Following this cover page are scanned images of no-opposition summary judgment motions and ordersfiled on the selected date. The documents are displayedin no particular order. However, all of these documentsare searchable.

To find a specific order, please use the Search/Findfunction within a PDF viewer.

1) Select Edit > Find in the main menu or press Ctrl-f(Command-f or Apple-f on a Mac);

2) Enter the index number, a word, or a phrase in the formfield provided and press Enter or Return.

In most applications, the first appearance of the indexnumber, the word, or the phrase in the document will behighlighted.

Tip: Ctrl-f opens the Find function in most applications,including browsers and PDF viewers.

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY OF NEW YORK

NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

Index No.: 190501/13,ROBERT WALSH

ANDJOAN WALSH

IN RE: NEW YORK COUNTYASBESTOS LITIGATION

NYCALLA.S. Part

------,~----------,--------~ (l'·\o.A.\ ~~,~\t)This Document Relates to:

WHEREFORE, defendant, Courter & Company, Inc., hereby requests summary

judgment in the above entitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules § 3212, dismissing

plaintiffs' complaint against defendant, Courter & Company, Inc., with prejudice in this action,

and there being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant, Courter & Company, Inc., be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and

without costs.

York

---=~~--f------J 20l'Attorney for Plaintiff(s)Robert Walsh and Joan WalshLEVY KONIGSBERG, LLP800 Third Avenue, 13th FINew York, New York 10022(212) 605-6200

--~-=-=:::----'-----lI'---'---H-.JC.--=~/'~Attorney for DefendantCourter & Company, Inc.MCGNNEY & KLUGER, P.e.80 Broad Street-Suite 2300New York, New York 10004(212) 509-3456

WON. PETERH. MOULTON

IIJdex No.: 190501113

~o OPPOSITION SUMMARY,JUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

: NYCAL,j'LA.S.Part'5Dj (M~lil~l.)' .

ROBERT WALSHAND

.JOAN WALSH

This Document Relates to:,

, SUPREME COURT OF, THE STATE OF NEW'YORK, ," . - - - --COUNTY OF NEW YORK '.IN RE: NEW YORK COUNTY

ASBESTOS LITIGATION "'"

~, ..

WHEREFORE,gefenrlant, Flowserve Corporaticm;hereby requests summ~ry judgment

in the abov~ entitled C:~e"pursuanr 'to Civil Practice Law Cl l1d R~Jes § 3212, disluissing'

plaintiffs' coirip!.~int ~gainst defendant, FJowserve Corporation, with prejudice in this action,and

there being rio ~ppo,sition thereto,

ORDERED, t!)at ~pon notice to aJlco-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant, 'Flowser\:,e Corporatton, be and the sCime ani hereby dismissed with prejudice and

without costs. '

Amber K'Long; Esq.Attorney for I'Iaintiff(s)Robert.Walsh and JoimWalsh"LEVY KONIGSBERG, LLP800 Third Avenue, 13IIl FINew York, New York 10022(2 I2) 605-6200 "

-Laura B. Hollman, E q;'AttorneY·for Defendant,Flowserve CorporationMCGIVNEY'& KLUGER, P.c.80 Broad Street-Suite 2300New York, New York,l0004(212) 509-3456 '; .

SO ORDERED, ~.~"'\~~, ',~.rEfERH.MOULT~N4

I"

/..

, .

".

"~

:'.

.'"--.

,. ,

(','."

. '.'.

......, j.""

1

1

1

1

·1• '. 1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

" 1

1

1

1

1

1

1

'I

1

1

1

1

1

1

JI

,I

,I1

1

1

1

,I

1

1

'I

1

1

1

,I

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

,II

:' f",f

):t,

'. -.

." :':": ,,:; ,~. '1'-./1 i :.:;),:;)::! .?, ':'" '! i ;';1.'1:1::1.",'-" ;:;,

,.., '" ,,: ,'." :,; ;'::1'::'.""7.1;::: il} I'

.• ~I .~~ I.,f - ,~:~, ::"".- i >

~ .' :OJ: "I .',' ,:r,.; _:~-::",; ;'._ ,

-..

<:

, .,

1'"

, ,

~. ''',-....

. I~ -

WHEREFORE,defend~nt, Jenkins Bros., hereby reC)uests summary judgment in the

above entitled t\a:se>p~5)liantto·Civil Practice Law and ~ules§ 3212, dismissing plaintiffs',. .. .,:.-. ", ~ -', '.~: ' . ; ..

complaint against cief~ndarit, Jertk~ns Bros., with prejudice in 'this action, and there'being no

opposition thereto,

ORDERED, 'that upon, notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant, -Jenkiris Bros,., be and the same are hereby dis~issed with prejudice and without costs.\ '

Dated:New~~ York.( '. ,2015·

. .~' :'. '",

r~ . ~-

\_- ti~l~'Patti Burshtyn; Esq; , ,Attorney for ~liiirttff(s)Richard G. 'S~ith;'WEITZ & LUXEN'BER«(P~C.' ,

• '. , . ..' ~:';:' ., •• ".. '4-"

700 Broadway"''';,..:. >:'New York, New¥ork 1-0003(212) 558;.5500" . '.

-~ . -.' . ,~~ 7':~. .,'j

~ ..

", .

,"

i",'

""- .;~

9."'t:-~:.:):~'~· "C."

,',

!

'"

;..

, , .T'

: ' .. .'

'/'

Index No.: 190303/13

NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

ALEXANDER RIVERA

AND

NYDIA RIVERA

IN RE: NEW YORK COUNTY

ASBESTOS LITIGATION

This Document Relates to:

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY OF NEW YORK .

NYCAL

LA.S. Pa~5D(Moulton, 1.)

-------------------;

WHEREFORE, defendant, BonsaI American, f/k/a W.R. BonsaI Company, Improperly

pled as BonsaI American, Inc. Individually and as Successor to W.R. BonsaI Company and as

successor Pro Spec f/k/s Permalastic Products, hereinafter referred to as BonsaI American, f/k/a

W.R. BonsaI Company, hereby requests summary judgment in the above entitled case, pursuant

to Civil Practice Law and Rules § 3212, dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against defendant,

BonsaI American, f/k/a W.R. BonsaI Company, with prejudice in this action, and there being no

opposition thereto,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant, BonsaI American, f/k/a W.R. BonsaI Company, be and the same are hereby dismissed

with prejudice and without costs.

Matthew D. Sampar, Esq.Attorney for Defendant

BonsaI American, f/k/a W.R. BonsaI Co.

MCGIVNEY & KLUGER, P.C.80 Broad Street-Suite 2300

New York, New York 10004 0(212) 509-3456 f \ \.. e.

~ ==-=- _. ~JJI//5 ~ \ 1 1\\\'iHon. Peter H. Moulton \A~ ER\(S Off\CE

..,-rt C\.. ~11COU" NE\N ,!u~~

SO ORDERED,

Attorney for Plaintiffs

Alexander Rivera and Nydia RiveraSEEGER WEISS, LLP

One William StreetNew York, New York 10004(212) 584-0700

':,.' .' .. :.,':-.', .....

.., .. ..,.• " • .!I

.,': '.~.

ELIZAB:E:TH RENO

1 IndexN6.:>i90oio/201,5,,1,

,

.: NO OPPOSITION SUMMARY: JUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

.: :.

t··

WHEREF'OlW, de(enaant, Dap, Inc., hereby requests su~ary judg~ent in the above

entitled case, pursuant. to Civil Practice Law and Rules§ 3212, dismissing'plaintiffs' complaint. . ~ . . . " . '. ..

, . ,.

against.defendant, Dap, Inc., with prejudice in this aqioh, and there being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED;, that uponno~ice to all co-defend~nts, all claims and cross claims against

defendant, Dap, Inc., be and ,the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and without costs.

JosephAttorney or lain!iff(s)Elizabeth RenoTHE WILLlAMSLAW FIRM,P.C.245 Park Avenue, 39lhFloor,New York,'New:YO'rk '10167(212) 668-1122 '

Caroi Temp¢sui; Esq,Attonwy fot DefendantDap~Inc:' :'MCGIVNEY & KLUGER; P.C.,80Broad Street-Stiiie 2300.N~w .York; New ybrkl 0004(212) '509<345'6' ! ',' "

SO ORDERED" ...~ ~"Ron:- Peter H. ,Moulton '"

; .~

"

, .. ;. " .... ;. i

"'"I:,:.

&1J:j'J~I~. i.

604-824

;" .'

. ~ .... _.~~:. '.; ,, ~'. ."...:... ...:",

,\\\

,? '(5',"CI.Ii.ll.\) '.!.!-~3;':'\\r.

., ...~-~~ ... "'.". .::.

4," •

, '-

'. _!.

j,

....:;:.

~.~,,,'~<.. < :. " ....'. .~. ::.: : .:.....':. 1"-: ~, .

. '.' - ~'., -. " .. ~

IN RE: NEW/YORK. COUNTYASBESTOS LITIGATION

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK.COUNTY OF NEW. 'YORK

NYCAL·LA.S. Part 50

_____-'-;- ~ (Mou1ton,~)

This Document Relates to:Index No.: 190070/2015

. ELIZABETH RENO: NO OPPOSITION SUMMARY[ JUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

. . .

WHEREFORE; defendant, The Fairbanks Company, hereby requests summary judgment

in the above entitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules § 3212, dismissing

plaintiffs' complaint against defendant, The Fairbanks Company, with prejudice in this action,

and there being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant, The Fairbanks Company, be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and

without costs.

Dated: New¥/iY.'~w YorkY-£ ,2015__+-+-UC-.lL--?

Maria J. Ciccia, EsqAttorney for Defen antThe Fairbanks CompanyMCGIVNE:Y & KLUGER, P.C.80 Broad ·Stteet.:Suite .2300New York, Ne\\' York 10004(212)509-3456

Joseph P. i S,l sAttorney for Plaintiff(s .'Elizabeth RenoTHE WILLIAMS LAWFIRM, P.C.245 Park Avenue, 39~ FloorNew York, New York 10167(212) 668-1122

SO ORDERED, ~.,,--'. Hon. Peter H. Moulton'

r::;/J illS' .I I

f , L E'9464

MAY' 2 20\5TV CLERKS OfFICE

, COUN NEW YORK

",,,"1

.'

(o'~~~.~'

.\\Q:,~\

\. \ i'.·'-"

\.r·

.'

.' ~"~.,..

.-' .

~', .

'.'":,., ~

, ~ "."

-, ',"-.; 'J,',-r::-

, ri;t::~.. l~iH:

",' .' ,#& ..WHEREFORE, defe,ndant; Kleet LUIT.lber Co., Inc., hereby El:lquests summary judgment

, ,- '% 'in the above entitled.case, .pursuant to C~~~l Practice Uiw and Rules' § 3212, dismissing

, ... '. ~,.' '~~$r: ".. " ~. "plaintiffs' C()~Dplainf againstdefendarit; Kleetl..umber Co.,,Inc;:, ~ith .p'rejudice in this action,and

.. • ~ '.. . I· .

there being no opposition thereto,

/

.,

~ ;.• <.~ •

,~, "

;.!'',t';

. :.

without costs.

ORDERED" th~t uponn9tic~ ·to all~;~~defendants;,'all c.lai'rns and cross claims against,.' " .".. ;, '>~ ;\~il\~::'" , . ',"

defendant, Kleet Luniber: Cb:,·lrtc., ,be 'and tli,e same are.he~·e~Ydi'smissed with prejudice and.' '~',' ' \{~;j " . ,

Dated: Nil../)rk, ~e.wYork'\ ',')1'., ..,' 201-5' .

SO ORDERED,

.f\,~~'lt~f' ..

Kat'don. " ..... i~ K·•.··e·f!,·.·l;.·..l¥.~." o·o'k', E's'q'-.~,-i1 _

Attorn.; for Plaintiffs:· .. . . '<\.tto~Augustus Nazzai·o and.P~t1:il:i,i.Na?za:ro ';:;: . Kleet)Lumber Co., Inc.NAPOLI, BERN,RIPKA,SHK~)I~NIK&A:SSqCIATES, LLP . MCGIVNEY'& KLUGER, P.c. ,Empire State Building' :';' ;[~k'80'BroadStreet-Suite 2300350 Fifth Avemie, Suite 7413.. ., New York; New York 10004

I~ • - f

New York, New YOI'kIO) 18 ..,. .,. (2i2Y'509~3456

(212) 267-3700' . /:"",: .: '. ~::' , . ':~~g . ',.,~~.~;,H·., "'q'll/IS ,

~~~'1?i.-I;~. ~.~(\ ~I" ., ;'E{) ..'RCJN.PETERJfMOV~•.J;N· . f \ ~, ..~..,''" .; '" <~ ~.~.~ ,,. '. '. . 1: 1,Wol9:0002

b~~ , . \4~'( \ .' 'ff\CE;tt .: ·cOlltl1'ltl~~~~~ ..~i~.):

~\~.:"

, : ~y." ,,~I :.. ,

." " :.... ~. ,~~...' ' ., ~': i

,-,1--'}"";'

io'-......

,',

........... 1"•••

....: ~

,~ ..

· ..... ;,

\',-

.,:'.

"

"'t'<,.-""

" ..

- ,'.~.,

, \;

'.' ,

,,.

'" ,\, .

'0,

'"

. !,..;.1

"

r._, '~.

"

",

'"

'\.,:

' .., ..

" '.

"'...,; A, , "r, ~ . '.

,';~7> -.• ,. .. ,.

' ..

, "'.,'

, ~'

" '~< "

.~, i-'.- 4" •

~....., .

.. 1',

, ,

j Index No.: ,190024/14;' . .":

: , ~ ....

: NO OPPOSITioN'SUMMARY.;!JUDGME~T.MOTION AND ORnER

STEPHEN R. MA~TINAND '

RACHELLE'MASTIN

SUPREME COURT OF TFI,-m~TATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY OF'NEW.Y0RKi .:.INRE:, NEW YORK COuNTY : NYCAL .' ,\. 1;'

..... \··".ASBESTOSLn!IGAtidN" . , .~. I.A.S':,P,art.3'6"~" c'

---=--:-----'-_:,__' '-=-:'--c.c':-c'~,..,..':e.-.,--_---'------'-',2...'~"_____~: (tyloulto'n;'1').This Document Reiaies to:"

.' ." ~..... " '.- .

...•.

opposition'theteto;' '

WHEREFORE, defe.qoant, Jenkins Bros., here~y r~quests summary' judgment in. the.·4{; ..'......'"

above entitled case, pursuant to Civil Pr~ctice Law and Rule~' §·\3212, dismissing ,plaintiffs''. ':: ~_ .,' .'.' . i • • ':?"" ~ ~' • ~ • •'. '

c6mpl~int againsf'Oefendant; Jehkins Bros.:' with prejudice:::ii}·'!his. actIon, and there, being' no. , . ..' , 4' • :~\ ..~:'" •. ,'\, . •

':,,#

0RI?ERED, th~t ..upo·n notice to all co~defendants,;<~H. c!aims and cross daims against< t:, .'~ ,',:.. ~\.' :, .:

."

.~ .'

. ,.

\ .

",

.."

.~: ,,..,"

. '. v.Laura ~. Hollmall, Esq.. ,Attomeyfor"Defei1dant .Jenkins Bros.

. MCGIVNEY'&KLuGER,P.C.·8~j3r~ad Streef.,Suite. 2300

, Nevy York, NewYork10004 ,,' ..; (212) 'S09·J456'·'i"· ,

. . .',:~,;

.~ .

Patti' Burshtyn, •Esq.'·..Attorney fof. Pl~intiff(s) 'N \ '.

Stephen R. MaStip an.~ Rachelle: MastinWEITZ & hUXENBERG,.P.Ci700 Broadw.~y;.,;\\ "~'. '.'New york,·Ne\\CYork:I0003 . ."(212)'558,.550W:··· ',.;. ',;'" .

.. ' : "

.defendant, Jenk.in,s.;Br6s., ·b~':and~the.saine·are hereby dl~Il).is~ed with'prejudice and without costs.. -. v' • •• ,'. : _\.\ ;.

' ../ ..

,.

., ". :;,: I'~, " " .~. : ..... .

" 'I• -. ". ~ >

:,.:;.t',". "

.i." ,•.•.,•.:-., .J: ,.

. ~\ ..\

..•. ,..... .1

',.,", .' ~ ..: ,"

.1-\,.:"}.-: c "

, I

"

, ,

~\.-.

.','

" ~.

,i,.

,>-::"",

.. ~ 'i..

; ;-'<t~'~~",j r

.~,

"

......

. ,~,

' .

' .... ,r

.. ~.

"1'

',. :}.':"

"

.:.... jo, •

.:j ""

... :~

~" ..

,.;.' !

to ,;-'.

"o'.;~~.:~,

.'.. ;.

.J!

.,~,

::'

..';l.;,

.~

" .~~: .

".~ -, :.

"

Y·.:.'

',1 . 6.~ ~~

'jr~~:

'. ."

, ~.,

, ~;..

: :

. ~ .'

",".

".

~i

'r .:;~r

\'

..~ .~.._-~.~,''',:",.;\1. ,#

. <

."..,. ;-~.;-.

.~ v_:

'+:' ~':

" . ~

'.u': .~..

;.{: ..\"'~

.-:.r;

):

j'

'.

.~,

~ ..'

" ~., '

~.

'"

- '1'.

..... f.'

.~ .:

.~'"

, ,.. ,

"~/'

~ , .. It'.... :~.!. ~;.. ".'~

>"

. ': .i {.

• -'1, r<!-l~}~r"J;?- ,• ~(i'

"

~ ,>:!"

.... .~.~

..'

;.

."

. ~",~, ",':~.

<to,

t:.. ,."F;.

'j'

,n

it,.~. ,

,,"

','" ,':' !

'C<"!

.~. ;..,

.-y~ , .~

".;' ..>::\'

" ."t·'

,,', 'J.. '. ::'~~ •

" ,~,

\ ,

J'::",

"fro.' .5 .;ioI.' ,.~~.

A: Y;::j,t~i

"'.;

.~ .' ,'\ ..

':J:.:'

",i >,

',",

,,~;, .~

~.1 .,:.'

.'

"

-', .

,f .~...

.. ~ i\.'j.'"

~~~t.

" .

",,;'.1

~', ~,-.,

, .~

J''~,~:."

~"

.......

, .

'f ~.~; .

,(, ..

'. .,", ·· ..!T . ~

~. ,,{,·,.f:.,n ::) .;, "

~ .",:-. ,.... (.

~...

. "~.'

' .....,,. ...:,.... ~,

',rI'

" ,

..... !

.i~':. i.,.'.. :."~.

~."

~~>. "/~. ;;":;'. ,I.

,'tl- ,.

t.. ,

';'<'

: -.,"

'.This Docurpent Relates .to: ..

Index No.: 19004~115

"

MARTINKQCHNO OPPOSiTION SUMMARY .

o JUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

,

WHEREF()RE~ defendant; Jenkins Bros., hereby requests summary judgment in the above. ~. .. . ~. . .

entitled case,p~sili;k.,to ;Ci~ifi>f~ctice Law and' Rules §.'3212,dism:lsSing. plairttiffs complaint ... . ~"I..;~j~~>. :. J '~'. :;"" • '.~,.' .~ '.' .' '.,. -'.

against defendant~Jeri1lliisBfos., with prejudice and there b~fug no opposition thereto,

ORDERED;' that upon 'notice to all co-defendants; all claims and cross ,claims against\ '

r . .

defendant, Jenkins Bros., ble and the same are hereby dismissed"with prejudice and' without costs.. . -. ; ~ . . . -' ,

. , ; -'-' ' . ,,~

WEITZ & LUXENBE~G,P;C. 'Attorneys for Plaintiff' ':Martin Koch ".'700 Broadway... .'. . .New York; NewY6t:k.dOO.o3 / ....(212)558-5500··> -'.,.;" .. ' ,.

Laura B,' H~lIinan, lSq:MCGIYNEY &'KLUGER, P,C.Attorrieys fOf D6fendantsJenkins Bros. ' .80' Broap Street - 23rd.FloorNew York, New York 10004(212) 50?-3456 .' .

SO ORDERED, -,.....-,.'~7-"";;;;J;-'"~'.~._~~.'_.'"_'__. __~----'-'~.__.:......::::;~j!//.(&.... Z Hon. Peter H. Moulton .

2979-0040

... ,- .:~.p

I'. t.

. "

"'. .~ :.

I'

,;. "

" ..... :. .- .. ,

~...., '.

'.j;.. ..

.' ~ ,

"

"'-4i"':L~;

("".~:

.", "

·i;

.'

', .

. /' ~ ..

..

,f

Index No.: 19'0044/15

'.~ ,"'. ~.. , -; -.'

, \.,;',' ,:'

.;'.

. ~. <.

", ; ., ,

This Doct,iment Relates to:'"

.. (

MARTIN KOCHNO OPPOSITioN SUMMARYIDDGMENi MOTION AND ORDER

. '.

WHEREFORE, ,defendant, Tishman Liquidating Corporation, hereby requests summary.. ~ '. -' ... . .'.

, judgment in ~he; ~bo~e erifMed'case/putsuant to ,Civil ;practice:'Law,~d' ;Rules' § 3212, dismis~iIig

plaintiff's complaint ag~instgefendant, Tishman Liquidating Gorporation, with prejudice and there.'. - ',' ~ .. . ".. ,,. r. .. '

being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED,: that 'upo:n 'n()t~ce to all co-defendants, '~all, claims and' cross claims against

defendant, Tis~~ Liquidat~ng' Corporation, be. and the same are 'hereby dismissed with" ." ,.

prejudice and, withou{cdsts:.:' ".1: .

.~ ~ .... '

, I

WEITZ & LUXEN'BERG .p~<i. ::' .,'.', . ' ......:". .' -. ~., . . .' ..i .'

AttomeysJor Plajntiff .'f"·"

Martin·Koch. /' .~';,.~"'.. '700 BrOlidway '\', -.:New York,;New York 100,03(212) 558-5500 ,.'

. "

~. . - . .

~~MCGI'{NEY:~ KLUGER, P.c.AttotO¢ys f<?~ D.efendants .

, Tish.ina~'Liq:uldating C<;>rporation80 Broad Street'~ 23rd FloorNew Y~rk, New York 1'0004(212) 509~3456

!,) ....

...;,

'.~' '. .. . .~'~ .,

~ . ".

":\' .

.~ ....... ."

I .....

" .

f\LED2383;.30A6\S

~~'( lL I;'Off\CE, TY CLERKS ,. ,

COUN, NEW yORK,' , '

{N0400137cI} " ,,:

'\

~~~---\ \:;.1.,.\. . .

\ ,',1·

~,...

..

,,

I.

"

.,,

"

.t.

~' ,

--: .

i

,;.

I:;

"

, e

'.

, .

;'.,.

. :;~, .

"

..'.

'.

"'l '.'- .

,.I,'?

? .

)

) .

.-. -.~:, . ",,'

, .."

-- ..'("." ) ,,'; ~'

: ,

\UP.~ME.'C~:0RT. q~, rHE ~~ATE OF NEW YORK ,. .:~ ,COUNTY OF NEW YORK ' 'IN RE:,NEW YORK COUNTY" ' : NYGAL" '.

·AsiiESTd'S;~LtfIGATi©N·· ' {A:S~ pJrt 50; .• '. .' . \ .!. ~ , • ., (.' • ~ • ,.•' ., " . ' "' ..'. •

.. ':.';'" . . (Moulton"t) .

Ihdex No.: f90044/15

• '!,.

......

MARTiN KOCHNO OPPOSITION SUMMARY .JUDGMENT'MOTION AND ORDER

,~; '. . -.

WHEREFORJ;:, .defendant, Atwood & Morrill Company, hereby requests summary

judgment in the ~hove"etititiedcase, pursuant to Civil Practice 'Law and Rules § 3212, dismissing.' .",".

plaintiffs complairifagainst defendant, Atwood & Momll Company, with prejudice and there being

no opposition thereto, ". :

ORDERED, that: upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant, Atwood &3v{orrill Company, be and the same 'are hereby dismissed with prejudice.~ .".:, ' ~

and without costs.

. ~ ,

963-2369

,"F'I'l E D. MAY 12 2015

COUNTY CLERKS OFFICEINEWYORK '

-McoIVNEy:&;KLUGER, P.C.Attorrieysfo~ Deien'da~ts .Atwood & Mo~rill Company80 Broad Street - 23rd FloorNew Y9rk:: New York 10004(212) 509~3456

"',r:

, ~\,,' '.',I ~. ';' .

WEITZ & LUXENBERG;'·P·.C.Attomeysf6rPI~lntif{~'; ,Martin·Ko~h .. '. ,. ..".':''., '" ,700 Brmidway,>i. J,;., \ .... :. :

New York; Newyork·r0003(212) 558-5500,:' .'

. .'. ":";:",'~;::,::>~J_,:>:.".. " .SO ORDERED;";"~;" .' .--.

'.: '. ··~~<t,~·.?~~~:-pet~f;H.Moulton ':

{N040013 1-1 }

Dated: Ne~,k.'!rY~r,~," ;.l ,';:",2015 -. .'

. '''r,'':,·· ".. ." .

II "'. I:J'r f;,,~~

:'

,',

.-

Q"J"

~ ':,~. 1·;

-:" , .... J '"';' . iJIc I..

..;...?,~"'~.'::<.:,', 't~'.~

~ . $\': .i;: ,: ';f~... l'~':~: ~

~ " '.

.r.- ,-' ,.,_

-.

:~ .

".

, '-,".,

" .~

;, '" -',

. ! ,"\

. ~(

':.

SUPREME cotJlri~6F:THE:STATEolfNEW"YORKCOUNTY OFNEW.YORK·· . . . ....,.'

" ' .... ' ',y' "

~~----------------~~~---~---~--~~~0-~-'~~-~~~------~----------->eIN RE: NEW,YORK:CUY:' .' N¥CAL

ASBEstO$I)ITIGAnON, • .... ~ c;· •

---------------;.-.:.-----'..;---~~~-..:-~-.;.~.;~----:--:.~-------'7-----:~-x: ~"", .~ '""':"" .->:"" ..

This Document Relates.To: • :, Iftde>e No,:'196424~ 13~ c'.

' ..'-..

',;;,

~" ..

'. >

PETER RiCCI and MARIA RICCI, .. NO OPPOSITION"SUMMARy JUDGMENTMOTION"AND ORDER

---------------------~---~-~---~~---~------------------------->e, ~ 0 t' "

WHEREFOR:E.;·defepdant:Pneumo Abe>e LLC, successor in:interest to Abe>e Corporation" " ,,/, - ,'. (i -.' , ", , . ,:. \-,~ " ",

'. .

. (hereinafter'"Abe>e");;hei~~}'. reg~e~t's ~unimary judiment i~ the. ab9ve,,~ntitledcas~, pursuant to,. .. '. .. ,~'". .", ", '.'" " "

Civil Practice Law ahd:Rui~~'Section 3212, dis,rriissirtg'Plaintiffs' 6o~~laj~tagainst Abe>e, with, ' r;;~:.': . "";," - . . '.

. ~ .

prejudice, there be'ing:no. opp~sitibn thereto,

ORDERED, that-lIpon notice to all co~deferid~nts;all ~l~ims.an~rcross·clairris against", . . ~, . , . .' _:': ': '.' :~.-

f'l'l eO'·MAY' r2 2015".

COUNTY CLERKS OFFI~E. . NEW YORK ',"'.:

::.. " ,.. J.,..... ,

-,

'""

.,., "

G •

.- .. ;.-,

,~. '.

u' -";'- ,

\. ~

11047615v.2· .

Abe>e, be and are here,py.disinissed with.prejudice ,and without~'~osts.'·Dated: /frt.'7=>r1:>~" 2~i'5 '.- ....~.:..:'.' ~" .....

NewYo~~eewYork> . . . ~~.~.~~".;..__--------~.

~.'-"',' " ,:.~, • " ~ . -'~--:-;;-f.~f--"-'-----,,-----'-'=.'-""""--'-----'--

Chris Romanell~,Esq~:... ,. ,Alfre(i}.lSargentei/12sq, ......' . .' .WElTZ. & LUXENBERG, P;c.,. ., .~WKn.ffiJ~ARNELL'THACKSTONAttorneys for PlaiQtiffs, ' - -., .- & YOUNG ,LLP700 Broadway' .. ;..... .AttoI'ney's for.l)erend~mt,·· .New Yo'rk; Ny'l 0003 ;,,: .' '., Pneumo 'Abex'-LLC;:, Succe~sor iihiilter~st(212) 558-5500, 't to AbexCorpor~tion .'

. .' . 600 Le>eirigton. Ayenpe', 8~ Flo9r....., New York, N~wY()rk 10022-7678

(212)'~97~96~5" 'Ii", • L, ~

'.

I .

" ,',

. -'.. ',-'. :.- ,.;,.}

.' ~.< . "

INRE '

" ,

. ". ,;V :

NYCAL "

':J.A.S. Part 50'

, " .-, .

----............:.~;'_"_----'----'__:__-__:__-,-,------:---__,x· '. '

, .~

. ~'''t

Estate. of RICHARD J.P.EN"ESKI. -..,-".

.., :i-." ",';

IPodex No. 190552/12

NOOPPOSITION., ,,", , ,

, SUMMARY JUDGMENTMOTION AND ORDER

----~----'__:__---,'-.,-'--'--:-=----------~-x

WHE,.(u:FQ~/tief~n~antReynolds Metals Cornptmyhereby requests summary,. .- , " .'. ~", ',. ~ ..

.. ' . : '", . . ' .judgment in1he~bQ:y,~entit1edcase, pursuant to Civil PracticeL~wand~ules Section 3212,

" ';:". ". ':' .'\. - - :,.' '. .

dis~issing,.p'lairt,tiffs' 'cornpJaint against Defendant Reypolds Metals Company, with prejudice,I '~~

and there being no opposiji9)1' thereto, it is•• 1 '-'" ,,' .

., t" _ '1/- "

. ',': . -' "," "::1:'(.' . ".. > .' . . . f': '. '... 'ORDERED, thafUponnotic,e. to.all·co-defendants, aU'claims and cross claims against

. . .'. . .

"~'I

defendant, Reynolds Metals, Company, h~ and the same are hyrebY',di~missed~ithprejudice arxd..,~' .. .." .,'. . . . ... ~

.-,< .:.:"

.' '~.

Michael}. Curt:is" Esq: ,MALAB¥&,BRADLEY, LL(:

150 Br.QadwaY;'Suite 600New York~'NewYork1:0038Attorneys jor:jji/endant(212) 79'~70285

:OJ • \

;, .

\ ..' ." .

"

Dated:

without costs.

Frank Ortiz;Esq~' ,', OJ,,

WEITZ & LUXENUEliG:' PC '700 Broadway;" " .' " '

New York, New¥orkj10003·Attorneysjor'Pidifztijj(~) ,(212) 558-5509,'),,;":'

I

(

Dated: _:-T-'--+-<----:-------

. , " . ~'

so ORIiBJ{]OJ;);~': ==,~ " ":'Hofr;·:::pefer"H'.;"Moulton

,::' '1' ~,-' . .. \'. ". f "J "'~" -' j '.

'. "<. ',':0,

'"

.,\ ,,t,' .;...

, .).-:,J>""

'\.,'

... .-,'0 "

, ',~ ,

" ~

.~.'"

;,,~ "

,.'.-'

.~" "

' ....

, f

",.".

p",

-{,.I"'; "

.1

.'

;, ,

.''~".

"

'.':

,"

"

, ~,{

.:.

1""'-['

.,' ..

: ...., .

'"

,,'

.,

. ::>,

"

'.' .'

.',..'t.

\'",

.. '

"".

,";.,,'

c''''"

"

.:'0">-

",1-'

,',,"

' ....

'.i

...If,. \

,~jl " '" ~I"\';, '• " ':W'~ ,;."';'",.:;,}!l>,,,-,, ." : ~- ......,'J~":,~,,,.

~,y, ,lUll' ...",~

~ , ' ,, ,~ .

,.' '':';'~

,.~,>~"

','

~- 0.':

,,',

~', c'" i', ~,'

.,'0

<'"

,I

;,/

"i'" ~ ..

,',: . ". •...... v ."'";~i~:~~«!

SUPREME.<;0URT,OFTHE·STATE di NEW y;6RK\,D;~·,~:· ,COUNTYOF'NEWYOID<.·, '.. ,,0 lp'b,~,tk~;',>

IN RE " 'i,' '. .'.'" li:,~,'.:.,·.~,}.J,~.~.·~.,.•..:,.•.·.:..,N~I:'::'A'Y''~..•·~Si!·,A.~.,.,'p·,L'art·,'i•..·..,§'. 0·rE;~r;~(,j)~CITY::'·, ,, ASBESTOS LITIGATION

",

.' f'.'}' .

, "\

;.

. This DocumentRelates to:,

, . ~ ~~ .

:' c,"~------'-''-,---~-'----'--~------~'.x.':..' ,

, :;,:rnd~~ No. 190034115

WA~TER ANDREWS,;~andGERALDINE ANDREWS .' ~NO OPPOSITION". SUMMARY JUDGMENT

.. ' MOTION AND' ORDER-------'--~,·-----------x,

" './ ·.:,i'" ,,'.: ", .WHEREFORE, Defendant Reynolds Metals Company, 'hereby ·requests summary

, :., ~ ~. '.

judgment irt ~e~~b6~~ entitled case, pursuant to Civil Pr~~tice ~La\VandRules' Sectio~' 3i12,- .... ,_., ',",'

dismissing Plaintiffs',complaintagainst Defendant Reynolds'Nfetais Company, with prejudice,

and there being rio opposition thereto, it is,.. ,.

ORDERED, th~fuponnoticeto all co-defendants; aU: cl~irii.s· cuid cross claims against... '., ~'~

, .,',

defendant, Reyn6IdsM~talsCompany, be'and the'SaIi1eareh6feby dismissedwlth prejudice and~". 0

'. ~;:

without costs. "

Dated: Nework, New York.;.J . ;2015

~.-: ...ll<t<'"' .. .' !

- ,\l-.' 'J;,(: " . ,.1,:1 ,·i,., ' ' .

\";~,,;;:s,~.;;'.',~':' :'.,~:-" ... ,~ ,.'.','.: .,' .. :. . :: .'<1':1~, ::'~'r",o.; 0.,:;,< • '

,;Mi9'la$;VJ',};,;un~.~,Esq.MALAB¥~:& BRADLEY, LLC1'50B~~~d~ay:,S~it~600New.Y6tK;~New'Yorls' 10038Attorneysj~~ Defrmda~t(212) 791-0285'

.:,.t" •

" .." ,

i"\ :

.. .'

"" ,A'

. . .; ~."

SQORDERE~.-'-'-;H~,:...:c..!~.:..-'::.:-~--"-'~I-iO-O-~-·'. ated:_'--"-'--",'~'-+tc!..J.I)+f,...:..o-J~='·~·_:-'=f..----..r L E.·..... D.: 0\ 0" .... .';_

MAY , t 20\5:,'COUN~ CLERKS OF,FleE..

N~WYORK

, ' .... " '.. • '~', .f :.

,,"

.~ .. ":./;"'''.'''0- .

. t,

t':: ... '.~. ,",'

-, !., .. ~ -~ ~ ,:,;.

".,

• -!" ....1_· ..• ,

~ .!','

,I ','

·1~~: ,I,

"'- .I'."

"M:);.~;' I' .... ,

:r,.

.;: ::, : ..~ :' 1'~ .! ,~~. 'c '

:- ~;,·l , . ; ~

"'il

'"

r.,

...

,/

.....,,;. . /', .-

- :,.!/:' .. ,

,,'

,,''.,

....,. ,l;.' :l;."~ ~,'~\ ". - "I;~' \';', . -",;,

". .... c'

1',.

~.

.-.' ~ .

..'.... "

:~'. .~.'

, ,'';;

, ." ,

......I.'

'"yO:,;'7"- t,"\...',~·~,>d t.. '1 .... • :"t~·~·~~

'l'j ~I

J'(

~ "

I, .I

......

.-~

./ ....l!...

> .'. ~(.. ' :' .,

.. '

.r,·

,.'.

,"'.",

c,

;.; .,'

'"

,, ,~ ...

I ~ •

:, /:~.:'...>': ;

.. ' .{ " i· ~ ~

. . }~<i'

. r"~ •..

.:':;:~·it:· :..: :'.~

:'1

.;

'., ..

'.~: ­-;

::... ":

....

~ ~.i) ~,'

~~.;~.~: . t1

'"

t/;"".' !~ " ~\....

\~,:i ..

,i- .,"-.'~ .. ~., 'J-" .,'

,.','

. t

'.. SUPREME COlJRTOF THE.STATE OF NEW YORK

"'., ,"'" . "\

COUNTY OF'NEW.YORK. ..

INRE ~E'W:¥ORK'etfY '. . .,'-~' .

, ASBESTO.sLITIGATION;", ~: J.-". ."' •

,.' ·.X.

". ·.NYCAL

LA.S. ~art 50

--,----~"---'--~--'---------------'X

.This Documerif'Reiat~~;t~,:.,1 ~i".'.,

: ~<., "f ', .HER¥AN H. ~RE~.SE[;·alld FRANCOISE BRESSEL

. :','..

Inde~ No. 190112110

.NO:OPPOSITION .'

SUMMARY JUDGMENTMo.TION AND ORDER.,:

"------~----'-,.....-----------x

,- , _,I

:"', \..WHEREFORE', Defendant Reynolds Metals Co~p~y hereby requests summary \

. ,'- " , . ' - ., "

j'udgment in the ab?~~.'.~rititledcase, pursuanfto' Civil Pr~~tice.Law ~<:1: Rules Section 3212,..".,

"

dismissing Plai~tiffs;··comptaint.agains~DefendantReynol?s;Metal~Company',with prejudice,' .

and there being' no:oppo~itibP. thereto, it is"<. ..": ~ ,,: i". . . . '. ,-.

ORi>EREi)~;:tlf~tJJP9n n9tice to all c~-,defendarits; all claims and cross claims against, '. '" ~.' ·.>~!;:t.:·: ..: . ,'.' . '" '. ....... ....;, . .

defendant, Rey:no~g~tM:~.tals¢ompany, be and the sarii\8~'are her~bydismissedwith prejudice and.. ., . " . ,..- ~ ',.",' . ~ . ~ .

without costs. . . .;,.::,,:,, .. c'· " , '~'~'). ~ .

. ",'.'

Dated:

Frank Ortii~.£~~{;:~·;:.,:, .WEITZ &.tJ)iJXENBE~G;.PC700 BroadWay.'>.:...};,;,':-:'" ;

.. _ " "', i~~r/.\ ... ,..•. '.' /t., ',f . ".'.~:, /:

New York,New:~O'rK~:t0003' ,. ',', ".1 ".',1' '. ,,,> ...~;' ''Jt''J>\(~~,)~'

Attorneysfor.'P?pin~iJJ(st . .,(212) 558-5500-

•• ~ c ··ott'··· ".? '

, '.: .';-'i',"" " ,. ':',:~

.:' '.' .. '~~"

:,". Mic.ha~J J~,:Cyrtis, E~g.'·MA;LAJj¥·& BRADLEY, LLC

.15Q Broadw~y, Suite 600.New:y~tk,;N~wYork 10038:,AttorYi~j;ijor Defe~dantCi1,2r79:i~0285

., :'

' ... .'

. . ."~ , I

... i', " (.

' ..' ..'.: "

SO o.RnERED~-::':c:'"7:"··';-'''''''':'''~-'''-:-''':'----·-'Dated: _.-=·f;,..,."J..........!J/-+-"t_IS-:=.., _, ,." ...".. "',' '.", "'/"',. ' "". I ,.,

·'-'Horl'~Peter,H.··Mol:i:1t6n·· " E'' 0. /,'c'" .,.""., F l'L',..;,·· ....

. .MAY \ 2)0\5 ',; ."'COUNTY CLERK~:OfFICE,· "

NEW YORK

t:

,.1.'

,;

'J '

, ,

.:.

, ,'" ,

• ,~. 'i "-,

"

·1

.'

".-'.

" ,, '

.....,,I

~ '. '.

,.-

"

'. ~:

,-,

, ,. ';. .",,,,

.....

.... " ,.' ,;,; l

, ,

,"

< ", ~

" '

',I

tl

',I

: .... .'I

,""(0

, "

,:",

;.t.

~., .

,;,~ . :,~.:j:­

~~1f~.·';

'1...'"

"

ii, "

:,'

"

'.<" .~

_.' '1<1.'

,..... :", .~

,~. '.

.:, "

.::

..,

\','

"'..

"

"',·d.>~ ;,-,~.~

"+

':.

"-'"

'.t.:

\'

• ~'1, •

, .... 'I r , •.. ~ .

".'> .

. '--:....-~------:.;-,·-.:··---;,·,.,..:.,-"------------x

This.Doc~ent Relates to:....

EDWARD DELUCA· ". " .. '

.1••

";}:.<",'.:.'"

, / "'i

NO. OPPOSITION'"SUMlVlA~~::;rUbGIYIENTl\:10TIONAND ORDER

--~---'-~~-'-----.----------x

W:ilER:EFO~,D~fendantReynolds·Metals Coriipany p.ereby requests s~'ary.... '.' , "

judgment in'th~ ~bJ~~;~~ntitied case, pursuant to Civil Practice:La~ arid Rules· Section 3212,. .. ',' ,..' . ~:l.: ". . .

; .. "' ..

dismissing Plaintiff~' complaint against Defendant Reynolds,Metals'Company, with prejudice". ~ , . .

and ,there being 'no bpPosition. thereto, it is, ..

ORDEREI>,that upon notice to all co-defendants,. all clairrisan~cross claims~ga:inst·;': . 1 - : I

, "

defend~t, R~~olds)rvietal~Company, be and the s~e,are ·h.~~eby :disrriissed ~ith prejudi~e and". . ..~ . ',\' . .

", ,"

, "

without costs.

,",

, ' Michael'J:,Cufti(;Es~. , .'',MALABY'& BRADLlj}Y, LLC,';. 15!0;B'rdadw~y" Sui!e60'O .' '

'. New Yo*; New York. 10038. Atto.rney~,ifd~D~!endani, '

(212) ~9,1,-0285;: '",.,"

, .:

. . .. ...... " ": f.' . ".J • I ~:.' • ~

ew York;;New York,."'~;\ ''''!':''$(. ;'20 l'S '

.' "":-"", .:.~:.;~:~, ." "';".:~'; './.•"r,- '.

", .........Dated:

Frank Ortiz,.Esq. .WEITZ & 'LUXENBElfG,PC .

: ,'. ' . : :-~ .'. :.: ,'.. ;: '

700 Broadway . ':,' ,.",:;. ',", :.',

New York, New"Yoil{;19003AttorfJeys!or.,Plaintljj(s) ·· ..1

(212) 558-5500:' '

f'\ LE,D, MAY' 7.' 20\5 .

.' , .. TV CLERKS OFfiCECOtJN NEW "YORK .:,.

,,'

,'" 'C;;lh'l;/ s-" I

Dated:--'----'-+--'-''-I-'~----

j .;.-

.-

!', ,j

. ' / -

.: ' . .j', .' ~ "

'" '

"~'..

......,i' {~

,-

' .... '

i'..\ ,/:'

-",'" ,

.,,";.,

, .....

;.

,.- ~"

'.'

,;1

.','

, •• j

./

...;

"

: '.

"

.;

. ;~ .

··f,

:'~ ..

" I

.-'.r

....

,:.:

, .~ ;

..,I:

•.••,j.

I .

.,

'.'• :1.',',

';'

. '.

:;'

-,

.1

.~.

~;.:~ ..;"'. ,,', >'~;",\"."!

'.

'<.' "

. 'it.:·, "

... ~' ;.

~ ..'}:' ,

'J "',\

. :.',~.- ,,:\,;, .;'" (.' ,,', "-

. ..... •:;' ~. +' " ~ ~

, ~: .,"'" " . . ":. ,,~~.~; . '

•• ..". ~ ... ~ J

IN RE: NEWYORK~C6UNIY·ASBESTOS' ~lTIGAnON

This Document Relates to:

'.NYCAL

S' . ?:t<' c- (JLA.. Pattl'v U

.(HeiUet; J.) . ,

Index No::.oI90276/2014

DAVIn HARRISON.... ,.NO OP·POSITION SUMMARYroDGMENT MOTION ANDORJ)ER:," .

WHE~~bRE, defendant Union Carbide Cofp9ratic;m:', he;~by requests summary

judgrnent-in thehbove-entitl'e& case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212,

dismissing plaintiffs ~omplaint against defendant Union. Carbide C9rporation with prejudice,' .. ,,'

and there being no"9PPClsition' thereto" .~'. ' '

ORDERED,' that"upon notice to all co-d~fe~dants; all claims and cross ,claims 'against .

defendant Union Carbid~ 'Corporation be and the same are hereby :dismissed with prejudice and

without costs.

. Dated: NewYork, New York·

i/d:./ .. .,2Q15

r~ -=>" ......·~~r:~1~~:~~~' '~··~~~~:\tt1.~t;~i~<iyA~Ti&·~i~lJ.·LLP.Attorneys for Plaintiff, . ~ .'. Attomeys"fo{Uiiibri'Carbide Corporation' .19500 State Highw~W249,: Suite 4.20 . 116 Eiist27~h Street, 12th Floor'

. Houston, TX77'0.70 New'York, NY 10016' .(28]) 970-9988' (21~) 45,2-5JOO

.' .'. :

S00Jl.DERl!D,,: >If&-.:....:...:~~.. -:~--.-..-.~ ..... -f;/JIJlS, ,' ... <./.::~::~ ..~~I~itler .,9.""'-~,

.,', :·;.~::.~ ...~~.t.MOVLTQN':·,~ ,

,'•. " :1

, !:'.

" -

: ,

.""

" .:,S" .

", "'.

, ".,'. ~',

,? .

'. ,

'<i,

, '

.."

.',

'" .'\ ' ' ,: ~

.,

.,'.

t·,' ',>

..•..

: ;;, ~, :......

",

,1-4

. ~-

-...

, "

"

...1" "..

0'· ,"

'.

.:'?

:'~!/\;'.... ~~~:

:'I·.t~"

IN RE NEW YORK CITY','ASBESTb'S LITIGA~ION

-------'------'-'---'---'-----------,x ';

NYCAL,

., .. ;:

, ."1':

GEORGE WALSH andE'II:.EENWALSH," " .

" 'PI~intiffs,

'A.O,SMITH W,A:rER'P,~o.qUtTS Co.;'et,al., incld:ding":BLA'tKMER,,' ':':2:',';"" .\~., ' " .,'

I>.} , ',,,'

Defendants:

---------'-'-----,-'-----,-----,-----,----'----'----,--x" : ,: '1

.,". ,

, Inde~ No. 190037-2015

NO OPPOSITI,ON

SUMMARY JUD:GMENT MOTION

:AND ORDER·t

.-',,'

" '

WH EREFORE;:defenda,ntBlack'm'erhereb'y ;eq!..l~;ts surn\:n~ry judgm'er'lt in,the above-'':- , ' . . .~ ., " . \" .. . , ' . .

entitled case, pursuan't. t6"E!Vil Practice LaW an:d,R~:I~k :s~!:tI6n'i212, dismissing plaintiff's

complaint against def~hd,ariJ'BI~ckmer with pr~'udicei a'~'~;'th~r~:,pei~gno OPPo~ition thereto,

ORDERED, ~hat,;~'~p~nj':~oti~e to ~II co-de~enda'hts,all':tlai~~andcross claims against

defendant Blackmer b~:~~dthe same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and without costs.~ ..' r. ,

~ .. ';

Dated:

, ..,

WEITZ & LUXENBER'G;:P;C>, ~".'"

Patti Bu rshtyn, i Esq '. " ,: '"700,Broadway, ;;:, ",

. ':.. ~ . " :

New York· New York 1Q003.·,. "',' {.":r',,;..'·.'''~~'.,, '':;..t .',::.

Attorneys forJJ/aintiffs;,·,j,~., ,,':,:' ,". .;-,.': "'.:;:: I' ,.,'r".fo':·p·.; '.,

Geqrge and. f.i!.~en"Wa"sh;,'" '(212) 558-550b~' '" ::~<;\\:, ",,';

", " "

. ", ,J,'j')':::~-" . '. 't

SO ORDERED,~'« '.Jt~ .

, Hon: p,~ter H: M.~ultbn

" .I\iIA~B'y':~':BR,A'DLE''(,' LtC,

" :, :"'" ,< ': " :-, • ~,

'. ',~ .

,,~ ,

I " ',

...... "

',.'~ .

, .....;

" . .; ';,! .:. "I,

.:,:' .; .

. r ~

..~. ~...,',

'," .,' ;.....:r

.. ;.',

:.-,> ....

~ .,

'1,,,,,(,,,

. '.'~~"

''',I

'.. 1..: "(:,.f,:i"

'T', ~ ,

, .,'.- ~"

'''\''~~~)'". ~'

"";.t

,/'/

,",

, , ~-,

...,~ :

~, .

:'/,

, ~,

. ' .

".. '

" .'." "~ . ".

••' ..... f

' .. ' ~,,;'" ' ,. ,.' "~'-' ,

'\;.1':" ~., • ~.';., c' •t :, "c'

:' .••• J'. i

,;

, . " . ~."

'"'" ~ , ....., :t _.~t~ .' , ... .- ' .c~.,.,,:':"~~1;::~·-~~;~ ";'<1,.;,~~;~- ,\ "",+, ~.~ V ........... - ~i:<' "~'" ... '

('.': ", .

"".

.' ."

-'.' '........ ~ ~ t •

.._," '''' ~', - ...

.;.:'

'. '" 'y-

'.,- :0' t :'~.!

. - ." t' ·f·'l:.'

.' ':'<,\;~~;i:~::~;:: ~l~::¥~":_\'\ ~(;.~':

" "

'.' ','

.,',.

(

,",

. -~':'.

. , .:·'t o •

. " ~ .h •

. 0; ':• ," ~j

,~:~ .. '.\ .

-. "

',.

,.... "

....-., .'.

'. . ..". .. .

SUPREME COURT' OF TH{S;TATEOi="NE'W YORK'>'COUNTY OFNEW'YO~i'i'~: ., '. ' . .

. . .,.... ',~. .

' .. . ....~".

';',. ,

NEW YORK c!"rv.". '.. \

ASBE,STos(L1TIGATIONc

IN RE

______....,....,~~----,,----,-i.~----------'----".Xi .. ~

. NYCAi.,

'~ ,

~ . ...

.- -.' ~"

'. '. \

<';.",' .:'

", '~.'.."'::,N~>:OPPOSITION SUMMARY.,,', .JUDGM~NT.. ")'

>i{,\<\ . ',;,.4 .'

\....

.' A.O.SMITH WATE~)~R9DUCrS.CO.e"tal.including.. " , '

SUPERIOR BOILER WORKS, INC., ,

I"

Defendants.. ."

"

' •. -.,:., ,"

. ' • , . ,;. ._; ; " ._.• • • _ • _, . ., •' :1 . '" ,l - ...;. .~.; " ),' . '" ','. '

WHEREFORE;:deferidarWSUP.ERIOR BOILER W9RKS,.I~C.ijh~.r~by~equestssummaryjLidgment in

the ab6v~~i:ri~It~~~~~'~~:~u~~ua~~t~"ci~i:i,prac'ti~eL~wa~fd'ii~~u'~~e;'~~~~i~~3'iI~:di;~iss'lhg'plaintiffs:,

complain~ against S~P~R,19R BOilER W~RKS, INC.,·With· prei~q'ii:e,a~d'tli'~r~ ~eing:~o 'opposition. ... . ..... : . " .

l~he~eto, ":' . ~ .. ,' ~.

. " . . ,\ . -.' ':/, ", ..;.'.. . .~; '. :~~I<~:,":\I' ..," "<:~:~"':::'" i :,' ',.- :

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants; 'all'daim~)nd;crossdaHnsagainst defendant

SUPERIOR BOILER WORKS, INC., beand the same are~er,~~y"~;S~i~se~ ..~ith p~ejudiCe and without'" i.·

costs.

Dated: .

Patti Burshtyn, Esq.Weitz & luxenberg;~P,:t.

Attorn.eysIorPlaintiffs700 Broadway. " . '.New York,'''NewYork 10003'..', ..

.;... ...,' '..' .

Eva's(Way'ne,Esq~:"~, ", . ,

l\IIalab~ &.B.rp'diW,itc:;: :',' .•.AttQrneY~f8tlh'Sup~iioi·'Bo.i1er'W~rksl.lnc.

, '. ,.' .~ '.:"\ (.:' I .. ,. ,1 '.

150 Bro'adway,Suite'600' ,New York; NZ/idC)38, . ' .

.... '~'" '. :

" '

, .. \

' .. ~,

. ~.", .; ." .':: . ' .. '." '.~ ..:.

'j" ...' '.'

.:.~- .

,"

,.i;'t t

"I '.\

.. ''" ~" .

"".

.,\'

.,.'".,

"

"

',' -";:";:..,..,..... ,.......

,.

.,:~..\ .

\.'.,'-',

.,' .~~~~:""

"

.::','~•. 1,,0

,,'"

I ~.'

. \

•.T•

;'

......

.,~.: ".", -~","

',"

. \,.,'

. \

'': "',

~, .

' .., h

...., t_ ~,

I,',

"

·•••1:··

.-' . . -

.:-.'i

..•.

.,..:1.,: "

...'" '~~~~~ ~·/\~/;t~-'\.~:

".:'2 ..11'...

.~:t ';

"."

,\,,' 'I

.; ~.,:, .

."j,

. ... ',

,',

... ~

.',\ ',~,

. ,

",,"

.'.,

;'./~:.'ii<'f.';' '~. " f".:

,: ..

t,'

" ."

• ( "'.1 .~

.,:

.. ':l.

"'\,

,"

v-'

":," :. .

;.",

I r

, ',',......':~, .

"".

.' '

". ".

....

. '" ,',, .; .~." ,',.'

- ~ ,

", .. ' . ~

,\

~~'.

. -<,:;,;",:-;•.,~.,,{...,.,

.'"

, .

·"1

."-'1,,',

~t,:,;/,,~,

.,' ..

.: .

",> ;.~~' ., ..~':": '.:~c"".

~....:; "

"

" ..".'

',', 'I ' :"

~ , 7:':-t: ,.>".:.:, .. : ,.,-':;";-,J~ .~', '. ",' ,SUPREME COURTOFTHE'STATE OFNEWVORKCOUNTYOFNEWVORK: ." './ .

t·· ..,".. '

: '.;..' ...'.

J

______---'- -,-x

IN RE NEW YORK CITYASBESTOS LITIGATION

NYCAL

_________...,...- ~ .:...,,__----'-. x

ARTHUR J. BECKER and DENISE BECKER, Inde.?<No.190113-2014

Plaintiffs, . >' NO OPPOSITIONSU.MM~RV

.JUDGMENT .. '

. i·'"

A.O. SIViITH'.~WATE·RPR~DUCTS CO. et al. including.SUPERIOR BOILER WO~KS;INC.,

Defendants.________=-...,...- ~ ·x .

WHEREFo.RE;,.<;lefe~dant SUPERIOR BOILER WORKS, INC!.her-eby requ:e'sts.summary judgment in

the above-entit)~d:~~~~;'pJ'rs~ant to Civil prac~ice La~ and RUles'Se.cti6·h·3~i~~,; dismissin~,Plai~tiffs' .I ." " ",:: .< <., :),., ,)~:: , ,." _' .' - , .. ,' " .. : ~:. ~ " ' _-: ,:. ," .~' ,:. "

complaint againstStJPERIQR',BOILER WORKS, INC., with prejl,ldice, and ther.e 'being no opposition.';'.' .' ...} .

thereto,

ORDERED,that'upon notice to all co-defendants, all.~la'j'ms,anc:fcrcissd~ims against defendant

SUPERIOR BOILER'!"ORKS, INC., be and the same are hereby dismissed:'~'ithprejudice a~d~ithoutcosts.

.. X'.\ .J

. .. '

".., ~.;":.-..-,. ,..'j~~'; .

···.·~~;~fd:, '..Eva 5. WaYne,':Hq. "MalabV&:B~a'dley,' LLC' 'Attorheysfo~ /';:Superior Boiler W~rks; Inc.150'Broadway;:;Suite':~Oo: .New York, NY 10038C, .' .'

' ..-

Patti Burshtyn, Escg,:' .. ',

Weitz & LuxerH)~~g:;P~C:"Attorneys for Plaintiffs700 BroadwayNew Yo~k, New York 10003.

~~.",:.:,.,:.".

'yri~·,·

Dated:

·i

-: . "\

" 'It',

._', '•• :' _,,' ". _~ r

so ORDERED, ~...~.. ---:'-'~~---'----'--'-----".,--- _';H6;ij~~peterJi .:MoUIton

~;' ~;{.:>., :/.'.

.-,;1.

.,'

,'""

~"'" .. ,

~".

~ ",','--/::

.. ~. ... ~

,\t'

'-~ .

" ..: ~ ,

,"

: .' ..

.~,

.. f.'

,'.~

.. ~ -'

1-,'

;',\ .'

"',I

'. ~

v ';'~

1.: '\

,~.

,', .t'"

-:?"'.

~.

.'

. ',.

.~ \

" .... ) ..

I:.

'., M·......~,~. _.-•••••••••••• _ ..... _"".

I,'

. _ ~ , a_

~. ~~~:.7;~:~ '. :: .

'<·'\I:,.:t,.:-~':",:

. ~ '.

'{to,

" ,

':,... 'tt . ." v. '.

, (

) ,

,;

:':.

IN RE, NEW YORK',CiTYASBESTOS LinGAnON

NYCAL

----~-------'-------------x'I

CARLOS MUSZAK; , Index No. 190286/2014

, Plaintiff,

-V.-' '

( ,

NO OPPOSITION :SUMMARYJUDGMENTMOTION'AND ORDER

, A.O. SMITH WATERPRODUCTS CO.,ET AL,ihcl,~ding;,:$:WP;ERl()R'BbILE;RWORKS, INC., '

, "'I'~;!'~!\:::';"::~: ',:': ,,:c," 'Defendants. '"• ". ;1 :;I~·'-':..' .J. ;

',: ..

------~.,..,.,....--'----,--__,_------'-----'-----'-----x

WHEREFORE, defendantSUPERIORBOILER WORKS;iN'C. ("Superior':) hereby request,,,'

. ., ':.'~~", .,' ,'" .' . . '- .. ".. - ' .

summary judgment in the above-entitled case, pursuant to Civil PradiceLaw and Rules Section ,3212,

...... ::.' .... . . .·.1 .' '.

dismissing plaiiiti(fscolllp,!aint 'against defyndant Superior with prejudice, and there being no opposition• :. ~ " ~ •'. < • ' •

thereto,

, '" '"" ,'/,) ,'" " , " " ""ORDERED, th~tup9n 'notice t9 all co-defendants, all tlaiTl)s a'1d cross claims against defendant·. "~'" .....

•• l~ o' ",'

, Superior be and.the s'~I11~'~re,herebY dismissed with prejudice and witnout costs: "

Dated: New Y.or~/ewYorkS I .. ' , ,2015

,"!

Patti Burshtyn, Es'ii:,'\',/" '" Eva-S: \V,ayri'8;1t.sq', ' ,

WEITZ & LVXENilJE.RQ;"fC MALABY\&iB~pLEY~LLC ,700 BroadwaY':i:}r.i:,;:f:'J , 150 Broadway, S,uite600New York,New;Yb'f~4~OQ03 ' NewYcitk; N~w YotklO038Attorneys jor Pl!:tlnt!.li \ ~ , Attorneys jorDejendantCarlos Muszak ":-.,.,' Superi.or Boile1jT¥orks, Inc.

(212) 558-5500 (212) 791-0285

SOORDERED~" , Dated '§"b,lJS \\..~Q':;·"!:.'~~j~~!JSp~]{I~~H~kl'\k '---',-'-1/'--'-',.;,.;..j,/'-"-,----,. ~, . '. tt\\~~,,\ \Cf?

:4:"~;,',~,: ',. oU", " " ~c~~~~tf,''',:,,>:~.;~~H.~OVLT6N:' ·l- '-, CO\}~ ~~~., . '

I

(i,>

.1; ~: ... ~::. . '

"

"

1'\

',,'

)

'"

.:.-

".• ;

".!-cl.-,

.":.'

~ ~",'.'

~; .

.\;

. ' ......-

"

,; ~".- ,~, .

",,' ~.. ~ .

I

'\

I

'\

.,'"

,}

.-.

\

'\

. ~ :.i-

,.:,','. :',:-

,.''.

-,':- (I:

i·'

"

\

--;.,;,.\

r'

\~ ,

. ':'......

, "

',.'". :,.,:'. '. ,• . . "-", :; -.;it ~ .

{j S(jP~MECbUR;ofT,~E STATE-6FN12Wi6RIS;;~, ,,'t :' ,,":~;' ''COUNTY OF NEWYQRK.,; ,~' " ' .'

' ...•.;;~~.~~ -",,~-:;... ·,b, '. )';"1 .;.. " ...~.,

... .' .. '. '." ',,' ·x .. : ' .','IN' RENEW YORK CITY' .'" .., :. N:Y6AL "

ASBESTOS UTIGATION

----------;--~.....,;..-.....,;..--.:------x'

FRf.:D 6 BODDY,

Plaintiff,

-V.-. , . ~

NO,OPPOSITION~ ; ~

SUMMARY JUDGMENTMotroN AND ORDER

A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO., ET AL.,including, CROWN BOILERCO:,',:(

i

:Defendapts, i

~-----.,--~--'-:;,",----'-;-'---,-i-----~~-x . ~ ,

WHEREFORE, defendant CROWN BOILER CO., F/KJA CROWN INDUSTRIES, INC::~!

~ j. •

("Crown Boiler") he~~by request suthinarY'judgm~l).t in the above~erifi'tied case', pursua~t to Civil\" . '. . .. ,. :",' '.:" ". .

Pr~ctice ,La\Y,'and'Rules Sectio~ :3~.12;disrhissing plain,tif.f~' .c'Qn.:PI!li#t against defendant Crow~. . ',":... '..... . . .'

.':.~.

, Boiler with~iJt prejudic~~ and there, being no opposition thereto,. .' ., .~. ". ....',. ,

ORoERED;,that upbn ~6ticeto all co~defendants, all claims and cross claims against,. '" ~. .

:":,

defendant C..rown 13oil~r bti'and the .'~ame'~re'her~byp{smissed wit,0 prejudice and without ~osts:

I';:..

. ',:': ~

Eva.S:·,W~Yrie,E~q.

IYtAL.AB¥&<)llUDLEY, 'LLC');50 Broadwi(y,. S~it~ 600, ,

" 'N¢w Y6~J(~N~«'York 1d03~:Attor/1eys for Diifendant ' ,

Crown Boi!eY¢?, '. (212) 791~.o285::··

.; .

Dated:' New York, New York, 'th, I ", 2q15

.< • '''.

:>,:'~'-;;'.',...Michael Rqbe~ts,':I;:sq.,;'" ' ';WEItZ &LUXENBER"G,PC .' ,·;r·700 Broadway . . ," . ; .

Ne~ York,'New,YofblO003 ,'.

AttorneysforPla'intifj"'

, Fred C',Boddy' ,!: .-' -,r S~(212) 558-550.0 " :

, .. ,. ".

·~)~.j>.:·~.55'!~~t~~:.. ~ ... ',' .' ::'~,:,!. :::",:;,: ~"'~'~~U:H'.:·;:;

:;,;::..." . <.: '..... :'~..

", i >:r;,:',"; ~.;>./ \.. ;.;,;: ': ,,~,~:'.,' ..\:";\:.1'-.'. '.. ':":'.'~,',;,.: ' .' - :. '.. ; : : .... ~., " ;.': '<:,

.--~,.,."--:'",,,77:~.~.,:~~;'"'~,,-.-~;P'~l~d; ';:,t}!.~l'.~,: ",Hon:'Pet'eh-i·.,Moulton'...... . .. ," ,';':"

"

"

L~

I·.··",

j

I:

"., -c'

, ...' ....

. ~.

, ""

I

.,':it

",.~~ .

'.

J : ./:, :

.:~ t. ...: .••• ;-.l.

•1i,;"

; .

-', <,r

"'",,'

...- - ..~._ ..

J

"" ',I v.:'.'1 .

"".i '.

(: r

Jo.~: :

.. '.~

.1

..:..:. "",: .

" .

j. ~ ~::.;, ..

'I

,' . • '.j

..':

",

.~,

,:' ....

''''','

:', ..,

;....

",',',.

"

.;,

~,

','

.. <:

,'\',

./.'

• ( ;. ., ~ ,~ ~... I ".

'f:' " ••

. '

. "

',' '., ....\ ....'I: . ,;-1', ,

.", ".~ . ,.,'",

'" I ,Ct. 'l,',:",~,•. t.,~,"~",~~, q-

....,"~, ")'. .' .~ ,

.,\ .

'. ,

'J\"'"',

, '

....~ \

. '-:·i "

'.' :

,;' .

....

',.;0', .,''-'',' I"

NYCAL

" f."

.... . " ... " " '~. .

:, .J .

" ..'

-.' 'I' .;: ~ '. '.' . . .;' -' ~"· • ;. ~ : .;' • ':'~... 'i> '. ~, .) '.

...< 1:.. ," 'i;' , .

SUPREME COURT-OF THE STATE'QF-NEW YORK .COUNTy'OF NEWMORK ':. . ...... "'.'

, '. ,., '.~ .. : ." . ,

. . ... '-*,:>'.<',.'. . '..•' ":'4:: ',,' ':, ' .. ~..""', ~ _'

IN RE NEW YORKiCITY..· :.~ .. ' . :.

ASBESTOS LrFiGATION

-------------,------,--'--.,...---~-__.,,..:_;.x

CARLOS MUSZAK; . ." Index No. 190286/2014

-v.:~.

'. Plaintiff, NO OPPOSITIONSuMMARY JUDGMENT

. MOTION 'AND ORDER

A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO.,.ET AL.,including, CROWN BOILER CO.: '. . . \.,

" .

...../" ,.' ': _:~~>i. .' .',' '~'f.; .' ,\.. Defendants'.~': .:' ".:. '. '\ ,~ .'. 1 •

",' . '~ .. : \. " .:-., . :,-' '.'-~----'---'----,----,---'--'-----"·'-----.,...,.."...---,--..,........,----,,-~~x.

·.··,i, -;

wtIEREFORE, .defendant CR6WNBOILBR,.:~CO.;FIK/A CROWN INDUSTRIES, INC... . : ,'. -." . ' ,

("Crown Boil~r") hereby req'~est sum'mary judgment in the above-entitl.~dcase,' pursuant to Civil· . ",'" ,: . ":',- .

Practice Law and Rtile~'Se'ction 3212; dismis~in'!fplaintiffs' compla!ri~aga:instdefendant Crown..' :--, ~'. ~

. '. '. . I' ,,' '/.::,. .~:.l".' ~," ',- '.,:':. ,< ~.._.. '~ ~~: .Boiler with :prejudice, and;~hei~:'b~irig n~ opposition.;~h:,~r.eto,

•. .' . . ":.. ~.~.,,,">}: ,.~~,:!.:'..:" '. '. f ". .,... . .

, ORDERED, thatup0'n notice.'toaJI ca-defend~ll:its,all cl8:jms and cross claims against:".' ". '..' '

1'\

'defendant Crown Boiletbe and.th~.sarrtear~hereby dismissed ~lthprejudice and without costs." ~, ' " :'.> ". ,~-,.~,,; -' , . -; , .,: .' ,'''.:. ' ' ., .

'.".l'p, ", ; ;'~l '

~':

fl'l>E D.MAY \ 2 20\5

. COUNTY.CLER~S OFFICENEWYORK .'

. !

Dated:_. ..,-:.,E)"-+~J...;.,,.;ij+-··It,,-=.~:......· _

Ey~S. LW~)mel'Esq:;.; i

MALAlfV &~BRADLEY LLC. i~~ ;.:, ,

150 Broadway, Suite: 600 .New York, New York 10038Attorneysjor DefendantCrbl1J~·jj~iler!Co.· .(21'2) '791-02.85

. . . '. " ",

Dated: . New Y?rk1.:! Y.ark: .. '?JdJ- ,2015.. ':::1·· •. · , :

Q!!:0 .~..:,.. '.'-.. \/:~ \,~:..,-,"";"~"-'.-:.',

.'1·... · : I. . t·.~;):·";

. ", ~-~ ", .~:,.~." .. :~>-:-;',.[ ,

SO ORDERED,. 'Jdi::~,..:-:~' ,;>~:, .. , '.-II"'. ': .' I ." "~I '"'. :,~ ~.", '1

.' Hon>B~~r" Klei6Ilcitler

· .,;·','",7et't{\+. ·M~.J,\\6A.

·MJN~.~.H.,~OULTON

Patti Bu~shtyn:Esq.·· ..... , ':

WEITZ'&__LUXENB~RG; PC700 Broadway '.New York, New York 10003 .

Attorneys for Plaintiff.Carlos Musza.k(212) 558:5500

' ...

• \ '.' > .1,....

..-.....-.-'.:..

.:'. '

/". ."-:","','

. ".

.f

.', l,: ,.'

, .•...

..'~. ' ; .

I.'.. .< .1. ..

"

{

.I'""

..-,,'.

~~', " '

) :."

:-- ,~"

:. ....~.;.: ... ' ••'W' /:~. ~ ":.'

,~~ '.(' ~,' '-/-.5" 'l"

, '.

.' ,;\1

i',

I:.

"

'.'

. ~.

) "

. ~ .... '

. \.

......

.,.

•C ~'.....

,...., ,

,.;

. o' •.

';'::\

.. , . ~.. :

',I. ':t

0',·

.",

(

..;,'

... '

.~

."

..' . ..,~: :," ~

.. '..~: .'.

--- '

,',,'

{>,

I'I,

.\

...,.. ';1 \ ~

.. '.,'_. "

.. ...:.. : < -~~ ...: •

. '('.".' .,,' '--(',

'-:--'.

, ,"',.', '('

"":;"V~-~;<'~/{t~?:~~}{,::!~~t: ;, '} :(..":-' ,~>

~..>

.r·"· '.

.:;"r.

" ."

',',• 'I' " '

.. '.-: ~.. ... . ' ~ ,.

INRE' NEW YORK CiTY,ASBESTOS LITICiATION

.... ",NYCAL.,,_.' ,,( . .,' '

, LA.S: Parf50'

FRED C.BOD~Y, \'

.... ',

In:dex No. 190i3'112015 1

)

,Plaintiff(s),

,-against-

,'NO OPPOSITION,SUMMARY JUDGMENTMOTION AND ORDER

.', ~ : J

A.O. SMITHWATERPR.:ODUCTS CO., eta!.,including.lMO~CSE b.IES$L;::~F; . :

" ." " 'Defendants.

. '.-

"r'"

c,,'"

I

'," "

"

WHEREFORJE;,Defendant Morse Die'sel, Inc:, hereby requests ,summary j~dgm'ent in the• '," • {.~. .,:- '''' ':' • '<~' • ...' '. :;~ '.:" '. .' ". •

'above-entitl~d GaS~,pursuan(tb'Civil Practice Law and Rul~,s Section<3212, dismiss~ng plaintiffs

, comphlint a.gainstdefepdanfMor~eDiesel; Inc., without prejudice; and there ,being n~ opposition~ . ~". : ," "" :. ~ ; , ~.. . .

thereto, ' ',",",~ 9 ,

ORDERED,;that up'6nnotite to all co~defendants, 'all claims and cross-claims against" ." :J ", ; .

defendant Morse Diesel, Inc., be, and the same are hereby ,di~rrifsse(twithou.t prej~dice and- . ..

without costs. ~~' .

• ""I'

"',;:?

Mich~:;~S:ES~,j:;:

,,'

SOORDE~~/', .., ' ,. '~ijOIi.:\~eter H. ¥ou,lton

, "

R.osario,etta, .Esq.," MALABy::&"BRA.DLEY, LLC

Attorneys"jQr Defendant' ",'150 Bro~dway;Suite ,600 ',"New York, New'York 10038(2 i2) 791-0285":

'i,',

> '~

F Il EDMAY 12 201S"

COUNTY CLERKS 'OFFICENEW YORK

'-", '

New York, New YorkhAYl 1 ,2015

. •. 7

i '

Dated:

,,'" f,

., <~ !

" /' ,- t '

.':>,- .'

"'·'t·'. "

)~ '.

:. ,,' ,"'!.f.

'!

'" ~-~

";" 0

."-~

, "

: :: ~\ .: '.' : :".

'. )

. ( . ,~~

'i,1

.:,.. ~ l;'~"

"''';,.'

'\ .

.,- .: ..

/. , , ;

, ;; , ·r '; ; ,;~:'-; .' ! .;: !., . ; ,, .I , :;!l . -, '.' ...... '1'"'

I

,..•..

.;.- ;!.. .... ,

\.

'. ,;', ~'.

.' ......,,'....';

.. .

\, ,

'.~ _.

.,'-J

.:;:

.~.. :

,~, .

.....

..;. ..

,'::':

. ", -\- ~ . ,-- ~ ,;

,'.r.

>'\ '

SUPREME·¢bURT}?F.~[J:Ie:S;rArE"OF; NEW ybRK .,'COUNTY OFNEW,Y9RK.. . ~. . .

" '~.~'.."'"

. ~,

".----7~_,...._--..-..;..;....-..;..;..--~~--~--~---x~

IN RE NEW YORK.CITY:. ' '.ASBESTOS LITIGATION. .. . .

NYCAL

'. x','

FRED C. BODDY,

-v.-

Pla.intiff,

~ ;-.

o Index No. 190137/2015

···'NO OPPOSITION.SUM~A.RYJUDGMENT~ MOTION AND ORDER·

A.O. SMITH'WAtI:n~~pRO~U¢TS"'cq:; .ETA-C, incl~ding,.\~·UP}:RlrRB0!LERWORKS;INC.,. .... " ;.... "

"

~' ';

'. Def~ridants.";;'

__~......:---,-_........,..--,-_,...._""":--'-;~__-_":"':"":-'--.,;--.,...--.o;'·x.. ·WHEREFORE, defendantSuPER.IOR BOILER WORKS; INC.~ ("Superior") hereby request

. "; : ' .

summary judgment in'the'above~e~titledcase, pursuantto Civil Practice Law and R~les Section 3212,. ," .' .. ' " ~ ,. --'-,." .'

";~, . '. '" ~ " :~.' ,.," ,

dismissing plaintiffS c9tnplaint,againstdefendant Superio(with'prejudice, and there being no opposition. ,'. .- - : ." .

thereto,~ ....

. \:

ORImRED, th~t upon notiCe to all co-defendants, all claims and crqss claims against defendant. , . :. ~'.. . '.

~, f ','..o

Superi~r be and the same are' h~teby dismissed without prejudice and without costs.., . ~.' \ '.

.;,.

;~ -.. JI~-?' . ::, '.~<" .,."

.. ".

.,~htif.IS:' )"'j ':-

Dated:-~--r--7,-f-'-"----

. 'j.::.

SOORDERED~' ·;.:0·.·. '. '.

, ... ,": 'Hon: .PdferH. M.6ulton"" •. ~J

Dated: . New York, New. York./t/f;Y.l'·,20)5 ." '..,.

~L2~",~~::·"~:':""::':'\~"}~~~/>~'----'-'-":"";i'~~ichael' Ro.ber.t~,.'~sq·:~:' ."<-'>:' ::,.~::,;:;~, ('. ',Ev"a ~S,:'¥~Yil~;.rE'sq.~··~·

WEITZ ~ LVXENB~.RG,·PC"MALABY.&'BRAl)LEY, LLC. 700 Broadway 0 150Br6adJ,:~:y;:S~ite 600 ..

New York, liew York W003 . New Yc>rk;'1)JeW;Vork 10038Attorneysfor Plaintiff Attorneysfqr p¢fendantFred C.Boddy . . . Superior,'Boilei""Works, Inc.

(212) 558-5500: ' (212),791'-02.85'

, ~. '.

"'--.'" "

.... '~~.,

'..,..'

'. ,,,-: ...

r,-"!",;

, '....: ',.4"

: •••U

,L

.'

('0;.,

.... "-'---l'

. ,-\

'. ,4,' .~-,.....

.)"d

"~ .~':

o •

"','

. ;';,

.'.~'

(.. .. ~

"

.~ .:

;.' ,

i.

.1..;,"

. ~:' . ~.:

;,.".~""

r ,:

, ,

....

'j

'-'.'

',f.....:.

,Jl(' ;"t'.. ,, ,~~

" '

......

. n"to,':"','c'

~ " :;.;. '} ~ .., :; ~ .',.,

"

~~. :~':: ";:~>~ :<.:

~i. ',:

~ ~~~ ,:

.:':.; :. ))'::.

....•

......

, ,',~,

..,<

.~ .... ..;.

l::r!~Ll;,f:}:':",:' "

;,'"

. "-l,I';, P·'i::l~·..:i:'2J'.'~./"i

'"

.. :.U 1. {: .' ~. "j .: :,~!.: :'.::: rf~,'

, "~ ... .., ~

' .. ,

',' . .,;.J .• .~J': .',;'

.'

.:'. <':.~" \

;.' I".'

... t,.;;"

.lo, ....

""';'.

.. : .....\ , '

,}

..,:" .'

.;.

..~. ,

··Il, ",

.~. .Q~.• .:i J :-.. '..,

""': '_~",.:,':AT~~.,;;.;;tf

'~'., ,

;', -, ~ . ' " '~ • . . •. i \ ! '. i ; ,-', " " '.

'.'f

"';'~:: .fr:;\

. ~. .

"" .. '

:~

".J

"

.;.,. -.)

. t, •

, ~-.""

~'f .. :."

>~i~i,~, '

":,

'":'.

'.:'

, ~ .

\., ......,..;... ..•. )

.. ': .;,;, ..~

'.',

','':'.< ••;i,: ~ .,~

.',:'"

~..

/,,:. • I •

<;/~;.'~:~:I'j~]t 1~~:~fr7~'~<~['j ¥';Z· ;",,, ,t' ".\~". .' ,>" 'c.., ';,

,:,,;~'t~k!(~:i~Y~'~j;,:~:', " .. , :::'t ;,":. '';' ,)" .~~/:.'{

"~

',.. ;...

~~ ..-.-:

:

.,

.,.',-

.;..•4'

,::.

, J

• 't '.'; .. ~~" ... ' : ....

r·' .

. ' ~,

',..~. ). '. .~

'. NYCALLA.S/Part 50 .(Moulton, l)

SUPREME C.oW~t.;OF.,THE\§·T~JJ;>OFNEW YO~. " :~.><. :.'COUNTY·OF:NEW.YfORK '. . ;.

.; '. ~i.;";·~:;,.; .. '/,,(: . <~ ; :1.,.,f,I",_":' "-."" • j: :

',' " ,',' '::'"

NEW,YORK: CITY;'ASBESTOS LITIGATION

. ' .

INRE

---------'-----:-~--'-'--------x,

ROBERT T. GLASER, Index No. 190060/14

Plaintiff, .

A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO., ET AL.,.. ,..including, MORSE.DIESEL;'iNC:~· .

, " '~' <' "

, .NO OPPOSITIONSUMMARY JUDGMENT

. MQ.TION AND ORDER

'_1-'

pefendants;." .

-----------'-----'------:--'------x

WHEREFORE,Defen,dant Mors~.Diesel, Inc., heid;yrequest~.summary judgment in the. . .,... :.., ·,... ·.1 . . .. :" C'O . '

above,~entitledcase~-par~u~t~to~t~i~lLpiacticeLaw anctR4tes.Se¢iionJ212;·dismissing plaintiff s.'. • • , • ' " " ..... .;".., • • :";' ••••': ." " ,~< 1'..<,", ',' I.:" . .complaint against defend'antMorse'!p·lesel,Inc., with::prejudice, anir.th~re being no opposition thereto,

• ". I ," " .:-.... ;. '. .' •.••.. .'," '.....' '." •.i. : .

ORDERED, thafupon notice.fo al} co-defendarits;;irll.~lahns and·cross.,claims against defendant, • • .~ •. ,,. • • I '-. '.' ~," " , t"".· ;,,:

Morse Diesel', Inc., be and' ihe:scim~i:~e'hereby, dismi~s.ed~~tli':pr~j·udice and without costs." • .' " '.: ~ I' .\ " • :;•..;. • • • .' .;! . .

Dated: New York, N~w York~y 6 ,2015

Patti Burshtyn; Esq.. :':'.' .'WEITZ & LU~NBE:RG" Pc.Attorneys for Piaiyz!i.ffi..':.... . "Robert T. Glaser :'. ,'.

. '~. '1

700 Broadway" ."NewYork,l'few York 10~Q.3

(212) 558-5500 .

.~ :. '

9c&-o.·/~

Rosarro.·G.hettatE.~q.MALABY-&}BRADLEY LLC

'. 0 ".... .' \":":/' . ,

AttorneysfortErefendantMorse·DieseI,Inc.. :150 Broadway, Suite 600New York, New York 10038(212) 791-0285

", . ". .....

\ .,; . (,

.; ..:,.':.... t'.

';(

1<.'.~.

,"

~, ,

,',

" ,

"~- ."

<••

:'i;

. \~,

.,., ,

.r'

",

. :....~

" ...

".1. " ~ -... .;

I

iI:I . I

.,

"

:" t·j

',.

: ~ ,',,'

::.,

.. :'......:>.; .•..\-<. -:".

>:. "'.'. /- ..... ~.:

" ~ '-,:~,!: .:.: ~, .-:>..~ ~ ;l ~". . _'.

~ '-, ;. : .... f ~..

'.:',

. ,~'.f; ~. ~' ..~ '.

.", 'c " ~

.'"='",:

.~ , ;, .

------------,--------,---x

NYCALI:A~S. Part 50(Moulton, 1.)

-:\.":~":. -. .' - :::,/ ':.'

NEW'YORK CITY·.ASBESTOS LITIGATION

. " , .

SUPREME COV~]i9f;TtIE, S.T~TE OF NEW YORK'COUNTY OF NEW1T,ORK .. -'. ~.. ,

, :- I, "' .. '.?'" ..... \

INRE

. .

JANE DISTEFANO and PHiLIP DISTEFANO, Index No. 190364/14

Plaintiffs,

A.O. SMITH'WAT~RP.RObUc.tsCO., including,MORSE DIESEL, .INC. .. ~. .

. . . ~..,'

NO ,oPPOSITIONSUMMARY JUDGMENTMOTION AND ORDER

cI..... Defendants,

\.-------------'------------,-.x

. ,

. ,, ,

WHEREFORE, D6fendant Morse Diesel, Inc., herebyrequests ~ummaryjudgment in the... '. '.' .,.".~~~:.. '. '. - "; . " :-- ,: r

above-entitledcase,'purs~~fto Civil!>ractice Law and Rules Section 3212,: d.ismissingplaintiffs' -. . . - :. <"-;"" ·~~;o~~'..:., "l:~ :': Y>.~ : '.~ -. . ~':" " - .'complaint againstdef~ilcla:nrMqf,serI!)iesel,Inc.; with prejudice, and there being no opposition thereto,

.•....- _.,. r'R"~"'''~ . -.. , ',-_.. _ -•.

.ORDERED,th~{~pb~'ri6tic~;toall co-d~fenci~t~'>~ll claifn~ and cross-claims against defendant. "; :.., !.'•. j ". '.' ' . ,. ' .

Morse Diesel, Inc., b~ancithesan)e'~~h~r~bY dismissed \¥ithp~ejucii~eand without costs. .',"- .' , ..,.' ""'. ,,'" ' :. '~. ~, .:'. . ~ .

. ',-,\.

Dated: I New Yp*, New.. York,.:"'.. ' . ~ / r ,2015 '

~ .

. \ . ,

"~ES~'~'.'WEITZ &LUXENJlE:RG:f;C.'Attorneys forPlaintifjS .. ~' 'Jane DiStefano and-Philip DiStefcmo '700 Bro~dway ."New York, New York 10003.' I

(212) 558-5500

~.".~.~.'. .- .' .... . _:: .

.. :. "'. • • .. -~.: ': '" • __ • ~ 0 ~ ,'. ,_ •

'.'~ :.. ,: '-,.·~~~~···~-'010;\ --'~..::::----. Eqka .L..:F.raefike!;sq. . '." MAuABV&,'BRADLEY LLC .

" • '., '~ ... :'. <':' • ;"',', ';:'0 r-: :"~.. ,'; ., .. Atto.rneys!or.l1i!e,ndant .. MOrse Diesel, Inc.

150 Broadway, Suite60bNew York, New York 10038(2J2) 791-0285

',SO ORJJE~b~~~iri~'1~~tiitp~.'.' . ·;.::{;'<~;~~~f:f! ;:::: ....

.... ::!. ;>:~~ t ~," ·:i~..,.~' -., .; .": .

.:j,,"

, .. \ "\ ..

. r.. ,;,,~.

. ' ....

. '. ~', ,",,- ,

.'. .:,

':.

',.

\ .'

."'.

'.; ,

"" .. "

'_'_ ·.i

.f·

,./,. I'

; "t.,

, ­.. '

'.

I.

• • '1· ...

,''','

';.

";'

. ~ t.,~, ,

'\

;;.j~~~.. ~~:~'\ .. ,.: ... ~'-

. J , ~,

"

"

I/

\

''','

..',~;.'

.·f

"', "";: .....

. '.'

.~ t . .' I

;,~. ' .

.',"

'. '~

' . .,''I' ,'0

" "

-<.1

.... -

:.'

"',

/

"~

-J

. I

~. -:"-'j:~ R~_' .::~

/

.(",~ .

...•..

.', f r '~~r ",I __ .. :

.,'J .. ',

',. :',• .. ·-f·

-:','

'<-'

, ,'~.

':'1'1",.';~, .......

~.Y. ;

'0"

',t·

,., .~

'~'~:'"

, '/."~

:j' ", ."~;'; ,I'...

. . ,. '.. .' .' ,.~, ;:. .' '

, SUPREME.COURT OF THE'STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY Of.NEW·'YORK " .

!. •

'.

" ,------,----'--'-~"""7,'-,,"'--'---,---------~,x'

INRE NEW yORK CITY,ASBESTOS LITIGATION

~).. ~ ..

,NYCAL.' "

----------------.."....---xCARLOS MuszAK, In4yxJ~~~ 19028612014

, "

.,,:,/ ,.:.~. ,~,'

. .~ ,. . ., '.'

.. ; .• ",t~:', .1';

N9'9P,posITIONSUMMARY; JUDGMENT

.. 'l\:1Q.;tION AND ORDERf ~

, "

,-V.-..~!, , .

A.O.· SMITHWbTErj:.P)~~QPJ}~ts' CO., eta!., ;inCluding vII<iN6'~p.WMf;:mC;(' ';,-

,.' . :~\X;}":, "'" .,~,," .Defendants.

Plaintiff,

-----'--------''-----------------'--~.x:1 .

" wHER$FO~~ def~Qdcint'VikingPump, Inc:,("V~~~g,?)' he~~'by req~ests ~'~ary, '," '~-.. ;, _:~; .: .,._' ', .... '.._. ,. .-: ;: '_ !:<.....~.·,.;f.:i~ ~;~~;I,: ..:-..~:~" '. '; .. ,'.' '. ,..: . .

judgment in the., a:b<;ry~~eqti!~~(tca~e, ,pUrsuant to Civil;Pniytic¢,;..r;,awaiid~l;i1es Section 3212,. ", ".\.':_',;' ,-.," "';{";j::'~:. "t",.~,l', .-",":. ,-.-' < .... , < .. '::JT:,:,.:.;,:t~l> .::'.::\' /' .' -....

dismissing plaiJit~frs'c'9.~i?taidtaga,insJclefendah.'t' YikiIlg'.withpf.ejpdl~e;:,~4 there.be'ing no, • , ,. '.' "'" ~ •• '.1 ' " • . , .' '\. '. ".' : ~". ; '\ . ' . - I' • , '. •

opposition thereto,' ,. " . . .' ,,' v, ,.>" 'r ":<:, ' , " '. . ' ,~-...

, .;'.~.• ';'., . :'1_ ~-. • ~~.' ".... : ,i~,,::~<',,,:_ r~~.: ,..-<ORDERED, t9at,,~pb'h'n6ticeto all co-defendaiits" aJCtf'li.tns'and cross claims agctinst

.,' ',' ~:'::;<_ ... ::;:' .,.;-~,- •.~,,: -... ;'

defendant Viking be and-the same are herebydismissed:withPt~Judice'~dwithoutcosts;. 'j~' '-.~ . I .

Dated: New, YOr"k)j,ew, York', ,J:: t·· 2015" I .,:. ' .?

.'.,

,~ ,

','I '

", .

.W~·~:"Patti B~shtyn, BS,q.\ ,.'< ," Gr /e e Mario,·Esq. 'WEITZ &BUXE~JlE:RG~PC "'M;\ ~JJY,&l,lRA])LEY,LLC700 Broad~ay , ,'l$pBroa~W'ay,'S~ite,6bO .New York, N'eW'Yorkl0003 New York;-t'Jew, York 10038Attorneysfor:,r..i4'(ntifl" .: A~t9rn~ysJor 'pefendimt ~,Carlos Muszak ' ,':,' J!i'ktng PiimpI~'c, " . ' , ~V',(212) 558-5500',:;' '. (212)' 79i<0285',' \V b G

. ,', ','. . ~ \ ",'~~""o~~\V~ ,

SO ORDERED,~" , Dated::;--"""":S--t'I~n'r--l}$:..,.-'"-' ' ~~ v\'~~'Z~~, , \ ','Hon;:::SM~; Klein I18~r' ' r J . ~ ~"' ...

'.', ....:;.?~(~. M().;\~()(\. .,'; .(p~~ ~~,

'MON.·PEf.ERH.~OULTO~"~.'. c, .'.... " •••• '" ' •

. : .' ~ '.

~ " '

t'· ,...L

"..~ .

. " ',.

"

.""~ : :

. , ~

.:...... "

.·:,·f.·., •.·.·.-~·•. : '.~' -~.,' oJ'. ~ .;•, . ;:''',.:},(

,.~ ." -~. -- Co.:.,_.:..~ ...~.: ., ":-~'-""'-""'-"" ' ... ~ ;.. _._..... ..:......

" .

. .",

-:'t. ; .•

",''',

. l'~!

,.;;.

'\

;:'

.. . . ,':.

: ~"; ;li4r::~··~.J.\

,-;;'.

,,"

.;,:"

"... :. ...

\.'

1-.' .• :....

.". ~.~'. "'. , ; .•. 'i

~'. ~ ;:

\/

" f"

',.," .~ {.

, ' ... ~ "

\'

.,.' .

.' .~ ::

',,' ~.

.•

':' ..)

;.:. '

....

:.' .;j.

.'::

".'

. ·t

tj

. ,,'

," r

..~',~'........, '

" .

r·

....;." I .. .~"., ',J>

.<.'

. ," - ~ ,':i'.If.)':'S l..~

, ", .~.• ..·f1 " ""':\.' '. "

;.,'.' .!.

".~" ." : '~I ';

:.. '

-, NYCALINRE

----------,'---'--:..........;-"---~-'-------x.'·!".' ,. "

NEW YORK'CITY' .ASBESTOS LITIGATION

-----'------'----,----------xGEORGE E.. WALSI:I .~d·.EILEEN.WALSH,

Plaintiffs,

-v.-r: ,~

:Index-No; .190037/2015

.NO OPPOSITIONSlJMMARY JUDGMENTlVIOTION AND ORDER

A.O.SMITH.WATERPRODuctS CO., eta!., .includfng ViKING::BTJMP,·INC., . . . .

,4-';· '

Defendants.

--------,------'--~------x.' i ~ .'... '....

. ' .. , .... , ... ,.. ~: -:.

. WHEREFORE;'defendant Viking Pump~ Inc;.("Viking") hereby requests suinmary'.' ."

judgment in the aboy~~erititled:~~se;\pursuant to Civil Pr~~tice Law and Rules Section 3212," ..: ~ '...,:',,''':, :< :".:: ::;~'<'~'/' ...~:'- ': '" '.; ,," ~ '. , .: : .~', '.' .~,"

dismissing plail)tift:'~i9dri:u)I~iJ;lfagainstdefendant V~k:~pg::M'ithwejudice,and there being no

oPP'o~itiohther~i6';"~';";:', ',~'; . . .....: ..... ". , .. ,. -'. '.' ..... '.>, ,.', . ~" -'.:;:\ '; .>~ .: :,~ '. ::- ,.' . '.. 'f .' ,:' ,:. ': ." ~"",.,_ . ...:.,'... • . •

. . ORDERED, that uP.ori'.J;lotice to all c().':defendant~;·al~.~laims. ffi.1d 'crm,s'claims against

defendant Viking be'ahcft4e: s~me ~e hereby dismis~~d \Vi~h;:pr~j~dice:and~'ithoutcosts.

Dated:

. ,

., ,';,.,.,': ..

···,/:,·p··eMDa~SCha~.ESq. '-===

. MALABY&BRADLEY,LLC .. . .150 Broadw~y, Suite 600

Ne~~i Ybrk~·;i4e\¥ 'York 10038 .' .Attorney; for Defendqnt

." Viking PUmP. Inc. ., .' . "CH2) 79i'~0285:": ..

.' .

New ~:=!w.:brk·'d .",. ~.., ." :1·,·:?0;l5.

Q&Nj2~-( .....

Patti Burshtyn, Esq:·WEITZ&L:UXENB~J~G,,·P'C ..700 'Broadway.. :.': .. :,..f ... ,...• :: '

New Yark, New Yo~k 100'03 .Attdrn~y~jo/'picdntiffs ::' . .,Geo.rge;E; ;W.4Zsh,.e~ti(.::, .. · ,:'; .(212) 5'58-550.0:' ";' .. : : .... '.

,::' .~ " ,', ;':.: ,"<:,., ~, ,..

~ .,'.:t.,;>_,.,

',-"

-1,L

. ',',

".

. .. ~.

,'"',." -'.. .. 'I' ., •••••••', .r \ \.' .~.':':"'\l-{.'J.~'..'_~';".'_:''Ji.}~:';-.~\. ~l ":".J~.:~; .:. ':"-'~..c ,. ..

:.-1

.4 _ •• ~-:'_-: •. _.~ ..•__"4' _. or • • '_ •.•• ,.

' .. -~. ,":. >,,~, . ~

......::. -~--~ _~ - _;. '~':-.. "_.-

..:"".'.

. ~;

;',.-,'

.' ~=-~ ;; 4;'..

. '\.~. ~ ,: - ','t' ,"

~\:;~~>C ~:.::·'!'..I.' _'.;:~ .": ."..;...."'

" ~. _.~...::l :'~ .:" ' /,'~''''';:i ·~~.,~~t}"''4.::~.-~i ..j:·.-, ..

; ~

:'- ",.. ..

..". :~~ ~. '; ···:··:·-:~.~.~~;L~·:.l.~

;.

~ ,

:Orj' '..' .. ,..~ '.' .. :-.

.(. I

.•. ·1. ,,;,. •.. ' .,'.,' "

:.'~ f.-. ::.. ;.~:-.

~', "" ..... ;. '.! •

'-':""

. ~

-~_..', I-

.~:.,"

.' "

'I

..... t.

",. ~,

..: .

• 1, "

..',,'.

' ..J- "

'. ., ~,i, •

~..-

..'

I',

:., \ .

,l.;,~ i ""'. ~/'~~

"V, ," t",)::~:.,,.

. , .'":'.: .

',"

:"

.:~

" .".~~

"" '

- "','j

'" ".-

NYCAL. ,

":.'NEW Y:6RK~:CITYASBESTO'S LiTIGATION

,~:.~ '. \ ., .~.t _' "~.',':' " • .

. I"~ •. , . '"

, . .

SUPREME'CO~RT OFT~Estlt~'dF'~E~'yb'Rid:',:, '.~COUNTY OF NEW. YORK,' ',' ",',:; ,',:,"' ..... \~"',': ;" " \,':";,'

• • • ....' .~T' '~'.," '-"/ "1 .•" i!~ '",',

"X'

INRE'

MINARD'S. FOSTE~ and THALIA FOSTJ?R,"

','x.", ,.~' . t

," InqeX No. '1 9q308120 14v • '.':.'

._ ,.~ , • " .' ", '1 • ~ • I, ,

WHERE.Fb~~ ,def~iIdant VikingPump;In~~,(':.y#<ing"}hereby requests summary. ,,.' "-,' .:~,}~. ':<~:~j.: '':'>'' ."... . f. Y )'~<~....:,.~.:'~.~:'-. ,..:»)"" ~:::,'. >, ~t~·.: '~. o~ , ..' < '

judgment irith,e,abo've.:.el).titled"case,'PU!su~qq,qvilPractice Law and Rules Section 3212,• > • '., _ "'.' • -4" -:'.' ,:" • r:. ,," ~,~.:'\';, .. ,....,

dis~issingplaintiffs'complaintag~in~t4~fehdantViking:.wifh-·.pfejljdice,¥1d there being no'., ' " \.. '!" J • • • ,: >~:' " ',;>" "

opposition the'reto,. '/J,: ..., ,, .... • . • ,f~ • . •. ,: "'_'::.\:"\"\~" '~-:"" ,.L,';{;" ,.: .. \' '.. -",o.' •

ORDERED, thatup9n notice'.to aU. co,~def~hdan~s/ ~,Uclaims ~,d cross claims against: ..,. ., ',. -~.- '. ',Y."\" "'.' . ,."c <~ " ,, . t" •

defendant Viking be'''arid the s~e we hetebY.dismlss'~4'wjth preju~ice .and without costs., ..', _.f· ." \~"".. '~ " I.,

----'---------,.------,.--'----,---,.l;--',,""'-,.....".---:....-~x'

AIm &LlQUI<:Q'SY.SWEM§' QJRfQRATiON, ~s' ~"""suc6~ss'or-by~h).etgetJ. tQ'~YF;Ff>.J;,t:rpuMPs~'YNC.; 'et qi.~· ,".

, includihgVIKlNG PBMP, INC.,. 't ~<o:"

'I

"."

;','.:'. '

• • ,'f

"NOOPPOSITION .,SUMMARy JUDGMENT'IVioiION AN:D ORDER

"

I',.

.. ; ~:.

"~ .. : -I,

., Plaintiffs,"

-V.-

. \'.'. ..

'-," " ....

Dated:

,,' ,;, ",j,

....:",' ,',

, .::. "'~'.

I,):''',!-

:,.

"

',' '\ ,,,.,'~ . ':

",

/.

;; .

........

:,

.. _:;.,- .. j....

"'~'- -~

,'.:'

~~-( \,1:.".c'

:~, .,

"

.,~, 'f

$

. .~'~~

i,

, .~

'.':, .

.~, .

t.; ,:

"',. ~ .'

"

~"-~ ~'".-" '<" :.. ;"

"

,', ',' ",

.~,- ...,., .,,.. ;1)'"

~. ;~~ ...." .

" .

•.....

",

')

~ ..

,',

'fl..••

.'

. '.

:~.

, .>

",

.'.

' ..... "',

'".,~ '.

,:.:;:"

, ",

• '<I,

~. "i/':..-~ .

I •

.~.'

.\.",

',,,,'

, .~

, :

-. ,~.

:'/~"

",'.

i .

'.':.' .

;'.'

.:;.

:.~

"i.}"

,~

; ~';'.

': .," '"

'f,

.. .:.: ..,-' ""','

,,;-',''1>

, '" ",,1;' ,> •

. u'j i - ..'

SUPREME;C6t~t::6F~tHE st~f~::dFNEW YORK;· .COUNTy' OFNEVI' YORK :.' '. ' :'" .', .... , "~'c'

:: . '

. -' . ~.~' ~

INRE NEW YORK·CITYASBESTOS.. tITIGAnON

NYCAL- .

.;., ,

FRED c: BODDY,.' :.:.

Index No. 190137/2015

Plaintiff,

-V.-

A ...O. SMITH WAfER PRODUCTS.CO.,·etal" ".' including'VIKINGPUM:p:~::iNc., ;' .,", .

,NO OPPOSITIONSUMMARY JUDGMENTMOTI()N ANi> ORDER. ,,'. '~;..

Defendart~s,·

;----~~----~-"'-----"'--...........,~-'-;--x,·"~ .

WHEREFORE,defendant'Vikii.1g Punfp::'Inc. ("Viking")"herebyrequests suinmary'. . .', .~. '. "',• ~ . ',,' " ' .. , .",:':3 : .

judgment in theabove;;;en~itl¢.dca.se;·pUrsuantto'CiviLPractiye Law and Rul~s Secti9P 3212,. ,',', .. \.

'. dismissing.plaint.iffs',com'~~aihf a:~~inst defendant Viking ~ith prejudic::e, and'there being no'. ". ' . \" . '

opposition-thereto;,'

ORDERED,that:upon notice to allc();.deferidants, all cl~jms and crQ,ss c1aimsagainst

defendant 'Vikingbe ~rid'the sam~'arehereby dismissed Withb~tp~ejlidic¢ ~nd without costs,. .',. . . ~ " .

;.

. \

,\'

.. David p;.c i(f~r; Es, .',. MADABY&.BRADLEY 'LLC

- ...... :";.,' , '-'-' ' '." ':' '

150 BroCi;dway,· Suite 600 " ,NewYo'rk,N~w York 10038". .' " ,

A:ttorneysforJPef~ndant

Viking Puii[h.f~c.", . (212) 791';0'285

Dated:N~:w'y'ork,New York' > .

·':lll#I'.'4.' :.,1015• :.,.,~ , • -' 1 'i'

"

~' :~:.:"~./':',~.£': "" '.~~.,' ' .. ,." " .

.~:< .:,:.~ ",..

SOORD~RE~/;q ', ••'

, .' . ·"·;,1iI0fr::Peter·H;~Mouhon.,'. .:. <,'.' ," ',.'.~"., • '. < '.. : ~~ .

} '.:'

Michael Roberts,}:s~.< .. ,. r-,' ,'"WEITZ & 'LUXEN}lERG: PC700 B~()aqway">',;" "New 'York; NewY:o'i-kj 0603 ; '."AttornejJsfo;~'PlC!infifj)"'" .'

. ,Fred C. Boddy; :.: ~."

((12) 558:5500 ',:'.. '.,'''. :" ....;.~ .~~ . , ." :, .

-.

': !> :),

~ , ..,.

.. '

"-,;;\_Cr'.,; .'"

,". '

~

I,'"

.,.,,'~, ~

.i

..~

. ,I

."

....

1_.,

,-,-:,

, ~ .. .'.. :-)' " ' .~-

;..,'

,~. '."

II·'.

'.:

' ..., ';....•' ~••r- ,.

:'',i'

: ,~. J,~:

'.

.,: .~~.

, 'i,.~~ ( :- ".

,,~. I •.. ' V'

i;_,

.:~. "

,;;.

,~ ,... ,~,~".~,.~.:, :'l:~ ~~.:'<I: ~.,~:; • . .. ' j.\,I;";' •

;~~::,: {',:' "'I ·,;.5~'('//··· '-//;?;. ":~' YL::: :~~:'~

~ "

'r';:•

, "

~ , '. ~

".~.

.~ "': ''.i/"

.n,';.,.

..",-

~, ,j:;, .. ". " ~ ,

......

~f :

J .. ,' t,··;jii; " <

~.. ,' .' '~

, '

'.

.. i,

,."

.:'.

,.f, '.'\;'.' - --

,::.' ~', "

\ ."......

SUPREMECOURTi:OF THE'STATEOF NEW Yc5~K), .',.' .COID~TY'C)F NEW~ORK ..,' ..

INRE

--~---'-:--d·.~':-'-'...;,.'....,.."'::;"..",....:...,;,.__-""f.......o.".:........,.----"--,:;-\,..-,-,'-'--;'-~,,.,,,,• • '\"','/t,',,<:~,.

"NEWYbRk CITY 0;.0 . ,.,' :'NYCAV"."A~mESJOS LITIGATION 'Li\:S';"pili 50

. " ~t

This DocUll).ent Relates to: .. Ind~~' No. 190i75/13 .

Estate of FRANK VERDERO~A..1 , , I,.

. ·NO,OP.POSITION. ';SUMMARY JUDGMENT

. : ' . :MQTION AND ORDER. .:" , .

·x'.

• lI-\'.

WHEREJ?ORE, Deferid~tReynolds Metals Ctirb.pah,y h:ereby requests summary• • .• 'j. .......

'. ,

judgment in the' above entitle,crtase, pursuant to Civil Practice I;aw(l.p.dRules Section 3212,. :. .; . .-

.'", ..:"".' . .", ,. . , .. , .' ,.~'. .

dismissing Plaintiffs' cO~I?lai~tagainstDefendant Reynolds ~etal~:~bmpany, with prejudice,. . ,'t' . ",'

and there beingno opffiosi.ti6b thereto, it is

. . <:;;: :,,;;/',:::.' ':<, . .;:.. """ :: ..ORDERE:J), tljat,upop'noti¢eto allco-defendants~aU claims andqoss claims against

, .:., ,- .\~~. "; '..' .-1:' '. :. .. .... .

defendant,.Reynolds M~ta&'~C~mpany,be and the same'ar~h~iebydismissed with prejudice and:' .. '~' -', . '.'~": \ ""~'; :.,~ . .' . .-~ ...'.... ~' " . .

"

without costs., ....

',' ;.'. ~ r .,.

<,',

Mich~elj.. C@is; f:'~q..MALA.By:~l~~~J)LEY, LLC1,50 Broaaway; "S~illte 600 .. ",-..: 1:,., "

New York.NewYork 10038," ''-'.-

Attorneys for fYefendcmt(212)791-0785" :

Dated: w York, New York

'.' ·::,fA3~~..~;':~..'·.,; ", ".....,.' .' .. ,';.; ,'/...~' -,: '~~, ." ' ... ,,'.

,~. '~ • " ,'¢, '

, . ',',' , '", ':' < .',

Frank Ortiz, Esq. .' . ,.' .WEITZ & LUXENBERG~;}~6ji",,':,..

< • 0 ""''1,: 'i '" ""

700 Broadway .. , ~: .New York,New York Ip003.::Attorneys jorPlaintifjdJ:":·::;'· " .(212) 558-5500 "},'Zi' .

:( "

"

'. ':.' ,....

.. .." ,"

~ated:

: :< ... "

....,.

" .

' .... ;' l~. ,; '" ~' .';.':0 __ • ,'" '

,;t. ,Ji'.,... ..... ; ./

"',"

, . ~

,,'

;.-

.j' '.

!n., •

oJ.'

t;'

, i'~,'

I',' .0-\

, '

'I'

~,. (' ..;

,"

:.. '

'"• '.1';'

.".j,

",".

.• ,~ 't

')

'. ',' '.

f:

" .

',.:',.'

·'1

'" ,

'.. '~. j' ~'\ .~:~: 1 ~;

";'.

·~O '.

'.

:- ~'.

....

, (

.~; "

....

:1,'1

~ ,il

':~ .

,",., <

0 ...

" .. '

'. ',""'.-' ;

\)

"

SUPREME'COUR)' or·' TfIE STATE or NE\VYORKCOUNTYOF NEW YORK

IN RE: NEW YORK City. ASBi3StOS tll'IGATrON

. This Docum:cntRelatcs to;

ADRIANR.. SMITH

NYCALLAS: part50

(Monnon, {). .

1ndexNo: '190084/2015

NO OPPOSITIONSUl\TMARY.JUDG;t\iENT NIPTION AND ORnER

WHEREF9.~E:dcfcndantCertaintceo Corporation, hereby,requcstssurtullaryjlidgmclit

iii theab~o'Ve;.entifleq"(:ase,Pllrsu~nt to Civil Practice. Law and Rules Section 3212, dismissing .

plaintitTscomplait\tag~iilstdefendant Ccrt~inT~ed Corpor;;ltio!Jl with prejudice, and there being

noopposilion th~ret01

ORDERED, ~hat upon notice to.all co-defendants, all claims ;md cross ~laillls against

defcndantCcrtainTced Corpotatii::m, be and the same arc hereby dis;lllissed with prejUdice and.

without costs.

Dated::Ncw York~Ncw YOl:ktlPt! 1..-- .~2 ;2015

Danie J. i sse ~rg,. ," .MElttrr"Z&"'VASSF~nBEtu';, .I...L'Aftorneys for Plaintit(845 Third AVCllUC,! Jill Floor.New York, NY 10022(212) 397-1988

~f.~Brianp-. Sexton,Esq:~ ---DARGER ERRAN'fEYAVITZ & BLAlJ, LLI>AtLontcyS for Ce"ihl.inTeed Corponltioll116 East2ih Street, 12ihFlo()[Nc\\!York; NY 100.16(21 Z) 452-5300

so ORO(f,RI10,

,~; ., . , ".~'.. ~. .' 'L _ .

SUPREME' COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW yoRk: ., ,"COuNTYOfNEWV"ORK " . '" '.,'

IN RE: NEW YORK, COuNTYASBESTOS LiTIGATiON

This Document Relates to:

CARLOS MUSZAK and LUISA MUSZAK......

, NYCAL

Index No: 190286/2014

NO 'OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION ANDORDE~

WBEREFORE, de~endant CertainTeed Corporation hereby requestssummary judgment

in the, above~enti~led,case, pursuant to Civil Practice'LaW'and Rules Secti~n 3212, dismissing

plaintiffs' ~omp{ain~:'~ga,instdefendant CertainTeed Corporation with prejudice, and there being, ,

no oppositioll t}iereto,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant CertainTeed Corporation be and the same are' hereby dismissed with prejudice and

without costs.

Dated: New York, New York

~_O~:·~JL,2015

~.

.---'--R~.

Patti L. Bursh,tyn, Esq.WEITZ & LUxENBERG, P.C.Attorneys for 'Plaintiffs700 BroadwayNew York, NY 10003(212) 558-5500 .

Jonathan. Kromberg, .Esq. ".DARG.~'ERRA~tE YAVITZ & BLAU LLPAttorneys for 'C,ettaiilTeed.Corporation116 Easi 27th Street; lith Floor 'Ne:WYork; NY 10016(212) 457-5~()0 .

SO ORIJERED;· .•·~1<10ulton

'::<

,', ,1,

: t ""':l"~

"<;_'i

".:.

"i,

,'-' , , •.;:- .. ',' -: - '-;.j.,:

..:.: .

i/,."l

.. :' :.-',,"

. .i

.;

"

:,'

':.', .

. t·

".

'J

-.,. .:... ":'.

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW'YORKCOUNTY OF NEW YORK

IN RE: NEW YORK COUNTYASBESTOS LITIGAnON

This Document Relates to:

CARLOS MUSZAK and LUISA MUSZAK

NYCAL

Index No: 190286/2014

NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION ANDORDER

WHEREFORE, defendant Amchem Products, Inc. nlkJa Rhone Poulenc AG Company

nlkJa Bayer Cropscience, Inc. hereby requests summary judgment'in the above-entitled case,

pursuant to Civil Practice Law ~d Rules Section 3212, 'dismissing plaintiffs'complaint against

defendant Amchem Products, Inc.' nlkJa Rhone p'oulertc'AG Company nlkJa Bayer Cropscience,

Inc. with prejudice, and there being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant Amchem Products, Inc.nlkJa Rhone Poulenc AG Company nlkJa Bayer Cropscience,

Inc. be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and without costs.

Dated: New York, New York

6'/Y-,2015

Patti L. Burshtyn, Esq. ' .WEITZ & LUXENBERG, P.C.Attorneys for Plaintiffs700 Broadway ,New York, NY 10003(212) 558-5500

Jonatha,.r(B: Kromberg, Esq. 'DARG£RERRANTE YAVITZ & BLAU LLPAttorneys·for Amchem Products, Inc..116 East 27t~ Street, 12th FloorNew York, NY 10016(212) 452-5300

--;••J....

SO ORDERED, . -H-o""'iI~:;""'. ....,.e....te:;.....r-H-.-M~I-C:U-I-to~n-: ~'=-==-----=':=..-""'::----~ "'/1 S

, ,

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY OF NEW YORK

INRE: NEW YORK COUNTYASBESTOS LITIGATION

This Document Relates to:

NYCAL

Index. No: 190256/2014

NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION ANDORDER

WHEREFORE, defendant Amchem Products, Inc. nlk/a Rhone Poulenc AG Company

n/k/a Bayer Cropscience, Inc. hereby requests summary judgment in the above-entitled case,

pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212, dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against. .~.

defendant AmchemProducts, Inc. n/k/a Rhone Pouleric AG .c<>mp;my n/k/a Bayer Cropscience,

Inc. with prejudice, and there being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant'Amchem Products', Inc. n/k/a Rhone Poulenc AG Company n/k/a Bayer Cropscience,. ~ .

Inc. b~ arid the same are hereby:dismiss.ed with prejudice and without costs.• • .. I • !. :....' ' '-- - " . . .. ~'." .. . ..

Dated: New York, New York

6.( Lj ,2015

.....

CDc6J--fV::-,-----__Patti L. Burshtyn, Esq.WEITZ & LUXENB.ERG,P.C.Attorneys for Plaintiffs700 BroadwayNew York, NY 10003(212) 558-5500

JOl titan B. Ktomberg, Esq. .¥A~GER ERRANTE YAVITZ & BLAU LLPAttorneys for Amchem Products; Inc.116 East 27th Street; 1ih FloorNew York, NY 10016(212) 452-5300

I

\I

.1 -. , .. ' ... I~·

;...'

.;,'{ ",. ,.:,"'\ ": ",1 "

-..,,;.. .... -...- ~~ "

1/ --------------

','. " ,'r ~ '''J' .. .;". ".

NO oPPOSrrIONSUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION ,AND'ORDER

. ;

~..~ "

" ,

LOUIS M. AMBRIC;:() ~l'YT) ISABELLEAMBRICo. .. c

'... ' . , ~ , ; .

This Document ReIatdi;to: <>., ": .,' ..

.. ~. C'. .~·i· ,.,' . : 1..' .. •

~ -', .; .' .• ,:~:" .~', ,~. i;'-"«J:J" ,u.i,'" > 0i~?' . '. ,:i,'

SUPREME. CQQ:~:I,~9F,JHE':S1f~TEOF NpW.vqRKr· ....<COUNTy ORNEW~)'J)RK':<:::}';~.,",::":, /. :; "~:':,' :,IN RE: NEW\Y0RK:cbONtY'~? :~;,. '"

. ':.. ' ,.."':, :".,!.'~';'<'C')"''':'' .:~:~;, .._~~,.", ,,' "~~,::,t:,,, t' ~

, ASB:~S49~~LTTI{:~Ji~\TI0~~". ~, ~,:,r; ~..;<~J., ~"'I -.;::~. • •.• '-' ',1

....•~ -: ..;':',: . 'J ';:', . . . .'., .

WHERE:F'ORE; qefendant,c.Q,uro Dyne Corporation, hereby requests summaryjudgment., 'j. ." " .• ,

I:I

In the above en.~itled case', pursuant to Civil Practice. Law and Rul,es §, 3212, dismissing

plaintiffs' complaint,: a,gai:qst de(e.~dant, Duro 'Dyne CorPoration, .with prejudice in this action,

and there being no 9PPo:siiion thereto,

'"ORDERBE>, 'that .uppnnotice to all c~.,defendants, all" clairiIs and cros~ claims 'against

. :,: .

defendant, Duro Dyne' Co,rporation, be and the same ar~ 'hereby dismissed ,with preju.dice and.: r: ~..' '. • ,,1,'

without costs. . "·'·r'",'.

'.

'bated: New.s..•.:·.'rk~·'.; ei:¥.:~il(."·'J":'; .~' ,"'2015

Attorney for piaintif(s:, . '".' '.Louis Ambiicoa:rrd:Ysabell&:Airibii~b\ViLENf~~·G.0G~~IAN&:SpifzE~·?',,':

l' 10'Wiili~:·Sti~~ti;.~,\'.~' " \~':" . "N~w York;:NeW:Ybrk 10038' .: ' .•.C2l2) 267~309i ~< ~ '~::'':'c:;::';.'. ,> .~:"

: ,'. ",t.:

. 'Chauvron S.'Leo,ta~d,.f;.~q.·Attorney for Defendant ~:

., P~r:qP:Yri~,qorP6t:~tion ;~;i'. 'MCGIVNEy:&'KLuGER, P:C.

',' v" ',,', i:;i·?p:·Br~~~<ic$~re~t~.Stiite.23:60 .,New York, New York 10004C?12) 509-3456 ..

~, '.

soORDEREJ5"~ultOrt' ~.. ):

.... ~.'

.,

(,

'''.' .

... '~

," .....

.. ~

.\~. ' ./ ' :: ~ ~,'

.' ,

. '"

• . J;

./ }'"

"

".':-:-0

" .

t'

",(

,"':' '~, ."

,: : ; '.

......... ~,,, .. ..-

. ,;'

i,

. , ~,

~';

, .

(

I

.'

~...

!

0" ..,,'.

.'

..;

<. -' ~,

.... ~

~ ", '

!

. :

.:.... ,

~. :,,"

...',~ "

," ,,'

SUPREMECOuRT.OFFfH,E· STATE'OF NEW YORK':COUNTYOF~NEW'¥0RK.'.{·, : ~. ::' '., ' ..::.INRE: .NEW. YORK::'€ONNTY' .;:NYcAL'" ....

. ASBESTOS~BIiFIGATION . ·:::iifi\;~gP.~.§94:{;....'.. ' . ;. ,:.~/.' :. ". '. l~oll1tori::t·r,.

THIS DOCUMENT REFERS TO: -i' ' .. :11"'\;'.-." '.'

I Index No:.:

. JOSEPH P. HADDEN AND ELEANOR HADDEN

,.":

. .~OOPPOSITION

SUMMARY JUDGMENTMOTION ANDORDER

WHERF:.E..,,9RE,:defendant, Courter & Company, me., hereby requests summary judgment, . - .. ,

~,' '

in the aboveentitled·,cas.e, :pursuantto Civil Practice. Law and Rules. §3212, dismissing plaintiffs

complaint against. 'defel)daht, Courter & Company, In,c...~ith prejudice, and there being no

opposition thereto,

ORDERED, that upon riotic~'.toall co-defendants;allc1~ims amtcross'c1aims against defendant,

, ". . , ~"-' ." ".. ',1- '. \'. .. : . .

Courter & Compa,ny, 'Inc., 'be and the same are hereby -qismissedwith, prejudice and without

"costs.

Dated: ~~rk, ~ew York~t , J£:,2015

1:::Pil~.-'--,---"-,.----WEITZ & LUXENBI;:RG;.:P,.C.... 'Attorneys forPlamiif( /';~.::',...Joseph P. Hadden anet':El¢$or Hadden700 Broadway: . '. . .... •~;•.' .New York,' .~ew ¥ork i0003~

(212) 558':5500 ' '.'-"' ..

• "" ; I) ;

','\. ..-: :: ~ ': -~",.. ~"... "" '"

SO ORDERED. ~~:H.Moulton.;.'.

~. .'

z""2 ':kEsq. .,.

---- .

)}.:.-, .1122-10298

c' ;

{N0396513-1} .

I\

\\

.\ .j'

.,

'.,

.' >

.<., ....::••

" :'

-;:" i. "'".

"'.<.', '.~ .

..... ... ? ',.~ 4" '•

.::~>. " ','

" .

, .

..'.....-',

.' ,, '

." ,".-.'\:.' :"::. \, .. , .

,' .., ,

.:'. :::. ,{ .~:, ',

.. ~ ... - .•~ ".".,' :....SUPREME COURT'OFTHE,:Sr:ATE OF NE\¥YORKCOUNTY OF~:W':Y:0~':',"~e,~":,; •.... , ";' .:. . ,:.... . ,,~ .":',,INRE: NEWYORK COUNTY. . .'iNYCAL; ':,.:; '.:

' ...:.: " -;~ •. I,' ""-~," .~ -:'.(:'>'-,'", I~_-,·j··::':·~'::'·>.\ '. ~C"";~ ~'. '

A~BESTO~LITIGA,II0N ',' "J"{,\;,~,:igfl!!:~2:9.:':·:/,'~;,··"',:,' ., '" ":' ri(Mouli6il';J), .... '

THIS DoeuMENT" REFERS TO: .; .:' ,.,H;., ..." ~.'.,I'I Index No.; '114204/93, 131543/93,I.

" . I'

JOSEPH P. HADDEN AND ELEANOR HADDEN .:iI

. I NO OPPQSITION: SUl\1MARY JUDG~ENT: MOTION AND ORDERI ~ .. ' . .i

I'

WHEREFORE, defendant, Treadwell Corporation, hereby requests summary judgment in

the above' entitled case, purs~antto Civil Practice Law and Rules§. 3212, dismissing plaintiffs.• . ,r .

complaint against d~fendant, Treadwell Corporation· with prejudi¢e,'and there being no opposition

thereto,

ORDERED, that upon notice to: all co-deferidantsi all 'claims and' eros,s claims against defendant,.- . . '", . ..' '.. ....:

Treadwell Corporation, be~4:the:same are'her~by disInis~ea,wiihprejudiceand without costs.

",

~\)\).\'S\ '\2.~ffio",.:WEITZ &LUXE.N~ERG,:P.C.

Attorneys for Eiaintiff . . .Joseph P. Hadd'eh and)3le~~rH~dden '700 Broadway' ",New York, New York 10003,',

. (212)-S58~5500' ,

K , cmI(M)Cook,'Esq.Me I. EY&KLuGER,P~C.

Attomey~t6r Defen~ants "Tre~dweil Corporation'80-Bhnid:Streei,::'" 23rd FloorNew, York, New¥otk 10004(212) 509-3456

1235-9784

{N0396523-1}

...•

i'

t,;.

"',r! .t·

,.'

,"

.;-

, .' .". ~

: NO OPPOSItION SUMMARYi JUDGMENiMOTION AND ORDER

"

i Index. No.: q31 05/98, ..

. ,

. , .ALPHQNSE R.LITZ

ANDJULIA LITZ

IN RE:,NEW ):OR*C6HNTY~ :.. ASBESTbsrd:riG;\TiON

.:-~ ~ >.

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OFNEW 'YORK:...':COUNTy.OFNEW'YORX ',' .. ·.;1 ~ ..':'

• ' .. , ,_/:.-~ v ". "'. /.

WHEREFORE, defendant, Courter & Compapy, Inc., hereby requests summary

J

judgment in the abo,v.e entitled case, pursuant to Civil practice·L~.w·aridRules § 3212, dismissing: ."

plaintiffs' complaihtag.ainst defendant, Courter &. Company, Inc., with prejudice 'in this action,.' .... . . '" '.' '.

and there being no oppositiolJ, thereto,'I.'

. ORDERED, that upon notic'e to all co-defendan~s;"all claims and cross claims against. . .'. ..... .

defendant, Courter & Company" Inc., be arid thesam.~ ~e :l)~ry}~y dismissed with prejudice and'. . ', ;' " '.1~

'1.

without costs.

','Dated: New York, New York

Lj-/y . ,2015

.'

...~.~

0~~rJ'4it&t:~~dq". ,..Alphonse R: titz..·anc(Juha LitzWEITZi&LuXENBERG,P:C.·· .706 Broad\.\Ta'Y· ";;." ..... 'New York, New York 10003. ' ..(212) 55'8'::5500 "

'.-. '('.J : ~

~..

,~ .

--_ ...

1122-12,78I ~~'. '. " .

. ''-''''~>i' ,~ . '~.

'0',,' .

. ... '-,r '

. "

~ .

",-

._.~--

",'-

. .'"'-

. u' (.

.,.; t'

•

. ~.,

. \.

\\." ...

,,~ ";' >~ .~~ ~.~_':~, :' , . 'i.'.

'''., '. '.

" I t ~" . ,'.

._ ,.. ':"., '.... .: - .'.' C'· ".,< ',_\ - , ~~',

SUPREME COURT <?F :TffE:SJA'TJ?: OF NE~,Y6I3iI<;':'" ,,, .. " ./. J '. 0 Ii:5l - .' ~C~UNTY OF:t'{EW ¥(:)RKr» .... . ' 0 ",' i~ ·\,.i,: .'. ,: 0"" ••~:. 0 ~.:.':~" ': J%~~© " r-, •.•

IN RE: NE~ .Y0,RI\ ~qlJ)~1Y .: . . :. ; ..;T l;J:YC1\L :,' ".,. : ' :'. ' ..: or.; t "0 • •~Ur?J/S;:-T;\.ASBESTQS LIT,IGATIGN' .>.' ,,: .LA,.s.R,:a"rr,50,· .",;,::, .::" , .~ . .A-1Ay· :, .. :.~Ud)

..~,.:.. ":>~.,"".",.o ';;io{Moult0~";~)'{ ,;~;,..:. ' ..' ~Vl'i :?62(jlS:, ." ',:'~ '; '.- " ,'. ~..'. '; . ;" ,:", - ,.,' .;;" "'}.:'

This' Document Relate~fo:.·~ . C . ,'::0'

:' \" "f" ,,' .": i Inde~'No.: 1 BI O$i98,ALPHONSE R: LITZ ' .

A'ND' .' ,JULlA LITZ : NO OPPOSITION -SUMMARY

.\ ~ JUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER'"

------------------', .

WHEREFORE, def~ndant, Treadwell Corporation, hereby requ~sts summary judgypent in. . '...... ','

the aboveentitl~d:cas:e;pursuan(t~ Civil Practice Law and Rllles ,§ 3212, dismissing plaintiffs'. ': \ . '. '~ .

complaint against defendant, Treadwell Corporation, with prejudice' in this action, and there'. '. -.. ..

being no oppdsition theret~"

..·.oRDERED,~ that upon nO,tice to aU co-defeIldarits, all claims and cross claims against. ,

defendant, Treadwell ,co~~rati~n" be and th~ :same areh~rJ~~Y dIsmissed with prejudice and

without costs.

Dated: New York, N~~i York. 'L/ l-j '; 2oi~ l

..f' ;

. /

Att9rrte¥f9i:pefe?9~tTreCi9weU 'C.<;>rporaJiol1: .

.'MCGrVNEY&KLuGEB-, P.t. .80 Broad Stre~t-Suit~2300 .

. Ne~~York,::New York 10004(212)509-3456

. . ,

W~-ii""~tto~'wt~~.~~·~F'-:~ .)Alphonse R. -Litz':aild JiilifiLitz ..WEITZ & LUXENB.ERC}P.C.' :700 Broadway.;· ...... "'.: ... ; ". ", .'.~ . ,,, -( .' ',.' '. "~ :

NewyoiK,New "¥o~k 100,03,'(212) 558::.5500' .,' : ...

.....1235-792

'~':. -; " t. ,

',. ....',)

•

..;

"

'\,

(

,..',".

'-,:.

."

.;

.~ . \',

,Co

,"

'.

, ,.')

.'/-

, '

',,',

:v 'j

r

"

. ... :

.\ '.' , '

. ,~

....

,.v,•

. :",

" "',;,.... \,' ....~.. '.' '

X'FBWl464i~Aeg.u::,JJl~Hj,2;~~~o .. .,'", ,i " ..t '~;, ,,; .'SUPRHME€CJtJRT'OFTHE:STATEOF NEW'Y0RK,. ;,( ,;COUNTY'UF NEW.YORK'· ":",". ,.! "";,,~.,, , i· . '. "

~-,:----~-----~----------;,~~-:,------~~---,:'-'~-'------;'-----~----~---X "'::,"": ' ,"STEPHEN;,B: FOLEY,.as Afdministrator f~r,the Estate' ',·'No OPPOSITION SUMMARY

".QfJOliN,FeLEY:~(.fS'rEPHENP:F:OLEYas .' :ropGMENT MOTION'ANDExecutor'for the Estate of BARBARA FOLEY, ORDER '

, . ',!, , .' Pl~ntiff(s),

"

- 'agains!,~, ... ' ., .: .\ ~

'" ':' J.~:., .' ... ,;

';, ~I :

, A.O. SMITH VIATElt'PRODUCTS CO., et al.;:.' ..

. Defendants.~ . .

---------------------;.;.~-------~------------------------~--------/C

" Index No.: 125210/02

NYCALLA.S'. p~)6'~O

WHEREFORE, defe~dants FULTON B6ILl~:RWbR:KS;iNC.hereby request summary.. ,,' ~ . ." . :: '.

'. .judgment in,the above-entitled case,pursuant to Civil Prattice'Law and Rules Section 3212,

.dismissing plaintiffs' compl~lntagainst defendants FULTON BOILER WORKS, INC. with '.. .

, prejudice, and there being"p.ooppositionthereto,, ,

. ,;

ORD~RED;thatupon..notice to all co-qeferi4ants, all da.ims.and cross claims against,.,';';' .

• .,. ,'" " ~ 4.~_ .". • ,,' , '

defendants FULTON BOILER WORKS, INC.,be·ahdthe;s~e are hereby dismissed with:.,. . .."' . ," .0'·'· ," - . , . .

prejudice and with,QU.t costs.Jr.·, ..

'"YhztJ lS~ ',.,'

!- .. II.; .. ,<

"

/j

I '....j

,'. ',.: " ,. "- ,',

.:'-,'

.....

......

, ..,.

'.',,:

.. ' ........

,; ... '

r 0 '~ r

..,. fl'."

.-'"0'" ,

\;';'.

.;.

-:';"

. ,:..~

'. ~-+ ,

..', ~

'."

"

" .

, .,-. 0 ~

.... , ,.I't

,OJ'

, ..

" ".

"'~ A

'·7< .~ , ~''; ;, ." ;

,'.'. r

'; , ,

:\:'0:C'

"

.,'

,.,,'

;, ,.

,'?--';

~ .

:1·

_~·'dl."~' 'j~"'""-- -' ,"\~: • .. " '\x/\...}.

. ' , "

'.'.

' .....~~#l~

<~/

t';\.

"

,'.

,I""'-

~'J..'..," .. , ,

~ '..' /'

, )

;..

. '.

;', .

'<Y':

.::-.' ,.--'.j '"." ,

,-". .. ~

N()-OPJ>QSITIQNSUMMARYJUDGMENT MbtIONANDOlIDER

. ',: '

I .1; •

• ";..•• "'" ',' '<.~. \ -.;.. :

• b ,," 1...

-,, ... ~~~~. .

(' ..:'\; .''1) : •.••• -.' "

"-

PJ~!ntiff(s),

~.:, '.",-. . -,

.,' - . :,' ,- .' .... - .;X:IFBWI46119Ilegiil/fl;brlw;v20L5' ,-

.,- ;", ",' j

SUPREM:E· CaURIT' 'dE THE'STATB OF NEW Y6RK~},·COUNTY bF'NEW'Y'0RK ,." '-, - . i.' .'- ,> .; ~-

----.-------~-----.,~-,-:-~.~-~~7:,--;.---~-~~-;.---:~-:------------- ..---XROBERTF. TERRY-and- JANET TERRY,. '. ~ ..,". .

. - against- Index No.: 118317/02

A.C. & S, Inc., -etaI.

Defendants.-----.. --,-----..:,-'----.-.--.---..----..-------------~------------------:. X

NYCAL" " 6'bLA.S. Part;.ff ,"

- "

WHEREFORE, defendant' FULTON BOI~ER WO~S, INC. l:er~by requests summaryf'i. •.

judgtnentin the above-entitled"case, pursuant to Civil Practice' Law and Rules S_ection 3212,. . ~ "

dismissiQg plaintiffs' complaint agaipst defendant FULTON BOILER WORKS, INC. with.. . .

_ prejudice, and.therebeing·no:dpposition theiet~, .:,".i . ~ . • "

...

ORDEREDjhatupon notice to all co-defendan~s, aIrclaims and cross claims against. "'J"'~ . . ~.. .

defe~dant FULTON BofLER WORKS,rNC. De and·the-sarile,'are hereby dismissed with

Charles Ndi.l,,·Esq. ' .

_t~~~~K.f~~rg~t~~~.~~;!Wbtks, Inc.

.2 Rectpf Street" 14tl1 Floor_N¢wYotk; New York 10006

(21,2) :, B-3600,

prejudice and.withou.tc0sts.k-\ \. \'1\ \? /.

r ..FraiU< . rtiZ; :Esq~ ~ .

~~i:~.I~~~~:;~~fs;: .700Bro~q~aY~,. .' .

:New York,NY'~10003{212} 558~5~500-' .

: ..

"(jl<", ~."'\M-.". :" ' , "'~: .,~,', .~

,- '. '. ',.,.••••. _ _ ott •

('

""':

..

..f .

'r

. ,",' :~~

~;, .

.,

.)' ,',"

"':"

" \r .;~.;

.~. "

;' ....,,'

...,. f' .;,

.-- I.' " .. " .......

,"

,; r'-'~

~': ..'.. ',.""

\',

.,..~ .

17 ,'.-,

, ..

"'." ". ~' :",,'

.•.•

" \

('.' "

:,:- ". -?

........ ,>!"''T .....

;;'-"

...~...

...•

.'

", "

': .

.. ...

,-. ,"

\- p.

:0>.:. : ... '...

/- "

~. ,

" ,.\'. -,' ... ",./

..•.;..,

" .\ .,:.

~", .

,": ."'-"

"'"

" , ." .:

..~ .

'. I

yr.:...::,.,.' .. '.

.~. ', .

.";:

, .":'

.....

" <- ~ •

. ' ,',

CLBS9382/Iegal/no;sjinlfebhlat);201S' 'c. " ',' ", .'. .,"

SUPREME-COURT OF 'HIl~>STAtE OF·'~EW YQR:'K .~COUNTY OF NEw'.tORK.· . ' .-------~---~---_:~-~~-:~------~--~:_-:~--------~--------------~--)(ROBERT F. TERRY and JANET TERRY,

, )

A.C. & S'. INC., et al.,

Plaintiff(s),"

-against-

. NO OPPOSITION. \ SUMMAJZYJUDGMENT

MOTION AND ORDER

Index No.: 118317/02

NYCAL. LA.S. Part)6 SO

Defendant(s),---~-----------~--------------~------~---------------------------)(

.WH~REFORE, defendants CLE!'-VER-BROOKS, INC. hereby request summary

judgment in the' above-~ntitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212,

dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against defendants CLEAVER~BROOKS, INC. with prejudice,

and there being!no opp6sit.ion thereto,"

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all Claims and cross claims against

defendants CLEAVE~-BROOKS, INC. be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and

Frank Ortiz, Esq..Attorney for phd:ritiffWeitz & Luxenberg700 BroadwayNew York,'NewYork 10003

'.":

Sh~wri~ .... 41"AttomeysfotD'efeIidant

,CLEAYER-BROOKS, INC.Barry McTiernan & Moore,2 Rector Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 10006(212) 313-3600

i~:'

"

""".;""',';:'"

';.

1'"

~ -

~. ..

"ilT

,o"

• 'if. '.

,,~

'-;;.

':., ,.'",'

I,

r~ •

..,....<it ,

"~ ..

" ., t-'"

"1', ·r

r.', :

,'':- "

"

.~

"

;c

..>

, '

......

,:.'1' "

,.,-:'

~: '

., ......

. ~ .-' ~~-...,..

',."

" I

"',:.

i,

.. ,'.

~.,. C'""

. :~, "

....,~ .. t

dy.·,

'"

~,<i, \' ,c'"

.'.,...

"

''; .

o. ", :~'.,

o .;~ -' '.

X:CLBI59368IlegavNOSJlI,i;(ebr'uary2015 :;:', ;.~"': ••-' '. ~;J' ;"' -;; <;." '.,.

SUPREMECOURtOFTHESTA'TE OF'NEWY-ORi< "~;);;'"""••""."" ,,': .', .... ;COUNTY:OF>NEW:Y;ORK""\<' -' _ -:,'- '-.: . "-

---~-~~7~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~:~:-~~~-~;--~-----~~---:~-~~~~~~~~}tSTEPH:ENP'~:~FOLEY~:as'Adrriiriistnltorfotthe Estate':N'ocOPPOSITION SUMMARY ..

_. Of.JO~:.F8tEY (~d'$/~~r~eN P.f.QLEY as ' JUDGMENT MOTIONAND--Executor 'for. the E~lateofaARBARAFOLEY, 'ORDER '.,

.' _Plalntiff(s),_

'~~ "

- against- .. .Itide)( No.: 125210/02

WHEREFORE, defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC. hereby reques~ summai-y', . '.

I

I.

I

-AO. SMITH WATERPRODlJCTS CO., et al;:. ,

. Defendants.----------------~--~~~~--~---------------------------------------)(

-'NYCALLAS. Part)-ffSD

judgment in the above-entitled case, pursuantto Ci'vil P-ractic6 Lawand Rules Section 3212,

dismissing plairttiffs'complajnt against defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC.. with prejudice,

·rSha,Wilt~a

Attorneys for leaver-Bro.oks, Inc~

Barry McTiernan & Moore2.R~ctor Street, 14th Floor_Nf/J/'York, New York. 10006(212) 313-3600

-' . ..Frank Ortiz,Esq:' ." __Attorney for P.la~ntiffs

Weitz 8i"tuxenberg700 Broa,dway, . _New York;'New York roo'O~-

and there being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED, thai upon notice"to al1,co~~efendants, all claims and cross claims·against·

defendants CLEf\VER-B~eOKS, INC., be and the sake are hereby dismissed with prejudice and .

without costs4

1@/;:;) ..)~ '72- /'~~~~/~-~' -'g)J:'..",~:,~".,.r.' )~(!~'?~1~~'P·.. ·f· __.._" .... ;:,.' .,'V~l\'4 "': ,'~~._' . .

.~ . I

:; ",

. .., ~

".

~.. -....-!"

"

'-" ,

'r.

" '

, I

.~

,~0 .(I~..I

"

"

. ~...... ~. - -.-

,"':-,' ." .' .~i"·

: '.:: .

.-;-,.."j

: i; ~ ' .•' .:-. ~ • ~" "!,.

;.

,,:-,--,<. ",

._, "I. ';.. "

. •. ~~. .j'

.. ' . ~.~ .. ' . ""n. ,

X:FBW/45717i1eg~IINd;;Jj;jie~~i~&~015 :' "', ",', _~," ~J, ,, ':", ,.;~o':\":~:~;SJ,' ',,~;f,~, ,,' "" ',' ';; .: " ,,:(e<'.~;I·~Fr ,,<', ..

SUPREME'COUR1,'(jJF:rHEiSTA:fEOF NEWYORK, .' ',~;;'; ',:

~~~_:2'~~~y:~~~~~":::~::::-_:_;_::_------:----:~ij~~:;" .. -.: .' ."DAVID JOSEPH ~~RNES andTERRY L. BARNES, " 'NQ'OPPOSITIONSpMMARY

, , . ',:i;TUDGMENT MOTION J\ND,; Phlintiff(s),ORDER

:.. against:"

, Defendants.'------------.;--_:":'~ -;.~ -:--::--------'--';--------:--------------------,---X"

~ .

"" Index No.: 106578/02, 112741/02 &

114779/04

. NYCAL, >I.A.8. P~.oo- Sb

\

"'.' .-"t

WHEREFbRE,'defendants FULTON BOILER: W'ORKS, INC. hereby request surtunfu"y

judgmentin'the above-entitled case,pursuant to Civil Practice Law,and Rules Section 3212,, "l , ' ",' ,

dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against defendantsFU~TONBOILER WORKS, INC. with

prejudice, and there being,n? opposition th.ereto,

oRDE@D, that upon, notice to aU co-defendants, ,air clairi,ls,arid cross claims against,~~ • ", .' "'~.,~ ,M"~"

defendants FULTON B6ILER WORKS, INC., be and the saple are hereby dismissed with• ., . j' . . ~J,' . . ~

'prejudice and witl10ut costs.

1.-\\\1 \ \~,

.. '~: .~ .....

. .;~

'" • ,"" I

'. '

,:;'-'

~..

:'..

>', ~

. ,::::'.

~..

• i

. .~ .

.;1:,:' <:.

. ' ~

...;

, .. '.

" '.'

...... _. ....

:'J.

. ,'.

'," ~, >-"

'.'."

J.

.', ' ..

.'.

'.., , <.~, '.'0'

;',

':'.

" ,-\

'0,

r-', ~

.'-, .

..-.-" ..~ ~.

. . ~.,

'i'' ..

?'.~.

"'.

.J •

.','

'>-:7:..

1/'>:,~(

",

"

;.<. -<',,'

~," .'. ~.. '. , ".",'

: .. ~.

Plaintiff\s), .

- against- '. lri4ex No.: 190093/09, .

A.C &S. IN~., et aL; .. ;.

.Defendants.

-----------------~-~~~---------~------~~------------~------------)(

'>',

NYCA:LLA.S. Pa;rt~ .9

WHEREFORE, defendants FUr.-TON BOILER WORKS; INC. hereby request 'SUrnn'lary

judgment in the above-entitled case, purSUaIlUO Civil Practice ;Law an<:rRules Section 3212,

dismissing plaintiffs' complaint 8:gainst defendants FULTON BOILER WORKS, INC. with

prejudice, and therebeingn9 opposition thereto,... " ,~I ~'

. .. ~ , . ;. .

ORDERED; that upOli::notice to all co-"'defenQants', allc'~mms and cross claims against• • ~ , • -..... ' • .' - . ~.'. 4' ; ,.::- .. " •. '.: ~" • : ..

defendants FULTON BOILEKWORKS, TNC.,be aI1d the same are hereby dismissed with.

. ;

:..:.. ...

Brian FeId;:·Esq.Attoineys. for' Fulton Boiler Works, Inc~

Barry M<;Ti~rnan & Moore2 Rector Street, t'4th FloorNew~York, Ne~ York J0006(212) 313-3600 .

.~

.:; ......... - .... ..

:....:.. r

.' ..

. .:' ';~.:-r.:."';'~ ".' .

•.>.

prejudice and with04.t co.st,·.' ./' 'd_{ z6 \.5.~~./";'.' ~."." '~"dJ''. . :.<,Pl.:: :..~,::::'·.. ' .:.'T..~f

..... ' .. tjIj:.' . ".. ' ' ,;: ." ....

. . .

SOORDEllliD'fi~~tCJ~:J1i~~·ffNJIS';":::,;'~!~f~;'~CJUL-ro,~ '...", ·

'. ":...

. Frallk Ortiz, Esq....' "Attorney·for Pla#ltlffs ; .Weitz & Luxenb~rg';' .700 Broadwa~ . '.' "':'.New 'York, New ¥orblO003

~. .

, ..F~ '7"' . ~:.-: .

.•<,

~.' .

• oj".

'.<1

" ~..,".'

'- '- .• ... I..... -~ ,~

';

: :

:"',_:;

~ \1' '.

,.' '

'.::-",

' . .i;

.J.'

."

f'

"1'

'.

,.'

,,'

~{ .'.:, ~.'

,::'

,,:'

;.

'-"~ .:,'

' ..;~

>.'."

·...... ·,t;'

,_.~

~, :

':'

.'

"'..

, .

,~ '.

',,',t." .'

'.'" .

~ .....' I" ...

',:.~ ,', ,..

"\ ',."• ' : :~'... ..'. .;';t..•t/ ~:;~,i}'~:~' ;)v·:':.\ < ~: : '. ~; f~'

X: FBWI457931legaUNOSJMlfeliruary201r' i, . .

. . ~>,,: ;:;;:~~k~'~r':' ,,': ::r~· .. <-:~:~: ~'. "- ... ;', . . ..;. I,:. . ."

~~~~6~?J1~\~,~·~S~ATE:P~.NE~Yq~".·: ;., .,'" r------,.---;.------~.~~-~~~~.~~~~:~~'"~.;:-'",~,~~.~-------------~~.,--------.;-~ ". ,- ::" " . -

FRANCES A: BARJUO;·a,s ExecuttixJor the Estate of '- NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYEDWARD S. BARRIO ,~d FRANCES A. BARRIO,' 'JUDGMENT MOTION ANDIndividually, " , ;:, . ORQER

Plaintiff(s),

-'against ,-, Index No.: 113153/02 & 107221102

A.C. & S. INC., etai'.;

. _~ :~f.'.: . Defendants.

-----~--------~,..,-.;~.,~:~-----.,--------7---------~----------------)( , -

NYCALLA.S: Part}8'5U

WHEREFORE; defendants FULTON BOILERWORKS, INC. hereby request summary

- judgment'in the above-entitled case, pursuant to ,Civilpractice Law and Rules Sect~on 3212,

dismissing plaintiffs':compliunt against defendants FULTON BOILER WORKS, INC. wjth. , . , . " ,:' . .' ..

,- prejudice, and .ther~: ~eing nn:ppposition thereto,'. <.

~ . ~~

ORDERED"that up,pn notice to all co-defend;t~,ail~¢laims ,a'nd cross claims against• • .", " '... , .": ~ • 'ft" !'

.~' ::~.

defendants FULT6NBOIL~RWORKS, INC., b'eaI,ld the',same ,ate h~reby dismissed with

, ,

': Bdah'FeId; Esq.Aftom~ys for Fulton 'Boiler Works, Inc.Barry McTiernan & Moore .2 Re.9tor street, 14th"Floor -- 'NewYbrk, New Yark 10006. . ~'- , " . ,

(212).313-3600 '_ ~Q'

~~ "

SO~RDERED~' . ;6'j,.,',_IJt/~ ~ \'" ,'\. 'l),,~O',._c:J(\C~. '. . '-":~terMoulton ~ f;~'1-"'~' ,

,MoN~:~EtER'H~'MOULT(lN' '" .-I (j~ '{O~ ,

' ...",' :, "'\ CO~'t\\~~~, ' ",',

Frank Ortiz, Esq., Attorney for Plaintiffs

Weitz &Luxen~erg700 Broad'VayNew York, New York lOO'03" . ';." .' ..," .":,

- '

"

.;:

....:.

:.',"

I ... •

..- I.

..

.~"

'd.;~

.'!~ •.

.:......

;..:

>.,:

::.:.

r.;

..'

;.,.

~.

"':.,"

;:

''.','',

" .

", ,"

'..,,:. "

. '. ~ ......

"; .'...

~- ,

::,.:

,,~.

"

;. :

""j..

."" ~, ';.

.f".....<1 j.~,

.'

\ .

t· "" .-,',,:\ : ..:-

. . ~ . .

X:CLBI59453IlegavNOSJMlfeb;uary2015 ' ",

. ;" -",' :; ';",:.,.', /,~..:.~': :,.:,~:~~,,, ~' .., .. , ~." ' ":. _r~. ,. .'SUPREME~COURT'OFTHE·S.TATE:OF'NEW<Y.oRK'COUNTY'oF;NEW~.Y.oRK· :.' .:. .... . , '___~__~~~ :_C~~~~~~_~_~~:L~~ ~~~'~~~~~ ~_~~~ ~~__ ~ ~)(:

, FRANcES.pL:BAiUu'6~ 'ak' 'E~~6utrix"for th~ Estat~ ~L .EDWARD s.BARR1(f~dFRANCES A. BARRIO,Individually, .' , ' .

Piai~ti~f(s),

..

" ..........,. I"

~.:.. '; .

'..",,?

• "of

'"

",-I'

. {... ~

'. '.

,,':'/' :,~ . r .• '", .','

. , ..'. ~ ..;..'."' ; ~

: 1..

.~b~~~~T~;T~g~~:YORDER .'

- against-

Defendants.---------------~--------~~---------~--------------------~--------J(

Index No.: 113153/02 & 107221102,'.-,

NYCAL. .LA.S,. Part...J6 5'"'"b

WHElmFORE, defendants eLEAVER-BROOKS,'INC', her~by request suiiunary .

judgment in the above-entitled.case, pursuant to Civil p'ractic~Law aJ?d Rules Section 3212,. '.' r '. •. ,

dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against defendants CLEAVER'"BROOKS, INC. with prejudice,. ,.;"" .- '. . " . ~\ '.

.arid there being no oppO'sitionthereto,

ORDERED, that upon notlce to all co-:defendiillts, ;Ulclai~s and cross claims against

defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC, be and the s$e are hereby dismissed with prejudice and

without costs, ,

. 4!2.a!l'S·· '::'.. ", ~'"',".: ,.,.: .~.. ···.;~;,.;4~·'·~' ..•.. B);';.;:c·Yf~:.·

.' .. '.. ....;:. . . " ~ .

Frank Ortiz, Esq: ..Attorney. for J:>laintiffsWeitz & LtiXenb,erg'700 Broadway, ,'. '

.New York, New York 10.003

..,. ~ .,:".. :' -:

"

I·, ." ,

'", '.

-, ,

-.f •.' \.. :~

;--.

':.:

".

.,'J

·:.l ;:.

,":'""

.'~: .

"

.';-l ..-_~ •

-'

..' ~ , '. ;; '. '

,­'¥'

. , .

.. :'

'. / ."

.,

,r

" ,

.."

'>- ••• ;

",'-

...:,:::/' ':..

"",',:',~

".'

,'-

',-,"

,~ .

l i~· :

.':'

"';'

~"

",

··f.,

,:,

,',

X;CLBIS8822itegaUNOSJMlfebrudry20iS .

SUPREME COURT OF THE STAlE OF NEW YORK

COUNTYOFNE'YYORK.. .' . .----------------------------~------------------------------------)(IRVING'BERGSOHN,

Plaintiff(s),

-against -

A.C. & S. INC., et al.;

F'ILEDMAY 12 2015

COUNTYc'. NEWLEyRKS OFFIce

. .ORK

NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION AND

. ORDER

Index No.: 190093/09

.NYCAL·vLA.S. Part~ Si

Defendants.-~---------------------------------------~----~------------------)(.

WHEREFORE, defendams CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC hereby request sUmtbary""~"

judgment in the above-entitled case, pursuant to Civil J:>.ractice'Law and Rules Section 3212,

dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC with prejudice,

and there being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED, thatup6n notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC., be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and

. with~ut c6sts\_IIZ61, 'S .'~"~.':' tt······;~·····:·~<·.··'~' .. . . .,'-. '.'" .

. '. '. ." .' . :) -', ~~" ,

. . .

,..... " -, .. --:" .'.....-. ". .;

. . :1-,

Frank Ortiz, E;sq~

Attorney for PlaintiffsWeitz & Luxenberg700 BroadwayNew York, New York 10003

SO ORDERED, .~HOI). Peter Moulton

. . .; .'; ':'.' ..~

Shawnette Fluitt, Esq.Attorneys for 'Cleaver-Brooks, Inc.Barry McTiernan & Moore2 Rector Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 10006(212) 313-3600

" "

. ~l

,,~,,,'c·'

'S;"",'

'.,:

.. ';,

·"'P

.':.

,"rA .

", :'

. ~:~,J

;;

"'.,

",....' J"_

",

"t,'.

:'

, "

/.

"';

'>.' '

C:",

, /G' " ',,''V\~~~''~ .•~'\

. '.' .,

'. ",, ~ ,

, .~

...~,

,~

"

c "

':;

.... :

'.' .(

Plaintiff(s),

. '." "-~:' 'r', """" " ,',": ...~.~ ,',

X:CLB/55414/legallNOS:JM/februiiry2015 0' .... ,, ._,.' .... :' ':,::4~,<~P~'~~-;~_,~f~:~>~_,'- ,,' .. " . :,:"~,~" ~ .. "

SUPREMEC0I:1R1::'·0F:J;HESTA1'EOF NEW YORK'.;' ., ~ " '.. " ", ;,~~ '::-..;i:,;>~:,~.- ~·~,<·'_:':_<i··"·'('-".~<. ",~:';"':_;'- .... '.~ ,:.. <' I ••••,-:-:••~"' ,~;,:;,. ",

COUNTY OF NEW'YORK :, '. "...... ,,~ " .,' .,-------------,.---~:--~~~-~Lt:,-~---~,:·----~'.,-.----;.----------------X'

. DAVID JOSEPH;BARNES and TERRY L. BARNES, ," . NOOP.POSITION~'SUMMARY~, . .' . ; '; JuJ)GlVIJtNT MOTION AND

O:ItI>ER'- against -. ',~ ,

'··t····

:'Index No.: 106578/02, 112741/02 &114779/04

A.C.&S. rNC.; et'~L;',":' "

.,b~fendants.-----------::.---:-:---.::'::...;.":'-::.-----:~---:_----------------~------------.- x·

,"!. I'" ,

NYCALLAS. Part)6" SO

WH;ER£f..bRE:defe~dantsCLEAVER-BROOKS; ;~C .. hereby request sUIl1fTI~r";'

judgment in the above-entithid case, pursuant .to Civil i;ra~tiCb L~w and Rules Section 3212,, , " ': ' ''', "

. .

dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against defendaritsCL~AVER-~ROOKS, INC: :With prejudice,, !'-.' .', . •

and there being no opposi~ion .thereto,~::

.,'

ORDERED;'that upon notiCe to all co-defendaPts,i~U claims and cross claims against, . . . "

. defendants CLEAVER':BROOKS,·'INC.,'be and the sam:e'are hereby dismissed with prejudice and: ': .".. " :" :.}. ~. . ' .

i

without costs.,10.,

". ,.'

'...:~ .

Frank Ortiz; sq:" : Sh'a. .' e', . ,; Esq.Attorney fOr.':Plaintiffs . 'Attorrteys for Cleaver-Brooks, Inc.Weitz & Lu)(enberg , ~arry.Mctietnan & Moore700 BroadwilY .... 2 Rector.Street, 14th Floor.NewYork"N'ew York1JQ'0Q3New York, New York 10006

r,:' ¥\"'i' (212)3\3-3600 .' "~Q

~~"iA~'. '~:'~:::::::::::-?,'~-JJJl7IS 'f \ \.. 'l.~~ < " f.

~~ \ 1.~~SOff\C .

- ~ C\.~"iO~1[..,CO\)~ ~~~ .

. .

SO'ORDERED,

. .'i'. '.' .. ",....,;" .

~ "."

I .

. "'.

.: <. ~

, ;

.~.

.-' '"' :"'1'.\. -

r

,,," ,.'

~ ~ ..:,'",.

'1,

- .-

: 'r'

:-

'. ,"' ,'.

....t',

\",

. ... . ;'."):1'"-" \

"

", ...

".'...~'.

, '.

",

;:~ .~ ,

':.,

'f.'.(

""~. ,''';

'."-:.,~. , ;.

.II"... ",,':- ~..

"",".

",

,')' ,"

.. '

"

......,. .. • v.~·, .. ';Q

.,'

: t'...':.' .: .

.... f

,;.... ~.

'.~ .

..; , .:.

. i'-:

- .'

".'.;

, ~ :..; {. ~ 2,

" ,.

~ ," ". ,-.. .

.,0;,,/

. ~.

,.,;;..-' '., ',:

__ ~:; .. ·,·,t',··~:. (..,';. " .~.. '- • '1' ~,,,,

... "

.'".\,.

:,::

~.',-,

"

-'

'.t'· ..

",

"'~..

..; ':

: (, ..:. i;:~~..

,,;,1 ',:

,',;.

~.,

.-. I·.··

" .. \

Plaintiff(s),

:.'

,". ... .-,'

If1- r ... !, 't ';,

'" /""'!,,,):,::',;, " ," ,,:'::':;::6',<::~\d'"X:{(MilJ9168,/leg(/IINOSJMI', " '<, :". ',("" ":'0'/;""""'"

SUPREMECOURT'OF THE' STATE'OF NEWYbin(:'.';':,;'~·/',COUNTY OF'NEW'YORK' , , "'0 /:',','

...-.---------...:--~~ -~~~ ~~.~.----.'-._ ..--,.----------------- ---~-.-X,··.. 'LAWR;ENCE wO~tERSand VERA WORTERS, ' NO OPPOSITION SUMMARY

JUDGMENT 'MOTION AND~ . ' . . .

QRDER

';" • .... ;1-agamst·' ,. ~ ": :.'

3M COMPAN~,et,al.';

::~, .,' , " . Defendants,:--~---~---'~-~,;- :~;-~- -:-~.- ;:.:~\. ~-----:-,----------------------.--~-X

"index No,: 190403/13• of ••-'.' •,; .

'.

, WHEREFOREi,defe'ndants JOHN. CRANE'lNC 'Hereby'request summary jud~ment in

the ~bov~~entitied' c:ase,p'ursuant to Civil Practice La;w'~dRules Section 3212, dismIssing." .' • p' • •

plaintiff~lcomplai~(againsfdefendants JOHN €JMNE INC. with,prejudice, and there'being no

, "

opposition thereto,.' t" ,. - <

ORDERED, that'upon notice to all co-d~fenc\.a~ts;,~l claims and crossclai~11s against..~ . ..

defendants JOHN CRANEiNC.,be and the sain~ arehereby dismissed wit!? prejudice and

;..,.,;: .. "

",. -

t' .~",

,;. " .

~:.: .~ :t:',"

"

,without costs: .

HiJ-SjJ5 .'.I. "

, "

; ,

'.'. ','

", .~

'\ : .~~

~,' ,? .

"

"I'

",

~'< -

.,.....

"

, .

"'"

. .'.

~".

,j' "

:. ~.

,;

~.~.. '

.... ,~,

",'

~ ~ ..

''; "

.~..

,;

, "',

.-:.-, :',

'.

~. . ,:...",;, .

,',

", "

! '~' ,

,,'

""

..,'; ."'~ )"

~ .,,'; .

.',-

"

.. ","

".' " . ~ ..

.,"

• '1<>

. ~.

.' ~ .

;-.'.i_, ..

. ~.

, ,

.',;_,t:

'".

"'i»'

, I ~~ ..;,;",1:. '

.-.] ",

"

, i

, "

-'.;'

'!\"

." ~

,,'• j',

,; .;

:...,

"

,. ,-"

"

','

,",',

t,',.

,'., .,'

"0'.,-

" .,+loa

.;'!

,"

"

"

'.,:"

",c'

,_, "1 .": ..,;;;-:",?, .

1t10Ttub'f\~ ~~ 'YJt~;:I{~,<t;,t(nl':...., ..... '." - ~n'.. :--",~,.r"":~~ ',' ~ 0; ~}

.. ',~:" ,. ~". c.'

c) .'

,I

'"'G' •

"

,',.

'., '

... ; :

r;I

". '.~. " ~.: ::' : , .' .- .....'" ',,- ..t~, - '.. ,

~..~~.....,•._._.. :: ·:··:.·:-·~·····""·--·l T····

,,~ ·L

"",',

, •••':- .. : •• M •• ~. ~.' ,. '!

I'.'

.~ , .: ,

. ','

X:DOM/~O}9~./legIr~OSJ!.~iA~jJi;~iF-:-··'·· .' ;.':' ',' -.. ..., ., " .' .....

SUPREME COURTOF THE;:~TATEOFNEW YORK.COUN'i~y. OF NEWYOR.K· ". . "c" ,/:

j~;JE-~isTEF~~O-~d:~P~{t8;~is~i;~~o:-----X'".:?'·~O.:JjPPOSITION SUMMARY.. ' '. ." ., .' '. . ;;".niDGM~ENT MOT;ION AND.

'.~ Plaintiff(s), . ORDER •. "

: .'.-••,•• ;. ~.. •. '.' ••-.-.. 't'••••. ~ " ..."-' ----.- •••• .-. ~.' _. ; ••• -. I

.t.. '" '.,.,.~,4!;',. .,' Defendants.

--------- .::~i,'::~ -----------~ ----- -~;'----~-:--------------------'X:'.

If.idexNo:: 190364/14,

.. NYCAL '.. ". ·"ot '-'0

'.~ 1.1\.S. Part -rJ b

,~ '":,,',...

.. - against ­:.' '{'J~)~ <b

A.O.SMITHWATER:PRObUCTS CO., et a1.; "

,I

....••,#

---'l 'I.' ,

. y ' ..

.'

,".:I3nanf.~ld;)::sq,· . .At.t6iTl.eys'f.Qf.POMCO Prod~cls Texas, Inc.

·.Barr~ .McTl'ernan ~'.Moore'.' '. ~'. '2ReCtb:r~:S~eet,'14th Floor

.. N:~""¥9it(,Ne~ York t0006 .. , (ir2Y3j3C.369~.

.'.".

, .

. _,1':',_ 'It-:. . .. " ;.~;" .•::' . _ ,~ •.. ~''''' .~ "

..WHEREFORE, defeudaIits;DOMCO PRODUCTS TEJM.S; INC. hereby. r.equest. <:. " .-, ',' ,-: ' - ,... '

s~ni~a~ ludgn;e~t ·in,me;~,~~.~e-entitled ca~e,p~rsh~t.toC;:vil PractiCe La:w. and Rules Section: .. " '. . ". ; ~

-. r ..

3212, dismissing phlliltiiiisi :c~mpIaint agairist defendants'DOMeO PRODUCTS TEXAS, INC.. . : ~ :. -, :'.::"/' " ".'- "',"

with prejJiiice,1i~dth~reib"~~rig no (jpposi4orithereto,:'!' '. . ):.;~ ..:-.:.' ':.~ <> '~".' ~.: - . . .

ORnEREn';·th~t'~~n notice to all co~defendants;'all' claims:and cross claims against"'. i" :;: ' r:', ..::;,'. .',' . .•. :..,.. ','

defendants'DOMCQPRODUCTS.TEXAS, INC.,beabd the same are hereby disinissed with. .) ~ -/:'.' '" " ' .- ~ i .. .' ':- . . •. .'" .,.. ,

"' ,prejudic.e,M~ without90st~·. ". . ..

.~~ff1L5. ..'. ,': ": :..;~,.'.,: ....;:.~. ;:':"':' ...

; ,

.: '.~- ...\ :":t~' ".'..<: . .~" ~.

. /

, .;,.y

.....,.'

......,., ','

. j,

l' '

.";;-,

"

. ~ ~.

.' .

. .' ~". : .... ", '""

: ''i';",'

'-:., ."

"

,j

·~·.-,::r·;~ .. ,~....~

, .~

"'~

' .. e:."

.~ ~ .

"

", "

,~ ~:. ;' ,,',',

.. '-'f..., ;

(. ;.,~..,,):.;

• ,'rI ',.' ~ t

" ~

y

~ '.

~1·,

, <f;

I,

. ~'~.

.' ~ ..~ .. ' .

• ~ ,0'

" .

: .•.. \.:.'

,:

",

.....~ •. \'i,

,.

'"

. ,~ .'.\ .", "'-:'" ~ ,.-'

'. ""~ ',. :

""'.'

.' i : '~,

l'.,.~."1.

!- .

'i:

"t"

~ \ .:

"','1,

.'.-"

:,,,,'

,,'

"

,.'-,-, .

: .

··.C, .:;

"

,,'.'.: :; ~ .",.,

• i),,,

t : ''"-:~

" ....

',+,

-;-: .. ,

. , : .

........ 'ft

"

. ~"

; .

':;"

/'.'

.~ :"

.-l..

::.

....

" '

. ~.

" '. • j~1 .

/' ~.' ...

;: ~

X:CLBIS9s14IligallN.bSlMJinaH:II20iS A • '~'" , '., >., ,SURR;EJYtE'OQTttRill:OF TfIE STATE OF NEW ·YORK· .,:"

• L ' '. • L)' • .- ..' ~ .' • • ..~ _~"

COUNTY OF'NE'W YORK .' ' , ", "",~.~~__ ~ ~_~_;.~·~""L.;~~_~~;_~_~~~~~; __'~ ..~---~---~~x . .".;WILFREp L HINES, JR. ari'd NOREEN ANNHINES, . ,NO OPPOSITION SUMMARY

JuDGMENT MOTION AND.OItOltR" .'..

Plaintiff(s),

- a~aiIlsf- Index No.: 116038/06

A.O. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS CO., et al.;,

\

;NYCALLA.s.,P~5'c ,

Defendants./' -~--------_.._-----~---~---~-----~--~--------~------------;;. ....~--~)(

. WHEREFORE, defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC. hereby request summary

j~dgment 'i'h 'the above-~ntitled case, pursuant to CivilPracti~e Law and Rules Section ~212,

dismissingplaihtiffs' complain't against defendants CL,EAVER-BRpOKS, INC. with prejudice,•••.J

and there peing :no opposition thereto"

ORDERED, that upon notice to all 'co';"def~rtdants; all claims and cross claims against. . , ~ ".. '. '

defendants CLEAVEK·BROOKS, INC.,' be and the sallie are h~rebY'dismissed~with prejudice and" . , .

. SO ORDE~D'~e-i:':':;";n--'".M~e""-j~-e~~. -:.. -:---6:/11/IS, .' :, .. " .:DJOU~rOll·,

'r·, " .. .

..-

,::n~~1';t!4:~~:R()0KS, INc:2 :R:edor Sti'e¢i, ·14th'FloQt:N:ewYotk;New YOfk10006(212) 31,3~3600 '- .. ;, ~ :

~ • '\ .i".

without ~osts. \.~ \ ).. ~\ \>

....' ." :- t.-.~~;~' .

,'..'. ;

,.' .

,',<)

)

'..

"

.'

:!"

':'-,', '

.~'

.. '

.',:'

.r

.'..

.......

, ,

,.

. 'i,

..;

,.'> .' ~~

.'i.

;'

~t· •

......~.~.

t,

, "4 ,,:-,~ '. ~ :

'.:

•. i

'"

',,:

. ~

..,'

To", . ',1

~-,

.'.".".'

;',

. I',~ ../ ".

,.. :: _ ,::: ·:·"~~';';''''~··''~~;·'~~''·.·.'O''i'·.~·'·· .~ ." .:.... '

"iX:CLB/586651Iegir.I/NOSJMI"'jarcIi2015~~.,, '.. ;. ." . '. '.' . ..' ". SUPREME:t30URqt-OFitHE'Str:ATE QF NEW~¥QRK:'·· " ..

=~~!C:.~!J[~3_~~5S,: ::__~:;~:L_;_~}.:::x.i:Y~ ~.." , . .'. ....., .PATRICIA ANN HUTNICK PASTORE;:as Executrix' ,~ .NQ.OPPo.SITION SUMMARYfor the Estate. of PAUL M.HUTNICK, JR., . ," .'JtJI>,61V1ENT MOTION 'AND'.' 'OiIDBR' .'

. {

., '

Pl~intiff(s),

.-, .

Index No.: 122'549/01 .

., ....

A.C. & s.mc,; ~taL;" .

'/. :'

, NY-CALEi\.s. P~rt ~b 0

Defendants.-------- -"~'~;;'.- -';:.---'-- -.~;" ..--~-- --_:-.-,:,---;-~~- -':. -- ..--~ -~ ....----.-----X .;. ."

,':', .

. . ...WHEREE(}RE,~.def~hdants _CLEAVER::B.ROQKS,JNC;.,:here.byr.equ.es.tsummary.. ... ''': ~. . ':" ,. . -. . . . . ' ,

. .

judgment iIi the ab6ve-¢ntine~:case, pursu~tto C.ivil)ractl'6~·Law and Rul~~ Section 3212,. '. ': ~:•. ':":::.' '~.: . c·.'. • f.... '" . '.

dismissing. plaintiffs' con;pl~int against defendants 'CLEAVER-~ROOKS, INC. withprejudice,.

, (212) 31,3,-3'600'."

. , ..

,'. aITy.c;I.yrnan ;~~e

2 ReCtor-street; 14thF'}oofNew' Yoik,Ne~ York 10006

~.....

.' . ,". ' ....... , : "'. '. .~:""' .. ~.

...~~-s~,~, ,'.

, .~e:,~P,,'.~-.-'--

, 1ttOrff¢~$;t~ri:SLBAV~R:B~OOkS, INC.

,

and there being no'9PPositiorttJ:1ereto"

ORDER:ED~ tli~~~llpori\~otice tP.all co-defenda!n~; all claims and cross claims against

defendants CLl;A'1ER';,BROOKS, INC.,'bean~ the sam~ are hereby dismissed with prejudice and-. :i . . ', '. ". .

without costs.

',,'

. ~

,. ",

. . ...;'",'. ~'. ",..~. ,

d, .­ .-

.'; >(.,"

\.

:.;'j

::j

j

,j

::},J. j

j

j'j

j

j

j

j

j

Jj

j

j

"j'j

j

'j~.,~. "l,

, ;:;j

,~j,j

j

j

j

j

,:'j:j

j

.•j

JJ,Ij

'~j.:'~

i:.'j

"j.,.,j

:"

'>'. '.

r; ..

::"p'" " j

"'j

'"

,...

! ..

",

..,

<'

..... ."

:( ;

",

i .

~: .

" ,

~", .-, ~.

".

J'~,'"

"

""'"

~,

,,"

.17.

. ) .'FJ

.~"

"',<

",

". '

;-) ,

"

..x,~· ~,..:, ";~' .

, , '.' ~ " , ~ ..

-",L ::

'y.

J" "';""." ;:-'.,"

.. ,~'

j:'J - t! l'

.~' ;.

., ,

. ";'.

",',

-...' ~ .~

.:.

,I,

'",

'",,"

"',.

.' ."\'.

. :;

",',

"

"

J'

".

...• :

\.

'"

'.. :

.,,":.

.<~. ',.-'

... (

~>' ." .'

" '~'"

'f',

:.. ....

.~ ...

, ""r''''

f:>."

.,.'

,,-

.-$, •

':-"

,< ,

, ~-..

~,

, ~

I,'

'~''''.

':> "

.',.'" ;:,q " ;:

;.~;'. // .. ~ ~'[

,~.A"

",.' ;.

. '. ~n

<. t:'-'-

.' '; '"

J'I','

. .:,.'

,;

'-;.,'

'J

\ ,

I;

X:ciB/59516/leg~iJN6SJM/nlarCIl2015,1, ' '. ,', -')"SUPREME COURif:Q}\THE STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTYOFNEWYORK ',.. .'-

-------~------------~:_-~~-------------~------------~~-----~~-~~-)( ,

ROSE ANGELA KALACHMAN; as Administratrix forThe Estate of MELVIN KALACHMAN and ROSEKALACHMAN, Individually,

. Plaintiff(s),

- against -

A.a. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS co., et al.;NYCAL

Defendants.----------------------~----------------------------~-------------)(

'"NO OPPOSITIqN SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION ANDORDER

Index No.: 190240109

WHEREfORE, defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC. her~by request summary

judgment in the above-entitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice..Law and Rules Section 3212,

dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against defendants CLEAVER"BROOKS, INC. with prejudice,

and there being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co~defen.dants, an claims and cross claims against

defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC., be and thes'~e are hereby dismissed with prejudice and~ ." • I . •

!

without costs..'-\\ \-) \\ );,,;

~"CFrank Ortiz, Esq;Attorney for PhiintiWeitz & Luxenberg: , ' __---.J

700 Broadway' "New York;N'ewYork'10003

sHii\it'ff':~ i:i j .. , ' ,,'sq.',,'Attorneys ,,{CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC.Barty M¢Tiemaii &- Moore2 Rector Stteet~ 14th Flo@fNew York, Ne\¥, York 10006(212) 313:-3600:"

I

SDORDERED,,~t;KteiI1 Ileitl~, .;-sJJijJ:s '>f<,,:" .:,:

>IIoN.PEf.Jf~MOJJLTON"J

".,

.'

. ...'

. ,I.

"

..,

.·'l.

~.."

.;

\.,'

"

"

" .

I,

.'.:

'.

.y,

., .. '.

'..

..'.\..

"

....' ..

" ,-

';

" .~

" ,"!-',

" "'''.J .f..

:~II.

,."

't:o

.'.-'''''. ': "

.,-J,

.'

' ... '

,,' .-

• C !

Plaintiff(s),

.,~, .

v -"

'1,\:.,

.~ ," .::\ ,.,

, • • l

, X:CLBS9167,'iLegfIIINOSiMI " r .' " ~ .:,: ~/,r ' ' / .~SUPR.Eivq~coutrt(;>FTHE STATE OP,NEW'YOR.:t(·COUNTY OF NEW.YORK_____._~~~--- .•---~-~ ..-~----.- _.._.:_. --.:------ ----;.--~--X "LAWRENCE'WORTERS '~d VERAWORTERS,'-: . 'NO:OPPOSITION SUMMARY'

·~lI~GIy.i,ENT MOTION ANDOR))ER

- ag~inst ~ :. ,. Index No.: 190403113

3M COMPANY; eta!.; ':,., '.' ':. :~~~ .

Defendants.-~---------~---~~~--------~~"-~~_ .._--------;.--_:_;--;.-------_._~-){

:NYCAL. .' ()LA.S. Part)e' S;.

,', .,

' .. WHEREFORE, defe~dants CLEA VER:.BROOKS; INC. Hereby request'summary

.j~dgriie~t in the above-erttitlec!: case, pursu~t to C;viYPractice ~aw and Rules Section 3212,. -- . . '

di;~~issingp.la.inti,~fslcomplai,nt againstd~feildants CL.EA VER-BR,OOi(S, INC with prejudice,.. ., ':,'

... aridthere:bei,ng·I~?~OPPbSiVon thereto, .~,,' .', 1- '-,,: 1 '

ORDERED;thatupon notice to all. co-defendants, 'a1l',cfaims and ~ross claims ~gainst• • " ~ cl" ':.; ~

defendants CLEAYE!{..BROO,(S, INC., be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and:,'" "J; .. :~II"....... '

......-:;~'---',.--': ... :,,;, .'" ", ;,". '

JOH~:'t/jI:d:jiji::";~~,sq?-',.~~Attorney:for Plaintiffs' .'-.Levy ~Pi1ig~perg.;: '..}OO T~ird.A:'~pue'., . .', .New York; NewYork'l 0022;

. . .~~. '.,>-'.

..%...._...~'"'.::,...... : . ....-~~::~

,., ..• ;,;:.;---:-:.:~ /~ " ..'"

Co' . /,;., :;'/".. ',~ ,/,(.~ -~

Brian .Feld, Esq..Att0rneysforpeaver-~rooks, Inc.Barry M~Ti~rnan& Moore'.2 ReCtor 'Stre~t, 'r41~ F,loor

" New York, New 'york 10006...... (212) 31?~3600.-~'

'f'" ,

... ..

'.; .'

.~..','

, ~,,' .

so O~~~P··.· ..~.p;.i.,,";'.\(..~-;fu-it""",~~-r----:-_&:~J:4.r~, ~ . ,;..~ ','

, ""'~' >~,: :~~PErERH.MO"UL'rbN ", ':, ·~r~, "/';" '..: t: ;'" "" • .~ "-'~ ~'.:' ,J

" ':,

'.~

.,'",',

, ,',d.'

, .,"

-. ~ .

.'"

, .

. ~ -;

'~-. "

.:~

,,'

.,fj

..

",' .'

..' ~"

,,'

"

",'I·

'.. "

11',

j.?

:,,' .'. ','

,'.

) : :'::-.

.... .. ,~

.:... '.

.,<..' l.,

.'l-'

.' ~,

".......

;\,;,',.:.;.-,

....

' .• ~I"

,'. ~

'.j

"

.,$ ,

{'

, , ""

,oi '

'"

" .~

'. "

"

':',,"; :

•• <",0;.'

..~,

"

"" ..

"'-"

;,

'(.', -

:',

~. ~ I

,j

t:~ '

;.,.'

':' ...... ~',

',;,

I.''',~ :

"l";,

. ,

·:..J-ih /;,":,'/

'''.;J". J,

,~" ...... '. ~,

/"."

"'."

", .

" .~,,,,.'

:.",

..;

t·-·'

.,': '.

-,'-,1 '.,

" -~.

- . ~.

",,;",

,.. '

c.

.'

1"1'.~ ,

"j,

-'~~": ' .'

. '

, ~"';

NYCAL 't:A:S,~'1?art;)E('5D

.,~:,\ .";~ 1

.', '

~ "

.~,

, AJR'~~I,~'4n~;·.~¥:,~f[~M~"CQRP"et~l,;'

-"~:~~c~;i~)'~1'"7,-~;~~~t~'?~~~~;;~+~~7:-'~e1;~~~~:~----"~"~--.~~~/X '

. . 'r~~Q~;i~'f~nd~ri(S CLEAWEg'~~~:~~&:tNJt"here~Yr.q:~t":mmary,jUclgfl1¢p.t:;i~Jh~~~Q,Qy'f:,'~el}tltl~g>c'tls.e;~PurSUIl,Dt:tO c.i;Yir'PI:ac.,ii9~,1L.~w;.andA~ill,es,,~~¢'tiQl1,,32t2,

, ~' ,l<, " ,.' , '::, " ," "" " ,

~iSI}1Y~~mgH)J~i.I1.~ffi!::t.~~~!ai~t',~gilil1st ,d~fenq~n~:~dL'EAV(ER-BRO.Q,K$; 'INC, With ,prejudice".'

" .

..,.: .

-{.:

'.~.

'. ~.,

without.c(j'st~, ' ; , ~ :',';:'If!i-jJi6~,:.:"" '. -,:':,' :' "'"

~- _.', "

," :;.".

. j-.

. .. ',,'

'".:

-:.~

'1'"-"

.. (,;

'~'..~ .

, ", '

• ...< ~'

.::.

••. L

" ", :,'...

" t

i'"

','

, '~"

; t"

" .~ ~.

, .. '

'"

'1'-

,'1

. '.'

.. ~ ,

- 't

,..

'f~'

,,'

\. '

,"

........-~ .

,,'.,"

;.~ f'

:' ,>

'.' .. ';"";'

;..~. '.

• l

"',

'..... '

,,'

\'"

.,"

4.'···.

\;:.f:\.

,,:

.'.- ~'

,"

"

'.'. ~.

'r

.' .

....-

\,,,

;,'

• i'

~..

,~,

"~l'. C.

;.'

;;

/.' -

.',

',' :

. ,

"

"(;. '''' ...-

i·'" . ~...

'.; ,

:"<-.

. ..,. ~ '.

~.I:·; .. '.-.' ,,-~~,-, ... ' .,........

'. :

."NO oPPosrnON SUMMARYJ'UDGMENTMQTION ANI)ORDER: .

, ,,,.. ,.,....•,.. ,,.,.,,,.

.j' ,. \I • '

:'''. :

.Pl~ntiff(s);

.." . ..,.; .. '." -.- •...-~ .

'. 1 •

I·,·r;..::,,,~ " ~ ,~'

: • : ..•~, t , \7

"lr'.,\ 's:';""r· ~ , • ".~, ':..

:.~ ."': : ,,' ,:', ' '. ~

:1. ":" ,'>'~:_"" ,12'. ~. ~:_. ".,.. ~ ~=\::_~ .., .~. ~ ~ .,Y:ciD/60j97.Weg~vNOSJM/APRIL2iJJJ .' ..;.: _ . :'. :~ '.

SUPREM~ c6mi~?Op.-r~ ST~TE: OF NEW YORK':'~' .COUNTYOF'NEW YORK~---~~-------:'~":--7---'~--,---~-~----"-;-----~-~------------------X·JANE DIST~FANOand: PHILLIP DISTEFANO;

., -. _ : _.. ,,~~. .,....:-.-..

, .".'

_against:7".

A.O. SMlTHWAJER. p,RODUCTS CO., et a1.;': .

.. . ..:",' Defendants. . .--7--":·.--~·_·.'-:~~~-···__··'·----_-":-----"~---~---~---_·~---..:~-·_-x

I~dexNo.: 1'90364/14

NYCALLA.S. Part,.Jff',S-D

'. WHEREFORE, defen'dants CLEAVER-BROOK~; INC. hereby request swnmary

j~dgment in~tlie aboY~~entitl.edcase, pursuant to Civilpr,a:ctice La,!¥ and Rules Section 3212,. . ... . I

dismissingplaintim'iomplaintagairiSt defe.nq,ants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC. with prejudice,.' .' ;.. .,' . ..,.. ~ .'

. : .,'.

~ .""'? ~ .

and ther~;.b~ingno~oPP9~ition thereto,: .~ ~ ,

'" \<. < ,,~(' :"-,f ,,' . " ,.:.:~. , , . .. ORDERED, th~t(.upon notice.to 'all cq.defeJldan~s, all claims and cr9s's elaimsagainst

. " '/ . c', ,."•.,:"".,.. .',' ..': ;il.'....· ,'. • <.... .

defendantS CLEAVER~BRo.OKS,INC" be and thes'iinie are hereby dismissed, with prejudice and, . , ~, ' ,~ .', .

.. , ,

witp.~tit costs. ' ,.

':'.'

...•' ••~...Brian e1; ~~q.'.' .

, " ,Attor:neys [or:eleaver-Brooks, Inc." . aairY,McTiel1}an,& Moore '

2 'Rect().r S~~t, 14th Floor'New· York, Ne'W"York 10006(2'r:i}31?-3.600 '. .

; '.

• ;>,':'•. '

", ,;:'

"';.' .">

'.,'

,t ".

~~tt~:Bur,shtyJl,'~~q;.;·:'~·.', .AttorneyJor Plaintiffs ,:':-, :,.: 'Weit;z"8i Luxen8~rg , e -, '

700J3rqadway: .. ",,:,),' :New York, New. York' 10003,

" ,

, .' " "" ::';" .. '":.~

I , • • , " ~J

~'..::,.;.:

"0

...... ; ..

:;', ..':.:-'

"

., ,~,

.. '....

"

,,!.,~,.(~ .. , ; ~ . ,i

<••"

': .

.\

• I~

...... .,~ '.

.. M.

"'.~

':, ,~,

~'"

.~' " '

',!-,,'

, 0, ,

t'".

." .-.:••J

: ;~ ,

"

''.-. ~"., 'i:' ;.'

":., ,

"'.,,;.'

,,:, . .::- 'i"_

:.... ,,~,

. i;;·,r ,I.e '.. .

'~,'

"',

, ,~ ,i " ~ ,~. .,;

. ,

"

, ,

,;.. ' ,.;-:i ...... '.-

~ -:

.'',.t I~ ,

','\

"~.:..,,

.':

.'

/\ ....

','

:~

~\:J.'., 1

.;."

!.'

'"J,

~' ~ .

.q .,

~ ~,

, "::','

'.' ",,'

.~- ~;'."

I'- '.1

.~ .:: '" ,....,." .' ....1'. ,-.-

, ~

", ',.

"':i ,.

~'.. r '

"'.

"~c ,

~.. '

"... ~, ...

.•..-....

;"' .• C,l.

.,'1>.

"

I,

,."

-,"f

,', J

• -f ~.

"

"f'

, ,",

,l.:,

:.-t'.:

t.'

':

:......'"

.~ .. ,

C':

,:.~"~'• ojl,",~'. .

',' ., ,~,~,

c •• '

. ,

:" ~'., /

"'.' ..

1; " ..'"

. .~

.' ".; (,-1;, ,}

i;,;S' ,~ ,:. . ~ 'I., •

,''',?,• # ~ '.'

.. " . ~'

..:.;.: :~

, t'

... ' ~

: ;. ~:

.;

'\

'."'"

,',

..".'

",

:~.

,:'

" '

..~ '.

"

"

/ ,

, )~'.. .~.' " ," .:'~ i:~'

~ ". '. ..... ::;, ", '.. :·:iX:FBWiJ483SAegdIINOSjMln'ilrclt2iJi'S:.;;,·;. :: ..•. '....,., :'~:<:.' '~, / ."

s~!!!~%~~~~~~=~~~~~_~~~:ii'r~;,"1~C," "WILFRED L. HINES·;;!R.artdNOREEN ANN HINES;·' ;.. Nt>::,OPPOS'I'fION SUMMARY

., . . ":'iffitd.t>,'GlVIENT MQ'tlo'N A~n. ;,(ijRDER ".

Plaintiff(s),;' "

- against-· .' 'Index No.; 11603S/06

AO. SMITH WATER PRODUCTS, et al.; ." ".1. : .

_/" .NYCAL .~,

. '. ~()LAS. Part)6' b, . . ',. •. ... ' D~efendants. . . '..----~-------------:-~-----~----~_._~-~-----------------~----~----)(..

• ~. . •':: '. • _ . _ .', ',,': " .•~. •.1,j<';'·

WHEREFORE, 'defendants FULTON BOILER WORK§; INC. hereby request summary~ . . ..

.' ,,- .~"~

. ... - . ." .,' . - ,;,;,j,:.".. . '

defendarits FULTON BOILER-WORKS, INC., be and the san1'{~ate hereby dismissed with. ; . ;~.' .. .. ,' .

'~', .

, j .. '{~'"

..'

;n.';.8.,.. , \.L" 0."..~.v~. ~'-'- :... '

.....'~' "

\", .....

",.:' ,t,_ ,,: .J..

...•.. \ •. :(,.?'r- "':'

;.'

. r -.•

".' .'.

",...

, . '. r. ... t._·

SOORDJ?~f;.' ',. "~-:-",:.;":';""!.'--,,-,,.:,---:'-:-..'--:....-s:JiiiIis:~:. .~}Ic)P·>S#¢iJ)~KI¢iti·\H~itl~~ .. ' , "

. '. .' .~s·~:,':{f~::i.\.>~-'~J-, ,;:}·:·V:·... ';~~:·~i/·'> ,'. .:' .·.MON·.PETEiftLMOULTON'. _·;.f·~'· '•. ' -,:, ~, ...._; ~," ):;;.<'\.,'

..

prejudice andwithoutcQsts.< ". . ~\),.)-\\)'

"'" .

FranI< Qrtiz;,·. $, ,'.,'. .

·~~l{~,~·£h~~~~~J~f~~ ...··700. Bt.oadway T.·

New Ybtl<:;'New Ydrk 10.0.03'.'~. ' ••• C f·:,,·;.o .

..,. . . :~~. "". '-..:', ",

\ .

. . \I

_ ,.,;A :.-.d" ... ' ~1.. ~ - 'l'

,J,'.,;.-

,..

. ~.:,.

.. ' . ,, If'

)

,0'

~," .." :'

(,.

-.'. ,"

,..,,:'

.\ '.

.~.

'.;'.'

, r".

,',r

,',

: ~ '.' J .,~ ~ .1.~' '..

fr'

~ '.'... '

..,'\'. "

"

.:,:.',

I'

r •• ' !~

d.,

c .

., 0

._.~ r •

".: .

• -y'''', ~.

.'

• -;>'

~ ,') .{ .

.' . '''~

'''',

J.

.'~ ;

J". -,<'

....

"i'"

~ F~'\";'..

,> ': •. "

. .~

'.',

.';

" ,",

'. :" ; " -.;. .... ~ ::.', ''.~.

,," .. '

ROSE ANGELAKALACHMAN, as AdministratrixFor the EstateofMELVINKALACHMAN, Md RQ'S:EANGELA KALAC:RM'AN; In<;iividually, ' .'

., Plaintiff(s),

- against - ,

A.O. SMITH WAT;ERPRODUCTS, et al.;

Defendants. ,--------~---~-------~~------~-----~~----~-~--~-------------~-----)(

NO o'PPOStTION SUMMARYJl,]DGMENT MOTION ANt>,ORDER, {

',.Index No'.: 190240/09

'NYCAL "LA.S. Part;>e SO' ,

r,

WH~REFORE,defendants FOLTONBOILER WORKS'; INC.. hereby request summary

judgment in the above-entitled case,pursuant to :Civ:ilFractice Law and Rules Section 3212,. . l' •

, " . ." . \. (i ... , •

dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against defendants FUCrONBOILER WORKS, INC.,with• • _: ". ',,' , • A ~ ';':. • • ;.. '. ~

prejudice, and there being I:Iq.opposition,thereto,'

'., ORDERED, that upo~ notice to all co-def~~dan~~; aIlclaims,and cross claims against.. 'j "'~

" " " , ,.'y ", .', h

defendants FULTON BOILER WORKS, fJ'JC.,be arid the same are hereby dismissed with:. '. ". .. ". . :-.t ~ .

" ,

prejudice and without co~ts.·

~\~,\\C;

Frank'Ortiz, sq.'Attorney for PlaintiWeitz & Luxertbe.tg .700Broadway '~" '.: 'New York, 1\i'ew,york 10'003

. ~"

,:~:·Ch.eu:les'Nea],·Esq.

Atfbrtieys for F(dton Boiler Works, Inc.Barry McTiernan. & Moore '2 Rector St~eet; 14th Floor"

'" NewYork, New York i0006(212) 3 i 3:3~600

.~ . .

. SOORDERED,~'.'\'>"i.·>,. ",'" " (H0 Q"'S1:le,i:ljyI<J@iR H@itl~/

.,._~~~tf.at;H~;MOULtON-. \".. .

~, ' 2.

'.

-"b/11,!,/S:,':, /', ''\I.. . .~ ;

.' . ~~ ~

,. ~:.

.' ..' .

.'''''.:' .-;

', ....-:'.' .....

, , (

). ,'.'",;"-,

"

, ,

';.

,~ '.

~) >

, .'

',"

,:' .'

, ..

"

i',

'..

"\ ,

"'.;' .1-

'i

: ...

, j,

'.1

, "

,',. \'.

it·,. .... '.' :'.;: .

.1

.~'

.~ ,

"

.:,',;-

. ~. -.' .",.i-~ .~'.,

...... ':. ",',::."~{';

......

,'<

,'..

,.',J

'.

"

,,'

:.'):.....:.,,'

. ,j • .,'.";

'-

I"~

:".

, ,

I,

:.,'f:;

.. .'.J _

:~, ,;~

,"',! •

. ':

:"

.,/~ ",""~-"l .••.

('':'

y .....

~~. '.~ ...::'

" I,

, .~

"

I ;', ,

" - against -

AIR & LIQUID SYSTEMS ,CORP., et at.;

Defendants.----------------------~----------------~-~-----------------------){

Index No.: 190386/11

NYCALI.A.S.'Part~SD

, ,

WHEREFORE, defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC. hereby req\lest summary.' . , : '. .

judgment in the above-entitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212,

dismissing plaintiffs' complaint against defendants CL~AVER·BROOKS, INC. with prejudice,

and there being no opposition thereto,

, ORDERED; that upon notice to all co-defendants~ 'all claims and cross claims against. .defendantsCLEAVER.BRQOKS~ INC., be and the same are'hereby dismissed with prejudice and

without costs.

. .... . LI/15/16

.C~~·· .. ·.>David Chandler, Esq.Attorney for Pla.intiffsKarst & Von Oiste576 Fifth AvenueNew York, Ne~'York 10036 ", ,

Suzann~ albardier, Esq.Attorneys for Cleaver-Brooks, Inc.Barry McTiernan & Moore2 Rector Street; 14th FloorNew York, New York 10006(2'12) 313-3'600

SO ORDERED, ~..,' ~111J~-, .d~teiil-Heithil

. ,.' .

,,~.P.ErER";MOOLTON

I'

"<.:J

.,'-.1_'

lil

,.

.~ .

Ij

' .. -.:"

, "

'"

;,

X;DOMIS5R2J!AegQvNOsjMl~fn,201J . . ....

SUPRElV1E COURTOF TI!E'STATE OFNEW YORKCOUNTY OF NEW y'ORK' "-------------._---~~--.--~------~-------------------~----------){WILLIAM SMITH and JOAN SMITH, his wife,

Phuntiff(s),

- against-

AKZO NOBEL PAINTS,LLC. ,et a1.;

. NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION ANDORDER' .,

Index No.: 190424/11 .

NYCALLA.S. Part.J{f t:U

Defendants.

---------------~------------~-------------------------.----------){,

wHEREFORE, defendants'DOMCO PRODUCTS TEXAS, INC hereby request- .

summary judgment in the ~bove-entitled case, pursuant ~o Civil Practice Law and Rules Section

3212, dismissing plaintiff~' complaint against defendants'DOMCOPRODUCTS TEXAS, INC. .

WithpreJ~dice~and there being no opposition thereto,_

ORDERED, that upon'noti~e to all ~o-defendants, aHclaims and cross claims against

defendants DOMCO PRODUCTS TEXAS, INC., be and the same are hereby dismissed with

prejudice and without costs. .

. Y{:23!16Gi..........-.... -:-.. >....:....<,Douglas VonOist~,-Esq.

Attorney for Plaintiffs .Karst & Von Oisfe _576 Fifth AvenueNew York, N~wYork 10036

/ ..~

Sh . e e, .tt,Esq.·Attorneys for DOMCO Products Texas, Inc.Barry McTiernan & Moore2 Rect<;>r Street, t'4th FloorNew York, New York 10006(2'12) 313-3600

•• Y,

.SO·ORPEREb,,:~.,.....,·.·.--·...~.-----,b"jlljJ6·. . ',~ Hon Sbecrj' Kleia ~cider

, , .. :, '." . ~

. 'lION'" '. ......- . .'" ." .' ~~J!RH;&lOVL'I:ON

• ~ : r. ':

, ",

~ ,.'

:: J

('.'.

"

"

.. ~,

" .<'l""

.-~ '"

,"J

..,'

'f,' '<: "~,.... -.-

" "_0."'./"1

r

" ..,~.,)

-~;

'i

, .,;,./. :,,,~

."

\'

"~' . ,~ , '.

'. I~

~.: ., I

.,.;.

, ~.;

',.<'

'.,

'... ,'

\,,'.

, .','

·,

)ty~~'".r ""?,

.'';;

'..,

~ ..-.,

: ••~ -14 ', I'

'. '-~ .. c;;" ',.'

."

, ", 1:"" ",'

, .. '".

X:CLBlJSR89M'koiJ,,'w,al'10is :,'" "~"r,; ,- -.<' , ¥' • . ..

~OJ)PPOSITION SUMMARY,JUDC;MENT MOTION ANDORDER

.: .- '.','ll.~

Plaintiff(s),

SUPREME-COURT 'OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK:,·.COUNTy,qF:'NE:W',Y'ORK/ ..... '.,.,..--._-_._----~~~--~~-~---------~~_.._._.---------~------~._~j( .;WILLIAM SMITRafid JOAN' SMITH, his wife,..) .. , .

, ' Index No.: 190424111

II "

AKZO NOBEL PAINTS, tLC. ,et al.;, "r·

Defendants.----._._-~-----------~~--------------~--~-----------------_._--~)(

.~~F:q,RE, defendW;its eLBA VER~BR()OK§;·INC. hereby request summary

judgment in th~. abbve~~ntilledcase, pursuant to CivilJ~ractice.Law and Rules Section 3212,. I"", ' .' ",'.' .'(,

• •• • 0. ,~ , .....

.dismissing plaintiffs' comp!ainJ against'defe~dants',CL~~VE,.R-BROOKS, INC., With prejudic~,,: ':; .. '" '. :. ' . .

.and there 'bein~:~o:~ppositiori ,theteto,, ":>. ':;;r :,;", . '. '., '.'. " . . '.

ORDE~D',that upon n9tice to~ll¢-defe'Iidapts~allclai,msand cross claims against. ~., "::t" "':: .. ' ' •.: t::;.: .::-;~- ;.', " .' ',;.defendants CLEA VER~BRQOKS; INC., be and the ~am~,atehereby dismissed with prejudice and-. . .. ~ .

....'.~.

;,':.

",

...

. Sl1awn~tt¢Fl ltt, Esq. .Attorneys .for Cleaver.;BrQoks'; Inc.' '..Barry McTiernari & Moore .

: 2 R~ctor Street, 14~ Floor'New 'V,ork; New York '-0006(212}31J-3600 '

.. ......:

,,':' "

(I' 'J::~.J. I

.' ~ '. .. ':..

"'/ ...

I

i•• '-1.'

.,

y. " , ....

. ' ~

. .. ',.t, '

"'~

.. ~,.

1

'I',

-.:

•... '.:.

,; 1'1 '. ~j~. I. ,

,.' .'

:.-, .

:,'

: ~ ~- ,

','"

, ~;'.

"

t..

) .'

'.1

;, ...

1 '

CLB55855IJegaJ/nq~jmlAiri'l 2012' , .-!

SUPREIv1EC6uRTOF THE STATE OE NEW YO~COUNTYOF NEW YORK

----~--~-~-~-~-----~~~-~--------~-:------------------------------J(,JOSEPH MUNNELLY,

Plaintiff(s),

-against-

,NO OPPOSITION~UMMARY JUDGMENT

. MOTION AND ORDE;R

Inde~ No.: 190415/11

A.O. SMITH W~TER PRODUCTS CO., et aI., NYCALI.A.S.;PartJO' 5l)

Defendant(s),------------------------------~--~~---~-----------------~--------J(

. WHEREFQRE,defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC. hereby request summary.1 ,~~;I " • • _,.. ~~ .

.~". ;. ~.

judgment in the above:-entiti~cl:,case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212,

dismissing plaintiffs'complaint against defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC. with prejudice,

and there being no opposition thereto,

ORDERED, that upQn notice to all co-defendants, all' claims and cross claims against ';_ I

defendants CLEAVER-BROOKS, INC. be and the saqle are hereby dismissed with prejudice and

SO ORDERED, ~J6~-fi -II-ei-d-&r-'_-,---.:::!..'f)//1/1 S-" " J;' '

','

,RON. PErERM.MOULTON

Shawnette uitt,Attorneys .for DefendantCLEAVER-BROOKS, INC.Barry McTiernan & Moore2 Rec,tor Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 10006(212) 313-3600 ~Q

~ \ \.. 1."I>~ c;~ \1.., O~~~ ..

~~ ~~~.,. (j~€'{O~~ ,

COU~~~~~

without costs'., L-\ \ ')..:, \ \$"

J-e ,Attorney for Plairitif '

_ Weitz & Luxenberg700 BroadwayNew York, New York 10003

, \

.....

,'"~ ,

.,..<;

."

. c);

I;'

"·c

.'

....

.- .~'

..'"

"

.....

,.

..•. ;

.,.....

. ~' .

".

. ~,. ~;,. ,:

.:i

,.

"f '.<\

'i •••

,.

. \

.......:.

.-

,I'"

," '.~

'-.,,'

;1

'.'"

:{

'.

.::'''..-.'f'··'

. . "

. '.~,., f~"

~" .L

,':

.;'-

.."' ::"'~ .:.:...., . ' ~: :."': \.:.

,.:', ' • T c,~. t,_', .1 '~";;:.~~.;p.~~~~.',' ,. .. .. " . -, ' ".','. ;,tr."

.. 'SUPRENlEiCQ"0'RTJOf,1fHE STATE OF NEW¥ORK:' .

.;g~~~~i@#~~~r~~~~~~-,---~-_.:----,~~:_---'~~--~.~'~'~.~~:~.~~:" '~YCAL.,IN ~:-~EW ~i~RI/€~)tjN:rY . ,':"' ....\'... . I.A:S. Part)(1 'SO .'

::, A·ASBESifQS imnGATION," ,,(Eeitl@r, J.) ,

.-------------------_.'~-~--_. _!. ~---------------------_..--_....'~ -- ~{-~:~'--

1~' '.- _. .. .,.

.~ ~:;

~.'''' ',-j.~,

'::', \'~:i" '-.-,: ; ..,. .. : .,... -:" ' "":~ ~ ",

.', ,'.

.' ,< \.,.'TMc:CG:ubk)3/13/15

INDEXNO."o.r. .... ".

.. 190195/09,r'."'~ ,

" " u "THIS DOCUMENT RELA:rES TO:

, ' ,

,DONALD:E:,MCcORMICK, SR. NO .OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION AND

'ORDER-------------------~':_----~-~--,-~------------------;----------------------

~REFORE,defendant Consolidated Edison Company ofNew York, Inc.. . ',' '..

, .hereby requests SumInary judgment in the above-entitled case, pursuantto Civil P~actice Law"

~' ' ,

andR~les,Bection'~212, dismissing plaintiffs c<?~plai~t;~gainstdef~ndantConsolidated Ediso~.. ,"

Compapy ofNew Y~rk, In~. with prejudice,andthereheing no opposition thereto,',.,.

\ • ' .<

: l.ORDERED;that uponnotice'to all co~defendarits; all claims and cross-claims. .' .

, . ' ' ','" . ," ,:;,: '. :, ", ", :

.,against defen'danrConsolidatedEdison Company of~NeJV'~Y.?rk, Inc.; be and the same are hereby.... ,j •.

. "....

dismissed with preju~ice,andwit4outcosts.

Dated:,.Nfw,YYo~~;~ew YOrk"(1--i~'2>,/ )'r~/J~

:?N?;.~ ..~ ..

"

,/

",: i:T:iijjdthy;, "McCann, Esq.::,' ," "'.~ '" }'•• •"J '., _ . " .•.. "

!'D~V::JID!M:.-Sf\NTORb,:'ESQ.

,;":~"~'AttbMiey for Defendant.' ' ..'. '¢'6~soUdate~rEdison Company of1':J~w,

" Yo'rk Inc. .",. ,

..,' ',4 Irjing.Place ."N~w;Y6rk, NY 10003-359S

. " "

Our File NoS-4125-09

, ,

... ,.•..

..·t ,- ~' ..~:h:'."'.~;.~~..

, ....~. . .,' ': .

,- ,

t. ':

"

",

,;

::;.

•.. .j.

i ·,i':.· ,,' ~~~

'"".(

·f·

I"f

I

. ~ f:

',,, .

.::. ."

:!

","

'.>., \

..~.~ '.... ;

, !

':;.

.. f:

,;.. .

, ".,'

.:: :..~.:"':~ :-'\.

"

," .!

",J ...

",

. ~,

',I

,.':'. '. ;:; '. :,

::::::,-.'.

...:',

,'

~, ..~.,:

1"

I

'I,: ....:

;..-,

, k'

",-"'". .r,-,'

""

"

~....

f' .",

.....

"

\

,I,

. ~.

t, of

,·,_·i.

,: .'

'-'~-..

, ,

::

.', ,-' ~,;, . '. I • ,

. .'

. :: "

r'

" :-~. ' "

. \'

. "- ~'.

" .. ! ,« ~ •

'." .,' ...~': . :'-'." '~-''i.~~\'7>'.. ;::'):.~':-: ,_., '."' ", - .".' ~ 'i:- : -:"~:~ '.-SUPREME<COUKpeF.THE .STATE OF NEW·¥E>RK.

'1'()~tr:l~~'~W;Y:()g[<;, i.' i . . ':~;:L,.. NYCAL __

IN RE:'NEW,YORI~>COUNTY'" lA.S.,Part;ffS:O ..ASBESrOWLITIGATION, 'fHcit]~) . ,

..- \~ :~;':! .'

.,-TMc:CCGpk)3/i3/l5

THIS DOCUMENT'RELATES TO:I .

INDEXNO. "107099/02;'11 7579/02

i

I

. RONALD.R.DoEDEMA .. NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYmDGMENT MOTION ANDORDER

._-------------------------------------------------~---~---------~--------

..•..Wl:IEREFORE,defend~t ConsoliclatedtdisonCompany:of New York,Inc.

hereby reques~s sUInIriary'.judgment in the above-entitled ,case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law

and Rules Section 3212, dismissing plaintiff s complaint against defendant Consolidated Edison

Company bf:N~wYork)nc.with prejudice, and there being no opposition thereto,, ;...'.,.

" ' ...~. . .

.ORDERED, 'that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross-claims. "

against defendant ICons9lidated Edison Company .0fNew Y<:>rk;, Inc., be and the same are hereby: .. ,~. .

.. ,( " ";:1 '

dismiss.~d ~th :prejudice'and:without costs.'·,: .........

. Dated: New Yo~kA 'e~~otk' ,..... '. .. I) tP/~

k"i~'>.' ; '. j' .. ,:, . .' .:-'.; " ' ...

.-Timothy . McCann, Esq.'.DAvID M. SANTORO, ESQ., -Attofuey for. Defendant .

Consolidated.Edison Company of New .Y0lk~JI).c.

4 lriri'llg,PlaceNew'York, NY 10003-3598

Our File NoS-7187~02

: :'.. '.:" .....

.-<'..

:,:', .

;. '. ~ "

'1'"

):

.>I)'":,'l';,~,,,,~:'( ''';;'1 -r~ /,- ",',_ '\:'1' :~"..l,· t ": ( ..1. \ .', r. ;. '; J..J(}'~~;:

... ~

":'i,:

~:.' ,",:. \' i;' :(,'", ,\".,C,.' . '_. ,"-, • .~ .'~: ',' \ .. \:.:.' I '/ t'- !:"':'

.....':':·':f.'!'·

'~. :'

" .. '

, ~.

::~. ('

. t>- . .I,'

,/

, ;'

" : :~. l.;'.'"

',.1.'0'>," " ,,' ...., .,.... >' .~.

'!~;..7~ ,,~~ ;.','~,-.. '"

'''.~.~ .

" J;I' ;::

, ~ :

'."

.,/,'

,.\I<~i:~..,; ~

',r'''\'',. ~~.. ;:. : '. ' .

'cr>':c••

. ' 'I:~'

.«

-,',. , '~

,:}:";:"

.. ,............

\'"'

,,'.1•., ...." .. ','

r,

" \

, f'

c'

.', .,'

\'."

.. ':... ',?-, .

'" .t.',

,,:)

, <.

." + i'",.'

,: ,~.

". ,':.~ .

• ., ~ ."'1,.. <:, 'f; ," ,. '~ . '.;~ ::.. . . .'

',".~' ',~. J: ' . .. '.' ,," ';:::', :., :':: ' J , ' .SUPREME.C®URT OF THESTATE,OE NEW YORK' , ....:

,:~QYN.::·~..f.t.Q(~~WJ~9~ ~ ..> ":~'~". "~""':.]' .' . ' ." , , ". . . ' ", . ,,·NYCAL· .,IN RE: NEW YORK COUNTY, 'J" ,'. ,~ I LA.'S. ~art;/}'l' :',

,ASB?S1bS.LITiGATIC?N, ,..' , . , :(~eitlo/, J~... '. .':".,,'.,.. ',." ~.. ~ : .. 7.: _.. _.'•.<•••••• ,". _ •• ".' 'f":,J~ ~: •PErERa.MOV~TO.N

" '. '-'INDEXNO. ,THIS DOCUMENT RELATES TO:' 190324/10

.". ~'.

, ;., ',\

.,

'TMc':CC(jpk) ,11/20IJ4

LEONARD HOUCK

_______________ .:._ .. :A_'~ ' ~ :._. '__ ;._~ __

NO oPPosrrION SUMMARY':mDGMENT MOTION ANDORDER

, ~" t.· .

~.t .

WHEREFORE, deferid?fit Conso1idat~d, Edison Company 6fN.~wYork, Inc.(" ,) ...'. ,

hereby requests sUrnrpary j~qgment in the aboYe-entit1ed~~se,IlUr$Uant to Civil Practice Law• • ¥. .?... .,;,.'.,

'. .,: ,::.~.. ~'~ " :?': '.-;:' ';S" .: " .:. '.' ..and Rules Secti'cH?- 3'212', dismissing plai~tiff's complaint against defendant Consolidated Edison'. . :... . .'

,CompanY'ofN~wYqrl,c; Inc. with.prejudice,fu,ld ther~. byipgno oppositi.on thereto," '~ .. ' ". ",../' ,', .. :,. .,.

ORDERED, that upon notice to, all co-defendants, all claims and cross-claims, , .' .' • • ~ • ' '.. j•• '. .:~ •

'. ~" ,:; ·~:+,:f,· '" '. -"', . :';:./--, . ':"',. ~ .. , ','; :',,' ... ',. .", .,J'

againstdefendant.Cbn's'olidated Edison Co~pany6fNew'York, Inc., be ~d'the same ¥e hereby. , 'V·.,t,. . '

disihissed with preji.icii~~and without costs.' '

·'i.": I,/

,r

-i ;

" ..

'~dl~~~CC~·ESq....••

'c. pA.VID M. SANTORO, ESQ.':'Attorrieyfor Defendant·

,,:: c' r:·. "Cons9lidatedEdison Company ofNJw:York, Inc:' .-:, e.

4 Irvmg PlaceNew york, NY 10003-3598

.. ,., " ~ ..;.. .

''t.

....-

Our File No, 8-4139-10

SO. ORDERED:, ,,i ,0.

.:',

<"

:," ..

::t, -'; ."

,', ..~""1'J" , "/'< ',.

",:,,!.>'>}.

.:"';.

".,.

.'

\,

. 01,:

,'to "'j'

,j

','

.','

:.'1. , ,-~

,'- <,

.' '"

-','

'"

',,:1

.~.... '

. .~

'~' . ',"

'I .. '

"

",'1."'"

:,..

,';

:." ..

.'~ :

":t

-~ ".

.:,' ,

'''·f. '..

·.e_:

"';.

, .1

I"",, '

"

~.

.~ '.,"-.. ,f

....'.

".,

.... \.

'~Ii"

" f

.'

.... .

-,

'""

. f".'j

o,.t>

; ..~

... .-'J

,.

TMc:CCGpk) .6126/t4

,t " ...•

~ " v "' ' ..: ,,' ..'. ~ 0., •

'," ,

• ), f. '

,,', ~y :."

\.,' .'.

. " ",,',

I',I

IRWIN N. JAFFEE . 'NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION AND

···.ORDER._---------------------_:_------------------------~------------------~----... ' ',:' ,

. :'" .; .::" ~:WHE:R:EFORE, defendant Consolidat~d,:~4i~pnCompany9fNew York, Inc., I "'~:". ,:" ., ,". - • ,. , " "1'" '.. .; , . '

hereby req~~:~ts.s~~ijudgment in the ,~~ov~:-e~~:;led'2ase,'pursuantt~ Civil Practice Law':',",' <

•• ,. J

and Rures,se2iiqn)212, dismissing plaintiffs compl~intagainst defendant Consolidated Edison. .: ' ':'" .· .'

CompanyofN~~York, Inc. with prejudice"and;the~e bfl1ng no opposition thereto,· .. "', :, : .

:,' . ,

· ".

dismissed with,':ptejudice a:nd Without costs.

, _ ·f ~~' , '" ~. .

, ORDERED,thatupop. notice to aIlco-:4efe.pdants, all claims and cross-claims,... ~ ~i,' • -. . ..fr, . ,.

...'- '.. _ ···.';~r· <.::~.:" .'" '~"1';~ '." .' , ';. ,:'.J " -/" .',.,:,', , .

'agai.pst defendant CoilsolidatedEdison Gompany ofNew Nork, Inc., be and the same'arehereby, .', '. "~:' ~ . "., , " . ~' .' , "~"':';' ~ ':~,,"' -

,.- ".. "'.''-.

• ',~, • ''', ,r

.. '... 'i:

, ' .. ~ .:.. ~.. ."

, '. ,1)~othy McCann; Esq., ',~, b'A:VID M. SANTORO, ESQ.

, ,;::.:;,' "'Att~tney for D'efendant . .. , :'Consoiidated Edison Company ofNew

... ': .York, Inc., 4 ilr-ving ·Place ..; .

:·"New.York, NY 10003-3598 ".-. : ~

. Our FileNoS-6394-99

SO ORDERED:

· '~.

. :.'

.;

'~ .\

. i... ·

'.

" ,"

." ,~,

. ~ .. ;

..J;"

., .. ,; ..... ' ..

,:... ;'....:/.. -.:

;",

.'"'-'_: ......

r :.'

,,' '. ~ .

.. ~' ...... -,j

'., ..~ :

:.'. :.: .":1: .:,'

,,-::""',

:7.~, '

.... '",' '.',7:!': •. ' ,.." .. ~ ... ~

• l--.', ,';

,..< ·t'.

.,;;:..:....;.'-

\. .~ ,

.,~ . '.;

,',

.~ .

,-

\ "

'" .·.r· .....

:,. 'c.

.,

,I..' !'

""

.:-,•• T

,_ \' \,- \ : i ~

, .\

. '.~

It',-....

",·.-t

"

. '.:

--, ~,~A..~- -r..- ..' ~

.; ....

. ',"

.' '. \~'5- : ~. ';". 11' '..

".1

.. ,.....

~/~ ...,...:.....,~:..- ....;. ......,

;.f'~~(_.: ;~

.....

i'

, , ~,

'/.

.,;<"

.\;,-:,

.:\

"

!.,

, , ....

".'.

:.~ ~:..',':, .' ,~

'.;f..." f.~

'7--'

... :~\ . -".~ "

" :'f'~'~~ }; , ~ "

. . .~.: . .' .';0 ,,;,:.' "": .... :' • ,..; . . • . ,'. '_ ,',." ~,: :. . ", . , . ," : .

;',. " ':\VHEREF€>,;RE,defendant:ConsoFdatedEdisonC<;>mpany.ofNew York, Inc.':!~'._' -.~.- ,:\" .,~.. ,,' . -I....: :::>.' .• . " ..

:hereB~"'re~d¢~t~ S~~y judgment in the ab~ve-entit;~'aica$e, pursuant to Civil Practice Law ..

.·.J:~:~Vle,s 'S:~6:tiOh.:~212, di~miSSing plajntift's cofuPI~in~ ~g~id~~"defend~tConsolid,~ted,Edison .. : - '" '.: " \., '.'. . .

. _----------------------------------~----------------- --------------------

I'

,"

'I .,.; ;.....":'.

, .,0,;

. NQ'OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT'MOTION ANDORDER

'.,':,:

'.

.'.~ "

I·

. : '1':,'

Company o~:Neityork, Inc: with prejudice, and th~re:p~ingno opposition thereto, ..~ '", ,. ", . . -. • '. -;i'..' ~. -: .

I :11':'· '.J .

,-,"':r.:. -)0;:'.

ORDERED; that upon notice to all,co,def~ridants; all claims and cross-claims: .... ·i.,.:. , '.' ," I, . ~ ""<1'.':;;':'.:":' , "... ','"

agmnst defendaiitConsolidated Edison Company; ofNe\¥ York, Inc., be ,and the same are hereby• ! .j • • ~: ~.:::-, """' .: ., '.\ •

," ..

" ,~;' .. ', ."

. . ~

;,'w_

"',. .,.

<,-,',

" : ~

" '," ", .Ti1!?:q~p'Y' ,¥cc:ann,.£~q: ...', . ·:.·:·'JID~VilD:,M;;SANTORO, ESQ...

"". . ;" : ./~'""'.~'..'./~:7 ~~"'.~<~~~ .4' '; ~ ~.: ",':' • ' ••

~,' .,', ""p:i':f» ~~t}~l11~y,Jo:r:D~fende;mt .'~, '·.. >\lt~.. ,':':Co~s~yida!ed;iEdison·CompanyofNew

l~ ,·:·::'· •.)Toil; Inc. . ,., ." ....'.; ::':'~:.. ,4 In:i~g'~lace ,

P:· .' "" '. '.New York, NYJ~q03-3598. ~ .

dismissed wirh;'prej'udiceand,Without costs.· '.' .. '~ . .. ':. . . . :

"eo.. .' \ ~.. :, ~ .:'.,- 1,,·, " .:j,.... ,.

Dated: NeWYork;'New'Y0rk

4It4N's-','.

'Our File No,S-4927~98

'!'

.,'

',>

,­c, •••. ·

"d..

't'"

'. .,.',

........ ''1,_ ..ft" ,

:,

; .'., .

.'

'~ .'

"i',., ,-'. ,~" ,.. - :2

. "

,"',::

t, .." ' ',.},

: ~ ~ ,'., .. .',

" .',;,.-,

,y '~

h ..

'" .~ .. ~. .: " , ;,' ... .' I. "J' .,:.

, .~ ,"/;"

·.·'1:"

~ .'.

•"?

,",.:'.

";', ',' '\0"; ;.1

.'

.. '. ,,4,. :~ :-"

,.'.-,

",I'.

, ::

.J.,;

,''''''~ .. '

..:j'.';.. :.'.,' .~'l' .•...• " •..•::•.. ·r.. ,:<.'.,. • r;::..:;.\;j; ;

,;. ,''', "

"

'", ,,~.,i,~ '.~

',,-' :

: ~,

.. ' ~

~' ... "

..... ,,'?-

'~ ~"

,.1 ...)

.f

'..~ .,~.

.;' ,.

t;~ :.,,< (~~~~.Ili.~)~~:'>:j ~ '_:;;.. :.:

"

....

~:, .. '",'_roo

.:;. :.1\ .~.

{

J'

~. ,.- ".:. "

.."'.:'~. '. .

TMc:CCGpk)3/11/15

'... ALPHONSE LlTZ :>: 'NO OPPOSITION SUMMARY..JUDGMENT MOTION AND

ORDER.----------------~-------------------------------------7~---------~-------..:;"

"WHEREFORE, defendant Consblid~t~d,Edi$~~·CompanyofNew York, Inc.• ',:;" ••• ' >.~ • >:' ~';;'.,' ;', ~,:,_l. !-;'" ~ "t' ,"', .. • :' • ••. <::' :~';' \' .

hereby'feei:l,le.~t~.~~aryjudgmentjn the above-e~~W~d,c·~.se, pl,lfsuant to Civil Practice Law." . c, .,! . j:' .

and. RtilesSe~ti~n :3:2:1"2,: dismissing plaintiffs'complaint ~g~instdefendantConsolidated Ediso~·. '. . ., i w '

Company ofN:ew Y9rk,.Inc. with prejudice,' andthere being ~o opposition thereto, .'. . ~ ,:.

,~~ .

cQRDERED"thatuponnotice to all'to-defendants, allclaims and cross-claims

.agai1?-stdefend~tCoijsolidated'Edison\J6ippariy b'rN~':V Y~rk, 'Inc., be and,the same are her~by':...... ;;;., .', I". ~'~"l'.~&'·":" ~' ..',": - ~,~••

• > _~,,_~, : ' • .; • ':6'~'

dismis~ed with prejudice.and without costs.' ." f.'. ",' '... • • _ ,~,

. . ~ . .., ,

. :r.", .

I, .' ~ ••f.· '., ~,'1 ' ,". ;

'.... . .'

I.

::.. '.,' ,.,' . ,.' -\"

Dated:N~:y )jo~k;\.~ew Yhf.k., ....· .. : '::'l < Iy..- .-'to ~-r '.

..•. /.

Our File No8-5198-98

j .

. ., ..

,.'

:1 .' '"

.,'

-"",,,:,

.''; :'

_.~

'.:'

",

.~.,. !

\'"

'-, :• .1"

"..";,

,', ..,~

.~ " ~J:. ",I';••

:. :

....~"":>'

1\,,;!:"

""

.". ~.

y •

. ~

.'I'

,I·

....,

"

-, ,

V,,; I.

,f". J

f',.' ..'.. ~ Y; :,'

-. '

'., ~

'. ~

.,.,

..'!f"c

~ .... '. ?

-I.:,. ,'". ~

I·

'".... i""~..... ~} ..J '. '. ;. J .: •• ' .,' •• ' ~ ;".' ;.;. :.~ • :: •

. " .:

,. ,-,

;.,." -.

,1\

.....,-J ,.

~'

": :~

.~. ,~ . ' 'r,'

.,; .'

.J'\',

,. _' r

v

..... ".1'::

. .~: .::

" .

.' .1.

',,; ,.

."J'

i, "!' ' .. ' t"

SUPREMECOURTOF THE\STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY OF:NEW YORK' ','

lNRE ::;NEW'YQRK'CI'TY

":~SBE~,T6s'\ITiqATION

." ;

NYCAL'I.A.S ..,Part 50

--~..,.---,-:--.,....--'--------'----------'.X

This DocUment,.Relates','to:

ROBERT SWANSON and STEPHANIE SWANSON'

----~----'----'-'-.,..,..,....---..,.--'--;__-----x

Inde~No.. ll.9377/00V', ,I ,"

'NO OPPOSITION,SBMMARY JUDGMENTMOTION,·AND· ORDER

,..

WHEREFOR;E,'pefendant Reynolds Metal~ Company, inc.dn:e~,tlysuedherein as.":.; ,.'." .' " , ..

1 • ~.J _. " • . ' ' '

"Reyriolds Metal~: COnip'~y; as ,successor in interest to Atlanti'cA~hestosqmy." hereby requests

summary judgfilent i~:,the abo~e 'entitled case, pursuant to CiviYPractice ,L~w and Rules Section

3212; dismissirig.Plai4tiffs' complaint'again$t Defendant:Reynolds' Meta~sCompaI).y, with

prejl:1dice, and.there beirig::no ;'opposition thereto, it is, .' ~ ,,- ... ... ,

•. !;

.. ORDERED,.tha~Jlp~ri,;noticetoall co-defendants, all'daimsand ~ross dai,ms against" .!.' '- . ,"'.' :. " -", .,:,',

".'~' ' . "

. defendant, R~ynoldsMetals'Company, be. and the same:'are h~te~ydi'smiss'ed with prejudice and", ,," ;""", ',., , .' J' , .,;' .':, :'1'-' ,; "., ' ::. ,Ij •

/' ',J.

without costs.

Dated:

Frank Ortiz, Esq. . ..... ~,

WEITZ & LU~NBERG~~PC;:' ." , ' .,' ,

700 Broadway~;:..,I"_,I.

New York, New-York J0003.Attorneys for Plaintiff(s)(212) 558-5500

;'

Mich~el J;J~Wtis~':;~sq..' ,MALABY8t"BRADL'EY LLC. . ,. ....'150 Brdadway, Suite 600New.\70fk;Ne~ Y~rk 10038Attorneysfo~'Defendant(212))91'-0285 .

:.pated: '§j,:'(":',l/~,,' .. /':',. /'7 ·'r-• , >, \ J "':' • I' • \' ,~

" . '!'s, "!

" ,

...•

...,,' (

0-":'

."

'.r:

;. "

<". ' ••.•

:'

'.

"'...•

"'. '".

,; ~., it"

T'

.;'.'

"~ .• J

~ . ~',

I ..... : ..

'.,

.' ~..

"

'"I

.. (.

,.

.1.<,"

~, .

f·

"'"

.. ' " . ',',

< ••

~"'"

··t'.,'J.•. ~ {',

i~ • J I,,

\ ,.'

~ .' ..

., (

..~.', ~' ~

l~, •

'(";".

'.~ .

'.:

"t.

.. '

.•• 'V=-;';" ,-

..;"

';i ,I',."

\.

, '"

, ,~ ,

SUPREME COURT' OF THE STATE.QF NEW YORKCOUNTy'OFNEW:YORK '.

',~------"------'....;;..'-'-.·~-_~----~--x

..~~.~, ,.

INRE NEW' YORK CITY,>.ASBESTOS LITIGATION

NYCAL' ..Tks. Part 50

...--------,-.,.:...,..,..--,-:.....;;·-"-,··-----------,-x

This Document Relat~;~ to:\~ :::

Index No. 123950/01

Estate ofNOR;8ERTC>SAMUDIO . NO OPPOSITION ., .SUMMARY JUDGMENT

MOTION AND ORDER-------:---:-~----,----------x

WHEREF6RE~ I?efendant Reynolds Metals Com.p~yhereby requests sumrriary, .

;,'1

judgment in the ahove entitled'~~se, pursuant to' Civil Prac~i~eLaw ciild Rules Section 3212,, ' ,

dismissing Pl~intiffs' cOJpplaint against Defendant Reynolds Met?ls ,Company, with prejudic~, ." . ' -.', .

-,'

and there being nooppo~itiqn th~reto, itis, ' • ;, =.-' .. • ••~.:::. '

ORDERED,Othatupon l1oticetoall co-defendants, allrclaims and cross claims against. ". ..' . - ,

, "i I ;;; to' '\ .' :1 "

defendant, Reynolds Me,~alsCqI!1Pap.Y;be and the same ar~ hereby·dismissed with prejudice and, .,,~ ;" , '" '. '. .. . .'

without costs; . ;: .. ,

, ..:'

Dated:

Frank Ortiz, Esq;' ",';- ."(,";~~" ",. <.1. ,

WEITZ & ~UxENBERt,PC .700 Broadway. '. ' ','New Y~rk, N~w York::{:'0003Attorneys for Pla,rntf}j;(;Y .(212) 558-5500

Micha~l f':~Curtis, Esq.MALABY·&.BRADLEY, LLC.150Br0adway~Suit6600.:New York;N~w:York'10038

. . .' .;.to" ..'<-

Attorneys/at D-efenrJant(212) i91-0285

.:".

~\

.~. "

• J'',.,

,;'

"

" . ""., r ~":!: ...

.,j'

".,.',:

.r ..·"

'"'I)';

..;-.. j

"~ ,

'-"';~ ....',. ,,' .

'0;:"'

" "'

. ~:~.'. ' ..

,.}

'~. '':0. ,"..

":'"

, "

.; J

'''''

""~. '" .'., ,~:\ "

SUPRJ?:MEC96~TO~~,~HE·.STATEOF NEW YOIU<:·~ ,COUNTY qP'N:EW YORK ,',;,." .,

, '. . \'~

J,' ,,,, . ". . ~

",

INRE

.•.. -" .

'N~W' YORKC1TY,"<,,::. ,'I, <' ", :

ASBEstos LITIGATION '. \".:, '.'

, " ,x,;'0' I

. .,', N:yO'At·: ,:.'" .,::,'j-, I A'S p'irtso

... . -.~. - .",' .'.

'X

MARION ROBiNSON~dNA6ly1IROBINSON

This Document RelCl;tes to;. ,: ....' .

i~~~'x'No. 116632/99:;''''' ... ,' .

~. ~

" .NO OPPOSITION,,' .' SUMMARY JUDGMENT

',"r·', , ';.', , .", ,; I

: MOTION AND ORDER"'1,

, ,WHEREFORE, Defendant Reynolds Metals,C0mpany, incorrectly s~ed herein as.' . . .

.. '

"Reynolds Metal~ Corhp~y" as ~'u~~essor in interest t~/Atlariti6 Asbes,tos Corp." hereby requests. ',:.: '. ' ",'

, summary judgment in the ab6~eeri.W~~d ~ase, p¥rsua~~:';t6 .Giyil P;~ctice Lawand Rules Section. " :.'" .. '.~ _:' . '.',' " . '" .

, .AC' ' .'~.' .',

" ...

without costs:

3212, dismissing Plaii1~iffs'compl~iJ;1t against Defend'aqt Re;n~ld~",Met~ls Company, with. ' . ,.'~,.,.~ .. :', ',:., " ,:);".' .,~,.""'~'" ',' " '. . ': ,

prejudice, and' thet¢,~6ih,g.n6,.o'ppo.sitibn thereto, it is

'ORDE~~',:;t~~~i~pbii;~~ii~~;'to all cO-defe~dants',ail cla'i~s and cross claims against,,,;< . ;(:.~l,t'· '\ ,;~, ' ,. ~ :, : ~ ,y. '

defendant,ReyriOlds'.¥,~tals,Compky, be anci the same'~e'here1:>ydismissed with prejudice and '_ ' ~ '. r:, " "". ., '" " ~.,: .. , :"" . ~ .

::., • ,~t'!

1·'

. ,."

Frank:Ortiz, Esq.:: ' ,WEITZ & 'LUXEN:QERG, PC '700 Broadway " ," , "

New York, New York,lOOOj ,;,Attorneys for' Plain{if!(S)(212) 558-5500 j,

. ~I

~".": '

, .~,' (.,:,' ":' ':.i. ;',>' . \

. ",',"';. '

MicJ:ia~iJ.ctirrti's; 'Esq., MALA!iJY.i~BRADLEY, LLC

150 J?roadway, Suite 600NewlYork,:New York 10038

"f;-t ',-

Attorneys for Defendant

, (21,2)',791-0285

Dated:

"',

, .. '

.' ~, -,

'on "'0'\

.,.'';,~ ,

·t."'

. -: '

~ ' .

, .,~. :~.

.. ~ '.

,;'."

.{'

o. '.:

, '. ~ :.

j',.

- ~, ;,".,Pc

>,~',_, t

1~' 0'.

""""', ~.

.,,-

~, ,

, ,, '.

, ~ ,.,

.:..'

,,<. "

';-.:

,;

,-

....

- :"-,

, :

".,' .\1

'.: .

','

,;

,'.(-

,to, 'f .... ~ ,

-,

.: \

J ..

't·'

. ,,~,~

,I

,;,:.j,'

"

'"

, '

, > ": 1..,'

".--:"';'

,,'

' ..,.'

:1 ",'

;',.1:".

-~J!~~. ,~

~I~.~_-·,.,..- ,1, -''0'/' 'J>. _,_;.::.~/:J:r;.::f-'J,;' , ,

':','

. ....

t"

".:

.....

~ ..

.,' "

:"

.", ..

',"] .

. " .:".":",.""

I." .'. \.-

~' '.• ~; ','I • .,.

SUPREME CO-qR.T OFTHES~ATE OFNEW·YO'~:."':'COUNTY OFNEW~ORK ..' ',"} , ..

., '. '., .,.... .'

----~..,....,....--'-___::_'''7._'':''-.'------------;-,X'; ;. '.

INRE NEW ybRK Cfry.·ASBEsTb>.S tITTOAnON

, , ,

. ... ',':}:J"YCAt>:',:,~') .'. :"'1 . . .' . ,.' . .

, TA.S. Part 50~ ..

This Document Relates,to:

----~~----'---~---------'----'-X'. "

jiid;~,No. 190156/09" ,

~ ,t

Estate ofGARY'P. 'MURRAY~ -,

. NO'OPPOSITION'1~1~" ',__ '. -' . ,.'

SV'lVIMARY JUDGMENTMOTION AND OJIDER

---.,....----~-----'------------:....-x

:, .-

WHEREFORE, Defendaht Reynolds' Metals Company),~reby requests s~ary.' ~ ~ .

judgment in theab~ve,~ntitled case; pursuant to CivilPractlceEawiand Rules SeCtion 3212,.J. .,.. - , "

dismissing Plaintiffs," complaint. ~gainst Defend~t Reynolds Metafs',Company, with prejudice,. ~.. ',' ....". . ,', ......~. '.

and there being rio opposition"theret6, it is

ORDERED, th~rupon n6tice:to all..co-defendants" ail;'~l~ims' and cross claims against. . ,,\, ' ....~. ..::<

.' ~'. .defendant, Reynolds,Metals COrP-pany, b~,'an~ th.e sc@.e:~e:h~iebY dismissed witl;1 prejudice and

Without costs.I'

I.

I, ,

Dated: New York, New York·',~ \\\"D-~'2'015 ... '

tY~, .. 'CJ''''''''~'',,', "~(I •• I>.... ~' I','

• • ;.' ~~.~ ."/.1 -.. ,. .'

:. ~

'"""-- ....,_., "'.

• ''':;'.:', b'·' ',' ':.' , • ",

MiGhael),J;:uiti~~Esq. ,MALABY';~~'BRAriLEY LLC

I. •.• " 0 '., ";" i,t,~,·;,~t:",,- "~;, '

15.0 Broadway~' Suite fiOONe~ Yo~k,New Y~rk 10038

;:,"1':.,',' , .

,At~orneysfor,Defendant(21'2) 791-02,85

''',.

./

.' ., .,

, I ~ 0.:, A, ,~:.:. e' ':' t.':

,. .

'\

, '

I,'

- ','

'. "

"

'-.j

." 0,

-~ - ..

: . ':' ~ ~ ,:,.'

;.,:

·'·f

,. ,

. ~ j

.. :--

,;'(-;.:.:.~ ,

"

!' '''(

,'.

4 ~.'

,-.r,"c,;' ....

'v'·,

\~. )~. ; l'

.''Ir~p .~ :,"'t /;~J?

. ".

j ~ •

, .t.":' ':~ ...,; '~" '!.

.-\;',

-',',"

, .

. '('

"

....;.

~.. '

~.. .' ...-.

;' ..~.. ,"

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY OF NEW YORK' '. , , ,

, , '..'

INRE . ',' 'NYCAL,', i.\A:S.,Rart50

' .. ,."._. "':.,

-...,...---'---...,...---...,...-...,...------------'-',x' '".'~;':""

This Document Relates,t~:' "'IIHfe~ ~o.109247/00

...,...-----,-.,-...,...-----;:;\','"...."---:,----:..,...,...--..,-----------:-.x" "".,

NEW YORK CITYASB~STbS L~TIGATION

Estate of JOSEPHc. MINERVINO",

':, '.':

-------...,...--..,------'----------:-,x

fN@ OPfOSlTIONSUMMARY JUDGMENT

:,MOTI'ON AND ORDER','II ' '.

','

wHEREF;ORE, Defendant Reynolds Metals CO~ParlY hereby requests,slimmary(0 ~,~ .,

judgment in the above entitled ca~e, pUrsuant'to',Civil Prac,ticeLaw arid R~les Section 3212,. . . ;

dismissing:Plaintiffs,\ ~~mpl~intag~inst Defendant Reyri914~~,Metals:Com:pany,with prejudice," , •. - " ! ' .,,', "".

and there 'being' no opposi~i6n'thereto, it is

ORDE~D, that up()n notice,to 'all co-defehdarttS;'all claims arid cross claims against> • • ,.; , '-', ~ - .', •

, ' ,

'1, . : " ."

defendant, ReYnolds ,Metals CompaI1Y, be and' tl;1e,sarnear~'her~by dis,missed witp prejudice and, , • • ". , ~ .,,' 0

, with6ut-costs~ .. '

.... ,- ,' .. "

~rank Ortiz, Esq~, !~. ,I . l~'

WEITZ&"LUXENBERG.iPC ":: ,, ",,' , ,'.. ' .. ':

700 Broadway'" " ,,New York, New York'1000) ,Attorneys for Plaintif!(s)(212) 558-5500

Michae1';1."curtisiE~q.{ ,MALABY'&BRADLEY, LLC150;Bro~dway,SUite' 600

'NewYork"New York 10038"" .. ~ --' , ' .

4iiorneys/or Deftndant(~'t2ri~ii:''0285 .' ,, .,',, , '

\ ,~'

'~- :"

If" ._

. ".~ .' '~.. .

,'''-, "

,-C""

r

",I.,

cr ", i,: ,,'. "

,,'-,-

"j}

. ...:..

.i .

'~ .

,"

.~ .:

,;\

. "IQ~ \.

.. ",V,

",

".J

.~.

, OJ',

. ,".

"

~'. ~.

.'

, .,c'·

'.;;.:11

.'.'

"i ',' ~

'., .,

.i

: ..... ;"

i '.J

." .~

','i.- ~'.

', .. !.,

".....

-: .....''J~ .~

.t, ,.,0'.'

.~ .

. ~'.

,'.

"

",.'

-'.':

","

;'1"

'-.-'-,

......,t'

,,",

,t· "~C~.1'\~ '\f'"­

'r'.,"

,: ~.

"

SUPREME COURT:<JFTHESTATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY OF NEi(Yoiu<

. ,t.

"..

INRE

---~-----"';"'.:-::.(-.-'-,.--...:.-....=;------ .x

NEWYORK'CITY'. ASBESTOS'LITIGAlION

"NYCAL ..lA,S.Part:SO

"', "

-------'---~---'-----------.:...-x

This DocUment Relate~.iQ: IhdexNo. 105485/00, 125767/9~". .',, . ".

. _. '\ ',' •• ".c.

HENRY ROBERTLENZ '. ' ''NO-OPPOSITION..'. "SUMMARY JUDGMENT

"';; , .'MOTION AND ORDER

____~__• .._';'.'"'-i._·----"-,-__~ _____,.·:x'"

WHEREFOR,.;;E;Defendant Reynolds Metals Company, incorrectly sued herein as. ' '.

"Reynolds Metals 'C9riiP'an:y,;~s 'su9,eessor in interest to Atlantic Asbestos Corp." hereby requests. . ~~'. ,.' , ~ .

~/ ..

summary judgment in\th~~~bp~eeIltltledcase, pursuant-to CiviiPr~~tice Law and Rules Sectiont: '., '. ~'. '",," .' . . '. ",

;.-.' . ~:. ~

3212, dismissing Pla~p.tiffs' compla:int against"Defendant Reynolds Metals Company, with. " ....:.,~,}..:: ..< :.':' .. .'

prejudice, arid~tlie~¢"P:¢'ing'!1o:opposition thereto, it is, . 'f" :(r;' t; ~':\ :'<> .

ORDEREDtt1)~t'upO.n,riotice.to all co,.defendants', a~l claims and cross claims against. .. • '.". ~ ~'" , r,., ,','". ..

defendant, Re~olds:r0~i~~s;Cdrri:pany, be and the saine ate';h~reby dismissed with prejudice arid:':}'.':: . .,

Frank Ortiz~ Esq. . ,'>'.

WEITZ &,LUXEN~ERG;PC,- .... \' .

700 Broadway '~.;;":" , .New York, New "yqrk,10003Attorneysfor Plai~'tif1(s) ;(212) 558-5500 " n

,.' (.'

, >.' .. ' ,. ~ -' .;

. ,',

SO ORDERE'.~:f:~;ii~~:,,·::r:;:.·\..·Y~;;':;;~· '.:~;> '" ;.

'4J

1~,···',;<S:y~;L~~·'·-·, :._"~'" ". .~~."'f • \:~:1.Fio~·.~tPeter. 'fl.: 'N!ioulton .t· - '-

~••. " .~'~(, ;~)~\~ :::.: _. ~ i~.;f..:' .. ~ \ ~<l ~ :j. .' ',' '.'.' ., Of". - 1

.;. .'. ~~:. ,I ,:'

. ,,'j

' .

Michael 1. Curtis, Esq..MALA~Y&BRADLEY, LLC150,Broadway, Suite 600 .New Yqr:k, New York 10038Attorneys/or, Defe11dant

. (21.2) 791-0285

. ~-).....,.

'". f'

. ,.' .

/;:'- .

," ".j

without costs...

Dated:

<.

, .'

. ','

-... '/," ..'.

,".

/,., :;;: '~i

, :

'" "~

"

0(",; ....

",

"

,.. >.

:.

....

.',~ :':

';

\'\.~ .... '

'.

.' " .< .•

.:~

, .

" '",'

f ,

" -i\' .',.t, ,~.'

,< ; .1"

"

j, : ~ T,!1 ,..

-·~:~,~~~t~·t·, .) ! .

.:;"

) ",'

',: I,

"~' >

. ; ~'.. '

,. ii'

,'.

1\:' ','",',

. . ,. ~ , ," .

' .. ~',

" '

.;

".

.{.,- ,.;

. \ ('~'"

INRE

: •..•:- -- ',I U •.;;,tJi'~'" ~'i.~t"U

"

, . '.4:,''.'.' I •

. '.:{' "'.",

"'NycAL,, I:~:.S:'~~rf50':~

,. ' (' '

,:r:\

".~' .

,.', j,

:: ; ~ ..

" .'., ':~. '::'. " '-

THOMAS DoudBEB.'rY: '. ".' . ~ :,

.' .' "~'-'/

.. No O'P:POSITIbN':,~ ". "

SUMMARyJuD'(;MENT.,':M(XfION ANU':ORDER ':~

I~ ,

--------~"'---:'~----'-..,....,..-----------,--?C.

WH~REFO~;befendan{.Reynolds Metals Co~pany. hereby iequ~sts stimmaI1;';:, ! ,.;. . ";

judgment irtthe' ab6v~;,erititle(fcase; pUrsuant to Civil,Pr~ctice'Law ~d Rules S~cti~n 3212, ,";','.• -••• , .'.' • \,. • < , • '. • \

, ":', . .' .-. , , .. ". t. ,'" _~ .. ~ .,' ., . ':', : . .'.dismissing Plaintiffs' complairitagaiI)st Defendant Reyp.:61<is 1Yfet~ls Compariy, with prejudice, ' '

, :~~. ~:{~',~:'~~~:, ..... ,: .' :',:-;t',~' ". .:!," ~,' I,

and there being no::dPP',~~hionthere'to, itis,''l' :>, ',: :~~:'c>,:,~':" {, . ".' ,~,:" ,', , , ..' '~:: ' , ' .

ORDEREIlnnat'upoIi"notice to all co-d~fendanfsi 'aH.claim~~C3.l1d ,cross claims again~t) '';~:!~.:; \f '! "::,' '.~~.,' 'j'..' ·l~,.. . . .' !' ".:' ~'. ". . ) , ~:. ':.

defendant, ReYti'oI4s,N1¢tals~G8'rJp~;, be and th~.sani'e ar6 herebY'dismisse~lwitli prejudic% :md,,'I,. '

. without costs.r .'"t', •.

Dated:

• '. ." .'I"f_ ~~"'--~_ir ',,:'",i:"/:Frank OrtIZ, ESq,;i::',~;,'~?'~,' .:'

WEITZ·&,'LUxE~:BEi~G1"pC, ".,,:'" " '.: ..-:.-~'.'t(.L;: . C:~>:/t'?,::~i" ,"-'.' .'.,.... :... ~_"~"

700 Broadway:' .\':",'';\ ,";: ': '" .New York::Ne~~¥6iMhooO'3 :\,,:o:.',i':' ..Attorney~ for.'p'iq'in~fjj{s) , ,'::, ~ . ,(212) SS8-5~;'00;" ,','

..,~.~. ~ ..~~',': .. .' ... ., ..~ ....; - ,

b .

,Micha~} J."Curti§;\'Es'q}"MALAB¥ ~',B~titEYLL'C:, - - . ~ ~; i: : -,. ':"',:~.:/; .'''''. ' .

.:1.50 Broadway, Siiite600:'( , . ' .,.:, .' \!c" '.:..., ..

NeW York, New'York 10038..:::. Att(!rney~jQr]j>efendant

,,': :,(2~:~)' 791:-02,8'S' ,,""

. ;',

'1",'

, ~.' '

~ -,,' ." -~' ,;, ' ','

'"~. .:

. ,..~., .~

, .~.

""~

~ ...

,. '

... _, ....

';1':,1 -. >"

~ ..

f·,

';'

, " . '

. ..,.. ' ,,'

- " <:: ~

,.'J

, "

"":, .,':',

' ..

•• 1

. '..~,," .~

,',

"s

. '. ~.

,,'

; ','

j,'

','

' ..~

. "

.:' :" '.1

... : ••u',;--.

, • --. ~: I "

.~.; I ~.,l .'j'

".-

/

.~

. ,~

~••<

/,, "',f;

",

..:'.1'

~.• ~ 1. ,t" ~'

'".\ .

".~i' •

"r}'"hi. . . ~ ..~ ..'~" '

_', f

,I.

~, '

.:

"',

(~i,~~

" f' €~~:(c

, . .., .

';.'

,,1

t. '

.' .' ~ '... ;;'

" ..'~

.~ . 't, ,,,'

, ......SUPREME CO:URT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK

, COUNTY OF; NE\\r¥OiU(;," '

, ~: x'. ~. ~" .. ' ',', . . . "j',

,NEW YORK tHY , '<NYCAL.AS~ESTdsLITiGAi;lON ': ,',,>. >i:A:S.:Part 50

".- '~.'"" " . . .

------'------"--',-".,.,-"~----'------"---""---'---'--~\:'

lNRE

This Doc~entRelates to,: I~dex,N.o. 1002·i1/.01, 119397/00

ANTHONY D~ANGELO and ANN P'ANGELO'

'" .,' .

! c ,,~,~':'OPPOSITION',S,ul\'lMARY JUDGMENT, ':MOTION ANn ORDER

"

" x

WHEREFORE, Defendant Reynold$ MetalsCorri~an§, incorrectly sued herein as. , '.' ' .

. . '

"Reynolds ,Metals' GOD;1pany',as successor in interest to'Atl~ticAsbestos Corp." hereby requests. ;'.:. ,....;' . . .

J , summary judgment ipthe abQve'entitled case, pursuant to Civil.Practice Law and Rules Section', . . . ."', '

3212, dismiss'ingP'laiJ).t~fd;:';C9mplaintagainst DefendcintB;eynolds Metals Company, withI 'I ',",::\'; .". • '. .' ,

prejudice, and th~r~.h~in~;ri~ opposition.ther~to, it is, ,, '~~ , ';~':~~:~;~'::~ . :"J' :~ • . ,. • ,i,. "

ORDERED, th'atuP9ihidt~ceto all co-defend'aiJ.ts,.ali'Claitrl~ and cross claims against~ 'f' " • " : '. ;' ," ...." •

•~ • t ,," :

,,',., ~';~;"':" ..l, . • '.' • <,:" : ~:'.' I: ~ .-defendant, Reynolds Metals 'Company, be3.J).d the sameare.h~reby·dismissedwith prejudice and

:. ". .. ." .,. " ':' ~.' .. .

," ~ .' ;", j i ; .

without costs."~ \ "

Dated: New YQr:~, New York "

':' ,'.:,:~';'/~~()l.:~r;-:~:" "~..,,',, ....~.'.~"'~'.,., ,." :.- ',I, ' , ,",t" \

••• ' ':l, • • ". ':' l;'

,~:(.'l ~~' I '<.. ... '.~ .,' ,'1. '

Frank Ortiz, E,sq>., .,"" . '.' ,,,,:,:,, '-,-l\1...,.\-ch"""'a-e"'"'"lj"7""'.-:6-.oo""',:...>ois~{;~'E~"s·<-q.=':"'~~~'---'------

WEITZ & LUx:E'NB~RG",PC " MALABV &U·iU.nLEY, LLC700 Broadway:, ," ,,:' , 1'50 'Bm~dwaY;~tSuit~ 600

• '." I.

New York, New York 10003 ' N,y~.;Yprk;.New York 10038Attorneys jorf:!aint!ff(sj' Attorrzeys!or, Vdje'ndcjn't(212) 558~5500,' 0'1'2)791-0285", ' ,

.,. "\

, ' ..",'

'\

, " • ~ ••".. !.,

- .....

.' .~.

'f

... :

\'

, .'

Co .•

.,'

..•.

~.

t,.o .~ ..

....,.

•,.i

."'1).. :'

<I',·

."

.,

../,

.~ .

"\

(. ,~ . "

'7' ,' .

,"

,.'4

:;. ,0·... i

',1

,;".

',-'t..:"-,'. ~.~... J ~ • .'

. ,;

.",

;,' "

.,'"

..-:'

.:..

".

... -; t '~.

,..~

'.'':;

.~,.'. ,~'

f.", .<

"03-'

.:,,'

,A.

i.

.,,',-\.

.<~ ,"~, ' f

.\ .

. e.': <._",' .:' ,',

r.,~·. ..',' ','

.' " .. r,··j. '

SUPREMECoui~,OF THE STAtE OF NEW YORK' ', '. ,- . '. "f'.. . .-

COUNTY OF NEW YO~i

---.,.----~____:'_.,------':-~~-------X''.' .,~

INRE ; NEiWYORKtCFfY, , 1\SBESrOS LIiIGAfION

1.' .,;

',. NYCA~''. ': LA.'S. Part 50

.,------:-------',-----------..,--X

This,Document Reiates;to:" .. "

Index ,No. 104830/02

JOHN J. CURLEY'· " NO.OpposrtIoN;;siJl\i~M!\RYJUDGMENT

.... . MOTioN AND ORDER

I .. ~.,

I ~:••

I"

----~-------------''------,--x

WHEREFORE, Defendant Reynolds Metals Co~paiJyh~reby requests summaryll: ' . '. -.' " \. . - . .'

judgment.inthe a:bovle' entitle(l.case~ Pwsuap.t to' Civil PdcticeLaw and·Rule~SectioJl 3212,. . " '.' , .:', ',",' ':J'

dismissing P.l~intiffs'tco~plairit ag~inst DefendaIit' R~~oicis:I\1~f~ISCompany, with prejudice,'. . . . . . ',' , .,~...:' .

, ~~J' '

, and there being.~o, ,?ppositi'6ti' ~hyreto, it is.. ' ... ~':.':.' . .'.' '

ORDEREI>., thafup~~notice to' all co-defe.riciants·, aii claIms anq cross' claims against, .. , " ." "',.....•. I . , ,";.',: ,t.,;.. ,'~. .

",defendant, ;Reynolds MetalsCQmpaIiy, be aJ1.d~the,sa,me are hefepYdismi~sed with prejudice and.' , " '. '. ..:".- '" ." , .. "

• "',<;' •• ~.: ..

"I' without costs. .. ' ',; ~-:.. .:.

,; :, . ,'I.'.

Dated:

Frank Ortiz, Esq; , "r ..WEITZ & LUXENBERG, PC700 Broadway:".. . .... "New York, New York -10003 : ','

" ;'. .

Attorneys for Plaintiff(s)(212) 558-5500

.,.,'

,t ~ • •

'., -.

MiChael-IT .. ;C.urtis/:Esq.·MALABY&'BAADLEY LLC'. . , .. "

, 150Brpa:dW~y, Suite 600New Yb'fk,;N~\v Yor~ 10038Attorij.eysjor iJ~jendant(212)791-0285'

r,,.. '. \

:::'.. ',,' .1

, ,"

,\

"

,',

;: ;,

"I

/"

J .f

. :;\.

..;'

,.,....

... :.

"

,-!'

,.:>

.,;

"

" ,

~" .. :

'.~ .. ' .;

Ii

,-

~. :::--" ..

• J ~~..p~~::~. }~:

,,........

.'

-.,/

-.; .

.. :'

~ .', .

., .

• J .,

.' ~ ,

';"

. ..- '.._~ ....

:ii.....

't: .

.',;--1'''-: ,'.. ,. ',.., ,,' . ,":" '~.' , ,

SUPREME C.9U~T Q~~ THE STATE OF NEW YO~>,COUNTY OFN;EW YORK

, " x ' • .,:. ,I

INRE NEW YORK CITYA~)]3EST(;YS.LITiGATIbN

'NYCAi,:," ;, i~kS. pili-i 50:'

j;

-----'---'---~-"'"'-,--'--"--'-''------------x

This Document Relates'to: ,,'

LAWRENCE J. COprNORS and KATHERINECONNORS

-----'--'-----,-----------'--'------x

"Inc;lex No; 1 1143SI-9S:

,"",

, NO OPPOSITION

~lJ~~YJU~FMENT, MOTIONAND ORDER,

",

WHEREFQRE, Defe114apt Reynolds Metals Company; iIl~orrectly s~edhereiil as• '. I, ' • '."

"Reynolds Metals CoriIpan~,as successor in interest to Atlantic Asbestos Corp.'?' h~reby requests

:' , •. ' ',.' , : 'a , , '

sumniary judgment·in the above entitled case, pursuant toCivi1.Practi~e,~aw and R~les'Section, : /. ',-:.:~ ,

3212, dismissing plaiJitiffs:17complaint against' Defen9ant Re~QJ.ds Metals'Company, with. , , . ,,: '." ,,' .., . ;'.,' ~', .

.. ,:prejudice, and t,herebeing::no ,oppo'sition thereto, it is .

. .' .': , " ':" ",;''-,1;

". :,

ORPERED, th&t~l,.lROnii~tice to'all co-defendants, all claims ffild cross claims against~' '>, .'J. . • • • .;: "". ' '. ..., •

defendant,Reynolds:M~t~is C6~P~y, be and the' same are hereby dlsmis'sed with prejudice and

without costs. " '.J

• • . " ~ I

Frank Ortiz, Esq; .', ', ' '.WEITZ & LU~NB.ERG', PC700 Broadway .. '.,New York,New yo~k.i,0003

Attorneys for P~aintiff(s)

(212) 558-5500 '

SOORDERE~:> ...... ,,~;:..,. " , ,',, ' . ,: ~ ':;"~" \) '. '~:.

:: <,:' :.~~~l}i~.,r.,~t~rH" ~,oulton.•...:~ • " ,~" :.' " -,:{:,;, . ".i:.>'

'I", .

, :, ,... "

.;

'., .':' , ,';.

~\, ,,'

Micha¢t.;}; 'Curtis, 'Esq. .MALABY'~& 'BRADLEY, LLC150 Bro.adway,'S'uit~66·0 'New York, New York1 0038Attorneys/or D~f~ndant '(212) 791-0285

.'j

.. ,;

" ,.,

, ,

, '

,":.'

"

",'

, ,

"

f.'.

,.". '

",,!,"

...."

..

:'

- '.

" ,

',i

l.~' .~

. \

J':" .'

•,

:~

"~ " -(

r l ,,jrj.. ,

~,',".~.':"'~'~~. i'- ~~.

",~, ~.,

-"-- " '.~ ".

.',.

,.....

".•..,

.;~ I:

Iv \

(

J""

'"

.....

-"

"

.;

.,,;."

:,'

INRE

, ';.:.~

.' "

Index:No. 104329/00

Estate of ARMONDJ.,CAPOGNA' 0.."

NO OPPOSITIONSUMMARY JUDGMENT. ", ., ~.

M01'ION AND ORDER------'--~__:_---~-~.,...------~x,

" ,

WH~REFORE, Defep.dant,Reyllo~ds Metals Coin-party hereby requests summary, , ' -. ",

..' ..

judgment in the ~b0've~ntitled ,case, pursuantto Clvil'PradiceLaw:and Rules Section 3212,.' ..' • ':. 'c _:: '''", .. ,.

dismissing Plaintiff~/~ompii~~t:~gainst Detend~t Re''Ynolps Met~ls Company, with prejudice,. ".: .. . ". ,"" . '.. .

and there being'no op'posi~i~~~thei~to, it is, .- ", " ~.. ',' . , .;....

,,'

ORDERED, t4at·upon"noti~e,to all co-cief~nd~t~,ailc.1~ims and'cross cl~ims against" . . " :.",

" '~. ~~~' ~"., ....' ,. .

defendant, Reyllo'lCls',M~tals Compan~;be and'the .'same ar~ hereby,:dismissed with prejudice and. 'o J

without costs. . .•• '. r

'. ~;", .

'.

. .'.;;.

,0 00 ,:):'

Dated: NewjYotk{N'W'V'bi!c, ',,,,

o o' 0 '\ .' i:"':'~~lJl(\)~51:, , J " ...~' 0 r ;~~'l. , .: ' • " :

. .'1;: '.~ ': ~ ~. '" J'~, • \ ' -'--_~----' ~,.-- _

Frank Ortiz, Esq::!' ....;,. ,', :MichcieVJ·:,\Curtis, Esq.

WEITZ &'LriXE~BihiG, PC' MAiABY: &,BRADLEY, LLC700 Broadway," " 15Q\erpadway,'Suite,600 'New York, New Ydr.k\l0003 New Y;ork~Ne\V,~York 10038 'Attorneys for PldintifJ(s) Attor.n(}Y~Jor Dejendant(212) 558-5500 (212)'.7,91-028S::

" ,~.'

,',

i'.

Dated:'\

, <'p'". ~.~

'ol ,~

"

:,-.:

';",

:', ;;

..! ••..•

-"

',;T.'... ' \ .....

-, ~:

.•• ._.-t'

.'

.1.,.

.~ .~:. '

'_.;

"

i .

i,'

..;.,

:~. 'r:':}~1~~·~:.~.,.'

.' I,

<' ••-,':'.''';, ,

';f;h~, t:~,,~,;

,·,f, ",

'-.. '

-: ........., .~1. .",.. .., ~.

. 1

,~. '• ~ +' - ,

.. '

, :1

'-" •. l.'"

.,.1

::.< .. ',

'; ',/ ',". ,',", --.:' '.

',,"' ."

'.' "

• 0 ~""

INRE

SUPRE~"ll~:COBRT;qF:;THE>StATE~OfNEW YORK':'COUNTY'OFNEW YORK . "

>.', ' , . ',.

____--,--'-'-..,....,-.,.--,.._,.......,.,~----,.~,.......,.,-------".. ,-=-.,•. ~;., ,••...: .': . ': ..., , j 0', t< .• '. -': " ; '-~~'-I' .;

NEW' 'YORK ,CITY ...

ASBESTQS(ITIGATION..:'- .

---,.......,.,---,-----'.;.,,-~---,-~~-------x ,:, '

This DocumentRelates 'to: i '

Estate of WARD. BUMOWS

". '

. , .·":'r,Itl'dex No. 110352/00'.... :.,.

•.:, .... ". NO,opposiTION

".' SUMMARY JUDGMENT, "'. .'.1

, '",l ' ' ... ' '. '..

'. . MOTION AND@RJ)ER

" x·t',

WHEREFORE, Defendarit Reyn~ldsMetais C(}'~~'ariY:-iI),c6rrectly .sued herein iis• • ~ • 0 " -, • " ... '.~ .~: 1'- .t"

' ..

"Reynolds Metals Cohiparty, Individually and as successorih,iD:terestto Atlantic Asbestos Corp.".: .: ".: . ",. '. . ,';'.;':;:i~:;."~> >:' . . .

hereby requests summaryjtidgment.in the above eiititled~'ca~e;Spurstian,t to Civil Practice Law and.".. " ",. \'.' .

. ' :,': r·. ,. , ": -. _ ".: " "

Rules Section ,3212, di~m{ssirig"Plaintiffs; cbri.1plaint~g~.itf~tDefendant Reynolds Metals~ :'.;.-, :}~;:.",i _'.~ ~;~< '~" ' ,

Company; with prejlldlce,~dthete~dng nq: oppositio4·tl:1'~~,etq,:it''l~.' • '. ',' ,> ' ',',;:,:",:'.,' .,.' .

ORDEREI?, that tip:onn9tice to all co-def~rid.apts, ·all da:ims and cross ~laims against

defendant, Reynolds:'Met~ls'Coh1pany,be 'and thesarne~~.h~rebydisinissed wit,h prejudice and, , 1 ~: \ ,~ I~·l. ~, ' , 0' " .-'. "

without costs.

\-' " I

't-,.

,~., .

":""~";-"")"", ~" . : .' : :'"

, " °

\ ,0. \, "•.•••• <'

, >0

Micli~~LJ. Curtis,oEsq..M)(£~BY &BRADLEY' LLC

..... . ,h. .. _,,' ,

150'Biba:dway, Suit.e 600Ne~ Y6rk; Ne~ Yark 10038'

'.. ,I' , "

A(torneys jor-Defendant(212) 791-0285

..'':' .f".,':

','

." .'.

\ '.'

.J'.

"~\t,'. _~~, f ~ :

~"

. j, .' ,~ ,

~ ..

,,'..

j' ......

. ' ')

.," ,,'

.......-...'

-'.\.

... -."~.", ..

, ~ .

.;.' .

"t;':

4 .'

.".:'

,~-.

. :.~,~. t, C;:-,,',

...

'.' .....,\

~.':' .'4 J, • ~ 1',

'.:' .

:"<1.

. ".'

.,. l •

,-

I . '.... ~. J • '.

.. " ~.,. ..,: 1' •

c .

,,",.. ,+

. "

,.c.'\~ ,

'. ·V

"

"..' ,: ...... --

'}' '. '

. i~;.).,. ;-;,"

,. .' ','

\, .

"

... "':;'~"'~~4~'

" . :.~

.......'\.~ '.-

"

1',-

~;'". . .. \:. ,.--'.~ . , ;

'.' '.1' It r -

SUPREME, CbURT OF 'tHE STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY OF ,NEW YORK, ,

'. I,

INRE NEW,YORK CITY­A.stn3'STOS' iI'rIGATION

. ',."

This Document Rylates to:

'f, ,

EDWARD BENDERSKI

,Ih~'~~ No~,121394/0()" '

N07'OppOSrtION '~pMMARY JUDGMENT

, ," , ,MOtlON AND ORDER...•::>', '

---=--------,-------------x:',:J..

'. . .~. ,

,',

. , " . ".;/~:.',., c ' ":' . '.WHEREFqRiE" Defen!iant Reynolds Metals Corilp~Y hereby requests summary

" ' .. ,' . h:.~,;, .

judgment in the ab~~e:eQ.titled;;9'~se,;pursuantto Civil Pr~~t~c,~.Law.~(fRUlesSe~tion 3212,, -", . , . ~:,." ,~, .. " _,' ::. '" :';"'J- "~~- ;'.; ~ '., c .' • '. •

dismissing Plaintiffs'~ompJ~iri~ ~gairist Def6ndabt' ReYnoibs:Metat~C~mpany, with prejudice,, I:..,:' . " • -,'

and there being ~o ,opppsition thereto~' it is;;. '.

.,j'

, ','

';'.- :l" ': . , 'O~ , . .:. ,: ,

, ORDERED, th~tupoIi'notice to all co-defep.dants" all Claims and cross claims against','-', . '. -,;'. -", '. -,' ..

,.-, ".

defendant, Reynold~ IyIetals Company, be~d'Vie~,~~;¢~ ~e:~by dismissed with prejudice andJ • '. •

without costs. ,;.

• f. ,

Dated: New.Yor~"N~w Yerk

~~:1~Y",#~? 2~,15 , , ,~':,' ,~,,~£~

FrankOrt~~f)!/~!~'WEITZ & LUXE:N:BERG;'PC.,700 ,Broadway " ",'

New York, New York 10003, ' • 1".

AttorneysfqrPlaintiff(~)(212) 558-5500

. ;,~

Mic~aeH,:, C~!~~ ;~~q.,'MALAB\(&::BRADLEY LLC

" . ':~ "," ',' , , ',150~Br6a.dway, Stijte 600, New Yo'~k, NewY()rk 10038

• I ;.I",~,,' :. '.' .

Attorneys for':J:J.efendant(212) 79.l':0?85,

' ..... ,.

" ,',-

'0"..."',. '\' .. , ".. '

,I

" '

, ...'"

.',1'- ". ~~- >.., ,

. ' .." " ~..... "'.'

~,',_ ", ..,~. ,_!J ~ :;:,

':

'i, ,

"':.. '.':'

"It;

,'.

,"

, -:;..' .~...

"

J; .~

1 .•'-"

,,'

"

.::

~..

"

,::

if ':"

,,1

L

. ,~

~~-- ,-

'"

•' ">

-,\ ~

','

"

" -~ . '.

, " ...

~, ' ,"1

" "

."'.

,\ ~.

-.:'~-:. ,'.t'

".. '.'

,c~., '.t"::. t· :.j~ ..

..;..

.~" ..,'-. \...; ".',"

','I'

, - ~ ,.:,',"

t"

,", ,,_;1

~ '.

. '

<-'.:

......' ..

,.- .'

1,

<' • f ~:I."..~

'.'

.. ,~ ~

.... ,-

(

i l~:::-"

"f

"' ..

SUPREME COURT Of THE STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTYOF NEW YORK

","

NEW YORK CITY ,': A:si~ESTOSLITIGAnON

INRE

"',i; .___---.,--__-'--_--:----"-..,....-~c""';:-~'__'~:.~_--'-,-___:__~.x' . . .

)N~CAL':";""LA.S. ,Part 50

-------,----,---.,.----~--------'-__:_--'-,x,'

This Docliment Relates to: '" I.ndex No. 114328/02,,107404/02,

ELSENE A. BARTLETT NO ,OPPOSITIO'N'SUMMARY JUDGMENT

MOTION AND ORDER

--------------'--------,x

\ '. ,~'.".

WHEREFQ:RE, Defendant'ReynoldsMetals CO~PallY,incorrectly sued herein as

"Reynolds Metals Company, as succ'essqr in interest to Atlantic Asbestos Corp." hereby requests. . .\"

. I' .• .,.....

summary judgment in the ilbo;ve entitled case, pursuant to Civil 'Practice Law and Rules,Section

3212, dismissjng Plaintif~s' c~~plaint against D'~fendant Reynolds Metals Company, with

prejudice, and there beIng no qppo;sition theretb,it is "

ORDERED, that upon rr6tice to all c0-def~ndartt§;.allcl~ims,and cross claims against. : . ';'.'.' :;- , • • to'. " -.- ,~. .

••l •

defendant, Reynolds Me,talsCmI1PanY, be and,the same'%~;h~reby dismissed'wit~prejudice and'.' ....' ~ . ,. ~".

without costs.

. • ~-:~,-?......, .-- .....Frank OrtIZ, Esq: :::WEITZ &,LUx,EN:BE.~C;'PC700 Bro:ad\¥ay ,'. ~"New York;New York 10003Attorneys for Plaintiff(s)(212) 558-5500

Michael J.:Curtis;'Esq., MALABY'& :BRADLEY, LLC,150 Br()adway;:Suite 600NewYork, New York 10038

Attorneysfo~ Defendant(212) 791"',0285

, .' ~\.

",

Dated: 5/1~

.. "---'-....

:'

\.

•. t-.'1;."

l'

,'.

. .

.,',

- l'~ ." .....

.~J 1,<:

OJ:

" '~'.

.J

, ~ ..

",

,.,'J

}.'

"

"

,'J

f·

, .

,,-,','

,"'l:.

. 1 ~

, ,. " ,

','

"

,:·l'

:'.'

"'-1

,,',

..'

'\T . ':I.~ .,.. • ~\,,~

... '

.~ .'.

SUPREMECOURT~ OFJHE· STt,.TI?OF NEW YORK.COUNTY OF NEWYORK'

.,..... ,..-.- .. ' . .. ','

INRE

,i.

NEW YORK CITYASBESTOS LITIGATION

:. ,""

. '::':~\'.. ,

N).{CAL

OJ, ~-

JOSEPH C. MCKENDRY

.. ' x ....

. '.. I~dd~No.113335~01

Plaintiff,'li.

-agairrst- ..

'.' ~'

:1. .>' .';~:~'\.:. ... ' NO OPPOSITION.:,\. :SUMMARY JUDGMENT

:>'MO,TiON AND ORDER..' ": "'~,~:. .

A.C. and S" INC. (A~STRbNG 'CONTRACTING &. ,.SUPPLY), et ai" in~I~'dj!1'g RE.~OLDS METALSCOMPANY, as ~uc~e~s\;r'fn'ihtet~stJb Atlantic Asbestos,'.:Corp., ,Y .. .,.'

.;~

Defendants.

, ",'.

_______-+-.'-"-',.......-'~~"_"_'_"_'_ ,..--""''.:'"''.':.~''j(.O:,'.•;.~:, ';', .-,',or ... ,:,~. _1 : .'

. ", -.' ~. ; "" ,'.' . ~:.~. "'~;::_:'.> .:,.P, "

WHEREFORJ?,;~e(~ndarit.Reynolds,Meta:lsG0mp~l1Y~,·i,rtcbrrectly sued herein a~ ."successor in .,.:;";:", ,,"',i.' .:;'.~.". -.,,' '~"". '" ':.~"_.,., ,. _.~,>:,~'~"-':_ . ~)":.; '"I' ~:',:>,~ c'" •

interest to Atlantic Asbes·~os'Cbrp.,"(hereihafter'~R,.eynold,s"),.h~:i~,l:>Yr¢quests summary judgment in the..:•••., ..•• _'_f. ". • ... ,'"., ;:.,:,.:,~.~,; '~:'~l,~;\i;'}" I' • • ,

above-entitled case; pursuant t9',Cjv,iI Practice Law:an'oi'RuJ't:lS Se'ctl()o 32'12; dismissing plaintiffs'" . "'.:: '. ~.'._ ...... ~.-.:_...... - .. \:' 'j "'~' ,.,,:.• ,~. ':'~-'" " ',~

complaint against d,~fendantRt<~i)9,lCl.S:,,~i~hprejudice,~~l~th~f~ b.e~~~'no:'oppo~itionthereto, ,-',' ":',,, ~'t~:"" ,..' ;; ,. ,':,' . :','" '-, ' ;;'>"\;':~~':("\;~- ·;'r·'~·:·: "

ORDERJ;<:D;:,tha,riIpon, nbticetbalJ:co-dt<,fenc;iants;l ~11 cl~irri's and cross claims against defendant

Reynolds be and thesafu~~~;¢he;ebY ~is~i~s'ed,with prej~~~c~ r.ria..~~iiho~t costs.'. 5\ ' ',~ . ' .",' ./:I,~ :.:.;;

I ~:

.'.

'.,'", .',

, ".;'

Dated:

WEITZ

Erik Jacobs, Esq;; .,'.;, ..,700 Broadway, (jth Fld6' .. '.

. . '~,:'-"Y' \

New York, New.YorK'IO003" r;; .': _: ~ .:.

Attorneys jor'plaintiffJoseph C. McKendry.(212) 558~5500 ., :.',

;::;;~.':.,:t~~j~~~f% "SO ORDERED;;;'/'~; ..,.,.

. \: ,;' '-' ',.". ;t';' ~'i.-., '" "'" -, .':1:',; :' 'oJ:!-" ;:~' ..:' ,<' :', " ~ -'

.,',.. oil't.:Pete't/libMOillton."}~!:;'.p.~~j.:'.~'::\' :,"i,f;" :,: .

.';:

':.' ,

.,", :.1" ' 'J"-,

.,,.'!' ,':

"

' ......,'.

-.;.'

!'

". -",:'

4•••

,'f~ ,

,L

••-,!.

,-...

"

"t.

" ~.

"/'.

I-',!

. ~,

.1, ..,' ...

"

.. ,:::

'. '".,

..'

,':.

"

-", .

" \?. ~ ~ ~.(, "" \!<J "" I

.3'" ,_ '.

"'..

."o ~,

\'11"

;..".

'\".t~

.....

. '

(,

,I,,'

/':~\""- "",

''''''''~' t

...... "<'-l.

~-I' \.

. \, ,.

,"':

'-i:'"

,.

.>.>j" •

',.

. .'

'>.'

. :..:

, "

,;,~"

'j

,;;'1

I.

This Document Relates to:

IN RE: NEW YORK CITYASBESTOS LITIGATION

MILES R. PEDERSEN AND JOSEPHINEPEDERSEN

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK'COUNTY OF NEW YORK

NYCALI.A.S. Part 50

-----------------1 (Moulton, f)

Index No: 115822/01

NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

WHEREFORE, defendant Amchem Products, Inc., nlk/a Rhone Poulenc AG Company,

nlk/a Bayer Cropscience, Inc. ("Amchem Products") hereby requests summary judgment in the

above-entitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212, dismissing

plaintiffs' complaint against defendant Amchem Products, with prejudice, and there being no

, opposition thereto,I\,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant Amchem Products, be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and without

costs.

---

/4; ... - r;;JJ)jJsHon.Peter H. Moulton

~: New York, New Yorkyo/ ,2015

, r

j SuzanWEI & LUXENBERG, P.C.Attorneys for Plaintiffs700 BroadwayNew York, NY 10003(212) 558-5500

SO ORDERED,

~~S-q.----'DARGER ERRANTE YAVITZ & BLAU, LLPAttorneys for Amchem Products, Inc.116 East 27th Street, 12th FloorNew York, NY 10016(212) 452-5300

, --";-' ~ .., 'i

:.'.;';,

INRE

• :. r ,I; ~ •

SUPREME .cOURT~6F,-;rHESTATE OF NEW YORK

_C_O_UN---..,...T_Y_O-:-'F--,:'N~:.::.~E~~T"'.,7+::;,,°:'::i:~:";~-'-~---'--'-· ..,.;...-''"7""' ~----'-••X,,:::-.,: "i . ~;'~>.}/.~:? ."

.' NEW;~YbRK· CITY'ASBESTQS LITIGATION

"':t" • :.;"

.. ,

' ..

·t .

NYCALLA;S. Part 50(Moulton, l)

------"---~----'-__,_--,-'--------,-----x

SANDRA W. CAPQGNA, Individually and as\ \ '.' . -. '" ,

Executrix for the EstateQf ARMOND J. CAPOGNA,I~dex.No. 104329/00

i25799/99

.Plaintiffs,

'. 'II

A.C. and·S;,INC.,inci'j.{ding~ Mo'RSEDIESEL; INc.., , ", " '.~ . .~. 1",' . • : ''

NO OPPOSITIONSUMMARY JUDGMENTMOTION AND ORDER

. Defendants,

;"__,___,_-------'-:---'-:--'-;--'--~---------x

WHEREFORE, De(eridant.Morse Diesel, Inc., herebYTeque~ts summary Judgment:iii the. ;':"f~"~; . . ':'~~:':'~ ~.)~ .:' .... '.\<~: .,' . .' . . ""'''. '.' . . .'

above~entitled;9ase, :pursuant"toCivil:Ptactice Law aIJ,d:Rul.es Section.'J212,.dismissing plaintiffs'.' .." " .. ',;1 . ..". .... '.. - . . '

complaint agaln~t ~efendant Moi~e';Piesel,Inc.,with prejudice, ahd.there being no opposition thereto,:- ':, • , • T '. • ~ , • • • :,~, '

.. ORDERED;·that.uponnotice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross.,.claimsagainstdefendant

rviorse·Diesel~.mc.,Qe.;.aI}dthe;s~~·~ehereby ~ismiss~~ with ,prejudice ~d.witho~t costs.• • '.. • • • ."' : .::' '..... "... • • • ~. ~ • • • .' • -'. " ".;'" f • • •"; •

'. ;.,

",.'A/In''V'l:V'Z--.. ,'. "" .

,David"I-tJones':, ':' ~• " ... '. '-. ,.~. lo.

MALABV;&6RADLEY, LLCAttorney~jor'D~fendantMorseDfesid, Inc:150 Br~adway, Suite 600New YQrk; New York '10038(212)79 1-0785 .• '. '. : ..'. ." .' - .'.' . ,.: ,. , ,

'j'

- ~~ ~- _ -- ..

.Phan Alvarado, Esq:'WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Pc.Attorneys for Plaintiffs ,.Sandra W· CapogY/'{;I, Individually ·-.and asExecutri'~for the Estate.ofArlflondJ Capogna700 Broadway'New York New¥ork;l0003 .... _' .. .... ':.'. . ,.' --', ~', '.:" .... ',": ~.,' .

(212) 558-5500 "".,-' :-'. ,'; ..''' ..,.' :, \:,;.·:·..:' .. ,.~::-~_·I~., ,:r·· ..',:·,· :- ·,I t

.; •• "I t ." .., ••.• :- .:., .,., ,.,.' ". ,., _ .'. ' .• ' .•. ~ •_" . ',/ ';~""".' -:.:.' ~ . !.' •.•... ' ,,: I..••• ~ .... ' , • j:: ... ., '.~*'..

.. , •..... ". -,'. -,--, ;-', ."", ",' d"- " , ,.'., "'''." ,;l~:' "":' ,....., .,:.; ,> ~?if!-;':i.-' '.~,.S~ ~~~~~{;l~~),~,:;'··;;;:~C·y~',':,,::,v,:::,~~'P:"" ... ,". ..Dated;.. ~'r;jI:)·j./5· .~'',X",' :~.,' ~.,~ o««\V, ,.

. 'drti'Peter.·H. Moulton .. I/.: ,"',' ". ,..1.'," .L~,.' ,>.<:': ..;:.,;: . ,;.. , " '.,!~~I,;·:~·«--<¢;'f"O~+' '.

\, v~,·~ :~~~~~'.

vO~ ~ , .. :.

", r~"· " .. ,'........'. .,' ..

';; ..

<.,

.. ., .~

~:.,;:.'. . . . .

·.l.

: .... f..;

, .•..t. ,r

> •., '7"

"

... :,

.'.::

, :'._, l:1

"~I

.-,.,

,.

..', ....,'

.~

......_~,.. _, ...":' ~"",; .~.:; ...... ,:.;'

...

.' ~ i" " .

"1'

;.!.~ .... : ... f.! ~' .' c:~ ~~.~. ,:.:..~i.:: l·' .•" .•.• ..-;. :h~ . ....... ". I..' ~.i.:.: _~.,;.' ,

"::"', : j •. ' ,; .•' ~; ,i.: l "

,;', '.'.': .,1 .' ~;: , .~, .~ ,.. I ~ . ; '. ;. 'I ;

,.'..','!:.

.",,',.,'1.J"" ~.,;, .;.~j .... ',~.~ ... '~,: ~',-(

...:.

,,'C .••,> ,'~:

,,"

. " .~

..'

, .'.

- - - \:.-.

' .

:,. •. '. -!

,. "

• .I..~.

".\

i"

'."

'1":.',I"r

. ~ .' .' ... ~ ··fl: :. ..... ~;' :.:.,

~"

.f':

. ,

..'

I I .,.... ," I -~ ".,

_.'::.'! '

'\

-.,~'.,; f

','

~".

.~ I....

.. ""': ' .~:.'~ :'

.. "

SUPRE¥E(J91JRT.OF}'HE STATE OF NEW YO~" ',,'COUNTYQFNEW YORK " ~'~,

; "" "~~{,~?;.;, ,'IN RE NEW idRK CITY . "NYCAL

. I,. .

A~BEST,OS LITIGATION ·(A.S.Part 50": ,,:, "(M~ulton"fJ

t~ ~ • •

------,---:-'"---'--:----'--------~x,;,

,,('

I',' ..

GERALD CASTAGLIOLA and OLIVIACASTAGLIOLA, :

Plaintiffs, ' " ,

'A.O:SMITI-L"WATElfpRODU.CTS CO.,~in'c~uding;, !

,MORSE~DIESE.L C;ON,STtRUCTION CO., IN.c~ , ",. , "'.' .. -- .

,,~ I

Defendants,

" Index No. 108752/99,

, ,NO ,QPPOSITION, ,'" ,\ '

':" SUMMARY JUDGMENT:",'M01tIONAND'ORDER. .."...

,'.;'"', ','

I,I

H, .,"'. ."

" .,;" . ,., . " " ~:' ~_~,_'. '.".. . .' " ~;.;:>,,;, .~ I.:. . .WHEREFORE, Defendant MorseDiesel~Inc. (inGorrectl)(.iiatiled herein as "Morse-Diesel

'. ' . ; I:,;' ,~,,>'~:'_\~'.'~ '; "..:>'. . .' :Construction Co., Inc.") "hereby requests summary jUdgment4H.'the"a~~)ye-eiltitled ca~e, pursuant to '

Ci~il Pracii~e: Law and Rules Section 3212, dismissin~;pl~intif~kif~ori1piaint against def~ndant Morse, ;- :.' .' ..~<.:, .'. .' :::.:'.' '.\";:":~fl:'~··';~'::,·.; '.:" ..,<'~'l..< : :-..... ~

Diesel, Inc., with prej'udice, :and there' being'no oppositionjh,~t:e.tq·/" .", ,',:, , ' " , ' :, ,,', ','"" "",0' ':,,',' \ ,:,:, , '

ORDERED~ that lJpon notice to all co-defend(lIlts,'allplainis and cross-claims against defendant

Morse Diesel, Inc., be and the same are hereby dismissed wit~ prejudice and without costs.•• '. I ,,'

.: .....,./-':..•1,:' ,~ ,. • ..'

Phan Alvarado, Esq: " 'WEITZ & LUXENBERG, Pc.Attorneys for Plaintiffs' ,Gerald Castcigliola and Olivi'a Cas~agliola

700 Brqadway ",' " ',,"New Y~rk~ Ne,w Yor~,10003 ,(212) 558-55'00

i,

"

'..,.., ~,

" ~..

.1'•• : :.'."

!,'"

',; ,';

'-. ,. , .. :.

I;{'.

'r ...\ .I .

,..~ ,

.,'1'!. "

,

1

.,1"

..~.

. ~ ,",I

".

".~ ."

.. / ..::':'.i~· ~~~!:~~ '~;.~;~{ '.. :'~' ::."'.'.._.. ~.'°il·1 ,. ,-'

,.~ t. , ~,

"

;' ..,

-•. I,. 'j ?".

.. ' 'r~ C,. f i.'_' ,:.'"I :-

•• ~ J ..... , \ •• . ', • t ~ _.:: ',.; . _ .~.' ~. •• ~ •

'p. : ~ : ~.

C':' :

".,'

'I

"

\'

, ./:. :' '. . -.' ;'~ ~.

...•.;

. )

,:.

...,-'.

.' i::'~'"

\.~ .

\"

:.-~;: ..~

. ' I

:"'.'1:

:··:~t ') u::>~~:

~..

. ,":;.

. ';

....; ."

NYCALI.AS~ Part 50(Moulton,!.)

, .: ": 'iJ • ":

',t • ',' •• ;+.~.

.... ,.:' x·NE~'~ORK CITYASBESibS'LITIGAnON

,'.; ';" .'

INRE

SUPREME CCnJRT OF. THE STATE OF NEW~YORK'COUNTY OFNEWYd>iU(', ,':". ' , -:: '.,.", ',',

' ...; .. -.. ,

:.1,' ~1~,- . \. /' .'

, x

JANICE E. POTTER;: as Execlitrix for· the Estate ofGLENN L BURRO.WS,. . " .....

:.,' .l

'Ip.dex No. 1l0353jOO ,'108355/00

Plaintiffs,

A.C. and S., INC\ 'i4~IJ<!i~i,,~MOR:SEDIESEL, Il'fC.,, ,,1 OJ. ::..,. ,:". '/ .~~t~ :~ ~ 'r.J:, ' • •

" ,:. -;: ~'.: ".' ,'" .. . :l'~ .

":',

:.-.

. :,::~ <,-:··'i "

.Defendants .'." '. ':'

'.'

, "ij,.

,NO OPPOSITION'SUMMARY JUDGMENTMOTJONAND ORDER

-----'-'-"-~---.,..'-'--,.------__,__--__,__--x'.,. '~., . (,

. ~'ll.~. ;,

:1

~If!- t .' t. :,. ,,-.~ r " " '., f' '.

WEITZ & 'LUXENBERG,P.C;:ii; .'Attorneys for Plath;Wffs ',' ;.;','< ;,"

Janice E Potter, asE)(eq:l;llrix for the Estate'o!Glenn L. Burrows700 Broadway.. . ...;New York, New York'l0003'(21'2)558-5500 '. , ./,. .

WHEREFoIffi):pef6ridant'Morse.Qiesel~Inc., hereby. requests sUIllIilary judgment in the. ' .. ' '~"'" . .. ...

above-entitled ca~e;;,~Q,~h.~~to:Civil,rraGticeLaw and~ules.S~,~~ion3.212, di~rnissi.ng plaintiffs'. ," .... ,;. ,>;.-.,:::_;:_~:.:'>.~'~~,:\:"1.1'.":.. ', . . _ .'"., .',: '~"'" ':~ ~~~ ",' ' .

complaint agairi.sta~J~rlQWit;MorseDiesel, Irlc., withprejudice;'a:r1dth~re being no opposition thereto,'. '..~ ..:'.: ..'('.:';'.~f:. y~/t;,. >, . - .' .> ....', <'," 'tt' ,

ORDERED,tha(iiporijlOHce'~p all co-defendants, all claims:and cross,.claims against defendant• '. ,o!.' ,~> ,'. . ' .'~ .. ~. '." "

Morse Diesel,fu.c.~b~:;iih'd:ih.e:$.@i~\~rehe~eby 4ismissedwith prejl.ldice and without costs.,'. '.' . ·>·::%~'~{lf!'§>~':';;';·.::'( ',> : '.. :;.= '<:, .

Dated:NewYork,)~:¢W·¥ork , . ;Ail.' 1L)';~:i20i5

~pe,,:.- .. :,:.~,,::.,,<,., '

. .,;,' .' ,'.,,~ . -- I .......

• .' .. -;:».' .:....~ • ;> 'I _ ••

~ ',.-'.;~~,<:.. ~~:~~ .,~ . ": ~.

,,: r,' :".-' ,• ~ r.o,"

'":, ".I~

:' ~ ... '

".. '

- " .....,.:."'t••

",: .'

.:...

i,"

"

.~, .~}

, ,. " ~,

,,'. :' ~-:J '.:

'., ; (,'..,... ":1 '~" ...

."...

j', .,.'. ~m'." i .

',' .,"':.t' ,', '

, I.'.,',I,:

.' ~ .

'~' ,

. ,.. -".

~~:'J,

: ~. .:"

. ~'

" .i .):.. ..

~. '

....',.

,I,'

."".

·-,··~l·,· !'p. , . r1:~,:r j.'. '" ,.):

" '

'. ;.~ -: ~ll.?~:" ~~ :..

...... • ,,l-'-' ••:.-~••

.~'.."-

, '." \:'.

. ,;}..:;';<r;:

'~ ,',

, " ,,~,~

"

, ".~. ~.

: :·t(.',': ..

\

'". \','

.,'.~ ,

..;" .

I,"~

>' •

'J.", .

I",

~, .", ",:''_,."

.. ,., :~

,

,,

'~ .: " ~~: ..

'.~~•• 0 "

';'" :. ~ ...I l" ;'.

:',"/ "/. iJ,.'"",'., • ',;'

....,...... /.': .. '

"~'.. " ," I ~

I ~."".."

,i'-

:'. ,; .~~ \

, '> ~. ; .... : \ : " •

<#'. ~ •

.' ;~:,.

~>",,'/

"" •• 1.

','or"~ ,

"'l,

0'

,f·I",

, ~.'

J.;",

""

-~~~:,:.':.1

..... :-1"_,ti'/'.'

'i

":':-, ,

j • L.

'I."

',~ '1' , .

'. \t::·~. "/ .

j'"

• .':~. I • • • ;~'" .'

SUPREME COURT'0F:.THE:S1ATE'OF.NEW;·YORK: " -;.<~{, ,COUNTY OF,NE.\Y;Y·9.RK.:,~~·~:;;.;\,'· :.;" ," : .:- ;. .\

INRE

---~----,'.,......,'--~-"....,.---.:------,----'----;"--------x'\' .,. I c.~' •

.'NEWY0RKdITY'ASBESreS.'tI;fIOA·TION

. " ",

JOSEPH C: MCKENDRY,',.'"to '. ~,

IndexNo. 113335-01

Plaintiff,

-against- . '.: .'

. NO OPPOSITIONSUMMARY JUDGMENTMOTION ·AND ORI)ER

t',:j'

A.c. and S., INC., (ARMSTRONo. CONTRACTING &SUPPLY), et a!.,incIudt·ng M'bRSSEJ~bIESEL .INTERNATION~, ~C~..;::; . -":'. ' .

.~ ... . \ :'

.:, .... ':',,"

" Dd~ndants: ", ',;.. :1

-'." \

. .:.

':.-'

",-.....----~...,...--''---''':-~-----'----,-,..,.....,.....,--'----'-----,-----){

. '.... ' ".'"

. "

. I

WHEREFOI~E;.(iefendant Moise.-Diesellnte'rnatiopal" I~C:.(hereinafter "Morse'''), hereby requests. .'., ." " i '.. ' ..

summary judgment iri:tb~1i~6v~)ehtitledcilse, pursu~~tto .Civii Practice Law and Rules Section 3212,. .,' ,', "~/:" " .. ,.'"i· l

: • ". '.' ... ', •• :. • ,;":. • •••• • • •

dismissing plaintiffs'complainhigainst defendant Morse ~itffpreju~ice, and there being no opposition\. , . ' .. ,' -.,', , '. - " ','

, .:~ ',_. • !'! :

. thereto,. :: .~. . .' .... '.' .

ORQERED, :t6'#!1P~.ii·{r~t·i6e·t6~p C(h.defe~.~ants"alr.'C1ain1S,~nact;ss Claims against defendant I~!'t:·\.-r:~\.,<·~: ;:~.vJ\.;' .. :."'~.....' "~~':~~':J'.::":'::. _~ '>'/1 ,~"~~.:'."'. . .

Roper be and the same.~te herebyqis.inissed with p"rejudi~e·afid without costs... ,,\,,~, i.. <.>:. ~""" . ','"

,';"

I

.'1-.

, '.

~~)r'f'.DLEY, LLC

,",.

,Rasa' i'o'ch tta, Esq..15<>,:, .oadway, Suit~600\; .. ~New~yqrk,I'few York 10038

. Attorney~for Dejencla1',ltMorse-I){esellnte'r'riational, Inc.(212)-79,,}:-0285: '.:' ( ::..

r

~ ~ ., .

" .

,," " ".f, ... ,.'

" -' .

. i

", .

WEITZ & lLJ'V~

Dated:

.Erik Jacobs, Esq:'.700 Broadway, 6ih Plo6i', .Ne'wYork, NewVork 1000'3Attorneysfor Plaintiff .Joseph C. .McKendry' . .''''

. (212) 558~550~~"~;.> ..." .

,SO ori,nERE.D·.' \ '::~.: ' /j.~. ,'r. "..~...I\:.L.I ','.,"< •.• ,',- '.·.1 !!..... "

'. ;:~"'.> or:,.peter H. ,Moulton; .'.'. ~..

", :'-; i.·: .

.j;

:: "

;".r'

l)- \ I: 1 "

'.,--

)

',' 'l" ..

, ~

:'.

>.,'.,

:."

, .

'0..

,"

'.;:

"c-" -",.

- C',:

.~ ." '-;.~ .

. ,,-

'"

_..Iv

.' ~ . . ~.

,~> :

r

.'

,J

, "" ~. - .

~ t,. ,

-..."'-- .

",'.,',

'.~ .,'1,

.'f,

-,, ,

, ;

,J

"'.1 1

'f

, ,I'

;'':;.,

.... ~~. .

'/ .'.), " ,

,,'

/

"

i,

·t :i

:. "

;.' ..... '.

.';

:"'.

".':

" ,-:"', ',-, • ~".1

-',';..

" ,. ""

"J'. '

; I'

-,

'!'

",' ,',' >',," ,.,:';: '

SUPI¢ME COV1f{Of T¥~~TATE9FNEW YORK'COUNTY OF NgW,;YORiJ(' "

."-~------,--'+""-' :..,:.:·':·,,-----,-',--,.-------..,..-------:-x'

INRE NE\V YO,~,CITY,ASBESr~SLITIGA'IION

NYCAL. '-.

, LA.S. Part 50'.~.; ,

This Document Rei~t~s,10:,·. ",: :. r':'

"

ARNOLD YARCZ0WER and ELISE A.: .. '. ' l, , , ~. - ,

YARCZOWER ..

.~.

NO OPPOSITION.SUMMARY JUDGMENT,MOTION AND ORDER

.- '<"

------....,----'---,~----'-: ..:..:.\~'__',,_....,__--~--~x. .t","

WHEREFQ~';r:befendantReynolds Metal'sCompany"incorrectly sued herein as.' .... ,~ -'t;.' .', , ' .

"Reynolds Metals ,Company, asimccessor in interest toAtlffilticA'sbestos Corp." hereby requests. '.,.,',

summary judgmendn,th~ above entitled case, pm'SUallt to Civil PractIce Law and Rules Section., " :,.;<:~- ." , '.

"','. '

' ..:'.'

3212, diSniissingPl~i'htiffs:;'cofuplaintagainst Def~ndant Reyrtolds Metals Company, with. ··':>:'~L: . ".';:;' ,.,r ' . ' ., '.

prejudice, and th~fe,peip:g no;6pp6~!tion thereto, it is ' ., .' ". ,'t-: -. ::. ''-,' ","

ORDERED,~tif~!:~port.rioticeto' all co~defendap.ts; all c~aimsand cross cl.a,ims against,. !.' :::.,', '. .-,' -' ", "\'.

defendant"Reyn()lds M~t~I~C:Qmp'any, be and the same ~e he~ebydismissed with prejudice and .

without costs'.. : "::, , :,,;:':y':. . '. ',\"~,','.: ,". . . , " .

.;, ('..~, "

'J. ',;,.

".. -.' " .'-:}:It

Michael J. Curtis, ,Esq':MA:LA;BY & 'BRAQLEY,LLC:15'0 Broadway,'8uit¢ 600

'New York; New:):o.rk 10038 .Attorneys jorDejend{:mt '(212) 791'-0285

" ",

,;';-" ','.

Frank Ortiz, Esq~,

WEITZ &'LUXEN.~ER~,PC700 Broadway .' .... ,

New York, New York 10003Attorneys jor Plai,ntiff(s)(212) 558-5500 "'.

Dated:

~,'"

J .'"""

, ..~. :'

. "-,,~': --' .:. . : .,-.~ ,"t, ' . "~,, "

.,;

-,' ,;~.,V

)t':

'.',

9 <l .'t~, :' I,

.'

to.

',i

, '~- .0."

'l",ft

" .t'

" .~"-r·.

",'

".'

1.-: "

",

'/:' l'o'Y,

'j

'.

" ,.,,~ .

'~'.

.: ~:,"

n,' , ..,", "'.

; .~

" "

.,"

.. ' .',~

" .

'.'&

:O.t,'" 'c

',J

!( ,

"",

./

j,

.,'~

"

f'

,,' • -0, ~'

','

,'0 ,, /,: "

" ..... :., '.:;

"~ ",' ".~ ~,/

"

,. ,_..--"- _.,

""'J

:.

,\

,'::?

".:.:

,.:"-..

..:,.''"

'.' ·.9.:, I

.~. :'

'.,,'

-"

'. ,." . '\. '.'

':

IN RE: ,NEW YORK CITYASBEsTos'.[nioATION

, ,... :~ ,~; :¢...; I

:,1. t,'" \

:.~' "J • ;" ~,:f; :::'~~'.. ~,:.... ."' '. .SUPREME ..COURT;QFTHESTATE OF-NEW YORK; ,':",COUNTY OP:NEWy6R1<. ",,; " "

, . 'L,-:'~\~ ,

NYCALI.A:S.Part§O

----------,----'-----'--,-------,---1 (Moulio1:~/-$.),This Document Relates to:

Index No: 107845/06 '

EDWINH.'FLAHERTY,

, ,"

NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

,.. . ~ "

WHE~F6RE:"defend~nt Dal-Tile Corporation (su~d hereip.,as Dal-Tile Corporation,. ," .: i".

individuallyand ass'uccessot to American Olean Tile Co.),h~re1?YTequests summary judgment

in theabove-entit"tedcase;puisuant to Civil Practice Lawarid'Ru!es'Section 3212, dismissing, ,

plaintiffs complaInt against defendant Dal-Tile Corporati9n,with p~ejudice, and there being no. ~.' .

opposition thereto, '

ORDER;Em;that upon.notice, tq all co~defendants,at'rCliims"andcross claims againstr J ,'.::: ...,.' • , ." .:~"::" '. . ."' "~'. • - . .

defendant D~I-TiI~ Coq,oration'beand'the same ~rehereby~i~mfssed:with prejudice and without. . ~, .

costs.

'.~'\

Dated: N,?! ,York,;',.:+-.J,,'e,'~,',Y,';Ork ,5 Lf. ': ' ';:20d.,

SO ORDEREp,. ',' c, , ' ,

'~:.: ::' ;H<)ll;;"Peter:!:(j\1oulton ",". '. {.' ,0. ,.. \_:,.,.";~,/":.~.-:, • ",:, ·r:,.' "

./' .

Judith A. Yay.' "sci'"DARGEI{E' "Nit YAVITZ & BLAU, LLPAtt6rmfysforDal-'Tile Corporation'116 E~.st:27:!h'Str~e~, i2th 'FloorNew York, NY 10016(212) '452-5300'

. ~

• 'o.'

,.'

, ;, .',

~. '; ~'- -'", ."

"", ,'. ". ,,'.

1 l

."

(.

.,1;,

)~

,t •.

i'

,.

..:::;,

-j"

,<

<' "~.'

.,

. "

'.".'-or

I:.

\ ,-\

<.-•. '.. .

. ....

" .0:,

.'.~; .

~"

i_.'

"

'#

:' c '. "r

JOSEPH C. MC KENDRY

This Document Relates to:

SUPREME ~OU~Tqf::rHESTATEOFNEW YORK.COUNTY QFNEWNORK",

~ ," "','

IN RE: NEW YORK CITY, NYCAL' , ,'.,.. "

ASBESTOSLITIGAnON---------~----____lLA.S. Part 50

'.~ ,

(Moultop,,:t.)

Index,No:;113335/01

NO OPP;OSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOrION AND ORDER

WHE:trnF0R-P, defendant-Dana Companies, LLC, sued here'in as Dana Corporation,,,', '.

("DanaCoIIl;panies")' her~,~yd'e4uist~ ~ummary judgmerit in the'above.;entitled case, pursuant to

. ' . .

Civil Practice La~ and Rule~Sedion 3212, dismissing plaintiffs complaint againstdefendant

Dana Companies with prejudice, and there being no opposition tfier~to, ,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all cla;ims and c~oss claims against

. . , '

defendant Dana Companies be and the·same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and without

costs.

Dated: ~e~,YOrk,. NeW~York"~ ,_------L~~ \~, " 2015~", '

~\¥y:;Au:>e.s, 'f;.s@-., " ",.'. ,,' ,o,/'i} .-' ,: I:'

WEITZ,&:LUXE B:E ,,;l\C::'>,;o, ,Attorneys.for,Plaintiff:,' <:. 'j'

700 Broadway "..,New York,NY 10003(212) 558-5500 '

SO ORDERED,':Ho' . Pet~l<H .. 'Moultcin

" .", '; ~ ",;' . ." . '. ;

-:' .'

lUQitp 'A:;Xayit~,' ',ei,,' ., .•'"DARGERE ", TEyAVITZ& BLAU,LLP:', . ..~," ;-:;;:'. , ,'_:," ',"" ,;,;" " ,'" -;", /.' " " ' ...;', '

, AttOql(~YS(:for:DanaCompames, ELC ''1J6 'Ea~~:2:7th Stre,et/tih Floor

., NeW Yotk~NY; 10016. (212) 452-5300 '

"

.-/. \' .'.. ' ,,~, . "~

,~.J

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORKCOUNTY OF NEW YORK

IN RE: NEW YORK CITYASBESTOS LITIGATION

This Document Relates to:

JOSEPH C. Me KENDRY

NYCALLA.S. Part 50

(Moulton,1.)Index No: 113335/01

NO OPPOSITION SUMMARYJUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

WHEREFORE, defendant Arilchem Products, Inc., hereby requests summary judgment

in the above-entitled case, pursuant to Civil Practice Law and Rules Section 3212, dismissing

plaintiffs complaint against defendant Amchem Products, Inc., with prejudice, and there being

no opposition thereto,

ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross claims against

defendant Amchem Products, me., be and the same are hereby dismissed with prejudice and

without costs.

Frank Qtti~, Esq £Q .:>ALOS.s (:£,.(6>-.WEITZ & LUXENB , p.e.Attorneys for Plaintiff700 BroadwayNew York, NY 10003(212) 558-5500

Judith A. Yavitz .DARGER E TE YAVITZ & BLAU, LLPAttorneys for Amchem Products, Inc.116 East 27th Street, 12th FloorNew York, NY 10016(212) 452-5300

SO ORDERED, ~ ~/lJ)S~Moulton

NO OPPOSITION .SUMMARy JUDG~NTMOTION AND ORDER

111222/01 &.115822/01

NyCAL. ".r.'A.S:' Part 50

.....

.~, .

..:. :-:t.:.~ .... ~.:. ;.!~~~·~~:;r~~<:~:::'~:~.

.....:.rr~:,:l.,• t·. "., ....

.'1.,' ..•.., •

,:'

. ,' .. '

"'., ' .' ~. ).,.

.:.:

" .....

. :'.'

.','..., " ....

.·,.i

MILES R.PEDERSEN

INRE: NEWt:V:ORK:COUNT¥ . :, .,:.....~'li:. " ASBE·s*DSLh:£Gi\T.lbN~ ..:'+<:

. " ..

THIS DOCUMENT::r{ELATES TO:

r,' .

SUPREME';COBRTOP"ffiHE,STATE OF NE\"iYORK· c. '. ,

COUNT¥6F:ME,\y~;¥@ltK.:~:\·\.. " '. "', ", .·?,~.~:·:/·(':'C. '.'

(Moulton,l;)--C.. ~_ _=_:_~=-:-~-------'------;

"

TMM:jrn

05/06/15

" WHEREFORE,. defendant, Consolidated Edison COJnpany of New York, Inc.

herebyreguests sumin~ judgment in the above:entitled case, pUrsuant to Civil Practice Law

a~d Rules, Section 3212, dismissing plaintiffs corriplaillt against defendant Consolidated Edison. '. ,':

Company ofNew york,Inc.with prejudice, 'and'. there being no:opposition thereto,'

" .ORDERED, that upon notice to all co-defendants, all claims and cross-Claims: ~",

against defend~t" Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc;, be and same are hereby\' .' ;

dismissed"with prejudice andwidjout costs.

OUT File No;:S~6029-01

'4 •• '. "::':.

Dated: New':¥ork, New YorkMay ()~"2615

Suzarine Ratcliffe, Esq.WEITZ & LUXENBERG, ,P.C.Atto9teys.for I?:laifitiff '700 ~roadway·,

New York, New York 10003

(

.' ':"':""'-'. ~ . • 1

,<

,.

./

.,' :. \

",

:,

',\

'"f

(

......

.,• I~

.' .. .'I

..:.'. .',-

,<.' .'

., t· ,,' .'.t •.

".Il'..',

",

,'. '. '.

:~ .... . " " "', ·.··i(·.~·· ,':'" , AFFIDAVIT OF SERMICKBY:MAIL

t'

~~..''.", ".;

. -:," '~~ '1'.'

~,

:.-

" Th~ undersigned being duly sworn deposes and says: that I am over the age of 18I ' ", , ,

years; am not a party to'tps aC,tion; and am employed in th~'office'ofDAVID M: SANTO~O,

, the attorneyforConsolidated Edison Company of New York,)nc.

'>,That on the'¥ 'day of May, 20is, I s~t:V,edt?eannexed NO OPPOSITION ....

SUMMARY,JUDGMENT MOTION ANDORPER, upon: ~.",>';

Nancy,McDonald, Esq. ,McELROY, DEUTSCH, MOLyANEY & CARPENTER ," ' 0

Att()meys for A.O: Smith ; FlowserVe, Cutler Hammer, Controls Systems Division Robertshaw;Robertshaw Controls Company, Rockwell Automation, ;41c., f/k/a Rockwell International' ,Corporation, and,:StewartWamer,Corporation, Federal Pacific Electric Co.; Lipe-Rollway Corp.,BytonJac~son·p.umps ' " , ,1300 Mo~t Kernbel Avenue ;,Morristown, NJ07962~2075'

Arthur Bronip~rg, Esq.:', , § "

MARSHALL, DENNEHYWARNER, COLEMAN &' GOGGONAttorneys for BMCE, Inc. f/k/a United CeiJ.trifug~l1 Pump'425 Eagle Rock Avenue "Roselahd, NJ 07068

Julie Evans,Esq.:WILSON, ELSER,MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN & D~CKER, LLP ,Attorney forA.~\V.Che~terton Co.2/13/15, CarrierCoip'.;Encsson, Ind. and as, successor to' .Anaconda Wire & Cable, McCord Corp. 'indiv. And as,successoi;to A.E. Clevite, Inc., J.P.Industries, Oakfabco Inc., ,ITE as"Su~~essorin' Interest" t'6'Bulld~g'Electric, AT & T, Conwed;AIlleritan ,~iltrite 'Ine., '1/1'6/15 COI!trol Components Inc. and, S:W. Anderson Sales; OtisElevator Co.; Rockbestos Wire & Cable; Texaco Refining& Marke~ing,Burnham, LLCindividually'and,as suc<;:essm to Burnham Corporation' " '150 East 42nd Street

, New York, NY 10038

Michael Tanenbaum, Esq. :.SEDGWICK .I:;LP:, "':::C, '. ".\: " : .-

' ... .1.1. ~. . '. ~ ," '. _c:. ..: '. ~;' . '. _ ' ..

Attorneys, for:G~J)~r<l,1121e,~tltf.~q~~ f/k/a Viacom ffl,<la Westinghouse and Foster Wheel~r; " ,Exxon Mo.bj1;QPfp''';:-iC~terpiJJa,r,'Inc., and Perkins Engines, Inc. and Harmon Research-Cottrell

. 'r". ~':'" ',.,' ".. "',,' . ,...~i·· • ~

,Three Ql:th;w~yCenter; 1t'th',fJodr"Newark;NJ07102';' '. '

.'. ,;;.

"

.. ~.

.;;

'~:,:J ......:(~~.~,.

II'II,

'-.-.

. "

'"

,',

'; \

, ":.'

I~ )

, ,

' ...

>:,

.~'~ ... '".:

: :.:,...:.::'"

JudithYaviti,".Esq. . .'.: ., '. ~, j' ".. ....' , Jot.,.. ,

DARGER,.~ER;R.:ANTE, ;yAYITZ& BLAU LLP ',: ,. .'>Attqmeys;¥6r,{;~~o~.Irrd~'s#1es::me.: Hopeman:'B~oth¢~s;:)~c";, and United GilsomteLa.boratories~'tt~dainTeed;!.iJjm~n:'tarl;>i4e,Aillthem' an,d::Dana Corporation, Mine SafetyAppliances C6fupany; Gou}i:fElectronics Inc.;,Beazer East~ ·Inc: flk/a Koppers Company, Inc.116 East 2ih Street, 12th Floor . ,', " : , '" :'< ,,' ,

New York;'NY IOQI6' 'l. <'

Suzanne Halbardier,"Bsq:'", ' ../BARRY, McTIERNAN: & MOORE, ' ':~'.t, .Attorneys for Fulton Boiler 'w6rks, Inc., ,Cleaver Brooks; ~dGeneral Refractories, hic. andDavis & Warshow; !ric.; Atlas Tumer, Inc., Jolui Crarte,'Inc.;ECR Internatiorial~Inc.;·f/k/aUtica'

,BoilersandM~leyCoolmgTechn~logies" Twin Disc, Inc.; Olympic Glove and Safety Co.2 RectorStf~et,:'14th Floor~', ' 'New York,"NY:1P006 .':'

'Kerryann c~ri~~:,.E~q~ , ,;,~.McGIVNEY &",I<LUQER,P.C.Attorneys'{or Puerto Rico,"SafetyEquipment Co., Safeguard Industrial Equipment Company,Patterson Pump, Oakfab'eo,Iri;e. alkfa Kewanee Boillilf Corpqrati,ofl (4/3/13),Kentile, Courter &Co., Treadw~'llCorporatibn;Tislu:nanLiquidating Gorp., MiltoQ Roy Company, Tremco, Inc.,Columbia Boiler Company, Leslie Contf91s, Inc.,:F~y Spofford & Thorndike ofNew York f/kla 'Wolfe & Munier,Il1;c;"Richatqdndustties yalve'Group', The Nash Engilleering Company, DAP,GAFCO; Hoke,'iI1}c~;"QrolJ'-R~yilo1dsEngineering; NY. Protective; Zum Industries, Inc.; LeslieControls, hic., George Ai' Fulfer Co., . ,80 Broad Street, 23 Floor' , ;New York;NY 10004-2209'"'.,'" '". ~. ,

Angela DiGiglio, Esq. ' '"K&LGATESLLP,:.'.",·" ',,' ' "I'" ,:

Attorneys for Crane Co~,'~rane pumps & Systems; Ipc., Crane Environmental, Inc. andSchneider El~ctricUSA, fuc~{lkiaSquareD, Jenkihs 'Bro.s. Valves, Natio~alUS Radiator, andPowers, aDivision of Watts Water Technol<?gies; Inc./tdy Industries, Inc. flk/a TeledyneIndustries Inc. In~ividually ahd as supcessor't({FlimisEngineerihg

: 599,Lexi'ngton Avenue ',New York, NY 1Q022

':1

Scott R. Eme~y,Esq~L'¥NtH DASKAL EMERY LLP , . '., ,Attorneys for GoodyecJ '~f,ire:& Rubber Company,'Goodyear ~~ada, Inc. and Georgia Pacific,Chrysler-,', '. " . '

264 West 40th StreetNew York, NY'IOOT8', '

John J. Farwing, ESCF' "

CULLEN,{~:~W,~~,AN:" <:~::;:~"" " "," , 'AttorpeyS:fQf~:J?tuuhmnC~rnora}ioJ;l~G()uld Puinps and Mario & DiBono44Walf::Siie:d:\15th 'Fiooi~',V"o" ;',' ", <, '

.', :" ': -.'1'"'' :.' '., • • ..~ , ," . . ~ '.. ' . .' ..

New Yofk~·'NY10005;.2407 ', ' .,',. " '.... '

.,'.:=, ;,"

.. , ..~

.,.• j,

.' .•.. -,

.. '/,

'::":'."-'

..\'

·;~ ,

; .

._. ~ I

,":'U!·.·l·'·

,"

," \.'

'," 'r.-,;··";' .:::'}':n:;:1!<2:~:~f:tf}~t~~f1f:';t:" "r:~"~;~~!;;;' ',':A~!~;,"L,"

';'. '~', >; '.""'~:O; .~. .. '

"y::""{',

. '~.

- :. .. . ; \ ~

':1':' .",' ..

Ro~~r.(¥~I~RY;:,~§si·',~;~,' . : ',';.,:;-: ,M~LAB-Y·i&\BIQM)L'E;Y·· LLG .... ,; : L?', .- .~" .

, •••• <, '-,,:' .~::. '·':"'~~-.<I~·,:,,' ':'.-.;.. ,.:{~" ','. ; " .•. :.~.~~.;".>,.:-' .: ':.'~;;,;';~(/ ; .. ' 'Attoiriey~JorCBS:Jlkla ;Y;~acoiri f/k/a Westinghd,iise,yMofse;o:Siesel;J. H. France Refractories,Alcoa~Iric\:CrownBoiler;S'tipeiior Boiler Work§:\~c. Reyriolds Metals Company, Bakers PrideOven Co,; puiirto'san ; . " " .'.'. '150'Broadway,iSuite 600New York, NY 10038 '

Richard Marin; Esq. , 'MARIN GOOPMA,N,LLPAttorneys for.:Keeler/DoiT.Oliver Boiler Company500 Mamaroneck'Avenue 'Harrison, NY1'0528,>

"" .. '.~ "

Marc S. Gaffiley{E~q. "HOAGLANP,.EONGQ,iMGRAN, DUNST & DUKAS .Attorneys.for.Kohl~rCornpany,. J.ohnson Control~, :.Iilc., 84 Lumber, York International, GreatLakes Power Proa,libts;Jnc., individually and as Sticcessor to .the Paragon Gear Works of Tauton;Chicago Pnetilnatiq Intein~tiohal Inc. '40 Patterson Street' 'P.O. Box 460 ,','New BrunsWiGK,iNJ'08903 ,

:'1;" ,',

Anna M, DiLqn~dO",Esq.,. ", MARSHABL/DENNEHY WARNER, COLEMAN&,GbGGON

Attorneys :for Bo~gWamerCorporation, BO:nd~xand Lockheed Martin as successor in interest toMartin Maflett<:t:;!Robert A..Keasbey Co.; Thyssenkrupp'Eleyator Corp~ indiv. and as successor:ln':interest' to Dover Elevator Corn.pany , ,.'~ ,.,' "105 MaxessR6~d,Suite 303",Melville,N'y 11747 ,'"

~ .y:, ,

Andrew Sapon,-;"Esq., ' , ,',LITCHFIELD<,'CAV.O LI~P . .~. l'· .

Attorneys for Pre~ier :R~fra(;tories, Inc. flkla Adience;Inc.flkla. BMI Alcoa, Inc. (WTC Cases),Eaton Hydraulics, LLC, Eaton Hydraulics, fuc.,yickers, Inc., New 'Holland North America, Inc.,O'Connor Constructors: Inc. flklil Thomas O'Conllor& Co.; lnc.420 LexingtonAvenu~, Suite 2104 ' .New York, NY)0170':2199,

. :,, ,

HAWKINS P~~ELL THACKSTON & YOuNO,~Ll:~ ", , ' ,Attorneys 'for ~pme Engineering and Man~acturing;C9rporation and Pettibone/Traverse.Lift,LLC and Oakfa'!?co, Inc. a/k/a Kewanee Boiler Corpor~tion (4/3/13); Pneumo Abex LLC(8/2/13), The Btidd Qompany flkla AThyssenKruppBuad Co~;'PullmanPassenger Car Co.,Pestolite ElectTI~'.f:nc'.,The N~.wdell Co. Inc., New World ~tone C~""l(elly-MoorePaint 'Company'-" . '.:.: ", ,:,-'; ~ . .' '600 Lexiri@o·n •.~yehlte, 8th Floor'

, ~~., "\'---";","-'1:1'"'(;];"'_;' .,I~"· " ~

New YorR·:QN;Y~?\l0022 ,,'. ., . ~;;.:', '.. ' .. , .

":

.-;-0.' .:' -.,~

,\" Ii"

","

".<

/ :r

,(

, "

I':'

" '". \~

.. <'~l"' ,';" , <I":.: : .~":. .' ~ , .: ?\: f 'J'o:~.~ . . ; .

P4iI~p.J.'O'R9urke;;Esq.':',;,,: ;({:" , " .LEWIS B~,SBOIS}?ISG*RQ:&.,SMITH,LLP, '",- .,' ',,< "

Attorri~Ysfor~P€erl~s~Jndustrie~::fuc. and Kaise~~;d:)'psuIn,Cpmpany, hic." 77 Water Street, Suite 2100:,' " ' '"

New York, NY'io'Q05 I

Giovanni R~gwa, Esq.WATERS,McPHERSON &,McNEIL , , ,Attorneys for\;DB;Rileyand Turner Construction Company;;and FlowserveoInc.300'LightinglW.ay, 7th Floor , .P;O. Box-.1560 ,,' ':0 .'

Seclmcus'~"NJ;:07096 '", . ·\:~t

Patrick J. DWyer',', " ,SMITH; STRATTON, WISE,.HEHER~ BRENNANAttorneys for' Goodrich Co~oration; flkJaThe B,f. .G06dri~h Company, Individually and assuccessor'in ini.e~est to Th~Clev~lanq PneinnaticC,onipapy, it Division ofthe PneiimoAbex , 'Corp., awholly'o-wned sub'sidiaryofAbex, Inc. ' ': '100 Park Avenue, Suite 16'00"New York, NY 10017

Heidi Baker; Esq., """',, ., .,'

McMAHON"MART~E'& GALLAGHER ,Attorneys foi:E,astern,Retractories Company, Inc. and Tishman(WTC), Bradley Corponition55 WashingtonStree(:':': :!i',' '

Brooklyn, NY:(l2,oi,"', , , ", <'

"" ..

Frank A. Cec~r~; E~g;,. '.' " , ( ',': ,,' "AHMUTY;:I)EMERS,& MGMANUS,' ",',

;!~!r"~\, " ..', , "i".'. " ", • _.; '.

Attorneys f6i'~Tishman,CoristructionCorp., Troy Belting;>,& Supply, Yuba Heat Transfer;Fischbach '&~~o're;Tha:tnes &:Betts ' " , ,.'

, , .. Jv,;· ' .. '. " ,1

200 I.U.~i!lietsRoad. 'Albertson, NY 11507 '

StephenBals~6,Esq. ".- ',.,:,GARRITY;QRAHAM;'Ml)RpHY, GAROFAL0 & FLINN,P.C.

"<;'A~orneYs"!forUmti~f.'8onveYerCorp.' ", 72 Eagle Rock Avenue, Suite 350P~O. BO)(438' " '" 'East Hario~er,NJ 0793'6:.··;'

, '

"r·-' " .' ,. -' ..";~'-,'

",::~A::.,,~~;:;\i\ii.,~'i\~;,1,l".~, :

,.' ..' .'

, ,

,"

~ • ,0: '.

'l' .•.

'"

". '

: ..~

. "'j{:;;,~ .'.

:'"" .

" ,~- •-:. • • •...:.. J; '.' .,' , :1 .~

"

......' \ 'r.:

I' .Chri;s;iim,g~~h,:J;:~.~:"'.:.:'..."'.' .. .'. .' .'.<~::'~{~::'.;':,~;;" ..:.;;,~>;SEGAL .Me:CAMBRIDGE SINGER & MAHONEY,"LTD. "

"_,," , 'C,'t,' " " u_•••• ,,',!' " ... , _ 1. _' : ::~. '~'. .'. _..', • '

Attorneys'for A'W.'Chesterton Co.(as of2/13/15);·tcf:B;'Fuller and;'Weil"-McLainCo., GarlockSeali~g'T~chnologies;tL~, The Anchor:·PackingCo.,Fairbarlks'·Mo~se Puinp & FairbariksMorse~E.ngipe, individually;an~ as successor to Go·Qdrich·Corp.; f/k/aB.F:. Goodrich; GardnerDenver~ Inc., Southern'Tier Insulations, CUIIlIIlons Engine Co., )nc. and Compudyne Corp. Indiv.and asS.p,cc~~·~or'~9. Yor~ S'hipley; Curtiss Wright Corporation, Auro~a Pump"Co., Mannington .Mill~,Ip.9~;I:IWb~rt!:l\lros~; ~c, .,850'1bircLAveriue"'Suite 1100. , " .-~, : ::: " ', .. ', . .

New YOr1<,)'fY:'l 0022

by depositing a;trU~ copy.of the same enciosed in a post':pa.id wrapper in an official repository. . . . .

, . .' .. ,~'. '; " . ~ ~ ...., ' .: . . , ,

. under the exclusive care and; custody of the United States Postal Service or by delivering a true"", "

copy of the s~e in 'a po~~-p~~ wrapper ,to: an authorized United States Postal Service empioyee," .,', '.:"" .; , , ,

directed tothe':said.:party/p~ies~tthe address(es):set forth above, such being the addressees)• ." ,1-_", ~- J" • , • : i

... designated by the said'~party/parties for that purpose..

• '. ,'. I"

I".' .:',,1

','

:.\'

Sworn to before me thisday of May, 201~..

u···· '.

. . ". . " .. . ,.'. ' . - '. ,... ','" . , , ~- ::.: "

:' , ,', ': ' ...... ::-,

. BERNARDO. HERBE~ .',NOTARY'PUBLI9, Stllte of NewYOft(

. . .No..01HE62201.25Qua\\~le~lnOrang~ q()ur~18'

cornmlsS~ci,,;ExPlresAPflI12, ..

"

: ....

, .,

".' ".,

·i

,.....

.,'.

."

rrr:il'1Ff::Jh .~: (u j.,\t,1I-,<"iQ .. ;llOY i'J~~1 k; 'JIS/2 .~IU.'3IF! Y';f, "(lj,~

es tossa3H ffJ oIi,'l(.rtiJOO !'.ll!:'li;'O Ii! Q:l,I/'J!.,,',:

IHOS .S r li'iCj,\ :,~,..,I,"x:?i :;{)I:>'::lrj'l.i:., "

I.-~ " ,,--- .

':D/"\ VI DM . ,:S;~.rN'T ORO'. '~'..j.''',', :..~~, ,- -., . ~--..:-. -',-~)

ATT~RNEY:FOR .'C·ONS'OLID.ATEDEDISON COMPANY,OFNEW'YOR'~;INC. :

• .' 4'IRVING'pLACi:' ,.. "

NEW YORK.'N.Y. 10003·

,TEL. NO. (212) 460-3355

, ,..,: .

Suzanne Ratcliffe, Esq..Weitz &. Luxenberg, P.C.700 BroadwayNew York, New York 10003

Re:' Miles Peders~ri':~. Con Edison'Index Nos.: 111222/01; 115822/01Con Edison File No.: S-6029-01

Dear Suzanne:

Pursuant to your agreement; 1 enclose theNo Opposition SurrimaryJudgment Motion and Proposed Order on behalf of Consolidated Edison CompanyofNe'Y York, Inc. in this case. Please execute and re4Im it for filing with the .Court.~· . '

Tihank you for your atteIition,and courtesy.

,Very truly yours,

David M. Santoro

By:

TMMEnclosurecc: Remaining Defense Counsel

,e;;.

.> - .... ~.

.J

· -_..

.,\

.'

.\,\\

.' .] '.

"c.

INDEX NO.111222/01SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK .,.COUNTY OF NEW YORKIN RE: NEW YORK COUNTY

ASBESTOS LITIGATION,

THIS DOCUMENT RELATES TO:

MILES R. PEDERSEN

NO OPPOSITION SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION AND ORDER

DAVID M. SANTOROAttorney for

Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc.4 Irving Place, Room 1800

New York, New York 10003-3598Tel. No. (212) 460-3355FAX No. (212) 677-5849

'.

To

Attorney(s) for

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE:

Service of a copy of the withinis hereby admitted.

Dated: 19-----------

[ ] NOTICE OF ENTRYthat the within is a true copy of an entered in the office of the clerk of the within named court on 19 .

[ ] NOTICE OF SETTLEMENTthat an Order of which the within is a true copy will be presented for settlement to the HON. one of the judges of thewithin named Court, at on 19 at M.

Dated:Yours, etc.,

DAVID M. SANTORO

Refer all communications to: Timothy M. McCann

)f~OAM3N

3~I:I:lO S)f~31~Al.NnO::>

SIOl ZI A'f~

a 311 ~