exhibit z1 email 4 july 2002 richard priman dnr to ben sturgess peter care lenthalls dam gate...

5
$AtAst2AA2 Agi42 8741255118 I,IDE BAY IAJATER ,r'.'t". I hopcmy olfcrs to condnuc ncgoriatint through Mr Rhulc,s company aod in alkin8 him to 'fib up compcnsaaon rarucs in rclaliooro all rhc differcntoptio'! ,,ill bc of essisrancc ro you, add rha! )/ou \rill icc rhir ro b. protrcssivc and s dcnon$r.bd x,irh ro rror* alon, with you. Yourssinc{cly dt44 TIM*ALDR'N T'e4'2 CHIEF EXECT'TIIE OFFICER *IDE BAy rvArER coRpoRATroN lt-J b,b a ' 4^*#' ,ffi/,!tr?*Z% p#4*,'?^?-ffi;fu4 tu:ffi-fffi'.2.Mt4;t

Upload: lenthallsdamgatefail

Post on 26-Oct-2015

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Lenthalls Dam Gate Failure email - confirmation of flood risk upstream notification of state government of risk. Confusion of public officials as to the scope of the project. Fraser Coast Regional Council /Wide Bay Water Corporation / incorrectly lodged planning application

TRANSCRIPT

$ A t A s t 2 A A 2 A g i 4 2 8741255118 I,IDE BAY IAJATER

,r'.'t".

I hopc my olfcrs to condnuc ncgoriatint through Mr Rhulc,s company aod in alkin8 him to'fib up compcnsaaon rarucs in rclalioo ro all rhc differcnt optio'! ,,ill bc of essisrancc royou, add rha! )/ou \rill icc rhir ro b. protrcssivc and s dcnon$r.bd x,irh ro rror* alon, withyou.

Yours sinc{cly

dt44TIM*ALDR'N T'e4'2CHIEF EXECT'TIIE OFFICER*IDE BAy rvArER coRpoRATroN lt-J b,b a

'

4 ^ * # ',ffi/,!tr?*Z%p#4*,'?^?-ffi;fu4

tu:ffi-fffi'.2.Mt4;t

r o r ) / ou r l n ro r ^ '

' ' , , a \ Y r , { r

' - ' . , i" - - - - - o r i s i n a . I M e s s a s e - - - t " * - , { \ ' - { } r I t " / I-'-,.:T: ;l:::.y:"|'il",oo, ,,,n, *'J*

-{) vf , *l', / ..

-{, ff;i"::: L,.aison; c,aydon "."n, o:'f#"ra"" *!*, --7 '-,o'o

, 'r

: lrblecE: Fw: LenI'ha]l's Dant t^B 9123 e:.c./,,/i ,_r/ * ,,*,1sf : MinisEer Lr.aison; claydon c..s, o:k#Hei";

- l - - , - - / ,

lrblecE: Fw: Lenr'ha]l's Dant t^B 9123 eic/,,/i .,-./ A

- f

l_--r+ -,rf./ ;_-j-1 €

Re our earLier conversat ion. j ^.rhanks fo! of ferrns to help.

'

. ,1\ . - (

* l , ,P]ease see ar lached e-mai l f rom Mike Snith. , / '

- . ,<

' ,''

d''** lilike is -askiEg D€ to advise {a} wbets}rer the teking of ifan/for purposes of raisi.ng lhe.ra* to 6r ir at{rrogrlate wh€lr th. cLr.rrenc intenti;n ii\rof"f* a 2!l raising and {b)uheth€r there is any impealiment !o rhe raiEinq "t ,n" a"nz.t

I tlrink th€a€ ale queations that could be berter airected tjrC^e resuming aurhoriry,but i f you can anEwer Ehern to Uike's sar isfacr ion, so * i f '

+ Arrothe! DAt.ter involves a ninisterial response rhar has t.o be dratteil !o a 1errer-it'Een bt /s Eathe! AIIan rho parceives 6otne lr€rgonal healrb anat safety issues as a\. - /nseqlrence of-the Autholty's aplE ent witlralrawal of arl offer to retocare her farnily.s-:of'lircy to safe grorrnd above poasible flood 1eve1s.

_ ,- have endeavoureal to conlact a pete! Care of WBl{(apparently Bob Halse has)vrce on th j .s quest ion but to no avai l . This par t icu lar matCer seems ro me

-?/ , round engineer ing advice and corpensaL:on issues.

M i c h a e l S h r n e .

- - - - -Or ig j .nal Message--- - -F!c@: Nj,ke Sith (tllnistelialtSent : Tuesalay, ? Uay 2002 10: t? l l {To: shine ttichaelGc: Ealen OtkasSubject: Lenlhal l 's Dam. LAB 9?23 etc

I have haal a discnssion with Helen re lhis issue.

Re: the lelt'er froin Hon Tom Balton l.lp !e Esther AfLan:

I f you refe! the let ter to rhe RSD for rhe area he should be able toal locate an off icer fani l iar wiLh the area and issues !o helD draft aresponse. I ! may also be lseful to ger creg Claydon {cenerai Manager Water

F o.n: Priman FlichardSent: 04 July 2002 13:07l"i qlurgess Ben .4.&fbl.ct FW: L.nthaltb Dam LAB 9729 e{c .{ i'o?^

/':" ' l r:-----ori di n:r oaiJ, -'t t'\r-*,

-i"i ig"-M.'sJili o" ".r' 'r r or claydon cres I rf , 1. ',.

Senr: Thulsday, 75 r iay 2AO2 2:q6 pMTo: Priftan Richard r-=\ '. ./ .subjecE: Fw: rJelchalL's o.., Us gX{ltt *f

,-,,/'t-

u.*, c4 '

,/,, ..14 l { . , u , , ,

4Richald /i,,^ t ,,".,. \-',.,i

nNftJn 1 ,1-J7'r n - , r t l ( ' /

r t ' V

le f t ) for

rQ

to . cast h is eye over the drafE response before i r comes back here.' rpptov ing

rhe acguis i t ion r

T h e r e i s . i n s u f f i c i e n t i n f o r F a i i o n o n r n e f r t e f o r m e r o1 3 . _ l l i I i " j l . " . 1 : . r 4 o ! e i n f o r n a r i o n n a y a l l o w a p p r o v a r . -aovlce.co the Minisler that he cannot. be sat isf ied lbaEfn::i..13.?f,lT! Act iEt satsisficd, p;r;i;il ii;;

- l 1 Lreconmend app!oval

3 9 { 6 ) of the

l*fl I : li.:i re. is reasoaa.uiy-;;;i;ii;';;;'fi,:{ ff:i.rD4r ta to De tak€a is appropriate, artd ie sapablc oi-ch

re ther€fore need you !o advisej -.1: \. , _/i*..

:*_-_q:Pe'. ti'" iiir"s ;'i;; r". p*D"=:I :.::i.gE:o\da,D r+-Gn iF:*'"";i:ffJnff.::"r:ff:J**:'.:; ;;i-1.-fi:ftSf*a 1 .,..& d \

:3:i3.i"::' i: #::::: :i::"?H, il"u:* h'. *. * ".pr"o.i'd "",*c e ov' zt;;;;;i;;.';,;;::;:''""T.7'" ".4J"1 * ot: :. .eler/6,.to ;4_=

il #f*T:-li"-"r"r""'. ^"u j,/p'1".'J'ngQ "on'.'**-ri acquis-:.e"td.^, tf .1?i!.Hil:r:i. r::H::":,y:.f''^ ".';"rG "op'o'**-d:'i'"-' :i:flru, n7:,

rerEe!, i! he decides .h. i";"gffi-l:,I*;{.ff:l:lSeg acqrij,.rio,. _,/iPlease sive he a cair Lo discuss .{.""*A*"""\; /J.,. , \_l _.. \J.,. i , .

J,;;;-;;;;;--- --'-'-'i?4--- - '.-./* ''�rr '.*.,Por icy Advrso! t"27' //Ph: 0? 389 63690 <' ; - , -VFaxt 01 )21062\4 .--a /Mike. snd lh@nini s cer ial . q1d. s,ov. au J '

^; / -- ,

?j:i.:.:f Eh.e Minister ro! Narurar Resources """.sif.]_ '

,_l*':":'r;; *xii";in:i,!$.:!:#m:'n:si:iry. r:*'t f.'

the I shouldLhe

* !'hethe! ttrere is a''rr :ry"di;a Je;.';;i.idir )

.^,

5?

? 6

rile / R€f number LABS 9723, 9?24 & 9725PLopsty s@ic6 (Acquisitiont

21 lune 2002

Ms Esther Allan81 Keiredy TerracePADDINGTON QLD 4059

Dear Fslher

Thank you for your letter of 27 May 2002 in which you highlight three main points of concem in relationto the proposed resumption by Hervey Bay City Council of parts of your property for augrnentation ofLenthails dam.

I apologise for the delay in responding.

In respect ofthe first point, it is true that the Council has the resumption ofparts of tkee (notjustone) ofyour properties. Th€ parts relate to Lot I 4 on LX972 and Lot I on LX148.

Apropos points 2 and 3, I advise that onadvefiing to that Corporation's e-mailissues would be resolved by the parti

Under the circumstances, inAllans, wsons would be held in abeyance pending its

conversition tlut,muni6atd{ td.you. there;efrarftd aiidanh ofwrinen advrce'-qfufia n.""'{dq";6ik " *,. i,t\"*.,/> _, \

't ,-=,r\J' ' .{

--} r -.'1'-j

,n*) .' (.',1..1"^**"- N'\ \ Leler 3

{"ncl lnafoqr.aiui**pecrarion lhat lhe resumprion"ryA:?"\-'ioJtt T vrd Council's applications for resumption in

x F"r ("\^. .,), \ ._/ \ \, !. ranocerrre

X, .r i h.- \ .. Lelet3{ \ .' '\ \ \\ cnr Mail & vLlturc st€e6i. I \ \\ woor'oonsabba oro 4102

1 \ $, Locled Bas 40 coorya.oo\ 1 ) Delivery cenue Qld 4'sl

Telephone+61 7 34062825

\ .'t. Website www.dnr.qld.sov.au

-;,.

, n r R, , Subsequentiy, by e-mail of 30 May 2002, in leply to this Department's inquiry of 30 May 2ff2. Wrde _

{ .,-

Bay Water advised that its offer to you was still unresolved, but indicated a positive outcome waspending.

In the circumstances, I shall again inquire of the corporation as to the present position regarding itsnegotiations with you.

Please contact me on Ph 34062826 ifyou have any enquiries regarding the contents of this lener.

Yours sincerely

)l/^r/4

Michael ShineSenior Property Olficer, Acquisltions

Pagez ol2