for children and young people on the autism...
TRANSCRIPT
Learning outcomes
To consider:
• barriers to learning and curriculum access for
children and young people on the autism spectrum
• differentiation strategies to facilitate curriculum • differentiation strategies to facilitate curriculum
access
• homework, testing and examinations and out-of-
school activities.
2
The world turned upside down
Teaching styles that are effective for typically developing children and
young people are often NOT as effective for those on the autism
spectrum. Consider the following – in your experience do learners on
the spectrum enjoy or are they motivated by these activities?
• learning by listening
• novelty, new events, trips, special days • novelty, new events, trips, special days
• opportunities for small talk
• pleasing others
• open-ended tasks
• role-play/imaginative tasks
• group work
• playtime/break.
3
Autistic differences can impact on learning
• Language not sufficiently developed to follow teaching
• Slow verbal processing/difficulty in sustaining attention to teacher talk: has not fully listened to/remembered teaching
• Learning difficulties
• Difficulty in dealing with open-ended tasks
• Problems in organising ideas into a coherent sequence
• Lack of empathy makes for a poor imaginative response• Lack of empathy makes for a poor imaginative response
• Perfectionist: can’t handle making mistakes
• Easily distracted or forgets what the task is
• Turns topics to ones of his/her own interest
• Problems concentrating in a noisy environment
• Lower ability at putting feelings/needs into words and communicating/asking for help
• No motivation or wish to please the teacher by trying
4
• Difficulties transferring learning from one situation to another: failure to make connections/see big picture
• Uncertainty over choice and opinion; problems with anything that is speculation rather than fact
• Rigid perceptions of what they feel they can do/can’t do, like/don’t like: can be difficult to engage in some tasks
• Black and white thinking: lack of appreciation of grey areas in group
discussions
• Poorly developed social skills: difficulties in team games and group
taskstasks
• Dyspraxic-type coordination difficulties: weak pencil
control/balance/ball skills
• A wish for social success can lead to skewed priorities.
But not all of these difficulties in any one young person!
5
Activity 6.1 Barriers to learning
• Seat yourself next to a colleague. Identify two different
children or young people on the spectrum who you teach or
support.
• Consider the autistic differences checklist (Handout 6.1) for • Consider the autistic differences checklist (Handout 6.1) for
each child or young person you have identified. Highlight the
differences experienced by child A and discuss as you do so.
Then repeat, highlighting the checklist for child B.
• Compare the highlighted patterns. What does this tell you
about barriers to learning for each child?
6
How do we overcome barriers to learning?
Common practice is to overcome barriers and improve
curriculum access through additional adult support.
BUT
Ofsted (2010) found that additional adult support is not always
effective in removing barriers to learning: effective in removing barriers to learning:
• extra adults may help the child to complete the task rather than
actually helping him/her learn
• the child may work solely with a TA and never with the teacher
• the close presence of an adult may make a child more socially isolated
SO
further planning is needed
7
Differentiation for children and young
people on the autism spectrum
Schools have a responsibility to:
• set suitable learning challenges
• respond to diverse needs
• overcome barriers to learning.• overcome barriers to learning.
… all of which require planned differentiation taking
into account characteristic differences of the autism
spectrum.
8
Differentiating lesson objectives
and content
• Differentiated learning objectives which take into account
individual needs; personal targets in priority areas (social,
communication and thinking)
• Selective content• Selective content
• Earlier and easier content
• Content used to teach a more basic skill
• Different content
9
Differentiating teaching styles
• A more practical/kinaesthetic approach
• Clearer links between learning (mind maps are useful)
• Visual teaching styles:
• mind maps and/or flowcharts
• careful use of the interactive whiteboard• careful use of the interactive whiteboard
• showing artefacts and photographs
• showing information in diagrammatic form
• see the text rather than just hear it read
• making good use of modelling: let the child watch
• ‘one I made earlier’.
10
Case Study 1
‘When writing an autobiography assignment Cynthia
fixated on describing her pets and her interactions with
them in minute detail. A teaching assistant worked with
Cynthia to draw out a mind map to help her plan out Cynthia to draw out a mind map to help her plan out
exactly what should be included in her autobiography.
This mind map was then used to develop a writing
frame, which enabled Cynthia to expand her
autobiography to encompass a greater range of topics
and to reduce minute details.’
11
Auditory processing difficulties
• May not understand or process language effectively
• Difficulties in screening out other noises and knowing which sounds
to attend to
• Sensory integration problems (only one sensory channel processed
effectively at a time – eg, hearing, vision, touch, smell)effectively at a time – eg, hearing, vision, touch, smell)
• May not realise you are talking to him/her when talking to the class
• May need to ‘translate’ spoken language into visual images
• May tune in and out, resulting in patchy understanding
• Listening can be very stressful and tiring
• Literal interpretation/confused by ambiguity
• Too much language - results in overload
12
Improving access to auditory teaching
• Cueing in
• Tolerating looking away
• Differentiating discussion questions
• Chunking listening by using short tasks
o use of discussion partners
short pencil/whiteboard tasko short pencil/whiteboard task
o exercise breaks.
• Use of discussion partners
• Modelling clarification
• Praising pupils for seeking clarification
• Teaching and reinforcing good listening
13
Activity 6.2
Differentiation: adult support
Talk in mixed pairs of teachers and support staff about
the role of teaching assistants in supporting children
and young people on the autism spectrum in your
setting. Teachers: ask TAs which strategies they find setting. Teachers: ask TAs which strategies they find
most effective in the following areas: a) supporting
learning b) promoting curriculum access c) increasing
independence.
What do TAs feel they need to know to enable them to
differentiate effectively for individuals on the
spectrum?14
Differentiating support: teaching assistants
• Pre-teaching (formal or informal)
• Focusing, prompting and repetition
• Overt modelling
• Modifying language/translating
• Alternative recording • Alternative recording
• Working away from the class
• Structuring up the task
• Help the pupil understand the teaching
• Visual ways of presenting tasks
• Writing social stories
15
Alternative methods of recordingIdeas include:
• Scribing
• Computer applications
• Writing frames (see
example opposite)
Science experiment _____________
We got……………… ………………….,
…………………… and …………………...............
1. First we…………………………………...........…
……………………………………………...............….
2. Then we …………………….........……..………example opposite)
• Sorting tasks
• Simplifying descriptive
writing
• Tops and tails
……………………………………...............………….
We saw that…………….................…………….
………………………...................……………………
3. This made us think that
..................................................................
..................................................................
4. We learned that …………….............….....
……………………………………...................………
16
Structuring up tasks: task lists
• You could use scrap paper, a small whiteboard or a laminated sheet with the initial task printed.
• Ask the pupil Tell me what you have to do first ..... then...etc.
Example task list
1. Copy title and date,
underline.
2. Cut out the hurricane
pictures.
3. Stick them in your book have to do first ..... then...etc.
• Jot the steps down in order.
• The pupil works through,
ticking off as done.
3. Stick them in your book
in order.
4. Under each picture explain
what is happening.
5. Put your hand up to let the
teacher know you have
finished.
17
Ask a teaching assistant to listen and
provide prompts:
Note anything important the
child or young person will
need to remember.
Note some important
words eg
Heat chocolateheat
Melts, runny, sticky
Cool chocolate
Goes solid, hard
cook
heat
beat
mix
bake
18
Visual ways of presenting tasks
Different ways of helping the pupil to see what they
need to do.
• Use a highlighter pen to attract the pupil to
instructions or to places where they should write
• Use writing frames to structure answers• Use writing frames to structure answers
• Give diagrams to label
• Give ruled space for answers
• Specify how many sentences 1 2 3 4 5 6
• Use a computer application such as Clicker
• Make up a worksheet with a simplified task (see slide 22)
• Make a pictorial instruction/jig (see slide 20)19
Case study 2
‘Yolanda was struggling with how a maths task was presented in
her textbook. The page was littered with pictures that were
irrelevant and distracting. The way in which the maths was
presented varied from numbers to words. Instructions were
wordy. Yolanda needed a lot of help to get through it and felt wordy. Yolanda needed a lot of help to get through it and felt
confused and anxious as she was doing so. It was decided that
the TA’s time would be used to prepare a visually clearer
worksheet which she was then able to work through more
independently as she could see what she had to do, instead of
directly working with Yolanda. Tactile counter pieces were also
provided to help enable the task to be more tangible, rather than
abstract.’
21
Visually drawing attention to important
information
Today we are working on:
23
Today we are working on:
The Romans
Case study 3
‘During an art lesson, and following the teacher’s instructions,
Paul seemed at a loss as to what to do and just stood at the table
with materials in his hand. Paul’s teacher asked a peer at his
table to describe and show what they needed to be doing during
the art lesson. The teaching assistant then prompted Paul to the art lesson. The teaching assistant then prompted Paul to
explain what he was to do as he undertook each step. If he got
stuck, she prompted another pupil to demonstrate that step. The
steps were then recorded in a bulleted list which Paul could refer
to when needed. This combination of peer modelling and a visual
list worked well to support Paul in recalling instructions.’
24
Case study 4
‘The teaching assistant has noticed that Ben does not
take in what is being covered in class explanations and
introductions. Knowing that the topic of the Egyptians
had some difficult vocabulary, Ben’s TA decided to pre-
teach some of the words and concepts dealing with
ancient Egypt. They worked together cutting out images ancient Egypt. They worked together cutting out images
and pasting them next to words that were to be covered
in the introductory lesson. The TA encouraged Ben to
listen out for the key words to be mentioned by his
teacher. Ben was more attentive in the introduction, and
was helped when his TA discretely pointed to some of the
key word cards they made as the introduction went on.’25
Activity 6.3
Working in teacher/teaching-assistant pairs and
using the worksheets provided, identify visual
strategies which could be used to differentiate
the tasks for a child or young person on the the tasks for a child or young person on the
spectrum who you teach or support. Discuss
how these could be applied to other subjects
and tasks.
26
A word about social stories
and curriculum access
Social Stories (Gray, 2010) may be helpful in promoting
access to the ‘social curriculum’. Many children and
young people on the autism spectrum do not work out
easily what the expected behaviour in particular easily what the expected behaviour in particular
situations is; social stories combine well with visual
strategies, explaining social rules and providing
guidance in an ‘autism-friendly’ way (Howley and
Arnold, 2005).
27
A word about social stories and curriculum access
Social stories can be written to support curriculum access, for
example providing information about the following types of
topics which are common ‘barriers’ experienced by children and
young people on the spectrum:
• When does the teacher want me to answer questions in class?
• Working with my talk partner in class.
• Correcting mistakes.
• Asking for help in class.
• Tackling problems in maths.
• Winning and losing.
• How to take tests.
28
Case study 5‘Becky had a diagnosis of Asperger’s syndrome and a statement of special
educational needs with full-time support at school. Even with this support
Becky was highly anxious and prone to emotional outbursts, usually borne out
of frustration with herself. In particular, Becky could not tolerate making
mistakes. Becky’s intolerance of her own errors became a major stumbling
block to her inclusion. Very little work was completed as, in nearly every
lesson, Becky tore up her work. She disrupted lessons with screams of rage.
She went home each day emotionally and physically exhausted. Staff decided She went home each day emotionally and physically exhausted. Staff decided
to try social stories and collaborated to write a simple story that explained
that making mistakes was OK and, in fact, this meant you were learning
effectively. The story suggested alternative actions to tearing up her work and
getting upset: to say ‘Never mind, everyone makes mistakes sometimes,’ to
put a line through the error and continue working. The story was shared with
Becky. In class when Becky made a mistake the TA modelled saying ‘Never
mind, everyone makes mistakes’ and putting a line through the error. Becky
loudly and angrily joined in and did as shown. She gradually internalised the
story and performed the new actions for herself.’
29
Supporting group work
Social differences characteristic of the autism spectrum mean
that group work poses yet another set of challenges for the
youngster with autism. Barriers may arise due to:
• difficulties sitting in close proximity to others
• not listening or appreciating others’ ideas • not listening or appreciating others’ ideas
• failing to take turns in discussions
• insisting on own viewpoint
• inability to share
• inability to co-operate and collaborate
30
Supporting group work
• Begin with partner work if a group is too stressful for the
individual
• Use ‘your turn’ cards to visually clarify whose turn it is to
speak – use a toy microphone with young children
• Make it clear how long the individual is expected to • Make it clear how long the individual is expected to
participate – set small time limits and gradually build eg:
first… 15 minutes group work, then...5 minutes doodling in
quiet area
• Give role cards to group members (eg, thinkers, scribe,
illustrator, time keeper, presenter)
31
• Teach how ‘group work’ works, eg, by use of video interaction
guidance to model social skills of group members – this has
the added benefit that the individual can replay the video
repeatedly as needed
• Support with visual structure which indicates principles of
group work (see next slide for an example)
• Allocate the child or young person on the spectrum a task
within the group which uses their strengths or interestswithin the group which uses their strengths or interests
• Provide a visual strategy (communication card) which enables
the individual to leave the group if too anxious
• Consider developing a series of social stories (or articles for
older students) that explain the social rules of group work and
why it is important for group members to follow these rules
32
Group working
Your names
Taking turns
Sharing
equipment
Helping
each othereach other
Listening to
each other
Agreeing
how to do
things
33
Activity 6.4
Working in the same teacher/teaching-assistant
pairs, and using the highlighted lists which
identified barriers to learning and curriculum identified barriers to learning and curriculum
access (Activity 6.1) for each child or young
person, identify two or three ways of improving
their access to the curriculum. Prepare to
feedback to the whole group.
34
A word about tests and exams
For public exams, school tests and classwork generally, the
following access arrangements may be available to pupils on
the autistic spectrum as necessary for different individuals:
• taking tests in a quiet room
• 25% extra time to allow for slower processing or writing speed• 25% extra time to allow for slower processing or writing speed
• a reader
• a scribe
• rest breaks
• a prompter
• possibly oral language modifier (questions explained in more
simple language)
35
A word about homework
• To many pupils on the autistic spectrum homework is an illogical and unfair
feature of life; this can be an initial problem to overcome
• Some pupils will literally not have heard you set the homework: try not to
leave it to the end of lessons to set it
• For many their notes are insufficient for them to recall what to do: try to
provide step-by-step instructions, preferably written or presented on the provide step-by-step instructions, preferably written or presented on the
school VLE or via email
• Some pupils obsess over homework: you may need to set them a time limit
• Some pupils fail to plan for homework properly: build in organisational
support
• A surprising number do the homework but fail to hand it in: ensure that staff
ask the individual directly for their homework
36
Case study 6
‘Bronwyn was a Year 7 pupil who was getting increasingly
argumentative with her school and family over the issue of
homework. She saw no use or purpose to it whatsoever. A TA
decided to write a social article explaining the reasons why
teachers gave homework. She planned this with Bronwyn’s
parents, and ensured that the message would be reinforced both
at school and home. The article highlighted the positive aspects of
homework – such as how it consolidated and practised one’s
learning, and gave opportunities to extend learning that couldn’t
be completed during the day. Although not completely happy with
the concept of homework, Bronwyn began to understand its
purpose and gradually grew to accept it as a necessary part of her
school routine. The TA was then able to help her formulate useful
strategies to get homework completed on time.’37
Disability discrimination: breaking down barriers
The Equality Act (2010) defines disability as
‘….., a physical or mental impairment which has a substantial and
long term adverse effect on his or her ability to carry out
normal day to day activities.’
Autistic spectrum disorders are a lifelong disability.
Reasonable adjustments must be made to include the child oryoung person with autism in all aspects of school life.
38
Protection from discrimination• Schools must not treat disabled pupils less
favourably (unless you can satisfy a court that what
you did was reasonable in the circumstances).
• Schools must make reasonable adjustments for
disabled pupils. (This means you must anticipate the
39
disabled pupils. (This means you must anticipate the
barriers disabled pupils may face and take steps to
remove or minimise them.)
If a school treats a disabled pupil (or prospective pupil)
less favourably than another for a reason related to his
disability, and without justification, they may be
breaking the law.
Characteristics of autism may present many barriers to
including children and young people in the wider
curriculum, eg, out-of-school trips, extra-curricular
activities. However, these types of activities are
important for raising self-esteem and developing social
interaction skills.
With careful planning, taking into account individual
needs and differences, individuals on the spectrum can
be fully included in all aspects of school life.
40
Activity 6.5
Working in small groups, select two of the topics below and
identify barriers to including a child or young person on the
autism spectrum.
• Lessons at the swimming pool
• Lunchtimes in school
• The Christmas show
• Attending an after school club
• A trip to a zoo
• A residential trip to an activity centre
Identify strategies to break down barriers and to enable
participation.
41
In summary
Autism spectrum differences present particular barriers
to inclusion in learning and curriculum access.
Autism-friendly strategies help to break down barriers Autism-friendly strategies help to break down barriers
to enable access and participation.
Strategies are most effective when combined – future
training will explore examples of combined strategies.
42