ANNEXES

ANNEX 1 LIST OF AFFECTED LANDS – SON TAY HYDROPOWER PROJECT.............

ANNEX 2 PROJECT INFORMATION BOOKLET (PIB)......................................................

ANNEX 3 TERMS OF REFERENCE..................................................................................

ANNEX 4 CONSULTATION MEETING MINUTES.............................................................

ANNEX 5 SOME PHOTOS OF CONSULTATION MEETINGS..........................................

SFG2158 V5

1

ANNEX 1 TYPES OF AFFECTED LANDS – SON TAY HYDROPOWER PROJECT

No. OWNER No. OF FIELD TYPE OF LANDNo. MAP OF THE LAND

AREA OF THE FIELD (M2)

AREA OF OCCUPIED FIELD (M2)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7XÃ SƠN DUNG         

1 Trần Văn Thang            thửa số 4, tờ số2 4 RMS 2 4,147.0 4,147.0  Thửa số 9, tờ số 1 9 RMS 1 2,643.4 841.92 Đinh Văn Kiêu            Thửa số 16, tờ số 2 16 RMS 2 694.7 694.73 Đinh Vặn Quyên            Thửa số 15, tờ số 2 15 RMS 2 699.6 699.64 Trần Văn Trân 1   2 5,209.5 4,737.9  Tờ số 2 , thửa số 1   RMS      5 Đinh Văn Tra            Thửa số 2, Tờ số 2 2 RMS 2 3,660.0 3,623.0    Ghi chú: Đinh Văn Tra đã bán đất và cây cối lại cho Vương Hoàng Hiếu 6 Đinh Văn Ui            Thửa số 3, Tờ số 2 3 RMS 2 3,860.4 3,855.4    Ghi chú : Đinh Văn Ui đã bán đất và cây côi lại cho Phạm Ngọc Minh  7 Đinh Văn Trim 5   2 8,137.6 7,934.4  Thửa số 5, Tờ số 2   RMS          Ghi chú : Đinh Văn Trim đã bán đất và cây côi lại cho Đỗ Minh Đức 8 Đinh Văn Thu            Thửa số 6, Tờ số 2 6 RMS 2 2,119.4 2,097.2    Ghi chú : Đinh Văn Thu đã bán đất và cây côi lại cho Phạm Ngọc Minh  9 Đinh Văn Ru            Thửa số 7, Tờ số 2 7 RMS

22,732.4 308.1

  Thửa số11, Tờ số 2 11 RMS 4,008.4 2,423.0

2

    Ghi chú : Đinh Văn Ru đã bán đất và cây côi lại cho Nguyễn Thị Sương 10 Đinh Văn Hiêu            Thửa số 8, Tờ số 2 8 RMS 2 7,087.2 4,585.5    Ghi chú : Đinh Văn Hiêu đã bán đất và cây côi lại cho Phạm Ngọc Minh  

11 Đinh Văn Đi            Thửa số 9, Tờ số 2 9 RMS

2884.5 884.5

  Thửa số 12, tờ số 2 12 RMS 3,423.0 1,773.9    Ghi chú : Đinh Văn Đi đã bán lại toàn bộ diện tích , cây cối cho Đỗ Minh Đức

12 Đinh Văn Vút            Thửa số 10, Tờ số 2 10 RMS 2 4,121.6 2,679.1    Ghi chú : Đinh Văn Vút đã bán đất và cây côi lại cho Vũ Tiến Trung 

13 Đinh Văn Vũ            Thửa số 13, tờ số 2 13 RMS 2 4,297.0 2,349.3

14 Đinh Văn Ngữa            Thửa số 14, tờ số 2 14 RMS 2 3,116.0 1,548.2    Ghi chú : Đinh Văn Ngữa đã bán lại toàn bộ diện tích , cây cối cho Vũ Tiến Trung 

15 Lê Tuấn Lâm            Thửa số 1, tờ số 1 1 RMS   2,993.8 10.2

16 Vy Thị Lợi            Thửa số 8, tờ số 1 8 RMS 1 1,570.9 351.8

17 Nguyễn Thị Sương            Thửa số 7, tờ số 1 7 RMS

1

2,579.8 628.7  Thửa số 6, tờ số 1 6 RMS 3,359.8 1,601.7  Thửa số 5, tờ số 1 5 RMS 707.8 389.5  Thửa số 3, tờ số 1 3 RMS 1,950.1 586.3    Ghi chú: Các thửa số 3, 5, 6, 7 Nguyễn Thị Sương Mua Lại của Đinh Thị Trí 

18 Đinh Văn Trung            Thửa số 4, tờ số 1 4 RMS 1 973.7 461.7    Ghi chú: Đinh Văn Trung đã bán lại thửa số 4, tờ số 1 cho Đỗ Minh Đức 

3

19 Đinh Văn Gần            Thửa số 2, tờ số 1 2 RMS 1 853.0 2.2

XÃ SƠN MÙA         1 Đinh Văn Bình            Thửa số1, tờ số 1 1 RMS 1 916.0 125.42 Đinh KLá            Thửa số 2, tờ số 1 2 RMS 1 2,237.0 459.43 Đinh Ka Reo            Thửa số 3, tờ số 1 3 RMS 1 1,368.1 218.04 Nứa đk > 50 cm            Thửa số 4, tờ số 1 4 RMS 1 2,571.1 827.25 Đinh Văn Xia            Thửa số 5, tờ số 1 5 RMS 1 8,607.9 4,313.1    Ghi chú: Thửa số 5, tờ số 1 Đinh Văn Xia Đã bán đất , cây cối lại cho Bùi Bá Hùng 6 Đinh Văn Nớ            Thửa số 6, tờ số 1 6 RMS 1 6,050.6 2,872.4    Ghi chú: Thửa số 6, tờ số 1 Đinh Văn Nớ Đã bán đất , cây cối lại cho Huỳnh Thị Hà 7 Đinh Văn Việt            thửa số 5, tở số 2 5

RMS 21,081.6 425.6

  thửa số 7, tở số 2 7 3,635.8 1,635.6    Ghi chú: Thửa số 5, tờ số 2 Đinh Văn Đại đã bán đất, cây cối lại cho Đinh Văn Việt 8 Đinh Thị Yến            Thửa số 6, tờ số 2 6 RMS 2 1,262.6 536.49 Đinh Văn Rởi            thửa số 4, tở số 2 4 RMS 2 17,498.3 9,136.2    Ghi chú: Thửa số 4, tờ số 2 Đinh Văn Rởi dã bán đất, cây cối lại cho Huỳnh Thị Hà 

10 Đinh Văn Vêm                RMS 2   7,364.2    Ghi chú: Thửa của Đinh Văn Vem tách từ thửa số 3, tờ số 2 của ông Đinh Văn Sút 

4

11 Đinh Thị Yên                RMS 2   6,815.0    Ghi chú: Thửa của Đinh Thị Yên tách từ thửa số 3, tờ số 2 của ông Đinh Văn Sút

12 Đinh Văn Trường                RMS 2   3,639.6    Ghi chú: Thửa của Đinh Văn Trường tách từ thửa số 3, tờ số 2 của ông Đinh Văn Sút 

13 Đinh Văn Nâng            Thửa số 2, tờ số 2 2 RMS 2 18,728.1 1,633.6    Ghi chú: Thửa số 2, tờ số 2 Đinh Văn Nâng đã bán đất, cây cối lại cho Bùi Bá Đại 

14 Đinh Văn Nâng            thửa số 2, tờ số 2 2 RMS 2 18728 7,340.2    Ghi chú: Thửa số 2, tờ số 2 Đinh Văn Nâng đã bán đất, cây cối lại cho Bùi Bá Đại 

15 Đinh Văn Tân 1 RMS 2 9,555.1 142.8  thửa số 1, tờ sô 2          

XÃ SƠN TÂN, KHU ĐẦU MỐI        1 Đinh RaO 1 RSM 1 13045.1 1089.5  Làng Đak rổi 1 4 RSM   7505 1410.5    5 RSM   17692.3 4001.2    3 RSM     3744.5    Ghi chú: Thửa số 4 ông Đinh RaO cho con rể là Đinh văn Ri     Ghi chú: Thửa số 5 ông Đinh RaO cho con gái là Đinh Thị Huế 2 Đinh Văn Niết            Làng Đak rổi 1 2 RSM 1 55526.7 7044.43 Đinh Văn Bên            Thôn Đakbe 6 RSM 1 12884.3 4725.64 Đinh Văn Tra 7 RSM 1 32219.1 21221.5  Thôn Đakbe Ghi chú: Đinh Văn Tra đã chuyển nhượng toàn bộ cho ông Vương Hoàng Hiếu 5 Đinh Văn Bun            Thôn Đakbe 8 RSM 1 26970.4 10021

5

6 Đinh Văn Đua            Đăk Be 9 RSM 1 6767.6 6766.37 Đinh Văn Liếu            Kamang I 22 RSM 2 7108.3 619.38 Đinh Văn Lành            thôn Đăk be 11 RSM 2 735.2 31.29 Đinh Văn Trang            Kamang I 10 RSM 2 3264.5 98.6    12 RSM   10911 2773.3    37 RSM 3 9562.6 2850.6

10 Đinh Thị Inh            Đăk rổi II 14 LUC 2 207.5 25.4    15 LUC   227.2 225.5    16 LUC   126.5 126.5    17 LUC   141.9 141.9    18 RSM   5600.7 3317.2    20 RSM   3587.1 1502.2    21 RSM   19393.5 15233    29 RSM   8308.7 1939.6

   Ghi chú: Tổng diện tích đất RSM bồi thường 21992,m2, đã đền bù hạng mục đường thi công 6409,9m2, diện tích đền bù còn lại là 15582.1 m2 

11 Đinh Văn Minh            Đăk rô II 27 RSM 2 5561.1 1561.6    30 RSM 3 1532.4 213.5

12 Đinh Văn Hiệp            Kmang I 24 RSM 2 12906.2 7808.9    25 RSM   22350.9 603.4    26 RSM   43561.8 7048.3    28 RSM   3447.5 650    Ghi chú: Tổng 4 thửa trên là 16110,6m2 trong đó đã đền bù hạng mục đường thi công là 12808,4 m2, diện tích đền bù còn lại

6

là 3302,2 m2 13 Đinh Văn Xéc            Kmang I 13 LUN 2 2435.6 353.6

14 Đinh Văn Co            Kmang I 31 RSM 3 2993 848.1

15 Đinh Văn Đỉ            Kmang I 15 RSM 3 3690.8 299.1    53 RSM   5137 1176.8

16 Đinh Văn Quân            Đăk rổi II 16 RSM 3 3967.5 687    38 RSM   9744.8 3825.3

17 Đinh Thị Xuân            Kmang I 41 RSM 3 15441.9 5214.1

18 Đinh Văn Nang            Kmang I 39 RSM 3 34082.9 9581.1    Ghi chú: Đinh Văn Nang bán lại cho ông Nguyễn Đình Tân 

19 Đinh Văn Bôn            Đăk Be 40 RSM 3 2257.3 67.2

20 Đinh Văn Ôn              31 RSM 2 3019.7 2499.5

XÃ SƠN TÂN, KHU NHÀ MÁY        1 Đinh Văn Trinh            Làng Camang 1 103 LNK

5732.4 732.4

    7 LUC 329.2 329.2    Ghi chú : Bà Trần Thị Hồng Nhiên mua lại toàn bộ của ông Đinh Văn Trinh 2 Đinh Văn Trơn            Làng Camang 1 8 LNK

5785.0 785.0

  Đinh Văn Vít 9 LNK 6,117.9 4,090.5    Ghi chú :Thửa 9 (dt 4090.5 m2) ông Đinh Văn Vít bán lại cho bà Trần Thị Hồng Nhiên

7

3 Đinh Văn Tôn           Làng Vay Bua 1 20 LNK 5 3,757.3 3,757.3

4 Đinh Văn Hê           Làng Camang 1 21 LNK 5 5,309.2 3,545.0

5 Đinh Văn Đạo            Làng Camang 1 13 LUC

51,005.1 1,005.1

    3 LNK 8,336.2 1,194.7   Ghi chú :Cả 2 thửa trên ông Đinh Văn Đạo đã bán cho ông Nguyễn Đình Tân 

6 Đinh văn Kẻo            Làng Vay Bua 1 10 LUC

5

596.4 596.4    52 LUC 106.8 106.8    74 LUC 25.5 25.5    49 LUC 206.7 206.7    50 LUC 44.4 44.4    75 LUC 38.1 38.1    79 LUC 198.4 41.8    73 LUC 229.3 93.77 Đinh Văn Hiệp           Làng Camang 1 41 LUC

5

69.0 69.0    39 LUC 101.3 101.3    38 LUC 33.1 33.1    54 LUC 334.7 334.7    53 LUC 248.9 248.9    51 LUC 192.0 192.0    Ghi chú : Tất cả số đất trên ông Đinh Văn Hiệp đã bán cho ông Nguyễn Đình Tân8 Đinh Văn Nay            Làng Đakrô 1 44 LNK

51,280.2 1,280.2

    77 LNK 4,975.6 1,549.4    66 LUC 170.4 72.1

8

    65 LUC 200.3 116.7    Ghi chú : Tất cả số đất trên ông Đinh Văn Nay đã bán cho ông Lê Sinh Tùng 9 Đinh Văn Vem            Làng Vay Bua 1 18 LUC

1126.6 126.6

    55 LUC 462.1 462.110 Đinh Văn Trôn            Làng Camang 1 33 LUC

5

521.6 521.6    32 LUC 202.9 202.9    15 LUC 164.8 164.8    16 LUC 106.7 106.7    43 LUC 221.2 221.2   Ghi chú : Thửa đất 16 , 43 tổng dt 327,9 m2 ông Đinh Văn Trôn đã bán cho bà Trần Thị Hồng Nhiên

11 Đinh Văn Phương            Làng Vay Bua 1 57 LUC

5207.7 207.7

    56 LUC 307.0 255.912 Đinh Văn Ghen            Làng Vay Bua 1 29 LUC

5157.0 157.0

    34 LUC 96.0 96.0    Ghi chú : Toàn bộ đất trên ông Đinh Văn Ghen đã bán cho bà Đinh Thị Gùi 

13 Đinh Văn Tha            Làng Camang 1 47 LNK 5 2,453.3 2,453.3    Ghi chú : Toàn bộ đất trên ông Đinh Văn Tha đã bán cho bà Hoàng Thị Lan

14 Đinh Văn Vít            Làng Camang 2 23 LNK

51936.7 1937

    45 LNK 472.5 472.5    Ghi chú: cả 2 thửa trên Ông Đinh Văn Vít đã bán cho bà Trần Thị Nhung 

15 Đinh Văn Trếp            Làng Camang 1 76 LNK 5 3,991.4 1,377.9

16 Đinh Văn Kiều          

9

  Làng Camang 1 48 LNK 5 7,428.6 4,903.917 Đinh Văn Trăng            Làng Camang 1 62 LUC

5

129.1 3.9    4 LUC 1,008.7 1,008.7    61 LUC 155.9 19.6    22 LNK 7,264.3 3,967.5    83 LNQ 4,625.4 2,994.9    Ghi chú :Thửa số 83 đã đền bù 1577.8m2 vào hạng mục đường thi công 

18 Đinh Thị Nghiêu            Làng Camang 1 82 LNK 5 5,781.7 4,639.7   Ghi chú: thửa số 82 (diện tích đền bù 4639,7 m2) đã đền bù 1531,9 m2 vào hạng mục đường thi công 

19 Đinh Văn Điền           Làng Camang 2 30 LUC 5 220.3 220.3

20 Đinh KLút            Làng Camang 1 36 LUC

5138.1 138.1

    37 LUC 39.9 39.9    35 LUC 128.1 128.1    Ghi chú : Cả 3 thửa trên ông Đinh KLut đã bán cho bà Trần Thị Nhung 

21 Đinh Văn Năc            Làng Đăkrô 80 LUC

5392.0 110.4

    67 LUC 255.7 85.5    Ghi chú : Tất cả số đất trên ông Đinh Văn Nắc đã bán cho ông Lê Sinh Tùng 

22 Đin Văn Kim            Làng Y Ry 58 LUC

575.3 75.3

    63 LUC 154.4 92.7    Ghi chú : Tất cả số đất trên ông Đinh Văn Kim đã bán cho ông Lê Sinh Tùng 

23 Phạm Hoài Đào            Làng Camang 1 64 LUC 5 326.8 170.4    6 LNK 4 7,906.6 3,762.5

10

24 Đinh Văn Lăng            Làng Camang 1 19 LUC

5267.5 267.5

    26 LUC 218.5 218.5    24 LUC 116.7 116.7    Ghi chú : Thửa đất 19; 26; 24 (tổng 602,7m2) trên ông Đinh Văn Lăng đã bán cho bà Chức     25 LUC

5156.4 156.4

    40 LUC 15.9 15.9    Ghi chú : Thửa đất 25; 40 (tổng 172,3 m2) trên ông Đinh Văn Lăng đã bán cho bà Phượng   8 LNK 4 3,942.6 2,966.5

25 Đinh Văn Mai            Làng Camang 1 5 LNK 5 1,034.6 1,034.6

26 Trần Thị Hợi              31   5 689.5 429.5

27 Đinh Văn Trung            Làng Camang 1 46 LNK 5 3411.8 3411.8

28 Đinh K Rẻo            Làng vay bua I 72 LUC 5 177.1 88.3

29 Lê Thị Bích Loan              86 LNK 5 1483.7 0.5

30 Đinh Văn Hố            Làng Vay Bua1 69 LUC

5212.2 67.8

    68 LUC 321.8 125.231 Đinh Văn Đà            Làng Camang 1 6 LUC

5

331.2 331.2    12 LUC 235.8 235.8    17 LUC 220.7 220.7    11 LUC 385.4 385.4    14 LUC 163.8 163.8    27 LUC 234.0 234.0

11

    71 LUC 196.3 67.8    70 LUC 45.3 33.0    81 LUC 229.9 54.3

32 Đinh Văn Trăng            Làng Kmang I 25 LNK 4 8,237.8 1,721.1

33 Đinh Văn Đin            Làng Kmang I 12 LNK 4 11,734.9 5,194.9

34 Đinh Văn Trơn            Làng Kmang I 21 LNK 4 7,020.1 4,109.6

35 Đinh Văn Trếp            Làng Kmang I 22 LNK 4 3,367.6 2,886.8

36 Đinh Văn Đĩ            Làng Kmang I 18 LNK 4 6,710.8 4,255.6   Ghi chú: thửa số 18 (diện tích đền bù 4255,6 m2) đã đền bù 1311,2 m2 hạng mục đường thi công 

37 Đinh Thị Vẻo            Làng Kmang I 7 LNK 4 3,915.9 2,501.8

XÃ SƠN TÂN, KHU PHỤ TRỢ        1 Đinh Văn Thư              1 LNK 5 8,024.0 3,027.22 Đinh Văn Đạo            Camang 1 2 LNK 5 10,874.6 4,865.93 Đinh Thị Nghiêu            Camang 1 82

LNK5 5,781.7 870.4

    24 4 1,330.8 734.14 Đinh Văn Trăng              83 LNQ 5 4,625.4 1,630.4    23 LNK 4 477.6 135.55 Đinh Văn Đạo            Camang 1 3 LNK 5 8,336.2 4,444.3

12

    Ghi chú: ông Nguyễn Đình Tân mua lại của ông Đinh Văn Đạo 6 Đinh Văn Mai              84 LNK 5 3,915.3 1,706.67 Đinh Văn Tôn              85 LNK 5 5,759.0 2,362.8    Ghi chú: Thử 85 đã đền bù 1012,4 m2 vào hạng mục đường thi công 8 Lê Thị Bích Loan              86 LNK 5 1,483.7 831.99 Đinh Văn Krôm              88 LUC 5 24,9 21.8

10 Đinh Văn Lít              89 LNK 5 3,551.6 109.6

11 Đinh Văn Vít              91 LNK 5 1,472.6 303.6

12 Đinh Văn Đôn              1 LNK 4 5,237.1 54.5

13 Đinh Thị Tốt              2 LNK 4 7,755.1 6,179.9    9 LNK 4 4,172.1 121.7

14 Đinh Văn Đin              5 LUN 4 295.8 113.8    12 LNK 4 11,734.9 1,730.7

15 Phạm Hoào Đào              6 LNK 4 7,906.6 2,152.9

16 Đinh Văn Đăm              13 LNK 4 3,762.7 1.8

17 Đinh Văn Trơn              21 LNK 4 7,020.1 1,042.9

18 Đinh Văn Trếp          

13

    22 LNK 4 3,367.6 480.619 Đinh Thị Tríp              3 LNK 4 5,973.8 2,439.3

20 Đinh Thị Đền              2 RSM 3 24,662.9 4,637.5    10

LUC

3 82.0 59.6    11 3 73.8 72.7    12 3 54.3 54.3    13 3 86.7 86.7    14 3 79.1 79.1    18 3 77.6 77.6

21 Đinh Văn Qua              19

LUC

3 77.2 77.2    21 3 95.7 95.7    22 3 57.2 57.2    23 3 49.4 49.4    24 3 84.6 84.6    25 3 87.5 87.5    32 3 41.3 41.3    33 3 30.5 30.5    34 3 43.6 43.6    35 3 44.5 44.5    36 3 80.2 80.2

22 Đinh Thị Xuân              41 RSM 3 15,441.9 239.9    Ghi chú: bà Đinh Thị Xuân bán lại cho Ông Đinh Văn Trinh 

23 Đinh Văn Trinh              20 RSM 3 1,630.4 849.0    26 RSM 3 587.3 587.3

14

24 Đinh Văn Minh              55 RSM 3 1,450.5 1,450.5    54 RSM 3 1,796.9 1,796.9    49 RSM 3 2,386.7 760.7    27 RSM 2 5,561.1 1,925.8

25 Đinh Văn Quân              38 RSM 3 9,744.8 1,025.5    50 RSM 3 7,192.8 304.0

26 Đinh Văn Đĩ              42 RSM 3 11,814.9 1,019.0

27 Đinh Văn Nang              39 RSM 3 34,082.9 3,042.8    Ghi chú : Nguyễn Đình Tân đã mua lại thửa số 39 của Đinh văn Nang 

28 Đinh Thị Yếu              45 RSM 3 12,275.1 6,225.7    46   3 4,549.8 4,523.8    Ghi chú : Nguyễn Đình Tân đã mua lại thửa số 45, 46 của Đinh Thị Yếu 

29 Đinh Văn Quyền              48 RSM 3 6,939.3 2,257.3

30 Đinh Văn Thanh              47 RSM 3 4,588.3 2,184.0

31 Đinh Văn Liếu              7

RSM2 28,211.4 309.2

    8 2 2,675.3 543.732 Đinh Văn Xéc              6

RSM2 4,222.9 617.6

    13 2 2,435.6 2,082.033 Đinh Văn Lành              11 RSM 2 735.2 704.1

15

    9 2 2,379.8 2,215.934 Đinh Văn Trang              10

RSM2 3,264.5 3,166.0

    12 2 10,911.0 5,581.135 Đinh Thị Inh              14

LUC2 207.5 182.1

    15 2 227.2 1.7    18

RSM

2 5,600.7 1,320.4    19 2 5,494.2 2.2    29 2 8,307.7 4,754.2    21 2 19,393.5 2,600.9

36 Đinh Văn Hiệp              24

RSM

2 12,906.2 2,986.5    25 2 22,350.9 11,397.1    26 2 43,561.8 3,557.5    28 2 3,447.5 290.7

   Ghi chú : Tổng diên tích bồi thường các thửa trên là 18231,8 m2 Trong đó đã đền 5000 m2 bãi thải cho đường TCVH2, diện tích bồi thường còn lại là 13231,8 m2 

37 Đinh Văn Thương              30 RSM 2 1,895.3 386.3

38 Đinh Văn Nét              2 RSM 1 55,526.7 1,480.3

XÃ SƠN TÂN, ĐƯỜNG DÂY 22KV & TBA KHU NHÀ MÁY      1 Đinh Bà Rủ            Trụ số 1 1 LNK 1 471.4 3.2  Trụ số 2 1 LNK 1 4,209.3 7.82 Đinh Thị Lin            Trụ số 3 1 LNK 1 2,043.5 7.83 Đinh Văn Liêm           Trụ số 4 1 LNK 1 5,282.8 3.2

16

4 Đinh Văn Tôn            Trụ số 5 1 LNK 1 6,567.0 3.25 Vương Hoàng Hiếu           Trụ số 6 1 LNK 1 640.5 2.5

6 Đinh Văn Vít            Trụ số 7 1 LNK 1 1,472.6 3.97 Đinh Văn Lít            Trụ số 8 1 LNK 1 3,563.7 2.58 Đinh Ra Hê           Trụ số 9 1 LNK 1 1,729.5 2.5

9 Đinh Văn Bun            Trụ số 10 + TBA 1 LNK 1 7,428.6 9.5

XÃ SƠN TÂN, ĐƯỜNG DÂY 22KV & TBA KHU ĐẦU MỐI      1 Đinh Văn Đấy            Trụ số 1 1 RSM 1 609.9 2.52 Đinh Văn Bâng            Trụ số 2 1 RSM 1 252.8 3.93 Đinh Văn Đầm           Trụ số 3 và 12 1 RSM 1 3,161.2 3.9

4 Đinh Văn Về            Trụ số 4 1 RSM 1 2,045.3 3.9  Trụ số 7 1 RSM 1 605.9 7.85 Đinh Văn Đà           Trụ số 5 1 RSM 1 1,367.0 3.9

6 Đinh Văn Viên            Trụ số 6 1 RSM 1 1,667.7 3.97 Đinh Văn Vị            Trụ số 8 1 RSM 1 2,830.7 7.88 Đinh Văn Đi          

17

Trụ số 9 1 RSM 1 1,859.8 2.5  Trụ số 10 1 RSM 1 2,432.3 3.9  Trụ số 11 1 RSM 1 1,223.2 3.99 Đinh Văn Bun            Trụ số 13 1 RSM 1 8,074.0 12.3

18

ANNEX 2 PROJECT INFORMATION BOOKLET (PIB)

MINISTRY OF INDUSTRY AND

TRADE

SOVICO – QUANG NGAI ENERGY

COMPANY LIMITED

SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF VIETNAM

Independence – Freedom - Happiness

PROJECT INFORMATION BOOKLET

SON TAY HYDROPOWER PROJECT

Quang Ngai province

Introduction to Son Tay Hydropower Project

Son Tay Hydropowerplant is located in Son Mua, Son Tan and Son Dung Communes, Quang Ngai Province. It is far 3km away from Son Tay center, far 60 km away from Quang Ngai city in the West, next to roads and there are natural conditions which facilitate the construction. The main objective of Son Tay Hydropower Plant is to supply electricity to the local and connect to national grid electricity, give contribution to increase industrial output of the province, create jobs for people, businesses and the area. With the capacity of 18MW, anually, Son Tay Hydropower Plant will supply national grid electricity with around 72,85.106kWh. Besides, the hydropower plant plays an important role in local economic development and landscape.

Position of Son Tay Hydropower Plant was studied and approved in Additional Planning of Hydropower System on Dakdrinh River, Quang Ngai Province, this is a plant at the middle of two hydropower plants Dakdrinh 1 (now is Dakdrinh Hydropower Plant) and Dakdrinh 2 (had been planned, not built yet) in order to utilize the remaining unexploited catchment of Dakdrinh hydropower plant (the works of Son Tay hydropower plant are all in energy route of Dakdrinh hydropower plant).

Son Tay hydropower plant is supplied water from two reservoirs: (i) the first reservoir is catchment of major dam (the main water supply regulated by day and night) and (ii) the second reservoir is catchment of sub-dam (no capacity regulated by day and night). The total catchment area to dam system of Son Tay Hydro Power Plant is 186,0km2, in which the second reservoir cluster has catchment area of 8,0km2 and catchment area of the first reservoir cluster is 178,0km2.

The whole proposed project includes two main components: the cluster headwork (dam, spillaway dam, water intake, sand discharger, sub-dam, water transfer channel) and energy route (collecting water channel,water intake, connecting concrete pipe, tunnel, surge tank, penstock, plant, discharge channel. Pressure boosting station and operational management buildings).

The operational buildings of Son Tay hydropower plant is only considered at a sufficient size to serve operational personnel, with some items allocated as follows: (i) 2-storey center management building. The structure is tempered wall with 220mm brick and concrete floor. The center building is near the plant and transformer station, this can ensure operational management is facilitated; (ii) houses for staffs are in the area with enough space for the daily needs of about 15 people (iii) the scale of operational management building for pressure is

19

large enough for 1-2 staffs working 24/24 hours a day; (iv) the scale of operational management building of cluster headwork is enough for 1-2 staffs working 24/24 hours a day.

The Son Tay Hydropower Project has been contructed for 2.5 years (from 2014 to 2016), in which pre-construction phase will be prepared for the last 6 months of 2014, and planned to begin construction in January 2015 and completed in December 2016.

Sovico Quang Ngai Energy Company will be main responsible for constructing and managing to operate the Project. The implementation budget for this construction will be financed by World Bank (WB)..

20

Table 1 - Implementing Progress of RP

Activities Progress

Information dissemination and community consultation July 2014 - August /2014

Preparing the Resettlement Plan (RP) August /2014 - September/2014

Submitting the Resettlement Plan (RP) October - 2014

Approving the Resettlement Plan (RP) December - 2014

Information dissemination affer RP to be approved January 2015

Making compensation and allowance payment January – March 2015

Monitoring and Evaluation January 2015 - June 2016

Implementation of construction January 2015 – December 2016

Scope of land and asset acquisition for the project.

During the process of inventory of loss (IOL) in July and August 2014, 394,187 m2 acquired land of 131 HHs in 3 communes Son Dung, Son Tan and Son Mua is affected, 7898.9 m2 land managed by Son Tan commune is affected .

What will happen to AHs with the damaged assets and livelihood income? People affected by the project will be compensated in cash at replacement cost for land and assets on land (such as houses, trees, crops...) and other assistances, including assistance for livelihood restoration depending on the severity of impacts.

What are entitlements of project affected households? After considering the factors affect on the market value, replacement cost calculated for the compensation of land and property on the ground, PPC of Quang Ngai province issued the Decision No 08/2013/QD-UBND on 28th January 2014 on issuing the regulations on compensation, support and resettlement when the State acquires land in Quang Ngai province; Decision No 25/2014/QD-UBND on 6th June 2014 of Quang Ngai PCP enacted regulations on the compensation rate for house and structures applied in Quang Ngai province;Decision No 64/2011/QD-UBND on 17th December 2014 of Quang Ngai PCP on issuing unit price of affected trees and crops on land due to clearance compensation in Quang Ngai province.

Table 3 – Summary of entitlements of the project

No. Type of impacts Policy 1 Loss of

Income/Livelihood due to loss of productive land

Assistance for life stabilization and job creation Support equivalent 5 times of agricultural land price of

recovered agricultural land – not depend on the percentage of land acquisition (Supported area does not exceed the land allocation quota of local)

Also, additional assistance for AHs as follows: 21

No. Type of impacts Policy

losing from 30% to 70% of total area of agricultural land: 30 kg of rice per person per month for 6 months if not relocating and 30 kg of rice per person per month for 24 months if relocating;

Losing more than 70% of total area of agricultural land: 30 kg of rice per person per month for 12 months if not relocating and 30 kg of rice per person per month for 236 months if relocating.

In the case of compensation “land for land”. With AHs compensated in land, assistance for production

will be 5,000,000 VND/peson under working age; for household with members, each person will be assisted plus 2,000,000 VND from the second member.

2Loss of house and have to relocate

Assistance for transporting materials Moving within a province, not more than 20km: support with

3,000,000 VND/HH Moving within a province, distance more than 20km: support

with 5,000,000 VND/HH Moving to the other provinces: if northern provinces, support

with 8,000,000 VND/HH; if central and southern provinces, support with 10,000,000 VND/HH.

Assistance for renting house Cash assistance as follows: (i) HHs with less than 5

members: 800,000 VND/month; (ii) HHs with more than 5 members: 1,000,000 VND/month; and HHs with single person: 600,000 VND/month.

Time of assistance: from handing over their acquired land to the Client until receiving land for resettlement.

Assistance for tenants Transportation allowance with 2,000,000 VND/HH and cash assistance for life stabilization equivalent 30kg rice/person/month during 3 months.

3Loss of income source due to business interruption

Economic organizations, households with registered business have been interrupted, assistance with 30% of income after tax according to average income in previous 03 years will be provided.

4 Assistance for vulnerable groups

Local policies for families entitled to social assistance when the State recovers land and they have to relocate:

Those who participated in Revolution for Independence before 1945, Military Hero, Vietnamese Hero Mothers, Labor Hero, relatives of military martyr who are receiving monthly social allowance, wounded or disabled soldier, and those ones who receive social assistance similar to war

22

No. Type of impacts Policy disable persons losing more than 81% human working capacity will be supported 5,000,000 VND/house user;

Wounded soldiers, sick soldiers, and those entitled to policies as for wounded and sick soldiers with labor capability loss of from 61% to 80% will be supported 4,000,000 VND/house user;

Wounded soldiers, sick soldiers, and those entitled to policies as for wounded and sick soldiers with labor capability loss of from 41% to 60% will be supported 3,000,000 VND/house user;

Wounded soldiers, sick soldiers, and those entitled to policies as for wounded and sick soldiers with labor capability loss of from 21% to 40% will be supported 2,000,000 VND/house user

Those who award a Resistance Medal - first class; Medal of Victory - First class will be supported 1,000,000 VND/house user;

Households entitled to the State’s social allowance policies will be supported 2.000.000 VND/HH.

Assistance policy of the project: (i) Assistance for changing job (work at the factory) and

(ii) income restoration in the form of training on farming techniques.

Complaints and grievance redress mechanism.

The complaint related to any issue of the Son Tay Hydropower will be resolved through negotiation to reach consensus, all complaints should be passed 3 steps before elevating to the court: (i) Stage 1: Complaints from APs for the first time shall be lodged verbally or in written form with the resettlement officials of CPC. The resettlement officials of CPC and Task force on resettlement will try to resolve the issue within 15 days from the date the complaint is received. (ii) Stage 2: If no understanding or amicable solution can be reached or if no response is received from the grievance committee within 15 days from filing the complaint, the APs can elevate the case to the DPC or District Compensation Committee. It is expected to respond within 15 days upon receiving the APs appeal. APs should bring his/her complaints within 30 days from the date of initial registration and give the documents to prove their claims. (iii) Stage 3: If the AP is not satisfied with the decision of the DPC, or in the absence of any response, the APs can appeal to the PPC. With the assistance of the Compensation and Resettlement Committee, the Provincial Compensation Committee and Department of Natural Resources and Environment, Department of Finance, the PPC will issue a decision on the appeal within 30 days from the day the complaint is received. (iv) Stage 4: If the AP is still not satisfied with the decision of the PPC or in the absence of any response within the stipulated time, the APs, as a last resort may submit his/her case to the provincial court.

Where can AHs find more information related to resettlement?

23

Summary of Resettlement plan, the detailed entitlements of the project, compensation unit posted on mass media of CPC, DPC and Sovico Quang Ngai Enegy Company.

Where can AHs find more information related to resettlement?Mr/Ms. …………………Position…………………Tel………… (Representatives of Son Tay DCARB).Mr/Ms. ………………...Position………………….Tel……….. (Representatives of Son Tay DCARB)Mr/Ms. ………….…Position… ……….Tel…………. (Representatives of Sovico Quang Ngai Enegy Company).

24

ANNEX 3 TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR INDEPENDENT RESETTLEMENT MONITORING CONSULTANT

I. Introduction1. The general objective of the Renewable Energy Development Project (REDP) is to increase the supply of least-cost electricity to the national grid from renewable energy sources on a commercially sustainable basis in an environmentally and socially sustainable manner. Son Tay Hydropower Plant is built on Darkdrinh river,level-1 tributary of Tra Khuc river, flows from the Southwest to Northeast, the bedriver slope is high, the terrain is totally mountainous, the vegetation cover is mainly primary forest and regenerating forest. Son Tay Hydropower Plant will generate to supply national grid electricity with installed capacity of 18MW.2. Son Tay hydropower plant is supplied water from two reservoirs: (i) the first reservoir is catchment of major dam (the main water supply regulated by day and night) and (ii) the second reservoir is catchment of sub-dam (no capacity regulated by day and night). The total catchment area to dam system of Son Tay Hydro Power Plant is 186,0km2, in which the second reservoir cluster has catchment area of 8,0km2 and catchment area of the first reservoir cluster is 178,0km2.3. The whole proposed project includes two main components: the cluster headwork (dam, spillaway dam, water intake, sand discharger, sub-dam, water transfer channel) and energy route (collecting water channel,water intake, connecting concrete pipe, tunnel, surge tank, penstock, plant, discharge channel. Pressure boosting station and operational management buildings).4. The operational buildings of Son Tay hydropower plant is only considered at a sufficient size to serve operational personnel, with some items allocated as follows: (i) 2-storey center management building. The structure is tempered wall with 220mm brick and concrete floor. The center building is near the plant and transformer station, this can ensure operational management is facilitated; (ii) houses for staffs are in the area with enough space for the daily needs of about 15 people (iii) the scale of operational management building for pressure is large enough for 1-2 staffs working 24/24 hours a day; (iv) the scale of operational management building of cluster headwork is enough for 1-2 staffs working 24/24 hours a day.5. The Resettlement Plan and the Ethnic Minorities Development Plan have been prepared as requirements of WB to aim: (i) Involuntary resettlement must be avoided where possible, or be reduced to the lowest possible extent by selecting appropriate design options. Where involuntary resettlement is unavoidable, the resettlement activities must be prepared and executed with sustainable development programs and sufficiently provided investment supports, enabling displaced people to benefit from the subproject. The displaced people will be fully consulted and allowed to participate in preparing and implementing activities of Resettlement Plan; (ii) ensure that negative and positive impacts have been considered, and relevant measures have also been proposed to eliminate risks or highly mitigate the impacts of the project on the lives and culture of the ethnic minority at affected areas.

II. Objectives

1. General objectives of External Monitoring Agency (EMA) are to provide the third party with information and periodic assessment reports with:

(i) Resettlement activities include: 25

- Achievement of resettlement objectives;

- Changes in living standards and livelihoods;

- Restoration of the economic and social base of the affected people;

- The effectiveness, impact and sustainability of entitlements and income restoration programs; the needs for further improvement and mitigation measures; and

- Strategic lessons for future policy formulation and planning will also be drawn from the monitoring and evaluation of resettlement

(ii) Issues related to ethnic minorities development such as:

- Implementing the proposed measures to minimize the negative impact;

- The other negative impacts on EM that have not been evaluated or have not yet identified mitigation measures.

- Implementing assistances for developing the local EM community;

- Information has been provided fully or not, the consultation process with ethnic minority people has been implemented or not and if even, was it effective?

- The process of grievance redresses of ethnic minority people for EMDP and other issues that they have to face.

III. Approach methods

2. The methods for external monitoring and evaluation of land acquisition, compensation and resettlement and EM development activities include:

- Review of Detailed Measurement Survey (DMS): As soon as the detailed design is finalized and staked to the ground by Sovico Quang Ngai Enegy Company and CARB, data collection from all APs to establish their eligibility and entitlements will be carried out. The data that will be entered into a database to document the following: a) socio-economic status of affected households; b) nature and extent of losses; and c) entitlements to compensation and other assistance. These data will be made available to the EMA, to enable them to establish a baseline for monitoring and evaluating project benefits. During the conduct of the DMS, the EMA will also monitor the DMS process to determine and assess if DMS activities are being carried out in a participatory and transparent manner.

- Socio-Economic Survey (SES): The SES is designed to provide a clear comparison of the success and/or failure of the resettlement program to restore their livelihoods and living standards. In general, if a lag of 3-5 years or more occurs between census and SES and actual land acquisition, demographic and socio-economic factors may change significantly. In this Project, if land acquisition is not carried out within two years after SES, Sovico Quang Ngai Enegy Company and CARBs will carry out another SES. A post resettlement survey will also be undertaken by the EMA 6-12 months following completion of resettlement activities. Special attention will be paid to the inclusion of women, ethnic groups, the very poor, the landless and other vulnerable groups, with set questions for women and other target groups; and, the database disaggregates information by gender, vulnerability and ethnicity.

26

- Participatory rapid appraisals (PRA): The PRA will involve obtaining information, identifying problems and finding solutions through participatory means including: a) key informant interviews; b) focus group discussions on specific topics such as compensation payment, income restoration and relocation; c) community public meetings to discuss community losses, integration of resettled households in host communities or construction work employment; d) structured direct field observations, for example, of resettlement site development; e) formal and informal interviews with affected households, women, ethnic minority, and other vulnerable groups; and, f) in-depth case studies of problems are identified by internal or external monitoring and required special efforts to resolve.

- Verification of Replacement cost survey: The EMA will also verify whether compensation paid were at replacement cost. A special market study to validate whether the rates used in compensation in land and other non-land assets were at replacement cost will be undertaken.

IV. Requirements for External Monitoring Agency (EMA)

3. EMA will be an experienced resettlement and social or ethnic minority development consultant. EMA has been established from experienced specialists on resettlement, social and ethnic minority development monitoring for projects funded by ADB, WB, and JICA. They have a University or Master degree (in social sciences or related fields), at least 5 years’ experience in in the preparation and implementation of RP, EMDP and fluency in spoken and written English.

V. Reporting

4. External monitoring, inspection and evaluation reports will be made on yearly basis, except for the first stage, it is requested to be made twice/year. All external monitoring reports will be made available to the affected households by placing reports in the commune/ward and field offices and will be uploaded on WB website. Table 1 and Table 2 describes monitoring and evaluation indicators during RP and EMDP implementing phase.

Table 1 Monitoring and Evaluation Indicators on implementing RP

Type Indicator Examples of VariablesProcess Indicators(By district and commune)

Staffing Number of Sovico Quang Ngai Enegy Company and field staff on Project, by job function; and

Number of other line agency officials available for tasks

Consultation, Participation and Grievance Resolution

Number of consultation and participation programs held with various stakeholders;Separate consultation with women (Kinh), female headed households and ethnic minority women;Grievances by type and resolution;Number of field visits by EPMU staff; and

Number of local organizations participating in project

27

Type Indicator Examples of VariablesProcedures in Operation

Review of DMS including verification/quantification procedures in place and effectiveness of compensation delivery system;Number of land transfers effected; and

Coordination among Sovico Quang Ngai Enegy Company, relevant provincial departments, and provincial and district officials,

Output Indicators(By district and commune)

Acquisition of Land Area of productive land assets acquired (crop land, aquaculture ponds, garden land, etc.);Area of residential and other non-agricultural lands acquired; Area of communal/government lands acquired; and

Area of other lands acquired.Structures Number, type and size of private structures acquired;

Number, type and size of community structures acquired; and

Number, type and size of government structures acquired.

Trees and Crops Number and type of private crops and trees acquired; Number and type of government/community crops and trees acquired; and

Crops destroyed by area, type and number of owners.Compensation and resettlement

Number of households affected (for land, buildings, trees, crops);Number of owners compensated by type of loss;Amount compensated by type and owner;Number and amount of allowances paid;Number of replacement houses constructed by concerned owners;Number of replacement businesses constructed by concerned owners;Number of owners requesting assistance to purchase replacement land, and number of purchases effected;Number of individual sites and levels of development of sites;Number of entitlements delivered;Number of entitlements used by APs;

Suitability of entitlements to affected households as per RP objectives;Number of non-titled AHHs receiving replacement

28

Type Indicator Examples of Variablesland; andNumber of severely affected, very poor or other vulnerable households receiving special assistance and participating in income restoration programs.

Impact Indicators(by district and commune)

Household Earning Capacity

Employment status of economically active members;Landholding size, area cultivated and production volume, by crop;Selling of cultivation land;Changes to livestock ownership – pre- and post disturbance;Changes to income-earning activities (farm and off-farm) – pre- and post disturbance; and

Amount and balances of income and expenditures.Changes to Status of Women

Commune/Village Resettlement Committees include Women’s Union and Women from affected households; Involvement of women in the process of preparation of IOL;

Number of grievance complaint filed by women and resolutionNumber of women (including female headed households and ethnic minority women) negotiated compensation effectively;Joint registration of land in the name of husband and wife;

Number of meetings held by women from affected households in planning of livelihood activities;Number of women engaged in gainful livelihood activities/income earning activities/employment in Industrial zones (including female headed households and ethnic minority women);Number of women participated in capacity building workshop/ training; Number of women understand the process of resettlement activities ( entitlement, compensation process, etc);Number of women participated in discussion of resettlement site selection;Participation in commercial enterprises; and

Participation in community decision-makingChanges to Status of School attendance rates (male/female); and

29

Type Indicator Examples of VariablesChildren

Participation in project construction.Settlement, Community and Population

Growth in number and size of settlements;Growth in market areas;Influx of new settlers, including those with and without land rights;Changes in economic activities and income-generation opportunities; and

Changes in social, cultural and community conditions.

Table 2 Monitoring and Evaluation Indicators on implementing EMDP

Monitoring and Evaluation Issues

Basic indicators

1. The progress of EMDP implementation

- The plan has been shared with the community.- The plan is in line with the implementation conditions of ethnic minority people and is joined with them.- The plan is relevant to the progress of other activities.- Adequate human resources available to implement the plan.- Sufficient funding for implementing the plan.

2. Implementing community consultations and local people’s participation

- Local EM community, commune authorities and village leaderships and mass organizations are provided sufficient information on EMDP, implementation plan and grievance mechanisms.

- Local EM community, commune authorities and village leaderships and mass organizations are involved in relevant activities, especially monitoring the implementation of EMDP.

3. Implementation of measures to mitigate negate impacts from the facility.

- All measures for mitigating negative impacts from the facility are effectively implemented.

- There are no additional negative impacts arising from the facility, and if otherwise, there must be a community consultation on mitigation measures and implementation of the same.

- Various sectors and branches effectively collaborate in implementing measures to mitigate negative impacts from the facility.

4. Implementation of specific - All activities that support the EM development as set out 30

Monitoring and Evaluation Issues

Basic indicators

developmental interventions for local ethnic minority people

in the EMDP are implemented effectively.

- Various sectors and branches effectively collaborate in implementing interventions for community development.

5. Grievance Mechanisms - Ethnic minority community has a clear understanding of the grievance mechanism.

- District Resettlement Compensation Committee, commune-level social organizations and commune people’s committee have a clear understanding of grievance mechanism and are able to assist EM people to implement such mechanisms.

31

ANNEX 4 CONSULTATION MEETING MINUTES

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40

41

42

43

44

45

46

ANNEX 5 SOME PHOTOS OF CONSULTATION MEETINGS

47

48