eE ir s'f*rau fufirarr f€-dr ti:fr:) rtsqrtffrrur={ct fxfif}rrr Efr rhr&em, *g -e, ffi

(ulrF-4 m+r)

i'nH

f

,*/ ,\i.t r..@l

:;-

IN TI{E HIGH COURT IFOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH

c.w.P. ruo. l8 otrx of 2014

Balwinder Singh S/O Kulbir Singh working as Efi Teacher at G.P.S.Saneta Block - Kharar 3, Distt. S,A.S. Nagar (PB.) and others

Versus

SUlt of PunJab through Principal Secretary, Education Department, Civil

Secrgtariat, Chandigarh and others

.,..Respondents

INDEX

Sr.N

o.

Particulars Dates Pages Courl

Fee

1. List of Events 01.09.2014 01-07

2. Gliitwrit Petition 01.09.2014 08-40 1400-00

3. Affidavit 01.09.2014 41-42 Nit

4. Annexure P-1 (Details) 01,09.2014 4345 02-00

5 Annexure P-2 (Letter) 21.07.2010 46-47 02-00 ,

6 ffin-exure P-3 (Chart) 01.09.2014 4849 o2-q0

.08.2013 50-80 10-007

I InnexureF-6 (order) 10.09.2013 81- 96 oo-00

I Annexure P-6 (Letter m502001 le7 1-00

10 ffiF--7 (Judgment 21.03.1996 98-104 03-00

11 ffiexure P-8 (Judgment 24.04.2014 105-1 14 03-00

12 Annexure P-9 (Order) 04.02.2014 115-11603-00

4_--

,t

13 AnnocurcP-l0 (Order) 09.07.2008 117-118 02-00

11. Power of Attomey 01.09.2014 119 03-00

12 Total Gourt Fee 01.09.2014 1437.00

ytrnaculala

13 Annexure P-2 (Letter) 21.07.2010 120-121

14 Annexure P4 (Minutes) 06.08.2013 122-136

15 Annexure P-5 (Order) 10.09.2013 137-145

16 AnnexureP-10 (Order) 09.07,2008 146

1. The main law points involved in this writ petition has been

mentioned in para 15 at page 36-32 of the paper book.

2, Rclevant law and etatutes:

(i) The Constitution of lndia.

(ii) Punjab State Education Ctass-ilt (School Cadre)Service Rules, 1978

(iiD Punjab State Education Class (lil) Schoot Cadre(First amendment) Rules 1995

2. Any other Case: NitAny Caveat Petition: No

CHANDIGARH:

DATED: 01.09.2014

(AMR|K STNGH)

ADVOCATE

COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS

ENROLMENT NO. P€67/2003

---i

Jtt

'6*

List of Dates & Events

the pe

department and since than they are workingthe same post r,vhere as some of them u,Els havinghlgher quaflficaflon of B,A. B.Ed. whitE foining as ETT

in the department and other have acquired thcafter their appointnent as ETT Teacher and all

them are qualified to be appointed/promoted as

!r as on now .Details of the petitioners ,regardinginitial appointment and date of acqulring the eligible

is attached as Annexure p-1.21.|im th"

the basls of their qualification and the regpondent, vtde tetter dabd 21.07,2010 asked the

Diskict Education Officers to send .thecases of the eligible teachers who fulfils the

criteria till 10.0g.2010 for the post of Hinditnjabi ,science and Math Master/Mistress but no casethe post D.p.E. ,English and Social Studies was called

Copy of the letter dated Z1.O1.2O1O is athched as

Masbr but the same were kept pending and none ofthe JBT/ETT teacher wes promoted despite having 15%quota reserved fot. thern by way of promotion .Here it isnecessary to mention that there werre number of postslying vacant of English Master and D.p.E. under thisguota but even than there case was not called .

r

II

P-2.

t,

i,

:,

30.08.2009 the non teachtng/Ministeriar staff for promotion asrnaster on the basis of the administrative instructionsdated 26'09'200l to send the cases of the candidateswho fulfi[ the etigibirity criteria tiil 30.0g.200g vide refter09.07.2008

fnat ig

promoted the non teaching/Ministerial staff as mastorvidc ordcr datod 27.05.2010 whoee caroE were oartedvrde retter dated og.o7.20og and who were furf*ing therequisite qualification titt 30.0g.200S .

tette@called the cases from non teaching/Ministeriar staff forpromotion as master stating that the cases were caredon 0g'07'2009 ti, 30.0s.200g and they were promoted on27 '05'2010 but there were reft out oases who courd notbe promoted on that date therEfore to send the casescomplete in all aspeeds who fulfils the criteria up to27'05'2010.Here it is necessary to mention srat ehrfierthe cut of date was 30.0g.200g and norrr in order toaccommodate the persons who had not even acquiredthe quarification ti, 30.0g.200g ,the said retter was issuedon 2g'03'2013 changing the cut of date for erigibiritycriteria to 2t.OS,ZA'10 from 30.08.200g with themalaflde lntention b accommodate the privaterespondents who had even not acquired the requisitequalification on 30.0g.200g and passed the requiredexamination only after g0.0g.200g.

thesffi

,

\A

out of totat

masters/Mistress are working in the department andout of these there are 10751 Social Study Master ,5949 Punjabi Master and 1ZZ1 D.p.Es are working inthe department and out of these rt f/o quota earmarkedfor non teaching/Ministeriar staff is carcurabd than arsoonly 107 posts of Social Studies ,Sg of punjabimastors and only 12 posts of D,p,Es are meant forthis category and 105 Social study master,74 punjabi

Master and g D.p.Es. were already working in thedepartment from this category and therefore only 2 posts

of social studies master were to be filled where as therespondents prornoted 66 candidates from thiscategory exceeding the said strength by O4 posts fromthiscategory and inthesame way there wasT4punjabi

,l I

was convened ano@strength of each subject ,it was written that there are1167 vreander takrn! ftc toEr eanclloncd strength of the'mastsr rn the departnent rn to acoount r.c. 40713 andordercd to fill 4,67 vacancies @ 1.yo of 40719 postswhere as these vacancies were of different subjectsbut in order to accommodate the private respondents,the almost whole vacancies were filled out of theposts meant for the subject of Social Studies , punjabi

Master and D.p.Es against the interests of thepotllioners .The detalled chart showrng thc Etatus of thetotalrtrcngth ,workrng strength of drfierent subjacts anddetails of ttre respondents working in excess of theirquota is attached as Annexure p-3

I

!

II

,t

I.t

L

I

ii

,i

il

i'liI

I

I

iltl

j

masbr e@should be 59 only therefore they were already Workingin excess to the tune of 15 posts but they promoted63 candidates more fronr this category and in theD.P.Eg also there were to be only 12 candldatesworklng and g wers already working therefore only 4posh were to be promoted but 1g candidates werepiomoted from this category in totally illegal ,arbitrarymanner ignoring the candidature of the petitioners whoar' forming the feeder cadre and has been waiting fortheir promotions against 15 o/oguota meant for them.Copy of the minutes of the screening commiftee dated08.08.2019 is attschsd as Annsxu re p4

the respondent promoted 176 candidates to the posts ofmasbr in the respondent department from the nonteaching/rt4inisteriar staff on the name of reft out case of30'09'2009 where as 114 candidates out of this hadacquired the requisite qualification only after 30.0g.200gtherefore their cases can not be said to be reft out c€rsesat erL copy of the order dated 10.09.2013 rs attached as

of the s(ecutive instructions dated 26.09.2001 in which1% quoh has been given to non teaching/ministeriarstaffin violation of rules where as this Hon,ble court hasalready struck down the similar instructions . videjudgment dated in the case of Gurdeep Singh Gi[Versus state of punjab in CWp No. 420g of 1g96.Copy

t44

Annexure p-5

,!

!,{

'i

:l

:

dahd 21.03.1gg6 is attactred as Annexure p€ and p-7respectively.

oneNanak@@attendant fired the civir writ petition No.4274 0f 2011before this Hon'ble court claiming the promotion as $.S.Macter on the basis of the lnstructione iesued on?E.U1!TZ and 26,0g.2001 and during the proceedingit became apparenry crear that workshop Attendant isnot a feeder cadre for promotion to the post of Mastertherefore no direction for promotion can be issued underthe Punjab State Education Class Iil (Schoot Cadre)Service Rules, lg,g .Copy of the judgment dated24.O4.ZO14is attached as Annexure p_g

er sdEro 24.04.2014hag spccrfrca'y herd that the instrucrons providing foradditional sources for promotion to the post of master,which is not provided by the statutory rules are cleartyviolative of law laid down by this court and tf,"r".n rlnaffidavit was fibd before this HoresPondents withdrawing a[ rr.n ,rr;;;:TJ;:prornotions

orders dated 10.0g.20lg promoting 176respondents in violations of rubs has not beenwithdrawn.

r nat white-prGomg

the instructions dated 26.09.2011 ,l./oguoh has been, . t I ro quo[a nas beenpresoibed for non teachinffiinisterial staff but it is

::j from the order dated 10.0e.2013 thar out of.,,sr uUl CIJ176 promotions 66 candidates fron_ n thecategoryof

a.

!/

Master na

Marterc were workrng in the d,partment at that timethercfure onry 107 posts were meant for them and out

of this 105 s.s.[{asters were arready working from the

category therefore onry two candidates were required

to be promoted but the respondent has promoted 66candidates as S.S. Master affecting the pefitionerswho has been waiting for since rong and even theircasoS wers not calted.ln the Beme for the punjabi Macter thcre total 5g4gPunJabl Masters wsre working and therefore the nonEaching /TUinisterial staft was having the claim of s9posb and 74 Punjabi Masters were already workingbut again 63 punjabi Masters were promoted which isclearly contrary to the rures and even the instructions

which has been set aside by this Hon,ble high court .

Similarly there areTotal 1221 D.p.E. were working inthc respondent'department and g D.p;Es from thiscategory were alreadylvorking but.inspite of that theypromobd 18 D.p.E.s wtrere as no case from thecategory of the petitioners were asked and simitary nocases were asked for promotion as English Masterfrom tre petitioners tiil date but two persons from thecategory of the respondents has been promoted asEnglish master

the respondents as according to the statutory rules25To Quota has been earmarked for promotion from the

category of ETT/JBT teachers and c and v teachers

ffi

are suffering due b-th- misdffi'ffi

and further siphoned their quota to the persons whoar' not entifled at a[ under the rures and the simirarprrctlor hac bccn dapruciatcd by the Hon,blo htghcourt.

outofl76m@order dated 10.09.2013 on the pretext of teft out casesof 30.08.2009 ,114 ol them has acquired the necessaryqualification of B.A. B. Ed onty irr 2009-2010 where asthe petitioners who has been appointed against ETTposts and was having the eligible qualification muchrrrrior to ttre pcrtioncr hae not bcen consrdc'd eo far .

of the petitioner for promotion whereas the respondentshas promoted the private respondents who are notelQible according to the rules as th-ey are not from thefeeder cadre'for promotion to the post of Master/Mistressbut they have been promoted whereas inspite ofsubmission of the case by the petitioners the respondentshas faited to.consider their case for promoron which istotally lllegal, arbitrary and whimsical .

Hen@

CHANDIGARH:

DATED: 01.,09.2014

:l

I.t

I

I

A'{*'-(AMR[( s|NGH)

ADVOCATE

COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER

ENROLMENT NO. P€672003

d

d\IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH

CWP NO. ol 2AM

1' Barwfnder srngh s/o Kurbir srngh working ac ETT Tcacher atG.p.S. Saneta Block _ Kharar 3, Distt. S.A.S. Nagar (pB.)

2' Ranjrt srngh s/o Kashmir singh singh working as ETTTeacher at G.p,S. Manku Majra, Btock Nurpur Bedi, DisttRupnagar.

3. simmi D/o sh. Trirok Nath Kakkar working as ETT Teacherat G.p.S. Swara Block _ Kharar -1 , Distt. S.A.S. Nagar (pB.)

4' Barwant singh s/o Harjit singh working as ETT Teacher at. G.p.S. Bhurde, Bloclr Ghamkaur Sahib, Distt Rupnagar.

5' Nhmar singhs/o bh. Gurm"ir singh working ae ETT Teacheraf G.p.S. lGinaur Block Morinda Distt. Rupnagar.

6' Jagir singh s/o charan singh working as ETT Teacher atG.p,S. lGngar, Block Takhatgarh, Distt Rupnagar

7' Rajvinder singh s/o Hakam singh working as ETT Teacher atG'p's' Nabipur, Brock sirhind-1 Distt Fatehgarh sahib.

8' Anju Bara wo Rajesh Kumar working as ETT Teacher atG'p's'rabour cobny Mandi Gobindgarh, Brock sirhind 2,Dlrtt FaEtrglrt Sahlb.

---"''

9' Kiran Bah D/o om parkash working as ETT Teacher atG'p's. Tarkhan Majra, Brock sirhind 2, Distt. Fatehgarh sahib.10' Barwant singh s/o Khurdam singh working as ETT Teacher atG'p's'chanarath Karan Brock sirhind-2,District FatehgarhSahib

- tb}-

A' 11' I(rmrlflt Krur D/o th. lnttcdlt Slngh worklng ar ETT Teachcrat G.p.s. MundiKharar, Brock Kharar -1 Distt. s.A.s. Nagar.

12- Brahmjot rGur D/o sh. r.derjit singh working as ETTTeactrer at G'p.s. shampur Brock Kharar-l DistrictS,A.S.Nagar (pB)

13' Gurbachan sing,h s/o Ujagar singh working as ETT Teacherat G.p.S. phase-Vll Hock Kharar -3 , Distt S.A.S. Nagar.

14' Damandeep Kaur D/o Harjinder singh working as ETTTeecher at G,p.S. Majrt Jafran,Block_ Rupnagar 2. Diett.Rupnagar

{5' Anir Kumar s/o sh. s*a R?m working as ETT Teacher atG.p.S. Raipur Block Takhtgar Diskict Rupnapar

16' Guliaar singh s/o Balvir singh working as ETT Teacher atG.p.S. Bikapur Lower District Rupnagar

17' Harreen Kaur D/o s. Jasbir singh working as ETT Teacher atG.p.S. Mahain District Rupnagar

18' Refcsh Kumar s/o rnderparworking as ETT Teacherat G.p.s.Dasgraye Dlstrict Rupnagar

19. . Harkesh riumar s/o Dhanpat Rai working as ETT Teacher atG.P.S. Hayaatpur Dishict Rupnagar

20' Bhinder Kaur D/o Barbir singh working as ETT Teacher atG.p.S. Kalaran Bbck Morinda Distt. Rupnagar.

21' sukhjinder singh s/o Pyara singh working as ETT Teacher atG.p,S. Nangla, Distt Sangrur.

22' DHar shgh s/o Nirmat singh working as ETT Teacher atG.P.S. Mund-Kherha, Distt patiala .

29. Amandeep Singh S/O S.Davinder SinghTeacher at G.p.S. Ana.aj Mandi pataran

otstt patiala.

working as ETT

Block Samana 1,

24. Sukhvir Kaur D/OTeacher at G.p.S.

Bathtnda.

Sh. Ajwinder Singh working as ETTPatti Sool Mehraj , Block Rampura, Distt

27.

26.

28.

Ruby srngta D/o sh. pawan Kumar working as ETT Teacher

at G.P.s. PattiKaran Mehraj, Brock Rampura, Distt Bathinda.

suriil singh s/o sh. chandan Ram working as ETT Teacherat G.P.s. DhabiGurjran , Brock samana 1 District patiara

Nirmal lGur D/o s.Gurdev singh working as ETT Teacher atG.P.S. Bhallian , Block Chamkaur Sahib , Distt Rupnagar.

Ravinder lGur D/o Gulrjar singh working as ETT Teacher atG.P:S. Bchrampur Zlmlndara, Dlstt Rupnagar.

. .. Petitioners

Versus

Sbte of punjab through principal Secretary, EducationDepartment, Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh,

Direator pubric rnstructions (sE), punjab, Vidya Bhawan,Punjab schoor Education Board comprex sEcroR -62Mohatt (PB)

Mjay Kumar superintendent office of D.E.o. (E.E) Barnata(Barnala) nou Social Studies Master.

Surinder Kumar Junior Assishnt G.H,S. Bajotala (Mansa;

nour D,P.E. '

Neelam Junior Assistant G.s.s.s. sumraye Jandiara(Jalandhar) now Social Studies Mistress.

sudesh Ku:mari Librarian G. M. s. s.s. Jarandhar (Jarandha r)now Social Studies Mistress.

Surinderpal Singh Clerk Office Of D,E.O. (E.E) Gurdaspur

(Gurdaspur) norr D. p. E.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

l039.

A

n

10.

11.

12.

13.

14.

15.

8' satya DeviJuniorAssistant G.s.s.s. Handesra (AjiEarh) nowpunJabl Mistress.

Laxmi DeviJuniorAssistant Govt. Mahindra corege patiara(Patiala) now Social Studies Mistress.

Pa,ccp KumarJuniorAeeist.nt G.H.s. $waah wara (Fajrka)nor Punfabi Master.

sinder r*ur crerk G,H.s. Jiyud (Bathinda) now sociarstudiesMistress.

Balwinder tGur S.L.A. G.S.S.S. Bhad, (Fatehgarh Sahib) nowPuniabi Mistress.

Kurdeep singh s'L'A- G.s.s.s. Jawaharnagar (Ludhiana) nowPunjabiMaster.

Sarat Saohdsva S.L,A. G.H.S.S,S. Kamikhcda (FaJlllta) nowSociat Studles Mistress.

Surinder Kumar S.L.A. G.G.S.S.S. Sareeh (Jalandhar) nowSocial Studies Master.

Kuldeep Singh S.L.A. G.S.S.S. Bhadi (Fatehgarh Sahib) nowD.P.E.

Vifay Bata S.L.A, G.S.S.S, Ajnoha ( Hoshiarpur) nou punjabi

Master.

Bafieet singh s.L.A. G.s.s.s. pabri (parara) now sociarStudles Master.

Surinderpal Kaur Junior Assistant Office Of D.E.O. (E.E)Jahndhar (Jalandhar) now Social Stud jes Mistress.

Kusum lata Khanna S.L.A. G.S.S.S. patiala (patiata) nowPunjabi Mastress.

Rajinder Kumar Juni. scare steno office of D.E.o. patiara(Patiala) norr punjabi Master.

16.

17.

18.

19.

20.

21.

9.

A22.

26.

24.

Sukhdeep Rani s.L.A. G.H.s. chakk Maafi (Ludhiana) nowPunjabi Mistress.

uma Rani Librarian G.G.s.s.s. Jettoh (Faridkot) nour sociarStudies Mistress.

Suman Lata Librarian G.S.S.S. Sareyana (Hoshiarpur) nowHindi Mistress.

Kulwlnder Kaur Librarian G.G.S.S.S. Suhanpur Lodhl(lGpurthala) now punJabl Mistress.

Avtaar singh s.L.A. G.s.s.s. sherpur (sangrur) nor punjabi

Master.

Pritparsingh s.L.A. Diet Faridkot (Faridkot) now Hindr Master.Arvinder Singh S.L.A. G.H.S. Mamman (Gurdaspur) nowSochlstudies Master.

Vinod Kumar s'L'A. G.G.s.s.s. Abohar (Fajirka) now sociarStudlcs Magter.

sangeeta Junior Assistant ofrice of D.E.o. (E.E) Ludhrananow Social Studies Mistress.

Harpreet Singh S.L.A. G.S.S,S. Guwara (Sangrur) nowPunjabiMaster.

Manmeet Sin$ S.L.A. G.H.S. Gudham (patiata) now punjabiMaster.

Gurdeep singh s.L.A. G.G.s.s.s. Budrada (Mansa) nowD.P.E.

Gurdecp Kaur steno Typrst rneervice Trarning centre Ferozpur(Ferozpur) now punjabi Mistress.

Kanchan sharma Librarian c.s.s.s. Manwar (pathankot) nowSocial Studies Mistress.

Sangeeta Rani S.L.A. G.G.S.S.S. Malerkofla (Sangrur) nowHindiMistress.

26.

27.

28.

31.

32.

33.

34.

3s.

36.

t

t2'q'l.

37. Kuldecp Singh Llbrary Rcctor3r G.S.S.S. Akatgadda(Tarrantrer:rn) novrr punjabl Martor.

Avtaar Singh S.L.A. G.H.S. Bacho Khurdh (Bathinda) nowSocialstudies Master.

Amarjeet Singh S.L.A. G.S.S.S. Diyatpur:a (Ajitgarh) nowSoclal Studles Master.

Shagufta parveen Library Restorer G.S.S.S. Bhogiwal(Sangrur) now Hindi Master.

{aypal Bansal S.L.A. G.S.S.S. Mandi Fuil (Bathtnda} nowSoslalShrdler Magter.

Tajlnderpal Slngh S.L.A. G,S.S.S. Bhogiwata (Sangrur) no,vHindi Master.

Gurkirparsingh s.L.A. G.s.s.s saraba (Ludhiana) now sociarStudies Master.

Anuradha Junior Assistant G.H.s. Beedh sikhanwara(Farldkot) now Hindi Mistress.

Amardeep singh crerk ffice of D.E.o. (E.E) Fafidkot(Farldkot) now punjabi Master.

Rakesh singh Junior Assistant G.H.s. Ara Karan (Mansa)now Punjabi Master.

Gunneet Singh S,L.A. G.H.S. bharoad (Ludhiana) now punjabi

Master.

Manmohan Kaur Junior Assistant G.s.s.s. Ladke Nangar(Rupnagar) now punjabi Mistress.

Pararnjeet singh Junior Assistant G.H.s. Khedi Musarmana(P.diala) now Math Master.

Manesh Kaur Clerk c.H.S. Radeyata (Ajitgarh) nor punjabiMlstress.

38.

39.

43.

48.

41.

42.

4.

48,

47.

49.

50.

l3

45.

A-Br.

52,

Bhavna srngh Junior Assistant G.H.s. Jarhgadi (Ludhiana)

now PunjabiMaster.

susil Kumar crerk o.s.s.s. chuhdiwara Dhanna (Fijirka) nowSochlStudies MagtEr.

Jagparvesh sarma crerk Govt. Goilege patiara Mandar Nabha

(Patiata) now punjabi Master.

Gursewak singh crerk G.H.s. Manawan (Moga) punjabi

Master,

Harpreet singh c'erk Govt. coilege Jandiara (Jarandhar) nowSocialsludies Master.

Mandeep Garg crerk G.s.s,s. Jethukay Bathrnda (Bathinrra)now Soolal Studlee Mettcr.

ManJot slngh crerk G.H.s. Ahemadhpur (Kapurthara) HindiMaster.

Reshma crerk G.H.s. snori Gate (patiara) now Math Mistress.

Ravinder Kumar Junior Assistant G.s.s.s. Bhundarh (MuktsarSahib)

Yadvinder Kumar Junior Assistant Office Of D.E.O. (E.E)Sangrur (Sangrur) now punjabi Master.

Prihm Kaur Steno Diet Sangrur (Sangrur) now punjabiMistress,

Pushpinder lGur crerk G.s.s.s. Mahori Karan (sarrgrur) nowPunjabi Mistress.

Gurkamal Kaur Cle* G.S.S.S. llwaal Gagarhpur (Sangrur)nor Social Studies Mistress.

Ranbir Kaur crerk s.corege physicar patiara (pa*ara) nowPunjabi Mistress.

Harpreet rGur Junior Assistant office of DEo (sE) pataiara(Pathla now Hindi Mistress

57,

58.

59.

61.

62.

63.

64.

65.

l.I"'€)

A66.

47.

Kamar Kishor Junior As:istant G.H.s. Nanagar chaowdrian(PathankoQ now Sociat Studies Master

Lakhwnder Kaur crerk G.H.s. Maud (Faridkot) now punjabiMistress

sandeep Kumar crerk G.s.s.s. tappa Barnata (Bamara) nowPunfrbifriartcr

Manprect singh creri< oFFrcE of DEO (sE) Faridkot (Faridkot)

now Soc,ial Studies lUiaster

Gagandee, kaur crerk G.H.s. Korti rnarian (Amritsar) nowScience Mistress

Harjaap Singh Clerk G.S.S.S. Dhangrati (Ruppnagar) nowPunjabiMaster. : .Dheraj Khera JuniorAssistant G.H,s. sanhu Dhaown (MukstarSaahib ) now Socialgtudise Marter

rert Goyar Junior Assistant office of DEo (E.E.) sangrur(Sangrur) notr Hindl Master

seema Aroia cre* Qovt. Rajindra cortege Bathinda(Bathinda) now Hindi Mistress.

Maninder sharma Junior Assitant Govt. R:'corege sangrur($angrur) now punjabi Master.

Tajinderpal Kaur Junior Assistant office of DEO. (E.E )Ludhiana (Ludhlana) now punjabi Master.

Damanpreet Singh Junior Assistant Office of DEO (SE)Rupnagar (Rupnagar) now Social Studies Master.

Hariaspreet Singh Cterk Office of DEO (SE) Ludhiana(Ludhiana) now punjabi Master.

Punish Kumar Cterk G.H.S. Jhaloor (Sangrur) now EnglishMaster

68.

70.

71.

72.

73.

74.

76.

77.

75.

78,

79.

rltriililffifll*tdreil1

II

i,l

' :tv l5

A

81.

Paramvgsr Kaur Junior Assistant G.H,s Khuddran GurabSingh (Mukbar Sahib) now punjabi Mistress

sama sharma crerk G.H.s Haibowar Kafian Ludhiana now

Social Studies Mistress.

Harbans srngh crerk G..H.s. sanghera (Bamara) now socialStudies Master.

Gurvinder Singh Junior Assistant G.H.S. Chak Ram Singhwala

(Bathinda) now D.p.E

Navnccch Kumar Singhla Junior Assistant G,H.S. Gaagha(Sangrur) now Social Studles Master.

Harpreet rNder singh Junior Assrstant ffice of DEo (sE)Bamala (Bamala) now Social Studies Master.

Avinder Kumar crerk G.s.s.s. Rupana (Boys) (Muktsar sahib)now PunjabiMaster.

Harjeet par singh crerk G.s.s.s Jassi pawn wari (Bathinda)nout D.P.E

Amandecp Slngh G.S.S.S. Bhalwaan Sangrur (Sangrur) nowPunjabiMaster.

Rahndeep singh crerk G.s.s.s. (Boys) Bhudhara (Mansa)

nor D.P,E.

Manpreet singh Junior Assistant Diet Faridkot 6ariorot) nowSocialstudies Master

Jasmeet Kaur crerk G,G.s.s.s. Division No. 3 (Ludhiana) nowSocial Shrdies Mistrees.

lgberpREET srngh crerk ofircE of D.E.O. (sE) Amrr*ar(Amribar) now punjabi M.aster.

Neetu Gautam crerk offioe of D.E.o. (sE) patiara (patiara)nowHindi Mistress.

83.

85.

86.

89.

90.

87,

91.

92.

93.

i .,

-*

' -:$A t7

now

A

06.

96.

94. Repak Sharma Clerk G.H.S. Aalampur (Hoshiarpur)Socialstudiee Maeter.

Anoop srngh Grerk G.s.s.s. Dyarpur.a MrrJeka (Bathrnda) nowSodal Studies Master.

Beant Kaur crerk G.H.s Nathana (Girrs) (Bathinda) now HindiMishess.

Panwant Kaur crerk G.H.s. Gag lG,an.(Ludhiana) now sociarStudies Mlstress.

Gagandeep Singh Clerk G.H.S. Uppat (Ludhiana) now D.p.E.Shaalu Rani Clerk G.S.S.S, Hoshiarpur (AJitgarh) now SociatStudlcs Mlgtrees.

Anfari shamra crerk G.H.s. Kathror (pathankot) now sociarStudies Mistress.

Parwinderpat singh crerk G.s.s.s Lambhran (Jarandhar) nowPunjabi Master

Kultaran Singh Clerk Ofiice of DEO (SE) Gurdaspur(Gurdaspur) now punjabi Master.

Tanveer Singh Clerk G.S.S.S. Ghal khurdd (Ferozpur) nowPunjabl mastsr.

Amit Joshi Cterk G..S.S.S, Mahilawaati (Hoshirpaur) .nowSocialshrdies Master

Ravinder r*ur crerk Diet Rupnagar (Rupnagar) now sociarStudies Mistress

Ranjit singh crerk Govt. corege shri.Muktsar sahib (Muktsarsahib) nor Social Studies Master.

98.

99.

102.

103.

105.

100.

107. Ramandeep Singh Clerk G.H.S. Ballowaat (Ludhiana) nowS,caiistudies Master.

Simarjeet Kaur Clerk Office Of(Ludhiana) now D.p.E.

101.

lU.

106.

108.DEO G.E.) Ludhiana

/\109. Avtaar srngh crerk G.H.s. cheema Jodhpur (Bamah) now

PunjabiMaster.

Nrrmar singh crerk G.H.s. Romana Arvedh singh faridkot)Now punjabi Maeter

PenmJrt )..ur crsrk GSss Bhagwan pur Jattarr pauah NowSocial $udy Mistress

Gurmukh singh crerk G.H.s. Khiari wara Bathinda NowD.P.E.

Jasurant Kaur Clerk G.H.S. Amlnwala (Moga) nor punjablMistress.

Gurmeet Kaur Glerk G.H.S. Bhindran (Sangrur) now SocialStudiee Mistress.

Kurhsrvscr grngh crerk G.H.s. parasaur (sangrur) nor sociatStudies Master.

Pawandeep Kaur Cterk G.S,S.S. Aarif K. (Ferozpur) nowPunjabi Mistress,

Amanbir Kaur crerk G.H's. parasaur Karan (Tarantaran) nowSocial$udies Miskess.

Sandeep Kumar Clerk G.H.S, Kingraan (Muktsar Sahib) nowSocialstudies Master.

Amandeep Kaur Clerk G,H.S. GhaepunJabiMistress.

vrvrn \rrrrro' .'h€€B Mandl (Paflala) now

'Davinderdeep Kaur crerk office of DEo (E.E) Ludhiana(Ludhiana) now Soicial Studies Mistress.

Harjinder Singh Clerk G.S.S.S pasaurh (Sangrur) now punjabiMaster.

Sandeep Kumar Cbrk G.S.S.S. Dhrnow puniabi Master.

nddi lGdeem Faiilka)

110.

111.

,13.

,15.

116.

117.

118.

119.

112,

114.

120,

121.

1?2.

r

;

^.ll-

lLi, tr-r' I rrr n t .fr..,r.rr

l8

124.

Shruti Kaanth Clerk G.S.S.S. Kanuwaan (Boys) (Gurctaspur)

now lilath Mistress.

Charanjiv Sharmi ebrk G.H.S. Shareeftura ( Amrfhar) nowMath Master.

Deepak fuora clerk G.H.s. Raipur (Fajitka) now social studiesMaster.

Jerprest Kaur crark offlce of DEo (s.E.) parara (patiara) nowPunJabl Mlstrees,

Veerpal lGur Clerk G.H.S. Keedeyaan Wala (Fajitka) nowSocial Studies Mistress.

lnder Singh Clerk G.H.S. Fatehpur Maniyan (Muktsar Sahib)now Punjabi Master.

Gobind Singh Cterk G.S.S,S. Shajiti (Sangrur) now punjabiMaster.

Nasesb Kaur Library Restorer G.G.S.S.$. Maloet (MulrbarSEhib) now punjabi Mistress.

Laxmi DeviClerk G.S.S.S Naruana (Bathinda) now D.p.E.Jinderpal Clerk Ofiice Of DEO (S.E) Muktsar (Mukhar Sahib)nor punjabiMaster.

Amandeep Singh Cterk G.S.S.S. Chakserewala (MuktsarSahib) now Socialstudies Master.

suktnrinder Kaur crerk G.s.s.s pakhi Karan (Faridkot) nowPunjabi Mistress.

PankaJdeep Arora Cbrk G.H.S. Lannde-Roadey (MuktearSahib) nov Socialstudies Master.

Jadeep rGur crerk G:s's's. Rajgarh Kubbeh (Bathinda) nowSocial Studies Mistress.

Sukhwinderjeet Kaur Clerk Office Of DEO G.E.) Ajitgarh(4ttgarh) now punjabi Mistress.

125.

120.

127.

128.

129.

130.

134.

135.

136.

131.

132.

133.

137,

x123.

20

,^is6,

139,

140.

Vrnlhdccp $lngh Ctcrk G,H.S. Nengat Moga (Moga) nowSoclet Studlee, Macter.

Amrt Maini crsrk offrce of DEo ( E.E.) Faridkot (Faridkot) nowScience Master.

Jatinder Kumar Clerk

Master.

Nangal Salempur (Ajitgarh)

G.H,S. Jananal (Sangrur) now Hindi

141' sukhveer Kaur crerk G.s.s.s sadha singh wara (Mansa) nowSocial Sfudies Mistress.

142. Nardecp Kumar Clerk G.S.S.S.nouv punJablMaatcr.

143' sunir Jasroua crerk G.s.s.s. Nangar Ghoor (pathankot) nowHindi Master.

1*.' Batjinder singh cbrk G.s.s.s. pandori sindhwaan(Iarantaran) now D. p. E.

145' Jagdev singh crerk G.H.s. Baniwaar (Mansa) now D.p.E.146' Gursevak singh cterk Govt. corege shri Muktsar sahib(Muktsar Sahib) now Socialstudles Master.

147' Manu Larnr cbrk offce of DEo (s.E.) Amritsar (Amritsar)now HindiMaster.

148' Rajvarinder singh crerk G.H.s, Fatehgarh panjhgariyaan(Sangrur) now punjabi Master,

150.

Harpreet singh crerk G.s.s-s. Thuriwaar (Bamab) now sociarStudies ftdasler,

AMnd sarda crerk Govt, corege (Boys) Ludhiana (Ludhiana)now Social Studies Master,

Mohammad Assad Aheaan Cbrk G.H.g. Takhar tGltan(Sangrur) nor English Master.

Neetu crerk Govt' corege Gurdaspur (Gurdaspur) now sociarSturlies fUlistress.

149.

151.:ilr;i..!

;:ll:i

:'

,t:

;j;

152,

E -t

,A

1e4.

155.

Gurmeet singh crerk G.s.s.s. Bhikhiwfnd (r-arantaran) nowSocialstudies Master.

Sanbjeet Kaur Cterk G.H.S. Tappakheran (Mukbar Sahib)norr Soctal gtudlsc Mi,rtre$.

MIee Bhar' crerk Govt. corege Gurdaspur (Gurdaspur) nowHindiMistress.

Satinderpat Singh Clerk G.S,S.S. BtD.p.E.

v,e,n \r.o,u.u. tshUfiial (pathankot) now

Kapit Kumar Cterk G.G.S.S.S.

Science Master,

Pathankot (pathankot) now

Rajlvinder Singh Clerk Diet Gurdaspur (Gudaepur) now D.p.E.Hrpreil Shgh Cbrk e.G,S.g.g. Begowaat Tarawaat(Pathankot) now D.p.E

Sandeep Kumar Cbrk G.H.S. tGlabala (Gurdaspur) nowD.P.E.

Ramandeep Singh Clerk Office Of DEO (S.E.) Gurdaspur(Gurdaspur) now Social Stu,Jies Master.Prabhjot Kaur Clerk G.S.S.S. Ghaloti (Moga) now punjabiMisiress.

Amrinder Slngh Clerk G.H.S. Chatha Nanher:a (Sangrur) nowPunjabiMaster.

il::""na crerk e'H's' Dhariwaar (Amritsar) now punlrabi

Sukhminder Kaur clerk G s.s.s. sahnri ^

..st_:_.punjabi Mistress.

v'e'^ u u'S's' saholi (Ludhiana) now

Katvafieet Singh Clerk G.H.S. Kofla Meher Singh (Moga) nowSocial S&,rclies Master.

156.

157.

158.

159.

160.

1A2.

161.

1&4. Naresh Kurnar Cbrk G.H.S. Avakha (Gurdaepur) now MathMaster.

166,

165.

167.

-*2t

tI!.

I.|

,iII

I

J,J

IItI

II

.t

,l

,Aioa. Bharat Bhushan Bajaj crerk G.H.s. Fatuhi Kheda (Muktsar

Sahib) nor punjabt Masbr.

D',avarjeet Kaur crerk G.G.s.s. Katana Kafian Ludhiana(Ludhiana) now punjabi Mistress

.i

sukhveer Kaur crerk G.H.s. Dhoro Karan (Ludhiana) nowSoclal Sfudicg Mtstrcss.

Varrnderpar crsrk G's.s.s. (Boye) Bhikhi (Mansa) now HindiMasler.

Kamaljeet Singh Clerk G.H,S. Lakhan Kailan (Gurdaspur) nowSocialstudleE Master.

shaminderjeet Kaur crerk Govt. corege Ajnara (Amrio,ar) nowSocial Studies Mistress.

Harvinder rGur crerk G.H.s. Larpur (Tarantaran) noiv punjablMlelrere.

Sukhjoepat Singh Cterk G.H.S. Bhuch Mandi (Gkts)(Batrinda) now D,p.E.

Gurveer Singh Clerk G.H.S.S.S. Bhadaur (Bamala) nowPunjabi Master.

Navjot Singh Cterk G.H.S. Chechiyaan Chorhiaan (Gurdaspur)now Science Master.

Mandeep Singh Cbrk G.H.S. Rarh (Mansa) now ScienceMaster.

Allthe T.ponO"nr No. 3 to 178 C/o D,p.t.(fE) ,punjab ,Vtdya

Bhawan punjab sdroor Education Board comprex ,sector62 S.A.S.Nagar (pB)

171.

172.

173.

174.

177.

176.

176.

178.

....Respondents

ry

-.IL

t{

I,l

IIi

A CM Wrlt petiilon under Artictes Z26n2Z of the

constitution of rndia, praying for issuance of anappropriate writ ,order or direction especiary in the nature'of oertiorari quashing the order dated 10.09.2019(Annexure p_E) vide which the respondent No..3 to 17ghas been promoted as master/mistress rro, the nonteaching/ministeriar staff which is not a beder cadre forpromouon to the post of master/mistrese in vioraron of thepunJab state Education crass ,r (schoor oadre) serviceRuree 1g7g and for issuance of a w.rit h the nqture ofMandamus directing the respondents to consider the caseof the petitioners for promotion as ma$erlmistress

. accordrng to the vacancies earmarked for them and atsorvhen he other candidates has been promoted asmaster/mistress in the respondents department, with all@ngequential benefits llke seniority, promotion

, anearsof salary along with interest etc.

AND/OR

For issuanoe of any other wdt, order or direction which this' Hon'bre court may deem fit and proper under the facts and' circumstances of the case-

RESPEGTFULLY SHOWETH:.

1' That thc petironer is an emptoyee of the punjab EducaronDepartment and is a citizen of rndia and as such is entired to invokeffie orha-ordinary writ Jurisd icfion

Articre 226n270f the constitutio

of this Hon'bb high court under

n of lndia by way of fiting thepresent writ petition.

'"et

J.,.1..rl'*

2. That the petitioners joined as ETT teachers ,in the educationdeprilmcnt and gina6 than they ere workrng on the samc postwrron es rom€ of them wes having the highcr quarfication ofB'A' B.Ed. whre joining as . ETT teacher in the department andother have acquired the same after their appointrnent as ETTTeacher and a, of them are.quarified to be appointed/promotedae Master as on now .Detairs of the petitioners ,regarding theirinitiar appointrnent and date of acguirrng the etigibre quarifi,cationis attactred as Annexure p-l

l

3. That the pofitionors are ellgible for promotfonbarts ef thctr quatification and the respono"r,:";:::rfll:fEtter dabd 21.07'2010 asked the concerned Distri- ;;;L;;;

:officers b send the comprete cases of the erigibre teacrrersi wtrofurfirs the e,bibre criteria ti, 10.08.2010 for the post of 'Hindi. ,punjabi ,science and Math Master/lt/istress but no c€lse for thepost D.p.E. ,English and Social Studies was cafted .Copy of thefetterdated Z1.OZ.ZO1O is attached as Annexure p-2.

4' That tfre pefitioners sent their cases for promotion as Master butthe same wer. kcpt pending and none of the JBT/ETT teacherwas promoted despite having 15% quota reserved for them byway of promotion .Here it is necessary to mention that there werenumber of posb lying vacant of English Master and D.p.E. underthis quota but even than there case was not cafied .5' That ihe respondent department carted the cases from the nonteacrring/ttdinisteriar staff for promotion as master on the basis ofthe administrative instructions dated 26.09.2001. to send the@ses of the candidates who futfir ,r^ ^t:_*.,..oo.og.200g virre retter 09.07.200g

the efigibirrty cri,teria ff,

24

25

Ao. That rgnori'g the rutes ,the respondEnt department promoted the

non teaching/Ministerial staff as ma$er vide order dated27.05.20fi whose €ses were cared vide retter dated 09.07.200gand wrro were furfiring the requisite quarfrcation ti, 30.0g.200g7, Thrt the recpondent vide tcttcr dare d 2g.09.2013 agarnet caredthc cases from non teaching/Ministerial staff for promotion asmaster shffng that the cases were cailed on 0g.07.200g till30.09.2009 and they were promoted on 27-05.2010 but there werereft out ca8e8 who courd not be promoted on that date thereforeb send the cases complete in a[ aspects who fulfils the criteriaup to iz'os'zoto'Here it is necessary to mention that earrier thecut of date uae 30.ob.2oog and now in order to a@ommodate thepsruonc wfio had not cvcn acgulred the quafiflcation till30.09,2009 ,the said retter was issued on 2g.03.2013 changing the

cut of date for erigibirity criteria to 27.05.2010 from 30.0g.200gwith the mahfide intention to accommodate the privaterespondents who had even not acquired the requisitequalification on 30.0g.200g ald passed the requiredj examination onfi after A0.0g.200g.

8' That thereafter the meefing of the screening cornmittee wasconvened and without taking the sandioned etrength of sachsubJect ,it was wrltten that therr: are 467 Vacancies hking thetotal sanstioned strength of the rrssfer ,. -*: .,l^account i.e. 46713 .no o,a.,,.o ;ilrJ ::::,J;t;, :4A71-3 posE where as these vacancies were of differentsubjects but in order to accommodate the private respondents

,tfie almoet whole vacancies werer filled outof thepoets meantfor the subject of Social Studies , punjabi Master and D.p.Esagainst the iilerests of the petitioners .The detai,fed chart showing

!

,+ar\

26

-A

Athe status of the totar strength ,working strength of differentsubjects and detairs of the respondents working in excess oftheir guota is attrached as Annexure p-3

g. That out of totar skength of 4671g,there is onry 35349masters/Mistress are working in the department and out of

.thEse rhere ar6 10751 sociar study Master , 5g4g punJabi

Mrdor' and 1221 D.p.Ec arc workrng in the depertmrnt end outof there fi 1!o quota earmarked for non teaching/Minrsteriar staffiscalculated than also only 107 posts of social studies ,sgof punjabi masters and onry 12 posts of D.p.Es are rneant forthis calegory and 10S Social study master,74 punjabi Masterand g D.p.Es. were arready working in the department from thiscategory and therefore onry 2 posts of sociat studies master wereto be

'illed where as the respondents promoted 66 candidates

frum thb catqor! eloccdrng the rerd strength by 64 postB fromthrs cabgory and in the same way there was 74 punjabi masterarready working in the department whereas this shourd be 59onry therefore they were arready working in excess to the tuneof 15 posts but they promoted 63 candidates more from thiscategory and in the D.p.Es also there were to Oe onfy fZcandidates working and g were already working therefore only4 poots were to be promoted but 1g candidates were promotedfrom thls category in totalty iltegal ,arbitrary manncr ignoringthe candHature of the peflfloners who are forming the feedercadre and has been waiting for their promotions against 15 o/oqu'h meant for thern. copy of the minutes of the screeningcommittee dated 06'0g.2013 is attached as Annexu re p4

10. That ignoring the sanctioned strength and stiatutory rubs therespondent promoted lT'candidates to the posts of masbr in

f""rrrrr,I

,t'I

t::

;I

{iI

i

1

\ t!jr. 27

thr,*pondmt departnentfrom thc non tcrohrng/Mrnrrbiler ctaffon thc name qf bft out case of 30.0g.200g wrrcre as 114candida*s outof this had acguired ttre requisite quarification onryafter 30.0g.2009 therefore their cases can not be said to be teftout cases at all. Copy of the order dated 10.09.2019 is attached asAnnexure p-S

11- That the respondents has been promoted on the basis of theexecuuve instructions dated 26.09.2011 in which 1% quota hasbecn given to non teachrng/ministeriar sEff in vioraflon of rureswhar aa thrs Hon'brc court hag arrsady struak dorn the srmirarinsfudbns vide judgment dated in the case of GurdeepSingh Gitt Versus state 0f punjab in CWp No. 420g of1gg6.Copy of the instructions dated 26.09.2001 and judgmentdated 21.09.1996 is aftached as Annexure p-6 and p-lrespectively.

12' That one Nanak chand who was working as workshop attendantfired the civir writ petition No. 4274 0f 2011 beforc thh Hon,brecourt crarming the promotion as s.s. Master on the basig of theinstrudions issued on25.04.1g72 and 26.09.2001 and during theprooeoding il became apparenry crear that workshop Attendant isnot a feeder cadre for promotion to the post of Master thereforeno'direction for promotion can be issued under the punjab stateEducation Chss lll (School Cadre) Service Rules, 1g7g .Copy ofthe judgment dated 24.04.2014* attached as Annexure p-g.13' That the order dabd 10.09.2013 (Annexure p_ ) is iregar, arbttraryand ftereficre the same ie ffable to be set aslde orgrOUnds:_

'v vs oer ESIOO On the follOrling

l

,l

(lir)

onry 107 posts were meant for them and out of this 105S,g. Mertcrs vyerg already rrrorking fiom ths catcgorythcnrfore . only two candidatps woro reguired to bepromoted but the respondent has promoted 66 candidates.as s's' Master effecting the petitioners who has beenwaiting since bng and even their cases were notcalled. ln the same for the punjabi Master there total Sg4gpunjabi Masters were working and therefore the non

' teachrng /Ministeriar staff was havfng the craim of 5g postsand 74 puniabi Mastexg wore6s punJabi r;; ;. ;:.::

-ffi ,:', ;::;contrary to the rubs and even the instrucflons *n,.n n.,been sd aside by this Hon,ble high court . similarly thereare Tohl 1221 D.p.E. were working in the respondent

departrnent and g D.p.Es from this category were alreadyworking but in spite of that they promoted 1g D.p.E.swhere as no case from the category of the potitjonerswere asked and similarly no citses were asked forpromotion as Engtish Master from fire pefifloners tilldatebut two persons from the category of the respondents

has been promobd as English master.

":

That his Hon'bb high court virde order dated 24.04.2014has specifically held that the instadditionar sources.for promotion ro *'o'onr

providing for

e Post of master, whlchls not provirded by the statutory rubs are cbarly violatitre oflaw hid dorun by this court and thercafrer an affidavit waslled before this Hon,ble court by the respondentswithdrawing all such instructions but the promotions

a

^d

'-bi

rl

order' dated 10.09.2013 promoting 176 respondents inviolations of rules has not been withdrawn.

(iv) That whire promoting the respondents on the basis of the' In tructonr dabd 26.09.201 1 ,1?6 quoh hac bccnprltcrtbsd for non tcachlng/minirterial ctaff That thepetifibners are suffering due to the misdeeds of therespondbnts as according b the stafutory r.ules Zio/oquota has been earmarked for promotion from thecategory of ETT/JBT teachers and c and V teachers butthe respondents has failed to consider their cases andfurther siphoned ttreir quota to the persons who are notsnfiUed at all under the rubs and thc shllar prasflcohar bccn dcprechted by th,s Hon,ble hlgh court(v) That out of ll|persons

!who had b€en promoted videorder dated 10,09.2013 0n the pretext of reft out cases of30.09.200g ,114 of them has acquiied the necessaryquafffication of B.A. B, Ed onty in 2OOg_zArc where asthe pefitioners who has beern appointed against ETT posts

and was having the eligible qualification much earlier to' the petitioner has not been considered so far(vr) That ,re pefiuoners a," g6fl5i1g as ETT teacher since bngand I is apparent from Annerure p-1 that alt of trem haveaquired ttre requisite qudification for promotion as Master

and they were having the teaching experienoe of more than10 years as on now but inspite of calling their cases since. 2009, they have not been promoted so far whereas theinerigibre cand,ates firke the respondent no. 3 to 17g hasbeen promoted fuice til 2hfi whereas none of the

dlt.Irlttlr.sEl{&or l'3.,i*, ., .-,,'-..,n-.,..-",,-..--,-,.,..."., . ,,,. .,@,...._.,. ,..,.,,,. .,- .. ,, .,. ,, ,

. "'-1,.ct 33

ucandidates from the cabgory of ETT/JBT and c & v cadrehas been promoted inspite of caring their cases 2 times.

(vli) That the respondent has even faired to ca, the cases forpromotion to the post of Engrish Master whereas number of' persons has been promored as Engrish Master/Mrsrress arsofrom the non-teaching/ministerial staff

(vlll) That ore Prlncipal of occupM fisE hae to be apilrsd and oncethcre are rubs prescribing the mode ofappointnenupromotion

the respondents can not deviate fromthe same and they have to fi, the posh according thes*rtutory rubs but in this case the officiar respondents hasfound a nbbte method to divert the quota to inerigibrecandidates by promoting the non-teaohing/ministeriar

staff. .(ix) That it is necessa'to mention that non" ot n" ,eepono"ntNo' 3 b 17g has pasced the bacrrer ergrbrity teet which ismandatory cond*.n for appointment as a teacher/master.Therefore without passing the said examination thepromotion of the respondent no. 3 to 17gis void ab_initio thusthe order dabd 10.09.2013 is riabre to be set aside on this

9round ilself.

(x) That this Hon'bre High court vide order dated 04.02.2014 hascategorica'y rreu "rn view of the aforesaid Division Benchjndgment of thrs court, prima facre, the rnstructions issuod

subsequenfly proviOing for addifional sourceq for promotionto the post of Masters, which is not provided ro, in ttr"statutory rures, are crearry viorative of hw hid down by thiscourt'" copy of the order dated o4,oz.2,uis attached as

Annexure p-g.

,&(xD

(x,r)

Thrt tho rapondcnt hae promotcd numbor of pcrronreg.inlt the rures and who w're even junior to the pefitionersand it is apparent from the oder dated 10.09.2013 that therespondent No' 143 to 17g has been appointed onry in theyear 20052006 vvhereas the pefitioners hae Joined in thedepartment as ETT/JBT teacher between 19g6 to 2OOZ.That some of the respondents has passed the qualiffing

examination oniy in the year 200g-10 which is apparent fromthe minutar of thc screening commrttee datcd 06.0g.2013thenrfore thoBe Flersons can not be said to be left ou, casesvvhercas the respondents has treated them erigibre evenwhen they were not having passed the qualiffingexamination at that time.

(xiri) That it b further necessary to mentioned that whire passingthe order dated 10.09.2013, the respondent no, 3 to 17g hasbeen prornoted w.e.f. 2l.OL.ZArc on the ground that theyoourd not been consrder earrier whereag I i8 neaessary tornen'on that the cases were cared vide retter dabd09.07.200g (Annexure p-10) from the candidate who wereerigibre upto 30.0g.200g therefore it is astonishing whirePropoting the respondent No. 3 to 17g, the candidates whohad acquired the quarification in 200g-10 has abo been

promoted in vioration of the statutory rures. copy brtne orderdated 09.07.200g is attached as Annexure,p_10.

(xlv) That the respondent no. 101 to 17g are junior to the petitionersinoe they have jolned the department hter than thepetitionerc and they'bre not the part of the feeder cadre

therefore they can not be said to be eligible br promstionwhich has been conferred upon them in totary iregar and

+ 34

35

,rarbitrary manner due to their proximity to the respondent No.1 and 2 and iregar benefits has been confe*ed upon them.

(xv) Thrt vide ordcr datsd 10.09.2013 (Annexurc p-4) th€rccpondent No' 3 to 17g has been praced in the pay scare of10300-34900 with the grade pay of Rs. 3600/- trvtrich amountto giving them more up gradations then the petitioners andhere it is necessary to mention that vide order. dated10'09'2013, a superintendent, a crerk as we, as s.L.A. hasbeen promoted giving them the benefits of the grade pay ofRs' 5000/'whereas they were having the grade pay of Rs.3200/- onty therefore the same can not be bnned agpromoUon but a fresh recruitment.

(w, That tre promotions of the responoent no. 3 to 17g ie in hct afrad uFOn the excheguer since a person who was drawing agrade pay of Rs. 3200/_ has been granted the grade pey ofRs. 5000/_ whereas in the order it has been mentioned Rs.3600A onfi whereas the sarne has been revised in the year' 2011 itself to the grade pay of Rs. 5000A. Therefore, thesame was armost frth to seventh step for the promoteos butIn thls case the sarne has been done by promoting theres,ondents iregary and arbitary wfthout botfrering for therules.

(nrO Ttrat the promotion order of the respondents are a back doorenty as neither they have passed the Teacher efigibitity testnor they were from the feeder cadre for promotion and it isfurther submitted that they are having the separate channelfor promotion therefore the impugned order is not sustainabrein tfie eyes of raw and the same is riabre to be set asrde.

I

I

I

I

I

I

i

{

!

IIIl

A(wiil) That fie respondents has faired to considerer the caEe of

the petfiioners for promotion whereas the respondents has' promoted the pe*ons in vioration of rures whereas thevacancies for promotion for the category of the petitionersaru ryinE vacant and rn fact the samc is drver*d to thernergrblc candrdates in vrotation of the rured with the mahfiderntention and without considering the cases of tre petitionersrvho are entifled for the same.

That the petitioners are fulfiring a, the quarificaron as we, ase'grbirity cribda is enff ed for promotion from the date whenother canditrates has been promoted as Master/rvristress arongwith a' consequentiar benefits since they have been depri,edfrom thcrr ragrtimate craim of being conerdcrpd and promotedwhen the other candidates has been promoted.That the main questions of law invorved in this petition for kindconsideration of this Hon,ble Court are as under :_

14.

15.

r) Whettrer the official respondents can promote therespondent No' 3 to 17g who are not from fire feeder cadrefor tvfaster/Mistress in vioration of punjab shte Education. Class_lll (Sctrool Cadre) Service Rubs 19Zg & punjabState Educaticn Chss-lll (School Gadre) Service (lrt

Amendment) Rules lgg5 ?ii) Whether fte official respondentr l can fill the total 1% posts

prescribed for art the categories of master/mistress from thesubject of Social Sfudies, punjab master And D.p.Es evenfor the vacancies prescribed fo,r the ofher subjects liikescience and Maths etc? -'-- v''rsr suoJ.(

I

-f

x, lll) Whcilrer the offlclal respondents can supersede thestatutory rutes by way of administrative instructions thuspromoting the respondent No. 3 to 17g without adhering tothe statutory rures for recruitment and promotbn to the postof Mastei/Mistress?

rv) wrether the order dated 10,09.2013 (Arrnexure p.4)promoting the respondent No. 3 to 17g is iltegat, arbitraryrnd wfrrmercerthcrefore the sems rs?riabrE to be ect arrde?

.v) wrether the petitioners who has joined in the service prior' to the respondent No. 3 to 17g who had been promoted

, vrdE order dated 10.09.2013 are senior to the respondentstherefure entifled for promotion?

vl) wheffier inpite of having lsolo quota earmadced for thecategory of J.B.T./E.T.T master, the respondents alejustified b ignore the petitioners whereby promoting thefnsliglble candidatcs tn vlolaflon of rulee?

vri) tA/hether the officiarrespondents can promote any one dueto their proximity tryithout taking the statutory rures intoconsideration?

That the petitioners has bft with no. other aftemativeerfficacious or speedy remedy except to approach this Hon,brehtgh court by way of filing the present writ petition

That no appear or revision ries against the impugned order exceptto approach thrs Hon'bre court by way or firing the present writpetiffon.

That the pefitioners has not filed any other such or similarpeti'tion either in this Hon'bre court or in the Hon,bre supremeCourt of lndia on the same or similar faets.

I

16.

17.

18.

A.It is therefors, re.pecffully prayed that this Hon,btE

Court mey ttlndly bc pleased to lseue:-

(i) issue a writ in the nature of certiorari quashing the orderdated 10.09.2018 (Annexure p-S) vide which therespondent No, 3 to 1lg has been promoted asmaster/mistress from the non teaching/ministeriar staffwhich is not a feeder cadre for promotion to the post ofmester/mistese in viora*oq of the punjab shte Educationctare rtt (schoorcad.) service Rubs 197g

(ll) bcuc a rrrlrlt in the nature of MAndamus directing theftrspondents to consider the case of the petitioners for' promotion as master/mistress according to.tne vacanciesearmarked for them and abo when the other candidateshas been promoted as master/mistress in the respondentsdepartment, with a, consequentiar benefits fike seniority,promotion

, arrears of salary along with interest etc.(lli) lsgue any other appropriate writ, order or di,restion which

thia l,fon'ble court may deem fit under n" ,..O *Ocircumstances of the present case.

r

(iv) Advanoe notices b the respondents may kindly bedispensed with

(v) certifieo copies of annexure p-1 to p-10 may kindry beo(empted

(v0 Co* of the pefition be awarded in favour of the pefitionersand againet the respondent

(v')The record of the promotions may kindry be summonedand responsibirity for the defauruiregar action for promotion

' mayftindry be fixed to avoirc the recunence of the same.

I

.t

I

^r

Chandlgarh:

Dated: : ol. o!.a?o/vPetitioners

, -g*;sr, .(.",hh6s ...._sr-a,cLl_

'&**t*r

OR/AND

Any other appropriate wrrt, ordcr or drreotion that thisHon'blc Court may deem fit and proper ln the pecullar factsand circumstanoes of this case:

tCrtor;-gal4r0.ffifo*tffii(teqi'^*'ffi,,J 2.-rll".,r' tal d._ he44(R*q*ln fl,,";;i

Through:

fp*-(AMRtKstNcH)

couNsEL,o*.rJXJffi*.\

-1.\,....1,\\

31

a.

I

tF"u,lls'n roj25,

^

- t,',rd*.

t

Verificatiotr

verrfied that the.contents of above mentioned writ petftion fromParra 1 to 14 and para 16 to 1g are true and co,ect to our knowredge ,and contents of para 15 being regar are berieved to be correct as \adybed by tfrc counrcl. No part of it is fialsE and nothing matErlat haebccn kopt oonocaled thefeln.

CHANDTGARH

Dabd: Ol.ol.iollPetitioners

Gre, -4+ry*btd s -*.s..cary,,:Lt-ti* s--.ir> "'..*Effi%,*--"ffiffi'4*#.H.*ffir-.ffi#m'W'W,N,,fu"ffi

,&wfriw#;Wa"=$ffi

udya..+-.*

FW,^ti;J;',i,7' XJ kq**'l)'Clr*,G;A2olr

TIde_

,{.IN THE HIOH COURT FOR THE STATE OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH

CWp No. ---.-- --12014

Barwrnder singh s/o Kubir singh working as ETT Teacher at G.p.s.Saneta Block - Kharar 3, Distt S.A.S. Nagar (pB.) anO others

Versus

... Petitionerc

state of punJab through principar.secretary, Education Department, civirSecrctariat, Chandigafi and others.

....Respondents

Affidavit of Batwinder Singh S/O Kubir Slnghworking as ETT Teacher at G.p.S. SanetaBlock- Kharar 3, Distt. S.A.S. Nagar (pB)

l, the aboveand declare as under:_

named deponent do hereby solemnly affirm

1. That the deponent ie wefi versant with the facte of this caseand the'vrft petition has been prepared as per the instructionsgiven by ttre deponent.

That the deponent has gone through the writ pelftion andfound he same as correct.

Ei

t- ri,/' L{ (.

2,

, i,,{'9' qL

Thatthe contents of para 1 to 14 and para 16 to 1g ar€ true, end cones't to my knowredge and informaron as derfuecr fromthe rccortr snd cont.ntE Of para 15 bcrng rcgar erc bercvrdto be correc{ as advised by the counser. No part of it is farseand nothing materiarhas been kept conceared therein..

Chandigarh

Dated ; o l" 01, &olVVerificationi

verified that the contents of my above affidavit are true andcorrrc{ to my knowredgc, No pan of it io wrong and nothrn, has bcenconcaeled thcrsln.

Chandigarh

Dated , ol. o7, &h

.9,2)

{

d'*' EorJ tfx Euubli Et[i 6t\(.t.-1:. ''liri,, ntg ,7B$iast'a5

6

@';S--b"pon"nt

vDeponent

-, , Sq-j

i'ffip.,.,,

'i

a

7 R.rvinder Slngh Sn. Hel(.m Slngh c.P.S. Nabtpuy,-@ffi

sdlrb

u3.o1.2002

8 Anju Bah Er. R.Jr.htcmrt e.r.o.Eroour t;olony.. F.G.S.:f=tFH-

1.U.2NEIT6

f,iltn Erla 1998Mrrrt-, FE6- 0r.oTm 2009 2000lh

ia

ltr.tsr]WE---(F.O,s)

r.z00z 2003 2006

K.m.U[ K.rJ i-ry- sn. hd.mgEh--12 9t,12,2007 200tr- 2006s.F.S. Sharnpur,--S.-i[SlGgar

ol.12.200120@

't3 Gwbachan-ffi vJ.gEr glngn G.P.s. Phasmi--14 oemendcflEli 2@7ol,En c.P.s. Ma,E]m;-

-

14.r0.8-,s An,l Kumar 200ac.P.s. R-iFui--=---

15.r0.96,6 aufiatrStrp-- sh.Em-mEh-- aou 2008-G,P.s. ETEFE;2070

I

17 Harleen Kaur S. Jasbir Singh 07.12.01 1997 :zooij i't8 Rajesh Kurn-ar Sh. lndcrpit c.P.S. DasgrayEn .o5.zoo2 1995 2010t9 Ah. Dhrnp.t R.[ G.P.S. H.yastpur 2007 200820 Bhlndcr Kiur EffilEiiEiinrE- 12.5.1{97 199.1 1 99221 SukhJlndiiEingF Sh. P!/ara Slngh NEngta 20.05.2002 2011 z0i3----22 Didar Singh /e-

Il\-Sh. NlmalSffi

s-F37rm.J-ffiaiFffiirn -1s.12.2$1 2006

23 E.D.drd.r Slneih- so.04.2002 2012 zol!,65

2a tutrhvtr K.at ln.6lt^4n!ar alhgrli o.F,s, p.tu Ood Mrnr-J_ 00,0{,3002 zooa26 RuDry llnglt o.P.s, Prilt Krf.nmfi-F: 11.12.1867 2000 il,{)an sudtt Stnch th.Cha,xm-ffii-- o.F.8;Ena6r@im-- oE t0.leod 1got27 Nlmal lGui E.GudryStngh c,.P.S. Bhallian '1o.188E 't995 201128 Ravinder Kaur sh. Gufar S-[I c.P.s. Bfr rampd2Gifia;A- 14.10.1998 2000

1vr^r. tullW.

A-I^/-1

-tid\

d

Annexure p-2

office of Direstor Education Department (s.E.), punjab, chandigarh

lO'

All Distrlst Education Offioers (E.E.)

Punjab

Memo No. 1 9/04-1 0Estt-2(4,S,6)

DaEd Chandigarh

sub:- Regarding sending of the case for promotion of J.B.T./E.T.T.

cadre to Master/Mistress cadre

ln ths departnent underthe rationarisafion eoheme frorn the newrycroatsd pocb, the post sf Master/Mlstrese cadre from J.B.T/E.T.T. cadre

in thc prcmotional quota are to be filed. Those emproyees who areeligible for promotion to Master/Mistress cadre, their cases should besend to this offioe comprete in arr respec{s through speciar messenger on

the attached performa. This shourd be ensured that the employee shoutd

be eligible for promotion in a[ respects on the rast date of sending thecase. The cases send after the rast date wiil not be considered and itswhole responsibirity rie on the concemed District Education officer.Thoec employees who are erigrble for Master/mistross cadre for morethan one subject they wifi have to'give the affidavit that to which subject

of the Master/Mistress they wish to take the promotion. District Education

ofiicars wilt serrd the cases upto g.10.2010 after completing trese in allrespects' The concerned Block Eclucation officer and Dlstrict Educaflon

officer will put the date on each case under their signatures. The cases

without date wifl not be cohsidered. These promotions are to be doneonly for the posts of Hindi, Punjabi, and Math & Science Master/tvlistress.

so, no promotion case other than these should be send. The District

I46

,l+Education officer will send the separate list for females and mates as per

the attactred Perbrma No. 2. one Eoft copy of thesE liets also be send.

These llsG should be send in joy font in M.s word in the conrputer. The

District Edumtion officer wifi atso give the certificate that no case

rsmalni pcnding.

Thc orrllcr omcr rond for promofion wlll not be oonsidcred,

The copy of the above is send to the followings for information and

necessary action.

1. Princlpalsecrehry, punJab Government school Education Board2. Dlrccbr GcncralSchool Erlucafion, punaJb, Chandlgarh3. Dlrector Education Department (E.E.) punjab, chandigarh

4. All Gircle Educational Officers, punajb

5. Alt District Education Officers (S.E.) punjab

Endorsement No as above

sd/-

Assistant Director (SA (2)

Dated Chandigarh 21 .01 .2010

sd/-

Assistant Director (SA (2)

Tr,* yovraA"l,uo

Nr^p.;/r-t

-+

I

I

=tf'5

48

Ann.xure p-3gubJ'otwlr'Ltu.o,tol.laalllb}rnrnuPllrdporlrlvrailpo.t lnth.d.p.rtn nt.ndt96quoir i.6no2.o7,2olo

^

-t

49

ays */U1ft't--

n"l

sobnao SO.t0 cals 2CtC a1 1 €3S.StrxlL! 13462

le10761 27(,1 107 105 2 66 +84

u.},.E. A 1221 tOrlil 10 a 2 18 +16Maths 680t1

- r 177a 2030 47 I 3SAgriculture 149 89 80 I Isaml(dt 88 t0 45 a a

A

Annexure p-4

subject The report of the minutes of fie meeting of the screeningcommltbc dabd 06.0g.2013 regardrng promotion of the reft out casec upto27'06.2010 0f non teaching eEtabrishment under 1% quota for the promotionto the masbr cadre

Through the order No. 1g/07-200g E-2(4,5,,6) Dated 27,5.2010of office of Director pubric rnstruotions (s.E.) punjab Master/Mishess werepromoted for oonsidering the reft out Glses of these promotions incontinuanoe with the above promotions, The cases of non teachingesEbllshment fulfllllng the qualiflcations for promotion to Madcr/tvilstrcssupro 27.6,2010 we. demandcd by the ffiice through Memo No. 1g/og-2013Estt-2(1,7) DaEd 2g-&2013 to estabrish the erigibirity,of these emproyees forpromotions the Govemment had formed the screening cornmittee on04.08.2013. The meeting of the committee is herd on 06.g.2013under thechairmanship of Hon'bre Director Education Department (s.E.) in which thefollowing members participated,

1) Director Education Department (S.E.) prjnjab2) DirccfiorAdmlnBtration3) Registrar Education Department4) Assistant Director (S.A._2)

Chairman

Member

Member

Member Secretary5) sh. Ratan singh (superintendant Gd-l) Member (As Reserved cat)6) sh. Jaghrsingh (superintendant Gd-1) Member (As Handicapped)By starting the proceedings of the meetings and presenting the agenda

. Assistant Director (s.A'2) office of D.p.f (s.E) punajb Aj,t Garh totd that asper Punjab state Education crass-r! (schoorcadre) service 11srAmendment) Rures 1gg5 in master cadre 750/o quota through Dire€fi

Trfr'

.-..1.G,

A

recruitment and rest 25% quota is to be fited through promotions. rn the

above 25% quotra the 15% quota is to be filed from trained graduatas

J.B.T./ETT Teachers and 1}o/oquota, from trained graduate,s crassicar andvemacular teachers.

As per .punjab Govemment Education Department Merno No.

7&gnw1-2Edu2l1g?65 Dated chandrgarh 26-9-2001, ,,rt haB beon decrdedby thc Govlmmcnt thet 9% posts ln thc mastor cEdre bc lllbd from the c &v cadre through promotion instead of lao/o posts and 1% posts are to befilled from the Ministerial shff cadre Non Teaching staff. Because it wilt taketirne to amend the concemed service rutes so for the tirne being the formalapproval ls be[ng given regardlng this. while fulfilting 1 % posts fromMinisteriar cadre Non Teaching staff it is to be ensured that the emproyeesare futfilling the required qualiftcations for the concerned posts,,

Keeping in the above in view Director Education Department (S.E.)PunJab firrough hb rctbr No. 19/07-2008 E-2 Dated g.7.zooghad demandedthe caseg upb 30.0g.200g from non teaching estabrishment for promoting tornasbr/mrstrees. Afler considering the received cases the erigibre emproyeesw're promoted to Master/tuistress through above office order No. 1g/07-2008-E-2(4, 5, 6) dabd 27.5.2010-At the time of the above promotions somesenior emproyees were reft out from promotions due to which the departmentis receiving a rarge number of court cases are being received by thedepartment' ln the abovei promotions, there are many left out cases who arenot promobd' other than thls at the tlme of framlng the eliglbllity conditionsof emproyees of minieteriar cadre for promotion to the ministeriar cadre. AGondiuon of typed Esb passing was revied. Regarding this in tre cwp No.2277512010 uras fired in Hon,bre punjab & Haryana High court in thedecision dabd 7.2-201g of this writ it is said that cond*ion of type test is notacceptable.

A

ln llglrt of thc rbow dsolrlon of the .ouil, the amsndmcnt ln thepromotlon of t'g pcfiuoncrs incruded in cwp No.22zrit2010 hag been doneon fte mndltion of the decision of L.p.A. to be filed.

At his time, the detair of posts of Master cadre in the department asper the information from Diskict Education ofiicers and Mrs data is asfollows:-

Through the order No. 1gl07-2 oog E-2(4,5,,6) Dated 27.5.2010of office ofDirector pubric rnetrustions (s.E.) punjab Master/Mistress were promoted forconsidering the refr out cases of rhese promotions in continuance w*h the

lrhe N-T--I6n'teaching estabtishmEnt

under 1o/o quola

rThe No.reffiFworking promoted from

non teaching quota

---l

lefto@

467-259

L'DIEiT are as

Dumb

Visuaily

impaired

Ortho

.e6.1o1m6TfimEf

1 26.1 31 .1 36.1 41,1 46. 1 51 . 1 5

6. 1 61. 166. 171. 176. 181.186,

1 91. 1 96.201 .206.21 1.21A.22

1.226.231.23A.241

o.. I

*

reservation

3

2

.t'#

Iabove promotions' The cases of non teaching estabtishment fulfilling thequarifications for promotion to Master/Mistress upto 27,5.2010 weredcmandcd by the oilfios through ,cmo No, 19/0g-2013 Egtt 2 (1,7)Daterr 2g-3'2013. Ail thE cases received from the emproyees for promotion areconsidered by the screening committee and the fofiowing decision weretakeni

j

Thoee emproyees who are not rype tests passed and are erigibre forproootion they are considered on the condition of firing L.p.A. byttredepartment in i.w.p. zzlTslzolo

Those ministerial staff emptoyees, S.L.A and LibraryRsrtorer/Asrrrtrnt Lrbrarran Agergtants who doEe not frnd prace in therr

. eenrorrty flets but thgsc empbyeea are erigibre for promottorr as per ruresbecause they fulfill the conditions of prornotion. They were considered forpromotion but the instructions to the concemed branch has been issued thatwithin one month the seniority of these emproyees be fixed in their feedingcadre and tillthat tinre their promotion wilt be temporary.

Those emptoyees who do not fulfi* the condition upto 27.5.2010 or aperiod of tess than 2 years is there from their appointmenupromotion upto

27,5,201:Othoee caccs were rejected by the committee.Thosc emproyees who are outriders fiom the clepartment such as the

emproyees working in N.c.c. whose appointment officer are D.p.r. coreges,Punajb their craim of cases rrcre rejected by the committee. The screeningcommittee has decided that firstly for firing the points reft vacant rn the rosterare considered. After rTring the vacant points of the roster register the reft overcases were @nsidered for promotion. After considering these cases, thedeeision as follows has been taken:-

s.NoI

I

wame,.--.--

Designation,

Present place

Categ

ory

Seniori

ty No.

Date oi-appointm

ent lI

SubjeE Date

of

passi

Whet

her frt

for

pr0m

I specil"rI

remar

ks

:irlltrr.{8&rlrrrlltllrru]i".lr'.I. N".4Fr"{I-.,{..., a . ,.'.,,,.., ,, ',. ,. .,,,. ..,..... .......f.....,.-.....,.._,., ..,.... -, I

53

Iof po8$ng,

Oldrlct

ng of

B.Ed/

B.PE

dl

D,PE

dl

olion

or not

1 vlJsy Kum.r-Superfitendent

Bamala

(Bamah)

Hsndt

ceppe

d

Ortho

GEN

07.08.79 Soclat

Studies

l-11.8e I Not

lmark

Ro$a

r

res8rv

ation

vacan

I

Agnin

st 1702 Varinder KumE

Superintendent

Dlet

Sangrur

01-1e60- eunJabi 27

09-00

Fltbrprom

otion

Accor

dhg

to hle

merit

3I

surttidrrmEF

Juni,orAseishnt

Bajautel

(ttlansal

GEN 317 14-01-80- DPE 29.

06.09

Ftr for

prcm

oton

Accor

ding

to his

merit

4; .ragdish

I cn"noe.

f sueertnbnoent

I ofiioo i

srngrur I

GEN 17-0/.{,0 Social

Studies

I 03-

I o.-ro

Fit lbrprom

olion

Accor

ding

to his

medt

5 Bslw,ndsr

Singh Cterk

G.S.S.S.

lGpurthala

eEc 2(tt)q.UZ Punjabt 30.

11{9

Fil for

prom

otiort

Accor

ding

lo his

msrit

6 Neelam Jrm6i-

AssLshnt

GEN 650-- 4o.1U{.2 Social

Sfudit.s

1 5-

09-89

Fit brPr0m

olion

Accor

ding

to his

merit

ry

*

55r+.

III

Ii

II

/I

I

I

I.t

I.!,iri

IJ

I

II

I

iII

I.g.S.S.S.Sumr.l

Jandiala

(Jalandhar)

rxrdeeh Kumad

Libnarian,

e.s.s.s

Jalandhar

(Jrhndhrr)

lsc zo-1u-62 SocialStudles

30-

03-92

lFitbrlo,o,I orim

Again

st

vecan

t

rogter

Polnt

No.91

I E urtldtr PatrSlngh Clert

Gurdaspur

GEN 929 10-05.e5 DPE 11-

1 1-98

Fltlor lffiiprcrn | ,,nnothn I to r,i,

I

I merirI satEEi--

JunlorAectstant

Ajlt Garh

(,EN t:, 11.06"85- Pun;Ebi 07-11€9

01- -

01-80

Fit For

profii

ollon

F['6r-prom

otion

Accor

ding

to his

merit

Aoco;

dirU

to hie

mcrlt

10 LaxmlDfJuniorAssishnt

Gorommcnt

Ittlahtndn

Collqe, patiala

(Patiata)

cEN

re2-fi.7m Social

Studies

11

IPrudtpmmai-JunlorAesisbnt

Fazllka

GEN 1031 01.07-67 Pun abi 16-

09-09

I Fil for

I o.,notion

FiiETprom

otlon

Accor

ding

to hls

mcdt

Accor

dirg

to his

msrit

12 uns6r Kaur

Clerk

Battrinda

GEN- 1050- 2e{&sTTSEia

Studies

30-

09-09

It BatwtndeimS.L.A

(Fatchgrrh

Sahib)

sc 79/-snJ€ot 12-

08.08

Flt forprom

ollon

Again

st

vacan

t

roster

Po,tnt

N0.9614

^ulgry rilngh GEN 25-0er7

s.LA"utrlaot | 12-

12-04

Rtfor fffiforo, I o,r,gotion I to ni,

I

la--J75,J

'ar*

4

56

I

/

Jtwthtr Nrgar

(Ludhlrnt)

25-08T7-

mrrlt

15 Eulfirulndff

Slrgh S.L.A.

Gbvemment

School

Lurlhlana

(Ludhiana)

PunJabi 26.

06.05

11-

1r.95

Ftt tur

prom

otkn

Fit for

prom

olion

Ag€h

st

vaqrn

t

rosler

point

No.10

1

15 S:ci Sachdeva

s.L.A.

O.8.8.8. t(rmt

l(h.n F.afl(ll

L'EN 811 2$(ro$ Social

Studies

Accoi

ding

lo hls

mllt

17 I sudnder-

I rumar, s.r..e

Jatandhar

GEN q40

?5T-l

zu-09.87 Soclal

Studies

15-

09.89

Flt lbr

prorr

otlon

Aceai

tling

to his

merit

Kutdtp singh

S.L.A

G.S.S.S.

(Fatehgarh

srhb)

SC 30-09.E7 DPE :/4-

06.09

Fitbr I

As6i;prom I stotion I ,ro,

l,f .,,",I Potnt

| ruo.rololle vflay AaE--

s.LA. c.s.s,s.

AJneha

(Hoshirarpu4

GEN l84m l'o-I os-ag

Fil br

ilom

olion

lAccor

I oins

l. to his

merit

20 Baflit slnEh--S.LA G.S.S.S.

Pabri(pafiah) l

('EN 850 3edm7 uoctal

Studies

07- -

04-09

Flt forprom

otion

Aocor

ding

to hisI

merit Il'- SrinderEi--l(aurJunlor

Asetgtant

Jalandhar

lcEN-1097 26-11-87 Doc,ar lrr_ TmETffi

studtes lorc, f Rrom f one

/ /*' /**n^usum

Lata GEN 9tv 28-12-81 run abi 21- rFmIffiI carer I oins

57I

I

i

I

Khanna S.L.A-

G.S.S.S.

Pa0ala (patiata)

09-89 alprom

otion

to his

merit

23 Rilttdlr Kumrr

Junlor 8orl.

Sbno

Patiaa

GEN z&05-89 PunlrEi- 18.

09.05

30-

09-09

I Nor

tu,ilthc

b6nctt

mark

Flt for

prom '

otion

Aaaoi

I(FanoKot)

31 ArvlnderSingh

s.L.A,

G.H.S. Makhan

(Gurdaspur)

(jEN 10-03-92 Social

Studies

17

11-92

Fithrprom

otlon

Accor

ding

to his

merit

32

8.1.A.

Aboher

(Fazika)

GEN 1287 13.03.92 Soclrl

Studlss

20-

07.98

FltftrpKrm

ollon

Accor

dlng

to hlc

MEfiI

33 GurmeetEingh-

s.L.A.

G.S.S.S.

Talwandi RamaI

(Gurdaspur) |

stsN12e.06E2

I Hindi

l"'-10e00

16:

09{9

Fit fur

prom

ollon

Accoi

ding

lo hls

medt

; lEanffi-I

I JunlorAreiotant

luronrnr

GEN 1513 1e-080t Social

Studies

Fit for I Accor,* | ahsoton

I rnr

I mcat

I'u f Hamtlcts,Eifi-

I r.r^ o,s.s.s.Guana

9*r'l I

t,EN

; 14Eo- 2om'F

1

nuntE6i- I 30-

10,,,

Ftt tbr

prom

otion

I Accor

I dlng

lur,rtl.rrit

l| 36- f Manpnet-

I

I slneh s.L.A.

Kharam

(Pariara)

GEN 1527

I

I

1

Punfabi 30-

09-09

Fit fon

prom

otion

Accor

ding

to his

merit

37 curdeep Sinlf-

s.L.A.

Butlh Leda

(iratna) l

GET ooo 17-11-93 DPE 24- -

10{8

Fit forprom

ollon

Acdor

ding

lo hie

*.138-- tGur

Sbr

ser!

cenl

Fera

rsoep Kaur

no Typist in

doe tainlng

ire

lzepur

sc--

I

22.06-e4Jpunjabi30-

09{9

Fit for

prom

olbn

Again

st

vScan

t

roater

point

No.11

#

: '-Y'4'

4

i

t_

ti

iiitrl

il

il;l

ilrl

il

il:

il

(FrrgzpEo-0

39 Kancnen

Sharrrn

Llbrarian

G.S.S.s.

Menbal

(Pathankot)

GEN 28-07-94 I Social

lr,ro.o

15-

04€7

FIt fo/

plom

otlon

Accor

ding

to his

merit

40 Sangeets Rani

8.1.A.

MrlrrhoUr

(8rnglur)

GEN 1604 13-0sEa Hin-Ai--l 1 9-

01-10

Flt for

prom

odon

Accor

ding

to his

,narlt

lo',- Kuldlp Singtr:

Libnry

Rqistar

G.S.8.S.

Akelgada

(Pathankot)

I GEN 05-1 1-94 Punjabi 05-

05.08

Fitlbr

pr0m

otion

Accor

ding

to his

merit

42 AvtarSingt-

s,LA. S.S.S

Uctrhr KnuiO

(BahtnOa;

cEN Tt6-E6= 28-12-e4TSAI

Studtes

13-

11-04

Fit for

prom

o0on

Aocor

ding

to hle

mcril

43 lAmariitSingh--

lr.r^.I

Ic.s.s.s.rDyalpua

(AjlQarh) I

GEN I 1721 rc-03-90 I Social

Studies

03-

12{/9

Ftttor

prcm

oti'on

I Accor

I ano

lror,nmenl

44 Sagufata-

Pravin Library

Reglatsar

o.g.s.s.

Bhoglwat

(Sangrur)

oBe 28-03-95 Hindi_- 29-

1 1-96

Fit for

prom

otion

Accor

ding

to hts

merlt

45 4pet-Eeoeai-

s.L.A" G.S.S.S.

GEN 177eT0;2E5:

Studies

00-

09-09

F'I 'bIprom

otion

lrtnrding

to his

-

I

II

it.

i

:.

L

thgh s.L.A

G.S.S.s.

Bhogirwd

(Sangru4

s.LA c.s.s.s.

Saraba

(Ludhiana)

lGurJunlor

&drtsnt

G.s.s.s. (Borc)

Nangal

(Roopmgs4

prom I stotbn I vacan

t

roSter

point

N0.12

6

JunlorAssbbnt

Faddkd

09.09

03-0e

6l+

t.MUailmana

(Patlala)

3G

09-09

T05-03

16-

09-09

Fitbrprom

otion

Fittur

prom

otlon

Again

st

vacan

t

rcttBtpolnt

No.13

1

ffi;-dirU

to his

merlt

il Manlsh lGur

Clerk G,H,S.

Rilhlr(4rtsrrh)

sc 1798 27-09-97 Punjabi

55 Bharna Singfi-

JuniorAssistant

Ludhlane

GEN 1807 03-10.e7 PUn abi

I vu.n[Kumar

I cn* G.s.s.s.I

lChurtWata

Khanna

(Fuilkr)

GEN 1820 13-10-97 Social

Studies

Fn brprom

oticn

Aocor

ding

to his

merit

loz Jrgpnve$ -Sharma.Clert

PaUala lulandat

Nabha (patiah)

GEN 1842 -uf F'Un aDi 30-

09-09

Flt for

prom

olion

Accor

dlng

lo his

medt

58 Gurlor,u8k (JEN 1876 fi-17.€fl I PunjabiSingh Cterk

G.H.S. Manava

(Moga)

16-

09-09

Fll for

prom

olion

I Accor

I o'ng

I o r,i'medt

Cltcrlr

Govcrnmcnt

College

Jandhh

(Jalandhar)

GEN 1920 1e01-98- .EOCtal

Studles

13-

12-07

Fltbr

PrcM

otbn

Aocor

dtrlg

to ht3

merit

I

60- I SumandeeR-I

| *" G's's's'Jaduka

Bathinda

(jEN1 955 o2:o4Ee- Social

Stucties

30- TF[6r-TEA;or-0, Io'o' f o,nn

I otion I to rrls

I I m.,it

llElnt.@mtqr.e' .L.fr. E.'*tr.o_! . , tr

Clert G.H.S.

Alrm.dpur

(lGporthate)

l0marJunlor

Asshtant

c.s.s.s.

Bhudat

(Mukatsar

Sahib)

Kumar Junior

A..hbnt

8rngrur

(Sangru0

KaurClerlr

G.S.S.S.

MohallKalan

(Sengrur)

\

Accor

dlng

to his

rnedt

st

vacan

t

roster

point

No.13

Clerk Otrrce

(Grudasp.1

Cler{< G.S.S.S.

ia

^Euwlt

Org|rhur

(Smgrur)

69 RanbirlGur

Clerk

Gowmment

Gollege

Physical Patiata

(Patiala)

GEN ZtJUS 09-10-98 Punjabi 30-

09..09

30.

09.09

Fir br

Plunotlon

Fltfur

pRrn

oUon

Accor

ding

to his

merit

70 Harpraet laur

JunlorAl.bbnt

PrUrh

GEN 2089 05-1 1-98 Hindl Accor

dlne

lo hlrmorlt

71 lGmalKtchdrc-

JunlorAssisEnt

Pathankot

sc 2094 0&11-9E social

Studies

09.

10-09

Fltbr lAgaTprom lootion | ,ron

l,I ,o",",

I point

I uo.,,t,

72 Lakhwinder

Kaur Clerk

O.H.g. Modh

(Feddkog

SC 2114 11.12-98 Punjabi 16-

09.09

Fit fur

prom

otion

Agair

st

vScan

I

rottor

polnt

No.14

673 Baohittar Singh

Clerk G.S.S.

Ajneda Kalan

(Patiala)

SC 2116 17.12-98 l,unJa0t 31.

12-09

Fit brprom

otion

Agaln

st

vaqan

t

roster

polnt

No.15

174 uandeep

KumrrOrrk

G.S.S.6. Tapa

Bamala

GEN 2130

,

21-01-99 PLrnJabi 04-

I 1-09

Fit for

prcm

otlon

Accor

ding

to hle

merlt

75 Manpreef -Singh Cterk

GEN 2132 25-01-90 Social

Studies

16-

09-09

Fit lor

prom

otion

Accor

ding

to his

!

'14.53

iI

i

I

I

^

lGur Clerlr

O.H,8, Kotll

llllL(&ifu.i

Cbd(O.S.S.s.

DutEurall

(Roopnegar)

Junbr Alsldant

G.H.S.

Mukebar Sehtb

C[od(

Goramment

Rajindra

Collsge

Balhhda,

B.filnd.

Sharma Juniol

Assbhn[

Gorenment.

Colleg6,

Sangrur

kaur Junior

Assbhnt

Ludhhna

prom I dingotlon l ro hi6

' I mBrlt

c$ngh Junlor

Asebbnt,

Roopnagar

Studies 09{9 promotion

ding

to his

merit

84 Ha{aspreet

Singh Clerk

Ludhhnr

GEN 2314

2316

22-01-00 Punjabi 16-

09-09

Fit for

prom

otion

Accor

ding

to his

marlt

E5 Punbh Kumrr

Clcrt

Sangrur

OEN zz-ot-00 Engllch 3&

06-04

Fitbrprom

otion

FiiEiptoln

olion

Aocor

ding

to his

meril

86 PanamvtGil

JunlorAssietbnt

Gulab Slngh

(MukaEar

Sahib) l

GEN 2317 2241-00 Punjabi 30-

09-09

Accor

ding

to hie

merit

87 Shama Sharma

Glerk G.H,S.

Hcbrwrt Krhn

(Lurlhlene)

(,EN 22-01-00 Social

Studles

31-

03-09

Fit for

prom

otlon

Accor

ding

to hls

mcrlt

88 ttarbans StngF

ChrkG.H.S.

Sangora

(Barnala)

sc 2334 25{1-00 Social

Studies

30-

09-09

lFitfor

| ,,,

I olion

I Aoain

Ist

| ,r..nIr

roster

point

No,15

o89 Gurwinder

Singh Junior

turlrhnt

G.H.S chek

Ram Slngh

Wala

(Bathlnda)

GEN 2398

I

r0-03-00 DPE 28-

05-07

Fil for

prom

otion

Accor

ding

to hls

malt

l90 wavnish Kumar

JuniorAssistant

G.H.S. Gaga

GEN 2400E

Social

Studies

30-

09-09

ritbr I

Accorprom I oinsotion

I ro rris

I medt

55

.,(

4(tmgru0

91 r.hrphdtr

SlrBh Junior

Assishnt

Barnah

GEN 2410 10.03.00 Social

Studies

14-

12.03

Fltbrprom

otion

Acc&

ding

to hh

merit

92 tEwlngtr

KumarClerk

G.S.S.S.

Ruprnr Mundc

(Mulchr

Sehib)

SEN 2411 10-03-00 Punja6l 16-

09-09

24-

10-08

Fitbrprom

otion

Accor

ding

to his

merit

93 HarjltpalSingtl

Clerk

G.S.S.S. Jassi

PeWalt

(Bahinda)

GEN 2418 1 1-03-00 DPE Fir for

prcm

otion

Accor

ding

to his

meril

94 Amninder

Singh Junior

A.rlrLnt

o.s.8.8.

Balwan

(Sangrur)

GEN 2421 1 1-03-00 Punjabi 1?-

0848

Fittur

prcm

olim

Accor

ding

to his

moilt

95 Rabldeop

Singh Clerk

G.S.S.S.

Munde

Budhlada

(Mansa)

SC 2427 1 1-03-00 DPE 12-

06-09

Fittur

prcm

otion

Again

st

vacan

t

roster

pofnt

N0.16

96 M.npraet

Slngh Juntor

Assbbnt Dlst

Fafflot

(Far6to$

GEN 2429 13-O3-00 Social

Studies

16-

09-09

Flt lorprom

olion

A@or

ding

to his

merit

97 Jasmlt l(aur GEN 2460 1643-00 Sociai 16- Fit for Accor

re-1.

I

I

66i:

T-

67t(

EUhClert

Andtsar

(Amdbar)

Amanpr€et

Elngh Clrrk

O.H.3, B.h

(A!trfl..o

Clert c.H.S.

Alampur

(Hchlarpur)

pmm I ding

olion I ro his

Cled( G,s.S.S

Dyalpura Mirze

tO (B.thlnd.)

Cl$kG.H.S.

Nabhana

(Ba0rhrda)

Cbrk G.H.S.

Gag Kahn

(Ludhiana)

Slngh CH(

G.H.S. UpEt

(lrtdhbna)

.J

106 ShrllRml

Clerk G.S.S.S.

l'loshiarpur (Ajit

Garh)

GEN 2601 20-09-00 Social

Studies

29-

08-07

FN ET

Prom

olion

Accor

dlng

to his

merit

107 Atua[ ghrrmr

ClrrkG.H.8.

Kahlor

(Paffiankot)

OEN 2014 T3.r6',06'- Eocl.l

Studlcs

18"

11-04

FltTOT

prcm

dlon

Acoor

dlng

to hls

msrit

PaMnderPal

Slngh Clertt

G.S.S.S. Labra

(Jatandhar)

SC 2636 12-10-00 Punjabi 01-

05-06

Fithrptoill

ofron

Accor

dlng

to his

mcril

109 Ku!tsran Siryh

Cled(

Outdtrpur

BC, 2640 14-03-00 Punjabi 05-

09-09

Fit for

prom

oton

Again

st

wcan

t

rogt€r

point

No.l6

6110 Tanwir Singh

Cle,kG.S.S.S.

Khalkhurd

(Ferozepur)

GEN 30.10-00 Punjabi 31-

03-09

Fit for

prcm

olion

Aocor

ding

to his

merit

111 AmitJoshi-

Cterk c.S.s.S.

Ir[.hllrmI

(Horftllpud

GEN 2657 08-1240 Social

Studies

27-

07-o4

Fil 6rprom

otion

Accor

ding

lo hi8

mcrlt

112 Haish l0mar

Clerk Office

Paeh

GEN 2690 14-09.0 I Punjabi 19-

05-10

Fitbr fffiprom I oing

oton I ,o ni,I merit

113 Ravinder Kaui

Clerk Dlet,

Roopnagar

GEN- 2701 2f -09-01 uoclat

Studies

16-

09-09

FI forprom

otion

Agcor

ding

to his

rnedt114 Kulwinder

Singh Clerk

GEN 2743 21.09{i Punjabi 22-

05-10

Fit brprom

olion

Accor

ding

to his

medt

rJ"t1'

-

I

68

:- .1,-il

f\.

E.tt.E. Mander

(Paliala)

115 RaniitSingh

Clcrk

Govemment

College Sh.

Muketcsr Sahlb

(Mulcrtrrr

9thlb)

GEN ztg6 25-09-01 Social

Studles

03-

02-10

Ftt lor

Prom

ofon

Accor

ding

to his

merit

116 R{hderSlngh

MahiJunior

Asslshnt

GorBmmcnt

Rlpudman

Collegc Naba

(Patiala)

SC 20-0&0r Social

SUdies

2b

09-00

F[ tbr

prom

otion

1,17 Ramfficep-

Slneh Ctrrk

O.H.S. Bdcwet

(Ludhlana)

27fi 0&12-01 UOCEI

Studlaa

15-

01-10

Fitbrprcm

ollon

Again

8t

vtcan

trosler

point

N0.17

118 SimafiitKaur Jfficterk ILudhiana I

2720 04-10-01 DPE 1 z-

06-09

Fil for

prom

otion

Accor

ding

to hls

medl119 Avtar Singh

Clerk e.H.S.

Cheerna

Joffipur

(Barnala)

GEN 2225F

I 05-10-01 Punjabi 04-

11.(l9

Fit for

prom

otion

Ac@r

ding

to hls

mcdt

120 ltianmotran

Sharma Clerk

G.H.S. Lohat

(Gurdaspur)

GEN 2799 06.10{1 08.

04-a2

Fitllbr

prom

olion

lwan

ding

b hismedt

"*

A

70

't21 NHmgneh

Cl.[*O.11,8,

Rom.n Abd

Srtgh

(F&tdGt)

OEN ?730 1.10-01 Pun abl 18.

06.09

FI IOT

Edmoton

A0@r

dlng

to hts

llxnlt

122 Paramjlt l(arr

cb*G.s.S.s.

Bhagmnpur

Jatb (Pethta) I

I

BC 2744 10-10-01 Soclal

Studies

2V

.to{9F iorprom

otlon

Accor

dlng

to hls

m6rit

123 oumillhShah--

Cbd( O.H.8.

Khy.llwrl.

(B.thinda)

GEN 2t69 2&10.01 OPE 24.

10.08

Flt trprom

o0gn

Agoo,

dlng

lo hlr

mcrlt

'l2A Jasuent Singt-

Cled( c.H.S.

Amimh

(Moga)

2754 zc-19-o1 Punjabi 16-

0$,09

Fittur

proNn

olion

Again

st

vrcgn

t

roEter

poinl

No.17

6125 GurmetEui-

CLd( O,ttS.

Bhdri

(Sangrur)

I

GEN 2798 o t-1241 Soclal

StrdlGs

30-

09.09

Fit 6rpfom

otlon

Acaor

dlng

bhbmbrit

16 lfu$etmor

Shgh CHt

G.H,S. Pabeor

(Sangrur)

GEN 2803 07-1241 Sooial

Studies

21.

04-10

F1t br

Prom

otlon

A@rding

lo hls