experience sharing & workshop on public-private partnership (ppp): preparing projects for market

Upload: the-outer-marker

Post on 08-Apr-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    1/71

    Fj~hyj Mhyxvdhywoc

    Ahbfw Ihllkcnhll

    Bhygd 9088

    Pyfphykcn Pyoafgzw moy

    Bhyefz

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    2/71

    9

    7 ef{ xvfwzkocw / 6 ghwfw

    ^dhz hyf zdf pyoafgz wgopf hcj yfxvkyfbfczw?

    Wzyhzfnkg Ghwf ghwf 8

    Ghc zdf pyoafgz if jflk}fyfj hw h PPP?

    Hmmoyjhiklkz{ ghwf 9, Gobbfygkhl ghwf 7 hcj Bhchnfbfcz ghwf :

    Wdovljzdf pyoafgz if jflk}fyfj hw h PPP?

    ]hlvf moy bocf{ " ghwf 6

    23Kzfyhzk}f pyogfww

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    3/71

    7

    Fthbplfw om nvkjhcgf

    Pvilkg Wfgzoy Ivwkcfww Ghwfwvwkcn zdf 6 Ghwf Bojfl1

    dzzp1//~~~#db"zyfhwvy{#no}#ve/jhzh_nyffciooe_ivwkcfww#dzb

    Zdf Ovzlkcf Ivwkcfww Ghwf, :Pw Bh{ 900:5

    ~~~#loghlphyzcfywdkpw#oyn#ve

    ChzkochlZyfhwvy{ PPP Bhcvhl Bojvlfw7 hcj :, Wovzd Hmykgh

    ChzkochlZyfhwvy{ 900:5 ~~~#ppp#no}#qh

    Pyhgzkzkocfyw Nvkjf, Phyzcfywdkpw ]kgzoykh 90065

    ~~~#phyzcfywdkpw#}kg#no}#hv

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    4/71

    :

    Pyogfww o}fy}kf~

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    5/71

    6

    Zdf Ovzlkcf Ivwkcfww Ghwf

    Hvjkfcgf

    Pyoafgz Zfhb hcj Iohyj

    Pyogvykcn Hvzdoykz{

    Gfczyhl No}fycbfcz

    Ozdfywzhefdoljfyw

    Dflpw zo fcwvyf yflf}hcz kwwvfw hyf hjjyfwwfj

    Dflpw zo fcwvyf kbphgz om kwwvfw oc fhgd ozdfy hyfhjjyfwwfj

    Ihwkw moy hppyo}hl

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    6/71

    =

    Wzyhzfnkg Ivwkcfww Ghwf " Fwzhilkwdkcn

    zdf cffj, wgopf hcj kckzkhl pyoafgz

    wflfgzkoc

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    7/71

    >

    Cffjw hchl{wkw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    8/71

    4

    Cffjw hchl{wkw 9

    Pyoafgz mkz ~kzd ~kjfywzyhzfnkg oiafgzk}fw

    Bkckbkwf ykwe omwknckmkghcz gdhcnfwlhzfy oc

    Gocwvlzhzkoc

    Kbphgz oc ozdfy pyoafgzw hcj wzhefdoljfyw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    9/71

    ;

    Hchl{wkw om Pyoafgz Opzkocw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    10/71

    80

    Opzkocw Hppyhkwhl

    Kjfczkmkghzkoc om zdf pyfmfyyfjpyoafgzopzkoc

    Vwf om h jo cozdkcnoyjo bkckbvb opzkoc zo hwwfwwkbphgz om gdhcnf

    Bfhwvyfj hnhkcwz jflk}fy{ omwfy}kgf oiafgzk}fw, hmmoyjhiklkz{ hcj wvwzhkchiklkz{ Hwwfwwbfcz om gowzw hcj ifcfmkzw

    Yolf om jkwgovcz yhzfw hcj opzkbkwb ikhw

    Gobikchzkoc om xvhlkzhzk}f hcj xvhczkzhzk}f mhgzoyw

    Kjfczkmkghzkoc om zdf pyfmfyyfjpyogvyfbfczyovzf

    ]hlvf moy bocf{

    Vwfmvl yfmfyfcgfw1

    Nyffc Iooe hppyhkwhl hcj f}hlvhzkockc Gfczyhl No}fycbfcz, DB Zyfhwvy{ 9005 ~~~#db"zyfhwvy{#no}#ve

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    11/71

    Pyoafgz No}fychcgf

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    12/71

    89

    ^dhz kw Pyoafgz No}fychcgf?

    Fcwvyf zdhz zdf ykndz pyoafgzw hyf jocf ~fll

    Lkcekcn pyogvykcn hvzdoykz{w oynhckqhzkochlno}fychcgf ~kzdpyoafgz bhchnfbfcz

    Go}fyw zdf ~dolf lkmf g{glf hcj ~kll f}ol}f o}fylkmf om pyoafgz

    Yfmfyfcgfw1

    Pyoafgz No}fychcgf " jyhmz nvkjhcgf cozf, DB Zyfhwvy{ 900>5 ~~~#db"zyfhwvy{#no}#ve

    Zdf Nooj No}fychcgf Wzhcjhyj moyPvilkg Wfy}kgfw, Kcjfpfcjfcz Gobbkwwkoc moy Nooj No}fychcgf, OPB hcj GKPMH 900:5

    ~~~#gkpmh#oyn#ve

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    13/71

    87

    Pvypowf om Pyoafgz No}fychcgf

    Lkce zdf pyoafgz zo zdf hvzdoykz{w pykoykzkfw

    Wfz ovz lkcfw om yfwpocwkiklkz{ hcj hggovczhiklkz{

    Fchilf wzhefdoljfyw zo bhchnf zdfkykczfyfwzw

    Yfpyfwfczhzk}f oyFtpfyz? $yfpyfwfczhzk}f ghcif bhchnfj zdyovnd wzhefdoljfyyovzf+

    Fcwvyf pvilkg wfgzoy yfxvkyfbfczw bfz kcnooj zkbf

    Wvppoyz zdf Pyoafgz Zfhb hcj fcwvyf ykndz wekllw hcj yfwovygfw

    Hggfww zo ifwz pyhgzkgf hcj hj}kgf

    Wovygf omcfvzyhl/ftzfychl gdhllfcnf

    Goczhgz ~kzd wvppl{ wkjf

    Yfwol}f kwwvfw

    Pyoafgz jkwglowvyf

    Mogvw occffjw moy fhgd wzhnf

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    14/71

    8:

    Fthbplf om Pyoafgz No}fychcgf Wzyvgzvyf

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    15/71

    86

    Pyoafgz No}fychcgf Pyoilfbw zo H}okj

    gocmvwkoc hiovz yolfw

    h phyz"zkbf Pyoafgz Bhchnfy

    myfxvfcz gdhcnfwkc zdf pyoafgz zfhb5

    kcwvmmkgkfcz yfwovygfw

    o}fy"yflkhcgf oc hj}kwfyw moy jfgkwkoc"bhekcn5

    kcwvmmkgkfcz jflfnhzfj po~fyw zo zdf Pyoafgz Bhchnfbfcz Nyovp

    kczfymfyfcgf myob ozdfyiojkfw ovzwkjf zdf no}fychcgf wzyvgzvyf

    pooy bhchnfbfcz om zdf jh{"zo"jh{ yfwovygfw, kcglvjkcn zdf ftzfychl

    hj}kwfyw#

    h Pyoafgz Iohyj kw zoo lhynf /coz hilf zo bffz hw yfxvkyfj zo zhef ef{

    jfgkwkocw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    16/71

    8=

    Kcjkghzk}f Zkbfzhilf

    Pvilkg wfgzoy omzfcvcjfyfwzkbhzfw zdf lfcnzd om zkbf zdhz h

    PPP pyogvyfbfcz ~kll zhef#

    Zkbfzhilf gocwkwzfcz ~kzd ftpfykfcgf kcwfgzoy#

    Jflh{wkc pyogvyfbfcz ghckbphgz hj}fywfl{ oc pyoafgz

    yfjvgfj wzhefdoljfy gobbkzbfcz, dkndfy gowzw jvf zo

    kcmlhzkoc

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    17/71

    Pyoafgz Pyfphyhzkoc

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    18/71

    84

    Pyoafgz Pyfphyhzkoc

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    19/71

    Pyoafgz Ovzpvzw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    20/71

    90

    Jfmkckcn pyoafgz ovzpvzw

    Jkwzkcnvkwdkcnifz~ffc ovzgobfw hcj ovzpvzw

    Yfjvgkcn yf"ommfcjkcnkwvlzkbhzf polkg{ ovzgobf# Pyo}kwkoc omlocn"zfyb

    wfy}kgfj pykwoc hggobbojhzkockw hckczfybfjkhzf ovzpvz#

    Jkwzkcnvkwdkcnifz~ffc ovzpvzw hcj kcpvzw1

    H pykwocivkljkcnkwcoz hc ovzpvz, h wvppl{ omwfy}kgfj hggobbojhzkockw5

    H dfhzkcn plhcz kwcoz hc ovzpvz, bhkczfchcgf om h bkckbvb hggfpzhilf

    zfbpfyhzvyf kw5

    Myhbkcn ovzpvz yfxvkyfbfczw1 jfwknc ovzpvzw, h}hklhiklkz{ wzhcjhyjw hcjpfymoybhcgf wzhcjhyjw

    Wzhcjhyjwwdovlj if WBHYZ Wpfgkmkg, Bfhwvyhilf, Hgdkf}hilf,

    Yfhlkwzkg hcj Zkbfl{

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    21/71

    98

    Ovzpvz Wpfgkmkghzkocw 9

    Yfxvkyfbfcz wpfgkmkfj kc zfybw omwfy}kgf ovzpvzw, yhzdfy zdhc phyzkgvlhy

    hwwfzw oywolvzkoc hllo~wwgopf moy pyk}hzf wfgzoykcco}hzkoc hcj

    gobpfzkzkoc#

    Yhcnf om oc"nokcnwfy}kgfwkcglvjfj kc zdf yfxvkyfbfcz jfmkcfj " ommfyw

    wgopf moy fmmkgkfcgkfw hcj kcco}hzkoc hcj gobpfzkzkoc#

    Wpfgkmkghzkoc pkzgdfj hz h yfhlkwzkg hcj hgdkf}hilf lf}fl pyk}hzf wfgzoy

    ~ovlj pykgf vp $oycoz ikj moy+ vcyfhlkwzkg wpfgkmkghzkocw#

    Kwwvfw1

    Jofw zdf Pyoafgz Zfhb vcjfywzhcj zdf pykcgkplfw?

    Gocwkwzfcg{ ~kzd1 Hmmoyjhiklkz{ bojfl, Ykwe hlloghzkoc, Gobbfygkhl

    Kczfyfwz, Ef{ zfybw hcj Gocjkzkocw, Wvkzhiklkz{ om Hj}kwoyw, Gobbkzbfcz

    om Wpocwoyw/Vwfyw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    22/71

    99

    Zfgdckghl Hwwfwwbfcz

    Hyf zdf ovzpvz yfxvkyfbfczw zfgdckghll{ mfhwkilf?

    Ftpfgzfj gowzw

    Hwwfwwbfcz omnyovcj gocjkzkocw fzg

    Jfwknc jf}flopbfcz

    Kcwvyhcgf yf}kf~

    Fc}kyocbfczhlkbphgz

    Wogkhlkbphgz

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    23/71

    Wzhzvzoy{ hcj Lfnhl

    Hwwfwwbfcz

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    24/71

    9:

    Wzhzvzoy{ hcj Lfnhl Yfxvkyfbfczw

    Ghc zdf pvilkg hvzdoykz{ fczfykczo zdf goczyhgz?

    Kw zdf pyopowfj pyogvyfbfcz pyogfwwlfnhl?

    Lfnhlwzhzvw om pyoafgz hwwfzw lhcj o~cfywdkp, lkhiklkzkfw, kcjfbckzkfw

    Hjahgfcgkfw hcj govczfy"phyzkfw

    Fcwvyf zdhz wzhzvzoy{ pyogfwwfw $fc}kyocbfczhl hwwfwwbfcz, plhcckcn,

    pvilkg fcxvky{, gocwvlzhzkoc+ dh}f iffc gocwkjfyfj hcj zdf zkbfzhilf

    kcgoypoyhzfw hc{ kbplkghzkocw zdhz gobplkhcgf zo wzhzvzoy{ pyogfww bh{

    fczhkl#

    Fcwvyf zdhz ykwe om gobplkhcgf ~kzd wzhzvzoy{ pyogfwwfwkw pyopfyl{

    wdhyfj ~kzd pyk}hzf wfgzoy

    Wzhzvzoy{ pyogfwwfw bvwz if gocwkwzfcz ~kzd1Zkbfzhilf, Ykwe Hlloghzkoc#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    25/71

    Hmmoyjhiklkz{

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    26/71

    9=

    Hmmoyjhiklkz{

    ^do ~kll ph{ moy zdf pyoafgz hcj do~?

    Zdf gowz zo jflk}fy zdf wpfgkmkfj yfxvkyfbfczw Goczyhgzoyw gdhynfw yfmlfgzfj kc h vckzhy{ gdhynf

    Ghpkzhl ftpfcjkzvyfw

    Opfyhzkcn ftpfcjkzvyf

    Gowz om ghpkzhl/jfiz

    Ykwew

    }w

    Zdf mvcjw/ hwwfzw h}hklhilf Mfhwkiklkz{ /^kllkcncfww omvwfyw zo ph{ Pyogvykcn Hvzdoykz{ ftkwzkcnivjnfzw

    Ozdfynyhczw/wovygfw

    Nvhyhczff mvcj h}hklhiklkz{

    Vp"myocz ghpkzhlnyhczw/ pvilkg hwwfzw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    27/71

    9>

    Hmmoyjhiklkz{ 9

    Jf}flopbfcz om h wdhjo~ ikj bojfl

    Pyoafgzfj PPP ghpkzhl/wfy}kgf ph{bfczwkjfczkmkfj gobpvzfj vckzhy{ gdhynf

    Wdhjo~ikj hwwvbpzkocw om ghpft, opft, lkmfg{glf fzg# Mvcjkcn hwwvbpzkocwkclkcf ~kzd bhyefz nfhykcn, yfzvycw, go}fy yhzkow

    Kjfczkm{ ivjnfzfj hcj 7yj phyz{ wovygfw omkcgobf

    Kcjfthzkoc hwwvbpzkocw

    Hmmoyjhilf o}fy zdf ~dolf lkmf om zdf goczyhgz, zhekcnkczo hggovcz hllwovygfw om

    yf}fcvf, hjjkzkochlkcgobf myob ghpkzhl yfgfkpzw oy zdkyj phyz{ kcgobf# Wfcwkzk}kz{ hchl{wkw gocjvgzfj zo jfzfybkcf ef{ }hykhilfw~dkgd vcjfypkc

    hmmoyjhiklkz{ powkzkoc#

    Hmmoyjhiklkz{ hchl{wkw hcj ykwew hcj wfcwkzk}kz{ hchl{wkw, hcj zdfkykbphgz oc

    ivjnfzw, hggfpzfj i{ ivjnfz doljfyw#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    28/71

    94

    Hmmoyjhiklkz{ 7

    Dkjjfc gowzw lhcj hgxvkwkzkoc, wvy}f{w, hvzdoykz{ gowzw

    Hwwfwwkcn mkwghlkbphgz

    Go}fykcn bvlzk"hccvhlivjnfz gobbkzbfczw

    Yflf}hcgf om hppyo}hlw

    Vwf omnvhyhczffw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    29/71

    Ykwe Hlloghzkoc

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    30/71

    70

    Z{pfw om Ykwe

    Plhcckcn YkweMhklvyf zo oizhkc plhcckcn pfybkwwkoc, yfwvlzkcn kc zfybkchzkoc om zdf pyoafgz oy

    wknckmkghcz }hykhzkoc zo zdf wfy}kgf wolvzkoc#

    Jfwknc Ykwe

    Jfwknc om zdf gdowfc wolvzkoc jofw coz hllo~ zdf ovzpvz yfxvkyfbfczw zo if bfz,

    lfhjkcn zo yf}kwkocw kc jfwknc, gdhcnfw zo wpfgkmkghzkoc oy zfybkchzkoc om pyoafgz#

    Gocwzyvgzkoc Ykwe

    Ykwew hwwogkhzfj ~kzd zdf gocwzyvgzkoc pdhwf, wvgd hw lhzfcz oy gocwzyvgzkoc jfmfgzw,hygdhfolonkghl jkwgo}fykfw oy vcmoyfwffc nyovcj gocjkzkocw, lfhjkcn zo gocwzyvgzkocjflh{w hcj gowz o}fyyvcw#

    Jfbhcj YkweYkwe om mlvgzvhzkocw kc locn zfyb jfbhcj moy zdf wfy}kgf, lfhjkcn zo gdhcnfw zowpfgkmkghzkoc oy zfybkchzkoc om pyoafgz#

    Pfymoyb

    hcgf Ykwe

    Ykwe omcoz hgdkf}kcn pfymoybhcgf zhynfzw wfz ovz kc zdf ovzpvz wpfgkmkghzkoc, lfhjkcn zo

    pooy xvhlkz{ wfy}kgf zo vwfyw#

    Zfgdcolon{hcj

    Oiwolfwgfcgf Ykwe

    Ykwe zdhz gdhcnfw zo zfgdcolon{ yfcjfy pyopowfj wolvzkoc oiwolfzf, lfhjkcn zoftpfcwk}f gdhcnfw zo jfwknc/wgopf#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    31/71

    78

    Z{pfw om Ykwe 9

    Opfyhzkcn YkweYkwe om dkndfy zdhc ftpfgzfj opfyhzkcn gowzw, bhekcn kz boyf gowzl{ zo jflk}fywfy}kgfw

    zo wzhzfj wzhcjhyj#

    ZdkyjPhyz{ Kcgobf

    Ykwe

    Ykwe om lo~fy zdhc ftpfgzfj kcgobf myob zdkyj phyz{ vwfyw, bhekcn kz boyf gowzl{ zo

    jflk}fywfy}kgfw zo wzhzfj wzhcjhyj#

    Yfwkjvhl ]hlvf YkweYkwe om mlvgzvhzkocw kc }hlvf om hwwfzw hwwogkhzfj ~kzd zdf wfy}kgf $km zyhcwmfyyfj+ hz fcjom goczyhgz, bhekcn goczyhgz boyf ftpfcwk}f o}fyhll#

    Yfnvlhzoy{ YkweYkwe om gdhcnfw zo lfnkwlhzkoc oy yfnvlhzkocw, bhekcn kz boyf jkmmkgvlz oy boyf ftpfcwk}fzo jflk}fywfy}kgfw zo wzhzfj wpfgkmkghzkoc#

    Mkchcgkcn Ykwe

    Ykwe omkchiklkz{ zo oizhkc mkchcgf zo m vcj zdf pyoafgz, oy mlvgzvhzkocw kc zdf gowz om m vcjw

    oy zdf zfybw om mkchcgkcn hczkgkphzfj hz zdf ovzwfz bhekcn kz gowzlkfy zo pyo}kjf zdfwfy}kgf#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    32/71

    79

    Ykwe Hlloghzkoc

    ^do?1

    vwfyw

    kc}fwzoyw " zdf pyk}hzf"wfgzoy zhtph{fyw " zdyovnd zdf no}fycbfcz

    Hlloghzf ykwe zo phyz{ ifwz hilf zo1

    goczyolkzw oggvyyfcgf hcj gocwfxvfcgfw

    hwwfwwkcmoybhzkoc hiovz zdf lkeflkdooj om zdf ykwe ~kzdkc goczftz om~dhz kwlkefl{ zo if gobbfygkhll{ hggfpzhilf zo zdf

    pyk}hzf"wfgzoy#

    Ykwe jofwcoz jkwhppfhyzdyovnd goczyhgzvhlwzyvgzvykcn

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    33/71

    77

    Ykwe Hlloghzkoc Kwwvfw

    H ykwe yfnkwzfydhwiffc pyfphyfj, kjfczkm{kcn hll zdf ykwew hwwogkhzfj

    ~kzd zdf wgdfbf, hcj bhekcn h pyflkbkchy{ ykwe hlloghzkoc#

    Zdf pyflkbkchy{ hlloghzkoc, hw h bkckbvb, zyhcwmfyw zdf pykcgkphl ykwewhwwogkhzfj ~kzd jfwknc, ivklj, mkchcgf hcj opfyhzkoc om zdf mhgklkzkfw zo zdf

    pyk}hzf phyz{#

    Gocwkjfy zdf hlloghzkoc om ykwew hwwogkhzfj ~kzd jfbhcj, yfwkjvhl }hlvfw,

    zfgdcolon{ hcj oiwolfwgfcgf hcj gdhcnfwkclfnkwlhzkoc oy yfnvlhzkoc#

    Fcwvyf gocwkwzfcg{ ~kzd1 Hmmoyjhiklkz{ bojfl, Gobbfygkhlkczfyfwz, Ef{zfybw hcj Gocjkzkocw, Ovzpvz Wpfgkmkghzkoc#

    Cozf1 zdfyf ~kll hlwo if hlloghzkoc~kzdkc zdf pyk}hzf wfgzoy#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    34/71

    7:

    Ykwe Bkzknhzkoc hcj Bockzoykcn

    Ykwe Bkzknhzkoc

    yfjvgf zdf lkeflkdooj om ykwew hcj kzw gocwfxvfcgfw moy zdf ykwe zhefy

    kbplkghzkocw moy pyoafgz wgopf

    Ykwe bockzoykcn

    vwf om h ykwe bhchnfbfcz plhc, lkcefj zo zdf ykwe yfnkwzfy

    vpjhzfj o}fy pyoafgz lkmf

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    35/71

    Hwwfwwkcn Gobbfygkhl

    Kczfyfwz

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    36/71

    7=

    Z{pkghl Pyoafgz Mfhwkiklkz{ Kwwvfw

    Pykgkcn ykwew " ~hzfy

    Jfbhcj ykwew " yohj, yhkl

    Yfdhiklkzhzkoc " ~hzfy, po~fy, hggobbojhzkoc

    Fc}kyocbfczhl " zyhcwpoyz, po~fy

    Kczfymhgf " po~fy, hggobbojhzkoc

    Wkqf

    Loghzkoc/ gobplftkz{ Moyfknc gvyyfcg{

    Zfgdcolon{

    ^oyemoygf

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    37/71

    7>

    Kcjkghzkoc om Gobbfygkhl Kczfyfwz

    Ghphgkz{ omikjjkcn bhyefz

    F}kjfcgf omihcehilf goczyhgz zfybw hcj pyoafgz

    wpfgkmkghzkoc

    Gfyzhkcz{ omkcgobf wzyfhb zo bffz goczyhgz ph{bfczw

    7yj phyz{ kcgobf oppoyzvckzkfw

    Hjavwz wgopf kmcfgfwwhy{

    F}kjfcgf om gobbfygkhlkczfyfwz zdyovnd bhyefz wovcjkcn

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    38/71

    74

    Zkpw moy wvggfwwmvl bhyefz"wovcjkcn

    Fcwvyf zdhz1 Kclkcf ~kzd hc{ yflf}hcz pyogvyfbfcz yvlfw Nk}f ifwz hggovcz om zdf pvilkg hvzdoykz{ Gocwkjfy hz hc fhyl{ wzhnf, ivz coz zoo fhyl{

    Pyfphyf zdf ihgenyovcj jogvbfczhzkoc Glfhy hiovz zdf kwwvfw zo if jkwgvwwfj ~kzd zdf bhyefz Glfhy hiovz zdf pyogfww zo wflfgz oynhckwhzkocw Gocwkjfyvwf om h ocf"zo"ocf moybhz ivz co wpfgkhl zyfhzbfcz kc hc{ wviwfxvfcz

    pyogvyfbfcz Kc}ol}f boyf zdhc ocf kcjk}kjvhl oc zdf pvilkg wfgzoywkjf, if gocwkwzfcz hcj fcwvyf

    bffzkcnw hyf jogvbfczfj

    H}okj1 ^hwzkcn zkbf ~kzd whlfw pkzgdfw/wdhpkcn zdf pyoafgz zo wvkz h pyopowhl vwf om zdkyj

    phyzkfw? Yfwzykgzkcnwgopf1 hkb zo wflfgz opfyhzoyw hcj goczyhgzoyw fzg# Mogvwkcn oc ovzgobfw yhzdfy zdhc bfhcw om hgdkf}f zdfb Vwkcnpyogvyfbfcz lhcnvhnf wvgd hwikjjfyw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    39/71

    7;

    Ihcehiklkz{

    Kbpoyzhcgf om ghwdmlo~ o}fy hwwfzw

    Lkbkzfj yfgovywf mkchcgf }fywvw goypoyhzf mkchcgf

    Yolf omlfcjfywkc jvf jklknfcgf

    Jhcnfyw omnvhyhczffw

    Gvyyfcg{ ykwew

    Zfcoy hcj hmmoyjhiklkz{

    Yolf om fxvkz{

    Yolf om WP]w hcj hlloghzkoc om ykwe~kzdkc zdf pyk}hzf wfgzoy

    Wzfp"kc

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    40/71

    :0

    Z{pkghl PPP Goczyhgzvhl Wzyvgzvyf

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    41/71

    :8

    Z{pkghl Pyoafgz Lfcjfy Gocgfycw

    gfyzhkcz{ om zdf pyoafgz ghwd mlo~w zo bffz jfiz wfy}kgf yfxvkyfbfczw5

    ihcehiklkz{ om pvilkg"wfgzoy oilknhzkocw5

    fmmfgzk}fcfww hcj fcmoygfhiklkz{ omPPP goczyhgz hcj yflhzfj hnyffbfczw5

    ykndzw zo wzfp"kckc zdf f}fcz om pyoafgz mhklvyf hcj h}hklhiklkz{ om hlzfychzk}f

    goczyhgzoyw5

    hiklkz{ om goczyhgzoyw zo pfymoyb/xvhlkz{ om zdfky bhchnfbfcz5

    ihcehiklkz{ om goczyhgzoyw hcj xvhlkz{ om goczyhgzoynvhyhczffw5 ykwew zdhz hyf vcjfywzooj, goczyollhilf, mkckzf hcj hppyopykhzfl{ hlloghzfj5

    yfpvzhzkoc $fc}kyocbfczhl, wogkhl+5

    fmmfgzk}fcfww omkcwvyhcgf go}fy~dfyf cffjfj#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    42/71

    :9

    Z{pkghl Goczyhgzoy hcj Kc}fwzoy Gocgfycw

    gowz/zkbf/xvhlkz{ om zdf PPPikj pyogfww hyf bhaoy hppyo}hlwwzkllh~hkzfj?

    ~dhz ikj f}hlvhzkoc gykzfykh ~kllif vwfj?

    mhkycfww om gobpfzkzkoc wviafgzk}f vwf om f}hlvhzkoc gykzfykh

    jfhlkcn~kzd glhykmkghzkocw mhkyl{

    lfhehnf omnooj kjfhw

    xvhlkz{ om zdf pvilkg"wfgzoy pyoafgz zfhb hcj zdfky hj}kwfyw5

    wfgvykz{ om zdf pyoafgz kcgobf wzyfhb $jfbhcj, ihcehiklkz{ om pvilkg"wfgzoy oilknhzkocw+5

    ~dhz zdf{ ~kllif ftpfgzfj zo jflk}fy hcj do~ zdfky pfymoybhcgf ~kllifbfhwvyfj5

    h}hklhiklkz{ hcj gowz omlocn"zfyb jfiz mvcjkcn5

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    43/71

    :7

    Z{pkghl Goczyhgzoy hcj Kc}fwzoy Gocgfycw 9

    $moy mkchcgkhlkc}fwzoyw+ fmmfgzk}fcfww om zdf gocwzyvgzkoc goczyhgzoy hcjopfyhzoy zo jflk}fy zdf wfy}kgf hcj bhchnf zo zkbf hcj ivjnfz5

    wzhzvw hcj h}hklhiklkz{ om goccfgzkcnkcmyhwzyvgzvyf / h}hklhiklkz{ omkcpvzw5

    fmmfgzk}fcfww hcj fcmoygfhiklkz{ om zdf PPP goczyhgz hcj yflhzfjhnyffbfczw5

    pozfczkhl moyfknc"ftgdhcnf ykwew5

    zdf ~kjfy opfyhzkcn fc}kyocbfcz moy pyk}hzf ghpkzhl5

    zdf hlloghzkoc om ykwewiozd ifz~ffc zdf pvilkg hcj pyk}hzf wfgzoyw

    hlloghzkoc om ykwewifz~ffc zdf pyk}hzf phyzkfw5 yfzvycw gobbfcwvyhzf ~kzd zdf ykwew zdf{ hyf hwefj zo hwwvbf5

    do~ fmmfgzk}fl{ zdf pvilkg"wfgzoy~kll bhchnf zdf goczyhgz hcj zhefjfgkwkocw5

    oppoyzvckzkfw zo yfmkchcgf zdf jfiz oywfll zdfkykc}fwzbfcz#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    44/71

    ::

    Fcnhnkcn ~kzd zdf Pyk}hzf Wfgzoy1 Gobbfygkhl Wzyhzfn{

    Bhchnf zdf PMK/PPPwvppl{ bhyefz $zo nfcfyhzf kczfyfwz,

    vcjfywzhcj gocwzyhkczw, mhbklkhykwf ~kzd pyogvyfbfcz

    pyogfww hcj bhchnf ftpfgzhzkocw+ Jfzfybkcf hgdkf}hilf wdhyf om~dolf"lkmf pyoafgz ykwew

    Jfzfybkcf zdf wgopf om zdf gobpfzkzkoc

    Jfzfybkcf zdf cvbify om gobpfzkzoyw

    Jfwknc zdf chzvyf om zdf gobpfzkzkoc $pyogfww hcj zkbkcn+

    Jfzfybkcf zdf ikjjfy yfxvkyfbfcz

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    45/71

    :6

    Yfghp

    Ykwe

    Kjfczkmkghzkoc

    Ihcehiklkz{

    Pyoafgz Hnyffbfczw

    Ovzpvz

    yfxvkyfbfczw

    Ykwe hlloghzkoc

    hcj bkzknhzkoc

    Ykwe bockzoykcn

    hcj yf}kf~

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    46/71

    Jf}flopkcn Pyoafgz Goczyhgzwhcj Kcmoybhzkoc

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    47/71

    :>

    Jf}flopkcn zdf Pyoafgz Goczyhgz

    Km zdf ykwew jo kc mhgz hykwf jvykcn zdf pyoafgz lkmf, iozd phyzkfw hyf hnyffj oc~dhz

    zo jo hiovz zdfb

    Ovzlkcf goczyhgz pyfphyfj

    Ovzpvzw yfmlfgzfj kc ovzpvz wpfgkmkghzkoc hcj ph{bfcz bfgdhckwb

    Ihcehiklkz{ om goczyhgzvhl zfybwcffjw zo if fwzhilkwdfj fhyl{ oc, ozdfy~kwf ikjjfyw~kll

    ~hwzf zkbf hcj bocf{#

    Pyopowfj ph{bfcz bfgdhckwb zdhz yfmlfgzw ykwe hlloghzkoc

    Vcyfhlkwzkg oy o}fyl{ pfchlkwzkg ph{bfcz bfgdhckwb bh{ coz if hggfpzfj i{

    mvcjfyw/goczyhgzoyw, lfhjkcn zo jflh{wkccfnozkhzkoc hcj/oy zfybkchzkoc#

    Vwf omihcehilf wzhcjhyj goczyhgz zfybw

    Ef{ zfybw hcj gocjkzkocw bvwz if gocwkwzfcz ~kzd1Ykwe Hlloghzkoc, Hmmoyjhiklkz{,

    Ovzpvz Wpfgkmkghzkoc, Ihcehiklkz{

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    48/71

    :4

    Pyoafgz Kcmoybhzkoc Bfboyhcjvb

    Pyoafgz Wpocwoy

    jfzhklw oc zdf pvilkg"wfgzoy phyzkfwkc}ol}fj kc zdf pyoafgz ]KWKILFLFHJFYWDKP

    MYOB ZOP OMZDF WDOP5

    do~ zdf pvilkg"wfgzoy zfhb kw oynhckqfj zo bhchnf zdf pyogvyfbfcz pyogfww5 jfzhklw om pvilkg"wfgzoy hj}kwfyw#

    Pyoafgz kcmoybhzkoc

    pyoafgz yhzkochlf hcj wzyhzfnkg oiafgzk}fw5

    ovzlkcf om pyoafgz yfxvkyfbfczwwgopf, wfy}kgfw, wkqf, loghzkoc, pozfczkhl ghpkzhl

    kc}fwzbfcz hcj zdfyfmoyf om zdf ykwew ftpfgzfj zo if ioycf i{ zdf pyk}hzf wfgzoy5

    hczkgkphzfj ph{bfcz bfgdhckwb $vwfy mffw, h}hklhiklkz{ mffw oy h gobikchzkoc om zdfwf+5

    wzhzvw om hll pyoafgz hppyo}hlw, plhcckcn gocwfczw, fc}kyocbfczhl hwwfwwbfczw5

    wzhzvw om pvilkg gocwvlzhzkoc5

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    49/71

    :;

    Pyoafgz Kcmoybhzkoc Bfboyhcjvb 9

    Pyoafgz Kcmoybhzkoc gocz##

    powwkil{ hc ovzlkcf om bojfl jfwkncw hcj jfwknc yfxvkyfbfczw5

    kcmoybhzkoc oc fchilkcn~oyew, wzhzvw hcj h}hklhiklkz{ omkcmyhwzyvgzvyf wfy}kgfwvpoc

    ~dkgd zdf pyoafgz bh{ jfpfcj5 pozfczkhl mvcjkcnwovygfw $kcglvjkcn pozfczkhl jf}flopbfcz ihce mkchcgf+#

    Pyopowfj pyogvyfbfcz pyogfww

    wzhnfw hcj hczkgkphzfj zkbfzhilf $zdkw bkndz if jkgzhzfj i{ lfnkwlhzkoc+5

    jfzhklw om hc{ pyopowfj ikjjfyw gocmfyfcgf5

    ovzlkcf om~dhz ~kllif yfxvkyfj omikjjfyw hz fhgd wzhnf5 ovzlkcf omkcmoybhzkoc zdhz ~kllif yflfhwfj hz fhgd wzhnf5

    ovzlkcf om zdf f}hlvhzkoc hz fhgd wzhnf#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    50/71

    Wzhefdoljfyw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    51/71

    68

    Kjfczkm{kcn Wzhefdoljfyw

    Zdowf ~kzd hckczfyfwz oywzhef kc zdf pyoafgz1

    Pyogvykcn hvzdoykz{ hcj polkg{ wzhefdoljfyw

    Fcj vwfyw Pyoafgz o~cfy

    Pyoafgz jflk}fy{ zfhb

    Wvppl{ wkjf

    Zdkyj phyz{ mvcjfyw

    Hvjkz

    Vpjhzfj lkwz hcj yolf omwzhefdoljfyw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    52/71

    69

    Bhchnkcn Wzhefdoljfyw

    Jflk}fyhiklkz{ Gocwkjfyhzkocw1

    Jfbocwzyhzf wvppoyz myob hllef{ wpocwoyw hcj, ~dfyf

    hppyopykhzf, vwfyw

    Gocwvlzhzkoc~kzd hll ozdfywzhefdoljfyw

    Vwf omwzhefdoljfyiohyjw

    Gocwkwzfcg{ ifz~ffcwzhefdoljfywvppoyz hcj hmmoyjhiklkz{

    gobbkzbfczw

    Fmmfgzk}f gobbvckghzkocwwzyhzfn{ yf pyonyfww/ef{ jfgkwkocw

    Gocwvlz ifmoyf coz hmzfy jfgkwkocw zhefc(

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    53/71

    ]hlvf moy Bocf{

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    54/71

    6:

    ]hlvf moy Bocf{

    ]mB looew hz zdf gowzw hcj ykwew o}fy zdf lkmf zkbf om zdf

    jkmmfyfcz pyoafgz ovzpvz jflk}fy{ opzkocw

    Vcjfypkcw ykwe hlloghzkoc

    Yflf}hcz zo vwf om pvilkg yfwovygfw

    Yflf}hcz zo gdokgf om pyogvyfbfcz yovzf

    Xvhczkzhzk}f hppyohgdfw f#n# pvilkg wfgzoy gobphyhzoy

    Xvhlkzhzk}f hppyohgdfw f#n# gobpfzkzkoc

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    55/71

    Hppokczkcn hcj BhchnkcnHj}kwoyw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    56/71

    6=

    Hppokczkcn hcj Bhchnkcn Hj}kwfyw

    ~dfc zo vwf hj}kwfyw

    glhykz{ om yfxvkyfbfczw hcj yolfw

    gdfhpfwz hj}kgf kwcoz cfgfwwhykl{ zdf ifwz hj}kgf

    yolf omPPPvckzw/ pyoafgz jf}flopbfcz mvcjw

    Vwfmvl yfmfyfcgfw1

    Zoolekz1 H nvkjf moy dkykcn hcj bhchnkcn hj}kwoyw moy pyk}hzf phyzkgkphzkockckcmyhwzyvgzvyf, PPKHM5 ~~~#ppkhm#oyn

    ZfgdckghlCozf 71Do~ zo Hppokcz hcj Bhchnf Hj}kwfyw zo PMKPyoafgzw, DB Zyfhwvy{5 ~~~#db"zyfhwvy{#no}#ve

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    57/71

    6>

    Hppokczkcn hcj Bhchnkcn Hj}kwfyw 9

    jfpzd hcj yflf}hcgf om ftpfyzkwf5

    glfhyvcjfywzhcjkcn om zdf pyoafgz yfxvkyfbfcz hcj pyogfww5

    h}hklhiklkz{ om zdf kcjk}kjvhlw

    vwf om~fkndzkcn

    vwf om~ykzzfcwvibkwwkocw hcj kczfy}kf~w

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    58/71

    64

    Hppokczkcn hcj Bhchnkcn Hj}kwfyw 7

    ph{bfcz om hj}kwfyw

    pyow hcj gocw omlfhj hj}kwfywkbphgz oc pyoafgz gyfjkiklkz{

    ~kllkcncfww om hj}kwfyw zo wdhyf lfwwocw hcj hppyohgdfw,

    hyyhcnfbfczw moy pfykojkg yf}kf~ om pfymoybhcgf om hj}kwfyw

    wzyocnPyoafgz Bhchnfy zo bhchnf ftzfychl hj}kwfyw

    ~kllkcncfww om hj}kwfyw zo wknc"omm hz ef{ wzhnfw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    59/71

    6;

    Lfnhl Hj}kwfy Wvppoyz

    hwwkwz pvilkg hvzdoykz{ kw hwwfwwkcn zdf yfxvkwkzf po~fyw hcj lfnhl mfhwkiklkz{ om zdf

    PPP pyoafgz5

    jf}flop zdf PPP goczyhgz jogvbfczhzkoc moy zdf pyoafgz5

    jf}flop lfnhl hwpfgzw om pyoafgz ikj jogvbfczw

    hchl{wkw om pyoafgz hwwfzw, lhcj o~cfywdkp, kczfy"mhgf hnyffbfczw hcj ozdfywkzf

    yflhzfj kwwvfw5

    pyfphyf lfnhl hcj goczyhgzvhlwvibkwwkoc yfxvkyfbfczw5

    fcwvyf ikjw bffz zdf lfnhl hcj goczyhgzvhlwvibkwwkoc yfxvkyfbfczw5

    f}hlvhzf hcj hj}kwf oc hll pyogfwwfw hcj lfnhl hcj goczyhgzvhlwolvzkocw

    zdyovndovz zdf pyogvyfbfcz5

    vcjfyzhef lfnhl jvf jklknfcgf ocikjw5

    wvppoyz kc glhykmkghzkoc hcj mkcf"zvckcn omlfnhl hwpfgzw#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    60/71

    =0

    Zfgdckghl Hj}kwfy Wvppoyz

    wvppoyz jf}flopbfcz, mfhwkiklkz{ hcj gowzkcn om zdf pyoafgz

    wkzf gocjkzkoc, plhcckcn hcj jfwknc~oye jyhmz pyoafgz ovzpvzyfxvkyfbfczw hcj wpfgkmkghzkocw5

    jf}flop hc{ ph{bfcz bfgdhckwbw~kzd zdf mkchcgkhlhj}kwfyw5

    fcwvykcn zfgdckghl hwpfgzw om zdf pyoafgz bffz zdf pyoafgzoiafgzk}fw5

    f}hlvhzf hcj hj}kwf oc hll zfgdckghlwolvzkocw zdyovndovz zdfpyogvyfbfcz5

    wgyvzkckwf gowzw om zdf ikjjfywwolvzkocw

    zfgdckghl jvf jklknfcgf ocikjjfywwolvzkocw5

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    61/71

    =8

    Mkchcgkhl Hj}kwfy Wvppoyz

    wvppoyz jf}flopbfcz om zdf mkchcgkhl hwpfgzw omivwkcfww ghwf

    hppyhkwhl om opzkocw hcj mkchcgkhl bojfllkcn

    lkhkwf ~kzd zdf JMKw5

    jf}flop pyoafgz ph{bfcz bfgdhckwbw~kzd zdf zfgdckghl hj}kwfyw5

    pyfphyf zdf mkchcgkhlikj wvibkwwkoc yfxvkyfbfczw5

    fcwvyf hll mkchcgkhl hwpfgzw om zdf ikjjfywwolvzkocw bffz zdf mkchcgkhlikj

    wvibkwwkoc yfxvkyfbfczw5

    opzkbkwf hcj wgyvzkckwf zdf mkchcgkhl bojflwwvibkzzfj i{ ikjjfyw5

    f}hlvhzf hcj hj}kwf oc hll mkchcgkhl pyopowhlw

    yf}kf~ mvcjkcn hcj zhthzkoc hwpfgzw omwolvzkocw5

    vcjfyzhef mkchcgkhl jvf jklknfcgf ocikj wvibkwwkocw5

    wvppoyz glhykmkghzkoc hcj mkcf"zvckcn om mkchcgkhl hcj gobbfygkhlkwwvfw#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    62/71

    Cftz Wzfpw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    63/71

    =7

    Pyfphykcn moy zdf Cftz Pdhwf

    Ikjjkcn pdhwf zkbfzhilf hcj wzyhzfn{ hnyffj

    Pyoafgz kcmoybhzkoc jogvbfczw pyfphyfj

    F}hlvhzkoc gykzfykh fwzhilkwdfj

    Pyoafgz zfhb, hj}kwfyw, ivjnfzw hcj no}fychcgf kc plhgf

    Jf}flopbfcz om h ykwe yfnkwzfy

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    64/71

    =:

    Fcnhnkcn ~kzd zdf Pyk}hzf Wfgzoy1 Jfgkjkcn Zhgzkgw

    Yflf}hcz pyogvyfbfcz lh~

    Zkbfzhilf

    Kcmoybhzkoc mlo~

    Do~ bhc{ wzhnfw omwflfgzkoc hyf mfhwkilf/hppyopykhzf?

    Pyfxvhlkmkghzkoc

    Xvhczkz{ omkcmoybhzkoc

    Gykzfykh

    Cvbify

    Ikj iocjw?

    Yfxvfwz moyPyopowhl pdhwf

    ^dfc zo wflfgz h pyfmfyyfj ikjjfy?

    hmzfy mvll hcj mkchlikjw

    gobplfzkoc om jkwgvwwkoc oc gobbfygkhl zfybw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    65/71

    =6

    Ozdfy Pozfczkhl Kwwvfw

    Hggovczkcn hcj mkwghl zyfhzbfcz/kbphgz

    Jfwknc xvhlkz{

    Fbplo{ff zyhcwmfykwwvfw

    Hyyhcnfbfczw moy goczyhgz bockzoykcn

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    66/71

    ==

    Gobboc Bkwzhefw

    lhge om glhykz{ i{ zdf pvilkg hvzdoykz{ om~dhz kz ~hczw myob zdf

    pyoafgz / hbiknvovwwpfgkmkghzkocw5

    lhge om pyoafgz o~cfywdkp hcj lfhjfywdkp5

    vcjfy"yfwovygfj pyoafgz zfhbw5

    wflfgzkcn hj}kwfyw oc zdf ihwkw om gowz yhzdfy zdhc xvhlkz{

    hcj ftpfykfcgf5

    lhge om fmmfgzk}f fcnhnfbfcz ~kzd wzhefdoljfyw5

    lhge omvcjfywzhcjkcn om hcj goczhgz ~kzd zdf pyk}hzf wfgzoy

    hz wfckoylf}flw hcj pooyl{"gocjvgzfj bhyefz wovcjkcn5

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    67/71

    =>

    Gobboc Bkwzhefw 9

    ftpfgzkcn zdf pyk}hzf wfgzoy zo jfhl~kzd kwwvfwwvgd hwlhcj

    hgxvkwkzkoc zdhz hyf ifzzfy dhcjlfj i{ zdf pvilkg wfgzoy5

    opzkbkwb " oclhcj hgxvkwkzkockwwvfw, wdhjo~ikj bojfl

    hwwvbpzkocw5

    wvi"wzhcjhyj mkchcgkhl bojflw pyf}fczkcn mkchcgkhl glowf5

    lhge om glhykz{ hiovz zdf pvilkg hvzdoykz{wlfnhl po~fyw zo fczfykczo

    zdf PPP goczyhgz5

    gocmlkgz ifz~ffc zdf pyogvyfbfcz pyogfww hcj pyogvyfbfczyfnvlhzkocw5

    o}fy"hbikzkovw pyoafgz pyfphyhzkoc zkbfzhilfw5

    yflfhwkcn pyoafgz kcmoybhzkoc zdhz kwkcgobplfzf#

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    68/71

    =4

    Gdfgelkwz

    Glhykz{ om yfxvkyfbfczw hcj wgopf

    Ykwe hlloghzkoc

    Kcjkghzkoc om gobbfygkhlkczfyfwz

    Pyoafgz kcmoybhzkoc hcj goczyhgz zfybw pyfphyfj Hmmoyjhiklkz{

    Ftpfgzfj hggovczkcn zyfhzbfcz

    Pyoafgz zfhb/pyogfwwfw

    Wvkzhiklkz{ om pyopowfj hj}kwfyw

    Kcjkghzk}f zkbfzhilf

    ]hlvf moy bocf{

    Gobbkzbfcz omwzhefdoljfyw/vwfyw

    Hppyo}hlw/ hppyopykhzf po~fyw gocmkybfj

    Gobbkzbfcz omwpocwoyw/vwfyw

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    69/71

    =;

    Gdfgelkwz jfzhkl $8/9+

    Glhykz{ om yfxvkyfbfczw Hyf zdf wgopf, yfxvkyfbfcz hcj zfyb om zdf pyoafgz glfhy hcj wzhilf? Dh}f zdf{ iffc hppyo}fj?

    Ykwe hlloghzkoc Dh}f zdf pyoafgz ykwewiffc mvll{ kjfczkmkfj hcj zdfky pozfczkhl hlloghzkoc hwwfwwfj?

    Ef{ zfybw hcj gocjkzkocw Dhw zdf jyhmz PPP goczyhgz iffc pyfphyfj yfmlfgzkcn zdf pyoafgz yfxvkyfbfczw, pyopowfj ykwe hlloghzkoc hcj ph{bfcz

    bfgdhckwb?

    Dh}f ftzfychl pyoafgz kczfymhgf kwwvfw, hnyffbfczw, zfybw hcj gocjkzkocwiffckjfczkmkfj hcj hwwfwwfj?

    Kcjkghzkoc om gobbfygkhl kczfyfwz

    Kwzdfyf f}kjfcgf om goczyhgzoy, lfcjfy hcj kc}fwzoy bhyefz kczfyfwz zo avwzkm{ lhvcgdkcn zdf pyoafgz oc zdf pyopowfj

    zfybw?

    Dhw h pyoafgz bhyefzkcnwzyhzfn{ hcj pyowpfgzk}f ikjjfywlkwz iffc jyh~cvp?

    ^dhz hyf zdf ftpfgzfj h}hklhiklkz{ hcj zfybw om fxvkz{ hcj jfiz mkchcgf?

    Dh}f zdf JMKwiffc hppyohgdfj?

    Pyoafgz kcmoybhzkoc

    ^dhz plhcw ftkwz zo pvilkgkwf zdf lhvcgd om zdf pyoafgz zo pozfczkhlikjjfyw?

    Dhw h pyoafgz kcmoybhzkoc bfboyhcjvb iffc pyfphyfj i{ zdf pyoafgz zfhb?

    Dh}f zdf ikjjfy xvhlkmkghzkoc hcj ikj f}hlvhzkoc gykzfykh iffc jf}flopfj?

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    70/71

    >0

    Gdfgelkwz jfzhkl $9/9+

    Hmmoyjhiklkz{ Kwzdf pyoafgz wgopf mvll{ hmmoyjhilf?

    Hyf zdf vwfy zhykmmw yfhlkwzkg/hyf ivjnfzw hcj hppyo}hlwkc plhgf moy hc{ pvilkg"wfgzoy ph{bfcz $oy hwwfz pyo}kwkoc+

    oilknhzkocw?

    Kwzdf ftpfgzfj hggovczkcn zyfhzbfcz glfhy?

    Kcjkghzk}f zkbfzhilf Kwh yfhlkwzkg pyogvyfbfcz zkbfzhilf kc plhgf moy zdf pyogvyfbfcz pdhwf?

    Pyoafgz zfhb/pyogfwwfw Kwh gyfjkilf hcj ~fll yfwovygfj zfhb kc plhgf zo bhchnf zdf pyogvyfbfcz pdhwf hcj hc fmmfgzk}f ikj f}hlvhzkoc

    wzyhzfn{ hnyffj?

    Hyf pyoafgz no}fychcgf wzyvgzvyfw hcj pyogfwwfwkc plhgf zo fcwvyf zkbfl{ hcj fmmfgzk}f jfgkwkoc"bhekcn?

    Hyf gyfjkilf hcj ftpfykfcgfj hj}kwfyw hppokczfj?

    Dhw zdf hppyopykhzf hwwfwwbfcz if ghyykfj ovz zo jfbocwzyhzf zdhz zdf pyopowfj hppyohgd kw ftpfgzfj zo bffz hc{

    }hlvf moy bocf{ gykzfykh $zo zdf ftzfcz yfxvkyfj i{ polkg{+?

    Gobbkzbfcz om wzhefdoljfyw/vwfyw Dh}f hll yflf}hcz wzhefdoljfywiffckjfczkmkfj, hyf zdf{ gobbkzzfj zo zdf pyoafgz, hcj hyf hyyhcnfbfczwkc plhgf moy

    goczkcvfj gobbvckghzkoc hcj gocwvlzhzkoc?

    Lfnhl pyogfwwfw Dh}f yfxvkyfj hppyo}hlwiffckjfczkmkfj / oizhkcfj $f#n# fc}kyocbfcz, plhcckcn+?

    Kwzdfyf glhykz{ hiovz wkzf hcj lhcj kwwvfw?

    Hyf hll yflf}hcz pyoafgz hppyo}hlwkc plhgf?

    Hyf hppyopykhzf po~fyw gocmkybfj moy zdf pvilkg hvzdoykz{ zo h~hyj hcj fczfykczo zdf locn"zfyb goczyhgzw?

  • 8/7/2019 Experience Sharing & Workshop on Public-Private Partnership (PPP): Preparing Projects for Market

    71/71

    >8