Download - Uni Sci- %28Evaluation Form-2013%29
7/26/2019 Uni Sci- %28Evaluation Form-2013%29
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/uni-sci-28evaluation-form-201329 1/6
UNIVERSITAS SCIENTIARUM
Themes covered: The journal will accept unpublished papers on any subject of natural, physical
or exact sciences.www.javeriana.edu.co/scientiarum/web
Categories of manuscripts:Universitas Scientiarum publishes original article, short communications(notes), review (meta-analysis, review of methods or concepts), mini-reviews, and methods article.https://docs.google.com/fle/d/0B_IdlsctkRrxS!"#$%ackd&'"g/edit(usp)sharing
Target pubic: The journal is addressed to researchers and graduates students of natural,physical and exact sciences, and in general to all those who contribute toscientic nowledge.
MANUSCRI!T EVA"UATI#N $#RM
Manuscript Entite:Manuscript Code:I% #vera assessment:
The manuscript is &seect one ' pease use an( coor):
A% !cceptable in its present form or after minor corrections annotated inthe comments section.
*% !cceptable once extensive revisions annotated in the commentssection are done" # am willing to re $ referee the manuscript.
C% %ay become acceptable if suggested data or experiments areprovided and&or revisions are done" re'uires rewriting and resubmitting" #am willing to re $ referee the manuscript.
+% ejection with the possibility to re-submit an improved version.
E% nacceptable (poor&no originality). *lease include reasons in thecomments section.
evista Universitas Scientiarum
ISSN 0122-7483 (versión impresa) ISSN 2027-1352 (versión en línea)
Carrera 7 No. 43-82 Edifcio CARLOS ORTÍZ Oc. 627 Tel-Fax: 320 83 20 Ext. 4070E-mail: [email protected]
+ page http&&www.javeriana.edu.co&facultades&ciencias &universitas&index.htmogot/, 0.1., 1olombia 2ur !m3rica
4
7/26/2019 Uni Sci- %28Evaluation Form-2013%29
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/uni-sci-28evaluation-form-201329 2/6
!riorit( for pubication &seect one, use -):
.% 5ey manuscript666666666
/% #mportant manuscript (competent, new nowledge or insights)
6666666666
0% seful manuscript (competent but repeats existing
nowledge)6666666666
1% %anuscript not recommended 66666666666
Manuscript t(pe &Seect the most appropriate for the paper, use -)
7riginal article
666
2hort communication (! shortened version of this paper should be published as a
note) 666
eview
666
%ethods article
666
##. Comments to the Editor (they will not be disclosed to the authors)
evista Universitas Scientiarum
ISSN 0122-7483 (versión impresa) ISSN 2027-1352 (versión en línea)
Carrera 7 No. 43-82 Edifcio CARLOS ORTÍZ Oc. 627 Tel-Fax: 320 83 20 Ext. 4070E-mail: [email protected]
+ page http&&www.javeriana.edu.co&facultades&ciencias &universitas&index.htmogot/, 0.1., 1olombia 2ur !m3rica
8
7/26/2019 Uni Sci- %28Evaluation Form-2013%29
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/uni-sci-28evaluation-form-201329 3/6
III% Comments to the authors (include your comments here or in the
electronic version" you can follow the priority of comments you consider the
authors should address. *lease follow the manuscript sections order)
• Ma2or comments:
• Minor comments:
evista Universitas Scientiarum
ISSN 0122-7483 (versión impresa) ISSN 2027-1352 (versión en línea)
Carrera 7 No. 43-82 Edifcio CARLOS ORTÍZ Oc. 627 Tel-Fax: 320 83 20 Ext. 4070E-mail: [email protected]
+ page http&&www.javeriana.edu.co&facultades&ciencias &universitas&index.htmogot/, 0.1., 1olombia 2ur !m3rica
9
7/26/2019 Uni Sci- %28Evaluation Form-2013%29
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/uni-sci-28evaluation-form-201329 4/6
:ame2ignature0ate;iliations
Please feel free to ll the following gaps, if you consider it isnecessary (according to manuscript type), or you can use them as
evista Universitas Scientiarum
ISSN 0122-7483 (versión impresa) ISSN 2027-1352 (versión en línea)
Carrera 7 No. 43-82 Edifcio CARLOS ORTÍZ Oc. 627 Tel-Fax: 320 83 20 Ext. 4070E-mail: [email protected]
+ page http&&www.javeriana.edu.co&facultades&ciencias &universitas&index.htmogot/, 0.1., 1olombia 2ur !m3rica
<
7/26/2019 Uni Sci- %28Evaluation Form-2013%29
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/uni-sci-28evaluation-form-201329 5/6
guide lines to review the paper and to write the editor and authorletters.
IV% Speci3c assessment (answer 'uestions that are relevant to the type of
manuscript" :! = does not apply. #f considered necessary, please justify youranswer in the comments section)
4ES N# NA
4. 0oes the manuscript not been published previously> 666 666 666 8. 0oes the manuscript describe original wor>(#f not original, list references of previous publications)
666 666 666 9. 0oes the manuscript present new nowledge in the eld>
666 666 666
<. 0oes the manuscript have methodological or theoretical interest> 666 666 666 ?. #s the title clear and precise> 666 666
666 @. #s the abstract descriptive of contents>
666 666 666 A. #s the introduction clear> 0oes it provide the bacground of the wor>
666 666 666 B. !re the problem, 'uestion and&or hypothesis explicitly indicated>
666 666 666 C. !re there enough details presented in the %aterials and %ethods section>
666 666 666
4D. !re the variables measured with precision and using the latest techni'ues> 666 666 666 44. !re ade'uate data (sample siEe) and statistical analysis provided>
666 666 666 48. !re the gures and tables of suitable clarity and 'uality>
666 666 666 49. !re the titles of the tables and&or gures appropriate> 666
666 666 4<. !re the authorFs conclusions supported by the data>
666 666 666 4?. #s the discussion pertinent to the main theme of the paper>
666 666 666
4@. !re the claims and interpretations valid> 666 666 666
evista Universitas Scientiarum
ISSN 0122-7483 (versión impresa) ISSN 2027-1352 (versión en línea)
Carrera 7 No. 43-82 Edifcio CARLOS ORTÍZ Oc. 627 Tel-Fax: 320 83 20 Ext. 4070E-mail: [email protected]
+ page http&&www.javeriana.edu.co&facultades&ciencias &universitas&index.htmogot/, 0.1., 1olombia 2ur !m3rica
?
7/26/2019 Uni Sci- %28Evaluation Form-2013%29
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/uni-sci-28evaluation-form-201329 6/6
4A. 0o the authors propose new 'uestions&hypothesis for further studies> 666 666 666 4B. !re references provided ade'uate and cited correctly>
666 666 666
4C. !re the references up to date> 666 666 666 8D. 1ould the paper be improved by shortening it>
666 666 666 84. !re the organiEation, style and grammar satisfactory>
666 666 666 88. 1an the manuscript be read by subscribers from diGerent disciplines>
666 666 666
evista Universitas Scientiarum
ISSN 0122-7483 (versión impresa) ISSN 2027-1352 (versión en línea)
Carrera 7 No. 43-82 Edifcio CARLOS ORTÍZ Oc. 627 Tel-Fax: 320 83 20 Ext. 4070E-mail: [email protected]
+ page http&&www.javeriana.edu.co&facultades&ciencias &universitas&index.htmogot/, 0.1., 1olombia 2ur !m3rica
@