9/21/2015
1
Public Perceptions of Genetically Modified Food
Cara L. Cuite, PhD
Associate Research Professor
Rutgers Cooperative Extension
Department of Human Ecology
September 17, 2015
• Long before we began to understand evolution and genetics, humans have been improving plant and animal species through a variety of techniques, including selective breeding and cross breeding.
9/21/2015
2
Genetic Modification/Genetic Engineering
• This process allows scientists to select specific genetic traits from one organism and insert them into the genetic code of another organism.– E.g., Inserting a bacterium gene into a corn plant, or an ocean
pout gene into a salmon.
• This was not possible using conventional methods. • As a result, agricultural products can be improved in a
faster, more accurate way.
What to Call this Process?
• Genetic Engineering?• Genetic Modification?• Biotechnology?
• What you call it matters.– 1/3 have no first thought or image related to the terms
• Biotechnology evokes the most neutral responses
• GM and GE evoke more negative images
9/21/2015
3
What to Call this Process?
Most of the world refers to the technology as genetic modification (GM) and to its products as genetically modified organisms or GMOs.
Google Trend Search Results
• Agricultural Biotechnology: ~ 4,800,000 results• Genetically Engineered: ~ 5,140,000 results• Genetically Modified: ~ 15,100,000 results• GMO: ~ 82,100,000 results
9/21/2015
4
European Labeling
• Pre-packaged products containing >.09% GMO ingredients, the list of ingredients must indicate "genetically modified" or "produced from genetically modified [name of the organism]."
US Labeling - Proposed
Genetically Modified
Genetically Engineered
• Alaska• Colorado• Georgia• Hawaii• Illinois• Kentucky• Maine• Maryland• Massachusetts• Minnesota
• New Hampshire
• New York• Oklahoma• Oregon• Pennsylvania• Rhode Island*• Tennessee• Vermont• Washington• West Virginia
• Missouri• New Jersey• Rhode Island*
9/21/2015
5
“GMO” is politicized
• GMO has been widely used by opponents of this technique as well as labeling advocacy groups.
Genetically Modified Foods or GM Foods
9/21/2015
7
Rapid Adoption in the US
• The United States remains the largest producer of GM agricultural products.• More than 181 million acres planted in GM crop varieties.• US harvests about 40% of the world's GM crops.
9/21/2015
8
US Crop Estimates - 2015
4 512
94 94
10
9577 79
7 6 6 6 5
0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%
100%
Corn Canola Soy Cotton SugarBeet
Conventional
Stacked Traits
HerbicideToleranceBT
USDA/ ERS: Genetically engineered varieties of corn, upland cotton, and soybeans, by State and for the United States, 2000-2015
Other GM Crops in the US
• Herbicide Tolerant Alfalfa• Virus Resistant Squash and Papaya
9/21/2015
9
GM Crops in the US (on the way)
• Apples that resist browning• Potatoes that resist bruising and produce low levels of
acrylamide when cooked at high heat
GM Crops (Approved but not Commercialized)
• Virus Resistant Plum• Color-Modified Rose• Delayed Softening Tomato• Male-Sterile Chicory
• Herbicide-Tolerant Tobacco• Herbicide-Tolerant Rice• Herbicide-Tolerant Flax
9/21/2015
10
Prevalence of GM Ingredients?
1. The U.S. government does not track nor trace GM ingredients.
2. GM varieties are sometimes mixed with non-GM varieties when stored.
3. Corn, soy, sugar, and canola are four of the most common ingredients in processed foods.
4. The majority of soy, corn, canola, and sugar beet used in processed foods is genetically modified.
Products that Might Contain GM Ingredients
• Soda, juice, candy, cookies, sweet snacks, cereal, or any other product that contains corn components or corn syrup
• Products with sugar from sugar beets
– 54% of the sugar sold in the US• Food with soy-based flavorings,
vegetable broth, hydrolyzed vegetable proteins, foods that contain gums or starches
• Canola oil or products that contain canola ingredients
• Products containing cotton seed oil
9/21/2015
11
GM Ingredients
• Estimates are that as much as 80% of processed foods on US shelves contain “GM ingredients.”
• BUT…This is hard to determine exactly, because the refining of most oils, corn syrup, and sugar removes any DNA from the product.
• So what is a GM ingredient?
• Bottom Line:Most of the processed foods you eat likely contain ingredients derived from GM crops.
RUTGERS SURVEY
1. What does the American public know about GM foods?
2. How does the American public feel about GM foods?
3. Do Americans want labels on GM foods?
9/21/2015
12
Survey Methodology
• Conducted using GfK Custom Research online survey panel
• Data collected October 23-27, 2013 • 1,148 respondents• Data weighted to project to the US population• Margin of error +/- 3.1%
Sample demographics
48.4% WomenMean age 50 yearsEducation• 40% high school or less• 28% some college or associates degree• 32% bachelors degree or higherEthnicity• 78% White, non-Hispanic• 7% Black, non-Hispanic• 10% Hispanic• 3% multi-racial and other
9/21/2015
13
Survey definition of GM foods
• Recruitment materials did not mention GM.• Initial questions about reading food labels and information people
thought should be on food labels.
• Introduction to GM:
“The remainder of this survey will focus on genetically modified foods.
Genetic modification involves methods that make it possible for scientists to create new plants and animals by taking parts of the genes of one plant or animal and inserting them into the cells of another plant or animal.
This process is sometimes called genetic engineering or biotechnology, and the plants and animals that result are sometimes called GMOs, or genetically modified organisms. Foods using ingredients made from these are often referred to as genetically modified foods or GM foods.”
Awareness of the Existence of GM Foods
• Before this survey, were you aware that genetically modified foods existed?– 25% say no
Rutgers 2013 Survey
N=1148
9/21/2015
14
Heard or Read?
• How much have you heard or read about genetically modified foods?• A great deal 4%• A fair amount 13%• Some 33%• Very little 29%• Nothing at all 19%
• Refused 2%
Rutgers 2013 Survey
48%
N=1148
How Much Do You Know?
• How much do you know about genetically modified foods?• A great deal 2%• A fair amount 11%• Some 32%• Very little 32%• Nothing at all 21%
• Refused 2%
Rutgers 2013 Survey
53%
N=1148
9/21/2015
15
Ever Talked about GM Foods?
• Have you ever discussed genetically modified foods with anyone?– 2/3 say no
Rutgers 2013 Survey N=1148
GM Foods in Stores Now?
• As far as you know, are there any foods containing genetically modified ingredients in supermarkets right now?
– Yes 43%– No 4%– Don’t know 51%– Refused 2%
Rutgers 2013 SurveyN=1148
9/21/2015
16
Perceived Availability of GM Foods
Percent of 491 Consumers who said GM foods are available in U.S. Supermarkets
GM food products currently available in supermarkets
GM food products NOT currently available in supermarkets
Rutgers 2013 Surveyn=491
Ever Eaten GM Foods?
• As far as you know, have you ever eaten any food containing genetically modified ingredients?– Only 26% say yes
Rutgers 2013 Survey N=1148
9/21/2015
17
Do Americans Have Opinions About GM Foods?• Our survey shows that people say they do not know
much about GM foods.– They are not talking or reading much about it.
• And why would they?
• This doesn’t mean that they do not or should not have an opinion about it.
Public Opinions About GM Foods
• Relatively uninformed opinions can be considered “uncrystallized.”
• These opinions tend to be:– Not well thought through.– Not strongly held.– Subject to change.– Influenced by the wording of questions.
• They are still important.
9/21/2015
21
What is the Basis for Opinions of GM foods?
• Would you say your opinion of genetically modified foods is based on a general feeling or specific issues?– General feeling – 50%– Both – 34%– Specific issues – 15%– Refused – 1%
N=1148
9/21/2015
22
Issues of Concern
“Please put a check next to all the issues that are related to your opinion of GM foods.”
%
Beliefs about GM foods
We know people aren’t reading or talking much about GM foods, but…• What are they reading about GM foods?• What stories or rumors have they heard?
– If they haven’t heard them, how likely are they to believe them?
9/21/2015
24
Decisions About The Veracity of GM Stories and Information
Hallman, Cuite, Morin, 2013
Decisions About The Veracity of Claims / “Facts”
Hallman, Cuite, Morin, 2013
9/21/2015
25
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Foods labeled as natural should be allowedto contain GM ingredients
Foods labeled as organic should be allowedto contain GM ingredients
I don't care if the food I buy contains GMingredients
I am careful never to buy food with GMingredients
I think it is safe for me to eat GM food
I would pay more for food that was NOTGM
I prefer to buy organic foods when I can
Attitudes about GM Food
Strongly Agree Somewhat Agree Somewhat Disagree
Strongly Disagree Refused
Note. “Unsure” was not offered as a response option
9/21/2015
26
Do Americans Think GM Foods Should Be Labeled?
Labels are not currently required
• Based on the scientific evidence, the FDA has concluded that current GM crops are not substantially different from their conventionally bred counterparts, and thus do not require labels.
• The FDA does require special labeling of a GM food when the characteristics of a familiar food product have been substantially altered.• E.g., if an allergen is introduced, or its nutritional qualities have
been altered. • Even then the label doesn’t have to say GM.
9/21/2015
27
USDA Organic Standard
• Products meeting the USDA organic standard are not permitted to contain GM ingredients.
Exceptions to organic rule
• The organic standard does not apply to GM animal products.
9/21/2015
28
Voluntary program for label certifying as NOT containing GM ingredients
Label Reading
• Beyond just looking at the brand name, how often do you read food labels?• Always – 10%• Frequently – 36%• Sometimes – 36%• Rarely – 14%• Never – 4%
• Refused – 1%
18%
N=1148
9/21/2015
29
Are GM Foods Required to be Labeled?
• Are foods that contain genetically modified ingredients required by law to be labeled as such in the US?
– Only 26% say no
Rutgers 2013 Survey N=1148
Do Americans want GM foods labeled?
• How you ask matters…
9/21/2015
30
Labeling Question 1
BEFORE MENTIONING GM FOODS• What information (if any) would you like to see on food labels
that is not already on there?
• No additional information needed—70%
• Presence of genetically modified ingredients – 7%• Country/Place of origin – 6%• Clearer information about ingredients – 4%• More information about nutrition – 4%• Others (each less than 2%)
Labeling Question 2
AFTER DEFINING GM FOODS• How important is it to you that the following information be
on a food label? (very or extremely important)• Grown using hormones (63%), • Grown using pesticides (62%), • Raised using antibiotics (61%),• Whether it was grown or raised in the United States (60%), • Whether the product contains allergens (59%)• Whether the product contains genetically modified ingredients
(59%)
9/21/2015
31
Labeling Question 3
• Current regulations do not require genetically modified foods to be labeled in the US. Do you think that genetically modified foods should be required to be labeled?– Only 8% say no– 17% are unsure– 73% say yes
Rutgers 2013 Survey
What about other studies of GM labeling preferences?
9/21/2015
32
• National polls indicate that when asked directly “should GM/GE foods be labeled” more than 9 in 10 Americans say “yes”.
National Surveys of Public Opinion of GM Foods
93 92
7366 63
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Reuters/NPR CR Rutgers AP IFIC
% w
ho s
ay th
ey w
ant l
abel
ing
9/21/2015
33
National Surveys of Public Opinion of GM Foods
93 92
7366 63
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Reuters/NPR CR Rutgers AP IFIC
% w
ho s
ay th
ey w
ant l
abel
ing
National Surveys of Public Opinion of GM Foods
93 92
7366 63
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Reuters/NPR CR Rutgers AP IFIC
% w
ho s
ay th
ey w
ant l
abel
ing
No DK/Unsure response option Has DK/Unsure response option
9/21/2015
34
Should GM Foods be Required to be Labeled?
• Current regulations do not require genetically modified foods to be labeled in the US. Do you think that genetically modified foods should be required to be labeled?– Only 8% say no– 17% are unsure– 73% say yes
Rutgers 2013 Survey
If not sure and refused are eliminated:
90% say yes
What percentage of Americans want GM foods labeled?
• 7%• 59%• 73%• Or higher?
It depends on how you ask.
9/21/2015
35
Who wants GM foods labeled?
What variables are related to belief that GM foods should be labeled?• Three separate logistic regression models
– DV 1: Volunteered would like GM on label– DV 2: GM Labels important– DV 3: GM labels should be required
9/21/2015
36
What variables are related to belief that GM foods should be labeled?• Predictor variables in models:
– Scale of Engagement with GM foods (aware GM existed, ever discussed, heard or read, self-assessed knowledge, awareness sold in stores, awareness GM labels not required, alpha =.82)
– Scale of approval of plant-based and animal-based GM foods (alpha = .80)
– Rating of safety of GM food– Opinion is based on specific issue vs. general feeling
• Demographic variables– Age– Gender – Education– Ethnicity
Logistic regression models
DV1: Volunteered GM on labels DV2: GM Labeling is important DV3: GM foods should be labeled
B Wald OR B Wald. OR B Wald OR
Engagement scale .445 33.992 1.560*** .076 3.705 1.078 .010 .048 1.010
Disapproval scale 1.163 20.418 3.199*** .612 30.230 1.843*** 1.078 44.377 2.939***
GM unsafe.598 8.022 1.818** .919 57.359 2.506*** .948 38.656 2.580***
Opinion based on
specific issue
-.071 .051 .931 .263 2.226 1.301 -.567 7.114 .567**
Gender .236 .757 1.267 -.399 6.236 .671* .129 .429 1.138
Ethnicity .111 .103 1.117 .329 2.346 1.389 .287 1.146 1.332
Age -.020 4.965 .980* .011 4.760 1.011* .011 3.328 1.011
Education 29.794 ** 11.477 10.328
Constant -7.430 51.833 .001 -3.942 39.915 .019 -2.233 10.410 .107
Cox & Snell R2 .205 .257 .231
Note. * p <.05, **p <.01, *** p <.001
9/21/2015
37
Who wants labeling?
• Engagement with GM foods is related to mentioning it in the open-ended labeling question.
• Saying your opinion is based on a specific issue is related to not believing GM foods should be labeled.
• Being older and being female is related to thinking GM food labels are important.
• Main finding, holds true across the three models:– Belief that GM foods are unsafe is related to belief that GM food
should be labeled.– Disapproving of plant- and animal-based GM foods is related to
the belief that GM foods should be labels.
• There is another way American consumers have been asked about GM food labeling.
• Opinions expressed in survey ≠ voting behavior
9/21/2015
38
Labeling Referenda
California (Proposition 37) 2012• 51% no; 49% yes
Washington State (Initiative 522) 2013• 51% no; 49% yes
Oregon (Measure 92) 2014 • defeated by just over 800 votes.
Colorado (Proposition 105) 2014• 66% voted against labeling bill.
GM Food LabelingInitiatives
9/21/2015
39
“Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act of 2015”• H.R.1599 – refers to “genetically engineered food”• Amends the Food Drug and Cosmetics Act (FDCA)
– No label can suggest that non-GE foods are safer than GE foods.– A food can be labeled as non-GE even if it is produced with a GE
processing aid or enzyme or derived from animals fed GE feed or given GE drugs.
– The FDA must allow, but not require, GE food to be labeled as GE.– The FDA must regulate the use of “natural” on food labels.– Preempts state and local restrictions on GE food and labeling
requirements for GE food, non-GE food, or “natural” food.
• Requires the USDA Ag Marketing Service to establish a program to certify non-GE food.
https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/1599
“Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act of 2015”• H.R.1599 – refers to “genetically engineered food”• “(3) The term ‘genetically engineered plant’ refers to a
plant or plant product (as those terms are defined in section 403 of the Plant Protection Act (7 U.S.C. 7702)), if—– “(A) it contains genetic material that has been modified through in
vitro recombinant deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) techniques; and – “(B) the modification could not otherwise be obtained using
conventional breeding techniques.
https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/1599
9/21/2015
40
Arguments in Favor of Labeling
• Proponents argue that labeling of GM food products would offer increased choices to consumers– Proponents say they have the “right to know” so they can
exercise their religious, philosophical, or dietary preferences.– Proponents want the ability to use market forces to express their
political views in support or opposition to the use of GM technology.
Some proponents say it would not significantly affect the cost of food.
Arguments Against Labeling• Maintaining “identity preservation” can be
logistically difficult– This may be especially true of processed foods with many
ingredients
• Changing the systems to maintain this could be costly
• Could create a patchwork across states.• Labels might be seen as warnings.
– Labels could imply that GM food products or ingredients are harmful or of lower quality than those produced through conventional means.
9/21/2015
41
How will labeling rules deal with other related technologies?
Mutation Breeding
• Rice• Corn• Wheat• Barley• Pears• Peas• Cotton• Peppermint
• Peanuts• Grapefruit • Sesame • Bananas • Cassava• Sorghum• Sunflowers
Mutation breeding using gamma radiation and chemicalshas produced a significant proportion of the world’s commercial food crops, including varieties of:
9/21/2015
42
Mutation Breeding
Gene Editing
CRISPR: (Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats)
– Segments of prokaryotic DNA containing short repetitions of base sequences
– Each repetition is followed by short segments of "spacer DNA" from previous exposures to a bacterial virus or plasmid
• Gene Editing– adding, disrupting or changing the sequence of specific genes
• Gene Regulation
9/21/2015
43
Future research?
• How does the public view these related technologies?– Do/can many Americans make distinctions between a trans-
species DNA transfer compared to altering the genes within a given organism?
• This is where some of our research is headed.
Conclusions
• For many, opinions about GM foods are not strongly held.– People report that they do not know much about GM foods.– Many people say opinions are based on a feeling.– People’s opinions may change as they learn more.
• Does the public want GM foods labeled?– Depends on how you ask.– When asking at the ballot box, we see a very different response
than in public opinion polling.
• The policy and technological landscape is changing rapidly.
9/21/2015
44
Acknowledgements
• Collaborators Drs. William Hallman and Xenia Morin
• Survey was sponsored by the Office of the Executive Dean, School of Environmental and Biological Sciences. – The opinions expressed are those of the author and do not
necessarily reflect official positions or policies of Rutgers, the State University of New Jersey.
For More Information:
Download our most recent whitepaper here:http://humeco.rutgers.edu/documents_PDF/n
ews/GMlabelingperceptions.pdf
Cara L. Cuite, PhDAssociate Research ProfessorDepartment of Human EcologyRutgers Cooperative ExtensionRutgers, The State University of New JerseyNew Brunswick, NJ 08901-8520(848) [email protected]