General DocketCourt of Appeals, 2nd Circuit
Court of Appeals Docket #: 12-4671 Docketed: 11/28/2012Nature of Suit: 3410 STATUTES-AntitrustIn re Payment Card InterchangeAppeal From: EDNY (BROOKLYN)Fee Status: Paid
Case Type Information: 1) Civil 2) Private 3) -
Originating Court Information:District: 0207-1 : 05-md-1720Trial Judge: John Gleeson, U.S. District JudgeTrial Judge: James Orenstein, U.S. Magistrate Judge
Date Filed: 10/20/2005 Date Order/Judgment: Date NOA Filed: Date Rec'd COA: 11/27/2012 11/27/2012 11/28/2012
Prior Cases: 08-4553 Date Filed: 09/16/2008 Date Disposed: 01/08/2009 Disposition: Fee default
Current Cases:Lead Member Start End
Consolidated12-4671 12-4708 11/28/2012 12-4671 12-4765 12/05/2012 12-4671 13-4719 12/13/2013 12-4671 13-4750 12/13/2013 12-4671 13-4751 12/13/2013 12-4671 13-4752 12/19/2013 12-4671 14-32 01/06/2014 12-4671 14-117 01/09/2014 12-4671 14-119 01/10/2014 12-4671 14-133 01/17/2014 12-4671 14-157 01/17/2014 12-4671 14-159 01/17/2014 12-4671 14-192 01/17/2014 12-4671 14-197 01/17/2014 12-4671 14-219 01/17/2014 12-4671 14-241 01/22/2014 12-4671 14-250 01/22/2014 12-4671 14-266 01/22/2014 12-4671 14-303 01/22/2014 12-4671 14-331 01/22/2014 12-4671 14-349 05/27/2014 12-4671 14-404 05/27/2014 12-4671 14-422 01/30/2014 12-4671 14-443 05/27/2014 12-4671 14-480 02/10/2014 12-4671 14-497 02/14/2014 12-4671 14-530 01/28/2014 12-4671 14-567 02/10/2014 12-4671 14-584 02/14/2014 12-4671 14-606 02/14/2014 12-4671 14-663 05/27/2014 12-4671 14-837 01/22/2014
Panel Assignment: Not available
Coborn's Incorporated Plaintiff - Appellant
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained]Goldstein & Russell, P.C.Suite 8507475 Wisconsin AvenueBethesda, MD 20814
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776
12-4671 Docket https://ecf.ca2.uscourts.gov/n/beam/servlet/TransportRoom
1 of 164 10/14/2015 12:49 PM
[COR NTC Retained]Constantine Cannon LLP9th Floor335 Madison AvenueNew York, NY 10017
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained]Goldstein & Russell, P.C.Suite 4047475 Wisconsin AvenueBethesda, MD 20814
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained]Constantine Cannon LLP335 Madison AvenueNew York, NY 10017
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR NTC Retained]Constantine Cannon LLP9th Floor335 Madison AvenueNew York, NY 10017
D'Agostino Supermarkets, Inc. Plaintiff - Appellant
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR NTC Retained](see above)
National Restaurant Association Plaintiff - Appellant
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained](see above)
12-4671 Docket https://ecf.ca2.uscourts.gov/n/beam/servlet/TransportRoom
2 of 164 10/14/2015 12:49 PM
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Affiliated Foods Midwest Plaintiff - Appellant
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Jetro Holdings, Inc. Plaintiff - Appellant
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR LD NTC Retained](see above)
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Jetro Cash & Carry Enterprises, LLC Plaintiff - Appellant
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR LD NTC Retained](see above)
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
National Community Pharmacists Association Plaintiff - Appellant
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR LD NTC Retained](see above)
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
12-4671 Docket https://ecf.ca2.uscourts.gov/n/beam/servlet/TransportRoom
3 of 164 10/14/2015 12:49 PM
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained](see above)
National Cooperative Grocers Association Plaintiff - Appellant
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR LD NTC Retained](see above)
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained](see above)
National Association of Convenience Stores Plaintiff - Appellant
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR LD NTC Retained](see above)
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained](see above)
National Association of Truck Stop Operators Plaintiff - Appellant
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR LD NTC Retained](see above)
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained]
12-4671 Docket https://ecf.ca2.uscourts.gov/n/beam/servlet/TransportRoom
4 of 164 10/14/2015 12:49 PM
(see above)
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained](see above)
National Grocers Association Plaintiff - Appellant
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR LD NTC Retained](see above)
Eric F. Citron, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Adam Owen Glist, AttorneyDirect: 212-350-2776[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas C. Goldstein, Esq., -Direct: 202-362-0636[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Gary Malone, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2744[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Robersons Fine Jewelry, Inc. Petitioner - Appellee
Jerrold S. Parker, Esq., -Direct: 516-466-6500[COR LD NTC Retained]Parker & Waichman, LLC1st Floor111 Great Neck RoadGreat Neck, NY 11021
Plaintiffs in civil action Jetro Holding, Inc. et al v. Visa U.S.A., Inc. etal 05-cv-4520 JG-JO Plaintiff - Appellee
K. Craig Wildfang, Esq., General AttorneyDirect: 612-349-8500[COR LD NTC Retained]Robbins, Kaplan, Miller & Ciresi, LLP2800 LaSalle Plaza800 LaSalle AvenueMinneapolis, MN 55402
William Jay Blechman, Esq., -Direct: 305-373-1000[COR NTC Retained]Kenny Nachwalter, P.A.Suite 1100201 South Biscayne BoulevardMiami, FL 33131
Thomas M. Campbell, Esq., -Direct: 212-344-1500[COR NTC Retained]Smith Campbell LLP19th Floor110 Wall StreetNew York, NY 10005
12-4671 Docket https://ecf.ca2.uscourts.gov/n/beam/servlet/TransportRoom
5 of 164 10/14/2015 12:49 PM
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Plaintiffs in civil action National Association of Convenience Storeset al v. Visa U.S.A., Inc. et al 05-cv-4521 JG-JO Plaintiff - Appellee
K. Craig Wildfang, Esq., General AttorneyDirect: 612-349-8500[COR LD NTC Retained](see above)
William Jay Blechman, Esq., -Direct: 305-373-1000[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Thomas M. Campbell, Esq., -Direct: 212-344-1500[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Bart D. Cohen, Esq., -Direct: 215-875-4602[COR NTC Retained]Berger & Montague, P.C.1622 Locust StreetPhiladelphia, PA 19103
Jeffrey Isaac Shinder, Esq., -Direct: 212-350-2709[COR NTC Retained](see above)
Plaintiffs in civil action Supervalu Inc. v. Visa U.S.A. Inc. et al05-cv-4650 JG-JO Plaintiff - Appellee
Thomas M. Campbell, Esq., -Direct: 212-344-1500[COR LD NTC Retained](see above)
William Jay Blechman, Esq., -Direct: 305-373-1000[COR NTC Retained](see above)
David P. Germaine, Esq., -Direct: 312-224-1505[COR NTC Retained]Vanek Vickers & Masini, P.C.Suite 350055 West Monroe StreetChicago, IL 60603
Robert C. Mason, Esq., -Direct: 212-715-1088[COR NTC Retained]Arnold & Porter LLP399 Park AvenueNew York, NY 10022
Paul E. Slater, Esq., -Direct: 312-641-3200[COR NTC Retained]Sperling & Slater, P.C.Suite 320055 W