Lessons Learned from Screening and Qualification of COTS
Capacitors
Alexander TeverovskyJacobs Engineering, Inc.
Work performed for EEE Parts, Photonics and Assembly Branch, NASA GSFC, Code 562
NASA Electronic Parts and Packaging (NEPP) Program
List of Acronyms
ETW June 14-17, 2021 2
AEC Automotive Electronics Council MSL moisture sensitivity level
BI burn-in PST power surge test
DCL direct current leakage PWB printed wiring board
DLA Defense Logistics Agency RB reverse bias
EM electrical measurements RVT random vibration test
ER established reliability S&Q screening and qualification
ESA European Space Agency SS sample size
ESR equivalent series resistance TC temperature cycling
FR failure rate TS thermal shock
IDC inter-digitated capacitor TTF time to failure
LAT lot acceptance test VR voltage rating
LT life test
Abstract
ETW June 14-17, 2021 3
A traditional approach to screening and qualification of hi-relCOTS capacitors and its limitations are analyzed. Results oftesting of four types of COTS capacitors for L2 projects aresummarized. The types include DLA drawing tantalum MnO2capacitors, high-voltage hermetically sealed polymer tantalumcapacitors, multianode COTS+ capacitors, and feedthrough BMEceramic capacitors. Lessons learned from this experience mightaccelerate processes and reduce risks of inclusion of COTScomponents in space projects.
Outline
Traditional approach to screening and qualification of hi-rel COTS capacitors and its limitations
Case 1: DLA drawing MnO2 capacitor Case 2: High-voltage hermetically sealed polymer
tantalum capacitors Case 3: Multianode COTS+ tantalum capacitors Case 4: Feedthrough ceramic capacitors Lessons learned
ETW June 14-17, 2021 4
COTS vs. MIL-Grade Capacitors
ETW June 14-17, 2021 5
Capacitors for different level space projects are selected based on reliability/FR grading.
Risk of using a COTS capacitor: Pm × (consequences of failure).
𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅𝒅 → λ𝑚𝑚 = λ/𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴
The major benefit of using ER MIL-grade parts is that they are assumed to be acceptable for most space projects if operating conditions are within the MIL range of temperatures and voltages.
Lack of confidence in consistency of quality in different lots of COTS capacitors → difficulties in reliability assessments for a given part type.
Contrary to MIL applications, space projects are often interested in a single lot of capacitors that are to be used at a relatively benign conditions → the need to assess reliability of a particular batch for a specific application.
Existing guidelines for S&Q of COTS parts typically follow MIL-spec requirements developed for relatively old technologies.
𝑃𝑃𝑚𝑚 = 1 − exp −λ𝑚𝑚𝑡𝑡𝑚𝑚 ,
1.E-5
1.E-4
1.E-3
1.E-2
1.E-1
1.E+0
1%/1000hr 0.1%/1000hr 0.01%/1000hr 0.001%/1000hr
prob
abili
ty o
f mis
sion
failu
re
failure rate
1 year3year10year20year
Life Testing of COTS Capacitors
ETW June 14-17, 2021 6
Increasing risks of WO failures for new technology capacitors can be managed.
If a COTS part can pass the relevant MIL spec requirements is it as good as a MIL part? Due to a small SS during LT and low confidence/trust
in quality consistency for COTS it is impossible to get acceptable FR without significant acceleration. Test results cannot be generalized for a given part
type → each lot should be tested. Existing LT for COTS capacitors is a quality compliance, but not a reliability test. LT conditions in the existing guidelines might be not applicable for advanced COTS.
If COTS capacitors fail MIL requirements for life testing, can it still be used? If not, but you wish to use the part very much, then should we:
A. Relax the requirements in the MIL spec (IDC, hybrids)?B. Assess acceleration factors and prove reliability for the mission?
IM failures WO failures
spec
failu
re ra
te
time
useful life
new technology
The beauty of WO failures: PoF approach and modeling
DLA #13008
ETW June 14-17, 2021 7
Benefits of frameless design: Better polarity indication Elimination of wire welding Extended range The part has a good self-healing
capability (10% of damage after scintillation breakdown)
T97 max rating 22uF, 250 mΩ, 63V
Sn/Pb
Silver epoxy
Ni
Examples of cracking at the anode and cathode in CWR06 capacitors
Potential problems: Integrity after soldering Insufficient screening (85C/40hr/VR)
Life test is optional (85C/2000hr/VR)
CWR06max rating
4.7uF, 1.5Ω, 50V
DLA #13008 10uF 63V S&Q
ETW June 14-17, 2021 8
Application conditions for a project: 28V, survival T range from -25ºC to 65ºC; possible transients during power-up 2-5 ms. Screening verification included monitored BI at 85C 63V for 160hr.One out of 85 samples failed after 50 hours. The appearance of the failure site suggested scintillation breakdown. Qualification tests using 45 samples reflow soldered onto test PWB: monitored cycling (30 TC -35 to +85C), power surge, and life test (2000hr, 85C).
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
80
100
0.0E+0
2.0E-6
4.0E-6
6.0E-6
8.0E-6
1.0E-5
1.2E-5
1.4E-5
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
tem
pera
ture
, deg
.C
curre
nt, A
time, hr
0.0E+0
5.0E-6
1.0E-5
1.5E-5
2.0E-5
2.5E-5
3.0E-5
0 500 1000 1500 2000
curre
nt, A
time, hr
85C 63V
The frameless technology improves performance and quality of the parts. DLA drawing parts might require BI verification. Life test at 85C 63V for 2khr corresponds to >1000yr during the mission.
Monitored TC life test
1/85 sample failed screening
TCH Capacitors
ETW June 14-17, 2021 9
A project selected 22uF 100V Ta caps to be used in 35V power lines with possible transient spikes up to 43V. Turn ON/OF cycles are relatively slow, ~300 µsec. Operational T~ 25 ºC and possible variations -20 to +30 ºC. Ripple currents below 20 mA, which is ~10 times below the specified limit.
TCH series are hermetically sealed polymer Ta caps developed for space applications per ESA requirements.
C-shape terminals were selected to reduce stresses from PWB. Screening of 420 samples included:
5 TC (-55C to +125C), power surge, hermeticity, and monitored BI (85C/100V/168hr).
LAT was carried out for 3 groups after reflow soldering onto test PWB or soldering simulation. Gr.I (20pcs): 100TC -55 to +125C -> EM -> humidity (85C/85% RH/2wk)
-> EM -> power surge cycling. Gr.II (20pcs): reflow soldering -> EM ->
stability at HT and LT -> RVT. Gr.III (60pcs): reflow soldering ->EM ->
monitored life test (85C/100V/2000hr)
Potential problems:• Dehermetization or excessive leak• Reverse bias pulses• Reliability at operating conditions
Effect of Dehermetization
ETW June 14-17, 2021 10
Small holes were drilled in several engineering samples of the part. AC characteristics were measured after dehermetization, exposure
to moisture, 100 TS, and HTS125 up to 3000 hours.
Significant capacitance variations in non-hermetic parts indicate moisture presence. Epoxy foam inside the package does not substantially delay moisture penetration. The level of moisture corresponding to RC does not degrade the parts. Hermetically sealed parts can withstand > 3000hr of HTS125, whereas non-hermetic
parts can fail even after 1000hr due to thermo-oxidative degradation of PEDOT/PSS.
Effect of Reverse Bias Pulses
ETW June 14-17, 2021 11
During PST, the parts were stressed by 60V 0.5 sec pulses with a ramp time < 0.3msec. Similar pulses in reverse polarity were applied at increasing voltages. The currents were also monitored at 60V RB.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0.01
0.1
1
10
0 1 2 3 4 5
volta
ge, V
curre
nt, A
time, msec
TCH 22uF 100V at FB
I_FB_60FB 60V
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0.01
0.1
1
10
0 1 2 3 4 5
volta
ge, V
curre
nt, A
time, msec
TCH 22uF 100V at RBI_10 I_20I_30 I_40I_50 I_6010V 20V30V 40V50V 60V
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0.001
0.01
0.1
1
10
0 5 10 15
volta
ge, V
curre
nt, A
time, sec
TCH 22uF 100V at 60V RB
I4V4
Reverse bias during PST does not damage the part. At 60V, failures at reverse bias can be observed after 10 sec. RB failures result in charring of polymer around the whole surface of the slug.
RB failure at 60V
Results of Life Testing (Gr. III, 60 pcs)
ETW June 14-17, 2021 12
SN100
0.0E+0
5.0E-7
1.0E-6
1.5E-6
2.0E-6
0 500 1000 1500 2000
curre
nt, A
time, hr
life test at 85C 100V
Screening: 4.3% of 420 pcs failed DCL before BI and 0.7% failed during BI.
Life test: No failures or significant
anomalies during monitored life testing.
No parametric degradation or failures after life testing.
Limit 220uA
Variations of AC characteristics through the testing
Conservative estimations show that 2khr life test at 85C, 100V corresponds to more than 1000 years during the mission.
Evaluation of Multianode TBM Capacitors
ETW June 14-17, 2021 13
Multianode capacitors allow for a substantial reduction of ESR that can be reduced to 35-70 mohms for MnO2 capacitors.
Available with Weibull Grade “B” reliability (0.1%/1000hr). Potential reliability problems: Greater risk of popcorning due to increased number of edges. Greater risk of breakdown due to a larger surface.
Soldering of 6 types of TBM capacitors (720 pcs) shows that with proper baking the parts can be safely soldered onto PWBs.
MSL1Preliminary tests showed that multianodecapacitors preconditioned per MSL1 have
cracks after reflow soldering
LAT of Multianode Capacitors
ETW June 14-17, 2021 14
No failures in 5 lots of capacitors. In one lot, 2 out of 120 samples failed life test.
Additional screening (BI) might be necessary in one of 6 tested lots. Using a 45(1) criterion per the guidelines, would have 83% chance of passing life test. Parts that passed the life test 120(0) at 1.1VR will have the probability of failure during a
20 year mission < 0.01%.
Test flow Qualification tests Life Test for a Failed Lot
SN18SN33
1.E-7
1.E-6
1.E-5
1.E-4
0 200 400 600 800 1000
curr
ent,
A
time, hr
22uF 35V at 85C 1.1VR
Multianode 22uF 35V capacitors
TTF, hr
cumu
lative
prob
abilit
y, %
1.E-1 1.E+1110 1000 100000 1.E+7 1.E+91.E-1
5.E-1
1
5
10
50
90
100
1.E-1
85C u=1.1
85C u=0.5
788 years
b=3.5
b=0.33
75C u=0.14use cond.
life test simul based on AF, use cond
simul. u=1.1, 85Csimul. u=0.5, 85Csimul. u=0.14, 75C
simul based on AF, 85C u=0.5
IM
WO
Feedthrough BME Capacitors
ETW June 14-17, 2021 15
AEC Q-200 feedthrough BME 0805, X7R, 10nF, 50V for use in 5V lines at 65 ºC max.
300 samples passed monitored BI at 125 ºC/100V/160hr with zero failures.
Monitored LT of 60 soldered samples at 125 ºC/100V/2000hr resulted in 2 failures.
For some AEC-Q200 parts BI is not necessary. Conservative estimations showed that at the mission conditions TTF > 10,000 years. Parts failing MIL life test requirements can be used for a space mission at
substantially derated conditions.
Life Test
time-to-failure, hr
cumu
lative
prob
abilit
y, %
1.E+2 1.E+121.E+3 1.E+4 1.E+5 1.E+6 1.E+7 1.E+8 1.E+9 1.E+10 1.E+111.E-1
5.E-1
1
5
10
50
90
100
1.E-1 x 58
125C, 100V
65C, 5V atAF=1.42E6
60% CB
Lessons Learned
ETW June 14-17, 2021 16
Instead of qualifying a COTS capacitor “for space”, we need to ensure that a given batch of parts has an acceptable probability of failure at specific application conditions for the required mission time.
Paradigm shift: reliability for the mission instead of compliance with MIL-spec (relaxed?) requirements.
Development of S&Q plans for COTS capacitors should include: Analysis of potential reliability concerns specific to the design. Qualification testing using sufficiently large SS of soldered capacitors. Analysis of application conditions. Assessments of reliability acceleration factors.
COTS+ capacitors require BI, unless opposite is proven statistically.