east side coastal resiliency project - new york · pdf fileeast side coastal resiliency...
TRANSCRIPT
EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY PROJECT
NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF DESIGN + CONSTRUCTIONIN PARTNERSHIP WITH THE NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF PARKS & RECREATION
AND THE MAYOR’S OFFICE OF RECOVERY & RESILIENCY
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1
PROJECT BACKGROUND• Project Goals - A Stronger More Resilient New York• Past Efforts - The BIG-U & Rebuild by Design• Where We Are Now - East Side Coastal Resiliency Project• What Else is Happening - Complementary Processes• Community Engagement Objectives• Project Team
PROJECT OVERVIEW• Where We’re Working - Project Scope• Project Schedule• Design Elements
ONGOING ENGINEERING• What’s There Now - Investigating Existing Conditions• What Happened During Sandy - Collecting Data and Existing Knowledge DESIGN AND PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT• Designing with the Community• Community Engagement Schedule• Create Concept Design Options through Workshops and Meetings
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
AGENDA
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
• Strengthen Coastal Defenses
• Upgrade Buildings
• Protect Infrastructure and Services
• Make Neighborhoods Safer and More Vibrant
The City’s 257 initiatives comprise a comprehensive citywide plan to reduce the risk of extreme weather and climate change
Coastal Protection Initiative 21: Install an integrated flood protection system in Lower Manhattan,
Including the Lower East Side
A STRONGER, MORE RESILIENT NEW YORK
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
REBUILD BY DESIGN
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
AUGUST2013
NOVEMBER2013
BIG TEAMPRESENTS
TO HUD JURY
HUD SELECTSBIG TEAM TO
FOCUS ON MANHATTAN
APRIL2014
JUNE2014
REBUILD BY DESIGN PROCESS
REBUILD BY DESIGNCOMPETITION
START
HUD AWARDS$335 MILLION
FEDERAL FUNDINGTO CITY FOR
ONE OF THE THREECOMPARTMENTS
DECEMBER2013
JUNE2013
CITY REQUESTSFOCUS ONEAST SIDE
CITY RELEASESA STRONGER
MORE RESILIENT NEW YORK
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
DECEMBER2014
JUNE2014
OFFICIALCONCEPT DESIGN
STARTCITY PROJECT TEAM
ESTABLISHED
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
DECEMBER2015
JUNE2017
SCHEDULEDCONCEPT DESIGN
COMPLETION
PROJECTCONSTRUCTION
START
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
PERMITTING
DESIGN REFINEMENT
SEPTEMBER2014
CITY ISSUESRFP FOR
CONCEPT DESIGN
EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
COMPLEMENTARY INITIATIVES
EAST
RIV
ER
PROJECT LIST1 INTEGRATED FLOOD PROTECTION STUDY (ORR)
2 MULTI-PURPOSE LEVEE STUDY(EDC)
3 PIER 42 PARK (DPR)
4 LOWER EAST SIDE ECOLOGY CENTER (DPR)
5 EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY PROJECT
6 RESILIENT NEIGHBORHOODS STUDY(DCP)
7 CON-EDISON
8 SOLAR ONE
9 HOSPITAL ROW INVESTMENTS2
34
7
8
5
6
9
1
2ND
AVE
1ST A
VE
AVE
A
PITT
ST
2ND
AVE
14TH ST
9TH ST
HOUSTON ST
23RD ST
MON
TGOM
ERY
ST
EAST
RIV
ER
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
• Continue Public Engagement Begun with Rebuild by Design
• Enable and Facilitate Input from Community Stakeholders through Design
• Collaborate with Community to Establish Design Alternatives in Each Project Area
• Discuss & Balance Opportunities with Project Goals
• Make Team Available as a Resource for Community Planning
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT OBJECTIVES
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
CITY
COMMUNITYENGAGEMENT
DDC / DPR / ORR
URBANDESIGN
BIG
STARR WHITEHOUSE
ONE ARCHITECTURE
JAMES LIMA P+D
FITZGERALD & HALLIDAYCOMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
PUBLIC POLICY
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE
PLANNING
LEAD
ENGINEERINGDESIGN
FLOOD PROTECTION + MODELING
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE
MARINE ENGINEERING
MATHEWS NIELSEN
ARCADIS
CH2MHILL
MANAGING LEADAKRF
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PROJECT AREA
2
PROJECT AREA
1
ESCRSTUDY AREA
2ND
AVE
1ST A
VE
AVE
A
PITT
ST
2ND
AVE
14TH ST
9TH ST
HOUSTON ST
23RD ST
MON
TGOM
ERY
ST
EAST
RIV
ER
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
JUNE2014
DECEMBER2014
MARCH2015
SEPTEMBER2014
JUNE2015
SEPTEMBER2015
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
HUD AWARDS$335 MILLION
FEDERAL FUNDING FOR ONE OF THREE
COMPARTMENTS
DECEMBER2015
EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCYRBD
OFFICIALCONCEPT DESIGN
START
SCHEDULEDCONCEPT DESIGN
COMPLETION
CITY ISSUESRFP FOR
CONCEPT DESIGN
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
DECEMBER2014
FEBRUARY2015
MARCH2015
APRIL2015
JUNE2015
AUGUST2015
NOVEMBER2015
Q1 Q3Q2 Q4
PROJECT AREA 2FEASIBILITY STUDY
REPORT
WATERFRONTSTRUCTURESINSPECTION
REPORT
BRIDGEINSPECTION
AND LOAD RATING REPORT
HYDROLOGY AND FLOODRISK ASSESSMENT
REPORT
SUBSURFACEEXPLORATION
REPORTS
DRAFTCONCEPT DESIGN
REPORT
FINALCONCEPT DESIGN
REPORT
DECEMBER2015
EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
OFFICIALCONCEPT DESIGN
START
SCHEDULEDCONCEPT DESIGN
COMPLETION
MAJOR DELIVERABLES
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
1.4
1.2
1.1
1.3
PROJECT AREA 22.1 CON-ED
2.2 ELEVATED FDR
2.3 23RD STREET CLOSURE
2.4 STORMWATER PLAN
PROJECT AREA 11.1 PROTECTIVE BERM
1.2 BRIDGES AND ACCESS
1.3 WATERFRONT AND CONNECTIONS
1.4 PIER 42 PARK/MONTGOMERY CLOSURE
1.5 STORMWATER PLAN
PROJECTELEMENTS 1.5
2.3
2.2
2.1
2.4
2ND
AVE
1ST A
VE
AVE
A
PITT
ST
2ND
AVE
14TH ST
9TH ST
HOUSTON ST
23RD ST
MON
TGOM
ERY
ST
EAST
RIV
ER
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
BELOW GROUND INVESTIGATION(AFFILIATED INITIATIVE DDC)
AUGUST 2014 - JULY 2015PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
LAND SURVEY
SEPTEMBER 2014 - FEBRUARY 2015
(AFFILIATED INITIATIVE DDC)
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
Q1 + Q2: SITE ANALYSIS / NEW DATA COLLECTIONJANUARY - JULY 2015
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
Q1: UNDERWATER INSPECTION OF WATERFRONT STRUCTURESJANUARY - MARCH 2015
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
??
Q1 + Q2: HYDROLOGY AND FLOOD RISK ASSESSMENTJANUARY - JULY 2015
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
Q1 + Q2: SUBSURFACE EXPLORATION PROGRAMJANUARY - JULY 2015
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
Q1 + Q2: PEDESTRIAN AND BICYCLE TRAFFIC STUDIESJANUARY - JULY 2015
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
Q1 + Q2: BRIDGE INSPECTIONSJANUARY - JULY 2015
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
C
B
A
Q1 + Q2: TREE INVENTORYJANUARY - JULY 2015
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
Q1: REVIEW AND INTEGRATION OF RELEVANT STUDIESDECEMBER 2014 - MARCH 2015
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
“ ”“ ”
“ ” “ ”“ ”
“ ”
CONTINUAL PUBLIC INPUT
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY PROJECT
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE CONNECTIONS• Locations• Landing Design• Bridge Design
EAST RIVER PARK BIKEWAY/WALKWAY AND RECREATIONAL FACILITIES• Addressing narrow segments• Allowance for Emergency and Maintenance Access• Programming and Connections WATERFRONT VIEW CORRIDORS• Height and Width of Flood Protection Elements• Finishes
PARK ECOLOGY• Planting Plans• Trees• Upland Connections
NEW ISSUES...
KEY ISSUES IDENTIFIED BY THE COMMUNITY DURING RBD
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PRELIMINARY COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT SCHEDULE
COMMUNITYWORKSHOPS
TASKFORCEMEETINGS
DECEMBER2014
MARCH2015
JUNE2015
SEPTEMBER2015
Q1 Q3Q2 Q4
CB3/CB6TASKFORCEMEETING 1
CB3/CB6TASKFORCEMEETING 2
COMMUNITYWORKSHOPS
ROUND 1
COMMUNITYWORKSHOPS
ROUND 2
COMMUNITYWORKSHOPS
ROUND 3
COMMUNITYWORKSHOPS
ROUND 4
COMMUNITYWORKSHOPS
ROUND 5
CB3/CB6TASKFORCEMEETING 3
CB3/CB6TASKFORCEMEETING 4
CB3/CB6TASKFORCEMEETING 5
DECEMBER2015
OFFICIALCONCEPT DESIGN
START
SCHEDULEDCONCEPT DESIGN
COMPLETION
EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
= STAKEHOLDER MEETINGS
REPORTSPROJECT AREA 2
FEASIBILITY STUDYREPORT
DRAFTCONCEPT DESIGN
REPORT
FINALCONCEPT DESIGN
REPORT
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
BERM OPTION
BRIDGE OPTION
BENCH OPTION ?
Q2+Q3+Q4: CONCEPT DESIGN DEVELOPMENTMARCH - DECEMBER 2015
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT / CONCEPT DESIGN
ENGAGE COMMUNITY/STAKEHOLDERS
COORDINATE WITHFEASIBILITY ANALYSIS
DETERMINE INPUT TOCONCEPT DESIGN
PRESENTATIONS AND COMMUNITY-TEAM-CITY
· OVERARCHING DESIGN PRINCIPLES AND OBJECTIVES
· WHERE THE DESIGN COMPETITION WORK LEFT OFF
· KEY DESIGN OBJECTIVES FOR PROJECT AREAS ONE AND TWO
· ENGINEERING OBJECTIVES
· CONCEPT DESIGN ISSUES, INCLUDING NEED TO CONSIDER ALTERNATIVES
FINAL CONCEPT DESIGN COMMUNITY-TEAM-CITY
· BALANCE COMMUNITY PRIORITIES WITH OPPORTUNITIES AND CONSTRAINTS
· RISK MITIGATION
· URBAN IMPACT + QUALITY OF LIFE · COST
INTERNAL MEETINGS TEAM
· OPTIONS AND ALTERNATIVES
· ENGINEERING FEASIBILITY
· BENEFIT/COST IMPLICATIONS
· TARGETED DESIGN CONCEPTS
WORKSHOPS AND MEETINGS COMMUNITY
· INPUT THROUGH ENGAGEMENT SESSIONS
· PUBLIC AND STAKEHOLDER NEEDS
· PRIORITIES FOR CONSIDERATION IN CONCEPT DESIGN
COORDINATION AND UPDATE MEETINGS CITY
· DESIGN RECOMMENDATIONS
· DESIGN OBJECTIVES FOR PROJECT AREA
· EVALUATE COMMUNITY PRIORITIES VS. OPPORTUNITIES AND CONSTRAINTS
1 2 3
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
HOUSING ? ENVIRONMENT ? PLANNING ? POLICY ?
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
KEY COMMUNITY / STAKEHOLDERS WORKING GROUPS
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
GROUP
ORGANIZATIONSCOMMUNITY GROUPS
CITY AGENCIES
PROJECT AREA
2
PROJECT AREA
1
2ND
AVE
1ST A
VE
AVE
A
PITT
ST
2ND
AVE
14TH ST
9TH ST
HOUSTON ST
23RD ST
MON
TGOM
ERY
ST
EAST
RIV
ER
KEY COMMUNITY / STAKEHOLDERS WORKING GROUPS
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
DECEMBER2014
OFFICIALCONCEPT DESIGN
START
ENGINEERINGDESIGN
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
URBANDESIGN
SCHEDULEDCONCEPT DESIGN
COMPLETION
DECEMBER2015
Q1 Q3Q2 Q4STAKEHOLDER MTGS
INITIAL ENGAGEMENT MTGS
DATA GATHERINGINSPECTION & TESTING(STRUCTURAL, GEOTECHNICAL, UTILITIES, TRAFFIC)
HYDROLOGY STUDIESFLOOD/RISK ASSESSMENT
PROJECT AREA 2FEASIBILITY STUDY
STAKEHOLDER MTGS
ENGAGEMENT MTGS/DESIGN WORKSHOPS
IMAGINE ALTERNATIVESESTABLISH PRIORITIES
FINAL HYDROLOGY ANDFLOOD RISK REPORT
COMPLETE FEASIBILITYSTUDY PROJECT AREA 2
DEVELOP PROJECT AREA1 AND 2 ALTERNATIVES
STAKEHOLDER MTGS
DESIGN WORKSHOPS
PRESENT ALTERNATIVESRECEIVE FEEDBACKDISCUSS PRIORITIES
REFINE ALTERNATIVE
DRAFT CONCEPTDESIGN REPORT
STAKEHOLDER MTGS
SHARE DESIGN RESULTS
SHOW EFFECT OF FEEDBACKSHOW COST-RISK COMPARISONSOPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE
FINAL CONCEPT DESIGNCOST-RISK-IMPACT ANALYSIS
OPERATIONS & MAINTENANCEANALYSIS
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY
QUESTIONS / DISCUSSION
PROJECT ID: SANDRESM1EAST SIDE COASTAL RESILIENCY