final action research educ 617
DESCRIPTION
Dr. Sevillano I´´m sending my Final Research. Thanks for the new oportunity.TRANSCRIPT
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 1
Fostering Multicultural Appreciation in learners through multicultural transformation improves their academic achievement
ByElsy Rodríguez
An action Research submitted to the classroom/action research evaluation in partial fulfillment of
the requirements for the degree of Master in Education
(Specialization in Guidance and Counseling)
(EDUC 617)
Ana G. Méndez University SystemDecember 2011
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 2
Approval Page
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 3
Abstract
Fostering Multicultural Appreciation in learners through multicultural transformation
improves their academic achievement abstract. Rodríguez, Elsy, 2011; Action Research project,
Ana G. Méndez University System.
The purpose of this action research project is to discover and evaluate factors influent in
the multicultural transformation in order to improve the process to those learners to fulfill their
academic achievement. Due to significant demographic transformation is on the horizon the our
nation; consequently teachers must prepare themselves and their students for the ever changing
with diverse races. A key element of effective multiculturalism in schools is anti-racist attitude
development through intellectual understanding. Multicultural programs must be provided to
schools to assist in ensuring that all students and staff can learn and work in an environment
characterized by positive attitudes an intercultural understanding.
Research Question was:
What are some aspects that may increase the learner’s academic achievement during the
multicultural transition?
The methodology that will be use it’s a combination between qualitative and quantitative
approaches. A semi-structured questionnaire with Likert-scale format will be run to collect the
awareness in learners. The surrounding for the research is a select learner’s on a private
education institution at Coral Springs, Broward County with an open age’s population. They will
answer a survey instrument. The researcher will execute a statistical analysis. The result will be
communicated.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 4
Table of Content
Page
Tile Page…………………………………………………………………………..…...…………1
Approval Page……………………………………………………………………….……………2
Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………………..3
Table of Contents...........................................................................................................................4
Chapter One: Introduction
Setting of the project . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Profile the Organization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Nature and Situation of the Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
Impact of the Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
Research Question . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Chapter Two:
Review of Related Literature …………………………………………………………….9
Brief History of the Topic . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
General Concerns about the Topic . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Factors Affecting the Topic . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
The Research Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Who Are the Most Affected? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Chapter Three: Methodology:
Description of the Methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
Rationale for the Methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 5
Participant and Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
Sampling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
Procedure………………………………………………………………………………...21
Data Collection and Instrumentation…………………………………………………….21
Data Analysis…………………………………………………………………………….21
Limitation / Delimitations………………………………………………………………..21
Time Line………………………………………………………………………………...21
Chapter Four: Results:
Evaluation Survey………………………………………………………………………..22
Results Related to Research Question………………………………………………...…22
Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………….24
Chapter Five:
Discussion………………………………………………………………………………..36
Assumption/Implication of Findings…………………………………………………….37
Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………….37
Recommendations……………………………………………………………………….38
References……………………………………………………………………………….39
Appendixes………………………………………………………………………………41
A. Study Conceptual Framework…………………………………………………….....41
B. Master Survey………………………………………………………………………..43
C. Surveys……………………………………………………………………………….45
D. Graphics…………………………………………………………………………...…56
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 6
Chapter One: IntroductionSetting of the project
This action research project is to identify new factors influent in the multicultural
transformation in order to improve the process to those learners to fulfill their academic
achievement. Learners were united in espousing a common objective for multicultural education
and pointing out where and how it should influence education policy and practice. They also,
believed it should have at its core new curriculum and methods of instruction that would enable
students to: (1) learn the history and contributions to society of the diverse groups who comprise
the population of the United States; (2) respect the culture and language of diverse groups’ (3)
develop new knowledge, understanding and appreciation of one’s multiple group characteristics
and how these characteristics can privilege or marginalize the individual and others; and (4) learn
how to bring about social and structural equality and take action toward that end.
Profile of the Organization
In a beginning people never thought that a multicultural environment would ever grow
confronting lack of communication and understanding between the different multicultural that
started to grow in different areas and community. The first situation that the nation had
demanded to address was, that would be able to give access to those new immigrant community
recently establish be able to communicate within their language in the areas of health, education,
and society.
Multicultural education refers to the ways in which all dimensions and aspects of
schooling address the needs and talents of culturally diverse populations to ensure equity and
social justice for all. It is both a philosophy and a process. As a philosophical concept, it is
rooted in the principles of democracy, social justice, equity and the affirmation of human
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 7
diversity. As a process, multicultural education is fluid and continually undergoes modification
to meet the needs and demands of an ever-changing society. To this end , it become a concerted
strategy and educational project or instrument that employs multiple knowledge’s of people
histories, and demonstrates an awareness of contexts as a social historical. In an effort to
challenger current state policies that discriminate against or simply ignore people based on their
socio economic status, race, gender, disability, religion and sexual orientation.
Nature and Situation of the Problem
There are a lot of cultures that come in different shapes and colors. Perhaps, this explains
why multicultural languages shape the world. Community of scholars, teachers and activists are
disconnect from their responsibility providing the necessary skills to meet the intellectual, social
and personal needs of these diverse learners. As a consequence, many students are dealing with
problems and issues of ethnicity, race, language, gender equality, and immigration were ever
present and often acidic but moreover, education rights. Community of scholars, teachers and
activists are grounded in reflection and critique is informative and necessary for meaningful.
Impact of the Problem
Teacher are disconnect from their responsibility of providing with the skills necessary to
meet the intellectual, social and personal need of these diverse learners. Today’s dated and
during the early of days multicultural education, resistance still strong in many places. It difficult
to get support on multicultural education, because of the existing bias against arguments that
spoke of equity and equality and or movement away from an assimilations ideology. Also, new
students trends a period multicultural education movement, where most scholars advocate for a
new multicultural education in their belief that it should promote structural equality and serve as
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 8
an instrument to examine inequality. Unfortunately, this trend interrupts the development
achievement goals on students with multicultural differences.
Research Question
What are some aspects that may increase the learner’s academic achievement during the
multicultural transition?
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 9
Chapter Two: Review of Related Literature
American Psychological Association Publication Manual. It is the Manual more used for writers,
editors, students and educators in the social and behavioral sciences. It provides guidance
from the ethics of authorship to the adequate word to reduce bias in language. It manual
offers to tables, figures, and the manner will result in strong, simple and elegant scientific
communication.
Bennet, C.I. (1995), This article develops a conceptual framework about complex
multidisciplinary roots of multicultural education. It shows the necessity to provide
educational researchers and teachers, educators, how they may design new inquiry a
teacher preparation programs in the meta-disciplinary field of multicultural education.
Drew, C.J., Hardman, M.J. & Hart (1996). This book shows the process of designing and
investigation, interpreting results, particularly experimental researchers, eliminates
alternative of explanation. A possible explanation helps for a good result.
Fowler, F.J. (1993) the author provides an overview of survey research process, learning and put
in practice using clear an easy to understand language, and it is also written for many
desirable features, particularly with respect to determinate audience.
Fraenkel, J.R. & Wallen, N.E. (2003) one the principal points, is correctional studies are carried
out either to help explain important human behaviors or to predict likely outcomes. It
shows the use of variables to make the prediction, is called the predictor variable and it
exist another variable that’s criterion variable and it when the prediction is made. The
author expresses multiple regressions that show a technique that enables a researcher to
determine a correlation between a criterion variable and the best combination of two or
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 10
more variables. This book explains each detail about it.
Garcia, E.E. (2001) the author projects what works in creating better educational opportunities
and effective school reform. She insists its necessary reflexing on the bicultural
experience of minority groups. Cultural root is asset in individuals. The book reflects
how and why our educational reforms, therefore may to build on rather than down play
the original culture and language of minority students.
Galvan, J.L. (1999) writer noted that in literature review the researchers or writers need to
summarize briefly each article. It focuses on a specific topic of interest to researchers
and interest to researchers, also may include a critical analysis of the relationship among
different words and phrases. Usually it provides a theoretical framework and rationale
for a research study.
Glesne, C. & Peshkin, A. (1992) showed a brief but comprehensive overview of qualitative
research that balances and keeping qualitative inquiry vibrant. Educators may turn to
qualitative inquiry, in this text; educators have diverse opportunities with an inquiry
approach. The text learns also numerous exercises that invite to reader the opportunity to
practice and renovate skills to be a qualitative researcher.
Sapsford, Roger and Jupp, Victor. (1996) the objective of the authors is to give students
understanding, evaluate and use evidence in their academic and professional work. This
book can be used for students from a wide range of disciplines (sociology, social
psychology, social policy, criminology, health studies, government and politics. Many
readers including nurses and other medical applicants, social workers and others in the
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 11
caring professions, workers in the criminal justice system, market researchers, teachers,
and others in the educations field.
Scholarly. Work in the University focused on assembling curating and supporting the use of
scholar information to promote research learning, and cultural engagement; in other
words, it is fixed on tracking what information faculty, students, and learners actually
need and on how and where they prefer to discover, locate and use it. Students have now
the opportunity to looking for materials from internet, where have joined library, catalog,
archiving finding aids, and more scholarly information. The author of this report has
formally examined how humanities scholars conduct and collate their research. This
study was based in a sample of scholars; nonetheless, the results are powerfully
suggestive of ways in which academic libraries can adapt to and develop in a rapid
changing environment.
Aueback, Susan brought together research perspectives that intersects the fields of leadership
and partnerships to inform and inspire more authentic collaboration. Alliances are
needed among educators, families, and community that value relationship building,
dialogue, and power sharing as part of socially just, democratic schools.
Nieto, Sonia (1999) showed that she sees multicultural education rather as a perspective from
which to focus on achievement excellence in student learning. The author’s view of the
illuminating power of education for teachers and students. The book focuses on teacher’s
practices, attitudes, and values, as well as policies and practices of schools the she
believes will promote the learning of all students. Instead referring to such students as
minority or disadvantaged. She uses the term “bicultural” and she sees multicultural
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 12
education indeed all good teaching, as transformative: at the end she recommends
teachers transform their practice on three levels: individual, collective, and institutional in
order to improve the educational potential of all students.
Pine & Hilliard (1990) have indicated that many counseling programs discuss multicultural
issues based on working with adults. A greater focus is needed to address the
multicultural needs of children in grades K-6. The problems associated with racism,
discrimination, prejudice, and stereotyping within public schools have been well
documented and help to counselors and teachers. When students have adhered to beliefs
about others or self-based on racial, ethnic, religious, gender, or other stereotypes, a
number of challenging situations have occurred. “School, which ought to be a civilizing
influence in our society, seems instead to be incubators of racial intolerance”. (Pine &
Hilliard) (p.593).
Ferrance, Eileen. She recommended teachers should be constantly researching and educating
themselves about their area of expertise, this is different from the study of more
educational questions that arise from the practice of teaching, Action research gives the
idea that educators will begin a cycle of posing questions, gathering, data, reflections, and
deciding on a course of action. This decisions help to change the school environment a
different set of circumstances appears with others problems posed, which require a new
look. Many action researches projects are started with a particular problem to solve,
whose solution leads into other areas of study.
Gollnick, D.M. & Chim, P.C. (2002) author make two questions in reference to relations:
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 13
What is a world view? And how can we explain the existence of the various world
views? There two questions were raised and his interest in enter-cultural relations goes
back well into himself when he learned the idea of “commensurability” between different
cultures, races, and even species. Frequently it is coming another question that rationing
with point of view with the cultures.
Brief History of the Topic
A new beginning in any multicultural transformative process it such is to examine the
issues, biases, prejudices, and assumptions that it’s carry into the classroom and how these
inform a curriculum. In fact, it’s must constantly engage in a process of examining and critiquing
anyone perspective because this also will affect the way on an approach transformation.
For many people, it is relatively easy and convenient to forget that the public school
system in the United States has an overtly racist, sexist, and classist history. But, a current
shortcomings in education within this historical context, it is important to remember, for
example, that most widespread challenges to overtly discriminatory educational practices have
occurred amazingly recently. Legislation-backed desegregation efforts were in full-swing around
forty years ago, and racial-, gender-, and socioeconomic-based tracking were common practice
even more recently--and still are, although less explicitly so.
As part of its process, multicultural education is a critique of the mono cultural content
and ethos of the current and prevailing Eurocentric system of education in the United States.
According to Parekh (2000). Eurocentric asserts the following two theses, which multicultural
education critiques. First, modern, that is post seventeenth century. European civilization
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 14
represents the highest form of life reached by humankind so far and provides the standards by
which to judge all others. Second, it attained its glory unaided by and owes little if anything to
non European. Its moral and religious foundations were laid by Christianity which, although non
European in origin was radically reshaped in light of the Greco Roman heritage and became a
progress force only after it had undergone much cultural filtering at European hands. Its third
major source was the rise of individualism, secularism, sciences, technology and so on, all
assumed to be unique achievements of modern Europe and based on its pre modern heritage. The
aims of education are to cultivate those capacities, attitudes, values and sentiments that created,
currently underpin and are cherished by European civilization. Including the capacities for
critical and independent thought individualism, the scientific and secular spirit and pride in
European civilization and underplays or ignores the achievements and contribution of others.
(Parekh 2000).
The curriculum was Eurocentric and male-centric, both in content and perspective,
virtually ignoring the history, stories, perspectives, literature, and accomplishments of women
and people of color. Few can argue that, historically, the public school system in the United
States was largely created and maintained for the professional and economic gain of upper-
middle class and wealthy white males and for the tracking into menial work of the poor, people
of color, and women. While conditions have improved and practices like tracking have changed
to make education more accessible to all students, many remnants of this discriminatory history
remain.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 15
In the case of the curriculum, thanks to the struggles and protests of those people who
were traditionally excluded from the curriculum, conditions have improved to an extent. Students
now learn about the accomplishments of certain famous women and people of color, and even
celebrate them during Black History Month, Women's History Month, Hispanic History Month,
and other special occasions.
Still, what has yet to happen is for these histories to be woven into World History or
American History as part of the total mosaic. Many argue that monthly celebrations only serve to
further define certain groups as "the other" whiles the "mainstream" curriculum is taught for the
rest of the year. Others argue that these celebrations help justify the failure of educators to teach
"Black History" in the U.S. as what it really is -- U.S. History.
Likewise, despite the addition of some diverse content into the curriculum, most
information is still presented from a Eurocentric perspective. The most repeated example of this
is the case of Christopher Columbus. Ask any group of people the first fact they remember
learning in history class, and most of them will say, "Columbus discovered America." This "fact"
remains the foundation from which U.S. History is built and conceptualized. But did Columbus
discover America? Through whose eyes is such a statement true? "Manifest Destiny" or
"genocide"? Similar questions can be asked of teaching practices in Literature. From whose
perspective was the "canon" chosen? Who decided that the only "classic" literature was written
in England and the United States? Has no equally great literature been written in Asia or Africa?
Current curricular frameworks, though they include more and more diverse content, fail
to make any real strides toward full inclusion. Likewise, they fail to break free from Eurocentric
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 16
perspectives. As a result, they continue to cheat all students out of a deep, multicultural
understanding of the world around them. Curriculum transformation efforts are necessary to
replace practices that simply further identify some as "the norm" and everyone else as "the other"
with practices that provide all students with a more complete and accurate understanding of
society, the world, and themselves.
General Concerns about the Topic
If, it’s from a multicultural perspective, no one way of viewing the world, no one cultural
standard, political doctrine or ideology can represent the full truth and value of human life,
therefore, multicultural education is essential to school and society. Thus, advocates and
proponents of multicultural education such as Atwater & Riley (1993); Baker (1997, 1983) Bank
(1969, 1993, 1995, 2004) describe the boundaries of multicultural education as inclusive of all
policy, practices and structures of U.S. schools curriculum, financing teacher recruit and hiring
pedagogy and student and grade level organization.
Multicultural education advocates a long comprehensive non patriarchal view of the
history and contributions of marginalized group to the traditional curriculum. It challenges and
calls into question previous omissions and distortions. It offers a set of related propositions that
are used to explain how a phenomenon was arrived historically: for example, concepts of cultural
deficit and at risk are used to define and place students of coolers and low income students
within a paradigm of stratification. Proponents of multicultural education continually challenge
the racism and sexism in arguments that contends that achievements have come about because of
for example. “reveal the kinds of structures and process characterized in the event that are
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 17
studied as well as what the consequences of the events are likely to be. “Finally, proponents of
multicultural education seek to illuminate the ways of thinking that influence institutional and
personal decision making and make clear the possible consequences that may arise from
following them.
Factors Affecting the Topic
Although, the coming together of the different groups; race, ethnicity, low socioeconomic
status, disability, gay and lesbian, religious and the varied constituencies and interest they
represent sometimes create theoretical confusion and ambiguity regarding the meaning of
multicultural education, it the coming together also, brings flexibility, as well as depth and
breadth to ideas regarding equity and equality and fosters coalescence around actions for social
justice. It can be a recall writing in 1975: “I think it would be wrong to posit a rigid and inclusive
definition of multicultural education. It’s would prefer to describe multicultural education as a
concept, because a concept embodies process, movement and as such its contours are flexible”
(p.2).
Although, the definition of multicultural was still inchoate during these early years, those
who adopted multicultural education as a topic of scholarly investigation and work and or who
used it as a theoretical lens for guiding their scholarship were united in their demand that school
policies and practices should be examined from a multicultural perspective and that school
policies and practices should prepare student to work actively toward social structural equality
and the promotion of cultural pluralism. For example, James Banks (1979), who analyzed
schooling through and ethnic studies and multicultural education lens, argues. “Ethnic studies
instruction should help students develop the ability to make reflective decisions on issues related
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 18
to ethnicity and to take personal and public action to help solve the racial and ethnic problems in
our society” (p.20).
The Research Problem:
Teacher are disconnect from their responsibility of providing with the skills necessary to
meet the intellectual, social and personal needs of these diverse learners.
Who Are the Most Affected?
With the missing attention on multicultural education from educator, learners from
different ethnicity are the population most affected on this research. Their differences in culture,
religion belief, life style, and moral values and more over, languages, become to be the important
elements that influence in the affectation. And, with other affectation, communities, business and
government are indirect affected as well because of the unfinished basic or professional
education which loge them on an unable personnel list for some specific professions.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 19
Chapter Three: Methodology:
Description of the Methodology:
On research methods, the qualitative research is a method of inquiry that it’s employed in
many different educational disciplines, mostly traditionally in the social sciences but, also in
market research and further context. Also, the qualitative researchers aim to gather an in depth
understanding of human behavior and the reasons that govern such different behavior. The
qualitative method also, investigates the why, and the how of decisions making. And, not just
what, where, when. Hence, smaller but focused samples are more often needed than large
samples.
However, in the social science also, quantitative research refers to the systematic
empirical investigation of social phenomena via statistical, mathematical or computational
techniques. The objective of quantitative research is to develop and employ mathematical
models, theories and hypotheses pertaining to phenomena. The process of measurement is central
to quantitative research because it provides the fundamental connection between empirical
observation and mathematical expression of quantitative relationships.
Therefore, the methodology that was used on this action research was a combination
between qualitative and quantitative approaches. A semi-structured questionnaire with Likert-
scale format was ran to collect the awareness in a select community. The surrounding for the
research as a select learner’s on a private education institution at Coral Springs, Broward County
with teachers of elementary school population. They was answered a survey instrument. The
researcher executed a statistical analysis. The result was communicated.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 20
Rationale for the Methodology:
Related to multicultural education, this investigation was created in order to find answer
and results which support new evidence that increase or create new tools where bring a new
transformation that improves learner’s academic achievement. Multicultural educator shut
included specific strategic which included multicultural factors that offer new teaching models
on their curriculum. Multicultural learners only will achieve their academic goals in on an
educational environment where this factor its included.
Participant and Characteristics
The immigrant’s from deferent’s countries come to United State without knowing the
official language of this country. Also, they come to a total new environment which has a new
culture they will learn to live with. Some immigrants decide to break those new barriers that
come with the process of a new adaptation on their new country where will be living and
growing. So, the characteristics on this participant are: all of those immigrants that become new
challenger in the education system. Also, other participant’s characteristics are: all of those
educators that in the education system teach multicultural to students.
Sampling
The sampling population was taken on a private educational institution. Sampling
population also, met the participant and characteristic previously establish on the research
methodology. Those characteristics demand that population sampling participant were teachers
of elemental multicultural students which are immigrants from other countries and multicultural
educator as well.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 21
Procedure
For the realization of this study, an extensive survey of literature was implemented in
qualitative instrument that was conducted. The procedure step were design and approval of the
project by the facilitator of the course; implementation of the research, development of the
theoretical framework, which supported the variables addressed in this research paper. The
teachers were surveyed, and the measures of outcomes tabulated.
Data Collection and Instrumentation
A letter which explained the study and requested permission to conduct the study was
brought to the Principal of the school. The survey was given to the teachers and they answered
all the same day.
Data Analysis
Statements data was collected using zoomerang. The independent variable for this study
was performing and achievement. The dependent variable was more tolerance, and help students.
The control variable was gender, ages, time teaching in schools.
Limitations/Delimitations
In order to find solution to improve the student’s achievement, teachers understood that it
is necessary their participation with the multicultural knowledge, literacy and relation with home
family’ students.
Time Line
The study was administered to 10 elementary school teachers in Broward County, using
the Likert Scale Survey format. Teachers completed the survey the same day. Analysis of all
survey took at November, 2011.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 22
Chapter 4: Results
Evaluation Survey
The results of this study showed affirmatively the research question. What are some
aspects that may increase the learner’s academic achievement during the multicultural transition?
The survey was administrated by researcher in November 2011; it was directed to ten elementary
school teachers. The survey was written in Linket-type format style, the answers were range
from SA-(1) = strongly agree A-(2) =Agree N-(3) =Neutral D-(4) =Disagree SD-(5) =Strongly
Disagree. A percentage and frequency table was used for each point of the survey. The sample
was taken in ten teachers from an elementary school, located in Coral Springs, Florida.
Results Related to Research Question
The survey samples were administrated to ten teachers of elementary school. They were
instructed to take a few minutes to fill out the evaluation survey, emphasizing the fact that their
opinions were very important and confidential, reflecting their teaching experiences with
multicultural students. The research attempts to help multicultural students’ academic
achievement.
Participant’s age is represented in Table 1, between 26-56 years old and the study shows
23.1%. Gender’s participant’s equivalent to female 61% and male 15.4% it was showed in table
2. They are teaching first grade 15.4%, second grade 23.1%, third grade 15.4%, fourth grade
7.7% and fifth grade 15.4%, represented in table 3. Participants informed about their years of
experience in teaching, representing of 1 to 3 years= 15.4%; 3-5 years=23.1%; and
6+years=38.5% showed in table 4.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 23
In the first sentence, table five shows teachers answered affirmatively, 63.8% agree and
23.1% strongly agree that they are familiar with their student’s multicultural background.
According with table 6 corresponding to second sentence, participants’ opinion was affirmatively
to training teachers enhance students’ academic achievement with 30.8% strongly agree, 48.5%
agree and only 7.7 % disagree.
In table 7 corresponding to third sentence, teachers answered if the multicultural students
usually have difficulties adjusting to school with different opinions, strongly agree 7.7%, agree
15.4%, neutral 23.1% and disagree 40%. Analyzing this answer it is obvious that some teachers
don’t understand multicultural immersion to adopt a new culture, and social- economics
problems that many families suffering when arrive to new country, adding a new language to
learn, at first time it is very hard to students enter to new ambiance.
Teachers accepted positively the opportunity of intervention focused on helping students
to have a sense of belonging improves achievement; it is showed in table 8, strongly agree 23.1%
and agree 53.8%. The last sentence represented in table 9, strongly agree 23.1%, agree 38.5%
neutral 7.7% and disagree 7.7% showed that teachers are pleased with parent’s involvement as
supporters. It is really necessary the parents participation in the school, teachers may contact
parents and they together help student. Parents must give more attention to children, not only like
supplier it is more than give economical support it is caring, love, confidence and quality time.
The last question represented in table 10 was answered affirmatively for all teachers,
showing in the study the importance that teachers involve more in the student’s background and
help them to be more comfortable in the new schools.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 24
The formal education is important and these have been interpreted as support for
strengthening existing teachers’ preparation programs in universities and increased expenditures
on post-college training to obtain productivity, especially in teaching where students have other
characteristics, as the case of multicultural participation in the school. If educators give the
positive matching between student quality and teacher training, the gain scores students grow up.
It shows the ability in the students reflect teacher value-added associated with education and
training.
In contrast to level education, master degree and more from teachers, the most important
it is the vocation to teach, because not all teachers show it. Some people helps to solution some
doubt about a class and he may not be a teacher, but he has the ability and the manner to help
others learning.
According to Frederick Douglas “It is easier to build strong children than to repair broken
men”.
Frequencies Variable: age, gender, grade teaching experience, education adjusting
intervention support training.
Conclusion
In the study observed, teachers understood that they may help to multicultural students
with another perspective, which could lead to reducing in the acting out of prejudice in
elementary schools. The schools are microcosm of society, this way we may see, racism,
discrimination and bias would be observed if it was effectively answered by teachers, acceptance
of self and others. Teachers accepted that is necessary the integration home-school. Banks noted
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 25
that “with content integration, individuals from diverse backgrounds could be included in the
academic material presented in the classroom”. Teachers and staff could focus on the diversity
and help learners according with their cultural diversity.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 26
Table 1
Represents Teachers participants’ ages
Frequency Percent
Valid 26-35 2 15.4
36-45 5 38.5
46-55 2 15.4
56-65 1 7.7
Total 10 76.9
Missing System 3 23.1
Total 13 100.0
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 27
Table 2
Represents Teachers participants’ gender
Frequency Percent
Valid 3 23.1
Female 8 61.5
Male 2 15.4
Total 13 100.0
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 28
Table 3
Which grade are teachers currently teaching?
Frequency Percent
Valid 1rs. grade 2 15.4
2nd. grade 3 23.1
3rd. grade 2 15.4
4th. grade 1 7.7
5th. grade 2 15.4
Total 10 76.9
Missing System 3 23.1
Total 13 100.0
Table 4
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 29
Represents – Years of experience in teaching
Frequency Percent
Valid 1-3 2 15.4
3-5 3 23.1
6+ 5 38.5
Total 10 76.9
Missing System 3 23.1
13 100.0
Table 5
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 30
Represents if teachers are familiars with their student’s multicultural background
Frequency Percent
Valid Agree 7 53.8
Strongly Agree 3 23.1
Total 10 76.9
Missing System 3 23.1
Total 13 100.0
Table 6
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 31
Training teachers enhance students’ academic achievement
Frequency Percent
Valid Disagree 1 7.7
Agree 5 38.5
Strongly Agree 4 30.8
Total 10 76.9
Missing System 3 23.1
Total 13 100.0
Table 7
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 32
Multicultural students usually have difficulties adjusting to school
Frequency Percent
Valid Disagree 4 30.8
Neutral 3 23.1
Agree 2 15.4
Strongly Agree 1 7.7
Total 10 76.9
Missing System 3 23.1
Total 13 100.0
Table 8
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 33
Intervention focused on helping students
Frequency Percent
Valid Agree 7 53.8
Strongly Agree 3 23.1
Total 10 76.9
Missing System 3 23.1
Total 13 100.0
Table 9
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 34
Teachers are pleased with parents’ involvement as supporters
Frequency Percent
Valid Disagree 1 7.7
Neutral 1 7.7
Agree 5 38.5
Strongly Agree 3 23.1
Total 10 76.9
Missing System 3 23.1
Total 13 100.0
Table 10
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 35
Do you believe teachers’ training improve students’ academic achievement?
Frequency Percent
Valid Yes 10 100.0
Missing System 3 23.1
Total 13 100.0
Chapter 5: Discussion
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 36
The experience in the collection data was very interesting, because I could to know the
interest that some teachers have in working with the minority and help them to adopt a new style
of live, new friends and new neighborhood. For some people is not easy entering within new
cultures and languages. Therefore students from other countries need some aspects that help
them to increase achievement academic, because some of them start a new school, in middle or
high school, that’s way teachers have a great responsibility to encourage students to study hard
and helping them to participate in different activities; as plays, sport teams, bands, etc.
The principal of the school permitted realize a survey to 10 elementary school teachers,
who accepted manifesting interest in the points planted in the study. The principal’s experience,
sense of community, organizational skills may help to school members to change an adequate
way to solve problems related to students, who reported feeling as they did not fit in his school
or ambiance, because the school is not a safe place for them, when they have suffered
discrimination; it can bring devastating effects, such as, students skipping classes, not
participating in academic or extracurricular activities, or dropping out of school. According to
Pine & Hilliard (1990) (p. 593) “Schools, which ought to be a civilizing influence in our society,
seem instead to be incubators of racial tolerance”.
Teachers received information about the privacy and confidentiality in the participation
in the study. . Having a boss that recognizes the issues of the school and she should help to
improve replace new positives way that students receive a better opportunity to grasp into a new
society. In this way multicultural learning may explore the tapestry of perspective in the world,
reaching across boundaries of ability, nationality, race, religion, and sexual orientation other
social and cultural identities.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 37
Differences are commons in the classroom, but the awareness of social justice and
equality is emphasized and everyone must attend to others with respect and give opportunity to
everyone communicate and learn.
Assumption/ Implication of Findings
Faculty giving the importance and quality to their vocational profession, they answered
affirmatively to the evaluation, because they have observed the difficulties that multicultural
students present of perspective in the world, nationality, race, religion, etc. Their parents not
always have the better job, a lot of them are working two job for complete the familiar support
and cover the spending, and it might be observed by teachers in the classroom, when a student is
coming from a low class or necessity more attention from parents in his homework’s.
When I went to visit the school, at first time I fought some difficulties to talk with
school’s principal, because it is not easy to enter to do some task, observation, etc., first we need
to show the fingerprints, because it is requirement from scholar bureau of Florida. I treated some
days later and the principal left on Thanksgiving off days and the end I could take the
information from teachers when they reentered to class.
Conclusion
By evaluation the results received we can come to conclusion that teachers can modify
their teaching, in order to increase the academic achievement of students from the racial and
ethnic groups, that are experiencing massive failure in our schools, and consequently in society.
Modifying instruction to improve the academic achievement of multicultural learners, it will
benefit all students because underachievement exists within all segments of the school
population. Teachers may exhibit more expectation, being more interested in the multicultural
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 38
students, offering to them acceptance and showing interest in to know more about their cultures,
beliefs, styles and languages.
Recommendation
In review of this evaluation I suggested, that we need more studies that consider factors
such as gender, social class and culture while examining literacy across diverse contexts. There
is necessary observe relationship between home and school. As well, we need to give deep
consideration on changes that we embrace. In family needs we cannot ignore their values and
desires in the new community for them. Teachers need to examine the ideologies that drive us
and critique our own quest to observe school transformed. There is a necessity for teachers to
understand literacy within their classrooms and appreciate the differences that may exist between
each one, home and school; it may permit interaction and it learns and helps to know the
diversity of communication and literacy forms and even the text types and instructional practices
used to read and write, as well as changing the nature of instructional activities and
implementing culturally responsive instruction.
School systems must know inappropriate conduct and prepare teachers have a
responsibility to understand and respond to the diversity of the families to the students they
teach, because it is community diversity and help the communication with learners. The findings
in this study we could appreciate teachers’ acceptation to improve on student’s advantages.
References
A.P.A. (2001). American Psychological Association Publication Manual. Fifth edition.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 39
Washington, DC: APA.
Bennett, C.I.(1995).Multicultural Education: Theory and Practice. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Buendía Eirsma, L., Colas Bravo, P. & Hernández Pina, F. (1998). Métodos de
investigación en psicopedagogía. Madrid: McGraw Hill.
Creswell, J. W. (2002). Educational Research: Planning, conducting, and evaluating
quantitative and qualitative research. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Decker, S (1969) An empty spoon. New York: Harper & Row.
Drew, C. J. Hardman, M. J. & Hart, A. W. (1996). Designing and Conducting
Research: Inquiry in Education and Social Science. Massachusetts: Allyn &
Bacon.
Ferrance, Eileen (1990) Action Research. Northeast and Island Regional Educational
Laboratory at Brown University
Fowler, F. J. (1993) Survey research methods. California: Sage Publications.
Fraenkel, J. R. & Wallen N.E (2003). How to design and evaluate research in
education. New York: MacGraw Hill
Fraenkel, J. R. & Wallen N.E. (2003). Student workbook to accompany: How to
design and evaluate research in education. New York: MacGraw Hill.
Garcia, E.E. (2001) Hispanic education in the United States. Maryland: Rowman &
Littlefield.Lanham.
Galvan, J. L. (1999). Writing literature reviews. California: Pryczak Publishing.
Glesne, C. & Peshkin, A. (1992). Becoming qualitative researchers: An introduction.
New York: Longman.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 40
Gollnick, D.M. & Chim, P.C (2002) Multicultural Education in a pluralistic society (6th Ed.)
Upper Saddler River. N.Y: Prentice Hall.
Hernández Sampieri, R., Fernández Collado, C. & Pilar Batista, L. (1998).
Metodología de investigación.
Martella, R. C., Nelson, R. & Marchand-Martella, N.E. (1999). Research methods:
Learning to become a critical research consumer. Massachusetts: Allyn and
Bacon.
McMillan, J. H. & Wergin, J. F. (1998). Understanding and evaluating educational
research. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Méndez, C. E. (1999). Metodología: Diseño y desarrollo de investigación. Bogota:
McGraw Hill.
Pine / Hilliard (1990) Multicultural School Counseling with Children in Grades K-6. New
Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 41
Appendix A
Study Conceptual Framework
Study Conceptual Framework
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 42
TOPICFostering Multicultural Appreciation in learners through multicultural transformation improves their academic achievement.
PROBLEMS (HYPOTHESES)
Teacher are disconnect from their responsibility of providing with the skills necessary to meet the intellectual, social, and personal needs of these diverse learners
TRENDS
The leadership in teacher training institutions has the responsibility of creating positive environments where multicultural initiatives can thrive. These transformative approaches will foster multicultural appreciation in learners and provide them with the competences necessary to effectively meet the challenges of the changing school demographics.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
What are some aspects that may increase the learner´s academic achievement during the multicultural transition?
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 43
Appendix B
Master Survey
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 44
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 45
Appendixes CSurveys
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 46
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 47
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 48
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 49
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 50
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 51
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 52
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 53
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 54
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 55
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 56
Apendixes D
Graphics
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 57
Graphic 1
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 58
Graphic 2
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 59
Graphic 3
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 60
Graphic 4
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 61
Graphic 5
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 62
Graphic 6
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 63
Graphic 7
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 64
Graphic 8
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 65
Graphic 9
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 66
Graphic 10
Running head: FOSTERING MULTICULTURAL APPRECIATION IN LEARNERS THROUGH MULTICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION IMPROVES THEIR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT 67