hey! there’s lead in my water!
TRANSCRIPT
The world leader in serving science
Hey! There’s Lead in my Water!
The Drinking Water Contamination Issue
Facing Residents of Flint, MI
2
How Does Lead Get Into my Drinking Water?
Lead in Drinking Water
3
How Does Lead Get Into my Drinking Water?
• Most households contain lead pipes or pipes with lead solder joints
Lead in Drinking Water
4
How Does Lead Get Into my Drinking Water?
• Most households contain lead pipes or pipes with lead solder joints
• Corrosive water passes through
the pipes
Lead in Drinking Water
5
How Does Lead Get Into my Drinking Water?
• Most households contain lead pipes or pipes with lead solder joints
• Corrosive water passes through
the pipes
• Chemical reactions take
place between the pipes
and the water
Lead in Drinking Water
6
How Does Lead Get Into my Drinking Water?
• Most households contain lead pipes or pipes with lead solder joints
• Corrosive water passes through
the pipes
• Chemical reactions take
place between the pipes
and the water
• Some of the lead dissolves
into the water
Lead in Drinking Water
7
How Does Lead Get Into my Drinking Water?
• Most households contain lead pipes or pipes with lead solder joints
• Corrosive water passes through
the pipes
• Chemical reactions take
place between the pipes
and the water
• Some of the lead dissolves
into the water
Lead in Drinking Water
Let’s Look at This
in More Detail…
8
Lead in Drinking Water
9
Lead in Drinking Water
10
Lead in Drinking Water
• Acidic (pH ~4-7)
11
Lead in Drinking Water
• Acidic (pH ~4-7)
12
Lead in Drinking Water
• Low alkalinity
CO32-
CO32-
CO32-
CO32-
13
Lead in Drinking Water
• High temperature
water
14
Lead in Drinking Water
• Saline (high levels of dissolved salts)
15
Lead in Drinking Water
16
Lead in Drinking Water
Attributes of Flint River
17
Lead in Drinking Water
• Low pH
Attributes of Flint River
18
Lead in Drinking Water
• Low pH
• High salinity
• High levels of chlorides
Attributes of Flint River
19
Lead in Drinking Water
20
There are 3 Common Sources For Chloride in Natural Waters:
Lead in Drinking Water
21
There are 3 Common Sources For Chloride in Natural Waters:
Lead in Drinking Water
Cl-
Cl-
1) Naturally occurring chloride salts
Cl- Cl-
Cl- Cl-
Cl-
Cl-
22
There are 3 Common Sources For Chloride in Natural Waters:
Lead in Drinking Water
2) Runoff from road salts
23
There are 3 Common Sources For Chloride in Natural Waters:
Lead in Drinking Water
3) Water disinfection chemicals
24
Lead in Drinking Water
25
Lead in Drinking Water
Challenges in Treating Flint River Water
26
Lead in Drinking Water
• Flint River has naturally excessive levels of chloride
Challenges in Treating Flint River Water
27
Lead in Drinking Water
• Flint River has naturally excessive levels of chloride
• Chloride reacts with iron pipes to form ferric chloride (FeCl3)
• Reaction with iron ties up chloride that should be disinfecting the water
• Additional chlorine must be added for disinfection
Challenges in Treating Flint River Water
28
Lead in Drinking Water
• Flint River has naturally excessive levels of chloride
• Chloride reacts with iron pipes to form ferric chloride (FeCl3)
• Reaction with iron ties up chloride that should be disinfecting the water
• Additional chlorine must be added for disinfection
• Organic matter present in Flint River
Challenges in Treating Flint River Water
29
Lead in Drinking Water
• Flint River has naturally excessive levels of chloride
• Chloride reacts with iron pipes to form ferric chloride (FeCl3)
• Reaction with iron ties up chloride that should be disinfecting the water
• Additional chlorine must be added for disinfection
• Organic matter present in Flint River
• Additional chlorine reacts with the organic matter
• Reaction produces trihalomethane (THM) by-products
• THMs well-known for carcinogenic properties
Challenges in Treating Flint River Water
30
Lead in Drinking Water
• Flint River has naturally excessive levels of chloride
• Chloride reacts with iron pipes to form ferric chloride (FeCl3)
• Reaction with iron ties up chloride that should be disinfecting the water
• Additional chlorine must be added for disinfection
• Organic matter present in Flint River
• Additional chlorine reacts with the organic matter
• Reaction produces trihalomethane (THM) by-products
• THMs well-known for carcinogenic properties
• Flint River has a naturally low pH
Challenges in Treating Flint River Water
31
Lead in Drinking Water
• Flint River has naturally excessive levels of chloride
• Chloride reacts with iron pipes to form ferric chloride (FeCl3)
• Reaction with iron ties up chloride that should be disinfecting the water
• Additional chlorine must be added for disinfection
• Organic matter present in Flint River
• Additional chlorine reacts with the organic matter
• Reaction produces trihalomethane (THM) by-products
• THMs well-known for carcinogenic properties
• Flint River has a naturally low pH
• Reaction with iron and lack of corrosion inhibitors for water treatment help
maintain low pH
• Acidic environment promotes reaction with lead in pipes
Challenges in Treating Flint River Water
32
Lead in Drinking Water
33
Lead in Drinking Water
• Corrosive Water
34
Lead in Drinking Water
• Corrosive Water + Lead Pipes
35
Lead in Drinking Water
• Corrosive Water + Lead Pipes = Lead Contaminated Water
Pb
Pb
36
Lead in Drinking Water
37
How Can We Stop Pipes From Corroding?
Lead in Drinking Water
38
How Can We Stop Pipes From Corroding?
Lead in Drinking Water
1. Water Treatment –
39
How Can We Stop Pipes From Corroding?
Lead in Drinking Water
1. Water Treatment –
• Filter to reduce the amount of chloride present
• Treat water to adjust pH, salinity, hardness
40
How Can We Stop Pipes From Corroding?
Lead in Drinking Water
1. Water Treatment –
• Filter to reduce the amount of chloride present
• Treat water to adjust pH, salinity, hardness
2. Corrosion Control –
41
How Can We Stop Pipes From Corroding?
Lead in Drinking Water
1. Water Treatment –
• Filter to reduce the amount of chloride present
• Treat water to adjust pH, salinity, hardness
2. Corrosion Control –
• Addition of certain chemicals
affects the chemistry in the water
• They can increase the pH of the water
• They can promote scale growth along the
walls of the pipes
• Orthophosphates found to be most effective
for a range of plumbing materials
42
Lead in Drinking Water
43
Corrosion Control
Lead in Drinking Water
44
Corrosion Control
Lead in Drinking Water
The Plumbing Superhero to Fight Against Corrosion
45
Corrosion Control
Lead in Drinking Water
The Plumbing Superhero to Fight Against Corrosion
With Corrosion Inhibitors
46
Corrosion Control
Lead in Drinking Water
• Orthophosphates react to form lead compounds - low solubility
The Plumbing Superhero to Fight Against Corrosion
With Corrosion Inhibitors
47
Corrosion Control
Lead in Drinking Water
• Orthophosphates react to form lead compounds - low solubility
• Insoluble precipitate forms protective layers on inside of pipes
The Plumbing Superhero to Fight Against Corrosion
With Corrosion Inhibitors
48
Corrosion Control
Lead in Drinking Water
• Orthophosphates react to form lead compounds - low solubility
• Insoluble precipitate forms protective layers on inside of pipes
The Plumbing Superhero to Fight Against Corrosion
With Corrosion Inhibitors
Without Corrosion Inhibitors
49
Corrosion Control
Lead in Drinking Water
• Orthophosphates react to form lead compounds - low solubility
• Insoluble precipitate forms protective layers on inside of pipes
The Plumbing Superhero to Fight Against Corrosion
With Corrosion Inhibitors
Without Corrosion Inhibitors
• Water reacts with the lead-containing pipes
50
Corrosion Control
Lead in Drinking Water
• Orthophosphates react to form lead compounds - low solubility
• Insoluble precipitate forms protective layers on inside of pipes
The Plumbing Superhero to Fight Against Corrosion
With Corrosion Inhibitors
Without Corrosion Inhibitors
• Water reacts with the lead-containing pipes
• Lead dissolves, generally as PbCO3 (PbCl2 soluble in hot water)
Pb Pb
Pb
Pb
Pb
51
Lead in Drinking Water
52
How Much is “Too Much” Lead in Drinking Water?
Lead in Drinking Water
53
How Much is “Too Much” Lead in Drinking Water?
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
Lead in Drinking Water
54
How Much is “Too Much” Lead in Drinking Water?
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
• Safe Water Drinking Act (SWDA) and Lead
Copper Rule (LCR)
Lead in Drinking Water
55
How Much is “Too Much” Lead in Drinking Water?
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
• Safe Water Drinking Act (SWDA) and Lead
Copper Rule (LCR)
• Maximum Contaminant Level
• Goal Concentration = 0 µg/L Pb
• Action Level Concentration = 15 µg/L Pb
Lead in Drinking Water
56
How Much is “Too Much” Lead in Drinking Water?
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
• Safe Water Drinking Act (SWDA) and Lead
Copper Rule (LCR)
• Maximum Contaminant Level
• Goal Concentration = 0 µg/L Pb
• Action Level Concentration = 15 µg/L Pb
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
Lead in Drinking Water
57
How Much is “Too Much” Lead in Drinking Water?
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
• Safe Water Drinking Act (SWDA) and Lead
Copper Rule (LCR)
• Maximum Contaminant Level
• Goal Concentration = 0 µg/L Pb
• Action Level Concentration = 15 µg/L Pb
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
• No safe concentration for Pb in blood
Lead in Drinking Water
58
How Much is “Too Much” Lead in Drinking Water?
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
• Safe Water Drinking Act (SWDA) and Lead
Copper Rule (LCR)
• Maximum Contaminant Level
• Goal Concentration = 0 µg/L Pb
• Action Level Concentration = 15 µg/L Pb
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
• No safe concentration for Pb in blood
• Blood lead levels (BLLs) containing 5 µg/dL could indicate
exposure to high levels of Pb
Lead in Drinking Water
59
Lead in Drinking Water
60
Lead in Drinking Water
Health Effects From Exposure to Lead
61
• Well-known toxin
Lead in Drinking Water
Health Effects From Exposure to Lead
62
• Well-known toxin
• Affects most organ systems in humans
• Infants/children experience more severe effects
Lead in Drinking Water
Health Effects From Exposure to Lead
63
• Well-known toxin
• Affects most organ systems in humans
• Infants/children experience more severe effects
• Symptoms in adults include:
Lead in Drinking Water
Health Effects From Exposure to Lead
64
• Well-known toxin
• Affects most organ systems in humans
• Infants/children experience more severe effects
• Symptoms in adults include:
• Joint and muscle pain
• Abdominal pain
• Headaches
• High blood pressure
• Memory loss
Lead in Drinking Water
Health Effects From Exposure to Lead
65
• Well-known toxin
• Affects most organ systems in humans
• Infants/children experience more severe effects
• Symptoms in adults include:
• Joint and muscle pain
• Abdominal pain
• Headaches
• High blood pressure
• Memory loss
• Symptoms in children include:
Lead in Drinking Water
Health Effects From Exposure to Lead
66
• Well-known toxin
• Affects most organ systems in humans
• Infants/children experience more severe effects
• Symptoms in adults include:
• Joint and muscle pain
• Abdominal pain
• Headaches
• High blood pressure
• Memory loss
• Symptoms in children include:
• Developmental delays (physical and mental)
• Loss of appetite
• Abdominal pain
• Stunted growth
Lead in Drinking Water
Health Effects From Exposure to Lead
67
Lead in Drinking Water
68
Lead in Drinking Water
How Much Lead is in Your Drinking Water?
69
Lead in Drinking Water
How Much Lead is in Your Drinking Water?
70
• Contact your local water municipality
• Collect and submit a water sample for testing
Lead in Drinking Water
How Much Lead is in Your Drinking Water?
71
• Contact your local water municipality
• Collect and submit a water sample for testing
Lead in Drinking Water
How Much Lead is in Your Drinking Water?
Additional Resources
72
• Contact your local water municipality
• Collect and submit a water sample for testing
Lead in Drinking Water
How Much Lead is in Your Drinking Water?
Additional Resources
• EPA document: Actions You Can Take to Reduce Lead in Drinking Water
(http://nepis.epa.gov/Exe/ZyPDF.cgi?Dockey=20001R4V.txt)
73
• Contact your local water municipality
• Collect and submit a water sample for testing
Lead in Drinking Water
How Much Lead is in Your Drinking Water?
Additional Resources
• EPA document: Actions You Can Take to Reduce Lead in Drinking Water
(http://nepis.epa.gov/Exe/ZyPDF.cgi?Dockey=20001R4V.txt)
• WHO guidelines and general education for lead
(http://www.who.int/ipcs/features/lead..pdf)