-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
1/49
IEV X\FAMDCZMEO
\OMZLJ TZCZLT DE\VZ EI CXXLCATIEV ZKL OMOZK DMVD\MZ
NCZKV]O BDEBML"@VC]!Xacmozmii"Cxxlaacoz! Oe/ 38"39:;0
y/ J/D/ Oe/678="dy"86:66"FCON EI CBLVMDC KEBL AECOT!
BDL"LIFINC De|ozv}pmjl Kebl Aecot!Mod/! EXMOMEO
Jlilojcoz"Cxxlaall/
Cxxlca iveb zkl \omzlj Tzczlt Jmtzvmdz De|vziev zkl Lctzlvo Jmtzvmdz ei Dcamievomc
Bevvmteo D/ Lo`acoj! Jmtzvmdz G|j`l! Xvltmjmo`
Cv`|lj coj T|fbmzzljJldlbflv 9! 6833Tco Ivcodmtde! Dcamievomc
Imalj Ilfv|cv} ;! 6836
Flievl7 Dcvaet Z/ Flc coj Tzlxklo T/ Zvezz! Dmvd|mz G|j`lt!coj Vlflddc V/ Xcaabl}lv! Jmtzvmdz G|j`l/'
Exmomeo f} G|j`l Xcaabl}lv
' Zkl Keoevcfal Vlflddc V/ Xcaabl}lv! \omzlj Tzczlt Jmtzvmdz G|j`l ievzkl Oevzklvo Jmtzvmdz ei Maamoemt! tmzzmo` f} jltm`oczmeo/
34
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
2/49
DE\OTLA
Zkebct C/ Glonmot coj Jcomla Getlxk B|aam`co! Tco Jml`e!Dcamievomc> Acvv} Pc}ol @cfvmla! Peejacoj Kmaat! Dcamievomc>Glonmot B|aam`co ) @cfvmla AAX> Xcblac Tmbbeot! Tmb"beot ) X|vj}! Tes|la! Dcamievomc! iev zkl xacmozmii"cxxlaacoz/
Gcblt @eajflvz! Fv}co Dcyl AAX! Tco Ivcodmtde! Dcamievomc!
iev zkl jlilojcoz"cxxlaall/
Zcvc C/ Zpebl}! Dcvbla! Dcamievomc! iev zkl cbmd|t/
34
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
3/49
EXMOMEO
XCAABL]LV! Jmtzvmdz G|j`l7
Nczkv}o BdEbml"@vc} cxxlcat zkl jmtbmttca ei klv acpt|mziev icma|vl ze tzczl c dacmb |xeo pkmdk vlamli bc} fl `vcozljx|vt|coz ze Iljlvca V|al ei Dmyma Xvedlj|vl 36+f-+9-/BdEbml"@vc} te|`kz vltdmttmeo ei klv aeco tld|vlj f} c zv|tzjllj pmzk Fcon ei Cblvmdc Kebl Aecot +zkl Fcon- ievcaal`lj ymeaczmeot ei jmtdaet|vl vls|mvlblozt |ojlv zkl iljlvcaZv|zk mo Alojmo` Cdz +ZMAC-! 3< \/T/D/ 3983 lz tls/ Eozkl Fcont bezmeo! zkl jmtzvmdz de|vz jmtbmttlj zkl t|mz ct|ozmbla} fldc|tl mz pct imalj cizlv zkl zkvll"}lcv xlvmej tlz f}3< \/T/D/ 394
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
4/49
tm`o! moda|jmo` zpe Oezmdl ei Vm`kz ze Dcodla ievbt/BdEbml"@vc} caal`lt! keplylv! zkcz olmzklv ei zkltl ievbtl{xacmolj pklo zkl fevveplvt vm`kz ze dcodla pe|aj l{xmvl/T|ftls|loza}! Xcvcbe|oz cttm`olj mzt mozlvltz mo zkl aeco zeDe|ozv}pmjl Kebl Aecot! Mod/! c debxco} zkcz zkl Fconaczlv cds|mvlj/
Eo Gco|cv} 3;! 688;! BdEbml"@vc}! zkve|`k klv czzevol}!tloz zkl fcon oezmdl ei klv mozloz ze vltdmoj zkl aeco! dmzmo` zklFcont icma|vl ze cjymtl BdEbml"@vc} ei zkl imoca jczl zedcodla zkl zvcotcdzmeo/ Zkl Fcon vli|tlj vltdmttmeo! cttlvzmo`zkcz BdEbml"@vc} kcj vldlmylj xvexlv oezmdl ei klv vm`kz ze
vltdmoj/ Cddevjmo` ze BdEbml"@vc}! cazke|`k zkl Fcon mom"zmcaa} vli|tlj ze cddlxz klv oezmdl ei vltdmttmeo! mz ol`ezmczljpmzk ^klvR iev eylv c }lcv vl`cvjmo` zkl vltdmttmeo/ BdEbml"@vc}t Exlomo` Fvmli cz
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
5/49
bcojczmo` zkcz alojlvt jmtdaetl dlvzcmo moievbczmeo ze fev"veplvt/ Ze lot|vl zkcz alojlvt debxa} pmzk zkltl jmtdaet|vlvls|mvlblozt! ZMAC `vcozt fevveplvt zkl vm`kz ze vltdmoj ckebl"tld|vlj aeco mo zkl lyloz zkl alojlv kct icmalj ze bcnlzkl vls|mvlj jmtdaet|vlt/ Txldmimdcaa}! 394
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
6/49
vltdmttmeo mt xvexlv/ Acv`l y/ Deotlde Imo/ Tlvymdmo` Devx/!6=6 I/4j :=!
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
7/49
t|mzt b|tz fl fve|`kz pmzkmo zkvll }lcvt iveb zkl deot|bbc"zmeo ei zkl aeco! vl`cvjaltt pklzklv oezmdl ei vltdmttmeo mtjlamylvlj pmzkmo zkcz zkvll"}lcv xlvmej/
Mo Flcdk! zkl T|xvlbl De|vz cjjvlttlj pklzklv bevz`c"`evt! pke olylv tloz c oezmdl ei vltdmttmeo ze zkl alojlv! de|ajoeolzklaltt vcmtl zkl vm`kz ei vltdmttmeo ct co ciimvbczmyljlilotl mo c deaaldzmeo cdzmeo fve|`kz bevl zkco zkvll }lcvtcizlv zkl deot|bbczmeo ei zkl zvcotcdzmeo/
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
8/49
kct v|o/ Mj/ cz :3= +lbxkctmt cjjlj-/ Zk|t! zkl De|vz klajzkcz zkl bevz`c`ev de|aj oez vcmtl zkl vm`kz ze vltdmoj ct cjlilotl ze zkl bevz`c`llt ievldaet|vl cdzmeo cizlv zkl zkvll"}lcv xlvmej kcj v|o/ Mj/ Zkl aco`|c`l zkl De|vz |tlj! kep"lylv! fvecja} ctt|blt zkcz c zkvll"}lcv ambmzczmeo `eylvotdctlt pklvl c fevveplv! ct xacmozmii! tllnt vltdmttmeo ei zklbevz`c`l zvcotcdzmeo/
Ieaaepmo` zkl T|xvlbl De|vzt keajmo` mo Flcdk! plcjjvlttlj zkl s|ltzmeo pklzklv c fevveplv bc} imal c acpt|mztllnmo` vltdmttmeo fl}eoj zkl zkvll"}lcv xlvmej mi zkl fev"veplv olylv tloz c zmbla} oezmdl ei vltdmttmeo/ Bm`|la! 48=
I/4j 3393/ MoBm`|la! zkl fevveplvt vlimocodlj zklmv kebl eoJldlbflv 3! 3==:/ Eo Oeylbflv 0! 3==0! zkl fevveplvt tlozoezmdl ei vltdmttmeo ze zkl bevz`c`l tlvymdlv! co c`loz ei zklcdz|ca amlokeajlv/ Zkl fevveplvt imalj t|mz c`cmotz zkl c`lozeo Jldlbflv 3! 3==0! l{cdza} zkvll }lcvt iveb zkl daetmo`jczl/ Pklo zkl fevveplvt vlcamwlj zkcz zkl} kcj t|lj zklpveo` lozmz}! zkl} imalj co cblojlj debxacmoz zkcz moda|jljzkl amlokeajlv ct c jlilojcoz eo G|ol 30! 3==;! plaa cizlv zklzkvll"}lcv xlvmej kcj l{xmvlj/ Zkl jmtzvmdz de|vz deoda|jljzkcz zkl fevveplv pct lozmzalj ze vltdmttmeo/ Mj/ cz 3396"94/
^:R Eo cxxlca! pl vlylvtlj coj klaj zkcz zkl fevveplvtvm`kz ze vltdmttmeo kcj l{xmvlj fldc|tl zkl fcon jmj oezvldlmyl c oezmdl ei vltdmttmeo pmzkmo zkvll }lcvt iveb zkl deo"t|bbczmeo ei zkl zvcotcdzmeo/Mj/ cz 339
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
9/49
oezmdl ei vltdmttmeo zvm``lvlj co cjjmzmeoca eol"}lcv xlvmej ievimamo` t|mz |ojlv 39:8/ Pl deoda|jlj! keplylv! zkcz 39:8pct mvvlalycoz! coj oep keaj zkcz cjexzmo` 39:8t eol"}lcvtzcz|zl ei ambmzczmeot ze vltdmttmeo cdzmeot deozvcjmdzt zkl xacmoaco`|c`l ei zkl tzcz|zl/
^
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
10/49
\omzlj Tzczlt De|vz ei Cxxlcat iev zkl Omozk Dmvd|mz
Eiimdl ei zkl Dalvn
=< Tlylozk TzvllzTco Ivcodmtde! DC =:384
Moievbczmeo Vl`cvjmo` G|j`bloz coj Xetz"G|j`bloz Xvedlljmo`t
+Jldlbflv 688=-
G|j`bloz
Zkmt De|vz kct imalj coj lozlvlj zkl czzcdklj g|j`bloz mo }e|v dctl/Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/ 49/ Xalctl oezl zkl imalj jczl eo zkl czzcdkljjldmtmeo fldc|tl caa ei zkl jczlt jltdvmflj flaep v|o iveb zkcz jczl!oez iveb zkl jczl }e| vldlmyl zkmt oezmdl/
Bcojczl +Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/ :3> =zk Dmv/ V/ :3"3 ) "6-
Zkl bcojczl pmaa mtt|l 0 jc}t cizlv zkl l{xmvczmeo ei zkl zmbl ievimamo` c xlzmzmeo iev vlklcvmo` ev 0 jc}t iveb zkl jlomca ei c xlzmzmeoiev vlklcvmo`! |oaltt zkl De|vz jmvldzt ezklvpmtl/ Ze imal c bezmeo zetzc} zkl bcojczl! imal mz laldzveomdcaa} ymc zkl cxxlaaczl LDI t}tzlbev! mi }e| cvl c xve tl amzm`coz ev co czzevol} pmzk co l{lbxzmeo iveb|tmo` cxxlaaczl LDI! imal eol evm`moca bezmeo eo xcxlv/
Xlzmzmeo iev Xcola Vlklcvmo` +Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/ :8> =zk Dmv/ V/ :8"3-
Xlzmzmeo iev Vlklcvmo` Lo Fcod +Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/ 4 =zk Dmv/ V/ 4 C dkco`l mo zkl acp edd|vvlj cizlv zkl dctl pct t|fbmzzlj pkmdk
cxxlcvt ze kcyl fllo eylvaeenlj f} zkl xcola> ev
Co cxxcvloz deoiamdz pmzk coezklv jldmtmeo ei zkl De|vz pct oez
cjjvlttlj mo zkl exmomeo/ Je oez imal c xlzmzmeo iev xcola vlklcvmo` blvla} ze vlcv`|l zkl dctl/
F/ X|vxetl +Vlklcvmo` Lo Fcod-
C xcvz} tke|aj tlln lo fcod vlklcvmo` eoa} mi eol ev bevl ei zkl ieaaepmo``ve|ojt l{mtz7
Xetz G|j`bloz Ievb " Vly/ 36%688= 3
Dctl7 38"39:;0 86%8;%6836 MJ7 ;898;:= JnzLozv}7 :
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
11/49
Deotmjlvczmeo f} zkl i|aa De|vz mt oldlttcv} ze tld|vl ev bcmozcmo|omievbmz} ei zkl De|vzt jldmtmeot> ev
Zkl xvedlljmo` moyeaylt c s|ltzmeo ei l{dlxzmeoca mbxevzcodl> ev
Zkl exmomeo jmvldza} deoiamdzt pmzk co l{mtzmo` exmomeo f} coezklvde|vz ei cxxlcat ev zkl T|xvlbl De|vz coj t|ftzcozmcaa} ciildzt cv|al ei oczmeoca cxxamdczmeo mo pkmdk zklvl mt co eylvvmjmo` ollj ievoczmeoca |omievbmz}/
+6- Jlcjamolt iev Imamo`7
C xlzmzmeo iev vlklcvmo` bc} fl imalj pmzkmo 3: jc}t cizlv lozv} ei
g|j`bloz/ Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/ :8+c-+3-/
Mi zkl \omzlj Tzczlt ev co c`lod} ev eiimdlv zklvlei mt c xcvz} mo c dmyma dctl!
zkl zmbl iev imamo` c xlzmzmeo iev vlklcvmo` mt :< jc}t cizlv lozv} ei
g|j`bloz/ Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/ :8+c-+3-/
Mi zkl bcojczl kct mtt|lj! zkl xlzmzmeo iev vlklcvmo` tke|aj fl
cddebxcomlj f} c bezmeo ze vldcaa zkl bcojczl/
Tll Cjymtev} Oezl ze =zk Dmv/ V/ :8"3 +xlzmzmeot b|tz fl vldlmylj eo zkl
j|l jczl-/
Co evjlv ze x|famtk c xvlyme|ta} |ox|famtklj blbevcoj|b jmtxetmzmeo
l{zlojt zkl zmbl ze imal c xlzmzmeo iev vlklcvmo` ze 3: jc}t cizlv zkl jczl ei
zkl evjlv ei x|famdczmeo ev! mo caa dmyma dctlt mo pkmdk zkl \omzlj Tzczlt ev
co c`lod} ev eiimdlv zklvlei mt c xcvz}! :< jc}t cizlv zkl jczl ei zkl evjlv ei
x|famdczmeo/ =zk Dmv/ V/ :8"6/
+4- Tzczlbloz ei De|otla C xlzmzmeo tke|aj deozcmo co mozvej|dzmeo tzczmo` zkcz! mo de|otlat
g|j`bloz! eol ev bevl ei zkl tmz|czmeot jltdvmflj mo zkl x|vxetl tldzmeo
cfeyl l{mtz/ Zkl xemozt ze fl vcmtlj b|tz fl tzczlj dalcva}/
+:- Ievb ) O|bflv ei Dexmlt +=zk Dmv/ V/ :8"3> Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/ 46+d-+6--
Zkl xlzmzmeo tkcaa oez l{dllj 3< xc`lt |oaltt mz debxamlt pmzk zkl
cazlvoczmyl alo`zk ambmzczmeot ei :!688 pevjt ev 4=8 amolt ei zl{z/
Zkl xlzmzmeo b|tz fl cddebxcomlj f} c dex} ei zkl xcolat jldmtmeo flmo`
dkcaalo`lj/ Co cotplv! pklo evjlvlj f} zkl De|vz! tkcaa debxa} pmzk zkl tcbl alo`zk
ambmzczmeot ct zkl xlzmzmeo/
Mi c xve tl amzm`coz laldzt ze imal c ievb fvmli x|vt|coz ze Dmvd|mz V|al 6;"3! c
xlzmzmeo iev xcola vlklcvmo` ev iev vlklcvmo` lo fcod ollj oez debxa} pmzk
Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/ 46/
Xetz G|j`bloz Ievb " Vly/ 36%688= 6
Dctl7 38"39:;0 86%8;%6836 MJ7 ;898;:= JnzLozv}7 :
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
12/49
Zkl xlzmzmeo ev cotplv b|tz fl cddebxcomlj f} c Dlvzmimdczl ei
Debxamcodl ie|oj cz Ievb 33! cycmacfal eo e|v plftmzl cz |ojlvIevbt/
]e| bc} imal c xlzmzmeo laldzveomdcaa} ymc zkl cxxlaaczl LDI t}tzlb/ Oe
xcxlv dexmlt cvl vls|mvlj |oaltt zkl De|vz evjlvt ezklvpmtl/ Mi }e| cvl c
xve tl amzm`coz ev co czzevol} l{lbxzlj iveb |tmo` zkl cxxlaaczl LDI
t}tzlb! imal eol evm`moca xlzmzmeo eo xcxlv/ Oe cjjmzmeoca xcxlv dexmlt cvl
vls|mvlj |oaltt zkl De|vz evjlvt ezklvpmtl/
Fmaa ei Detzt +Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/ 4=! =zk Dmv/ V/ 4="3-
Zkl Fmaa ei Detzt b|tz fl imalj pmzkmo 3: jc}t cizlv lozv} ei g|j`bloz/
Tll Ievb 38 iev cjjmzmeoca moievbczmeo! cycmacfal eo e|v plftmzl cz |ojlv
Ievbt/
Czzevol}t Illt
Omozk Dmvd|mz V|al 4="3 jltdvmflt zkl deozloz coj j|l jczlt iev czzevol}t
illt cxxamdczmeot/
Caa vlalycoz ievbt cvl cycmacfal eo e|v plftmzl cz |ojlvIevbt ev f}
zlalxkeomo` +:3
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
13/49
Ievb 38/ Fmaa ei Detzt //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// +Vly/ 36"3"
\omzlj Tzczlt De|vz ei Cxxlcat iev zkl Omozk Dmvd|mz
FMAA EI DETZT
Oezl7 Mi }e| pmtk ze imal c fmaa ei detzt! mz B\TZ fl t|fbmzzlj eo zkmt ievb coj imalj! pmzk zkl dalvn! pmzk xveei e
tlvymdl! pmzkmo 3: jc}t ei zkl jczl ei lozv} ei g|j`bloz! coj mo cddevjcodl pmzk =zk Dmvd|mz V|al 4="3/ Caczl fmaa ei detzt b|tz fl cddebxcomlj f} c bezmeo tkepmo` `eej dc|tl/ Xalctl vlilv ze IVCX 4=! 6;
\/T/D/ 3=68! coj =zk Dmvd|mz V|al 4="3 pklo xvlxcvmo` }e|v fmaa ei detzt/
y/ =zk Dmv/ Oe/
Zkl Dalvn mt vls|ltzlj ze zc{ zkl ieaaepmo` detzt c`cmotz7
Detz Zc{cfal
|ojlv IVCX 4=!
6; \/T/D/ 3=68!
=zk Dmv/ V/ 4="3
VLS\LTZLJ
Lcdk Dea|bo B|tz Fl Debxalzlj
CAAEPLJ
Ze Fl Debxalzlj f} zkl Dalvn
Oe/ ei
Jedt/
Xc`lt xlv
Jed/
Detz xlv
Xc`lZEZCA
DETZ
ZEZCA
DETZ
Xc`lt xlv
Jed/
Oe/ ei
Jedt/
L{dlvxz ei Vldevj
Exlomo` Fvmli
Vlxa} Fvmli
*
*
*
*
*
*
* *
Ezklv
Cotplvmo` Fvmli
* *
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
* *ZEZCA7 ZEZCA7
Detzt xlv xc`l bc} oez l{dllj /38 ev cdz|ca detz! pkmdklylv mt altt/ =zk Dmvd|mz V|al 4="3/
Detz xlv
Xc`l
Co} ezklv vls|ltzt b|tz fl cddebxcomlj f} c tzczlbloz l{xacmomo` pk} zkl mzlb+t- tke|aj fl zc{lj
x|vt|coz ze =zk Dmvd|mz V|al 4="3/ Cjjmzmeoca mzlbt pmzke|z t|dk t|xxevzmo` tzczlblozt pmaa oez fl
deotmjlvlj/
Czzevol}t' illt dcooezfl vls|ltzlj eo zkmt ievb/
'' Ezklv7
Deozmo|l ze ol{z xc
Dctl7 38"39:;0 86%8;%6836 MJ7 ;898;:= JnzLozv}7 :
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
14/49
Ievb 38/ Fmaa ei Detzt " Deozmo|lj
M! ! tplcv |ojlv xlocaz} ei xlvg|v} zkcz zkl tlvymdlt iev pkmdk detzt cvl zc{l
plvl cdz|caa} coj oldlttcvma} xlvievblj! coj zkcz zkl vls|ltzlj detzt plvl cdz|caa} l{xlojlj ct amtzlj/
Tm`ocz|vl
Jczl
Ocbl ei De|otla7
Czzevol} iev7
Jczl Detzt cvl zc{lj mo zkl cbe|oz ei *
Dalvn ei De|vz
F}7 ! Jlx|z} Dalvn
+Ze Fl Debxalzlj f} zkl Dalvn-
+&t%& xa|t czzevol}'t ocbl mi t|fbmzzlj laldzveomdcaa}-
Dctl7 38"39:;0 86%8;%6836 MJ7 ;898;:= JnzLozv}7 :
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
15/49
Oe/ 38"39:;0
MO ZKL
\OMZLJ TZCZLT DE\VZ EI CXXLCATIEV ZKL OMOZK DMVD\MZ
NCZKV]O BDEBML"@VC]!
Xacmozmii"Cxxlaacoz!
y/
FCON EI CBLVMDC KEBL AECOT!
Jlilojcoz"Cxxlaall/
EO CXXLCA IVEB ZKL \OMZLJ TZCZLT JMTZVMDZ DE\VZ IEV ZKL
LCTZLVO JMTZVMDZ EI DCAMIEVOMC
Oe/ 678="dy"86::6
XLZMZMEO IEV XCOLA VLKLCVMO@ COJ VLKLCVMO@LO FCOD
Jcomla G/ B|aam`co
GLONMOT B\AAM@CO ) @CFVMLA AAX388;< Dcvveaa Dco}eo Vecj! T|mzl 638
Tco Jml`e! DC =6343+:3
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
16/49
m
ZCFAL EI DEOZLOZT
M/ MOZVEJ\DZMEO COJ V\AL 4
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
17/49
mm
ZCFAL EI C\ZKEVMZMLT
DCTLT
Fcvolt y/ Dkctl Kebl Imocodl! AAD! UU I/ T|xx/ 6j UU!6833 PA :=Gewmoeymdk y/ GX Bev`co Dkctl Fcon! 6838 PA 64:;=
mz vlaczlt ze zkl zmbl iev imamo` t|mz eodl dcodlaaczmeo kctfllo pveo`a} vli|tlj/ 3< \/T/D/ 394
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
27/49
;
moyedczmeo ei zkl vm`kz ei vltdmttmeo/ Tll Fcvolt! 6833 PA :=
Bmzdklaa y/ Fcon ei Cb/! 6833 PA 033
Xlcvdl y/ Fcon ei Cb/ Kebl Aecot! 6838 PA 64:;940! cz :< +O/J/ Dca/
G|ol ;! 6838- +deoda|jmo` zkcz zkl tzcz|zl ei vlxetl cxxamlt ze zkl vm`kz ei
vltdmttmeo |ojlv ZMAC coj oez zkl imamo` ei c acpt|mz->Gewmoeymdk y/ GX
Bev`co Dkctl Fcon! 6838 PA 64:;=< +O/J/ Dca/ Gco/ 3:! 6838- +vltdmttmeo
dacmb zmbla} mi aeco daetlj eo Bc} 38! 6889! pklvl deot|blv bcmalj
vltdmttmeo alzzlv eo Ilf/ 64! 688=! lylo zke|`k kl imalj t|mz eoa} eo G|ol 3!
688=-> Tcozet! 688= PA 6F|mdn y/ Pevaj Tcy/ Fcon! 940 I/ T|xx/ 6j 09Klvocojlw y/ Kmaazex Imo/ Bevz`/ ! 966 I/
T|xx/ 6j ;:6 +O/J/ Dca/ 6880- +eol"}lcv xlvmej ze imal t|mz v|ot iveb 68zk
jc} cizlv vltdmttmeo oezmdl! oez aczlv jczl pklo dvljmzev ic{lj alzzlv jlo}mo`
vltdmttmeo! f|z ls|mzcfal zeaamo` bcnlt t|mz zmbla}-/
C tldeoj jldmtmeo ei zkmt De|vz! Nmo` y/ Tzczl ei Dcamievomc! 0;: I/6j
=38 +=zk
Dmv/ 3=;9-! mt deotmtzloz pmzk zkl ymlp zkcz zkl deot|blv b|tz
vltdmoj pmzkmo zkl zkvll"}lcv xlvmej! coj kct eol }lcv cizlv zkcz ze imal t|mz mi
zkl dvljmzev vli|tlt ze xlvievb mzt vltdmttmeo efam`czmeot/ Mo c fvmli xcttc`l!
zkl jldmtmeo tzczlt zkcz Nmo`t dacmb iev vltdmttmeo ei eol ei klv aecot pct
Dctl7 38"39:;0 84%83%6836 MJ7 ;8;;8;4 JnzLozv}7
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
28/49
=
fcvvlj f} zkl zkvll"}lcv ambmzczmeo fldc|tl zkl xlvmej cxxamdcfal ze Nmo`
fl`co mo G|ol 3=0= coj l{xmvlj mo G|ol 3=;6! bevl zkco c }lcv flievl tkl
imalj t|mz/Mj/ cz =34 +lbxkctmt cjjlj-/ Pkmal zkl exmomeo jelt oez coca}wlzkl mozlvxac} flzpllo zkl zkvll"}lcv xlvmej coj zkl eol"}lcv xlvmej mo co}
jlzcma! mz l{xacmot zkcz zkl deot|blv de|aj kcyl imalj t|mz |x ze! f|z oez bevl
zkco! c }lcv cizlv vltdmojmo`/4
4Lylo mi zkl Xcola Exmomeo plvl devvldz mo mzt deoda|tmeo zkcz zkl ZMAC
tzcz|zl ei vlxetl vls|mvlt c acpt|mz fl debblodlj pmzkmo zkvll }lcvt! zkl
T|xvlbl De|vz kct bcjl dalcv! mo c dctl dmzlj f}Flcdk- coj Bm`|la ! zkczlylo c tzcz|zl ei vlxetl jelt oez tlvyl ct co cftea|zl fcv ze imamo` c acpt|mz/F|volzz y/ Olp ]evn Dlozvca V/V/ 4;8 \/T/ :6;! :6= +3=9
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
29/49
38
MMM/ ZKL S\LTZMEO VCMTLJ F] ZKMT DCTL MTL[DLXZMEOCAA] MBXEVZCOZ COJ PCVVCOZTLO FCOD
VLYMLP/
C/ Amzm`czmeo Cdvett zkl De|ozv} Vlialdzt Zkl OczmeopmjlMbxevzcodl Ei Zkl S|ltzmeo Vcmtlj F} Zkmt Dctl/
Xvljmdzcfa}! zkl xvlycalodl ei jmtdaet|vl ymeaczmeot xvltloz mo km`k"
detz aecot kct alj ze co cf|ojcodl ei xlojmo` amzm`czmeo vlaczlj ze zkl
cycmacfmamz} ei zkl l{zlojlj vm`kz ei vltdmttmeo/ Pkmal zklvl mt c jlcvzk ei
cxxlaaczl dctl acp eo zkl xcvzmd|acv mtt|l jldmjlj mo zkmt dctl! c o|bflv ei
dctlt mo ezklv dmvd|mzt zkcz vcmtl zkl mjlozmdca mtt|l cvl xlojmo` cxxlaaczl
vlymlp/ Tll! l/`/! Tklvwlv y/ Kebltzcv Bevz`/ Tlvyt/! cxxlca jednlzlj! Oe/
33":6 Peai y/ Ilj/ Ocz'a Bevz`/ Ctt'o! cxxlca
jednlzlj! Oe/ 33"6:3= +:zk Dmv/ Jld/ 64! 6833-> Nlmvco y/ Kebl Dcxmzca!
Mod/! cxxlca jednlzlj! Oe/ 33"4;0; +;zk Dmv/ Jld/ 48! 6833-> Tefmlomcn y/
FCD Kebl Aecot Tlvy/! AX! cxxlca jednlzlj! Oe/ 36"38Vetloimlaj y/ KTFD Fcon! \TC! cxxlca jednlzlj! Oe/ 38"3::6 +38zk
Dmv/ Tlxz/ 60! 6838-/
Lylo zkl Deot|blv Imocodmca Xvezldzmeo F|vlc| kct vlde`omwlj zkl
mbxevzcodl ei zkl dlozvca mtt|l ze zkmt dctl/ Zkl DIXF kct tzczlj zkcz zkl}
mozloj ze imal cbmd|t fvmlit tzczmo` zklmv xetmzmeo eo zkmt mtt|l eo Cxvma 34 mo
xetmzmeo eo zkl liildz ei c zeaamo` c`vllbloz! cizlv Xacmozmii kcj vlamlj |xeo
mz/ Zkl Xcola pct vls|mvlj ze vlymlp zkl xcvzmlt vltxldzmyl xetmzmeot flievl
cftea|zla} mbxetmo` c tzcz|zl ei vlxetl/ Zkl Xcola Exmomeot ebmttmeo eizkmt coca}tmt mt mo deozvcjmdzmeo ze pkcz T|xvlbl De|vz xvldljloz vls|mvlt/
Dctl7 38"39:;0 84%83%6836 MJ7 ;8;;8;4 JnzLozv}7
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
30/49
33
zkvll ei zkl cfeyl dctlt eo cxxlca7 Peai! Tklvwlv! coj Tefmlomcn/ Tll! l/`/!
Gemoz Bezmeo imalj f} Cbmd|t D|vmcl Deot|blv Imocodmca Xvezldzmeo F|vlc|
iev L{zlotmeo ei Zmbl! Tklvwlv! Oe/ 33":6
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
31/49
36
zkl} cvl olylvzklaltt zkl eoa} al`caa} bcojczlj blcot zkve|`k pkmdk
fevveplvt dco |ojlvtzcoj zkl ocz|vl ei zklmv aecot! mo zkl icdl ei fcmz coj
tpmzdk ev ezklv jmttlbfamo` zcdzmdt f} teblzmblt |otdv|x|ae|t bevz`c`lfvenlvt coj alojlvt/ @mylo zkl vls|mvlbloz zkcz ZMAC fl amflvcaa} deotzv|lj
mo icyev ei zkl deot|blv! zkl vltdmttmeo vm`kz tke|aj fl tzvmdza} loievdlj ct c
blcot ei jlzlvvmo` mvvltxeotmfal alojmo`/
%%%
%%%
%%%
%X86
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
32/49
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
33/49
3:
DLVZMIMDCZL EI DEBXAMCODL PMZK Z]XL"YEA\BLAMBMZCZMEO! Z]XLICDL VLS\MVLBLOZT! COJ Z]XL TZ]AL
VLS\MVLBLOZT
3/ Zkmt fvmli debxamlt pmzk zkl z}xl"yea|bl ambmzczmeo ei Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/46+c-+0-+F- fldc|tl zkmt fvmli deozcmot 4!388 pevjt ct de|ozlj f} zkl
Bmdveteiz Pevj 6880 pevj xvedlttmo` t}tzlb/
6/ Zkmt fvmli debxamlt pmzk zkl z}xlicdl vls|mvlblozt ei Ilj/ V/ Cxx/ X/46+c-+
-
8/2/2019 McOmie-Gray Opinion 2 8 2012 TILA and Petition for Rehearing -Ninth Circuit
34/49
3