fly quiet report - flysfo

10
Images used by SFO are Rights Managed Images and have specific usages defined. Please see photography usage guidelines document for more information and only use approved images on SFO Widen Media Collective. Fly Quiet Report Presented at the December 6, 2017 Airport Community Roundtable Meeting Aircraft Noise Abatement Office Third Quarter 2017

Upload: others

Post on 01-Dec-2021

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

Images used by SFO are Rights Managed Images and have speci�c usages de�ned. Please see photography usage guidelines document for more information and only use approved images on SFO Widen Media Collective.

Fly Quiet Report

Presented at the December 6, 2017Airport Community Roundtable Meeting

Aircraft Noise Abatement O�ceThird Quarter 2017

Page 2: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

Fly Quiet Program San Francisco International Airport’s Fly Quiet Program is an Airport Community Roundtable initiative implemented by the Aircraft

Noise Abatement Offi ce. Its purpose is to encourage individual airlines to operate as quietly as possible at SFO. The program

promotes a participatory approach in complying with noise abatement procedures and objectives by grading an airline’s

performance and by making the scores available to the public via newsletters, publications, and public meetings.

Fly Quiet offers a dynamic venue for implementing new noise abatement initiatives by praising and publicizing active participation

rather than a system that admonishes violations from essentially voluntary procedures.

Program Goals The overall goal of the Fly Quiet Program is to infl uence airlines to operate as quietly as possible in the San Francisco Bay Area. A

successful Fly Quiet Program can be expected to reduce both single event and total noise levels around the airport.

Program Reports Fly Quiet reports communicate results in a clear, understandable format on a scale of 0-10, zero being poor and ten being good.

This allows for an easy comparison between airlines over time. Individual airline scores are computed and reports are generated

each quarter. These quantitative scores allow airline management and fl ight personnel to measure exactly how they stand

compared to other operators and how their proactive involvement can positively reduce noise in the Bay Area.

Program Elements Currently the Fly Quiet Program rates jets and regional jets on six elements : the overall noise quality of each airline’s fl eet operating

at SFO, an evaluation of single overfl ight noise level exceedences, a measure of how well each airline complies with the preferred

nighttime noise abatement runways, assessment of airline performance to the Gap and Shoreline Departures, and over the bay

approaches to runways 28L and 28R.

Page 3: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

SFO’s Fly Quiet RatingsFleet Noise Quality The Fly Quiet Program Fleet Noise Quality Rating evaluates the noise contribution of each airline’s fl eet as it actually operates at SFO. Airlines generally own a variety of aircraft types and schedule them according to both operational and marketing considerations. Fly Quiet assigns a higher rating or grade to airlines operat-ing quieter, new generation aircraft, while airlines operating older, louder technology aircraft would rate lower. The goal of this measurement is to fairly compare airlines—not just by the fl eet they own, but by the frequency that they schedule and fl y particular aircraft into SFO.

Noise Exceedance Eliminating high-level noise events is a long-standing goal of the Airport and the Airport Community Round-table. As a result the Airport has established single event maximum noise level limits at each noise-monitor-ing site. These thresholds were set to identify aircraft producing noise levels higher than are typical for the majority of the operations.

Whenever an aircraft overfl ight produces a noise level higher than the maximum decibel value established for a particular monitoring site, the noise threshold is surpassed and a noise exceedance occurs. An exceed-ance may take place during approach, takeoff, or possibly during departure ground roll before lifting off. Noise exceedances are logged by the exact operation along with the aircraft type and airline name.

Nighttime Preferential Runway Use SFO’s Nighttime Preferential Runway Use program was developed in 1988. Although the program cannot be used 100% of the time because of winds, weather, and other operational factors, the Airport, the Com-munity Roundtable, the FAA, and the Airlines have all worked together to maximize its use when conditions permit. The program is voluntary; compliance is at the discretion of the pilot in command. The main focus of this program is to maximize fl ights over water and minimize fl ights over land and populated areas between 1:00 a.m. and 6:00 a.m. Fortunately, because airport activity levels are lower late at night, it is feasible to use over-water departure procedures more frequently than would be possible during the day. Reducing night-time noise—especially sleep disturbance— is a key goal of SFO’s aircraft noise abatement program.

Shoreline Departure Quality Aircraft departing SFO using Runways 28L and 28R are also considered by the Fly Quiet grading system whenever they use the Shoreline Departure Procedure. This predominately VFR (visual fl ight rules) depar-ture steers aircraft to the northeast shortly after takeoff in an attempt to keep aircraft and aircraft noise away from the residential communities located to the northwest of SFO. By keeping aircraft east of Highway 101 the majority of the overfl ights will be experienced by industrial and business parks instead of residential areas.

In order to evaluate each airline’s performance when fl ying a Shoreline Departure, a corridor was established using Interstate 101 (green colored fl ight tracks) as a reference point. The corridor runs north along 101, beginning approximately one-mile north-northwest of the end of Runways 28L and 28R and continuing up into the City of Brisbane. Departures west of 101 are scored marginal or poor depending on their location.

Gap Departure Quality Aircraft departing SFO using Runways 28L and 28R frequently depart straight out using a procedure known as the Gap Departure. This procedure directs air traffi c to fl y a route that takes them over the area northwest of the airport over the cities of South San Francisco, San Bruno, Daly City, and Pacifi ca. In an attempt to miti-gate noise in this specifi c area, the Gap Departure Quality Rating has been included as a category in the Fly Quiet Program.

Since “higher is quieter”, aircraft altitudes are recorded along the departure route. Scores are assigned at specifi ed points or gates set approximately one mile apart, with the higher aircraft receiving higher scores.

Foster City Arrival QualityThe Arrival Quality Rating is the latest addition to the Fly Quiet Program. In an effort to further reduce night-time noise in neighboring communities, this rating is designed to maximize over-bay approaches to Run-ways 28 between 11:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. Airlines arriving to Runways 28 during these hours are assessed based on which approach fl ight path was used. Over-the-bay approaches are rated good (green colored fl ight tracks), versus over-the-communities which are rated poor.

Revised date: 5/15/09

Page 4: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

Airline Fly Quiet Summary Report - 3rd Quarter 2017 (July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017)Horizon Air Fleet Noise Quality 10.00 Noise Exceedance 9.97 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 6.25 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 8.74Air China Fleet Noise Quality 9.93 Noise Exceedance 9.89 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 6.14 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 8.65Volaris  Fleet Noise Quality 4.88 Noise Exceedance 10.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 9.17 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 8.02Emirates Fleet Noise Quality 10.00 Noise Exceedance 9.95 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 4.06 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 8.00SAS Scandinavian Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 8.13 Noise Exceedance 10.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 4.82 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 7.65ANA All Nippon Airways Fleet Noise Quality 7.15 Noise Exceedance 9.97 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 5.67 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 7.60Finnair Fleet Noise Quality 4.05 Noise Exceedance 10.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 10.00 Gap Departures 5.75 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 7.45Japan Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 7.15 Noise Exceedance 10.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 4.72 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 7.29Compass Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 10.00 Noise Exceedance 9.89 Nighttime Runway Use 3.07 Shoreline Departures 10.00 Gap Departures 4.70 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 7.11SkyWest Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 10.00 Noise Exceedance 9.97 Nighttime Runway Use 3.33 Shoreline Departures 9.30 Gap Departures 4.63 Foster City Arrivals 5.11 Final Score 7.06Swiss International Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 7.15 Noise Exceedance 9.97 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 3.82 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 6.98WestJet Fleet Noise Quality 5.82 Noise Exceedance 9.66 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 9.32 Gap Departures 4.64 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 6.89British Airways Fleet Noise Quality 6.69 Noise Exceedance 9.91 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 3.85 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 6.81Lufthansa German Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 9.09 Noise Exceedance 9.96 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures 10.00 Gap Departures 5.93 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 6.66Frontier Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 5.22 Noise Exceedance 9.89 Nighttime Runway Use 4.17 Shoreline Departures 8.78 Gap Departures 5.00 Foster City Arrivals 6.84 Final Score 6.65XL Airways France Fleet Noise Quality 4.05 Noise Exceedance 9.86 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 5.00 Gap Departures 6.96 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 6.47Southwest Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 5.81 Noise Exceedance 9.87 Nighttime Runway Use 3.06 Shoreline Departures 9.65 Gap Departures 3.97 Foster City Arrivals 6.10 Final Score 6.41Air India Fleet Noise Quality 7.15 Noise Exceedance 9.23 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 2.50 Gap Departures 6.74 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 6.41Delta Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 6.42 Noise Exceedance 9.89 Nighttime Runway Use 3.55 Shoreline Departures 6.75 Gap Departures 5.10 Foster City Arrivals 6.33 Final Score 6.34Turkish Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 7.15 Noise Exceedance 10.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 1.86 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 6.34Air Canada Fleet Noise Quality 5.92 Noise Exceedance 9.83 Nighttime Runway Use 4.17 Shoreline Departures 7.98 Gap Departures 3.14 Foster City Arrivals 6.89 Final Score 6.32Thomas Cook Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 4.05 Noise Exceedance 9.91 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 6.67 Gap Departures 4.58 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 6.30JetBlue Airways Fleet Noise Quality 4.77 Noise Exceedance 9.83 Nighttime Runway Use 3.64 Shoreline Departures 7.80 Gap Departures 5.60 Foster City Arrivals 6.05 Final Score 6.28Alaska Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 5.19 Noise Exceedance 9.90 Nighttime Runway Use 3.49 Shoreline Departures 9.33 Gap Departures 4.82 Foster City Arrivals 4.91 Final Score 6.27WOW Air Fleet Noise Quality 4.05 Noise Exceedance 7.90 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 5.00 Gap Departures 7.56 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 6.13Sun Country Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 5.82 Noise Exceedance 9.89 Nighttime Runway Use 3.33 Shoreline Departures 8.08 Gap Departures 3.33 Foster City Arrivals 6.15 Final Score 6.10Aer Lingus Fleet Noise Quality 4.05 Noise Exceedance 10.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 4.16 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 6.07Nippon Cargo Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 9.74 Noise Exceedance 9.72 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 5.88 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 6.07Virgin America Fleet Noise Quality 5.01 Noise Exceedance 9.91 Nighttime Runway Use 3.33 Shoreline Departures 8.73 Gap Departures 3.03 Foster City Arrivals 6.07 Final Score 6.01United Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 5.95 Noise Exceedance 9.81 Nighttime Runway Use 3.68 Shoreline Departures 6.27 Gap Departures 4.49 Foster City Arrivals 5.81 Final Score 6.00FedEx Fleet Noise Quality 3.85 Noise Exceedance 9.35 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 8.33 Gap Departures 3.08 Foster City Arrivals 5.08 Final Score 5.94Vietnam Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 5.64 Noise Exceedance 6.96 Nighttime Runway Use 1.67 Shoreline Departures 10.00 Gap Departures 5.42 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 5.94Virgin Atlantic Airways Fleet Noise Quality 7.49 Noise Exceedance 10.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 0.00 Gap Departures 5.91 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 5.85Air France Fleet Noise Quality 8.33 Noise Exceedance 9.90 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 5.06 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 5.82KLM Royal Dutch Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 5.06 Noise Exceedance 10.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 2.78 Gap Departures 4.88 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 5.68Asiana Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 7.24 Noise Exceedance 9.36 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 6.68 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 5.65American Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 4.96 Noise Exceedance 9.81 Nighttime Runway Use 3.68 Shoreline Departures 7.46 Gap Departures 1.18 Foster City Arrivals 6.50 Final Score 5.60Etihad Airways Fleet Noise Quality 7.15 Noise Exceedance 9.70 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 0.00 Gap Departures 5.45 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 5.57Hawaiian Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 4.05 Noise Exceedance 9.10 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 4.11 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 5.57China Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 7.36 Noise Exceedance 8.97 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 5.59 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 5.38Air Berlin Fleet Noise Quality 4.05 Noise Exceedance 10.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures 6.25 Gap Departures 1.09 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 5.35AeroMexico Fleet Noise Quality 5.82 Noise Exceedance 9.09 Nighttime Runway Use 2.54 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 3.64 Foster City Arrivals 5.12 Final Score 5.24Korean Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 8.60 Noise Exceedance 7.94 Nighttime Runway Use 0.23 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 4.42 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 5.24Copa Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 5.82 Noise Exceedance 9.23 Nighttime Runway Use 1.45 Shoreline Departures 6.92 Gap Departures 2.78 Foster City Arrivals 5.13 Final Score 5.22Avianca Fleet Noise Quality 4.97 Noise Exceedance 9.12 Nighttime Runway Use 2.70 Shoreline Departures 5.00 Gap Departures 4.18 Foster City Arrivals 5.11 Final Score 5.18Cathay Pacific Airways Fleet Noise Quality 7.15 Noise Exceedance 8.07 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 4.91 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 5.02Singapore Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 8.33 Noise Exceedance 8.73 Nighttime Runway Use 0.11 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 2.95 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 5.02China Southern Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 7.15 Noise Exceedance 8.95 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 3.54 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 4.93Atlas Air Fleet Noise Quality 4.45 Noise Exceedance 7.50 Nighttime Runway Use 1.27 Shoreline Departures 7.00 Gap Departures 4.39 Foster City Arrivals 4.91 Final Score 4.92China Eastern Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 6.20 Noise Exceedance 9.96 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 3.32 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 4.87Air New Zealand Fleet Noise Quality 6.52 Noise Exceedance 7.07 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 5.76 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 4.84EVA Airways Fleet Noise Quality 6.90 Noise Exceedance 8.34 Nighttime Runway Use 0.14 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 3.53 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 4.78Philippine Airlines Fleet Noise Quality 7.39 Noise Exceedance 7.27 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 2.90 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 4.39FIJI Airways Fleet Noise Quality 4.05 Noise Exceedance 7.49 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 5.59 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 4.28Qantas Airways Fleet Noise Quality 3.43 Noise Exceedance 0.00 Nighttime Runway Use N/A Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 5.14 Foster City Arrivals N/A Final Score 2.86Kalitta Air Fleet Noise Quality 3.43 Noise Exceedance 1.77 Nighttime Runway Use 0.00 Shoreline Departures N/A Gap Departures 1.63 Foster City Arrivals 5.00 Final Score 2.37

SFO Fleet Noise Quality Average is 6.35SFO Noise Exeedance Average is 9.08

SFO Nighttime Runway Use Average is 1.64SFO Shoreline Departures Average is 6.96

SFO Gap Departures Average is 4.60SFO Foster City Arrivals Average is 5.42

SFO Final Score Average is 6.01

Page 5: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

Fleet Noise Quality Rating - 3rd Quarter 2017 (July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017)Emirates Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 7.89 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 10.00Horizon Air Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 10.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 10.00SkyWest Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 10.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 105 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 10.00Compass Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 10.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 13 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 10.00Air China Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 3.46 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 9.93Nippon Cargo Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 3.90 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 9.74Lufthansa German Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 6.09 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 9.09Korean Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.05 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 3 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 8.60Air France Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.49 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 8.33Singapore Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.93 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 8.33SAS Scandinavian Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.96 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 8.13Virgin Atlantic Airways Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.84 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.49Philippine Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.09 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.39China Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 3.62 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.36Asiana Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 3.93 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.24ANA All Nippon Airways Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.43 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.15Cathay Pacific Airways Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.18 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.15China Southern Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.64 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.15Etihad Airways Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 0.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 0 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.15Japan Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.20 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.15Swiss International Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.17 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.15Turkish Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 6.80 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.15Air India Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.77 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 7.15EVA Airways Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.05 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 6.90British Airways Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.34 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 6.69Air New Zealand Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 6.52Delta Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.92 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 40 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 6.42China Eastern Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.63 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 6.20United Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.83 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 211 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.95Air Canada Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 6.75 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 14 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.92Copa Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 6.46 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.82Sun Country Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.82 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.82WestJet Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.82 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 3 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.82AeroMexico Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.54 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 4 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.82Southwest Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.70 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 48 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.81Vietnam Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 0.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 0 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.64Frontier Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 6.41 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 6 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.22Alaska Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.10 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 18 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.19KLM Royal Dutch Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.67 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.06Virgin America Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.31 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 62 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 5.01Avianca Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.18 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.97American Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 3.94 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 38 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.96Volaris Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 0.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.88JetBlue Airways Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 6.13 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 18 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.77Atlas Air Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 0.93 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.45Air Berlin Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.92 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.05Aer Lingus Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.05 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.05Finnair Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 5.38 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 0 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.05Hawaiian Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 6.21 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 2 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.05Thomas Cook Airlines Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 0.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 0 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.05WOW Air Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 0.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.05XL Airways France Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.05 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 0 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.05FIJI Airways Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 0.00 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 0 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 4.05FedEx Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 2.80 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 3.85Kalitta Air Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 0.60 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 0 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 3.43Qantas Airways Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 3.47 San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations for this quarter 1 Fleet Noise Quality Score is 3.43

Average Nationwide Fleet Noise Quality Rating is 4.67San Francisco Average Daily Jet Operations is 11.00

SFO Fleet Noise Quality Average is 6.35

Page 6: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

Noise Exceedance Rating - 3rd Quarter 2017 (July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017)Air Berlin Total Noise Exceedance 0 Total Quarterly Operations 278 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 0 Noise Exceedance Score 10.00Aer Lingus Total Noise Exceedance 0 Total Quarterly Operations 183 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 0 Noise Exceedance Score 10.00Finnair Total Noise Exceedance 0 Total Quarterly Operations 78 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 0 Noise Exceedance Score 10.00Japan Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 0 Total Quarterly Operations 185 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 0 Noise Exceedance Score 10.00KLM Royal Dutch Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 0 Total Quarterly Operations 258 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 0 Noise Exceedance Score 10.00SAS Scandinavian Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 0 Total Quarterly Operations 186 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 0 Noise Exceedance Score 10.00Turkish Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 0 Total Quarterly Operations 184 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 0 Noise Exceedance Score 10.00Virgin Atlantic Airways Total Noise Exceedance 0 Total Quarterly Operations 370 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 0 Noise Exceedance Score 10.00Volaris Total Noise Exceedance 0 Total Quarterly Operations 190 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 0 Noise Exceedance Score 10.00ANA All Nippon Airways Total Noise Exceedance 1 Total Quarterly Operations 185 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 5 Noise Exceedance Score 9.97Swiss International Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 1 Total Quarterly Operations 184 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 5 Noise Exceedance Score 9.97SkyWest Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 125 Total Quarterly Operations 19,313 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 6 Noise Exceedance Score 9.97Horizon Air Total Noise Exceedance 1 Total Quarterly Operations 153 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 7 Noise Exceedance Score 9.97China Eastern Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 2 Total Quarterly Operations 262 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 8 Noise Exceedance Score 9.96Lufthansa German Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 3 Total Quarterly Operations 369 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 8 Noise Exceedance Score 9.96Emirates Total Noise Exceedance 2 Total Quarterly Operations 184 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 11 Noise Exceedance Score 9.95Virgin America Total Noise Exceedance 220 Total Quarterly Operations 11,480 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 19 Noise Exceedance Score 9.91British Airways Total Noise Exceedance 7 Total Quarterly Operations 365 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 19 Noise Exceedance Score 9.91Thomas Cook Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 1 Total Quarterly Operations 52 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 19 Noise Exceedance Score 9.91Air France Total Noise Exceedance 7 Total Quarterly Operations 343 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 20 Noise Exceedance Score 9.90Alaska Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 69 Total Quarterly Operations 3,261 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 21 Noise Exceedance Score 9.90Air China Total Noise Exceedance 4 Total Quarterly Operations 184 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 22 Noise Exceedance Score 9.89Frontier Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 24 Total Quarterly Operations 1,097 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 22 Noise Exceedance Score 9.89Compass Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 54 Total Quarterly Operations 2,468 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 22 Noise Exceedance Score 9.89Delta Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 163 Total Quarterly Operations 7,371 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 22 Noise Exceedance Score 9.89Sun Country Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 10 Total Quarterly Operations 444 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 23 Noise Exceedance Score 9.89Southwest Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 236 Total Quarterly Operations 8,802 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 27 Noise Exceedance Score 9.87XL Airways France Total Noise Exceedance 2 Total Quarterly Operations 68 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 29 Noise Exceedance Score 9.86Air Canada Total Noise Exceedance 89 Total Quarterly Operations 2,609 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 34 Noise Exceedance Score 9.83JetBlue Airways Total Noise Exceedance 118 Total Quarterly Operations 3,353 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 35 Noise Exceedance Score 9.83American Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 268 Total Quarterly Operations 6,907 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 39 Noise Exceedance Score 9.81United Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 1,519 Total Quarterly Operations 38,763 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 39 Noise Exceedance Score 9.81Nippon Cargo Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 9 Total Quarterly Operations 154 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 58 Noise Exceedance Score 9.72Etihad Airways Total Noise Exceedance 5 Total Quarterly Operations 80 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 63 Noise Exceedance Score 9.70WestJet Total Noise Exceedance 39 Total Quarterly Operations 552 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 71 Noise Exceedance Score 9.66Asiana Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 27 Total Quarterly Operations 204 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 132 Noise Exceedance Score 9.36FedEx Total Noise Exceedance 34 Total Quarterly Operations 256 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 133 Noise Exceedance Score 9.35Air India Total Noise Exceedance 25 Total Quarterly Operations 158 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 158 Noise Exceedance Score 9.23Copa Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 54 Total Quarterly Operations 341 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 158 Noise Exceedance Score 9.23Avianca Total Noise Exceedance 51 Total Quarterly Operations 281 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 181 Noise Exceedance Score 9.12Hawaiian Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 68 Total Quarterly Operations 369 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 184 Noise Exceedance Score 9.10AeroMexico Total Noise Exceedance 134 Total Quarterly Operations 714 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 188 Noise Exceedance Score 9.09China Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 91 Total Quarterly Operations 430 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 212 Noise Exceedance Score 8.97China Southern Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 51 Total Quarterly Operations 237 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 215 Noise Exceedance Score 8.95Singapore Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 97 Total Quarterly Operations 370 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 262 Noise Exceedance Score 8.73EVA Airways Total Noise Exceedance 133 Total Quarterly Operations 389 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 342 Noise Exceedance Score 8.34Cathay Pacific Airways Total Noise Exceedance 172 Total Quarterly Operations 433 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 397 Noise Exceedance Score 8.07Korean Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 214 Total Quarterly Operations 506 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 423 Noise Exceedance Score 7.94WOW Air Total Noise Exceedance 78 Total Quarterly Operations 181 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 431 Noise Exceedance Score 7.90Atlas Air Total Noise Exceedance 168 Total Quarterly Operations 327 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 514 Noise Exceedance Score 7.50FIJI Airways Total Noise Exceedance 33 Total Quarterly Operations 64 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 516 Noise Exceedance Score 7.49Philippine Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 129 Total Quarterly Operations 230 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 561 Noise Exceedance Score 7.27Air New Zealand Total Noise Exceedance 111 Total Quarterly Operations 184 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 603 Noise Exceedance Score 7.07Vietnam Airlines Total Noise Exceedance 5 Total Quarterly Operations 8 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 625 Noise Exceedance Score 6.96Kalitta Air Total Noise Exceedance 132 Total Quarterly Operations 78 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 1,692 Noise Exceedance Score 1.77Qantas Airways Total Noise Exceedance 329 Total Quarterly Operations 160 Exceedance per 1000 Operations 2,056 Noise Exceedance Score 0.00

SFO Total Noise Exceedance is 5,115SFO Total Quarterly Operations is 116,835

SFO Average Exceedances per 1000 operations is 190SFO Average Score for Noise Exceedance is 9.08

Page 7: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

Nighttime Preferential Runway Use Rating - 3rd Quarter 2017 (July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017) between the hours of 1:00am and 6:00amAir Canada Total Operations 8 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 25% 01L/01R 75% 28L/28R Straight 0% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 4.17Frontier Airlines Total Operations 16 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 25% 01L/01R 75% 28L/28R Straight 0% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 4.17United Airlines Total Operations 371 10L/10R 1% 28L/28R Shoreline 12% 01L/01R 83% 28L/28R Straight 4% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.68American Airlines Total Operations 107 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 25% 01L/01R 60% 28L/28R Straight 15% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.68JetBlue Airways Total Operations 11 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 9% 01L/01R 91% 28L/28R Straight 0% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.64Delta Airlines Total Operations 31 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 13% 01L/01R 81% 28L/28R Straight 6% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.55Alaska Airlines Total Operations 64 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 6% 01L/01R 92% 28L/28R Straight 2% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.49Sun Country Airlines Total Operations 4 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 100% 28L/28R Straight 0% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.33SkyWest Airlines Total Operations 20 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 5% 01L/01R 90% 28L/28R Straight 5% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.33Virgin America Total Operations 29 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 100% 28L/28R Straight 0% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.33Compass Airlines Total Operations 87 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 92% 28L/28R Straight 8% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.07Southwest Airlines Total Operations 60 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 92% 28L/28R Straight 8% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 3.06Avianca Total Operations 90 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 1% 01L/01R 79% 28L/28R Straight 20% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 2.70AeroMexico Total Operations 71 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 76% 28L/28R Straight 24% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 2.54Vietnam Airlines Total Operations 4 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 25% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 75% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 1.67Copa Airlines Total Operations 76 10L/10R 4% 28L/28R Shoreline 16% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 80% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 1.45Atlas Air Total Operations 21 10L/10R 10% 28L/28R Shoreline 5% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 86% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 1.27Korean Airlines Total Operations 147 10L/10R 2% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 1% 28L/28R Straight 97% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.23EVA Airways Total Operations 145 10L/10R 1% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 99% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.14Singapore Airlines Total Operations 92 10L/10R 1% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 99% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.11Asiana Airlines Total Operations 5 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00Air France Total Operations 1 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00Air New Zealand Total Operations 1 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00China Airlines Total Operations 109 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00China Eastern Airlines Total Operations 1 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00Kalitta Air Total Operations 20 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00Cathay Pacific Airways Total Operations 113 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00China Southern Airlines Total Operations 6 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00Lufthansa German Airlines Total Operations 1 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00FIJI Airways Total Operations 4 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00Nippon Cargo Airlines Total Operations 3 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00Philippine Airlines Total Operations 10 10L/10R 0% 28L/28R Shoreline 0% 01L/01R 0% 28L/28R Straight 100% Nighttime Preferential Runway Score 0.00

SFO Total Nighttime Preferential Runway Operations is 1,728SFO Average For Runways 10L/10R is 1%

SFO Average For Runways 28L/R Shoreline is 5%SFO Average For Runways 01L/R is 37%

SFO Average For Runways 28L/R Straight is 57%SFO Average Score Nighttime Preferential Runway Use Rating is 1.64

Page 8: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

Shoreline Departure Rating - 3rd Quarter 2017 (July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017)Compass Airlines Total Operations 2 Successful Shoreline Departure 100% Marginal Shoreline Departure 0% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 10.00Lufthansa German Airlines Total Operations 1 Successful Shoreline Departure 100% Marginal Shoreline Departure 0% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 10.00Finnair Total Operations 2 Successful Shoreline Departure 100% Marginal Shoreline Departure 0% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 10.00Vietnam Airlines Total Operations 1 Successful Shoreline Departure 100% Marginal Shoreline Departure 0% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 10.00Southwest Airlines Total Operations 101 Successful Shoreline Departure 93% Marginal Shoreline Departure 7% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 9.65Alaska Airlines Total Operations 104 Successful Shoreline Departure 88% Marginal Shoreline Departure 12% Poor Shoreline Departure 1% Shoreline Departure Score 9.33WestJet Total Operations 22 Successful Shoreline Departure 86% Marginal Shoreline Departure 14% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 9.32SkyWest Airlines Total Operations 229 Successful Shoreline Departure 88% Marginal Shoreline Departure 10% Poor Shoreline Departure 2% Shoreline Departure Score 9.30Frontier Airlines Total Operations 49 Successful Shoreline Departure 76% Marginal Shoreline Departure 24% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 8.78Virgin America Total Operations 256 Successful Shoreline Departure 76% Marginal Shoreline Departure 22% Poor Shoreline Departure 2% Shoreline Departure Score 8.73FedEx Total Operations 6 Successful Shoreline Departure 67% Marginal Shoreline Departure 33% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 8.33Sun Country Airlines Total Operations 26 Successful Shoreline Departure 65% Marginal Shoreline Departure 31% Poor Shoreline Departure 4% Shoreline Departure Score 8.08Air Canada Total Operations 114 Successful Shoreline Departure 67% Marginal Shoreline Departure 26% Poor Shoreline Departure 7% Shoreline Departure Score 7.98JetBlue Airways Total Operations 93 Successful Shoreline Departure 56% Marginal Shoreline Departure 44% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 7.80American Airlines Total Operations 283 Successful Shoreline Departure 51% Marginal Shoreline Departure 47% Poor Shoreline Departure 2% Shoreline Departure Score 7.46Atlas Air Total Operations 5 Successful Shoreline Departure 60% Marginal Shoreline Departure 20% Poor Shoreline Departure 20% Shoreline Departure Score 7.00Copa Airlines Total Operations 13 Successful Shoreline Departure 46% Marginal Shoreline Departure 46% Poor Shoreline Departure 8% Shoreline Departure Score 6.92Delta Airlines Total Operations 283 Successful Shoreline Departure 46% Marginal Shoreline Departure 42% Poor Shoreline Departure 11% Shoreline Departure Score 6.75Thomas Cook Airlines Total Operations 3 Successful Shoreline Departure 33% Marginal Shoreline Departure 67% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 6.67United Airlines Total Operations 1,006 Successful Shoreline Departure 47% Marginal Shoreline Departure 31% Poor Shoreline Departure 22% Shoreline Departure Score 6.27Air Berlin Total Operations 12 Successful Shoreline Departure 25% Marginal Shoreline Departure 75% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 6.25Avianca Total Operations 1 Successful Shoreline Departure 0% Marginal Shoreline Departure 100% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 5.00WOW Air Total Operations 1 Successful Shoreline Departure 0% Marginal Shoreline Departure 100% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 5.00XL Airways France Total Operations 4 Successful Shoreline Departure 0% Marginal Shoreline Departure 100% Poor Shoreline Departure 0% Shoreline Departure Score 5.00KLM Royal Dutch Airlines Total Operations 9 Successful Shoreline Departure 0% Marginal Shoreline Departure 56% Poor Shoreline Departure 44% Shoreline Departure Score 2.78Air India Total Operations 2 Successful Shoreline Departure 0% Marginal Shoreline Departure 50% Poor Shoreline Departure 50% Shoreline Departure Score 2.50Etihad Airways Total Operations 1 Successful Shoreline Departure 0% Marginal Shoreline Departure 0% Poor Shoreline Departure 100% Shoreline Departure Score 0.00Virgin Atlantic Airways Total Operations 1 Successful Shoreline Departure 0% Marginal Shoreline Departure 0% Poor Shoreline Departure 100% Shoreline Departure Score 0.00

SFO Total Shoreline Departures 2,630SFO Average for Succesful Shoreline Departures is 53%

SFO Average for Marginal Shoreline Departures is 34%SFO Average for Poor Shoreline Departures is 13%

SFO Average Score for Shoreline Departures is 6.96

Page 9: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

Gap Departure Climb Rating - 3rd Quarter 2017 (July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017)Volaris Total Gap Departures 12 Gap Departure Score 9.17WOW Air Total Gap Departures 63 Gap Departure Score 7.56XL Airways France Total Gap Departures 7 Gap Departure Score 6.96Air India Total Gap Departures 76 Gap Departure Score 6.74Asiana Airlines Total Gap Departures 102 Gap Departure Score 6.68Horizon Air Total Gap Departures 3 Gap Departure Score 6.25Air China Total Gap Departures 92 Gap Departure Score 6.14Lufthansa German Airlines Total Gap Departures 183 Gap Departure Score 5.93Virgin Atlantic Airways Total Gap Departures 99 Gap Departure Score 5.91Nippon Cargo Airlines Total Gap Departures 77 Gap Departure Score 5.88Air New Zealand Total Gap Departures 92 Gap Departure Score 5.76Finnair Total Gap Departures 25 Gap Departure Score 5.75ANA All Nippon Airways Total Gap Departures 93 Gap Departure Score 5.67JetBlue Airways Total Gap Departures 73 Gap Departure Score 5.60China Airlines Total Gap Departures 214 Gap Departure Score 5.59FIJI Airways Total Gap Departures 32 Gap Departure Score 5.59Etihad Airways Total Gap Departures 39 Gap Departure Score 5.45Vietnam Airlines Total Gap Departures 3 Gap Departure Score 5.42Qantas Airways Total Gap Departures 80 Gap Departure Score 5.14Delta Airlines Total Gap Departures 144 Gap Departure Score 5.10Air France Total Gap Departures 154 Gap Departure Score 5.06Frontier Airlines Total Gap Departures 1 Gap Departure Score 5.00Cathay Pacific Airways Total Gap Departures 216 Gap Departure Score 4.91KLM Royal Dutch Airlines Total Gap Departures 21 Gap Departure Score 4.88SAS Scandinavian Airlines Total Gap Departures 92 Gap Departure Score 4.82Alaska Airlines Total Gap Departures 68 Gap Departure Score 4.82Japan Airlines Total Gap Departures 86 Gap Departure Score 4.72Compass Airlines Total Gap Departures 111 Gap Departure Score 4.70WestJet Total Gap Departures 7 Gap Departure Score 4.64SkyWest Airlines Total Gap Departures 793 Gap Departure Score 4.63Thomas Cook Airlines Total Gap Departures 9 Gap Departure Score 4.58United Airlines Total Gap Departures 3,745 Gap Departure Score 4.49Korean Airlines Total Gap Departures 249 Gap Departure Score 4.42Atlas Air Total Gap Departures 47 Gap Departure Score 4.39Avianca Total Gap Departures 23 Gap Departure Score 4.18Aer Lingus Total Gap Departures 91 Gap Departure Score 4.16Hawaiian Airlines Total Gap Departures 24 Gap Departure Score 4.11Emirates Total Gap Departures 92 Gap Departure Score 4.06Southwest Airlines Total Gap Departures 351 Gap Departure Score 3.97British Airways Total Gap Departures 171 Gap Departure Score 3.85Swiss International Airlines Total Gap Departures 91 Gap Departure Score 3.82AeroMexico Total Gap Departures 47 Gap Departure Score 3.64China Southern Airlines Total Gap Departures 117 Gap Departure Score 3.54EVA Airways Total Gap Departures 191 Gap Departure Score 3.53Sun Country Airlines Total Gap Departures 3 Gap Departure Score 3.33China Eastern Airlines Total Gap Departures 131 Gap Departure Score 3.32Air Canada Total Gap Departures 68 Gap Departure Score 3.14FedEx Total Gap Departures 13 Gap Departure Score 3.08Virgin America Total Gap Departures 486 Gap Departure Score 3.03Singapore Airlines Total Gap Departures 184 Gap Departure Score 2.95Philippine Airlines Total Gap Departures 115 Gap Departure Score 2.90Copa Airlines Total Gap Departures 154 Gap Departure Score 2.78Turkish Airlines Total Gap Departures 92 Gap Departure Score 1.86Kalitta Air Total Gap Departures 39 Gap Departure Score 1.63American Airlines Total Gap Departures 476 Gap Departure Score 1.18Air Berlin Total Gap Departures 40 Gap Departure Score 1.09

Total SFO Gap Departures is 10,107Average SFO Gap Departure Score Rating is 4.60

Page 10: Fly Quiet Report - FlySFO

Foster City Arrival Rating - 3rd Quarter 2017 (July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017) between the hours of 11:00pm and 6:00amAir Canada Total Foster City Arrivals 159 Successful Foster City Arrivals 38% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 62% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 6.89Frontier Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 38 Successful Foster City Arrivals 37% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 63% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 6.84American Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 476 Successful Foster City Arrivals 30% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 69% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 6.50Delta Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 331 Successful Foster City Arrivals 27% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 73% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 6.33Sun Country Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 13 Successful Foster City Arrivals 23% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 77% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 6.15Southwest Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 241 Successful Foster City Arrivals 26% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 71% Poor Foster City Arrivals 4% Foster City Arrivals Score 6.10Virgin America Total Foster City Arrivals 300 Successful Foster City Arrivals 22% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 77% Poor Foster City Arrivals 1% Foster City Arrivals Score 6.07JetBlue Airways Total Foster City Arrivals 290 Successful Foster City Arrivals 21% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 79% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 6.05United Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 1,408 Successful Foster City Arrivals 18% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 81% Poor Foster City Arrivals 1% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.81Copa Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 79 Successful Foster City Arrivals 3% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 97% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.13AeroMexico Total Foster City Arrivals 41 Successful Foster City Arrivals 5% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 93% Poor Foster City Arrivals 2% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.12Avianca Total Foster City Arrivals 92 Successful Foster City Arrivals 2% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 98% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.11SkyWest Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 233 Successful Foster City Arrivals 4% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 94% Poor Foster City Arrivals 2% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.11FedEx Total Foster City Arrivals 63 Successful Foster City Arrivals 2% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 98% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.08Asiana Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 5 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00China Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 10 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00Kalitta Air Total Foster City Arrivals 25 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00Cathay Pacific Airways Total Foster City Arrivals 8 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00Compass Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 124 Successful Foster City Arrivals 1% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 98% Poor Foster City Arrivals 1% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00China Southern Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 4 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00Lufthansa German Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 1 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00EVA Airways Total Foster City Arrivals 2 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00Hawaiian Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 3 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00Korean Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 66 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00Nippon Cargo Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 3 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00Singapore Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 1 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00WestJet Total Foster City Arrivals 10 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 100% Poor Foster City Arrivals 0% Foster City Arrivals Score 5.00Alaska Airlines Total Foster City Arrivals 167 Successful Foster City Arrivals 2% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 93% Poor Foster City Arrivals 4% Foster City Arrivals Score 4.91Atlas Air Total Foster City Arrivals 54 Successful Foster City Arrivals 0% Marginal Foster City Arrivals 98% Poor Foster City Arrivals 2% Foster City Arrivals Score 4.91

SFO Total Foscter City Arrivals 4,247SFO Average for Successful Foster City Arrivals is 9%SFO Average for Marginal Foscter City Arrivals is 90%

SFO Average for Poor Foster City Arrivals is 1%SFO Average score for Foster City Arrival Rating is 5.42