Williams AR # 1617 Page 1 of 87
Williams AR # 1617 Page 2 of 87
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
AIR FORCE CIVIL ENGINEER CENTER
MEMORANDUM FOR SEE DISTRIBUTION
FROM: AFCEC/CIBW706 Brooks RoadRome NY 13441
JUL 18 2013
SUBJECT: Restoration Advisory Board Meeting Minutes, 19 February 2013
1. Attached please find the final minutes from the 19 February 2013 Williams RestorationAdvisory Board (RAB) meeting held at the Arizona State University Polytechnic Campus asapproved by the RAB members at the 14 May 2013 meeting.
2. If you have any questions or comments, please contact Ms. Linda Geissinger at(916) 643-6420 x109.
Attachment:Final RAB Meeting Minutes, 19 February 2013
Lo'(t LL--t
CATHERINE RRARD, PEBRAC Environmental Coordinator
Williams AR # 1617 Page 3 of 87
DISTRIBUTION LISTFinal 19 February 2013 Williams RAB Meeting Minutes
Electronic Copy
Col. Len Fuchs, RAB Community Co-ChairCatherine Jerrard, RAB Co-Chair, AFCECDale Anderson, RAB, Gila River IndianCommunityScott Bouchie, RAB, City of MesaDon Atkinson, RAB, ADEQMatt Fesko, RAB, ASU graduate studentLonnie Frost, RAB, Gilbert Public WorksCarolyn d'Almeida, RAB, USEPALisa Marie Gerdel, RAB, Gilbert residentJames Holt, RAB, Queen Creek residentTom Zuppan, RAB, Gilbert residentAlan Ruffalo, RAB, Power Ranch residentDennis Orr, RAB, Gateway AirportPat Tennant, RAB, ASUTeresa Harris, RAB, Gilbert residentDoug Ashline, CitizenDominic Hernandez, CitizenDana Koziel, CitizenDon Lyon, CitizenBen Shunk, Gilbert residentLeo Pessin, Gilbert residentBeverly Selvage, Mesa residentThom Schuett, Queen Creek residentDon Smallbeck, AMECEverett Wessner, AMECJulie Hamilton, AMECEmily Corkery, AMECChris Courtney, AMECLinda Geissinger, AFCEC/CIBWBrian Sytsma, Napkin CommunicationsScott Johnston, Napkin CommunicationsMary Hall, AFCEC Public Affairs contractorGeoff Watkin, Cherokee Nation Gov. ServicesCalvin Cox, Cherokee Nation Gov. ServicesPatrick Banger, Town of Gilbert - City ManagerSharalyn Barnby, ASUAngela Creedon, ASULatonja West, ASUSteve Nielson, ASU
Joshua Hoyt, ASUSteve Hunter, ASURichard Malloy, ASUTheodore Betkie, ASU studentThomas Butler, USEPAEva Davis, USEPACollin DeWitt, Gilbert Fire Dept.Lawrence Dough, Able EngineeringVictor Gamez -Grij alva, CH2MHILLColleen Gilbert, Congressional Military AffairsMark Holmes, City of MesaJim Husbands, Booz Allen HamiltonAngie Kannada, Tierra DynamicsDan Kelley, Terra DynamicsAdam Mahamed, ADEQWayne Miller, ADEQDelfina Olivares, ADEQTravis Barnum, ADEQFelicia Calderon, ADEQLaura McNamara, HGLKimberly Vaughn, HGLRoger A. Fitzpatrick, HGLJohn Pekala, Environmental CorporationKathy Rall, Town of GilbertMartin Sepulveda, Sepulveda GroupBrian Sexton, Gateway AirportBrian Snowden, Arizona Green MagazineGlenn Stark, Gila River Indian CommunityGlen Stephens, Ch. 11 Mesa public accessArt Thomason, Arizona RepublicPhil Whitmore, CH2MHILLJanet Workman, URSJay Harbin, URSElspeth Sharp, URSDevan Phelan, Terra ThermJohn Meter, City of MesaDianna Saenz, AFCECSteve Willis, UXO Pro, ADEQ contractorBill Mabey, Tech Law
Attendees:NameMs. Cathy Jerrard
Mr. Len FuchsMr. Scott JohnstonMs. Mary HallMr. Dennis OffMr. Don Atkinson
Mr. Geoff Watkin
Mr. Jim HoltMr. Everett WessnerMr. Don SmallbeckMr. Leo PessinMr. Scott BouchieMr. Victor Gamez-GrijalvaMr. Matt FeskoMs. Pat TennantMr. Steve WillisCarolyn d'Almeida
Bill MabeyBeverly SelvageDelfina OlivarezEva Davis
Williams AR # 1617
Former Williams Air Force Base (AFB)Restoration Advisory Board (RAB)
Meeting Minutes
February 19, 2013, 7:15 p.m.Arizona State University Polytechnic Campus
Peralta Hall #1327171 E. Sonoran Arroyo Mall
Mesa, AZ
Page 4 of 87
OrganizationAir Force Civil Engineer Center (AFCEC) /Base Realignment andClosure (BRAC) Environmental Coordinator (BEC)/Air Force Co-chairRAB Community Co-chair/Gilbert residentAFCEC Public Affairs/ Napkin CommunicationsAFCEC Public Affairs/Napkin CommunicationsPhoenix-Mesa Gateway AirportArizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ), ProjectManagerCherokee Nation Government Solutions, AFCEC technical supportcontractorRAB Member/Queen Creek residentAMEC, AFCEC remediation contractorAMEC, AFCEC remediation contractorGilbert residentCity of MesaCH2MHILLArizona State University (ASU) student/RAB memberArizona State University (ASU)UXO Pro, ADEQ technical support contractorU.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), Region 9, ProjectManagerTechLaw, USEPA technical support contractorMesa residentArizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ), Public AffairsU.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Mr. Len Fuchs called the meeting to order at 7:15 p.m. and asked the attendees to introduce themselves.The RAB approved the November 2012 meeting minutes without changes. Ms. Cathy Jerrard provided abrief introduction and turned the presentation over to Mr. Everett Wessner.
Status Updates for ST035, ST012, FT002, SS017, and LF004Mr. Wessner presented updates for each site, see attached slides for more information. RAB andcommunity discussions for each site are presented below.
ST035, Former Base Gasoline Station Building 760Mr. Wessner summarized the slides presenting the site background, contaminants, and cleanup methodsin place. Soil vapor extraction (SVE) continues to remove fuel contaminants from the soil; groundwater
1
Williams AR # 1617 Page 5 of 87
monitoring is ongoing. The goal is to achieve site closure under the state Leaking Underground StorageTank (LUST) regulations.
Since the last briefing, a remediation well has been installed near the former source area and four newdowngradient monitoring wells were also installed. The remediation well is screened in two distinctzones. If there is a need to remediate groundwater, the well will have two zones it can target.
Groundwater flow continues to trend to the east with a slight northeast trajectory.
Benzene in groundwater near the source area has degraded significantly and no longer exceeds standards.Toluene, xylenes, methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE) and 1,2-dibromoethane (EDB) are all below thestandard except for MTBE and 1,2 DCA in MW09 and in two of the new downgradient wells (MW19Sand MW20D). MW09 is located next to the new remediation well (RW1). There is a possibility that whenRW1 was installed and developed it might have caused some temporary contamination to get into MW09.After the next quarterly sampling event is conducted later in February 2013, an evaluation will beperformed to determine future actions. The additional data and the plan forward for groundwater will beavailable at the May RAB meeting.
The SVE system has done a nice job removing total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) and the extractionrate is starting to decrease and flatten out, which is what typically happens as an SVE system cleans up acontaminant source. The system achieved 91.7% operational uptime, with the downtime due to weatherand shutting the system off while the remediation well was installed. A total of 3,231 pounds or 524gallons of TPH were removed during the fourth quarter of 2012 and17,000 gallons of TPH have beenremoved to date. The next performance sampling event is taking place later in February 2013.
Questions asked during ST035 presentation:
Mr. Holt asked why nothing shows up between the two 1,2-dichloroethane (1,2-DCA) plumes on slide 18.Mr. Wessner responded that previously five wells had 1,2-DCA. Two of the wells that had 1,2-DCAbefore do not have it now. There has been a decoupling where there is no 1,2-DCA above standard so itwould appear to be two distinct plumes.
Mr. Holt asked if that would suggest a different source. Mr. Wessner responded that would be doubtful,but instead the 1,2-DCA may just be barely below the standard, and therefore, not showing up in thedepiction of the plume areas. Mr. Smallbeck added that the distinction is likely due to decoupling andchanges in the direction of groundwater flow that has occurred over time. Some of the concentrationshave decreased in wells or the flow direction has changed so there is not a continuous plume.
Mr. Holt asked if that means parts of the plume have been cleaned up, but the contamination is still therein other places. Mr. Smallbeck responded that is correct.
Mr. Holt asked if soil vapor extraction is being used. Mr. Smallbeck responded the soil vapor extraction isconcentrated near the source area for the vadose zone, and not throughout the groundwater plume area.Mr. Holt asked if there are groundwater collection points. Mr. Smallbeck responded that there are not butthe soil cleanup keeps contaminants from further impacting groundwater.
Mr. Holt noted the slides show a slight change in gradient February through November and asked if thatis due to the amount of water flow. Mr. Smallbeck responded that is the direction the water flows.Mr. Holt said the numbers were 0.003 ft/ft and now they are 0.0023 ft/ft. Mr. Smallbeck responded theychange a little bit, but those are very small numbers. It is a thousandth of a foot. Mr. Wessner added it isa really flat gradient. Mr. Holt asked what made the change. Mr. Wessner stated it could be seasonal. Thegradient is the rate at which the water is flowing through the site. It could be affected by a rain event orany number of things.
Regarding the SVE operation, Ms. Tennant said that when it was originally installed the expectation wasit would run for about five years. She asked what the prediction is now. Mr. Wessner responded thecleanup is flattening off. Mr. Smallbeck added that AMEC has installed modifications to the system toincrease the rate of extraction from some of the wells that have the highest remaining TPH mass. After six
2
Williams AR # 1617 Page 6 of 87
months of operation with the modified system, AMEC will evaluate the results. By the end of 2013AMEC plans to conduct vapor sampling to see what residuals remain in the subsurface. If the remainingresiduals are low, AMEC would take soil samples to confirm that the SVE system has met the cleanupgoals. The system started running in 2010 and shutting down the system may be possible in 2014. Therehaven't been any detections of benzene in a few quarters and it is looking very good. Mr. Wessner addedthat the system is removing 500-plus gallons of petroleum every three months. It is still doing some goodand there is still some mass to be taken out, but it is good news that the rate is flattening out because thatmeans most of contamination has been removed.
ST012, Former Liquid Fuels Storage Operation
Mr. Wessner summarized the slides presenting the site background, contaminants, cleanup methods inplace, and the path forward. The primary soil contaminants for the site are petroleum hydrocarbons whichincludes benzene.
The 1992 OU-2 Record of Decision (ROD) pump-and-treat remedy was ineffective in cleaning thegroundwater. A pilot test for steam enhanced extraction technology was conducted and lead to a FocusedFeasibility Study (final FSS November 2012). The deep vadose zone, which is defined as greater than 25feet below ground surface (bgs), is currently being treated with an SVE system.
The water table is approximately 143 to 155 feet bgs, up 67 feet from1989. Mr. Wessner stated that therising groundwater is part of the problem. After the petroleum hydrocarbons were released, groundwaterlevels have risen, resulting in a portion of the material being submerged beneath the groundwater andtrapped within the soil pore spaces.
The November 2012 flow direction in the Upper Water Bearing Zone (UWBZ)/Cobble Zone (CZ) isnortheast. The flow in the Lower Saturated Zone (LSZ) is also northeast. During the November 2012sampling event, 27 wells were sampled. All concentrations of chemicals of concern (COC) are similar tohistorical data (2009-2011). The latest results showed an increase in some of the COC concentrations(such as benzene) in the UWBZ/CZ and a decrease in the LSZ.
The SVE system for the deep soil operated at 99.5% uptime from October through December 2012 with26,801 pounds (or 4,079 gallons) of TPH removed. Nine of the 27 wells are operating with an upwardtrend of product being removed from the deep soils. To date, 262,000 gallons of TPH have been removedand the next scheduled SVE performance monitoring is later in February 2013. Those results will beavailable by the next RAB meeting.
The groundwater containment system uses existing wells and equipment configured to allow operation ofa modified pump-and-treat system. Until a ROD amendment is signed to establish a new groundwaterremedy, the extraction system continues to operate to provide treatment and to reduce the potential forcontaminant migration in groundwater. The system began operating in January 2012, was shutdown inAugust for a retrofit, and was restarted in September 2012. Groundwater extraction is focused on thelower saturated zone. Extraction activities have removed and treated 9.5 million gallons of groundwaterand 181 pounds of benzene from January through December of 2012. The components remaining fromthe treatability study are now being used to contain the flow of groundwater until the final remedy can beput in place.
A draft Amended Proposed Plan was submitted January 2013 for regulatory review. A public meeting istentatively planned for April 18. Steam enhanced extraction and enhanced bioremediation is the AirForce's preferred treatment alternative. A Record of Decision is planned for summer 2013, RemedialDesign by fall 2013, and remedy construction in 2014. Annual groundwater monitoring will take place inNovember 2013.
Questions asked during ST012 presentation:
Mr. Holt asked if the figures show gradient intervals that are only five feet apart. Mr. Smallbeckresponded that the potentiometric surfaces are based on 1/2 foot (0.5 ft) contours.
3
Williams AR # 1617 Page 7 of 87
Mr. Holt stated he meant from the Upper Zone to the Lower Zone. He said the number at the end of theline, in the upper zone show 1187 feet and in the Lower Zone show 1183 feet. So they are only four feetapart?
Mr. Watkin responded that those are the static water levels based on wells screened in two differentzones. The lower zone is deeper than the upper zone with a well screen in each zone. The water enters thescreen and then seeks its own level within the well and that's what is measured. It's called the static waterlevel. The well screen is actually deeper, but the water level rises to its own level and it is the waterpressure that is being measured.
Mr. Holt asked if the water pressure in the lower zone is bringing the lower level water up to within fivefeet of the level in the upper zone.
Mr. Watkin indicated it was and added that measuring the levels in all the different wells is a way todetermine the gradient. The goal is to figure out how groundwater flows in the lower zone because thezones are geologically separated.
Mr. Holt stated it was thought that there was a non-permeable layer between the two. Mr. Smallbeckresponded it is not totally non-permeable. Water does move in between the layers but it is a definiteseparation from a hydrogeologic and pressure perspective.
Mr. Watkin stated that the well screens are at different depths. There are several wells in the upper zoneand several in the lower zone. The wells are separate so it can be determined out how water is movingbetween the two different zones. By taking measurements in all the wells in the upper zone it can bedetermined where the water rises from those well screens, and the direction and how fast the water isflowing.
Mr. Holt stated the numbers are not really the level of the upper and lower zone. They are the result ofpressure in those zones inside the wells. Mr. Watkin responded they are the level that the waterequilibrates at from each of those zones. It's not a measurement of the actual water in the zone; it's ameasurement of how the water behaves in the zone.
Mr. Holt stated one concern about the mixing of the upper and lower zones is it seems like the upper zoneis where the contamination is. Mr. Smallbeck responded it is actually the opposite; most of thecontamination is in the lower zone. Mr. Wessner referenced slide 30 as an example of the one well thathas groundwater contamination above action levels in the upper zone. Mr. Wessner referenced slide 31 asan example of multiple wells where groundwater contamination is above action levels in the lower zone.
Mr. Pessin asked why the ST012 SVE unit had 99.5% operational uptime when ST035 system operated at91.7%. Mr. Smallbeck responded that ST012 is a much bigger system and it was able to operate during aperiod when there was cold weather and rain that caused the system to shut down ST035. (Post-meetingnote: The ST035 system also had a planned shutdown during installation of a groundwater remediationwell in the source area.)
Mr. Fesko asked if the RAB members would be notified of the location and time of the Proposed PlanPublic meeting. The RAB members will receive a fact sheet notifying them of the Proposed Plan locationand time.
FT002 Former Fire Training Area No. 2Mr. Wessner stated soil contamination is the problem at this site and the COCs are benzene, chloroform,and 1,4-dichlorobenzene. There is no evidence that the site has impacted groundwater. A ROD was put inplace in 1996. It had a bioventing remedy for the soil but the soil cleanup goals were not achieved withthat remedy and the system was shut down. There is currently a Declaration of Environmental UseRestriction (DEUR) to prohibit residential use on the site because the goals were not met. The DEUR alsorequires applicable soil management procedures for excavations below 5 feet.
4
Williams AR # 1617 Page 8 of 87
On November 28, 2012, AMEC completed a Soil and Soil Vapor Sampling Work Plan with regulatoryconcurrence for sampling to determine if contaminant levels had decreased to the ROD cleanup goalsover the past 15 years.
A soil gas survey was performed December 4, 2012 and 10 soil gas samples were collected at the formerEastern Burn Pit. A soil investigation was performed January 7-18, 2013. During the investigation, 11 soilborings were drilled and sampled to 100 feet bgs at the former burn pits. ADEQ also collected samples toverify results and to evaluate the site for additional contaminants. Data will be evaluated and if RODcleanup goals are achieved, then a closure report for unrestricted closure of the site will be prepared forregulatory review in April 2013.
Questions asked during FT002 presentation:
There were none.
SS017, Former Pesticide/Paint ShopMr. Wessner provided background and a status update for SS017. SS017 is the old pesticide/paint shopand the chemical of concern is dieldrin in both the soil and groundwater. There was a removal action in2000 when soil contaminated with dieldrin was excavated. AMEC continues to monitor the groundwaterto evaluate the presence of dieldrin. There are levels of dieldrin in some wells that intermittently exceedscreening levels but there is no regulatory standard for dieldrin. The annual sampling is done in August.The Draft OU-6 ROD was completed in March 2012. The Air Force is preparing an updated riskevaluation for regulatory review.
Questions asked during SS017 presentation:
There were none.
LF004, Former Solid Waste LandfillMr. Wessner said that the OU-1 ROD dealt with soil contaminants at LF004, including dieldrin andberyllium in surface soil, and the remedy, a permeable cap, was successfully implemented. Thegroundwater has started to rise and as a result, groundwater impacts are being seen. There are ongoingsemiannual groundwater sampling events. The COCs for groundwater and subsurface soil areperchloroethylene (PCE) and trichloroethylene (TCE). The impacts to groundwater are bounded by thegroundwater monitoring network and a solution is being evaluated in the LF004 Focused FeasibilityStudy.
The semi-annual groundwater sampling event was conducted at 54 wells in November 2012 and thereport will be submitted in early 2013. TCE and PCE plumes are stable and adequately defined.Groundwater results indicate historically decreasing concentrations of TCE and PCE in hot spot areas;however, PCE in LF01-W19 increased in the November 2012 event. The next groundwater samplingevent will be May 2013.
The Draft Final Focused Feasibility Study is under regulatory review and a Proposed Plan public meetingis planned for May 18, 2013. A Record of Decision is planned for summer 2013, Remedial Design by fall2013, and remedy construction in 2014. Semi-annual groundwater monitoring will take place in May2013 and landfill maintenance is ongoing.
Questions asked during LF004 presentation:
Mr. Bouchie asked if the PCE and TCE concentrations shown are from the upper or middle zones or arejust the highest number. Mr. Wessner responded that the figures are shown by zone and the highestconcentrations wells (17 and 19) for PCE and TCE at the site are in the middle zone.
Contracting UpdateMs. Jerrard provided an update on contracting issues. The Army Corps of Engineers in Huntsville,Alabama is scheduled to award the contract for Munitions Response Site XU403 (located in Parcel N
5
Williams AR # 1617 Page 9 of 87
Debris Area) in February 2013. Once the contractor is chosen there will be more information on what theschedule is. The anticipated schedule is that all of the work plans will be submitted in the March to Junetimeframe.
There will be several different work plans submitted. One will be for the munitions removal, another onewill be for some chemical sampling. There will also be an archeological work plan to handle thearcheological areas of the site and there will be a special chemicals safety submission that has to gothrough several organizations for approval. Field work is anticipated to start in July 2013 and take twomonths to complete. It will include munitions removal, environmental sampling and debris removal.Following the completion of the field work there will be several different completion reports: onepertaining to environmental results and one pertaining to munitions results. The chemical safetysubmission also has to be closed out. In addition, 34 acres of the site were previously cleared formunitions. A No Further Action document for those 34 acres must be prepared as well.
Questions asked during Contracting update:
There were none.
Meeting Wrap-upThat concluded the information portion of the evening. There were no action items identified as a resultof the meeting. Agenda items for the May 2013 RAB included:
One item proposed is to have the munitions response contractor and the Corps of Engineersattend the next meeting to present the project.It was also suggested that the LF004 Proposed Plan public meeting be held at the May 14 RABmeeting. An abbreviated RAB meeting would be held to discuss the sites that have the mostactivity. Followed by an update from the Corps of Engineers and the LF004 Proposed Plan publicmeeting. Mr. Fesko stated that it would be nice to get at least a quick update on each of the sites.Ms. Jerrard agreed.
The next meeting on the schedule is a Proposed Plan public meeting for ST012 which will be heldtentatively on April 18, 2013.
Mr. Fuchs adjourned the meeting at 8:15 p.m.
The next Williams RAB meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, May 14, 2013 at 7:15 p.m. at the ArizonaState University Polytechnic Campus.
Attachments:
February 19, 2013 RAB meeting slide presentation
6
Former Williams AFB Restoration Advisory Board MeetingWi1116M9 AR
Date: 14 May, 2013
Page 10 of 87
Please sign in. If your information has changed since you last attended,please place an asterisllill next to your name.
NAME/ORGANIZATION ADDRESS PHONE1.
/ ,,., .,,,,,,
,,..r._,44 ,dii,tc(),_. 5111L ALA-8_4
5.SA-ciiI6Le iC
6.
hoe 467204/
IA Ca/VVOIA
-ni i Lk- G34,0(101 C26-01e 410
i0.\-A 9-,RAR.
11 _...... . ,
/ 2.
13.
14.
15.
I E -MAIL
WilElfams AR # Page 11 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Former Williams AFBRestoration Advisory Board
(RAB)
February 19, 2013
Arizona State Polytechnic CampusPeralta Hall Room 132
7171 E. Sonoran Arroyo Mall Rd.Mesa, AZ
2/19/2013
Wil617ms AR # Page 12 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Welcome& Introductions
Presented by:Mr. Len Fuchs / Ms. Catherine Jerrard,
RAB Community Co-Chairsand Scott Johnston
2/19/2013
WilElfams AR # Page 13 of 87
Welcome & Introductions
Mr. Len Fuchs, RAB Community Co-Chair
Ms. Catherine Jerrard, Air Force Civil Engineer Center(AFCEC), PM/BEC and RAB Co-Chair
Ms. Carolyn d'Almeida, Project Manager, U.S.Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Region 9
. Mr. Donald Atkinson, Project Manager, ArizonaDepartment of Environmental Quality (ADEQ)
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
WilElizms AR # Page 14 of 87
Agenda
Time
7:15 PM
7:30-8:30 PM
Topic
RAB Meeting Convenes
Welcome and introductionsCommunity co-chair remarksReview Nov 2012 meeting minutesand action items
Program Updates
ST035 UpdateNov 2012 Groundwater (GW) resultsOct-Dec 2012 Soil Vapor Extraction (SVE)Performance ResultsPath Forward
ST012 Status UpdateNov 2012 GW ResultsOct-Dec 2012 SVE Performance ResultsGW Containment Study ResultsST012 FFS, Proposed Plan and Preferred AlternativePath Forward
Presenter
Mr. Len FuchsMs. Catherine JerrardMr. Scott Johnston
Ms. Catherine JerrardMr. Everett Wessner
Integrity - Service - Excellence
WilElizms AR # Page 15 of 87
Agenda Continued
Time Topic Presenter
7:30-8:30 PM Program Updates continued Mr. Everett WessnerFT002 Status Update
Summary of Field Activities (Dec 12- Jan 13)Path Forward
8:30 PM
9:00 PM
SS017 Status UpdateOU6 Record of Decision (ROD) statusPath Forward
LF004 StatusNov 2012 GW resultsFFS Remedial AlternativesPath Forward
Meeting wrap-up Ms. Catherine JerrardOther Active ProjectsReview action items for next meetingCall for agenda items for next meetingPropose next RAB meeting - May 14, 2013
Adjourn Mr. Len Fuchs
Integrity - Service - Excellence
WilElfams AR # Page 16 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Program UpdatesSites ST035, ST012, FT002,
SS017, and LF004
Presented by:Ms. Catherine Jerrard, AFCEC
Mr. Everett Wessner, AM EC
Wil617ms AR # Page 17 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Site ST035, FormerBuilding 760 USTs
2/19/2013
adualiaaxa - adviaas - Xnagajui 1.0Z/6
aaweZ-1. dew uoge307 al!S 5E015
ELJOZpV 'ES8NeSeEl 83.10 .11V SWEIIIIM JeLIII0j
m
0
IaI
74
pa sooad
,41PdP1 3,11110 iued co, goIA.c.ananeinetomp.11010d1IPW...mem 0111 saamennloom saw. dew
PIE ae, agegosew me alue gum mem oauaei alal Noll dew a,
s MI
0 0
@llw g 0 = 1 :@leog
[CZ/KILO @]eaME
100 9 11 6 016 ON :ler
Ampunoe EIJV s =HUM JaLUJOJ
(09L 61-1!Pl!nel aeiwo) fuepuno9 gEILS
puaBai
rikieD.Ilifrnimi.
/'"
Mashur---Erz 13N-13 laIA=suie
0
ro
den uone307 CiaLSL8 Jo 8T ebPd # suIVE1DIETM
WilElfams AR # Page 19 of 87
Site ST035 Site Background
Building 760 gas station and oil/water separatorGas dispensing until 1986Tank and dispensing equipment removed in 1993-1994Oil/water separator removed in 1996
Vadose zone soil chemicals of concern (COCs)Benzene
Groundwater COCsBenzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, xylenes (BTEX)1,2-Dibromoethane (EDB)Methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE)1,2-Dichloroethane (DCA)
Soil Vapor Extraction (SVE) system to treat COCs in vadose zone soil inoperationSite cleanup regulated by ADEQ under Leaking Underground Storage Tank(LUST) regulation (R18-12-263)Ongoing quarterly groundwater monitoring
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Site ST035 GroundikafeiMonitorPtiii *date* Oct-Nov 2012 New Well Installation
1 new remediation well (RW1) installed near former source area2 discreet screen intervals to monitor and/or remediate the CobbleZone (CZ) and Upper Water Bearing Zone (UWBZ)
4 new monitoring wells (MW19S, MW19D, MW20S, and MW20D)installed downgradient of wells MW17 and MW18 for further plumedefinition2 discreet screen intervals per well to monitor downgradient COCconcentrations in the CZ and UWBZSampled during Nov 2012 Quarterly Event
Integrity - Service - Excellence
Site ST035 Groundwafer *date11617 AR #
401. Oct-Nov 2012 New Well Installation
1111
0 el1*dd'ze,as sif Rernediation well ,7*-4,4
07-WE-4 titP760-VMP-2
B750-VMP-11
6760 -SVE -3 41%.B7S0 TRWSB760- Ono mwiu
13760-M9411
r
B7.00,MW15
171760-09906R
0760 9MP 3 \\.,\4k, -. 1' ;
F ,ifz
..#%_ r * 13780-VMP 4
10 ,..0 at 41k- .
8760 -sye-z/.
0'. 1t., B7613 VMP-5
* . '
'*±.. .
P' eralta Hall
Picache Ha
R7130-SVF-5Ott.
Aravaipa Auditorium6750-VMP.7
Peralta Ha
8700 =MWO5
B760 MW12
I Sutton Residence Hall
13760-VMP4
It
Wanner Hall
-10011111141
if ON
14011P e e 1Alatatar 46
4.* 0111117$ ' 4
4,I
;7130-MWI
14
0760 MVVO!.
E176041VVO7R
0750 RAW17
New dwells
wngradi
B760-MW18re
.114A4401.0c$1..
15780-MW19S13760-M11/190
8760-MW2OS
1;' 61604'1"X
P 3
LegendNested Soil Vapor Extraction Well Location
Nested Vapor Monitoring Point Location
Ile Groundwater Monitoring Well Location
Decommissioned Groundwater MonitoringWell Location
Approximate Location of FormerBuilding 760
Approximate Location of FormerUnderground StorageTank
Approximate Location of Former BelowGrade Product Distribution Line
monitoringN
Feet A25 50 100
Working CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST035 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST035 Monitoring Well FIGURE
Location Map 2-1
Job N. 9101110001PM. EWDate. 1/30f2013 amed3Stale: 1^. 100.
I'zr=tr;.
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 11
Site ST035 Groundwafer# *dateAR
Nov 2012 Flow Direction6161R- -I I
B7ITAT5
E1760-MW111195.93
7603MW09
6760.61W06R1195.83
:11I E
.4<k[161
ak I 137,61041W 12
GroundwaterGroun%,--Flow Direction
0.023(Gtta4e0t
4 W "1.044 1101.
13767-MW19S I1
1
4;
B760-MW441
B760-MVVO8R 13760.11IWO7R4 1195.46 1194 -90
B760-MW171194.07
T
B760.MW13
1195.96
1195.34
B760-MW161194.06
1193.68
10144
lakB760-MW205
1193.77
Legend
Groundwater Monitoring Well Location
Potentiometric Contour Line- (Dashed Where Inferred) (ft amsi)
(Contour Interval = 0.5 ft)
Groundwater Flow Directionwith Gradient (ft/ft)
Approximate Location of FormerBuilding 760
Approximate Location of FormerUnderground StorageTank
Approximate Location of Former Below- Grade Product Distribution Line
Notes:
B760-MW12 Monitoring Well Identification1195.20 Groundwater Elevation (ft arm!)
ft Feet
It amsl Feet above mean sea level
0 25 50 100
Feet AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST035 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST035 Potentiometric Surface Map FIGURE
November 2012 Event 3-2
Job No. 9101110001PM: EW 0Date: 1/30/2013 ames.aie: - = no.
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 12
Site ST035 GroundWaiselothonitorliii *date2012 Quarterly Flow Directions
$8760-1,1,115
13760-191VV11
1196 04
19760.1/1W09/1955)
1194_30
19760419906R1196.20
8769-9,11,916119.989. s _
19760.1.199121195 10
Gradient = 0.003 ft /ft)
8750 -M WO OR1195:19 B760-1M17
1193.69
13760-1M/191195 99
B760-M9V18c, 1195.05
February 2012
8760-11/1W061i1195.90
WO,
ti13750-1919908R
1195 32 4B760.109913
1195 29
19700-1.4,1171199.92
AaB760.MW18
1193.90
August 2012
87604.1W12
5760-0/19906191195,37 ,-, 1,
1195 16
97' 0 -MW16
mite- r_Flow DireOlen
(Gradient = 0.04/ft4
8790,149/171193.87
13760.MW13.95 21
57.60.MW181113.83
May 2012
X
5760-519,1111195 93
13760,11AVV06Ft
1195.63
II Pn
13760-38614t 1 199 91
15,
19760-MWO91195.
glIMMe...4,2 _
Gritoundr leiFlow.Direction
'", 20
(Gr
.00
adient = 0.0023 ftLit;t
13760-MIN0BR1195 46
19760,1991311.95 34
13760-MW16.119422
760-1611,918
1194.96
B760-MW2051193 77
November 2012
LegendGroundwater Monitoring Well Location
Potentiometric Contour Line- (Dashed Where Inferred) (ftains')
(Contour Interval = 0.5 ft)
Groundwater Flow Direction with111 Gradient (ft/ft)
Approximate Location of FormerBuilding 760
Approximate Location of FormerNM Underground StorageTank
Approximate Location of Former BelowGrade Product Distribution Line
Notes:
B760-MW12 Monitoring Well Identification1190.20 Groundwater Elevation (ft ems!)
9 Feet
ft erns! Feet above mean sea level
o 50 100 200
Feet AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST035 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST035 Potentiometric Surface Map FIGURE
Quarterly 2012 3-1
Job No. 9181110001PM: EWDate: 1/30/2013 ame0Scale: 1" =200'
0.890.97.ro 99.
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 13
01Site ST035 GroundWhlerMonitorirt211pdate4N.ZP Nov 2012 Sampling Event
17 wells sampled (4 new monitoring wells included)
Groundwater flowing west to east
Benzene detected in 7 wells (8 wells in Aug 2012):Tier 1 Standard = 5 micrograms per liter (gg/L)7 wells < 5 gg/L (7 wells in Aug 2012)0 wells > 5 gg/L (0 wells in Aug 2012)
1,2-DCA detected in 7 wells (6 wells in Aug 2012)Tier 1 Standard = 5 gg/L2 wells < 5 gg/L - (1 well in Aug 2012)5 wells > 5 gg/L - (5 wells in Aug 2012); includes MW19S andMW2OD (new downgradient wells)
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Site ST035 Groundiii6leiVonitorirt 211i3date4* Nov 2012 Sampling Event
MTBE detected in 7 wells (3 wells in Aug 2012)Tier 1 Standard = 94 .t,g/L4 wells < 94 gg/L - (3 wells in Aug 2012)3 wells > 94 gg/L - (0 wells in Aug 2012)
MWO9 (existing well next to new RW1)MW19S and MW20D (new downgradient wells)
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Site ST035 GrOiiiidst4Mer MonitOririglii3dateNov 2012 Results > Tier 1 Standards
0760-MW09
GECAOEQ Tier
Nov-121 SW.MTBE sa 120/1201,2-OCA 5 48147
1114.1
X11
D780-MW10ADEQ Tier
1 SW. Nov-12
6760 -MW 795
vf 'IMTBE1 2-DCA
878000N17
1
ADEQ Tier1 SW. Nov-12
r
11A
0 0760-91W1956700-MW190-
8760-M8200'67110MV/200
13760-MW 200
COCADEQ Tier Results
Nov-121 SW.MTBE 94 /101 2-0CA 5 7.7
Legend
Groundwater Monitoring Well Location
Approximate Location of FormerBuildi ng 760
mg Approximate Locatton of FernierUnderground StorageTank
Approximate Location of Former eclowGrade Product Distribution Line
Notes:
ONO-1M M Mongoring Well Henbileolion8700616 101 MOngoring 8001010 no aealytee 00100100 abOsie
the RL during 2012
OriginadOupicate Rosaha
Analylleal result rpg/Ll equals or eNeeds theapplicable ADE() UST Test 1 Cumuli.. Action01311112111. For MTEE, A050 guidOnce PeceSeSfor a Correa.. Action Standard of 54 141(1. whenM drinking wrier wee is Oldie. (9000. 2002)
140. Microgram W. liter
l.2 -FICA 2-dideoroethena0000 Somme Department of Eaurronmenisi (MalayCOC Chemise of COIICEIll
MDL Method OeteMion Lirrd
MBE Methy1 tertiary butyl otherRL Reporting Limn
UST Underground Riorege Taos
.5117 1
0 25 50 100
Fool
Working CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite 5T035 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST035 COC Concentration* FIGURE
November 2012 3-4a
0 319101119031Pat:AM: amecOtn etfaale:cele: 1' r
....
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Site ST035 Grounwarer Monitoring UpdateNov 2012 MTBE lsoconcentration Map
11780414,415.
p-disc.,:
13760-POW-11<5 0 Ll
0760-MINC9130.0/120.0 Pan y
0760.MWO6RA5 017
29
islit 14a .111,111
la6,mil._
- *
;11#,
4a
13700-1,111414 0<5.0
111 mi
../
IR Mt .94 11, ik fibepol6v117 ' -6; if
t.611 1"°
B7604AW20illko7a`F
r
R
LegendMTBE Concentrations (mit) in Groundwater(Dashed Where Inferred)
594 pg /Le
ADEQ UST Der 1 Corrective Action Standard = 04 pg/L
4 Groundwater Monitoring Well Location
Approximate Location of FormerBuilding 780
111.Approximate Location of FormerUnderground StorageTank
Approximate Location of Former Below---- Grade Product Distribution Line
Notes:11760.MW19S
1200
odpo,q-<1.0
MTESE
ADEQ
MDLRL
UST
Monitoring Well Identif cationMTBE Concentration (pg/L)(Results that are ItaRlzad and bolded epochor eaceed the ADEL! UST Tier 1 CorrectiveAction Standard of 04 pg/L)OrIginanuplicate ResultsMicrogram per literNot detected at or above the RLMethyl tertiary butyl etherArizona Department of Environmental QualityThe analyte was positively identified but theassociated concentration Isar estimationabove the MDL and below the RLMethod Detection LimitReporting LimitThe enelyte wee analyzed Tor, but not detectedat or above the RL shownUnderground Storage Tank
o 25 50 100
Feet ADraft
Annual 2012Groundwater Monitoring Report
Site ST035 - Former Williams Air Force BaseMesa, Arizona
ST035 MTBE Concentrations FIGUREin Groundwater
November 2012 Event 3-7
Job No. 9101110001
amed9PM- EWea*, vieqe+3Scale: I" = 100t
-.s-ee
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 17
Site ST035 Grouriiiater Monitonh4 UpdateNov 2012 1,2-DCA lsoconcentration Map
Legend1,2-DCA Concentrations iiigfL) in Groundwater
{Dashed Where Inferred)
411". i."12
ADEQ UST Tler I' Corrective Action Standard c 5 go/L
Groundwater Monitoring Well Location
Approximate Location of FormerBuilding 760
inApproximate Location of FormerUnderground StorageTank
Approximate Location of Former BelowGrade Product Distribution Line
Notes:weirmoNo Monitoring Wet Identification
07 12-0CA Concentration (wit)(Results that are italicized arld bolded equal oremceed the ADECI LIST Tier I Corrective ActionStandard of 5 AIL)
20/2.7 OtiginabDupticate Results{..;12 Microgram per tier01 .0 Not detected at or above the RL
1.2-DCA 1 2-DichioniethaneADEO Arizona Department of Environmental Duality
F The analyte was positively Identified but theassociated ctn.:entre-1am iS an estrnaton abovethe MDL and below the RLThe anolyte wee positively identified, estimateddue to mains effect.
MDL Method Detection LimitRL Reporting LinnLI The analyte was analyzed fors but not detected at
or above the RL shownUST Underground Storage Tank
0 25 50 100
Feet AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST035 - Farmer Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST035 1,2-DCA Concentrations FiGURE
in GroundwaterNovember 2012 Event 34
1
Job No, eimoop,PR EWDate 2/4/212 amee9Scale 1' o 1017
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
WilElfams AR #
gife2trO352012 Annual Groundwater Summary
Concentrations of benzene in the source area have significantlydecreased since SVE startup in 2010
Toluene, Xylenes, MTBE, and EDB were below the Tier 1 Standards,except for the Nov 2012 MTBE results at MWO9 (next to new RW1) andMW19S & MW20D (new downgradient wells)
Concentrations of MTBE and 1,2-DCA have increased at the formersource area and immediately downgradient
1,2-DCA and MTBE were detected above the Tier 1 Standard at newdowngradient wells MW19S and MW19D, respectively
Ongoing quarterly groundwater sampling - Next event Feb 2013
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
WilElizms AR # Page 30 of 87
Site ST035 SVE System Update
Oct - Dec 2012
. 91.7% operational uptime
Total PetroleumHydrocarbons (TPH)removed - 3,231 pounds or524 gallons(646 gallons removed fromJuly-Sept 2012)
11 of 15 SVE wells operating(same as July-Sept 2012)
Integrity - Service - Excellence
WilElfams AR # Page 31 of 87
Site ST035 SVE System Performance
35,000
30,000
sal 25,000s_
a 20,000
0
cca, 15,000
a0
10,000(.7
25,000
00-
98.4%
99.8%
99.9%
The value above the bar represents thepercentage of time the system was
operational during that sampling period.
91.9%99.7%
901
91.7%
11§'.6!" 6
P'z' N%
O 06" sa N 06'
IlEstimated TPH Mass Removed per Quarter (Cumulative Volume TPH Removed
18,000
- 16,000
- 14,000
- 12,000
- 10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
WilElfams AR # Page 32 of 87
Site ST035 SVE System Summary
Average mass removal of TPH is declining as expected
17,000 gallons of TPH removed to date
SVE system continues operation within permit emissionrequirements
Decreased operational time due to weather related shutdowns
Next performance sampling Feb 2013
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wii(117ms AR # Page 33 of 87
Site ST035 Path Forward
Complete groundwater characterization and performremediation as needed
Continue SVE operation
Ongoing quarterly groundwater sampling - Next event Feb2013
Updated site strategy to be developed after February 2013groundwater sampling event
Achieve site closure under LUST regulation (R18-12-263.04)
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 23
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Site ST012, FormerLiquid Fuels Storage
Area
WilElfams AR # Page 35 of 87
Site ST012 Location Map
Ray-Rd
ii
e
aa
w
Willi ams=Fiel d-Rd
Legend
ST012 Boundary
C:I Former Williams AFB Boundary
0 025 5
Miles
Job No. 9101110001PM: EWDate: 05/09/2012Scale: 1" = 0.5 mile
Tlemapsioralm.beekomnaMalagemamwo.AmmakastrWtrise wttlAPAEC PnleotNimter9101113:01. TM map la
loWeekcanrneManNumamytirapanymo1.rupcomeswilogtwarra.AMEGaseimealoisM.almotor.mot,InceueMalys.t.pn/M.
Former Williams Air Force BaseMesa, Arizona
ST012 Site Location MapFIGURE
1-2
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 25
WilElfams AR # Page 36 of 87
Site ST012 Site Background
Former liquid fuels storage operation
19 underground storage tanks (USTs) and piping removed in 1990
COCs in soil and groundwater are TPH and benzene
Shallow soil (< 25 feet deep) cleanup achieved (1996): OU-2 ROD 1992
Deep vadose zone soil (> 25 feet deep) currently treated by SVE: OU-2RODA 1996
Water table (-143 to 155 feet below ground surface [bgs]) has risen -67feet since 1989
OU-2 ROD groundwater pump and treat remedy ineffective-Alternative remedies evaluated in a Focused Feasibility Study (FFS), Nov 2012
Ongoing annual groundwater monitoring (Nov)
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 26
WilElfams AR # Page 37 of 87
Site ST012 Groundwater COCs
COC OU-2 ROD Action Level (pg/L)
Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)
Benzene 5
1,2-DCA 5
Ethylbenzene 700Methylene Chloride 5
Naphthalene 28PCE 5
Toluene 1,000TCFME 2,100
Total Xylenes 10,000
Semi-volatile Organic Compounds (SVOCs)
bis(2-Ethylhexyl)phthalate 6
2-Methylnaphthalene NE
2-Methylphenol 8704-Methylphenol 870
Phenol 4,200
Metals
Antimony 6
Chromium (Total) 100
Copper 1,300Lead 15
Nickel 100
Silver 50
Zinc 1,400
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
4.1Upper Water Bearing Zone/Cobble Zone (UWBZ/CZ)
Site ST012 Groundwater Monitoring8UpdateNov 2012 Flow Directions
-01
T
Unity Ave
ix
,i, s X
1I X
X
i -- I I.'1
.... X " X
.., . 1.I 1 ii
X,
57012.U,21190 23
U7ysses Ave -um. v ST012.Ut2
191)2 511'90 45
drO,1,
57{11 2-1.175,..1 D4
7012-0O2
57012-UO2
4
ti 11°"1.
5
e
51,112-.3
-i. xi
\ \ \ ...-\..,''si,
'.9-:,ii --0
ge
5701241192 .11.,5
0
a
51'012.CP
as
X90
P1
Legend
Groundwater Monitoring Well Location4 Screened in the UWBZ,C2
Potentiometric Contour Line(Dashed Where Inferred) (ft ams1)(Contour Interval = 0.5 ft)
Groundwater Flow Directionwith Gradient (Mt)
Fenceline
3 ST012 Boundary
Notes:STo12 -REI-1A Monitoring Well Identification
1 l8t95 Groundwater Elevation di wrisli<11fiebo, Groundwater elevation not used for
potentionnetric surfaceft Feetamsi Feet above mean sea level
tit/EV/CZ Upper Water Bearing Zone I Cobble Zone
0 50 1W 200
11=1 Feet AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST012 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST012 UWBZ/CZ PotentiometricSurface Map
November 2012
FIGURE
3-2
Job No. 9101110001PM: VADote ar112913 amec9
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 28
Site ST012 Groundwater Monitoriag9UpdateNov 2012 Flow Directions
Lower Saturated Zone (LSZ)
_ .
Unity Ave
tt,ti
1 A
51,7124/38vla5 1,3
\ "IvM124107
ST012.W121107 06A
wo`kceck°0\el
ST012.W34
ST0t2.4V1.8
ST(112AN29
Reserve Center
Imo
ST0124,1351107i. 35
1182 62
iR
5 Screened in the LSZ
Legend
Groundwater Monitoring Well Location
Polentiornetrie Contour Line- (Dashed Where Inferred) (ft airis.1).
(Contour Interval = 0.5 ft)
Groundwater Flow Directionwith Gradient (ftift)
Fenceline
c ST012 Boundary
Notes:
ST0121113.1C Monitoring Well Identification1185.25 Groundwater gievatIon rfl ams4
ft Feet
ft ems! Feet above mean sea level1.S2 Lower Saturated Zone
50 100 200
Feet AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST012 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST012 LSZ PotentiometricSurface Map
November 2012
FIGURE
3-3
Job No. 9191110001PM EMI
Date: ZIMMSSnake I". 200' ame0
Integrity - Service - Excellence
Site ST012 GroundimieAli *Monitor l ticiateNov 2012 Results > Action Levels UWBZ/CZ
ST012-RB -1A
Analyte Units
OU-2 RODActionLevel 11120/2012
VOCsBenzene og/L 5.0 5500Naphthalene pgIL 28.0 37
ST012-10125.,
- 57012.110-1A511012-0O2, i
\ ST1112,13115'
ST012,50.204 /
ST01,035
;ysse, Avert.
STDISIA13
ST012-X01S hr
U.S. ArmyReserve-Center
ST012.0O3
ii
, a
I "
ST012-011:
0 I -
STOISCeat
0 %
4511012,127/ 01r012.13.3A
/ /
/ ST012-008
C-3
Legend
Groundwater Monitoring Well LocationScreened in the UWBZJCZ
Fenceline
ST012 Boundary
No-to,
ST012-RB-1A Monitoring Well Identification
Analytical result equals Or heapplicable 0U-2 ROD Aebon Level
pg/L Microgram per liter
COC Chemicals of concernOU Operable Unit
ROD Record o(Decismn
UWDZ/CZ Upper Water Bearing Zone/Cobble ZoneVOCs Volatile Organic Compounds
37
0 50 100 209
Feel AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST012 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST012 UWBZICZ COC FIGURE
ConcentrationsNovember 2012 3-4
Job No 5101110001NM:NM:
DateI,e/2;2013 amect9Scale I "= 205'
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 30
Site ST012 GroundmleAli#MonitorPiiial tfliciateNov 2012 Results > Action Levels LSZ
ST012-W13
Analyte Units
OU-2 RODActionLevel 1112812012
VOCsBenzene mil_ 5.0 2600Naphthalene pg/L 28.13 31
Ulysses Ave
5T012.W13
-totIF
ST0124107
I
Ana lyte Units
OU-2 RODActionLevel 1112612012
VOCsBenzene pg/L 5.0 1600
E
51312
'axs1
YL2-14138 \V0124,2
5T012 -W11
Ana lyte Units
OU-2 RODActionLevel 11/28/2012
VOCsBenzene pg/L 5.0 84
tiST212.035
ST0,2407
-034
ST012-RB-2C
Ana lyte Units
OU-2 RODActionLevel 11/29/2012
VOCsBenzene pg/L 5.0 9200Naphthalene pg/L 28.0 43Toluene pg/L 1000 3500
57012.52,2G
0,1012.,20
ST012-W29OU-2 ROD
Action 1111212012
Ana lyte Units Level 11112/2012 DuplicateTotal Metals
Chromium rngfl.. 0,1 0.42 0.38Nickel rrig/L 0.1 0.25 0.23
ST012-W07
Analyte Units
OU-2 RODActionLevel 1112712012
11127/2012
DuplicateVOCs
Benzene pg/L I 5.0 730 820
Legend
Groundwater Monitoring Well Locationti Screened in the LSZ
Fenceline
c 3 ST012 Boundary
Notes:9T012-RR-20 Monitoring Welt Identification
Analytical result equate or exceeds theapplicable OU-2 ROD Action Levet.
pgrt. microgram per liter
COC Chemicals 01004C6m
LSZ Lower Saturated Zone
mge_ m agra ma per !her
ou 00ml:141101ROD Record 01 Decision
VOCs Volatile Organic Cu wounds
50 100 200
Feel AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST012 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa. Arizona
ST012 LSZ COC Concentrations FIGURE
November 2012 3-5
Job No 9101110001PM. FA,1701., 21112013
=am5.10. ece?I" = 200'
---11,7:11,--:= --...1 --
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 31
,d Site ST012 GroundWitseliMonitorPiiii Cjiciate4.1Nov 2012 Benzene Results > Action Level UWBZ/CZ
- so"
Ulysses Ave51012.55021s-roz-col,
5U
STO 12-U12 90010.e.lnU 5 50 0
--- -m \
1J.S. ArmyWage rt BmCerlter
-ST012-005
.1
ti
ous
k
Surly-Ca
Legend
Benzene Concentrations {poll-) in Groundwater
5-999 pgit (011_1-2 ROD Action Level = 5 tipiLt
1000.4909 pg/L
000 pgIL
Groundwater Monitonng Well LocationScreened in the UWBZ/CZ
Fenceline
ST012 Boundary
Notes:
ST012-Re-1A Monrrorimg Wet Idenlrfisaticre5500 Benzene Coottanlart5aw 1pg/L5
{Recruits that are tatared and bolded ecual or100110 Ina 011 -2 ROO ROC. LePel Of 54.94
101 Microgram per her'1 -0 Not detected al or above the RL
F The analyla was positively kiesliFsed but Useas-sot-418d concertaion is an esimotbn [slowthe MIX and below the RL
CsiSeCtios Lollt
OU Operable UnitRL Reporting twat
ROD Record of NotionLI The analyse wee analyzed for, bat not detected
er above lne RL eta.MEV/CZ UMW Wale, soaring zone iCerkaa Zete
0 50 WO 200
Fwel AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST012 - Fenner Williams Air Force Base
tvtesa, Arizona
ST012 UWBZICZ Benzene FIGURE
Concentrations in GroundwaterNovember 2012 3.6
91011100iRif EWJet No.
Tial4: 2razei
ameeNo.
Saw: Ss Me
o.-
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 32
Site ST012 GroundimtseAli#MonitorPiiii tfliciateNov 2012 Benzene Results > Action Level LSZ
51012411/120 F
51012-1/04,29F
Ulysses Ave51-012.07
1600
51112-WI32600
5101 RS IC9200
sriez-uvoe<16V
1
510124511 ,98
WS ArmyReserve-Center 51012 037
700/810
Legend
Benzene Concentrations (RV in Groundwater
5-999 pgIL (OU-2 ROD Action Level = 5 pa)
1000-4999 pgIL
50,00 pg/L
Groundwater Monitoring Well Location6' Screened in the LSZ
Fenceline
C3 ST012 Boundary
Notes,
31012-Ria-aC Monitoring Well Identification9200 Benzene Concentration (pgiLl
(Results that are itel0ci0091 end bolded equal orexceed the OU-2 ROD Action Level of 5 poil..)
7301820 Original/duplicate resultspgirt. Microgram per liter<1.0 Not detected at or above the RL
F The analyte was positively identified but theassociated concentration is an estimation abovethe MDL and below the RL
LSZ Lower Saturated ZoneMDL Method Detection Limit
OU Operable UnitRL Reporting Limit
ROD Record of Decision
1.1 The a nalyte was analyzed inr, but net detectedat or above the RL shown
0 50 100 200
1=1Feet AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST012 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST012 LSZ Benzene FIGURE
Concentrations in GroundwaterNovember 2012 3-7
Joh No 9101110001PM EvVDate_ 20/2013Scale 1" = 200' amed9
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 33
,d Site ST012 GroundimtseAli#MonitorPiiii updateNov 2012 Naphthalene Results > Action Level LSZ
/ST012 r/
A./
Ulysses Ave6,-4-
4 #I
S1-012-V412
5T072-W111
_
ST012-.107
ST012 W29
/
57012-W37
ArmyReserve Center
08.541ST012-W24
F
4,rs fi
1 4 '
0
Iw
Legend
Naphthalene Concentrations (pot)in Groundwater
528 pg/L (0U-2 ROD Action Level = 28 pg/L)
Groundwater Monitoring Well LocationScreened in the LSZ
Fenceline
1:::: ST012 Boundary
Notes,
51012-R8-2C Mortitorng Well Iclentificaton43 Naphthalene Concentration (140
(Result that are li.VICIrier end bOlded eooal01exceed the OU-2 ROD Action Level of 20 pg/L)
4.8/5.4I Original/duplicele reSultSpg/L Microgram per liter
vi 0 Not detected at or above the RLa Sample concentration is similar to that found in
an associated blankF The enelvle wes positively identified but the
associated concentration is an estimation shovethe MDL and below the RL
LSZ Lower Saturated ZonaMDL Method Detection Limit
Olt Operable UnitRL Reporting Limit
ROD Record of Decision
LI The analyte was analyzed for, but not detectedat or above the RL shown
0 50 100 200
Peet AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite ST012 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST012 LSZ Naphthalene FIGURE
Concentrations in GroundwaterNovember 2012 3-8
Jog No p10111ciopiM: cy:u.
Qatst_Pilta amec50Scale 1.= 2nOl
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 34
Site ST012 GroundiVastei MonitoPtin4gaiii3dateNov 2012 Sampling Event Summary
27 wells sampled
Groundwaterflows southwestto northeast
All COCconcentrationsare similar tohistorical (2009-2011) data, latestresults increasedin UWBZ/CZ anddecreased in LSZ
No. WellsAbove ActionLevel - Nov
No. WellsAbove ActionLevel - Nov
Analyte 2012 2011
Benzene 6 7
Naphthalene 3 5
Toluene 1 2
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 35
WilElfams AR # Page 46 of 87
Site ST012 SVE System Update
Oct Dec 2012
99.5% operational uptime
TPH removed - 26,801pounds or 4,079 gallons-(3,870 gallons in Jul-Sept2012)
9 of 27 SVE wells operating(same as July-Sept 2012)
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
WiliSfams AR # Page 47 of 87
** Site ST012 SVE System Performance
200,000
180,000
160,000
a)&_ 140,000
ca
120,000
100,000-0a)
O 80,000Ea)
60,000
40,000co
0_ 20,000
0
0
The value above each barrepresents the percentage of time
For the 1st quarter of 2010,the system only operated from
23 February through 31
rMA rdMilI VAIM I
7 50,0006co
o g6
Lc)
I 111111111X111111 I
rn
co0)
300,000
250,000
200,000
150,000
100,000
0 0 0 0e\I` co
00 c'
Estimated TPH Mass Removed per Quarter Cumulative Volume TPH Removed
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wi14i7ms AR # Page 48 of 87
Site ST012 SVE System Summary
Average TPH mass removal rate continued toincrease Oct thru Dec 2012 as a result of SVE systemimprovements
TPH removed to date 262,200 gallons
Next SVE performance monitoring Feb 2013
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Site'ST01#2 GrodiktviaterContainment System
. Existing extraction wells and equipment configured to allowoperation of a modified pump-and-treat system
. LSZ extraction wells targeted for pumping
. Extraction operations began Jan 2012
Operations temporarily suspended Aug 2012 for retrofit;restarted Sept 2012.
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 39
Site ST012 Groundwater Containment $y$temLSZ Potentiometric Surface Map
Dec 2012 35 gpm Extraction
snotz-Lszes
ST512-MSYNOSC1 i nn os
ST012-Wriact., tosses
Legend
Groundwater Containment Monitoring WellLocation Screened in the LSZ
Groundwater Extraction Well LocationScreened in the LSZ(Only Pumping Wells Presented)(Extraction Rate = 35 gpm)
Potentiometric Contour Line (ft ems!)- (Dashed Mere Inferred)
(Contour Interval = 0.6 ft)
Groundwater Flow Direction
Benzene Concentration (5.0 pg/L) in- Groundwater- November 2012
(Dashed Where Inferred)
LSZ Groundwater Capture Zone
Fenceline
ST012 Site Boundary
Notes:
so312-913-2C Monitoring Well Identificationi,es.09 Groundwater Elevation ift -crash
9209 Benzene Concentration ipg/L)
colt_ Microgram per lifter
F The analyze was positively identified but theassociated concentration is an ohlonationabove the detection troll and below thereporting lint
ft canal Feet above mean sea level
gpm Gallons per minute
LSZ Lower Saturated Zone
a 25 50 toe
IMI1 Feet AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Containment System Status ReportSite ST012 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST012 Containment System LSZ FIGURE
Potentiometric Surface Map17 and 18 December 2012 3-8
Job No. SW1110001PM EWDote, 2/11201 3 amec(9Scale: 1" T IOC
Integrity - Service - Excellence 40
Site ST012 Groundwater Containment $y$tem
LSZ Potentiometric Surface Maps2012 Annual Summary
1 1 I aiiA
530124435
d . 362, ,91.27
--- // --- 3701241107
/ 1184.962860.
' \sTolz,mwsiolc \
ST0.12-1.320
17012-L320453012-wi3
4255 , 53612-MWNO1C,1104.37 1
37512-W32,118.5 a
11.
37012-MWNO5C1134 30
31'012-W03
128iI._89t
51,012,MVA0IC 1 ST012-RB-2C1184.561
..s; 069011
5.7012,W031185_32
51-012,W08/118547
ST012-MW1:105Cf1115.22
ST012 -437 ' TO,
20.60.
/'
33012-W131290
51012-Wse718
154 2 79
570124407 /-$1112-803-1C2860 / 4 1184 70,
51-012-111 5201
51131231141..103c
0184'14 570124403
ST11,12-W081154.99
31012-W341183 960 360
ST012-W381163_530.242 7
57012-R5-2C1104.51
-4- 8690
na455' 0 5909
2350
/;'"
1
Extraction Rate - 25 gpm
3 101 2 -41 3 I42901
52012 -Wil
Nit
March 19, 2012
..... -stiiii-iNre 7,./ ...4,... ''' -'.... 118623 ./., 1, .e, ,..- -. 07 C;L
0, 3. , co, % 6. 5,4 / 5,
\ .,,,,-97,012s-ra14,e ot
' 0'550
ST01241W07 31-012,3-.%.ma /
S
Extract= Rate' - 28 gpm
Legend
Groundwater Containment MonitoringWell Location Screened in the LSZ
Groundwater Extraction Well LocationScreened in the LSZ(Only Pumping Wells Presented)
Potentiometric Contour Line (ft amsI)- (Dashed Where Inferred)
(Contour Interval = 0.5 ft)
-1. Groundwater Flow Direction
Benzene Concentration (5.0 pg(L) in- Groundwater (Dashed Where Inferred)*
LSZ Groundwater Capture Zone
Fenceline
L__ j ST012 Site Boundary
Notes:
June 26, 2012
O
ST012.W391189 530.242
1012-432 ST012-MWN01C
57012-MWNOX4 1181 61t
1187.81 A 1187.054 57012-WOO1136.70.6,
S
ST012,-401 4
57012-1,520.1
570124492
570121AWNO1C11135.51....
3701244011187'21
,57,1a-rO
ST012-W031107_54
ST012-Wo7 51012-R19-1C1800 0155.19
14e
5T012-1SZ03!
ST0126iIWIVOIC11 85.53 53012-W03
1155.44
ST012-44081181 45
ST012-W1104.99
<1.0
ST01 ORB-2C1185_89
H 9200
ST012414W240.590 ST012-W37
1186 42820 ; SI-0124U.,
No Extraction September 14, 2012 ErtracLon Rata' - 35 gpm December 17118, 2012
ST012-RB-2C Monitoring trWil Identilloation1105.89 Groundwater Elevation In ems!)
0200 Benzene Concentration rugfLi
porl. Microgram per liter
F The 07110 was positively identified but Heassociated concentration is an estimation above thedetection liee and below the reporting lank_
arnsl Feet above mean sea level
grit Gallons per minute
LSZ Lower Saturated Zone
Benzene concentrations shown for March, June andSeptember are based on November 2011 data;concentrations shown for December are based onNovember 2912 data.
N0 59 10M) 209
Feel AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Containment System Status ReportSite ST012 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
ST012 Containment System LSZPotentiometric Surface Map
Quarterly 2012
FIGURE
3-2
Jot No. 9101110001
amed9PM. ESN
Date; 13 0131/2008.1e. 21"a
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 41
Site GrotificiviaterContainment System
Extraction activities influence potentiometric surface in LSZ
9.5 million gallons of groundwater extracted and treated fromJan through Dec 2012
181 pounds of benzene removed through Dec 2012
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wilafams AR # Page 53 of 87
Site ST012 Proposed Plan
Draft Amended Proposed Plan submitted Jan 2013 forregulatory review
Public Meeting - Spring 2013
Steam enhanced extraction and enhanced bioremediation isthe Air Force's preferred treatment alternative
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wilarams AR # Page 54 of 87
Site ST012 Path Forward
Pre-Design Investigation - Feb-Mar 2013
. Proposed Plan public meeting - Planned Date April 18 2013
Record of Decision - Summer 2013
. Remedial Design/Remedial Action Work Plan - Fall 2013
Ongoing annual groundwater sampling - Next event Nov 2013
Ongoing SVE performance monitoring and operation ofcontainment system
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wil617ms AR # Page 55 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Site FT002, FireTraining Area
Number 2
2/19/2013 45
WilElfams AR # Page 56 of 87
Site FT002 Location Map
cece
reWilliams- Field -Rd
Legend
FT002 Boundary
alFormer Williams AFB Boundary
Pecos-Rd
0 0.25 0.5
Miles
Job No. 9101110001PM: EVV
Date: 0512112012Scale: 1-, 0.5 m ile
Thom. 00.1 Mtn Inn Donn cnt.a vnn We ntl 0.0 andfint V/ Mn AMEC Prgti NuotiI 11101110001 Ms rtnpnaboon ce001. ken. W tun tva. And an Uwe
00341.004 wafrarnIOSP and 1.0 NEC 01511,01 WM.*IC or rnOtart rodIJIZIKNOrller a Ann 1101 palt Ot unnkalotl u:0.
Former Williams Air Force BaseMesa, Arizona
FT002 Site Location MapI FIGURE
1-2
ame0
Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wil617ms AR # Page 57 of 87
Site FT002 Site Background
Fire protection training activities (1958-1991)
Soil COC: benzene, chloroform, 1,4-dichlorobenzene
No evidence of groundwater impact
OU- 3 ROD 1996; Soil Remedy (bioventing) implemented in 1996-97
Final soil cleanup goals for unrestricted use not achieved
Declaration of Environmental Use Restriction (DEUR) to prohibitresidential use and require soil management below 5 feet
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wilafams AR # Page 58 of 87
Site FT002 Site Update
. Final Soil and Soil Vapor Sampling Work Plan submittedNov 28, 2012
Soil gas survey performed Dec 4, 201210 soil gas samples collected at former Eastern Burn Pit
Soil investigation performed Jan 7-18, 201311 soil borings drilled and sampled to 100 feet bgs at formerburn pits
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wilarams AR # Page 59 of 87
Site FT002 Path Forward
Evaluate soil gas and soil sampling data
If ROD cleanup goals achieved, prepare site closuredocumentation for regulatory review Apr 2013
The goal is achieving regulatory approval forunrestricted site closure by July 2013
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wil617ms AR # Page 60 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Site SS017, OldPesticide/Paint
Shop
2/19/2013 50
WilElfams AR # Page 61 of 87
Site SS017 Site Location Map
Ray-Rd
WMiams.Fiold.Rd
Rftryh
Legend
SS017 Boundary
1:21 Farmer Williams AFB Boundary
Pecos -Rd
0.25 0.5
Miles
Job NO. 91011112001PM: ESNDate: 0211512012Seale: 1-, 0.5 mile
nal. man Anna, noel. nal base feel:M.0h Pi el. an :ea armtn out wry1111Fc Irynrycl dt,antlar 110 11101101 Putman tat
nct teen .tuned try Idenatal land V.1, ar1 any Nall pert el 1,,
Ana mpt.n atalaniwnrinrarry rem op unneandan,:d
Former Williams Air Force BaseMesa, Arizona
SS017 Site Location MapIFIGURE
1-2
ame0Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wii6_17ms AR # Page 62 of 87
Site SS017 Background
Old pesticide / paint shop
Soil and groundwater COC: Dieldrin
Removal action for soil completed in 2000
Ongoing annual groundwater monitoring (Aug)
Draft OU-6 ROD Mar 2012
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
WilElfams AR # Page 63 of 87
Site SS017 Path Forward
Air Force to submit updated soil and groundwater riskevaluation for regulatory review
. Next steps will be based on outcome of soil and groundwaterrisk evaluation
Ongoing annual groundwater monitoring event - Next eventAug 2013
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 53
Wil617ms AR # Page 64 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Site LF004, Landfill
2/19/2013 54
WilElfams AR # Page 65 of 87
Site LF004 Site Location Map
Legend
LF004 Boundary
InFormer Williams AFB Boundary
0 0.25 0.5
Miles
Job No. 9101110001PM: EWDate: 07/1 8/2012Scale: 1", 0.5mile
71,0 tom. ncc Ggen Ernwp 6,1, ro,conshia6 11160,1,6 .116.11.1.GC 1,0100 14-4.4f COM Tux map PanMAMMA C661.0 4, 10.167 1.3. war nd " end Nrt, aim:
(66166.1661666frrtlita .16614n0 A MGC nuht irte %in fluid Web eee fir.
Former Williams Air Force BaseMesa, Arizona
LF004 Site Location MapIFIGURE
1-2
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 55
WilElfams AR # Page 66 of 87
Site LF004 Site Background
LandfillFormer solid waste landfillOperated from 1941 to 1976Closed in 1995 with a permeable soil cap(0U-1 ROD 1994)Rising groundwater tableOngoing semiannual groundwater monitoring
COCs> Dieldrin and beryllium in surface soil> Perchloroethylene (PCE)> Trichloroethylene (TCE)
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
ISite LF004 GroundiWialer Monitoriri41113dateWell Locations
IL' .4t
fib
t :441gre" alr'-' r. 4-........-,
_ LF01-W32D' t;dp.1 e IF
LPOI.V.25 ''.- ...
4.L.F01.WIS I s.LF.04LW31S
LF0.1,W3.1M.... " 'LFP.I.,..os ... ,o1.1390.,-.........1,01 LUNA
1,111 walr:,
A. 1.F01-1,030
,kr,01-L4035
LF01 W15
1--
1001 -Win
. =01-W14
1,01.W07
1101.W16
1,01-10.116 LF01-1-A065
LF0.14120
1,01.VVOSNI1101 VV17/)
1,01-W095 LF01.W09As
1.F01.1N38D
1001-1N175
1,01.V090
114
LFOIM28.10
FolM28.1)
L.
LFOL_tea
1,01AN205
1,01.W17
LF01-W,10 ,r
if01.W30,5
004-WOOD
LF01-VV3CM
F 6,7
LF0-1.W11F, ;
64,.4...1 PeregeLF01 W2.1 . r LF01W295
LF014724D
. LF01-11,1291,1
LF01.W24M
_ '0.1S
it'74P
"NaiED
Legend
Se Monitoring Wet Location
tB Observation Well Location
LF004 Boundary
Former Williams Air Force Base Boundary
0 100 200 40011 Feel AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite LF004 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
LF004 Monitoring WellLocation Map
FIGURE
2-1
Job No.. 91 0,110001
P" EV,Cale: 21812013
-Sae 1" = 400. amect9
Integrity - Service - Excellence 57
11.k Site LF004 GroundtileiRkonitoriPligHUfpilate4. * Nov 2012 Flow Direction
1114.
Wr f;
.'2r
WI 4
4es
i a i
LF,01-11.s0301107
LF01-L.4035
LF01.W1111.203
LF01-W3., LF014632 '1200 46 1291 02
LF01-W32M1.0 84
LF01-WaOS<1'202
LF01-.14
/9.1
F01,1,7151205.
5F01 -W101204
LF014,16
LF01.W07
LF01.162:11:4 4:
1,.:119501111
LF01.1,0981202
LF0,%I.A06M
2011, 4, 1
FI,11,...,10,5S
LF01 W3.1S
v°;
LF01-W3esM UV-MOD1203.63 1209.23
4 'ALF01-111120
1201.103
LF01-voro
LFIltypIke1199 OS
L001.W310 . -
1199
LE014909 0101-11301011195.94 leg] 15
',LEN MOM1196 44
11l 96.09 .0
1,171IN175
LF01.W116
LF,01 W11F1120' 20
LT,r--ANISisaiiitrardsum
dVIENEMENOMinlisrammia F01,W262045
LF 01,1,1961201n1
6,
LF0.11W1931251.95,
1.FO1 4119261.05
1,01-1,2413Ar2.1111.1
LF0.1-W2406,W195
L.F0741135512,51
1,01-W35M,20101-
LF111497251196 2C
LF0.1.W37M1155.35
LF01.W29M1196 04
as
LF01.1N36S
LF01.1,0601
Legend
44 Monitoring Well Location
Observation Well Location
Potentiometric Contour Line'(Contour Interval = 0.5 ft)
Groundwater Flow Direction withGradient (ft/ft)
rr-; LF004 Boundary
I= Former Williams Air Force Base Boundary
Notes:
LF01-W29M Monitoring Well Identification1196.04 GrOundWEIter Eh:radon (II arm!)
01202.117, Groundwater elevation not used for potontiometnnsurface contour.
Pot¢ritiorretnc 5211000 contours developed fromshallow groundwater monitoring well elevationsonly.
ft Feet
ft amsl Feet above mean sea level
o 100 200 400
Feel AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite LF004 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
LF004 PotentiometricSurface Map
FIGURE
3-2November 2012
401, No. 910/110001PM. EWDate 2/7,29V_ ameeScala. 1' -400
ORK If spa Maar M. MI RN in.. ea Um einilaa11...........,rad ,fte pr., eraespea....tt7snose.1=1 Art=nmer
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 58
Site LF004 Grounciii3terl4onitoriit Itbdate4.1 Nov 2012 Sampling Event
54 wells sampledResults
PCE and TCE only contaminants above EPA MaximumContaminant Levels (MCLs) and Arizona Aquifer WaterQuality Standards (AWQS) = 5 gg/LPCE in LF01-W19 increased in the Nov 2012PCE concentrations exceeded the standards in 17 wells;highest concentration 86 gg/L in LF01-W19 (up from 53gg/L in May 2012).TCE concentrations exceeded the standards in 13 wells;highest concentration 35 gg/L in LF01-W17 (down from 41tg/L in May 2012).
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
1,Site LF004 Groundtirgerthonitoriiid te4** Nov 2012 TCE Results
1.5111q11:r .
. n
- :C7141325 inisi
'SLF01-WI3e4- .-------'--- -----1,34-13,312Lrel.LAWS
'I' " r.-... 1, LF01-,065"---00.W.200----14 &-s,5i,, - - ar01.9/14 \;-- , SI
12
.-.11 1
0 .,,... 004121
li Pei. a 90 F\
1 0 lo ri, 1,01.1k403S,E 1
Groundwater e. oPF
4-----. Flow Direction .F0141/125
30II(1r'
1
"CF1514NIS ....I
I1 2t L.
LF01.L.110313
i'-' .e- 41.2 U LF01-1.006.-." .k. I 0 "
t \r 1,0141-10 le
LF81-W026
1,31-63,890.
LF01.1Z10913k&-'...
F
fP.:
LF01-.200.6.0
trot -W310
I Groundwater *9.1:F01:WV? ..s,1.801-W17D
" Flow Direction 7.0
LF01r18.240
9041! P r
FF01483312-1611
1_40181.13513
655F
Deep
Vol-WO/0
1.201.18,18 \AIM.
0 311,
LF01 1,0181.;_ 1,313,4/20
LF01.W16 tit181 F.
LF01-1N07 !FOI-WO3M24 F 07 FI-1
6'rj GroundwaterFlow Direction
^ LF7-ISIO;;-Ltp.10181(08,.,..,1 2
431111":11
OSfiF1,0148.3081 .
1,014.31190
LF01,V24M
up
tf:rA.
1,01 992015112:F
LC0141'360
Middle I
Legend
TCE Concentrations (pg/L) in Groundwater
(Dashed Where Inferred)
*5-10 143_
10-20 ag/L
20-30 pg./
030 (Aga_
'41/110S/MCL = Spoilt
11111.- Groundwater Flow Direction
IS, Monitoring Well Location
LF004 Boundary
Notes:Lroa-wirra Monitoring Well Identification
20 Maximum TCE Concentration (W/L}(Results that are &Oki:ad and bolded equal orexceed the AWOS MCL of 5 pgIL)
pg/L Microgram per liter
vl Not detected at or above the RL
AWQS Arizona Aouh'er Water Quality StenderdeF The anakyie wee positively identified but the
associated concentration Is en estimation abovethe MDL end below the RL
It ants! Feet above mean sea level
MCL Environmental Protection Agency MaximumContaminant Levels
MDL Method Detection Limit
RL Reporting LimitTCE Tnehloroethene
U The anelyte was analyzed for. but not detected ator above the RL shown
0 200 400 800
Feet AWorking CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite LF004 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
LF004 Depth-Specific Distributionof Trichloroethene (ICE) FIGURE
Concentrations in Groundwater 3-4November 2012
Job No 9101110001019 EVV
Dew- 2/0/2010 maec°Scale. 1" = SOT
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 60
Site LF004 GroundtiaterthonitoriPri4Vbdate4.* May & Nov 2012 TCE Results
Shallow Groundwater Zone
May 2012
.1. 6-
..p-LF01-W325,1.0 t.I-.
.
-
LF0 -LACT35I.:F. C7T't---N15
L F01 -W13 . - 3 -
--,LF01 W14as,
LF1-wiso :1
Gro ndwaterFlowDiroction
LF W21
4,
LF01-11495D1 - " F
LF01 _,ACLF.01,-2VVZ0 S1
LF11-14/1 TSf7
LF01-W3OS6.2
L F0.1
3M....M. L F01 -1,..29S
LF1-W365Q
'11444, Shallow
November 2012
V r `7,/- "'PI
, t ....5'LF01-LAD3S
LF0144315,,-...,-1-1.0 .J
1:iF01-,A1211.F01-1-.4065---1-F01-W205----------.114,11,-I } 5 , 12 , '4'0 '4.
LF014111-4 \1V V . 0 96 F
,ffir 7%
LIF01-VV3OS
A... S.fi
L 01 -W3753 7
Flowtian "arGr
L F 01 ;17;oundterwa -. 028 F,
10 LF01 W11R
""7111.1=111111.1411111110r16-..,......721..10.111..s..LF01-41/28 - LF01,W105
..."..m_7.,-..16..
LF01=W358..<1 0
L.F01 W24L F01-W293
is
Shallow
LegendTGE Concentrations (pg/L) in Groundwater M4111' Groundwater Flaw Direction(Dashed Where Inferred) *AwaSima= 5 pgIL
1 *5-10 pg/L 1 20-30 pg/L Monitoring Well Location
30 pg/L ill-7 LP:104 BoundaryI
10-20 pg/L
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Site LF004 Groundwater- lVlonitoring'UpdateMay and Nov 2012 TCE ResultsMiddle Groundwater Zone
May 2012
1'.*
."` r LF01.14180 /q F LV LA 06 RI
11."' LF09 W1611 F.fiF
1FLt9tiO7LF01-W09rd
.0.55 F 5,
9
LF 01 40/20LF101-W32611.4
I V-, Groundwater
Flow Direction111110
0701 W03 LH:1-77./28W,:1 20 1 3 -
L F01-16117"41
ti
'11LF01111/3106
LF01-1M113011.1
4 4 F
Lrol.wzam6./
L.F01-1/4/35M0 F
LF01.N3Ehlfl U
LF01-40/37M3
S
LF 01-41/29M0.10
Middle
November 2012
47 2-
-LF01-1A1180 15 F LF01-LAC6M L601=511/20
LF0I.,N16 13 8.1 4'0 8, F.
FOI,'WO7 LF01IND4A1' ' 351.14:. 4 0
0 t
.
OrLF01-41,32M _ e -
03: Fl_F01-41/3.1011
vit ,,,o/of =iv
j Groundwaterr-- Flow
1.
LF01-W11M20
20
LF01-W37M5F3
LFoi-vilsom42i
10. 01-11428141
itialiV.:17V....0.8grow -
LF01/1/19z 10
5
it LF01-1/035M0.70 F
LF01-W28/V10.21 F
001.11024M5.7 -1 I-ma-
I_Fai-vgaw<1.0.0
Middle
LegendTCE Concentrations (pg/L) in Groundwater(Dashed Mere Inferred) *AwaSimeL= 5 pg&
*5-10 pg/L 1-1 20-30 pg/I_
I 10-20 pg/L I pg/L
mIIIIP Groundwater Flaw Direction
Monitoring Well Location
P-z LF0O4 Boundary
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 62
Site LF004 Groundwater- lVlonitoring'UpdateMay and Nov 2012 TCE ResultsDeep Groundwater Zone
May 2012
i
Ground Waterr ----- Flow Direction
LF4:11-LAM2o4: "u4
LF01-0/100.83E
LF01-0/32D.3.25
fi
LF111-LADF
LF01-YV2dEl
LF01-4M1,31 D
iF01W09A
LFD1 W1713L F.0144090
.19LFCt144110
I 9
L.F01 -W15 D2.3
ir1-F61:W2.80
D.35 F
LF01-W3OD,1 tl
LH] YVZ4D
LF01-W351).0.39 F
November 2012
LegendTGE Concentrations (pg/L) in Groundwater 110111, Groundwater Flow Direction(Dashed Where Inferred) *AwQMACL = 5pgii
Monitoring Well LocationI *5-10 igfL 1-1 20-30 ig /L
10-20 Jg1L 30 pg/L -±1 LF004 Boundary
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 63
Site LF004 GroundWaleiVonitoriPri4bhdate-42* Nov 2012 PCE Results
.. ' 4 f ...J .1.
.1 ' ,i, i1: . ,11. .411' , j a
ILL'IP. / e
LF01.151325
- 0.0 F
2601-74036 F01711315LFOI.W13 ...-, 1 0L1, ,...--' . % L461135066 5.--LF 01 11102.03i. I 2F131-W21 10 05, 762,1.141 3 \t., LF21.W37020. ;/.
0601411/175 LF01.W305 0 ....I LF.31-1/3139S 52 .4 1.5
4-46,111-W15.4. 0 3...L. 7,01,,...
Groundwater LF01.W111.,0_62 F-- -- Flow Direction
rEmEMEMillille ......1.0
Legend
PCE Concentrations (pg/L) in Groundwater
(Dashed Where Inferred)
I I *SAO tigiL
I I 10-20 pull_
I I 20-30 pglL
1 a30 pgit
rtOW05/MCL a- 5 pgL
)110. Groundwater Flow Direction
St Monitoring Well Location
rE,.....; LF004 Boundary
Notes:LF04401M Monitoring Well Identiftcation
9.5 Maximum PCE GOOnen11,9011 (pot)(Results that are italiCized and bolded equal Or.0.0001 the AWQSMCL of 5 pg/L)
pgIL Microgram per liter
<1 Not detected at or above the RL
AWOS Arizona Aquifer Wider Duality StandardsF The analyte was positively identified 1)1.1t the
associated concentration is an estimation abovethe MDL and below the RL
tt ernsl Feel above mean sea level
MCL Environmental Protection Agency MaximumContentment Levels
MDL Method Detection Limit
RL Reporting Line!
PCE Perchtoroethene
U The anaryte was analyzed for, but not detected ator above the RL shown
N0 200 400 500I1 Feet A
r. .--tr v
r "...PI-,- ,1 Jr, --, 2- -. .7 ... -. , i 1_.
../ ''-sl ., .. ,./ -'' ..., Or .1- -'1::
1$01-403251 7
L701.W1(1.0 30 7 2,7,0616 _......./'-'----- 1 0731.W.3151,..-
+-'. ' 2.401A520 .6.----7---- '-'2 2F51W16 - 6.0
.-2I 075F .c.0601.31/17121
1,11W07'2\ LF01-W17 LF01-W366.1 0 30 F
31 4 . 2 51.-1'3 'Y..- 2F31-2561510
I 4" 9.5GroundwaterFlow DirectionJIIIII
LF111412413 1,01-2142611116.457:1:1;_=6.23_27..73.1M - LF01..W19 30 134 86 °9'L601;5606
5 31 F__/_2 0...----TO
i -LF01 -W1eS 1,01-W20
... - 1,131-W2SA' 4 14 17 6.2
3r,-".--72 30 F.......-
',, LF0t-W35S 10al 11-LF,01-W365,1LF014535M
5
LF01-W3651.:1 CU
Li Shallow =' '-'''. --t-7A-J i-i
Middle,4. r i;,,, -eL----43
4 NIf ,..
i, oe-, 'i / --,- . , . ,
1 . 3 ,
t ,IPir
... i , .. or. - "ri a . . ' . *
i - - ' i" I. '-- . :I ::, ...-
-
r ' - 1.601-LAO3D .LF51:241.06 1_601-1,111131..--1. ,1021 51.- - : e,r 3n - LF31 -W203
2F01-4610 43s ,,,
. \ 27211.W09A1.3
LF01.W17,23' LF01-W3OD
't. '' -- Fj 11,
2F01-W1121 ' 2,Groundwater L'".5..;'9° . a, 1 7
.--- Fiow Direction
11110.76014/19D
... -"' 1-7 LTF 1 .W2a--P- - - 6.6 2721.3420D
2 ,8 F .ge ..1.,/, .5
5 LF31-W3537
'", "
'
eherE5'7.----- .-
111
AligilL.117.47,17115
-
.'-311;;°.1"
'''',
.---.
-....
616476 0731 - 1029 5.6333
51We 3.1611.2076 arne0
wap 6197756 ft os6
Working CopyAnnual 2012
Groundwater Monitoring ReportSite LF004 - Former Williams Air Force Base
Mesa, Arizona
.1.6-571*.>
p ___
LF004 Depth Specific Distributionof Perchloroethene (PCE)
Concentrations in GroundwaterNovember 2012
FIGURE
3.8
.kob, No_ 1300,1110.031
amec°Mete: 2fat201350.8166 l'1=13001
--1..n==..-r....7:372% "'-Deep
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 64
Site LF004 GroundWitei-RA4' onitoriPri47Ubd ateMay and Nov 2012 PCE Results
Shallow Groundwater Zone
May 2012
-( 144
L101 -4413 LF.01-LAO3S1 U 0 U-44
LF01-W14-4 6 t., LF01 W21
LF.01-LAKS
4:001W32S
$ LF01W2OS 47'
6.9
LH4I-V/31S
L F01 -W375o F
--- 4e,LF01-W29
VW 0 F'
L F61 N3650
Shallow
November 2012
LLF01-W13. F 01 LAO3S
<1 U
LF 01-W211 3LF01-V414,LJ
LF,..0149053LF01-1.4/15
G ratindwat rr----- Flow Direction1/0.
0.35Fglos.
LF01-12A06S. 5.--LF01-1N20910 7.8
0 36 F
LF01-4417352
Lf 01-1N375o r
10
LF01-W19554
LF01-9924LF -'114 29S
5.2
s,LF01-41136S
LF01-W36.0<1 0 U
"AL--a-
Shallow
LegendPCE Concentrations (4/L) in Groundwater(Dashed Where Inferred) AWQVARCL = 5 pg.d_
L *5-10 ig /L ' 20-30 pg/L
10-20 pg/L z30 pg/1_
Groundwater Flow Direction
le Monitoring Well Location
P-7 LF004 Boundary
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 65
Site LF004 Groundwater- lVlonitoring'OpdateMay and Nov 2012 PCE ResultsMiddle Groundwater Zone
May 2012
L 01-W08
'LF1:11.W19
0 29 F.
LF01-Wle0 7-1 F
L FOi -W07
GrollndwatcrFlow Dirot:tion
rli701W32M5-
'LP.0.1-LADBM
L F -mism
r
I a
1.1
LF014120 4
71v
, A6
LF014417 LF014/5/501M
01-0 93 2.0
LF01ANO1M3357
LF91-W2SM1
IF01-1,435M8.7
iFo-r-AmmnJ
11F01.-Wi9r604 1
Middle
November 2012
LF01-LA0fiM
7?,4
1..F011-rie07 LF01-44/09M
r""Y3 ,!ri.1
7
GroundwaterFlow Direction
LF61-4V32M
'4 1 ' i- a,''' I.Fo1..061M
ILF01-11420 '!nit----r 71
r.1 r
t / 4T-id4
-
6.4
LF0144117
11 5;m
9 -5
-
--,-rdLIFI:ta 48/31111A
LF01.W3OM 03374 2 C or-..
' - b_ 4_ -Sr
w, . A.
LF01 -0/24M1..F01-W19 3086
1020
LE111-0i29M009F
1...F011&35M5.2
LF01-W36M
I Middle
LegendPCE Concentrations (pgIL) in Groundwater 11111. Groundwater Flow Direction(Dashed Where Inferred) Awasrma = 5 pg/f_
*5-10 pg/L 20-30 pg/L Monitoring Well Location
10-20 pgIL 1 a30 IJgIL ;LF004 Boundary
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence 66
Site LF004 Groundwater- lVlonitoring'UpdateMay and Nov 2012 PCE ResultsDeep Groundwater Zone
May 2012
r.
r ATI' ,!.401-
!Fat- LA.03D<1 U
le"
LF 91-VV10LF01-14'09A
5LF01 -W1710
- 35L F01-W.D9 D
4I 01:F01-W11
21.
GroundwaterPlow Direction
LF 01-W32D1
Ar,L FOl LA 06
G
J.;
LF014/3105.5
L FO/ -.MOD<1 aU
4.41
. 111M
'bar C, GO -
LF01-W190YY-
" kL:
LF01:W751:114
Fper,
Deep
1
November 2012
f:'4 f r.,? 1
.. \ /,
/t ,. ,
, -ii, .,,,,a I.LF.01-410 leXLF01-LA03O
<1.'.'
LFD1-4410.5
GLFO,13.4D
GroundwaterFlow Direction
TAT2
0 68 F
1111111,-
LH:11 -W221)1 2
L.Fal 063 9 - LFD1.W200
LF 01 -VVO9A19
L
LF01.'0176'? 7
LF01-0/11D".".. - 1 .
s.5
I
LFP1-W3.0D'.1 D U
LF01-15550
I
LEVI -4V24D
LegendPCE Concentrations (pg/L) in Groundwater 11111. Groundwater Flow Direction(Dashed Where Inferred) 'AwQviwct_ = 5 pgd_
771 *5-1° PO- 20-30 PO-Monitoring Well Location
LF004 Boundaryr -10-20 pg/L 3t) pg/L
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wil6iams AR # Site LFOO4Nov 2012 Summary
Groundwater results indicate historically decreasingconcentrations of TCE and PCE in hot spot areas;however, PCE in LF01-W19 increased in the Nov2012 event.
TCE and PCE plumes are stable and adequatelydefined
Next groundwater sampling event May 2013
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
LF 0
1 -W
17
Site
LF
OT
RC
E S
ourc
e A
rea
Con
cent
ratio
ns S
ince
200
8
110
100
go JV 40
0
LF01
-W17
His
toric
al T
CE
Con
cent
ratio
ns
99
83
0
2/19
/201
3In
tegr
ity -
Ser
vice
- E
xcel
lenc
e69
.- i
. F a
l -W
19
Site
LF
ilmsP
CE
Sou
rce
Are
aC
once
ntra
tions
Sin
ce 2
008
120
100
50 20
0
LFO
1 -W
19
His
toric
al P
CE
Con
cent
ratio
ns
11
T-
gi'
. , ,g
2g
2g
Dat
e
1-1
.-I
"I1-
1E
-1ri
4..
T
g0
3-i
z
2/19
/201
3In
tegr
ity -
Ser
vice
- E
xcel
lenc
e70
Wil617ms AR # Page 81 of 87
Site LF004 Path Forward
Draft Final Focused Feasibility Study underregulatory reviewProposed Plan public meeting Planned Date May14, 2013
Record of Decision- Summer 2013Remedial Design / Remedial Action Work Plan-Fall 2013
Ongoing semi-annual groundwater monitoringNext event in May 2013Continue landfill maintenance
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wil617ms AR # Page 82 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Contracting Updates
Presented by:Ms. Catherine Jerrard
AFCEC
WilElYams AR #
Munitions Response Site XPLaJg4033ofA8r7ea 1
Final Munitions Response Action
Contract Award scheduled for Feb 2013
Work Plan Submittals and Approvals Mar-Jun 2013
Field Work Begins July 2013Munitions Removal ActionEnvironmental SamplingDebris Disposal
Completion Reports 2013-2014
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wil617ms AR # Page 84 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Meeting Wrap-Up
Presented by:Mr. Len Fuchs/ Ms. Catherine Jerrard
RAB Community Co-Chairsand Scott Johnston
2/19/2013
WilAizms AR # Page 85 of 87
Meeting Wrap-Up
Review action items
Call for agenda items for next RAB meeting
ST012 Proposed Plan public meeting Planned DateApril 18, 2013
LF004 Proposed Plan public meeting / RAB meeting(Proposed date May 14, 2013)
Meeting adjourned
2/19/2013 Integrity - Service - Excellence
Wil617ms AR # Page 86 of 87
Headquarters U.S. Air ForceIntegrity - Service - Excellence
Meeting Adjourned
2/19/2013
FINAL PAGE
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
FINAL PAGE