs Mackay 0171 328 9111

Result Settled 24 12 97

15 days 19.1.98

Chancery Number 95 T 203 Targetti v Altima Lighting

Representatives Mr Richard Meade 8 New Square. Eversheds Paul Garland 0171 919 4500 Mr Adrian Speck 8 New Square. Dawson & Co. Dorothy Briffa 0171 404 5941

Result Settled by consent 21 1 98

3 days 26.1.98

Chancery Number 96 O 4446 Otto (UK) Ltd v Bayne Machine Works

Representatives Mr Richard Hacon 11 South Square. Rickerby Watterson 01242 224422 Mr Graham Shipley 19 Old Buildings Trowers & Hamlins 0171 831 6292 Mr J Linwood

Result Settled 19.12.97

7/10 days 19.1.98

Chancery Number 97 B 5657 (Long application) BBC Worldwide v Pally Screen and others Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr John Baldwin QC 8 New Square. Lane & Partners 0171 242 2626 J V Fitzgerald New Court Temple. Edge & Ellison, Leicester 0116 247 0123

Result Summary judgment refused

1 day 26 1 98

Chancery Number 97 B 4299 Appeal Besalon v South Strong Industries

Representatives Mr Michael Fysh QC. 8 New Square. Edwards Evans & Co. Mr T Johnson 0171 405 4916 Mr Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Maycocks 0171 375 0586

Result Appeal allowed. Design cancelled.

1 day 17.12.97

Chancery Number 94 F 5139 Fylde Microsoft Systems v Key Radio Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Iain Purvis 11 South Square. Harrison, Drury Starkie 01772 258321 Mr Guy Tritton One Raymond Buildings Clifford Cowling 01252 725006

Result Judgment 11.2.98 See Patents web site for full judgment

3 days 27.1.98

Chancery Number 96 L 2620 Carrol Products & Design v Superframe Group plc

Representatives Mr Richard Arnold 11 South Square Goodman Derrick 0171 404 0606 ref TL Mr Roger Wyand QC One Raymond Buildings. Bird & Bird 0171 415 6000


2/3 days 2.2.98

Chancery Number 97 Z 2149 Zweva Holdings & Anr v Valley Industries & Ors

Representatives Mr John Baldwin QC 8 New Square & Miss J Reid 11 South Square. Maycocks Mr Peter McBride 375 0586 Roger Wyand QC One Raymond Buildings & Mr Colin Birss 3 New Square Travers Smith Braithwaight 248 9133 Miss Whitley


3 days 9.3.98

Chancery Number 96 H 51 Hoechst Celanese Corp v BP Chemicals Mr Justice Jacob

Representatives Antony Watson QC & Andrew Waugh 3 New Square. Taylor Joynson Garrett. Mr Price 0171 353 1234 David Young QC & Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Bird & Bird Mr Jenkins 0171 415 6000

Result Judgment 26.3.98. Mr Justice Jacob See Patents web site for full judgment

8 days 9 2 98

Chancery Number 97 P 6934 (Appeal) IN THE MATTER of the Trade Marks Act 1938 (as amended)

Estimate 1/2 day 9.3.98

Chancery Number 97 B 1495/6. Mr Justice Pumfrey Boston Scientific v Palmaz Expandable

Estimate 8 days 23.3.98

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

3

AND IN THE MATTER of Trade Mark Application No 1,478,638 by Perfetti SpA to Register the mark “CHLORALIT”) IN CLASS 30 AND IN THE MATTER of an Opposition thereto under opposition No 34430 by Warner Lambert Company. Mr Daniel Alexander , 8 New Square Mr Guy Tritton, One Raymond Buildings

Result Appeal allowed with costs.

Ran 1/2 day

Crafts Representatives

Mr David Kitchin QC 8 New Square & Mr A Waugh 3 New Square. Eversheds. Mr M Burden 0171 919 4500 Mr Michael Silverleaf QC 11 South Square. & Miss Emma Hinsworth 1 Essex Court. Linklaters & Paines 0171 606 7080


Ran 8 days

Chancery Number 97 P 4101 & 4100 Philips Electronics NV v Video Duplicating Company & Philips Electronics NV v Ingman Ltd Mr Justice Laddie Mr Paul Lasok QC Moncton Chambers, 4 Raymond Buildings and Mr Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Bristows Cooke & Carpmael 0171 400 8000 Mr Nicholas Green Brick Court Chambers, 15-19 Devereux Court. Hammond Suddards 0171 655 1000


3 days 16.3.98

Chancery Number 97 S 4108 Smith Kline Beecham v Connought Laboratories Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Andrew Waugh & Mr Colin Birss and Mr Adrian Speck. 3 & 8 New Square Stringer Saul Mrs Steinfeld 0171 631 4048 Mr Simon Thorley QC and Mr Daniel Alexander. 3 & 8 New Square. Bird & Bird Dr Gaythwaite 0171 415 6000

Result 5.5.98 On respondent offering to surrender patent, order for revocation and consequential orders made. Part of the petitioner’s cost be paid on indemnity basis. Judgment given.

8/10 days 6 5 98

Chancery Number 97 C 1489 Compaq Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Henry Carr 11 South Square. Bird & Bird. 0171 415 6000 Mr Ward Mr Michael Edenborough One Raymond Buildings. Gordons 0171 421 9421

Result Judgment given 23.3.98.

3 days 23 3 98

Chancery Number 97 W 6881 Wheelwash Limited v Wheelclean (International) Limited & anr.

Representatives Mr Lissack QC 35 Essex Sreet and Heather Lawrence 11 South Square. Wacks Caller, Manchester Mr Graham Shipley 19 Old Buildings. Halliwell Landau, Manchester 0161 835 3003 Mr George Hamer 8 New Square. Berrymans Lace Mawer

Result Settled on third day of trial. Order made.

5 days 11.5.98

Chancery Number 95 C 2014 Carflow Products (UK) Limited v Linwodd Securities & ors Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Denise McFarland 3 New Square Martineau Johnson 0121 200 3300 Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square.. Travers Smith Braithwaite 0171 248 9133


1 day 25 3 98

Chancery Number 96 U 6421 Unilever Plc v Carter-Wallace Ltd

Representatives Mr Antony Watson QC 3 New Square & Mr Daniel Alexander 8 New Square. Herbert Smith. Laura Deacon 0171 374 8000 Mr Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square & Mr Henry Carr 11 South Square. Needham & Grant 0171 241 5866


3 days 22.6.98

Chancery Number 97 O 1923. WL 80/98 Oneac v Raychem Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr John Baldwin QC & Mr Richard Meade 8 New Square. Hammond Suddards. Mr L Cohen 0171 655 1000. Mr A Watson QC 3 New Square & Mr James St Ville 8 New Square. Bird & Bird. Mr Broadhurst

3 days 30.3.98

Chancery Number 94 D 2438 Davis v Ecoprogress Ltd

Representatives Mr Tom Mitcheson 3 New Square. Gold Mann & Co 583 1407 Mr Marshall Andrew Norris 3 New Square


3 days 10.6.98

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

4

0171 415 6000 Result

Judgment 7.5.98 See Patents web site for full judgment Chancery Number 97 D 5697 84/98 Siegfreid Demel v C & H Jefferson & anr Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. D Martin & Co 01892 541292 Mr Robert Onslow 8 New Square. Berrymans 0171 638 2811


2 days 6.4.98

Chancery Number 97 B 5768 125/98 British Technology Group Ltd v Depuy Orthopaedics Inc. Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Christopher Floyd QC 11 South Square. Bird & Bird. Ms Brazell Mr Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square and Mr David Lloyd Jones Brick Court Chambers. Simmons & Simmons 628 2020 Mr Mooney


15 6 98 2/3 days

Chancery Number 97 J 6736 Joan Philomena Jones

Representatives Fry Heath & Spence. 01293 776880 Comptroller General. The Patent Office

Result Withdrawn. 28.3.98.

29 3 98 Half day

Chancery Number 97 N 2698 Mr Justice Jacob Bristol-Myers Sqibb Company v Baker Norton Pharmaceuticals and Napro Biotherapeutics Inc

Representatives Mr Andrew Waugh and Justin Turner 3 New Square. Simmons & Simmons Dr G Kamstra 628 2020 Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square and Mr Piers Acland 11 South Square. Roiter Zucker Mrs McKay 0171 328 9111. Mr Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square and Mr Roger Wyand QC One Raymond Buildings. Bird & Bird. Ms Audrey Horton 0171 415 6000

Result See Patents web site for full judgment

4 days 6.7.98

Chancery Number 97 M 6198 Mod-tap W Corp v Communication Trade Supplies

Representatives Mr Colin Birss 3 New Square Taylor Joynson Garrett Mr Ian Purvis 11 South Square


22.6.98 2 days

Chancery Number 96 V 7408 Visx Incorporated v Nidek Company Limited Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Mr Antony Watson QC & Mr Justin Turner 3 New Square. Lovell White Durrant Mr Macfarlane 0171 236 0066 Mr Christopher Floyd QC & Mr Iain Purvis 11 South Square. Rowe & Maw 0171 248 4282


7 days 20.7.98

Chancery Number 96 D 161 84/98 Discovision Associates v Discotronics Ltd & Anr Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Watson QC, Guy Burkill & Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Lovell White Durrant Antony Harper 0171 236 0066 Mr Martin Howe QC & Mr Richard Meade 8 New Square. Macfarlanes Mr A Millmore 0171 831 9222

Result Judgment reserved 14.5.98. Judgment on 29.7.98 See Patents web site for full judgment


Transferred to Birmingham. Chancery Number 97 H 3960 Hadley Industries PLC v Metal Sections Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Mr Henry Carr 11 South Square. Wragge & Co 0121 233100 Miss Denise McFarland 3 New Square. Eversheds 0115 9507000 Niall Head-Rapson


3 days 22.9.98

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

5

Chancery Number 97 M 5179 Modtap Corporation v BI Communications PLC

Representatives Mr Colin Birss 3 New Square. Taylor Joynson Garrett Mr Thornham 0171 353 1234 Mr Robert Onslow 8 New Square Hewitson Becke & Shaw 01223 461155 Mr Niel Ackerman dealing

Result Settled on second day of trial, 11.6.98


Chancery Number 97 P 5304 Personal Care BV & anr Pifco Ltd v Philips Domestic Appliances Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr David Kitchin QC and Mr Richard Meade 8 New Square. Bristows Cooke Mr Brown 0171 400 8000 Mr Piers Acland 11 South Square Bird & Bird


Estimate 2days 5.10.98 Ran 3 days

Chancery Number 96 B 4432 Braided International Lines v Fly Fishing Corp Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Ashley Roughton One Raymond Buildings. Martineau Johnson 0121 200 3300 Miss Sarah Ludlum Mr Alastair Wilson QC and Mr Peter Colley 19 Old Buildings. Edwards Geldard 01222 238 239 Mr Kempton.



Chancery Number 95 C 7494 WL 311/97 Charlsworth v Relay Roads Ltd Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Mr Mark Platts-Mills QC & Mr Michael Tappin 8 New Square. Dibb Lupton Alsop Graeme Orchison 0345 262 7288. Miss Fiona Clark and Mr Tom Moody-Stuart 8 New Square. Schneider & Co. Mr Simon Page 242 1711.

Result Judgment 1 February 1999 See Patents web site for full judgment


Chancery Number 97 M 5925 Mul-T-Lock & Anr v Wishside Limited & Anr Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr James Mellor 8 New Square, Hammond Suddards Mr Richard Miller QC and Mr T Mitcheson 3 New Square Needham & Grant. Mr A Cooke 01712425866


2 days 15 7 98

Chancery Number 95 H 4657 B61/98 Hewitt v McCann

Representatives Mr Robert Onslow 8 New Square. Davies Arnold Cooper Mr Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Wragge & Co 0121233 1000 Mr Barron

Result Settled 10 10 98 Order made

2 days 16.11.98

Chancery Number 96 C 6792. W/L 374.97 Consaf Engineering v Emtunga Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Colin Birss 3 New Square Bird & Bird Mr Chahil 0171 415 6000 Mr Richard Arnold 11 South Square. Slaughter & May ref CJH


Estimate 4 days 29 6 98 Ran 4 days

Chancery Number 98 B 2512 WL 287/98 Balmoral Group Ltd v CRP Marne Ltd & anr Mr Justice Jacob

Representatives Denise McFarland and Andrew Norris 3 New Square. Moon Beaver, Mr Norris Alastair Wilson QC and Rory Sullivan 19 Old Buildings


3 days 16 11 98

Chancery Number 97 P 7012 Pollypipe v Lewis Russell Jackson

Representatives Mr Michael Hicks 19 Old Buildings Miss Jacqueline Reid 11 South Square .Order 14 refused on 21.7.98

Estimate 1 day 10.7.98 Ran 1 day

Chancery Number 97 B 6228 WL 35/98 Bayer Corp v Octarpharma Ltd Mr Michael FyshQC sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge

Representatives Simon Thorley QC and Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Simmons & Simmons Antony Watson QC 3 New Square and Daniel Alexander 8 New Square. Bristows 0171400 8000 Mr Ralph Cox.


Chancery Number 98 F 2169 Christopher Simon French v Paul Julian

Estimate 1 day

Chancery Number 97 B 3851 Cartonneries DE Thulin SA v White Knight

3 days 30 11 98

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

6

Mason & anr Mr Justice Pumfrey Mr Richard Arnold and Mr J Shaw 11 South Square Jacobsons 222 Strand London. ref SJK Miss Catherine Newman QC 13 Old Square. Wragge & Co


20.7.98 Ran 1 day

Products Ltd. Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Mr Henry Carr QC 11 South Square and Michael Tappin 8 New Square Dibb Lupton Mr Kirby 0171 814 6351 Mr David Young QC and Mr Justin Turner 3 New Square


Chancery Number 97 M 3722 Norton Health Care v 3M - The 610 Patent Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square & Mr Henry Carr 11 South Square. RoiterZucker Mrs McKay 0171 328 9111 Mr David Kitchin QC & Mr Michael Tappin 8 New Square. Linklaters & Paines. Mr N Jones 0171456 2000


5 days 22.7.98

Chancery Number 98 W 1063 B 86/98 Davina Wheatley & anr v Drillsafe Ltd & ors. Mr Justice Ferris

Representatives Mr Mark Vanheagan 11 South Square Mr Michael Edenborough 1 Raymond Buildings

Result Judgment reserved 4 12 98 See Patents web site for full judgment

2 days 2 12 98

Chancery Number 97 B 5540 Bradley Glass Ltd v Temple Components ltd

Representatives Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square. Beechcroft Stanleys Thomas Moody-Stuart 8 New Square

Result Withdrawn 29 7 98 and refixed to General Chancery list for 22 2 99.

1 day 31 7 98

Chancery Number 96 L 2139 350/97 Lighting Electronics v Thorne Lighting. Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr M Hicks 19 Old Buildings. Bevan Ashford Mr Lomas 01392 411111 Mr Henry Whittle 11 South Square. Bird & Bird 0171 415 6000

Result Judgment reserved 7 12 98 See Patents web site for full judgment

Estimate5 days 26 1198 Ran 7days

Chancery Number 97 Q 3885 Quadrant Holdings v Quadrant Bio Resources Ltd. Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Richard Seymour QC 4 Raymond Buildings & Mr Henry Carr 11 South Square. Bristows Cooke & Carpmael 0171 400 8000 Mr Charles Falconer QC Brick Court Chambers and Tom Moody Stuart 8 New Square.Hewitson Becke & Shaw. 01223461155 Mr Niel Ackermann dealing.

Result Judgement 27 11 98 See Patents web site for full judgment.

Estimate 5 /7 days 2 9 97 Ran 6 days

Chancery Number 94 S 1719 Sandvik v Pfiffner Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Nicholas Green QC Brick Court Chambers Herbert Smith. Duncan Curley Sinclair Roche & Temperley


Estimate2 days 8 12 98 Ran 2 days

Chancery Number 98 C 2437 In the matter of an application for appeal by Simon P Carrington patent number GB2261136.

Representatives Simon Carrington Mr Daniel Alexander 8 New Square The Comptroller General, Patents Office, Cardiff, Wales

Result Appeal dismissed.

Estimate 1 day 30 7 98 Ran 1/2 day

Chancery Number 96 M 768. 88/98 WL 88/98 Melea v Cimpress

Representatives Mark Platts-Mills 8 New Square Field Fisher Waterhouse. Mr Jennings. 481 4841 G Hobbs QC and Mr Edenborough 1 Raymond Buildings


3 days 18 1.99

Chancery Number 95 H 3456 10/12 Chancery Number 98 O 1102. B217/98 1day

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

7

Hoechst Celanese Corporation v BP Chemicals and Purolite Int. Ltd (account of profits) Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Antony Watson QC & Mr Andrew Waugh QC 3 New Square. Taylor Joynson Garrett Mr Price 0171 353 1234 Mr David Young QC & Mr Guy Burkill 3 New Square Bird & Bird Mr Jenkins 0171 415 6000

Result Judgment given on 16 10 98 See Patents web site for full judgment

days 16 9 98

Isaac Oren & anr v Red Box Toy Factory & Ors Isaac Oren & anr v Martin Yaffe International Limited Mr Justice Jacob

Representatives Ashley Roughton 1 Raymond Buildings Llewwlyn Zietman 0171 842 5400 & Turner Parkinson 0161 833 1212 and Charles Russell 0171 203 5000 Peter Prescott QC 8 New Square Schneider & Coy Ernest Schneider


25 1 99 Ran 1 day

Chancery Number 98 E 3801 Eli Lilly v Novo Nordisk

Representatives Mr Michael Silverleaf QC 11 South Square. Linklaters Mr Ian Karet 0171 456 2000 Mr Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square Taylor Joynson Garrett 0171 353 1234 Mr James Marshall.

Result Directions given

1 day 12 10 98

Chancery Number 98 R 846 Reflective Technology Industries Ltd v Reflective Technologies

Representatives Mr Michael Hicks 19 Old Buildings Heather Lawrence 11 South Square


2-3 days 1 2 99

Chancery Number 97 S 5754. WL65/98 Samsung Electronics v Fujitsu Micro

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Mr Richard Meade. 8 New Square. Simmons & Simmons Mr Simon Thorley QC and Mr Guy Burkill, 3 New Square. Bird & Bird

Result Settled. 16.9.98

5 days 13.10 98

Chancery Number 97 B 5540 Bradley Glass Ltd v Temple Components Ltd

Representatives Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square . Beechcroft Stanley. Mr Jonathon Radcliffe Mr Thomas Moody-Stuart. 8 New Square


22 2 99 3 days

Chancery Number 97 S 4108 Smithkline Beecham Biologicals SA v Connaught Laboratories Inc Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives David Young QC and Adrian Speck 3 New Square. Stringer Saul. Mrs Steinfeld Daniel Alexander 8 New Square Bird & Bird. D Wilson


1 day 21 10 98

Chancery Number 98 N 131 Napp Pharmaceutical Ltd v Asta Medica Ltd Mr Justice Jacob

Representatives Christopher Floyd QC and Richard Hacon 11 South Square. Lovell White Durrant 0171 236 0066 ref 239/C Antony Watson QC and Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Bristows. 0171 400 8000 Mr Frankel. Result Settled 22 3 99

2 days 24 3 99

Chancery Number 98 N 131 Napp Pharmeceutical Group Ltd v Asta Medica Ltd. Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Christopher Floyd QC and Richard Hacon 11 South Square. Lovell White Durrant 0171 236 0066 ref 239/C Richard Miller QC and Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Bristows. 0171 400 8000 Mr Frankel.


1 day 23 10 98

Chancery Number 95 C 3418 Colpac Ltd v St Neots Packaging Ltd Mr Justice Jacob

Representatives Mr James Mellor and James Abrahams 8 New Square. Withers 936 1000 Nichole Hirst Mr Michael Hicks 19 Old Buildings. Barrel Alexander Chart. 242 4422. Peter Mooch


19 April 1999 8 days

Chancery Number 96 W 428 and 98 W 806 Tanis Patricia Wakefield v Maxon Cellular

7/10 days 10 5 98

Chancery Number 98 E 3801 60/99 Eli Lilly & Co v Novo Nordisk

3 days 26 4 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

8

Systems. Representatives

Mr Richard Meade 8 New Square. Wragge & Co. Mr Harris 0121 233 1000 Mr Guy Burkill & Mr Tom Mitcheson 3 New Square. Eversheds. Miss Henders 01222 71147.

Result Action Ch 96 W 428 Settled 29 10 98. Action Ch 98 W 806 awaits trial as shown

Mr Justice Jacob Representatives

Simon Thorley QC and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Taylor Joynson Garrett 0171 353 1234 Mr Hodgson Michael Silverleaf QC 11 South Square Linklaters 0171 456 2000 Mr Karet

Result See Patents web site for full judgment

Chancery Number 98 R 277 Raintex Ltd v C & A (Order 14)

Representatives Mr James Pickering Enterprise Chambers, Ian Guyster & Co Mr Jon Turner Monckton Chambers.

Result Withdrawn 30 10 98

1 day 4.11.98

Chancery Number 97 I 3442. WL 196/98 Tesco v Instore Products Mr Justice Jacob

Representatives Christopher Floyd QC 11 South Square and Douglas Campbell 3 New Square Denise McFarland 3 New Square


3 days 10 5 99

Chancery Number 98 P 1661 Pat 1/98 In the matter of an application for appeal by Charalambous Portelli Patent Number - GB2288679A. Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Charalambous Portelli in person. Mr Daniel Alexander 8 New Square. The Comptroller General, Patents Office, Cardiff, Wales

Result Appeal dismissed with costs.

1/2 day 2.11.98

Chancery Number Ch 98 T 315 Tetra Pak Food & Beverage System AG v APV UK Ltd

Representatives Antony Watson QC and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Bristows Mr Brown 400 8000 Simon Thorley QC and Douglas Campbell 3 New Square Slaughter & May Mr C Kickson 600 1200


17 5 99 5 days

Chancery Number 96 R 3171 & 96 R 5680 Bourns Inc v Raychem Corp & ors. Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Michael Silverleaf QC 11 South Square Michael Bloch QC 1 Essex Court

Result Judgment 9.30am 17 11 98. See Patents web site for full judgment

PtHd from 22.10.98 Next on - 11.30am 2 11 98 & 10 30am 3 11 98

Chancery Number 99 W 0380 & 98 P 5484 Worldwide Snakeboard Marketing Limited & ors v PMS International Far East Limited

Representatives. 3 New Square Henry Carr QC 11 South Square


24 5 99 5 days

Chancery Number 97 P 4101 & 4100 Philips Electronics NV v Video Duplicating Company & Philips Electronics NV v Ingman Ltd Antony Watson QC and Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Bristows 0171 400 8000 Peter Prescott QC and Fiona Clark and James St Ville 8 New Square. Hammond Suddards 0171 655 1000


5/7days 1.3.99

Chancery Number 97 H 3960. 4-5 October 1999 Hadley Industries PLC v Metal Sections Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Mr Henry Carr 11 South Square. Wragge & Co 0121 233100 Miss Denise McFarland 3 New Square.Eversheds 0115 9507000 Niall Head-Rapson Mr Justice Neuberger Judgment 21 10 99 Not handed down. Not on the web site

2 days 5 10 99

Chancery Number 98 W 806 WL 99/98. Wakefield v Ericsson

Representatives. Henry Carr QC and Ian Purvis 11 South Square.

Result Consent Order made. Trial withdrawn. 10.11.98

7/10 days 4 5 99

HC 99 00505 B 73/99 Thermos Ltd v Aladdin Sales & Marketing Ltd Mr Justice Jacob

Representatives Douglas Campbell 3 New Square Taylor Joynson Garrett. Mr Benson 353 1234 Guy Burkill 3 New Square Garretts Mr Richard 344 0344

Result

2 days 25 10 99 Fixed 25 5 99 Ran 1 day

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

9

Judgment 26 10 99. Not on web site Chancery Number 96 C 4344 WL 211/97 Co-Flexip Stort Comex Seaway Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Richard Miller QC & Justin Turner 3 New Square. Clifford Chance Miss Croft Mr Antony Watson QC and Mr Thomas Hinchcliffe 3 New Square Bird & Bird Miss Stephens 415 6000

Result Judgment 22 1 99 See Patents Court web site for full judgment

5 days 9.11.98

HC 03090 Novartis v Roy Calne Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Henry Carr QC 11 South Square Bristows John Baldwin QC M Tappin and Lindsay Lane 8 New Square Linklaters. Jeremy Brown


2 days 2pm

2 11 99

ran for 2 days

Chancery Number 97 B 4885/6 Boston Scientific v Cordis

Representatives Mr David Kitchin QC and Mr Richard Meade 8 New Square & Mr Andrew Waugh 3 New Square. Eversheds. Mr M Burdon 0171 919 4500 Mr Michael Silverleaf 11 South Square & Miss Emma Himsworth 1 Essex Court. Linklaters & Paines Mr Bird 0171 606 7080

Result Settled. August 1998.

5 /7 days 2311 98

Chancery Number 96 R 7835 Rolac Ltd v Gatley Engineering Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square D Micklethwaite One Raymond Buildings Chancer Number 96 R 7834 Rolac Ltd v Passenger Lift Services Mark Vanheagen 11 South Square Denise McFarland 3 New Square

Result Settled

4 days 1 11 99 fixed 2 3 99

Chancery Number 97 T 1174 Tyco Toys & anr v Tomy

Representatives Mr Christopher Floyd QC and Mr Richard Arnold 11 South Square. Simmons & Simmons Mr Antony Watson QC 3 New Square and Mr Richard Meade 8 New Square. Denton Hall


7 days 7.12.98

Chancery Number 98 S 5905 Sara Lee Household & Bodycare UK Ltd v Johnson Wax Ltd Mr David Young QC

Representatives Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square and Michael Tappin 8 New Square. Bristows. Mr Nodder 400 8000 David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square. Taylor Joynson Garrett. Mr Price 353 1234


3-4 days 16 11 99 fixed 30 3 99 ran 16, 17 18 22. (4days)

Chancery Number 98 T 3030 In The Matter Of Trade Mark No 2023940 for the mark Jeryl Lynn Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives John Baldwin QC 8 New Square Simmons & Simmons 0171 628 2020 Colin Birss 3 New Square

Result Judgment 9.30am 4 12 98 See Patents web site for full judgment

2 days 17 11 98

Chancery Number Ch 97 T 6275 & Ch 98 T 360 Goldschmidt AG v Eur-O-Compound & ors Mr DavidYoung QC

Representatives Mr Christopher Floyd QC and Mr Richard Arnold 11 South Square. Bristows 0171 400 8000.Edward Nodder Mr Michael Fysh QC and Mr Michael Tappin. 8 New Square. Walker Morris 0113 283 2500. Mr James Mitchener

Result Judgment reserved See Patnets web site for full judgment

5-7 days 8 12 99 Fixed 2 3 99

Chancery Number 98 H 4568. 347/98 Mandy Nicola Haberman & anr v Jackel Int Ltd Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Michael Fysh QC and Adrian Speck 8 New Square. Paisner & Co. M Tofalides. 0171 353 0299 Mark Platts-Mills QC and Michael Tappin 8 New

3 - 4 days 1.12.98 Ran 4 days

Chancery Number 99 F 2196 Christopher Simon French v Acme Jewellery Limited

Representatives Alastair Wilson QC 19 Old Buildings. Jacobsons solicitors 222 Strand Richard Arnold 11 South Square Wragge & Co

Result

7 days 11 10 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

10

Square. Freshfields. Nick Carter 936 4000. Result

Judgment 2pm 15 1 99 See patents web site for full judgment

Settled

Chancery Number 97 P 6352 PCME Ltd v Goyen Controls & Co Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Richard Meade 8 New Square. Bristows Cooke & Carpmael. Mr Holmes 0171400 8000 Mr Colin Birss 3 New Square. Barlow Lyde & Gilbert. Mr Howse 0171 247 2277

Result Judgment 22 1 99 See patents Court web site for full judgment

Estimate 3-4 days 9 12 98 Ran 7 days

Chancery Number Ch 97 T 6275 & Ch 98 T 360 Goldschmidt AG v Eur-O-Compound & ors Mr David Young QC Representatives Mr Christopher Floyd QC and Mr Richard Arnold 11 South Square. Bristows 0171 400 8000.Edward Nodder Mr Michael Fysh QC and Mr Michael Tappin. 8 New Square. Walker Morris 0113 283 2500. Mr James Mitchener Result Judgment 26 01 00 See web site for full judgment

5-7 days 8 12 99 Fixed 2 3 99

Chancery Number 98 U 3053 (Long application) Unilever PLC v The Proctor & Gamble Company Mr Justice Laddi e

Representatives Geoffrey Hobbs QC 1 Essex Court Simon Thorley QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square

Result Judgment 24 2 99 See Patents site for full judgment

1 day 15.12.98

Chancery Number 98 M 5396 Metronor v Geodetic

Representatives R Miller QC and Justin Turner 3 New Square Wragge & Co Michael Silverleaf QC and Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square. Beachcroft Wansbroughs. Mr J Radcliffe


4 – 5 days 03 07 00 fixed 28 09 99

Chancery Number 98 P 1087 In Chambers Polymasc Pharmaceuticals PLC v Dr Stephen Alexander Charles Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Selywn Bloch Littleton Chambers Mr Richard Miller 3 New Square

Result. Judgment given same day. Not on web site

Estimate 1 day 17 12 98 Ran 1 day

HC 99 02226 Novo Nordisk A/S v DSM Nv Representatives David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square. Bird & Bird. Ravider Chahill Simon Thorley QC and Justin Turner 3 New Square. Lovell White Durrant.

Result Settled

13 03 00 4-6 days fixed 5 10 99

Chancery Number 98 H 3702 3/98 In the matter of an application for an appeal by R W Hartley and E R Livesey Patent Number 2271755

Representatives Urquhart-Dykes & Lord (Manchester) 0161 832 9353


1/2 day 20 1 98

Chancery Number 94 S 1719 Sandvik Aktiebolag AG v KR Pfiffner (UK) Limited & ors Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square. Herbert Smith Ian Milligan QC 36 Essex Sreet and Adrian Speck 8 New Square Sinclair Roche & Temperley Richard Hodgson Design Chambers Reynolds, Parry –Jones & Crawford


19 06 00 10-12 days fixed 27 5 99

Chancery Number 98 N 2455 and 2692 NEC Corporation v Hyundai Electronics UK & anr

Representatives Henry Carr QC 11 South Square. Bristows 0171 400 8000 Antony Watson QC and Guy Burkill 3 New Square

Result

10 days 18 10 99

Chancery Number 98 E 1973 Edscar v Protec Int Ltd & anr

Representatives Guy Triton One Raymond buildings Schneider & Co Roger Wyand QC and James Graham One Raymond Buildings Lochners


19 06 00 2 –3 days fixed Dec 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

11

Settled 12 1 99 Chancery Number 98 W 4910 8/98 In the matter of an application for appeal by Dr P F Wilde Patent Number GB9406423 Representatives Mr Robert Onslow 8 New Square Lovell Jackson Matthews for Dr Wilde Eric Potter Clarkson, Notts.

Result Withdrawn

1/2 day 20 1 99

Chancery Number 95 C 2886 Concept Engineering v Brookdale Tool

Representatives Roger Wyand QC One Raymond Buildings Iain Purvis 11 South Square. Reed Roper & Reed


2 – 3 days 03 07 00 fixed 04 11 99

Chancery Number 98 P 4904 In the matter of an application for appeal by J M Pemberton Patents Number 2240974

Representatives. Mr J M Pemberton Piers Ackland 11 South Square. Dibb Lupton Alsop. Ref PAS.PN


1/2 day 21 1 99

HC 99 04538 Intel Corporation v Via Technology Inc

Representatives David Kitchin QC and James St Ville 8 New Square Bird & Bird Antony Watson QC 3 New Square and Adrian Speck 8 New Square Bristows Mr Philip Westmacott 0207 400 8000


7 days 27 11 00 fixed Nov 99

Chancery Number 97 T 6180 127/98 The Horne Engineering Co Ltd v Reliance Water Controls Ltd. Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Piers Acland 11 South Square. Bird & Bird Mr Williams 0171 415 6000 Daniel Alexander and Thomas Moody-Stuart 8 New Square. Maycocks. Mr Maycock 0171 375 0586

Result Judgment 10 6 99 See web site for full judgment

4/5days 12.1.99

Ran 5 days

HC 00 0645 Via v Intel

Representatives Christopher Floyd QC and Hugo Cuddingham 11 South Square. Bristows Peter Prescott QC and James St Ville 8 New Square. Bird & Bird


5-7 days 21 02 01 fixed 07 04 00

Chancery Number 97 M 6568 Macky Designs Inc v Behringer Specialised Studio Equipment & ors. Order 14

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Lindsay Lane 8 New Square C D Whittle 11 South Square

Result Judgment given. Not on web site

1 day 22 1 99

HC 99 3030 TLC 291/00 Molins PLC v G.D.SpA

Representatives Stephen Males QC 20 Essex Street and Ian Purvis 11 South Square. Bristows 0207 400 8000 Michael Silverleaf QC 11 South Square. Linklaters

Result Settled June 00

3 – 4 days 11 12 00 fixed 30 03 00

Chancery Number 97 H 3960 APPLICATION Hadley Industries PLC v Metal Sections Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Henry Carr 11 South Square. Wragge & Co 0121 233100 Miss Denise McFarland 3 New Square. Eversheds 0115 9507000 Niall Head-Rapson

Result Directions Given

12 2 99 half day

HC 99 01919 TLC 200/00 Rohm & Hass v Collag Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Henry Carr QC and Piers Acland 11 South Square Hammond Suddards Christopher Floyd QC James St Ville 8 New Square Bristows Mr Alan Johnson 0207 400 8000

Result Judgment reserved 06 06 00 Judgment 28 July. See web site for full judgment

06 06 00 1 day fixed 06 03 00 ran 1 day

Chancery Number 98 J 4873 Pat 6/98 In the matter of United Kingdom Patent No 2276438 and a reference under section 37(1)(a) of the Patent Act 1977. J W Greaves & Co Ltd v Kyffin Mr Justice Pumfrey

17 2 99 half day

HC 99 02754 TLC 425/99 Dyson v Hoover Mr Michael Fysh QC Sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge

Representatives David Kitchin 8 New Square and Guy Burkill 3

4/5days 17 07 00 (Fixed date) Fixed 14 01 00

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

12

Representatives Mr Peter Colley 19 Old Buildings. W P Thompson & Co, Liverpool. 0151 709 3961 Mr R Kyffin

Result Appeal dismissed

New Square. Olswang Christopher Floyd QC and Piers Acland 11 South Square Judgment reserved 24 07 00


ran 7 & half day

Chancery Number 98 H 4160 In the matter of Patent Number GB2241729 an appeal by Derek Spring. Mr justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Derek Spring


17 2 99 half day

HC 99 3033 TLC 104/00 Optodisc International Limited and Optodisc (Cyprus) Limited v QVC & Digital Armor Limited

Representatives Richard Arnold 11 South Square. Rowe & Maw Guy Tritton One Raymond Buildings

Result Settled

3 days 23 10 00 fixed 03 02 00

Chancery Number 98 B 2303 Bencor Limited v Diamant Boart

Representatives John Baldwin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square Eversheds - Newcastle Peter Prescott QC and Adrian Speck 8 New Square Bristows


7 days 5 5 99

HC 99 05062 TLC 120/00 City Technology v Alphasense Ltd Mr David Young QC

Representatives Iain Purvis 11 South Square Mark Platts-Mills and Robert Onslow 8 New Square

Result Judgment reserved 13 10 00

Result Judgment 26 10 00 See Court Service web site for full judgment

3 days 10 10 00 fixed 15 02 00 Ran 4 days

Chancery Number 96 C 7279 CA Greiner & Sohne Gesellschaft MBH v Technoplast Kunstoff Technic Gesellschaft MBH & anr

Representatives Henry Carr QC 11 South Square. Eversheds. Mr Barry George Hamer 8 New Square. Field Fisher Waterhouse.


5 days 26 7 99

HC 99 0226 TLC 223/99 Novo Nordisk A/S v DSM N/V Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square Bird & Bird Simon Thorley QC and Justin Turner 3 New Square Lovell White Durant

Result Judgment 21 12 00 See Web site for full judgment

6 days 10 11 00 date fixed May 00 Ran 7 days

Chancery Number 98 B 5369 Appeal. In the matter of a patent application by Adrian Philip Binney under No 9708228.3

Result Appeal allowed.

18 2 99

Chancery Number 95 M 1672 Mead Corporation & Mead Packaging Ltd v Riverwood International & New Materials Ltd Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives G Hobbs QC 1 Essex Court and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Shoesmiths & Harrison. Mr J Hill 01604 629977. A Watson QC 3 New Square and George Hamer 8 New Square. Osborne Clarke Mr Peden 01179 230220

Result Settled on 3rd day of trial 4 3 99

5 days 2 3 99

Chancery Number 98 S 6415 14/98 An Appeal in the Matter of an application by Sterling Fluid Systems Limited under Section

Half day 30 3 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

13

247 of the Copyright Designs and Patent Act 1988. And an appeal against the decision of a Master given on 25 1 99 relating to Andrews Sykes Group PLC and Sterling Fluid Systems Limited.

Representatives Mr T Mitcheson 3 New Square. Wragge & Co Beveridge Ross & Prevezer Comptroller General

Result Withdrawn by consent 9 3 99 Chancery Division 98 T 6769 Appeal. In the matter of Application GB 9720181 based upon International Application PCT/US9602776 in the name of Theile Kaolin Company.

Result Withdrawn 12 3 99 by consent

10 30am 18 3 99

Chancery Number 97 C 3613 WL No (AWAITS) Catsoft UK Ltd v ASI Europe Ltd

Representatives Arthur Ashton One Raymond Buildings. Collier Bristow 0171 242 7363 Miss Fiona Clarke 8 New Square. Hartwig 0181 681 2893

Result Removed form list 10 7 98 for a new date to be fixed. Settled - date unknown. Informed 17 3 99

1 day (13 7 98)

Chancery Number 98 H 6854. Pat 10/98 An Appeal in the Matter of an Application by Peter A Hulmes and an opposition by Examiners of the Patent Office. Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Peter A Hulmes Mr D Alexander 8 New Square for the Comptroller General


Half day 10 30am 30 3 99

Chancery Number 94 B 5219 Patrick John Brain and Ingledew Brown Bennison and ors

Representatives Mr Mark Platts-Mills QC 8 New Square Mr Christopher Floyd QC and Miss Jacqueline Reid 11 South Square


5-7days 9.6.99

Chancery Number 97 M 6568 Mackie Designs v Bohringer Specialised Sudio Equipment. Order 14 Mr Justice Pumfrey


1 day 22 1 99

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 WL No 352/98 Texas Electronics v Hyundai Electronics

Representatives Henry Carr QC 11 South Square and James St Ville 8 New Square Bristows 0171 400 8000 David Brown Antony Watson QC, Guy Burkill and Douglas

10 days 19.4 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

14

Campbell 3 New Square. Simmons & Simmons. 628 2020 Mr Freeland David Kitchin QC and Ian Purvis 11 South Square. Bristows 400 8000 David Brown

Result Judgment reserved See Patents web site for full judgment Chancery Number 96 R 3171 & 96 R 5680 Bourns Inc v Raychem Corp & ors. Application


1 day 26 4 99

Chancery Number 98 M 1421 350/98 Monsanto Company and G D Searle & Co v Merck & Co Inc & Merck Sharp & Dohme Ltd

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square Bristows 0171 400 8000 Mr Powell David Young QC, Justin Turner and Thomas Hinchcliffe 3 New Square. Lovell White Durrant. Mr McFarlane 0171 236 0066


Half day 27 4 99 fixed 13 4 99

Chancery Number 98 I 4087 ICI Chemicals v Lubrizol Corp

Representatives Anthony Watson QC 3 New Square and Richard Arnold 11 South Square. Bristows. Mr Gilbert 400 8000 Simon Thorley QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square Simmons & Simmons. Mr Willoughby 628 2020


8 days 22 6 99

Chancery Number 97 M 5801 Massmould Holdings v Portola Packaging

Representatives Michael Fysh QC and Lindsay Lane 8 New Square. Hammond Suddards Mr Larry Cohen Mr Andrew Waugh QC and Miss Denise McFarland 3 New Square. Olswang Mr Cottrill 208 8888


10 5 99 5-7 days

Chancery Number 98 J Johnson Matthey PLC v Degussa Aktiengesellschaft and W. Lindner Maschinen GmbH Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Andrew Waugh QC 3 New Square. Olswang Mr Andrew Inglis 0171 208 8888 Mr Piers Ackland 11 South Square Bird & Bird 0171 415 6000 Mr Miles Gaythwaite


5 – 8 days 28 9 99

Chancery Number 98 T6701 WL No (AWAITS) Texas Electronics v Hyundai Electronics

Representatives David Kitchin QC and James St Ville 8 New Square. Bird & Bird

5 days 13.12 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

15

Antony Watson QC and Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Simmons & Simmons. 628 2020 Mr Freeland

Result Settled 9 6 99 Chancery Number 98 T 2532 Alfred Alexander Taylor v Ishida (Europe) Ltd & anr. Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Adrian Speck 8 New Square Martin Howe QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square

Result Judgment reserved 9 6 99 See web site for full judgment

6 days 20 5 99 Ran for 11 days

Chancery Number 98 O 2841 Optimum Solutions Ltd v The National Grid Co PLC & ors

Representatives Antony Watson QC 3 New Square and Richard Meade 8 New Square. Bristows. Andrew Waugh QC and Daniel Alexander 8 New Square. Slaughter and May


3 days 9 6 99 fixed 16 4 99

Chancery Number HC 99 01041 & 01541 Breed Automative Technology v BK Racing Ltd Application

Representatives Richard Arnold 11 South Square J Reid 19 Old Buildings

Result Withdrawn by consent.10 6 99

Half day 18 6 99 fixed 21 4 99

Chancery Number 98 S 5110 ICI 63/99 Sepracor inc v Hoechst

Representatives Richard Miller QC 3 New Square. Piers Ackland 11 South Square Hammond Suddards. Mr Cohen 655 1000 Simon Thorley QC and Douglas Campbell 3 New Square Bird & Bird Trevor Cook 415 6000

Result Removed from list by consent to be re-fixed

4-5 days 26 7 99

Fixed 31 3 99.

Moved from

Chancery to

patents.

Chancery Number HC 99 01147 Appeal 2/99 In the matter of Patent Applications GB 9412950.9 and ors in the name of Kenneth Francis Prendergast Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Dr J G Holdcroft 3 Grays Inn Square (Patent agent) Daniel Alexander 8 New Square Comptroller-General The Patents Office


Half day 7 7 99 2pm fixed 30 3 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

16

Chancery Number 94 U 5239 Union Carbide Corporation v BP Chemicals Limited

Representatives Simon Thorley QC, Andrew Waugh QC and Thomas Mitchenson, 3 New Square. Simmons & Simmons. Mr Mooney Michael Briggs QC Searle Court Chambers Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Bird & Bird. Mr Harris. 405 1111


15 –20 days

3 5 00

fixed 29 3 99

Chancery Number 98 H 4568 WL No (AWAITS) Mandy Nicola Haberman v Jackal Int Ltd Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Michael Fysh QC and Adrian Speck 8 New Square Mark Platts-Mills QC and Charlotte May 8 New Square

Result Withdrawn by consent 29 7 99

3 days 28 9 99

Chancery Number 98 A 4550 Ag-Chem Manufacturing Inc & anr v Soyl Ltd & ors Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square. Hammond Suddards Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Gordons Thomas Moody-Stuart 8 New Square

Result Withdrawn by consent 29 7 99 to be refixed

4-5days 21 9 99

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 WL No 352/98 Texas Electronics v Hyundai Electronics Mr Justice Pumfrey

Result Judgment 30 7 99. See web site for full judgment

Heard 19 – 26

April 1999

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 Alfred Alexander Taylor v Ishida (Europe) Ltd & anr. Mr Justice Pumfrey


Heard 20 5 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

17

Chancery Number 99 02071 Bracco SpA v The General Hospital Corporation

Representatives Roger Wyand QC 1 Raymond Buildings. Bird & Bird.Miss Horton Simon Thorley QC and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square Bristows. Mr Judge.

Result To be refixed . Decision by Neuberger J 29 7 99

5 days 22 5 99

fixed 19 7 99

Chancery Number 98 E 5095 Eli Lilly v Novo Nordisk Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square Taylor Joyson Garrett Michael Tappin 8 New Square Linklaters

Result Judgment given. Not on web site

1 day 2 9 99

fixed

7 7 99

Chancery Number 97 M 0583 Milner Neocal Limited v Mrs Ellen Milner Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Justin Turner 3 New Square Alistair Wilson QC 19 Old Buildings

Result Judgment 2pm 13 9 99 See web site for full judgment

1 day 3 9 99 re-fixed 8 7 99

HC 99 01520 and HC 01908 Rocky Mountain Traders Ltd v Hewlett Packard & anr Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Richard Miller QC and Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Charles Russell Colin Birss 3 New Square. Eversheds


2-3 days 7 9 99

fixed 7 7 99

ran for 3

days

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

18

Chancery Number 98 P 5199 Playhut Inc v Spring Form Inc Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mark Platts-Mill QC and Mr D Campbell 3 New Square. Needham & Grant Mr Michael Silverleaf QC 11 South Square Halliwell Landau


14 9 99 2 days

Chancery Number 97 P 7012 WL 91/99 Polypipe PLC v Lewis Russell Jackson Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr Christopher Floyd QC 11 South Square and Mr Hicks 19 Old Buildings. Pinsent Curtis. S Chandler Henry Whittle and Miss Jaqueline Reid 11 South Square Briffa & Co Mr Oliver Mayland


25 10 99 7 days fixed

23 2 99 extended 8-10 days 6 10 99

Chancery Number 98 T 6031 Technolog Limited v Wessex Electronics Consultants Limited

Representatives Michael Silverleaf QC 11 South Square Linklaters Heather Lawrence 11 South Square Briffa & Co


3 days 22 5 99

fixed 22 9 99

Chancery Number 98 M 1421 350/98 Monsanto Company and GD Searle & Co v Merck & Co Inc & Merck Sharp & Dohme Ltd Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade Charlotte May 8 New Square Bristows 400 8000 Mr Powell David Young QC, Justin Turner and Thomas Hinchcliffe 3 New Square.Lovell White Durrant Mr McFarlane 236 0066 Judgment reserved 22 10 99 See Patents web site for full judgment

15 days 4 10 99

extended from 10 days to 15 days

on 9 6 99 Ran for 15 days

HC 03090 Novartis v Roy Calne Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Henry Carr QC 11 South Square Bristows John Baldwin QC M Tappin and Lindsay Lane 8 New Square Linklaters. Jeremy Brown

Result Judgment reserved 4 11 99 See Web site for full judgment

2 days 2pm

2 11 99

ran for 2 days

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

19

Chancery Number 98 N 2921 Nergeco v Ellerker Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Henry Carr QC and J Reid 11 South Square Lochners Richard Arnold and Hugo Cuddigan 11 South Square Lupton Fawcett


9 11 99 3 days

fixed 13 4 99

ran for

one day

HC 99 02181 & Ch 98 S 5156 Strix Limited v Otter Controls Limited Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Antony Watson QC 3 New Square and Heather Lawrence 11 South Square. Lovell White Durrant Peter Prescott QC 8 New Square. Clifford Chance


5 days 22 11 99

fixed 7 5 99

Chancery Number 98 O 1765 Oakley Inc v Adidas Internationa BV & anr

Representatives Roger Wyand QC and Michael Edenborough One Raymond Buildings. Matthew Arnold & Baldwin Denise McFarland 3 New Square. Reynold Porter Chamberlain. Mr Hobson


7 12 99 2 days fixed 28 5 99

Chancery Number Ch 98 E 5524 WL No 60/99 Eli Lilly & Company v Novo Nordisk (Pen syringe)

Representatives Simon Thorley QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square. Taylor Joynson Garrett. Mr Hodgson David Kitchin QC and Adrian Speck 8 New Square. Linklaters Mr Karet


3-4 days 19 1 00 fixed 11 3 99

HC 99 03098 Appeal In The Matter of Patent Application No GB 9827460.8

Representatives Andrew Ward Daniel Alexander 8 New Square. Comptroller General Cardiff Wales


Half day 20 12 99 2pm

Chancery Number 98 A 6244 Allibert Equipment SA v Ravensbourn Plastices Limited & Ors Representatives Richard Hacon 11 South Square. Pinsent Curtis Colin Birss 3 New Square Wragge & Co


2-3 days 31 1 00 fixed 20 9 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

20

Chancery Number 98 S 5281 Phillip Walter Strong v Onward Design Ltd

Representatives Roger Wyand QC One Raymond Buildings. Bird & Bird Michael Chappell 1 New Square


3 days 6 3 00 fixed 20 9 99

Chancery Number 98 E 5095 Ely Lilly v Novo Nordisk (Insulin Analogs) Representatives Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square Simmons & Simmons David Kitchin QC and Michael Tappin 8 New Square Linklaters & Paines


8 days 21 2 00 fixed 4 5 00

Chancery Number 98 M 1421 350/98 Monsanto Company and GD Searle & Co v Merck & Co Inc & Merck Sharp & Dohme Ltd Mr Justice Pumfrey Representatives David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade Charlotte May 8 New Square Bristows 400 8000 Mr Powell David Young QC, Justin Turner and Thomas Hinchcliffe 3 New Square. Lovell White Durrant Mr McFarlane 236 0066

Result Judgment 04 02 00. See web site for full judgment

15 days 4 10 99 extended from 10 days to 15 days on 9 6 99 Ran for 15 days

HC 98 03134 Dr Anthony Stephen De Silva Farmer v Moseley (Holdings) Limited and RTK Marine Limited Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Dr Anthony Stephen De Silva Farmer in person Matthew Kine 7 New Square Michael Hicks 13 Old Buildings Judgment reserved 19 11 99


15 11 99 4 days Ran for 4 days

Chancery Number 98 B 4600 50/99 & HC 99 00178 NLS7/99 Bespak PLC v Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company (joined with) Norton Healthcare Limited v Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company

Representatives Christopher Floyd QC and Mr Richard Arnold 11 South Square. Herbert Smith Andrew Waugh QC 3 New Square and Michael Tappin 8 New Square Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square and Piers Ackland 11 South Square.

Result Settled second day of trial

13 03 00 4 – 5 days ran 1 day fixed 5.3.99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

21

Chancery Number 98 N 4732 WL No 43/44/99 Nutrinova Nutrition Specialists Food Ingredients GmBh & anr v Scanchem Limited Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square. Taylor Joynson Garrett 353 1234. Mr Cohen Heather Lawrence 11 South Square. Addleshaws. Judgment reserved 24 12 99


29 11 99 5 days ( 15 days)

HC 00 0 0020 Appeal An appeal by Mr Denis Wight against the decision of the Comptroller on 20 12 99.

Representatives Mr Denis Wight in person Mr Daniel Alexander 8 New Square Comptroller General. Treasury Solicitor


Half day 22 03 00 fixed 10 01 00

Chancery Number 98 P 3160 Procter & Gamble Company v Lever Bros

Representatives SimonThorley QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square. Simmons & Simmons. Mr R Willoughby David Kitchin QC, Daniel Alexander and Charlotte May 8 New Square. Bird & Bird


27 03 00 3 – 4 days fixed 5 5 99 Ran 1 day

Chancery Number 98 H 4568 Mandy Nicola Haberman v Jackal Int Ltd Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mr Michael Fysh QC and Adrian Speck 8 New Square Mark Platts-Mills QC and Charlotte May 8 New Square


3 days 26 09 00 fixed 18 10 99

HC 99 02517 Oxford Gene Technology v Affymetrix Inc Mr Justice Jacob

Representatives A Wilson QC 13 Old Buildings Allen & Overy Richard Seymour Monckton Chambers and Richard Meade 8 New Square Bristows Dr Penny Gilbert 0207 400 8000

Result Judgment reserved 08 03 00 Judgment 7 April 2000 See web site for full judgment

6 -8 days 29 02 00 ran 7 days

Chancery Number 95 I 3482, 95 D 5843, 96 D 5368, 98 D 5476, HC 99 00381 HC 99 04282 TLC 122/99 David J Instance Limited v Denny Bros Printing Ltd

10 04 00 5 days Time Estimate changed

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

22

Mr Justice Laddie Representatives

Christopher Floyd QC and Richard Hacon 11 South Square. Hammond Suddards Antony Watson QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square. Eversheds. Ms Davies 020 7919 4500

Result Judgment reserved 11 04 00 Judgment 2pm 14 04 00 See web site for full judgment

From 6-8 to 5 days 03 03 00 Fixed 23 07 99 Ran 2 days

HC 00 1058 Appeal Mr Justice Pumfrey In the matter of the Trade Marks Act 1994 In the matter of Application No 2024696 by Hermes Properties Limited

Representatives Lindsay Lane 8 New Square. Linklaters .Tom Hope Registrar of Trade Marks Treasury Solicitor


9 30am 19 04 00 fixed 21 03 00

HC 2022 Appeal Mr Justice Pumfrey In The Matter of the Registered Designs Act 1949 and In The Matter of an Application by Golden Edge Enterprise Limited to cancel Registered Designs Nos GB 2052008 & GB 2042653 in the name of Chitlink Electronic International Limited

Representatives George Hamer 8 New Square. Marks & Clerk Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Eric Petter Clarkson

Result Appeal allowed

Half day 9 30am 16 05 00 fixed 03 05 00 ran half day

HC 00 00888 Appeal Mr Justice Pumfrey In the matter of European Patent (UK) 0469776 in the name of Eveready Battery Company Inc.

Representatives Mr George Hamer 8 New Square. Marks & Clerk Mr Mike Gilbert Mr Daniel Alexander 8 New Square. Treasury Solicitor for Comptroller General


9 30am 18 05 00 ran half day Fixed 20 03 00

Chancery Numbers 98 A 2508 & 98 S 4719 Allergan Inc & anr v Sauflon Pharmaceuticals Limited

Representatives Peter Prescott QC. 8 New Square Clifford Chance 0171 7600 1000 Michael Silverleaf QC 11 South Square. Lochners


4 days 19 09 00 fixed 23 09 99

Chancery Number HC 98 5251 TLC 290/00 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide Inc. v Procter &

7 days 08 05 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

23

Gamble (UK) Limited & anr Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Antony Watson QC and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Bristows Ms Sally Field 0207 400 8000 Simon Thorley QC and Colin Birss 3 South Square Simmons & Simmons

Result Judgment reserved 15 05 00 Judgment 21 07 00 See web site for full judgment

fixed 22 6 99 & 19 7 99 ran 6 days

HC 99 03546 TLC 312/00 Stoves Limited v Baumatic Limited Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Richard Davis 7 New Square. David Knight, Lochners 01483 414588 Michael Hicks 19 Old Buildings Christopher Branson, Boyes Turner & Burrows. 0118 959 7711

Result Judgment reserved 24 05 00 Judgment 28 07 00 Not on website

3 days 22 05 00 Fixed 17 11 99 ran 2 1/2 days

HC 99 02670 TLC 191/99 Jon Sapey v Trianco Redfyre Limited Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives John Lambert of Sheffield. Keeble Hawson Moorhouse, Sheffield 0114 272 2062. Jonathan Armstrong Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Leathes Prior. Mr Barlow. 01603 610 911

Result Judgment reserved 14 06 00 Judgment 31 07 00 Not on website

2 days 12 06 00 fixed 16 09 99 ran 3 days

Ch 99 M 01896 TLC 253/99 Stems Corp v Astec-Microflow Ltd & anr

Representatives Henry Carr QC and Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square Bristows Mr David Brown 0207 400 8000 Simon Thorley QC and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square Richards Butler

Result Settled August 00

4/5 days 11 09 99 fixed 22 9 99

HC 98 O 2841 (Strike out application) Optimum Solutions Limited v (1)The National Grid Company Plc, (2) The National Grid Company PLC, (3) Eastern Electricity Group PLC, (4) Logica PLC Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Antony Watson QC 3 New Square Reynolds Porter Chamberlain (for claimants) Andrew Waugh QC 3 New Square and Daniel Alexander 8 New Square. Slaughter & May for 2nd defendants Michael Bloch QC 1 Essex Court Cameron Mckenna for 1st defendant

2/3 days 19 09 00 2-3 days fixed 21 06 00 ran 1 day

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

24

Result Judgment 20 09 00 (Not on Court web site) HC 99 4380 TLC 637/00 Gencor Limited and FW Screens International Limited and FW Screens Limited & Ors Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square. Hammond Suddards Matthew Kime 7 New Square

Result Argument as to costs only issue which remained.

half day 27 09 00 fixed 24 05 00 sat half day

Ch 98 A 450 TLC 260/00 Adamsez (N.I) Limited v Topravit Limited Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Mr David Micklethwaite, One Raymond Buildings. Sorrell & Co Mr Richard Edwards 3 Verulam Buildings. Lee & Pembertons 020 75891114

Result Judgment reserved 07 09 00 Judgment 13 09 00 (Not on web)


HC 99 03126 TLC 636/00 Amersham Pharmacia Biotech AB v (1) Amicon Limited (2) Millpore (UK) Limited (3) Millipore Corporation Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Henry Carr QC and Ian Purvis 11 South Square. Bristows Alan Johnson 0207 400 8000 Christopher Floyd QC and Guy Burkill 11 South Square. Needham & Grant David Cubbins

Result Judgment 26 10 00. Not on web site. Full judgment with transcribers. (Marten Walsh Cherer)

5 days 24 10 00 Fixed 19 01 00 Ran one and half days

Ch 98 A 4550 TLC 671/00 AG Chem Equipment Co Inc v Soyl Ltd

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square Hammond Suddard Ms Dannilunas Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Gordons Mr Turner Thomas Moody-Stuart 8 New Square. Foster Baxter Cooksey. Mr Dalton

Result Settled. 31 10 00

4/5 days 11 12 00 fixed 08 11 99

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

25

Chancery Number 98 M 2151 TLC 351/00 Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company v ATI Atlas limited & anr Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Andrew Waugh and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Bristows. Mr Nodder 0207400 8000 Richard Hacon and Heather Lawrence 11 South Square. Pinsent Curtis. Mr Saunders 0113 244500

Result Judgment reserved Judgment 31 10 00 Not on website

6 - 7days 17 07 00 fixed 23 07 99 ran 7 days

HC 00 1837 IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION BY MULTILOAD TECHNOLOGY LIMITED FOR RESTORATION OF THE UNITED KINGDOM PATENT GB2262350 UNDER SECTION 28 OF THE PATENTS ACT

Representatives Mr Anthony Pluckrose (Patent Agent) Pluckrose Boult Wade Tenant. Daniel Alexander 8 New Square Comptroller Generals Office


Half day 02 11 00 10 30am fixed 25 05 00

HC 88 3836 (Application) Palmtree Holdings Ltd and Sheffield Gear & Engineering Co Ltd (Strike Out)

Representatives Mary Vitoria QC and Thomas Moody-Stuart 8 New Square Michael Hicks 13 Old Buildings

Result Order made Trial 11 6 00 Central London County Court

1 day 02 11 00 NB 2pm Fixed 03 07 00

HC 99 4482 APPEAL FROM THE DECISION OF THE COMPTROLLER-GENERAL IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION BY CRYSTAL CANOPIES LIMITED FOR CANCELLATION OF REGISTERED DESIGN NO 2068265

Representatives Richard Davies 7 New Square. Cruikshank & Fairweather, Patent Agents (Mr Shanks) Kennedy & Co Glasgow G1 2DT Comptroller-General


Half day 03 11 00 2pm fixed 27 06 00

HC 99 01110 TLC 645/00 Lilly Icos v Pfizer Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Simon Thorley QC, Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss 3 New Square. Taylor Joynson Garrett David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square. Bird & Bird

Result Judgment reserved 18 10 00 Judgment 08 11 00


16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

26

See web site for full judgment HC 99 01959 TLC 696/00 Marshalltown Trowel Company v Ceka Works Ltd Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Ian Purvis 11 South Square. Rowe and Maw Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Simmons

Result Judgment 09 11 00 (Not on net)

2 days 08 11 00 NB 12 fixed 19 01 00 ran 2 days

HC 00 2870 (Application) Synthon BV v Beecham Group plc

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC and Adrian Briggs. Simmons & Simmons (For defendants as applicant) Michael Silverleaf QC 11 South Square

Representatives Settled 24 11 00

1 day 30 11 00 fixed 17 07 00

Chancery Number 98 C 3219 TLC 331/00 Collag Corporation & anr v Merck & Co Inc Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Stephen Males QC 20 Essex Street and James St Ville 8 New Square. Bristows Mr Alan Johnson 0207 400 8000 David Young QC and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Lovell White Durrant

Result Judgment reserved 13 07 00 Judgment 29 11 00 Not on web site


HC 99 03993 TLC 661/00 Asahi v MacoPharma Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Simon Thorley QC and Guy Burkill 3 New Square Cameron McKenna Mr Nick Beckitt Christopher Floyd QC 11 South Square and Douglas Campbell 3 New Square Wragge & Co

Result Judgment reserved 24 11 00 Judgment 05 12 00 See web site for full judgment

3/4 days 22 11 00 fixed 16 12 99 Ran 2 days

HC99 04340 TLC 644/00 TRW Automotive Systems Limited v Autoliv Development AB

Representatives H Carr QC and Ian Purvis 11 South Square Bristows David Brown 0207 400 8000 Christopher Floyd QC 11 South Square and G Burkill 3 New Square Bird & Bird Settled 15 11 00

4 days 29 01 01 fixed 08 03 00

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

27

HC 00 4176 (Application for Strikeout) Rambus Inc v (1) Micron Europe Limited (2) Hyundai Electronics UK Ltd

Representatives (Rambus) J Swift QC Monckton Chambers Bristows (Micron) Nicholas Greene Brick Court Chambers Arnold & Porter (Hyundai) Gerald Barling QC Brick Court Chambers Simmons & Simmons

Result As a result of an aplication before Mr Justice Laddie on 19 12 00 this action was stayed subject to the outcome of EPO hearing

2 - 3 days 29 01 01 fixed 12 12 00

HC 00 4177 Rambus Inc v Hyundai Electronics UK Limited and Micron Europe Limited

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square Bristows Antony Watson QC and Guy Burkill 3 New Square Simmons & Simmons Henry Carr QC 11 South Square and Adrian Speck 8 New Square. Arnolds & Porter

Result As a result of an aplication before Mr Justice Laddie on 19 12 00 this action was stayed subject to the outcome of EPO hearing

20 days 04 02 02 fixed 30 11 00

APPEAL Chancery Number HC 99 01049 Appeal 1/99. In the matter of an application for a supplementary Protection Certificate No SPG/GB97/008 by BASF AKUEBGESSELLSCHAFT

Representatives Denise McFarland 3 New Square. J Y and G W Johnson (Patent Agents) Daniel Alexander 8 New Square Comptroller-General The Patents Office NOTE Taken out 6 12 99 by consent to await outcome of the reference by the Dutch Court to the Court of Justice of the European Community in August 1999.

Half day 20 12 99 10 30am (was 07 07 99 but refixed re Euro decision) Fixed 19 09 99

Ch 98 I 2985 David John Instance & anr v Reynders Etiketten NV

Representatives Christopher Floyd QC and Piers Acland 11 South Square. Hammond Suddards Thomas Mitcheson 8 New Square

Result Proceedings stayed 16 10 00 by consent pending outcome of parallel proceedings in Netherlands

3 days 25 06 01 fixed 14 06 00

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

28

HC 0002569 TLC 794/00 Hewlett-Packard Company v Teco Information Systems Europe Limited

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Adrian Speck 8 New Square Linklaters Halliwell Landau

Result Settled. 02 02 01

14 05 01 5 days Fixed 20 07 00

HC 99 02711 TLC 736/00 HC 99 02913 TLC 735/00 HC 99 03020 TLC 737/00 Wells v Winstones Ice Cream & Ors

representatives Douglas Campbell 3 New Square Michael Hicks 11 Old Buildings


1 ½ days 24 01 01 fixed 23 08 00

HC 00 1650 TLC 993/00 George Wilson Industries Limited v UGI Smith Meters Limited

Representatives Justin Turner 3 New Square. Wragge & Co Richard Arnold 11 South Square


3-4 days 11 12 01 fixed 07 11 00

HC 97 M 3482 TLC 348/00 M & H Plastics v Alan Derek Spencer Pettyfer Mr David Young QC

Representatives Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square. LHP Law Jacqueline Reid 11 South Square Briffa & Co



HC 99 2533 TLC 638/00 Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company & another v Rennicks (UK) Limited and Nippon Carbide Industries Co Inc & another

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC & Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Bristows Mr E Nodder Simon Thorley QC & Colin Birss 3 New Square. Lovells Mr A Cobden (1st Def) Bird & Bird Mr N Jenkins (2 & 3 Defs)

Result Taken out of list pending final decision of the EPO. Consent order 26 02 01

30 04 01 6 – 7 days Fixed 24 03 00

HC 99 1720 TLC 385/00 McGhan Medical UK Limited v Nagor Limited and Boisil Limited Mr Michael Fysh QC

Representatives Michael Tappin 8 New Square Bristows Richard Hacon 11 South Square Gouldens


3 days 14 11 00 ran 3 days

HC 99 02833 TLC 655/00 CIL International Limited v Vitrashop Limited

Representatives Richard Arnold QC 11 South Square and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Taylor Joynson Garrett Martin Howe QC and Thomas Moody-Stuart 8 New Square. Lane & Partners.

Result Adjourned 28 20 01 to 02 03 01 Settled.

2 ½ days 26 02 01 2pm fixed 25 01 00 re fixed 31 01 01

Chancery Number 93 K 937 and HC 99 02916/7 and HC 99 03241 TLC 695/00 Mr Justice Neuberger Kiren Amgen v Boehringer Mannheim & ors and Hoechst v Kiren Amgen

Representatives Antony Watson QC , Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss. 3 New Square Taylor Joynson Garrett David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square Bird & Bird Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square, Iona Berkeley and Michael Tappin 8 New Square. Herbert Smith


25 days 15 01 01 ran 27 days

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

29

Ch/2001/APP/0132 APPEAL In the matter of the patent No GB 2 240 558 in the name of Ash & Lacy Building Products Limited and in the matter of a Section 71 Application and a Section 72 Application thereto by Silkbill Limited.

Representatives Mr Michael Edenborough One Raymond Buildings. Nabarro Nathanson (appellant) Mr Richard Halstead. Wynne-Jones, Laine & James, Chartered Patent Agents of Cheltenham

Result Withdrawn by consent 08 03 01

Half day 2pm 20 03 01 fixed 27 02 01

HC 99 04998 TLC 894/00 Silk Bill Ltd v Ash Lacy Building Products Ltd

Representatives Ian Purvis 11 South Square George Hamer 8 New Square

Result Settled

13 06 01 2 days fixed 23 08 00

HC Awaits Wooley Jewellers Ltd v Argos

Representatives 3 New Square

Result Removed from trial list 15 03 01 – No Number of action No TLC Number No details of counsel or solicitors provided No copy of CMC Order provided

19 09 01 3 days 19 02 01

HC 99 03189 TLC 501/00 Micromatice A/S v Dispense Systems International & ors Mr Justice Neuberger

Representatives Colin Birss 3 New Square Guy Burkill 3 New Square


4-5 days 26 03 01 Date fixed unknown believe May 00

Ch 99 01388 TLC/857 Designplan Lighting Ltd v Vandelite Lighting Ltd Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Nicholas Levyseur 3 Paper Buildings Geofrey Pass 40 King Street Manchester

Result Discontinued 08 03 01



Representatives Antony Watson QC , Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss. 3 New Square Taylor Joynson Garrett David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square Bird & Bird

3 days 01 08 01

HC 99 04645 TLC/89/01 & 93/01 Oxford Gene Technology v (1) Affymetrix Inc (2) Affymetrix UK Ltd and (3) Beckman Coulter Inc

Representatives Peter Prescott QC and Charlotte May 8 New Square. Bird & Bird David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square. Bristows


26 03 01 13–15days was 8-10 first fixed 12 01 00 refixed 19 04 00


Representatives Antony Watson QC , Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss. 3 New Square Taylor Joynson Garrett David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade 8 New Square Bird & Bird Simon Thorley QC 3 New Square, Iona Berkeley and Michael Tappin 8 New Square. Herbert Smith

2 days 10 09 01 ran 2 days

HC 98 6027 TLC 994/00 Surface Technology PLC and Ultraseal International v (1) Peter David Young, (2) Ultraseal International Limited and (3) MX Systems (UK) Limited

Representatives Richard Arnold 11 South Square. Wragge & Co Daniel Alexander 8 New Square. Bird & Bird


8-10 days 08 10 01 fixed 07 11 00

HC 99 5062 (Application) City Technology Limited v Alphasense Limited

Representatives Ian Purvis 11 South Square Mark Platts-Mills QC and Robert Onslow 8 New Square


2 days 08 10 01 fixed 03 04 01

HC LFL Group Limited v I Connelly and C Connelly

1 day 08 05 01 fixed

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

30

Representatives Hugo Cunningham 11 South Square Michael Hicks 19 Old Buildings Eversheds


05 04 01

HC 99 00468 HC 98 S 6782 ( (2) Springform Inc, Finecard International Ltd (t/a The Ninja Corporation v Worlds Apart Ltd Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives (1) Michael Silverleaf QC (claimants) 11 South Square Halliwell Landau Mr Moakes (Ninja) Alastair Wilson QC 19 Old Buildings Rowe & Maw (Worlds Apart)

Result Judgment 29 05 01 Not on web site


HC 99 5310 TLC 642/00 Novamont SPA v Green Light Products Ltd

Representatives Simon Thorley QC and Justin Turner 3 New Square. Simmons & Simmons Mr Robinson David Young QC 3 New Square. Briffa


4 days 16 07 01 fixed 13 07 00

HC 00 2676 TLC 32/01 Icon Health & Fitness Limited v Precise Exercise Equipment Inc Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Douglas Campbell 3 New Square Wragge & Co Denise McFarland 3 New Square. Blake Turner (Reduced by consent from 3 to 2 days on 06 06 01)

Result Judgment 20 06 01 (Not on website)

19 06 01 2 days fixed 15 06 00 ran 1 day

HC99 04555 TLC 999/00 Inhale Therapeutics Systems Inc v Quadrant Healthcare PLC Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC 3 New Square and Richard Arnold 11 South Square. Simmons & Simmons Henry Carr QC and Piers Acland 11 South Square Bristows Dr Penny Gilbert 0207 400 8000


6/7 days 14 05 01 Fixed 01 01 00 for 04 03 01 Re fixed 07 02 01 ran 7 1/2 days

Ch 97 W 5151 TLC Waters Limited v Hewlett Packard Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Geoffrey Hobbs QC One Essex Court and Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square Shoosmiths Roger Wyand QC One Raymond Buildings and Daniel Alexander QC 8 New Square Bird & Bird

Result Judgment 10 25 04 01 Not on website


HC 00 4746 TLC 219/01 29 11 01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

31

Celltech Chiroscience Limited v Medimmune Inc

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Daniel Alexander 8 New Square Antony Watson QC 3 New Square and Richard Meade 8 New Square Was 05 06 01 fixed 28 03 01 in Gen Chancery list. Moved back into Patents list and refixed 11 06 01

Result Adjourned on 20 07 01 after an application before Mr Justice Laddie to await a decision by the American Supreme Court in Festo

3 days fixed 11 06 01

HC 00 3010 TLC 196/01 Glynwed Pipe Systems v Uponor Ltd

Representatives Ian Purvis 11 South Square. Jonathan Radcliffe of Field Fisher Waterhouse Henry Carr QC and Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square Mr S Jackson Addleshaw Booth & Co


3-4 days 26 07 01 fixed 04 09 00

HC 00 679 TLC/126/01 Sabaf SpA v (1) MFI Furniture Centres Ltd (2) Meneghetti SpA Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square. Jonathan Radcliffe Field Fisher Waterhouse A Wilson QC and Peter Colley 19 Old Buildings Middleton Potts

Result Time estimate changed on 20 06 01 from 3 –4 days to 6 – 7 days.

Result Judgment 31 07 01 See website for full judgment

2 days 18 07 01 Pt hd 6 – 7 days 03 07 01 fixed 27 09 00 ran 5 days

HC 00 00244 TLC/176/01 Titus International Plc v Hafele UK Ltd Mr Michael Fysh QC sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge of the Patents Court

Representatives Geoffrey Hobbs QC One Essex Court and James Marshall Taylor Joynson Garrett Christopher Floyd QC and Henry Whittle 11 South Square. Shoosmiths


29 01 02 4 days fixed 07 03 01

HC01 00787 JB Ltd v Taka Ltd

Representatives Michael Edenborough Hogarth Chambers Theodore Goddard Denise McFarland 3 New Square Petman Smith

Result Settled

1 ½ days 28 11 01 fixed 08 08 01

HC 01 APP 010651 Mr Justice Laddie APPEAL from the decision of the Comptroller-General by Thibierge & Comar SA (Appellant) and Rexam CFP Limited

2pm ½ day 14 09 01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

32

(Respondent) Representatives

Adrian Speck 8 New Square Bristows Richard Arnold QC 11 South Square Urquhart Dykes and Lord

Result Adjourned sine die

fixed 11 09 01

CH 97 B 4804 (Costs application) Brawley v Marczynski Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives James Mellor 8 New Square Graham Shipley 19 Old Buildings Gorna & Co

Result Judgment given 17 09 01. Not on website

17 09 01 Half day Fixed 08 06 01

CH/2001/App 010229 IN THE MATTER OF European (UK) Patent No 0 071 308 in the name of Whirlpool Europe B.V. AND IN THE MATTER of an application for revocation by BSH BOSCH and Seimens Hausgerate GmbH AND IN THE MATTER OF an appeal by the Proprietor/Appellant to the High Court against the decision of the Hearing Officer dated 5th February 2001 to revoke the Patent Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square Baron & Warren Dr Walther Wolff & Co James Mellor 8 New Square Pettman Smith Comptroller General of Patents Cardiff Road Gwent NP10 1RH


19 09 01 1 day fixed 05 06 01

Pat 92 080 David Jones v (1) Max Halliday (Trading as “Excaliber Hand Tools”) (2) Excalibur Hand Tools Ltd) now known as Proffincome Limited (3) Jack Lewis (4) Cedric M Clapp

Representatives Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square Alun Rees Solicitors Michael Hicks 19 Old Buildings Charles, Crookes & Jones

Result Settled second day

1 ½ days 20 09 01 fixed 04 07 01

HC 00 2955 TLC 481/01 (1) Knowledge Kids Enterprises Inc (2) Leapfrog Toys (UK) Limited v (1) Scanna Technology Limited (2) Tomy UK Limited (To be part heard in court 38 for video link)

Representatives Peter Prescott QC and Adrian Speck 8 New Square Beresford & Co David Young QC and Geoffrey Pritchard 3 New Square. Briffa & Co


02 10 01 3 days fixed 11 05 01

HC 00 3375 TLC/479/01 Trespaphan v Polinas Plastik Sanayi Ve Ticareti SA

09 10 01 3 days

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

33

Representatives Douglas Campbell 3 New Square Bird & Bird Daniel Alexander and Iona Berkeley 8 New Square Stephenson Harwood


fixed 11 05 01

HC 00 00792 TLC 344/01 L Woolley Jewellers Limited v A & A Jewellery Limited

Representatives Denise Mc Farland 3 New Square. Carvill & Johnson Graham Shipley 13 Old Buildings Ralph Davies & Co

Result Transferred to Patents County Court by order of Jacob J 10.10.01.

2 days 25 10 01 fixed 03 04 01

Ch 98 I 2984 TLC/ 261/01 (1) David John Instance (2) David J Instance Limited v (3) Faubel & Co. Nachf. Gmbh and 4 CCL Labels Inc Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives (1) & (2) Piers Acland 11 South Square. Hammond Suddards MJD (3) Thomas Moody-Stuart 8 New Square Jonathan Radcliffe Field Fisher Waterhouse (4) Andrew Lykiardopoulos (solicitor advocate) Bristows

Result Judgment reserved 05 09 01 Judgment handed down 10 10 01 Not on web site

2/3 days 04 09 01 fixed 15 03 01 order of Mr Justice Pumfrey ran 1 ½ days

HC 99 4062 TLC/258/01 HC 00 03984 TLC/424/01 Arjo Ltd v Liko AB & anr Mr Justice Laddie

Representatives Henry Whittle 11 South Square. Wragge & Co. Kate Swaine Antony Watson QC and Douglas Campbell 3 New Square. Lovells

Result Judgment handed down 8.11.01 See web site for full judgment

4 days 2pm 24.09.01 fixed 20.03.01 ran 6 days

HC 01 0389 TLC 234/01 Elida Faberge Ltd v Colgate-Palmolive Mr Justice Pumfrey

Representatives Michael Fysh QC and Daniel Alexander 8 New Square. Wragge & Co John Baldwin and Michael Tappin QC 8 New Square Freshfields

Result Judgment reserved 13 09 01 Judgment handed down 1.11.01 Not on web site

2/3 days 10.09.01 fixed 21.03.01 order of Mr Justice Pumfrey ran 3 days

HC 01 1344 TLC 489/01 Thompson Plastics (Hull) Limited v Tetraform Composites Limited

Representatives Justin Turner 3 New Square Gosschalks

3 days 17 10 01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

34

Colin Birss 3 New Square Martineau Johnson


fixed 09 05 01

CH 2001APP552 APPEAL by Apple Computer Inc to the Registered Design Appeal Tribunal from the decision of the Comptroller General

Representatives Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square. Brookes Batchelor Patent Attorneys Comptroller General

Result Appeal allowed. Question of costs adjourned. Not on web site

½ day 24.10.01 fixed 26.07.01

HC 1998 04550 AG-Chem v SOYL Ltd

Representatives Hammonds Suddard Edge Gordons

Result Consent order received 26.10.01 settling proceedings

CH 2001 APP 1651 APPEAL on stay of execution from the Patent Office in the matter of Rexham CFP Ltd v Thibierge & Comar Mr Justice Jacob

Representatives Richard Arnold or Mark Vanhegan 11 South Square, Urqhuart Dykes & Lord Adrian Speck 8 New Square, Bristows

Result Judgment handed down by Jacob J 9.11.01. Appellant to pay assessed costs in four months. See web site for full judgment

½ day 1.11.01 Fixed 24.10.01

HC 00 1584 TLC 199/01 Thomson Licensing S.A. and Deutsche Thomson-Brandt GmbH v Pace Micro Technology PLC

Representatives Christopher Floyd QC 11 South Square and Guy Burkill 3 New Square. Bristows Mr Justin Watts Michael Silverleaf QC, Henry Whittle and Brian Nicholson 11 South Square. Pinsent Curtis. Ref SBJC

Result

Settled 13.11.01 Action and counterclaim discontinued by consent

7-9 days 05.11.01 (reduced on 3. 10 01 from 15 days) fixed 20.10.00 Started 12 11 01 Ran 2 days

CH 2001 APP 010716 APPEAL by Clear Focus Imaging Ltd against decision of the Comptroller General

Representatives Atkinson Burrington Wilson Gunn M’Caw

Result Appeal dealt with on paper. Judgment

½ day 22.11.01 fixed 23.10.01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

35

handed down 16.11.01. See web site for full judgment. HC 00 4644 TLC 809/01 (1) Automotive Motion Technology Limited (2) Dana Automotive L imited v (1) TRW Fahrwerksysteme GmbH & Co KG (2) TRW Automotive Electronics & Components GmbH & Co KG (3) TRW Inc (4) TRW Systems Limited

Representatives Antony Watson QC Thomas Mitcheson 3 New Square Nabarro Nathanson Henry Carr QC and Iain Purvis 11 South Square Bristows


2 days 26.11.01 fixed 25.07.01

Ch 98 H 3134 Dr Anthony Stephen De Silva Farmer v (1) Moseley (Holdings) Limited (trading as RTK Marine) (2) RTK Marine Limited and (3) Composite Industries Limited

Representatives Dr Farmer in person (Moriarty Westlake (Mr Stephen Gisby) (Counsel awaits) (1) and (2) Michael Hicks 19 Old Buildings Lester Aldridge (Mr Richard Byrne) (3) Sterling Ford Insolvency Practitioners (Mr D P Gendall/Mr M Aaron) (Counsel awaits) Originally fixed on 4 5 99 for a seven day hearing commencing 07 02 00. Taken out of list on 24 01 00 by order of Mr Justice Neuberger to come on again not before October 00. Directions hearing before Mr Justice Neuberger on 15 03 10 to ascertain position and trial date. Order made on 15 03 01 to be fixed.

Result Settled 18.11.01 Notice of discontinuance received 20.11.01

03.12.01 4/5 days fixed 04.05.00 refixed 27.03.01 To be heard by Christo-pher Floyd QC sitting as a Deputy Patents Court Judge

HC01 CO3968 TLC 678/01 Iain McGuffie (1) Fleet (Line Markers) Ltd v Superturf Products Ltd (2) Opex Sports Ltd (3) George A Palmer

Representatives Giles Fernando, 11 South Square, Wragge & Co (Miss Parikh) Piers Acland, 11 South Square, Hammon Suddards (Mr Clay) Transferred to Patents County Court 05.12.01

2/3 days 01.05.02 fixed 21.01.01

HC 00 5702 Natsteel Engineering PTE Ltd v Stinis Beheer BV HH Judge Fysh QC

Representatives Roger Wyand QC and Richard Davis, Hogarth Chambers, Denton Wilde Sapte Douglas Campbell, 3 New Square, Bird & Bird

Result Settled. Consent order received 10.12.01

15.01.02 2/3 days fixed 11.05.01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

36

(A) HC 00 4267 (B) HC 00 4266 TLC/126/127 (A) TV/Com International Inc v (1) OnDigital PLC (2) Societe Europeenne De Controle D’Acces and (3) Canal Plus Technologies SA (B) TV/Com International Inc v (1) Telewest Communications PLC (2) Nagravision SA (3) Kudeslski SA

Representatives (A) Richard Miller QC and Robert Onslow, 8 New Square, Wragge & Co (Claimants) (1) John Hornby Solicitor Advocate of Clifford Chance (2) and (3) Iain Purvis and Hugo Cuddigan, 11 South Square, Freshfields (Mr Forsyth)

Result Order dismissing action and counterclaim in part (A) of proceedings received on 10.12.01. First defendant now called ITV Digital plc and not OnDigital plc. Second part of action (B) TV/Com International Inc v (1) Telewest Communications plc (2) Nagravision SA (3) Kudeslski SA not affected and still listed to commence on 18.3.02 with a reduced time estimate of 4-5 days.

Representatives (B) Richard Miller QC and Robert Onslow, 8 New Square Wragge & Co (Claimants) (1) (2) and (3) Henry Carr QC, Piers Acland, Benet Brandeth, 11 South Square, Bircham Dyson Bell (Mr Langley)

8 days 18.03.02 fixed 19.02.01

HC 99 4579 Ampy Automation Digilog Limited v Siemens Metering Limited

Representatives Michael Silverleaf QC and Jacqueline Reid, 11 South Square, Lochnes (Mr D Knight) Henry Carr QC, 11 South Square and Michael Edenborough, Hogarth Chambers, Nabarro Nathanson (Michelle Valcherro)

Result Settled.

2 days 20.05.02 fixed 12.07.01

HC 99 3633 TLC 202/01 (1) American Home Products Limited & (2) Professor Sir Roy Calne v (1) Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited & (2) Novartis Pharma AG

Representatives John Baldwin QC and Michael Tappin, 8 New Square, Linklaters (Claimants American Home Products) Henry Carr QC and Piers Acland, 11 South Square, Tom Mitcheson, 3 New Square, Bristows Removed from list on 1 June 01 due to increased time estimate original date 7.6.01 4-5 days

16.01.02 10 days fixed 06.06.01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

37

Result Settled. Confirmation letter received from Linklaters 20.12.01. HC 00 5233 TLC 236/01 (1) Stephen Tickner (2) Timothy Woodhouse v (3) Honda Motor Company Limited (4) Honda Europe Limited (5) Honda Motor Europe Limited

Representatives Anthony Watson QC and Geoffrey Pritchard, 3 New Square, Memery Crystal Peter Prescott QC, 8 New Square and John Hornby of Clifford Chance Jacob J

Result Judgment handed down on 24.01.02. See web site for details.

4/5 days 13.12.01 fixed 05.04.01 Ran 2½ days

CO/2341/2001 The Queen on the application of Ash & Lacy Building Design Products v Comptroller General of Patents Designs & Trade Marks (transferred from Administrative Court – application for permission to apply for judicial review)

Representatives Daniel Alexander 8 New Square, Treasury Solicitor Michael Edenborough Hogarth Chambers, Nabarro Nathanson Laddie J

Result Judgment reserved. Judgment given on 01.02.02. Not on web site

30.01.02 1 day Fixed 24.10.01

HC1999 No 02916 HC1999 No 02917 HC 1999 No 03241 Kirin-Amgen Inc v Transkaryotic Therapies Inc (Amendment proceedings before Neuberger J)

Representatives Anthony Watson QC and Andrew Waugh QC, 3 New Square, Taylor Joynson Garrett David Kitchin QC and Richard Meade, 8 New Square, Bird & Bird Hearing dates 4 to 8 February and stood over to 19 February Pt Hd.

Result Judgment reserved. Judgment handed down at 9.00am on 21.03.02. Copy on website.

5 days 04.02.02 fixed 10.09.01 Ran 8 days

(A) HC 00 5802 TLC 248/01 Cairnstores Limited v Aktiebolaget Hassle (B) HC 01 C 05093 Generics (UK) Ltd v Aktiebolaget Hassle

Representatives (A) Christopher Floyd QC, 11 South Square and Michael Tappin, 8 New Square, SJ Berwin & Co (Mr Rose) Simon Thorley QC and Colin Birss, 3 New Square, Simmons & Simmons (Mr Kamstra)

3 to 3 ½ days 06.02.02 fixed 06.04.01 Time est changed from 4-5

HC 01 01366 Berry Floor v Kronotex

Representatives Roger Wyand QC Hogarth Chambers, Bird & Bird Henry Carr QC 11 South Square, Allen & Overy

Result Settled. Letter of consent to vacate from list received from Bird & Bird on 06.02.02.

½ day 08.02.02 (fixed date) Fixed 24.10.01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

38

Representatives (B) David Young QC, 3 New Square and Adrian Speck, 8 New Square, Taylor Joynson Garrett Simon Thorley QC and Colin Birss, 3 New Square, Simmons & Simmons Laddie J

Result Judgment reserved. Judgment handed down on 06.03.02. Copy on website.

days on 31.01.02 Ran 4 ½ days

HC00 963 TLC38/01 (1) Stena Rederji Aktiebolag (2) Stena Line Aktiebolag v (1) Irish Continental Group PLC (2) Irish Ferries Limited (3) Irish Ferries (UK) Limited

Representatives Richard Arnold QC and Hugo Cuddigan, 11 South Square, Barlow Lyde Gilbert (Rajita Sharma) Richard Miller QC and Douglas Campbell, 3 New Square, Holman Fenwick (CJH) Laddie J

Result Judgment reserved. Judgment handed down on 25.04.02. Copy on website.

3/4 days 15.02.02 fixed 03.05.01 Ran 3 days

HC 00 3655 TLC385/01 NewTransducers Ltd v Labtec Enterprises UK Ltd

Representatives Peter Prescott QC and Adrian Speck 8 New Square, Simmons & Simmons (Mark Robinson) Mark Vanhegan, 11 South Square, Fishers, (Mr Killin) (Time estimate increased from 5 days on 7.6.01)

Result Settled. Letter of consent to vacate from list received from Simmons & Simmons on 14.01.02.

7-10 days 25.02.02 fixed 18.01.01

CH 2002 APP 0072 APPEAL by Takeda Chemical Industries Ltd against decision of the Comptroller General

Representatives Daniel Alexander, 8 New Square, Elkington and Fife, Sevenoaks Kent Charlotte May, 8 New Square, Treasury Solicitor

Result Case adjourned back to Patent Office for further hearing. Reserved to Laddie J.

½ day 11.03.02 fixed 05 02 02

CH 2001 APP 992 APPEAL by Woolard against decision of the Comptroller General

Representatives Peter Prescott, 8 New Square, Gordons Daniel Alexander, 8 New Square, Treasury Solicitor Laddie J

Result Judgment reserved and handed down on

½ day 12.03.02 fixed 15.01.02 ran 1 day

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

39

12.04.02. See website for full judgment CH 2001 APP 0846 APPEAL by Dell USA LP against decision of the Comptroller General

Representatives Dr Tim Watkin, Lloyd Wise, Tregear & Co Daniel Alexander, 8 New Square, Andrew Prior, Treasury Solicitor

Result Letter received from Lloyd Wise, Tregear & Co dated 4.02.02 indicating that appellant no longer wishes to proceed with appeal.

½ day 13.03.02 Fixed 14.12.01

(A) HC O1C 04025 TLC 773/01 Smithkline Beecham v Generics (UK) Ltd (B) HC 01C 03268 BASF AKT v Glaxo Smithkline plc

Representatives (A) Andrew Waugh QC and Justin Turner, 3 New Square, Simmons & Simmons Simon Thorley QC and Thomas Hinchliffe, 3 New Square and Mark Chacksfield, 8 New Square, S J Berwin

Representatives (B) Roger Wyand QC, Hogarth Chambers and Michael Tappin, 8 New Square, Addleshaw Booth Andrew Waugh QC and Justin Turner, 3 New Square, Simmons & Simmons Pumfrey J

Result First part of action (A) between Smithkline Beecham v Generics (UK) Ltd settled 14.03.02. Judgment reserved on second part of action (B). Judgment to be handed down at 9.30am on 12.07.02. Copy on website. Costs and further argument adjourned to 9.30am on 17.07.02

8 days 14.03.02 original fixture date of 18.03.02 changed by order of CMC on 30.11.01 Ran 7 days

HC 00 4266 TLC 127/01 TV/Com International Inc v (1) Telewest Communications plc (2) Nagravision SA (3) Kudslski SA

Representatives Richard Miller QC, 3 New Square and Robert Onslow, 8 New Square, Wragge & Co (Claimants) (1) (2) and (3) Henry Carr QC, Piers Acland, Benet Brandeth, 11 South Square, Bircham Dyson Bell (Mr Langley)

Result Settled on 3rd day.

4-5 days 18.03.02 (time estimate reduced from 8 days on 10.12.01 as a result of first part of action HC 00 4267/ TLC/126 being dismissed)

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

40

fixed 19.02.01

HC 01 C04135/HC 01 C04136 Intel v Via Technologies and Ors (Competition Issues)

Representatives Nicholas Green QC, Brick Court Chambers and James Abrahams, 8 New Square, Bird & Bird Paul Lasok QC and Jon Turner, Monckton Chambers, Bristows Lawrence Collins J

Result Judgment reserved 12.04.03. Judgment handed down 14.06.02. Copy on website.

3 days 09.04.02 Ran 2 days 11& 12th 04.03

HC 00 4470 TLC 406/01 (1) Alcatel (2) Alcatel CIT v (1) Marconi PLC (2) Marconi Communications Ltd (3) Marconi Communications SpA

Representatives Peter Prescott QC and Daniel Alexander, 8 New Square, Bird & Bird (Lorna Brazell) Christopher Floyd QC and Iain Purvis, 11 South Square, Bristows (John Allcock)


5/6 days 11.04.02 fixed 27.04.01

HC 00 4957 TLC 171/01 SEB SA v (1) De’Longhi SPA (2) De’Longhi Limited

Representatives Henry Carr QC, 11 South Square and Thomas Moody-Stuart, 8 New Square, Wragge & Co (Nick Briggs) Andrew Waugh QC , 3 New Square, Andrew Lykiardopoulos, Solicitor Advocate Bristows, Bristows (Ralph Cox) Pumfrey J

Result Judgment reserved. To be handed down at 10.30am on 26.07.02. Copy on website.

5 days 22.04.02 fixed 23.03.01 Ran 4½ days

HC 02808 TLC 827/01 Dranez Holdings AG v (1) Medivent (2) Zamir Hayek

Representatives Mr Iain Purvis, 11 South Square, Mishcon de Reya Mr Richard Miller QC and Thomas Mitcheson, 3 New Square, Denton Wilde Sapte


3/4 days 09.05.02 fixed 14.06.01

HC 01 00641 TLC 469/01 A Fulton Company Limited v Totes Isotoner (UK) Limited Registered Design

Representatives Richard Arnold QC, 11 South Square, Gouldens Simon Thorley and Thomas Hinchliffe, 3 New Square, Denton Wilde Sapte Note. Trial adjourned on 09.05.02 by way of an application hearing before Mr Justice

4 days 15.05.02 fixed in Gen Ch and transferred to Patents Court 19.09.01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

41

Pumfrey. To be refixed either in the Patents Court or General Chancery

Result Transferred to Patents County Court by Pumfrey J on 17.05.02.

(A) CH 1998 No L 5360, CH 1998 No T 5562, HC 1999 01870 Levi Strauss & Co v Tesco (B) CH 1998 L No 5439, CH 1998 No T 5667 Levi Strauss & Co v Costco

Representatives (A) Henry Carr QC, 11 South Square, David Anderson QC, Brick Court Chambers and Hugo Cuddigan, 11 South Square, Baker & McKenzie (Harry Small) Geoffrey Hobbs QC, 1 Essex Court and Daniel Alexander, 8 New Square, K Legal (Eddie Powell)

Representatives (B)

Counsel and solicitors as for claimants (A) above Counsel as for defendants (A) above, Nabarro Nathanson (J Cook) Pumfrey J

Result Judgment reserved. To be handed down at 9.30am on 31.07.02. Copy on website.

1 ½ days 21.05.02 fixed 13.03.02 Ran 2 days

HC 01 012444 TLC 642/01 Storage Computer Corporation (a company incorporated in the State of Delaware) Storage Computer UK Limited v Hitachi Data Systems Limited

Representatives Simon Thorley QC, 3 New Square and Adrian Speck, 8 New Square, Bird & Bird (ALD/MPH/86) Peter Prescott QC and James Mellor, 8 New Square, McDermot, Will & Emery (HS/rb/17575) Pumfrey J

Result Judgment reserved. Handed down at on 21.08.02. Not on wbesite.

5-6 days 18.06.02 fixed 13.07.01 Ran 10 days

HC 01 01834 TLC 123/02 Commtel (UK) Ltd v Amstrad plc

Representatives Richard Miller QC, 3 New Square, Clifford Chance James Mellor, 8 New Square, Eversheds Trial adjourned as a result of application on 13.06.02. To be refixed for 3 days in December 2002.

Result Settled. Consent order received 19.06.02.

3 days 27.06.02 fixed 18.01.02

HC 01 01444 TLC 510/01 AEA Technology PLC v (1) Michael Mulholland (2) Air Pollution Abatement Ltd

10 days 15.07.02

HC 01 C05159 TLC 69/02 Aktiebolaget Hassle and Astra Zeneca v Generics (UK) Ltd

3-4 days 15.07.02

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

42

Representatives Selwyn Bloch QC, Littleton Chambers and Tom Hinchliffe, 3 New Square, Eversheds (Vicki Salmon) Mr Males QC, 20 Essex Street, Mr Higgins Goldsmith Building, Selwyn & Co (Mr Selwyn)

Result Settled 25.04.02. Consent order received 29.04.02.

fixed 18.07.01

(Infringement action) Representatives

Simon Thorley QC and Colin Birss, 3 New Square, Simmons & Simmons (Mr Doring) Christopher Floyd QC, 11 South Square and Adrian Speck, 8 New Square, Taylor Joynson Garrett (Mr Cohen)

Result Action stayed as result of hearing by Laddie J on 26/27 March. Patent not valid.

fixed 30.01.02

To be heard by Mr Justice Jacob CH/2002/APP/0341 APPEAL by Andrew Tobias Ward against decision of the Comptroller General

Representatives Andrew Ward (in person) Daniel Alexander, 8 New Square, Treasury Solicitor

Result Appeal dismissed with costs. Permission to appeal refused.

½ to 1 day 16.07.02 fixed 16.05.02

HC 01 01878 TLC 35/02 Sun Chemical Corporation (2) Sun Chemical Pigments Limited v CIBA Speciality Chemicals Holdings Inc.

Representatives Peter Prescott QC, 8 New Square and John Hornby Clifford Chance David Kitchin QC and Michael Tappin, 8 New Square, Linklaters Letter received from Linklaters on 25.02.02 indicating increased time estimate of 10 days. Trial vacated from list and to be relisted.

10 days 17.07.02 (time estimate increased from 4/5 days to 7 days on 29.01.02 and to 10 days on 25.02.02) fixed 26.09.01

HC 01 01586 Fletcher v (1) Trevor Davies (2) Public Forums Internet PFI

Representatives Mr Fletcher (in person) (1) Alex Hall-Taylor, 4 New Square, Irwin Mitchell (Peter Wilde) (2) Tom Hinchliffe, 3 New Square, John Lewis (Solicitor Advocate) Pumfrey J

Result Judgment reserved. Extempore judgment to be given at 10.00am on 1.08.02

1-1½ days 22.07.02 fixed 20.06.02 (originally listed for 27.06.02 Changed with consent of parties)

HC 01 01870 TLC 127/02 Nutrinova v Hope Chemicals

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC and Colin Birss, 3 New Square, Taylor Joynson Garrett John Baldwin QC, 8 New Square, Linklaters

Result

4 days 19.09.02 fixed 30.11.01 (Arnold Suhr part

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

43

Default judgment entered against Hope on 19.07.02. Settled with Arnold Suhr. Consent order received 26.07.02

of action settled June 02)

HC 01 01878 TLC 35/02 Sun Chemical Corporation (2) Sun Chemical Pigments Limited v CIBA Speciality Chemicals Holdings Inc. To be heard by HHJ Fysh QC sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge

Representatives Peter Prescott QC, 8 New Square and John Hornby Clifford Chance Simon Thorley QC, 3 New Square and Michael Tappin, 8 New Square, Linklaters

Result Trial vacated with consent of parties 31.07.02. Action stayed until 1.12.02.

10 days 14.10.02 fixed 28.03.02

Laddie J HC 02 C01333 Goldschmidt v Cognis Deutschland GMBh (Application under CPR Part 11)

Representatives Michael Tappin, 8 New Square, Bristows Simon Bennett, Solicitor Advocate Lovells

Result Settled. Action discontinued by claimant.

1 ½ days 2.00pm 23.09.02 fixed 26.07.02

Laddie J CH 2002 APP/0570 Appeal by Laurence Antony Brooks against decision of the Comptroller General

Representatives Mark Vanhegan and Benet Brandreth, 11 South Square, Harrison Goddard Foote (Mr Lunt) Counsel (to be advised), Treasury Solicitor

Result Appeal withdrawn.

1 day 27.09.02 fixed 25.07.02

HC 00 04746 TLC 219/01 Celltech Chiroscience Ltd v Medimmune Inc

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Daniel Alexander, 8 New Square, Bird & Bird Antony Watson QC, 3 New Square and Richard Meade, 8 New Square, Blair & Co Jacob J

Result Judgment handed down at 10.00am on 28.10.02. Copy on website.

3 days 1.10.02 (fixed Jul 02) Ran 1 ½ days

HC 01 C04646 TLC 108/02 Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV v Aventi Ltd

Representatives Henry Carr QC, 11 South Square and Guy Burkill QC, 3 New Square, Bristows (Justin Watts) Richard Davies, Hogarth Chambers, Kingsford Stacey Blackwell (Mr Sayid) Trial vacated as a result of application held on 18.07.02. To be relisted not before 11.11.02.

3-4 days 01.10.02 fixed 21.02.02

HC 01 01034 TLC 835/01 Synthon BV v SmithKline Beecham Plc

Representatives Michael Silverleaf QC and Piers Acland, 11 South Square, Bird & Bird Andrew Waugh QC and Justin Turner, 3 New Square, Simmons & Simmons Jacob J

7 days 07.10.02 fixed 05.09.01 Ran 5 days

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

44

Result Judgment handed down at 10.00am on 03.12.02. Copy on website. To be heard by HHJ Fysh QC sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge HC 02 C01532 Smithkline Beecham v Alpharma Ltd

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC and Justin Turner, 3 New Square, Simmons & Simmons (Rowan Freeland) Daniel Alexander and Charlotte May, 8 New Square, Stephenson Harwood (Margaret Lewis)

Result Trial adjourned by consent, floating from 09.12.02

2-3 days 21.10.02 (fixed 02.08.02)

HC 99 02754 Dyson v Hoover Enquiry into damages

Representatives David Kitchin, 8 New Square and Guy Burkill QC, 3 New Square, Olswang Christopher Floyd QC and Mark Vanhegan, 11 South Square, Weightmans Vizards


10 days 21.10.02 fixed 28.09.01

Application for costs HC 99 02754 Dyson v Hoover

Representatives David Kitchin, 8 New Square and Guy Burkill QC, 3 New Square, Olswang Christopher Floyd QC and Mark Vanhegan, 11 South Square, Weightmans Vizards

Result 1. Following acceptance of payment in Dyson entitled to standard costs down to acceptance. 2. Dyson entitled to base + 1% interest on damages, 3. Dates from when interest on damages to run fixed. 4. Dyson entitled to interest on costs at same rate from mid point of commencement of enquiry to acceptance. 5. Dyson to have ¾ of its costs since acceptance of payment in. 6. Permission to both sides to appeal.

1 day NB 11.00am 21.10.02 fixed 04.10.02

Appeal from decision of the Comptroller General Patent Office CH/2002/APP/0650 Oystertec plc v Edward Evans Barker

Representatives Richard Miller QC, 3 New Square, Berg & Co Guy Burkill QC, Edwards Evans Barker Jacob J

Result Judgment handed down on 14.11.02. Copy

1 day 31.10.02 fixed 09.10.02

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

45

on website. (A) HC 01 C04833 TLC 124/02 Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Inc v Istituto Gentili SpA (B) HC 02 CO343 TLC 245/02 TEVA Pharmaceutical Industries Inc v Merck & Co Inc (C) HC 02 C00844/845 Arrow Generics Ltd v (1) Istituto Gentili SpA (2) Merck & Co Inc (D) HC 02 C01025 Generics (UK) Ltd v (1) Istituto Gentili SpA (2) Merck & Co Inc

Representatives (A) Simon Thorley QC, 3 New Square and Piers Acland, 11 South Square, Bird & Bird David Young QC and Tom Hinchliffe, 3 New Square, Lovells (B) As (A) above (C) Michael Tappin, 8 New Square, S J Berwin David Young QC and Tom Hinchliffe, 3 New Square, Lovells (D) Andrew Waugh QC, 3 New Square, Taylor Wessing David Young QC and Tom Hinchliffe, 3 New Square, Lovells Jacob J

Result Judgment handed down at 2.00pm on 21 January 2003. Copy on website.

7-8 days 05.11.02 (estimate increased to 5-6 days by consent 12.03.02 and to 7-8 days on 3.05.02) fixed 01.02.02 Ran 5 ½ days

Appeal from decision of the Comptroller General Patent Office CH/2002/APP/0744 CH/2002/APP/0746 Halliburton Energy Services v Baker Hughes Inc

Representatives Justin Turner and Dominic Hughes, 3 New Square, AA Thornton & Co (Philip Curtis) Daniel Alexander, 8 New Square, Boult Wade Tennant (Sarah Merrifield) Jacob J

Result Appeal dismissed with costs.

1 day 14.11.02 fixed 22.10.02 (date changed from 15.11.02 at request of court)

HC 00 5493 TLC 764/01 British Telecom v Intec

Representatives David Kitchin QC and Robert Onslow, 8 New Square, Wragge & Co Peter Prescott QC, 8 New Square and Iain Purvis, 11 South Square, Arnold & Porter

Result Settled. Letter of consent to vacate from list received from Wragge & Co 21.10.02.

5 days 18.11.02 fixed 2.10.01

CH 98 F 2196 TLC 712/01 Acme v French

Representatives Richard Arnold QC, 11 South Square, Wragge & Co

5-7 days 27.11.02 fixed 2.10.01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

46

Alistair Wilson QC, 19 Old Buildings, Jacobsens

Result Settled. Consent order dated 14.10.02 HC 02 C01532 TLC 604/02 Smithkline Beecham v Alpharma Ltd

Representatives Andrew Waugh QC, Justin Turner and Geoffrey Pritchard, 3 New Square, Simmons & Simmons (Rowan Freeland) Daniel Alexander, Charlotte May and Iona Berkeley, 8 New Square, Stephenson Harwood (Margaret Lewis)


2-3 days 09.12.02 fixed 02.10.02

To be heard by Mr Justice Pumfrey HC 01 C01435 TLC 131/02 Intel v Via Technologies (Chipset)

Representatives David Kitchin QC, 8 New Square, Henry Whittle and Brian Nicholson, 11 South Square, Bird & Bird Christopher Floyd QC, 11 South Square, Adrian Speck, 8 New Square, Bristows (Justin Watts) Trial date vacated with consent of parties and the court 12.11.02, to be relisted for 12.05.03

8 days 9.12.02 fixed 21.12.01

RESULTS OF APPLICATIONS Chancery Number 97 Q 3885 Quadrant Holdings Cambridge Limited and anr v Quadrant Research Foundation and ors

9am 4 12 97

Orders relating to discovery made

Chancery Number 96 H 51 Hoechst Celenese Corp v BP

9.30am 4 12 97

Orders relating to discovery made.

Chancery Number 97 S 4180 Smith Kline Beecham v Connought Laboratories

9.30am 8 12 97

Trial fixed for 6 5 97. Reserved to Mr Justice Laddie

Chancery Number 97 L 3947 Lacroiz Duraib SA v Kwikform UK Limited

9.30am 9 12 97

Defendant’s application for summary judgment for finding of non-infringement dismissed with costs. Leave to appeal given.

Chancery Number 97 B 1495 Boston Scientific v Palmaz

9 30am 12 12 97

(1) Agreed order for further and better particulars of particulars of objections. Agreed order for additional expert witness. Costs in cause. (2) Respondents application for further admissions in relation to allegation of infringement, dismissed with costs.

Chancery Number 97 B 6228 Bayer Corp v Octapharma Ltd

9.30am 17 12 97

Terms of discovery agreed between parties. Application withdrawn 14 12 97.

Chancery Number 97 U 5284 Unilever v ARC

9 15am 18 12 97

Order for directions made.

Chancery Number 95 T 302 Targetti v Altima Lighting Ltd

10am 18 12 97

Order made as to exchange of expert evidence before 5 January 1998

Chancery Number 95 O 3948 OCLI v Pilkington

10am 18 12 97

Consent order made as to terms agreed. Stood over as Motion by Order.

Chancery Number 97 P 6352 PCME Ltd v Goyen Controls Co UK

9.30am 12 1 98

Telephone summons. Withdrawn by consent.

Chancery Number 95 H 51 Hoechst Celanese Corp v BP Chemicals

9.30am 13 1 98

Telephone Summons Withdrawn by consent.

Chancery Number 97 D 5697 Demel v C & H Jefferson & Logan

10am 13 1 98

Application to stay in English proceedings refused. Leave to amend pleadings. Timetable for trial fixed provisionally

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

47

for 6.4.98 for 3 days. Chancery Numbers 96 R 7384 and 96 R 7835 Rolac Limited v Passenger Lift Services Rolac Ltd v Gatley Engineering Ltd

9.30am 14 1 98

Timetable set. Infringment and amendment to be tried together.Leave to set down for trial to take place not before 1 6 98. Estimate 2 days.

Chancery Number 96 D 5697 Dentsply International Inc v Ivoclar-vivadent Ltd

10.30am 15 1 98

Settled. Application withdrawn 18 12 97

Chancery Number 97 H 3796 Hadley Industries PLC v Metal Sections Ltd

9.30am 15.1.98

Directions given.

Chancery Number 94 S 1719 Sandvick v Pfiffner

10am 16 1 98

Withdrawn to be joined with application on 23 1 98

Chancery Number 97 M 5179 Mod-Tap W Corporation v B I Communications Plc

10am 16.1.98

Withdrawn by consent.

Chancery Number 97 B 1489 Compaq Computer

9.45am 19 1 98

Withdrawn by consent

Chancery Number 97 B 1495/6 Boston v Palmaz

9.30am 19.1.98

Leave to amend particulars of objection. Application to strike out paragraphs in particulars of objection refused.

Chancery Number 97 W 6881 Wheel Wash Ltd v Chum Engineering

20.1.98 9.30am

Application for summary judgment or interlocutory injunction refused. Speedy trial ordered. Timetable set. Action set down to commence on 25 2 98. Estimated duration three days.

Chancery Number 96 W 428 Tanis Patricia Wakefield v Maxon Cellular Systems

9.30am 21 1 98

Withdrawn by consent. Order made.

Chancery Number 96 D 161 Discovision Associates v Discotronics

9.45am 22 1 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Notice of Motion. Withdrawn by consent. To be re-fixed.

Chancery Number 97 U 4863 Ultra Frame PLC v BAC Ltd

9.30am 22.1.98.

Directions given

Chancery Number 94 S 1719 Sandvick v Ppiffner

9.15am 23 1 98

Mr Justice Neuberger. Application for extension not allowed.Counsel to draft order with liberty to re apply. Cost order made.

Chancery Number 97 S 5745 Samsung Electronics Co Limited v Fujitsu Limited

9.30am 23 1 98

Directions given

Chancery Number 97 P 1383 Petrolite Holdings v Dino Oil

9.30am 26 1 98

Withdrawn by consent 26.1.98. Order made.

Appeal 16/96 British Coal v Glaverbell

24.2.98 Appeal withdrawn 26.1.98

Chancery Number 97 M 4456 Thomas McAlister McNieven v Wallace

9.45am 26 1 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Judgment in default of defence.


9.40am 27 1 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given. Order made

Chancery Number 96 V 7408 VISX v Nidak

9.30am 27 1 98

Leave to amend particulars of objections refused in part. 4 year limit on discovery removed. Plaintiff ordered to provide written statement of grounds for asserting that all 51 claims in patents were independently valid.

Chancery Number 97 D 5697 Siegfried Demel v Jefferson

10am 28 1 98

Application for interlocutory injunctions refused on defendants giving assurance that no threats would be made. Defendants to specify which claims of patent in suit alleged to be infringed within 10 days. Costs in cause.

Chancery Number 93 K 937 Kiren Amgen v Boehringer Mannheim & ors

2pm 29 1 98

Deputy High Court Judge D Young QC

Chancery Number 97 S 5754 Samseng Electronics & Co v Fujitsu Micro Electronics

9.30am 29 1 98

Trial date fixed to come on not before 13 10 98 general Chancery list.

Chancery Number 97 Z 2149 Zweva Holdings v Valley Industries

9.30am 30.1.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Application to put in experiments refused.

Chancery Number 97 U 5044 Ultraframe v Northstar Systems

9.30am 2 2 98

Withdrawn by consent, Order made. 30.1.98

Chancery Number 96 C 2160 Chiron v Evans

10am 2.2.98

Order for costs made.

Chancery Number 95 C 2014 9.15am Telephone Summons. Order made. Trial date fixed for

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

48

Carflow Products v Linwood securities 3.2.98 25.2.98 Chancery Number 97 C 4152 Claydon v Claydon Hamilton

9.30 4 2 98

Mr Justice Jacob. Withdrawn by consent. Order made.

Chancery Number 97 B 1489 Compaq Computer

9.30am 5.2.98


Chancery Number 97 T 1174 Tyco Toys v Tomy UK

9.30am 6 2 98

Mr Justice Jacob. Withdrawn by consent. Order made

Chancery Number 97 P 1383 Petrolite Holdings v Dino Oil

9.30am 10.2.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Judgment to be given Monday 16.2.98

Chancery Number Davis v Ecoprogress Ltd

10am 10.2.98

Consent order made

Chancery Number 97 W 6881 Wheelwash Limited v Wheelclean

2pm 12 2 98

Order made. Trial moved to not before 21.4.98

Chancery Number 94 S 1719 Sandvick v Zhuzou

10am 13 2 98


Chancery Number 97 B 1495 Boston v Palmaz

10am 16.2.98

Order made. Mr Justice Jacob

Chancery Number 95 C 7494 Charlsworth v Relay Roads

10am 18 2 98

Order made Mr Justice Pumfrey

Chancery Number 97 O 1923 Oneach v Raychem

10am 18.2.98

Order made Mr Justice Jacob

Chancery Number 95 C 3418 Colpac plc v St Neots Packaging Ltd

10am 19.2.98

Order made Mr Justice Pumfrey

Chancery Number 98 A 479 Anderson v Beldray

10am 3.3.98

Withdrawn by consent. Order made

Chancery Number 97 B 4885/6 Boston Scientific Ltd v Cordis Corp

10am 24.2.98


Chancery Number 97 M 6198 Mod-tap W Corp v Communication Trade Supplies Ltd

9.15am 24.2.98

Withdrawn by consent. Trial set down for 22.6.98 in the Patents Court.

Chancery Number 97 T 1174 Tyco Toys (Matel) Inc v Tomy

10am 26 2 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent. Trial fixed for 7.12.98

Chancery Number 97 W 6881 Wheelwash Limited v Wheelclean International

10.30am 26.2.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent.

Chancery Number 97 B 5768 British Technology Group Ltd v Depuy Orth.

9.45am 27.2.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn by consent. Trail date fixed for 15 6 98

Chancery Number 97 S 4108 SmithKline Beecham v Connought Laboratories

9.45am 27 2 98

Mr Justice Laddie. Consent order and order for discovery made.

Chancery Number 96 D 161 Discovision Associates v Discotronics Ltd

10am 3 3 98

Mr Justice Laddie

Chancery Number 96 H 51 Hoechst Celanese Corporation v BP Chemicals and Purolite Int Ltd

10.30am 4.3.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Orders relating to discovery and further conduct of the proceedings made.

Chancery Number 94 C 3477 Cantor Fitzgerald v Thompson UK

9.15am 5.3.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order made as to discovery

Chancery Number 97 B 1495/6 Boston Scientific v Palmaz

10am 6.3.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Order made as to further conduct of case.

Chancery Number 96 V 7408 Visx v Nidek

9.30am 10.3.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Order for discovery made. Leave to appeal refused.

Chancery Number 96 B 4432 Braided Fishing Lines v Fly Fishing Corp

10am 10.3.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Two applications for security refused.

Chancery Number 97 T 6180 The Horne Engineering Co Ltd v Reliance Water Controls Ltd

9.45am 12 3 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order made for trial to be set down.

Chancery Number 96 C 4344 Co-Flexip Stort Comex Seaway

12pm 12.3.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Application to move the trial date due to illness of witness. Order made for trial to be heard on 9.11.98

Chancery Number 94 S 1719 10am Mr Justice Neuberger. Withdrawn by consent.

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

49

Sandvick v Zhuzo 13 3 98 Chancery Number 97 B 3851 Cartonneries De Thulin SA v White Knight Products Ltd

9.45am 18 3 98

Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent. Order made.

Chancery Number 97 H 5151 Hewlett Packard GMBH v Wates Corporation

10am 20 3 98


Chancery Number 97 T 1174 Tyco Toys (Matel) Inc v Tomy UK

9.30am 8.4.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Withdraw to be heard on 24.4.98

Chancery Number 26.3.98 Cantor Fitzgerald v Tradition UK

9.45am 26.3.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Removed to general chancery list to be heard as a notice of motion the matter not being patents.

Chancery Number 97 H 4108 Smith Kline Beecham v Connought Laboratories

9.45am 25 3 98

Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn. Consent order 24.3.98

Chancery Number 97 H 3960 Hadley Industries PLC v Metal Sections

2pm 25.3.98

Mr Justice Jacob. Application to change trial date. Moved to 22 September 1998.

Chancery Number Pifco v Phillips

9.45am 31 3 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn

Chancery Number 95 H 4657 Robert William Hewitt v P McCann Ltd

10am 30.3.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Directions made. Trial to be set down not before 1 July 1998. Reference to Practice Directions regarding advisability of using the Telephone Summons system for certain cases.

Chancery Number 96 L 6884 Lucas Industries PLC v Lawrence Shaw

9.30am 31.3.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Leave to amend defence. Application for split trial refused. Directions given.

Chancery Number 97 N 3766 Norton v 3M

9.45am 1.4.98

(S) Mr Justice Laddie. Application for specific discovery refused. Leave to amend particulars of objections.

Chancery Number 96 W 428 Wakefield v Maxon Cellular Assistance

9.45am 2.4.98

(S).Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent 1.4.98.

Chancery Number 97 M 4790 Matthew Gloag & So v Welsh Distillers

10am 2.4.98

(S) Mr Justice Laddie. Order made


9.45am 3.4.98

(S) Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent 2.3.98

Chancery Number 97 M 5925 Mul-T-Lock v Wishside

9.45am 3.4.98

(S) Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn

Chancery Number 96 M 768 & 96 M 1099 Melea Ltd v Cinpress

9.45am 7 4 98

(S) Mr Justice Laddie. Leave to discontinue action. Plaintiff to pay costs to be taxed on normal basis. Conditions imposed re future litigation.

Chancery Number Samsung Electronics Co v Sujitsu

9.45am 8.4.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent.

Chancery Number 94 B 5219 Braine v Ingledew Brown

10am 8.4.98

Mr Justice Neuberger. Directions made.

Chancery Number 97 B 5540 Bradley Glass Ltd v Temple Components

9.30am 22.4.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. To be set down as a speedy trial - 1 day in duration.

Chancery Number 97 Q 3885 Quadrant Holdings v Quadrant Research

9.45am 23 4 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Consent order made.

Chancery Number 97 N 2698 Bristol Myers Squibb v Baker Norton Ph.

9.45am 24.4.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given. Costs in cause

Chancery Number 97 T 1174 Tyco Toys v Tomy

9.45am 24.4.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent. Order made.

Chancery Number 94 B 5219 Brain v Ingledew

10am 27.4.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Order made.

Chancery Number 97 S 5709 Scotia Holdings PLC v Peter Black Health Care

9.45am 27.4.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order for directions made including order for primer.

Chancery Number 353 1234 Hoechst Celanese Corp v BP Chemicals

9.45am 28.4.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn. Consent order made.

Chancery Number 92 B 5624 Biogen Inc

10am 29.4.98

Mr Justice Neuberger. Leave to amend given.

Chancery Number 97 N 3766 Norton v 3M

9.45am 29.4.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given. Order made.

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

50

Chancery Number 97 M 5179 Mod Tap W Corp v By Comms

9.45am 30 4 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Leave to amend granted. Trial extended to two days

Chancery Number 97 W 6881 Wheelwash v Wheelclean

9.45am 1.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent 30 4 98

Chancery Number 98 C 2343 Roy William Campbell v Karren

9.45am 5.5.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent 1.5.98

Chancery Number 97 M 4456 Thomas McAllister McNiven v Wallace & ors

9.45am 5.5.95

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Chancery Number 97 B 5768 British Technology Group Ltd v Depuy Orthopaedics

9.30am 6.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Adjourned to a date to be fixed for judgment.

Chancery Number 97 U 1608 Nestle v Unilever

9.45am 6.5.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Consent order made.

Chancery Number 95 C 3477 Cantor Fitzgerald v Tradition

9.45am 8.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order made

Chancery Number 97 B 4804 Peter Brawley v Marczynski

9.45am 15.5.98

Mr Mark Goodwin (solicitor) Telephone summons. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent and order made.


9.30am 12.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Amendments allowed. Letters of request

Chancery Number 97 M 4456 Thomas McAllister McNiven v Wallace & ors

9.45am 14.5.95

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn.

Chancery Number 97 B 5768 British Technology Group Ltd v Depuy Orthopaedics

4pm 14.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Application to amend refused with costs. Leave to appeal.

Chancery Number 97 M 5179 Mod-tap v By-Comms

9.45am 15.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order for amendment.

Chancery Number 96 C 6792 Consaf Engineering v Emtunga

9.45am 18.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order agreed between parties

Chancery Number 97 M 5801 Massmould Mouldings v Portola Packaging

9.30am 19.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order made

Chancery Number 97 P 6317 Ch 98 D 276 David Halsall plc v Bestoy NY Ltd

9.45am 20.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey Telephone summons. Directions given. Order made

Chancery Number 95 C 3418 Colpac v St Neots

10am 20.5.98

Mr Justice Neuberger

Chancery Number 97 B 5540 Bradley Glass v Temple Components

9.45am 21.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey Order agreed between parties.

Chancery Number 96 B 4432 Braided International Lines v Fly Fishing Corp

2pm 21 5 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. No order made. Dealt with by consent.


9.30am 22.5.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Directions made. Telephone summons

Chancery Number 98 W 1063 Davina Wheatley Bortec Ltd v Drill Safe Ltd

9.45am 22.5.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given.


10am 21 5 98

Mr Justice Neuberger. Directions given.

Chancery Number 95 C 3477 Cantor Fitzgerald Int v Tradition UK

9.30am 2.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Stood over to 9.6.98

Chancery Number 95 B 8130 & 4432 Braided International Lines v Fly Fishing Technology Ltd

10 30am 2.6.98

Mr Justice Neuberger (Motions Court). Directions given

Chancery Number 94 D 2483 Davis v Ecoprogress Ltd

10am 3.6.98

Mr Justice Laddie Telephone summons. Split trial agreed. Directions made.

Chancery Number 98 Q 1947 QA Environmental Products

9.45am 3.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Agreed between parties. Directions made.


9.45am 4.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Agreed between parties. Directions made.

Chancery Number 98 L 3038 Light Dome Road Marker Inserts Ltd v Knight Advanced Plolymers Ltd

10am 5.6.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Telephone summons. Order made for one day trial to be heard the last two weeks of July.

Chancery Number 95 H 3456 9.45am Mr Justice Pumfrey Telephone summons. Consent

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

51

Hoechst Celenese Corp v BP 5.6.98 order made. Chancery Number 95 C 3477 Cantor Fitzgerald Int v Tradition UK

9.30am 9.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Judgment 10 30am 12.6.98

Chancery Number 95 I 3482 David Instance v Denny Bros

9.45am 11.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn

Chancery Number 98 N 131 Napp Pharm. Group Ltd v Aster Medical Ltd

9.45am 12.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey Order made and trial to be set down in general chancery list


10.15am 12.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order made. Trial to be set down for one day not before 6.7.98

Chancery Number 96 M 768 Melea Ltd v Cinpres Ltd

9.45am 16.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn 15.6.98 by agreement

Chancery Number 96 C 6792 Consaf Engineering v Emtunga

9.45am 19.6.98


Chancery Number 96 M 768 Cimpres Ltd v Melia

9.45am 17.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 96 V 7408 Visx Incorporated v Nidek Company Ltd

9 45am 18 6 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Application for discovery denied.


2pm 23 6 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent on 19.6.98

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 Texas Electronics v Hyundai Electronics

9.45am 22.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given. Stay refused. To return in 14 days


9.45am 23 6 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent.


10.30am 24.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey.

Chancery Number 97 N 2698 Bristol-Myers Sqibb Company v Baker Norton Pharmaceuticals and Napro Biotherapeutics Inc

10am 26.6.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Petitioner given option (to be exercised by Tuesday 30 June 10.30am) to amend particulars of objections in which case trial date of 7 July vacated on terms as to costs, or to withdraw application to amend in which case trial date is confirmed.

Chancery Number 97 P 5304 Pifco Ltd v Phillips Domestic Appliances

9.30am 26.6.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdraw by consent


10am 30 6 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey.Withdrawn by consent


9.45am 1.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Trial date set for 2pm 14 4 99

Chancery Number 95 C 2014 Carflow Products (UK) Ltd v Linwood Securities

9.30am 2 7.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Order made.

Chancery Number 98 B 2512 Balmoral Group Ltd v CRP Marine Ltd

10am 2.7.98


Chancery Number 97 N 2698 Bristol-Myers Sqibb Company v Baker Norton Pharmaceuticals and Napro Biotherapeutics Inc

10am 3.7.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent 2.7.98

Chancery Number 95 H 3456 Hoechst Celanese Corp v BP Chemicals & Purilite Ltd

9.45am 3.7.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 2.7.98.

Chancery Number 98 W 806 Tanis Patricia Wakefield & Ors v Ericsson Ltd.

9.45am 8.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn 2.7.98

Chancery Number 95 C 3477 Cantor Fitzgerald Int & ors Tradition UK Ltd

9.45am 3.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn with agreed order.

Chancery Number 94 B 5218 Braine v Ingledew Brown Bennison Garrett

10.30am 8.7.98

Mr Justice Laddie (Motions Court)

Chancery Number 96 v 7408 Visx Incorporated v NideK Co Ltd

10am 8 7 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Injunction refused. Costs reserved.


9.45am 9.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Agreement reached. No order made. Costs reserved.

Chancery Number 98 A 1984 10.30am Mr Justice Pumfrey. Application dismissed.

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

52

A Fulton Company Ltd v Grant Barnett & Co Lt

9.7.98


9.45am 10.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Application for extension of time for discovery approved.

Chancery Number 98 N 131 Napp Pharm. Group Ltd v Aster Medical Ltd

9.45am 13.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent


9.45am 16.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent. 15.7.98

Chancery Number 95 H 3456 Hoechst Cellanese Corp v BP Chemicals

9.30am 17.7.98

Mr Justice Laddie (Telephone Summons). Withdrawn to be heard on 20.7.98

Chancery Number 96 S 6004 Sony Electronics Publishing Ltd v Computer Exchange Games Ltd

10.30am 17.7.98


Chancery Number 95 H 3456 Hoechst Cellanese Corp v BP Chemicals

1.30pm 20 7 98

Mr Justice Laddie (Telephone Summons). Withdrawn.


2.pm 20 7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey Order agreed

Chancery Number 97 Q 3885 Quadrant Holdings v Quadrant Bio Reources

2pm 21 7 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order agreed


9.45am 21 7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Put over as a restored motion to 12 noon 29 7 98.

Chancery Number Opt-Tel Ltd v Telecom

9.45am 22.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent.

Chancery Number 95 C 2014 Carflow Products v Linwood Secureties

10am 23.7.98

Mr Justice Laddie.Telephone summons Directions given

Chancery Number 98 M 1421 Monsanto Co & GD Searle and Merek Inc

9.45am 24.7.98


Chancery Number 97 C 4152 Claydon v Claydon

9.45am 28 7 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order 14 granted

Chancery Number 98 R 2938 Ramair Filters (Europe) Ltd v Thomas Ivor Goodwin

9.45am 28 7 98


Chancery Number 94 I 7002 Iscar Ltd v Plansee

9.30am 31 7 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent 28 7 98. Order made.

Chancery Number 98 R 846 Reflective Technology Industries v Reflective Technology Inc.

9.45am 29.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Application dismissed. Directions given.

Chancery Number 97 B 5540 Bradley Glass Ltd v Temple Components.

11am 29.7.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Leave to discontinue on terms. Judgment for the plaintiff.

Chancery Number 98 T 360 TH Goldschmidt AG v Euro-o-Compound Belgium

9.45am 30 7 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order agreed.


11am 30.7.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Order made. Directions given.

Chancery Number (awaits) Cambridge Positioning Systems

12noon 30.7.98

Mr Justice Laddie (Ex parte). Agreed order.

Chancery Number 96 M 768 Melea Ltd v Cimpress

9am 31 7 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Telephone summons.

Chancery Number 98 W 806 Wakefield, Newell & Pendawell Ltd v Ericsson

9.30am 31 7 98

Mr Justice Laddie. Leave to amend statement of claim. Amendment proceedings to be joined in Maxon case. Discovery ordered. Application for security stood over. Defendant’s cost in cause.

Chancery Number 97 H 3960 Hadley Industries PLC v Metal Section

2pm 31 7 98

Mr Justice Laddie Telephone Summons

Chancery Number 97 T 1174 Tyco Toys & anr v Tomy

11am 31 7 98

Mr Justie Laddie. Withdrawn by consent. 30 7 98

Chancery Number 94 S 1719 Sandvik AB v KR Piffiner (UK)

12noon 31 7 98

Mr Justice Laddie. Telephone summons. Withdrawn by consent. 30 7 98

Chancery Number 97 B 5540 Bradley Glass Ltd v Temple Components.

10am 31 7 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn. 29 7 98

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

53

Chancery Number 98 W 806 Wakefield, Newell & Pendawell Ltd v Ericsson

9.30am 24 9 98

Mr Justice Laddie. Order made


9.45am 2.9.98


Chancery Number 98 D 3365 Doerman v Scalewatcher

9.45am 4.9.98

Withdrawn

Chancery Number 98 T 360 T H Goldschmidt AG v Euro Compound Begium NV

9.30am 7 9 98

Withdrawn

Chancery Number 96 M 768 Melea Ltd v Compress Ltd

9.30am 9.9.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey.

Chancery Number 98 N 131 Napp Pharmaceutical Group Ltd v Asta Medica Ltd

2pm 10 9 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Stood over to 11 9 98. Order for directions given.

Chancery Number 98 W 806 Wakefield v Ericsson

9.15am 15 9 98

Telephone Summons. Withdrawn.

Chancery Number 94 C1867 Colpac v St Neots Packaging Ltd

9.30am 16 9 98

Mr Justice Laddie. Pt Hd. Further hearing on 18.9.98

Chancery Number 97 B 6228 Bayer Corp v Octaphama Ltd

9.45am 17 9 98

Withdrawn 16.9.98

Chancery Number 94 C 1867 Colpac Ltd v St Neots Packaging

9.30am 18.9.98

Mr Justice Laddie.Trial date changed to a date to be fixed with Clerk of the Lists.

Chancery Number 98 X 3769 XAAR Technology Ltd v Calcomp

9.45am 13 10 98

withdrawn 21 9 98


9.45am 23 9 98

Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given as to discovery.

Chancery Number 98 W 806 Wakefield Newell v Ericsson

9.30am 24.9.98

Mr Justice Laddie. Security ordered. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 M 1421 G D Searle Merck Inc v Cox

9.30am 25 9 98

Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given.

Chancery Number 95 M 7229 Melea v Cimpress

9.30am 1 10 98

Telephone summons. Withdrawn 29.9.98

Chancery Number 97 O 1923 Raychem Ltd v Oneac Corp Ltd

9.45am 2.10.98

Summons withdrawn. Consent Order made


9.45am 15 10 98

To be heard with another application in the same name on 23 October 1998. 1 day.

Chancery Number 98 O 1102 & 98 1103 Isaac Ofen & Tiny Hove Ltd v Redbox (Toys) UK Ltd and Martin Yaafelt Ltd & Argos

9.30am 19 10 98

Withdrawn 5 10 98

Chancery Number 96 A 2086 A T Engineering v Aptec Surface

9.15am 7.10.98

Withdrawn 6 10 98 to be refixed

Chancery Number 96 A 2087 AT Poeton v Horton

9.30am 20 10 98

Withdrawn 6 10 98 to be refixed

Chancery Number 98 I 4087 I C I Chemicals v Lubrizoc

9.45am 8 10 98

Withdrawn. Agreed order made 6 10 98

Chancery Number 97 B 6228 Bayer corporation v Octapharma Ltd

10 15 am 9.10.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Telephone summons. Withdrawn 8 10 98. Agreed order

Chancery Number 97 A 3077 AMTL Corp v Food Tolerance

9.45am 12 10 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn 9 10 98 Agreed order


9.30am 13.10.98

Directions given Stood over to 23 10 98

Chancery Number 98 A 3258 Adnan Latif v Isis Inovation Ltd

9.30am 16 2 98

Withdrawn 14 10 98

Chancery Number 97 C 7012 Polypipe v Lewis Jackson

9.30am 14 10 98


Chancery Number 98 A 1057 9.30am Directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

54

ACO Technology PLC v Hauraton Kaskade Ltd

15 10 98

Chancery Number 96 R 3171 & 96 R 5680 Bourns Inc v Raychem Corp

9 45am 16 10 98

Directions given

Chancery Number Awaits Goldschmidt AG v Eurocompound & ors

9.30am 19 10 98

Directions given

Chancery Number 96 M 768 Melea v Cimpress

9.30am 20 10 98

Directions given

Chancery Number 96 R 3171 & 96 R 5680 Bourns Inc v Raychem Corp

9 25am 16 10 98

Telephone application.

Chancery Number 97 W 5151 Helett Packard v Waters Corp

9.30am 21 10 98

Withdrawn. Agreed order

Chancery Number 98 I 4087 Lubrizol Corp v Imperial Chemical Industries.

9.30am 22 10 98

Summons In chambers. Withdrawn 21 10 98. Order made.

Chancery Number 96 C 7279 CA Giner v Technoplast Kunstoff Technic

9.30am 29 10 98

Summons. In chambers. Withdrawn 13 10 98 to be re-issued in one month’s time

Chancery Number 97 M 3722 Norton Health Care v 3M

9.15am 22 10 98

Motion Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 96 R 3171 Bourns Inc v Raychem Corp & ors

10 30am 22 10 98

Motion. Adjourned as part heard to 2 11 98. See details in list of trials.

Chancery Number 97 B 4804 Peter Brawley v Michael Marezynski & anr

9.15am 23 10 98

Telephone Summons. Withdrawn 22 10 98 Consent order made

Chancery Number 98 N 131 Napp Pharmaceutical Group Ltd v Asta Medical Ltd

10 30am 23 10 98

Motion. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 E 3801 Eli Lilly & Co v Novo Nordisk

9 15am 26 10 98

Telephone summons. Directions given. Order made

Chancery Number 98 B 2512 Balmoral Group v CRP Marine

9.30am 26 10 98

Summons. In chambers Order made. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 N 4731 Nutrinova Nutrition v Scanchem UK Ltd

9.15am 28 10 98

Summons. In chambers. Plaintiff given leave to ammend particulars of infringement. Ordered to produce statement of claim within 7 days. Plaintiff to pay costs on indemnity basis.

Chancery Number 97 C 7012 Polypipe v Lewis Jackson

9.30am 29 10 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey. Motion. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 R 277 Raintex Ltd v C & A

10 30am 4 11 98

Order 14. Withdrawn 30 10 98

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 Texas Instruments v Hyundai Electronics

9.30am 30 10 98

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number98 T 4928 Alfred Alexander Taylor v Ishida (Europe) Ltd & anr

9 45am 2.11.98

Summons. In chambers. Trial fixed for 24 5 98

Chancery Number 95 M 1672 The Mead Corporation & anr v Riverwood International & anr

9.30am 3 11 98

Summons. In chambers. Directions given


9.30am 4 11 98

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn 3 11 98

Chancery Number 96 M 768 Melea Limited v Cinpress Limited

9.30am 4.11.98

Motion. Withdrawn 3 11 98

Chancery Number 97 T 6180 The Horne Enginering Co v The Reliance Water Controls Ltd

9.30am 5 11 98

Summons. In chambers. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 W 1063 Wheatley v Drillsafe

9 30am 6.11 98

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn

Chancery Number 98 I 1103 Isaac Oren & Tiny Love Ltd v Red Box Toy Factory Ltd & Yaffe Int

9.30am 6 11 98

Summons. In chambers. Trial date set for 18 12 98

Chancery Number 98 W 806 Wakefield v Ericsson

9.30am 11 11 98

Motion. Withdrawn. 10 11 98. Consent order made.

Chancery Number 95 W 4297 9.45am Motion. Order made.

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

55

Rugby Building Systems Ltd v AR Hodgspn Steels Ltd

10 11 98


9.30am 13 11 98

Restored summons. Mr Justice Pumfrey

Chancery Number Ch 97 T 6180 The Horne Engineering Company Ltd v Reliance Water Controls Lts

17 11 98 NB

9.30am

Restored Motion. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 J 5714 Johnson Matthey PLC v Degusa Aktiengesellschaft & anr

18 11 98 9.30am


Chancery Number 98 D 3365 Dolman v Scalewatcher

19 11 98 9.45am

Summons by telephone. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 H 4568 Harberman v E & A Marketing

19 11 98 9.30am


Chancery Number 98 S 6027 Surface Technology Plc v Peter David Young

24.11.98 9.30am

Motion Directions. Mr Justice Neuberger. Injunction granted (as agreed by Parties) S/O MBO 1st available date after 15.12.98

Chancery Number 98 M 1421 G D Searle Merck Inc v Cox

25 11 98 9.30am

No Order on notice of motion, save costs in Plaintiff’s cause

Chancery Number 96 M 768 Melea Limited v Cimpress Limited

1.12.98 9.30am

Mr Justice Laddie - application for directions re order. Withdrawn by consent 30 11 98. Order made

Chancery Number 94 S 1719 Sandvik v Pfiffner

2.12.98 9.30am

Motion. Withdrawn. Consent order made.

Chancery Number 98 N 2455 & 2692 NEC v Hyundai

9.30am 9 12 98

Summons for directions. Withdrawn 4 12 98

Chancery Number 98 I 2983 David John Instance & anr v Eteco S.A.R.L.

9.30am 4 12 98

Notice of motion. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 E 3801 Eli Lilly & Co v. Novo Nordisk

9.30am 4.12.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey - application for stay. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 E 4167 Eliza Tinsley Group Plc v. Tool & Steel Products Ltd

9.30am 7.12.98

To join two Defendants. Directions given


9.45am 7 12 98

Motion for directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 95 C 2014 Carflow Products (UK) Limited v Linwood Securities (Birmingham) Limited & Ors

9.30am 8 12 98

Summons for directions. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 T 315 Tetra Pak v APV

9 45am 8 12 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey - Summons for directions. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 S 5110 Sepracor Inc v Hoechst Marion Roussel Limited & ors

9.30am 15 12 98

Motion. Removed from list. Not enough time. To be set down during 1999.

Chancery Number 94 I 7002 Iscar Limited v Plansee Tizet GMBH

9.30am 9 12 98

Motion. Withdrawn 8 12 98 to be refixed.

Chancery Number 98 N 131 Napp Pharmaceutical Ltd v Asta Medica Ltd

9.30am 10 12 98

Mr Justice Pumfrey Summons for directions. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 C 3129 Collag Corporation & Anr v. Merck & Co Inc

9.30am 10.12.98

Summons for directions. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 S 6027 Surface Technology PLC v Peter Young & ors

10am 15 12 98

Motion.Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 11 12 98

Chancery Number 97 T 6180 The Horne Engineering Co Ltd v Reliance Water Controls Ltd

9.30am 11.12.98

Motion for directions.Mr Justice Laddie. Application to change trial date refused.

Chancery Number 98 L 2976 Michael John Lunn v Andrew Grayshon

9.30am 11.12.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey - Summary judgment re Order 14. Order made

Chancery Number 98 F 2196 Christopher Simon French v Acme Jewelry

9.45am 14 12 98

Telephone Summons. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 J 5714 Johnson Matthey PLC v Degusa

14 12 98 9.30am

Motion.Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given Trial set down for 14 September 1999

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

56

Aktiengesellschaft & anr Chancery Number Alfred Alexander Taylor v Isheda Europe Ltd

9.30am 15 12 98

Summons Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given

Chancery Number 96 A 2086 AT Poeton v Horton

9.30am 16 12 98

Summons. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 A 6244 Alibert Equipment v Ravensbourne Plastics Ltd

9.30am 16 12 98

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 15 12 98. Consent order made

Chancery Number 98 S 5799 3 Ms v. Smith & Nephew

9.30am 17.12.98

Mr Justice Pumfrey .Application for extension of time. Directions Given.

Chancery Number 96 C 7279 CA Giner v Technoplast Kunstoff Technic

9.30am 17.12.98

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 Texas Electronice v Hyundai Electronics

9.30am 18 12 98

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 N 4732 Nutinova v Fuerst Day Lawson.

9.30am 21 12 98

Restored Summons. Mr Justice Laddie . Directions made

Chancery Number 98 O 1765 Oakley Inc Adidas Int & ors

9 30am 12 1 99

Summons for directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent 11 1 99.

Chancery Number 97 P 5304 Personal Care BV & anr Pifco Ltd v Philips Domestic Appliances

9.30am 13 1 99

Leave to appeal. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Granted

Chancery Number 98 S 5905 Sara Lee Household & Bodycare UK Ltd v Johnson Wax Ltd

9.30am 25 1 99

Summons for directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 13 1 99

Chancery Number 98 F 6089 Forbo-Karommenie v Sommer Ltd

9.30am 15 1 99


Chancery Number Ch 98 E 3046 Errut Products Ltd v Bomag GmbH

9.30am 18 1 99

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn 15 1 99

Chancery Number 98 D 6187 Rowlett Catering Appliances Ltd

9.30am 19 1 99


Chancery Number 98 H 4328 Hewlett Packard GMBH v Waters Corporation and Waters Ltd

9.30am 19 1 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn

Chancery Number 96 G 2541 Graco Children’s Products Inc v CNH Ltd

9.30am 21 1 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn

Chancery Number 98 N 4732 Nutinova v Fuerst Day Lawson.

9.30am 20 1 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey . Directions given

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 Alfred Alexander Taylor v Isheda

9.45am 21 1 99

Summons for direction. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 21 1 99 Cartonneries De Thulin SA v White Knight Products Ltd

10am 21 1 99

Further argument. Mr Justice Neuberger

Chancery Number 98 B 4600 Bespak v 3M

9.30am 22.1.99


Chancery Number97 H 3960 Hadley Industries PLC v Metal Sections

9.30am 22.1.99

Telephone summons for directions. Mr Justice Neuberger. Directions given


4pm 22 1 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Trial adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Chancery Number 98 N 131 Napp Pharmaceutical Ltd v Asta Medica

9.30am 25 1 99


Chancery Number 97 P 6352 PCME Ltd v Goyen Controls & Co

9am 29 1 99

Further argument. Mr Justice Laddie


1 2 99 Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 B 2302 Bencor Ltd v Diamont Boart UK Ltd

9.30am 2 2 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Laddie Court 51. Directions given.

Chancery Number 98 M 2151 3Ms v ATI Atlas & ors

9.45am 3 2 99

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn 2 2 99

Chancery Number 97 P 7012 Pollypipe PLC v Lewis Russell Jackson

9.45am 4 2 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey – directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

57

Chancery Number Texas Instruments v and Hyundai Electronics

10am 5 2 99

Motion Mr Justice Pumfrey – directions given

Chancery Number 97 A 6110 AB Volvo v Heritage Leicester Ltd

9.30am 8 2 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. - Vacated

Chancery Number A 4550 Soyl AG v AG Chem

9.30am 12 2 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. - Vacated

Chancery Number 98 N 4732 Nutrinova Nutrition Specialists Food Ingredients GmBh & anr vFuerst Day Lawson & Scanchem Limited

NB 10.am 12 2 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given – further adjournment to date to be fixed.


12 pm 12 2 99

Motion. Application to vary order. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Minute of order approved.

Chancery Number 98 P 5484 and 99 W 308 PMS International & Ors v Worldwide Snakeboard Marketing

9.30am 15 2 99

Motion to consolidate. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given.

Chancery Number 94 U 5239 Union Carbide Corp v BP Chemicals

9.30am 16 2 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Minute of order lodged.

Chancery Number 98 T 4928 Taylor v Ishida Europe

NB 10 am 16 2 99

Motion. Request for discovery. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Adjourned.

Chancery Number 97 F 2412 Farmer v Mosley Holdings Ltd & anr

9.30am 17 2 99


Chancery Number 98 T 4160 Texas Instruments and Hyundai Electronics

9.30am 18 2 99


Chancery Number 97 P 7012 Polypipe v Lewis Russell Jackson

2pm 18 2 99

Application for extension of time re service of witness statements. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn

Chancery Number 98 N 4731 Nutrinova Nutrition v Scanchem UK Ltd

9 30am 19 2 99

Motion. Request for unless order. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent


2pm 19 2 99

Ex Parte on notice. Directions given

Chancery Number Johnson Matthey PLC v Degussa AKT

9.30am 22 2 99


Chancery Number 93 E 7192 Uni-Continental Holdings Ltd v Eurobond Adhesives Ltd

10.30am 22 2 99

Further argument. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Adjourned for several weeks

Chancery Number 95 M 1672 Meade v Riverwood

2 pm 22 2 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn 22 2 99.

Chancery Number 98 P 2952 Pure Energy Corp v Williamson & Others

9.30am 23 2 99

Motion. Security re costs, further and better pars, etc. Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 E 5095 Eli Lilly and Company v Novo Nordish A/S

23 2 99 12pm


Chancery Number 98 L 2976 Michael John Lunn v Andrew Grayson & ors

9.30am 9 3 99

Summary Judgment. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent. Order made

Chancery Number 98 H 4568 Haberman v Jackal Ltd

4 3 99 9 30am

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent. Trial date fixed for 26 7 99.

Chancery Number 98 P 5199 Playhut Inc v Spring Form

9.30am 5 3 99


Chancery Number 97 B 4804 Brawley v Marczynski

8 3 99 9.30am


Chancery Number 98 E 5524 Eli Lilly & Co v Nova Nordisk

9 30am 10 3 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn

Chancery Division Napp v Asta

10.3.99 9 3 99

Motion. Strikeout. Mr Justice Pumfery. Directions given

Chancery Number Sykes Group v Stirling Fluid Systems

9.30am 11 3 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn 10 3 99


9.30am 16 3 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

Chancery Number 98 I 4087 ICI Chemicals v Lubrizol Corporation

9.30am 17 3 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions Given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

58

Chancery Number 99 P 1250 Pfizer Ltd v Hallmark Int Marketing

9.30am 18 3 99

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent

Chancery Number 98 I 2983 David John Instance & anr v Eteco S.A.R.L.

9.30am 25 3 99

Summons . Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn.

Chancery Number 98 T6701 Texas Electronics v Hyundai Electronics

10am 19 3 99

Summons. Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 Alfred Alexander Taylor v Isheda (Europe Ltd) & anr

10 30am 19 3 99


Chancery Number 98 C 3129 Merck v Collag

9.30am 22 3 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn by consent

Chancery Number 97 P 7012 Polypipe PLC v Leis Russell Jackson

9 30am 26 3 99

Summons for directions. Withdrawn by consent 19 3 99. Order made

Chancery Number 98 E 3046 Errut Products Ltd v Bomang GMBH & anr

10 30 31 3 99

Summons for directions. Withdrawn by consent

Chancery Number 98 M 2151 3 M v ATI Atlas Ltd & anr

9.30am 23 3 99


Chancery Number 98 S 5905 Sara Lee Corp v SC Johnson Corp

9.30am 24 3 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey Direction given

Chancery Number 98 A 6328 Andrew Sykes Group PLC v Sterling Fluid Systems Ltd

9.30am 31 3 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice PumfreyWithdrawn by consent 24 3 99

Chancery Number 98 N 4731 Nurtinova Nutrition v Scanchem UK

9.30am 25 3 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent

Chancery Number 99 B 01429 Briscoe & Briscoe v Middy Tackle

9.30am 26 3 99

Motion Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent

Chancery Number 98 N 2921 Nergeco SA v Ralph Ellesker Ltd

9.30am 26 3 99

Summons Mr Justice Pumfrey, Directions given

Chancery Number 89 L 6370 Lubrizol Corporation v Exxon

9.30am 31 3 99

Motion. Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 26 3 99

Chancery Number 96 H 7981 Hydro Int v Christopher Evans

9.30am 29 3 99

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given.

Chancery Number 97 A 3077 AMTL Corp & anr v Food Tolerance Testing Ltd

9 30am 18 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Direections given

HC 99 01520 Rocky Mountain Traders Ltd v Hewlett Packard

2pm 31 3 99


Chancery Number 98 S 5110 Sepricor v Hoechst

11am 31 3 99

Summon. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Trial date fixed


2.30pm 31 3 99


HC 99 01520 Rocky Mountain Traders Ltd v Hewlett Packard

10 30am 15 4 99


Chancery Number 97 B 5024 Barton & Cullis v Cayless & ors

9 30am 13 4 99

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given.

Chancery Number 96 R 3171 Bournes Inc v Raychem

2pm 13 4 99

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Fixed for 26 4 99

Chancery Number CH 98 R 6397 Rocky Mountain Traders Ltd v Hewlett Packard

2pm 14 4 99


HC 99 00505 Thermos Ltd v Aladdin Sales & Marketing

9.30am 15 4 99


HC 99 01041 HC 99 01451 Breed Automotive Tech. Inc v BK Racing Ltd

9.30am 16 4 99

Summons’ for directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent

Chancery Number 98 E 5095 Eli Lilly & Co v Novo Nordisk

10am 16 4 99

Summons. Mr Justice Neuberger. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 Alfred Alexander Taylor v Ishida (Europe) Ltd

9.45am 16 4 99


16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

59

& anr. Chancery Number CH 98 R 6397 Rocky Mountain Traders Ltd v Hewlett Packard

4pm 16 4 99


Chancery Number 97 U 5044 & 98 U 4112 (1) Ultra Frame UK Ltd v Northstar Systems Ltd (2) Ultra Frame UK Ltd v Sea Quest Systems Ltd

9 30am 19 4 99


Chancery Number 98 B 2821 Britax Winguard

9 30am 21 4 99

Summons for directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent 19 4 99

Chancery Number 96 R 3171 & 96 R 5680 Bourns Inc v Raychem Corp & ors.

9 15 am 20 4 99


Chancery Number 99 01259 Farmer v Brewer

9.30am 20 4 99

Summons for directions, Directions given

Chancery Number 98 T 6031 Technology Ltd v Wessex Electronics Consultants Ltd

9 30am 23 4 99


Chancery number 95 M 818 McKenzie v Fox and Gibbons & anr

9.30am 26 4 99



10 30am 26 4 99

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order made.

Chancery Number 95 M 818 McKenzie v Fox & Gibbons

9.30am 26 4 99



10 30am 27 4 99

Motion. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order made.

Chancery Number 97 P 7012 Polypipe PLC v Lewis Russell Jackson

9.30am 28 4 99

Summons. Mr Justice Neuberger. Directions given

Chancery Number 97 Q 3885 Quadrant Holdings v Quadrant Reasearch

9.15am 28 4 99

Summons. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 L 5360 & 98 T 5562 Levi Strauss & Co v Tesco Stores Ltd

27 4 99 9 30am


Chancery Number HC 99 01429 Briscoe Trading as Seven Sports & Leisure Middy Tackle Ltd

10 30am 4 5 99


Chancery Number 98 A 2508 Allergan Inc & anr v Sauflon Pharmaceuticals Ltd

9 30am 5 5 99

Application for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey.Directions given

Chancery Number 97 I 3442 APV Tetra Pak Food & Beverage System AG v APV UK Ltd

9.45am 5.5.99

Application for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

Chancery Number 98 P 3160 Proctor & Gamble v Lever Bros

9 30am 6 5 99

Summons Pumfrey J. Withdrawn 5 5 99

Chancery Number 98 S 5156 and 98 S 4701 Strix Ltd v Otter Controls

9.30am 7 5 99


Chancery Number 97 B 4804 Peter Brawley v Michael Marczynski

9 30am 14 5 99

Application. Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 13 5 99 by consent

Chancery Number 99 00642 Result International Limited & Robert Seymour v Comic Relief Ltd & anr

9.30am 24 5 99

Application for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent

Chancery Number 98 B 1602 Bell Laboratories v Inn of Eight Ltd

9.30am 19 5 99

Application. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent 18 5 99

Chancery Number Bourns v Raychem

9.30am 18 5 99

Application. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery number 98 L 5360 Levi v Tesco

3pm 18 5 99

Telephone application. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given


10am 19 5 99

Application Mr Justice Pumfrey. Mention

Chancery Number 97 H 3960 & 98 H 3878 9.30am Summons. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

60

Hadley Industries v Metsec 20 5 99 Chancery Number 99 W 0308 Worldwide Snakeboard Marketing Ltd v PMS International Far East Ltd

9 45am 21 5 99

Application Mr Justice Neuberger. Directions given

Chancery Number HC 99 02461 Nutrinova v Ellis & Everard & anr

9.30am 26 5 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. withdrawn

Chancery Number 97 L 6702 Label Connections Ltd v Martin Bunzl Marketing Ltd

1pm 27 5 99

Summons for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Pt Hd from 17 5 99. Settle. Consent Order made

Chancery Number 98 N 4732 Nutrinova v Scan chem Ltd & Fuerst Day Lawson

9.30am 27 5 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey


10am 27 5 99

Application. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given.


2pm 27 5 99

Application. Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given and stood over to 8 6 99

Chancery number 98 T 360 Goldschmidt AG v Euro Compound

9.30am 28 5 99

Application. Directions. Mr Justice Laddie. Directions made

Chancery Number 98 S 6782 Spring Form Inc & anr v Worlds Apart

9.30am 11 6 99

Motion Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent


9.15am 8 6 99

Application. Mr Justice Laddie. Order made

Chancery number 98 S 6027 Surface Technology PLC v Peter David Young

9.30am 8 6 99

Motion. Mr JusticePumfrey Withdrawn by consent 8 6 99

Ch 98 S 6782 Spring Form Inc & anr v Worlds Apart Ltd & anr

9.30am 11 6 99

Motion. Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent 8 6 99

Chancery Number 98 E 6818 EMI Ltd v Split Products

9 30am 9 6 99

CMC Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given

Chancery Number 99 H 1316 HFC v HSBC

9 30am 11 6 99

Application. Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 89 6 99

HC 01959 Marshalltown Travel Co v Ceka

9 30am 10 6 99

CMC Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent.

HC 99 00992 Hass Hop Products Inc v English Hop Products Ltd

9 30am 11 6 99

Application for directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 A 4550 AG Chemical Equipment Co Inc v Soyl Ltd & ors

9.30am 14 6 99

Application. Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn. Consent order made


9.30am 14 6 99

Application. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number Ch 97 T 6275 & Ch 98 T 360 Goldschmidt AG v Eur-O-Compound & ors

9.30am 15 6 99

Application Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 M 1421 Monsanto Company & anr v Merck & Co

9 30am 16 6 99

Application. Mr Justice Pumfrey

Chancery Number HC 99 01041 & 01541 Breed Automative Technology v BK Racing Ltd

10 30 18 6 99

Summons Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn

Chancery Number 98 A 2921 Nergeco SA v R Ellerker

21 6 99 9 30am

Directions. Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 K 5251 Kimberly Clarke v Procter & Gamble

9 39am 22 6 99


Chancery Number 98 D 5476 David Instance v Denny Bros

9.30am 28 6 99

CMC Mr Justice LaddieJ. Withdrawn 22 6 99.

Chancery Number 98 F 2196 Acme Jewellery Ltd v Christopher Simon French

9.30am 23 6 99

Application for directions. Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 S 5156 Strix & Otter

9.30am 24 6 99

Application Mr Justice Laddie By telephone. Direections given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

61

Chancery Number 98 S 5905 and 99 02038 Sarah Lee v Johnson Wax

9 7 99 9 30am

Applications. Mr Justice Laddie


10 30am 28 6 99

Application. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Stood over to 5 7 99

Chancery Number 96 R 7835 & 96 R 7834 Rolac Ltd v Gatley Engineering Rolac Ltd v Passenger Lift Services

9.30am 29 6 99

CMC Mr JusticePumfrey Directions given

Chancery Number 98 L 5360 Levi Strauss v Tesco Stores

30 6 99 9.30am

Application Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

Chancery Division 98 S 5281 Strong v Onward Design Ltd

1 7 99 9 30am

Application Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 30 6 99

Chancery Division 98 P 5199 Playhut v Springform

2 7 99 9 30am

Application Mr Justice Laddie. Directions made

HC 99 02072 Bracco SPA v The General Hospital Corp

5 7 99 9 30am

CMC Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 01316 HFC Bank v HSBC Bank

9am 5 7 99



9 30 5 7 99

Application Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 97 H 3960 Hadley Industries PLC v One Metal Sections Ltd & Metsec (UK) Ltd

9 45am 6 7 99

Telephone application Mr Justice Neuberger Directions given

Chancery Number 98 K 5251 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide Inc. v Procter & Gamble (UK) Limited & anr

9 30am 6 7 99

Application Mr Justice Laddie Directions given


7 7 99 10 30am


Chancery Number HC 99 01520 Rocky Mountain Traders Ltd v Hewlett Packard GmbH & anr

9 30am 7 7 99


Chancery Number 98 E 6818 EMI Ltd v Split Products

9.30am 8 7 99

Application Mr Justice Laddie. Consent Order

Chancery Number 97 F 2417 Farmer v Mosely Holdings

9 30am 12 7 99

Application Mr JusticeNeuberger. Directions given

99 01316 HFC v Midland Bank

10 30am 13 7 99

Application in Applications Court. Directions given

HC 99 02670 Jon Sapey v Trianco Redfyre Ltd

9 30am 20 7 99

CMC. directions given

HC 99 02675 3 M v Norton HC 99 02568 3 M v Bespak

10am 21 7 99

CMC Mr Justice Laddie. Directions made

Chancery Number 98 L 5360 Levi Strauss v Tesco Stores

9 30am 22 7 99

Application Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 95 R 3170 Bourns v Raychem

2pm 22 7 99


HC 99 02226 Novo Nordisk v DSM nv

9 30am 23 7 99


Chancery Number 98 E 1973 Edscar v Protec Int Ltd & anr

9 30am 26 7 99


Chancery Number 97 S 6144 Selectus Ltd v Milner Ltd

9.30am 27 7 99

Appeal from Master. Mr JusticeLaddie. Stood over by consent to a date to be fixed. Order made

Chancery Number Collag Corporation v Merck & Co Inc

9 30am 27 7 99

Application Mr Justice Jacob. Stood over to a date week commencing 2 8 99

Chancery Number 98 M 1421 Monsanto v Merck

Application Mr Justice Pumfrey Launched as an application in the Applications Court

Chancery Number 93 R 4839 Grapha-Holding AG v RMO Reist Marketing Organsiation AG

10am 28 7 99

Application Mr Justice Jacob. Withdrawn by consent. Order made

HC 99 03090 10am CMC Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

62

Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Ltd v Professor Sir Roy Calne

28 7 99

Chancery Number Rousselet v Kiren Amgen

12 noon 30 7 99


HC 99 02072 Bracco SPA v The General Hospital Corp

29 7 99 9 30am


Ch 99 M 01896 Stems Corp v Astec-Microflow Ltd

9 30am 30 7 99

Application Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 02517 Oxford Jean Technology v Affymetrix Inc

10 30am 30 7 99


HC 99 01110 Pfizer v Lilly Icos

9 30am 7 9 99

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Chancery Number 98 A 2508 Allergon v Sauflon Pharmaceuticals Ltd

9 30am 8 9 99

Application Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

Ch 98 N 6790 Net-On Line v Job Depot Ltd

10 30am 16 9 99

Directions. Mr Justice Laddie.Directions given

HC 99 02754 Dyson v Hoover

10am 17 9 99


Chancery Number 98 M 5395 Metronor AS v Geodetic Services Inc

9 30am 21 9 99

CMC Mr Justice Laddie Directions given. Transferred to General Chancery

HC 99 01919 Rohm & Hass v Collag Ltd

11am 21 9 99


Chancery Number 98 R 854 Stephen William Rudman v Essex and Sufolk Water

9 30am 22 9 99


HC 99 02439 & 00562 Strix v Otter Controls

10am 22 9 99

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Directions given

Ch 98 T 360 Goldschmidt v Eur-O-Compound

10 30am 23 9 99

Directions. Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent. Order made

HC 98 01765 Oakley v Addidas

8 30am 28 9 99

CMC Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent. Order made

Ch 99 M 01896 Stems Corp v Astec-Microflow Ltd

9 30am 23 9 99


Ch 96 O 7642 HMSO & Ordinance Survey v AA

2pm 24 9 99


Ch 95 C 2886 Concept Engineering & Design Corp v Brookdale Tool Co Ltd

9 15am 27 9 99

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Direction given

Chancery Number 98 C 3129 Collag v Merck

2pm 28 9 99


Ch 98 A 84 Fulton & Co Ltd v Grant Barnett

9 30am 29 9 99

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Direction given

HC 99 03633 American Home Products Corp v Novartis Pharmaceuticals Ltd

10am 1 10 99


Chancery Number 98 N 4732 Nutrinova Nutrition Specialists Food Ingredients GmBh & anr v Scanchem Limited

10 30am 1 10 99


Ch 96 O 7642 HMSO & Ordinance Survey v AA

11am 1 10 99

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn

Chancery Number S 5905 Sara Lee v Johnson

9 30am 8 10 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

Ch 97 T 6180 Horn Engineering v Reliance Water Controls

9 30am 12 10 99


HC 99 02833 CIL International Ltd v Vitrashop Ltd

9 30am 13 10 99


HC 99 02439 & 00562 Strix v Otter Controls

9 30am 14 10 99


16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

63

Chancery Number 96 R 7835 Rolac Ltd v Gatley Engineering

10am 14 10 99

Directions Mr Justice Neuberger

Chancery 98 N 4732 Nutrinova v Scanchem

9am 15 10 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey by telephone

Chancery Number 98 T 2532 Alfred Alexander Taylor v Ishida (Europe) Ltd & anr.

9 30am 15 10 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions

HC 99 02913 AM Wells v GMD Mouldings

9 30am 18 10 99

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions

Ch 97 P 7012 WL 91/99 Polypipe PLC v Lewis Russell Jackson

9 30am 20 10 99

Directions Mr justice Pumfrey Directions

Ch 98 P 3160 Procter & Gamble v Lever Bros

9 30am 21 10 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions

HC Chapham Papers v Thibercase & Comar

9 30am 22 10 99


Ch 98 E 3895 EM & I (Safety Systems) Ltd v Selantic Ltd & ors

9 30am 25 10 99

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn

HC 99 01919 Rohm & Hass v Collag Ltd

9 30am 27 10 99

Directions. Mr Justice Laddie.

HC 99 02517 Oxford Gene Technology v Affymetrics Inc

9 30am 28 10 99


Ch 96 C 4344 Coflexip v Stalt Comex

9 30am 29 10 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consent

Ch 98 E 5524 Eli Lilly & Co v Novo Nordisk

9 30am 2 11 99


Ch 98 P 5199 Playhut v Springform

9 30am 4 11 99


Ch 96 O 7642 Ordinance Survey v The AA

9 30am 5 11 99

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Directions given

HC 99 03546 Stoves Ltd v Baumatic Ltd

9 30am 8 11 99


Ch 98 A 2508 Allergan v Sauflon

9 30am 9 11 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions

Ch 98 B 6000 Bulkpac Ltd v SCA Packaging Ltd

9 30am 10 11 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by agrement

HC 99 02920 Holliday v Hancox.

9 30am 11 11 99


HC99 02916/7 and HC99 03241 Hoechst v Kiren Amgen

10 am 15 11 99

Directions Mr Justice Neuberger. Directions given

HC 99 04079 Smithkline Beecham Group PLC v United Trade Limited & Ors

9 30 am 18 11 99


Chancery Number 98 E 5095 Ely Lilly v Novo Nordisk (Insulin analogs)

9 30am 19 11 99


Chancery Number 97 P 7012 Polypipe v Lewis Russel Jackson

10am 25 11 99


HC 98 05395 Metronor ASA v Geodetic Services Co

9 30am 1 12 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by agreement

Chancery Number 92 M 9819 Mabuchi v Johnson

9 30am 2 12 99

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by agreement. Order made

Chancery Number 98 E 5324 Novomont v Biotech

9 30am 6 12 99

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn to be refixed

HC 99 04079 Smithkline Beecham v United Trade Ltd

9 15am 3 12 99


HC 1999 0418 Addavita Ltd v Biotechna Environmental Int Ltd

9 30am 8 12 99


HC 99 03033 Optidisc International v QVC & Digital Arm

9 30am 9 12 99

Directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn by consnet

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

64

Ltd HC 99 4380 Gencor v FW Screens

9 30am 10 12 99


HC 99 04998 Silkbill Ltd v Ash Lacey Building Products Ltd

9 30am 14 12 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey. Withdrawn

Chancery Number 98 O 1765 Oakley Inc v Addidas Int

9 30am 10 12 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey, Directions given

Chancery Number 98 C 3258 Latif v Isis Inovation Ltd

9 30am 13 12 99

Directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

Chancery Number 95 C 2886 Concept Engineering & Design & anr v Brookdale Tool Co

10 30am 15 12 99

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

HC 99 03993 Asahi Medical Co v Maco Pharmo UK

9 30am 16 12 99


Chancery Number 95 C 3477 Cantor Fitzgerald v Michael Howard

10am 16 12 99


Ch 96 D 5368 Denny v Instance

9 30am 16 12 99

Directions Mr Justice Jacob. Directions given

HC 99 03030 Molens v GD Italia

10 30am 17 12 99

1 day. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions given

HC 99 03189 Micro Matic v Diopense Systems International

9 30am 17 12 99


HC 98 3160 P & G v Lever Brothers

9 30am 20 12 99


Chancery Number 96 R 3171 & 96 R 5680 Bourns Inc v Raychem Corp & ors

11 30am 20 12 99


HC 99 02517 Oxford Gene Technology v Affymetrics Inc

9 30am 21 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Jacob Directions given

Chancery Number 98 M 0251 Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Co (3M) v ATI Atlas & Namsa

9 30am 21 12 99



10 30am 12 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent 11 1 00


9 30am 20 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn 11 1 00

HC 99 02517 Oxford Gene Technology v Affymetrix Inc

10 15am 13 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 12 1 00

HC 1999 03126 Amersham Pharmacia v Millpore

9 30am 13 1 00


HC 99 02226 Novo Nordisk v DSM

10 30am 13 1 00


HC 99 04768 Hoberman v Grossman

9 30am 24 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent. Order made


9 30am 14 1 00


Ch 95 3482 Instance v Denny Bros Printing

9 30am 18 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Neuberger. Withdrawn 17 01 00


9 30am 18 01 00

Order as to costs. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Order made

Ch 98 P 3160 Proctor & Gamble & Lever Bros

9 30am 20 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Directions made


9 30am 21 1 00

Directions Mr JusticePumfrey. Withdrawn 20 01 00

Chancery Number HC 98 5251 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide Inc. v Procter & Gamble (UK) Limited & anr

9 30am 25 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn 20 01 00

Ch 97 K 6390 Somerfield v Lorch Schilling

9 30am 24 01 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn 21 01 00

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

65

HC 99 04555 Quadrant Health Care v Inhale

9 30am 25 1 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent 24 01 00

HC 99 05062 City Technology v Alphasense Ltd

9 30am 26 01 00



9 30am 02 02 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn 27 01 00.

HC 99 04538 Intel v Via Technology

9 30am 28 1 00


HC 99 01959 Marshalltown Trowel Co v Ceka Works Ltd

9 30am 31 01 00


HC 99 02988 Novartis v Imtex Sangstat

9 30am 01 02 00

CMC Mr Justice Laddie Directions given

HC 99 02226 Novo Nordisk A/S v DSM Nv

11 00am 01 02 00


HC 99 04951 Unilever v Frisa

9 30am 3 2 00


HC 99 03189 Micromatic v Diofense Systems Int

9 30am 4 2 00


HC 99 2517 Oxford Gene Technology v Affymetrix

9 30am 11 02 00


HC 99 02670 Jon Sapey v Trianco Redfyre Limited

9 30am 09 02 00


QB number Saf-T-Pak Inc v Sea Air Containers

9 30am 10 02 00

Directions re security Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

Ch 97 A 3077 AMTL Corp v Food Tolerance Testing Ltd

9 30am 11 02 00

Costs Mr Justice Laddie Directions given

HC 99 5171 Sony Kabushiki v Goodmans Industries Ltd

9 30am 17 02 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent. Order made

HC 99 4709 Smith Kline Beecham v United Trade Ltd

9 30am 14 02 00


Ch 98 E 5324 Novomont v Biotech

10 30am 16 2 00

CMC Mr Justice Laddie (half day) Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 5402 Boston Scientific Ltd v C R Bard & Ors

9 30am 15 02 00


HC 99 02533 3Ms v Rennicks

10 30am 15 2 99

Application (half day) Mr Justice Laddie Directions made

HC 99 02568 3Ms v Bestpak & anr

9 30am 16 2 00

CMC Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent 25 02 00

Ch 98 P 3160 Proctor & Gamble v Lever Bros

9 30am 18 02 00


QB number Saf-T-Pak Inc v Sea Air Containers

9 30 am 18 02 00


Chancery Number 95 I 3482, 95 D 5843, 96 D 5368, 98 D 5467 HC 99 04282 David J Instance Limited v Denny Bros Printing Ltd

9 30am 25 02 00



9 30am 21 02 00


HC 00 729 L Woolley Jewellers v A & A Jewellery Ltd

9 30am 22 02 00

In Chambers. Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent

Chancery Number 95 C 7494 WL 311/97 Charlsworth v Relay Roads Ltd

10 30am 22 02 00

Directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey. Directions made

HC 99 1919 Collag v Rohm & Hass

9 30am 24 02 00


HC 99 4709 Smith Kline Beecham v United Trade Ltd

10 30am 01 03 00

Return from 14 02 00. Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn 29 02 00

HC 99 4473 Sony Corp v Maxplay

9 30am 02 03 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 01919 9 30am Directions Mr Justice Laddie Telephone Application

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

66

Rohm & Hass v Collag 06 03 00 Directions given HC 00 0645 Via Technologies Inc v Intel Corp

9 30am 14 03 00

CMC Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn 07 03 00

Chancery Number 98 B 4600 50/99 & HC 99 00178 Bespak PLC v Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company

9.30am 08 03 00


HC 99 4380 Gencor PLC v FW Screens

9 30am 09 03 00

CMC Mr Justice Laddie Telephone Application Directions given

HC 99 4340 and 00 574 TRW v Autoliv

9 30am 10 03 00

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn by consent. Order made

HC 99 04538 Intel Corp v Via Technologies

9 30am 20 03 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withrawn by consent

Chancery Number 97 D 3166 AA v Dept of the Environment for Northern Ireland

9 30am 21 03 00


HC 99 3675 Helifix v Product Licensing

9 30am 22 03 00


Chancery Number 98 C 3219 Collag Corporation & anr v Merck & Co Inc

9 30am 22 03 00


Ch 98 6781 & 6782 Springform v Toy Brokers & Worlds Apart

9 30am 28 03 00


HC 97 M 3482 M & H Plastics Ltd v Allen Derek Pettyfer

9 30am 28 03 00

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

HC 99 1720 McGhan Medical Corporation v McGhan Medical Limited

9 30am 30 03 00


HC 99 04538 Via Technologies Inc v Intel Corp

9 45am 31 03 00


HC 99 3090 & HC 99 3633 Novartis v R Calne

9 30am 04 04 00



9 30am 12 04 00

CMC Mr Justice Jacob. Withdrawn by agreement 07 04 00

Ch 96 2741 Pektron Ltd v Micraflow UK Ltd

9 30am 13 04 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Consent order made. Withdrawn 11 04 00

HC 98 3129 Collag v Merck

9 30am 14 04 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions Given

Ch 96 S 657 Schutz Werk Gmbh v Societe Van Leer

9 30am 17 04 00

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn by consent 14 04 00

Ch 97 W 5151 Ch 98 H 4328 Waters Ltd v Hewlett Packard

9 30am 17 04 00


HC 99 01919 Rohm & Hass v Collag

10am 17 04 00

Further Directions Mr Justice Jacob Directions given

HC 99 2754 Hoover v Dyson

10am 18 04 00


HC 00 0099 Lefroy Brooks Ltd v Marflow Engineering Ltd

9 30am 18 04 00


HC 00 01336 Umbro Europe Ltd v Atvar Sing Bains

9 30am 18 04 00


HC 99 2988 Novartis v Sangstat

10am 19 04 00

CMC Mr Justice Jacob Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 03546 Stoves Limited v Baumatic Limited

9 30am 19 04 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent. Order made

HC OO 417 Oliver Jevons v 3Ms

9 30am 19 04 00


16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

67


2pm 02 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 2pm Half day

Chancery Number 98 N 4732 WL No 43/44/99 Nutrinova Nutrition Specialists Food Ingredients GmBh & anr v Scanchem Limited

9 30am 02 05 00

Further argument Mr Justice Pumfrey Half day


2pm 03 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 2pm Half day (pt hd)

HC 99 04380 FW Screens Int v Gencor

9 30am 03 05 00

Directions. Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

HC 99 04062 Arjo v Liko

9 30am 09 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Direections given

HC99 5062 City Technology Ltd v Alphasense

9 30am 11 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn with consent order

Ch 98 I 2895 David John Instance v Reynders Eticetten

9 30am 12 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn by consent

Ch 97 M 3482 M & H Plastics v Alan Pettyfer

10am 11 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn Consent order

HC 99 2226 Novo Nordisk v DSM NV

9 30am 18 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent.

CH 97 C 4152 AJ Claydon v Claydon Hamilton Automotive

9 30am 15 05 00


HC 2022 APPEAL

9 30am 16 05 00

Mr Justice Pumfrey

HC 00 1899 Surface Technology Plc v Ultraseal International

10am 17 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Neuberger Direections given


9 30am 17 05 00


HC 00 888 APPEAL

9 30am 18 05 00

Mr Justice Pumfrey

Ch 96 S 657 Schutz Werke GmbH v Vaan Leer (UK) Ltd

9 30am 19 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn. Consent order

Ch 98 F 6089 Forbo-Krommenie v Sommer Ltd

9 30am 19 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions made

HC 99 2670 Jon Sapey v Trianco Redfyre Limited

10am 19 05 00


Ch 98 I 2984 David John Instance v Faubel & Co Nachf GmbH

9 30am 22 05 00


HC 99 5310 Novamont SpA v Green Light Products Limited

9 30am 22 05 00


Ch 98 M 6802 John Joseph McKinley v Associated Cooperative Creameries

9 30am 24 05 00

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey Settled Order made

HC 00 1650 George Wilson Industries v UGI Smith Meters

9 30am 25 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn. Consent order

Chancery number 97 B 4804 Brawley v Marczynsky Business Lines Ltd

9 30am 25 05 00



11am 25 05 00

Directions Mr JusticePumfrey

HC 99 3189 Micromatic AS v Diopense Systems

9 30am 26 05 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn. Consent order made

HC 99 4579 Ampy Auto v Siemens and East Midland Electric

10am 26 05 00

CMC Mr Justice Neuberger Direections given

HC 99 2226 Novo Nordisk v DSM NV

10am 08 06 00

Directions Mr Justice Neuberger.Directions given

HC Awaits 9 30am Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

68

Kooltrade Ltd v XTS Ltd 13 06 00 Chancery Number 98 M 2151 TLC 351/00 Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company v ATI Atlas limited & anr

9.30 am 14 06 00

Disclosure Application Mr Justice Neuberger Directions given

HC 99 4380 Gencor v FW Screens Int.

9.30am 14 06 00


HC 00 1899 Surface Technology Plc v Ultraseal International

10am 15 06 00



9 30am 15 06 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions Directions given

HC 1999 02754 Dyson Appliances Ltd –v- Hoover Ltd

9.45am 15 06 00

Directions for further evidence Mr Justice Neuberger Directions given

HC 99 5225 Glen Dimplex Heating v Robinson Willey Ltd

9 30am 16 06 00


HC 99 3033 Optidisc Int Ltd v QVC

9 30am 21 06 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn. Order agreed


9.30 am 22 06 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Direections given

HC 00 00729 L Woolley v A&A Jewellery

1000am 22 06 00

Directions Mr Justice Neuberger Directions given


9 30am 26 06 00


Ch 98 M 2151 3Ms v ATI

9 30am 29 06 00


95 I 3482 David Instance Limited v Denny Bros Printing Ltd

10 30 am 04 07 00


99 3126 Amersham Pharmacia Biotech AB v Amicon & ors

9 30am 05 07 00


95 X 4907 Xylum Corp v Peter Gorog

9 30am 06 07 00


HC 2000 090359 Kooltrade Ltd –v- XTS

9.30 am 11 07 00

Trial of the issues (2 hour estimate) Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

HC 00 2423 Panduit Corp v Band-it Co

9 30am 12 07 00


HC 00 574 Autolive v TWR

9 30am 14 07 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Diretions given

98 P 3836 Palm Tree Holdings Ltd Sheffield Gear & Engineering Co Ltd

9 30am 17 07 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn


9 30am 19 07 00


HC 00 2569 Hewlett Packard v Teco Information Systems Europe Ltd

9 30am 26 07 00

CMC Mr Justice Jacob CMC agreed and consent order approved. No appearance necessary

HC 00 3010 Upnor v Glynwed Pipe Systems

9 30am 24 07 00


99 4645 Oxford Gene Technology v Affymetrix Inc

9 30am 25 07 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey (2 Hrs)

Ch 97 C 5434 Co-Flexip v DSND

10 am 25 07 00


HC 99 2533 3 Ms v Rennicks

9 30am 26 07 00


HC 00 2870 Synthon BV v Beecham Group

10am 27 07 00


HC 99 4950 Unilever v Nestle

9 30am 27 07 00


16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

69

HC Awaits AC Egerton Limited v British Telecoms PLC

9 30am 28 07 00


HC 99 4645 Oxford Gene Technology v Affymetric

10am 28 07 00


HC 00 2911 Proctor & Gamble

9 30am 06 00 09


HC 00 2676 Icon Health & Fitness Ltd v Precise Exercise Equipment Inc

9 30am 08 09 00


HC 98 3134 Farmer v Moseley

9 30am 12 09 00


HC 00 3244 Reynolds Boughon Ltd v Classic Compaction Ltd

9 30am 10 09 00


HC99 4555 Inhale v Quadrant

9 30am 15 09 00


93 B 6681 Bowater Packaging Ltd –v- Smurfit Corrugated Ltd

9.30 am 10 10 00

CMC Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent 15 09 00

HC 00 679 Sabas v Hygena

10 am 19 09 00


HC 99 3033 Novo Nordisk AS v DSM NV

9 30am 20 09 00


HC 9 3993 Asahi v Maco Pharma

9 30am 21 09 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent.

HC 00 1823 Precise Exercise Equipment Incorporated v Forza Fitness Equipment Limited

9 30am 22 09 00

CMC Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent

HC 00 2423 Panduit Corp v Band-it Co

9 30am 26 09 00


HC 99 5402 Boston Scientific v CR Bard Inc

9 30am 27 09 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 4808 William Constantine v W Constantine & Littlewoods Organisation

9 30am 03 10 00


HC 00 1915 DSM-NV v Trouw (UK) Ltd

9 30am 05 10 00

CMC Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn Consent order


9 30am 09 10 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 1959 Marshalltown Trowel Co v Ceka Works Ltd

9 30am 06 10 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Telephone Application. Withdrawn

HC 00 2423 Panduit Corp v Band-it-co

10am 06 10 00


HC 99 3033 Novo Nordisk AS v DSM NV

9 30am 11 10 00


HC 99 3241 Kiren Amgen v Roche Diagnostics

9 30am 11 10 00


HC 99 4996 Hans Georg Huber v Robbins & Mers Ltd

9 30am 13 10 00

CMC Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent

Ch 97 W 5151 Waters Limited v Hewlett Packard

9 30am 19 10 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consnet

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

70

HC 00 1584 Thomson Licensing S.A. and Deutsche Thomson-Brandt GmbH v Pace Micro Technology PLC

9 30am 20 10 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Directions given Trial fixed

Chancery Number 98 N 4732 WL No 43/44/99 Nutrinova Nutrition Specialists Food Ingredients GmBh & anr v Scanchem Limited

9 30am 24 10 00


HC 99 0226 TLC 223/99 Novo Nordisk A/S v DSM N/V

9 30am 26 10 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie

HC 00 3520 Ritork Controls Ltd v Zoedale Plc

9 30am 30 10 00


00PAT002/3 Deutsche Institute Fur Textil-und Faserforschung v Fibreguide Ltd and H W Lee Consultants

9am 01 11 00

Telephone application for Patents County Court Mr Justice Laddie. Directions. Directions given

97PAT021 Town & Garden Country Products v Spear & Jackson Garden Products Ltd

9 30am 06 11 00

Patents County Court business Mr David Young QC sitting as a judge of the Patents County Court. Withdrawn by consent


9 30am 10 11 00


HC 99 03126 TLC 636/00 Amersham Pharmacia Biotech AB v (1) Amicon Limited (2) Millpore (UK) Limited (3) Millipore Corporation

9 30am 07 11 00

Further argument Mr Justice Laddie Directions given

HC 00 679 Sabas v Hygena

9 30am 13 11 00

Telephone application. Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

HC 99 5171 Sony

13 11 00 Application with General Chancery (half day)

HC 00 1584 Thomson Licensing S.A. and Deutsche Thomson-Brandt GmbH v Pace Micro Technology PLC

17 11 00 9 30am

CMC Pt Hd Mr Justice Laddie Directions given


9 30am 23 11 00

Directions Mr Justice Neuberger Telephone application Directions given


9 30am 24 11 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 4645 Oxford Gene Technology v Affymetric

10am 28 07 00



9 30am 27 11 00

Directions given Mr Justice Neuberger

Ch 97 A 3077 AMTL Corp (UK) Ltd v Food tolerance Ltd

9 30am 28 11 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Direction given

HC 98 6872 Springform Inc v Worlds Apart

29 11 00 9 30am

Directions Mr Justice Laddie. Withdrawn by consent.

HC 00 2808 Dranez Anstalt v Medivent Ltd

10 30am 30 11 00

Application (strike out) 1 day Mr Justice Laddie Directions given

HC00 4177 and 4176 Rambus v 1, Hyundai and 2. Micron

30 11 00 9 30am


HC 99 4555 Quadrant v Inhale

01 12 00 9 30am

Discovery. Mr Justice Laddie Withdrawn

HC 99 3633 HC 3090 Novartis v Calne

10 30am 04 12 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie (Half day) Directions given

HC 99 01110 TLC 645/00 Lilly Icos v Pfizer

10 30am 05 12 00

Form of order 2 hrs Diarections given


9 30am 07 12 00


Ch 97 A 3077 AMTL Corp (UK) Ltd v Food tolerance Ltd

9 30am 06 12 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie Removed from list to be dealt with by correspondence. 05 12 00

HC 00 3010 9 30am Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

71

Glynwed v Upnor 06 12 00 HC 99 04645 Oxford Gene Technology v Affymetrix Inc

9 30am 08 12 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 15mins Adjourned to 20 12 00

00PAT001 Wheelwash v Chunnel Plant Hire

9 30am 11 12 00

Directions .Patents County Court application 30mins Withdrawn 08 12 00


9 30am 15 12 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Withdrawn by consent

00 01803 Fitness v Leisure

9 am 19 12 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1hr Withdrawn 14 12 01

00PAT0010 Panduit Corp v Band-it-co

9 30am 15 01 00

Directions Mr David Young QC sitting as a judge for the Central London Count Court 30 mins Directions given

HC 99 3633 HC 3090 Novartis v Calne

9 15 am 18 12 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1 ½ hrs Directions given

HC 00 4176 Rambus v Micron Europe Limited

10am 19 12 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie One day Directions given to stay proceedings


9 30am 20 12 00

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey (2 hrs) Direections given

HC 99 01110 TLC 645/00 Lilly Icos v Pfizer

2pm 20 12 00

Form of order Pt Hd 2 hrs Mr Justice Laddie

HC 99 2833 CIL Int Ltd v Vitrashop

10 15 am 21 12 00

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Withdrawn by consent

HC 00 4266 & HC 00 4267 1. TVCom v Ondigital 2. TVCom v Telewest

9 30am 18 01 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 30 mins Directions given

HC99 03189 Micromatic v Dispense Systems

9 30am 25 01 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 30 mins Withdrawn by consent

00 Pat 009 William August Warheit and Applied Concepts Inc v Olympia Tools Ltd

9 30am 26 01 01

Pat County Court . Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions 15 mins Adjourned to 02 02 01

HC 99 4645 Oxford Gene Tech. V Affymetrix

10am 26 01 01


HC 99 02833 CIL International Limited v Vitrashop Limited

4pm 30 01 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey Telephone Application Directions given

00 PAT 010 Panduit Corp v Band-it-co

9 30am 31 01 01

Pat County Court Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 ½ hrs Directions given

HC 97 M 3482 M & H Plastics v Alan Derek Spencer Pettyfer

2pm 01 02 01


HC 00 01099 Pike v Price

9 30am 01 02 01

Strike out application Mr Justice Pumfrey ½ day Directions given

00 Pat 009 William August Warheit and Applied Concepts Inc v Olympia Tools Ltd

9 30am 02 02 01

Pat County Court . Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions 15 mins Directions given

HC2000 3166 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v Orion Electric (UK) Ltd

9.30am 06 02 01

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey 1hr Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 03189 Micromatice A/S v Dispense Systems International & ors

9 30am 07 02 01

Directions Mr Justice Nueberger 30 mins Directions given

HC 99 4555 Inhale Therapeutic Systems Inc v Quadrant Healthcare

9 30am 07 02 01


HC00 679 Sabath v Hygena

9 30am 08 02 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 30mins

PAT 00 006 Iain Mcguffie and Fleet (Line Markers) Ltd v Supaturf Products Ltd

9 30am 16 02 01

Patents County Court Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 30mins Transferred to be dealt with at CLPC 08 02 01

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

72

HC 99 3633 HC 99 3090 Novartis v Calne

9 30am 09 02 01


HC 99 2833 CIL International v Vitrashop

9 30am 13 02 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 ½ hrs Directions given

HC 00 03655 NXT Transducers Ltd v Labtech Enterprises UK Ltd

9 30am 14 02 01

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey 30mins Directions given

HC 99 4062 Arjo Liko v OK

9 30am 16 02 01

Mr Justice Pumfrey Directions 1 ½ hrs Directions given


9 15am 28 02 01

Telephone application Mr Justice Laddie 15 mins Withdrawn 16 02 01

00 Pat 005 Hitech Auto Parts v CJ Imports UK Ltd

9 30am 20 02 01

Patents County Court CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey 1hr Directions given

HC Glaxo v Dowelhurst

9 30am 22 02 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 20 mins Withdrawn

HC 00 2955 Scanner Technology Ltd v Tomy UK & Leapfrog

9 30am 23 02 01

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 hr Directions given

HC 98 6027 Surface Technolgy PLC v Peter Young

10 30am 23 02 02

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey ½ day Directions given

HC 00 4644 AMTL Dana v TRW

9 30am 27 02 01

Strike out Mr Justice Pumfrey 2hrs Withdrawn to be refixed

HC 00 3010 Glynwed Pipe Systems v Upnor

9 30am 28 02 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 hr

HC 99 36333 Novartis v AHP/Calne

9 30am 02 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 hr Withdrawn by consent 1 3 01

HC 00 1024 Kalsep Limited v X-Flow

10 30am 05 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 day Directions given

HC 00 244 Titus Int PLC v Hafeley UK Ltd

9 30am 06 03 01


PAT Franco Ferrari v Horatio Myer

9 30am 14 03 01

Pat County Court Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 30 mins Withdrawn

HC 00 5233 Mr Tim Woodhouse v Honda

9 30am 08 03 01


HC 00 4746 Celltech Therapeutics Ltd v Mediminne Inc

9 30am 09 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 hr Directions given


9 30am 12 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 30 mins Pt Hd Stood over to 13 03 01

PAT 009 William Warhat v Applied Concepts Inc

12pm 16 03 01

Security for costs 2 hrs Withdrawn by consent 13 03 01


NB 11am 13 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 2 hrs Directions given

HC 00 05802 Astra Zenica v Cairn Stores

9 30am 13 03 01

Strike out Mr Justice Pumfrey 2hrs Judgment 9 30am 16 03 01

00 PAT 002/3 Deutsche Institute Fur Textil v Fibreguide

12pm 14 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 2 hrs Removed from list due to papers not being prepared for judge and no application notice with fee paid prepared.

HC 005493 BT v Intech Telecom

10 30am 14 03 01


HC 99 03189 Micromatice A/S v Dispense Systems International & ors

9 30am 15 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Settled Consnet order

Ch 98 H 3134 Farmer v RTK Marine Limited

10am 15 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Neuberger 30 mins Directions given

HC 98 I 2984 David Instance v Faubel & ors

9 30am 15 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 30mins Directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

73

HC 98 S 6027 Surface Technology PLC and Ultraseal International v (1) Peter David Young, (2) Ultraseal International Limited and (3) MX Systems (UK) Limited

10 30am 15 03 01

Direction Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 day Directions given

94 PAT 0023 Flexible Directional Indicators v AA Thornton

9 30am 20 03 01

Pat County Court Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 3hrs Adjourned by consent

HC 00 05802 Astra Zenica v Cairn Stores

10 am 19 03 01

Decision from directions hearing on 13 03 01 Mr Justice Pumfrey

HC 00 3010 Glynwed Pipe Systems v Upnor

9 30am 21 03 01


HC 01 0389 Elida Faberge Ltd v Colgate-Palmolive

9 30am 22 03 01

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey 30 mins Directions given

HC 99 3633 Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited & anr American Home Products Limited & anr

9 30am 29 03 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 hr Withdrawn 27 03 01. Consent order

HC 00 5686 Geovani Maria LaPorta v Mila Hardware Ltd

9 30am 28 03 01


HC 00 4957 Le-Creuset v Inter Continental Cooking & Tableware Co Ltd

9 30am 04 04 01

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey 30 mins Withdrawn by consent 30 03 01

HC Biotel Ltd v Pioneer Hi-Bred North

9 30am 03 04 01

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 ½ hrs Directions given

HC LFL Group Ltd v 1 Connelly Trading as Crystal fires

9 30am 05 04 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 hr Trial set for 08 05 01

HC 98 S 6027 Surface Technology PLC and Ultraseal International v (1) Peter David Young, (2) Ultraseal International Limited and (3) MX Systems (UK) Limited

NB 2pm 10 04 01

Further argument Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 hr Withdrawn 09 04 01 Action settled

HC 00 04644 TRW v Dana

9 30am 10 04 01

Strike out Mr Justice Pumfrey 2 hrs Directions given

HC 98 6781 Springform v Fine Card Int & Toy Brokers

9 am 11 04 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 30 mins Withdrawn 10 04 01

HC 00 05078 Armer Ltd v Power & Design Ltd

9 30am 11 04 01


HC 01 01532 Du Pont v Collag Ltd and Agform Ltd

10 30am 11 04 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 3hrs + Directions given

HC00 0582 Cairnstores Limited v Aktiebolaget Hassle

2pm 24 04 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 15 mins

HC 01 0054 Decon Laboratories v Veltek

2pm 24 04 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 20 mins Withdrawn 24 04 01

HC 99 3633 Novartis v A & P

NB 10am 26 04 01

Application to ammend Mr Justice Pumfrey 45 mins Withdrawn 24 04 01

HC 00 2808 Dranez Holdings v Samir Hayek

9 30am 03 05 01


00 PAT 005 Hitech Autoparts Inc v Towergate Two Ltd & Stylex Ldtd

2pm 26 04 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 20 mins Withdrawn 25 04 01 Consent Order

HC 00 171 Fenn Street Promotions Ltd v Comic Relief

9 30am 26 04 01

CMC Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Directions given

HC 98 4555 Quadrant v Inhale

9 30am 26 04 01


PAT 94 0023 Flexible Directional Indicators

10 30am 26 04 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 3 hrs Directions given

HC 00 4470 Alcatel v Marconi

9 30am 27 04 01


HC 00 5702 Nat Steel Engineering v Stinis

9 30am 30 04 01

CMC Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

74

00PAT 006 Fleetline Markers v Supaturf Products

9 30am 02 05 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Withdrawn. Consent Order

HC 00 02808 Dranez Holdings Aktiengesellschaft v (1) Medivent Limited (2) Zamir Hayek

9 30am 03 05 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Withdrawn

HC 00 5233 Woodhouse v Honda

9 30am 17 05 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Withdrawn. No fee paid or application notice .

92PAT0080 David Jones v Halliday and Excalibur Tools

9 30am 08 05 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 2 hrs Withdrawn by consent

HC 01 0344 Thompson Plastics Hull Ltd v Tetraform Composites Ltd

9 30am 09 05 01

CMC Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Trial date set

HC 00 03375 Trefpaphan UK Ltd v Polinas Plastik

9 30am 11 05 01

CMC Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Directions given Trial fixed

HC 88 3836 Palm Tree Holdings Limited v Sheffield Gear & Engineering Co Limited

NB10 am 11 05 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1hr Directions given

00 PAT 011 Kavanaugh Balloons v Cameron Balloons

9 30am 15 04 01

CMC Mr Justice Laddie 45 mins Withdrawn by consent

HC 97 B 4804 Peter Brawley v (1) Michael Marczynski (2) Business Lines

9 30am 16 05 05

Telephone application Directions Mr Justice Laddie 15 mins Directions given

HC 00 679 TLC/126/01 Sabaf SpA v MFI Furniture Centres Ltd & anr

9 30am 17 05 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 15 mins Directions given

HC 01 0389 TLC 234/01 Elida Faberge Ltd v Colgate-Palmolive

9 30am 21 05 01


HC 00 029252 Daimler Chrysler v Euro Car Parts

9 30am 22 05 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr withdrawn by consent

HC 01 787 Jay-Be Limited v Take Limited

9 30am 23 05 01

Telephone application CMC Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Directions given

HC 00 2808 Dranez Holdings v Zanir Hayek

9 30am 24 05 01

CMC Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Withdrawn by consent

HC 99 1919 Rohm & Hass v Collag

9 50am 06 06 01

Telephone application Directions Mr Justice Laddie 15 mins Directions given

HC 99 4062 TLC/258/01 Arjo Ltd v Liko AB & anr

9 30am 11 06 06

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Withdrawn 06 06 01

HC 00 679 TLC/126/01 Sabaf SpA v MFI Furniture Centres Ltd & anr

9 30am 14 06 01

Strike out Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Directions given


9 30am 18 06 01


HC 98 I 2984 Instance v Saubel

9 30am 21 06 01


HC 00 4746 TLC 219/01 Celltech Chiroscience Limited v Meimme Inc

9 30am 22 06 01


HC 01 01870 Nutrinova v Arnold Suhr

9 30am 25 06 01


HC 00 05493 BT v Intech Telecomms System

9 30am 28 06 01

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey 30 mins Withdrawn by consent

PAT 01 004 Ciba v Coopervision

10am 28 06 01

CMC Mr Justice Neuberger 30 mins Direections given and judgment reserved

HC 00 05233 Woodhouse v Honda

9 30am 29 06 01


HC 01 01244 Storage Computer Corporation v Hitachi Data Systems

9 30am 05 07 01

CMC Mr Justice Pumfrey 15 mins Hearing vacated by order of Mr Justice Pumfrey. To be heard with Application on 13 07 01

PAT 00 009 William Warheit v Applied Concepts

9 30am 06 07 01


16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

75

92 PAT 080 David Jones v Max S Halliday

9 30am 04 07 01



9 30am 05 07 01


HC 01 1444 & HC 00 5788 AEA Technology plc v (1) Michael John Mulholland (2) Air Pollution Abatement Limited

9 30am 05 07 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 45 mins Taken out of list to be refixed

HC 00 3655 NXT Transducers Ltd v Labtec Enterprises UK Ltd

9 30am 09 07 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 15 mins Withdrawn by consent 04 07 01

HC 00 3182 Seiko Group v Intercity Watch Company

9 30am 06 07 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Withdrawn by consent 05 07 01

HC 00 2870 Synthon BV v Beecham Group

9 30am 10 07 01

CMC Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Withdrawn by consent 09 07 01

HC 99 4062 TLC/258/01 HC 00 03984 TLC/424/01 Arjo Ltd v Liko AB & anr

9 30am 12 07 01

Directions Mr Justice 1hr 30mins Withdrawn by consent

PAT 01 009 BSH Industries Ltd v Jaguar Cars Ltd

9 30am 13 07 01


PAT 00 009 William Warheit v Applied Concepts

9 30am 13 07 01


HC 01 01244 Storage Computer Corporation v Hitachi Data Systems

10 am 13 07 01

Strike out Mr Justice Laddie 1 day

HC 01 1444 & HC 00 5788 AEA Technology plc v (1) Michael John Mulholland (2) Air Pollution Abatement Limited

9 30am 16 07 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 2hrs Withdrawn by consent. Order made.

HC 01 1878 Sun v Ciba

9 30am 17 07 01


PAT 01 008 Niagra Healthcare plc v Mr Neville C Alderson

9 30am 19 07 01

Judgment in default Mr Justice Laddie 15 mins Withdrawn by applicant on 18 07 01

HC 00 4746 TLC 219/01 Celltech Chiroscience Limited v Medimeme Inc

9 30am 20 07 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 2 ½ hrs Directions given

HC 00 4266 TV/Com v Telewest and Others

9 30am 23 07 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1 ½ hrs

HC00 3783 PAG v Hawk-Wood Ltd

9 30am 24 07 01

Telephone Application Directions Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Directions given

HC 00 04644 TRW v DANA

9 30am 25 07 01

CMC Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Directions given

PAT 01 004 Wesley Jessen Corp v Coopervision

9 30am 31 07 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Directions given

HC 98 F 5799 Smith & Nephew Plc v 3 Ms

9 30am 31 07 01


HC00 4470 TLC406/01 (1) Alcatel (2) Alcatel CIT v (1) Marconi PLC (2) Marconi Communications Ltd (3) Marconi Communications SpA

9 30am 20 09 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Withdrawn by consent 11 09 01

HC 01 1344 Thompson Plastice (Hull) Ltd v Tetraform Composites Limited

9 30am 12 09 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrrey 45 mins Directions given

HC 99 0562 City Technology v Alpha Sense Ltd

9 30am 13 09 01

Directions Mr Justice Pumfrey 1 ½ hrs Directions given

HC 00 2952 Daimler Chrysler v Euro Car Parts

NB 11 30am 13 09 01


PAT 01 014 Didion Manufacturing Co v Henley Foundries

12 noon 13 09 01

Directions Mr Justice Neuberger 20 mins Withdrawn by consent

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

76

PAT 01 003 Joffey v Goodwin

9 30am 14 09 01


HC 01 3307 RD Impex APS v Linpac Mouldings Limited

9 45am 26 09 01

Telephone Application (CMC) Mr Justice Laddie 15 mins Withdrawn by consent


9 30am 19 09 01



9 30am 20 09 01

Directions Mr Justice Laddie 1 hr Directions given

HC 00 5233 TLC 236/01 (1) Stephen Tickner (2) Timothy Woodhouse v (3) Honda Motor Company Limited (4) Honda Europe Limited (5) Honda Motor Europe Limited

10 am 21 09 01


CH 97 B 4804 Brawley v Marczynski

10am 24 09 01

Further argument Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Directions given

HC 00 679 TLC/126/01 Sabaf SpA v (1) MFI Furniture Centres Ltd (2) Meneghetti SpA

9.30am 25 09 01

Further argument Mr Justice Laddie 30 mins Directions given

HC 00 4266 TV/Com v Telewest and Others

9 30am 28 09 01


HC 01 C 04025 Generics UK v SmithKline Beecham

11 30am 01 10 01

Directions Mr Justice Jacob 15 mins Application for interim injunction adjourned. Further hearing on 23.10.01. Undertakings given meanwhile.

HC 01 1344 TLC 489/01 Thompson Plastics (Hull) Limited v Tetraform Composites Limited

11 45am 01 10 01

Strike out Mr Justice Jacob 45 mins Application to strike out parts of witness statements mainly successful.

HC 98 03134 Farmer v Mosely (Holdings) Ltd and RTK Marine Ltd

9 30am 02 10 01

Directions Mr Justice Jacob 2hrs Claimant’s application for further disclosure refused. Claimant’s application for adjournment of trial date refused. Amended directions for trial given.

HC01 1034 SmithKlyne Beecham v Synthon

9 30am 03 10 01

Application to amend specification Mr Justice Jacob 30 mins Agreed directions in patent amendments proceedings to be heard with trial.

PAT 01014 Didion Manufacturing Co v (1)Henley Foundries Ltd (2) Jeffrey Fletcher (3) JFK Engineering Ltd

9 30am 04 10 01

Directions Mr Justice Jacob 9 30am 30 mins – merged with hearing on 5 10 01 (same parties) Defendant's application for extension of time for defence and counterclaims granted. Claimants to pay cost of application.

PAT 01014 Didion Manufacturing Co v (1)Henley Foundries Ltd(2) Jeffrey Fletcher (3) JFK Engineering Ltd

9 30am 05 10 01

Directions Mr Justice Jacob 9 30am 20 mins see above

HC 00 3375 TLC 479/01 Trespaphan v Polinas Plastik Sanayi Ve Ticareti SA

Midday 05.10.01

Claimant's application to adjourn trial refused.

PAT 01 010 Adrian Grant v Haydock

9 30am 08 10 01

CMC Mr Justice Jacob 30 mins Directions for trial in Patents County Court given.


10 30am 08 10 01

Application to strike out. Half day. Mr Justice Jacob Application from 8.10.01 stood over to 10.10.01. Application to strike out stood over for trial. Case transferred to Patents County Court for trial on same date (25.10.01)

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

77

HC 010 1273 Fenchurch Environmental Group Ltd v Liquid Technologies

9.00am 11.10.01

CMC Jacob J 30 minutes Telephone application Application to transfer case to Manchester and for directions. Directions by consent given for hearing of ultimate trial in Manchester

HC 00 4957 SEB v De Longhi

NB 9.30am 11.10.01

Leave to serve amended reply Jacob J 1 hour Application to strike out plea of commercial success refused. Application to amend plea of commercial success in part allowed and in part refused.

PAT Wesley Corporation

9 30am 12.10.01

Application Jacob J 30 mins Application to strike out infringement claim of second patent in suit dismissed. Claimants ordered to provide early witness statements concerning infringement of that patent.

HC 00 4267 TV Com International v ITV Digital

9.30am 18.10.01

Directions Jacob J 30 mins. Agreed order received 15.10.01.

HC00 3783 PAG v Hawk-Wood Ltd

10 30am 15.10.01

Directions Pumfrey J ½ day Directions given

HC 01 C 04025 Generics UK v Smithkline Beecham

10.30am 23.10.01

Interlocutory injunction Jacob J 1 day Interim injunction granted. Trial date fixed for March 2002.

HC 01 01870 Nutrinova v Arnold Suhr & Hope Chemichals

9.30am 26.10.01

Telephone application to adjourn directions hearing on 30.10. 01 to 7 or 8.11.01 Jacob J 10 mins Vacated by consent 25.10.01

HC 01 01870 Nutrinova v Arnold Suhr & Hope Chemicals

9 30am 30.10.01

Directions Jacob J 1 hr Vacated by consent 25.10.01

HC 01 C 03307 R D Impex APS v Linpac Mouldings Ltd

9.30am 29.10.01

Telephone application CMC Jacob J 30 mins Vacated by consent 26.10.01

HC 98 03134 Dr Anthony Stephen De Silva Farmer v Moseley (Holdings) Ltd & Ors

9.30am 31.10.01

Directions Jacob J 15 minutes Application by defendant to strike out for failure to comply with orders for witness statements and expert reports adjourned to 2.11.01 at 2.00pm. Claimant’s costs summarily assessed.

HC 01 CO 03968 Iain Peter McGuffie & Anr v Supaturf Products Ltd & Ors

NB 10.15am 2.11.01

Directions Jacob J up to 1 hour Vacated by consent 1.11.01

HC 98 03134 Dr Anthony Stephen De Silva Farmer v Moseley (Holdings) Ltd & Ors

2.00pm 2.11.01

Strike out application Jacob J 30 minutes Amendment to statement of costs allowed. Costs of and Occassioned by amendment (including costs thrown away by abandoned claims) to be the defendant’s. Costs of today in the case

CH 96 C No 4344 Coflexip & Stolt Comex

9.30am 7.11.01

Directions Pumfrey J up to 1 hour Directions given

HC 00 5233 TLC 236/01 Woodhouse v Honda

9.30am 9.11.01

Directions Jacob J 30 minutes Applications for further directions: 1. Further experiment allowed. 2. Permission for experiments in reply. Question of yet further experiment deferred to enable defendants to consider. 3. Other minor directions given.

Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV v Aventi 9.11.01 Jacob J. Order on paper allowing amendment of particulars of infringement.

CH 99 01919 Rohm & Haas v Collag

9.30am 13.11.01

Variation of Order of Neuberger J Pumfrey J 2 hours Directions given

HC 00 4470 TLC 406/01 Alcatel v Marconi

9.30am 16.11.01

Directions Pumfrey J 2 hours Directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

78

HC 01 01244 Storage Computer Corporation v Hitachi

10.30am 28.11.01

Disclosure Jacob J 3½ hours Application for sequential evidence as to infringement partially successful. Directions for enlargement of confidentiality club and other minor directions. Costs in the case.

HC 01 C 03307 R D Impex APS v Linpac Mouldings Ltd

Order dated 28.11.01 transferring case to the Central London County Court (Patents County Court)

HC 01 C03268 BASF v Smithkline Beecham Smithkline Beecham v Generics

NB 9.30am 30.11.01

Directions Jacob J 1 hour Application by BASF for action against Generics to be delayed so that their claim for revocation could be heard with action at a later date refused. BASF claim for revocation to be heard with action. New commencement date of 14.3.02. Application for expanded statement of case by SKB in BASF’s proceedings granted. Application by SKB to bring new cause of action in to existing proceedings refused. SKB to pay costs of both other parties.


NB 10.00am 30.11.01

Case Management Conference Jacob J ½ day Defendant’s application for transfer to Patents County Court refused. Inspection of second defendant’s factory in China ordered by consent. Inspection to be by claimant’s independent expert. Inspection by unnamed single joint expert refused. Costs reserved. Application relating to stamp duty point adjourned to 4.12.01 because skeleton arguments served late.

HC 01 C5083 Generics (UK) Limited v Aktiebolaget Hassle

10.30am 4.12.01

Jacob J ½ to 1 hour To become party to the action Cairnstores Limited v Aktiebolaget Hassle scheduled to commence on 6.2.02. Application by Generics for their claim for revocation ordered to be heard at the same time as the Cairnstores action fixed for 6.2.02. Action for infringement against Generics not to be heard at the same time. Minor consequential directions.


NB 11.00am 4.12.01

Jacob J 1 hour Resumed application Application to have Stamp Act defence dismissed. Issue adjourned for applicants to attend upon the Stamp Office. Defendant’s costs in any event not to be assessed until after trial.

HC 00 03572 Kooltrade Ltd v XTS Ltd

9.30am 7.12.01

Leave to join solicitors and directors as 2nd and 3rd defendants Pumfrey J, 2 hours Judgment given on 10.12.01. Not on website.

HC 00 02952 TLC 875/01 Daimler Chrysler v Euro Car Parts

10.15am 11.12.01

Case Management Conference Jacob J, 20 minutes Action transferred to Patents County Court for 3-4 day trial

HC 00 4957 TLC 171/01 SEB SA v (1) De’Longhi SPA (2) De’Longhi Ltd

9.30am 17.12.01

Disclosure Jacob J, 30 minutes Application for disclosure in part successful, in part refused. Order for statement as to dimensions in alleged infringement.

HC 01 CO 4646 Philips v Aventi

9.30am 18.12.01

Case Management Conference Jacob J, 30 minutes Time for defence and counterclaim extended. Timetable for trial ordered. Costs in the case. Trial date not to be before 1.10.02.

HC 01 01244 Storage Computers v Corporation v Hitachi

9.30am 20.12.01

Application Jacob J, 20 minutes

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

79

Application for disclosure of confidential defendant documents to consultant of claimant (not being an expert witness) refused.

(1) HC 01 C04136 Intel Corporation v Via Technologies Inc & Realtime Distributions (2) HC 01 CO4135 Intel Corporation v Via Technologies & Elitegroup Computer Systems

9.30am 21.12.01

Case Management Conference Jacob J, 1 hour Directions application in two actions, HC 01 C04135 Intel v Via Technologies (Chipset) fixed for 9.12.01 for 5 days, and HC 01 C04136 Intel v Via Technologies (CPU) fixed for 3.2.03 for 10 days. Order that competition defences in both actions be heard separately from patent issue. Directions for strike out application of competition defence given.

(1) HC 00 5802 TLC 248/01 Cairnstores v Aktiebolaget Hassle (2) HC 01 C 05093 Generics (UK) Ltd v Aktiebolaget Hassle

NB 10.30am 21.12.01

Extension of time to serve expert’s report Neuberger J, 15 minutes Directions given.

HC 012 C04135 Intel Corporation v Via Technologies & Elitegroup Computer Systems

9.30am 14.1.02

Case Management Conference, Laddie J, 45 minutes Hearing vacated 21.12.01

HC 01 C 04377 Overend Enterprises Ltd v Innovative Technical Solutions

9.30am 15.01.02 (fixed 19.12.01)

Judgment in default (unopposed action) Laddie J, 30 minutes Order granted

HC 99 3633 TLC 202/01 (1) American Home Products Limited & (2) Professor Sir Roy Calne v (1) Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Limited & (2) Novartis Pharma AG

9.30am 17.01.02 (fixed 21.12.01)

Application to amend patent Laddie J, 1 hour Directions given

HC 01 C0 5093 Merck Generics v Aktiebolaget Hassle

9.30am 21.01.02 (fixed 11.01.02)

Case Management Conference Laddie J, 1 hour Directions given to fix trial


9.30am 22.01.02 (fixed 17.01.02)

Further Directions Jacob J, 30 minutes Further directions given relating to inspection of factory in China

HC 01 C04833 Teva Pharmaceuticals v Instituto Gentili

9.30am 24.01.02 (fixed 13.12.01)

Case Management Conference (moved from 23.01.02 by consent of parties on 11.01.02) Pumfrey J, 30 minutes Directions given. Trial to be listed.

HC 01C 01435/01436 Intel v Via Technologies (Chipset) Intel v Via Technologies (CPU)

10.30am 24.01.02 (fixed 18.01.02)

(1) To fix date for strike out application (2) To fix trial date of European defence action Jacob J, 30 minutes Trial of competition defence and counterclaim commencing April 2003

HC 97 03482 M&H Plastics Ltd v Pettyfer

9.30am 25.01.02

Directions Laddie J, 1 hour Hearing vacated by consent on 24.1.02, transferred to Patents County Court


2.00pm 25.01.02

Further Directions relating to inspection in China Jacob J, 15 minutes Permission given for Counsel to attend the inspection

HC 01 C05327 David Charles White v Metropolitan Police & Ors

9.30am 28.01.01 (fixed 16.02.02)

Strike Out Application, three paper applications for strike out issued by Serious Fraud Office, Bank of England and Metropolitan Police Legal Services. Laddie J, 30 minutes Directions given

HC 01 C04626 Hoover v Dyson

9.30am 31.01.02 (fixed 21.12.01)

Application for disclosure and further directions Laddie J, 1 hour Order made

HC 00 05788 9.30am Application for disclosure

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

80

AEA Technology plc v Michael Mulholland & Air Pollution Abatement Ltd

1.02.02 (fixed 18.12.01)

Laddie J, 2 hours Vacated by consent 31.01.02

(1) HC 02 C00218 Arrow Generics Ltd v Smithkline Beecham (2) HC O1C 03268 Smithkline Beecham v BASF

9.30am 1.02.02 (fixed 28.01.02)

(1) Application for expedited trial (2) application Jacob J, 1 hour Application of Arrow Ltd to join proceedings fixed for 14.03.02 refused. Arrow to pay costs. Application by SKB for particulars of common general knowledge adjourned by consent.

HC 02 2808 Dranez Holdings v Hayek & Medivent Ltd

9.30am 5.02.02 (fixed 28.01.02)

Application for further and better disclosure Laddie J, 30 minutes. Withdrawn by consent 01 02 02

HC 02 C00278 H Lundbeck A/S v Alpharma & Ors

9.30am 11.02.02 (fixed 29.01.02)

Directions Laddie J, 30 minutes Moved from Patents Court to General Chancery list to a date to be fixed. Order made.

HC 0101244 Storage Computer Corporation v Hitachi Data Systems Ltd Hitachi Data Systems Ltd v Storage Computers

9 30am 14 02 02 (fixed 02.02.02)

Directions Laddie J 1 ¼ hrs Removed from list on 13.02.02 because of increased time estimate. To be re-fixed.

HC 99 2388 Decon Laboratories Ltd v Fred Baker Scientific Ltd

9 30am 21 02 02 (fixed 07.02.02)

Directions Pumfrey J 30 minutes Directions given

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

81

HC 02 C 00218 Arrow Generics v Smithkline Beecham

10.00am 21.02.02 (fixed 07.02.02)

Join action Jacob J 1 hour (date changed from 14.02.02 on 11.02.02)(date changed from 18.02.02 on 14.02.02) Application by Arrow for its action for revocation to be heard with existing proceedings on 14.03.02 refused


9.45am 26.02.02 (fixed 15.02.02)

Further directions Jacob J 20 minutes (application moved from 22.02.02) Meeting between experts ordered

HC 010 1244 Storage Computers v Hitachi Data Systems

9.30am 27.02.02

Application Laddie J ½ day Directions given


10 30am 04.03.02 (fixed 6.02.02)

Directions Laddie J, 3 hours (date changed from 28.02.02 on 11.02.02) Hearing held in private. Judgment given – not on website

HC 01C 04025 Smithkline Beecham v Generics (UK) Ltd

10.30am 06.03.02 (fixed 05.03.02)

Application Jacob J, 10 minutes Time for patentee’s reply of evidence extended to 5.00pm on 07.03.02.

HC 01 05179 Beecham Group plc v Generics UK

NB 10.30am 06.03.02 (fixed 18.02.02)

Case Management Conference Jacob J, 30 minutes Order for speedy trial not before 01.10.02 floating in General Chancery. Parties to agree directions for readiness by that date.

HC 01 CO1435 Intel v Via Technologies (Chipset)

9.30am 08.03.02 (fixed 04.03.02)

Further and better information Jacob J, 1 hour. To be relisted with a half day estimate.

98 N 4731 Nutrinova v Scanchem

10.00am 08.03.02 (fixed 20.02.02)

Confidentiality issues Pumfrey J, 30 minutes Directions given

HC 01 CO4669 Menashe v William Hill

10.30am 08.03.02 (fixed 25.02.02)

Preliminary issues, Jacob J, 1 day Judgment reserved. Handed down on 15.03.02 (copy on website)

HC 02 C00343 Teva Pharmaceutical Industries v Merck & Co

9.30am 12.03.02 (fixed 26.02.02)

Case Management Conference Laddie J, 30 minutes Withdrawn by consent. Consent order submitted.


9.30am 12.03.02 (fixed 28.02.02)

Application for specific disclosure Pumfrey J, 30 minutes Directions given.

HC 02 00278 H Lundbeck A/S v Alpharma Ltd & Ors

10.00am 13.03.02 (fixed 25.02.02)

Application by second and third defendants (Omegafarma) to have application against them discontinued Laddie J, 2 hours Order made

HC 02 00278 H Lundbeck A/S v Alpharma Ltd & Ors

10.30am 27.03.02 (fixed 14.02.02)

Application for interim injunction Jacob J, 1 day Settled. Letter of confirmation dated 13.03.02 received from Bird & Bird.

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

82

HC 01C 05093 Generics (UK) Ltd v Aktiebolaget Hassle

9.30am 26.03.02 (fixed 14.03.02)

Application to have 15.07.02 infringement (HC 01 CO5159 – Aktiebolaget Hassle & Astra Zeneca v Generics (UK) Ltd) vacated. Laddie J, 1 hour Part heard on 26.03.02 and settled on 27.03.02

HC 0101878 Sun Chemical v CIBA Speciality Chemicals

9.30am 26.03.02 (fixed 28.02.02)

Application re experiments Jacob J, 45 minutes (original hearing date of 12.03.02 vacated on 8.03.02 and relisted for hearing on 26.03.02) Liberty to claimants to adjuce evidence of an experiment which is to be demonstrated to the defendants. Trial date to be fixed through the usual channels not before 15.10.02. Parties to agree directions in amendment proceedings such that the amendment evidence is served with the main evidence. Costs of trial date application in the case. Costs of experiment application defendants costs in the case.

HC 01 C0 4136 Intel v Via Technologies

9.00am 27.03.02 (fixed 22.03.02)

Serve admissions Laddie J, 30 minutes Settled 26.03.02

HC 02 C00341 LG Electronics v Elenex

9.30am 10.04.02 (fixed 19.03.02)

Case Management Conference Pumfrey J, 30 minutes Withdrawn 28.03.02


9.45am 05.04.02 (fixed 19.03.02)

Further directions re experiments and disclosure Jacob J, up to 1 hour Disclosure of documents relating to process ordered. Permission to claimants to adjuce experimental evidence that second defendants alleged process does not work. Other routine directions given.

HC 02 C00279 Allergan v Pharmacia

9.30am 08.04.02 (fixed 05.03.02)

Case Management Conference Jacob J, 2 hours Liberty to fix trial date for early 2003. Consolidation of infringement revocation and declaration actions consequential directions as to pleadings.

HC 010878 Sun Chemicals v CIBA Speciality Chemicals

9.30am 17.04.02 (fixed 25.03.02)

Directions on amendment application Pumfrey J, 20 minutes Result. Withdrawn by consent 15 04 03

HC 02808 Dranez Holdings v (1) Medivent (2) Zamir Hayek

9.30am 18.04.02 (fixed 04.04.02)

Strike out application Pumfrey J, 30 minutes Part heard and adjourned to 26 04 02 9.30am

HC 01 CO4779 Ali Guryel & Bromcom Computers plc v TASC Software & Ors

9.30am 23.04.02 (fixed 25.02.02)

Case Management Conference Pumfrey J, 1 hour (original date of 12.4.02 changed by consent on 08.04.02) Costs in the case. Draft order to be presented for approval. Trial to be listed, time estimate 3 days. Draft bundles 14 before trial.

HC 02808 Dranez Holdings v (1) Medivent (2) Zamir Hayek

9.30am 01.05.02 (fixed 18.04.02, re-fixed 24.04.02)

Part heard Strike Out application adjourned from 18.04.02 Pumfrey J 1 hour Costs order made in favour of Medivent

HC 01 CO4646 Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV v Aventi Ltd

9.30am 02.05.02 (fixed 26.04.02)

Application for further information Pumfrey J 20 minutes Order made as requested. Permission given for Counsel’s costs in the event to be assessed.

(A) HC 02C00844/845/846 9.30am Application to join TEVA Pharmaceuticals action

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

83

Arrow Generics Ltd v (1) Istituto Gentili SpA (2) Merck & Co Inc (B) HC 02C01025 Generics (UK) Ltd v (1) Istituto Gentili SpA (2) Merck & Co Inc

03.05.02 (fixed 25.04.02)

commencing on 05.11.02 Jacob J 1 hour Applications by Generics and Arrow for their applications for revocation of UK patent 2,118,042 and EP (UK) 998, 292 ordered to be heard with existing applications by TEVA. Time estimates altered. Applications by Arrow for revocation of EP (UK) 402, 152 ordered to be heard separately at a date to be arranged in January 2003 with a 5 day estimate.

HC 98 4731/4732 Scanchem Ltd

9.30am 03.05.02 (fixed 22.04.02)

Application to release legal representatives Pumfrey J 1 hour Legal representatives released in accordance with order

HC01 00614 A Fulton Company Limited v Totes Isotoner (UK) Limited

9 30am 09 05 02

To ammend pleadings & admit further evidence Pumfrey J 1hr Result. Defendant to pay cost of trial adjournment. Defendant will submit agreed minute of order as directed.

CH 1996 C4344 Coflexip SA v Stolt Seaway MS Ltd (Enquiry as to Damages)

10.30am 13.05.02 (fixed 26.04.02)

Case management conference and application to strike out Pumfrey J ½ to 1 day Taken out by consent to be refixed

HC 02 C00629 Falcon Games v (1) US Eurolink plc (2) Value Network Co Ltd

9.30am 14.05.02 (fixed 01.05.02)

Application for judgment in default Pumfrey J 10 minutes Directions given regarding costs. No order made.

HC 02 C0040 Rockwater Ltd v Coflexip SA

10.00am 15.05.02 (fixed 30.04.02)

Case Management Conference Jacob J 5 minutes Routine directions for trial. Trial date fixed floating from 20.01.03 for 3 days.

HC 01 01878 Sun Chemical v CIBA Speciality Chemicals Holdings

NB 10.00am 15.05.02 (fixed 14.05.02)

Further directions re trial date Jacob J 15 minutes Application for trial date to be adjourned to December refused.

HC 01 00641 TLC 469/01 A Fulton Company Ltd v Totes Isotoner (UK) Ltd

9.30am 17.05.02 (fixed 14.05.02)

Further directions re trial date Pumfrey J 10-15 minutes Order made to transfer action to Patents County Court

HC 01 012444 Storage Computer Corporation v Hitachi Data Systems Ltd

9.30am 22.05.02 (fixed 21.05.02)

Application for extension of time for service of witness statements Pumfrey J 10 minutes Hearing vacated by consent 22.05.02

HC 01 C04646 Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV v Aventi Ltd

NB 10.00am 31.05.02 (fixed 28.05.02)

Further directions on trial Jacob J 30-45 minutes Consent order against former director for disclosure of information about manufacturing source. Similar order against defendants in liquidation.

Intended Action Smithkline Beecham v Alpharma

NB 10.30am 31.05.02 (fixed 30.05.02)

Ex-parte injunction application Jacob J 2 hours Hearing vacated by consent 30.05.02

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

84

HC 01 012444 Storage Computer Corporation v Hitachi Data Systems Ltd

10.0am 10.06.02 (fixed 31.05.02)

1. Security of Costs 2. Amendment to particulars of objection Neuberger J 30 minutes Vacated by consent 09.06.02


9.30am 14.06.02 (fixed 28.05.02)

Application to lift confidentiality order on certain documents Jacob J 30 minutes Vacated by consent 10.06.02

HC 01 01034 Synthon BV v Smithkline Beecham plc

NB Midday 11.06.02 (fixed 21.05.02)

Application to strike out notice of experiments Jacob J ½ to 1 day 1) Application for strike out of notice of experiments refused for reasons to be given later. Permission to appeal granted. 2) Application for “amendment” of notice to experiments granted on the basis that patentees may see a repetition. 3) Application concerning admission of experiments conducted in other jurisdictions adjourned to be heard by 21.06.02. 4) Claimant’s application for further information granted.

HC 01 CO1435 Intel v Via Technologies (Chipset)

10.00am 12.06.02 (fixed 29.05.02)

Application for disclosure Jacob J 30 minutes Application adjourned to be heard with applications by defendants, time estimate 1 day

HC 01 01834 Commtel (UK) Ltd v Amstrad plc

9.45am 13.06.02 (fixed 11.06.02)

(1) Application for disclosure (2) Application to amend particulars of objection Jacob J 30-45 minutes Amendment to allow citation of new prior art allowed. Trial adjourned to allow patentee to seek amendment to the patent (to be fixed for December 2002). Order for further disclosure concerning defendant’s alleged copying. CMC to be arranged for early October.

HC 02 C00279 Allergan v Pharmacia

10.15am 18.06.02

Application to include someone in a confidentiality agreement Jacob J 20 minutes Vacated by consent 17.06.02

HC 02 C010416 Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV v Opal Computers Ltd

Consent order signed by Jacob J 19.06.02. Extension of time for defence to enable parties to negotiate.


10.30am 19.06.02

Judgment on refusal of application for strike out of notice of experiments Jacob J

HC 01 01586 Fletcher v Public Forums Internet (PFI) & Anr

9.30am 20.06.02 (fixed 14.06.02)

To transfer case from General Chancery to the Patents Court Pumfrey J 30 minutes Transferred to Patents Court, to be heard on 27/28 June with a 1-1½ day estimate. Costs in case.

HC 02 CO1532 SKB v Alpharma

11.00am 24.06.02 (fixed 11.06.02)

Injunction Jacob J, up to ½ day Application for interim injunction adjourned until 7 days after judgment in SKB. Upon undertakings by the defendant, order for the supply of a sample for analysis on terms.


9.30am 27.06.02 (fixed

Application concerning admission of experiments conducted in other jurisdictions Jacob J, 1 hour

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

85

12.06.02) Directions as to the admission of further experiments. Costs of previous application for which judgment was given on 19.06.02 awarded to claimant

HC 01 C04833 Teva Pharmaceutical Industries v Instituto Gentili SpA

9.30am 03.07.02 (fixed 20.06.02)

Directions Jacob J 1 hour Directions for evidence concerning amendment to patent given by consent

HC 02 C01490 Generics (UK) Ltd v Merck & Co Inc

03.07.02 paper applica-tion

Jacob J Consent order for Generics (UK) Ltd to join Arrow Generics Ltd v Merck & Co Inc action (HC 02 C00845) floating from 03.02.03

CH 1996 C4344 Coflexip SA v Stolt Comex Seaway MS Ltd

10.00am 04.07.02 (fixed 24.06.02)

Directions Jacob J 30 minutes Times for disclosure for defendant’s disclosure re-set. Defendants to pay costs

HC 01 4135 Intel v Via Technologies (Chipset) (s/o for further argument to 08.07.02 and 10.07.02)

10.30am 05.07.02 (fixed 13.06.02)

Applications for: 1) Disclosure 2) Product description 3) Discovery Pumfrey J ½ to 1 day Limited disclosure allowed with safeguards. Other issues adjourned for three weeks – date to be fixed.

CH/2002/APP/0347 Vericore Ltd v (1) Vetrepharm Ltd (2) Alpharma

9.30am 11.07.02 (fixed 20.06.02)

Directions Pumfrey J 1 hour Adjourned for further directions and argument until 24.07.02

HC 99 02754 Hoover v Dyson

2.00pm 12.07.02 (fixed 25.06.02)

(1) Disclosure; (2) and/or further information; (3) timetable; (4) leave to serve recommended statement of contention Pumfrey J ½ to 1 day Order made as directed.

HC 02 C00629 Falcon Games Ltd v (1) US Eurolink plc (2) Value Network Co Ltd

10.00am 16.07.02 (fixed 26.06.02)

Application for committal Pumfrey J 30 minutes Agreed. No committal and order made.

HC 02 C01532 SKB v Alpharma Ltd

17.07.02 not before midday (fixed 15.07.02)

Interim injunction Pumfrey J ½ hour Hearing vacated by consent 16.07.02

HC 01 C03268 BASF v Glaxo Smithkline plc

17.07.02 9.30am

Costs and further argument on judgment Pumfrey J 2 hours

HC 01 01870 Nutrinova v Hope Chemicals

10.00am 18.07.02 (fixed 04.07.02)

Trial directions Jacob J 2 hours Judgment against second defendants by reason of breaches of court orders

HC 01 CO4646/HC 02 CO1556 Philips v Princo (original fixture of 02.07.02 adjourned with consent of parties)

10.00am 18.07.02 (fixed 13.06.02, re-fixed 02.07.02)

Application by Princo to join Philips v Aventi trial floating from 01.10.02 Pumfrey J ½ day Trial date vacated. To be relisted not before 11.11.02.

HC 01 C0 5317 Monitoring Technologies Ltd v Bell Group plc

9.30am 19.07.02 (fixed 27.06.02)

Case Management Conference Pumfrey J ½ to 1 hour Security of costs agreed. Consent order.

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

86

HC 00 5493 Brititsh Telecom v Intec

10.00am 19.07.02 (fixed 10.07.02)

Application to amend particulars of objection Jacob J ½ hour Settled 18.07.02

HC 02 C01100 Associated Octel Co Ltd v (1) Exxon Chemical Patents Inc (2) Infineum USA LP

9.30am 26.07.02 (fixed 02.07.02)

Case Management Conference Pumfrey J 1 hour Agreed order 19.07.02

HC 00 02808 Dranez v Medivent Ltd & Zamir Hayek

9.30am 23.07.02 (fixed 19.07.02)

Telephone application to adjourn hearing on 26.07.02 Pumfrey J 10 minutes Settled 23.07.02

HC 00 02808 Dranez v Medivent Ltd & Zamir Hayek (original hearing date of 09.07.02 refixed on 01.07.02 with consent of parties, time estimate increased from 2 hours to ½ to 1 day

10.30am 26.07.02 (fixed 24.06.02)

Application for third party costs order Pumfrey J ½ to 1 day Vacated by consent, to be relisted after Court of Appeal hearing floating from 14.10.02

HC 00 04746 Celltech Chiroscience Ltd v Medimmune Inc

9.30am 26.07.02 (fixed 22.07.02)

Directions for trial date Jacob J ½ hour Vacated 24.07.02

CH/2002/APP/0347 Vericore Ltd v (1) Vetrepharm Ltd (2) Alpharma

10.30am 24.07.02 (fixed 11.07.02)

Further directions and argument Pumfrey J 1 day Judgment reserved


10.00am 25.07.02 (fixed 16.07.02)

1. Amendment to timetable leading up to trial 2. Amendment to pleadings to bring in proceedings Jacob J 30-45 minutes Counterclaim for infringement added to existing action. Consequent procedural directions. Time estimate now 5 days


10.30am 25.07.02 (fixed 25.06.02)

1. Inspection of original disclosure 2. Application by claimant for 4th expert witness Pumfrey J ½ day To be relisted w/c 19.08.02, time estimate 30 minutes

HC 01C 04025 SKB v Generics (UK) Ltd

Not before 2.00pm 25.07.02 (fixed 16.07.02)

Confidentiality of documents Pumfrey J 1½ hours Judgment reserved.

HC 01 C 03268 BASF v SKB

9.30am 29.07.02 (fixed 22.07.02)

Further argument Pumfrey J ½ hour Settled 26.07.02

HC 02 C01138 Michael Bruce Fraser & Ors v Oystertec & Ors

10.30am 29.07.02 (fixed 04.07.02)

Application under CPR 19(9) to seek sanction of the court for a claim to continue as a derivative action Pumfrey J ½ day Permission granted to continue claim. Costs in case

HC 014135 Intel v Via Technologies (Chipset)

9.30am 30.07.02 (fixed 17.07.02)

Directions to amend one of the patents Pumfrey J 1 hour Vacated by consent 29.07.02

CH 1996 C4344 Coflexip SA v Stolt Seaway MS Ltd (Enquiry as to Damages)

10.30am 30.07.02 (fixed 15.05.02)

Case management conference and application to strike out Jacob J ½ to 1 day

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

87

Lost profits claim struck out with liberty to re-plead. Permission to appeal. Defendant’s time for disclosure extended. Application for extension of confidentiality club adjourned.

HC 02 C01532 SKB v Alpharma Ltd (application moved from 9.30am on 02.08.02 with consent of parties)

NB 2.00pm 01.08.02 (fixed 19.07.02)

Restored application for interim injunction Jacob J ½ day Application for interim injunction by consent undertaking until trial. Trial date fixed for 21.10.02, time estimate 2-3 days. Costs reserved on issues of infringement only.

CH 1996 C4344 Coflexip SA v Stolt Comex Seaway

10.15 am 09.08.02 (fixed 08.08.02)

Directions on order Jacob J 10 minutes Application to determine whether price reduction claims in enquiry as to damages should be struck out. Directed to be heard at a date to be fixed.

HC 01 C1435 Intel v Via Technologies (Chipset)

21.08.02 Notice of enforcement Pumfrey J 1 hour Minute of order to be drafted and directions given


23.08.02 Directions re expert witnesses Pumfrey J 30 minutes Directions given in relation to discovery of expert evidence

98T 04928 Taylor v Ishida

10.30am 26.09.02

Directions Laddie J 30 minutes Consent Order

HC 02 C01046 Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV v Opal Computers Ltd

26.09.02 Laddie J Tomlin Order

HC 02 C01761 Generics (UK) Ltd v Merck & Co

26.09.02 Laddie J Consent Order

HC 02 C0916 Sala Group Ltd v County Safety Services Ltd

26.09.02 Laddie J Consent Order

HC 02 CO2149 LG Electronics Inc v (1) NCR Financial Solutions Group Ltd (2) NCR Corporation and Commercial Software Management Ltd

NB 10.00am 04.10.02 (fixed 01.10.02)

Directions hearing Jacob J 30 minutes Directions for hearing of: 1. Application to set aside service out of jurisdiction 2. Whether there should be a preliminary point as to exhaustion of rights 3. Ordered to be heard on 23.10.02 with a preliminary point as to the application of Patents Act 1977

HC 02 C01747 Aromate Industries v Choudhury Trading Corporation Ltd

10.00am 08.10.02 (fixed 01.10.02)

Application for default judgment Jacob J 30 minutes Application withdrawn on 04.10.02, to be relisted

HC 01 01586 Fletcher v (1) Trevor Davies (2) Public Forums Internet

10.00am 09.10.02 (fixed 03.10.02)

Application by solicitor for second defendant to come off the record Jacob J 10 minutes Application granted


NB 10.30am 17.10.02 (fixed 08.10.02)

Amendment to particulars of claim and particulars of infringement Pumfrey J 1 ½ - 2 hours Withdrawn 08.10.02

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

88

HC 02 C00939 Paul Artemi & anr v Computer Patent Annuities Ltd

11.00am 17.10.02 (fixed 07.10.02)

Case Management Conference Jacob J 1 hour Proceedings stayed for 6 months to enable discovery from 3rd parties in US.

HC 02 C02968 Hollywood Tanning Systems Inc & Anr v Laughlin Products & Ors

NB 11.30am 17.10.02 (fixed 14.10.02)

(1) Time for service of application on 2nd/4th defendants be abridged; (2) claimants to have permission too serve claim on 1st/3rd/5th defendants in USA; (3) injunction, declaration & directions Jacob J 30 minutes Permission to serve defendants 1, 3 and 5 out of the jurisdiction. Injunction to restrain threats and malicious falsehood granted against defendants 2 and 4. Application stood over for a date to be fixed within the next 2 weeks.

HC 01 C03268 SKB v BASF & Ors

2.00pm 17.10.02 (fixed 09.10.02)

Directions on amendment proceedings Pumfrey J 1 hour Agreed order.

HC 02 C00278 H Lundbeck v Lagap Pharmaceuticals Ltd

10.30am 18.10.02 (fixed 14.10.02)

Interim injunction Jacob J 30 minutes Directions for application for interim injunction to be heard on or about 11.11.02. Order for speedy trial.

CH 1996 C4344 Coflexip SA v Stolt Comex Seaway

NB 10.30am 18.10.02

Restored application for strike out from 30.07.02 Jacob J ½ day Claim for damages for price reduction struck out or ordered to be repleaded.

HC 00 4957 TLC 171/01 SEB SA v (1) De’Longhi SPA (2) De’Longhi Limited

10.30am 18.10.02 (fixed 14.10.02)

Argument re costs arising from trial Pumfrey J ½ day Agreed order. Leave to appeal granted.

HC 02 C02149 LG Electronics Inc v (1) NCR Financial Solutions Group Ltd (2) NCR Corporation and Commercial Software Management Ltd

10.30am 23.10.02 (fixed 04.10.02)

1. Application to set aside service out of jurisdiction 2. Whether there should be a preliminary point as to exhaustion of rights 3. Preliminary point as to the application of s.68 of the Patents Act 1977 Jacob J 1 day 1. Preliminary point under s.68 decided in favour of defendants. 2. Order for preliminary point as to whether defendants licensed to be heard early in 2003. 3. Application for disclosure of documents to defendants’ clients allowed. 4. Application for setting aside service on 2nd defendants refused.

HC 02 C03016 Terraplas v Portable Roadway Systems Ltd

10.00am 24.10.02 (fixed 16.10.02)

Injunction and delivery up Jacob J 1 hour Application for interim injunction adjourned for evidence. Hearing date to be as soon as possible on or after 02.12.02. Undertakings given meanwhile. (Action transferred to Patents County Court 31.10.02)

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

89

HC 02 C00440 Rockwater Ltd v Coflexip SA (date changed from 25.10.02 at request of the court on 14.10.02)

NB 10.30am 24.10.02 (fixed 04.10.02)

1. Disclosure 2. Directions on experts 3. Extension of confidentiality club 4. Further and better particulars Jacob J ½ day Application for discovery of documents relating to alleged infringement refused.

HC 02 C01490 Generics (UK) Ltd v Merck & Co Inc

10.00am 29.10.02 (fixed 16.10.02)

Directions on reply experiment Jacob J 1½ - 2 hours Upon Arrow agreeing to answer questions about earlier experiments, application for discovery of documents refused. Generic’s application for discovery of Arrow’s experiments settled by consent.

HC 02 C03101 SKB plc v Apotex Europe Ltd

NB 11.30am 29.10.02 (fixed 23.10.02)

Interim Injunction Jacob J ½ day Interim injunction granted until 21.11.02 with directions for further evidence.

HC 02 C01532 Beecham Group plc v Alpharma Ltd

Application for an order under CPR.5.4(2)(c) and 5.4.3 for certain documents from the court record pursuant to an application for inspection made without notice withdrawn 07.11.02

HC 02 C00845/HC 02 C01490 Arrow Generics Ltd v Merck & Co Inc Generics (UK) Ltd v Merck & Co Inc

9.30am 06.11.02 (fixed 30.10.02)

Directions Laddie J 30 minutes

HC 02 C02026 Dyson v Harvard International

9.15am 08.11.02 (fixed 24.10.02)

Case Management Conference Jacob J 1 hour Directions given for trial

HC 02 C02149 LG Electronics v NCR Financial Solutions

09.30am 08.11.02 (fixed 30.10.02)

Further directions Jacob J 15 minutes Vacated 31.10.02


09.45am 12.11.02 (fixed 08.11.02)

Further information from claimants and statement of case Jacob J 30 minutes Vacated 08.11.02

HC 02 C02978 H Lundbeck A/S v Lagap Pharmaceuticals Ltd

Consent Order 08.11.02

Consent order for inspection of factory agreed by Jacob J


9.30am 14.11.02 (fixed 08.11.02)

Directions on 09.12.02 trial Pumfrey J 30 minutes Vacated by consent 12.11.02

HC 02 C02968 Hollywood Tanning Systems Inc & Anr v Laughlin Products & Ors

10.00am 15.11.02 (fixed 31.10.02)

Extension of injunction Neuberger J 1 ½ - 2 hours

HC 02 C02150 LG Electronics Inc v Clevo Computer Co

10.00am 18.11.02 (fixed 11.11.02)

Extension of time to serve defence Jacob J 20 minutes Time extended for first defendant’s defence and counterclaim to 13.01.03. Time extended for 2nd defendant’s defence with unless order against 2nd defendant.

HC 02 C002978 H Lundbeck A/S v Lagap Pharmaceuticals Ltd


Consent order extending confidentiality club for inspection agreed by Jacob J

HC 02 C002978 10.30am Application for interim injunction

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

90

H Lundbeck A/S v Lagap Pharmaceuticals Ltd

18.11.02 (fixed 18.10.02)

Jacob J ½ to 1 day Vacated by consent 05.11.02


2.00pm 20.11.02 (fixed 14.11.02)

Defendant’s application for extension of time for filing evidence Jacob J 10 minutes Vacated 15.11.02

HC 02 C02149 LG Electronics v NCR

NB 2.00pm 20.11.02 (fixed 11.11.02)

Application to fix split trial dates Jacob J 15 minutes Vacated 14.11.02

HC 02 C03403 Lundbeck A/S v Neolab Ltd

10.15am 21.11.02 (fixed 11.11.02)

Directions Jacob J 30 minutes Vacated 20.11.02

HC 02 C01857 BMR Research & Development Ltd & Anr v The Dezac Group Ltd

Consent order 21.11.02

Consent order for directions agreed by Jacob J


NB 10.15am 21.11.02 and 9.30am 22.11.02 (fixed 30.10.02)

Interim injunction Jacob J 1-2 days Part heard – to be listed for 27.11.02

HC 02 C00845 Arrow Generics Ltd v Merck & Co Inc

9.45am 22.11.02 (fixed 14.11.02)

Disclosure Pumfrey J 30-45 minutes Vacated 21.11.02

HC 01 C04176 Daesang Europe BV v Ajinomoto Company

10.00am 26.11.02 (fixed 14.11.02)

Telephone Application Disclosure by claimant Jacob J 15 minutes Application adjourned for hearing in open court because papers not properly supplied

HC 02 C02399 Ascot (S&F) International Ltd v Airborne Footwear

Order 28.11.02

Order for action to be transferred to Patents Court and be consolidated with claim number HC 02 C02432 approved by Jacob J

HC 01 01878 Sun Chemical Corporation & Anr v CIBA Speciality Chemicals Holding Incorporated


Consent order staying action until 01.04.03 approved by Jacob J


10.00am 28.11.02

Judgment on application held 21/22.11.02 Jacob J

HC 99 00642 Result International & Anr v Comic Relief Ltd & Anr (application moved from 06.12.02 to 28.11.02 at request of court)

10.30am 28.11.02 (fixed 06.11.02)

(1) Amend statement of case (2) Directions on exchange of documents (3) To fix trial date Jacob J 1 ½ hours Consent order for directions. Actions stayed to enable mediation.

H 1998 T No 4928 Alfred Alexander Taylor v (1) Ishida (Europe) Ltd (2) Ishida Co Ltd


Consent order extending confidentiality club approved by Jacob J

HC 02 C01138 Michael Bruce Fraser & Ors v Oystertec & Ors

10.30am 04.12.02 (fixed 07.11.02)

Directions and security of costs Jacob J ½ day Security for costs and procedural directions including directions for summary judgment application

HC 01 C04810 2.00pm Amendment to the product and process description

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

91

Stolt Offshore MS Ltd & Ors v Coflexip SA & Anr

04.12.02 (fixed 22.11.02)

Jacob J 1 hour (1) Trial adjourned by consent owing to increased time estimate. To be refixed. (2) Claimant’s application for amendment of product and process description adjourned. (3) Costs reserved.

HC 02 3397 Zipher Ltd & Ors v Markem Technologies Ltd

9.30am 05.12.02 (fixed 29.11.02)

Application for speedy trial Jacob J 45 minutes Action stayed pending trial of intended action of which undertakings given to issue by Monday. Trial to be heard by a Deputy High Court Judge to commence on 24.03.03 for 5 days

HC 02 C03535 P&M Products v Choudhury

9.30am 05.12.02 (fixed 03.12.02)

Injunction Laddie J 1 hour Attendance by claimants only. Timetable agreed and order made.

(1) CH 02 499 Synthon AB v Merck & Co Inc (2) HC 02 C03597 Niche Generics Ltd v Merck & Co Inc

9.45am 06.12.02 (fixed 26.11.02

Case Management Conference/Directions Jacob J 30-45 minutes Trial floating from 03.06.03. Directions for trial given.

HC 01 C03268 SKB v (1) Apotex (2) Generics UK (3) BASF (4) Alpharma

10.30am 06.12.02 (fixed 18.11.02)

SKB’s application to strike out statements of case of BASF and Alpharma Pumfrey J 1 day Judgment to be given at 09.30am on 13.12.02

HC 01 C05317 Monitoring Technologies Ltd v Bell Group plc

9.45am 09.12.02 (fixed 22.11.02)

Further security Pumfrey J ½ hour Order made

HC 02 C002978 Lundbeck v Lagap Pharmaceuticals

10.00am 09.12.02 (fixed 22.11.02)

Confidentiality issues Jacob J 1 hour Vacated by consent 06.12.02

HC 02 C00939 Paul Artemi & Anr v Computer Patent Annuities Ltd

10.30am 10.12.02 (fixed 20.11.02)

Security of costs Jacob J 2 hours Vacated from list 29.11.02

HC 01 C05173 Build-a-Bear v (1) Hamleys (2) The Bear Factory Ltd

09.30am 12.12.02 (fixed 09.12.02)

Directions Jacob J 30 minutes Application for adjournment refused. Trial to float from 24.02.03. Time for service of witness statements extended to 10.01.03.

HC 01 C04176 Daesang Europe BV v Ajinomoto Co

NB 09.45am 12.12.02 (fixed 29.11.02)

Disclosure Jacob J 30 minutes Vacated by consent 11.12.02

HC 01 C01034 Synthon BV v Smithkline Beecham plc

09.30am 13.12.02

Costs in case heard 7-11 Oct 02 Jacob J Up to 1 hour


09.30am 13.12.02

Judgment in application heard on 06.12.02 Pumfrey J 1 hour


NB 10.00am 13.12.02 (fixed 10.12.02)

Directions Jacob J 1 hour

16/05/2012 11:23:26 SECTION 3

92


9.30am 16.12.02 (fixed 18.11.02)

Further directions Pumfrey J 1 hour Vacated from list on 13.12.02. To be relisted not before 15.01.03

HC 02 C03403 Lundbeck A/S v Neolab Ltd

NB 10.00am 16.12.02 (fixed 05.12.02)

Injunction Jacob J 2 hours Consent order, hearing vacated 13.12.02

HC 01 C04779 Frontline Technology Ltd v TASC Computers & Ors

09.30am 17.12.02 (fixed 12.12.02)

Amendment to pleadings Jacob J 1 hour Vacated by consent 16.12.02

HC 02 C01747 Aromate Industries Co Ltd v Choudhury Trading Corporation Ltd

9.45am 18.12.02 (fixed 28.11.02)

Default judgment on behalf of claimant Jacob J 30 minutes Vacated by consent 16.12.02

HC 02 C02978 Lundbeck A/S v Lagap Pharmaceuticals Ltd

NB 10.30am 18.12.02 (fixed 09.12.02)

Injunction Jacob J 1 day Vacated by consent 17.12.02

No action number Merpro Group Ltd v Dynamic Processing Solutions Ltd

10.30am 19.12.02 (fixed 10.12.02)

Pre-action disclosure Jacob J 1-2 hours Application for pre-action disclosure adjourned for date to be fixed

HC 02 C03639 IVAXX v Merck & Co

10.15am 20.12.02 (fixed 19.12.02)

Extension of time for service of process description Jacob J 15 minutes Time for process description extended

diary section 6

Documents