fire safety inspection report - fair factories...
TRANSCRIPT
FIRE SAFETY INSPECTION REPORT
CAESAR APPARELS (EXTENSION) (OLDNAME RAHIMA TEXTILES LIMITED)
BISIC INDUSTRIAL AREA, BLOOCK-A, PLOT A/2, TEABOARD, BAIZID
June 15, 2014
Other Factories: Mahanagar Packaging Ltd and Quality FashionLimited
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 2
Fire Safety Inspection ReportCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name Rahima Textiles Limited)
IntroductionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name Rahima Textiles Limited)manufacturing complex was surveyed for fire safety on 6/15/2014 by HughesAssociates, Inc.
The purpose of the survey was to identify significant fire safety issues and toprovide recommendations for remediation based on applicable standardsspecified by the Accord. The scope of this initial fire safety inspection waslimited to the review and identification of major fire safety issues. Theinspection did not include identification of minor deficiencies, which will befurther addressed as part of follow-up inspections.
LimitationsThe information in this fire safety inspection report was obtained during a visitto the facility and during interviews with local factory management. It has notbeen possible to provide independent verification for all the information anddata collected, and, therefore, Hughes cannot accept general responsibility foromissions or errors arising from inaccuracies in this report from the informationobtained.
The findings and recommendations in this report are not intended to imply,guarantee, ensure or warrant compliance with any government regulations.Additionally, the results do not imply in any way that compliance with thefindings or recommendations as stated in this report will eliminate all hazards,risks or exposures or that hazards, risks or exposures not referred to in thisreport do not exist. Compliance with the findings and recommendations statedin this report does not relieve the factory owner from obligation to comply withspecific project requirements, industry standards, or the provisions of any localgovernment regulations.
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 3
Factory Building Name(s):Caesar Apparels (Extension) (old name Rahima Textiles Limited)
Factory Address:BISIC Industrial Area, Bloock-A, Plot A/2, Tea Board, Baizid
Points of Contact:Md. Abu Jahed Monju,Manager (HRD & Admin)Caesar Apparels Limited+880 31 682551, 2581047-8 (Ext-116)[email protected]
Abdur Rahim,General MnagerCaesar Apparels Limited+880 31 682551, 2581047-8 (Ext- 103)[email protected]
General Factory Information
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 4
General Building Information - Caesar ApparelsNo. of Stories Below /Above Grade
0 / 6
High Rise No
High Rise Comments: The highest occupiable floor is located 16.75 m. above grade.
Occupancy Classification G2 IndustrialF BusinessH2 Storage
Floor Plans Available No
Date Of Construction Construction started in 2007 but still not completed.
Major Renovations No
Other Tenants Yes
Comments Mahanagar Packaging Ltd is on the ground floor and QualityFashion Limited is on the second floor.
Floors Occupied ByFactory
First and third floor
Use
Finishing, Cutting, BoilerSewing, Office, Store
Floor Occupant Load
13
150411
Construction FeaturesNon-Combustible Yes
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 5
Fire-Resistive Yes
Building SurroundingsNorth Single storied structure without separation.
South Open space.
East Two storied structure without separation.
West Open space.
Vertical OpeningsStairs Enclosed in Fire-Rated Construction?
Yes
Unsealed Penetrations inStairs
Yes
Unprotected OpeningsFrom Stairs
Yes
Shafts Enclosed in Fire-Rated Construction
Yes
Floors withOpenings/Penetrations
No
Other Vertical Openings No
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 6
Egress FeaturesTwo (2) exit stairs serve the building. Egress from the first floor is provided by the East exit stairand an exit on the South. Ground floor is provided by two (2) exits. Each floor, except the thirdfloor, has an adequate number of exits with sufficient exit capacity based on occupant load.The exit capacity of the third floor (271) is insufficient for the maximum occupant load (411). Allexits are remotely located. All exits discharge to the exterior of the building. All exit stairs areopen on all floors due to unprotected openings. The exit discharge path serving the East exit isless than 10 ft wide and is not separated from the generator room.
There is storage located in all the exit stairs on all the floors. There are unsealed penetrationslocated in the East exit stair on the second floor.
Sliding gates and doors are used at building exits, exit stairs and along egress routes. Egressdoors with locking features are present at building exits, exit stairs, along egress routes andexit discharges. All gates and doors are open and unlocked during the inspection. Emergencyevacuation plans are located at the exit stairs and adjacent to exits. Fire drills are conductedmonthly, records are provided during the inspection.
Floor Exit Capacity
13
501271
No. Exits
22
Occupant Load
150411
GeneralExit Number/CapacityAdequate
No
Exits Remote Yes
Exit DoorsSliding Gates/DoorsUsed?
Yes
Egress Doors SwingCorrectly?
Yes
Egress Doors Lockable? Yes
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 7
Exit StairsAll Stairs Discharge tothe Exterior?
Yes
Discharge CapacityAdequate
Yes
Handrails on at least OneSide?
Yes
Storage Located inStairs?
Yes
Exit Access From Factory AreasStorage in Egress Paths? No
Egress Paths ofAdequate Width?
Yes
Excessive TravelDistances, CPT, DE's
No
Emergency PlanningEmergency EvacuationPlans Provided?
Yes
Fire Drills Conducted Yes
Records Maintained Yes
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 8
Emergency Evacuation Plan
Fire Protection Features
Sprinkler SystemNo sprinkler system is present in the building. Based on the height of the highest occupiablefloor, automatic sprinkler protection is not required.
Fire Hose SystemHose cabinets with 1.5 in. hoses are provided on the West side of the factory floor.Hose Size(s) Provided 1.5 in.
Locations On the West side of the factory floor.
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 9
Fire Hose Cabinet
Fire Water SupplyThe fire hose system was supplied by gravity from a roof tank having a reported total capacityof 2,000 L. The tank is fed by an underground cistern, with a reported capacity of 30,000 L.,that is accessed from the North exit stair. There is no fire pump connected to the system.
Source(s) Tank
Location Roof
Capacity 2,000 L.
Fire Pump No
Fire Alarm SystemA fire alarm system is provided in the factory building. It consisted of manual alarm switchesand horn units installed on the factory floors. Reportedly, the activation switches on each floortrigger the fire alarm for the entire building. No functional test is conducted on the systemduring the inspection. There is no fire alarm panel or system supervision present during theinspection. No records or assertions of regular testing or maintenance of the fire alarm systemare provided.
Type of System Manual Fire Alarm System (Audible)
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 10
Fire Panel Location None
Visible NotificationAppliances?
No
Audible NotificationAppliances?
Yes
Alarm Annunciation ManualWhole Building
Functional TestConducted
No
Regular Inspection,Testing, & Maintenance?
No
Manual Fire Alarm Switch Fire Alarm Horn Unit
Fire Detection SystemSingle station smoke alarms are located in various places throughout the factory. These smokealarms are not tied into the fire alarm system. In the event they detect smoke, they will providea local alert sound. No records or assertions of regular testing or maintenance of the firedetection system are provided.Type of Detectors Single Station Smoke Alarms
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 11
Regular Inspection,Testing, & Maintenance?
No
Single Station Smoke Alarm
Portable Fire ExtinguishersPortable fire extinguishers, consisting of a mix of CO2 and dry chemical extinguishers, areprovided throughout the building. There is a foam extinguisher located in the generator room.Inspection tags show recent and up-to-date inspections.
Types Provided CO2, dry chemical extinguishers and foam extinguisher.
AdequateNumber/Spacing?
Yes
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 12
Portable Fire Extinguisher (CO2 and DryChemical) Portable Fire Extinguisher (Foam)
Manual Fire Fighting EquipmentEach floor has firefighting equipment staged on the factory floors near the East exit stairentrance. Types of manual firefighting equipment provided included: buckets, escape hoods,bolt/lock cutters, shovels, hooks, stretchers, rope and personal protection equipments.Types of EquipmentProvided
Buckets, escape hoods, bolt and lock cutters, shovels, hooks,stretchers, rope and personal protection equipments.
Location of Equipment On the factory floors near the East exit stair entrance.
Other Features
Emergency Lighting & Exit SignsThere are multiple florescent lights that have an alternate “Instant Power Supply” (IPS) locatedinside exit enclosure walls and on each floor. Based on the number and location of emergencylighting units, there does not appear to be adequate illumination of the means of egress. Eachfloor has a number of illuminated exit signs, a mix of directional and non-directional, locatedalong the exit access and at exits. The factory management has reported that these are allserviced by normal electricity as well as by multiple “Instant Power Supply” (IPS) units. Thereare no records or assertions of regular testing or maintenance of the emergency lightingsystem.
Exits and Exit AccessProperly Marked withExit Signage
Yes
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 13
Emergency Power IPS
Emergency Lighting forExits & Exit Access
Yes
Regular Inspection,Testing, & Maintenance?
No
Emergency Light Exit Sign
ElevatorsNo elevator is provided in the building.
GeneratorsA single generator serves the building. It is located in a separate single storied structureoutside the factory building adjacent to the East exit stair discharge. The structure does nothave proper fire-rated separations. Additional fuel storage is not present.Location(s) In a separate single storied structure outside the factory building
adjacent to the East exit stair discharge.
Inside Fuel Storage No
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 14
Fire Rated SeparationsProvided?
No
Generator
BoilersA single boiler serves the factory. It is located on the first floor. The boiler room does not haveproper fire-rated separations.Location(s) On the first floor
Fire Rated SeparationsProvided?
No
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 15
Boiler
TransformersA single transformer serves the building. It was mounted on the pole outside the building.
Storage AreasThe storage room on the third floor is separated by non-fire-rated construction with unprotectedopenings. Storage is observed to be open to production floor on the first floor.Fire Rated SeparationsProvided?
No
Open to Factory Floors? Yes
Open to Exit Discharge? No
Additional InformationNone
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old nameRahima Textiles Limited)
Page 16
Findings & Recommendations
Table 1 summarizes the major fire safety issues identified during the inspection.Recommendations have been provided to address each issue.
An implementation schedule shall be developed by the factory to remediate each of thefindings. The specific timing of improvements, including any requested extensions due todesign / installation constraints, shall be submitted to the Accord for approval.
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 17
No. Category Finding RecommendationRemediationTimeframe
Table 1. Findings And Recommendations
Fire RatedConstruction
The exit stairs are notseparated from workareas and other spaceson each floor by fire-rated construction.
Provide minimum 1.5-hr firerated doors and seal allunprotected openings toseparate the exit stairs fromwork areas and other buildingspaces on all floor levels.Ensure that the fire doors areself-closing and positivelatching and that they areprovided with fire exit (panic)hardware where servingproduction floors.
If fire doors are required to beheld open for functionalreasons, provide automatic-closing devices tied to the firealarm system.
Within 3months
F-1
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 18
Fire RatedConstruction
Unsealed penetrationsand openings arelocated in exit stairenclosures.
Seal all penetrations andopenings in exit stairenclosure walls to maintain thefire separation.
Within 3months
F-2
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 19
Fire RatedConstruction
The boiler on the firstfloor and generatorroom outside the factorybuilding adjacent to theEast exit stair dischargeis not separated by fire-rated construction dueto openings, non-rateddoors and penetrations.
Separate the boiler andgenerator room by a minimum2-hr fire-rated construction.Seal and protect all openingsto maintain the required fireseparations.
Within 3months
F-3
Fire RatedConstruction
Storerooms used forcombustible storagesare not separated byfire-rated constructionon the third floor.
Provide dedicated storagerooms separated by minimum1-hr fire-rated construction.
Within 3months
F-4
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 20
Fire RatedConstruction
Areas used forcombustible storagesare open to the factoryfloor on the first floor.
Provide dedicated storagerooms separated by minimum1-hr fire-rated construction.
Where separate storagerooms are not feasible,provide defined storage areasand limit the storagearrangement as follows:- Maximum height of 2.4m andmaximum area of 23m2.
Separate areas of unenclosedcombustible storage by aminimum clear distance of 3m.
Within 3months
F-5
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 21
Fire RatedConstruction
The exit discharge pathserving the East exit isless than 10 ft wide andis not separated fromthe generator room.
Seal all penetrations andopenings to the generatorroom along the dischargepath, up to a height of 10 ft., toprovide a minimum 1-hr fireseparation.
Within 6months
F-6
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 22
Egress Exit capacity (271) is notadequate for theoccupant load (411) onthe third floor.
Reduce occupant load to notmore than available exitcapacity (271).
In future, provide additionalexits to increase occupantload.
ImmediateF-7
Egress Egress doors and gateswith locking features(padlocks) are providedat building exits, exitstairs, along egressroutes and exitdischarges. All gatesand doors are open andunlocked during theinspection.
Remove locking features fromall egress doors and gates.
If locks are required forsecurity reasons, utilizespecial door locking featurescomplying with NFPA 101.
ImmediateF-8
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 23
Egress Storage was located inall the exit stairs on allthe floors.
Remove all storage from exitstairs and egress paths.
ImmediateF-9
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 24
Egress Collapsible gates andsliding doors areprovided at buildingexits, exit stairs andalong egress routes.
Replace all gates and slidingdoors along the means ofegress with side-hinged,swinging egress doors.
If locks are required forsecurity reasons, utilizespecial door locking featurescomplying with NFPA 101.
Within 1month
F-10
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 25
Fire Protection The fire alarm system isantiquated, not a listedsystem, and does notprovide alarm andnotification featuresconsistent withacceptable standards.
Replace the fire alarm systemwith a new, listed addressablefire alarm system inaccordance with NFPA 72.
Designwithin 4months,install
within 9months
F-11
Fire Protection Inspection, testing, andmaintenance for the firealarm system are not inaccordance with NFPA72.
Inspect, test and maintain thefire alarm system, and keepwritten records on-site, inaccordance with NFPA 72.
Within 3months
F-12
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 26
Fire Protection The building is equippedwith single-stationsmoke alarms. Smokealarm activation soundsonly a local alarm anddoes not provideautomatic fire alarmnotification ofoccupants.
Remove single station smokealarms. Provide automaticsmoke detection throughoutthe building in accordancewith NFPA 72.
Within 6months
F-13
EgressLighting
Inspection, testing, andmaintenance for theemergency lightingsystem are not inaccordance with TheACCORD Standard.
Inspect, test and maintain theemergency lighting system inaccordance with TheACCORD standard. Keepwritten records on-site.
Within 3months
F-14
EgressLighting
Based on the numberand location ofemergency lightsobserved, adequateillumination levels arenot anticipated alongegress routes on thefactory floor and theNorth exit stair.
Test the emergency lightingsystem on each floor andprovide additional emergencyfixtures to provide adequateillumination along the meansof egress. Provide a minimumillumination of 10 lux at thefloor level within exit stairs andexit discharge paths andminimum 2.5 lux along exitaccess aisles.
Within 3months
F-15
Accord - Bangladesh RMG Fire Safety InspectionCaesar Apparels (Extension) (old name RahimaTextiles Limited)
Page 27