evaluation ofopsonic andleukocyte function with a

11
Blood, Vol. 42, No. 1 (July), 1973 121 Evaluation of Opsonic and Leukocyte Function With a Spectrophotometric Test in Patients With Infection and With Phagocytic Disorders By Thomas P. Stossel Paraffin oil droplets containing Oil Red 0 and coated with Escherichia co/i lipo- polysaccharide were ingested rapidly by human peripheral blood phagocytes only if they were pretreated with normal serum. This property formed the basis of a screen- ing test in which lipopolysaccharide-coated particles were opsonized with patients’ serums and then were added to autologous leukocytes suspended in two portions, one of which contained nitroblue tetrazolium. After these incubations the cells were washed and extracted with dioxane. Oil Red 0 and nitroblue tetrazolium formazan in the dioxane extracts were spectrophoto- metrically assayed, thereby providing si- multaneous determinations of the initial rates of ingestion and nitroblue tetrazolium reduction. The test differentiated opsoni- cally-deficient serums and chronic granu- lomatous disease phagocytes from normals. Serums from individuals with bacterial infections had supernormal opsonic ac- tivity, and leukocytes from these pa- tients had increased rates of nitroblue tetrazolium reduction in response to ingestion. P HAGOCYTOSIS, the major defense mechanism against pyogenic infection, is a complex act that when properly executed includes ingestion and killing of microorganisms. Many microbes resist engulfment unless the opsonins of normal serum alter their surfaces rendering them readily ingestible by poly- morphonuclear and mononuclear phagocytes. Increased susceptibility to pyo- genic infection is the hallmark of congenital and acquired gamma globulin deficiencies’ and of certain congenital and acquired disorders of the complement system;2 and defective opsonization has been documented in these disorders.3’4 Thus, opsonic impairment is the commonest form of phagocytic dysfunction. The best characterized syndrome in which intraphagocytic killing is deranged is chronic granulomatous disease in which phagocytes do not generate hydro- gen peroxide, a major microbicidal agent, during ingestion.5 Despite normal ingestion,6’7 normal content of granule enzymes,8 and normal discharge of these granules into the phagocytic vacuole,7 granulocytes of these patients fail to kill catalase-positive microorganisms.9 A biochemical marker that correlates with hydrogen peroxide generation by polymorphonuclear leukocytes is the reduction of nitroblue tetrazolium to nitroblue tetrazolium-formazan,’#{176} a reac- tion that occurs in the phagocytic vacuole.” The rate of reduction of nitroblue tetrazolium during ingestion of polystyrene spheres by peripheral blood leuko- From the Hematology Division, Department of Medicine, Children’s Hospital Medical Center, and Department of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Mass. 02115. Submitted October 26, 1972; revised January 12, 1973; accepted January 16, 1973. Supported by USPHS Grants Al 08173 and FR 00128. Thomas P. Stossel, M.D. : Established Investigator of the American Heart Association; Associate in Hematology, Children’s Hospital Medical Center; and Assistant Professor of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Mass. © 1973 by Grune & Stratton, Inc. For personal use only. on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.org From

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jan-2022

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

Blood, Vol. 42, No. 1 (July), 1973 121

Evaluation of Opsonic and Leukocyte Function With a

Spectrophotometric Test in Patients With Infection

and With Phagocytic Disorders

By Thomas P. Stossel

Paraffin oil droplets containing Oil Red 0

and coated with Escherichia co/i lipo-

polysaccharide were ingested rapidly byhuman peripheral blood phagocytes onlyif they were pretreated with normal serum.This property formed the basis of a screen-

ing test in which lipopolysaccharide-coatedparticles were opsonized with patients’

serums and then were added to autologousleukocytes suspended in two portions, oneof which contained nitroblue tetrazolium.After these incubations the cells werewashed and extracted with dioxane. Oil

Red 0 and nitroblue tetrazolium formazan

in the dioxane extracts were spectrophoto-metrically assayed, thereby providing si-multaneous determinations of the initialrates of ingestion and nitroblue tetrazoliumreduction. The test differentiated opsoni-cally-deficient serums and chronic granu-lomatous disease phagocytes from normals.

Serums from individuals with bacterialinfections had supernormal opsonic ac-

tivity, and leukocytes from these pa-tients had increased rates of nitroblue

tetrazolium reduction in response toingestion.

P HAGOCYTOSIS, the major defense mechanism against pyogenic infection,

is a complex act that when properly executed includes ingestion and killing

of microorganisms. Many microbes resist engulfment unless the opsonins of

normal serum alter their surfaces rendering them readily ingestible by poly-

morphonuclear and mononuclear phagocytes. Increased susceptibility to pyo-

genic infection is the hallmark of congenital and acquired gamma globulin

deficiencies’ and of certain congenital and acquired disorders of the complement

system;2 and defective opsonization has been documented in these disorders.3’4

Thus, opsonic impairment is the commonest form of phagocytic dysfunction.

The best characterized syndrome in which intraphagocytic killing is deranged

is chronic granulomatous disease in which phagocytes do not generate hydro-

gen peroxide, a major microbicidal agent, during ingestion.5 Despite normal

ingestion,6’7 normal content of granule enzymes,8 and normal discharge of

these granules into the phagocytic vacuole,7 granulocytes of these patients fail

to kill catalase-positive microorganisms.9 A biochemical marker that correlates

with hydrogen peroxide generation by polymorphonuclear leukocytes is the

reduction of nitroblue tetrazolium to nitroblue tetrazolium-formazan,’#{176} a reac-

tion that occurs in the phagocytic vacuole.” The rate of reduction of nitroblue

tetrazolium during ingestion of polystyrene spheres by peripheral blood leuko-

From the Hematology Division, Department of Medicine, Children’s Hospital Medical

Center, and Department of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Mass. 02115.

Submitted October 26, 1972; revised January 12, 1973; accepted January 16, 1973.

Supported by USPHS Grants Al 08173 and FR 00128.

Thomas P. Stossel, M.D. : Established Investigator of the American Heart Association;

Associate in Hematology, Children’s Hospital Medical Center; and Assistant Professor ofPediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Mass.

© 1973 by Grune & Stratton, Inc.

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 2: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

122 THOMAS P. STOSSEL

cytes of patients with chronic granulomatous disease is markedly diminished.’0

Therefore, measurement of this reaction, the quantitative nitroblue tetrazolium

test, is an assay for detecting patients with this disorder,’2 but it does not aid

in the diagnosis of opsonic deficiencies.

A chemi�ally quantifiable microbial substitute, paraffin oil droplets contain-

ing Oil Red 0 and stabilized with bacterial lipopolysaccharide, is rapidly

ingested by phagocytes only if pretreated with serum.13 This paper describes

the use of such particles in combination with nitroblue tetrazolium as a screen-

ing test that, with 8 ml or more of blood, precisely and rapidly quantitates

serum heat-labile opsonic activity, the ingestion rate of phagocytes, and leuko-

cyte oxidative metabolism. It efficiently detects opsonic disorders and chronic

granulomatous disease. It also demonstrates differences in phagocytic function

between normal and infected individuals and thereby emphasizes the impor-

tance of choice of controls in studies of phagocytosis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Preparation of Leukocytes

The following adaptation of published procedures for preparation of human leukocyteswas utilized.5’12”4 Venous blood was drawn into a syringe containing 1 ml of ACD (NIH

formula A) for every 4 ml blood. In general, 8 ml of blood were taken from children and16 ml were taken from adults in the standard screening assay. Then 6% dextran (500,000molecular weight) in 0.15 M sodium chloride, 0.5 ml/ml of blood, was taken into thesyringe; the syringe was placed on its plunger, and the erythrocytes sedimented for 45-60

mm at room temperature. A sample of the supernatant plasma was taken for Wright’s-stained smears, from which the percentage of phagocytes (band forms, neutrophils, and

monocytes) was enumerated. The remainder was added to plastic, conical 50-mi centrifugetubes. Subsequent procedures were performed at ice bath temperature. Erythrocytes wereremoved by addition of 0.8% ammonium chloride, 2 ml/ml of plasma, by mixing for 1mm, and by centrifugation of the cell suspension at 80 g for 10 mm. The leukocyte pelletwas suspended and washed twice (centrifugation at 80 g for 10 mm) with 50 ml of 0.15 Msodium cholride and then was suspended in Krebs-Ringer phosphate medium, pH 7.4,approximately 1 ml/8 ml of blood originally obtained. A sample of this leukocyte sus-pension was removed for determination of cell number with the electronic Coulter Counter,

and the remainder was used for the phagocytic assay. Depending on the white cell countof the original blood sample, this final suspension contained 1-8 X i0’� leukocytes/ml.Since completion of these studies, it has been determined that omission of the ammoniumchloride lysis step yields leukocytes with less tendency to aggregate and that the degreeof erythrocyte contamination arising from this omission does not affect the test results.

Preparation of Oil Red 0 in Paraffin Oil

Oil Red 0 was distributed in approximately 500-mg amounts to 20-ml screw-cappedglass tubes containing 0.5 ml of chloroform. The solution of Oil Red A (Allied Chemical

Co., Morristown, N.J.) and chloroform was diluted to 20 ml with heavy paraffin oil (FisherScientific Co., Pittsburgh, Pa.) (density 0.89) and was shaken overnight. The tubes werecentrifuged at 2000 g for 1 hr. The supernatant fluids were pooled in an Erlenmeyer flaskwith a side arm, and the chloroform was removed by evaporation overnight at 50#{176}Cundervacuum. The Oil Red 0 solution in paraffin oil was centrifuged again, as described above.

Analysis of the optical density of the final solution over a period of weeks revealed nochange indicative of dye precipitating from the solution. The optical density of this solu-

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 3: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

OPSONIC AND LEUKOCYTE FUNCTION 123

tion at 525 nm (the absorption peak) was used to compute a constant (K) for convertingoptical density to milligrams of paraffin oil ingested, where:

K=OD x 0.89

ml

Preparation of Emulsion

Thirty milligrams of Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide 026:B6, prepared by the Boivinprocedure (Difco Laboratories, Detroit, Mich.)15 were suspended in 3 ml of Krebs-Ringerphosphate medium in a thick-walled plastic test tube and were dispersed by sonication for

5 sec. One milliliter of paraffin oil containing Oil Red 0 was layered over the lipopoly-saccharide suspension. The oil was emulsified into droplets by sonication for 45 sec. Thetip of the sonifier probe was kept just below the oil-aqueous interface. For convenience,a large amount of emulsion could be prepared in this manner and frozen at -20#{176}Cwith-out alteration of its properties.

Preparation and Standardization of Nitroblue Tetrazolium Solution

Nitroblue tetrazolium is relatively insoluble in salt solutions, and the concentrationsdescribed in the literature, 1-2 mg/mI, are overestimates of the actual amount of materialin solution. This conclusion was verified with several lots of nitroblue tetrazolium from

different suppliers. Therefore, the following procedure was utilized to standardize stocknitroblue tetrazolium solutions. Nitroblue tetrazolium was suspended in Krebs-Ringerphosphate at a concentration of 2 mg/ml and then was filtered through a 0.3 j� Millipore

filter. Of the filtrate, 0.1 ml was added to 0.4 ml of 1 mM ascorbic acid in 0.2 N sodiumhydroxide. The nitroblue tetrazolium was quantitatively reduced to formazan by this pro-cedure, and the insoluble residue was collected on a 0.3 j� Millipore filter. The entire filterwas dissolved in 2 ml of p-dioxane with heating to 85#{176}C,and optical density was imme-diately determined at 580 nm. The actual concentration of the filtrate was approximately318 �g/ml. Formazan, prepared as described above, was weighed on tared Millipore filters,

and its optical density was determined, thereby providing a conversion factor from opticaldensity to micrograms of formazan (14.14 �ig formazan/optical density unit, for a 1 cmlight path in dioxane at 25#{176}C).

Preparation of Serum

Whole blood was allowed to clot at room temperature; the serum was separated by

centrifugation and was analyzed immediately or frozen at -70#{176}C.

Opsonization of the Emulsion

Test serum, 0.4 ml, or Krebs-Ringer phosphate medium (control) was incubated with

0.4 ml of the paraffin oil particles at 37#{176}Cfor 15 mm.

Incu bations

To two siliconized glass or polycarbonate plastic 15-mi centrifuge tubes was added 0.015ml of 0.i M freshly prepared potassium cyanide in Krebs-Ringer phosphate medium and0.4 ml of the leukocyte suspension. Krebs-Ringer phosphate medium, 0.4 ml, was added tothe first tube, and nitroblue tetrazolium solution, 0.4 ml, was added to the second tube.The tubes were shaken in a water bath at 37#{176}Cfor 5 mm, and then 0.2 ml of particles,opsonized by the patient’s serum, was added. After 5 mm more of shaking at 37#{176}C,6 ml

of ice-cold 1 mM N-ethylmaleimide in 0.15 M sodium chloride was added, and the unin-gested emulsion was removed by centrifuging the cells at 500 g, discarding the supernatant,

disrupting the leukocyte pellet by tapping the bottom of the centrifuge tube, and repeating

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 4: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

124 THOMAS P. STOSSEL

the centrifugation with 6 ml of fresh 0.15 M sodium chloride. The tubes were then drainedby inversion, and the inner surfaces were wiped with tissue. Oil Red 0 and formazan

were extracted from the pellets by adding 1 ml of dioxane and heating the extracts at 85#{176}Cfor 15 mm. The optical densities of the solutions clarified by centrifugation at 1000 g for

15 mm were determined at 525 nm and 580 nm.

Calculation of Results

For 5-mm incubations, milligrams paraffin oil ingested/mm/b7 phagocytes was quanti-

fled from the dioxane extract of the incubation that did not contain nitroblue tetrazolium:

OD525 X 50 x K

leukocytes/ml x (bands, PMN, and monocytes)

100 leukocytes

Where K is the conversion constant described above and 50 is a factor accounting for the

time of incubation and bringing the final result to a base of 107 phagocytes.Nitroblue tetrazolium reduction, micrograms formazan generated/min/107 phagocytes

was derived from:

(OD580 of extract with formazan) - (OD580 of extract without formazan) X 50 X 14.14

cells/mi X (bands, PMN, and monocytes)

100 leukoyctes

The formazan-paraffin oil ratio was the quotient of the second calculation divided by thefirst.

Patients

Apparently healthy subjects were designated as normals. Cord blood was obtained fromsix full-term newborns. These serums had normal IgG concentrations, nearly normal C3concentrations, but low levels of 1gM and IgA. Blood was also obtained from febrilepatients with a variety of pyogenic infections. In this study, note was not made of duration

of illness or of treatment. Five patients with chronic granulomatous disease, three malesand two females, were studied. The diagnosis was established by the failure of their

leukocytes to augment hexose monophosphate shunt activity and quantitative nitrobluetetrazolium reduction during phagocytosis of latex beads. Two of four female carriers ofchronic granulomatous disease had previously been identified by the quantitative nitrobluetetrazolium test.’2 Serum and leukocytes were obtained from patients with normal serumimmunoglobulmn concentrations but with C3 levels of less than 1000 mg/liter; from four

with systemic lupus erythematosis, one patient with acute glomerulonephritis, and one

patient with Type I essential hypercatabolism of C3.4 Serum and leukocytes were collectedfrom one patient with untreated congenital agammaglobulmnemia and from two patientswith acquired hypogammaglobulinemia. These patients had normal C3 levels.

Other Studies

The quantitative nitroblue tetrazolium test was performed by the method of Baehnerand Nathan,’2 and histochemical estimation of nitroblue tetrazolium reduction by individualphagocytes ingesting zymosan was made by the technique of Nathan et al.11 Immuno-globulin and complement determinations were performed in the laboratory of Dr. C. A.Alper by means of quantitative immunoprecipitation.’6

RESULTS

Human leukocytes ingested lipopolysaccharide-coated oil droplets at an ex-

tremely slow rate unless the particles were first preincubated with fresh

normal serum (opsonized) (Fig. 1, left). If the particles were opsonized, a

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 5: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

OPSONIC AND LEUKOCYTE FUNCTION 125

Fig. 1. Left. Effect of serum on rate of � ___________________________. � [,#{176}ARrICL�s

ingestion of lipopolysaccharide-coated pa- � PR-/NcUSArED 03

raffin oil droplets by human leukocytes. � ________. . 0 � _., �

Right. Effect of serum concentration on � .o � �

initial rate of ingestion of particles. � ,/

� 0.5 � 0i

k ,sSerum

a � � � � � 0

2 6 0 J 4 I � Undilutsd

M/Nt/T(S SE#{149}RUM

rapid rate of ingestion, constant with time for 5 mm, was instantly initiated.

If the cells, rather than the particles, were preincubated with serum, the maxi-

mal rate of uptake was attained after a delay. This phenomenon is illustrated

in Fig. 2 (left), where the kinetics of nitroblue tetrazolium reduction during

phagocytosis of lipopolysaccharide emulsion are shown to parallel those of the

uptake of Oil Red 0 shown in Fig. 1.

The opsonic process was completed within 15 mm at 37#{176}Cand was inhibited

by incubation of the system at 0#{176}C,or in the presence of iO� M EDTA, or if

the serum was pretreated with zymosan or heated at 56#{176}Cfor 30 mm. When

the concentration of opsonized particles added to the system was doubled, the

initial rate of ingestion was not altered, indicating that the standard concen-

tration of particles was saturating and that true initial rates of ingestion,

independent of particle concentration, were measured. Figure 2 (right) shows

that the nitroblue tetrazolium concentration was not limiting under the assay

conditions, where the final nitroblue tetrazolium concentration was approxi-

mately 150 ,�g/ml. Figure 1 (right) reveals that the opsonic activity of human

serum, as determined in the standard assay system, was limiting and was

proportional to serum concentration. Under standard assay conditions, the

optical density at 580 nm of extracts containing Oil Red 0 alone was approxi-

mately 20% of extracts of paired incubations that contained nitroblue tetra-

zolium as well. The former was subtracted from the latter to quantify nitroblue

tetrazolium reduction. The optical density of formazan at 525 nm was almost

80% of that of Oil Red 0. Therefore, it was not possible to perform the entire

assay with a single incubation containing both Oil Red 0 particles and nitro-

blue tetrazolium.

Figure 3 summarizes the results of the phagocytic screening test for normal

individuals and for patients with different diseases. Serums of patients, which

Fig. 2. Left. Effect of serum on rate of

nitroblue tetrazolium reduction by human � [S(RUM I ‘�

leukocytes incubated with lipopolysaccha- � 12� PRE-/NCUS4T(D � is

ride-coated paraffin oil droplets. Either � � Part�lss Iparticles or leukocytes were preincubated � 8 frX�.4 � ‘#{176}

as indicated. Right. Effect of nitroblue � ,�‘

tetrazolium concentration on initial rate of � � , \ a �

nitroblue tetrazolium reduction by human � CC.IIs

leukocytes ingesting serum-treated par- � 2 � :� 3�0 90 50

tides. Incubations were for 5 mm at 37#{176}C. �irnirs

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 6: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

126 THOMAS P. STOSSEL

t test.

1:Significance of difference between normal and infected cells.

Fig. 3. Initial rates of ingestion of lipo-

� � polysaccharide-coated paraffin oil drop-� � � lets by leukocytes engulfing particles pre-

� � � 4� treated with autologous serum are shown� � � in left of each column. Ratios of initial rate

� � � I of nitroblue tetrazolium reduction to initial� � � rate of ingestion are shown in right-hand4� � portion of each column. Leukocytes and

� serum were obtained from normal andinfected controls (black circles), patients

with C3 deficiency (open circles), immunoglobulin deficiency (open squares), chronicganulomatous diseases (black triangles), chronic granulomatous disease “carriers”

(black squares), and newborn infants (open triangles). The range of normal is evident

from this figure.

were deficient in C3 or which lacked immunoglobulins, promoted subnormal

phagocytic rates, as did serums of six newborn full-term infants. The lesion

was localized to the serum by appropriate mixing experiments. While the

range of normal ingestion rates was quite large, patients with bacterial infec-

tions tended to have ingestion rates greater than the normals, although overlap

with the apparently normal population was considerable. Mixing experiments

(Table 1) implicated primarily but not totally the serum as the source of this

enhancement. In these mixing experiments, the serum used to opsonize the

particles was often ABO incompatible, but it was shown in other studies that

the activity of a given individual’s serum was essentially equally effective with

incompatible or compatible cells.

Nitroblue tetrazolium reduction is a function of ingestion (Fig. 2). Therefore,

the rates of nitroblue tetrazolium reduction shown in Fig. 3 are corrected for

ingestion rates. Patients with abnormal serums, despite having diminished

absolute nitroblue tetrazolium reduction rates, had normal reduction rates

when corrected for the impaired ingestion. Leukocytes of patients with chronic

granulomatous disease had subnormal rates of nitroblue tetrazolium reduction

even after correction for ingestion. Mothers of two of these patients had

nitroblue tetrazolium reduction rates intermediate between normals and the

Table 1. Comparison of Serum and Cells of Normal Controls and Infected Patients

Serum

Rate of ingestion

Normal cells infected cells(mg paraffin oll/107 phagocytes/min)

NormalInfected

0.138 (0.121-.O.157)#{176} 0.148 (0.133-0.175)0.353 (0.202-0.406) 0.425 (0.266-0.501)

p <0.011: p <0.011:

p<0.05tp<0.05t

*Mean and range for six separate samples.

tSignificance of difference between normal and infected serum based on Student’s

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 7: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

OPSONIC AND LEUKOCYTE FUNCTION 127

patients. Two others consistently had reduction rates in the low normal range,

and the same results were obtained with the quantitative nitroblue tetrazolium

test. Histochemical studies showed that these mothers had two populations

of leukocytes, one that reduced nitroblue tetrazolium in phagocytic vacuoles

containing zymosan particles and one that did not. The leukocytes of patients

with bacterial infections tended to have nitroblue tetrazolium reduction rates

greater than the normals, even after correction for the enhanced ingestion

rates (Fig. 3).

In all of these studies, the data have been expressed in terms of phagocytes

defined as band forms, segmented neutrophils, and monocytes. Eosinophils

were excluded. When Wright’s-stained smears of leukocytes ingesting opso-

nized lipopolysaccharide-paraffin oil droplets were examined, engulfed particles

were clearly apparent as lucent vacuoles within the cytoplasm. Eosinophils

rarely ingested the particles. Band forms, segmented neutrophils, and mono-

cytes appeared to participate equally in ingesting the droplets, although precise

quantitation of relative rates of uptake could not be assessed by this morpho-

logic technique. At least 90% of the phagocytes of the tests summarized in

Fig. 3 were mature segmented neutrophils.

DISCUSSION

Analysis of phagocytic function in the evaluation of patients with suscepti-

bility to pyogenic infection requires assessment of opsonization, ingestion, and

killing of microorganisms. The nature and method of activation of all serum

opsonins are not yet established. Nevertheless, the importance of gamma

globulin and of complement,’7 particularly of activated C3,’8”9 in promoting

phagocytosis of microorganisms is well established. The opsonic activity of

serum for the lipopolysaccharide-paraffin oil particles is heat labile. In studies

described elsewhere, it has been determined that opsonization of these particles

involves C3 fixation by means of the alternate complement pathway, i.e., the

properdin system. This fixation is enhanced by antibody to lipopolysaccha-

ride.’3 Not unexpectedly, therefore, the screening test introduced in this paper

detected opsonic deficiencies associated with hypogammaglobulinemia, and

with diminished serum levels of C3 secondary to various disorders.

The assessment of ingestion requires readily quantifiable substrates for

phagocytosis. This substrate must be easily separable from the phagocytes so

that true internalization may be differentiated from nonspecific adhesion and

that saturating concentrations of particles can be employed. When these

criteria are met, it is possible with a single time point to determine initial rates

of ingestion.20 A short incubation period is preferable when dealing with

phagocytes in suspension, since clumping of these cells occurs rapidly at

37#{176}C.The ability of paraffin oil droplets in general to satisfy these criteria

has been discussed,2’ and data pertinent to the kinetics of this system for use

with human phagocytes have been presented in this paper. The findings that

no ingestion of lipopolysaccharide-paraffin oil particles occurred at zero time,

at O#{176}C�or in the presence of 1 mM N-ethylmaleimide and that the initial rate of

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 8: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

128 THOMAS P. STOSSEL

engulfment was saturable with respect to particle concentration strongly mdi-

cate that nonspecific adherence of particles to cells was not included in the

measurement of particle uptake.

The most direct method for assessment of killing of microbes by leukocytes

involves measurement of loss in viability of a microbial population suspended

with phagocytes.22 This technique has provided much useful information about

phagocytosis and originally detected a bactericidal defect in chronic granu-

lomatous disease.9 This method, however, is time-consuming, is relatively

insensitive and imprecise, and does not provide optimal quantitative resolu-

tion.20 The importance of hydrogen peroxide for mntraphagocytic microbial

killing has made it reasonable to utilize reactions that correlate with hydrogen

peroxide generation, such as nitroblue tetrazolium reduction, as an indirect

quantitative approach for detection of clinically relevant killing defects. Other

processes that are associated with hydrogen peroxide generation and can be

quantitated reliably include hexose monophosphate shunt activity23 and fixa-

tion of iodide to protein.24 The latter reaction is particularly pertinent because

it requires the presence of peroxidase-containing granules and normal degranu-

lation. Hence, it can detect deficiency of myeloperoxidase, an adjunct to hydro-

gen peroxide-mediated microbial killing, as well as absence of hydrogen

peroxide. These biochemical tests, however, do not differentiate impaired in-

gestion from deranged leukocyte metabolism because the rates of the meta-

bolic reactions are functions of the ingestion rate.21 The screening test

presented in this paper does differentiate immediately between diminished

ingestion and impaired oxidative metabolism.

In addition to detecting opsonic deficiencies and chronic granulomatous

disease, this test also revealed increased opsonic activity of serum from patients

with bacterial infections. Enhanced serum opsonic activity has previously been

observed with serum from patients with subacute bacterial endocarditis25 and

from heroin addicts.26 Leukocytes of infected patients demonstrated super-

normal ingestion and nitroblue tetrazolium reduction rates (Fig. 3). Resting

leukocytes in whole blood of patients with certain infections may spontane-

ously reduce nitroblue tetrazolium, producing formazan precipitates in or on

the cells.27 The basis of this type of nitroblue tetrazolium reduction and its

relationship to the reduction occurring during particle ingestion remain to be

defined. However, the influence of the clinical state of the subject on test

results is noteworthy, because it emphasizes the importance of defining the

control group. The difficulties encountered in this study and by others28 in

detecting carriers of chronic granulomatous disease by quantitative methods

may represent an example of this problem. In the report that introduced the

quantitative nitroblue tetrazolium test,’2 the reduction of nitroblue tetrazolium

by female carriers of chronic granulomatous disease was considerably closer to

the patient population than to the controls. The control cells were derived

from patients with infections in that study, and the lower limit of nitroblue

tetrazolium reduction for normal controls may not have been appreciated. This

lower limit leaves little room for carriers. Histochemical methods first sug-

gested by Windhorst et al.29 are useful for verifying the presence of the carrier

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 9: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

OPSONIC AND LEUKOCYTE FUNCTION 129

state. These techniques, unlike quantitative tests, have the advantage of not

being influenced by compensation on the part of the normal cell population.

They are not totally satisfactory because they rely on subjective factors, and

the morphology is not always optimal.

The normal initial rates of ingestion found for leukocytes of patients with

chronic granulomatous disease engulfing lipopolysaccharide-coated particles

opsonized with autologous serum confirm and extend the findings obtained

previously using albumin-coated paraffin oil droplets,7 and by others using

bacteria as test particles.9 Although the patients were not actively infected

when the studies were performed, it is notable that the ingestion rates were

at the lower range of normal. It is unlikely that a subtle impairment in inges-

tion accounts for the abnormal metabolic responses of these patients’ leuko-

cytes, but it will be of interest to determine whether failure to enhance

ingestion in the presence of bacterial infection is another feature of this

syndrome.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The author thanks Mr. John Hartwig and Miss Marilyn Taylor for technical

assistance; Dr. David G. Nathan, Dr. Chester A. Alper, and Dr. Fred S. Rosen for advice;and the Children’s Hospital Medical Center and Peter Bent Brigham Hospital House Staffsfor referring patients.

REFERENCES

1. Rosen FS, Janeway CA: The gamma

globulins. III. The antibody deficiency syn-dromes. N Engl J Med 275 :709, 769, 1966

2. Alper CA, Rosen FS : Genetic aspectsof the complement system. Adv Immunol14:251, 1971

3. Mickenberg ID, Root RK, Wolff SM:

Leukocytic function in hypogammagiobulmn-emia. J Clin Invest 49 :1528, 1970

4. Alper CA, Abramson N, Johnston RBJr. Jandi JH, Rosen FS : Increased suscepti-

bility to infection associated with abnormal-ities of complement-mediated function andof the third component of complement (C3).N Engl J Med 282:349, 1970

5. Holmes BH, Page AR, Good RA: Stud-ies of the metabolic activity of leukocytesfrom patients with a genetic abnormality ofphagocytic function. J Clin Invest 46:1422,

19676. Holmes BH, Quie PG, Windhorst DB,

Good RA: Fatal granulomatous disease of

childhood : An inborn abnormality of phago-

cytic function. Lancet 1 :1225, 19667. Stossel TP, Root RK, Vaughan M:

Phagocytosis in chronic granulamotous dis-ease and the Chediak Higashi syndrome.N Engl J Med 286 :120, 1972

8. Baehner RL, Karnovsky MJ, KarnovskyML : Degranulation of leukocytes in chronicgranulomatous disease of childhood. J Clin

Invest 46:187, 19699. Quie PC, White JG, Holmes B, Good

RA : In vitro bactericidal capacity of human

polymorphonuclear leukocytes : Diminished

activity in chronic granulomatous disease of

childhood. J Clin Invest 46:668, 1967

10. Baehner RL, Nathan DG : Leukocyteoxidase : Defective activity in chronic gran-ulomatous disease. Science 155 :835, 1967

11. Nathan DC, Baehner RL, Weaver DK:Failure of nitroblue tetrazolium reduction in

the phagocytic vacuoles of leukocytes inchronic granulomatous disease. J Clin Invest48:1895, 1969

12. Baehner RL, Nathan DC : Quantitativenitroblue tetrazolium test in chronic granu-lomatous disease. N Engl J Med 278:971,1968

13. Stossel TP, Alper CA, Rosen FS:Serum-dependent phagocytosis of paraffin

oil emulsified with bacterial lipopolysaccha-ride. J Exp Med 137:690, 1973

14. Brubaker LH, Evans WH: Separationof granulocytes, monocytes, lymphocytes,erythrocytes and platelets from human

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 10: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

130 THOMAS P. STOSSEL

blood and relative tagging with diisopropylfluorophosphate (DFP). J Lab Clin Med73:1036, 1969

15. Webster ME, Sagin JF, Landy � John-son AG : Studies on the 0 antigen of Sal-

monella typhosa. I. Purification of the anti-

gen. J Immunol 74 :455, 195516. Ritchie RF, Alper CA, Graves J: Auto-

mated quantitation of proteins in serum andother biological fluids. Am J Clin Pathol (inpress)

17. Ward HK, Enders JF: An analysis ofthe opsonic and tropic action of normal andimmune sera based on experiments with thepncumococcus. J Exp Med 57:527, 1933

18. Johnston RB Jr, Klemperer MR, AlperCA, Rosen FS : The enhancement of bacterialphagocytosis by serum : The role of comple-

ment components and of two cofactors. JExp Med 129:1275, 1969

19. Smith MR, Wood WB Jr: Heat labileopsonins to pneumococcus. I. Participationof complement. J Exp Med 130:1209, 1969

20. Michell RH, Pancake SJ, NoseworthyJ, Karnovsky ML : Measurement of rates ofphagocytosis. The use of cellular monolay-

ers. J Cel! Biol 40:216, 196921. Stossel TP, Mason RJ, Hartwig J,

Vaughan M : Quantitative studies of phago-cytosis by polymorphonuclear leukocytes:

Use of emulsions to measure the initial rate

of phagocytosis. J Clin Invest 51 :615, 1972

22. Maal#{216}e 0 : On the Relation Between

Alexin and Opsonin. Copenhagen, EjnarMunksgaard, 1946

23. Sbarra AJ, Karnovsky ML : The bio-

chemical basis of phagocytosis. I. Metabolicchanges during the ingestion of particles bypolymorphonuclear leukocytes. J Biol Chem234:744, 1971

24. Pincus SH, Kiebanoff SJ : Quantitativeleukocyte iodination. N Engl J Med 284:744,1971

25. Laxdal T, Messner R, Williams RC,Quie PG : Opsonic, agglutinating, and com-plement-fixing antibodies in patients withsubacute bacterial endocarditis. J Lab ClinMed 71:638, 1968

26. Nickerson DS, Williams RC, Box-meyer M, Quie PG : Increased opsonic ca-pacity of serum in chronic heroin addiction.Ann Intern Med 72:671, 1970

27. Park BH, Fikrig SM, Smithwick EM:Infection and nitroblue tetrazolium reduc-

tion by neutrophils: A diagnostic aid. Lancet2:532, 1968

28. Presig E, Hitzig WH: Nitroblue-tetra-

zolium test for the detection of chronic

granulomatous disease-technical modifica-

tion. Eur J Clin Invest 1 :409, 1971

29. Windhorst DB, Page AR, Holmes B,

Good RA : The pattern of genetic transmis-

sion of the leukocyte defect in fatal granu-lomatous disease of childhood. J Clin Invest47:1026, 1968

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom

Page 11: Evaluation ofOpsonic andLeukocyte Function With a

1973 42: 121-130  

Thomas P. Stossel Test in Patients With Infection and With Phagocytic DisordersEvaluation of Opsonic and Leukocyte Function With a Spectrophotometric 

http://www.bloodjournal.org/content/42/1/121.full.htmlUpdated information and services can be found at:

Articles on similar topics can be found in the following Blood collections

http://www.bloodjournal.org/site/misc/rights.xhtml#repub_requestsInformation about reproducing this article in parts or in its entirety may be found online at:

http://www.bloodjournal.org/site/misc/rights.xhtml#reprintsInformation about ordering reprints may be found online at:

http://www.bloodjournal.org/site/subscriptions/index.xhtmlInformation about subscriptions and ASH membership may be found online at:

  Copyright 2011 by The American Society of Hematology; all rights reserved.Hematology, 2021 L St, NW, Suite 900, Washington DC 20036.Blood (print ISSN 0006-4971, online ISSN 1528-0020), is published weekly by the American Society of

For personal use only.on April 12, 2019. by guest www.bloodjournal.orgFrom