hedgehog pathway blockade offers hope for childhood brain cancer

1
For personal use. Only reproduce with permission from The Lancet Publishing Group. THE LANCET Neurology Vol 1 October 2002 http://neurology.thelancet.com 334 Newsdesk Most AMPA-type glutamate receptors expressed in human glioblastoma cells lack the GluR2 subunit and are therefore Ca 2+ -permeable, according to new research. Prevention of Ca 2+ influx via these receptors, in response to endogenous glutamate, inhibits migration and proliferation of glioblastoma cells, and induces their apoptosis, say Shogo Ishiuchi (Gunma University School of Medicine, Maebashi, Gunma, Japan) and colleagues. This may provide a new therapeutic strategy for prevention of glioblastoma invasion. Glioblastoma multiforme is the most malignant tumour of the CNS. “In Japan, the 5 year survival rate is 6·3%”, says Ishiuchi, “and median survival is 9–12 months, despite intensive efforts to treat glioblastoma with a combination of surgery, radiation and chemotherapy.” In part, the prognosis is so poor because surgery can rarely remove all of this extremely invasive tumour. To learn more about glioblastoma biology, Ishiuchi’s team examined AMPA-receptor expression in 16 surgical specimens. AMPA receptors contain combinations of four subunits, GluR1–4. Receptors that include the adult version of GluR2, which has an arginine at a crucial position within its channel-lining region, are Ca 2+ - impermeable; receptors lacking GluR2 are permeable to Ca 2+ . Most glioblastoma cells from the surgical specimens expressed GluR1 and GluR4, but few expressed GluR2 abundantly. Adenoviral transfer of GluR2 into a glioblastoma cell line that expresses only GluR1 and GluR4 caused the cells to become less motile and increased the number undergoing apoptosis. In mice, introduction of GluR2 into tumorigenic glioblastoma cells prevented tumour formation in the cerebrum and treatment with the AMPA-receptor antagonist YM872 reduced the growth of subcutaneously seeded glioblastomas (Nat Med 2002; 8: 971–78). “This paper shows very nicely that transfection with GluR2 reduces prolif- eration and migration in glioblastoma cells, indicating that calcium is needed for these behaviours”, says Michael Bennett (Albert Einstein College of Medicine, NY, USA). Other groups have also found glutamate receptor antagonists to be antitumour agents, he comments, “and I would like to know whether receptor antagonists work against tumour cells injected into the brain rather than subcutaneously. Nevertheless, even given the potential for side-effects associated with receptor-antagonist treatment, if I had glioblastoma, I would be glad to try an AMPA antagonist.” Indeed, the Japanese team is currently planning a phase I trial of AMPA antagonists in the USA. But, warns Ishiuchi, “even if this is successful, it will be at least 3–5 years before this approach to glioblastoma treatment reaches the clinic”. Jane Bradbury Hopeful channel to glioblastoma treatment revealed Blocking the activity of the “hedgehog” signalling pathway slows tumour growth and may be useful for the treatment of medulloblastoma—the most common childhood brain cancer. Despite major advances in therapy, around 40% of patients with medullo- blastoma die from the disease within 5 years of diagnosis. “Treatment can be highly aggressive involving many rounds of chemotherapy and infusions of haematopoetic stem cells”, says study co- author James Olson (Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, WA, USA). About 20% of patients with medulloblastoma have a mutation in one of the genes of the hedgehog pathway, which was identified as a treatment target when Phil Beachy and colleagues (Johns Hopkins University, MD, USA) discovered that it is inhibited by a plant-derived compound called cyclopamine. “Knowing that some medulloblastomas were caused by too much hedgehog signalling drove the current experiments with cyclopamine”, recalls Olson. The team was surprised at the success of the approach: “When we began this work, we hoped that cyclopamine would help the 20% of patients that had hedgehog mutations”, explains Olson, “but seven out of seven patient samples underwent cell death in response to the drug, raising the possibility that nearly all medullo- blastomas might depend on hedgehog signalling—even in the absence of identifiable gene mutations.” (Science 2002; 297: 1559–61) “This study adds important novel data”, Guido Reifenberger (Heinrich- Heine-University, Düsseldorf, Germany) and Torsten Pietsch (University of Bonn, Germany) comment. However, they caution that tumours with aberrant hedgehog signalling, which also have other mutations enabling them to keep growing when the hedgehog pathway is blocked, may be resistant to cyclopamine treatment. Reifenberger and Pietsch suggest that if tumour types that respond favourably to cyclopamine are identified, “molec- ular analysis of resected tumour-tissue samples” could be used “to select those patients who are most likely to benefit”. Olson is hopeful that hedgehog blockers will be in clinical trials within 5 years: “We will do everything possible to move this [research] forward, given that these drugs hold promise to be highly effective and minimally toxic.” “There will undoubtedly be efforts to identify drugs that can be synthesised in the laboratory, rather than extracted from plants”, he adds. Hannah Brown Hedgehog pathway blockade offers hope for childhood brain cancer Corn lily: source of cyclopamine Photograph used by permission of USDA-ARS Poisonous Plant Research Lab Rights were not granted to include this image in electronic media. Please refer to the printed journal.

Upload: hannah-brown

Post on 16-Sep-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Hedgehog pathway blockade offers hope for childhood brain cancer

For personal use. Only reproduce with permission from The Lancet Publishing Group.

THE LANCET Neurology Vol 1 October 2002 http://neurology.thelancet.com334

Newsdesk

Most AMPA-type glutamate receptorsexpressed in human glioblastoma cellslack the GluR2 subunit and aretherefore Ca2+-permeable, accordingto new research. Prevention of Ca2+

influx via these receptors, in responseto endogenous glutamate, inhibitsmigration and proliferation ofglioblastoma cells, and induces theirapoptosis, say Shogo Ishiuchi (GunmaUniversity School of Medicine,Maebashi, Gunma, Japan) andcolleagues. This may provide a newtherapeutic strategy for prevention ofglioblastoma invasion.

Glioblastoma multiforme is themost malignant tumour of the CNS.“In Japan, the 5 year survival rate is6·3%”, says Ishiuchi, “and mediansurvival is 9–12 months, despiteintensive efforts to treat glioblastomawith a combination of surgery,radiation and chemotherapy.” In part,the prognosis is so poor because surgerycan rarely remove all of this extremelyinvasive tumour.

To learn more about glioblastomabiology, Ishiuchi’s team examinedAMPA-receptor expression in 16surgical specimens. AMPA receptorscontain combinations of four subunits,GluR1–4. Receptors that include theadult version of GluR2, which has anarginine at a crucial position within itschannel-lining region, are Ca2+-impermeable; receptors lacking GluR2are permeable to Ca2+.

Most glioblastoma cells from thesurgical specimens expressed GluR1 andGluR4, but few expressed GluR2abundantly. Adenoviral transfer of GluR2into a glioblastoma cell line that expressesonly GluR1 and GluR4 caused the cells tobecome less motile and increased thenumber undergoing apoptosis. In mice,introduction of GluR2 into tumorigenicglioblastoma cells prevented tumourformation in the cerebrum and treatmentwith the AMPA-receptor antagonistYM872 reduced the growth ofsubcutaneously seeded glioblastomas(Nat Med 2002; 8: 971–78).

“This paper shows very nicely thattransfection with GluR2 reduces prolif-eration and migration in glioblastomacells, indicating that calcium is neededfor these behaviours”, says MichaelBennett (Albert Einstein College ofMedicine, NY, USA). Other groupshave also found glutamate receptorantagonists to be antitumour agents, hecomments, “and I would like to knowwhether receptor antagonists workagainst tumour cells injected into thebrain rather than subcutaneously.Nevertheless, even given the potentialfor side-effects associated withreceptor-antagonist treatment, if I hadglioblastoma, I would be glad to try anAMPA antagonist.”

Indeed, the Japanese team iscurrently planning a phase I trial ofAMPA antagonists in the USA. But,warns Ishiuchi, “even if this issuccessful, it will be at least 3–5 yearsbefore this approach to glioblastomatreatment reaches the clinic”.Jane Bradbury

Hopeful channel to glioblastoma treatment revealed

Blocking the activity of the “hedgehog”signalling pathway slows tumourgrowth and may be useful for thetreatment of medulloblastoma—themost common childhood brain cancer.

Despite major advances in therapy,around 40% of patients with medullo-blastoma die from the disease within5 years of diagnosis. “Treatment can behighly aggressive involving many roundsof chemotherapy and infusions ofhaematopoetic stem cells”, says study co-author James Olson (Fred HutchinsonCancer Research Center, WA, USA).

About 20% of patients withmedulloblastoma have a mutation inone of the genes of the hedgehogpathway, which was identified as atreatment target when Phil Beachy andcolleagues (Johns Hopkins University,MD, USA) discovered that it isinhibited by a plant-derived compoundcalled cyclopamine. “Knowing thatsome medulloblastomas were caused bytoo much hedgehog signalling drovethe current experiments withcyclopamine”, recalls Olson.

The team was surprised at thesuccess of the approach: “When webegan this work, we hoped thatcyclopamine would help the 20% ofpatients that had hedgehog mutations”,

explains Olson, “but seven out of sevenpatient samples underwent cell death inresponse to the drug, raising thepossibility that nearly all medullo-blastomas might depend on hedgehogsignalling—even in the absence ofidentifiable gene mutations.” (Science2002; 297: 1559–61)

“This study adds important noveldata”, Guido Reifenberger (Heinrich-

Heine-University, Düsseldorf, Germany)and Torsten Pietsch (University ofBonn, Germany) comment. However,they caution that tumours withaberrant hedgehog signalling, whichalso have other mutations enablingthem to keep growing when thehedgehog pathway is blocked, may beresistant to cyclopamine treatment.Reifenberger and Pietsch suggest that iftumour types that respond favourablyto cyclopamine are identified, “molec-ular analysis of resected tumour-tissuesamples” could be used “to select thosepatients who are most likely tobenefit”.

Olson is hopeful that hedgehogblockers will be in clinical trials within5 years: “We will do everything possibleto move this [research] forward, giventhat these drugs hold promise to behighly effective and minimally toxic.”

“There will undoubtedly be effortsto identify drugs that can be synthesisedin the laboratory, rather than extractedfrom plants”, he adds.Hannah Brown

Hedgehog pathway blockade offers hope for childhood brain cancer

Corn lily: source of cyclopamine

Phot

ogra

ph u

sed

by p

erm

issi

on o

f U

SD

A-AR

SPo

ison

ous

Plan

t R

esea

rch

Lab

Rights were notgranted to include this

image in electronicmedia. Please refer to

the printed journal.