discipline: physics subject: characterization techniques ... · author (cw): dr. ajit k. mahapatro...
TRANSCRIPT
-
Discipline: Physics
Subject: Characterization Techniques for Materials II
Unit 3: Surface Morphology
Lesson/ Module: Electron Beam Lithography - II
Author (CW): Dr. Ajit K. Mahapatro
Department/ University: Department of Physics and Astrophysics,
University of Delhi, New Delhi-110007
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 1
Contents
Learning Objectives……………………………………...…………………………………..……….2
1. Introduction ………………………………..……………………………………...........…............3
1.1. Lithography…………………………………………………………………………..…3
1.2. Specifications for E-beam lithography…………………………………………………3
2. Computer aided desgin (CAD) software programs……………………………………………3
3. Function of Resists in Electron Beam Lithography …………………………………………...4
3.1. Types of Resists…………………………………………………………………….…..4
3.2. Characteristic features of resist films…………………………………….……………5
3.3. Resist Development………………………………………………………………………6
4. Trajectories of Electrons in the Resist Layers.………………………………………………7
5. Proximity Effect and Resolution Limit……………………………………..…………………8
6. Issues with e-beam lithography …………………………..……………………………………9
7. Defects in Electron-Beam Lithography …..…………………………………………….……10
Summary………………..………………………………………………………………………..11
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 2
Learning Objectives:
From this module students may get to know about the following:
i. Use of Resist in Electron Beam Lithography
ii. Trajectory of Electrons in the Resist Layer
iii. Issues with Electron Beam Lithography
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 3
1. Introduction
1.1. Lithography
Lithography provides an advanced tool for designing structures at micro/nano-meter scale by pattering on
surface of various materials. It allows the interaction of electromagnetic particles with the organic and
inorganic molecules and subsequent chemical dissolving produces features of sizes in the order of the
incident wavelengths. Photolithography utilizes photons for patterning at hundreds of nanometers and higher
energetic sources of electron beam is utilized for designing structures at tens of nanometer scales. In the
electron optics, the refraction index changes continuously and electron interact with each other. Electron
lenses are used to converge the electron beam, magnetic lenses are used to twist the beam, and electrostatic
optics has larger aberrations than magnetic. Feature sizes at tes of nanometers could be produced using
electron beam lithography.
The electron beam lithography is used to create nanoscale patterns by exposing the electron beam of a
scanning electron microscope (SEM) to a sensitive chemical termed as e-beam resist. Generally, a SEM
system with nano pattern generator system (NPGS) hardware and software could work as e-beam
lithography system. Pattern design of the required features to be written on the e-beam resist is programed
using a computer aided design (CAD) based NPGS software.
1.2. Specification for E-beam Lithography
The parameters for a specific e-beam lithography system are:
The pixel exposure time
The dose for large areas (C/cm2)
The dose for one pixel
The pixel area
The area exposed per second
The current density in the spot (A/cm2)
The bandwidth of the deflection and focusing systems as well as resist sensitivity limit the speed of
pattern writing.
2. Computer aided desgin (CAD) software programs
Computer aided desgin (CAD) software programs utilizes schematic capture tools or polygon editors for
designing and drafting patterns compatible for very-large-scale integration (VLSI) technology. These tools
run almost exclusively on UNIX workstations, and generate the standard intermediate graphic database
system GDSII format. Software tools in these sets include analog and digital simulators, silicon compilers,
schematic capture, wire routers, design-rule checkers for complementary metal–oxide–semiconductor
(CMOS) and bipolar technologies. Design Workshop runs under the Macintosh OS, UNIX, and Windows
PC compatibles, with output in caltech intermediate form (CIF) or GDSII format, which include tools for
rule checkers, routers, simulators, and concentrate on the core graphical editors.
Inexpensive graphical editors include AutoCAD and other general-purpose CAD tools for PC compatibles
and the Macintosh. AutoCAD and other similar programs generate Drawing Interchange Format (DXF),
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 4
which could be easily converted to GDSII with a separate program. AutoCAD has the disadvantage that it
was not designed for lithography and can generate patterns for 3D structures that cannot be rendered by e-
beam systems. The DXF format does not support datatype tags, which are used to specify individual dose
values for geometrical shapes. Datatype tags are important when compensating manually or automatically
for the proximity effect.
3. Function of Resists in Electron Beam Lithography
Electron beam lithography follows three important steps (as sketched in Fig. 1) of resist coating using spin
coating, e-beam exposure, and developing the resist for patterning features at nanometer scale. This requires
a resist that can be chemically changed under exposure to the electron beam. Various resists with different
properties exists, which require different chemicals for development and lit-off process. Polymethyl
methacrylate (PMMA) is one of standard positive resist with highest resolution for e-beam, and can be
purchased in several molecular weight forms (50 – 950 K) that usually dissolve in chlorobenzene. Other
organic and inorganic chemicals with positive and negative resists on exposure to electron beam are
tabulated in Tables 1 and 2.
Figure 1. Patterning using e-beam lithography
3.1. Types of Resists: There are two different types of resists exist.
Figure 2. The polymer chains of (a) positive and (b) negative resists after exposure to e-beam
3.1.1. Positive tone resists: They undergo a conversion from low to high solubility upon exposure to
electrons. After development, the exposed structure is deeper than the surrounding due to chopping of
polymer chains. For example, poly-methyl methacrylate (PMMA), a long chain polymer, broken into
smaller, more soluble fragments by the electron beam. Schematics for this breaking is shown in Fig. 2.
Another common positive resist is ZEP 520, which also consists of a long chain polymer.
Cross-link
Chainscission
(a) (b)
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 5
Figure 3. (a) Molecular Sketch of the polymer sub unit of poly (methyl methacrylate). (b) Scission of the
polymer chain during EBL exposure. (c) Chemical reaction of resist polymer after exposure to e-beam.
3.1.2. Negative tone resists: In a negative tone resist, the electrons convert the material to low solubility
upon exposure to beam of electrons. After development, the exposed structure is higher than the surrounding
due to crosslinking of polymer chains. For example, hydrogen silsesquioxane (HSQ) undergoes a cross-
linking reaction to combine smaller polymers into larger and form less soluble compound.
3.2. Characteristic features of resist films
i) Resolution: It defines smallest feature size that could be generated.
ii) Sensitivity: It defines the minimum electron dose required for chemical modification for the whole layer
thickness (termed as clearing dose). It is dependent on the accelerating voltage and developer, and
independent of resist thickness.
iii) Few examples of organic and inorganic e-beam resists are tabulated in the Tables – 1 and 2.
Polymer Tone Sensitivity
(C/cm2
)
Resolution
(µm)
PMMA Positive 4x10
-5
-8x10-5
0.1
P(GMA-co-EA) Negative 3x10
-7
(10keV) 1.0
PBS Positive 8x10
-7
(10keV) 0.5
COP Negative 4x10
-7
1.0
P(GMA-co-EA) Negative 3x10
-7
(10keV) 1.0
PGMA Negative 5x10
-7
(20keV) 1.0
PCA Positive 5x10
-7
(20keV) 0.5
Table 1. Organic e-beam resists
(c)
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 6
Table 2. Inorganic e-beam resists
3.3. Resist Development
After exposure, the resist is immersed in a liquid developer to dissolve the fragments of positive tone and
non-cross-linked molecules of negative tone resists. Temperature and duration are crucial parameters for
resist development. The hotter and longer the development is, farther along the continuum of solubility the
dissolution extends. During development, the solvent enters into the polymer matrix and starts dissolving the
surrounded fragments. Gel formation takes place as the molecules starts interacting and is sketched in Fig. 4.
Figure 4. Positive resist during development. Polymer-solvent interactions can result in gel
formation and swelling
The thickness of the gel layer depends on the amount of fragmentation and strength of the solvent used.
Swelling of the polymer can also occur. Once completely surrounded by solvent, the fragments detach from
the matrix and diffuse into the solvent. Longer fragments are less mobile and more strongly bound to the
matrix, thus takes a longer time to dissolve. Exposure and development are interrelated, as short exposure
with long or aggressive development can be equivalent to heavier exposure with short development.
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 7
4. Trajectories of Electrons in the Resist Layers
A good quality electron beam is categorized by a stable and high brightness electron source used to achieve
high positional accuracy with limited astigmatism and small spot size. The quality of the spot is determined
by the electron optics and degree of focus. The electron column under vacuum reduces gas scattering of the
beam. At higher currents and lower energies, mutual electrostatic repulsion by the electrons leads to
divergence of the beam. As the electrons enter the resist, they begin a series of low energy elastic collisions
(Fig. 5), deflecting the electrons slightly. This forward scattering broadens the beam by an amount that
increases with thickness, and this effect is more pronounced at low incident energies scattering usually limits
the final resist pattern to a larger size.
Most of the electrons pass entirely through the resist and enters deeply into the substrate. Exposure produces
both the forward scattering and backscattering, as shown in Fig. 5. Fraction of those electrons eventually
undergoes large angle collisions to re-emerge into the resist at some distance from the point at which they
left it. These backscattered electrons may cause exposure microns away at higher energies from where the
beam entered. This leads to the proximity effect where electrons writing a feature at one location increase the
exposure at a nearby feature, causing pattern distortion and overexposure. The density of features becomes
an important factor in determining necessary exposure levels. Backscattering can be minimized by exposing
on a thin membrane substrate.
Figure 5. Electron trajectories in resist: An incident electron produces secondary electrons.
Dependence of resolution on energy and back scattering.
Another electron trajectory consideration can be described by secondary electrons. These are low energy
(upto few tens of eV) electrons produced through ionization resulting from inelastic collisions by the primary
incident electrons. Secondary electrons have short range (several nanometers) due to their low energy but
may ultimately limit the resolution possible with EBL. These secondary electrons are capable of breaking
bonds at distances away from the original collision. They can also generate additional, lower energy
electrons, resulting in an electron cascade. Hence, it is important to recognize the significant contribution of
secondary electrons to the spread of the energy deposition.
Another issue is electrostatic charging, if writing onto an insulating substrate. If there exists no pathway for
the absorbed electrons to dissipate, charge build up occurs and defocus the electron beam. In such cases, a
thin metal or conductive polymer layer is required above or below the resist.
ForwardSca ering
Substrate
50kV
Resist
BackwardSca ering
Backsca ering20kV
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secondary_electronshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron_avalanche
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 8
In general, for a molecule AB
e− + AB → AB− → A + B−
This reaction is known as electron attachment or dissociative electron attachment, and is most likely to occur
after the electron has essentially slowed to a halt, as it is easier to capture at that point. At higher energies,
the cross-section for electron attachment is inversely proportional to electron energy, and approaches a
maximum limiting value at zero energy.
5. Proximity Effect and Resolution Limit
The proximity effect is predominantly a result of back-scattered electrons with high kinetic energy, reflected
from the substrate and entered again into the resist layer, causing exposure of the resist away from the region
of incident beam, as shown in Fig. 6. The backscattered electrons originated from collision with atoms in the
substrate and travel in the resist at wide angles compared to electrons in the primary beam. The amount of
backscattered electrons, and thus the amount of the proximity effect depends strongly on the accelerating
voltage and the substrate composition. The smallest features produced by electron-beam lithography have
generally been isolated features, and the electrons from exposure of an adjacent region spill over into the
exposure of the defined feature and effectively enlarge its image. Hence, the desired feature resolution is
harder to control. For most resists, it is difficult to go below 25 nm lines and spaces. The proximity effect
manifests secondary electrons leaving from the top surface of the resist and then returning at tens of
nanometers distance away.
Figure 6. Resolution limit for an electron beam line, showing the proximity effect.
Interaction of electrons with the resist leads to beam spreading through elastic and inelastic scattering in the
resist, back scattering from the substrate and generation of secondary electrons. This result higher line width
for very low spot sizes too. For example, 10 nm beam line could produce patterns at 100 nm precision. In
practice, although, the range of secondary electron scattering is quite far, sometimes exceed 100 nm, but
becoming very significant below 30 nm.
Electronbeam
Substrate
Resist
Direc onofscan
Desiredline
RealResistImage
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 9
The electrons enters the resist and few of them experience small angle scattering events (forward scattering),
which tend to broaden the initial beam diameter while some experience large angle scattering events
(backscattering). The backscattered electrons cause the proximity effect, where the dose that a pattern feature
receives is affected by electrons scattering from other features present nearby. During this process the
electrons are continuously slowing down, producing a cascade of low energy electrons called secondary
electrons with energies from 2 to 50 eV. They are responsible for the bulk of the actual resist exposure
process. The range of secondary electrons in resist is only a few nanometers and contributes little to the
proximity effect. The net result could be an effective widening of the beam diameter by roughly 10 nm. This
largely accounts for the minimum practical resolution of 20 nm observed in the highest resolution electron
beam systems. In basic SEM conversion systems the proximity effect caused by the backscattered electrons
limits the resolution to 100 nm. This resolution level can be increased using dose correction method. The
consequence of proximity effect is that small features are exposed less than the larger features, and causes
significant distortion in very small features.
The simplest dose correction method uses double layer e-resist and only works for quite large features (~1µ).
The other dose correction methods usually consist of calculating the cumulative exposition rate that a feature
receives directly from the beam and also from other features, and then compensating for the excess dose by
adapting the beam current (from feature to feature), the speed with which the beam scans over the sample, or
the shape of the drawn features.
EBL is developed using scanning electron microscopes to which a pattern generator and beam blanker is
added to control areas of the viewing field to be exposed. Modern EBL tools are fully dedicated patterning
systems that employ high brightness electron sources for faster throughput and high resolution mechanical
stages to be able to expose step-by-step large substrates under the relatively narrow field of focus of the
electron beam. These direct writing systems have the advantage of extremely high resolution and the ability
to create arbitrary patterns without a mask. Their disadvantage is the long times taken to write large,
complex patterns. Efforts to overcome this challenge include projection EBL and the use of parallel beams.
6. Issues with E-beam Lithography
(i) Uneven distribution of resist on the substrate: This changes the working distance along the substrate and
few areas are better focused than others.
(ii) Improper or insufficient focusing: The pattern may be under-dosed and may not allow features as desired.
(iii) Astimagtism: Lack of uniformity in the desired pattern
(iv) Under/over-exposing the resist: Each substrate requires different dosage and different sized patterns
have variations in optimal dosage.
(v) Proximity effect: Generally, the features need less dosage due to spreading of secondary electrons.
(vi) Physical defects are more varied, and can include sample charging (either negative or positive),
backscattering calculation errors, dose errors, fogging (long-range reflection of backscattered electrons),
outgassing, contamination, beam drift and particles.
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 10
7. Defects in Electron-Beam Lithography
(i) Shaping error: This occurs in variable-shaped beam systems when the wrong shape is projected onto the
sample. These errors can originate either from the electron optical control hardware or the input data that was
taped out. As might be expected, larger data files are more susceptible to data-related defects.
(ii) Physical defects are more varied, and can include sample charging (either negative or positive),
backscattering calculation errors, dose errors, fogging (long-range reflection of backscattered electrons),
outgassing, contamination, beam drift and particles. Since the write time for electron beam lithography can
easily exceed a day, "randomly occurring" defects are more likely to occur. Here again, larger data files can
present more opportunities for defects.
-
Characterization
Techniques for Materials II [e-PG Pathshala]
Department of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi 11
Summary
i) The electron beam lithography used for writing arbitrary patterns on the resist
with high resolution, high density, high sensitivity and high reliability. These
characteristics are interrelated to fabricate complex device structures at molecular
level precision.
ii) Factors that complicate these objectives are delocalization of electrons due to
forward and backscattering (proximity effects), collapse of the pattern due to
swelling and capillarity forces, and fluctuations in the sizes of features (line edge
roughness).
iii) Interaction of electrons with the resist leads to beam spreading through elastic and
inelastic scattering in the resist, back scattering from the substrate and generation
of secondary electrons. This result higher line width for very low spot sizes too.
For example, 10 nm beam line could produce patterns at 100 nm precision. In
practice, although, the range of secondary electron scattering is quite far,
sometimes exceeding 100 nm, but becoming very significant below 30 nm.
iv) The procedure followed during e-beam lithography includes pattern designing
using CAD software and then written on the e-beam resist by electron beam
exposure followed by developing the exposed wafer to take off the resist from the
unwanted region for the mask.
v) The resolution depends on a number of factors including resist thickness, density,
writing speed, and beam current.