S T A T E O F CALIFORNIA Budget Change Proposa l DF-46 (REV 08/16)
- Cover Sheet
Fiscal Year Business Unit Department Priority No. 2017-18 3900 Air Resources Board 2
Budget Request Name 3900-302-BCP-2017-A1
Program 3510-CLIMATE CHANGE
Subprogram
Budget Request Description Implementation of Oil and Gas Methane Regulation
Budget Request Summary The Air Resources Board requests a total of $2,603,000 in 2017-18 and $1,816,000 ongoing thereafter to support implementation of the Air Resources Board's Oil and Gas Methane Regulation (Greenhouse Gas Standards for Crude Oil and Natural Gas Facilities). This request includes 2.0 permanent positions and $2,318,000 (including $2 million in contract funds) in 2017-18, and $1,816,000 (including $1.5 million in contract funds) ongoing thereafter, from the Cost of Implementation Account. In addition, this proposal requests onetime equipment costs of $285,000 from the Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Administrative Fund.
Requires Legislation
1 lYes K i N o
Code Section(s) to be Added/Amended/Repealed
Does this BCP contain information technology (IT) components? • Yes IE1 No
If yes, departmental Chief Information Officer must sign.
Department CIO Date
For IT requests, specify the project number, the most recent project approval document (FSR, SPR, S1BA, S2AA, S3SD, S4PRA), and the approval date.
Project No. Project Approval Document: Approval Date:
If proposal affects another department, does other department concur \A/ith proposal? | 3 Yes • No Attach comments of affected department, signed and dated by the department director or designee.
Prepared By Date Reviewed By Date Floyd Vergara 3/28/17 Alice Stebbins 3/28/17
Department Director Date Agency Secretary Date Richard W. Corey 3/28/17 Matthew Rodriguez 3/29/17
Department of Finance Use Only
Additional Review: • Capital Outlay • ITCU • FSCU • OSAE • CALSTARS • Dept. of Technology
BCP Type: • Policy • Workload Budget per Government Code 13308.05
Onuinal Signed by PPBA f^oratt i PPBA Date submitted to the Legislature.
APR 1-2017
A. Budget Request Summary
The Air Resources Board requests a total of $2,603,000 in 2017-18 and $1,816,000 ongoing thereafter to support implementation of the Air Resources Board's Oil and Gas Methane Regulation (Greenhouse Gas Standards for Crude Oil and Natural Gas Facilities). This request includes 2.0 permanent positions and $2,318,000 (including $2 million in contract funds) in 2017-18, and $1,816,000 (including $1.5 million in contract funds) ongoing thereafter, from the Cost of Implementation Account (CCIA). In addition, this proposal requests one-time equipment costs of $285,000 from the Cil, Gas, and Geothermal Administrative Fund.
B. Background/History
Assembly Bill (AB) 32 (Chapter 488, Statutes of 2006), the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, designates the ARB as the state agency charged with monitoring and regulating sources of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. AB 32 sets a goal for California to reduce GHG emissions to 1990 levels by 2020 and instructs that reductions be maintained and continued thereafter. SB 32 affirms the authority granted by AB 32 and directs that this authority be used to meet a GHG emissions reduction goal of 40 percent below the 1990 level by 2030. These laws task ARB with quantifying the GHG emission reductions required to meet these targets, implementing a mandatory GHG emissions reporting system, and adopting a Scoping Plan that describes the measures and other actions planned to achieve the emission reduction goals. Implementation of AB 32 and SB 32 includes enforcing and refining existing regulatory measures as well as developing new regulatory measures that achieve real, quantifiable, cost-effective reductions of GHG emissions that will keep California on track to achieving the required reductions of 40 percent below the 1990 level by 2030.
The AB 32 COIA was established for the purpose of recovering costs incurred by carrying out the provisions of AB 32 (and now SB 32). These costs include implementing existing regulatory measures identified in the applicable AB 32 Scoping Plan, as well as costs that support the development of new or proposed regulatory measures that are specifically identified in AB 32 or the Scoping Plan prepared under AB 32, and that are supported by legislation. COIA expenditures are separate from Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund (GGRF) expenditures. GGRF expenditures cover the cost of carrying out non-regulatory projects that also reduce GHG emissions.
The ARB's mission is to promote and protect the public health, welfare, and ecological resources through effective reduction of air pollutants while recognizing and considering effects on the economy. This proposal allows ARB to meet this mission by requesting resources to better enable affected districts in California to implement ARB's Oil and Gas Methane Regulation (regulation), which achieves reductions of approximately 1.4 million metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent with volatile organic compounds (VOC) benefits of over 3,500 tons and toxic co-benefits of over 100 tons annually.
The oil and gas regulation was first envisioned in the 2008 climate change Scoping Plan, and was given added importance after the massive natural gas leak at the Aliso Canyon storage facility. Recent research has identified methane "super emitters" as significant contributors to emissions from the oil and gas sector. Similarly, research shows that a large fraction of emissions is produced by a small fraction of sources. These emissions are unpredictable; therefore regular ground-based inspections are essential to identify and limit emissions. ARB proposed a regulation to the Board in July 2016 to reduce methane from oil and gas operations, and the Board voted to adopt the regulation at the March 2017 board meeting. The anticipated reductions in methane (a climate super-pollutant), and the co-benefits of reducing VOCs and toxics, are important for meeting California's climate and air quality goals.
ARB staff has worked closely with staff from both the districts and Division of Oil and Gas and Geothermal Resources (DOGGR) to develop the proposed regulation and portions of the regulation will supersede DOGGR's emergency regulations adopted after the Aliso Canyon natural gas leak.
The proposed implementation dates included in the regulation are January 1, 2018 for reporting, record keeping, and leak detection and repair requirements. The proposed regulation further identifies equipment replacement or purchasing requirements to be effective January 1, 2019. Given these
l :\Unit\BCP\DF-46_Cover_Sheet_August2016.doc
proposed implementation dates, resources will be required by mid-2017 in order for personnel and programs to be prepared for tire January 2018 implementation date. Districts may also need to update a significant number of permits. If significant changes occur or the regulation is not approved, staff will revise the request. The regulation would reduce emissions from both upstream (production, gathering and boosting stations, and processing) and some downstream facilities (natural gas storage and transmission compressor stations). Regulated entities must take actions to limit intentional and unintentional emissions from active and idle equipment and operations.
Timeline
The Board adopted the regulation to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from oil and gas facilities at the March 2017 board meeting. The item was originally heard in July 2016 along with staffs recommendation for 15-day changes. The primary changes following the July hearing included amendments to the monitoring requirements for natural gas underground storage facilities and amendments to the leak detection and repair requirements. The Board also considered and approved the Final Environmental Analysis and the written responses to comments received on the Draft Environmental Analysis at the March 2017 board meeting. The Final Statement of Reasons will be finalized by early May 2017, and the final regulation package will be submitted to the Office of Administrative Law prior to June 3,2017. The requirements of the regulation go into effect beginning in early 2018.
Workload Metrics
The regulation's enforcement and implementation provisions recognize that California's local air districts already play an important role in regulating the oil and gas sector, and are intended to build on their efforts. Based on our experience implementing other, similar regulations, ARB estimates 2 additional staff are needed to register facilities and equipment, work with local air districts, collect reporting information, and conduct inspections and enforce in a limited number of districts or in an oversight capacity.
ARB estimates $2,603,000 in upfront costs and $1,816,000 annually thereafter to implement and enforce the regulation. ARB anticipates entering into contracts with air districts for a variety of activities, including setting up registration and permitting programs, training, equipment, designing and creating reporting databases, and other costs to establish the program. ARB staff assumes most local air districts will choose to take the lead in implementing and enforcing the regulation, with ARB playing a backstop role, as they are more familiar with operators, conduct inspections nearby or at the same sites and in many instances have been regulating such sources for decades. However, even if districts decide to implement and enforce this regulation, there is an annual cost for ARB to manage the reporting and inspection requirements in the regulation. The annual costs include leak detection and repair (LDAR) inspections, annual reporting, updating registration, and other compliance-related tasks. The inspections would need to be done on a regular basis so that the more than 1 million pieces of equipment are in compliance with the regulation. In addition, ARB will purchase equipment that will be shared among the districts.
C. State Level Considerations
This proposal will allow ARB to meet its overall mission to promote and protect public health and welfare as well as support goals of reducing GHG emissions under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Chapter 488, Statutes of 2006 ) and addressing short-lived climate pollutant concerns under Chapter 523, Statutes of 2014.
With the recent gas leak at Aliso Canyon, recent scientific understanding of the importance of methane super emitters, and ongoing concerns relating to exposure in and around communities near oil and gas facilities, ARB recognizes a need to monitor oil and gas facilities throughout the state on a regular basis. ARB will continue to coordinate with the DOGGR, the Fublic Utilities Commission, other agencies, and especially local air districts, on these activities.
ARB staff has worked closely with staff from both the air districts and DOGGR to develop the proposed regulation and portions of the regulation will supersede DOGGR's emergency regulations adopted after the Aliso Canyon natural gas leak. This proposal includes contract costs which would allow the districts to enforce the regulation, which is more efficient than both ARB and districts enforcing the regulation, or
l \ l n i f \R r .P \nF - / lR r.mior .Rhoot A i ini ict Dm fi rlnr-
just ARB enforcing it. Local air districts are more familiar with sites and operations and are already visiting and inspecting sites. In many cases, the districts also have existing programs that can be expanded to accommodate requirements under the regulation. The costs associated with this program are higher with ARB-only enforcement than with district enforcement due to the need to travel, train new staff, and set-up programs, including a registration program.
D. Justification
This proposal will address several key mandates for ARB, including its overall mission to protect public health and reduce greenhouse gases. In addition, the activities funded by this proposal will enable enforcement of the Oil and Gas Methane Regulation, thereby fulfilling the commitment in the initial AB 32 Scoping Plan and its first update to adopt an "Oil and Gas Extraction GHG Emissions Reduction" measure. The justification outlined below discusses key aspects of the proposal in terms of the overall goal to support the regulation.
ARB staff estimates that the regulation will require 2.0 positions and $2,603,000 in FY 2017-18 and $1,816,000 annually thereafter. Costs for equipment are listed below:
Equipment: Qty Unit Cost Total Cost
OGI IR Camera 3 $85,000 $255,000
Toxic Vapor Analyzer 3 $10,000 $30,000
The costs associated with this program are higher with ARB enforcement than with district enforcement due to the need to travel, train new staff, and set-up programs including a registration program. These costs are based on district estimates given existing programs, if any, as well as specific district level information on equipment costs, labor rates, case management and enforcement procedures, permitting needs, and source locations. These costs are anticipated to be imposed beginning in the 2017-18 fiscal year.
ARB resources are already fully committed to meeting existing statutory and other mandated priority programs, so a redirection would not be possible without adversely affecting ARB's ability to fulfill its statutory and mandated priority obligations.
Similarly, district staffs are fully committed to meeting their statutory and other mandated programs. Although district enforcement of the proposed regulation is the most administratively efficient, this cannot be accomplished without additional resources for the districts and ARB (in an oversight role).
E. Outcomes and Accountability
This proposal will provide resources to assist districts to implement the regulation. Progress and outcomes will be measured by the number of inspections conducted, emissions avoided, equipment turnover, and compliance percentages. The proposal is also expected to result in increased knowledge of emissions and impacts and inform any further necessary actions to reduce emissions.
In addition, ARB will work with the local air districts to submit the following progress reports every year: 1) the AB 32 semi-annual progress reports due to ARB by June 30 and December 31 of every year; 2) the AB 32 annual fiscal resource report due to ARB by December 1 of each year; and 3) the annual GHG emission reduction 'Report Card' due to Gal EPA by October 1 of each year.
F. Analysis of All Feasible Alternatives
Alternative 1. ARB and District Implementation and Enforcement
Under this alternative ARB would receive 2.0 positions and $2,603,000 in FY 2017-18, and $1,816,000 ongoing thereafter, for implementation of the oil and gas regulation.
Pros: This alternative would facilitate reductions of 1.4 million metric tons of 0 0 2 equivalent reductions, over 3,500 tons of VOCs, and over 100 tons of toxic air contaminants. This would be the most efficient use of resources.
Cons: This alternative would require additional resources.
l :\Unit\BCP\DF-46_Cover_Sheet_August2016.doc
Alternative 2. ARB-Only Enforcement
Under this alternative ARB would provide enforcement of requirements.
Pros: ARB enforcement would result in consistent enforcement of the requirements statewide.
Cons: To provide enforcement, ARB would need to develop programs and expertise which would need extensive travel to sites located throughout the state. This would result in increased resource needs due to added staffing and associated travel costs and could result in confusion as districts are already on site for VOC based regulations. Local air districts are more familiar with sites and operations and are already visiting and inspecting sites. In many cases, the districts also have existing programs that can be expanded to accommodate requirements under the regulation
Alternative 3. District Only Enforcement.
Under this alternative, districts would receive contract funds to assist the implementation and enforcement of the oil and gas regulation without ARB support.
Pros: Lower costs to ARB because the one-time equipment cost of $285,000 and positions would not be needed.
Cons: Provisions in the regulation would not be implemented including registering facilities and equipment, collecting and reporting information, and conducting inspections and enforcing the regulation in the districts.
Alternative 4. Status Quo
Under this alternative, additional resources would not be provided to assist districts or ARB in implementation of the regulation.
Pro: No additional resources required.
Cons: In this case, companies are less likely to comply with the regulation if no enforcement or reporting requirements exist. ARB would lose the opportunity for reductions of 1.4 million metric tons of C02 equivalent reductions, over 3,500 tons of VOCs, and over 100 tons of toxic air contaminants.
G. Implementation Plan
The recommended alternative (#1) will be implemented over a multi-year period and will be completed as indicated below:
• Personnel hiring, which can be initiated in July 2017 Initiating equipment purchases and program development in 2017-2018 Permitting can begin in 2017-2018 with new equipment permits by Jan 2019 Initiating start-up of program - January 2018 Inspections and reporting begin 2018
Progress and outcomes will be measured by the number of inspections conducted, emissions avoided, equipment turnover, and compliance percentages. Reporting requirements in the regulation include ambient air monitoring data, flash emissions testing results, separator and tank throughputs, gas-oil and gas-water ratios, and leak flow rates or concentrations. Since these data are reported before and after installation of control equipment, as well as before and after leak repair, emissions and reductions can be calculated.
H. Supplemental Information
None
I. Recommendation
ARB recommends approving its request 2.0 positions and $2,603,000 in 2017-18, and $1,816,000 ongoing thereafter, to administer and implement the Oil and Gas Methane Regulation (Greenhouse Gas Standards for Crude Oil and natural Gas Facilities). Protecting public health from the harmful emissions resulting from oil and gas production and related activities requires ARB and district implementation of the requirements of the regulation. If this proposal is not approved, ARB and districts
l \ l ] n i t \ R C P \ D F - 4 6 C o v e r S h e e t A u o u s t 2016 doc
will not be adequately able to implement and enforce the oil and gas regulation and opportunities to reduce significant amounts of methane, VOC, and toxic emissions from these types of facilities will be lost.
l :\Unit\BCP\DF-46_Cover_Sheet_August2016.doc
Air R e s o u r c e s Board Attachment A Workload Justi f icat ion
F u n d ; C o s t of Implementation A c c o u n t
Posi t ion Title: Air R e s o u r c e s Engineer/Oi l and G a s Methane Control Regulation Enforcement
Workload Measure F Y 2017-18 F Y 2018-19
Descr ipt ion of task Number of
T imes the task w a s performed
Number of hours needed to
complete task
Total number of annual hours
Number of times the task was
performed
Number of hours needed to
complete task
Total number of annual hours
Inspect ions and Investigations: Plan and conduct field inspect ions/ invest igat ions; Travel to-from inspection locations: Review records and reported information, Issue Notices of Violations
36 20 720 36 20 720
Case Management and Resolut ion: Prepare case sett lement documents : Schedule and conduct sett lement conferences. Prepare cases for lit igation.
10 100 1,000 10 t o o 1,000
Training and Equipment Maintenance: Procure and maintaing inspect ion equipment and tools, Complete required subject matter and health and safety " training
10 8 80 10 8 80
Total Hours 1,800 1,800
1 0 Position Equivalent = 1 800 hours
Numbers are based on previous workload expenence
Air R e s o u r c e s Board Attachment A Workload Justi f icat ion
F u n d : C o s t of Implementation Account
Posi t ion Title: Air Pollution Spec ia l is t
Workload Measure F Y 2017-18 F Y 2018-19
Descr ipt ion of task
Number of T i m e s the task
will be performed
Number of flours needed to
complete task
Total number of annual hours
Number of t imes the task will be
performed
Number of hours needed to
complete task
Total number of annual hours
Coordinate wit t i and support Air Districts in Implementat ion and Enforcement of Regulat ion
60 6 360 60 6 360
Deve lopment and/or Mainta inence of Report ing Database
25 40 1000 25 40 1000
Work with Enforcement on Inspect ions and Investigations: Plan and conduct field inspect ions/ invest igat ions: Travel to-from inspect ion locations, Review records and reported informat ion: Issue Notices of Violat ions
17 20 340 17 20 340
Respond to Public Commen t or inquiry 10 2 20 10 2 20
Work with Enforcement on Training and Equipment Maintenance: Procure and maintaing inspection equipment and tools. Complete required subject matter and health and safety training.
10 8 80 10 8 80
Total Hours 1,800 1,800
) 0 Position Equivalent - I 800 houis
Niimoers are based on previous workload experience
u T i ; i ; i : \
AIR RESOURCES BOARD INDUSTRIAL STRATEGIES DIVISION
JANUARY 2017 137.55 Authofiied Positions
flSSTPIVISIQW CHIEF: Rajinder Sahota
673-450-3878-001
CHIEF. CEA3
Floyd Vergara 673-450-7500-001
EJIEtSECJl Brittany Sherwood 673-450-1245-001
ADMINISTRATIVF SECTION
AGPA Qna Sterling
673-450-5393-701
Q i m Carol Wysong
673-450-1139-801 Valenhne Montoya 673450-1139-802
Rachel Pallatn 673450-1139-803
PROGRAM PLflNNING^S MANflGEMEHI
AR SUP II Jim Aguila
673450-3763-001
Ryan'^hauLnd 673450-3762-002
67345tl-388?-006 Vacaiil (Schaulaiid) 673-4b0-3887-O07
Chris Halm 673450-3887-008
Rania Heider 673450-3887-010
SUBSTANCE EVAEUAT1QN SECTION
AR SUP I Renee Lawyer
673450-3762-013
AR FNG Aubrey Gonzalez 673450-3735-024
APSPEC Julie Bllilngton
6734 50-3887-044 Carmen Spranger
673450-3887-045 Jose Saldana
673450-3887-050 Ursula E. Lai
673450-3887-052
_L..,..
673-450-''3763-002
m ARSUPI
Greg Mayeur 8734 50-3762-004
T r ^ 673450-3
Bartiara Bamberger 673450-3887-015 Jeffeiy Coronado
673460-3887-016 Joseph Grinnell
673450-3887-017 Stephen Shelby
673-450-3887-018 Alex Ylu
673450-3887-019
UIATF P H A
67345O-3762-O01
.AR BlayneT ,
673450-3735-001 BCP 2016 L01
673-450-3735 037
A P S P E C UacanI(Lee)
673-450-3887-001 Raimir Ral
673450-3887-002 Vacant (Morgan) 6734;i0-388M03
Robert Languell 673450-3887-004
Supriya Francis 673450-3887-005
S l l E J
673450-3735-Vacant (McPla-ct 673 450 3/3:1-00,')
6 7 3 * * l ? 0 - » 6
Vacant(Knox) 673 4S0-3887 023
PROJECT ASSESSMFNT BRANCH
ARSUP II Wes Ingram
673450-3763 003
ENERGY SECTION
: « • 673450-3762-007
' Marcelle Surouik : 673450-3875-003 : Stephanie Kalo I 673-450-3875-004
I _. . . rick
673450-3735-007 Rosah/a Lopez
673450-3735008 Joshua Kim
673450-3735-009
A E i Thomas Pomates 873450-3887-030
Gary Coliord 673450-3887-031
ICIIMATF CHANGE POLICY SECTION
ARSUPI David Mallory
673450-3762-009
APSPEC Lori Gilbert
673450-3887-036 Trish Johnson
673450-3887-037 Jenifer Klger(,8)
673450-3887-038 (.8) Theresa Richardson 673450-3887-039
Molly Munz (,8) 673450-3887-040 (,8)
Johnnie Raymond 673450-3887-041
TRANSPORTATION EUELS BRANCH
673450-3763-004
FUELS SECTION
Manisha Singh 673450-3762-O10
Jing Yuan 673450-3875-006
Greg O'Brien 673450-3735-014
James Guthrie ,673450-3735-021 Stephen d'Estertiazy
673450-3735-025 Veronlka Pesinova 673450-3735-036
APSPEC Reza Lorestany
673450-3887-M3
6 7 3 4 W - 0 4 6
673450-3?^'T)11
,AREI Yon:
6734:. Vacani
3735-011 .[Doulfyi
67J-450THS-0V>
673450-3887-047 Jordan Ramalli, 673450-3887-1
fUELS
Anthy Alexlades 673460-3735-020 V.rcant (Pr'tcfsOii) b;,J-450-37'J5-023
Jlglng Fan 673450-3735-034
JelfKessler 673450-3735-035
Fira^At^^neneh 673450-3887-042
Kamran AdIII 673450-3887-046
L A GAS AND GHG MITIGATION BRANCH
mm Elizabeth Scheehle 673450-3763-005
OILANDCJtS SECTION
ARSUPI Jim Nyarady
673450-3762-014
AR FNG Chnstian Hurley
6734 50-3735-026 Joseph Fischer
673450-3735-027 Tiffany Mateo
673450-3735-028
AP SPEC V-icaiU (LH'twiinr) 673-4 50-3887-0,'.3
Joelte Howe 673450-3887-054
Carolyn Lozo 673450-3762-016
KatHeen^i^zawa 673450-3875-009
AEXNTT ' Vacant (Cayabyab) 673-450 3735 0l2
Michael GInty 6734 50-3735-632 j
C ^ s e y ^ t l 67J450-3e87-056 :
Luis Leyva 673450-3887-057 Vacani (Kozavva) 673-460 3887-060 i
ARSUP I ' Terrel Ferrelra
673450-3762-015
an 673450-3875-007
Andrew Mrowka 673450-3735-029
Linda Lee ; 673450-3735-030 - Vacani (Nnwiun) ; 673-450-3735-031
.APSpEC Lynn Yeung
6734 50-3887-055
AR.SUPI Alexander Mtehell 673450-3762-017
STAFF APS Var.int i l cvinci
673-450-3875-008
mm XupmoLl
673450-3735D33
673450-3887 VarantlKmq)
6;3-450-3887T)58 Sarah Penfleld
6734 50-3887-059
673-45"d-m7-061
J-3887-tl51
AIR RESOURCES BOARD INDUSTRIAL STRATEGIES DIVISION
AUGUST 12, 2016 PROPOSED
Oil and Gas BCP
flSSTPIVISIQN CHIEF:: Rajinder Sahola • 1
• 673-450-3878-001 " r
CHIEF. CEA 3
Floyd Vergara 673450-7500-001
PROGRAMF AGEMENT BRANCH
AR SUP II Jm Aguila
673450-3763-001
Gl IMATE CHANGE PROGRAM EVALUATION BRANCH
ARSUP II 'acani iSahi una)
•11)0 37U-002
EJSESLSEOJl Brittany Sherwood 673450-1245-001
PRO IFCT ASSESSMFNT BRANCH
lUEJ! igram
673450-3763-003
TRANSPORTATION FUELS BRANCH
AR SUP II SamWade
673450-3763-004
I A cuts AND GHG MITIGATION BRANCH
E l i z a W i h . 673450-3763-005
AR SUP I Vac.inl (Lavvuinl
673-45O-.17i,30O2
APSPEC VatanK Liub)
673.450-3887-006 Ryan Sohauland
673450-3887-007 Chris Halm
673450-3887-008 RanIa Heider
673450-3887-010
r i IMATF CHANGE 4iiI:lM«n«ITiT
KarenTutteri.ss) 673450-3735-0021.95)
A P S P E C John Swanson
673450-3887-011 Wade McCartney 673450-3887-0 T2
Syd Partridge 673450-38877013 Marc Vayssleres
673450-3887-014
SUBSTANCE FVAIIIATION SECTION
ARSUPI Renee Lawyer
673450-3762-013
&RING Aubrey Gonzalez 673450-37354)24
A P S P E C Julie Bllilngton
673450-3887-044 Cairnen Spranger
673450-3887-045 Jose Saldana
673450-3887-050 Ursula E.Lai
673450-3887-052
£BQ1 lATlON
Barbarat 673450-3887-015 Jeffery Coronado
673450-3887-016 Joseph Grinnell
673450-3887-017 Stephen Shelby
673450-3887-018 Alex Ylu
673450-3887-019
CI IMATF CHANGE PI ANNING SECTION
AR SUP I Chuck Sekjler
6734 50-3762-001
AR ENQ Vacuiit (Gmly)
673450-3735 001
AP SPEC Natalie Lee
673450-3887-001 Rajmir Ral
673450-3887-002 Blayne Moigan
573450-3887-003 Robert Languell
673450-3887-004 Supriya Francis
673450-3887-005
Mary Jane Coombs 673450-3762-006
Dayd Altaood 673450-37354104 V.icant (McClK oj 67,3-450 373:3-005
Mark SIppola 673450-37354)06
Ro^rt'j^xon 673450-3887-009 Vacant (Nichols) 673-450-3887-020
Mlhoyo Fuji 673450-388r-021
Eileen HIavka 673450-3887-022
William Knox 673450-3887-023
MARK^H^^y^j^^QRING
IRSUpi
6735"5i": Udcaiit (Donovan) 6 7 3 - 4 5 0 - 3 8 8 7 0 2 9
6734"l«-J^^-062
ENERGY SECTION
673450-3762-007
. STAfFAPS ,̂ Marcelle buroyik
673450-3875-003 Stephanie Kato
673450-3876-004
K e f t f f i i c k 673450-3735-007
Rosalya Lopez 673450-3736-008
Joshua Kim 673450-3735-009
Thomas^^omaies 673450-3887-030
Gary Coliord 673450-3887-031
REGULATORY ASSISTANCE SECTION
ARSUPI Tung Le
673450-3762-008
STAFF APS Chris Gallenstein
673450-3875-005
ARENG Due Tran
6734 50-3735-010
AP SPEC Stephen Welter
6734 50-3887-032 Eyan Powers
673450-3887-033 Patrick Au
873450-3887-034 Steye Eve
673450-38874)35
I CLIMATE CHANGE POLICY ! SECTION
ARSUPI David Mallory
673450-3762-009
i AP SPEC I Lori Gilbert ! 673450-3887-036
Trish Johnson 673450-3887-037 Jenifer Klger(,8)
673450-3887-038 (,8) Theresa Richardson 673450-3887-039
Molly Munz(,8) 673450-3887-040 (,8)
Johnnie Raymond 673450-3887-041
FUFIS SECTION
AR.SUPI Manisha Singh
673450-37624)10
STATEAPS Jing Yuan
673450-38754)06
G r ^ _ . 6734a)-3735-014
James Guthrie 673450-3735-021
Stephen d'Estertiazy 673450-3735-025
Veronlka Pesinova 673450-3735-036
APSPEC Reza lorestany
673450-3887-043 Vacant(Surovik)
673-450-3887-046
F U E L | g ^ T I G N
GET
6734'55-3?33(j11 Vacini (Uoolt vi G;:I4;,0 3 7 2 5 0 1 5
6 7 3 % » 1 6
' ^3^3^017
673450-3735-013 Anthy Alexlades
673460-3735-020 Vacant (Pcluisonj 673,.lb0-3735-02-1
Vacani (BCP) 673-450-3725-034
JelfKessler 673450-37354)35
APSPEC Vacant (Ptisinova) 673-450-3887-042
Kamran Adill 673450-3887-048
AR SUP! Jim Nyarady
673450-3762-014
ARENG Christian Hurley
673450-3735-026 Joseph Fischer
673450-37354)27 Tiffany Mateo
673450-37354)28
APSPEC Vacant (Dirtwilei) 673 4 50-3887 053
Joelte Howe 673450-3887-054
PROPOSED 073-450 3887 XXX
PROGRAM ASSESSMENT SECTION
A R S U P I Carolyn Lozo
673450-3762-016
A R E N G Adrian Cayabyab 673450-3735-012
Michael GInty 673450-3735-032
APSPEC Casey Scott
673450-3887-056 Luis Leyva
673450-3887-057 Kathleen Kozawa 673450-3887-060
^ A R S U P I , TerrelFerreira
673-450-3762-015
tiawan 673450-3875-007
Andrew t̂jrowka 6734 50-3735-029
Linda Lee 6734 50-3735-030
Chns Newton 6734 50-3735-031
.AES Lynn Yeung
673450-3887-055
TECHNOLQCYSECIION
Alexander M4cbell 673450-3762-017
STAFF APS V,i(..tnl (I cvinc)
673-450 3875 008
ARENG Xuping LI
67345(!-3?35-033
673450-3887-?)51 Sara King
673450-3887-058 Sarah Penfleld
673450-3887-059
6 7 3 4 W 0 6 I
AIR RESOURCES BOARD ENFORCEMENT DIVISION
JANUARY 2017
r.iTArinMS ANO RFCKTBATIQW ENFORCEMENT BRANCH
ARSUP II Michael Guzzetla 673.210-3763-001
CITATIONS AND HOTLINE SECTION
AR SUP I Rlchelle Bishop
673-210-3762-001
AP S P E C Vacaiil iHankins) ( 5) 6 7 3 - 2 1 0 - 3 6 8 7 - 0 0 3 { 5)
Vacant (Bistiopj 673 210 3667-004
Edwin Virgin 673-210-3887-005
AREN James Ac .
673-210-3735-002 Gieg Mc Mahan
673-210-3735-003 Rich Miller
673-210-3735-004
673-210-3887-006 Michele Burken
673-210-3887-007 Zuzana Vona
673-210-3687-008 Ava YaghoobiracJ
673-210-3887-009 Caiol Carlson
673-210-3887-010 vj^ar.l avcj ihcfk i r t i )
fS73 2)0 --ie87-C.il Bradley Shaw
673-210-3887-012
S S A vAC.fxtq: iiCP 2016 673 210 51S7 7tU
AR ENG Wendy Maienknecht 673-210-3735-005
AP gP£C Randy Rhondeau
673-210-3887-013 Adam Gomez
673-210-3887-015 Kristen McKinley
673-210-3687-016 Vacant (Berumen) 67.3-210-3887-017
Carmen Madia 673-210-3887-020
Bradley Penick 673-210-3887-027 Alfonso Arambula 673-210-3887-030
Kenneth Stark 673-210-3887-053
673-210-3735-006 Shannon Downey 673-210-3735-008
A P S P E C Cynthia Stover
673-210-3887-018 Stephen Binning
673-210-3887-021 Ryman Simanqan 673-210-3887JD22
Luke Duval 673-210-3887-023
Ann Stacy 673-210-3887-024
Nelson Van 673-210-3887-026
Eric Bissinger 673-210-3887-029
hrin ^lanton 673-210-3887-031 Claira Aramouni
673-210-3887-032 Martin Gunn
673-210-3887-033
673 Juonq 1-210-73. 1887-071
. 673-210-393^-001
AR FIELD REP R Vcccnl IKonnefJJ 673-210-3937-002
Brent Ttiomas 673-210-3937-003
Hector Polo 673-210-3937-004
Mike Bernard 673-210-3937-005
M ^ e F a a 673-210-3762-005
T a ^ m 673-210-3735-009 Christopher Patno 673-216-3735-010
Xlangyt LI 673-210-3735-011
An§f t#? i f rez 673-210-3887-014 673f2ic/3'8874)19
Julian Ortiz 673-210-3887-025
Aldo Chaney 673-210-3887-028
Olufemi Olaluwqye 673-210-3887-070
AR ENG Tony Zeng
673-210-3735-012 Jeremiati Bearden 673-210-3735-013
AP S P E C Gtegory Honzay
673-210-3887-034 Gretchen Ratliff
673-210-3887-035 Marcos Banaga
673-210-3687-072
A P S P E C , , Luz Ciccarelli
673-210-3887-043 Fred Schmidt
673-210-3887-044 Victoria Villa
673-210-3887-045 Tony Doan
673-210-3667-046 Long Liu
673-210-3887-047 Erin Petate
673-210-3887-048 Thomas Lopez
673-210-3887-049
Vacant 673-210-J887-O36
Juan Delgado 673-210-38187-037
673-210-3687T039 67''3'm^3?8''7°.S'40
RAILRPAP I ENFPRCl
JNE SECTIPN
Debbie ^Vossing 673-210-3762-010
MIchefllTc^ftt^Wood 673-210-3875-002
AP ? P E C Rebecca Geyer
673-210-3887-050 Alex Barber
673-210-3887-051 Hector Pelayo
673-210-3887-052 Robert Hamamoto 673-210-3687-054
Scott Underhil! 673-210-3887-055
David Kemena 673-210-3887-056
AR FIELD REP III Damacio Arevaios 673 210-3938-002 Shallendra Pratab 673-210-3938-003 Ching Chun Yang 673-210-3938-004
AR FIFI D R F P I I Sal Atatorre
673-210-3937-006 Jose Andujar
673-210-3937-007 ValenteArmenta 673-210-3937-008
Vacant (Buenrostro) 673-210-3937-009
Claude Karim 673-2104937-010
Billy OBnen 673-210-3937-011
Barry Pratt 673-210-3937-012 Vacanl(Watkins) 673-210-3937-013
George Popple 673-210-3937-014
Matthew O'bonnell 673-210-3735 016
Vacant (Rubin) 673 210 j735-0l7
A P S P E C Canssa Ganapathy 673-210-388f-057 Mary Rose Sullivan 673-210-3887-058
Julie Stanfield 673-210-3887-059
Enc Walton 673-210-3887-060 Joseph, Gormley
573-210-3887-061
AR SUP I Ronald Nunes
673-210-3762-013
AR ENG John Abbey
673-210-3735-021
AP SPEC Katerina Knchevsky 673-210-3887-062
Hortencia Mora 673-210-3887-063
Sara Tamber 673-210-3887-064
AR SUP I Jeff Lindberg
673-210-3762-014
AR E N G Nestoi Castillo
673-210-3735-016 Taylor Grose
673-210-3735-019
AP S P E C Vickie McGrath
673-210-3887-065 Ahmad Najjar
673-210-3887-066 Kim Nguyen
673-210-3887-067 v j : an! iLMivcr}
bVJ zlO 3flS7 UhO Maria Lorea
673-210-3887-069
ARFR II Heidi Kroll
673-210-3937-015
AIR RESOURCES BOARD ENFORCEMENT DIVISION
August 10, 2016 PROPOSED
Oil and Gas BCP
Vacani (Carlsunt 6/3 211) 3887 1)01
CHIEF. C E A 3
Todd Sax 673-21O-75O0TX1I
CITATIONS AND REGISTRATION ENFORCEMENT BRANCH
AR 5GPII Richard Smith
673-210-3763-001
A R S U P I Timothy Gergen
673-210-3762-001
AP S P E C Renae Hanklns (.51
673-210-3887-003 ( 5) Rlchelle Bishop
673-210-3887-004 Edwin Virgin
673-210-3887-005 Kenneth Stark
673-210-3687-053
Michael Guzzetta 673-210-3762-002
A R E N C . , James Aguila
673-210-3735-002 Greg Mc Mahan
673-210-3735-003 Rich Miller
673-210-3735-004
f\v sfatmn 673-210-3887-006 Michele Burken
673-210-3887-007 Zuzana Vona
673-210-3887-008 Ava Yaghoobirad 673-210-3887-009
Carol Carlson 673-210-3887-010 Kelly Weatherford 673-210-3887-011
Bradley Shaw 673-210-5887-012
DIESEL PRQ9RAM? ENFORCEMENT BRANCH
AR SUP II Heather Brown
673-210-3763-002
DTIT l Kathy Walton
673-210-1139-801
AR SUP I Vacant Brown)
673-210-3762-003
W e n d y - * ^ . . . . ) d y ^ 673-210-3735-005
Rand^ tfhmuleau 673-210-3887-013
Andrea Juarez 673-210-3887-014
Adam Gomez 573-210-3887-015 Kristen McKinley 673-210-3887-016 Gerald Berumen
673-210-3687-017 Cynthia Stover
673-210-3887-016 Terty Allen
673-210-3887-019 Carmen Madia
673-210-3887-020
SECTIPN
AR SUP I. Warren Hawkins 673-210-3762-004
S l ^ n e y ^ u 673-210-3735-006 Shannon Downey 673-210-3735-OOS
Steptien^mning 673-210-3667-021 Ryman SImangan 673-210-3667-022
Lucas Duval 673-210-3887-023
Ann Stacy 673-210-3867-024
Julian Driiz 673-210-3667-025
DIufemI DIaluwoye 673-210-3887-0/0
Xiangyi Li 673-210-3735-011
AP S P E C Nelson Van
673-210-3887-026
673410613702
EXECASSI Vacam (Cicticnn) 6/3 710 1/7S-001
VEHICLE. PARTS 8i CONSUMER PRODUCTS ENFORCEMENT BRANCH
A R S U P II Gregory Binder
673-310-3763-003
S21 Angela Lemoncito-Salazar 673-210-1139-602
SI.O-S
,AR SUP I Judy Lewis
673-21(5-3762-006
673-210-3887-031
Martin Gunn 673-210-3887-033
Duona Trinh 673-210-3887-071
Kenne ran 673-210-393f 001
AR FIELD REP II Vacant(Kodacrs) 673-210-3S37-002
Brent Thomas 673-210-3937-003
Hector Polo 673-210 3937-004
Mike Bernard 673-210-3937-005
Lisa Vacoubian 673-210-3762-007
STAFF APS Dean Hermano
673-210-3675-001
Tony Zeno 673-210-373^012 Jeremiah Bearden 673-210-3735-013
AP S P E C Gregory Honzay
673-210-3887-034 Gretchen Ratlitt
673-210-3887-035
6 ? 3 » f 4
673^r0- '5 '8m39
6 ' 7 ' ! f - 5 l W o V l 673^T0?3'?6r042
FIELD QPERATIPNS BRANCH
i l
Amanda ^pellman 673-210-1139-803
£U£L
Ju^n t^somio 673-210-3762-009
A R E N G Rachel Connors
673-210-3735-015
, AP S P E C Luz Ciccarelli
673-210-3887-043 Fred Schmidt
673-210-3887-044 Victoria Villa
673-210-3887-045 Tony Doan
673-210-3887-046 Long Liu
673-210-3887-047 Vacant (Cole)
673-210-3887-048 Thomas Lopez
673-210-3667-049
IAD & MARINE NFDRCEMENT
SECTIPN
Debbie I.Yossing 673-210-3762-010
Michllfe^g^utgLood 673-210-3875-002
AP S P E C RebeccaGeyer
673-210-3887-050 Alex Barber
673-210-3887-051 Hector Pelayo
673-210-3887-052 Rotierl Hamamoto 673-210-3667-054
Scott Underbill 673-210-3667-055
David Kemena 673-210-3667-056
£ J .
FIELD ENFDRCEMENT SECTIPN
AR SUP I Nancy D'Connor 673-210-3762-011
AR FIELD REP III Damacio Arevaios 673-210-3938-002 Shallendra Pratab 673-210-3938-003 Ching Chun Yang 673-210-3938-004
AR FIELD REP II Sal Alatorre
673-210-3937-006 Jose Andujar
673-210-3937-007 Valente Armenia 673-210-3937-008
Ramiro Buenrostro 673-210-3937-009
Claude Abdul-Karim 673-210-3937-010
Billy D'Brien 673-210-3937-011
Barry Pratt 673-210-3937-012
John Watkins 673-210-3937-013
George Popple 673-210-3937-014
ENFPRCEMENT SPPPPRT BRANCH
S ^ ^
TRAININP SECTIPN
Lelsa^^us'h 673-210-3762-012
STAFF AP SPEP Bruce Oulrey
673-210-367 5-(503 Rajeev Sehgal
673-210-3675-004
Matthew Sl jonnel l 673-210-3735-016 Yevgenly Rubin
673-710-3735-017
AP S P E C Carissa Ganapathy 673-210.388/05/
Mary Rose Sullivan 673-210-3887-058
Julie Stanfield 673-210-3667-059
Eric Walton 673-210-3867-060 Joseph Gormely 673-210-3887-061
AR SUP I Ronald Nunes
673-210-3762-013
AR EN John Abbey
673-210-3735-902
AP SPEC Katerina Krichevsky
673-210-3887-062 Hortencia Mora
673-210-3867-063 Sara Tamber
673-210-3667-064
OlSTI
Ne / fgr l l i l l l lo 673-210-3735-018
6ysmlif?)'g5 67|:j75^3^lfe6 673-'zio'?f8'^7-067
Vacant (OiiverJ 673-210-3837-068
3°6r069
673-210-3937-015
BCP Fiscal Detail Sheet BCP Title: Implementation of Oil and Gas Methane Regulation
Budget Request Summary
BR Name: 3900-302-BCP-2017-A1
FY17 CY BY BY+1 BY+2 BY+3 BY+4
Personal Services Positions - Permanent 0.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0
Total Positions 0.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0
Salaries and Wages Earnings - Permanent 0 183 183 183 183 183
Total Salaries and Wages $0 $183 $183 $183 $183 $183
Total Staff Benefits 0 87 87 87 87 87 Total Personal Services $0 $270 $270 $270 $270 $270
Operating Expenses and Equipment 5301 - General Expense 0 4 4 4 4 4 5302 - Printing 0 2 2 2 2 2 5304 - Communications 0 4 4 4 4 4 5320 - Travel: In-State 0 8 8 8 8 8 5322 - Training 0 2 2 2 2 2 5324 - Facilities Operation 0 20 20 20 20 20 5340 - Consulting and Professional Services -
External 0 2,000 1,500 1,500 1,500 1,500
5346 - Information Technology 0 8 6 6 6 6 539X - Other 0 285 0 0 0 0
Total Operating Expenses and Equipment $0 $2,333 $1,546 $1,546 $1,546 $1,546
Total Budget Request $0 $2,603 $1,816 $1,816 $1,816 $1,816
Fund Summary Fund Source - State Operations
o r v d z j Of. Gas, and Geothermal 3046 - . . . 0 285 0 0 0 0 Administrative Fund
0 285 0 0 0 0
_ _ „ . 7 Cost of Implementation Account, Air 0 2,318 1,816 1,816 1,816 1,816 Pollution Control Fund
0 2,318 1,816 1,816 1,816 1,816
Total State Operations Expenditures $0 $2,603 $1,816 $1,816 $1,816 $1,816
Total All Funds $0 $2,603 $1,816 $1,816 $1,816 $1,816
Program Summary Program Funding
3510 - Climate Change 0 2,603 1,816 1,816 1,816 1,816 Total All Programs $0 $2,603 $1,816 $1,816 $1,816 $1,816
BCP Title: Implementation of Oil and Gas Methane Regulation BR Name: 3900-302-BCP-2017-A1
Personal Services Details
Salary Information Positions Min Mid Max CY BY BY+1 BY+2 BY+3 BY+4
3735 - Air Resources Engr 0.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 3887 - Air Pollution Spec 0.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0
Total Positions 0.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0
Salaries and Wages CY BY BY+1 BY+2 BY+3 BY+4
3735 - Air Resources Engr 0 94 94 94 94 94 3887 - Air Pollution Spec 0 89 89 89 89 89
Total Salaries and Wages $0 $183 $183 $183 $183 $183
Staff Benefits 5150350 - Health Insurance 0 27 27 27 27 27 5150500 - OASDI 0 14 14 14 14 14 5150600 - Retirement - General 0 46 46 46 46 46 Total Staff Benefits $0 $87 $87 $87 $87 $87
Total Personal Services $0 $270 $270 $270 $270 $270