gemara notes 49 - 51
TRANSCRIPT
Gemara Notes p. 48
דף ס עמוד א
One is only חייב for something
that is exposed, but not
something hidden
One is חייב for anything that
stands upright, including trees
and animals
One is חייב for anything that
stands upright, including trees
and animals
One is חייב even if his fire burned only one of the objects listed
One is חייב even if his fire burned only one of the objects listed
Since it says “or” by the standing grain, it also says “or” by the field
רבנן ר' יהודה
Why does the Passuk need to teach the word “field”?
To include that one is חייב to pay for the earth and stones that were singed
So why didn’t the Torah just write “the field”, and not write the other three?
If the Torah had only written “the field”, I would have said he is only חייב for what is in the field, but not the ground itself. Therefore the Torah taught “the standing grain” as well to teach us that “the field” refers to the ground itself.
הוה אמינא
Gemara Notes 47 - 50
דף ס עמוד א
הוה אמינא(What I would have thought
without it)
קא משמע לן(What it teaches
us)
קוציםOne is not חייב for things that have such little value
One is חייב for things that have such little value
גדיש
One is not חייב for something worth so much, because it must have been an אונס
One is חייב because we don’t assume its an אונס
הקמה
One is – רבנן for things פטורthat are hidden
One is – ר' יהודהalso חייב for trees and animals
השדהOne is חייב for even the burnt soil and stones