Download - Green atm final
1
Green ATM
Welcoming remarks
Alain Siebert, Chief Environment & Economist
Amsterdam – 9 March 2011
Agenda
9:30 Welcoming remarksAlain Siebert, Chief Economist & Environment, SESAR Joint Undertaking
9:35 SESAR’s environmental approach9:35 SESAR’s environmental approachCélia Alves Rodrigues, Environment Officer, SESAR Joint Undertaking
9:45 Strategic fitPierre Caussade, Senior Vice President Environment & SustainableDevelopment, Air France
10:00 Quick wins: Examples from the fieldOceanic/En-Route: Rudy Kellar, Vice President Operations, NAV Canada y , p ,Terminal: Evert Westerveld, AIRE Project Manager, LVNL Surface: Robin Onghena, DSNA
Page 2
2
Agenda
10:45 What comes thereafter: moving towards the perfect flight with SESAR Captain Peter Larsson, Airspace User Lead Expert for Project B4.2, S di i Ai liScandinavian Airlines
11:00 Final word and end of technical workshop Alain Siebert, Chief Economist & Environment, SESAR Joint Undertaking
END
Page 3
SESAR Environmental Approach
ATC Global 2011
Green ATM workshop – 9 March 2011Célia Alves Rodrigues – Environment Officer
3
Build a new ATM system that is Build a new ATM system that is able to meet future mobility needs able to meet future mobility needs while protecting the environmentwhile protecting the environmentwhile protecting the environmentwhile protecting the environment
Page 5
Main Opportunities
• One programme: collaboration and inclusiveness
• Building a compelling Environmental Case, driver to secure industry buy-in
• Support the development of adequate standards and regulation to support ▪ Sustainable development and global regulation to support deployment
• Practical/fact oriented approach
• Innovative thinking
Page 6
p gemissions on top of the political agenda
▪ ATM enhancements are the main opportunity to reduce aviation's footprint before 2020 – confirmed by a recent study
4
Environment is a priority for SESAR
Three Layer Environmental Approach
1. Implement greener practices in
2. Principles to be applied to the SESAR R&D programme
p g pthe workplace and reduce SJU’s environmental footprint (not presented)
the SESAR R&D programme
3. Incremental SESAR deployment and monitoring
High Level Environment Objectives
SESAR should be recognised as the most environmentally - conscious ATM developmentATM development programme in the world
Enable 10% fuel savings per flight as a result of ATM improvements alone
Improve the role of ATM in developing environmental rules
Be the driver of change!
Page 8
5
R&D
Ensure that Environment is treated as a priority inside the
Page 9
treated as a priority inside the Programme
• Ensure progress & facilitate collaborative decisions
M i h ff i
SJU management response
• Monitor the effectiveness of the R&D activities to define environmental rules
• Gate to gate environmental considerations
• Develop the SESAR label
• Validation close to operations
• Monitor other research projects
Page 10
6
SESAR programme level – Projects (1/2)
• 80% of SESAR projects address environmental issues directly or indirectly
• Establish & monitor environmental performance targets and indicators
• Develop compelling environment cases
• Support decision making
Page 11
• Advanced validation methodology ensuring end-to-end consideration of
SESAR programme level – Projects (2/2)
to e d co s de at o oenvironmental aspects in all R&D activities
• Focus on data collection in the field versus use of models/simulations
• Consideration of environmental trade-offs –noise / CO2 in parallel
Page 12
7
AIRE - Atlantic Interoperability Initiative to Reduce Emissions
• Capitalize on present aircraft capabilities
P id b t ti• Provide best practices and success stories
• Demonstrate benefits by performing flight trials
• Accelerate transition to implementation
• Mapping of AIRE projects with SESAR projects
• A pragmatic transatlantic partnership
Page 13
AIRE Expansion
• Expand – more regions & partners
• More focused taking into account previous AIRE results and SESAR developments
• Full integration in overall SESAR lid ti dSESAR validation roadmap
• Disseminate AIRE best practices
Page 14
8
Incremental SESAR deployment and monitoringmonitoring
Page 15
Ensure the deployment and effective use of new and greener ATM technologies
2012 objectives
• Initial 4D trajectory is validated in an operational environment supported by satellite-based t h ltechnology
• 5,000 flights, including 500 military, are SESAR labelled
• SESAR benefits are demonstrated on city pairs connecting 8 European airports
• Airspace users have signed up• Airspace users have signed up to the SESAR business case (including the environment case) for time-based operations
Page 16
9
Proposed Approach
• Compelling Environment case is developed for first SESAR deployment Packages (applicable from 2013)
• Deliver early R&D results enabled fuel burn reductions of approximately 2% in 2012 (baseline 2010)
• Reduce taxi out by 1 minute perReduce taxi out by 1 minute per departure in major airports
• Assess CO2 footprint of current noise abatement procedures
Page 17
Conclusions
• Environment is a priority for SESAR
• Ambitious environmental targets
• ATM Master Plan is our common roadmap to successsuccess
• PPP works and is a unique opportunity to introduce change
• Validation as close as possible to the operational environment
• Capitalizing on present aircraft capabilities and local partnerships matter to us: concrete p pdemonstration of results now with AIRE
Lets make it happen together!
Page 18
10
Thank you …
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
www.sesarju.eu
Strategic fit
Pierre Caussade – Air France
11
KEY ISSUESKEY ISSUES
FOR A SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Pierre CaussadeSenior VP Environment and Sustainable Development
Air France
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
Some key figures for Air France-KLM
1 Group, 2 companies
Revenues (2009-10) = 21 billion €
Workforce (31.12.09)
Ground Staff : 73 000 Flight Attendant : 26 000 Cockpit Crew : 9 200
Fleet : 594 aircraft
Network : 236 destinations within 107 countries
3 businesses
71 millions passengers
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
1.5 millions tons of cargo
Engineering and Maintenance customers : 150 airlines worldwide
Founding member of the SkyTeam alliance
12
Addressing five key issues for a sustainable development
Combating climate change
Building a sustainable relationship with our customers
Minimizing our environmental impacts
Promoting a responsible human resources policy
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
Driving local development
Our Climate Action Plan :
Combating climate change
We modernize our fleet
We optimize our daily operations
We promote research programs (aircraft, engines, alternative fuels, ATM…)
We actively contribute to international negotiations in order to
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
y greach a global agreement under the umbrella of ICAO
We support environmental programs led by NGO’s
13
Combating climate change
Some key figures :
1 ton 3 15 tons
2 to 3 %
1 tonfuel burnt
3.15 tons=of CO2 emitted
3.8 liters/passenger/100 km
95
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
of global man-made CO2 emissions 95 gCO2/passenger/km
AF KLM fuel efficiency
Manufacturers, airlines, airports and ANSPs bodies have
Combating climate change
jointly and globally committed to specific goals to cut aviation-related CO2 emissions :
by 2020, to improve energy efficiency by 1.5% a year
from 2020, to ensure the stabilization of CO2 emissions and further neutral carbon growth
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
by 2050, 50% reduction of CO2 emissions compared to 2005 levels
14
Key factors for CO2 emissions reduction (source : IATA)
KEY
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
An other key issue : to minimize noise pollution
We promote ICAO “balanced approach” :
Cutting noise at source
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
Cutting noise at source
Operating noise abatement procedures
Regulating land-use around airports
Restricting operations
15
Focus on ATM issues
We fully support SESAR and NextGen research Programs
We are proud to have been fully committed to SESAR since day 1 We are proud to have been fully committed to SESAR since day 1
AF operates first “green flight” from Europe to USA (part of AIRE program) – 6 april 2010
But we need to go FURTHER
Quick wins
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
Quick wins
Pragmatic developments : low investment but significant results
Conclusion
Finally, what is at stake ?
Our licence to grow !
“We strive to achieve sustainable development through financial social and environmental excellence”
ATC Global 2011Amsterdam – 09 March 2011
financial, social and environmental excellence
Jean-Cyril SpinettaChairman of Air France-KLM
16
Quick wins: examples fromthe field
Rudy Kellar – NAV Canada
Evert Westerveld – LVNL
Robin Onghena - DSNA
17
Background
•SESAR Joint Undertaking (SJU) 2007 Modernization of European ATM systemCoordinates relevant research
•AIRE (Atlantic Interoperability Initiative to Reduce Emissions) Managed by SJU and FAA Accelerate pace of Performance BasedAccelerate pace of Performance-Based
Operation Implement fuel efficient procedures - all
flight phasesCapitalize on current aircraft capabilities
and best practices
Opportunity
Lead: NAV CANADA
Partners: Air France, NATSPartners: Air France, NATS
•Assess and trial flights over North Atlantic
• Identify and prioritize ATM procedures and systems for potential to reduce GHG emissions
•Participating airlines:Participating airlines:Air Canada
United Airlines
British Airways
Delta
18
ENGAGE Corridor SolutionEUROPE – NORTH AMERICA Go ADS-B
for a GREENER ENVIRONMENT
Current Operations
19
ENGAGE:Opportunity on the NAT
•Promote:Collaboration
Technology
Best Practices
•More efficient operations
•Improve performance•Improve performance
•Opportunity to re-think and modify North Atlantic traffic
Track Structure:without expanded surveillance
Altitude
20
East Coast ADS-B©
AIR
BU
S S
.A.S
. All
righ
ts r
eser
ved.
Con
fiden
tial a
nd p
ropr
ieta
ry d
ocum
ent.
Surveillance Airspace
Track Structure:with expanded surveillance
*
*
© A
IRB
US
S.A
.S. A
ll ri
ghts
res
erve
d. C
onfid
entia
l and
pro
prie
tary
doc
umen
t.
*Targets of opportunity to vary altitude &
Mach
*Altitude
21
How Do We Achieve This?
ADVANCED OCEANIC
NATS = SAATS
OCEANIC ATC
SYSTEMS
© A
IRB
US
S.A
.S. A
ll ri
ghts
res
erve
d. C
onfid
entia
l and
pro
prie
tary
doc
umen
t.
NAV CANADA = GAATS+
A Collaborative Approach…to keeping an eye on aviation and the environment
ANSP:
NAV CANADA
ANSP:
NATS
© A
IRB
US
S.A
.S. A
ll ri
ghts
res
erve
d. C
onfid
entia
l and
pro
prie
tary
doc
umen
t.
CUSTOMERS:
AIR FRANCE
ADVANCED TECHNOLOGIES
22
ENGAGE Trial Dates
• Demonstration Flights - 2010gJune: World Environment DayNovember: AIRE A380
• Phase 1 – Approved December 2010Pre-ops validation & proof of concept NAT flight trials
• Phase 2 – Spring 2011
© A
IRB
US
S.A
.S. A
ll ri
ghts
res
erve
d. C
onfid
entia
l and
pro
prie
tary
doc
umen
t.
Operational flight trials (possible multiple flights)Multiple flight simulation trials Flight data analysis Fuel burn and GHG results - Summer 2011
• Review flight trial results
• Compile and analyze data
Next Steps
p y
• Proactive communications:Achievable GHG emissions
Efficiency benefits
• An invitation to Montréal
© A
IRB
US
S.A
.S. A
ll ri
ghts
res
erve
d. C
onfid
entia
l and
pro
prie
tary
doc
umen
t. An invitation to Montréal, Canada
Trial results to date and findings
May 2011
23
“Collaboration
A Powerful Thought….
Collaboration equals innovation.”
© A
IRB
US
S.A
.S. A
ll ri
ghts
res
erve
d. C
onfid
entia
l and
pro
prie
tary
doc
umen
t.
Michael Dell
© A
IRB
US
S.A
.S. A
ll ri
ghts
res
erve
d. C
onfid
entia
l and
pro
prie
tary
doc
umen
t.
CIFER
24
© A
IRB
US
S.A
.S. A
ll ri
ghts
res
erve
d. C
onfid
entia
l and
pro
prie
tary
doc
umen
t.
CIFER - Looking Ahead
For more information:
www navcanada ca
© A
IRB
US
S.A
.S. A
ll ri
ghts
res
erve
d. C
onfid
entia
l and
pro
prie
tary
doc
umen
t. www.navcanada.ca
25
SESAR Technical Sessions
Green ATMGreen ATMQuicks wins, examples from the field
Schiphol AIRE trial
Sheet 49
Trajectory Based Night Time CDA’s
Evert Westerveld
LVNL, ATC the Netherlands
The Challenge
• Night “Transitions” (CDA from FL70) in place since mid 90’s
• Inbound “long haul wave” between 04:00 am and 05:30 am LT
Sheet 50
• Bunching effects (with subsequent vectoring and holding) during “bad nights”
26
The ChallengeCurrent night time procedures
Sheet 51
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
03:55 LT
Sheet 52
27
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:00 LT
Sheet 53
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:05 LT
Sheet 54
28
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:10 LT
Sheet 55
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:15 LT
Sheet 56
29
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:20 LT
Sheet 57
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:25 LT
Sheet 58
30
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:30 LT
Sheet 59
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:35 LT
Sheet 60
31
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:40 LT
Sheet 61
The ChallengeExample of current night time ops
04:45 LT
Sheet 62
32
The Project
• Optimization of existing night time OPS
• Pre-planning and sequencing of flights
• Taking benefits from trajectory information exchange
• Cutting excess trackmiles and level segments
Sheet 63
• Cutting excess trackmiles and level segments
• Increasing percentage of top-of-descent type CDA’s
The Concept1. Automatic Connected Aircraft (= 80 %)
SITA / ARINC
ACARS DL
KLM OCC
ACC execPre-Planner
Operator
MQ message set
33
The Concept2. Web Connected Aircraft (= 10 plus %)
SITA / ARINC
ACARS DL
Delta OCC
ACC execPre-Planner
OperatorWeb Interface
The Concept3. Non Connected Aircraft (= 10 minus %)
Radio Telephony
ACC execPre-Planner
Operator MUAC / NATS
Coordination by telephone
34
The Pre-Planner
Sheet 67
Status early March 2011
• Receiving live KLM trajectory data
• Technical testing completed
• Traffic analysis phase starting up
• Procedures documentation @ 80%
Sheet 68
• Planning of first OPS tests in progress
35
Trial Planning
Phase 3: Tuning pre-planner in operationsApril 8 – Sept 30, 2011
Phase 4: Full functional test (alt/spd restricted)October 2011
Phase 5: Emission Reduction TrialNovember 2011
Sheet 69
Work to be done…
Definition of Nominal Agreed Routes
Sheet 70
36
Organizations to acknowledge…
Atlantic Initiative to Reduce Emissions
ATC GLOBAL 2011SESAR TECHNICAL SESSIONSMARCH 9, 2011
37
AIRE 2009/ 2010/2011 – CDG Surface Trials
Performance of flight trialsvalidating solutions for the
reduction of CO2 emissions
Olivier DELAIN
Robin ONGHENA
Laurent RENOU
CDG Surface Trials initiatives
•Three initiatives have been addressed in 2009:• “Departure taxiing with one or two engines off”• “Minimising arrival taxi time”Minimising arrival taxi time• “Reduction of departure taxi time”
Evaluation 1 Departure taxiing with one or two engines off March 22 to April 10, 2009 16
Evaluation 2 Minimising arrival taxi time April 14 to April 24, 2009 28
Evaluation 3a Reduction of departure taxi time (Phase A) June 02 to June 09, 2009 6
Evaluation 3b Reduction of departure taxi time (Phase B) October 19 to October 22, 2009 309
Identification Evaluation Title Dates Flights
38
Ensure consistency with CFMU slot if any
1Minimise the RWY pressure while guaranteeing a sufficient number of aircraft at RWY entries so that the
2
Reduction of departure taxi timeContext and Objectives
Avoid too many aircraft in taxiways to increase safety, reduce stop and go, lower waiting times at RWY threshold, thus reducing fuel consumption and CO2
emissions
4
3at RWY entries so that the RWY controller can optimise the management of RWY
Manage the taxi time to sequence pushback times and ensure that the aircraft arrives at runway threshold at calculated times
emissions
Benefits Analysis of GLD process (Arthur D.Little, 2007):
Reduction of waiting time at RWY: 1700T of fuel/ year (Air France)Reduction of taxi time from stand to holding point: 2300 T of fuel /year (Air France)
Anticipate capacity increase by having a buffer of aircraft ready
For departure
5
DMAN STPV(Flight Data Processing System)
TOBT, TSATRWY capacity,RWY pressure,RWY configuration
GLD algorithm SARIA DPI Generator
TOBT TSAT
Airport and Airlines Systems
Alerts CDM@CDG website
DPI
CTOT
p y
CTOT: Calculated Take Off Time DPI: Departure Planning Information messageGLD: Gestion Locale des Départs (Implementing Pre-Departure Sequence Concept)SARIA: Système d’Allocation de Ressources et Informations Aéroportuaires (ADP airport database)STPV: Système Traitement Plans de Vols (French FDPS)TOBT: Target Off Block Time (time at which an AO or GH estimates will be ready -all doors closed, boarding bridges removed and pushback vehicle available - and ready to start up/pushback immediately upon reception of clearance from the TWR (CDM implementation. Manual)TSAT: Target Start Up Approval Time (The time provided by ATC taking into account TOBT, CTOT and/or the traffic situation that an aircraft can expect start up / push back approval)
39
AIRE and PDS
Three main AIRE steps in parallel of PDS full implementation:
1. The green flight: several tests during 2009 and 2010 (AIRE 1)2 The GLD evaluation from oct 19th to Oct 22th 2009 (AIRE 1)2. The GLD evaluation from oct, 19th to Oct 22th 2009 (AIRE 1)3. Greener airports under adverse conditions (AIRE 2)
CDM@CDG project status:
The commissioning of DMANHMI , linked with PDS system, is inoperation (live) from November 9, 2010 at Paris Charles de Gaulleairport.
After Munich and Brussels, CDG is a labelled CDM airport (IP1) since, p ( )November 16, 2010 (00:00 utc).
The scope of operational situations covered by this project includes
Planned RWY closure,
Low Visibility Operations,
Situations where all aircraft have to de‐ice,
Snow conditions
Greener Airports under Adverse Conditions
40
DMAN general interface for the Clearance Delivery Position
DMAN specific interface for TWR supervisor
41
What comes thereafter: moving towards the perfect flight with SESAR
Captain Peter Larsson – ScandanavianAirlines
42
A successful flight with SESAR - from an airline perspective
2011-03-09
Peter Larsson
Flight Captain, Scandinavian Airlines
AU lead B4.2
BDT, Business Development Trajectory
• Months or years before flight• Not shared outside the airline• Gradual iterations and refinement (within the airline)
08.10
ARN
07.00
CPH
05MAY2025
43
SBT, Shared Business Trajectory
• User preferred and PBO, Performance Based Operation with minimum cost and environmental load. Both CPH and ARN will likely be ”managed” airspace withseparation service.
• Shared with ATM system• Gradual iterations and refinements between airline and ATM system
08.10
ARN
08.15
07.00
CPH
07.05
08.04:30
SBT, Shared Business Trajectory
07.36
07.48
08.1508.09
ARN08.02
07.28
07.0507.17
CPH
07.21
44
08.04:30
SBT, Shared Business Trajectory
07.36
07.4807.50
07.37
08.1508.09
ARN08.02
07.28
08.1108.17
07.0507.17
CPH N50074E009303.0,R,2032,N54370E011559,4000,132814.0,,,N55134E012293,4000,133349.0,,,N55224E012377,4000,133512.0,,,N55332E012479,4000,133651.0,R,2034,N55484E013024,4000,133912.0,,,N56076E013272,4000,134225.0,,,N56203E013440,4000,134434.0,,,N56339E014020,4000,134651.0,,,N56459E014185,4000,134853.0,,,N57216E015078,4000,135458.0,,,N57544E015553,4000,140038.9,,,N58064E016132,4000,140243.0,,,N58167E016287,3539,140433.B,,,N58184E016312,3449,140451.0,R,1192,N58563E017301,1900,141232.A,,,N59091E017539,1900,141541.1,L,355,N59172E018092,1530,141744.0,R,972,N59319E018122,1042,142035.C,,,N59481E018181,550,142403.0,L,238,N59538E018202,483,142447.0,L,102,N59471E017580,247,142744.0,,,N59438E017568,138,142856.1,,,N59400E017554,17,143031.1,,,
Gradual iterations and refinements into :07.21
RBT, Reference Business Trajectory
07.50
07.37
08.04:30
Minimised air distance;saving emissions
Continous descent operations;saving emissions and noise
ARN07.2807.28
08.1108.17
08.04:30
Continous climb operations;saving emissions and noise
07.0507.17
CPH
07.21
07.1707.05
• Agreement – not a clearance• Airlines agree to fly – ANSPs agree to facilitate• Times are estimates, but can also be targets and/or constraints• Automatic updates outside predefined thresholds• Revised if constraints change or RBT cannot be achieved
07.21
45
2500
90%
100%
Baseline 330NM Green FlightPost flight monitoring
500
1000
1500
2000
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
Ackumulated fuel used (kg)
% of Max Fuel Flow/H
eight
Fuel Flow (% of Max) TKOF thrust excludedHeight (% of Max)
Ackumulated fuel used (kg)
00%
10%
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
Distance (NM)
Questions?
46
Final word
Alain Siebert – SESAR JU
Thank you for your attention!
Visit us at the SESAR JU booth inhall 9 and meet the SESAR experts!
47