ethics written submission

7/23/2019 Ethics Written Submission

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ethics-written-submission 1/8

Bhupinder Kumar Sharma

Vs.Bar Association, Pathankot

Ankit Shukla

Bhaskar Shama



Citations: AIR2002SC47, 2002(1)ALD24(SC), 2002 (46) ALR 213, 2002(1)ALT41(SC),

2002 (1) AWC 121 (SC), 2002GLH(1)299, JT2001(9)SC40, 2002(1)!LJR199,

2001()SCAL"1, (2002)1SCC470, #2001$119TA%&A'774(SC), (2002)1!L"C396

Co*a+: D! &o-a.at*a an/ S-ia*a !ati, JJ

a5ts:

A..a

1 A..ant -as i/ a..a a8ainst t- o*/* o t- a* Con5i o !na an/

Ha*;ana Hi8- Co*t an/ t- a* Con5i o In/ia n/* s5tion 3 o A/o5ats A5t

2 T- a* Con5i o* -i+ ia o* +is5on/5t an/ n/* t- s5tion 3<3)(/) o t-

A5t

3 T- Rs.on/nt Asso5iation in a =*ittn 5o+.aint ino*+/ t- a* Con5i aott- +is5on/5t o t- A..ant, to =-i5- it too> 5o8ni?an5 an/ t-*o8- its

Dis5i.ina*; Co++itt *+o/ t- na+ o A..ant *o+ t- *o o Stat

4 S5- D5ision =as *it*at/ ; t- a* Con5i o In/ia In A..a, an/ t-n A..a

=as o*=a*// to S.*+ Co*t o In/ia



< A*8+nts o -a o A..ant:

T- Insti8ation =* not s..o*t/ ; an; i/n5s an/ t-

n@i*; =as not o t-at =as *@i*/ in s5- 5ass

It =as aso Contn// t-at t- !nis-+nt 8in =as aso 8*oss;

/is.*o.o*tionat

6 A*8+nts on -a o Rs.on/nt

T- Rs.on/nt =* o o.inion t-at t- n@i*; =as .*o.*;

/on an/ t- *.o*t o -i+ 5ontinin8 t- sinss =as s+itt/ to

s /8T- 5o*t =as aso +a/ a=a* o t- a5t t-at t- a..ant =as

5ontinin8 -is sinss /*in8 t- .n/n5; o a..a o* t-

a* Con5is an/ t-is Co*t an/ -as 5ontin/ to /o so n at*

8iin8 an n/*ta>in8 o* t- sa+.



T- Co*t os*/

(i) H =as *nnin8 a .-oto5o.i* /o5+ntation 5nt* in t-

5o*t 5o+.on/, !at-an>ot, an/ t- s.a5 o* t- sa+ =as

aott/ to t- a..ant in -is .*sona 5a.a5it; on a55ont o -is

in8 -an/i5a.B

(ii) H =as *nnin8 a !CSTD oot- =-i5- =as aott/ in -is

na+ *o+ t- !ET D.a*t+nt n/* -an/i5a. @otaB

(iii) H =as .*o.*ito*Gn*a &ana8* o t- !na Coa

*i@tts, !at-an>ot, a .*iat 5on5*n an/ - =as .*sin8 t-

sinss-is int*st in t- sai/ sinss n on t- /at =-n -is

stat+nt =as *5o*// ; t- Dis5i.ina*; Co++itt on

12<1996



Dn5: T- A..ant sai/ t-at - s/ to 5a**; ot t-os sinsss t sin5 - is an

n*o/ A/o5at no=, t- sai/ sinss =as ta>n 5a* o ; -is at-* an/ *ot-*

'D"R A' RAL AGR""&"'T

T- Dis5i.ina*; Co++itt too> 5a* to os* a t- o*a an/ /o5+nta*; i/n5s

.t o* it an/ ti+at; too> /5ision o /a**in8 &* -.in/* F+a* *o+

.*a5ti5in8 as an a/o5at n/* t- n S5tion 3<(3)(/)

T- a* Con5i o In/ia in an a..a *it*at/ t- /5ision an/ sai/ t-; -a

*a..*5iat/ t- i/n5 o t- +att*

In t- o*+ o A..i5ation

12 W-t-* o* not a..i5ant n8a8/ o* -as * n n8a8/ in an; t*a/, sinss o*

.*ossion, i so t- nat* o s5- t*a/, sinss.*ossion an/ t- .a5 =-* it is o*

=as 5a**i/ on T- ans=* s+itt/ ; a..ant a/o5at is as n/*:

'o, not a..i5a



•T- Dis5i.ina*; Co++itt o a* Con5i o In/ia sai/ t-at t- a..ant -as ta>n t-

n*o+nt ; as /5a*ation,

•H n s..*ss/ a +at*ia a5t ( S5tion 26 Stat a* Con5i 5an *+o -is na+),

- =o/ not -a n n*o/ in t- i*st .a5 i s5- a5ts =* >no=n H is 8it;

o !*ossiona +is5on/5t

"i/n5s A.**5iat/

• 'o t*ans* o !C

•

Tsti+on; o at-* an/ *ot-*



JDG&"'T

Evidence------Quasi Criminal matter------Undertakin-------!isconduct-----

"isproportion

= a* o t- i= t-at t- in/in8 *5o*// -o/in8 t- a..ant 8it; o .*ossiona

+is5on/5t is s..o*t/ ; t- as/ on 5o8nt an/ 5onin5in8 i/n5 n /8/ ; t-

stan/a*/ *@i*/ to stais- +is5on/5t as *@i*/ to .*o a 5-a*8 in a @asi 5*i+ina

5as ;on/ *asona /ot W /o not in/ an; +*it in t- a*8+nt t-at t- +is5on/5t

a8/ a8ainst t- a..ant =as not .*o.*; .*o/ ; t- stan/a*/ *@i*/ to .*o s5-

a +is5on/5t T-* is aso no +*it in t- 5ontntion t-at t- i/n5 =as not .*o.*;a..*5iat/ ; ot- t- Dis5i.ina*; Co++ittsB not-in8 =as *o8-t on *5o*/ to /is5*/it

t- i/n5 / on -a o t- 5o+.ainant an/ no +at*ia =as .a5/ to s..o*t t-

a8ation o t- a..ant t-at t- ++*s o t- *s.on/ntAsso5iation -a/ an; 8*/8 o*

i=i a8ainst t- a..ant

17 W a* na to sa; t-at t- 5on5**nt in/in8 *5o*// ; ot- t- Dis5i.ina*;Co++itts a8ainst t- a..ant as to -is .*ossiona +is5on/5t, is a in/in8 as/ on no

i/n5 o* is as/ on +* 5onn5t* an/ n=a**ant/ in*n5 Hn5 t- sa+ 5annot

/ist*/

W 5onsi/* it st an/ a..*o.*iat to +o/i; t- .nis-+nt to /a* t- a..ant *o+

.*a5ti5in8 . to n/ o D5+*, 2006



T-an>;o

ethics written submission

Documents