SKAGEN Focus
Status Report November 2016
2
• The fund is a highly concentrated equity fund with a broad all-global mandate. The overall objective is to invest in a few
select investments with an exceptional risk/reward profile from an absolute return perspective.
• The target number of positions is 30-35 and the top ten positions should constitute 40-50% of the portfolio. At the end of the
month, the fund holds 35 positions, and the top ten positions account for 43% of the portfolio. The cash position is 6.7%.
• SKAGEN Focus* was up 2.5% in the month measured in EUR, while the global equity markets (measured as MSCI AC
World) were up 4.2%. In 2016, the fund is up 13.2% while the global equity markets are up 8.5%.
• Whiting Petroleum, Citizens Financial and Taiheiyo Cement were the strongest contributors to the fund’s performance in
November measured as absolute contribution in NOK. TerraVia, Fila Korea and Schaeffler were the main detractors during
the month.
• During the month we initiated a position in Tesoro, a US refiner (see attached fact sheet for more information). Our position
in US mid-cap bank Citizens Financial was sold out as the stock reached our price target. Copper miner First Quantum was
also sold out following a strong re-rating of the shares towards our price target.
• The fund has a broad mandate to invest in all geographies and sectors. The fund is also market capitalisation-agnostic, and
currently small-cap** positions constitute 19% of the fund, while mid-cap and large-cap positions account for 41% and 38%,
respectively. These figures may vary meaningfully over time.
Summary – November 2016
* Unless otherwise stated, all performance data in this report relates to class A units and is net of fees.
** Small-cap defined as market cap below USD 2bn, large-cap more than USD 10bn.
3
Note: All returns beyond 12 months are annualised (geometric return)
* Inception date: 26 May 2015
Results, November 2016 in EUR
A
November QTD YTD Since inception*
SKAGEN Focus A 2,5% 3,6% 13,2% -2,8%
World Index* 4,2% 5,5% 8,5% 0,4%
Excess return -1,7% -1,8% 4,7% -3,3%
4
-12-11
-10-9
-8-6-6
-6-5-5
-4-4
-2-1-1-1
-1-1
00
01
12
22
23
34
55
67
9
DENMARK SOUTH AFRICA
FINLAND NETHERLANDS
GERMANY
AUSTRIA HUNGARY
KOREA SWITZERLAND
FRANCE THAILAND
HONG KONG JAPAN
SWEDEN NEW ZEALAND
NORWAY CHINA
SKAGEN Focus A UK
MSCI ACWI SINGAPORE
RUSSIA CANADA
USA GREECE
INDIA MALAYSIA
POLAND PORTUGAL
SPAIN CZECH BRAZIL
INDONESIA MEXICO TURKEY
Markets in November 2016 in EUR (%)
5
4
13
-9-8-8
-7-7-6
-5-2-2-2
-2-2
01
3
4
888
91111
12
1314
2022
2325
3250
INDIA FRANCE
NETHERLANDS JAPAN
SINGAPORE AUSTRIA
CHINA MSCI ACWI
KOREA HONG KONG
NORWAY UNITED STATES
INDONESIA SKAGEN Focus A
SOUTH AFRICA TAIWAN
NEW ZEALAND THAILAND HUNGARY
RUSSIA BRAZIL
POLAND
MALAYSIA
GERMANY PORTUGAL
SWEDEN UNITED KINGDOM
CZECH REPUBLIC
SPAIN SWITZERLAND
MEXICO TURKEY FINLAND
Markets YTD 2016 in EUR (%)
6
Sector distribution Geographical distribution
8
9
4
18
11
11
3
4
7
0
9
0
11
6
21
7
0
3
16
18
10
12
5
7
Health Care
Consumer Staples
Consumer Discretionary
Industrials
Materials
Energy
Cash
Utilities
Telecommunication Services
Real Estate
Information Technology
Financials
2
18
1
2
7
1
32
0
4
1
23
17
13
0
2
57
1
1
8
10
Cash
The Nordics
Oceania
North America
Middle East & Africa
Latin America
Europe EM
Europe DM ex. The Nordics
Asia EM
Asia DM Index
Fund
Sector and geographical distribution vs index (Nov. 2016)
7
Holdings increased and decreased during November 2016
Key buys
• Tesoro (new) – please see fact sheet at the end of the report
• E-MART – position size increased following signs that company
turnaround is on track
• Whiting Petroleum – position size increased as balance sheet
is improving faster than expected and valuation looks
increasingly attractive
Key sells
• First Quantum (out) – the position was sold out following
strong re-rating of the shares
• Citizens Financial (out) – the shares of this US mid-cap bank
reached our price target and were sold out in the month
• Pilgrim’s Pride – position size lowered as uncertainty around
litigation risk continues to loom
8
Largest holdings in SKAGEN Focus
As of 30/11-2016
*JBS is the main owner of Pilgrim’s Pride, which is a 1.2% position in the fund. These two positions should be viewed as one, with a total weight of 5.2%.
Price P/E P/E P/BV Price Upside to Holding
2016e 2017e last target target % size, %
American International Group Inc 63,33 16,7 11,6 0,7 90 42 % 8,0%
Taiheiyo Cement Corp 358,00 9,1 10,9 1,3 420 17 % 4,4%
E-MART Inc 188 000,00 15,5 13,5 0,7 270 000 44 % 4,4%
Softbank Group Corp 6 712,00 7,6 10,9 3,2 9 600 43 % 4,3%
Jbs SA 9,76 45,2 6,5 1,1 22 125 % 4,1%
SBI Holdings Inc 1 432,00 12,8 12,9 0,8 3 000 109 % 4,1%
Teva Pharmaceutical-Sp ADR 37,70 7,4 6,9 1,1 90 139 % 3,9%
China Telecom Corp Ltd 3,75 15,8 13,9 1,0 8 113 % 3,6%
Tesoro Corp 81,35 16,0 13,3 1,7 120 48 % 3,5%
Infineon Technologies AG 15,78 19,9 17,4 3,5 20 27 % 3,4%
Top 10 positions 12,9 10,8 1,1 63,1% 43,4%
Total Equity (35 positions) 93,3 %
Cash 6,7 %
Total Portfolio 100,0%
9
Largest positive contributors Largest negative contributors
Main contributors MTD 2016
NB: Contribution to absolute return
Value Creation MTD (NOK MM): 30
Company NOK (000)
Whiting Petroleum 10 725
Citizens Financial Group 10 595
Taiheiyo Cement 7 335
AIG 7 194
Synchrony Financial 6 258
Company NOK (000)
TerraVia Holdings -11 095
Fila Korea -8 511
Schaeffler -5 562
Pilgrim's Pride -4 966
Rentech -4 499
10
Largest positive contributors Largest negative contributors
Main contributors QTD 2016
NB: Contribution to absolute return
Value Creation QTD (NOK MM): 52
Company NOK (000)
AIG 15 259
Citizens Financial Group 15 028
First Quantum Minerals 10 442
Whiting Petroleum 9 913
Taiheiyo Cement 9 479
Company NOK (000)
TerraVia Holdings -15 108
Fila Korea -12 343
Jbs -10 772
Teva Pharmaceutical Industries -6 390
Schaeffler -5 888
11
Largest positive contributors Largest negative contributors
Main contributors YTD 2016
NB: Contribution to absolute return
Value Creation YTD (NOK MM): 99
Company NOK (000)
South32 27 594
Pan American Silver Corp 23 180
First Quantum Minerals 22 266
AirAsia BHD 20 030
Haitai Confectionery & Foods Co Ltd 15 971
Company NOK (000)
Teva Pharmaceutical Industries -14 552
Fila Korea -13 008
TerraVia Holdings -11 685
Schaeffler -10 281
Rentech -9 181
12
Most important changes Q4 2016
Tesoro (New)
E-MART
Whiting Petroleum
Teva Pharmaceutical
Industries
Samsung SDI
China Telecom
Jbs
Fila Korea
Philips Lighting
Alphabet
Taiheiyo Cement
Jenoptik
Softbank Group
First Quantum Minerals (Out)
Aercap Holdings (Out)
Citizens Financial
Group
South32
Pilgrim's Pride
SK Hynix
Synchrony Financial
Holdings reduced Q4 Q4 Holdings increased
13
Key earnings releases and corporate news, November 2016
SBI Holdings
(4.1% weight)
Investment case update
Neutral. SBI Holdings is a complex conglomerate within the financial sector in Japan, with many activities in venture capital and financial holdings,
including private and public pharmaceutical companies; thus, the company reporting always contains mark-to-market accounting which makes headline
numbers not very indicative of their operations. The company is the country’s largest online broker.
The financial services business profits grew 1% in the first half of 2016 versus the previous year, implicitly gaining market share in a falling market. The
biotech division had a drawdown of JPY 4,936 million, primarily due to an already published failed drug, while asset management had a very solid JPY
2,877 million gain (versus -262 in first half of 2015, indicating the erratic numbers described above).
SBI Savings Bank of South Korea seems to be turning around, and Investment Banking is involved in 19 deals in 2016. The pharma pipeline is very
broad in pharmaceuticals, but we consider this option-value only. The company, in yet another division, has become active in the FinTech/blockchain
space during the year.
AIG
(8.0% weight)
Investment case update
Compared to our original investment thesis, AIG continues to deliver on exiting non-core assets and increasing financial leverage, from a very low base,
to return a significant amount of capital to shareholders in the form of buy-backs below book value. After an exceptionally strong 2Q, this quarter
showed a mixed picture on the operational turnaround in its underperforming commercial P&C business. While cost reductions seem to be ahead of
targets, underwriting did not continue its improvement this quarter, and the adverse developments in the prior year’s reserve is clearly an issue we
hoped AIG had moved past.
Fact
Our operational turnaround case is all about commercial P&C. On costs, the company continued to reduce costs, improving the expense ratio to 27.6%
(vs. 29.6% in 3Q15) and the company seems to be ahead of its very ambitious targets. On underwriting, the quarter did not continue the strong
improvement we saw last quarter. While the core loss ratio improved 190bps to 64.8% it did deteriorate from 61.7% in 2Q. Management remains
confident of its 62%/60% targets by 2016/17 as they are making progress in portfolio optimisation. The big disappointment was adverse prior year
reserve developments (adding 5 points to the combined ratio). AIG has returned USD 9.8bn to shareholders YTD. With recently announced divestitures,
the company seems to be on track to exceed its deployment target of at least 25bn through year end 2017 – current market cap is USD 61bn.
14
Key earnings releases and corporate news, November 2016 (cont.)
SK Hynix
(3.2% weight)
Investment thesis update:
Positive. SK Hynix reported solid 3Q16 results benefitting from improved market conditions due to increased seasonal demand and better than
expected PC demand and orderly supply additions leading pricing to continue to increase. Revenue increased 8% QoQ while operating profit grew by
60% QoQ, with a margin level of 17% (11% during Q2). The strong increase in profit was mainly driven by the increased cost savings and reversed
inventory losses.
Going forward the company expects supply constraints and low inventory for DRAM to boost industry pricing. An increased proportion of production
from their new 21nm plant and improving yields, should benefit profitability going forward. The stock has been strong this year, up almost 40% (KRW)
following a volatile start of the year. As the stock went from one of our top 5 losers to a top 10 net gainer, we have decreased the position and adjusted
its target weight.
Facts
The company reported Q3 2016 sales of KRW 4.2tn with an operating profit of KRW 726bn and EBITDA of KRW 1800bn.
China Telecom
(3.1% weight)
Investment case update
China Telecom is the second largest telecom service provider behind China Mobile, in a maturing industry yet with potentially massive growth in data
downloads. In Q3, total operating revenue grew 7% YoY while operating expenses grew by 8% (driven by tower rentals and network
expansion). EBITDA decreased somewhat (margin down 2pp) while net profit increased 9%, mainly due to reduced financing costs and depreciation
that has now been moved to the TowerCo. The mobile service segment (40% of sales) continues to be the main growth driver of sales, driven by
increased 4G penetration and the increased subscriber base. Handset data traffic grew by 117% YoY and 24% during the quarter. The wireline
segment revenue (50% of sales) increased by 5% supported by growth in both volume and number of subscribers. Given that there has been no
change to the full year capex target indicates that the period with elevated capex levels is potentially coming to an end and could draw attention to the
attractive mid-term free cash flow dynamics of the company. The stock is attractive on current earnings power, and at a major discount to other industry
peers at EV/EBITDA of less than 4x.
Fact
In Q316, the company reported revenue of RMB 87bn. EBITDA decreased to RMB 25.5bn. The company added 5.6m mobile subscribers to the current
total base of 212.5m and added 2.7m wireline broad band subscribers to the current total base of 121m.
15
Key earnings releases and corporate news, November 2016 (cont.)
Softbank
(4.3% weight)
Investment thesis update:
Softbank is a Japanese telecom and internet conglomerate with its main assets in Chinese online-giant Alibaba, US-based telecom operator Sprint and
Domestic Telecom businesses (mainly Softbank Mobile). In Q217, overall sales fell 3% while EBITDA grew 5% over last year. The Domestic Telecom
business posted a marginal increase in revenues but EBITDA 5% higher than last year. Sprint continued to show signs of recovery as margins rose to
29% (25% a year ago) and are contributing solidly. Yahoo Japan posted surprisingly strong numbers with sales up 48% and EBITDA up 18%. The
recently acquired processor developer ARM Holdings was consolidated from Sep 6, only marginally impacting quarterly results. The company
announced the set-up of the “Softbank Vision Fund”, an IT focused fund of up to USD 100bn over the next five years. Softbank indicated it will
contribute 25% of the assets (Saudi Arabia’s public investment fund stands for 45%) and funding will come gradually from free cash flow. In this set-up,
Softbank will collect fees and will be able to invest without overly burdening the balance sheet. Following the quite controversial ARM deal, net
debt/EBITDA stands at 4.0x which is supported by the relatively stable cash flows from the domestic telecom business. Management stated a goal to
reduce debt to 3-3.5x in the next few years. We believe the implicit share discount to conservative fair value of the underlying assets, assuming the
price paid for ARM Holdings, is fair in a longer term perspective. It is in excess of 30% and then there is very little value attached to the myriad of
unlisted transport and e-commerce stakes acquired by the company over the last few years.
Facts
In Q217, sales decreased 3% to JPY 2145bn while EBITDA rose 5% to JPY 655bn (margin of 31% vs 28% last year).
Samsung SDI
(2.0% weight)
Investment case update
The SDI share has suffered somewhat due to the Note 7 recall. The current share price reflects the value of net cash (KRW 20k per share) and value of
its 15.2% stake in Samsung Display (KRW 70k) only. Hence, we get the KRW 18k/share in listed shares and all operating divisions for free. Even
applying a zero value to its loss-making large battery/ESS operations, operating activities are still worth KRW 35k/share. The buy-back announcement
signals that the board share our view on valuation.
Facts
3Q16 operating loss of KRW 110bn marks a significant worsening from KTW -54bn in 2Q16 and was due to KRW c95bn costs related to recall of
Galaxy Note 7. Adjusted for this, small battery had an operating profit of KRW 10bn for a margin of 1.6%. Samsung has not yet announced the reasons
for the Note 7 problems but as phones with batteries from a second supplier ATL were also affected, this might not be a battery production issue. If so,
SDI should get reimbursements from Samsung. Large battery/ESS grew sales by 5% QoQ and 25% YoY to KRW 223bn, despite the lack of market
access in China, where timing of access or access at all remain uncertain. Operating loss narrowed from KRW 95bn in 2Q16 to 64bn. Electronic
materials had more or less flat sales of KRW 439bn with stable operating profit QoQ of KRW 39bn. SDI announced that it will spend KRW 300bn on a
buy-back of c4.8% of shares in the next three months, which is well covered by a net cash position of KRW 1.44tr.
16
Key earnings releases and corporate news, November 2016 (cont.)
Schaeffler
(2.8% weight)
Investment thesis update:
Schaeffler is a Germany-based automotive/industrial company; mainly active in engine and transmission systems (auto) as well as bearings (industrial).
The company executed, with exceptionally poor timing, an IPO of its shares in the middle of the Volkswagen emission scandal in October 2015. In
Q316, revenue rose 1% where Automotive was the strongest contributor (77% of sales) increasing 4%, while the industrial segment posted a revenue
decline of 7% over last year. Overall EBIT margin contracted to 12.8% from 13.4% sending EBIT lower by 4% primarily due to poor margin within the
industrial division. From a geographic perspective, China grew 16% and now constitutes 15% of total sales. The results from the industrial side in
particular are on the weak side, and the company launched yet another restructuring program and intends to cut 500 jobs and consolidate plant
capacity within this division. The company reaffirmed recent guidance for FY16 at 3-5% revenue growth, 12-13% EBIT margin and free cash flow of
EUR 600m, indicating a substantial cash yield. The company has been successful in de-levering its balance sheet and, based on current earnings
power and potential margin improvements ahead, we think the stock should trade at least in line with other high-quality auto-parts/industrial names, and
suggest the initial upside to be about EUR 18-19/share.
Facts
Revenue increased 1% to EUR 3.3bn in Q316. EBIT decreased by 4% to EUR 417m, equivalent to a margin of 12.8%. Net income increased 16% to a
level of EUR 178m. FCF amounted to EUR 264m. Management confirmed full-year guidance.
E-mart
(4.4% weight)
Investment case update
E-mart is a Korea-based company principally engaged in the hypermarket business. The company has been struggling with saturation in its core
discount format and increasing competition from new online entrants. The company reported consolidated sales growth of 10% while operating profit
grew by 11%. Profitability improvement was seen across core segments. Same-store sales in the hypermarket segment were up 1.4% (after falling
0.8% in Q2) while segment operating profit grew by 5.4% due to cost efficiency improvements. The company continues to roll-out its private label
content which increases at a high pace. “Other business” including wholesale concept Traders and online E-mart mall saw continued strong sales
increases and profitability improvement, especially Trades (operating profit up 57% YoY). Reduced losses at Chosun Hotel and profit growth for
Shinsegae Food contributed to operating profit growth, while the company’s convenience store and overseas units saw profits contracting somewhat.
We believe the current stock valuation still indicates a very limited probability of fundamental improvements, as it is trading at EV/Sales below 0.5 and
EV/EBITDA at below 6x. The stock is supported by asset values in non-core holding Samsung Life and property values as 85% of the current stores are
owned and current balance sheet is probably under-estimating its market/replacement values.
Fact
In Q316 consolidated sales increased 10% from last year to KRW 4567bn. Operating profit grew 11% YoY to a level of KRW 215bn. Sales growth:
Hypermarket +4.1%, Traders +17%, Online +24%.
17
Key earnings releases and corporate news, November 2016 (cont.)
TEVA
(3.9% weight)
Investment thesis update:
While another outlook cut is disappointing (Teva provided revised guidance as recently as July), sentiment is understandably at rock-bottom following
the string of negative news this year. As contrarians, we cannot help but wonder if the saying “It's always darkest before the dawn” isn’t now particularly
applicable at Teva. There are several triggers that could lead to a sentiment and share price reversal: 1) Teva cited slower-than-expected new drug
approvals for the lower guidance but re-iterated that the applications are still there and the pace should pick up in 2017/2018; 2) Generics pricing is not
deteriorating beyond -5% negative YoY as per Teva with a one-off Allergan transaction causing the -7% pricing figure in Q3; 3) On the price collusion
allegations, the CEO adamantly denied any knowledge of the matter which may turn out to be non-material; 4) Management said it would stop M&A and
use cash flow to pay down debt (to 3.5x ND/EBITDA) which is positive as their M&A track-record is poor; and 5) The Copaxone court ruling in early
2017 is widely expected to go against Teva, so could surprise on the upside. While sliding earnings estimates have limited the usefulness of P/E
multiples, we think the share’s risk-reward at these levels looks attractive. Teva remains the world’s largest producer of generics and has nearly 50% of
all current FDA first-to-file applications to support future earnings.
Facts
Teva Q3 numbers roughly in-line with expectations, but FY 2016 mid-point guidance lowered for revenues (from USD 22.3bn to USD 21.8bn), EPS
(from USD 5.30 to USD 5.15) and operating cash flow (from USD 5.9bn to USD 4.9bn) due to new sales materialising more slowly than expected. No
2017 guidance issued. Copaxone revenue figures (USD 1.06bn) slightly ahead of consensus as the 40 mg version is holding up well. Teva has
established a USD 520m provision for the FCPA investigations pertaining to conduct in Russia, Ukraine and Mexico.
JBS
(4.1% weight)
Investment case update
Brazil-based JBS has transformed itself from a mid-sized local beef producer to one of the largest food companies in the world since its IPO in 2007.
Today it has a leading global market share position in beef, poultry (through 76% owned Pilgrim’s Pride in the US) and pork. The share price has been
weak following the decision from BNDES to block a restructuring plan of the company, which included plans to list its international businesses in the US.
The Q316 report provided a mixed picture of its operations, where the US, except for chicken producer PPC, saw recovering trends. The strength was
primarily within JBS USA Beef (EBITDA margin up 200 bps and up over 30% over last year) which is now clearly benefitting from lower input costs as
cattle prices have moved lower in the region. On the weak side were chicken producer PPC (already announced), JBS Mercosul and JBS Foods
compared to last year. The company generated substantial free cash flow in the quarter (BRL 700m), which we think is set to continue. Net debt was
still high but stable at 4.0x EBITDA (debt mostly in USD). The investment case remains based upon an operational turnaround including a continued
recovery in beef margins and better capital discipline which coincides with a multi-year low valuation of 5x EV/EBITDA forward multiples. Solid cash flow
generation has the potential to pave way for a net debt reduction towards 2.5x in the mid-term.
Fact
Net revenue fell by 4% to BRL 41bn while adjusted EBITDA was down 18% over last year. Net income was BRL 887m over BRL 381m from last year.
18
Key earnings releases and corporate news, November 2016 (cont.)
Crown
Confectionary
(1.6% weight)
Investment thesis update:
Crown Confectionary is a South Korea based company engaged in the production of confectionary products such as biscuits, wafers and snacks – the
second largest in the country despite its market capitalisation. The company has many subsidiaries and is, among other things, also the main
shareholder of Haitai (66% stake post-IPO), a former position in the fund.
The Crown investment case is based on the normalised level of the currently depressed domestic food and beverage industry and the underlying
market value of its assets, which are not reflected in the company’s current share price in our opinion. Ongoing weakness in the snack industry has
continued after a depressed first half of the year, and an unusually warm summer. The company reported Q3 numbers with slightly falling sales and
further deterioration in profitability while they indicated a more positive outlook for 2017. The main reason for the margin detraction this quarter was a
negative impact on gross margins in the form of higher input costs and an unfavourable product mix.
The company is in the process of reorganising its company structure in 2017, into a holding company and the food divisions below. We think that this
could ease management’s ability to turn the business around, give rise to faster management decisions, give key employees equity stakes, and unlock
further shareholder value. In addition, the international business is a major opportunity for the company, if Orion (#1 company in Korea) is any guide.
Massimo Zanetti
(0.8% weight)
Investment case update
Massimo Zanetti, the Italy-based coffee producer, operates in three main segments: Private Label (50% of sales), Mass market (42%) and Food service
(8%). The company went public in June 2015 at a meaningfully higher share price than the current price, and has since been 67% family-controlled. In
Q316, volume growth was flat YoY and sequentially. A stable pricing environment led to flat sales YoY. On the positive side profitability improved due to
a better gross margin and lower opex, contributing to a 4% growth of EBITDA YoY to a margin level of 8.6%. The company’s capsules volumes, a
strategically important area for the company, continued to grow strongly (12%) but at a softer pace compared to earlier quarters. The company
negatively revised its full-year guidance due to the loss of a private label contract in the US and the increase of input costs. Green coffee prices
(Arabica) are currently up 20% since August and the company unfortunately failed to extend its hedging program post Q2 results. Management expects
to increase list prices in the mass-market and food service from Q117, assuming input costs stays at current levels or above. We think the company
continues to have an outsized opportunity to increase margins in the mid-term, driven by a shift into the single serve segment and the launch of its first
ever efficiency program. Forward free cash flow yield in the stock is potentially above 10% at these levels.
Fact
In Q316, the group reported revenues of EUR 228m down 5.5% over last year. Total volume for the group increased by 0.5%. EBITDA came in at EUR
19.5m, up 4% and equivalent to a margin of 8.6%. Revised full year guidance (without their latest acquisition): 1-2% in volumes and EBITDA growth and
net debt below EUR 225m.
19
Key earnings releases and corporate news, November 2016 (cont.)
Tesoro
(3.5% weight)
Investment thesis update:
The company owns and operates seven refineries in Western US. They also have a substantial retail operation (selling refined products to gas stations)
and a logistics segment (separately listed in a so-called MLP) which owns pipelines for transporting the refined product. The company announced the
acquisition of Western Refining (USD 4.1bn), which will expand its presence in Texas, New Mexico and Minnesota. Western also has a substantial retail
operation in its footprint and a separately listed MLP for its pipeline assets. These assets will most likely be combined over the coming year. The
company sees substantial synergies of USD 350-450m over the first two years and increased its share buyback by USD 2bn. The market responded
favourably to the transaction indicating that premium paid is relatively fair (20%) and credible synergies have been identified. We believe Tesoro is
undervalued with respect to its different assets, and putting a market multiple on the retail business would indicate that the refinery business is implicitly
trading at 2-3x EV/EBITDA which is a distinct discount to peers. The announced transaction would delay any activist investor involvement, but a future
breakup remains a credible catalyst for the investment case. As a side-note, activist investor Elliot yesterday announced a major holding in close peer
Marathon Petroleum, suggesting a similar path for creating value.
Fact
The company announced the acquisition of Western Refining (WNR US) for USD 4.1bn.
Whiting Petroleum
(3.0% weight)
Investment case update
Whiting Petroleum is an independent E&P company primarily focused on on-shore oil properties in the US. The company raised capital in early 2015
after the poorly timed acquisition of Kodiak Oil and Gas in late 2014, funded mostly with debt. After executing a capital-raise in early 2015, the company
has struggled in an environment with a lower oil price and high debt levels. The company has managed to take down debt gradually, primarily by selling
non-core assets but also by implementing a rather painful debt-equity conversion transaction. The company announced a partial sale of two processing
plants to Tesoro Logistics for USD 700m and continues to execute on non-core asset sales. Through cost-cutting and lower capital expenditures, the
company is now able to reach operational cash flow neutrality at levels below the current oil price. On a forward EV/EBITDA perspective, without
assuming any dramatic increases in the forward oil price and further de-levering of the balance sheet, the stock appears to have solid upside.
Fact
The company announced the sale of its Robinson Lake and Belfield natural gas processing plant. The midstream assets are being purchased by
Tesoro Logistics for USD 700m (50% to WLL). The transaction is expected to close in Q117.
20
Key earnings releases and corporate news, November 2016 (cont.)
AIG
(8.0% weight)
Investment thesis update:
The US multi-line insurer was bailed out by the US government following the financial crisis and has since then started a transformation process aiming
at reaching peer-group profitability and exiting non-core assets. The company’s asset base can for simplification reasons be viewed in three main parts;
the operating portfolio (about 80% of assets), DTA (target to utilise) and legacy portfolio (20%, target to shrink/divest). Targets for 2017 were largely
confirmed in the form of 10% return on equity on the operating portfolio and an overall 2016/2017 capital return target of USD 25bn (current market cap
is USD 65bn). The forecasted increase in profitability will mainly be driven by further efficiency and underwriting improvements, specifically in
commercial P&C. The company indicated it is ahead of schedule for its USD 1.4bn operating expense reduction program. Key to the investment case is
further improvement in the P&C combined ratio and establishment of a lower volatility asset-mix in its investment portfolio. The stock is trading at 0.8x
book value with continued bright prospects for capital returns, and with a longer term ROE potential in line with the peer group, even in a non-split
scenario.
Infineon
(3.4% weight)
Investment case update
Infineon is a German semiconductor manufacturer founded in 1999, when the semiconductor operations of the parent company Siemens AG were spun
off. The company produces semiconductors and systems solutions. The company reported solid Q416 numbers with core segments, relating to hybrid
and EV (60% of sales) performing well driven by strong underlying demand. Group revenues were up 3% from last quarter and 5% compared to last
year. The automotive division (40% of sales) grew 13% YoY and expanded margin by 170bps to 17.1%. The Power Management and Multimarket
segment (30% of sales) saw its margin detract somewhat due to a negative impact relating to weaker smartphone demand. Full year profit margin came
in at 15.2%, down somewhat compared to last year but still above the given target. Free cash flow generation during the quarter continued strongly and
increased the current net cash position. After achieving the 15% through-the-cycle margin target during the last fiscal year, Infineon announced a new
target of 17%. The margin improvement will mainly be achieved via a higher utilisation rate at the company’s existing 300mm fab plant and cost benefits
arising from the integration of International Rectifier, which it acquired in 2014. During the conference call, Infineon indicated that it plans to cover about
half of the margin gap between the current 15% and the 17% target during 2017. We believe that Infineon has a unique position with its enviable market
positions in the structural shift towards hybrid engines, auto electrification and the autonomous car (especially within radar applications) and the
explosive growth from increased semi-content in these areas. As this has started to become reflected in the share price, we have been taking down the
position. We still see upside on current valuations and a discount to high quality industrial peers, but have adjusted our position size due to risk/reward.
Our target price is EUR 20 (trades at 16).
Fact
Infineon released Q416 numbers; Sales of EUR 1.7bn and net income of EUR 225m. Segment result margin came in at 16.7%. The company
generated EUR 169m of FCF, increasing current net cash position to EUR 471m.
21
Key earnings releases and corporate news, November 2016 (cont.)
Fourlis
(1.0% weight)
Investment case update
Greek Fourlis has two main business activities: (1) operator of IKEA stores in Greece, Bulgaria and Cyprus and (2) operator of Intersport stores in
Greece, Cyprus and Turkey. The company operates seven IKEA stores (five in Greece, one in Cyprus and one in Sofia, Bulgaria). Currently about 65%
of sales are derived from the IKEA operations. In Q316, the company total sales grew by 5% YoY. Both IKEA and Intersport grew sales by 6%.
Compared to last year IKEA EBITDA margins expanded from 11.2% to 13.2% while Intersport expanded 40 bps to 9%. Total EBITDA grew 21% YoY.
Net debt decreased by EUR 14m to EUR 120m despite the fact that Q3 is the seasonal peak for IKEA’s inventory. The debt level is still rather elevated
at 3.2x net debt /EBITDA, but the company has several non-core assets, including land plots in Bulgaria, that could be sold to reduce the debt pile.
Management expects to be able to reduce debt further by year end. During the conference call management mentioned that the board will propose the
reinstatement of a dividend for FY16, given the consistent cash generation and improving operating dynamics. On an overall basis, the home furnishing
market in Greece has lost more than 70% of its value since the peak of 2008 and is currently just 0.4-0.5% of GDP in Greece and competition has been
substantially reduced in the ultra-long recession. We believe that there is a gradual improvement towards normalisation of the business environment
which is combined with operating leverage, resulting in substantially higher earnings power in the mid-term.
Fact
Fourlis released Q316 numbers where IKEA and Intersport sales were up 6% to EUR 81m over last year while Intersport increased 6% to EUR 37m.
Overall EBITDA increased 21% to EUR 13.7m while EBITDA margin expanded from 10% to 11.6% over last year.
22
The 10 largest companies in SKAGEN Focus
AIG is an international insurance company serving commercial, institutional and individual customers. The company provides property-
casualty insurance, life insurance and retirement services. AIG was at the very centre of the financial crisis as the central bank for
mortgage insurance – it was bailed out in a USD 180bn bail out. The company has two core insurance holdings: Sun America and
Chartis that it intends to keep.
Largest cement company in Japan and 13th largest globally with approximately 40m tons total capacity (about 60% in Japan).
Japanese cement market is an oligopoly with three players following consolidation. Geographic revenue mix: Japan 80%, US 15%,
Other 5% (Singapore, Vietnam, HK, Philippines, Australia). Segment revenue mix: Cement 65%, Mineral resources 10%,
Environmental business 8%, Construction materials 10%, Other 7%); private/public 50/50. Integrated with minerals business providing
large part of internal raw material needs.
E-MART Inc. operates E-Mart discount stores. The company retails food, clothing, household goods, electronics, and other items
through several branch stores. Revenue breakdown: E-mart offline 70%, Traders 6% (wholesale), E-Mart mall/online 5%, Hotel 16%,
With Me (convenience format/CVS) 3%. Market share 48% in core discount format in South Korea.
Japan-based Softbank is a telecom and internet conglomerate. The company’s main assets are 1) the Chinese online giant Alibaba
Group (32% holding). Alibaba is the leading online commerce platform in China, active both in retail and wholesale; 2) US-based
telecom operator Sprint (80% ownership) which provides wireless services in the US and is the third largest wireless network operator
after Verizon and AT&T; and 3) domestic telecoms (mainly Softbank Mobile, third largest telco in Japan after KDDI and NTT Docomo).
Brazil-based JBS has transformed itself from a mid-sized local beef producer to the world’s largest animal protein processor in just a
few years since its IPO in 2007. It is now the world’s #1 beef, #2 poultry and #3 pork producer by sales. The company operates in six
main segments: JBS USA Beef (40% of sales, US beef processing), Moy Park (14%, UK-based chicken and foodservice provider),
Pilgrim’s Pride (14%, 2nd largest chicken producer globally; separately listed in the US; PPC US, JBS ownership 75%), JBS Mercosul
(13%, Brazil-based beef processing), JBS USA Pork (10%), JBS Foods (9%, prepared foods and poultry processing).
23
The 10 largest companies in SKAGEN Focus (cont.)
Japanese company established in 1999 as an online financial services company, incubation arm of Softbank. Acquired E*Trade
Securities in 2003, Softbank sold out in 2006. Three main businesses: i) Financial services; ii) Asset management, iii) Biotech Financial
services. Building an ecosystem to offer full range of financial services: SBI Securities: Dominant provider of online securities services in
Japan, #3 in new tax-saving NISA behind Nomura and Daiwa. SBI Sumishin Net Bank: pure-play internet bank. Also active within
insurance (Life & Non-life), Mortgages (through securitisation), trading system and FX trading.
Teva’s history can be traced back to Jerusalem in the 1930s. Today Teva is the world’s largest producer of drugs that have gone off-
patent. HQ in Israel; presence in 60 countries; 45k employees. Teva’s strategy is to focus on 1) Central nervous system (CNS) 2)
Respiratory and 3) Improved versions of existing drugs (not just Teva drugs) and 4) Production of biosimilar drugs. In July 2016, The
US Federal Trade Commission granted Teva approval for the acquisition of Allergan’s generics business (Actavis).
China Telecom is a full services integrated information service operator in China. The company, along with its subsidiaries, is engaged
in the provision of basic communications services, including wireline telecommunications services, mobile telecommunications services,
value-added services, such as Internet access services, integrated information services and other related services. China Mobile, China
Telecom and Unicom are the largest and dominant service providers in the country. China Telecom is the growing 2nd player behind
China Mobile in a maturing industry, yet with massive growth in data downloads.
Tesoro Corporation refines and markets petroleum products and provides transporting services. The company operates refineries, as
well as a network of retail and refuelling stations in the western United States. Tesoro also markets gasoline and diesel fuel to
independent marketers and commercial end users.
Infineon Technologies AG designs, manufactures and markets semiconductors. The company’s products include power
semiconductors, microcontrollers, security controllers, radio frequency products and sensors. Infineon markets its products to the
automotive, industrial, communications, consumer and security electronics sectors.
24
Tesoro (TSO US) USD 79 History, what they do and how case was found
• Refinery segment (50%) - The company is the fourth largest independent refinery in the US. Tesoro owns and operates seven petroleum refineries in the Western
US with a combined capacity of 845k barrels per day. The refineries are located in California (Los Angeles), Pacific North and Mid-continent.
• The refinery business earns a crack spread which, simply put is the price difference between the refined product (diesel, gasoline and jet fuel) and crude oil.
• Marketing segment (30%) – The marketing segment sells gasoline and diesel fuel (95% integrated) in Western US through own branded retail outlets/gas stations
and to external parties such as ARCO, Shell, Exxon, Mobil. As of June 2016 there were 2500 Tesoro branded outlets in its markets with the bulk in California.
• Logistics segment (20%) – The logistics segment mainly consists of TLLP (separately listed MLP – ticker TLLP US, listed in 2011, market cap of USD 4.7bn) which
has three segments: Gathering (29%), Processing (19%) and Transportation (52%). TLLP owns and operates over 3500 miles of crude oil, natural gas and refined
products pipelines. Revenues are fee based. Tesoro owns 33% of the company but is consolidated into the accounts. Tesoro holds 100% ownership in TLLP General
Partners (GP) which receives interest payments from the listed unit.
• ESG – Historically there have been issues around health and safety as well as certain labour practices. These seem to be largely behind the company and we seek
continuous information on relevant topics.
Rationale for investment
• Robust market position – the larger refineries in the US have strong market positions in its geographic footprints and barriers to entry are high. Major new refinery
capacity has not been built in decades.
• Implicit value of the refinery business is about 2x EV/EBITDA assuming value of retail/marketing segment at discount to peer group levels (MUSA US, SUN US, CST
US, CASY US) and company ownership stake in TLLP (both GP and LP). While being viciously cyclical, pure refineries such as Valero (VLO US) typically trade at 5-
6x EV/EBITDA over the cycle.
• Attractive free cash flow generation – normalised free cash flow yield should be about 8-9% (USD 0.8bn/year) supporting valuation.
• Strong balance sheet – the bulk of the group debt sits in TLLP unit, while “core” Tesoro is close to net cash.
• EBITDA composition transforming from pure refinery to higher margin business such as marketing/retail and logistics (in 2010, 80% was refining while current target
is around 40% in 2018/2019).
Potential triggers
• Increase in TLLP ownership via drop-down of assets to simplify corporate structure
• Spin-off or IPO of the marketing segment (Valero spun off its retail operations in 2013 in CST US)
• Open ownership structure which could pave the way for active shareholders to push for release of substantial sum of the parts undervaluation of the company
• Increased availability of oil supply and lower input costs - possible progress in exploration of on-shore California’s Monterey Shale, which is one of the largest
reserves in the US of oil and gas
Risks
• Pressure on crack spread (generally reprices with lag when crude goes higher)
• US consumer health
• Higher input costs (mainly gas pricing)
Target price
We set a target price of USD 120 which would indicate an implicit valuation of 5x EV/EBITDA of the refinery business within Tesoro. This would equal 9x mid-term
EV/EBITDA on the aggregate Tesoro group.
Key figures:
Market cap USD 9.5bn
Net debt/EBITDA 0.8x
EV/EBITDA 6.0x
EV/Sales 0.7x
P/BV trailing 1.7x
Free float 100%
Owners
Vanguard 10%, State Street 7,5%, Blackrock 6,9%, Hound Partners 4,2%, AQR CapitaL 2,9%
25
• The company is perceived as a refiner but in reality over 50% of operating income is derived
from marketing and logistics. The cyclical nature of the refining business lowers the interest for
the stock. 1/3 of analysts at hold/sell.
• The company’s rather complicated corporate structure (GP and direct ownership in listed TLLP)
is clouding the fundamental value in the stock.
• This mid-cap (USD 9bn) is covered by 20 analysts currently.
• We set a target price of USD 120 (current price of USD 79) which would indicate an implicit
valuation of 5x EV/EBITDA of the refinery business within Tesoro. This would equal 9x mid-
term EV/EBITDA on the total Tesoro group.
Under-
valued
Under-
researched
3U addition
Unpopular
For more information please visit:
Our latest Market report
Information on SKAGEN Focus A on our web pages
Unless otherwise stated, performance data relates to class A units and is net of fees. Historical returns are no guarantee for future returns. Future returns will depend, inter alia, on market developments, the fund manager’s skill, the fund’s risk profile and subscription and management fees. The return may become negative as a result of negative price developments. KIIDs and Prospectuses for all funds can be found on our website. SKAGEN seeks to the best of its ability to ensure that all information given in this report is correct. However, it makes reservations regarding possible errors and omissions. Statements in the report reflect the portfolio managers’ viewpoint at a given time, and this viewpoint may be changed without notice. The report should not be perceived as an offer or recommendation to buy or sell financial instruments. SKAGEN does not assume responsibility for direct or indirect loss or expenses incurred through use or understanding of the report. Employees of SKAGEN AS may be owners of securities issued by companies that are either referred to in this report or are part of the fund's portfolio.